You are on page 1of 20

O2

H2 NH3
Electrolysis

O2

Air N2
separation

CO2 CCS

Steam
reforming
H2 NH3

LNG
O2

Air N2
separation

MAN B&W
two-stroke engine
operating on
ammonia
2 MAN Energy Solutions
MAN B&W two-stroke engine operating on ammonia

Future
in the
making
3

Contents
1. Introduction 05
2. United effort towards a future decarbonising fuel 06
3. Reflections on ammonia as a future two-stroke marine fuel 07
4. In the process of developing the first two-stroke, dual-fuelled engine for ammonia 11
5. Summary and outlook 15
6. Bibliography 16
7. Acronyms and abbreviations 17
4 MAN Energy Solutions
MAN B&W two-stroke engine operating on ammonia

Ammonia as a marine fuel is put into perspective as


this paper presents our current knowledge about
ammonia as a potential long-term fuel for
two-stroke marine engines. We address the
challenges encountered by the maritime market,
which are best described as a paradigm shift to
ensure compliance with global decarbonisation
goals.

To develop an engine for a new fuel such as


ammonia calls for partnerships, cooperation and an
understanding of the market interests. MAN Energy
Solutions works diligently towards designing the
MAN B&W engine for operation on ammonia and
offering retrofit conversions of existing two-stroke
engines to ammonia.

Decarbonisation constitutes one of the largest


transitions encountered, and the short deadline to
succeed requires a united and committed approach
from the entire supply chain from well to wake.
5

1. Introduction

One of the future fuel candidates Another distinctive feature is the ability processes, that is, ignition, combustion
receiving a growing global interest and to operate on almost any fuel or fuel and emissions as well as fuel handling.
likely to play a significant role in the quality with no or limited decrease in
decarbonisation is ammonia (NH3). Our efficiency and with the reliable Therefore, research of ammonia as a
aim with this paper is to share our performance and operating fuel for two-stroke engines involves
current knowledge about ammonia as a characteristics as the conventional extensive testing with a complete
potential long-term fuel for two-stroke two-stroke engine even in adverse engine monitoring setup to achieve
marine engines and to give a new weather conditions. fundamental information about, for
update on the development of an example, the ignition properties of
ammonia-based propulsion. The fundamental reasons for the large ammonia in a two-stroke engine, pilot
tolerance to poorly ignitable and fuel requirements and emissions. These
Thanks to the carbon- and sulphur-free burning fuels are the low speed of the research results will govern the final
molecular composition of NH3, engine, allowing time for the design of the ammonia-burning engine
combusting it in an engine creates combustion to finish, and the large and auxiliary systems.
near-zero CO2 and SOX emissions. dimensions, leading to large
From a well-to-wake perspective, volume-to-surface ratios, which is
ammonia becomes a carbon-neutral beneficial for a complete combustion
fuel when produced from renewable and low wall heat losses.
energy sources like electricity
produced from hydropower, wind or The beneficial carbon-free nature of
solar energy. Furthermore, emissions of ammonia also implicates that ammonia
air pollutants related to carbon (black combustion physics will not fully
carbon or soot, unburned resemble the combustion
hydrocarbons (HC), methane slip, and characteristics of previously known
carbon monoxide (CO)) are eliminated. two-stroke fuels. To provide our
customers with an optimised and
One of the characteristics defining the reliable engine of the well-known
two-stroke engine portfolio of MAN standard of MAN Energy Solutions, it is
Energy Solutions in Fig. 1 is the fuel vital to research the entire propulsion
diversity. solution and two-stroke engine

