Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Yuki Yoshioka, David W. Siu, T. Derek V. Cooke, J. T. Bryant, and Urs Wyss
Clinical Mechanics Group, Department of Mechanical Engineering, Division of Orthopaedics,
Department of Surgery, Queen’s University, Kingston, Ontario, Canada
Summary: This study aimed to define the articular geometry of the metatar-
sophalangeal (MTP) joint of the great toe. Embedded in resin blocks, five pairs
of cadaveric first MTP joints (all from men) were sequentially cut in the sagittal
plane with a milling machine, removing 0.5 mm of bone in each cut. The
photographed cartilaginous outline of each cut was digitized against reference
markers, which enabled a computer system to superimpose each outline in
three dimensions. The intersesamoidal ridge was found to be parallel to the
lateral shaft. The peak of the ridge was just lateral to the midline of the MT
head. The articular outline, through the ridge of each sample, was circular;
however, other surface contours were noncircular. The undulating plantar as-
pect of the MTP head formed by the intersesamoidal ridge and related grooves
was found to have symmetric relationships to the sesamoid bones and a con-
sistent orientation to the shaft. The roiinded distal dorsal aspect of the MTP
head showed consistent differences to the concavity formed by the phalangeal
base. The sample size is too small for the sizing of prostheses but it is adequate
to study the geometry of the MTP joint. More data are needed for the accurate
replication of a resurfacing prosthesis and understanding of joint kinematics.
Key Words: Geometry-Metatarsophalangeal joint-Prosthesis.
The purpose of this study was to define Metatar- The success of reconstructive surgery for arthrit-
sophalangeal (MTP) joint geometry accurately, es- ic derangements of the MTP joint is directly influ-
pecially as it reflects articular surfaces involved in enced by the factors that control the rotation of the
load bearing and their relationships to stabilizing toe around the long axis of the metatarsal (1). Thus,
mechanisms for the joint. The acquisition of these features of local geometry between the trochlea and
data is considered as an essential prerequisite to the the sesamoid bones, as well as the articulations to
development of an anatomical resurfacing prosthet- the phalanx, directly influence the kinematics and
ic replacement. stability.
Clinically, many symptomatic disorders affect
the first MTP joint. These include congenital and
acquired malalignments such as hallux valgus, os- MATERIALS AND METHODS
teoarthritis, and rheumatoid arthritis. Surgery for
these problems is common. Although reconstruc- Eighteen great toe MTP joints were excised as
tions for MTP arthritis have been devised, including intact samples from nine male, disease-free fresh
a variety of partial and complete replacement ar- cadavers obtained from the Department of Pathol-
throplasties (lo), none restore the deranged joint ogy, Queen’s University (Table 1). Of the 18 MTP
kinematics to normal. joint samples obtained, nine were used for geomet-
rical analysis and nine for studies of macrohistol-
ogy. Each sample was obtained en block via a prox-
Address correspondence and reprint requests to Dr. T. D. V .
Cooke, Division of Orthopaedics, Department of Surgery, imal incision through the first metatarsocuneiform
Queen’s University, Kingston, Ontario, Canada K7L 3N6. joint and a distal resection through middle of the
878
FIRST METATARSOPHALANGEAL JOINT GEOMETRY 879
TABLE 1. Clinical data of the first The joint sample was carefully aligned in an alu-
metatarsophalangeal joint samples minum frame with three pairs of threaded alignment
~~
Sample Age (yr) Sex Height (cm) pins that extended from each side wall. Each meta-
1 59 M 173
tarsal was set with the lateral aspect of the bone
2 71 M 173 parallel to the bottom surface of the frame and the
3 73 M 173 superolateral border of the bone set parallel to a
4 79 M 176
5 82 M 172
side wall (Fig. 1); each position was checked by
6 85 M 167 vernier-caliper measurements, a protractor, and a
7 60 M 162 square set to a tolerance of 1 mm and 1".
