Professional Documents
Culture Documents
2. What is Touting?
In law, touting is the act of soliciting and marketing legal services in an unethical
and intrusive manner. This can include unsolicited approaches, advertising, or
referral services that undermine the professionalism and ethical conduct
expected of legal practitioners.
(a) who procures, in consideration of any remuneration moving from any legal
practitioner, the employment of the legal practitioner in any legal business; or who
proposes to any legal practitioner or to any person interested in any legal business
to procure, in consideration of any remuneration moving from either of them, the
employment of the legal practitioner in such business; or
(b) who for the purposes of such procurement frequents the precincts of Civil or
Criminal Courts or of revenue offices, or railway stations, landing-stages, lodging
places or other places of public resort."
In India, lawyers are prohibited from advertising to preserve the dignity of the legal
profession. The ban is meant to:
i Prevent the commercialization of the legal profession
ii Prevent the use of unethical methods
iii Prevent legal disparity
iv Avoid misleading the public
v Safeguard the interests of the country's less educated population
vi Prevent professional envy
vii Prevent any potential misrepresentation, exaggeration, or even false claims
which could mislead clients
The ban is based on the idea that law is not a trade and that advertising by lawyers
can manipulate or mislead people.
The basic difference between barristers and solicitors is that a barrister mainly
defends people in court and a solicitor mainly performs legal work outside court.
A solicitor is a qualified legal practitioner who can take instructions from clients and
advise on necessary courses of legal action. Solicitors may be responsible for handling
legal matters such as providing legal advice, drafting contracts, and negotiating
settlements.
In the event of a Court case, a solicitor will draft legal documents. Solicitors provide
clients with specialist legal advice on a wide variety of legal matters, which are
divided into contentious and non-contentious cases.
Barristers tend to specialise in courtroom advocacy and litigation, drafting legal pleas,
giving expert legal opinions and researching the theory and history of law. They are
responsible for presenting cases in court, arguing legal points and cross-examining
witnesses. A barrister wears a wig and gown in Court.
"Volenti non fit injuria" is a Latin legal maxim that means "to a willing person, it is not
a wrong". It is a common law doctrine that states that if someone willingly puts
themselves in a position where harm might result, they will not be able to bring a
claim against the other party in a tort.
Legal ethics are the principles of conduct that lawyers and other legal professionals
are expected to follow. They can also refer to the broader moral principles that
societies place on lawyers.
Legal ethics are a critical aspect of the legal profession. They ensure that lawyers and
other legal professionals act with integrity, competence, and diligence. They are
essential for upholding the rule of law, protecting the interests of clients, and
promoting public trust in the legal system.
7. Mention any two privileges of a lawyer?
Short Notes
1. Preparation of Case:
In the complex and ever-evolving landscape of the legal arena, the preparation of a
case is an art that demands meticulous attention to detail, astute legal acumen, and
unwavering dedication. As legal practitioners, we find ourselves entrusted with the
profound responsibility of advocating for our clients' rights and seeking justice in a
world of intricate laws and regulations. The process of preparing a case as a lawyer
necessitates a comprehensive and systematic approach, encompassing various
essential steps that pave the path towards success.
The journey from the initial client interview to the culmination of a trial or a
settlement is a testament to the synergy between legal expertise, thorough research,
strategic planning, and ethical representation. It is within these endeavors that we
strive to navigate the complexities, unearth the truths concealed within evidence, and
construct compelling narratives that resonate in the corridors of justice.
1. Case Analysis:
- Understand the Legal Issue: Thoroughly grasp the legal issue at hand, identify key
elements, and apply relevant legal principles to the case.
- Client Interview: Gather crucial information from the client, collect relevant
documents, and identify potential witnesses.
- Evidence Collection: Gather all pertinent evidence, such as documents,
photographs, videos, contracts, and emails.
- Assessment of Strengths and Weaknesses: Evaluate the case's strengths and
weaknesses, anticipate challenges, and address potential legal hurdles.
2. Legal Research:
- Statutes and Case Law: Conduct comprehensive legal research to find relevant
statutes and case law that apply to the case.
- Secondary Sources: Consult secondary legal sources like law review articles and
legal treatises to gain deeper insights into complex legal issues.
