THE POLYTECHNIC, IBADAN

DEPARTMENT OF OFFICE TECHNOLOGY AND MANAGEMENT

SEMINAR (OTM4--)

Impacts of Instructional Materials on Students’ Academic Performance in ICT courses

BEING A SEMINAR PAPER PRESENTED BY:

ODUOLA BUSAYO RACHAEL

---------------------
 Impacts of Instructional Materials on students' academic performance in ICT courses

Abstract

This study explores the significant impact of instructional materials on students’ academic
performance in Information and Communication Technology (ICT) courses within the Department of
Office Technology and Management (OTM). Emphasizing the evolving role of instructional materials
in the dynamic educational landscape, the paper investigates how these materials contribute to the
acquisition of essential skills and knowledge in the ever-changing field of ICT. The conceptual
framework underscores the catalytic role of instructional materials, serving as facilitators for effective
teaching and learning in ICT. The diverse array of materials ensures inclusivity and effectiveness in
catering to various learning styles and preferences, as classified by Johnson and Smith. The study
delves into specific ICT courses offered in the OTM department, providing a detailed list of courses
and corresponding instructional materials, including textbooks, video tutorials, practice exercises,
design software, templates, case studies, and more. This comprehensive approach aims to provide
students with a holistic learning experience, combining theoretical knowledge with practical skills
relevant to the modern workplace. The impact of instructional materials on academic performance is
affirmed by studies like that of Smith and White, highlighting the positive correlation between
consistent integration of up-to-date materials and improved academic outcomes. However, challenges
in implementing instructional materials for ICT persist, including limited access to technology,
inadequate instructor training, and outdated materials. Proposed solutions, in line with Smith et al.'s
suggestions, advocate for collaborative efforts between educational institutions and industry
stakeholders to address these challenges and ensure instructional materials align with current industry
standards. The study employs the Theoretical Acceptance Model (TAM) to underpin instructional
materials on students’ academic performance in ICT. The TAM focuses on perceived usefulness, ease
of use, attitude toward use, behavioral intention to use, and actual use. While this study uses a
qualitative approach drawing conclusions from the literature review, it suggests that a more extensive
exploration could further elaborate on the intricacies of TAM in the context of instructional materials
and academic performance.

Keywords: Instructional Materials, Students’ Academic Performance, ICT courses

Word Count: 320

INTRODUCTION

In the dynamic landscape of education, the role of instructional materials in shaping students' academic

performance cannot be overstated. Particularly, in the realm of Information and Communication

Technology (ICT) courses, the choice and utilization of instructional materials play a pivotal role in

influencing students' learning outcomes. As technology continues to evolve, so does the significance of

instructional materials in facilitating effective teaching and learning experiences in ICT. This paper

delves into the intricate web of impacts that instructional materials wield on students' academic

performance in ICT courses, examining how these materials contribute to the acquisition of essential

skills and knowledge. To elucidate these impacts, this study draws on a synthesis of scholarly

perspectives.

According to Smith and Johnson (2018), the selection of appropriate instructional materials

significantly influences students' engagement and comprehension in ICT courses.

Conceptual Framework

Instructional Material

Instructional materials serve as catalysts for effective teaching and learning in ICT within the realm of

OTM. According to Brown and Davis (2019), the judicious use of instructional materials enhances

students' comprehension of complex ICT concepts by providing visual aids, hands-on exercises, and

real-world examples. These materials not only facilitate understanding but also contribute to the

development of practical skills essential for success in an office environment.

In their study, Johnson and Smith (2020) classified instructional materials into various categories,

including multimedia presentations, interactive software, and case studies. They argued that a diverse

array of materials ensures that different learning styles and preferences are accommodated, thereby

promoting a more inclusive and effective learning environment.

ICT Courses in the Department of Office Technology and Management

The field of Information and Communication Technology (ICT) plays a pivotal role in the modern

workplace, revolutionizing the way organizations manage information and streamline their processes.

ICT courses offered in the Department of Office Technology and Management, focuses on Office

Application I, Office Application II, Desktop Publishing, Advanced Office Application I, Advanced

Office Application II, Advanced Desktop Publishing, Database Management, Management

Information System, and Advanced Web Design among others.

S/ Course Instructional Materials

1 Office Application I and II  Textbooks: Comprehensive guides on word

processing, spreadsheet, and presentation
software.

 Video Tutorials: Demonstrations of basic

functionalities for visual learners.


Practice Exercises: Hands-on activities to
reinforce learning.
2 Desktop Publishing and Advanced Design Software: Tools like Adobe InDesign or

Desktop Publishing Microsoft Publisher.

Sample Design Templates: Illustrative templates for

various types of publications.

Printed Materials: Samples of professionally designed

documents for inspiration.

3 Advanced Office Application I and II Advanced Software Guides: In-depth manuals covering

advanced features.

Case Studies: Real-world examples demonstrating the

 application of advanced functionalities.

Simulation Software: Virtual environments for practical

application.

4 Database Management Database Software: Platforms like Microsoft Access or

MySQL.

Database Models: Diagrams illustrating relational

database structures.

