Professional Documents
Culture Documents
CLINICAL IMPLICATIONS
The results of this study support a relationship between occlusal wear and noncarious
cervical volume loss for 3 teeth in a single individual. Should future studies support
this result, it could have a profound influence on diagnosis and treatment of noncar-
ious cervical lesions. If the occlusal function theory is correct, it might be possible to pro-
vide diagnostic criteria that determine susceptibility to noncarious cervical lesions,
and prevention could be as simple as an enamelplasty. Treatment of existing lesions
might also require enamelplasty to reduce stress and a judicious choice of restorative
materials that can better accommodate cervical stress.
Should such materials have their maximal properties where Vc is the cervical volume loss and C is a con-
engineered to resist toothbrush abrasion, to resist stant. This equation implies that the cervical volume
repeated flexure and microcracking, or both? Also, loss is directly proportional to the occlusal work per-
knowing the cause of noncarious cervical lesions pro- formed on the tooth (occlusal function):
vides the possibility of early diagnosis and prevention.
Vc ∝ Wt = F • L
Careful clinical observations have provided mounting
evidence in favor of the occlusal function theory. Lee
Evidence from studies of tooth biomechanics sup-
and Eakle2,3 noted an anatomic relationship between
ports the plausibility of the occlusal function theory as
occlusal wear facets and cervical lesions on the same
the pathogenesis of noncarious cervical lesions, but
tooth. Ott and Proschel’s4 clinical study found a sig-
direct, quantitative clinical evidence has been difficult to
nificant relationship between working occlusal con-
obtain. The major obstacles are accurate measurements
tacts and the wedge-shaped defects in posterior teeth.
of the volumetric loss of cervical lesions and direct mea-
Heymann et al5 also found a relationship between the
surements of the occlusal force and the excursive path.
loss of cervical restorations and the presence of a trau-
Three-dimensional digital techniques exist that enable
matic occlusion, which is expected to cause more cus-
accurate quantification of the volumetric loss of tooth
pal flexure. Grippo6 recognized the need for an
structure.8-12 Direct measurement of the occlusal force
additional category of noncarious cervical lesions to
and the excursive path length are difficult to measure at
distinguish these lesions from lesions whose cause may be
any point in time and nearly impossible to measure over
abrasion or erosion. He introduced the term abfraction.
an extended time period. A possible solution is to mea-
Finite element modeling and other studies of tooth
sure these parameters indirectly through occlusal wear,
biomechanics recently dispelled the notion that the
which can be measured very accurately using the 3-
cervical area of the tooth is a low stress area.7 Coronal
dimensional measurement techniques. Occlusal wear is
stress trajectories originating at the point of occlusal
a complex phenomenon that is influenced by occlusal
contact can reconcentrate in the cervical area of the
force, lateral excursion, and material properties such as
tooth.7 Furthermore, this observation is supported
the yield hardness (H). The relationship between these
clinically by the placement of strain gages on the buc-
parameters is expressed by the equation:
cal surfaces of teeth and the use of a bite force trans-
ducer to construct stress-strain curves for the tooth
V/L = K • F/H
crown in situ. These studies showed that buccolingual
flexure of the crown occurs clinically and that the where V is the volumetric loss that occurs while the
point of maximum flexure is in the cervical area. teeth are in contact over the distance L, F is the
Clinical observations by Heymann et al5 and Lee occlusal force, and K is a constant referred to as the
and Eakle3 noted that occlusal force and lateral excur- wear coefficient.9 It is reasonable to assume that the
sion are the chief etiologic agents of the noncarious material properties of enamel are the same in the pos-
cervical lesion. Based on this observation, the occlusal terior region of the same mouth and are relatively sta-
function theory states that the volumetric loss of tooth ble with time. This leaves the simpler concept that
structure in the noncarious cervical lesion is a function occlusal wear, as measured by volume loss, is propor-
of the occlusal force (F) and lateral excursion (L) over tional to the occlusal force times the lateral excursion:
which that force is applied. An expression for the rela-
V0 ∝ F • L
tionship between occlusal force and lateral excursion
can be derived from the equation for work performed where V0 is defined to be the occlusal volume loss.
on a body (W): Thus, measuring the volume loss on the occlusal sur-
face provides an indirect measure of the total amount
W=f•d
of force applied to the tooth and where it was applied
where f is the force applied to the body and d is the to the tooth during the measurement time interval.
