Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Metals in The Hydro Cycle
Metals in The Hydro Cycle
nl
W. Salomons U. Forstner
Metals in
the Hydrocycle
Springer-Verlag
Berlin Heidelberg New York Tokyo 1984
wim.salomons@home.nl
Dr. WIM SALOMONS
wim.salomons@home.nl
Preface
W.SALOMONS
U.FORSTNER
wim.salomons@home.nl
Contents
1 Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
2.1 Introduction . . . . . . . . 5
2.2 Metal Ions in Aquatic Systems 6
2.3 Speciation of Dissolved Metals 10
2.3.1 Physical Separation 11
2.3.2 ASV-Labile Species 13
2.3.3 Ion-Exchange Methods. 15
2.3.4 Speciation Schemes 15
2.4 Interaction with Ligands. . . 18
2.5 Interaction with Particulate Matter 24
2.5.1 Sorption Processes. . . . . 25
2.5.2 Mechanisms. . . . . . . . 25
2.5.3 Sorption on Metal Oxides and Organic Substances 28
2.5.4 Sorption of Metal-Organic Complexes 33
2.5.5 Interactions in Natural Systems 36
2.6 Solid Speciation . . . . . . . . 44
2.7 Metal Interaction with Organisms. . 50
2.7.1 Metal Uptake by Organisms. . 50
2.7.2 Solid Speciation and Bioavailability 55
2.7.3 Transformation of Metal by Organisms. 58
3.1 Introduction . . . . . . 63
3.2 Composition of Sediments 63
3.3 Transport of Sediments . 65
3.4 Distribution and Deposition 67
3.5 Grain Size Effects. . . . . 69
3.6 Anthropogenic Influences on Metal Concentrations in
Sediments . . . . . . . . . . . 76
3.6.1 Background Concentrations. . . . . . 76
3.6.2 Sediment Core Studies . . . . . . . . 78
3.6.3 Quantification of Environmental Impact 79
wim.salomons@home.nl
VIII Contents
4.1 Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 99
4.2 Natural and Anthropogenic Emissions of Trace Metals 100
4.3 Atmospheric Particles . . . . . . . . . . . . . 103
4.4 Deposition of Atmospheric Particles. . . . . . . 109
4.5 Metal Concentrations in Urban, Rural and Remote
Atmospheres . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 113
4.6 Environmental Impact of Airborne Trace Metals 116
4.6.1 Terrestrial Ecosystems . '. . . . . . . . 117
4.6.2 The Arctic and Antarctic Aerosol . . . . 124
4.6.2.1 Concentrations in Arctic and Antarctic
Areas . . . . . . . . . . 125
4.6.2.2 Seasonal Changes . . . . . . . . . . 126
4.6.2.3 Origin of the Arctic Aerosol . . . . . 128
4.6.3 Metals in the Oceanic Aerosol: Continental or
Ocean Derived? . . . . . . . . . . . . 131
4.6.3.1 Formation of the Oceanic Aerosol.. 131
4.6.3.2 Sea Surface Microlayer . . . . . . 133
4.6.3.3 Composition of the Oceanic Aerosol. 134
wim.salomons@home.nl
Contents IX
wim.salomons@home.nl
x Contents
References. . 291
wim.salomons@home.nl
1 Introduction
Trace metals have been transported along the hydrological cycle since the first oc-
currence of water on the planet earth. Water providing the medium for weathering
of the continents as well the medium for transport (together with the atmosphere)
of trace metals.
Figure 1 gives a schematic presentation of the movement of trace metals along
the hydrological cycle. The outer ring represents the particulate transport, the in-
ner ring the movement of soluble trace metals and the interactions with the particu-
lates. Finally, the center represents the atmosphere and its influence on all parts
of the hydrological cycle.
Along the pathway from continents to the oceans, the trace metals are subject
to a large number of processes. During transport environmental changes effect the
distribution over the dissolved and particulate phases. The accumulation in the lat-
ter causes a retention in the transport to the oceans, which under normal circum-
stances (transport in solution) takes only days to weeks. Particulate trace metals
may permanently accumulate in lakes or in river systems. However, this does not
mean that those metals are removed from the system. Sediments act as a reservoir
and changing environmental conditions may cause a remobilization of the accumu-
lated metals.
wim.salomons@home.nl
2 Introduction
Tropo.spheric _
winds
Surface water _ _ __
currents
Particles. dr0.Ps _ _ _ __
settling in air
Particles
settling in water---
Ground
- - - -water flow
Evaporation.
- upwelling in oceans
Ocean floor
- spreading
_ _ _ _ _ Sedimentation
oceans and lakes
(m/y)
Fig.2. Characteristic velocities associated with major transport processes in the hydrological cycle.
(Lerman, 1979)
Important processes are taking place at the interface river/ocean and in the con-
tinental shelf. In these areas an accumulation of natural and anthropogenic trace
metals takes place. In addition. estuaries and shelf areas are areas in which har-
bours and industrial centers are located. By nature harbours and estuaries are ef-
ficient sediment traps, a feature which interferes with human activities. Huge quan-
tities of (contaminated) sediments have to be removed from the world's navigation
channels and are dumped either on land or in the ocean. In this way they end up
in places, which they never would reach by natural processes.
Once the riverine (or atmospheric) trace metals have entered the oceans, they
take part in the intricate biogeochemical processes and cycling in the world oceans.
Ultimately, they become incorporated in the oceanic sediments, where they will
spend several millions of years before taking part in the next hydrological cycle.
Each part of the hydrological cycle has its own time scales for the movement
of metals in it (Fig. 2).
From the rates of sedimentation on the ocean floor to the velocity of particles
in the atmosphere differences of 10 13 are found. Also the residence time of trace
metals in the various reservoirs varies from days (rivers, atmosphere) to several
thousands of years (oceans).
Another highly variable factor is the particulate concentrations. High concen-
trations are found in rivers and in estuaries, whereas the concentrations in the
oceans are extremely low (Fig. 3).
Due to variations in time scales, biological activity and particulate concen-
trations, the processes are seldom taking place under equilibrium conditions; kinet-
ics play an important role.
Trace metals are introduced directly in each compartment (Fig. I) and are
transported from one compartment to another. Sources for trace metals are the
wim.salomons@home.nl
Introduction 3
Environment
Concent rat ion (mg I"
10-4 10-3 10-2 10-1 10 10 2 103 104 105
Rivers
Estuaries - surface
-bottom
Shelves -surfaca
-middle
-bottom
Oceans - surface
-middle
-bottom
Natural Anthropogenic
LITHOSPHERE
ROCKS
11000.000.0001
Fig. 4. Present-day and pre-historical cadmium fluxes. (Brunner and Baccini, 1981)
natural processes of weathering and erosion and volcanic activity. However, with
the large-scale extraction of ore from the earth's crust, it is necessary to take into
account the great influence man has on metal cycles. This is especially the case for
metals found in the atmosphere. Historically the rate of emission of trace metals
to the atmosphere has been low due to their low volatility. However, with the ad-
vent of high-temperature processe's like smelting and fossil fuel combustion, the
rate of emission for some trace metals has substantially increased. This shift from
natural control to anthropogenic control represents a significant perturbation of
metal cycles.
As an example of this influence the pre-industrialised and present-day cycle of
cadmium are presented in Fig. 4.
For cadmium most fluxes exceed the natural ones. Fluxes to the atmosphere
are more than 5 times the natural flux. Most of this cadmium is deposited on the
continents and influences terrestrial ecosystems.
wim.salomons@home.nl
4 Introduction
The influence of man on trace metal cycling is not restricted to the increase of
fluxes. Deforestation, construction of deep harbours and man-made reservoirs af-
fect the rate of transport of particulate trace metals. The acidification of continen-
tal waters and soils, the introduction of complexing agents (e.g., NTA) in natural
systems as well as the eutrophication all affect trace metal behaviour and cause per-
turbations on the natural pathways from rivers to the oceans.
In this book we will give an account of the presently available knowledge on
the movement qf trace metals along the hydrological cycle, emphasizing the pro-
cesses. In order to do so, the book.is divided in two parts. The first part (Chaps. 2
and 3) gives an overview on new developments on speciation, adsorption/desorp-
tion and diagenesis of trace metals; aspects which are common to all parts of the
cycle. In the second part (the main theme of the book), the individual parts of the
hydrological cycle, atmosphere, continental waters, estuaries and oceans, are dis-
cussed.
wim.salomons@home.nl
2 Interactions with Ligands, Particulate Matter
and Organisms
2.1 Introduction
A rough description of the occurrence and behaviour of trace metals in aquatic and
terrestrial systems is presented in Fig. 5. In the aquatic environment four abiotic
reservoirs are distinguished: the suspended matter, the sediments, the surface
waters and the pore waters. These four reservoirs strongly interact with each other.
Between the suspended matter and the metals in solution, adsorption/desorption
and (co-)precipitation processes take place. The suspended matter and the de-
posited sediments are interlinked through sedimentation and erosion processes.
Processes taking place after deposition (diagenesis) provide the interstitial waters
with sometimes high concentrations of trace metals, which through processes such
as diffusion, consolidation and bioturbation are able to influence the metal concen-
trations in the surface waters.
All four reservoirs as well as the groundwater and the soil in the terrestrial en-
vironment influence metal uptake by biota. The determination of the bio-available
fraction in each of the abiotic reservoirs is presently one of the major study areas
in metal research. Bio-availability as well as the interactions between the abiotic
AnUAT I C
STUDIES
Fig. 5. Schematic presentation of metal reservoirs and their interactions in aquatic and terrestrial sys-
tems
wim.salomons@home.nl
6 Interactions with Ligands, Particulate Matter and Organisms
reservoirs is determined by the speciation of the trace metals, speciation being de-
fined as "the determination of the individual physico-chemical forms of the ele-
ment which together make up its total concentration" (Florence, 1982).
In this chapter a review on speciation and bio-availability of trace metals in
aquatic systems will be given. Terrestrial systems are discussed in Chaps 4.6.1 and
5.2.4.
The behaviour of trace metals in aquatic systems is highly complex due to the large
number of possible interactions with ill-defined dissolved and particulate com-
ponents and non-equilibrium conditions. Direct precipitation of metal compounds
may take place when external factors change. These precipitation barriers com-
monly arise because of changes in pH, in oxidation potential, or in concentrations
of precipitating substances. Causes for precipitation include interactions of water
with solids, mixing with other water, and loss or addition of gases (Rose et aI.,
1979). Major types are (see Perel'man, 1967, as cited by Rose et aI., 1979):
(a) oxidation type (iron- and manganese-oxides or native sulfur precipitated by
oxidation of reducing solutions and usually caused by water emergence at the sur-
face or a flow of reducing water out of a swamp);
(b) reducing type (U, V, Cu, Se and Ag precipitated as metals or lower-valency
oxides by reduction of oxidizing water and usually caused by an encounter with
organic matter or a mixing with reducing waters or gases);
(c) reducing sulfide type (Fe, Cu, Ag, Zn, Pb, Hg, Ni, Co, As and Mo are pre-
cipitated as sulfides by reduction of oxidizing sulfate waters, usually by the action
of sulfate-reducing bacteria) (U, V and Se may also be precipitated and the causes
are the same as for the reducing type, but they require the presence of dissolved
sulfate);
(d) sulfate-carbonate type (Ba, Sr and Ca precipitated by increased sulfate or
carbonate as a result of the mixing of waters, the oxidation of sulfide, or passage
into carbonate rock);
(e) alkaline type (Ca, Mg, Sr, Mn, Fe, Cu, Zn, Pb, Cd and other elements pre-
cipitated by increased pH, usually caused by the interaction of acid waters with car-
bonates or silicate rocks, or its mixing with alkaline waters);
(t) adsorptive type (adsorption or coprecipitation of ions on accumulations of
Fe-Mn-oxides, clays, and organic materials) (the cations of transition metals and
those with high valence tend to be more strongly adsorbed than anions and low-
valency cations).
If relevant stability constants are known, the equilibrium concentration of a
dissolved metal, its inorganic speciation and its stable solid compounds can be cal-
culated. The solubility curves for cadmium and zinc in Fig. 6, taking into account
the range of carbonate content normally encountered in inland waters (10- 3 to
10- 2 mole dissolved CO 2 per litre), show a minimum at pH values of9.3. Assum-
ing pH values to be 7 to 8 in normal river waters (under oxidizing conditions) it
wim.salomons@home.nl
Metal Ions in Aquatic Systems 7
1.2
0 \ 1._. 1O-.Jeco2
1.0
0..,
~O
I I
~\
,\\1
10-2 Mole C02 0.8
-1
, f'\ 0.6
r
-2 \
Zn 2 +
\
\
\
~\ line 0.4 I
I
't \~ ~ ~
I
I
'- \ 0.2 I
e
-4 :z:
.!E'
\\ ~\. '., C
:z:1 I
." .,
U -5 0.0 N Ol~
III \,\ -I:z:
.2
., ' ~ \ ~:O
-6 -0.2 1-
CadmiUm~ ',:,\ \
/I
I C
IN
" 1'..\ -0.4
-7
" " ....... ~ , l
..... " ... __ .... I
I
-8 -0.6
a
' ...... _/
~' Eh
b
-9 (V)
4.0 5.0 6.0 7.0 8.0 9.0 10.0 11.0 pH 2 4 6 8 10 12 14
pH ~
Fig.6a,b. Solubilities of zinc and cadmium as a function of pH (Fig. a) and fields of stability of solids
and dissolved zinc species in the system Zn + CO 2 + S + H 2 0 at 25°C and I atm (fig. b) in water
(from Hem, 1972). (a) Total dissolved carbon dioxide species, 10- 3 and 10- 2 mole/I, resp.; ionic
strength of 0.0; Log C in moles Zn or Cd/I. (b) Dissolved zinc activity, IO- s mole/I; dissolved carbon
dioxide and sulfur species, 10- 3 mole/I
has been calculated that between 100 and 1000 ~g/I zinc (and 5 to 100 ~g/I cad-
mium) may be present in the dissolved state. In the system, Zn + S + CO 2 + H 2 0,
where the zinc concentration is 10- 5 molar (together with 10- 3 moles of dissolved
CO 2 and sulfur), three solid phases are possible: the sulfide, carbonate and hydrox-
ide of zinc. In aerated water, zinc carbonate is the stable phase if the pH fall below
8.3; above a pH of8.3 a precipitation of zinc hydroxide occurs.
The solution of this type of chemical equilibrium calculation is usually accom-
plished by the use of readily-accessible computer programmes (see Nordstrom et
aI., 1979). Also the calculation ofthe dissolved speciation of trace metals is readily
accomplished. An example of recent calculations on the dissolved speciation of
trace metals in seawater and in surface waters is given in Table I.
Modelling of aquatic systems is still hampered by the absence of good data
bases to validate the models used. Only in the last few years has it been possible
to overcome the technical problems associated with the sampling and analysis of
trace metals at the ppb or sub-ppb levels. At present, geochemical modelling is ex-
tremely valuable in predicting trends under changing conditions and is at present
one of the objects that mathematical modelling can achieve quite well. However,
it should be understood that any model is only as good as the equilibrium constants
used (or parameters used for kinetic submodels) as well as the preconceived ideas
the modellers have in their particular description of the system.
wim.salomons@home.nl
8 Interactions with Ligands, Particulate Matter and Organisms
Cation Free OH F Cl 80 4 C0 3
wim.salomons@home.nl
Metal Ions in Aquatic Systems 9
10 Cu. mg/I
6 5 pH 4
I i i
A
,ICurJHIz~1
---,------------------_.
C.JOH~CO,
*
• log KcuO= -19.9
Equilibrium with
B I"SO:' -:\l----::::::::::::
I'---CU-10-H~'-.• .,. ::::
.. log KcuO= -19.9
No equilibrium with PC0 2 atmosphere c EcuillO• • • •~C~.,~IO~~~~:::::::::
• log Kcuo =-20.35
* Experimental curve A. K . value DI CuO 1. 19.9
5.6 6.0 6.4 6.8. 7.2 7.6 8.0 C . K. y,i!lue of CoO I . 20.35
Fig.7. Experimentally determined relationship between pH and copper concentrations and the results
of three model calculations using the Charon geochemical model
the atmosphere over the river stretch considered. The calculation in which equilib-
rium with CO 2 was allowed for gave the best agreement between observed and cal-
culated values; however, inserting a different K-value of CuO gives a better agree-
ment. Also the solid phases controlling the solubility in this rather simple system,
depend to a large extent on the K-values used and on equilibrium with the atmo-
sphere (see insert in Fig. 7). This example shows the complexity in the geochemical
modelling of even a simple system.
Geochemical modelling may also be used to evaluate the need for additional
parameters to be measured as was shown by Jenne et al. (1980) in their study of
the behaviour of cadmium in drainage waters from a mining area in the USA. It
was found that the disagreement between observed and calculated cadmium con-
centrations was not due to thermodynamic data of octavite (CdC0 3 ) but rather
that the incorporation of sulfide levels at a fractional milligram per liter level was
sufficient to find an agreement between the results of the geochemical model and
the experimental results. Similarly Jenne (1981) concluded that to reliably evaluate
solubility equilibria of metal sulfides and phosphates in water contaminated by oil
shale leachates, that the detection limits for sulfide and phosphate need to be at
least as low as 0.005 mg/l and 0.01 mg/l respectively.
The greatest limitations in computing aqueous speciation in natural waters are
the absence of appropriate methods to address the complexation of metals by or-
ganic ligands and the disequilibrium between redox couples (Jenne, 1981). Addi-
tional limitations include the lack of sufficient thermodynamic and kinetic data
and the lack of competence of the available geochemical models. The most urgently
needed data for geochemical modelling include (Jenne, 1981):
wim.salomons@home.nl
10 Interactions with Ligands, Particulate Matter and Organisms
The various methods to determine the speciation of trace metals in solution can
be divided in four broad categories:
- Chemical equilibrium models.
With the readily available chemical equilibrium models it is possible to calculate,
once the species in solution have been identified and the relevant equilibrium
constants are known, the equilibrium distribution of trace metals over the vari-
ous organic and inorganic complexes taken into account by the model.
- Physical separation methods.
Using physical separation methods, like filtration, it is possible to classify the
species according to size.
J~_'~h __ J
equilibrium models I 1pure pbases
MOOELLING
--------.1 1______ - -
size fractionation
- - -
UV photolysis
OPERATIONAL ASV .... ith ch!'!!.i£I!.!.P~!!!L8.!'E.~nl ____
MEASUREMENT
Chelex
-------, I
-----------------~------
extraction procedures
- J - - - - - -
DIRECT ISE I
LECTROCHEMICAl A§,V-=-=-=J ------ -------,
MEASUREMENT exhaustive ele~troIY.!lis_ .~_ _ ____ J
BIOLOGICAL
UPTAKE
phyto
plankton
_______________ l_______ ~-------,
paJticle feeders I
- - - - " --- -- - .J
Fig. 8. Classification of metal compounds according to size and methods to determine the distribution
of the trace metals species in natural waters. (Redrawn after Turner and Whitfield, 1980).
wim.salomons@home.nl
Physical Separation 11
- Chemical methods.
With the chemical methods the metals are classified according to their interac-
tion with substances like chelating agents or by their behaviour at the mercury
electrode during voltammetric measurements.
- Direct chemical methods.
Few methods exist for a positive identification of metal species in solution, ex-
ceptions are the organo-metal species, for which several elegant methods have
been designed (Chau and Wong, 1983).
In most cases the three methods are combined into speciation schemes. Fur-
thermore biological assays have been developed to determine the influence of metal
species on organisms. Figure 8 gives a summary ofthe various methods in use.
Size fractionation alone is potentially a useful technique for speciation since the
bio-available fraction is generally associated with the smaller size categories (Bat-
ley, 1983) and several methods exist to fractionate metals in surface waters with
physical techniques.
The most common method to speciate metals in surface waters is filtration
through a 0.45 11m nominal pore size filter. In this way a distinction is made be-
tween "dissolved or soluble" and particulate metals. Two filters are generally in
use:
- cellulose membrane filters
- polycarbonate filters
The cellulose filters are depth filters with a thickness of about 150 11m, an ir-
regularly shaped pore structure and interconnecting pore parts. Particles may be
trapped within the membrane structure. Furthermore, they represent a consider-
able surface area for adsorption.
The pore size to filter thickness ratio is smaller for polycarbonate membrane
filters, which are more like screen filters. They consist of films with a thickness of
about 10 m in which the required holes are etched. Due to their structure they offer
far less area for adsorption. A disadvantage is the fact that they are more prone
to clogging and often require vigorous stirring of the solution (breaking up oflarg-
er particles). A review of manufacture and use of these filters has been given by
Strathmann (1981).
Both vacuum and pressure filtration is applied; however, with the latter method
phytoplankton cells may be ruptured. These ruptured cells contribute to the solu-
ble organics, nutrients and metals in the filtrate (Florence and Batley, 1980). In
waters with a high turbidity the results may be effected by the clogging of the pores,
and in extreme cases the water is filtered through the filter cake instead of the mem-
brane filter.
It should be stressed that all experimentally determined results on the fraction-
ation of extremely low levels of trace metals are subject to contamination from the
materials used and to adsorption during the filtration steps or during storage of
the water sample. Care should be taken to carry out the procedure as soon as pos-
wim.salomons@home.nl
12 Interactions with Ligands, Particulate Matter and Organisms
sible after sampling, because during storage, changes in pH, temperature and mi-
crobial degradations may take place, all affecting the distribution of metals over
the various phases (Benes and Steinnes, 1974; Smith, 1976; Florence and Batley,
1980; Piotrowicz et al., 1983).
A further size fractionation of the "dissolved fraction" passing through a
0.45 11m urn filter is possible with variety of techniques (Table 2). In using a com-
bination of ultra-membrane filters and polycarbonate membrane filters a range
from 1 nm to 12 11m can be covered (Hoffmann et al., 1981; v.d. Meentet al., 1982).
Some results of a sequential size fractionation of surface waters is shown in Fig.9.
Table 2. Physical methods for the size fractionation of "dissolved" compounds in natural waters
CARBON IRON
4 2
en 70%
.g
<.J
Q
Q 2
..
.....
15%
0
COPPER
_ 1.0 _ 0.4
~
5-
=
<..>D.5 ~Ol
0:
0
LEAO CAOMIUM
OA 0.4
wim.salomons@home.nl
ASV-Labile Species 13
In Minnesota and Mississippi river waters, the metals were found to be mainly
associated with the intermediate molecular weight fractions between 1000 and
10,000, in these fractions no detectible free or labile bound metals were found as
defined by ASV (Anodic Stripping Voltammetry), indicating that the complexes
belong to the very moderately labile or slowly labile fraction as defined by Figura
and McDuffie (1980). To obtain more information on the metals in the filtrates,
organic carbon determinations are carried out (Giesy and Briese, 1977; Hoffmann
et ai., 1981) or the organic matter composition is characterised with advanced tech-
niques like pyrolisis mass spectrometry (v.d. Meent et ai., 1982).
Sequential filtration by nUcleopore filters is also a convenient method to frac-
tionate aerosol samples (Heidam, 1981).
Dialysis methods have been used quite extensively by Benes and co-workers
(Benes and Steinnes, 1974; 1976; Benes et ai., 1976; Benes, 1980). A dialysis bag
is placed in the solution to be analysed. Only ionic species and small complexes pass
through the membrane. After equilibrium has been reached the contents of the bag
can be analysed with a variety of techniques to access the ionic fraction (and small
complexes) of metals in the sample. However, recent evidence suggests that not all
small ionic species [e.g. Cuz(OH)z] pass through (Truitt and Weber, 1981). Recent-
ly this method has been used in the field in combination with an active biological
monitoring programme (using the bivalve Dreissena polymorpha) to determine the
bio-available species of metals (Del Castilho et ai., 1983).
The disadvantage of this technique is its long equilibration time. However, this
drawback has been overcome by using a combination of dialysis and ion- exchange
techniques (Hart and Davies, 1977). The solution from the dialysis bag is continu-
ously passed through an ion exchange column in a closed loop system. In this way
an optimum concentration gradient is obtained over the dialysis membrane, speed-
ing up the separation.
Less often used methods include centrifugation (Lammers, 1967; Benes and
Steinnes, 1975) and ion exclusion chromatography (Gjessing, 1965; Betz, 1979;
Steinberg, 1980) and reverse-phase liquid chromatography (Lee, 1981; Mills and
Quinn, 1981).
Voltammetric techniques are the most common to obtain information on the spe-
ciation of trace metals in solution. The analysis is performed in a cell which con-
tains a mercury drop or film electrode. A voltage is applied to the mercury elec-
trode more negative than is necessary to reduce the metal ion in solution. The
metals move toward the electrode and are reduced, with the formation of an amal-
gam at the electrode. In this way metals are concentrated in the mercury electrode.
The amount of metal removed from the solution by this concentration step is about
0.25 % of the total content (Barendrecht, 1967). After this concentration step, the
voltage is reversed and a gradually increasing voltage is applied to the electrode.
As the voltage approaches the oxidation potential of one of the metals present, the
ions of the metal pass into the solution and the current increases. The potential at
which metals pass into the solution is characteristic for each metal and the current
wim.salomons@home.nl
14 Interactions with Ligands, Particulate Matter and Organisms
lower pH
Adsorption
Adsorption
METAL IONS :::;~;:::====t====>~
_ PARTICULATE
MATTER
Desorption
'lower pH ,
I
I Flocculation
I
INORGANIC
COMPLEXES ----~------3.~
I COLLOIDS
I
Fig.tO. Interrelationships between various metal species in water and their relationship to electro-
analytical methods. (Redrawn after Whitfield, 1975)
wim.salomons@home.nl
Speciation Schemes 15
In the ion-exchange method, the water sample is brought into contact with an ion-
exchange medium either in a batch technique or by passing the sample through a
column packed with the ion-exchange medium. Chelex is probably the most used.