LNG Ethane Methanol LPG Ammonia

ME-GI ME-GA ME-GIE ME-LGIM ME-LGIP → 2024

Fig. 1: MAN B&W dual-fuel two-stroke engine portfolio


6 MAN Energy Solutions
MAN B&W two-stroke engine operating on ammonia

2. United effort towards a future decarbonising fuel

At MAN Energy Solutions, we are an ammonia-based propulsion system. The Maersk Mc-Kinney Moller Center
committed to optimise the MAN Energy Solutions is the AEngine for Zero Carbon Shipping will be an
environmental impact of our engines. project coordinator and a part of the independent research centre, bringing
To develop an engine for new fuels cross-functional project team together together stakeholders from the shipping
such as ammonia calls for partnerships with Eltronic FuelTech (fuel supply sector, industry, academia and
and an understanding of the market systems), the Technical University of authorities. A highly specialised,
interests. An analysis of the actual Denmark and the classification society cross-disciplinary team will collaborate
potential is also essential before DNV GL [1]. globally to create overviews of
starting the development of the decarbonisation pathways, accelerate
ammonia engine. In this case, the fuel MAN Energy Solutions will integrate the development of selected
can enter the market as an intermediate existing technology in the decarbonising fuels and powering
fuel until green ammonia is available ammonia-based propulsion system technologies, and support the
and the logistics are in place. while designing the ammonia fuel establishment of regulatory, financial,
injection, combustion components, and commercial means to enable the
Minimising the impact of shipping on exhaust gas after-treatment technology transformation.
the climate and the environment is a and engine components. In addition,
crucial contribution to reaching the MAN Energy Solutions will provide the Furthermore, besides working closely
global climate targets. One of the engine test bed and conduct the engine together with our licensee Mitsui
ultimate goals would be carbon-neutral trial run. Engineering & Shipbuilding in a
transportation. Currently, worldwide partnership agreement we also work
maritime transport emits around 3% of As a step on the transition path towards together with different universities.
the global greenhouse gas (GHG) decarbonisation, Maersk, MAN Energy
emissions. Like other industries, the Solutions and five partners have joined
marine industry must decarbonise, and forces in launching the Maersk
the International Maritime Organization Mc-Kinney Moller Center for Zero
(IMO) has set a target of net-zero CO2 Carbon Shipping in Copenhagen [2].
emissions from shipping by 2050. Brian Østergaard Sørensen, Vice
President and Head of R&D Two-Stroke
Another uncertain and most essential Business at MAN Energy Solutions, has
parameter in the decision of the future framed the nature and successful
fuel is the prices of the future fuels. On progress of the present task:
the one hand, if green ammonia was
available today, it would be several “Decarbonisation will be one of the
times more expensive than largest transitions that we will see
very-low-sulphur fuel oil (VLSFO) and within the maritime industry for years
LNG. On the other hand, we and requires a holistic approach looking
acknowledge that the marine market at the complete supply chain from well
widely understands that if CO2 and to wake. No technology or company
GHG footprints are to be reduced for can do this alone, which is why we
the foreseeable future, some kind of need to join forces across the supply
international regulation of the CO2 and chain to meet this challenge. We at
GHG emissions needs to come into MAN Energy Solutions have
force. decarbonisation as part of our
corporate strategy, and developing
We have entered into commitments sustainable technologies and solutions
with other players to investigate the is at the core of what we do. While
opportunity for ammonia as the coming two-stroke engine technology will likely
future fuel and hydrogen carrier. remain the prime mover for deep-sea
shipping, cleaner fuels will play a larger
In this connection, we are happy to role in the future. MAN Energy Solutions
announce that the Innovation Fund recognises that there are several
Denmark has decided to support the pathways to achieving a carbon-neutral
development within the framework of economy and that we need to work
the project AEngine, the project’s aim together, which is why we are happy to
being the design and demonstration of have joined the Center.”
7

3. Reflections on ammonia as a future two-stroke marine fuel

Physical/chemical properties of or from electrolysis of water, as outlined temperature (20°C). To keep it in the
ammonia govern many of the design in more detail below. liquid phase if the ambient temperature
aspects of an ammonia-fuelled increases, it is common to design
propulsion system and auxiliary For comparison, Table 1 shows the non-refrigerated ammonia tanks for
systems, including storage. physical properties of ammonia, other approximately 18 bar.
alternative fuels, and MGO.
Vessel owners have to consider
ammonia storage and availability, Currently, parameters for fuel supply 3.2 Transition towards green
vessel trade pattern and related and injection pressures for NH3 are 80 ammonia production
emission regulations combined with an bar and 600–700 bar, respectively.
increased focus on the environmental However, these parameters make up Although it is in the nature of things that
impact of the vessels. the topics of further research and combustion of ammonia emits no CO2,
optimisation in the engine test scheme. as it contains no carbon atoms,
large-scale industrial productions of
3.1 Physical properties A comparison of the properties related ammonia are based mainly on a fossil
to storage in Table 1 shows that fuel feedstock for grey and blue
Generally, ammonia is produced via the hydrogen (H2) liquefies when cooled to ammonia production. This conventional
Haber-Bosch synthesis process from temperatures below -253°C, and LNG ammonia production produces CO2 as
hydrogen and nitrogen. While the at -162°C. By contrast, ammonia a by-product. Blue ammonia
nitrogen comes from air separation, liquefies already at -33°C. production involves capture of the
several production routes can be used generated CO2, which is liquefied and
to produce hydrogen, most prominently Liquid ammonia can be stored at a stored using the carbon capture and
from steam reforming of hydrocarbons pressure above 8.6 bar at ambient storage (CCS) principles.