distance through which the body moves. Substituting Comparing the occlusal wear equation with the
occlusal force for f and lateral excursion for d, the work occlusal function theory equation yields a relationship
performed on a tooth (Wt) is expressed as: between cervical volume loss and occlusal volume loss:
Wt = F • L Vc ∝ F • L ∝ V0
Assuming a simple linear relationship, the occlusal The purpose of this study was to investigate the
function theory for noncervical lesions can be occlusal function theory prediction that there is a cor-
expressed by the equation: relation between the growth of a noncarious cervical
lesion and the occlusal force applied to that tooth over
Vc = C • F • L = C • W the excursive path. The growth of the cervical lesion
was measured by volume loss in the lesion, and the
effect of occlusal force and lateral excursion was mea- and occlusal surfaces of each tooth, or about 75,000
sured indirectly by the volume loss on the occlusal sur- points for each replica.
face. The hypothesis was that there is a significant Sequential clinical impressions of the same teeth of
positive correlation between the 2 volume measure- the subject were made with vinyl polysiloxane impres-
ments. If this hypothesis proves to be true, it will help sion material (Express, 3M) supported in quadrant
clarify the cause of noncarious cervical lesions. metal trays and poured with epoxy in 1991 (8 years),
1994 (11 years), and 1997 (14 years). These replicas
MATERIAL AND METHODS
were digitized by using the same method described for
This preliminary study reports the results for a single the baseline.
male adult who was under the age of 30 at the start of The digital data were processed by using AnSur-NT
the study and who had documented noncarious cervical software (Regents, University of Minnesota, Minneapolis,
lesions that were observed over a 14-year time interval. Minn.). Color contour maps and 3-dimensional numeric
The subject grew up in a community with fluoridated comparisons were produced of the “before” and “after”
water, had excellent periodontal health and oral noncarious cervical lesions and occlusal surfaces.
hygiene, used no specific toothpaste, brushed primarily AnSur-NT software uses state-of-the-art techniques
with electric toothbrushes, had no unusual dietary and 6 degrees of freedom to fit the “before” and
habits, was restoration free, and had minor orthodontic “after” surfaces. The 2 numerical data sets for the before
treatment to correct the alignment of the anterior teeth. and after replicas are rendered on the computer monitor
The subject stated that he bruxed and clenched, but he as gray-scaled surfaces for easy visualization. Each sur-
did not report any muscle pain or discomfort. face is constructed from triangular surface areas that
Full maxillary and mandibular arch die stone models use the data set points as vertices.
from the subject were used as the 1983 Baseline. On one of the rendered images, an area was outlined
Articulation of the casts revealed a Class III malocclu- in which little surface change was expected. The 2 sur-
sion (group function) on the right and a Class I faces were fit to each other by minimizing the distance
canine-guided occlusion on the left. Quadrant replicas between the 2 data sets in the outlined area. The distance
were made from the stone models using a vinyl poly- was calculated as the z-difference between points with the
siloxane impression material (Express, 3M, St Paul, same x,y coordinates. For each x,y,z point in the outlined
Minn.), supported in quadrant metal trays and poured area in the before data set, the z value for the corre-
with epoxy die material (Epoxy-Die, Ivoclar, Schaan, sponding x,y coordinates in the after data set was calcu-
Liechtenstein). These epoxy replicas were digitized by lated by identifying the triangular surface that contained
using a null-point contact stylus system, as described the x,y coordinates, then calculating the z value using lin-
previously.8,10 A customized tungsten carbide stylus ear interpolation.
with a spherical tip (55 µm radius) was used to digitize The quality of the fit was measured by the RMS/pt
the replicas. The digitizer’s software corrected the mea- of the 2 z values. The RMS/pt is used to calculate
sured data for the stylus thickness. The precision and errors for all measured values. After the surfaces were
accuracy of this profiling system (digitized data plus fit, the differences between the 2 surfaces were high-
computer alignment) were determined by following a lighted by a contour map superimposed on one of the
method similar to that suggested by Hewlett et al.13 surfaces. Areas of difference highlighted by the con-
The upper hemisphere of a grade 5 precision ball tour map were outlined. Examining the individual
bearing with a diameter of 4.000 mm was digitized profiles was used to refine the border of an area.
and then compared with a mathematically generated Descriptive parameters, such as volume loss, surface
data set for the ball bearing. For each x,y coordinate area, maximum depth, and mean depth, were calculat-
point in the digitized data set, the z-difference between ed for areas of interest.
