Professional Documents
Culture Documents
2015 - 16 KSP With Cambodia (English)
2015 - 16 KSP With Cambodia (English)
Cambodia
2015 Knowledge Sharing Program
Construction and Infrastructure Policy Consultation Project
Project Participants
Execution of the Project (1) : Korea Research Institute for Human Resources
Kim Jonghak(National Infrastructure Research Division, PM)
Kim Jungi (National Infrastructure Research Division)
Oh Sungho (National Infrastructure Research Division)
Ko Yongseok (National Infrastructure Research Division)
Park Jongil (National Infrastructure Research Division)
Hong Kyoungsun (National Infrastructure Research Division)
Park Bora(National Infrastructure Research Division)
August 2016
Kim Dong-joo
President of KRIHS
Contents
1
Implications and Expected Effects of Logistics System
Development Strategies for Cambodia 1
Chapter 1. Introduction 3
2
Section 1. Review of Upper Plan 12
Section 2. Social Economic Status 16
Section 3. Current Status and Problems Related to
Logistics Infrastructure 23
Section 4. Implications on Policies 75
3
Section 4. Implication of Policies 114
5
Chapter 5. Conclusion 169
Reference 181
<Table 3-1> Comparison among the National Basic Plans on Logistics ···························· 84
<Table 3-2> Logistics-related Laws in Korea ···································································· 87
<Table 3-3> Logistics Surveys in Korea ············································································· 89
<Table 3-4> Agency Responsibilities ················································································· 91
<Table 3-5> Current Condition of Logistics Facilities Per Region ·································· 102
<Table 5-1> Supporting Project for Establishing a Basic Plan on Infrastructure ············· 176
<Table 5-2> Supporting Project for Global Infrastructure Funding ································· 177
<Table 5-3> Supporting Project for Establishing an International Construction Market · 178
<Table 5-4> Utilization of ODA and EDCF ····································································· 180
Cambodia 1
logistics complexes. This research divided Cambodia into six area, and designated
major cities as logistics complexes that have high traffic volume. The order of
major cities that have the high traffic volume is Phnom Penh, Sihanoukville, and
Kampong Cham. By this order, it shows that Phnom Penh which is the capital of
Cambodia has the most urgency to build logistics facilities. For the effective
linkage between logistics complexes, 8 logistics axes suggested based on analysis
of freight volume between areas. The result shows Sihanoukville-Phnom Penh
axis and Phnom Penh-Kampong Cham axis have the highest priority which reveals
it is necessary to build transportation infrastructure firstly.
This research suggested the modification of law and institution, the fostering
logistics industry, and the reform of logistics related organizations as the strategy
of logistics system development of Cambodia. At the moment, the comprehensive
reformation of logistics is urgent because there is no logistics related organization
or law system. This research suggested the logistics control tower organization
that can control logistics related organization due to the characteristic of logistics
that there are a lot of stockholders among government department. It is possible
to promote effective law system and fostering logistics industry after establishing
the control tower organization. It would cause more problems if each division
establishes similar laws and systems separatedly
Chapter 1. Introduction
Summary
Chapter 1 describes the background and objective of the task and makes
study method recommendations to draw up strategies relating to the
development of transportation and logistics in Cambodia. The strategy for
the development of transportation and logistics in Cambodia is classified in
two groups, improving hardware in terms of infrastructure and improving
systems in terms of software. The method to draw up a strategy for the
development of logistics is proposed through an analysis of transportation
and geographical information along with a review of the related data.
Chapter 1. Introduction 3
Therefore, Cambodia is faced with a problem of having to depend heavily
on foreign trade. The capital, Phnom Penh, has a highly concentrated
population and is currently experiencing critical issues encompassing local
housing and transportation. Due to a great portion of the population being
comprised of a younger generation, Cambodia has high labor productivity.
Therefore, labor-intensive industries such as apparel and sewing have
grown substantially.
<Table 1-1> Map and Overall Conditions of Cambodia
Kingdom of Cambodia
Area 181.035㎢
Capital Phnom Penh
Total population:
15,708,756 (2015)
Population
- Urban population
ratio : 20.7%(2015)
Population
82/sq.km
Density
Khmer 90%, minorities
Ethnic (Vietnamese, Chinese
Group Chams Tribe and
Gaoshan)
Khmer language,
French (above 50’s),
Language Chinese, English
(Youth middle age
group)
Tropical Monsoon
Climate
Climate
Source: https://www.cia.gov/library/publications/the-world-factbook/geos/cb.html
Cambodia has relatively flat topography with mainly low slopes and wide
plains with a tropical monsoon climate. Therefore, it possesses a
advantageous natural environment for farming and some of the preserved
resources are various mineral resources such as iron ore and limestone.
Although Cambodia has been promoting economic development through the
development of sewing and apparel industries since the 2000s, inadequate
1) Since 1992, Asia Development Bank (ADB) has been implementing a large project for infrastructure
development including roads, railroads, communication network, tourism, and human resource
development by establishing the “Greater Mekong Subregion” which is a joint development
project that includes regions such as Thailand near Mekong river valley, Myanmar, Laos,
Cambodia, Vietnam, and Yunnan region of China.
Chapter 1. Introduction 5
Section 2. Study Objective and Content
1. Objective of Task
The main content of this task are as follows. First, the current conditions
of social economy and logistics in Cambodia have been observed. The
economic standards and population size were observed for assessing the
social economy and current conditions of infrastructure facilities in Cambodia.
These includes the national master plan, roads, railroads, airports, and ports,
all of which are analyzed to further look into Cambodia’s logistics conditions.
Second, Korea’s experience and knowledge of logistics development has been
suggested. By taking Cambodia’s current logistics conditions into
consideration, aspects from Korea’s experience and knowledge of logistics
development which can be applied to Cambodia have been drawn. The third
content involves strategies for Cambodia’s logistics development with
logistics development strategy being categorized into hardware and software.
In terms of the hardware aspect, a development strategy suitable for
Cambodia’s current conditions has been suggested through analysis of GIS
and transportation demands.