Energy Energy Fuel tank size Supply Emission reduction


Energy storage type/chemical structure content, LHV density relative to MGO pressure compared to HFO Tier II [%]
[MJ/kg] [MJ/L] [bar] SOX NOX CO2 PM
Ammonia (NH 3) 18.6 12.7 (-33°C) 2.8 (-33°C)*1 Compliant
(liquid, -33°C) 10.6 (45°C ) 3.4 (45°C)*1 80 100 with regulation ~90 ~90
Methanol (CH 3 OH)
(65°C) 19.9 14.9 2.4 10 90–97 30–50 11 90
LPG (liquid, -42°C) 46.0 26.7 1.3 *2 50 90–100 10–15 13–18 90
LNG (liquid, -162°C) 50.0 21.2 1.7 *2 300 90–99 20–30 24 90
LEG (liquid, -89°C) 47.5 25.8 1.4 *2 380 90–97 30–50 15 90
MGO 42.7 35.7 1.0 7–8
Hydrogen (H 2) (liquid, -253°C) 120 8.5 4.2
1)
The relative fuel tank size for ammonia has been provided for both cooled (-33°C) and pressurised tanks (45°C)
2)
Assuming fully refrigerated media

Table 1: Alternative fuel comparison


8 MAN Energy Solutions
MAN B&W two-stroke engine operating on ammonia

However, ammonia has the potential to nitrogen, air is liquefied and separated industrial processes and as an
become the sustainable future fuel into its constituents. agricultural fertiliser means that it is
choice, when it is produced using already a commercially attractive
hydrogen obtained by using renewal However, when it comes to the product
energy sources, see Fig. 2. ammonia synthesis, the Haber-Bosch
process is still the industrially applied – It is less expensive and less complex
Ammonia (or anhydrous ammonia) is a method. to transport and store than hydrogen
globally traded commodity. The annual and other fuels in need of cryogenic
global ammonia production is temperatures
approximately 180 million tonnes, of 3.3 Challenges and advantages of
which approximately 80% becomes ammonia fuel – T
 he low risk of ignition in an ambient
feedstock for fertiliser production [3]. atmosphere makes the storage of
Therefore, transport and storage of There are challenges but also large quantities of ammonia safer
ammonia from production facilities to advantages associated with storage, than hydrogen in terms of fire safety.
end users have been going on for transport and combustion of ammonia
years. governed by the physical and chemical The lower heating value (LHV) of ap-
properties [3], see also Table 1: proximately 18.6 MJ/kg for ammonia is
3.2.1 Electrolysis of water comparable to methanol. The energy
To produce sustainable green ammonia – N
 H3 is carbon- and sulphur-free and density per unit volume of ammonia
using hydrogen obtained by electrolysis gives a clean combustion with (12.7 MJ/L) and the other alternative
of water (2H2O → 2H2 + O2), the near-zero generation of CO2 or SOX fuels, is lower than that of MGO (35
electricity must be produced using only MJ/L). To carry the same energy con-
renewable energy sources. – T
 he volumetric energy density of NH3 tent of ammonia relative to MGO will
is higher than for H2 require an approximately 2.8 times
3.2.2 Nitrogen separation from air larger volume if the ammonia tank is
Separation of nitrogen from air for – NH3 can be cracked to N2 and H2 cooled.
ammonia production takes place via
various technologies depending on the – NH3 is non-explosive unlike H2 Although ammonia has the potential to
required purity and amount of become the future fuel, it is a toxic
ammonia. In large-scale productions of – The widespread use of ammonia in substance that, regulation-wise, has