3. Case Strategy:
- Objective: Clearly define the case objective, whether it's winning the trial, seeking a
favorable settlement, or achieving a specific goal.
- Legal Theories and Arguments: Develop strong legal theories and arguments based
on analysis and research.
- Counterarguments: Anticipate possible counterarguments from the opposing party
and devise strategies to address them effectively.
4. Drafting Legal Documents:
- Pleadings: Prepare necessary pleadings, including complaints, answers, motions,
and discovery requests.
- Legal Memoranda: Draft detailed legal memoranda outlining the legal issues,
relevant laws, and how they apply to your client's case.
Section 42 the Advocates Act, 1961 provides that the disciplinary committee of a Bar
Council shall have the same powers as are vested in a civil court under the Code of
Civil Procedure, 1908, in respect of summoning and enforcing the attendance of any
person and examining him on oath, requiring discovery and production of any
documents;
The disciplinary committee of the Bar Council of India has the following powers:
i Make inquiries: The committee can investigate complaints of misconduct.
ii Withdraw cases: The committee can withdraw cases for its own investigation.
iii Hear appeals: The committee can hear appeals and order stays.
iv Review orders: The committee can review its own orders.
v Summon and examine: The committee can summon and enforce the
attendance of any person and examine them on oath.
vi Require documents: The committee can require the discovery and production
of any documents.
vii Receive evidence: The committee can receive evidence on affidavits.
viii Requisition records: The committee can requisition any public record or
copies thereof from any court or office.
ix Issue commissions: The committee can issue commissions for the examination
of witness or documents.
x Send summons: The committee can send summons or other processes to any
civil court for the attendance of a witness or the production of a document.
3. Lawyer as Psychologists
To work effectively with clients, witnesses, judges, mediators, arbitrators, experts,
jurors, and other lawyers, attorneys must have a good understanding of how people
think and make decisions, and must possess good people skills. Yet, law schools have
tended to teach very little, directly, about human behavior, and current critiques of
legal education do not focus on the importance of psychological insights to attorneys.
In particular, lawyers and legal education have not taken full advantage of the great
strides that have been made in the field of scientific psychology in recent decades.
Similarly, psychologists are not doing as much as they might to apply their discipline
to all aspects of law. Law and psychology texts and courses often focus primarily on
criminal rather than civil law and practice, and place their emphasis on the
psychology of juries, eyewitness testimony, interrogation, and trials. This Article
begins to fill some of the gaps that exist in the application of psychology to legal
practice, focusing on psychological insights that are important to the endeavor of
interviewing and providing initial counseling to clients in civil cases. Law students
commonly graduate from law school understanding little if anything about
perception, memory, communication, cognitive heuristics, or decision-making. While
good lawyers ultimately pick up some of this information through experience, there
is no reason to leave new lawyers to flounder based on a lack of understanding of
these psychological principles. Further, even experienced lawyers can benefit from
more explicit study of psychology. While the best lawyers may have intuited some of
what will be discussed here, some of the findings are counterintuitive, and even
experienced lawyers can improve their approach to interviewing and counseling by
drawing on relevant psychology.
Business Habits
1. Go to Bed Early, so You Wake up Early
To excel in business, you need proper focus. The days can get quite chaotic with the
phone ringing all the time, people coming in and out of your office, meetings,
meetings, meetings, and the Herculean effort it takes to reach inbox zero.
If you want to make it easier for yourself to focus on the activities that await you on a
particular day, waking up early is essential. Unless this is a habit that you’re already
exercising, we recommend that you make an effort to wake up at least two hours
earlier than you are waking up right now.
What do we mean by early? We find that the sweet spot is somewhere between 4 am
and 6 or 7 am. For those of you who are not early birds by nature, this may be a habit
that is challenging to instill, but we would argue that the more challenging you find it,
the more critical it is for you.
Want to hear our pro tip for waking up early? There’s no rule that says you need to
adopt this habit overnight, as that can shock your system and have the opposite effect.
You can start gradually, by simply moving your alarm 15 minutes earlier each day,
until you reach your goal.