8 68 M 168
9 74 M 162
Once firmly held by the pins, the sample was
Mean 73.3 169.5 completely covered with liquid polyester resin
mixed with a catalyst. Fiberglass was used to rein-
force the medium and lessen cracking during poly-
proximal phalanx; thus included were the whole merization. The samples were cured for 24 h at
first metatarsal bone, the proximal phalangeal base, room temperature. Once the resin block had hard-
the intra-articular structures, and both sesamoids. ened, it was removed from the aluminum frame and
Each specimen was fixed in 10% formalin for a trimmed to size before mounting on the tissue mill-
week prior to processing. Each sample was pre- ing machine. The sample was oriented with one side
pared in three steps: removal of soft tissues and of the block (dorsal or plantar) and the top part of
articular surface staining, alignment in a reference the block close to the joint sample outline.
frame, and embedding in polyester resin. All extra- The equipment used in the slicing has been dis-
articular soft tissues (muscles, tendons, and perios- cussed by Shiba et al. (8). The resin block with the
teum), except the joint capsule and ligaments, were joint sample was sequentially milled; each cut re-
removed. This allowed good adherence between moved 0.5 mm (0.020) of bone. After each cut, the
bone and polyester embedding resin during slicing. exposed surfaces were cleaned and photographed.
Staining of the articular surfaces was used to in- About 40 sagittally cut surfaces were obtained from
crease the contrast between cartilage and other tis- each specimen.
sues for better definition and subsequent photo- The developed photographs or slides (frames),
graphic reproduction. The staining used was varied taken by a Minolta XG9 camera on Ektachrome
among the following solutions: toluidine blue, saf- films, were analyzed in a Bell and Howell Mark I1
ranin 0, and alizarin red (7,ll). In three joints, the film analyzer. Each frame showed the cartilaginous
stain was injected with a 26-gauge needle through outline of the metatarsal (MT) head with its refer-
the joint capsule into the joint space. The other ence x and y coordinates projected onto a Hi-Pad
joints were opened, and the articular surfaces were digitizer. The cartilaginous outline of the MT head
immersed in stain mixed with formalin for 24 h. and the reference coordinates were digitized using a
FIG. 1. Sample alignment. The superolateral border was set to b e parallel to side walls (left), with the lateral surface parallel t o
t h e bottom of the frame (right). (Key: 1, bone; 2, alignment frame; and 3, holding pin.)
cursor. About 70 points were digitized from each deviation of 1.5 mm. The dorsoplantar diameter,
cut surface (outline) and stored on the magnetic which is the distance between the dorsal and the
tape of a Hewlett-Packard desktop computer for plantar surfaces at the middle of the intersesamoidal
further computer analysis and graphical representa- ridge, had a mean of 22.8 mm. All dimensions are
tion (9). After completion of the digitization, the labeled in Fig. 3; however, the actual values for
outlines of each frame were superimposed along the each sample as well as the mean values and stan-
z coordinate and stored as a complete file for that dard deviations are listed in Table 2. The three-
joint sample. These curved outlines could be clas- dimensional composite of each MT head was recon-
sified into four main types: circular (Fig. 2), ellipti- structed by superimposing all the digitized slices. In
cal, spiral (Fig. 2), and combined. To determine the so doing, a graphical display of the joint sample at
geometric center of any circle, at least three points any orientation was obtained from the computer
of the arc have to be known. When this rule was plotter. Figure 4 represents four different views
applied to the digitized information, a series of es- of the same MT head. Figure 4A is a side-
timated centers were calculated. Depending on the view-oriented parallel to the yz plane. The geomet-
degree of conformity of a particular profile to an arc ric center of the intersesamoid ridge is shown as C.
of a circle, the distribution of these calculated cen- An oblique view is shown in Fig. 4D. The configu-
ters might be localized around a central point. An rations of the ridge and sesamoid articulations were
average of a series of such loci provided an estimate reconstructed as aggregations or diversions of the
for the presence or absence of a central geometric curves. When the reconstructed image was viewed
relationship for that particular cartilaginous outline. from its dorsal aspect (Fig. 4B), the peak of the
The accuracy that could be achieved with the cho- articular surface was located more laterally than the
sen method was better than t0.5 mm for dimen- mid-point of the tibia1 and fibular borders. The pro-
sions and better than ?I" for angles. file of the intersesamoid ridge as viewed from its
lateral perspective is shown in Fig. 5. The ridge was
RESULTS found to be perpendicular to the transverse axis (T-
F in Fig. 5 ) and parallel to the lateral surface of
The dimensional data of the bony specimens are metatarsus.
summarized in Table 2. The transverse diameter of In the plane through the intersesamoid ridge, the
the head is the distance between the medial and articular outline had a rounded appearance, and
lateral sides when viewed from the dorsal aspect. analysis suggested the presence of a geometric cen-
The diameter had a mean of 22.9 mm and a standard ter. The radius of curvature for the intersesamoid
ridge ranged from 10.0 to 13.4 mm with a mean of
Z 11.4 mm (Table 3; Fig. 6). The trochlear surface,
T *' 11.18
however, closely approximated a series of spirals.