O2

H2
Electrolysis

O2

Air
separation
N2

Fig. 2: Illustration of green ammonia production


9

not yet been released for use as a vaporisation, which acts to cool the storage, supply, engine, and
marine fuel. in-cylinder charge. These combined after-treatment systems.
effects can make the Diesel-type
compression ignition of directly Despite the high toxicity, methods to
3.4 Thermophysical properties of injected liquid ammonia challenging. safely handle ammonia have also been
ammonia developed in other industrial
Ammonia also has an unusually high applications – such as refrigeration.
Some of the physical properties of minimum ignition energy, which can be Ammonia has been stored and
ammonia differ significantly from those challenging for igniting a premixed transported in tanks under modest
of other fuels typically used for marine ammonia/air mixture with an ignition pressure similar to LPG, and bulk
propulsion (see Table 1). These system. However, these properties also transport of ammonia on board large
differences will dictate both the have some positive aspects. These chemical tankers is done using
combustion system and the include a high resistance to knocking established technology. It is a common
performance layout of an ammonia (indicated by the research octane global commodity, which means that
two-stroke engine. number (RON)), which enables high the handling and shipping infrastructure
compression ratios in engines using is readily available.
Even though ammonia has a lower LHV premixed combustion, increasing the
than most other standard fuels, the low efficiency. Because of the low reactivity, the
stoichiometric air-fuel ratio hazards of accidental combustion or
compensates for this, resulting in a explosions are much lower than for
comparable in-cylinder energy content. 3.4.1 Handling characteristics of other fuel gases and liquids. Despite
In this context, ammonia is similar to ammonia the high toxicity to humans, a slip of
methanol. Ammonia as a fuel has a low The physical properties for storage and ammonia to the environment, even in
flame speed compared to the other fuel distribution are similar to those of large amounts, leaves no significant
common fuels. This leads to a slower liquefied petroleum gas (LPG). long-term effects. Due to the high
combustion process, which can reduce volatility in the gas phase, large
the efficiency. From a handling perspective, the most solubility in water, and rather high
important aspect of ammonia is its high chemical reactivity in water, it is readily
Ammonia has a high autoignition acute toxicity, which will have diluted and disintegrated in the
temperature and a high heat of consequences for the design of environment.

NH3
10 MAN Energy Solutions
MAN B&W two-stroke engine operating on ammonia

3.5 Trends in marine fuels The question remains whether a part of The shipping industry has updated its
the existing fleet will be CO2 /GHG GHG emission reduction targets to
As phrased by Thomas S Hansen, regulated even stricter than required by 20% reduction by 2030, and 70% by
Head of Promotion & Customer the energy-efficiency design index 2040, aiming for net-zero emissions by
Support at MAN Energy Solutions: “No (EEDI) or the energy-efficiency around 2050. The adoption of
one can afford to go green alone“. operational indicator (EEOI), or if alternative fuels is emphasised, with a
regulations will apply only to new goal to account for at least 5% of the
Introduction of regulation initiatives will vessels from a certain date [4]. Based energy use by 2030. Expectations for
be one of the cornerstones of the on the assumption that CO2 /GHG fossil fuels to remain in the maritime
transition. To incentivise the industry to regulations will become effective within industry for many years to come are
invest in equipment for future fuels, the next few years, a regulation of both lower based on the new MEPC80
regulation initiatives governed by existing and new vessels might be regulations.
subsidies, CO2 or GHG taxes have to expected. Not to the same extent, but
be introduced. in a way that allows the environment This possibility will lower the risk
the impeding benefit from the CO2 related to investing in a ship operating
The general public opinion is that the emission reduction and at the same on ammonia, since conventional
global warming challenge needs to be time avoids distorting the industry. ammonia is a commercial commodity
addressed and that the maritime traded in large quantities.
industry must contribute to the CO2 When looking at the market, we have
emission reduction. Today, the maritime picked up a distinct preference for
industry accounts for approximately ammonia compared to hydrogen. The
3% of the global human-caused CO2 explosion risk is one argument, but the
emission. The existing fleet consumes discussion more often concerns the
close to 300 million tonnes of fuel oil actual handling of hydrogen and the
annually. However, it also plays a cost of handling it ashore and on
fundamental role in the global board. Another important aspect is the
economy, transporting more than 80% high energy consumption required to
of the world’s total trade volume [3]. liquefy hydrogen at -253°C, a more
efficient approach is to use the
3.5.1 Prediction of the future fuel hydrogen gas in the production of
It is difficult, if not impossible, to ammonia, which liquefies at -33°C.
predict which fuels will carry off the title Handling of hydrogen is complicated
as future fuels. Since the future costs of and expensive compared to the
different fuels is hard to predict, the ammonia solution. Engineering a
shipowners want to be prepared. They practical solution for handling hydrogen
are aware that the transition requires that can be adapted to a typical
new fuels instead of the fuels we know two-stroke engine room is not without
today. The shipowners face a complex its hurdles. Still, many projects are
puzzle in the light of carbon-free or ongoing and continuously increasing in
carbon-neutral fuel prices several times number. The projects concern the
higher than the fuel oil prices today, development of production facilities,
and the fact that fuel often makes up logistics, propulsion plant engines, and
the largest operational costs for fuel supply systems (FSS) to handle
vessels. ammonia.