Sometimes you’ll be stuck at the same wake-up time for a couple of days, and that’s
okay. The body and the mind need time to adjust to a new sleeping regimen, and you
will notice that you’re getting sleepier earlier and earlier each evening.
2. Always Be Inspired
If you remember the exact moment when your initial business idea crossed your
mind, and then the exact moment you decided to make a go for it, well, that’s what it
means to be inspired. When all the pieces of the puzzle suddenly fit together, you feel
this rush and eagerness to just do something.
Although the feeling of inspiration is transitory, it’s good for your creativity levels to
keep an open mind and a proactive attitude so that you are always as accepting of it
as you can be.
You can, for example, find something that inspires you to watch, read, or listen to and
consume at least a bit of it every day. Whether “it” for you is a scientific channel with
the latest trends in tech development, a TED talk, an inspirational blog, or your
favorite podcast - it’s important that you do it each day.
3. Powerful Morning
Many successful people in business claim that the first part of the day is the most
important for them, as that’s when they feel the strongest and most energized. That’s
likely because it’s much easier to remain focused and concentrated in the morning
when you’re not yet overwhelmed by the challenges of the day.
But if you find that you are not as productive in the mornings as you want to be, there
are several things you can do.
You can start by implementing a powerful and engaging morning routine designed
around activities that fill you with positivity. For example, you can start the day by
filling out your Five Minute Journal, expressing your gratitude alone, with your
partner, or your whole family. There’s always a way to add to this routine gradually
and take it further one step at a time, by adding a short exercise routine, preparing a
healthy breakfast, reading a chapter from a book, or anything else that you find
inspiring to do in the morning.
Take your time building your morning habits, as forming a new habit doesn’t happen
overnight — it can take between three weeks and a few months.
4. Zero Inbox
Like clutter in our physical space, digital clutter can distract us and decrease our
capacity for concentration. To save yourself this added stress, we recommend that
you make it a habit to read, sort, and discard unwanted emails the moment they
arrive.
If your email service provider allows, you can also set up specific filters and
automation, but if it’s not possible, you can still try to keep your inbox clean manually,
so it’s easy for you to reach inbox zero each day.
Waking up early and completing an inspiring and empowering morning routine will
make it even easier for you to get into your MITs.
The challenging thing about MITs is choosing them. For people running their
businesses, everything seems equally important. But this way of thinking can lead to
burnout pretty quickly. We advise you to just get it over with, choose two or three
things that are the most important for the goals you’re committed to, and make them
the first thing you focus on in the morning.
According to this principle, 80% of the results that you achieve come from 20% of the
effort you have invested.
To illustrate, for a sales business, this means that 80% of the sales are coming from
20% of the customers.
You can find out how the 80/20 rule applies directly to your business and try to use
that information to rescale your efforts and focus on those activities, clients, or
customers that bring you the most significant value.
Our time on Earth is limited, which is both intimidating and beautiful at the same
time. To make sure we make the most of it, we can try to save time, just like we try to
save money before it’s gone forever.
Use all the tools at your disposal to create an excellent time-management system and
stick to it to avoid distraction and achieve your goals.
The Productivity Planner and The Mindful Focus Hourglass are two excellent tools to
help you with that. If you use them together, you’ll soon find that your daily and
weekly planning have never been more straightforward. The Productivity Planner is
designed to help you put together the perfect time management plan, while the
Mindful Focus Hourglass that lasts 30 minutes will help you execute your plan.
8. Daily Goals
There is no business without a business plan with clearly outlined long-term goals.
That’s something you probably know already. However, every big goal composes of
many smaller subgoals. The goal-units should get as small as daily goals. Some of the
most successful business people set goals for each day. A daily goal can be something
like ‘reply to all of my emails’ or ‘make at least two sales’.
It’s good to set your daily goals early in the morning when you feel fresh and energetic.
If you’re not sure how to set, manage, and measure achievable goals, perhaps check
out one of our previous articles on How to set achievable goals, where we explain how
to formulate your goals, what principles to use, how to pick your metrics for progress
and measure your success, and so much more.
Tracking your activities and measuring your progress using simple analytical
methods is the only way to be sure that you are moving forward.