When Chelex is added to the water sample it competes with the ligands for com-
plexation of the trace metals. The fraction of the metals not removed by the Chelex
resin is called the "bound fraction" and the fraction taken up by the resin, the "ex-
changeable" fraction (Hart and Davies, 1977; 1981a; 1981b). Calculation showed
that only if the formation constant between the metal and the ligand in solution
is in the order of 13 or 14 can it compete effectively with the resin. Therefore all
ligands with formation constants (log K) less than about II are stripped off their
metals. Those substances which keep the metals bound to them are probably non-
ion-exchangeable fractions, which exist as colloids and inorganic forms (Hart and
Davies, 1981a).
Figura and McDuffie (1979; 1980) used a kinetic approach for the separation
of metal species by Chelex resins by using a short equilibration time of about 7 s
by passing the water sample over a small column followed by a long equilibration
time with the batch technique (72 h). The CdNTA complex which is non-labile
with the ASV -method is now retained on the Chelex column. The fraction retained
by the column is termed the "moderately labile" fraction, the amount retained by
the batch technique the "slowly labile" fraction. The fraction not retained by the
column and by the batch technique is termed the "inert" fraction and is likely to
be similar to the bound fraction as defined by Hart and Davies (1977; 1981a;
1981 b). A range of ion-exchange materials was evaluated by Florence (1982) to
find a simple procedure to determine aquatic toxicity of trace metals. However, an
unequivocal recommendation could not be made, and should await algal toxicity
tests in progress.
Several of the individual methods discussed in the foregoing section can be brought
into speciation schemes to differentiate between forms of metals.
The first and still most comprehensive scheme was used by Batley and co-work-
ers (Batley and Florence, 1976; Batley and Gardner, 1978). The scheme divided the
sample in fractions passing in 0.45 J.1m um filter and separating the particulate
metals from the "dissolved" metals. The "dissolved" metal fraction is measured
wim.salomons@home.nl
16 Interactions with Ligands, Particulate Matter and Organisms
Sample
Filter
O,40flm Nucleopore
Fig.H. The analytical speciation scheme developed by Hart and Davies (1981 a)
Fe Cd Cu Pb Zn
1400
=
....
5- 1000 50 Parti c" late
Meta l Mp
""
Bound Metal
~ 600 30 Mb
<.J
Ion Exchangeable
10
Metal Mi.
200
Oialysabl e
Motal Md
Fig. 12. The Hart and Davies scheme applied to freshwater (F) and estuarine waters (E) from the Yarra
River (Australia). (Hart and Davies, 1981a)
with ASV making a distinction possible between ASV-labile and non-AS V-labile
fraction (called the "bound fraction"). The "dissolved" fraction is also passed
through a chelating resin column, before and after removing the organic matter
with UV -radiation. With this scheme they were able to identify seven classes of
compounds. The scheme is laborious (analysis time for one sample about 1 day),
which precludes its application to routine analysis, and the scheme is possibly more
complex than is needed for biological availability studies (Batley, 1983).
The Hart and Davies scheme (Hart and Davies, 1977a; 1977b; 1981a; 1981b) is
much simpler, it defines filtrable, exchangeable and dialysable metal fractions
(Fig. II):
The amount of exchangeable metal is determined in a batch procedure with
Chelex and the dialysable fraction is obtained with the combined ion-exchange-
dialysis technique discussed in Chap. 2.3.3. This method has been applied to lakes
and estuaries and some results are shown in Fig. 12.
wim.salomons@home.nl
Speciation Schemes 17
DIGEST, EVAP.
TOTAL TM'S
+ ASV
CHELEX COLUMN
CHELEX BATCH
13 DAYS)
DIGEST,
EVAP.
+ASV
'INERT'
Cd Cu
~
--------------------i-
_---------1
------------------
Susqbl~ann.
1
I 1 _
St. Lawrence
----...I-L.£..<..y.7?<~W7_7'S~'7"iI
_
Hudson
1-.
~ ________ ~~~~~~wu
Zn Pb
t========j-----~---~:~~:::
_---- -----------1 ~
~~ 1 _ Hudson
Fig. 13. The kinetic speciation scheme developed by Figura and McDuffie (1979; 1980) with results for
a number of river waters
wim.salomons@home.nl
18 Interactions with Ligands, Particulate Matter and Organisms
the "inert fraction". In this way trace metal complexes are differentiated according
to their kinetic behaviour. A scheme of this fractionation method, together with
some results are given in Fig. 13.
The scheme is simple and this operational approach could be useful for bio-
availability studies (Batley, 1983).
A size fractionation scheme of Hoffmann et al. (1981) consists of a centrifu-
gation step followed by filtration through 0.45 ~m filter followed by ultra- filtra-
tion over filters with nominal molecular weight cut-offs of lOS, 2.5 x 10\ 104 , and
10 3 • In the filtrate complexing capacity of organic matter as well as the total or-
ganic matter content were determined. Some results of this scheme have already
been presented in figure 9. The Harrison-Laxen scheme (Harrison and Laxen,
1981) consists of a size fractionation with nucleopore filters from 0.12 ~m to
0.0015 ~m. Apart from total filtrable metals, ASV-labile metals before and after
destruction of the organic matter are determined in the filtrates of the 1 ~m and
0.08 ~m filters. Chelex labile metals are determined additionally in the 1 ~m fil-
trate. Harrison and Laxen also carried out experiments with ultra-filters; however
these proved to be prone to adsorption and were not incorporated in the final
scheme. For most freshwaters studied the UV-radiation technique for destroying
the organic matter was not feasible, inorganic brown deposits were formed and a
pH increase was observed. Hasle and Abdullah (1981) combined ultra-filtration
followed by the determination oflabile, acid-soluble and total metals with ASV for
coastal seawaters.
Radiotracers were used by Amdurer et al. (1982) to study the behaviour of
metals in large marine microcosms. Their speciation scheme consists of filtration
through 0.45 ~m filters followed by sequential filtration with ultra-filters followed
by weight cutoff of 10 5 , 104 and 10 3 • Additionally the filtrate from the 0.45 ~m fil-
ters was passed through an activated charcoal column followed by passage through
a Chelex column. The fraction retained by charcoal represents some combination
of organically complexed and colloidal metals, plus dissolved inorganic species.
The species in the effiuent are obviously very unreactive towards most adsorbing
surfaces and complexing agents since they passed through a very strong adsorbent
(charcoal) and chelating agent (Chelex).
Most natural waters have a certain capacity to reduce the toxicity of added metals,
which has been attributed to the presence of ligands in the waters complexing the
added metal ions and making them less bio-available for organisms. Furthermore
the adsorption of metal ions to particulates in waters is influenced by the presence
ofligands (see Chap. 2.5).
The complexation of added ionic metals to natural waters is generally referred
to as the complexing capacity of the water (Hart, 1981; Neubecker and Allen,
1983).
The determination of chemical forms of organic matter in surface waters is
quite demanding, but is of little value in providing information as to possible in-
wim.salomons@home.nl
Interaction with Ligands 19
teractions of these species with inputs of heavy metals (Florence and Batley, 1980).
Therefore operationally defined methods are used to determine the response of sur-
face waters to the addition of ionic metal species.
When trace metals are added to a natural water sample, the metal ions are dis-
tributed over the various complexing ligands present. When equilibrium has been
reached the total metal concentration is given by (Hart, 1981):
[M]= [Mn+]+ [MI] + [ML] . (1)
Where: [Mn+] is the concentration of the free metal ion; [MI] is the total concen-
tration of the inorganic complexes, [ML] is the total concentration of the inorganic
complexes.
The metal-organic complex will be in equilibrium with the free ion:
L- *K[Mn+] [L t]
(2)
M - 1+*K[Mn+]
wim.salomons@home.nl
20 Interactions with Ligands, Particulate Matter and Organisms
3000
• Rhine
KdX1D BMol·l Complex;ng capac;ly 0.25" M
.IJsselmeer 2.0
K.D.7.1oBMol·l Complox;ng copac;ly 0.53" M •
2000 1.5
'-
'"
3-1.0
=
1000 ~
.!!
:0;
.!! 0.5
>
III
C
Fig. 14. Typical curves obtained for the titration of river Rhine and the IJ sseImeer and the relationship
between ASV -labile copper and the complexing capacity
wim.salomons@home.nl
Interaction with Ligands 21
Table 3. Summary of methods to determine the complexing capacity of natural waters. (Based on
Hart, 1981 and Neubecker and Allen, 1983, with some new additions of recent literature)
Voltammetric The solution is titrated with copper, Chau et al. (1974), Ernst et al. (1975),
methods and the response "ASV -labile" metal Smith (1976), Shuman and Wood-
is measured ward (1977), Duinker and Kramer
(1977), Hanck and Dillard (1977),
Sugai and Healy (1978), Shuman and
Cromer (1979), Baccini and Suter
(1979), Bhat et al. (1981), Hart and
Davies (1981), Blustein and Shaw
(1981), Tuschall and Brezonik (1981)
Ion exchange Metal ions are added to the natural Baccini and Suter (1979), Van den Berg
methods water sample which contains a certain and Kramer (1979a, 1979b),
amount of an ion-exchange medium Figura and McDuffie (1979),
(Mn0 2 , Dowex, Chelex). Metal left Crosser and Allen (1977)
in solution is measured with suitable
technique
Ion selective The solution is titrated with copper Buffle et al. (1977, 1980), Buffle (1980),
electrodes or cadmium ions, and the metal ion Giesy et al. (1978), Giesy (1980),
is measured with the ISE Sunda and Hanson (1979),
van den Meent et al. 1982), Giesy and
Briese (1980), McCrady and Chap-
man (1979), Bhat et al. (1981)
Biological Decrease in photosynthetic activity of Giichteretal. (1978), Davey etal. (1973),
methods plankton upon addition of metal Srna et al. (1980)
Growth suppression of bacteria upon Gillespie and Vaccaro (1978,1981)
addition of metal
Uptake of 3H-labelled amino acids Sunda and Ferguson (1982i)
by bacteria
Dialysis methods Copper ions are added to the surface Guy and Chakrabarti (1976), Truitt and
water sample and the uncomplexed Weber (1981)
and complexed metal is separated by
dialysis
wim.salomons@home.nl
22 Interactions with Ligands, Particulate Matter and Organisms
which includes both the free aquo metal ions, certain inorganic complexes (depend-
ing on pH) and organic complexes with small K values. Adsorption of organic mat-
ter at the electrode can depress the current signal for a given added metal concen-
tration resulting in an effect similar to that produced by binding ligands in solu-
tion. This can give rise to errors although the effect is only usually observed with
excessively high organic concentrations.
Ion-selective electrodes (both cadmium and copper) have been used quite often.
Although it is the only method which can measure the free ionic form, its main
drawback is low sensitivity. Natural waters have to be concentrated to obtain suf-
ficient ligand concentration to obtain a break in the curve. Large spikes have to
be added; in this way, strongly complexing ligands at low concentrations may be
overlooked. Apart from these two methods, which rely more or less on direct mea-
surement of metal species, there exist a number of techniques, which use an addi-
tional step to separate the uncomplexed from the complexed metal ions. In the
dialysis method (Table 3) the surface water is titrated with copper similar to the
preceding methods; however, in the solution is placed a dialysis bag, which allows
the free movement of small metal complexes. After equilibration the contents of
the bag are analysed. As has been mentioned above, a considerable drawback of
the technique is the rather long equilibration time needed.
An ion-exchange method for the determination of complexing capacity and of
conditional equilibrium constants has been proposed by v.d. Berg and Kramer
(1979a; 1979b). In the solution to be titrated a suspension of Mn0 2 is present. Add-
ed metal ions distribute themselves over the ion-exchange medium, the ligands and
part remains as the free metal ion. The total metal (Me+ MeL) in solution can be
determined after removing the Mn0 2 from suspension by filtration. In order to
evaluate the formulae properly, it is necessary to determine the free aquo ion.
This can be done by measuring the amount of adsorbed metal on the MnO z
suspension and relating it to an experimentally determined adsorption curve in ab-
sence ofligands. From the adsorption curve and the measured adsorbed metal con-
centration, the free metal concentration can be determined and plots of [Me]/[MeL]
versus Me can be constructed to determine Lt and K in a way similar to that as
described in the preceding section. In the calculation it is assumed that no adsorp-
tion of metal-ligand complexes take place. However, this type of adsorption cannot
be excluded (see Chap. 2.5.4.).
A number of studies have provided evidence that the free metal ion is the toxic
metal species for organisms (Sunda and Guillard, 1976; Gillespie and Vaccaro,
1978). This fact is the basis for bio-assay techniques to determine the complexing
capacity and in some cases also the equilibrium constants. The growth rate of an
organism (or other metabolic parameters) is measured as a function of added metal
ions. The first metal added will be complexed by the ligands present, and only a
small metabolic effect on the organism is the result. However, after all ligands are
complexed with metals, the added metal will remain in the ionic form and affect
the organisms.
Davey et al. (1973) used a marine diatom as the test organism. Seawater and
seawater to which EDT A and histidine as complexing agents were added were ti-
trated with copper and the growth depression of the diatom was measured. Gille-
spie and Vaccaro (1978) used bacteria cultures isolated from the Saanich Inlet in
wim.salomons@home.nl
Interaction with Ligands 23
100
Fig. 15. Depression in the uptake
of 14C labelled glucose by bacteria :;
'x
in water from the Sargasso Sea 0 x
II:
and Nantucket Sound as a func- ~
z 0
\
tion of added copper. (Redrawn 0
80
U
after Gillespie and Vaccaro, 1978)
I"
~
Z
0 I x NANTUCKET
t= 60
cC SOUND.
....
i I x
in
t/)
cC 40
\SA~GASSO
! "
x", x
w o
t/)
0
'x-
U
:::I SEA
....
"...
U
I
...
20
0
1-
1
1
0, - - - - -
00 4 8 12 16 20
ADDED COPPER (u9L- 1 )
British Columbia in a similar way. In the latter investigation the uptake of 14C la-
belled glucose was used as a metabolic parameter. Some results for the Sargasso
Sea and the Nantucket Sound are presented in Fig. IS.
The midpoint of the segment showing maximum change for each of the curves
was interpreted as the copper saturation point (Davey et ai, 1973), which is related
to the complexing capacity. Ultra-violet radiation, which destroys the organic mat-
ter, removed most of the complexing capacity present in the waters studied.
Gachter et al. (1978) studied Lake Alpnach in Switzerland and used native
phytoplankton as test organisms. The water was spiked with 14C labelled sodium
bicarbonate and the primary production was measured as a function of added cop-
per. Sma et al. (1980) compared the ASV-method for the determination of the
complexing capacity with a biological method employing a diatom. The biological
complexing capacity was defined as the differences in the amount of copper needed
to produce a 50% reduction in growth (EC so value) between filtered and ultra-fil-
tered water. A correlation coefficient of 0.993 was observed between the titration
method and the biological assay. The uptake of3H labelled amino acid by bacteria
in seawater from high- and low-productivity areas was used by Sunda and Fer-
guson (1982). The bio-assays indicated higher complexation of added copper in
high productivity coastal samples. The conditional stability constants obtained
were high and varied between 9 and II (log K).
A short summary of data on complexing capacity an K-values for natural
waters are presented in Table 4. (Part of the organic matter responsible for the
complexing capacity of natural waters originates from exudates of organisms,
which subject is treated in Chap. 2.7.3). Large variations in complexing capacity
of natural waters are observed. Although high dissolved organic matter contents
will in general cause a high complexing capacity, the ratio of complexing capacity
per mg of dissolved organic carbon (DOC) shows large variations. These large
wim.salomons@home.nl
24 Interactions with Ligands, Particulate Matter and Organisms
Table 4. Complexing capacity and conditional equilibrium constants for selected surface waters
Lake water:
Chapel Hill 31 S.2 (pH=7) ASV-titration. Shuman and Woodward
(1977)
Black Lake 126 4.8 (pH=6.S) ASV-titration. Shuman and Woodward
(1977)
Lake Alpnach 0.03-0.07 10.1-10.7 (pH=8.1) Bioassay with algae (Giichter et aI., 1978)
Lake Ontario 0.33 9.S (pH = 8.4) Ion exchange methods (V d Berg and
Kramer, 1979)
Melimex experiment 2.4 11.0 (pH = 8.8) ASV-titration (Baccini and Suter, 1979)
River water:
Magela Creek 0.07-0.46 7.5--8.S (pH=6.0) ASV-titration. Hart and Davies (1981)
Mississippi River 0.88-1.08 9.9-10.7 (pH =8.1) ASV-titration. Hoffmann et al. (1981)
Seawater:
Gulf of Mexico O.OOS-O.1S 9-11 (pH=8.1) Bio-assay with bacteria. Sunda and
Ferguson (1982)
Interactions between particulates and metals play an important role in the regula-
tion of dissolved metal concentrations (the most bio-available). Moreover adsorp-
tion is the first step in the ultimate removal of trace metals from the hydrological
cycle; the ultimate sink being the oceanic sediments. Changing environmental pa-
rameters like pH (acid rain), chlorinity (in estuaries) or the discharge of complexing
agents (NT A) all affect adsorption/desorption processes.
To understand the fate of trace metals in the hydrological cycle and to predict
the consequences of human changes an understanding of the interaction of trace
metals with the particulates is essential.
wim.salomons@home.nl
Mechanisms 25
Although much excellent research has been carried out on the physico-chemical
principles of trace metal adsorption on model substrates, the applicability of the
results to the "real world" is still hampered by our lack of knowledge on the surface
properties of aquatic particulates. However, recently a number of studies have
been conducted on model substrates and sediments, which are relevant to processes
in the hydrological cycle. The more relevant studies will be discussed. In depth in-
formation of the theoretical background can be found, for example, in the book
publications of Stumm and Morgan (1981) and Anderson and Rubin (1981).
2.5.2 Mechanisms
Various theories have been proposed to describe and interpret the adsorption of
metal ions on solid surfaces. With respect to the interactions with hydrous oxides
Stumm et aI. (1976; 1980) have summarized the following mechanisms:
(1) the Gouy-Chapman-Stern-Graham model which accounts for specific and
electrostatic adsorption;
(2) the adsorption-hydrolysis model which postulates that the adsorption ofhy-
drolyzable metal ions is directly related to the presence of hydrolyzed species;
(3) the ion-solvent interaction model which considers coulombic, solvation
and specific chemical energy interactions as the ion approaches the interface, and
which implies that a lowering of the ionic charge of the metal species (such as by
hydrolysis) decreases the ion-solvent interaction (which represents a barrier to
close approach of multiply-charged ions to the surface);
wim.salomons@home.nl
26 Interactions with Ligands, Particulate Matter and Organisms
(4) the ion exchange model according to which cations, upon adsorption on the
hydrous oxide surface groups (= Me-OH), replace protons;
(5) the surface complex formation model in which the hydrous oxide surface
groups (= Me-OH, or = Me-OH-HO) are treated similarly to the amphoteric
functional groups in polyelectrolytes as complex forming species.
While the "physical" -approach theories (1), (2) and (3) interprete the adsorp-
tion in terms of a combination of electrostatic interactions between ions and the
surface charge and ion-solvent interactions, the chemical-approach theories (4)
and (5) involving reactions of adsorbable species with chemical entities on the solid
surface - are now favoured by most researchers 1 (Hohl and Stumm, 1976;
Schindler et aI., 1976; Davis and Leckie, 1978; Davis et aI., 1978; Davis and Leckie,
1979; Westall and Hohl, 1980; Bourg, 1982).
Although model calculations of the adsorption of Cu(II) and Pb(II) on quartz
by Vuceta and Morgan (1979) suggest that both concepts can be used to explain
experimental data, there seems to be a justification for the preference of the chemi-
cal approach for two reasons (Bourg, 1982): (a) Some cations are adsorbed at pH-
values for which surfaces are positively charged (e.g. Pb on y-AI 2 0 3 ), and (b) the
tendency of ligands to form surface complexes with a given hydrous metal oxide
is similar to that of the solution complexation with the corresponding metal. A
summary of major coordination phenomena at oxide-water interfaces is given in
Fig. 16 (after Schindler, 1981).
These oxide surfaces can act as weak acids or bases in solution , undergoing
protonation in response to changes in solution pH (Stumm et aI., 1970; Benjamin
et aI., 1982):
SO-+H+=SOH (1)
SOH+H+ =SOH! (2)
(where SOH represents a single protonated surface oxide site). And, in addition,
the surface can enter into "complexation" reactions with other ions in solution, by
which protons are released to solution when an uncomplexed metal adsorbs:
(3)
This type of alteration in surface charge resulting from chemical reactions is fre-
quently referred to as "specific adsorption" (for details see Stumm and Morgan,
1981). Whereas the phenomenon was initially understood in terms of competition
for surface sites with protons and other cations, this model is now extended to the
adsorption of complexes of metals (Bourg, 1979).
Inspection of reaction (3) allows one to predict the effects on adsorption by
changing pH or adsorbent concentration (Benjamin and Leckie, 1981): Increasing
1 In a controversial discussion on the article "Ultimate Removal Mechanisms of Elements from the
Ocean" by Li (I 98 I) it has been proposed by Whitfield and Turner (I 982) that their electronegativity
model involving physical parameters such as ionic potential (z/r) and ionisation potential (Whitfield
and Turner, 1979; Turner et aI., 1980) could fully explain seawater composition without the compli-
cations associated with a mechanistic study of surface complex reactions, which - according to the
reply of Li (1982) - should be preferred as the consistent explanation to the observed partition of
elements between the solid and liquid phases in the ocean
wim.salomons@home.nl
Mechanisms 27
f;1~I'Jlnnnt~f;'ift~lntm
Anderson/Rubin: Adsorption of inor-
ganics at solid/liquid interfaces; Ann
Arbor Science Pub!., p. 6) (a)
(a) Acid-base reactions of surface hy-
droxyl groups ,-<-1 0 - H + M'+
~ "f-
(b) Deprotonated surface hydroxy Is co-
ordinate with dissolved metal ions. (b) r~~i;,i
Several species may be formed si-
multaneously.
.;~-O-H + Ml+
~
(c) Surface hydroxyls are replaced by ~~-O-H
W~~~~~
(e) ~'~-O- H + L + M
'+
' ~AA~· 1
SOH drives the reaction to the right, increasing adsorption; similarly increasing pH
increases adsorption of cations.
This behaviour - the fraction of metal adsorbed increases with increasing solid
concentration at fixed total metal concentration and constant pH - is directly anal-
ogous to the titration of a metal cation with a dissolved complexing ligand (Ben-
jamin and Leckie, 1980).
Results of Cd adsorption experiments in which metal partition between solid
and solution phases are varied over wide ranges of pH and concentrations of iron
oxide adsorbents are given in Fig. 17 (Benjamin and Leckie, 1981)
It has been stressed by Benjamin et aI. (1982) that since the location of the pH-
adsorption-"edge" depends on adsorbent concentration, a statement such as "cad-
mium adsorbs onto iron oxide at pH 7" is meaningless unless the concentration of
adsorbent (and adsorbate) is known.
In a general sense, a sorptive-desorptive reaction between solution and solid
phases can be a kinetic one (in which the relative amount of solute in the solution
and in the solid matrix changes with time), or it can be an equilibrium situation
in which the above mentioned relationship is attained rapidly and thereafter re-
mains constant. In the few cases where kinetics were investigated, surface reactions
were found not to be single step reactions (Chen et aI., 1973; Anderson, 1981). Ex-
periments by Benjamin and Leckie (1981) showed a rapid and almost complete
metal uptake lasting no more than one hour, followed by a second, slower uptake
process perhaps lasting days, or possibly months; the first effect was thought to be
true adsorption, and the second to be slow adsorbate diffusion into the solid sub-
strate.
wim.salomons@home.nl
28 Interactions with Ligands, Particulate Matter and Organisms
PERCENT Cd ADSORBED
100
80
/
5 X 107 M CdT
60 10.1 M
2S"C
Fe(OH b
40
c 1.3 X 10- 2
o 3.9 X 10- 3
x 1.3 X 10- 3
20
A 6.5 X 10- 4
+ 1.3 X 10-4
Since surface complex formation constants have been determined, such as for
the oxide/water interface (Davis and Leckie, 1979), humic substances (Perdue,
1979), and metal-multiligand systems (MacCarthy and Smith, 1979), models can
be devised to evaluate the competition between sites of soluble ligands and those
of surfaces of metal ions (Morel et al., 1973; Lu and Chen, 1977; Jenne, 1979). The
surface formation constants show the same trend in stability as the corresponding
solute complex formation constants (e.g., Stumm et al., 1980).
Typically adsorption of metals increases from near nil to near 100% as pH in-
creases through a critical range 1-2 units wide (Benjamin et al., 1982, see Fig. 17).
This means that a small shift in pH in surface water, as may occur in lakes, causes
a sharp increase or decrease in dissolved metal levels (Chap. 5.4.6).