To estimate the extent of the cartilaginous cover,
the angle formed between limits of the cartilaginous
surface about the geometric center, C, was mea-
sured in the plane through the ridge. It was found to
have a mean of 161" (75" dorsal and 86" plantar)
(Table 4).
The skyline outline of the trochlear surfaces was
examined from the dorsal aspect at lo" increments
TI -
:
of flexion (r) within the range of 10--8o", as illus-
trated in Figs. 7 and 8. The angles a and b, formed
10.39
by the tangents drawn on cartilaginous projections
of the trochlea on its respective medial and lateral
sides to the ridge, were measured (Fig. 7). The an-
gle b on the fibular plantar face had a minimum
Y, = 4.78 z, = 3.45 value at 50" and a maximum at 80". Relatively little
.Y change was noted for angle a during varying degrees
FIG. 2. Computerized analysis. Top: A cut section made of flexion. --
through the intersesamoidal ridge. Note the circular outline
with a tightly localized geometric center, C. Bottom: Away When the skyline outlines of the MT head were
from the ridge, the cut outline was noncircular. examined from the dorsal aspect, the grooves (each
presenting a slightly concave profile) were found to thereafter, they decreased in both width and depth.
change continuously for flexion angles 0-90" (Fig. The cross-section at the tibial groove at the ridge
7). The tibial groove was usually wider and deeper featured a milder and longer slope than that at the
than the fibular groove. Both grooves tended to in- epicondyle, which was steeper and shorter. The fib-
crease in depth as angle Y increased from 40 to 70"; ular groove showed only a simple shallow valley,
which was 1.5-2 mm shallower than the tibial
groove at its deepest section. The proximal pha-
LATERAL langes had oval (width greater than height) concave
articular surfaces. The concavities were shallower
c4- 'IF 3 - 1
'\
(larger radii of curvature) than the curvature of the
MT intersesamoidal ridge.
The mean transverse diameter of the phalanx was
19.8 mm, and the mean dorsoplantar diameter was
15.2 mm. The ratio of the vertical to transverse di-
PLANTAR ameters of the phalanges had a mean of 0.77. Both
qe-3
AXIAL
4 1 51
?
F
T
sesamoids were linked to the proximal phalanx by
short sesamophalangeal ligaments. The tibial sesa-
mophalangeal ligament was shorter than the fibular,
i.e., the tibial sesamoid was located closer to the
phalangeal articulation than the fibular counterpart.
The shape and size of the sesamoids differed; the
tibial sesamoid was usually larger and more elon-
gated than the fibular side (Table 2). Similar fea-
tures were reported by Sarrafian (6). The dimen-
sions of the tibial sesamoid were 10.6 (longitudinal)
x 8.8 mm (transverse) and 10.1 x 8.6 mm for fibular
FIG. 3. Measured dimensions of a sample MTP joint. Top:
Dorsoplantar diameter (key: 1, phalanx; 2, metatarsal head; sesamoid. Analysis of the sectional outlines of the
3, metatarsal length). Center: Transverse diameter of phalanx sesamoids showed that the longitudinal section had
(4) and metatarsal head (5), with widths (66')and lengths a navicular form while the transverse section was
(7-7') of sesamoids. Bottom: Dorsoplantar (8) and transverse
(9) diameters of metatarsal head. The dimensions are shown convex with a central crest. A firm ligamentous
in Table 2. structure, the intersesamoid transverse ligament,
linked the two sesamoids; it provided the gutter-like IA). Compared with lesser metatarsal heads, the
articulation for the intersesamoid ridge. When ses- first MT head is larger and quadrilateral in general
amoids were compared, the trochlea articulation of outline. The articular surface has three distinct
the tibial sesamoid was wider and deeper than that bearing areas: a distal superior phalangeal surface
of the fibula. The weight-bearing surface of the tib- and two inferior side-by-side sesamoidal surfaces
ial trochlea was found to be 78" deviated from the (tibial and fibular) (Fig. 10). These overlap and in-