This is especially important for long-term goals, where we can get lost in the sea of
smaller steps and can no longer tell whether we are moving forward or staying in
place.
Knowing how far you’ve come from when you first started out and how much is left
before the end can help you make necessary adjustments in your strategy and
estimate the time needed to pass certain milestones.
This is why it’s good to have progress metrics in place. Achieving daily goals can be
one of them. You can also track your progress hourly by setting a reminder for
yourself to write down what you are doing and what you have done so far. This may
create a bit of pressure, so we don’t recommend it for everyone. However, for certain
people, the awareness that time until the next alarm beep sounds is running out can
help them get things done when they’re on a tight schedule.
10. Networking
If you have a great plan, a good business strategy, and lots of knowledge but have no
connections, that factor alone can hinder your business success.
While most people understand that this is one of the basic principles of doing
business, not many people list networking as an activity they need to do every day.
Helping others, visiting social events that people from your or similar branches of
business often attend, reaching out for collaboration, making a page on social media,
and interacting with people are all ways of networking that may be beneficial for your
business.
Networking rarely pays off immediately. It takes time and repeated interactions
before things start to ‘click’.
Answer in detail
9. An advocate should not act on the instructions of any person other than his
client or the client’s authorised agent.
In Raj Kumar Prasad vs State of Arunachal Pradesh, (2006) 2 GLR 597, it was held that
it is the duty of an advocate not to act on the instructions of any person except for his
client or any person authorised by his client.
21. An advocate shall not enter into arrangements whereby funds in his hands
are converted into loans.
It means an advocate should not enter into any such arrangements which convert his
funds into loans. He should not lend or leave money to his client.
4. An advocate shall not accept a fee less than the fee, which can be taxed under
rules when the client is able to pay more.
An advocate shall not take a fee less than the fee, which can be taxed under rules when
the client can pay more. If the advocate accepts less than the prescribed fee, then it
shall be unethical and against the moral turpitude of the legal fraternity.
In case an advocate is not able to present the consent of the advocate who has filed
the matter for the same party, then he should apply to the court for appearance. He
shall, in such an application, mention the reason why he could not obtain such
consent. He shall appear only after obtaining the permission of the Court.
2. Constitutional power and function of state bar council
The State Bar Councils are statutory bodies established under Section 3 of the
Advocates Act, 1961. They act as regulatory bodies, making rules for the legal
profession and education in their respective states and also act as the
representatives of the advocates of that state, thereby acting in their interests.
They work in coordination with and under the supervision of the Bar Council of
India, which is a national body established under Section 4 of the Advocates Act,
1961.
In the Advocates Act, 1966, misconduct was not specified, but misconduct
envisages
infringement of discipline, although it would not be possible to set out
exhaustively what would constitute misconduct and indiscipline, which, however,
is broad enough to include wrongful omission or commission, whether done or
omitted to be done intentionally or unintentionally.
In Noratanmal Chaurasia v. M.R., the case The Supreme Court held that
misconduct was not specified in the Advocates Act, 1966, but misconduct
envisages violation of discipline, although it would not be possible to set out
exhaustively what would constitute misconduct and indiscipline, which, however,
is broad enough to include wrongful omission or commission, whether done or
omitted to be done intentionally or unintentionally
It has been concluded In Re Tulsidas Amanmal Karim that any behaviour that in
any way renders a person unfit for the exercise of his profession or is likely to
influence or embarrass the administration of justice by the High Court or any
other subordinate court may be regarded as misconduct.
In the case of a judge, if a lawyer's behaviour is such that it makes him incapable
of
becoming a member of the honourable legal profession and unable to be entrusted
with the responsible duties that a lawyer is called upon to perform, he would be
guilty of errors.
Thus, two tests were laid down following this case:—
(a) The conduct of the advocate is such that, in order to remain a member of the
honourable profession, he must be treated as unworthy.
(b) The lawyer's conduct is such that it must be deemed unfit to be entrusted with
the
responsible duties which the lawyer is called upon to perform.
These two tests have been interpreted as disjunctive and thus the fulfilment of any
one of the said criteria will be appropriate to regard the behaviour as misconduct.