The onset of the adsorption is characteristic for each metal. An adsorption edge
situated at a lower pH means a metal more competetive with H + and thus a larger
surface complex formation constant (data of Bourg, 1983, indicate that among the
various natural substrates montmorillonite is an exception as up to 80% of the sur-
face sites originate from charge deficiences caused by lattice isomorphous substi-
tutions and thus are not pH-dependent). Adsorption experiments performed by
Leckie et al. (1980) with cadmium, zinc, copper, lead, silver, arsenic and chromium
onto amorphous iron oxyhydroxide, y-alumina and a-Si0 2 as a function of adsor-
bent and adsorbate concentrations, solution composition, and pH (Fig. 19 and 20)
show that the pH of adsorption increases in the order Pb < Cu < Zn < Cd < Ag and
in the order SeO 4 < CrO 4 < Se0 3 < AsO 4 under otherwise identical conditions.
wim.salomons@home.nl
Sorption on Metal Oxides and Organic Substances 29
100
-----.-
Fig.18a, b. Metal adsorption on
organic surfaces (bacteria). (Af-
ter Nelson et aI., 19SI). Fig. ISa
gives the speciation-distribution
80 r-
diagram for cadmium, Fig.ISb
is the same for copper, both as a C
function of pH •u C~.
!
....
..'"
0-
c0 60 r-
.
.
E
.
is 40r-
.!!
•u
0-
t/)
-.~
~
20f-
CdCI-
CdS0 4 : ~CdC03
a 0
6.5 7.0 7.5 8.0
pH
100
/"
CUBactey·~
c
•u
!0-
r:
80
60
.
.!!
"S •
I •
..
Q 20
.!!
•u
0-
•
t/)
cu(0;7
10
•
CuC03 (aq)
b 0
6.0 7.0 8.0 9.0
pH
This means that under normal conditions in surface water (and at same concen-
trations of adsorbates and adsorbents) lead and copper are more strongly bound
to these surfaces than zinc and cadmium.
The hydrogen ion concentration, or pH, is probably the single most important
factor influencing metal adsorption also on organic surfaces. Experiments per-
formed by Nelson et al. (1981), however, indicate that the effect of pH on the ad-
sorption of copper and cadmium by bacteria contrasts with the pH adsorption
"edges" for these metals on inorganic surfaces. Whereas on oxide surfaces heavy
metal adsorption increases from near zero to near 100% over a narrow pH range
of about two units (see Fig. 17), the highly attenuated pH adsorption "edge" for
bacteria in Fig. 18 may represent the greater range over which protonation of sur-
wim.salomons@home.nl
30 Interactions with Ligands, Particulate Matter and Organisms
a
80
60
40
-3
am.- Fe(OH)3 (1x10 M)
0
100
80
b
60
40
20
100
80 C
60
40
0
4.5 5.0 5.5 9.0 9.5
pH
Fig.19a-i:. Fractional adsorption of metals on various oxide substrates (Fig. 19a: amorphous Fe(OHh;
Fig. 19b: y-AI 2 0 3 ; Fig. 19c: a-Si0 2 ) and effects of adsorbate concentrations (after data from Leckie et
a!., 1980)
face (and, to a much lesser extent, probably intercellular) functional groups occurs
(Nelson et aI., 1981). The adsorption maximum of copper in the vicinity of pH 8
(Fig. 18) appears to be unique to the biological system; copper speciation above
pH 7 is strongly influenced by formation of the soluble Cu(OH)z (aq.) complex
which becomes the dominant soluble species above neutral pH values. The data
wim.salomons@home.nl
Sorption on Metal Oxides and Organic Substances 31
given by Nelson et al. (1981) suggest that the equilibrium distribution of metals be-
tween bacterial solids and solutes is mediated primarily by physicalchemical
factors and is not influenced greatly by active biological transport processes.
A decrease in dissolved metal concentrations normally inplies a shift of the ad-
sorption edge to lower pH-values; i.e., at normal pH-conditions smaller concen-
trations of a certain metal are more thightly bound to the solid matter (at same ad-
sorbent concentration) than higher contents; these changes of the adsorption edge,
however, may be strongly different for the individual metals and solid substrates
[compare Fig.19a and b for different zinc concentrations with amorphous
Fe(OHh and different cadmium concentrations with y-Al203]. Copper sorption
onto a-Si0 2 was unique among all systems studied by Leckie et al. (1980) in that
increasing CUT increases fractional adsorption (Fig. 19c); such a relationship is ex-
pected if copper precipitates in bulk solution or on the a-Si0 2 surface or if the ad-
sorbing species are polynuclear.
Competitive adsorption has also been studied by Leckie et al. (1980) to get in-
formation about the distribution and energy of different groups of surface sites.
The result for adsorption of Cd on amorphous Fe(OHh in the presence of much
greater concentrations of Zn, Cu, or Pb (Fig. 20a) indicates that Cu contents have
a much smaller effect than that expected and that the predicted adsorption edge
is at a pH even higher than that for 5·10- 5 M Cd in the absence of competition.
PERCENT CADMIUM
100
100
a C
80 80
60
40
20
am.- Fa(OH)3 (1x1 0-3M)
0
6.5 7.0 7.5 8.0 8.5
pH
100
b
80
60
40
Fig.20a.;:. Fractional adsorption of cadmium on
oxide surfaces (Fig. 20a and 20e: amorphous
20
Fe(OHh; b: y-A1 2 0 3) and the effect of compet-
ing inorganic ions. (a and b after data from Leckie
OL-__ ~ __ ~ ____ ~ __ ~ ____J -_ _ ~
et aI., 1980; c after Benjamin and Leckie, 1982)
wim.salomons@home.nl
32 Interactions with Ligands, Particulate Matter and Organisms
This supports that oxide surfaces consist of discrete groups of sites and site ener-
gies; the preferred adsorption sites for Cd, Zn, Cu, and Pb are apparently distinct
from one another on amorphous Fe(OHh On y-Al z0 3 (Fig.20b) Cu and Pb do
not bind to the same high-energy sites - often less than 0.1 percent of the total num-
ber of surface sites available for trace element adsorption (according to estimate
of the authors) - as Cd, but Zn does. The latter findings suggest that there are great
differences in the site-specificity for individual metals on these surfaces.
Ligands which form dissolved complexes with metal ions can either increase or
decrease metal adsorption. Figure 20c (from Benjamin and Leckie, 1982) indicates
that chloride and sulfate (and ammonia) generally decrease fractional adsorption
of cadmium at a given pH. The decrease is consistent with the hypothesis that the
complexed metal absorbs somewhat less strongly than the uncomplexed metal
(Benjamin and Leckie, 1981). On the other hand, cadmium thiosulfate complexes
adsorb in a qualitatively different manner and, on oxides with sufficiently positive
surface charge, they can adsorb more strongly than free aquo cadmium (see Chap.
2.5.4.3).
The effect of ionic strength which - as in solution chemistry - can affect the sur-
face constants (Bourg, 1983) has practical implications for the metal sorption at
changing salinities, e.g. in the estuarine mixing zone (see Chap. 6). In a study per-
formed by O'Connor and Kester (1975) on the adsorption of copper and cobalt
from fresh and marine systems it was found that MgZ + interferes with adsorption,
presumably by competing with the trace metals for the surface sites. Similar indi-
cations have been presented in more recent studies by Gupta and Harrison (1981)
and Millward and Moore (1981) both suggesting that the major cations, calcium
and magnesium, are co-adsorbed with heavy metals and compete with these species
for adsorption sites increasingly with increasing salinity. An alternative explana-
tion for the reduced adsorption of heavy metals at higher salinities is the formation
of chlorocomplexes competing with adsorption. Experiments performed by
Salomons (1980) indicate a significant decrease of Cd-adsorption by chlorinity in-
crease. Recent data of Bourg (1983) show that the Cl-complexation and the Ca2+
(and MgZ +) competition are felt more strongly by Zn than by Cu because, for Cu,
surface constants are greater and the chi oro complex constants are smaller. In real
estuarine systems the effects of coagulation have to be considered for the evalua-
tion of solution/solid interactions of metals. Experimental data of Sholkovitz and
Copland (1981) indicate that removal of river-borne substances by coagulation
with Ca2+ at seawater concentrations ranges from large (Fe-80%, humic acid-
60%, Cu-40%) to small (Ni, Cd-15%) to essentially nothing (Co, Mn-3%) and
it is suggested that destabilization of colloids is the most effective mechanism dur-
ing these interactions.
Apart from competition between surfaces and ligands in solution, the various
phases in the sediment also compete for adsorption and complexation of the trace
metals (see Chap. 2.5.5). Oakley et al. (1981) studied, in model systems, the com-
petition between bentonite clay, iron and manganese hydroxides and humic acids
for sorption of trace metals in seawater. The conditional equilibrium adsorption
constants determined for Cu were much higher than those for Cd for all solid
phases. The affinity for humic acid relative to the other phases was high for Cu and
low for Cd. Based on the laboratory results, the model predicted that the clay frac-
wim.salomons@home.nl
Sorption of Metal-Orjanic Complexes 33
tion is a major sink for Cu and Cd for the geochemical phases used (Oakley et ai.,
1981).
As it has been discussed in Chap. 2.5.2 and in Fig. 16 (processes "d" and "e") the
interactions of metal-organic complexes with solid surfaces can easily be described
by electrostatic forces between charged entities. The surface charge of particulates
in natural waters, which may arise from chemical reactions at the surface, by lattice
imperfections at the solid surface (or by isomorphous replacements within the lat-
tice), and by adsorption of surfactant ions (Stumm and Morgan, 1981) is strongly
pH-dependent. Fig. 21 gives examples of surface charge data for suspended and
colloidal solids in natural waters; these simplified curves are based on results by
different investigators whose experimental procedures are not comparable and
may depend upon variables other than pH. However, the curves indicate charac-
teristic trends that at low pH a positively charged surface prevails; at high pH, a
negatively charged surface is formed, and at some intermediate pH (the isoelectric
point) the net surface charge will be zero. Qualitatively it can be assumed that
under normal pH-conditions of surface waters, silica, clay minerals, feldspars and
b-Mn0 2 are negatively charged and may exhibit a stronger affinity for positively
charged metal ions than do, for example, amorphous iron oxyhydrates or alumina.
This may be the major reason for observations, that in Fe/Mn concretions minor
transition metal cations, such as copper, cobalt, nickel, and zinc are associated with
the manganese phase, whereas elements with aqueous anionic charge such as silica,
phosphate and arsenic are related to the iron lamina (Jones and Bowser, 1978).
The various ways in which adsorption of the metal is affected when metal ions
bind to dissolved ligands to form soluble complexes,has been demonstrated by
Davis and Leckie (1978) and is schematically represented in Fig. 22 (from Benjamin
et ai., 1982).
Complexation may reduce the tendency of the metal ion to sorb, as apparently
is the case when cadmium ions form complexes with chloride or sulfate (Fig. 20).
Alternatively, if the ligand is an anion that adsorbs strongly at low pH, the ligand
may bind to the surface at low pH and "take the metal along with it", as this is
N
0.2
E
....
()
w 0.1
"<
a:
J:
() 0
w
~ -0.1
LL
a:
::)
(J) -0.2
0 2 4 6 8 10 pH 12
Fig 21. Effect of pH on surface charge of inorganic particles (Stumm and Morgan, 1981, P 613)
wim.salomons@home.nl
34 Interactions with Ligands, Particulate Matter and Organisms
Ii
Fig. 22. Schematic representation of the
Me
reactions leading to enhanced adsorption of a
metal at low pH in the presence of a complex-
ing ligand (from Benjamin and Leckie, 1982)
· Me
L19 <111.--- LigMe(aq)
Lig JJ
Low pH metal - ligand - surface interactions
Tf
Me
LigMe LigMe(aq)
Lig J,J
High pH metal . ligand . surface interactions
lDD
E
~80
Q)
'0
E
..360
c
.2
C. Fig. 23. Adsorption of various
:;40
...,
III complexes on y-AI 2 0 3 . Concen-
<I: tration of copper, ligands, so-
2D lids, and ionic strength are 10 - 4
M, 10 - 3 M, I g/Iiter, and 0.025
0 M, respectively (Elliott and Hu-
2 4 11 ang, 1979)
pH
the case, for example, for the effect of cyanide on nickel adsorption on (J(-FeOOH,
which is significantly increased at lower pH-values (Benjamin et ai., 1982).
Data of Elliott and Huang (1979; 1981) have shown that adsorption of many
organic metal complexes on oxide surfaces is primarily electrostatic in nature; that
is, binding of a negatively charged species to a positively charged surface. Fig. 23
depicts the adsorption of complexes of Cu(II) with glycine, aspartic acid and ni-
trilotriacetic acid on y-AI 2 0 3 . The most adsorbable species was the divalent
Cu(Asp h-entity, which experiences a greater Coulombic attraction for the positive
alumina surface than the somewhat less adsorbed CuNT A-univalent anion. Fi-
wim.salomons@home.nl
Sorption of Metal-Organic Complexes 35
100r-r---..---...-----r---:;--:.......-::p_....=::::::::=r-----.-----,
1:10
pH
Fig. 24. The effect of ligand:metal ratio in copper(IJ) removal (adsorption and/or precipitation). Con-
centrations of copper, 1'-Al Z0 3 and ionic strength are 10- 4 M, g/Iiter, and 0.025 M, respectively. Ligand
(NT A) concentration is variable. The dashed line represents the typical removal pattern of Cu(IJ) alone
due mainly to precipitation (Elliott and Huang, 1979)
nally, the copper-glycinate complexes exhibited the smallest preference for the y-
AI 2 0 3 surface (Elliott and Huang, 1979).
The effect of ligand to metal ratio is shown in Fig. 24 for the Cu-NTA-AI 2 0 3
system (Elliott and Huang, 1979). When Cu 2 + is in excess to NTA, hydrolysis al-
ters the picture of "Cu-only" to some extent; considering the curves, however, for
which NT A:Cu > 1.0, it is clear that an increase in ligand concentration results in
a decrease in Cu(II) adsorption at normal surface water conditions. Conceptually,
this effect can be visualized as a competition for surface sites between the CuNT A -
complex and the free NTA ligand. The HNTA 2 - competes apparently for avail-
able surface sites and hinders CuNTA - adsorption, the effect being most pro-
nounced in the pH region most conductive to "free" NT A uptake (Huang and El-
liott, 1979).
The reduced adsorption of metals in the presence of strong organic chelators,
which has considerable environmental significance with respect to the already per-
formed or planned replacement of detergent phosphates by NT A or EDT A (Chap.
5.3.5), has been demonstrated, among others, by Huang and Bowers (1980) and
by Theis and Richter (1980)in experimental systems, the latter using iron oxide as
solid substrate.
It should be noted, however, that part of these interactions cannot be explained
by simple electrostatic effects. In addition to these mechanisms, the functional
groups of an adsorbed ligand may serve as "new adsorption sites" for trace metals
at the surface or may simply stabilize adjacent surface sites. The "new adsorption
site" may be more reactive than an isolated oxide surface site, and in this sense the
presence of an adsorbing complexing ligand in an oxide suspension can change the
chemical microenvironment at the surface (Davis and Leckie, 1978). Initial efforts
wim.salomons@home.nl
36 Interactions with Ligands, Particulate Matter and Organisms
The solid phases interacting with dissolved constituents in natural waters consist
of a variety of components including clay minerals, carbonates, quartz, feldspar
and organic solids. These components are usually coated with hydrous manganese
and iron oxides, and by organic substances.
Iroti and manganese oxyhydrates can be present in X-ray amorphous, micro-
crystalline and in more "aged" crystalline forms both as coatings or as discrete
phases. Fe/Mn oxyhydrates are present in all parts of the hydrogical cycle. Alloch-
thonous particles in river systems already contain (aged) Fe/Mn oxides, addition-
ally they are formed in stratified lakes, estuaries, and at the sediment/water inter-
face. A further site, particularly for the deposition of Mn-oxide, is the surface of
carbonate minerals where there is a microzone of higher pH (Lee, 1975). It is main-
ly the differentiation under changing redox conditions which determines the rela-
tive accumulation of trace metals in Fe/Mn concretions in both marine and fresh-
waters.
Organic surfaces for metal sorption could arise in three possible ways (Hart,
1982): (i) from organisms such as bacteria and algae; (ii) by the breakdown of
plant and animal material and by the condensation of lower-molecular-weight or-
ganics (this material would characteristically have a high molecular weight and
would possess many of the properties of polyelectrolytes and colloidal materials);
and (iii) by lower-molecular-weight organic matter being sorbed onto clay or
metal oxide substrates (Davis, 1980; Davis and Gloor, 1981; Tipping, 1981). Al-
though the difference between these three surface types is not well understood, with
respect to trace metal uptake, there is a general agreement that at least one major
binding mechanism involves salicylic entities; other stronger binding entities (such
as peptides) may also be present in some systems (Hart, 1981). Data given by Hunt-
er (1980) and Tipping (1981) suggest that at least part of the organics adsorbed on-
to the particulate matter in natural waters has carboxylic and phenolic functional
groups available for binding with trace metals. The bulk of soluble organic matter
has characteristics similar to those offulvic acid (Saar and Weber, 1982); the hy-
drogen ion concentration determines which forms of the fulvic acid and metal ions
are prevalent. The trace metal adsorption capacity of organic matter is generally
between that for metal oxides and clays (Guy and Charkrabarti, 1976). Data from
wim.salomons@home.nl
Interactions in Natural Systems 37
reducing sediment show that all of the Zn, almost all of the Cu and a major part
of the Fe, Ni, and Co, but only small portions of the Mn are bound to humic type
material (Nissenbaum and Swaine, 1976). Organic-rich sediments from Lake On-
tario include nearly all the Cu, about 5-10% of the Pb, Cr, and Ni, and less than
5% of the Co, Cd and Zn in humic and fulvic matter; the metal contents of humic
acids at the sediment-water interface exceeded those at lower depths, suggesting
that the bulk of the metal burden is acquired in the water column or at the interface
(N riagu and Coker, 1980). Kerndorf and Schnitzer (1980) did not find correlations
between the affinities of trace metals to sorb on humic acid and their atomic
weights, atomic numbers, valencies and crystal and hydrated ionic radii.
The effect of organic substances from filtered lake water corresponds well to
the sorption characteristics for salicylic and phthalic acids on Al 2 0 3 -surfaces
(Davis, 1980). Sorption experiments on river sediments, which had been treated
with hydrogen peroxide (to partially eliminate organic matter) showed a significant
decrease of the sorption capacity for copper, zinc, cadmium and lead (Tad a and
Suzuki, 1982). Studies on the bonding of radionuclides on different organic sub-
strates (Clayton et aI., 1982) indicate both an increase and decrease of the sorption
characteristics - depending from ligands and concentrations of the organic com-
pounds. Investigations of Baccini et al. (1982) on the effect of organic matter in
the lacustrine environment revealed, that the deposition of organic substances on
solid surfaces usually coincides with a decrease of the sorption of heavy metals on
these substrates. An even more differentiated picture has recently been given by
Laxen (1983) in his experiments on the adsorption of Pb, Cd, Cu, and Ni onto hy-
drous iron oxides under realistic conditions: Uptake is slightly greater during co-
precipitation than adsorption, suggesting that adsorption sites are blocked as the
precipitate forms and ages (maximum 24 h). Soluble humic substances enhance
Cd, Pb, and Ni adsorption but retain Cu in solution. This behaviour is consistent
with the formation of soluble copper-humic complexes, which the enhancement of
adsorption for the other metals corresponds to the adsorption of humics ( < 10%
of total humics; Tipping, 1981), which is rapidly increasing over the range of
0-0.5 mg/I, approaching saturation above this value.
Sorption/desorption experiments on natural sediments have been performed by
many researchers, in a more or less empirical, qualitative way. Only recently, ef-
forts have been made to investigate the mechanisms and factors controlling the in-
teractions between dissolved and solid metal species in natural systems. An ex-
ample is the work of Lion et al. (1982) on trace-metal adsorption characteristics
of estuarine particulate matter, which includes a thorough examination of the con-
tributions of Fe/Mn-oxide and organic surface coatings, by adsorption ex-
periments onto the residual phases after several steps of sequential extraction (see
Chap. 2.6.). These initial studies of metal adsorption onto relatively unaltered es-
tuarine particulate surfaces were undertaken to evaluate adsorption kinetics, ex-
perimental precision, the effect of adsorbate/adsorbent concentration ratio and re-
versibility of adsorption equilibria.
The latter aspect is particularly interesting in this context, since it was demon-
strated that reversibility of the sorption processes was strongly different in natural
mixtures of solid substrates from the experience on well-characterized solid sur-
faces. Fig. 25 a,b, give the results of two separate experiments with lead and cad-
wim.salomons@home.nl
38 Interactions with Ligands, Particulate Matter and Organisms
30 30
equilibration
20 20
4 5 6 7 8 9 10 2 3 4 5 6 7 8
pH pH
Fig. 25A,B. Kinetics of desorption from unaltered salt marsh sediment A Cadmium, B lead. (From Lion
et aI., 1982)
mium on sediment samples from the oxidized surface layer of mudflats in the South
San Francisco Bay estuary (Lion et ai., 1982). Reaction systems were equilibrated
for 24 h at the appropriate pH for approximately 90% metal adsorption as deter-
mined by prior experiments; the pH was then lowered to that appropriate for 20%
to measure reversibility of sorption reaction. The results indicate slow release of
adsorbed Cd within a time frame of 96 h, whereas Pb was substantially non-labile
over the 264-h duration of the experiment.
In addition to these differences in the reversibilities between the sorption of
metals on mono-mineralic oxidic surfaces and natural sediments there is a
characteristic decrease of the slope of the adsorption edge for the natural solid
compared to the well-characterized surfaces, e.g. of amorphous iron oxyhydrate
(Lion et ai., 1982, see also Reid and McDuffie, 1981; Huang et ai., 1977).
Experimental data of Bourg (1982; 1983) indicate that the sorption edge of sed-
iments can vary considerably; the sediment of the Gironde Estuary, for example,
is characterized by a pH/ZPC (pH for which the overall surface charge is equal to
zero) of 4.84 which is similar to the charge conditions of kaolinite, whereas the
Rhone sediment exhibits a pH/ZPC of 9.42, more or less resembling to the mono-
mineralic sorbents such as y-A1203 and montmorillonite. These differences should
imply different sorption/desorption behaviour at changing salinities, e.g. in es-
tuaries. When the surface is positively charged (pH < pH/ZPC) increasing salinity
promoted desorption; when pH > pH/ZPC adsorption is expected under these con-
ditions.
The removal of trace metals from the sea-water into the sediment has found
much interest since the earlier days of marine geochemistry. The phenomenon of
"scavenging" or adsorption onto solid surfaces is frequently invoked by marine
chemists as an important control on the distribution of chemical elements in sea-
water, since the strong undersaturation with respect to most of the trace metal hy-
droxides and carbonates excludes precipitation of inorganic compounds as an ex-
wim.salomons@home.nl
Interactions in Natural Systems 39
-12
-4 Acetic Acid
-8 \r
0
0- 4
•
2 4
~
0
•
2
•
2 8
~
~
III
4 III
.2 .2
12
8
16
12
20
o -4 -8 -12 -16 -20 -2 -4 -6 -8 -10
log*K, SOLN
Fig.26. A comparison of the equilibrium constants defining metal/marine particle interactions. (After
Balistrieri et a!., 1981)
wim.salomons@home.nl
40 Interactions with Ligands, Particulate Matter and Organisms
Table 5. Percentage of cadmium and zinc not released from river suspended matter after treatment with
NaCl-solution (Salomons, 1980)
Adsorption time
Cadmium 24 30 33 37 40
Zinc 60 67 70 74 88
Table 6. Release of elements which had been adsorbed for 7 months on Mediterranean sediments
(from Duursma, 1976, after Ros Vicent et al., 1976)
Mn Fe Co Cu Zn Sr Ru Ag Cd Cs Ce Pb
day, 24% of the adsorbed cadmium and 60% of the adsorbed zinc remains bound
to the sediment (Table 5); after 60 days 40% of the cadmium and 88% of the zinc
bound to the sediment is not released after NaCI treatment. Apparently, the ad-
sorbed zinc and cadmium become more strongly bound to the sediment with in-
crease in time.
In an experiment performed by Ros Vicent et al. (1976) where elements were
adsorbed for more than 7 months by Mediterranean sediment, different leaching
rates were determined for the individual elements after treatment with acetic acid/
ammonium acetate (pH 5.4) and acetic acid (pH 2.3). Table 6 shows that among
the elements Mn, Fe, Co, Cu, Zn, Sr, Ru, Ag, Cd, Cs, Ce and Pb, strontium and
cadmium were extracted totally with the weak leaching agent, while iron, copper,
silver - and to a large extent also cesium, ruthenium, zinc and cobalt - remained
solidly bound on the sediment. This means that Sr and Cd are adsorbed only in
exchangeable positions without any immobilization into fixed inter-crystalline po-
sitions even after prolonged periods of contact (Duursma, 1976). Leaching with
unbuffered acetic acid significantly increased the rate of mobilization for iron
(75%), cobalt (67%), zinc (up to 47%), cerium (40%), copper and cesium (approx.
30%), compared to the buffered acetic acid extract (Table 6).
A comparison of the bonding intensity of stable metal nuclides and their in-
stable counterparts - the latter supplied from radioactive emission of nuclear
power and processing plants - in sediments from the lower Rhone River indicate
typical differences in element behaviour as a result of the different history of these
nuclides (Fig. 27a, b). The extractability of both cesium (stable Cs and Cs-137) and
manganese (stable Mn and Mn-54) isotopes were studied with a leaching sequence
including ammonium acetate (exchangeable cations), hydroxylamine hy-
wim.salomons@home.nl
Interactions in Natural Systems 41
Cs Mn
100 --.....-=....