Chapter 1. Introduction 7
<Figure 1-1> Study Strategies
1. Study Scope
Chapter 1. Introduction 9
10 2015 Knowledge Sharing Program Ⅲ
2015 Knowledge Sharing Program Ⅲ
Summary
To investigate the current transportation and logistics situation in
Cambodia, the rectangular strategy, the GMS plan, and the logistics plan of
neighboring states were reviewed. In addition, recent social and economic
trends were examined through Cambodian socio-economic indicator analysis.
Situational analysis of transportation infrastructure for passenger and cargo
freight including roads, railways, airports, and ports were reviewed to tackle
problematic issues. Regarding logistics, international trade flow volume, free
economic zones, and rice-related logistics channel flow were reviewed.
With the analyzed data, a SWOT analysis was performed to find the
strengths, weaknesses, competitiveness, and threats pertaining to Cambodia
to improve transport and logistics.
1. Rectangular Strategy
Source: KOICA, Master Plan for Railway Network Development in Cambodia, 2013
GMS is a plan that was established in 1992 by the Asian Development Bank
(ADB) to expand social infrastructure and to develop natural resources in the
Mekong Sub-region to support economic development and economic transition
of the neighboring states. It is a large-scale infrastructure development project
covering Mekong river transportation network maintenance, energy
development, communications network maintenance, and tourism development
targeted towards the neighboring states including Cambodia, China, Laos,
Myanmar, Thailand, and Vietnam. After completing development, more active
interaction between human resources and material trade are expected among
neighboring states.
<Figure 2-2> GMS Range and Site Inspection for GMS Railroad
Source: KOICA, Master Plan for Railway Network Development in Cambodia, 2013
In 2010, Prime Minister Hun Sen set a target of one million tons of rice export
and selected the rice industry along with the garment industry as the main
drivers for economic growth in Cambodia. However, in 2016 rice exports have
merely reached half of the targeted amount. Cambodia's rice production capacity
is about five million tons. The export numbers are poor compared to its
production capacity. This is due to the lack of rice processing and handling,
infrastructure and high logistics costs. Because of this, neighboring countries with
cheaper logistics costs such as Thailand and Vietnam have been importing
Cambodian rice to sell them to the international market after processing. This
inhibits the growth of the Cambodian rice industry.
Source: Ruth Banomyong, 「Developing National Logistics Policy: Lesson Learned from ASEAN」, World
Bank National Trade Logistic Blueprint Workshop, 2014.9
In 2013, the GDP per capita in Cambodia exceeded 1000 USD and the GDP
growth remained at a high level of 7% since 2010. However, the fiscal balance
scale is at -5% to the GDP and has been generating a yearly deficit of around
7~8 billion USD.
<Figure 2-5> Economic Growth Rate and Ratio of Each Industry to GDP
Source: KOICA, Master Plan for Railway Network Development in Cambodia, 2013
2. Population Distribution
In 2015, the population of Cambodia was 154 million and the capital,
Phnom Penh, comprised 10% of the total, at around 18.3 million. As the
population of the 194 districts' population distribution was analyzed by
population size and its distance from Phnom Penh, the population living
within 50km from Phnom Penh accounted for around 40% of the total
population.
Third tier shows below average population and is mainly located between
Battambang and Svay Rieng. From the analysis, it shown that overall, the
population is concentrated to the northwest of Phnom Penh. This is thought
to be, due to the fact that the population is highly concentrated in the
metropolitan area around Phnom Penh along with the fact that the
population is increasing in areas like Battambang and Siem Reap with the
invigorated agriculture and tourism in the areas.
3. Geographical Status
Mountainous Terrain
Plain Terrain
Plain Terrain
Export Volume
Population Size
Land
Sea
Cambodia Vietnam
Source: Enrique Aldaz-Carroll, 「Improving rice trade logistics to help reach 1 million tons export target」
World Bank National Trade Logistic Blueprint Workshop, 2014.9
Railroad
Waterway
Road
Source: Enrique Aldaz-Carroll, 「Improving rice trade logistics to help reach 1 million tons export target」
World Bank National Trade Logistic Blueprint Workshop, 2014.9
Source: http://knoema.com/WBLOGPI2014Nov/logistics-performance-index-world-bank-2014?location=1000230-cambodia
4) Related Organizations
Source: Enrique Aldaz-Carroll, 「Improving rice trade logistics to help reach 1 million tons export target」
World Bank National Trade Logistic Blueprint Workshop, 2014.9
1) Roads
Since the early 2000s when the country became politically stabilized, there
have been various road reconstructions and facility improvement projects that
have fixed, improved and built new roads. Some of the projects are also
currently underway throughout the nation via international contracts and ODAs.
As of September 2014, Cambodia has a total of over 55,000km road networks,
of which 1-Digit and 2-Digit consists of over 11,000km. They consist of
20.1% of the total road networks, and 1-Digit and 2-Digit also consist of
43.7% of total bridge expansion length.
Source: IRITWG, Overview on Transport Infrastructure Sectors in the Kingdom of Cambodia, 2015
Cambodia's NR3 road has very favorable conditions overall and vehicles
such as trucks were easily found, as there are many cars driving to nearby
private transport terminals. A lot of people also use this road for passing
the Takeo and Kandal provinces near the Phnom Penh area and there are
many road expansion constructions currently underway for the roads passing
through Phnom Penh.
The newly built beltway around Cambodia's Phnom Penh has good overall
maintenance conditions and has favorable road conditions. It is expected to
play a major role in Cambodia logistics as freight trucks are permitted to
use the road during the daytime. Other types of vehicles no longer need to
pass Phnom Penh to move to other regions, having a positive influence on
the overall traffic congestion.
Source: IRITWG, Overview on Transport Infrastructure Sectors in the Kingdom of Cambodia, 2015
Source: IRITWG, Overview on Transport Infrastructure Sectors in the Kingdom of Cambodia, 2015
Japan (JICA) conducted a pre-investigation for its road network plan, based on
China's road construction proposal, and proposed a road construction of 2,200km.
Source: IRITWG, Overview on Transport Infrastructure Sectors in the Kingdom of Cambodia, 2015
Also, the capital city of Phnom Penh plans to build 4 beltways - Ring Road
No.1(RR- I), Ring Road No.2(RR-Ⅱ), Ring Road No.3(RR-Ⅲ), Ring Road
No.4(RR-Ⅳ) - in order to alleviate traffic congestion.
