Professional Documents
Culture Documents
list of their electronic medical record due to the vitamin B12 Duration of high-dose metformin therapy, mean 5.2 (3.0)
(SD), years
malabsorption associated with these conditions. For this
Among the 62 study subjects with a serum vitamin B12 mea- level measured despite having a serum vitamin B12 level
surement of less than 350 pg/mL (reference range 157-1059), less than 350 pg/mL while on metformin. New documen-
77% did not have a follow-up MMA level measured. tation of anemia and neuropathy was noted in 28 (12%)
and 33 (14%) subjects, respectively. Among these subjects,
INCIDENCE OF VITAMIN B12 DEFICIENCY, ANEMIA, AND 29% of those with newly documented anemia and 42% of
NEUROPATHY those with newly documented neuropathy had no docu-
mentation of serum vitamin B12 measurement (Figure 3).
Six (2.5%) subjects had a new vitamin B12 deficiency
documented after a mean of 4.5 years of high-dose met-
Discussion
formin therapy. However, 13 subjects (5.5%) had a new
prescription for cyanocobalamin supplementation during VITAMIN B12 MONITORING
the study period (Figure 2). Forty-eight (18%) patients did
not have a new cyanocobalamin prescription or an MMA Less than 1% of study subjects met the recommendation
of having a serum vitamin B12 level measured annually
while on high-dose metformin therapy; most never had the
level determined. This finding persisted regardless of the
duration of high-dose metformin therapy. The risk of de-
veloping a metformin-induced vitamin B12 deficiency is
positively correlated with the duration of metformin use.3
Thus, it is notable that among subjects with a duration of
high-dose metformin treatment of 10 years or more, nearly
half (46%) never had a vitamin B12 level measured during
therapy (Figure 1). These individuals were at the greatest
risk for vitamin B12 deficiency, and the lack of monitoring
in these subjects may have resulted in several cases of vita-
min B12 deficiency being undiagnosed and untreated.
As previously discussed, patients with a potential sub-
clinical vitamin B12 deficiency (defined in this study as a vi-
tamin B12 level <350 pg/mL) should have a more sensitive
marker, such as MMA, measured.2,10 In this study, subjects
with low-normal vitamin B12 levels did not routinely have
Figure 1. Total number of serum vitamin B12 measurements per sub- follow-up MMA levels evaluated. Clinically significant vita-
ject by duration of high-dose (≥2000 mg/day) metformin therapy.
All subjects: N = 235; ≤3 years: n = 87; 4-6 years: n = 83; 7-9 years: n = min B12 deficiencies may have gone undiagnosed and un-
39; ≥10 years: n = 26. treated resulting from this lack of thorough monitoring.
Figure 2. Incidence of new documentation of vitamin B12 deficiency (n = 6), cyanocobalamin use (n = 13), anemia (n = 28), and neuropathy (n = 33)
among included subjects (N = 235) during high-dose metformin therapy.
Lack of awareness may explain the results found in this than the reported rate of vitamin B12 deficiency in patients
study. While monitoring vitamin B12 with metformin may on long-term metformin (6-9%).5-7
be novel to some, the relationship between metformin and
vitamin B12 deficiency has been recognized for several Anemia
decades, and monitoring vitamin B12 was a recommenda- Measuring vitamin B12 and folate levels is often part of a
tion during the time frame of this retrospective study.5-7 routine evaluation when a patient is found to have ane-
However, while this recommendation is included in readily mia.17 However, 29% of subjects in this study with a new
available drug information sources, the clinical practice documentation of anemia during high-dose metformin
guidelines from the American Diabetes Association do not therapy did not have a vitamin B12 level measured; an addi-
mention the need to monitor vitamin B12. The guidelines tional 36% with a vitamin B12 level less than 350 pg/mL
do not include such specific recommendations regarding did not have a follow-up MMA level or a cyanocobalamin
monitoring parameters for the medications used to treat di- prescription documented. Thus, up to 64% of the subjects
abetes. Thus, the lack of vitamin B12 monitoring found in on high-dose metformin with anemia may have had a clin-
the study could be because many providers may be unfa- ically significant vitamin B12 deficiency underlying their
miliar with this adverse effect of metformin and unaware anemia that went undetected.
of the recommendation to monitor the vitamin.