80
60 60 ,,
,,
,,
,
,,
,
40 40 '
a:stable Cs
a:stable Mn i;\\""",
20 b:Cs-134 20 b: Mn- 54
c: Cs-137
'lIo..-- ___ .... _____*b
o ~.--~--~--~--~~ o .~~--~--~--~--~
OR AC HY OX HP NA OR AC HY OX HP NA
Fig. 27. Comparison of chemical extractability of artificial and stable isotopes (a: stable Cs and Cs-\37;
b: stable Mn and Mn-54) from a sediment sample of the Rhone River (river km 268; Barrage Valla-
brcques)
wim.salomons@home.nl
42 Interactions with Ligands, Particulate Matter and Organisms
100
Sediment B = 1.0 9/1 o Oft.~ 't) Fig. 28.8 Cadmium adsorption on-
90 O~ to sequentially extracted estuarine
CdT = 10-7 M
80 qj? salt marsh sediment B. b. Lead
I~l
1=0.6 (NaN03) adsorption onto sequentially ex-
....Is
t;";r
T=250C
'tI
70 tracted estuarine salt marsh sedi-
.
'tI
C
60
ment B. (From Lion et aI., 1982)
iii 50
Ii
:IE
..
I) 'It
40
C
0
ai
IL
30
Sediment Treatment
20 x Unaltered
v v v MgCI2 Extracted
10 .,/ 0 NaOAc & NH20H-HCI Ext.
/! 0 0 0 H 2 0 2 Extracted
0
a 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
pH
100
Sediment B=0.25 gIl
90
Pb T =10-6 M
80 1=0.6 (NaN03)
..
'tI
70
T=250C
.
~
'tI
C
60
!:IE 50
..ai
C 40
30
IL Sediment Treatment
20 x Unaltered
v MgCI2 Extracted
10 o NaOAc & NH20H-HCI Exl
o H~2 Extracted
0
b 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
pH
wim.salomons@home.nl
Interactions in Natural Systems 43
I
IRON
INORGANIC LIGANDS
MANGANESE
HIGH MOLECULAR WEIGHT LOW MOLECULAR WEIGHT
~ ORGANICS ORGANIC LIGANDS 5"
" !!.
1 f
I" i
i
•
i
::I
I
n
0:
ca
i
I"
1
I
~
i
i
n coatings
~.L- ______ ______
sorption
~.
Sorplion
~~L-_ _ _ _ _ _ _
Sorpllon Sorption
z-.____~l~
! SUSPENDED MATTER
!I
n (particulate metal speciation)
-•
o3 T
I
i
•
Sedimentation
Resuspenslon
Fig.29. Summary of major processes and mechanisms in the interactions between dissolved and solid
metals species in surface waters
2. The speciation of the solid phases, particularly with respect to the nature of their
surfaces, determines the extent ofthe sorption, although mineral particles them-
selves are able to adsorb trace metals. The particles are often covered with hy-
drous iron and manganese oxides and/or organic films which have a great abil-
ity to remove trace metals from solutions. The nature of these coatings is still
subject to discussions; for a complete understanding of the metal behaviour in
aquatic systems more studies are needed.
3. Aging effects and other diagenetic processes taking place after deposition cause
a redistribution of trace metals over the various components of the sediments;
the available data suggest that these processes cause a stronger binding to the
sedimentary particles. However, for a better understanding more research is
needed on these kinetic changes and redistributions.
wim.salomons@home.nl
44 Interactions with Ligands, Particulate Matter and Organisms
Table 7. Estimation of the relative importance of mechanisms and substrates in metal accumulation
wim.salomons@home.nl
Solid Speciation 45
It should be noted that the various organic and inorganic phases are interre-
lated: clay minerals, carbonates, and other suspended materials form nucleation
centers for the deposition of Fe and Mn hydroxides as well as for organic coatings;
in systems rich in reactive organic matter the otherwise very important role of Fe
and Mn oxides as direct sorbants of metal ions is either overshadowed by competi-
tion from the more effective associations with humic acids or organo-clays (Jonas-
son, 1977), or is obscured by coating of organic matter (see Chap. 2.5.3).
Only part of the metal associations present may take part in short-term geo-
chemical processes and/or are bioavailable. From a look at Table 7 one would ex-
pect that mobilization and further release to the water phase and/or biological up-
take mainly occurs from the non-residual fractions, which, however, will behave
quite different under certain environmental conditions and according to their dif-
ferent stabilities. For the differentiation of the relative bonding strength of metals
in different phases, sequential extraction procedures have been developed which-
in combination with direct experiments on organisms - could also enable the es-
timation of the potential metal transfer from polluted particulate matter to biota.
However, whereas the determination of the relative binding strength seems to pose
basically operational problems the correlation with the biological parameters
(Chap. 2.7) is not yet satisfactory. Before discussing the relations between chemi-
cal phases of solid substrates and biological uptake an overview on the distribution
of trace metals in "detrital", "lattice-bound" or "residual" fractions will be given.
Problems related to soil fertility quite early led to the development of leaching
techniques to estimate the availability of trace metals in soils for plants (Jackson,
1958). Most of the earlier studies do not consider the various sinks for trace metals
in soils; some exceptions are studies on the speciation of copper by Shuman (1979)
and McLaren and Crawford (1973).
In the sediment-petrographic field, interest was focussed initially on differ-
entiating between authigenic and detrital phases using single step leaching tech-
niques. By chemical leaching with EDTA, dilute hydrochloric acid and acetic acid,
the distribution of elements in detrital igneous minerals and authigenic phases in
pelagic sediments could be estimated (Goldberg and Arrhenius, 1958). Further
progress was achieved by the introduction of a combined acid-reducing agent of
1 M hydroxylamine hydrochloric acid and 25% (v/v) acetic acid by Chester and
Hughes (1967) for the separation offerromanganese minerals, carbonate minerals
and adsorbed trace metals ("non-lithogenous fraction") from marine sediments.
Recent developments in solid phase differentiations were mainly promoted by
environmental studies, both in soil science and in water research. For the estima-
tion of the relative bonding strength of metals in different phases, extraction pro-
cedures have been applied, both as single leaching steps and combined in sequential
extraction schemes (Pickering, 1981; Salomons and combined in sequential extrac-
tion schemes (Pickering, 1981; Salomons and Forstner, 1980).
Methods for single leaching steps are given in Table 8.
In determining the amount of exchangeable metal ions, an extractant is used
which contains cations more strongly bound to the exchange positions as com-
pared with the metal; common extractants in use are BaCI 2 , MgCl 2 and NH 4 0Ac.
The ion-exchangeable fraction of trace metals is still ill-defined, as is indicated by
significant metal releases in replicate experiments (Salomons and Forstner, 1980).
wim.salomons@home.nl
46 Interactions with Ligands, Particulate Matter and Organisms
Table 8. Methods for the extraction of metals from major chemical phases in sediments (examples).
(After Salomons and Forstner, 1980)
To release metal ions weakly bound to specific inorganic sites (e.g. on carbon-
ates) extraction with 0.4 M HOAc, HOAc/NaOAc (pH 5), or complexing agents
(of moderate ligand strength) has been recommended (Pickering, 1981). A single
extraction method for the determination of trace metals associated with carbonates
makes use of an acidic ion-exchanger (Deurer et aI., 1978).
Dissolution of the amorphous (or "poorly ordered") inorganic phases can be
promoted by reducing the iron and manganese to lower valency states, e.g. through
reactions with hydroxylamine, oxalate or dithionite ions. Oxalate treatment did
not appear to attack crystalline material, but it has been shown that the degree of
interaction varies with illumination (Schwertmann, 1964; Eaton, 1977; Pickering,
1981). For routine investigations an extraction with 0.3 M HCl can be recom-
mended because this procedure requires fewer manipulations (Malo, 1977).
The metal fraction associated with organic matter has been extracted through
oxidation of this component with NaOCI or H 2 0 2 , by dissolving the sediment us-
ing Na4 P 2 0 7 , through proton displacement (with 0.5 M HCl) or by chemical com-
petition (e.g. using 0.05 N EDTA); the apparent ability of both EDTA and HCl
to release metal ions associated with both organic and oxide phases has led to these
being used as extractants for the evaluation of the total nondetrital fraction (Pick-
ering, 1981). For the dissolution of detrital or lattice-bound components a com-
bination of acids has generally been used. Nitric acid promotes destruction of or-
ganic matter, but when used alone or in conjuction with HCl or HCI0 4 , the pro-
cedure does not completely dissolve some types of silicate minerals.
A schematic representation of the ability of different extractant solutions to re-
lease metal ions from particulate matter is given in Fig. 30 (Pickering, 1981).
This diagram implies - dashed segments indicate areas of uncertainty - that ex-
traction procedures may only crudely differentiate between the different forms of
wim.salomons@home.nl
Solid Speciation 47
RETENTION MODE
EXTRACTANT
Ion Surface Precipitated Co.ppted. Co.ordinated Occluded Lattice
TYPE Exchange adsorption (CIIJ, S,OH) amorphous to organics (crystalline component
hydrous
Sites
oxides) ~~rJ:sjS (mineral)
MgCI2
Electrolyte -------
--- .....
HOAc HOAc/OAc-
--
Acetic Acid --------
(buffer)
(reducing)
HOAc +
-NH20H -------- ------
Oxalic Acid
(buffer)
HOx + NH40X
--- L!Q~~~I!~l_
dil. Acid
0.4 m
---- r-------- f----------
HCI
r--------~
--
(cold)
HCI + HN03; HN03 + HCI04
Acid (hot) -------
Mixtures HCI + HN03 + HF
---
II-HF)
Chelating
Agents
EDTA, DTPA
---------- ----
~1!?!!z -------- ---
-----
r-!!-~-~~ ±!!!~~~~L ---
~S202. ~trat'!........:!:. _HCDj
(alk.ppte)
Basic ------- ~H-----~
Solns. NaF
----
Fusion Na2CD3
(+ Acid leach)
Fig. 30. Schematic representation of the ability of different extractant solutions to release metal ions re-
tained in different modes or associated with specific soil fractions. Dashed segments indicate areas of
uncertainty. From Pickering (1981), in CRC Critical Reviews in Analytical Chemistry, Nov. 1981, pp.
233-266
wim.salomons@home.nl
48 Interactions with Ligands, Particulate Matter and Organisms
5. basic metal oxides may be formed during initial high pH conditions, for ex-
ample, for humic extraction with sodium hydroxide or sodium pyrophosphate
(Burton, 1978);
6. difficulties occur with all carbonate extractions: reprecipitation under oxygen-
ated conditions following CO 2 treatment, adsorption of organic compounds
on exchanger resin, pH effects on labile oxyhydrates. However, the major ad-
vantage of this step lies in the reduction of the buffer capacity of the sample
before applying the following leaching steps (Forstner et aI., 1981);
7. problems in the acid reducing steps are encountered particularly with the uti-
lization of the dithionite/citrate extraction (Tessier et aI., 1979): contamination
by metals in the reagent, clogging of the burner during atomic absorption anal-
ysis, decomposition of the extractant and formation of sulfides (most of them
being highly insoluble);
8. treatment with hydrogen peroxide affects both labile as well as relatively stable
bound metal components (Engler, 1980);
9. treatment with organic solvents are poorly suited for routine applications
(Salomons and Forstner, 1980); and
10. the differentiation of organic and sulfidic metal associations, e.g. in the peroxi-
de fraction, is not as yet possible (Calvert and Batchelor, 1978).
This scheme, including an additional step for exchangeable cations was used for
the study of sediments from 18 different river systems (see Chap. 5.3). In extension
of this sequence and using the experience of the work from Tessier et aI. (1979) a
six-stage chemical leaching process was developed for the assessment of the en-
vironmental compability of dredged materials that avoids some inadequacies of
earlier experiments (Forstner et aI., 1981; Forstner and Calmano, 1982):
Step I: Exchangeable cations - 1 M ammonium acetate, pH 7, solid/solution ratio
1:20, 2 hrs shaking time;
Step 2: Carbonate fraction - 1 M sodium acetate buffer, pH 5 (Tessier et aI., 1979);
1:20, 5 hrs shaking at 20°C;
wim.salomons@home.nl
Solid Speciation 49
wim.salomons@home.nl
50 Interactions with Ligands, Particulate Matter and Organisms
Cd, Cu, Pb and Zn in oxidized sediments, and the operationally defined humic
substance fraction of organic material is highly important in binding Ag
and Cu.
S. In a comparative study on the specificity of different leaching steps in the
"Tessier"-scheme on single mineral phases it was shown by Rapin and Forstner
(1983) that the carbonate extraction (Ca-, Mn-, Cd-, and Pb-carbonates) by
sodium acetate buffer was particularly "selective", followed by the acidified hy-
droxylamine hydrochloride agent for the mobilization of reducible Mn, Ni, Fe,
Cu, and Zn species from deep-sea Fe/Mn-nodules, whereas treatment of
goethite, hematite, vivianite, and various clay minerals produced controversial
data for the individual metal examples. Another result of this study was the
finding that iron and sulfur are more easily extracted from anoxic freshwater
sediments than from reduced marine deposits, probably due to the less stable
mackinawite-type minerals compared to the marine pyrite formations.
6. For all metal examples a clear decrease of the residual component is shown with
increasing overall metal concentrations. These data suggest that the surplus of
metal contaminants introduced into the aquatic system from man's activities
usually exists in relatively unstable chemical forms and should, therefore, be
more accessible for short- and middle-term geochemical processes - including
biological uptake - than the detrital, predominantly natural metal compounds.
7. With regard to the various influencing factors affecting the chemical as-
sociations of trace elements in less contaminated as well as in polluted sedi-
ments, investigations on sedimentary core profiles seem to be particularly use-
ful. Apart from the characteristic developments in the chronological sequences,
there is a major advantage in comparing samples when they have been treated
according to the same extraction procedures and analytic methods. This also
pertains to filter column experiments, as long as the filling material can be con-
sidered homogeneous with respect to grain size and chemical composition
(Forstner et aI., 1982).
There are two types of processes which influence the metal concentrations in or-
ganisms. These are:
- the metal concentrations in the abiotic reservoirs,
- the biochemical processes occurring inside the organisms.
Processes of the first type will be discussed in the main part of this book, the
second are outside the scope of this book. Several successful studies are being car-
ried out on the biochemistry of metals in organisms, especially with regard to bi-
valves (George, 1980; Fowler, 1981). In this chapter we will focus on methods to
determine the bioavailability in the four abiotic reservoirs. Bioavailability is de-
wim.salomons@home.nl
Metal Uptake by Organisms 51
..
•
Complexes or chelates
Less available
with organic materials
Ingestion as "fooer,
..
Precipitated insoluble Available only after
passage throughout
compounds and altered chemical
digestive system,
coprecipitate on solids conditions
absorption and
.
Incorporated in solid Available only incorporation into
biological materials after decomposition tissues/organs
Incorporated in the
Available only
crystalline structures
after weathering
of primary and/or
secondary minerals
Excretion of complexants
...
Leaching and decay
Feed_back mechanisms
Fig.31. Availability of metal forms for biological uptake (After Baudo 1982, reproduced with per-
mission of the author)
fined as that fraction of the total metal concentration in each of the abiotic re-
servoirs which is taken up by organisms (Fig. 5). The different forms of metals in
the growth medium and their effects on the uptake of metals in organisms are
schematically summarized in Fig.31 (from Baudo, 1982). It has been stressed by
Baudo (1982) that the last three forms pertain to the "consumer" organisms alone,
whereas the first three are equally shared with the "producers". The particulate
form of the element can assume an important role in the uptake processes, at least
for some kinds of organisms, such as filter feeders and deposit feeders. Conversely,
the biota may interact in a number of ways with its surrounding medium, modify-
ing the pseudo-equilibria among chemical species in the water-solid phases. The
bioavailability of trace metals in solution depends on their speciation.
Sunda and Gillespie (1979) studied the response of a marine bacterium to add-
ed copper and the influence of complexing agents like NT A, humic acids as well
as salinity. The response of the bacterium, as measured by the uptake ofC-141a-
belled glucose did not depend on the total copper concentration but depended on
wim.salomons@home.nl
52 Interactions with Ligands, Particulate Matter and Organisms
I-
28
Z
W
(J
II:
W
D.
..J
<I:
>
120
100 NTA .-.
Salinity _---_ - "4=----
....... -,-
>
II:
:::l
80
,I(-
.-
_,I ·,
III
I- 60
z Fig. 33. The percent survival of the grass
w 40
•
_.
0 shrimp Palaemonetes pugio as a function of
II: I
w 20 I the ionic cadmium concentration. (The data
-,/
Q.
the cupric ion activity. A relationship was derived between the inhibition of glucose
uptake and cupric ion activity. Growth rate inhibition of the estuarine diatom
Thalassiosirampseudona was also related to the cupric ion activity and not the total
copper concentration (Sunda and Guillard, 1976). In a study of the influence of
copper on growth of 11 species of marine phytoplankton (Gavis et aI., 1981) it was
observed that the pCu response curves are very similar to published curves for ti-
tration of negative surface charge of polymer molecules and bacteria. They sug-
gested that the cupric ion acts as a toxic agent by binding to the cell surface, de-
creasing negative surface charge and perhaps as a result altering transport systems
in cell membranes.
Allen et al. (1980) studied the influence of zinc and complexing agents on algal
growth and found a good correlation with the free zinc ion, the latter being calcu-
lated with a chemical equilibrium model. The influence of chlorinity and total cad-
mium concentration on survival of the grass shrimp Palaemonetes pugio is shown
in Fig. 32 (Engel and Fowler, 1979).
With an increase in chlorinity, the concentration of the free cadmium and the
toxicity of cadmium to the grass shrimp both decreased. In another experiment
wim.salomons@home.nl
Metal Uptake by Organisms 53
~ metals may be taken up from the ingested particles or from the pore waters,
~ is the uptake mediated by the food (e.g. bacteria) which accumulate metals from
the sediment and/or pore waters?
~ are the processes in the gut important or the binding of the metals to the sedi-
ments (Luoma and Bryan, 1978)?
The fact that particulate bound metals are available for organisms has been
proven by a number of elegant experiments conducted for the development of a
wim.salomons@home.nl
54 Interactions with Ligands, Particulate Matter and Organisms
I ~ ;..-: ~ ;; 1982)
0.0
;..-:
.... h V. h ~ ::
Kats Waarde Bath
Ellewoutsdijk
Fig. 35. Metals concentrations in M acoma Baltica exposed to the same concentrations of metal in sur-
face waters (Eastern Scheidt, The Netherlands) but in a different sedimentary environment. Ash-free
dry weight. (Marquenie, 1983)
wim.salomons@home.nl
Solid Speciation and Bioavailability 55
wim.salomons@home.nl
56 Interactions with Ligands, Particulate Matter and Organisms
trace elements in natural waters and soil solutions is still largely in the semiquanti-
tative stage.
While organic complexation usually reduces the bioavailability of solute forms
of trace elements (see Chap. 2.7.1), there are indications that increased trace-ele-
ment uptake through complexation may occur resulting from a decrease in rate and
extent of trace-element sorption by sediments, solubilization of solid forms of trace
elements in soils and sediments, a valence reduction and/or stabilization of the re-
duced valence state or vice versa and formation of physiologically active complexes
(Jenne and Luoma, 1977).
With respect to solid speciation (factor 3) much work has been done on the rela-
tion between chemical leachability and plant uptake of metals. Highly significant
dependencies have been evidenced for extractants such as 0.05 M DTPA (diethy-
lene-triamine-penta-acetic acid), EDT A (ethylene-diamine-tetra-acetic acid),
acetic acid, ammonium acetate and nitrate (Davies, 1975; John, 1977; Keeney and
Walsh, 1977; Webber and Corneau, 1977; Symeonides and McRae, 1977; see sum-
mary by Sterritt and Lester, 1980). It must be mentioned, however, that "the leach-
able fraction does not necessarily correspond to the amount available to vegeta-
tion" (Pickering, 1981). One major reason for this is the lack of information about
the specific mechanisms with which the organisms actively participate in the re-
moving of nutrient from the solid substrate: in the case of plant root activities these
interactions with soil components include redox changes (Chaney et aI., 1972), pH
alterations (Moore and Carson, 1974) and organic complexing processes (Lindsay,
1974).
Experiments on the availability of particulate-associated forms of trace metals
to aquatic fauna have mainly been performed by Luoma and colleagues. Earlier
results from several chemical extractions of sediments from San Francisco Bay by
Luoma and Jenne (1976a) indicate that these speciation data do not correlate in
a simple manner with the bioavailability of the respective trace metal. Concen-
trations of Cd or Co in deposit-feeding clam, Macoma balthica, correlated signifi-
cantly only with the concentration of the metal extracted by 70% ethanol or I N
ammonium acetate; concentrations of Cd, Co and Zn extracted by weak acids
(0.1 N HCI; 25% acetic acid), reducing agents (1 N hydroxylamine hydrochloride
in 0.01 N HN0 3 ; sodium dithionite/citrate) or oxidizing agents (H 2 0 2 plus citrate)
correlated poorly with bioaccumulation (Luoma and Jenne, 1976b). On the other
hand, even quantitatively minor sinks within aquatic sediments may be important
sources of some metals for Macoma balthica; e.g., uptake rates of cobalt and zinc
from biogenic carbonates (crushed clam shells) were significantly greater than rates
of uptake from other sinks (Luoma and Jenne, 1977).
Data of Luoma and Bryan (1978) from sediments in 20 estuaries in southern
and western England indicate that the concentration oflead in the deposit-feeding
bivalve Scrobicularia plana is largely controlled by the concentration in the sedi-
ment as modified by the inhibitory effect of iron; the Pb/Fe ratio in 1 N hy-
drochloric acid extracts appears to reflect the availability of lead to Scrobicularia,
since this value is almost directly proportional to the concentration of lead in the
animal. More detailed investigations including statistical analysis of data per-
formed by Luoma and Bryan (1979), suggest that the correlation between metal
uptake and solid species distribution reflects competition for various metal sorp-
wim.salomons@home.nl
Solid Speciation and Bioavailability 57
tion sites within the sediment. It is assumed that the availability of zinc to Macoma
in San Francisco Bay is controlled by the competitive partitioning of Zn between
two forms of hydrous oxide: hydroxylamine hydrochloride-soluble iron oxide and
ammonium acetate-soluble manganese oxide; organic materials affect the bioavail-
ability of Zn when present in concentration greater than 1 percent. The availability
of Zn to Scrobicularia appears to be primarily controlled by the ratio of humic sub-
stance concentrations to total organic carbon; solute Zn and low salinities may en-
hance Zn levels in Scrobicularia at some stations, as may oxalate-soluble Mn when
present in high concentrations (Luoma and Bryan, 1979). It should be noted, how-
ever, that factors other than solid metal speciation can significantly affect availa-
bilities of even deposit-feeding organisms, e.g. interactions with other metals
(Heisinger et aI., 1979) or predominance of physiological regulations of metal up-
take, as has been shown for the Zn distribution in Nereis diversicolor (Bryan and
Hummerstone, 1973). Investigations of Tessier and colleagues (1982) in an unpub-
lished report of the University of Quebec generally confirm the findings of Luoma
and Bryan (1978; 1979). The data from studies on bivalves Elliptio complanata and
Anadonta grandii indicate, that (1) only a part of the metals in the sedimentary
substrate is available for the organisms, (2) hydrous iron oxides playa "protec-
tive" role for the metal uptake by the organisms as they compete with the biogenic
mechanisms for metal adsorption, and (3) the reagents used for the extraction of
hydrous oxide fraction widely reflect the "available" metal forms in sediments. The
study of metal uptake by the water plant Nuphar variegatum in the same work of
Tessier et al. (1982) provides even more controversial results with respect to the
question of solid species interaction and availabilities. There are practically no rela-
tions between the metal contents in the stems and rhizomes of the plants and the
total concentrations in the sediments; on the other hand, there are highly signifi-
cant correlations to the concentrations of metals in specific sedimentary fractions,
demonstrating the usefulness of the differentiated approach in these studies. How-
ever, the plant experiments cannot be utilized for the estimation of the potential
bioavailability of metals from sediments, since the direct uptake from the water
phase is probably masking the relationship between the metal concentrations in the
sediment and plants.
The present state of knowledge on solid matter speciation of trace metals is still
somewhat unsatisfactory with respect to the assessment of the quantitative extent
of bioavailable element concentrations. This is mainly due to the effect of competi-
tion between adsorption sites in the solid substrate and selective mechanisms of
metal uptake by the different organisms; which - as has been shown by the work
of Luoma and Bryan (1978, 1979) - cannot simply be derived from the chemical
extraction data. This situation cannot be improved by more sophisticated extrac-
tion schemes. On the other hand, the usefulness of a differentiated approach on the
interactive processes between water/biota and - even only operationally - defined
solid phases has been clearly evidenced. The possible environmental implications,
e.g., during dredging operations, after land disposal of waste material, from acid
precipitation, for redox changes in the subsoil, and organic complexing near sew-
age outfalls, which may lead to a partial remobilization of the particle-bound
metals, can be qualitatively estimated, particularly when the hydrochemical con-
ditions are known. With respect to the more important environmental parameters,
wim.salomons@home.nl
58 Interactions with Ligands, Particulate Matter and Organisms
Organisms not only accumulate metals from the abiotic reservoirs (Fig. 5), but they
are also able to interact with metals and modify the processes affecting them. A
number of important processes are:
- the change in environmental conditions due to pH increase (e.g. algal blooms in
lakes, Chap. 5.4),
- the reduction of sulfate in sediments by bacteria to sulfide and subsequent for-
mation of metal-sulfide compounds (Chap. 3.7),
- redox conversions of inorganic forms (e.g. the oxidation of manganese, iron and
arsenic),
- conversion from inorganic to organic forms and vice versa, typically methyla-
tion and demethylation,
- the release of extracellular material by algae.