dorsoplantar axis of the MTP. When this orienta- terrelate with each other closely, so that separate
tion was combined with the medial rotation of the borders for territorial motion of each cannot be pre-
MT, as defined by Sarrafian (6) at 13", the weight- cisely identified. The phalangeal bearing area of the
bearing surface of the tibial sesamoid became par- head is smooth and convex. From the plantar as-
allel to the ground (Fig. 9). pect, a longitudinal crest, the intersesamoid ridge
rises between two grooves (trochlea). The grooves
DISCUSSION articulate with dorsal biconcave articular surfaces
of the tibial and fibular sesamoids and, in flexion,
The body of the first metatarsal, which is the with the inferior portion of the proximal phalanx. In
shortest and thickest of the five metatarsals, has a its proximal plantar extent, the ridge becomes less
well-marked prismatic form with three characteris- distinct, but the grooves continue the side-by-side
tic surfaces and borders (12): dorsomedial, lateral, articular surfaces for the sesamoids proximally
and inferior surfaces with superolateral, inferolat- (Fig. 10). Distally, the ridge and grooves merge with
eral, and inferomedial borders. The lateral surface the rounded form of the head at a point in line with
is consistently flat and appears in line with the ver- the bony axis of the bone. The outer (lateral) as-
tical orientation of the tarsometatarsal joint (Fig. pects of the MT head show bony protrusions (epi-
DISTAL VIEW
TABLE 4. Mearz values and standard deviations of tibia1 andfibular tangential angles of the ridge in relation to
flexion angle (degrees)
Flexion angle (R) 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90
Tibial angle (a) 77.6 71.3 77.4 76.5 76.9 76.8 77.3 78.5 -
(4.5) (4.3) (5.3) (5.3) (6.5) (5.7) (5.6) (5.7)
Fibular (b) 64.7 65.7 65.1 64.3 63.6 66.8 69.1 73.8 -
(8.8) (9.3) (7.6) (7.4) (6.9) (7.3) (7.7) (7.4)
Combined angle (a + b) 142.3 143.0 142.5 140.8 140.5 143.1 146.0 151.8 -
(9.1) (9.5) (7.5) (7.6) (7.6) (6.7) (5.7) (5.3)
tersesamoidal ridge were complex, representing the body weight occur via the plantar articulations.
combined side-by-side articulations of the sesa- MTP joint organization may be compared with the
moids. Geometric centers were not found for the condylar patella organization of the knee; here one
parallel cut sections of the MT head at any distance is viewing the MTP in reverse and assuming the two
from the ridge. sesamoids to be patellae, with the phalangosesa-
In the standing plantigrade position, about one moid apparatus and flexor hallucis brevis tendons
third of body weight is borne by the forepart of the to be the quadriceps mechanism. The motion of ex-
foot (12); this, carried through the head of the first tension at the MTP corresponds more to the flexion
metatarsal, equals about one sixth of body weight of the knee. In extension, the convex MT head has
(4,6). In walking, the center of gravity passes greatest contact with the elliptical concave facet of
through the big toe so that loads of more than the the phalanx; here the intersesamoid ridge does not
interrupt this conformity as it occupies the slot
made by the upward projections of the two sesa-
moids on either side of the thick plantar volar plate.
The form of this articulation is akin to a rail and
truck mechanism, which provides side-to-side sta-
bility during flexion/extension motion of the pha-
lanx. In extension beyond about O", the inter-
sesamoid ridge merges with the convex outline of
a+)l
the phalangeal articular surface. In positions of
MTP extension greater than approximately lo", the
sesamoids come to lie on this same surface, now
without sideways restraint (no ridge or groove). Be-
10 30 50 70 90 deg. Id
B '
FLEXION ANGLE
FIG. 8. Tibial (a)and fibular (p) groove tangential angles to
FIG. 7. Tibial (a)and fibular (p) tangential angles were rnea- the intersesarnoid ridge at varying degrees of flexion. The
sured in a plane of flexion (r) from the long axis. mean values and standard deviations are shown in Table 4.