the corresponding point in the mathematical data set AnSur-NT software was used to measure surface
was calculated. Precision and accuracy were calculated changes for both the noncarious cervical lesions and
as a function of surface angle (0% is defined to be hor- the occlusal wear. The descriptive parameters for com-
izontal). Precision is defined as the root mean squared paring the noncarious cervical lesion and the occlusal
difference per point (RMS/pt), and accuracy is wear facets on the mandibular left premolars and
defined as the mean magnitude of this difference. The molar were volume loss (mm3), mean loss of depth
mean accuracy and precision for surface angles from 0 to (microns), and anatomic location of the morphologic
60 degrees are 5 ± 2 µm and 3 ± 2 µm, respectively.11 change. Volume loss was calculated by using Simpson’s
Differences are typically less than 10 µm. rule14 to integrate the z-differences over the region
All replicas were digitized with a series of profiles. defined by area border. The error in the volume calcu-
Each profile was separated by 100 µm, and within each lation is estimated as the RMS/pt times the projected
profile the surface was digitized in 50-µm steps. surface area in the XY plane, plus a calculation error,
Approximately 25,000 points represented the facial for the Simpson’s method. Mean loss of depth is the
Fig. 1. Noncarious cervical lesions on mandibular left first and second premolars and first
molar, at 1983-Baseline; 1991-8 years; 1994-11 years; and 1997-14 years. Noncarious
lesions are wedge-shaped with sharp line angles.
Volume loss Mean depth Volume loss Mean depth Volume loss Mean depth
Tooth (mm3) (µm) (mm3) (µm) (mm3) (µm)
average of the z-differences over the area defined by of these gray-scaled images by volume and mean depth
the border and is reported with the standard deviation. is presented in Table I. An example of the corresponding
The correlation coefficient (r) was calculated for the loss because of occlusal wear is presented in gray-scale
paired occlusal and cervical volume loss data to deter- contours in Figure 2 for the first premolar. Table II pre-
mine whether a relationship exists and, if a relationship sents the occlusal volume loss and mean depth.
does exist, the direction of the relationship. The null Typical fitted profiles through the noncarious cervi-
hypothesis tested was that there is no relationship cal lesions for the baseline and the 14-year interval are
between the volume loss of the cervical lesions and the shown in Figure 3, where the location of the profile is
volume loss of occlusal wear for the same tooth (r = 0). indicated by the vertical line on the buccal face. The
The hypothesis was tested at the 5% level of signifi- correlation between the volume loss for cervical and
cance with the JMP 3.0 statistical software (SAS occlusal lesions is based on 9 measurements, 3 teeth
Institute, Cary, N.C.). (mandibular left first and second premolars and molar)
at 3 time periods (8, 11, and 14 years) (Fig. 4). The
RESULTS
correlation coefficient was calculated for the noncari-
The increase in size of the noncarious cervical lesions ous cervical lesion volume loss and occlusal wear vol-
for each of the successive years is depicted in the gray- ume loss. A strong correlation (r2=0.98) was found,
scaled images in Figure 1. The loss represented on each which was significant (P<.0001). A line of best fit,
Fig. 2. Occlusal surface of mandibular left first premolar shows 2 wear facets on mesial (blue)
and distal (pink) inclines of buccal cusp at baseline, 8 years, and 11 years that have merged
into 1 wear facet at 14 years.
Volume loss Mean depth Volume loss Mean depth Volume loss Mean depth
Tooth (mm3) (µm) (mm3) (µm) (mm3) (µm)
according to the least-squares criteria, yielded the that there is a significant positive correlation between
equation: the 2 volume measurements was accepted. Concurrent
with the acceptance of the hypothesis was the accep-
Cervical volume loss = –0.18 + 1.5 × occlusal volume loss
tance of the implied relationship between the volume
loss of the cervical lesion (Vc), occlusal force (F), and
DISCUSSION
lateral excursion (L):
The volumetric measurements in Tables I and II
Vc ∝ F • L
show a significant correlation (r2=0.98; P<.0001)
between tooth-matched occlusal wear and the noncar- The high correlation found in our study supports
ious cervical loss. For the single subject in this study, the clinical observations of Heymann et al5 and Lee
the null hypothesis was rejected, and the hypothesis and Eakle,3 who noted that occlusal force and lateral