3.5.2 Regulation initiatives The early, considerable, and increasing


For future CO2-emission-free fuels to interest in using ammonia as a fuel
become attractive, the fuel prices, made it part of the zero-emission
when considering all costs/incentives, strategy of MAN Energy Solutions to
must be comparable with traditional investigate and provide technology that
fuel prices. If achieved by a CO2 /GHG utilises ammonia as fuel.
regulation as mentioned, the period for
engine conversion to a future fuel can 3.5.3 Ammonia fuel mixture
be short once the regulation becomes Today, many of the vessels delivered
effective, and the implications to are ready for later dual-fuel adaption,
shipowners and yards must not be as the engine builders are ready or
underestimated. working on being ready to retrofit their
engine design accordingly.
11

4. In the process of developing the first two-stroke,


dual-fuelled engine for ammonia

As Fig. 3 shows, one of the conducted several hazard able to confirm the R&D potential of am-
characteristics describing the identification, and hazard and monia as a fuel during July 2023, when
two-stroke engine portfolio of MAN operability studies (hazid/hazop) the first combustion confirmations tests
Energy Solutions is the fuel diversity. together with classification societies, were obtained at the test facility
Since the beginning, the development shipowners, yards and system Research Centre Copenhagen (RCC) of
of the MAN B&W two-stroke engine has suppliers. MAN Energy Solutions [5].
been adapted to combust diverse fuel
types. Presently, we are working on verifying When the engine design is released,
the development concept of the the first engine can be prepared for test
In 2019, the journey towards a injection system and the engine design bed. The ammonia development
two-stroke engine operating on in general. We finalised the project reaches a major milestone
ammonia began, as illustrated in Fig. 4. development process of the ammonia when the first ammonia engine is
engine in 2021 and the commercial installed in a vessel during the first six
We started a pre-study of the fuel design verification is scheduled for months of 2024.
supply and injection concept and 2023. At the same time, we have been

Engine delivery Engine delivery ME-GI retrofit First sea trial First sea trial First order of MAN 4 x MAN B&W ME Hapaq Lloyd
for TOTE Maritime for TEEKAY LNG for Nakilat on methanol ethane B&W6G60ME-LGIP LGIP retrofit orders 9S90ME-C ME-GI
engines by Exmar for BW LPG, retrofit, dry dock
dry dock 2020 2020

2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020

ME-GI test at Demonstration Demonstration Development Ethane ME-GI/E PVU LPG testrig at LPG tightness LGIP cylinder
Research Centre test at HHI test at MES of ME-LGI development at RRC RCC and function installed on the ME-GA multi-fuel
Copenhagen (RCC) test at RCC research engine &
at RCC ammonia engine

Fig. 3: Fuel diversity and engine types

2019 2020 2021 2022 2023 2024

Pre-study Project kick-off Engine concept R&D Engine combustion Full scale engine 1st engine delivery
and emission test to yard

✓ N
 H 3 combustibility ✓ 4T50ME-X test ✓ Engine basic ✓ A
 mmonia fuel ✓ 1
 st bunkering of  ull scale engine
– F
investigation. engine received as concept defined supply & auxiliary ammonia at RCC. test at RCC
platform for the based on R&D and systems established evaluated for 1st
ammonia engine devel- simulations. in Research Centre ✓ 1
 st engine commercial design.
opment. Copenhagen (RCC). confirmation at
✓ A
 mmonia fuel supply RCC.  st ammonia fueled
– 1
✓ H
 AZID workshop on & auxiliary systems ✓ 1
 cylinder engine engine delivered to
engine concept. specified. and auxiliary system  ull scale design
– F yard.
preparation at RCC. work.
✓ C
 ombustion
chamber 1st  pecification of
– S
evaluation. emission
after-treatment.