The northern lane connects Cambodia's capital city of Phnom Penh and
Thailand's boundary region of Poipet city, totaling 386km, consisting of the lost
railroad which is 48km and the Phnom Penh~Sisophon part of 338km. Currently
most of the facilities have stopped operating due to either damage or a lack of
maintenance.
The Northern lane's degree of damage is approximately 200km (52% of total
length) of railroad lanes and 47 stops (96% of total railway stops), most of the
remains are also difficult to operate. The railroads, except for the repaired
48km portion of Sisophon~Poipet, were initially planned to have completed
repairs construction by 2013, but is being delayed due to insufficient budgets
and other reasons. The government is currently allocating the budgets in order
to restart the railroad operations.
<Table 2-9> Railroad Stations of Northen Route
No. Stations Lacation Distance (km) No. Stations Location Distance (km)
1 Phnom Penh 0+000 26 Krolaomplouk 209+600 11.909
2 Pochentong 6+723 6.723 27 Prey Svay 214+754 5.154
3 Fork 9+400 2.677 28 Maung Russey 223+104 8.35
4 Samraong 12+036 2.636 29 Koh Char 231+665 8.561
5 Trapeang Krasaing 15+200 3.164 30 Kork Trom 236+643 4.978
6 Tuol Leap 17+829 2.629 31 Phnom Thip Dei 244+240 7.597
7 Trapeang Thnaot 26+005 8.176 32 Svay Cheat 251+949 7.709
8 Bat Deng 31+443 5.438 33 Reang Kesei 256+236 4.287
9 Trach Torng 36+915 5.472 34 Sralso 262+125 5.889
10 Damnak Smach 42+563 5.648 35 O Dambang 268+158 6.033
11 Tbaeng Khpuos 47+131 4.568 36 Battambang 273+052 4.894
12 Meanork 55+665 8.534 37 Siem 279+367 6.315
13 Kraing Lovear 66+936 11.271 38 O Taky 284+536 5.169
14 Baraing 71+213 4.277 39 Chondeur Svar 298+171 13.635
15 Romeas 76+458 5.245 40 Chroy Srolao 306+222 8.051
16 Kraing Skea 93+834 17.376 41 Tuol Samraong 310+332 4.11
17 Kdol 111+147 17.313 42 Phnom Tauch 315+771 5.439
18 Bamnok 124+399 13.252 43 Chamcar Chek 321+930 6.159
19 Kamrieng 133+464 9.065 44 Mongkol Borey 330+204 8.274
20 Torteung Thngai 148+116 14.652 45 Sisophon 337+310 7.106
21 Pursat 165+467 17.351 46 Toeuk Thlar 342+420 5.11
22 Snam Preah 173+157 7.69 47 Sala Samraong 350+400 7.98
23 Trapeang Chorng 179+729 6.572 48 Sophy 356+800 6.4
24 Beng Khnar 187+541 7.812 49 Kaub 370+110 13.31
25 Svay Daunkeo 197+691 10.15 50 Poipet 384+300 14.19
Source: Ministry of Public Works and Transport
② South Route
Distance Distance
No. History Location between No. History Location between
stations (km) stations (km)
1 Phnom Penh 0+000 16 Ang Keo 98+500 14.800
When observing the overview of the operation of the passenger train, the
South Route has been inoperative since 2004 and the North Route has been
inoperative since mid 2008. Freight cars are still operating on the South
Route but have been inoperative on the North Route since 2009.
The objectives and indexes for the railroad development plan are as follows.
4 objectives and 7 indexes are specified below.
∙ Objective 1: Railroad development to contribute toward national
policies and economic development
- Strategy 1: Development through establishment of various growth
poles
- Strategy 2: National integration
∙ Objective 2: Railroad development for the eradication of poverty and
also regional development
- Strategy 3: Development of regional economy
- Strategy 4: Regional development for resolving poverty issues
∙ Objective 3: Establishment of international traffic network for
international cooperation and economic development
- Strategy 5: Establishment of international traffic network
∙ Objective 4: Establishment of low-cost, high-efficiency traffic
system through connecting transportation means
- Strategy 6: Establishment of integrated traffic network
- Strategy 7: Improvement of speed
To establish the previously mentioned railroad development plan, the
following railroad development plan has been established to include 5 main
routes, KOICA has proposed 8 local routes, a high speed route, an industrial
railroad, and a lead-in railroad based on 4 objectives and 7 strategies.
Through the establishment and implementation of the Cambodia Railroad
High-speed Railroad
384 400
~ POIPET ~ THAILAND POIPET ~ THAILAND
PHNOM PENH ~ SIHANOUK PHNOM PENH ~ SIHANOUK
260 243
Main Routes
VILLE VILLE
SISOPHON ~ SIEM REAP ~ SISOPHON ~ SIEM REAP ~
326 314
CHEUNG PREY CHEUNG PREY
BAT DOENG ~ KAMPONG CHAM BAT DOENG ~ KAMPONG CHAM
249 236
~ SNUOL ~ VIETNAM ~ SNUOL ~ VIETNAM
SNUOL ~ KRATIE ~ STUNG
249 OTDAR MEANCHEY ~ PREAH VIHEAR 181
Industrial Railroad
TRENG ~ LAOS
PREY CHRUK ~ OTDAR
74 PREAH VIHEAR ~ STUNG TRENG 113
MEANCHEY
KAMPONG THOM ~ PREAH
139 MONDUL KIRI ~ RATANAK KIRI 151
VIHEAR
Local Routes
1) Inland Waterway
Source: KOICA, Master Plan for Railway Network Development in Cambodia, 2013
Source: Belgian Technical Cooperation, Master Plan for Waterborne Transport on the Mekong River System in
Cambodia, Final report(Volume 1 Main Report, Draft), September 2006
Source: Belgian Technical Cooperation, Master Plan for Waterborne Transport on the Mekong River System in
Cambodia, Final report(Volume 1 Main Report, Draft), September 2006
2) Inland Ports
<Figure 2-37> Quantity of imported and exported goods through Phnom Penh Port
<Figure 2-38> Quantity of Imported and Exported Goods through Phnom Penh Port
Construction of the new port at Phnom Penh started with borrowing 28.2
million dollars provided by China at the beginning of 2010 under the condition
of setting limitations for low water, weight of traffic, and a processed capacity
of Phnom Penh Port. The first stage of the port was completed in December of
2012. There is a total of 3 construction stages and the port is currently
undergoing development.