Apart from these chemical changes organisms are also able to introduce physi-
cal changes. Important in this respect are:
- the production of pseudofaeces by bivalves in tidal areas, changing the settling
properties of the suspended matter and enhancing sedimentation (Chap. 3.4),
- the bioturbation of upper sediment layers (see Jernelov, 1970; Renfro, 1973).
Redox conversions occur at many places in the hydrological cycle. Important
are processes at the sediment-water interface (Chap. 3.7.4), at the river/sea inter-
face (Chap. 6.5) and probably the formation of manganese nodules (Chap. 7.4.3).
Of economic importance is the reclamation of metals from low-grade ores (Brierly,
1978; Lundgren and Silver, 1980; Brierly, 1981).
Redox conversions, e.g. the oxidation of pyrite, cause environmental problems
with regard to acid-mine drainage (Lundgren et aI., 1972). The rate determining
step in acid-mine drainage being the production of ferric sulphate, which is a
wim.salomons@home.nl
Transfonnation of Metals by Organisms 59
Air
HO
Water
CH 3 - As3- - CH 3 + H - As3- - CH 3
Trimethylarsine Dimethylarsine
Bacteria
OH CH 3 C~3
I I I
HO - As5"" - OH r-As3+- OHr- HO -As3 +-OH r-HO - AS+-CH3
II Bacteria II Bacteria II Bacteria II
o 0 0 0
Arsenate Arsenite Methylarsenlc Dlmethylarsenic
acid acid
Sediment
Fig.36A
a:
a:
w
FISH
l-
I e
~
Hg ° cH:!Hg~(cH}JIg
I-
Z
w
aa;;;:.' \ '
aactarla ::Ii
aacterla / Q
~HII2+ + Hll o w
HII2+~ ~ CIl
2 Bactarla
Fig. 368
Fig. 36. A The biological cycle for arsenic. 8 The biological cycle for mercury. (Wood, 1974)
wim.salomons@home.nl
60 Interactions with Ligands, Particulate Matter and Organisms
PseudDmDnas sp
powerful oxidant (Singer and Stumm, 1970). At high pH pyrite is oxidised chemi-
cally, but at pH values between 3.5 and 4.5 the ferrous-ferric oxidation is acceler-
ated by a factor of 200 by the bacterium Metallogenium, a further drop in pH (2-
3.5) causes an increase in the iron oxidation by 10 5 to 10 6 by Thiobacillus ferroxi-
dant. Therefore, the development of appropriate acidity in mining dumps is of
prime importance for the release of metals by microbial mediation.
Redox conversions pose severe problems for the management of pyrite-con-
taining soils (Pons and van Breemen, 1982). About 12.6 million hectares of soils
developed on coastal sediments are highly pyritic. These areas, mainly in the tro-
pics, are either poorly productive or unsuitable for agriculture because of their
acidity.
Methylation of inorganic metals is an important and relatively well-known bio-
geochemical phenomenon in natural systems and as been shown to occur for a
number of trace elements including Hg, As and Sn (Thayer and Brinckman, 1982).
The biomethylation of lead is still subject to controversy. Several investigators
have reported on the biological methylation oflead (Chau and Wong, 1978; Huber
et aI., 1978; Thompson and Crerar, 1978). However, experiments conducted by
Reisinger et ai. (1981) did not gave evidence for a biological methylation.
Mercury is the best understood example of an element that undergoes a com-
plex cycle in the biosphere and for which there is evidence for the biochemical and
molecular basis for the transformations (Summers and Silver, 1978). The biological
cycle of mercury is presented in Fig. 36A.
Bacteria in the sediments, capable of vitamin B 12 synthesis, are also capable
of methylmercury synthesis (Wood, 1972). The product is mainly monomethylmer-
cury under neutral and acidic conditions and dimethylmercury under basic con-
ditions (Beyer and Jernel6v, 1979). In addition to methyl mercury synthesis, de-
methylation is another biotransformation which can be carried out by micro-or-
wim.salomons@home.nl
Transformation of Metals by Organisms 61
ganisms in sediments (Billen et aI., 1974; Jernel6v et aI., 1975). Tin is another ex-
ample for which there is increasing evidence for biomethylation (Brinckman et aI.,
1982). Methyl-tin, produced by biological activity in the sediments, is able to react
with inorganic mercury and produce in this, abiotic, pathway methylmercury and
dimethyltin (Fig. 37).
The influence of organisms on the cycle of arsenic is complex. Arsenic is subject
to both reduction, oxidation and methylation (McBride and Wolfe, 1971; Chal-
lenger, 1945; Johnson, 1972). Its biological cycle is shown in Fig. 36B.
Arsenic behaviour in surface waters is strongly influenced by phytoplankton.
Sanders and Windom (1980) showed that the As(V) taken up by plankton is for
the greater part reduced, methylated and released to the surrounding medium. Cal-
culations based on measured rates indicate that 15-20% of the total arsenic is re-
duced by phytoplankton during spring and fall blooms on the continental shelf
(Sanders and Windom, 1980). A substantial amount of the arsenic taken up by ma-
rine algae is strongly bound to structural parts of the cell, up to 12 soluble organo-
arsenic compounds were formed by algae (Andreae and Klumpp, 1979). The over-
all cycle of arsenic in marine systems is similar to the phosphate cycle (Sanders,
1980).
Micro-organisms are known to produce large quantities of extracellular
polysaccharides which are organised in well-defined capsules around the cells or
are secreted as loose material. In a study on the toxicity of cadmium and copper
to the bacteria Klebsiella aerogennes (Bitton and Freihofer, 1978) it was found that
bacteria with polysaccharides on their cells exhibit less toxicity than cells without.
This was attributed to the complexation of cadmium and copper by the polysac-
charides preventing uptake by the bacteria. Experiments with the isolated capsular
polysaccharides showed that this material was able to complex between 18 and
54 % of added copper to the suspension and 9-18 % of the added cadmium. Since
these extracellular products are found abundantly in the natural environments
(Harris and Mitchell, 1973), they may contribute to the natural complexing capac-
ity of surface waters.
Polyphenols are excreted in large amounts by brown algae in seawater. Rates
of release may exceed 1 mgjkg fresh algae per day (Sieburth, 1969) and polyphenol
concentrations in nearshore waters may reach 2.5 mg per I. By complexing metals
and reducing the activities of metal ions, extracellular algal products could change
the speciation of metals and possible detoxify the cells' external milieu (Steeman
Nielsen and Wium-Anderson, 1971). Van den Berg et al. (1979) measured the sta-
bility constant for organic matter released by algae and observed log K values vary-
ing between 7.7 and 8.6 (for copper pH 7.6). The highest values were observed for
the organic fractions which were released in small quantities. The release of com-
plexing agents by 21 algal species and their copper complexins properties were in-
vestigated by McKnight and Morel (1979). Most eukaryotic species released mea-
surable amounts of a weak copper complexing agent, with a log K value of about
0.5. Modelling of the copper speciation with the measured log K value and a con-
centration of the weak complexing agent of 10- 6 (expected during of after dense
algal blooms) showed that most of the copper is present as the organic complex.
Of the seven blue-green algae studies, four produced very strong copper-complex-
ing agents with conditional equilibrium constants in the range of 10 8 to 10 12 . The
wim.salomons@home.nl
62 Interactions with Ligands, Particulate Matter and Organisms
study showed that the complexation by extracellular algal products can dominate
the speciation of copper in natural waters and lower the toxicity of copper; how-
ever, a detoxifying role can be envisaged only when the organic copper complexing.
compounds are not rapidly degraded (McKnight and Morel, 1979). In a later study
(McKnight and Morel, 1980) it was shown that the excretion products of the blue
algae were siderophores. Siderophores playa role in the transport of iron, and a
low iron concentration in the water stimulated the release of siderophores by the
algae studied.
wim.salomons@home.nl
3 Sediments and the Transport of Metals
3.1 Introduction
Sediments are important carriers for trace metals in the hydrological cycle, an as-
pect which will be discussed in chapters dealing with individual parts of the hydro-
logical cycle. However, sediment research has certain aspects of its own, which
warrants a separate discussion. Therefore, we will discuss those aspects of metals
and sediments which are common to all parts of the hydrological cycle.
Sediments can reflect the current quality of the system as well as the historical
development of certain hydrological and chemical parameters. Comparative anal-
ysis of the total concentrations of longitudinal profiles and sediment cores is per-
formed to determine metal anomalies in zones of mineralization (Rose et ai., 1979).
as well as from pollution sources (Forstner and Wittmann, 1979). The study of
dated sediment cores has proved to be especially useful as it provides a historical
record of the natural background levels and the man-induced accumulation of
metals.
Sediment analysis play an important role within the framework of environmen-
tal forensic investigations (Meiggs, 1980) in those cases, in which a short term or
past pollution event is not or only insufficiently traceable from water analysis.
In addition to their significance as an indicator medium, sediments are, depend-
ing on environmental conditions, a sink or a source for trace metals in the surface
waters. Metals are not necessarily fixed permanently by the sediment, but may be
recycled via biological and chemical agents, both within the sedimentary compart-
ment and also back into the water column (James, 1978). The recycling of miner-
alised organic matter and pore-fluid transfer processes are essential components of
models that are devised to describe the nutrient and pollutant dynamics of aquatic
systems (Lerman, 1977).
From an economical viewpoint it must be realised that sediments are also a me-
dium in which certain substances can be concentrated from solution and thereby
represent profitable sources of raw materials.
wim.salomons@home.nl
64 Sediments and the Transport of Metals
70
40
..
ii
60
.
D 50 ii
c D
·e c
·e
CD
> 40
:; CD
.~
E -.;
0c 30
~
c
/II
20 /II
i i
10
0 0
Nearshore sands (Gulf of Paria) Nearshore marine clays
Fig. 38. Mean mineralogical composition of nearshore sands and marine clays (Hirst, 1962)
- coarse sediments with grains exceeding 0.05 mm and subdivided into sands and
gravels.
Roughly these two groups differ in mineralogical, morphological, physico-
chemical and mechanical properties. Fine sediments mainly consist of clay min-
erals, organic matter and fine grained quartz, carbonate and feldspar particles. The
mineralogy of coarse sediments is in general less diverse, it consists mainly of
quartz with admixture of feldspar. The mean mineralogical composition of modern
nearshore sands and nearshore marine clays are shown in Fig. 38.
The organic matter plays an important role in the transport of metals, since it
is able to bind trace metals and takes place in diagenetic processes after deposition.
MoreQver, there is increasing evidence that suspended particles in natural waters
are covered with organic films which determine to a large extent their hydrodyna-
mic behaviour as well their adsorption characteristics (Neihof and Loeb, 1974;
Loeb and Neihof, 1977; Hunter and Liss, 1979; Balistrieri et aI., 1981; Hunter and
Liss, 1982).
Generally the coarse sediments consist of more or less rounded particles. The
shape and size of the fine particles is diverse (Lal, 1980; Lambert et aI., 1981). The
fine particles are charged, the charge depending on ionic strength and the surface
coatings. The surface charge is also responsible for the cohesion characteristics of
fine grained sediments.
In water, the particles tend to fall under the action of gravity, the velocity de-
pending on the size and the shape of the particles additionally the fall velocity is
influenced by the presence of naturally occurring surface coatings, solution elec-
trolyte and dissolved organic substances (Chase, 1979). Clay particles in an elec-
trolyte solution form aggregates of which the size depends on the type of mineral,
the strength of the solution and the hydraulic conditions (Whitehouse et aI., 1958;
1960; Einstein and Krone, 1962). Contrary, very fine and well dispersed particles
form colloids with a very low settling velocity. The formation of very well dispersed
iron colloids in estuaries may explain the transport behaviour of iron in coastal
areas (Mayer, 1982, see also Chap. 6.5). In the oceans, there is strong evidence that
wim.salomons@home.nl
Transport of Sediments 65
the larger particles scavenge during their fall through the water column small par-
ticles (Lal, 1977; Honjo, 1982). In concentrations exceeding about 5 kg/m 3 flocs
hinder each other, causing a decrease of the fall velocity. In concentrations of 150
to 400 kg/m 3 , the suspension is almost stable and acts as a heavy fluid, called fluid
mud. Fluid muds occur in some estuaries and are an important agent in the trans-
portation and deposition of fine grained sediments.
In deposited coarse sediments, the particles are simply stacked upon each other
but in fine sediments, the deposition of flocs, formed by inter-particle forces, leads
to a more open structure with cohesion. The microstructure of clay-rich sediments
has been studied with electron microscope techniques (Bowles, 1968; Mattiat,
1969). The micro-structure of undisturbed marine sediments from the Gulf of
Mexico are characterised by a loose, open, random arrangement of particles
(Bowles, 1968).
wim.salomons@home.nl
66 Sediments and the Transport of Metals
MEAN VELOCITY
(ii) IN m/sec
102r-----r-----~----~----,_----_r----~----_,
MOVEMENT
OF GRAINS
101~----~----T-----+----+4------r----~~~-1
0,2
161~----~----~~--+_~~1_----_r----_t----~
the whole water depth but the particles move very slowly. They remain in suspen-
sion for a long time and may travel over large distances, once eroded. The accumu-
lation of sediment in the water and its release take considerable time, leading to
a time lag between the rate of transport and the rate of flow. In general, the same
flow can transport a much greater quantity of fine sediments than coarse sedi-
ments.
The dependence of the mobility of the sediments on the hydraulic conditions
leads to a progressive sorting of sediments (and their associated contaminants)
with respect to composition and size. The most significant sorting is in the coarse
(sand, gravel) and fine (silt, clay) sediments. The former are found in the more en-
ergetic areas such as steep rivers, strong tidal currents and along exposed coasts.
Fine sediments (which in general contain higher metal concentrations) accumulate
in more quiet waters such as lagoons, tidal flats, flood plains and deep lakes. Of
course, the (non)availability of the typical fraction in the supply of sediments may
lead to another distribution; e.g. the muddy coast of Guyana.
After deposition the initial water content of sediments ranges from 40% (coarse
sediments) to more than 80% in fresh deposits of fine sediments.
Consolidation of the sediments, under their own weight and under the weight
of the overlying sediments, results in the expulsion of pore water. The particles of
coarse sediments form a rather rigid structure already at the moment of deposition.
Further deformation is relatively small and is reached very rapidly. Fine sediments,
especially the flocculated, form a very loose fabric with a very high porosity and
low permeability. Consolidation progresses slowly and may cause a 50% in reduc-
tion of the volume (see for instance Fig. 49). The compaction means a considerable
increase of interparticle contacts and, therefore, more mechanical strength against
erosion.
wim.salomons@home.nl
Distribution and Deposition 67
NEAP SPRING
Fig. 40. Velocities and sediment concentrations during a tidal cycle at neap and spring times (schemati-
cally)
wim.salomons@home.nl
68 Sediments and the Transport of Metals
schematically shown in Fig. 40. Not all the sediment is deposited around slack wa-
ter; erosion occurs around maximum flow. During spring tide the erosion lasts lon-
ger and the flow is stronger than during neaps, but the period of deposition is short-
er. The consequence is a much higher average concentration (and also greater vari-
ation) during the springs. The amounts of sediment carried during ebb and flood
show great variations during a fortnightly cycle.
In coasts and shallow seas, the orbital motion of waves is added to the other
flows; especially during periods of storm and high swell. They enhance the erosive
force of the water (Davis, 1978). The net transport caused by asymmetry of the
wave action itself is relatively small but the erosive action of the waves may facili-
tate the transport (in suspension) by flows, that themselves are too weak to carry
much sediments.
Estuaries are transitions from the river to the sea (Dyer, 1973): the freshwater
meets the denser saline seawater in a tidal area. The seawater intrudes along the
bottom, the riverwater flows seaward along the surface and there is mixing of the
two mainly caused by the tides (see also Fig. 115). Also the, sometimes very intri-
cate, systems of channels and shoals influence the flows. The seasonal variation of
the river discharge affects the salt intrusion and the pattern of resultant flows.
In view of this it is no surprise that transport patterns of sediments in estuaries
are very intricate and differ from case to case (Einstein and Krone, 1961). Floccu-
lation plays a role where fluviatile sediments encounter the salt from the sea. In
general estuaries are, geologically young, areas of accretion with zones of rapid de-
position where the river meets the tide, i.e. around the tip of the salt wedge (see
Fig. 113) and at the bar outside its mouth. Especially fine sediments are found on
the tidal flats and marshes.
All these transports of sediments playa part in the geomorphological develop-
ment of an area. The latter proceeds slowly compared with the apparent hydraulic
phenomena. As the study of transports shows the pathway along which sediments
travel, the study of the morphology of an area may reveal the sources and sinks
of the sediments. Both approaches lead to the observation that fine sediments,
which contain the highest trace metal levels, mainly come to rest in shallow or in-
tertidal areas which are ecologically important.
The construction of dams, canals, irrigation systems, deforestation, reclama-
tion ofland, navigation channels, harbour basins etc., changes the geometry of an
area. Such human interactions interfere with its geomorphology and so with the
patterns of flows and sediment transports. Erosion is induced in deforested areas,
downstream of dams and in trained rivers and estuaries. Deposition is enhanced
in reservoirs, irrigation systems, harbours and navigation channels.
The relative dimension of such works differs from case to case. The dredging
of a navigation channel in a very large estuary may hardly influence the general
system (McDowell and O'Connor, 1977) but in the course of time the construction
of harbours, e.g. near Rotterdam in the Rhine estuary, have given it a completely
artificial geometry.
Another important human factor is the displacement of sediments for construc-
tion works and maintenance dredging of harbours, navigation channels and re-
servoirs. Dredged material is dumped within an economically feasible distance of
transport. The most effective places of deposition are on land or in quiet water.
wim.salomons@home.nl
Grain Size Effects 69
Then, in fact, the sediments are withdrawn from the natural transport system. Less
drastic, but often cheaper, is dumping in deep water with the risk that (part of) the
sediments return to the location of dredging. Via the dredging process (polluted)
sediments may end up in places they never would reach by natural processes.
Metals are not homogeneously distributed over the various grain size fractions,
and large differences in total metal concentrations are observed in sediments sam-
ples from a single locality. Within the grain size spectrum, the finer-grained frac-
tion - consisting mainly of clay minerals - show relatively high metal contents. In
the silt and fine sand fractions the metal concentrations generally decrease as that
fraction is dominated by quartz components with low metal contents. In the
coarser fractions the presence of heavy minerals may cause the metal portion to
increase once more.
Alteration of the grain size spectrum of some characteristic components of sed-
iments are presented in Fig.41 for Lake Constance and Lower Rhine River sam-
ples.
The relatively insignificant differences of the grain size distribution curves do
not imply that material inhomogenities cannot be sometimes very large. Since the
greater majority of the particles range in the grain size of 2 11m to 20 11m, the in-
creased values for the specific surface area, for example, climbs in this grain size
spectrum in Rhine River sediment to a value that is clearly higher in the overall
sample of the Lower Rhine (24.3 m 2 jg) compared to 7.2 m 2 jg in the Lake Con-
stance sample. Two especially important carriers for trace metals are shown in
Figs. 41c and 41d: iron oxyhydrates are distinctly enriched in the Rhine River se-
diment compared to the sample from Lake Constance. The Fe-oxides prefer the
fine grained particle surfaces, and the humic substances apparently tend more to
collect on fine- to medium-sized silt grains. For phosphate compounds (Fig. 41e)
there is a preference towards the fine grain fractions. In the latter case the strong
enrichment in Lower Rhine River sediments occurs as non-apatic inorganic P-as-
sociations. Detrital carbonates (Fig.41f) generally possess a diluting effect on
metal concentrations in the coarser sediment fractions of Lake Constance, where
they are 4-5 times more prevalent than in the sample from the Lower Rhine River.
Different methods for grain size correction are compiled in Table 9 (after De
Groot et aI., 1976; Forstner and Wittmann, 1979; Forstner and Salomons, 1980).
These methods will reduce (not eliminate) the fraction of the sediments that is
largely chemically inert, i.e. mostly the coarse-grained quartz, feldspar and carbon-
ate minerals, and increase the substances active in metal enrichment, i.e. hydrates,
sulfides, amorphous and organic materials.
Separation of grain size is advantageous because only few samples from a par-
ticular locality are needed. However, separation of the fraction less than 2 11m in
settling tubes is time-consuming (the remobilization of metals - as has sometimes
been suspected - is relatively low; Jenne et aI., 1980). The fractions less than 173 11m
and 204 11m contain considerable percentages oflarge grains which are usually low
wim.salomons@home.nl
70 Sediments and the Transport of Metals
Lower Rhine • •
%
Bodensee 0----0
25
Grainsize % Specific surface
distribution (m 2 g" )
20 40
15
10 20
% Humic substances % Fe
(0.1" NaOH Extraction) (0.3"HCI Extraction)
1.0 1.0
® @)
0.5 0.5
® CD
0.3
15
0.1
0.06 0.2 0.6 2.0 6.3 20 63 0.06 0.2 0.6 2.0 6.3 20 63
Grainsize (}J.m)
Fig. 41 a-f. Grain size spectrum of some components in sediments from Lake Constance and the Lower
Rhine (partly from F 6rstner and Patchineelam, 1980)
in trace metals. Therefore, the fraction < 63 /lm is recommended for the following
reasons (Forstner and Salomons, 1980):
trace metals have been found to be present mainly in clay/silt particles
this fraction is most nearly equivalent to the material carried in suspension (the
most important transport mode of sediments by far)
sieving does not alter metal concentrations - particularly when water of the same
system is used
numerous metal studies have already been performed on the < 63 /lm fraction,
allowing better comparison of results.
wim.salomons@home.nl
Grain Size Effects 71
wim.salomons@home.nl
72 Sediments and the Transport of Metals
Mercury ~g/kg
D <50
o 50'100
• 100 · 500
• SOO'1000
• >1000
L.St.Clair
150km
River results from a rapid deposition from the western flow as it enters Lake Erie. As the contaminated
water mass flows south along the Michigan-Ohio shore, it deposits progressively smaller amounts of
mercury into Lake Erie. In Lake Ontario, there is a distinct grouping of elevated mercury levels near
the southern bank of the lake, especially close to the mouth of the Niagara River. Investigations carried
out by Fitchko and Hutchinson (1975) have shown that the dispersion pathways point to the Niagara
River as the prime source of mercury to Lake Ontario. The eastward extension of the Niagara mercury
"plume" is probably due to coastal currents, whereas the enrichment of mercury at the mouth of the
Genesee and Oswego Rivers appears to result from the contamination within their catchment areas.
The asessment of both sources and environmental effects of trace metals in par-
ticulate matter must predominantly consider the most mobile fraction of these ele-
ments, which is introduced by man's activities and bound to the sediment in sorbed,
precipitated or co-precipitated (carbonates and hydrous Fe/Mn-oxides) and
in an organically complexed form. Goldberg (1954) suggested that a large portion
of the "hydrogenous" metal fraction in recent sediments can be dissolved by spe-
cific attack with dilute acids; a residue of relatively inertly bound metals from the
natural rock and soil detritus ("residual fraction") can be found predominantly in
the coarser grain sizes. The metal data thus obtained by acid extraction should
compare favourably with data from the separation of the fine-grained fraction of
sediments (see above).
Studies by Cross et al. (1970) on the distribution of manganese, iron and zinc
in sediments of the Newport River Estuary, North Carolina and by Cross et
al.(1971) on marine waste deposits of the New York Metropolitan Region were
among the first to consider the chemical fractionation of non-detrital/residually
bound metals in polluted sediments by the application of 0.1 M and 1 M hy-
drochloric acid, respectively. In more recent studies other acids or acid concen-
trations have come into use for the general differentiation of metal species associ-
wim.salomons@home.nl
Grain Size Effects 73
ated with hydrous oxides, carbonates, sulfides and surficially sorbed materials
from the residual fraction (Table 9).
A practical example of this type of study is the initial assessment of trace metal
pollution in surface sediment from two Greek Gulfs by Chester and Voutsinou
(1981). The technique proposed by Chester and co-workers involved the leaching
of the samples with cold 0.5 M hydrochloric acid and has been shown to "provide
a rapid, inexpensive way of establishing the gross degree to which a sediment pop-
ulation has been subjected to trace metal pollution from the overlying waters".
From Fig. 43 it is evident that the highest non-residual concentrations of Cd and
Zn are found in sediments around Salonika and the industrialized area of the
northern Thermaikos Gulf, in particular in the region of the outflow of the Axios
River, which is an industrialized catchment area.
Investigation on sediment cores from Lake Erie (performed by Kemp et aI.,
1976) distinguished five types of elements according to their mode of distribution:
(a) diagenetically mobile elements, such as iron, manganese and sulfur; (b) car-
bonate elements, carbonate-C and calcium; (c) nutrient elements, organic carbon,
nitrogen and phosphorus; (d) enriched metals, such as copper, cadmium, zinc,
lead and mercury; and (e) conservative elements, e.g. silicon, potassium, titanium,
sodium and magnesium. The latter group of elements, labelled "conservative", are
of particular importance when determining comparative values of metals in de-
posits, e.g. in order to minimize grain size efects.