Fig. 4: Two-stroke ammonia engine development schedule


12 MAN Energy Solutions
MAN B&W two-stroke engine operating on ammonia

4.1 Engine foundation resources onboard. This is achieved In principle, the main differences
without fundamentally changing the between the fuel characteristics
When designing an engine governed ship operation. An advantage of the governing the ME-LGIP and the
by altered combustion physics due to ammonia-fuelled low-speed ammonia engine designs are related to
the chemical composition of a new two-stroke engine is that it will not heating values, the foul odour, and the
fuel, it requires thorough research of fundamentally change merchant corrosive nature of ammonia:
the influence on all conceivable engine shipbuilding or operation, and thus a – lower heating values (LHV) of the
design parameters to provide an simple and well-engineered solution is fuels:
efficient and safe engine and fuel in place to cater for the requirements  ⎼ 46.0 MJ/kg for propane (LPG)
supply system to the customers. of this novel fuel.  ⎼ 18.6 MJ/kg for ammonia

Currently, MAN Energy Solutions The findings will also govern the FSS – a
 mmonia is corrosive to copper,
carries out research at the RCC and in configuration. Part of the ongoing copper alloys, alloys with a nickel
different partnerships to assess the testing includes installation aspects concentration larger than 6%, and
combustion and heat release and the FSS design will eventually be plastic
characteristics of ammonia. The adapted to the outcome, we assume
findings of the research will guide the that the configuration for ammonia will The ideal solution is to reuse part of the
development of the specific fuel inherit main features from the dual-fuel LPG injection system on the
injection properties and clarify the well-known LGP supply system for ammonia engine and part of the LPG
nature of two-stroke emissions, when liquid injection. fuel supply system from tank to engine
operating on ammonia. [6].
As for the engine, development of an
Ammonia is a toxic substance, and FSS calls for a safe and reliable design
proper safety measures must be in based on the outcome of hazid and 4.2 Fuel supply system
place to safeguard the ship’s crew and hazop investigations. Currently, we considerations
the surrounding environment. In have performed three hazid
addition to catering for these investigations observed by Fig. 5 and the following sections
requirements, MAN Energy Solutions representatives from the classification highlight the main principles of the fuel
brings technology to the market that is societies, shipowners, yards and supply system for the ammonia engine
engineered to adapt to the skills and suppliers of components for the FSS. and dual-fuel operation.
work routines of the crew and the

Ammonia capture N2 vent


system
Vent air outlet
Recirculation Dry air inlet
system Knockout
drum
Knockout (engine)
LT drum HC FS
(system) FVT
Gas
safe
area ▸