A multi-purpose pier and resource logistics complex project is to
construct a pier to export rice, cassava, tapioca, wood chip, corn, and other
goods. This project, in 2013, had an assigned budet of 31.35 billion KRW
for the purchasing of the site and reinforcing the existing pier. In 2016,
20.68 billion KRW was budgeted for constructing 160 m of pier (52.03
billion KRW in total). 30 billion KRW has been assigned to the lease
Siem Reap Port is located near the Tonle Sap River 5km away from the
city. This port can only be used when the water level is at its greatest.
During the dry season, the depth of the Tonle Sap Lake is 10 m on
average and is 11km long located along the Siem Reap Port. The accessible
road of the port is also connected to the lake. Although a temporary
wooden port is established every dry season, the accessible road becomes
flooded and completely loses its function during the rainy season. Siem
Reap Port is mainly used for cargo transportation coming from Phnom Penh
after passing through the Tonle Sap River. Also, some ships are being
operated along the route.
Other inland waterway ports consist of Sre Ambel Port, Kampot Port, and
Sihanoukville Port - which has an oil cargo handling facility - and Oknha
Mong Port. Of these ports, Oknha Mong Port is being widely used for
importing small scale cargo. Kampot Port is currently undergoing
development for expansion. The other port expansion plans will be
planned and implemented in Koh Kong and Kiri Sakor for transporting sugar.
Furthermore, there are plans to develop a new port in Kiri Sakor near Koh
Kong, a new international port in Stung Hav near Preah Sihanouk, and a
passenger port in Kep Province.
3) Marine Port
- Length: 330 m
- Length: 200m
- Alongside depth: -13.50m
- Alongside depth: -7.50m
- Designed to accommodate vessel with 40,000 DWT.
- Logistic base yard: 26,900m2
- Dry bulk cargo storage yard: 27,900 m2
Type Area
Factory area 45ha
Commercial and Multi-purpose area 6ha
Inter-Modal logistic area 4.4ha
Green area 5.2ha
Admin maintenance office and parking 0.9ha
Utilities and roads 8.5ha
Total 70ha
Other sea ports include Koh Kong Port (SP1), Sre Ambel Port (SP2),
Oknha Mong Port (SP3), Stunghav Port and Oil Terminal (SP4 and SP5),
Kampot Port (SP6), and Kaeb Port (SP7). Koh Kong Port (SP1) is located
near the Thai border and has the most amount of ships and quantity of
transported goods compared to all other sea ports.
4) Dry Port
5) Flight
A high tourist demand was expected for Sihanoukville Airport as the area
surrounding the airport has been developed into vacation destinations.
However, a domestic airplane crashed near the Sihanoukville Airport in
2007 resulting in the temporary closing of the airport. After this incident,
Sihanoukville Airport was reopened as an international airport. For domestic
flights, there are 6 flights a day from Phnom Penh to Siem Reap and 2
flights a week from Sihanoukville to Phnom Penh. Besides these domestic
flights, there are no other domestic flights being operated.
Airlines Destination
<Table 2-31> Annual Overview of Handled Cargo at Siem Reap International Airport
(Unit: Ton)
Month
Year
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 total
2008 10 9 18 11 10 8 19 24 7 10 7 11 144
2009 8 9 11 9 10 6 11 6 5 6 17 16 114
2010 4 22 63 36 42 66 62 42 70 49 36 51 543
2011 18 6 15 10 11 17 16 17 16 24 24 27 201
2012 22 23 22 27 22 35 39 46 84 32 44 73 469
2013 85 47 77 79 67 96 93 93 106 54 59 69 925
2014 93 101 214 141 97 100 55 76 78 92 106 82 1,235
2015 138 75 143 78 78 115 177 130 143 130 159 308 1,674
Source: CAMBODIA AIRPORTS(www.cambodia-airports.com)
The SEZ obtained business approval from Council for the Development of
Cambodia (CDC). The Cambodia government considers the SEZ as one of
the best methods to attract foreign capital because foreign capital
investment is 100% permitted for SEZ. Furthermore, foreigners can be
employed for SEZ if a particular position cannot be fulfilled through local
human resources.
6. Issues
The pavement rate of 1-digit road which is the national main road is
high due to Cambodia’s continuous investment geared toward transportation
infrastructure. Although the average speed in main roads is 56.2km/h, it is
only 39km/h in the inner part of the city where poor road traffic conditions
presents itself. Local roads are not being managed well and the rate of
unpaved roads is high. This significantly decreases the functionality of
roads. Since the road network is not adequate, cargo is only transported
through main roads where the road network is in good standing. However,
most of the main roads only have 2 lanes and thus, cars frequently pass
each other which leads to high rate of accidents and safety issues. The 2
lane roads are overcrowded, needing an expansion to 4 lanes. Furthermore,
highways need to be established in order to process traffic flow and resolve
the back up of traffic when passing through different regions. The
Cambodian railroad has a very low share of transportation of about 1%.
This is because only one route, the south route, processes cargo in the
Phnom Penh, the capital of Cambodia, is a dense city with a high number
of people, cars, and capital. However, transportation infrastructure is
inadequate. Although modern buildings are being constructed, expansion of
transportation facilities is not being implemented adequately and therefore,
traffic congestion are becoming worse. In addition, main roads (NR) are
designed so that Phnom Penh must be passed through as the center in
order to get to other regions which adds to the issue of traffic congestion.
Therefore, a complex city traffic environment in Phnom Penh caused by an
overwhelming amount of car and motorcycle traffic induces an increase in
logistics costs and additional costs. Cambodia relies on importing most
products from Thailand and Vietnam. Although the Cambodian government
strives to achieve stabilization of price, the uncontrolled traffic environment
provokes unexpected supply interruption and price variation. The
government is seeking to encourage concentrated traffic to detour to other
routes by constructing a beltway. However, the Cambodian government is
facing a budget deficit and thus, constructing circulation roads may be
difficult if there is no financial aid from other countries. Therefore,
tremendous efforts are needed to overcome traffic congestion near the
central part of Phnom Penh by expanding the road network. Resolving
The threat lies in the fact that the economic structure of Cambodia
depends on external economic environments. In addition, the geographical
features of the land is vulnerable to weather changes such as flooding of
rivers during the rainy seasons which may become an obstacle when
striving to achieve logistic advancement in the future.