Aluminium was used in earlier studies, e.g. by Bruland et al. (1974), as a suit-
able reference element to trace the development of anthropogenic input into sedi-
ment profiles. Standardizing anthropogenic (and "abnormal" natural) metal con-
centrations to the contents of "conservative elements" such as aluminium and
potassium, i.e. on the percentage of clay minerals in dust samples or sediments has
at first glance one major disadvantage in that it gives a ratio value instead of a real
concentration. But it can be attempted - as Duce et al. (1975) have done for atmo-
spheric dust particles and Li (1981 b; 1982) for marine sediments - to standardize
the contents to a standard material, defining the enrichment factor, e.g. of element
"i" in the sample E~l as the concentration ratio of "i" to Al (Ci/C A1 ) compared
to the ratio in standard material. Average crustal igneous rocks (see Chap. 5.2.3)
is very often used as the standard material (Herron et ai., 1977; Weiss et ai., 1978),
but average shale (e.g. Turekian and Wedepohl, 1961) seems to be more represen-
tative of the continental soils (Lantzy and Mackenzie, 1979; Li, 1981 b).
On sediment samples from the Ems River Estuary in Northern Germany a
series of potential reference elements - Cs, Eu, Fe, Rb, Sc, Sm and Th (measured
by neutron activation analysis) - were tested by Ackermann (1980). Table 10 sum-
marizes the correlation coefficients "r" between metal contents and the percentage
of grain size fraction 20 )..lm and 63 )..lm, respectively, and the slope of the regression
lines, the quotient s(100%)/s(0%) from the ordinate values extrapolated for 100%
and 0% of the two grain size fractions (Fig. 44). The closer to 1.0 the correlation
coefficient r for a specific reference element lies and the larger the quotient s(100%
)/s(O%), the more exactly can a grain size correction be carried out. According to
Table 10, cesium appears to be the preferred reference element for 2 reasons: it is
particularly well correlated (r = 0.987) with the percentage of the < 20 )..lm fraction
and the quotient, s(100%)/s(0%) is greater than for the other elements. A test for
wim.salomons@home.nl
74 Sediments and the Transport of Metals
t
Zinc
N
I
• - I.~ -.'4
> 200 ppm
100- 200 ppm
70-100 ppm
50 -ppm
Fig.43a,b. Distribution of 0.5 M HCI-extractable cadmium and zinc in sediments from the Gulf of
Thermaikos, Greece. (After Chester and Voutsinou, 1981)
the applicability of the correction procedure was made on a 140 cm long sediment
core from the brackish water zone of the Ems River Estuary near Emden (Fig. 44b)
by Ackermann (1980). The layers deeper than 10-20 cm are older than 20-25 years
(Cs-137 dating). The curve of Zn-concentrations in the total sample varies with
depth and does not give an indication ofthe Zn pollution, being fully superimposed
by the much stronger grain size effect (thick broken line). The Zn data corrected
for grain size (solid line), on the other hand, clearly indicate the very significant
increase of Zn pollution during the last 100 years.
wim.salomons@home.nl
Grain Size Effects 75
b THESSALONIKI
• • •
t
N
0------1
In.mile
Fig.43b
Due to the very close geochemical relation between scandium and aluminium
(which is most often taken as a reference value), the measurement of these com-
ponents seems to be recommendable (Schoer et al., 1982; Thomas and Martin,
1982). An example is given in Chapter 5.2. for investigations on metal concen-
trations in sediments from the Elbe, Weser and Ems Estuaries and from the Ger-
man Bight (Southeastern North Sea).
Generally it appears that correction made with conservative elements is espe-
cially valuable. If separation of coarser grain sizes, for example up to < 63 ~m, is
wim.salomons@home.nl
76 Sediments and the Transport of Metals
,,
.
12 100 200 300
.--------.
Cs I
10
.".
.~ .-
,,0
/
0
~~• .;..:.. total sample
8
V,
6
4
.. •••
..............-.
,.
~ '"....
",0
2 "",-••
.........~.
,r-
......A.
r ~ 0,987
.t:.
Q.
50 0 ....
.... 0
\
/
•\
-3 I
0
I
•
,
O+-~---.--~-.--~--r--.---.--~-,
o 20 40 60 80 100 1: 0
•
.
%
A Fraction c 20",m
•E '0
I
/~rrected with cesium
li 100 0
\0 I
(/)
•\
I
0
\ •I
I I
•
0
B 0
\ \
•
150
Fig.44A, B. Correction of grain size by conservative element content: Relation to cesium. (Ackermann,
1980) A Regression line and correlation coefficient "r" of cesium and percentage of the fraction < 20
Ilm in sediment samples from the Ems Estuary (N. Germany). B Example ofa sediment core from the
Ems Estuary near Emden. Open circles: Zn in total sample; closed circles: Zn values corrected for
cesium contents
Table 10. Correlation coefficients, r and concentration ratios s(I00%)/s(O%) for some potential
reference elemen ts. (Ackermann, 1980)
Cs Sc Fe Rb Eu Th Sm
Fraction < 20 Ilm r 0.987 0.982 0.858 0.958 0.945 0.932 0.878
s( 100% )/s(O%) 14.0 7.3 6.4 3.4 3.1 3.2 3.1
Fraction < 63 Ilm r 0.919 0.937 0.789 0.900 0.947 0.944 0.911
s(I00%)/s(O%) >20 15 9.0 3.7 3.8 3.8 3.9
carried out prior to correction, still better results may be obtained. In our opinion
the separation of the fraction less than 63 Ilm offers an economical method for as-
sessing the distribution pattern of trace metals in a given area. To obtain more de-
tailed information it can be combined with the determination of the "mobile frac-
tion" and a further standarization with "conservative elements".
wim.salomons@home.nl
Background Concentrations 77
isting values for metal concentrations in order to derive the total enrichment
caused by anthropogenic influences.
To obtain an ideal comparative basis for environmental studies, the following
criteria should be fulfilled so as to achieve representative values for metal concen-
trations: a large number of sediment samples must be analyzed which correspond
with recent deposits in their (i) grain size distribution, (ii) material composition
and (iii) conditions of origin. A fourth criterium is that the samples must be un-
contaminated by civilizational influences.
Several possibilities have been discussed to establish background values for
trace metals (Forstner and Wittmann, 1979):
(1) average shale composition as a global standard value;
(2) fossil aquatic sediments from defined environments as a standard, taking into
account natural allochthonous and autochthonous factors and mechanisms as
well as regional influences;
(3) recent deposits in relatively unpolluted areas;
(4) short, dated sedimentary cores, which provide a historical record of events oc-
curring in the watershed of a particular river or estuary. These would enable
an estimation of both the background levels and the changes in input of an ele-
ment over an extended period of time.
Table 11 gives a few examples of background concentrations for heavy metals
evaluated according to method (1) to (3). The most suitable data for a global stan-
dard (method 1) proves to be that for fossil shales and data compiled by Turekian
and Wedepohl (1961) are often used as a global basis for comparison for metal-
contaminated sediments. For some metals, e.g. manganese, zinc and lead, the
values for this so-called shale standard agree quite well with the average concen-
trations that have been measured in recent shallow water sediments in less polluted
regions. For other examples, especially elements enriched in basic rocks, the shale
Metal Shale and clays (1) Sub-recent Lacustrine (3) Soils (4)
Rhine sediments (2) sediments (3)
wim.salomons@home.nl
78 Sediments and the Transport of Metals
values appear to be too high for comparison with modern sediments from inland
and coastel waters. Such elements, e.g. Cr, Ni, Co and Cu are marked with an as-
terisk (*) in Table 11. The corresponding concentrations in fossil Rhine River sed-
iments (from a sediment core taken near Cologne, Forstner and Muller, 1974) and
in soils (Ure and Berrow, 1982) underline the tendency to lower background values
for these metals. Lithologic peculiarities of the respective catchment basins must
be considered, especially for investigations covering only a limited surface area.
0.5 2
0
1
I
-+- I
I
18.2mm/y ---+
I
10
20
1 av.7.7mm/y _ ~
r __ -+- -_1.8mm/y
~--
E 30 --r --
..
u
III
I
.r:
Co
~ 40
50
Fig. 45. Plot of 21O-Pb excess against depth in a sedi-
ment core from the German Bight, Southeastern
North Sea (Dominik et aI., 1978). Solid lines: best fit
60 to all values in the interval 7-50 cm. Dashed lines:
best fit for intervals 7-19, 19-28 and 28-50 cm
wim.salomons@home.nl
Quantification of Environmental Impact 79
1979). The study of sediment cores is especially suited for the differentiation of nat-
ural metal enrichment, for example, in zones of mineralizations, and anthropo-
genic effects occurring in certain areas as a consequence of mining and smelting
activities (Allan, 1974).
Sedimentary cores are particularly useful when the individual phases of de-
velopment, which are recorded in the different layers of sediment material, can be
dated by means of certain granulometric characteristic, by pollen assemblages or
by isotope measurements. Among the latter methods the determination of the 210-
Pb and 137-Cs distributions have proved to be advantageous: 137-Cs is an artificial
radionuclide introduced into the environments by nuclear tests. The 137-Cs dis-
tribution in a sediment core should reflect variations in the atmosphere flux, pro-
vided the sedimentation rate is constant and no mixing or diffusion occurs. The ra-
dioactive isotope 2l0-Pb is derived from the decay of 222-Rn, which comes from
the earth's surface; once in the atmosphere this rare-gas daughter of238-U decays
with a half-life of 3.8 days. The charged daughter ions thus produced are chemi-
cally reactive and soon become irreversibly associated with aerosol particles (Ture-
kian et aI., 1977). The abundances of2lO-Pb and other decay products of 222-Rn
give not only information on mean residence time of the aerosol, but once intro-
duced in the aquatic system and in the sediments, they can be used for dating pur-
poses.
The sedimentation rate is determined from the slope of the least-square fit for
21O-Pb excess values plotted versus depth and expressed in mm/y. An example is
given in Fig.45 from a sediment core taken from the southern German Bight
(Forstner and Reineck, 1974), where two sections with sedimentation rates of 15-
20 mm/y are interrupted by a section showing a very low sedimentation rate or even
an erosion period (Dominik et aI., 1978). The 21O-Pb method is well-suited for dat-
ing events occurring during the last 100-200 years (Krishnaswami and Lal, 1978).
wim.salomons@home.nl
80 Sediments and the Transport of Metals
Table 12. Sediment enrichment factors (SEF) of heavy metals in selected examples from lacustrine and
marine environments
MeanSEF 5.3 1.4 2.1 2.2 1.2 8.7 1.3 4.1 3.5
a (I) Hakanson (\977), mean values from eight surficial samples (0-1 cm) versus natural background.
(2) Forstner and Miiller (\974), sediment core from central part (250 m water depth). (3) Vernet
(1976), mean SEF from coastal stations. (4) Walters et al. (1974), sediment core from central basin
(No. 13-2); Pb value from Kemp et al. (1976), mean of SEF from two cores of central basin. (5) Er-
lenkeuser et al. (1974), core A-GC from 28 m water depth. (6) Forstner and Reineck (1974), core 1/315
from 22 m depth
b NA=notavailable
the beginning of the century up to the present time and will have further increased
four and a halftimes by the year 2000.
In order to estimate the relative enrichment of trace metals by cultural effects
Table 12 depicts selected examples of core sediment studies on both lacustrine and
coastal marine environments. It is evident that zinc, lead, cadmium and mercury
are on the average particularly strongly enriched (the latter element more on a local
scale than the others). Suess and Erlenkeuser (J 975) have pointed out that the order
of enrichment in anthropogenically influenced sediments, cadmium> lead> zinc,
corresponds to the accumulation of metals in fossil fuel residues.
A quantitative measure of the metal pollution in aquatic sediments has been in-
troduced by M liller (1979), which is called the "Index of Geoaccumulation":
C n is the measured concentration of the element "n" in the pelitic sediment fraction
( < 2 11m) and Bn is the geochemical background value in fossil argillaceous sedi-
ment ("average shale", see Table 42; the factor' 1.5' is used because of possible
variations of the background data due to lithogenic effects. The Index of Geoac-
cumulation consists of 7 grades, whereby the highest grade (6) reflects 100-fold en-
richment above the background values (2 6 = 64· 1.5). In Table 13 two examples of
heavily polluted river systems in the Federal Republic of Germany are presented.
The index values of the upper Rhine (between Basel and Mannheim), before the
waters of the Neckar and Main Rivers enter the Rhine) lie at a maximum of 3 for
Cd and Pb. Cd reaches the highest grade (6) in the middle section of the river and
the lower Rhine (below the mouth of the Main River to the German/Dutch bor-
wim.salomons@home.nl
Quantification of Environmental Impact 81
Table 13. Geoaccumulation indices for metals in sediments from Rhine River and Elbe River
Igco I.eo class Upper Rhine" Lower Rhine b Elbe (Hamburg)C Elbe (Stade)d
>5 6 Cd Cd,Hg
4-5 5 Zn, Pb
3--4 4 Pb,Zn Cu Cd
2-3 3 Cd,Pb Hg Hg,Zn,Pb
1-2 2 Zn,Hg Cu Cr
0-1 1 Cu Cu,Cr
<0 0 Cr
" Base1-Mannheim
b Mainz-Emmerich (MUller, 1979)
C < 63 !lm-fraction (ARGE-Elbe, 1980)
d < 2 !lm (MUller, 1980)
der), which can be traced to influents from the Neckar River and from the Ruhr
area. The indices for Pb and Zn attain 4, and those for Hg, Cu and Cr each increase
by one (Fig. 86 shows the development of the Igeo indices in longitudinal profiles
of the Rhine River)
In the deposits in the Hamburg harbour area, which originate from the Elbe River,
the index of Cd and Hg is 6, whereas Zn and Pb have a geoaccumulation index rat-
ing of 5. The example of Elbe River sediments near Stade (given by Miiller, 1980)
shows a clear decrease of metal contents in estuarine sediments which is chiefly the
result of an increasing mixing of heavily contaminated fluviatile sediments with less
contaminated marine sediments in the tidal area (see Section 6.4).
In accordance with a suggestion by Tomlinson et ai. (1980) for the classification
of heavy metal levels in estuaries and the formation of a pollution index based on
enrichment factors in intertidal algae or fauna within an estuary it was possible to
obtain contamination factors by referring to baseline metal levels, as shown in
Table 11. The Pollution Load Index (PU) is at first determined for the different
metals at each site by calculating highest contamination factors (C.F. = metal con-
centration in polluted sediment/base value for that metal) are calculated, deriving
the n-th root of the n factors multiplied together: n cn· cn ... ' Cfn. Such site in-
dices can be treated in the exact same manner to give a zone index, and an estuary
index from the zone indices, e.g. Pollution Load Index for the zone = n site 1
. site 2 ... · site n; for the estuary = n zone 1· zone 2 ... · zone n, where n = the
number of contamination factors, sites and zones, respectively. The use of such an
index in simplified from is illustrated in Fig. 46 (from Tomlinson et aI., 1980).
The estuary is divided into three zones of approximately equal area - each zone
would normally consist of a number of sites - but in this example only one site is
given for each zone. Fig. 46 illustrates such indices using Fucus sp. calculated for
the east coast estuaries of Ireland. It is shown that the Avoca Estuary at Arklow
is by far the most polluted with regard to heavy metals, whereas Malahide and
Dublin are the least polluted. It has been inferred by the authors of this study that
unusually high levels of a single pollutant might result in an unusually low index
level if other pollutants in the system are present at near baseline concentration.
According to Tomlinson et aI., 1980 such a fault might be overcome by using a sub-
wim.salomons@home.nl
82 Sediments and the Transport of Metals
b POLLUTION LOAD
INDICES
Dundalk .w..; 1.88
a CuPbZnNi
z~ne ttSx1x2x6=2.78 2.78
IRISH
SEA
1.30
1.41
Estuary index=tl2.78xl.41x2.91=2.2S
Fig.46. Classification of Pollution Load Index (PU) after Tomlinson et al. (1980) and example for the
east coast ofIreland. For explanation see text
script to the index identifying any pollutants present in abnormally high concen-
trations; thus the index for the Avoca Estuary at Arklow (Fig. 46) would become
5.6 Cu Zn, indicating that copper and zinc were the major pollutants to give rise
to the relatively high Pollution Load Index.
It has been suggested by Tomlinson (1980) that while an index value cannot at
present provide information on the effects of the combination of pollutants on the
estuarine biota, it may enable the public to understand factors influencing the qual-
ity of a component of their environment, and it can indicate trends over time and
area. For the use of sediment parameters it will be necessary to determine an en-
richment factor corrected for grain size with the help of conservative elements
(Chap. 3.5). A further step in the application of these indices in assessing of pollu-
tion potentials would be the consideration of the mobility of a given element and
its environmental toxicity.
In this respect Tada and collegues (1983) classified pollution of Japanese rivers
by heavy metals in bottom mud using the values of 0.5 M-HCl-soluble metals in
a cluster analysis. This classification was in agreement with the pollution index de-
veloped by Nishida et al. (1980), which is based on the statistical concept that the
upper 10% of the probability distribution for a standard group would fall within
a critical region. Application of the 0.5 M-HCl-soluble data in this pollution index
should consider the aspect of "mobility" to some extent.
A sedimentological approach for an "ecological risk index" was introduced by
Hakanson (1980) and tested on 15 Swedish lakes representing a wide range in term
of size, pollution status, trophic status etc. These estimations - considered as a first
step in this field and undoubtedly open for many criticisms - are based on four
"requirements", which are determined in a relatively rapid, inexpensive and stan-
dardized manner from a limited number of sediment samples:
I. The concentration requirement compares data from the uppermost sediment
layers (minimum 5 sediment samples providing an even area cover of the lake/
basin) with a standardized set of natural background levels ofthe respective pol-
lutant.
wim.salomons@home.nl
Quantification of Environmental Impact 83
2. The number requirement is built on the idea that for practical purposes only a
limited number of substances can be used, which are determined from sediment
samples as "total concentrations". In practice, the sum of selected contaminants
and their concentration factors (PCB, Hg, Cd, As, Cu, Pb, Cr and Zn) represent
the "standard degree of contamination".
3. The toxic requirement differentiates the various contaminants according to an
"abundance principle", i.e., saying that there exists a proportionality between
toxicity and rarity (determined from concentrations in soils, water, plants and
animals) and to their "sink-effect", i.e. their affinity to solid substrates, which
may be evaluated, for example, from the quotient between the natural back-
ground concentrations in freshwater and the pre-industrial reference values for
aquatic sediments. After a normalization process the "sedimentological toxic
factor" is calculated in the following sequence: Zn = 1 < Cr = 2 < Cu = Pb = 5
< As=10 < Cd=30 < Hg=PCB=40.
4. The sensitivity requirement indicates that different lakes/basins have different
sensitivities to the different toxic substances. In this context the "bioproduction
index" as determined from the data on nitrogen content and loss of ignition is
used as the critical parameter for the "toxic-response factor" of a certain con-
taminant. (Other effects, such as the influence of pH, Eh, salinity, etc., which
may have a considerable impact on the toxicity of various metals, are not yet
included in these expressions mainly due to the insufficient knowledge on many
of these parameters.) Except for As, all the selected metals seem to be related
to the degree of bioproductivity in a similar way, i.e., the negative effects tend
to increase with decreasing bioproductivity; this effect is assumed to be the
greatest for Hg and on the same order of magnitude for the other metals.
where T~ = the toxic-response factor for a given substance; and C} = the con-
tamination factor (see 1).
Five steps, ranging from low to very high, describe the potential ecological risk
factor (E~) for a given contaminant; the four-step potential ecological risk index
(RI) is the sum of the individual risk factors, i.e. of the selected contaminants, for
a certain lake/basin. The examples from Swedish lakes in Table 14 show that within
the different classes of risk indices (RI-values) there may be quite characteristic
"contamination profiles" with prevalences for certain pollutants. For example,
Lake Norra Barken is characterized by high potential ecological risk factors orig-
inating from elevated contents of PCB and Cd, while in Lake Varmslandssjon -
in the same group of very high risk index - the concentrations of Hg pose the pre-
dominant problems. It has been stressed by Hakanson (1980) that this approach
could at first indicate the overall pollution impact in a certain aquatic environment,
expressed by the RI-status, but then - even more important in the practice of pol-
lution control- the risk factors point to those substances to which the most atten-
tion should be paid.
wim.salomons@home.nl
Table 14. The potential ecological risk factors (Er'-values) and risk indices (RI-values) of the 15 Swedish lakes. All figures marked· are hypothetical ~
Moderate Low
E:>320 320>E:> 160 160>E:>80 80>E:>40 E:<40
wim.salomons@home.nl
Blacken 305 PCB* Cd>Hg As* > Cu > Cr > Pb > Zn
Risk index (RI) moderate
150<RI<300
Haggen 275 Cd PCB*>Hg As*> Pb>Cu >Zn > Cr f
Vattern 248 PCB* Cd*>Hg As* > Pb>Cu> Zn>Cr [
Bysjon 231 PCB* Hg>Cd As· > Pb> Cu =Zn> Cr g-
Risk index (RI) low RI < 150
o
f
...,
E:::
~
Sampling of interstitial waters 85
The term "early diagenesis" denotes a large spectrum of mechanisms and effects
by which sedimentary constituents after deposition from the water column are
changed in their chemical form, involving new equilibrium between solid and their
dissolved species.
As a result different metal compounds are formed and also pore waters may
acquire high concentration of some trace metals. With regard to the processes af-
fecting metals in the hydrological cycle, the most relevant processes within the
broad spectrum of diagenetic processes are:
- the influence of deposited sediments on the composition of surface waters;
- the influence of deposited sediments and their interstitial waters on benthic life.
The more general aspects, common to all parts of the hydrological cycle will
be discussed in this chapter, the more specific details will be treated in the individ-
ual chapters dealing with separate parts of the hydrological cycle.
wim.salomons@home.nl
86 Sediments and the Transport of Metals
sampling will result in a fast precipitation of iron hydroxides (Bray et al., 1973;
Troup et al., 1974). These iron hydroxides are able to adsorb trace metals and
phosphorus from solution. Also the temperature during squeezing may affect the
composition of the pore waters (Bischoff et al., 1970; Fanning and Pilson, 1971).
The most intensive early diagenesis reactions are usually found in sediments where
variations of the redox conditions take place. Characteristic examples have been
described both from the still "natural" sediments of the deep-sea and from highly
polluted environments - e.g. deposits of dredged materials. Examples of redox pro-
cesses - involving the elements C, N, 0, S, H, Fe, and Mn - are arranged in Fig. 47
(Stumm and Baccini, 1978) in the sequence of reactions observed in an aqueous
system at various Eh-values. Since the reactions considered (with the possible ex-
ception of the reduction of Mn0 2 and FeOOH) are biologically mediated, the
chemical reaction sequence is parallelled by an ecological succession of microor-
ganisms - aerobic heterotrophs, denitrifiers, fermentors, sulfate reducers, and
methane bacteria (Stumm and Morgan, 1981). Driving force of reduction process-
es is the decomposition of organic matter by nonphotosynthetic organisms,
thereby obtaining a source of energy for their metabolic needs. The energy yields
can be evaluated from a combination of processes given in Fig. 47; reduction pro-
cesses involving oxidation of organic matter follow the sequence "aerobic transpir-
ation" (A + L -29.9 Kcal/equiv.), "denitrification" (B + L -28.4 Kcal), "nitrate re-
duction" (D + L -19.6 Kcal), "sulfate reduction" (G + L -5.9 Kcal) and "methane
fermentation" (H + L -5.6 Kcal). In this succession the formation of soluble
Mn(II) by reduction of Mn(III,IV)-oxides parallels or follows nitrate reduction,
whereas the formation of soluble Fe(II) by reducing Fe(III)-oxides takes place near
the conditions for sulfate reduction; the combination of the latter constituents for
insoluble iron sulfides is characteristic for more strongly reducing environments
(see below).
The sedimentary environments corresponding to these processes are, respec-
tively: "Oxic", "post-oxic", "sulfidic", and "methanic" (Berner, 1980).
The sequence of events affecting these transformations can be evaluated both
from pore water analyses and from mineral concentrates of typical diagenetic
phases in short sediment cores.
The succession of typical pore water constituents has been depicted by Froelich
et al. (1979) from the study of deep-sea sediment cores from the eastern equatorial
Atlantic (Fig. 48): Oxygen is consumed in the uppermost deposits during decompo-
sition of organic matter. This process - which involves dissolution of carbonate -
will release ammonia, which is subsequently oxidized to nitrate; N0 3 diffuses down
to be denitrified in the lower part of the core.
Not far below the nitrate maximum organic carbon starts to become oxidized
by simultaneous reduction of Mn0 2 , upward diffusing Mn 2 + -ions will be precipi-
tated in the stronger oxidizing part of the sediment sequence, an observation made
at first by Lynn and Bonatti (1965) on pelagic sediments. Since Mn0 2 -reduction
involves a small but characteristic effect on carbonate precipitation, the concentra-
wim.salomons@home.nl
Diagenetic Environments 87
-0.5
I
oI
+0.5
I
+1.0
I
E H Volt
-10 -5 o +5 +10 +15 +20 pE
<I O 2 - Reduction IA
Reductions
< Denitrification IB
MnOV)oxlde - I
MOl) C
N03 Reduction 1D
<
N2-NH 4 IJ
< H 2 Formation I K
-r- - -- -- -- I - - - f--
L I Oxldat. org. Mat.