FSS
LS
HP Heater/
cooler Gas
From NH3 pump safe
supply system area ▸

MAN B&W
engine
Nitrogen
Cooling supply
water

Fig. 5 Principles of the ammonia supply system showing main components


13

4.2.1 Principles of dual-fuel is delivered to the engine at the to the nitrogen separator, and
operation required temperature, pressure and ammonia in the vapour phase is
During dual-fuel operation, the quality. In most cases, the FSS has a captured in several columns filled with
ammonia fuel supply to the engine high-pressure pump, a heater, filters, water. The amount of ammonia
comes from the storage tanks via the valves, and control systems to maintain emission is controlled by the total
fuel supply system. To maintain the the ammonia fuel pressure and water volume in the columns. During
required fuel conditions at the engine, a temperature at varying engine operation of the ACS, part of the water
small portion of the ammonia fuel consumptions. is drained off and replaced by
continuously recirculates to the FSS via freshwater.
the recirculation system. 4.2.4 Fuel valve train
When the engine is not in dual-fuel The fuel valve train (FVT) is the 4.2.8 Safety and control systems
mode, the double block-and-bleed interface between the engine and The engine control system used for an
arrangements of the FVT depressurise auxiliary systems. The purpose of the ammonia engine is based on the
and completely isolate ammonia fuel FVT is to ensure a safe isolation of the system used for previous dual-fuel
systems inside the engine room from engine during shutdown and engines such as ME-GI (natural gas)
ammonia fuel supply and return maintenance, and to provide a and ME-LGIP (LPG). However, most
systems. Before every start, the nitrogen-purging functionality. The similarities are found with the ME-LGIM
systems are pressurised with nitrogen engine software control system (methanol) system.
to verify the tightness of the system. actively monitors and controls the
valves in the FVT. This functionality The control and safety strategies used
When dual-fuel operation stops, the ensures a safe environment on the for methanol and ammonia are largely
nitrogen pressure pushes back the engine after shutdown. unchanged since the demands are
ammonia fuel from the engine to the quite similar. Both media are toxic to
recirculation system. When the purging 4.2.5 Nitrogen system humans and pose a significant fire
sequence is complete, the FVT will Nitrogen must be available for purging hazard if they enter the engine room.
once again ensure the isolation of the engine after dual-fuel operation, for
engine room systems from supply and gas freeing prior to maintenance and The double-walled piping is
return systems. for tightness testing after maintenance. continuously monitored to detect fuel
The capacity of the nitrogen system leakages during engine operation. A
Throughout the entire operation, the must be large enough to deliver a positive detection leads to a controlled
double-walled ventilation system from certain flow at a pressure higher than stop of ammonia operation on the
existing MAN Energy Solutions the service tank pressure. The flow engine while the piping containing
dual-fuel engines detects any ammonia required depends on the engine size. ammonia is purged clean using
fuel leakage and directs it away from nitrogen, and any further leakage is
the engine room to a separate ammonia 4.2.6 Double-walled ventilation prevented. Note that a leakage takes
trapping system. system place from the inner to the outer pipe
To maintain a safe engine room, it is and not to the engine room. This
4.2.2 Recirculation system vital to detect any leakages from the additional barrier keeps the ship and
The recirculated ammonia fuel will heat ammonia fuel system and direct these crew safe at all times.
up in the engine during operation. To to a safe location. This has led to the
avoid two-phase conditions, a certain double-walled design of ammonia fuel
amount of ammonia fuel is recirculated systems and piping inside the engine 4.3 Emission reduction technologies
to a dedicated recirculation line. The room. A constant flow of ventilation air
same recirculation line recovers the is kept in the outer pipe in accordance It is expected, that the raw engine NOX
ammonia fuel from the engine whenever with IMO requirements. The system is emission level of a two-stroke engine
dual-fuel operation is stopped. already part of other MAN B&W running on ammonia will be at a level
dual-fuel engine designs. comparable to a conventional
The recirculated fuel may contain low-speed diesel engine. However, the
traces of sealing oil from the injection 4.2.7 Ammonia capture system pathway of NOX production during
valves. The recirculation line eliminates Ammonia systems must be designed combustion is quite different from the
the risk of contaminating fuel storage with an ammonia capture system (ACS) conventional engine, and hence also
tanks with oil. The recirculation line also to prevent release of ammonia to the the sensitivity to changes in engine
separates and bleeds off nitrogen from surroundings. The system consists of a performance.
the recovered ammonia fuel. knockout drum where the ammonia
pressure will be released, see Fig. 5. Obviously, ammonia will only be an
4.2.3 Fuel supply system Flash evaporation results in ammonia environmentally viable fuel if emissions
The FSS contains the equipment in liquid and vapour phases in the known from a conventional engine are
necessary to ensure that ammonia fuel drum. The liquid phase is pushed back not merely replaced with other types of
14 MAN Energy Solutions
MAN B&W two-stroke engine operating on ammonia

harmful emissions. Naturally, it is an removed from the exhaust gas in a


important part of MAN Energy catalytic reduction.
Solutions development efforts to
ensure that only very low levels of any Normally, the ammonia (reducing
problematic emission escape from the agent) required is added by injecting a
ammonia engine, and that the new fuel urea solution (CH4N2O + H2O) into the
will not create a new problem for the exhaust gas, however, ammonia can
shipping industry to consider. be injected as the catalytic agent
instead of urea. One of the benefits of
4.3.1 Selective catalytic reduction this is that an ammonia-fuelled vessel
technology already carries ammonia. The
To reduce emissions of nitrogen oxides consumption of ammonia for the SCR
(NO and NO2, commonly referred to as system will be very small compared to
NOX) and to fulfil the regionally different the ammonia fuel consumption.
emission regulations, engines from
MAN Energy Solutions have been Fig. 6 outlines the principle of selective
equipped with, for example, advanced catalytic reduction of the NOX content
selective catalytic reduction (SCR) in the exhaust gas.
technology. The SCR system using
ammonia was introduced in the 1990s In the catalytic reaction, NH3 and NOX
in four bulk carriers. Pending the are converted to diatomic nitrogen (N2)
outcome of the first engine test results, and water (H2O):
an increase in SCR volume and
ammonia consumption may be 4NO + 4NH3 + O2 → 4N2 + 6H2O
necessary to achieve compliance in 6NO2 + 8NH3 → 7N2 + 12H2O
Tier III mode.
By ensuring a complete combustion,
The SCR technology is an the emission of unburned NH3
after-treatment process, where NOX (ammonia slip) and the formation of
formed during the combustion is nitrous oxide (N2O) will be minimised.