Summary
Chapter 3 seeks to deduce critical points for Cambodia's logistics
development strategy by reviewing the history of Korean logistics
institution. Initially, Korea focused on reorganizing and readjusting legal
institutions related to railway and marine transport, as well as legal
institutions related to transport vehicles that serve as a critical component
of logistics and transport. Also, Korea promoted efficiency in managing
logistics by introducing various logistics management systems combined with
information technology. In the initial phase of logistics development,
particularly concerning the infrastructure for logistics, Korea, at the
government level, set up a Basic Plan on Logistics to select logistic
complexes for each regional units, and connected each complexes with
logistic axes, establishing a basic framework for a logistics policy. This
article thereby deduced critical points for Cambodia's traffic and logistics
development strategy by reviewing the initial stages of Korean logistics
infrastructure and legal institutions.
The cargo vehicle transportation industry in the 1950s and 1960s was
mostly managed by minor vehicle owners with petty capital, and was
developed into a system where the business operator who acquired a
transportation vehicle business license would buy the vehicles and entrust
them to a third party as he managed the company. As over-extended,
chronic problems concerning practices of registering a privately-owned
vehicle to a transportation company, in order to earn and receive payment
for each work (The 'Jiip' system), worsened, the Korean government sought
for the corporatization of those companies based on commercial law.
In 1970s and 1980s, the corporatization policy for the cargo vehicle
transportation industry continued due to its success in the passenger vehicle
transportation industry in the 1970s. Cargo vehicle companies sent a
petition to the National Assembly calling against direct management policies
due to the petty size of each of the companies, and certain limitations of
The following lists 11 critical points of the Basic Plan for Cargo
Logistics.
- Expansion of Area Central Logistics Facility
- Establishment of Cargo Transportation Network between Areas
Source:Ministry of Construction and Transportation(1994), Basic Plan for Improving Cargo Logistics
System to Cut Logistics Costs (1994~2003)
A detailed plan on inland cargo station was designed in the 1990s which
led to the establishment of inland cargo stations in the capital area and
Busan area. Restrictions on 'Cargo Vehicle Transportation Businesses' were
lifted to replace the license system with a registration system. A
government-led comprehensive logistics information network was initiated
to informationalize logistics and a logistics consultants certification system
was introduced.
1) Related Laws
Notable Korean laws related to logistics can be categorized into six types
for each subfield of logistics (port transportation, logistics industry, cargo
vehicle transportation, railroad, logistics facility) and the comprehensive
Framework Act on Logistics Policies superseding all areas of logistics.
Road ․ Railroad Harbor ․ Vessel Air · Aircraft Logistics Industry Logistics Complex
Promotion of
Logistics
Harbor Logistics
Industry
Road Act Transport Aviation Act Complex
Development
Business Act Development
Act
Act
Air Transport Framework Act
Korea Highway Logistics
Harbor Act Business on Logistic
Corporation Act Facilities Act
Promotion Act Policies
Trucking Safety of
Port Authority Sustainable
Transport Aircraft
Act Transport Act
Business Act Operation Act
Framework Act
on the Aviation Safety
Development of Ships Act and Security -
Railroad Act
Industry
Korea Rail International
Aviation
Network Ship - -
Security Act
Authority Act Registration Act
Ballast Water
Korea Railroad
Management - - -
Corporation Act
Act
Ship
- Management - - -
Industry Act
NOTE: Promotion of Cargo Logistics Act was changed to Framework Act on Logistics
Policies in 2008. Safety of Aircraft Operation Act was changed to Aviation Safety and
Security Act in 2002 which was once again changed to Aviation Security Act in 2014.
Promotion of Logistics Complex Development Act was changed to Logistics Facilities Act
in 2007.
3) Logistics-related Organizations
Korea's logistics policy is designed by various organizations. Specifically,
The Ministry of Land, Infrastructure, and Transport (formerly known as
Ministry of Construction and Transportation), the Ministry of Oceans and
Fisheries, the Ministry of Commerce, Industry, and Energy, and the
Ministry of Agriculture and Forestry participate in policy design. The roles
and responsibilities of each agency are listed in the figure below. Logistics
policy can generally be divided into logistics complex facilities, logistics
operation, logistics industry, green logistics, and international logistics. The
reason why various agencies participate in the logistics policy design is due
to its influence over various fields within the industry, transport, and
economy. The Ministry of Construction and Transportation (currently known
as the Ministry of Land, Infrastructure and Transport) has been at the
center of the logistics policy design to this day. The Ministry of Land,
Infrastructure, and Transport mainly deals with inland transportation and
logistics-related projects, notably managing logistics centers such as cargo
terminals, ICDs, and logistic complexes, and researching and developing
comprehensive logistics information networks and logistics equipment
standard pallets. The Ministry of Commerce, Industry and Energy is in
charge of establishing delivery centers and a common delivery complex that
has a direct influence on industries. The Ministry of Oceans and Fisheries
is responsible for managing logistics and its harbor facilities. The Ministry
of Agriculture and Forestry deals with logistics related to the agricultural
industry such as logistics of agricultural and livestock products, while
KORAIL participates in logistics policy design for comprehensive railroad
logistics stations and railroad information networks.
Source: Dong-sun Shin (2002), Studies Related to Establishing Government Laws and Roles,
Reconstitution of Korea Transport Institute
The inland cargo bases are categorized into integrated freight terminals
and ICDs which have been established near 5 major areas.
Main facilities of the integrated freight terminals are as follows.
① Cargo handling center, ② delivery center, ③ railroad
Integrated
transportation handling site, ④ maintenance utility
Cargo
facilities, ⑤ parking lot, ⑥ gas station, ⑦ washing
Terminal
facilities
① Container loading site, ② container work site, ③ sash
ICD equipment site, ④ maintenance utility facilities, ⑤
Parking lot
Inland cargo bases have been through the private sector project based on
Private Investment Promotion Law and the project initiatives are as follows.
It is composed of a plan confirmation stage, an execution stage, and a
construction stage. Validity inspection and location selection has been
conducted by the Ministry of Construction and Transportation which means
the construction plans for an inland cargo complex has been facilitated by
government bodies.