~ 1Sulfide - SO 4
N pxldat of Fe Ol~
0INH; -NO a/
p lOxldat of Mn on)
al N2 -NO-
R 1O2 - Formation
Oxidations
I -5 o +5 +10 +15 +20 pE
oI 5
I
10
1
20
I
K cal.! equivalent
tion of Mn2+ in pore fluids of both lacustrine and marine sediments may be con-
trolled by the solubility of Mn-carbonate rhodochrosite (Callender et ai., 1974;
Holdren et ai., 1975). Stair-step profiles of dissolved manganese, as observed by
Klinkhammer (1980) in sediment cores from the eastern Pacific (Fig.43), indicate
that the pore water chemistry of this element is more complex than simple oxida-
tion/reduction reactions predict and may suggest that Mn2+ is produced and con-
sumed in more than one zone. At greater sediment depth, the process of iron re-
duction to d Fe 2 + begins, thus indicating the persistence of iron oxides, but not
wim.salomons@home.nl
88 Sediments and the Transport of Metals
__ CONCENTRATION
:z::
.....
IL
W
o
3000 75
50 4 Fe
:::::
~ 2000
~~. :::::
l
~ 50
i
~~
~... ~o ~5(.....
1000 ......"':':.:::
::::-:"7 r-.
0
¥ '.,~~
~. 1=..... ~c;.
o o
o 60 120 180 240 300 360 o 60 120 180 240 300 360
75 Cr 75 As
f,.--- ~
..,.".-"
0-
..- ,.
.~.~
::::: / "'-0"
~
i 25
"'. _0- ~
ej,....
/"
k";......
"...
n
i 25
11 1'-.0
o~ o ~\ .n. .nil.
o 60 120 180 240 300 360 o 60 120 180 240 300 360
75 30
DOC O-P04
_0
::::: :::::
o
.. .. •.--
a- l~
01 50 01 20
..
~;:::-",.
E E
I\~ G ",'
.~;,;;...o"
i
-~
25 .~
~- :-::
~- ,::..; P''-
~o" ~~ ~o
o o ~o
o 60 120 180 240 300 360 o 60 120 180 240 300 360
days days
Fig. 49. Changes in the composition of pore waters in original freshwater (0), brackish water (... ) and
marine (0) sediments dumped into a marine environment over a 360 day period. (Kerdijk and Salomons,
1983)
wim.salomons@home.nl
Diagenetic Environments 89
manganese oxides, under anoxic conditions (Berner, 1981). It has been inferred,
however, by Froelich et al. (1979) that only a relative small portion of Fe is avail-
able for the reduction processes - namely Fe in oxidic coatings, not in the silicate
compounds. As for the MnOz-reduction, the change from Fe 3 + to Fez + usually
involves small effect on the carbonate solubility. Under certain conditions,
Fe(OHh and FeC0 3 (siderite) might be expected to coexist (Jones and Bowser,
1978). For deep-sea sediments, however, Klinkhammer (1980) suggests that
MnC0 3 saturation is seldom reached in the upper 40 cm of the cores and the pore
waters are always undersaturated with respect to siderite.
In stronger reducing environments the metal distribution should be controlled
primarily by the formation of (highly insoluble) sulfides; at lower HzS concen-
trations, it should be controlled by the stability of carbonate and phosphate
phases. The early diagenetic reactions involving stronger reduction processes have
been studied experimentally in the field by Salomons and Kerdijk (1983). Three
large pits (80 x 30 x 6 m) were dug in the Rhine River estuary below the water table
and were filled with freshwater (Waalhaven), brackish water (Botlek) and marine
(Maasmond) sediment. The consolidation rate and the changes in pore water com-
position were studied over a one-year period (Fig. 49).
The changes in the concentrations with time can be divided into three cate-
gories:
I. The concentration shows a decrease; this is the case for sulfate in all cases, nickel
in the sediments from the Maasmond, and arsenic from the Botlek and Waal-
haven sediments.
2. The concentrations show a continuous increase; this is the case for o-P0 4 ,
NH 4 , silicon, chromium, BODs and DOC.
3. The concentrations show a maximum and then afterwards decrease; this is the
case for iron and manganese in all three examples, for copper from the Botlek
and Waalhaven sediments, and cadmium in the Maasmond sediments.
A rapid increase in iron and manganese concentrations is observed in the first
few weeks (Fig. 4ge); during this period no sulfate reduction takes place as is shown
by the constant levels of sulfate. The electron acceptors for the degradation of the
organic matter are apparently oxygen and nitrate. The low oxygen levels cause a
reduction of iron and manganese and a subsequent appearance ofFe2+ and Mnz+
in the pore waters. Sulfate concentrations start to decrease after about 2 months.
The decrease is most rapid in the sediments with the highest organic matter con-
tents (Botlek and Waalhaven) but is slower in the Maasmond sediment. With the
decrease in sulfate concentrations, and the production of sulfide, the iron and
manganese levels start to decrease, possibly as the result of the formation of sulfidic
minerals. Silicon and ortho-phosphorous concentrations show a continuous in-
crease. The phosphorous release probably takes place as a consequence of the
breakdown of the organic matter; about 10-20% of the total phosphorous in the
sediments is organically bound (Salomons and Gerritse, 1981). The behaviour of
arsenic differs strongly between the three sediment types. In the Botlek and Waal-
haven sediment the concentrations decrease continuously, whereas in Maasmond
sediments, the same type of behaviour as for iron is found, suggesting specific in-
teractions between these two elements. Chromium shows a continuous increase in
wim.salomons@home.nl
90 Sediments and the Transport of Metals
1. Initiator reaction
2. Propagation cycle
F e2+ (aq) + O 2 (aq) bacteri') F e3+ (aq)
Fe3+(aq)+FeS2(aq) _____ Fe2 +(aq)+SOi- +H+(aq) (acidity)
wim.salomons@home.nl
Diagenetic Environments 91
... !lorg
-.....
..!
Fe 2+
.=-e
~
Fe(OHI 3
Oxidation - reduction
Fig. 50. Diagrammatic description of the behaviour of iron in the presence of organic matter (after Theis
and Singer, 1974)
Fe(IILOrg~ +3
02/ _Fe
Fe'~o.g ~ 1)OH
~oxidized Org
Fe (OH)3
Fig. 51. Model of geochemical leaching of FeS 2 as it may take place in a tailings pile (after Andrews,
1977)
wim.salomons@home.nl
92 Sediments and the Transport of Metals
Table 15. Geochemical classification of sedimentary (early diagenetic) environments. (Berner, 1981)
step in this system is the oxidation of ferrous ( + 2) iron to ferric ( + 3). In an abiotic
system, the oxidation of ferrous iron is roughly a factor of 10- 6 slower than in a
system mediated by bacteria (Singer and Stumm, 1970). Methods of controlling the
problems of acidic mine drainage include thermodynamic measures (elimination of
oxygen and the maintenance of reducing conditions), kinetic effects - the latter
methods clearly having the most advantages - and especially the application of
bactericides.
A scheme for the recognition and distinction of early diagenetic environments
has been proposed by Berner (1981) on the basis of typical mineral associations
(Table 15).
Mn0 2 -type minerals constitute a good indicator of truly oxic conditions. Post-
oxic (weakly reducing) conditions, involving successively the reduction of nitrate,
manganese and iron, are characterized by the presence of Fe 2 + Fe 3 + -silicates such
as glauconite, the absence of sulfide minerals and only minor contents of organic
matter (authigenic Fe2+ -Fe3+ -silicates, siderite and vivianite are stable neither in
the oxic nor in the sulfidic environments). Sulfidic and methanic (both strongly re-
ducing) environments typically contain significant amounts of organic matter, in
addition to either newly formed or pre-existing (from former diagenetic processes)
sulfidic iron minerals such as pyrite, mackinawite and greigite. Methane, vivianite
and siderite form more readily in non-marine sediments than in marine deposits
(Emerson and Widmer, 1978), due to an initially lower sulfate concentration in the
water. The mathematical modelling of diagenetic processes in sediments has been
given by Berner (1980).
The behaviour of iron and manganese in pore waters is fairly well known (Berner,
1980; Presley and Trefry, 1980). The manganese profiles reported in the literature
fall into the four categories shown in Fig. 52 (Presley and Trefry, 1980).
wim.salomons@home.nl
Diagenetic Mobilization of Trace Metals 93
SEA WATER
SEDIMENT
:m:
wim.salomons@home.nl
94 Sediments and the Transport of Metals
Fig. 53. Erfccts of pH and redox
64 potentia l on exchangeable d-I09
in Mississippi River sedimen t su -
pension . (after Gambrell et aI. ,
1977)
48
'#.
:;; 32
...
ell
ell
::»
o
....
ell
a:
~ 16
a"l
<::>
calculations on trace metal complexes in anoxic marine pore waters showed the im-
portance of bisulfide and polysulfide complexes as chief agents for trace metal sol-
ubility (Gardner, 1973; Boulegue, 1983; Emerson et aI., 1983).
In contaminated estuarine sediments of Bellingham Bay, Washington, Bothner
et ai. (1980) observed interstitial mercury concentrations up to 3.8 J.lg/l, from 16 to
126 times higher than the concentrations in overlying seawater. This is similar to
the enrichment of mercury in contaminated anoxic sediments of Mobile Bay, Ala-
bama. It has been suggested that, in general, higher Hg fluxes were associated with
low oxygen or reducing conditions in the overlying seawater (Bothner et aI., 1980)
and the chemical form of dissolved mercury in such sediments has been calculated
to be predominantly (98%) HgS2 (Lu and Chen, 1977). However, other complexes
of mercury with polysulfides and dissolved organic matter have also been postu-
lated for this type of environment (Andren and Harriss, 1975; Bothner et aI., 1980;
Elderfield, 1981; see below).
Holmes et ai. (1974) reported that the cadmium introduced into Corpus Christi
Bay Harbour from industrial effluents in the summer when the harbour water was
stagnant reach the surface sediment with the sulfide ions and precipitates as CdS;
in the winter months, however, the increased flow of oxygen-rich water into the bay
result in the desorption of some of the precipitated metal.
The pH-redox dependencies of exchangeable cadmium were studied ex-
perimentally by Gambrell et ai. (1977) with Mississippi River sediment (Fig. 53).
wim.salomons@home.nl
Diagenetic Mobilization of Trace Metals 95
A much greater proportion of the incubated cadmium isotope 109-Cd was re-
covered in the readily bioavailable form than for any other potentially toxic heavy
metal studied.
It is suggested that considerable cadmium release to relatively mobile forms
may occur as cadmium-contaminated sediment is transported from a near-neutral
pH, reducing environment to a moderately acid, oxidizing environment. Under
these conditions, cadmium levels of subsurface drainage water from upland dis-
posal of dredged materials may be increased, and cadmium availability to plants
growing on the material enhanced.
Significant enrichment of trace metals in pore waters of sediment samples from
Southern California basin, Saanich Inlet (British Columbia) and Loch Fyne (Scot-
land) has been explained by complexation effects with organic substances (Brooks
et aI., 1968; Presley et aI., 1972; Duchart et aI., 1973). In a comparative investiga-
tion Nissenbaum and Swaine (1976) found that with the exception of Fe, Ni, and
Co, which occur mostly as sulfides under anaerobic conditions, the elements con-
centrated in the interstitial solutions are those which are also enriched in sedimen-
tary humates. The transport of dissolved metals in the pore waters is, therefore,
strongly influenced by the vertical gradient of dissolved humic substances (Krom
and Sholkovitz, 1978).
Recent data of Elderfield (1981) from anoxic sediments of Narragansett Bay
R.I. indicate that approx. 80% of the total Fe and Cu, approx. 40% of the total
Ni, 10% of the total Mn were organically bound in the interstitial water of surface
sediments.
The concentrations of trace elements copper and iron in pore waters of sedi-
ments from a salt marsh along the Delaware estuary have been found to be con-
trolled mainly by sulfide formation; calculations show that copper is strongly com-
plexed probably with organo-sulfur ligands, whereas iron might be complexed as
such sulfur species to a much lesser extent than copper (Boulegue et aI., 1982).
While microprobe studies of zinc in anoxic sediments performed by Elderfie1d et
aI. (1979) have suggested that it is more likely for metals to be scavenged by Fe sul-
fides than to form discrete sulfide minerals, more recent investigations by Luther
et., 1980 on sediments of Newark Bay, New Jersey, using scanning electron micros-
copy with energy dispersive X-ray analysis evidenced zinc sulfide minerals; this was
the first report of framboidal sulfide minerals which contain a cation other than
iron as the major constituent in recent estuarine sediments. Nickel and manganese
however, were incorporated into the structure of pyrite and iron mono sulfide crys-
tals, respectively (Luther et aI., 1980).
Data of Hart and Davies (1977) indicate that the major portion of cadmium
in the interstitial water from a sediment sample of an urban creek at Melbourne,
Australia, was associated with colloidal labile species and more strongly bound
complexes; zinc and lead to the major proportion was associated with the colloidal
phase, 20% in labile forms and 10% in more tightly bound (organic) forms. Water
samples from the Woronora River of New South Wales (Australia) by Batley and
Giles (1980) including speciation studies, indicate an increasing solubility of bound
species of lead and copper in the anoxic interstitial water (mangrove sediment)
compared with oxic surface water; this should be the result of organic complexa-
tion, with which the increase in "labile" metal species is also associated. Character-
wim.salomons@home.nl
96 Sediments and the Transport of Metals
istic differences in the behaviour of copper and zinc are also observed in ex-
periments on sand filters by Forstner et al. (1979). The sand filter columns were
fed with river water containing added doses of humic acids and dissolved copper
and zinc. After 10 hours the copper concentrations in the filter outlet had increased
significantly, whereas no increase in the zinc concentrations were observed over the
whole 24-hours measuring period. Anodic stripping voltametry determinations
showed that zinc in the inflowing solution is basically labile bound, whereas copper
was in a more stable association with the complexing (organic) ligands. The labile-
bound zinc strongly interacts with the FejMn hydroxides of the filter particles,
whereas the more stable organic-copper complexes are only partially affected by
physico-chemical interactions with the filter material. Most of the organically-as-
sociated metals are "colloidal", equivalent to the high molecular weight organics,
presumably; if this colloidal material is genetically related to the dissolved organic
fraction, it has been proposed that it is dear that the alteration of the latter to the
former takes place very rapidly during diagenesis (Elderfield, 1981). It is possible
that this rapid coagulation is promoted by very high concentrations of interstitial
iron, as shown experimentally by Picard and Felbeck (1976).
Since the larger proportion of the metals was found to be associated with high
molecular weight organic material it appears, on balance, that diffusion of organi-
cally-associated metals will not be a major factor in metal transport; only in
situations where transport is by biological "advection" and not diffusion, metal-
organic complexes may be very important (Elderfield, 1981). Flux calculations
from pore water concentration gradients suggest that benthic fluxes of nickel, cad-
mium, and copper are close to zero or are negative, due to the above-mentioned
behaviour of metal scavenging by sulfides (Elderfield, 1981 b).
The studies carried out on metal behaviour in pore waters show the importance
of both complexation by organic matter and precipitation as sulfidic minerals on
pE
CI
.SCI)
Us::
:::10
"gN Fig. 54. Schematic presentation of the cycling che-
II:
lated heavy metals above the redoxcline (Hall-
berg, 1982, modified after Hallberg, 1972)
wim.salomons@home.nl
Diagenetic Mobilization of Trace Metals 97
their behaviour. Hallberg (1982) has discussed in detail the metal cycling in the top
layer of sediments as being the result of a competition of trace metal complexation
by organic matter and precipitation as sulfidic minerals, stressing the importance
of trace metals in pore waters as a dynamic system. As sediments accumulate, the
oxidizing surface layer is buried and gradually becomes deficient in oxygen due to
oxygen consumption and ultimately H 2 S is produced by sulfate reducing bacteria,
as is shown by a decrease in sulfate concentrations with time (see Fig. 54). The H 2 S
moves upward and encounters the oxidised layer as a consequence the metal com-
pounds existing as hydroxides, oxyhydroxides and various carbonates have a lower
stability and are redissolved (Hallberg, 1982). Furthermore, the microbiological
decomposition of organic matter produced intermediate compounds (as is evident
from the increase in DOC levels in the pore waters Fig. 49), which may act as metal
chelators. If a metal chelating compound has an upward transport rate which is
greater than that of the H 2 S, chelated metal will escape the H 2 S-zone. Thus a min-
eral cycle exists above the redoxcline where the chela ted metals are transported up-
wards (Fig. 54).
In this way the complexed metals escape from being trapped and fixed as solid
sulfide compounds and are concentrated in the uppermost layers. Sedimentation
causes an upward movement of the enriched metal layer: the metals climb with the
accumulation of sediments (Hallberg, 1982). Metals differ in their ability to chelate
so that the more easily chela ted ones tend to becom e enriched in the uppermost
layer. In such a dynamic system, the metals are chelated and/or complexed before
they meet the sulfide environment.
This dynamic approach can also explain the enrichment of iron, manganese
and phosphorus in the oxidised surface layer of marine sediments (Salomons and
Gerritse (1981). High concentrations of iron, manganese and phosphorus are
found in oxidised surface layers of marine sediments in the North Sea compared
with the underlying reduced layers (Table 16).
High dissolved iron, manganese and phosphorus concentrations are observed
in the pore waters of the reduced layer, these migrate upward as a consequence of
concentration gradients between the pore waters and the surface waters, a process
enhanced by consolidation. When the upward migration metals and phosphorus
encounter the oxygen-rich surface layer, they are reprecipitated. After renewed de-
position, the former surface layer becomes reduced and mobilization of Fe, Mn,
and P takes place. The released trace metals start migrating upward again and be-
come precipitated in the new surface layer. This process results in an upward mi-
gration of an enriched surface layer. Also adsorption of upward migrating chela ted
Phosphorus Manganese
/!g/g /!g/g
wim.salomons@home.nl
98 Sediments and the Transport of Metals
trace metals on the manganese and iron hydroxides in the surface layers seems
likely. Such an oxidised surface layer, therefore, may act as chemical barrier
against the upward flow of some trace metals and phosphorus to surface waters.
The difference in metal chelating ability of copper and zinc was used by Hall-
berg (1974) to trace anoxic and oxic conditions in recent and fossil sediments.
Under anoxic conditions the more easily chela ted copper may escape the sediments
to the surface waters. In this way the Cu/Zn will differ between sediments deposited
under oxidizing from sediments deposited under anoxic conditions in the bottom
waters.
It has been stressed by Beveridge et al. (1983) that a significant portion of the
organic matter of aquatic (both marine and freshwater) sediments consists of small
colloidial aggregates which are composed of highly cross-linked heteropolymeric
materials of biological origin and are very resistant to degradation. These most du-
rable polymeric networks - partly of bacterial origin - would interact with and se-
quester dilute metals from the aqueous phase, thereby concentration metals into
the sediment. Within a series of microbial or chemical transformations, sedimen-
tary diagenesis eventually would either recycle the metals to the overlying water
column or immobilize them in authigenetic mineral phases. In an experimental
series to simulate low-temperature sediment diagenesis of metal-loaded cells (using
an admixture of synthetic inorganic sediment which consists of calcium carbonate,
crystalline quartz, as well as of elemental sulfur and crystalline magnetite as redox
buffers) Beveridge et al. (1983) found the formation of a mixed assemblage of crys-
talline metal phosphates, metal sulfides, and polymeric, metal-complexed, organic
residues. Calcite raised the pH of the fluid phase of the sediment, which influenced
phosphate mineralization and inhibited metal sulfide genesis. This is the first in-
stance that metal sulfide framboid production has been definitely correlated to bi-
ological material.
The sometimes conflicting opinions on trace metal behaviour in pore waters re-
ported in the literature and the lack of a coherent set of data (e.g. analysis on both
solid and liquid phases including speciation) makes it difficult at present to present
a clear picture of the processes affecting trace metal concentrations in pore waters
and of the processes at the sediment-water interface.
However, the recognition of pore waters as a key factor in the geochemical cyc-
ling of trace metals in oceans, lakes, estuaries and their importance for the assess-
ment of dumping strategies will undountedly increase research in this area.
wim.salomons@home.nl
4 Metals in the Atmosphere
4.1 Introduction
Table 17. Atmospheric emissions of trace metals (x JOY g(y). Data are based on Nriagu (1979), except
for the Zn, Pb and Cd inputs from seaspray. (Weisel, 1981)
wim.salomons@home.nl
100 Metals in the Atmosphere
It is known that the atmosphere has been contaminated with lead since about 4500
BP (Fig. 55) when technology for smelting lead sulfide ores and cupellation of silver
from lead were developed in Southwest Asia (Patterson, 1971). Until 2600 BP the
annual production oflead was about 200 tons/year, while it rose to 10,000 tons af-
ter the discovery of the use of silver coinage in the eastern region of the Mediter-
ranean (Patterson, 1972). During the period 2100 to 1800 BP, the Romans mined
and smelted lead at a rate of about 80,000 tons/year and during this period the con-
centrations in the atmosphere probably increased about 5-fold above natural levels
(Patterson, 1972). Around 1940 there was a sharp increase in atmospheric lead con-
centrations due to lead emissions from automobiles (Murozimi et aI., 1969). The
present input of lead into the atmosphere is estimated at 400,000 tons/yr (Ng and
Patterson 1981).
There are less detailed historical records available for other trace metals and
hence other methods have been employed to assess the anthropogenic concen-
trations in the atmosphere. Three approaches have been reviewed by Galloway et
aI. (1980, 1982).
1. Compare the actual metal emission rates of natural and anthropogenic process-
es. This is the approach which has been used by Lantzy and Mackenzie (1979).
10 7
6 Spanish Production
10
of Silver /
in New World
"i:
~·i
5
0 10
iI:
.5
":s 10 4
.'l\\
./ t. ./.........
I " It
ell
g Industrial
"..a.
Revolution
/
0 Exhaustion S.·I
.
:0. 10 3
of Roman
lead Mines
I ve~
~roductlon
In Germany
"-
.a
·--t
II.
. 10
III
c: 2
0
Discovery ./ Use of
of /" coinage
cupell/tion•
1
10 ~ Rise and Fall Roman Republic
• of Athens \ and Empire
Fig. 55. Historical development in the use oflead during the last 5500 years (Settle and Patterson, 1980)
wim.salomons@home.nl
Natural and Anthropogenic Emissions of Trace Metals 101
Table 18. Natural and anthropogenic emissions of trace metals in the atmosphere and
the mobilization factor. Based on Lantzy and Mackenzie (1979) and Galloway et al.
(1980). The values in brackets refer to vapour emissions of the volatile species (Ag,
Hg and Se) from land and sea (The data on lead are from Ng and Patterson, 1981)
Natural anthropogenic
Ag 0.6 50 83
As 28 (210) 780 3.3
Cd 2.9 55 19
Co 70 50 0.71
Cr 580 940 1.6
Cu 190 2600 13
Hg 0.4 (250) 110 0.44
Mn 6100 3200 0.53
Mo 11 510 45
Ni 280 980 3.5
Pb 40 4000 100
Sb 9.8 380 39
Se 4.1 (30) 140 4.7
Sn 52 430 8.3
V 650 2100 3.2
Zn 360 8400 23
wim.salomons@home.nl
102 Metals in the Atmosphere
104
DNorth Atlantic Westerlies
o South Pole
103
102
~v ~~
to
"'-u'" 101
B it'"
<OJ
10"1
Element
Fig. 56. EF (crust) values for metals in the atmosphere at Bermuda and the South Pole (Duce ct aI., 1975)
Table 19. Expected enrichment for trace metals III the atmosphere and III atmospheric
deposition. Galloway et al. (1982)
However, several other sources apart from anthropogenic inputs and crustal
material contribute to the atmospheric trace metals. These include low temperature
volatilization. Particles released by vegetation and coal and fly ash have relative
concentrations of trace metals similar to average crustal material (Bertine and
Goldberg, 1971). Enrichment factors must therefore be used cautiously in attempts
to ascertain atmospheric trace metal sources (Duce et aI., 1976).
wim.salomons@home.nl
Atmospheric Particles 103
Most metals in the atmosphere are present in association with particles; an excep-
tion is mercury which is highly volatile and perhaps some volatile methylated spe-
cies of certain trace metals. The behaviour of trace metals in the atmosphere there-
fore is closely related to the behaviour of the atmospheric aerosol. Estimates on
the amount of particles introduced into the atmosphere are presented in Table 20.
Based on the size and nature of particles the following terminology is in use
(Cawse, 1982). Coarse range particles (diameter, d> 1 !lm) produced by disintegra-
tion of minerals or from resuspension of soil particles are called dust. Fine particles
formed from the gas phase by condensation are termed "smoke" and "fume". In
the case of fume the particles are generally from 0.01 to 1 !lm diameter, and are
often agglomerates of smaller particles. Suspended particulate matter < 15 !lm dia-
meter is usually defined as smoke. Mists (d > 40 !lm) and fogs (d = 5-40 !lm) are liq-
uid droplets. Finally, small hygroscopic particles, or condensation nuclei, are clas-
sified into Aitken nuclei (d<0.2 !lm), large (d=0.2- 2 !lm), and giant (d>2 !lm)
types (Cawsc, 1982).
x 10 12 g/year
wim.salomons@home.nl
104 Metals in the Atmosphere
r I I I
10- 2 10- 1 10° 10 1 10 2
--+ radius, I'
-
10 5
/ , ,-- .......
1/ ...........
r\."~"
10·
10 3
~
/ I
continental aerosols
I
10 2
",
! maritime aerosols
'~'"
!
i ;
10 1
II
u 10° !;?
-~
u
2i -1
:> 10
u
sea-salt particles
~
a. 10- 2
~
"
III
5!