Professional misconduct vis a vis court contempt
The spectrum of contempt proceedings is far broader than professional
misconduct
proceedings, as professional misconduct proceedings may only be carried out
against the lawyer, while contempt proceedings can be instituted against both bar
and bench members.
There is no fixed procedure for the initiation or penalty of the accused/ guilty in
the case of contempt of court and although proceedings are to be carried out in
the case of professional misconduct in compliance with the Advocates Act 1966,
which lays down a thorough procedure for the same.
In the case of proceedings for contempt of court, the Criminal Procedure Code and
the Indian Evidence Act are not valid because these proceedings are carried out
on the basis of the principles of natural justice- objectivity and fairness,
respectively. Cross-examination in contempt of court proceedings is tolerated in
restricted cases only.
For instance, Mr. R.K. Anand was not permitted to cross-examine Poonam
Aggarwal, who was in charge of the sting operation, in the case of contempt
proceedings against R.K Anand. In comparison, cross-examination is a significant
element of professional misconduct trials. As provided for in the Contempt of
Court Act, the penalty for contempt of court also varies from the penalty for
professional misconduct provided for in the Advocates Act, 1966.
LANDMARK JUDGEMENTS
1. State vs. Lalit Mohan Nanda
It is the responsibility of a Lawyer to defend his client's interests by all reasonable
and honourable means, but the opposite occurred in the case of State vs. Lalit
Mohan Nanda. In this case, the point of concern was whether Mr. Nanda was guilty
of professional misconduct for a violation of the laws on the professional conduct
of lawyers under Section 15(a) of the Indian Bar Councils Act, 1926. Advocate Lalit
Mohan Nanda was found guilty of professional misconduct by the Hon’ble Orissa
High Court, as he was found guilty of changing sides, meaning that after appearing
for the first party, he had appeared for the opposite party in the same case. The
responsibility of upholding a client's interest was violated.
The Bar and the Bench are like the two essential wheels of a chariot when it comes
to administering the law. They are interconnected and have their respective roles
in the legal system. In legal terms, the “Bar Bench relations” signifies the friendly
rapport between advocates and judges.
Both the Bar (advocates) and the Bench (judges) play crucial roles in ensuring
justice. Maintaining a harmonious relation between bar and bench requires
mutual respect and understanding from both sides.
Bar – Lawyers become registered advocates after completing their L.L.B. degree
from a university and undergoing specific training supervised by another
advocate, as per the rules. Collectively, these lawyers are known as the ‘Bar,’ and
an advocate represents the Bar. In most cases, the term “Bar” refers to a group of
licensed attorneys who practice in the courts of a state or a specific court.
Bench – The term “bench” refers to all the judges collectively, in contrast to the
term “Bar,” which encompasses all legal professionals. It also refers to the official
part of the court when judges are in session. Originally, the term ‘Bar’ referred to
the section of the court related to attorneys, but now it refers to the part of the
court dealing with judicial officers, known as the Bench.
It ensures that cases are heard fairly, legal principles are upheld and justice is
served. Communication, professionalism and mutual respect are key elements in
fostering a strong Bar Bench relationship, which ultimately benefits the legal
profession and the individuals seeking justice.
Difference Between Bar and Bench
The difference between Bar and Bench in the legal context is fundamental to the
administration of justice.
While the Bar influences case presentation and argues on behalf of clients, the
Bench holds the ultimate authority to determine case outcomes and uphold the
rule of law.
These differences emphasise their complementary roles within the legal system,
with the Bar advocating for parties and the Bench overseeing the delivery of
justice.
Here’s a table outlining the key differences between Bar and Bench in the legal
context:
Definition The collective term for lawyers Refers to the group of judges
Role Advocates who represent clients Judges who preside over cases
Function Present cases, argue and defend Hear cases, make legal decisions
Engagement in
Active in litigation and trials Passive, observing arguments
Advocacy
Professional
Governed by legal ethics Governed by judicial conduct
Conduct
Influence on
Influence case presentation Determine case outcomes
Outcomes
These differences highlight the contrasting roles and responsibilities of the Bar and
the Bench in the legal system, with the Bar advocating for clients and the Bench
ensuring the impartial application of the law and making legal decisions.