Source: Dong-sun Shin (2002), Studies Related to Establishing Government Laws and Roles,
Reconstitution of Korea Transport Institute
Terms and conditions for loans were set as with a 15 year payment
period after a 5-year grace period in order to minimize the financial burden
of companies. In addition, government reduces 50% of special surtax
imposed on income generated by site creation and transfer of buildings and
approved 15% of total investments as the reserve funds for investment.
Also, tax benefits including corporate tax exemption have been provided.
4)container yard
5) Ministry of Land, Transport and Maritime Affairs (2012), Quotation of Definition in the
“Second Comprehensive Plan of Logistics Facilities”
Source: Dong-sun Shin (2002), Studies Related to Establishing Government Laws and Roles,
Reconstitution of Korea Transport Institute
By estimating the total supply from this, the demand of area and
distribution area per region is estimated to be distributed for each region.
The estimated method and direction for general cargo processing unit is as
follows: the general cargo processing facilities are divided into two
categories: a cargo handling center and a delivery center. This is because
<Figure 3-7> Estimation of the Demand of Area for General Cargo Processing
Facilities
Source: Dong-sun Shin (2002), Studies Related to Establishing Government Laws and Roles,
Reconstitution of Korea Transport Institute
For the estimated data for the quantity of cargo OD goods in the target
year, the total quantity of goods with general cargo that surpass 100 km
from the entire cargo OD data of the National Transportation DB, of the
target year to calculate the cargo handling centers, has been estimated. For
collective delivery centers, the total quantity of goods was estimated by
Source: Ministry of Land, Transport and Maritime Affairs (2013), “Second Comprehensive Plan for
Development of Logistics Facilities” (2013~2017)
1. Logistics Industry
Source: Dong-sun Shin (2002), Study related to Laws and Roles of Government, Korea Transport
Institute
Source: Dong-sun Shin (2002), Study related to Laws and Roles of Government, Korea Transport
Institute
2) Standardization of Logistics
In Korea, the entire land was classified with regional units and
major logistic complexes were selected for each regional unit in
order to obtain nationwide logistic infrastructure. By selecting
sub-logistic complex areas adjacent to each logistic complex, “Hub
and Spoke” logistic complex facilities was established. This concept
refers to necessary facilities to reduce the travel distance of
logistics and to efficiently process import/export traffic volume
between each region. Korea assesses the size of facilities with basic
unit method along with selecting complex facilities for each region
and considers the size of traffic volume.
In order for Cambodia to advance its own logistic system to be
like Korea’s, the selection of logistics complex facilities by dividing
the whole nation into regional units is required. In addition, selection
of axes which connect each logistic complex by considering current
transportation facilities and traffic volume, along with expansion of
transportation facilities is required. However, in order to assess
specific size of facilities, logistics plans have to be established in
the future.
Summary
Logistics development strategies for this project will be presented with
the categories of “hardware” including roads, railroads, and logistics complex
and “software” including laws, systems, and the industrial system. As for
the hardware strategy, national logistics centers in Cambodia and logistics
axis which connects each logistics center have been suggested. Also, an
outline of investment priority for these axes has been proposed. From the
perspective of software, a basic plan on logistics and application plans for
logistics related laws and organizations have been proposed in order to
develop a logistics system in Cambodia.
1. Outline
1. Outline
Cambodia
<Figure 4-6> Population Size and Traffic Volume for Each Province
<Figure 4-8> Traffic Pattern in 2012 (Left), Expected Traffic Pattern in 2020 (Phnom
Penh – Other Regions; Right)
6) This is the proportional traffic volume based on the total traffic volume.
Cambodia shares its border with Thailand, Laos, and Vietnam. Major
facilities in border regions which function as the pathway for international
activities are shown in the following figure. Entrance points to Cambodia
other than the border areas of Siem Reap International Airport, Phnom Penh
International Airport, and Sihanoukville International Airport.
1. Western Cambodia-Poipet-Bangkok
2. Central/Eastern Cambodia – Bavet-Ho Chi Minh
<Figure 4-13> Major Importing Countries (upper graph) and Exporting Country
(lower graph) in Sihanoukville Port
Complexes in Cambodia
Cambodia
Analysis for selecting axes which connects major logistics complexes has
been conducted. As for transportation hubs, 6 domestic hubs and 3 overseas
hubs have been set by considering demographical information, a life zone,
and other relevant factors. There are 30 axes between the 6 major domestic
hubs. In order to consider the traffic demands in the future, expected traffic
in 2020 was estimated by using O/D traffic volume data in 2012. According
to the analysis result of traffic volume between the domestic hubs, the
highest traffic volume was presented between hub 5 (Phnom Penh) and hub
6 (P-Sihanouk) which accounts for 34% of total traffic volume. The second
highest traffic volume was shown between hub 5 (Phnom Penh) and hub 4
(Kampong Cham) which amounts to 24% of total traffic volume.
Based on the above traffic passage analysis, traffic volume generated from
major 8 axes which connect 6 hubs has been analyzed. 8 axes were
analyzed by categorizing traffic volume into private cars and trucks. As for
the traffic volume of private cars, traffic volume between the center hub 5
(Phnom Penh) and hub 4 (Kampong Cham) accounts for the highest volume
of 33%. Subsequently, the traffic volume between hub 5 (Phnom Penh) and
hub 6 (P-Sihanouk) amounts to the second highest traffic volume of 28%.
Traffic volume between hub 5 (Phnom Penh) and hub 2 (Siem Reap) was
14% and traffic volume between hub 5 (Phonm Penh) and hub 1
(Battambang) was 7%.
As for the traffic of trucks, traffic volume between the center hub 5
(Phnom Penh) and hub 4 (Kampong Cham) accounts for the highest
proportion of 27% and the same proportion was found between hub 5
(Phnom Penh) and hub 6 (P-Sihanouk). Subsequently, the proportion of
traffic volume between hub 5 (Phnom Penh) and hub 2 (Siem Reap) was
15%, followed by 11% of the proportion found between hub 5 (Phnom
Penh) and hub 1 (Battambang). Traffic volume of trucks has a different
tendency compared to traffic volume of private cars. Whereas the highest
traffic volume of private cars was found between hub 5 (Phnom Penh) and
hub 4 (Kampong Cham), the highest traffic volume for trucks was shown
between the center hub 5 (Phnom Penh) and hub 4 (Kampong Cham) and
between the center hub 5 (Phnom Penh) and hub 6 (P-Sihanouk). Hub 6
which includes Sihanouk Port has a higher traffic volume than other regions
and therefore, it has been confirmed that the traffic axis between
Sihanoukville and Phnom Penh is the main axis for traffic volume of trucks.