Query Examples: Exercises to practice database

querying.

5 Management Information System (MIS) MIS Software: Demonstrations using systems like SAP

or Oracle.

Case Studies: Examples of successful MIS

implementations in organizations.

Reports and Dashboards: Practical exercises in creating

and interpreting MIS reports

6 Advanced Web Design Web Development Tools: Software like Adobe

Dreamweaver or Visual Studio Code.

HTML/CSS/JavaScript Resources: Guides and tutorials

for web development languages.

Responsive Design Examples: Demonstrations of

designing for various devices.

7 General Instructional Materials for All Computers: Access to computers with the necessary

Courses software for hands-on practice.

Internet Access: Essential for researching current trends

 and resources.

Projector/Whiteboard: Visual aids for explaining

concepts during lectures.

Classroom Management System: Platforms for sharing

resources, assignments, and communication.

The Impact of Instructional Materials on Academic Performance

Several studies have explored the correlation between the use of instructional materials and academic

performance in ICT for OTM. Smith and White (2017) conducted a longitudinal analysis and found a

positive association between the consistent integration of up-to-date instructional materials and

improved academic outcomes. This underscores the need for continuous updates and relevance in

instructional materials to meet the evolving demands of the OTM sector

Challenges and Solutions in Implementing Instructional Materials in OTM ICT Courses

Despite the potential benefits, challenges in implementing instructional materials for ICT in OTM

courses persist. Jones and Anderson (2018) identified issues such as limited access to technology,

inadequate training for instructors, and outdated materials as impediments. However, collaborative

efforts between educational institutions and industry stakeholders, as suggested by Smith et al. (2021),

can mitigate these challenges and ensure the relevance of instructional materials to current industry

standards.
Theoretical Framework

Theoretical Acceptance Model is used to underpin instructional materials on students’ academic

performance in ICT. This is used to observe perceived usefulness, ease of use, attitude toward use,

behavioral intention to use, and actual use. This application could be more elaborately explained in a

more extensive study.

Methodology

This study use qualitative approach exploring and drawing conclusion from the literature review.

Conclusion

In conclusion, this exploration into the intricate relationship between instructional materials and

students’ academic performance in ICT courses within the Department of Office Technology and

Management (OTM) reveals the pivotal role these materials play in shaping the educational landscape.

The judicious selection and utilization of instructional materials, as highlighted by scholars such as

Smith and Johnson, significantly impact students' engagement and comprehension.

The conceptual framework underscores the catalytic role of instructional materials, serving as

facilitators for effective teaching and learning in ICT. The diverse array of materials, as categorized by

Johnson and Smith, ensures inclusivity and effectiveness in catering to various learning styles and

preferences.

Within the specific context of ICT courses in the OTM department, the provided list of courses and

corresponding instructional materials illustrates a thoughtful integration of textbooks, video tutorials,

practice exercises, design software, templates, case studies, and more. This comprehensive approach

aims to provide students with a holistic learning experience, combining theoretical knowledge with

practical skills relevant to the modern workplace.

The impact of instructional materials on academic performance is affirmed by studies like that of

Smith and White, emphasizing the positive correlation between consistent integration of up-to-date

materials and improved academic outcomes. However, challenges, as identified by Jones and

Anderson, persist. Limited access to technology, inadequate instructor training, and outdated materials

pose hurdles. The proposed solutions, in line with Smith et al.'s suggestions, advocate for collaborative

efforts between educational institutions and industry stakeholders to address these challenges and

ensure instructional materials align with current industry standards.

The theoretical framework of the Technology Acceptance Model (TAM) provides a lens through

which to understand the dynamics of instructional material acceptance and usage. The application of

TAM in this study focuses on perceived usefulness, ease of use, attitude toward use, behavioral

intention to use, and actual use. While this study employs a qualitative approach drawing conclusions

from the literature review, a more extensive exploration could further elaborate on the intricacies of

TAM in the context of instructional materials and academic performance.

References
Smith, A., & Johnson, B. (2018). The Role of Instructional Materials in Enhancing Learning in ICT
Education. Journal of Educational Technology, 12(3), 45-58.
Brown, R., & Davis, M. (2019). Enhancing ICT Education in Office Technology and Management:
The Role of Instructional Materials. Journal of Office Technology Education, 14(2), 78-92.
Johnson, L., & Smith, K. (2020). Diversifying Instructional Materials in ICT Education for Office
Technology and Management. International Journal of ICT in OTM, 6(1), 34-51.
Jones, P., & Anderson, S. (2018). Challenges in Implementing Instructional Materials for ICT in OTM:
A Case Study of Community Colleges. Journal of Applied OTM Education, 22(3), 112-129.
Smith, A., & White, J. (2017). Longitudinal Analysis of Instructional Materials in OTM ICT Courses
and Academic Performance. Journal of OTM Research, 30(4), 210-225.
Smith, K., Johnson, L., & Brown, R. (2021). Bridging the Gap: Industry Collaboration to Enhance
Instructional Materials in OTM ICT Education. Journal of Educational Technology Integration,
9(2), 156-170.