Given the low rates of vitamin B12 monitoring seen in Neuropathy
this study, it is prudent to note that annual injections of vi-
Neurologic damage, a possible consequence of met-
tamin B12 have been suggested as an alternative to annual
formin-induced vitamin B12 deficiency, can present as pe-
monitoring of vitamin B12 levels in patients on long-term
ripheral neuropathy and may be mistaken for diabetic neu-
therapy. This approach may be more cost-effective and
ropathy in patients on high-dose metformin.9 In these pa-
could also be considered, especially if access to primary
tients, detection of a vitamin B12 deficiency and correction
care or laboratory services is a concern.9
with cyanocobalamin is a simple means to potentially halt
progression of the neuropathy and prevent permanent neuro-
INCIDENCE OF VITAMIN B12 DEFICIENCY, ANEMIA, AND logic damage. In addition, the findings of Wile and Toth
NEUROPATHY demonstrated that metformin-treated diabetic patients had
more severe worsening of peripheral neuropathy compared
Vitamin B12 Deficiency
to diabetic patients with neuropathy who were not on met-
A new vitamin B12 deficiency was documented in the formin.18 In our study, less than one third of subjects with a
charts of 2.5% of subjects after an average of 4.5 years of new documentation of neuropathy received a comprehensive
metformin therapy. However, 5.5% of subjects had new workup for vitamin B12 deficiency (Figure 3). Although par-
prescriptions for cyanocobalamin supplementation, which ticular attention should be paid to monitoring vitamin B12 lev-
suggests that a larger percentage than was documented expe- els in diabetic patients on metformin who have or develop
rienced a clinically significant decrease in vitamin B12 levels neuropathy, the lack of vitamin B12 monitoring seen in the
while on high-dose metformin therapy. The pro-
portion of patients with clinically significant de-
creases in vitamin B12 may have been even
greater, as an additional 18% had a vitamin B12
level less than 350 pg/mL but no follow-up mea-
surement of MMA levels and no prescription for
cyanocobalamin. Thus, when including the 5.5%
of subjects who received cyanocobalamin sup-
plementation and the 18% with a potential sub-
clinical vitamin B12 deficiency, it is possible that
up to 23.5% of patients may have experienced a
clinically significant decrease in vitamin B12 dur- Figure 3. Vitamin B12 monitoring in subjects with anemia or neuropathy. Proportion
ing high-dose metformin therapy. These findings of subjects with new documentation of anemia (n = 28) or neuropathy (n = 33) who
did not have vitamin B12 levels measured at any time and who received an incom-
are comparable to those in other studies, which plete workup for vitamin B12 deficiency (defined as a vitamin B12 level <350 pg/mL
identified 10-30% of patients on long-term met- without a follow-up methylmalonic acid level or cyanocobalamin prescription), or who
received a complete workup for vitamin B12 deficiency (defined as a vitamin B12 level
formin therapy as having some degree of vita- >350 pg/mL, or a vitamin B12 level <350 pg/mL with a follow-up methylmalonic acid
min B12 malabsorption.5-7 The percentage of in- level and/or cyanocobalamin prescription). Anemia: no vitamin B12 measured, n = 8
(29%); incomplete vitamin B12 workup, n = 11 (39%); complete vitamin B12 workup, n
dividuals in this study who received cyanocobal- = 9 (32%). Neuropathy: no vitamin B12 measured, n = 14 (42%); incomplete vitamin B12
amin supplementation (5.5%) is slightly lower workup, n = 9 (27%); complete vitamin B12 workup, n = 10 (30%).
overall study population persisted in the subjects with neu- have been receiving a lower dose of metformin, resulting
ropathy, a patient population for whom the consequences of in a difference between the recorded duration of high-dose
an untreated vitamin B12 deficiency may be most significant. metformin therapy versus the total duration of metformin
therapy at any dose. As such, the cumulative duration of
STUDY STRENGTHS AND LIMITATIONS metformin use at any dose was not captured and could not
be analyzed in reference to the development of vitamin B12
This study has several strengths. Only subjects at high deficiency or related complications. In addition, while all
risk of metformin-induced vitamin B12 deficiency were in- subjects were on high-dose therapy at the start and end of
cluded in the study, as all patients were on high doses for the study period, subjects who had temporary dose adjust-
considerable periods. Thus, the subsequent finding that vi- ments to doses <2000 mg/day during the study period were
tamin B12 was not being adequately monitored has greater not excluded and these dose adjustments were not explicit-
significance given that this lack of monitoring occurred in ly accounted for in the study. This is a limitation, as these
a high-risk population. The use of an integrated electronic subjects would technically be at a slightly lower risk dur-
medical record that includes medical diagnoses and medi- ing the time of lower dose therapy. However, this is unlike-
cation prescription information allows for more compre- ly to significantly affect the results, since the purpose of the
hensive data collection, and the random sample of patients study was to evaluate overall vitamin B12 monitoring pat-
included in the study provides a more accurate picture of terns in a higher-risk group of patients rather than to prove
actual clinical practice. a dose-dependent relationship between metformin and vi-
This study also fills a gap in the literature. While several tamin B12 levels.