For private cars, traffic for work including commute vehicles seemed to be
highly generated due to many people being concentrated in Kampong Cham
and many business offices clustered in the area of Phnom Penh.
Development priority for each axis was examined by analyzing the current
situations of axes which connect 6 logistics complexes in Cambodia.
Similarly, current circumstances of axes which connects each hub(logistics
complex) to adjacent countries and overseas countries were analyzed in
order to determine priority when establishing an efficient international
logistics system.
In order to achieve this objective, current conditions and plans for a
transportation system in 8 axes which connect 6 domestic hubs(logistics
complexes) in Cambodia were analyzed and 4 international axes
(Thailand Axis, Laos Axis, Vietnam Axis, Internal Axis) which connect
adjacent countries and overseas countries were analyzed to decide upon
a development priority.
1) Assessment Method
After selecting major assessment indices for each axis and conducting
comprehensive evaluation, a development priority has been determined by
assessing scores for each alternative passage through scoring of each item
and applying weighted values as shown in the following table. Assessment
of domestic axes was based on the planned logistics infrastructure level
(40%) and the current infrastructure level (60%). As for the planned
infrastructure level, scores were given based upon development plans to be
implemented for roads, railroads, ports, and airports. With respect to the
current logistics infrastructure level, scores were given based on the
current condition of roads (paving ratio), railroads (whether they're being
operated), ports, and airports (number of ports/airports being operated).
Regarding the international axes, it has been evaluated based on a
planned logistics infrastructure level (40%), trade volume (35%), and
Elements Score
1. Planned Logistics Infrastructure Level (40%) 40
1.1 Road Grade 10
1. Arterial Roads 10
2. Service Roads 6
3. Others 2
1.2 Railroad Grade 10
1. Arterial Railroads 10
2. Service Railroads 6
3. Others 2
1.3 Port Grade 10
1. International Port 10
2. Domestic Port 6
3. None 2
1.4 Airport Grade 10
1. International Airport 10
2. Domestic Airport 6
3. None 2
2. Current Logistics Infrastructure Level (60%) 60
2.1 Road Condition 30
1. Unpaved (< 10%) 30
2. Unpaved (≥ 10% and < 50%) 15
3. Unpaved (≥ 50%) 5
2.2 Railroad Condition 10
1. Operative 10
2. Non-operative 2
2.3 Port and Airport 20
1. ≥ 3 20
2. ≥ 1 and < 3 10
3. None 5
Total 100
Elements Score
1. Operative 10
2. Not Operative 0
Total 100
Elements A1 A2 A3 A4 A5 A6 A7 A8
performance. For the 3rd quadrant, both demand and performance are so low
that need to be improved in the future. The 4th quadrant reflects low
demand and high performance and therefore, maintaining the current status
is recommended. In summary, it is recommended to select prior domains to
be selected from the 2nd and 1st quadrant.
According to the assessment results for domestic axes drawn from IPA,
Axis 1 (Phnom Penh-Sihanoukville), Axis 8 (Phnom Penh-Kampong Cham),
Axis 5 (Phnom Penh-Siem Reap), and Axis 3 (Phnom Penh-Kampong
Cham) were located in the 1st quadrant. These axes have a high demand
and high infrastructure level. Of these 4 axes, Axis 1 has the highest
demand and infrastructure level and therefore, it has been considered that
the current condition is highly advanced. Axis 3 and Axis 5 have a
relatively low demand but high performance. There are no axes located in
the 2nd quadrant. Axis 2 (Sihanoukville-Battambang) and Axis 6 (Siem
Reap-Stung Treng) were located in the 3rd quadrant. Since Axis 6 has a
low demand and very low performance, this axis needs to be improved on a
long-term basis. Axis 4 (Battambang-Siem Reap) and Axis 7 (Kampong
Cham-Stung Treng) were located in the 4th quadrant and thus, these axes
have a low demand and high performance. Since Axis 3 has higher a
infrastructure level compared to its demand, it has been shown that there
are already sufficient logistics infrastructure plans for this axis.
Strategies
1. Outline
Category Details
Based on the laws relating to logistics policies,
Establishment of National Basic establish mid/long-term strategies, visions,
Plan on Logistics and objectives to prepare changes in logistics
environment in the future
Framework Integration/modification of logistics policies,
Act on enhancing efficiency in logistics system, and
Logistics reinforcing competitiveness in logistics
Enactment of
Policies industries
Logistics Related
Distribution Establishment of distribution industry
Major Laws
Industry development plans, establishing infrastructure
Development for distribution industry development, and
Act enhancing efficiency of logistics functions
Establishment of Logistics Informatization of logistics and standardization
Industry Fostering Policies of logistics
Allocating roles for each governmental body
including Ministry of Public Transportation,
Restructuring of Governmental Ministry of Commerce, Industry and Energy,
Bodies Ministry of Land, City, and Construction,
Ministry of Trade, and Office of Customs
Administration
Logistics related laws deal with logistics facility and freight transportation
means including roads, railroads, ports, and airports and logistics industry or
logistics complex. The objective of these laws is to promote logistics
development and conveniency, and at the same time, to regulate logistics
related activities. In Cambodia, only the Road Act and Road Traffic Act are
currently enforced but there are no bills pertaining to logistics. Therefore,
the Framework Act on Logistics Policies and Distribution Industry
Development Act should be enacted in a timely fashion.
The objective of the Framework Act on Logistics Policies is to set basic
terms pertaining to establishment, implementation, and supportive measures of
domestic/international logistics policies, which aim at promoting efficiency,
advancement, and internationalization of a logistics system and competitiveness
of logistics industries, to contribute to nationwide economic growth.
In addition, this Act has set its basic ideology as perceiving the important
role of logistics, promoting quick, accurate, convenient, and safe logistics
activities, and harmonizing governmental logistics policies to facilitate
systematic development of logistics industries.