NO
Exhaust gas
NO2
NH3

NH3

This SCR process


requires ammonia
in order to work SCR
reactor

N2
H2O

Fig. 6: The selective catalytic reduction process


15

5. Summary and outlook

Decarbonisation is a central and highly The future will see cleaner fuels, and
integrated part of developing the two-stroke engine technology will
sustainable technologies and solutions likely remain the prime propulsion
at MAN Energy Solutions. motor for deep-sea shipping. Our
engine portfolio shows that the MAN
Ammonia is used as an energy carrier B&W two-stroke engines combust
of sustainable hydrogen and it is various fuel types. MAN B&W ME-C
intrinsically carbon free. MAN Energy engines are based on future-proof
Solutions develops a dual-fuel technology that already can be
two-stroke engine operating on retrofitted to run on LNG, LPG, ethane,
ammonia. The technology developed and methanol as the fuel. The
aims for 90% decarbonisation of the development of an engine type for
ship powertrain in a tank-to-wake ammonia supplements our extensive
sense, while maintaining high power, dual-fuel portfolio with an engine that
energy density and efficiency, and low will meet future market demands for
emissions. CO2-neutral propulsion including
retrofits.
However, as decarbonisation remains a
global endeavour and one of the largest The future installation of an
transitions within the maritime world, it ammonia-combusting engine can be
will require a united maritime industry adapted to the customer, for example
to question and evaluate the entire as a dual-fuel, modular retrofit solution
supply chain. for existing electronically controlled
engines, as an ammonia-ready engine,
The Innovation Fund Denmark supports or from newbuilding.
the AEngine project with the aim to
design and demonstrate an MAN Energy Solutions works diligently
ammonia-based propulsion system. towards offering retrofit conversions of
MAN Energy Solutions is the AEngine existing two-stroke engines to
project coordinator and part of the ammonia, preferably accommodating
cross-functional project team together the vessels’ five-year docking
with Eltronic FuelTech (fuel supply schedules after Q1 2025.
systems), Technical University of
Denmark and the classification society The advanced research and
DNV GL. development of MAN Energy Solutions
supports the transition of the industry
As an important step towards a by delivering the technology that helps
carbon-neutral economy, MAN Energy our customers bring emissions to
Solutions has joined forces with regulatory compliance, and even all the
important players on the market in the way to net zero.
launch of the Maersk Mc-Kinney
Moller Center for Zero Carbon
Shipping in Copenhagen. The
combined global and
cross-disciplinary effort will take us
one step closer to the research
required to highlight decarbonisation
pathways. Research, which can guide
and accelerate the development of
carefully selected decarbonising fuels.

Furthermore, the global teamwork will


support the establishment of vital
regulatory, financial and commercial
means to enable the transformation.
16 MAN Energy Solutions
MAN B&W two-stroke engine operating on ammonia

6. Bibliography

[1] Innovationsfonden

[2] Maersk Mc-Kinney Moller Center for


Zero Carbon Shipping

[3] Ammonfuel – an industrial view of


ammonia as a marine fuel, , Alfa
Laval, Hafnis, Haldor Topsøe,
Vestas, Siemens Gamesa, 2020

[4] Efficiency of Ships, IMO, 2004

[5] Press release – groundbreaking first


ammonia engine test completed,
MAN Energy Solutions, 2023

[5] MAN B&W ME-LGIP dual-fuel


engines, 5510-0210-00, MAN
Energy Solutions, 2018
17

7. Acronyms and abbreviations

CCS Carbon capture and storage


EEDI Energy efficiency design index
EEOI Energy-efficiency operational indicator
EGR Exhaust gas recirculation
FSS Fuel supply system
FVT Fuel valve train
GHG Greenhouse gas
GI Gas injection
GWP Global warming potential
HC Hydrocarbon
IMO International Maritime Organization
LGI Liquid gas injection
LGIM Liquid gas injection methanol
LGIP Liquid gas injection propane
LHV Lower heating value
LNG Liquefied natural gas
LPG Liquefied petroleum gas
MGO Marine gas oil
NG Natural gas
RCC Research Centre Copenhagen
SCR Selective catalytic reduction
VLSFO Very-low-sulphur fuel oil
MAN Energy Solutions
2450 Copenhagen SV, Denmark
P +45 33 85 11 00
F +45 33 85 10 30
info-cph@man-es.com
www.man-es.com

All data provided in this document is non-binding.


This data serves informational purposes only and
is not guaranteed in any way. Depending on the
subsequent specific individual projects, the
relevant data may be subject to changes and will
be assessed and determined individually for each
project. This will depend on the particular
characteristics of each individual project,
especially specific site and operational conditions.

Copyright © MAN Energy Solutions.


5510-0241-02ppr Oct 2023. Printed in Denmark

You might also like