studies demonstrating the relationship between metformin In conclusion, the results of this study demonstrate that
use and vitamin B12 deficiency support the need for routine vitamin B12 levels are not being routinely monitored as rec-
monitoring of serum vitamin B12 levels, there is a lack of ommended in patients on long-term, high-dose metformin
studies that examine whether this monitoring is being per- therapy. The discrepancy between recommended and actu-
formed in the clinical setting. This study adds to the litera- al practice is possibly caused by a lack of awareness re-
ture by highlighting the fact that patients on long-term, garding the effects of metformin on vitamin B12 absorp-
high-dose metformin do not routinely have vitamin B12 tion. It is important to educate providers about the utility of
levels measured, despite mounting evidence in favor of do- checking a vitamin B12 level annually in patients on long-
ing so, and potential cases of reversible vitamin B12 defi- term, high-dose metformin therapy, given that measuring a
ciencies may therefore go undiagnosed. serum vitamin B12 level is a readily available laboratory
The study is not without limitations, however. Due to test and the detection and correction of a simple vitamin
the study’s retrospective design, there are inherent limita- B12 deficiency can prevent unnecessary permanent neuro-
tions to the data. For example, with use of refill records alone, logic damage and anemia in this patient population.
it was not possible to determine adherence to the prescribed Because the vitamin B12– deficient state induced by met-
metformin regimen. In addition, only medical conditions and formin can emerge over the course of 10-15 years, this is-
sue will likely become more clinically significant, consid-
medications explicitly recorded in a subject’s medical record
ering that metformin has been on the US market for 16
and medication lists were reviewed for inclusion, exclusion,
years. It is possible that the rates of vitamin B12 deficiency
and data collection. Thus, some patients may have had active
attributed to long-term use of high-dose metformin could
medical conditions that were not documented in their com-
increase substantially. It is imperative that clinicians be
puterized medical records, and therefore the information was
aware of this potentially serious, yet easy-to-treat, adverse
not available. This may have led to an underrepresentation of
effect of metformin and be proactive in annually monitor-
the incidence of vitamin B12 deficiency, anemia, and neuropa-
ing serum vitamin B12 levels in this high-risk population.
thy in this study. This is evidenced by the fact that while only
6 subjects had a documented vitamin B12 deficiency, 13 pa- Sarah A Pierce PharmD, PGY1 Pharmacy Practice Resident, VA
tients had a new prescription for cyanocobalamin supplemen- Maryland Healthcare System— Department of Pharmacy, Baltimore,
tation during the study period. MD
Amy H Chung PharmD, Clinical Pharmacy Specialist, VA Mary-
Because data were obtained only from the electronic land Healthcare System—Department of Pharmacy
medical records of the VAMHCS, it is possible that sub- Karen Korch Black PharmD, PGY2 Ambulatory Care Pharmacy
jects may have previously filled prescriptions, including Residency Program Director; Clinical Pharmacy Specialist, VA Mary-
land Healthcare System—Department of Pharmacy
metformin, outside of the VA system. Therefore these non-
Correspondence: Dr. Pierce, sarah.pierce@va.gov
VA medications and durations of use were not documented Reprints/Online Access: www.theannals.com/cgi/reprint/aph.1R223
during chart review and data collection.
Conflict of interest: Authors reported none
Finally, data were recorded only for the period after sub-
jects had been started on high-dose metformin. They may We thank Christopher Gallagher PharmD for his assistance with this work.
si les patients sont à risqué élevés (≥10 ans de traitement) ou avec des pour évaluer l’effet de la surveillance du taux de la vitamine B12 dans
manifestations potentielles (neuropathie) de carence en vitamine B12. Les l’identification et le traitement de carence en vitamine B12 chez les
patients avec carence en vitamine B12 entraînant une anémie ou une patients sous metformine.
neuropathie risquent d’être non diagnostiqués ni traités en l’absence de
données de surveillance. Des études prospectives doivent être effectuées Traduit par Louise Mallet