The Framework Act on Logistics Policies defines responsibilities in which
governmental bodies, local governments, logistics companies, and shippers
shall bear such conditions and its details are described below.
1) Informatization of Logistics
2) Standardization of Logistics
Logistics
Logistics Logistics Environment International
Ministry Complex
Operation Industries al Logistics Logistics
Facilities
Expanding hub
facilities Establishment Cargo Transportation
Construction of
(including cargo of integrated transportation and
international ports
terminal, ICD, logistics industry, marine management
and airports and
Ministry of distribution information transport industry, of dangerous
supporting
Public complex, air network and warehousing, substances and
complex
Transportation freight terminal, development of cargo establishment
transportation
port terminal) automated transportation of green
brokerage
and background logistics brokerage logistics
industry
land development devices industry policies
of port
Promoting
informatization
of logistics; Participation of
Collection and Supplying Underground
Ministry of standard bar international
delivery center; advanced system; logistics;
Commerce, code; standard construction
construction of establishment of pipeline
Industry and pallet; projects;
collection and standardized construction
Energy introduction of management of
delivery complex packaging industry
standard free trade zone
logistics
devices
Construction and
expansion of
urban logistics
Ministry of Establishment Promotion of
complex Supplying urban Policy of
Land, City, of urban international
facilities; logistics facility green urban
and logistics logistics in
establishment and equipment logistics
Construction policies regional level
and improvement
of connected
logistics system
Establishment
of trade
information
network; trade
automation Connecting
Ministry of
- system; - - oversea trade
Trade
supporting EDI network
system;
financial and
insurance
information
Customs for
Establishment
Office of import and
of tax Management of
Customs - - export; operation
information bonded warehouse
Administration of customs free
network
zone
Chapter 5. Conclusion
Summary
In Chapter 6, comprehensive suggestions from this project have been
proposed by categorizing three domains: expansion of a national logistics
complex, establishment of a national logistics axis, and establishment of a
logistics policy and system. Achievements from this project are to propose
plans to develop Cambodian logistics infrastructure based on experiences in
developing logistics in Korea. In addition, plans to acquire assets for
initiating logistics strategies proposed from this study have been described
in order to assist the Cambodian government in establishing action plans
going forward.
For this project, we would like to suggest the following three feasible
policies based on the analysis of traffic volume between each region and its
geographical characteristics.
Axis 1 (Phnom Penh – Sihanoukville ①)⇒ Axis 8 (Phnom Penh – Kampong Cham ②) ⇒
Axis 5 (Phnom Penh – Siem Reap ③) ⇒ Axis 3 (Phnom Penh – Battambang ④) ⇒ Axis
7 (Kampong Cham – Stung Treng ⑤) ⇒ Axis 4 (Battambang – Siem Reap ⑥) ⇒ Axis 2
(Sihanoukville – Battambang ⑦) ⇒ Axis 6 (Siem Reap – Stung Treng ⑧)
As for the analysis results for the Cambodian logistics axes, Axis 1, Axis 8,
Korea has suggested logistics complexes and logistics axes that connects
these logistics complexes for systematic expansion of logistics infrastructure in
the early stage of the enactment surrounding logistics plans for logistics
development. Subsequently, the government expanded the logistics complex
and traffic network based on this plan. In order to apply Korean’s background
and experiences encompassing logistics development to Cambodia, 6 regional
logistics complexes and 8 logistics axes were proposed based on the analysis of
baseline data. Furthermore, Korea strived to create opportunities for logistics
development in Cambodia through proposing policies for establishing logistics
systems and organizations. This project aims to draw conclusions suitable for
the current conditions in Cambodia through information on geographical features
and data on traffic volume. These drawn conclusions were reviewed in a local
briefing session.
This is a proposal for financing the aspects that Cambodia needs such as
establishment of a Basic Plan on Logistics and development of logistics
complexes as part of the logistics development strategies proposed through this
project.
References 181
Red River in Hanoi, Vietnam. 2015
Shin, Dong Sun, 2002, Research on Government Functions in the field of
Logistics and Establishing Responsibilities, The Korea Transport
Institute
1) Definition of logistics
3. Logistics System
1) Shipping
3) Packaging
Packaging means to protect the value and status of a product during its
transport of freight, storing, and handling during the distribution process, as
well as wrapping the products with appropriate materials or containers to
promote sales. It can be seen as a versatile activity in which protecting the
cargo’s (materials, semi-finished products, finished products, returns, used
products, waste products, etc.) biochemical value and promoting efficient
transportation to increase the level of service.
5) Logistics Information
Various decisions are made at each phase for the logistics process.
Decision-making is a very important process that should be delicately dealt
with in order to achieve successful and efficient operation of the entire
logistics system. First, the raw materials provider should decide which raw
materials to use and how much, how to manage those materials, to which
factory such materials can be most effectively provided, and how to
transport them. Storage and logistics complexes should decide where to
establish their workplace, how their layout and space is allocated, how to
manage incoming products, how much stock to store in their inventories,
and how much they should receive in terms of storage cost. Transport
companies decide upon transport facilities, means of transportation, transport
routes, amount, each unit of transport, duration of transport, and
loading/unloading procedures. In recent years, an optimized transport
scheduling system and realtime location tracking system using cutting-edge
technology is becoming a reality.
<Figure 11> Decision-making and Mutual Transaction between Shippers and Transport
Service Providers
Forwarders are transport brokers who deal with all work that is required
after cargo are transferred from consignors until the cargo is delivered to a
consignee. They are responsible for assembly, store/release, shipment,
transport, insurance, storage, and delivery of the cargo.
Government agencies are a combination of various departments, local
A logistics network is a set of all the features and activities that are
related to transport, ranging from the supply point (generating), point of
goods and services, through to the demand point, and it can be shown in
various forms in accordance to the steps of the flow and its characteristics.
Logistics network design includes the material supplier location, factory
location, number of warehouses and their location, number of logistics
complexes and their location, product allocation and management methods,
transportation and schedule, vehicle travel route, and consumer location and
The logistics process design includes the warehouse and logistics facility
location strategy, inventory management strategy, transportation strategy,
and their performance has a direct impact on the customer service level.
Thus, according to an efficient logistics process design and combination, the
level of customer service can be improved.
Source: www.sap.com