\
'a
10- 3
"
K "
Z
ct
\ "\
10-·
air electricity
A
10- 5
1\
large Ions
\
10- 8
maritime continental
aerosols <{ aerosols? sea salt
Fig. 57. The average size distribution of aerosols over the continents and oceans and of seasalt particles
(Junge, 1974)
wim.salomons@home.nl
Atmospheric Particles 105
Chemical Conversion
T-
Volatility Vapors
Condensation
.002
Particle Diameter , micrometer
Fig. 58. Schematic diagram of processes involved in the formation of the three modes of atmospheric
particles and an example of a surface area distribution of the particles (Whitby 1977)
The curve shown in Fig. 57, which was used quite extensively before the 1970's,
masks the true structure of aerosols, because it erroneously suggests that the whole
distribution can be plotted as a continuous function (Whitby, 1977). In fact two or
three modes are usually observed in the mass or volume distribution ratio (for a
review see Whitby, 1977). The approximate range of these three particle modes and
the processes leading to their formation are summarised in Fig. 58. The physical
separation of the fine and the coarse mode originates because condensation pro-
cesses produce fine particles while mechanical processes produce mostly coarse
particles. The fine particle mode can be subdivided into a nuclei mode and an ac-
cumulation mode.
wim.salomons@home.nl
106 Metals in the Atmosphere
Table 21. Summary of processes acting upon the contaminants present in particle size classes of
airborne particulates (Hosker and Lindberg, 1982)
The small particles are formed by condensation processes. However the rate of
transfer from smaller to larger particles by coagulation decreases sharply for par-
ticles larger than about 0.5 !lm diameter. To transfer the mass present in the accu-
mulation mode to the coarse particle mode would require weeks (Whitby, 1977).
Thus for the usual few days residence time of fine particles in the atmosphere, the
accumulation mode particles are not a major source of particles in the coarse mode.
These particles are generated in a different way; they consist of wind blown dust,
primary emissions like fly ash, sea spray, volcanic dust and particles released by
vegetation (Fig. 58). As a consequence the nuclei mode of particles is important
for urban and near-urban areas. In aged aerosols found over rural and remote
areas, the accumulation mode and the coarse mode dominate. A summary of the
various processes acting upon the contaminants in the various particle size classes
is given in Table 21.
The bulk composition of the aerosol collected within different particle size
ranges is variable, for example the composition of a rural aerosol as shown in Fig. 59.
The soil related elements dominate in the two larger size ranges and amount
to more than 50% of the smallest size range. Flocchini et al. (1981) also observed
seasonal variations in the soil component concentration, being about three times
higher in summer than in the winter. No distinct seasonal pattern was observed in
the concentrations of sulfur, which is dominant in the small particle size fraction.
The mineralogy of urban aerosols from the S1. Louis area (USA) has been stud-
ied using X-ray diffraction analysis (O'Conner and laklevic 1981). The most fre-
quently observed component in the fine fraction «2.4 !lm) were (NH 4hS04 and
the double salts (NH 4hS04' PbS0 4 and 3 (NH4)2S04' H 2S0 4, The major com-
ponents they observed in the coarse fraction (2.4-20 !lm) were the minerals calcite
and quartz, reflecting the composition of surface rocks in the region.
wim.salomons@home.nl
Atmospheric Particles 107
4
2
3
5 5 4
m Sulfate 1 =SO. 5= K2 O 9= P
10 = 81
[J Soil related 2= MgO 6= CaO
3= AI2 0 J 7= Fe2 0 2 11 = Pb
4 =SiO 8 = Na 9a, 12=Other
Fig. 59. Size fractionated mass balance for Zion, Utah (U.S.A.). Redrawn after Flocchini et al. 1981
Ammonium sulfate was the largest chemical component (41 %) of the fine aero-
sol (d < 3.S flm) in the urban aerosol of Charleston, West Virginia USA (Lewis and
Macias 1980). Carbon was a large component of both fine and coarse particles con-
stituting 16 and 12% respectively.
Considering the diversity in the sources of trace metals, it is not surprising that
concentrations are not uniform according to particle size. An example for air over
Bermuda is shown in Fig. 60.
Iron, aluminium, manganese and chromium are found in the coarse size parti-
cles (around 1.S flm), cadmium, lead, zinc and antimony in particles smaller than
0.2S flm. For trace metals and other constituents, the particle size distribution can
be approximated by the mass median diameter (MMD): the particle size for which
SO% of the mass occurs on larger and SO% on smaller particles. A summary of
available MMD values for metals in the atmosphere is presented in Table 22. Some
data are also given in Fig. 64.
The metals found in rural to urban atmospheres and in marine air occur mainly
in the accumulation mode of particles. In the marine atmosphere the MMD is less
than 1 flm, and slightly higher in urban-rural areas. Compared with other com-
ponents of marine atmospheres like sodium (MMD about 4-S flm), the metals are
present in much smaller fractions. (see also Chap. 4.6.3.3)
Information on the mode of occurrence of trace metals in urban particulates
has been obtained with selective chemical leaching techniques (based on the sedi-
ment leaching methods described in Chap. 2.6). Standard Reference Material 1648,
urban particulate matter, was analysed with a sequential extraction procedure
(Lum et aI. 1982).
The results show high proportions of soluble metals, especially for Zn, Pb and
Cd. Co and Cr are more tightly bound in the residual fraction.
This high solubility of trace metals in atmospheric particulates is a general phe-
nomenon (Wallace et aI., 1977; Crecelius, 1980; Gatz et aI., 1982; Hodge et aI., 1978;
Ochs and Gatz, 1980), and shows that deposition on wet surface (e.g. leaves) and
in surface waters will results in a release of trace metals to the ecosystem.
wim.salomons@home.nl
108 Metals in the Atmosphere
Table 22. Mean MMD values for a number of metals. The data for marine air
are from Duce et al. (1979). The data from Eniwetok atoll are from Merrill
and Duce (1982) and those for rural to urban air from Rahn (1976) as cited by
Galloway et al. (1980)
Na 1
Ag 1
As 2
Cd 0.5 2
Co 0.75 4
Cr 3
Cu 0.8 0.96 1.8
Hg 0.5
Mn 0.4 0.88 2
Mo 1.2
Ni 1.5
Pb 0.4 0.25 0.4
Sb 0.35 1
Se 0.53 0.8
Sn 1.2
V 0.5 0.76 1
Zn 0.04 1.5
wim.salomons@home.nl
Deposition of Atmospheric Particles 109
Co Cr Ni Mn Cu Zn Ph Cd
Fig.61. Mode of occurrence of trace metals in Standard Reference Material 1648 (urban particulate
matter). (Drawn after table 2 in Lum et aI., 1982). 1 Exchangeable fraction, 2 Surface oxide and car-
bonate-bound fraction, 3 Associated with Fe-Mn oxides, 4 Organically bound fraction,S Residual frac-
tion
Trace metals are removed from the atmosphere by dry and wet deposition. The dry
deposition velocity of particulates (and gases) has been defined by Chamberlain
and Chadwick (1953) as the deposition flux F, divided by the airborne concentra-
tion C.
V=FjC.
The reference heights for airborne concentrations have historically been about
1.5 m for land surfaces and 10-15 m for ocean surfaces. The deposition velocity is
not the same as the gravitational settling velocity, since it is the summation of all
processes causing the flux to the surface; it is equal to or greater than the gravita-
tional settling velocity. Measured dry deposition velocities in the field vary by or-
ders of magnitude (for reviews see Sehmel, 1980; McMahon and Denison, 1979;
Slinn et aI., 1878). These variations are not surprising considering that Sehmel
(1980) listed close to 100 factors which influence the dry deposition removal rates.
The deposition velocity in polar regions (Greenland) is estimated at 0.5 cm s - 1
(Davidson etaI., 1981), and for ocean areas the estimates using different methods
are 0.8 cm s -1 (Crecelius, 1982) over vegetated areas it is much larger.
Three main processes cause removal of particulates from the atmosphere (Hidy,
1973; Galloway, 1980):
Sedimentation
The most common process by which particulates are removed from the atmosphere
(and also from water) is gravitational settling. The sedimentation velocity falls off
wim.salomons@home.nl
110 Metals in the Atmosphere
drastically for particles smaller than a few microns, so that this process is particu-
larly important for particles in the coarse-particle mode (larger than 5 11m diame-
ter).
Diffusional Transport
In the same way that gas molecules are transported by diffusional processes, the
smaller particles migrate by their own thermal agitation (Brownian movement) or
turbulent eddying in the air. Deposition by this process is especially important for
particles smaller than 0.3 11m in diameter.
Inertial Impaction and Interception
Impaction and interception are caused by the fact that particles do not follow ex-
actly the gasflow on objects and hence collide and are removed from the atmo-
sphere.
The removal at the surface of the earth depends on its nature. Large differences
in deposition velocities are observed for water surfaces and forest areas.
As already discussed, all three processes are not equally efficient for all particle
sizes. The smaller particles (less than 0.3 11m) are efficiently removed by diffusion
and impaction processes, and the large particles by sedimentation processes. How-
ever, there is a minimum deposition velocity for particles approximately in the
range of 0.3 to 0.5 11m; these particles have longer residence times since both dif-
fusion and inertial deposition and sedimentation are weak in this range.
The particle size of aerosols depends not only on their source and origin but
additionally on the humidity. Continental aerosols contain 15-30% of sulfate in
the accumulation mode, while the value for marine aerosols is 30-60%. Sulfate in
excess of 15-30% makes the particles hygroscopic and at normal humidities they
increase in size due to adsorption of water. The increase in size due to humidity
changes must be taken into account when considering the deposition of particles
over natural waters, since the relative humidity increases towards the water sur-
face.
Three cases of particle behaviour are shown in Fig. 62, namely for:
- hydrophobic particles, their size is not affected by humidity changes
- particles that will grow to the equilibrium size of ammoniumsulfate particles for
a relative humidity of99%
- the expected behaviour of ammoniumsulfate particles for a relative humidity of
100%.
One of the main features of the curves is the minimum in the deposition velocity
for particles in the accumulation mode. It should be noted that particles originally
hydrophobic may obtain a wettable/soluble surface coating after aging (Slinn and
Slinn, 1980), and show behaviour similar to hydrophilic particles. The high water
solubility of trace metals in both coal combustion emissions and ambient aerosols
has been shown by Lindberg and Harriss (1980, 1981).
Dry deposition of atmospheric pollutants is a continuous process, while wet de-
position is an intermittent process. In fact, only dry deposition may always be re-
lied upon to remove airborne pollutants and is always cleansing the atmosphere
(Sehmel, \980).
wim.salomons@home.nl
Deposition of Atmospheric Particles III
.-.
I.,
-,.
10
E Rat. limited b,.
o
.
"III
:.
C;
o
'i
:.
c::
o
;:
..o 102
•,.
Do
.
"III
CI
Fig.62. Predicted deposition velocities of particles to natural waters as a function of wind speed and
of particle size (Slinn and Slinn, 1980)
wim.salomons@home.nl
112 Metals in the Atmosphere
:0-
U
'u•
I:
......
;:
I:
o
~
'0
(,)
..:
2000r--------r--------,--------,--------,--------,
~ 1600
:!
•E
!
.
~c 1200
•E Mg
...
.! Gatz, St. Louis, to 7.2
a"i 800 50 km NW
it
I
8
! 400
:e.u
~
•
3 4 5
MMD, ~m
Fig. 64 shows the washout ratio as a function of the MMD for a number of
trace metals (Gatz, 1975).
Young aerosols have low MMD's and consequently a low washout ratio (the
results for 15 km from St.Louis). With an increase in age the MMD increases, and
probably also the attachment of the metal containing particulates to soluble
aerosols with a subsequent increase in washout ratio.
wim.salomons@home.nl
Metal Concentrations in Urban, Rural and Remote Atmospheres 113
As 0.2
Cd 0.4 0.4 0.6
Cu 0.5
Mn 0.5 0.5 0.5
Ni 0.6 0.5 0.5
Pb 0.6 0.3 0.2
V 0.4
Zn 0.7 0.4 0.5
Data on dry versus wet deposition of trace metals have been reported by Duce
(1979) for the marine environment and for rural and urban areas by Feely and
Larsen (1979). Some data ofthese studies are presented in Table 23.
The data indicate that dry and wet deposition both may contribute about
equally to the flux of atmospheric trace metals to the surface of the earth. Davidson
et al. (1981) reported data for polar areas and showed that dry deposition contrib-
uted less than 25% of the total deposition for elements with large enrichment
factors (e.g. trace metals). These data should be interpreted cautiously. Various
methods are in use to sample separately dry and wet deposition, with large differ-
ences in efficiency. The various methods to discriminate between wet and dry de-
position as well as the collection of atmospheric particulates have been discussed
in detail in the reviews by Hosker and Lindberg (1982), Cawse (1982) and Noller
et al. (1981).
wim.salomons@home.nl
114 Metals in the Atmosphere
Table 24. Concentrations of elements in air at non-urban and urban locations (ng kg - 1 air) Cawse (1981)
wim.salomons@home.nl
Metal Concentrations in Urban, Rural and Remote Atmospheres 115
...
CI
\
1000 Na\......l
"'
"
....
1000
I
m
jf.
iii
..
o
c
-
100 Zn .'
'
.s
z
o
i=
«
a:
I-
zW
(,)
Z
o
(,)
0.1 1 234123
1971 1972
10.000.....--------------------------,10.000
WRAYMIRES-NON URBAN
.j 1000 1000
...
I
m
jf.
iii 100
.
o
c
.s
10 10
~
i=
«
a:
I-
z
W
(,)
Z
o
(,)
Fig. 66. Seasonal fluctuations and long term trends in metal concentrations in the atmosphere (Cawse,
1981)
wim.salomons@home.nl
116 Metals in the Atmosphere
Pb 0.22 0.06 15
Zn 1.3 0.17 9.3
Cu 0.28 0.026
Ni 0.076 <0.072
Cr 0.10
V 0.076
Cd 0.050 0.0061 0.5
Mn 0.022 0.22 35
The element bromium showed the greatest increase in winter, to almost three
times its concentrations in summer. Increases for the elements As, Cr, Pb, Sb, V
and Zn are 11 to 2-fold compared with the summer period. This variation is at-
tributed to increased combustion of fossil fuels and the persistence of inversion
layers in winter (Cawse, 1981).
The long term records at the various stations (Fig. 66) show that downward
trends are evident for several elements over the last 8 to 10 years. Downward trends
are found for AI, Br, Co, Cr, Mn, Pb, Sc, V and Zn for all sites. The downward
trend is most marked for zinc. A decrease in industrial emissions owing to the eco-
nomic recession is considered the be the most likely cause of lower trace element
concentrations in air (Cawse, 1981). The deposition of trace metals from the atmo-
sphere depends on dry versus wet deposition and on local atmospheric conditions.
A large amount of data on the total deposition of trace metals have been reported
and some of them are summarised in Table 25.
Atmospheric metals have a global distribution and affect all aquatic ecosystems.
To illustrate the impact of trace metals on the hydrological cycle, three areas where
the atmospheric input is dominant will be discussed:
- terrestrial ecosystems
- ocean areas far away from the input of rivers and other point sources
- the polar regions.
Atmospheric trace metals are also one of the many sources of trace metals in
lakes, rivers, estuaries and near coastal environments. This will be discussed in the
relevant chapters.
wim.salomons@home.nl
Terrestrial Ecosystems 117
The influence of atmospheric trace metals has been studied in a number of forest
ecosystems. In these systems two pathways for the atmospheric trace metals can
be distinguished:
- the dry deposition of trace metals directly on the forest soil and on the leaves
of the trees and other vegetation;
- the wet deposition of trace metals. This will also remove the dry deposition from
leaves.
Trace metals deposited by both dry and wet deposition will interact with the
vegetation. Some metals appear to be taken up through the leaves, whereas others
are leached from the leaves (foliar leaching).
Within the forest ecosystems, trace metals are incorporated in the above
ground cycling fraction (leaves, needles etc), in the non-cycling fractions of the veg-
etation (wood, bark), in the organic-rich surface layers and in the soil. Part of the
metals accumulated in the forest ecosystem will be leached away from the soil and
enter streams and rivers. However, if the rate of input is not matched by the rate
of output, an accumulation of metals will occur.
Areas which have been studied in detail include the Walker Branch Watershed
(Lindberg et aI., 1979) in the USA and the Solling forest in W-Germany (Mayer,
1981 ).
The Walker Branch Watershed (surface area 97.5 ha) is located in Eastern Ten-
nessee and is situated within 20 km of two coal-fired power plants (annual coal
consumption about 7 x 106 tons) and within 350 km of22 coal fired power plants.
The Solling forest is located close to the major industrial region of Europe (the
Ruhr area). Using a mass balance approach it was shown (Andren and Lindberg,
1977) that no more than 5% of the total composition of the aerosol in the Walker
Branch Watershed could be accounted for by the local coal-fired power plants,
however they accounted for up to 20% of the concentrations of individual ele-
ments. The enrichment oflead in the aerosol could be accounted for by automotive
emissions, and zinc and possibly mercury by the three nearby power plants. How-
Table 26. Characteristics of atmospheric particles above the forest canopy at Water
Branch Watershed. The relative solubility is defined as (water-soluble concentra-
tion) ·IOOj(acid-leachable concentration). The acid leaching was carried out at a
pH of 1.2 and includes both soluble and acid leachable components (Lindberg
and Harriss, 1981)
wim.salomons@home.nl
lIS Metals in the Atmosphere
ever, these local sources still could not account for most of the As, Cd, Cu, Hg,
Se, V and Zn in the aerosol. Recent atmospheric trace metal concentrations at Wal-
ker Branch Watershed, together with the results of a speciation scheme are given
in Table 26.
The extraction scheme consists of an extraction with distilled water and an acid
extraction at a pH of 1.2. The results show the very high relative solubility of trace
metals in the atmospheric aerosol. The relative solubility increased with decreasing
particle size (Fig. 67) (Lindberg and Harriss, 1981), as also shown for coal combus-
tion emissions (Lindberg and Harriss, 1980).
The dry deposited particles on the leaves contained significant fractions larger
than 5 Ilm in diameter and also numbers of particle aggregates. The relative low
solubility of the deposited particles (for lead) is in accordance with the relative
coarse particle sizes. Similar high solubilities of metals in aerosols have been found
by Gatz et al (1982), who studied the solubility in rainwater. The distribution of
RELATIVE SOLUBILITY OF
PARTICLE ASSOCIATED
LEAD (%)
60
40
20
-----. -----
AERODYNAMIC DIAMETER
(,11m)
AMBIENT DRY
AEROSOLS DEPOSITED
PARTICLES
Table 27. Summary of mean data for the precipitation at the Walker Branch Watershed. (Lindberg
and Harriss, 19SI)
wim.salomons@home.nl
Terrestrial Ecosystems 119
the percent soluble metals showed the order Zn = Cd > Cu > Pb and differences for
all metals between sample types were in the order: wet> bulk = dry. The dry depo-
sition rate, the dry deposition velocity, the trace metal concentrations in the pre-
cipitation above and below the canopy (throughfall) and the total atmospheric de-
position for the Walker Branch Watershed is shown in Table 27.
The dry deposition rate follows the general relationship that the higher the
MMD the higher the deposition rate. Also the mean deposition velocities (as de-
termined from deposition on inert flat surfaces) reflect the influence of MMD. It
should be noted however, that the deposition velocities increase by a factor of
about 2-3 if the full canopy effect (larger surface area) of the forest during summer
is taken into account (Lindberg and Harriss, 1981). Mayer and Ulrich (1982) ob-
served higher deposition rates in a spruce forest compared with a beech forest. This
deposition excess of the spruce forest is mainly found during the winter period,
when beech has lost its leaves and therefore has a reduced surface area compared
with the evergreen spruce canopy. The dry deposition particles or their water sol-
uble metals are washed from the leaves during rain periods and are part of the flux
to the forest floor. Important with respect to potential negative effects for the veg-
etation are dew periods and small rainfall events. In those cases the dry deposition
particles are not washed offfrom the leaves, but instead dissolve partly in the water
film on the leaf. The dry deposition particles contain high concentrations of soluble
metals and as a consequence elevated metal concentrations occur in the water film,
which increase after subsequent evaporation (Table 28).
The metal concentrations are one up to several hundred times higher than typi-
cal rain concentrations in this area (Lindberg and Harris, 1982). The physiological
effects of surface deposited materials on vegetation either in particulate or dis-
solved form requires considerable study, as they are poorly understood (Lindberg
and McLaughlin, 1982). Possible effects may be damage to micro-organisms on the
leaf surfaces, epiphytes or the leaves themselves (Mayer and Ulrich, 1982).
The flux of metals to the forest floor differs from the sum of wet and dry pre-
cipitation, showing the effects of interactions between the precipitation and leaf
surfaces (Lindberg and Harriss 1981, McColl and Bush 1978, Heinrichs and Mayer
1980, McColl 1981). The enrichment in manganese is particularly high (see Table
27); for zinc and cadmium smaller enrichments are observed. Also the pH increases
in the throughfall precipitation.
The uptake of H + by the leaf surfaces and the concomitant loss of several ele-
ments suggests a combination of ion exchange and leaching processes. This foliar
leaching is important for manganese, zinc and cadmium in the Walker Branch Wa-
tershed (Fig. 68).
wim.salomons@home.nl
I ATMOSPHERE I
Incident precipitation Dry deposition
2 12
Foliar
leaching
I LEAVES
L~
49
'\ MANGANESE
Wash - of dry
depOsition I
~
LEAF
SURFACE
11 I
Leaf fall
31 To Ground
Idormant parlod )
\ It It
J V It
FOREST FLOOR
l ATMOSPHERE I
Incident precipitation Dry dep081tion
36 8
Foliar
I •• chlng
LEAVES I ZINC
I 32
Wash-of dry
depOsition I
~
LEAF
7
I SURFACE
1
Leaf f.1I
24 To Ground
\ / (dormant parlod)
V \V
FOREST FLOOR
I ATMOSPHERE J
Incident precipitation Dry depOsition
34 1
Foliar
leachi ng
I LEAVES
L 55 Wash-of dry
CADMIUM
depo81t1on I
~
LEAF
6
I SURFACE
1
Leaf fall
3 To Ground
\ It (dormant period
V V
FOREST FLOOR
Fig. 68
wim.salomons@home.nl
Terrestrial Ecosystems 121
If the flux of cadmium by the annual leaf fall is taken as being representative
of the total cadmium in the le<\,ves, then almost 20 times as much cadmium present
in the leaves at any time is leached from it to the forest floor during the summer
period. This indicates the high replenishment of cadmium (and also of manganese
and zinc) in the leaves.
The behaviour of lead is different from the other metals studied. For lead the
annual flux to the canopy exceeds the flux to the forest floor by a factor of 1.3. This
balance study, as well as leaf washing experiments, suggest canopy assimilation for
some of the deposited lead (Lindberg and Harriss, 1981). In the SoIling forest
(Heinrichs and Mayer, 1980), an assimilation oflead, copper and cadmium was ob-
served.
Part of the total flux to the forest floor will accumulate in the soil. However
part will be removed by leaching processes.
A compartment model and balances were constructed for two experimental
forest systems in Western Germany (Mayer, 1981). Part of the results of the balance
study are presented in Table 29.
The input given in Table 29 is the total deposition from the atmosphere on the
ecosystem. The throughfall is the input of trace metals to the forest floor. The ac-
cumulation in the soil is the balance of inputs through the through fall, litter fall,
and losses through uptake by roots and to the groundwater. The total balance is
the atmospheric input minus the losses to the groundwater. It differs from the ac-
cumulation in the soil, since this term also incorporates the storage in growing
plants. The balance (input> output) is positive for Cr, Fe, Ni, Cu and Pb, negative
for Mn and Co, and fairly balanced for Zn and Cd. The considerable seepage losses
of Mn, Co, Zn and Cd are caused by anthropogenic factors (e.g. the acid precip-
itation). Mayer (1981) showed that within forest ecosystems the micro-organisms
and vegetation with its root system are endangered by the heavy metal accumula-
tion at the soil surface; the accumulation has reached levels where deleterious ef-
fects are to be expected. Mobilization of the accumulated metals may follow any
kind of ecosystem manipulation like clearcut, fertilization, deposition of waste
products, spreading of deicing salts into roadside forests etc.
The significance of long-range atmospheric transport to the supply of trace
metals to terrestrial ecosystems may be illustrated by some recent data from Nor-
way (Steinnes, pers. comm.).
In a national study of trace element deposition using moss analysis (Rambaek
and Steinnes, 1980), it was found that areas in the southernmost part of the country
receive about ten times as much lead, arsenic and antimony as most areas north
of the 62° N. A similar trend but somewhat less pronounced was evident for zinc,
cadmium, silver, vanadium and selenium. In a simultaneous study (Hanssen et aI.,
1981) these elements were shown to be strongly intercorrelated in aerosols collected
at Birkenes, Southern Norway. A sector analysis confirmed that the highest air
concentrations of these elements in Southern Norway occur with trajectories from
..
Fig. 68. Processes affecting the annual flux of cadmium, zinc and manganese to the forest floor in the
Walker Branch Watershed. Based on data from Lindberg and Harriss (1981). Values represent the frac-
tion of the total annual flux to the floor that a given process contributes
wim.salomons@home.nl
Table 29. Metal balance for two experimental forest systems in Western Europe (Mayer 1981). A = Beech forest and B = Spruce forest. All data in g/ha/y N
N
Mn Ni Cu Zn Cd Pb
A B A B A B A B A B A B
Input 1750 5150 123 140 470 659 1632 1732 16 20.1 437 733
Throughfall 3840 5190 33 39 162 227 2169 2121 12.6 20.1 302 467
Accumulation in 2900 1300 88 78 310 300 110 246 1.4 3.2 49 76
lea yes and roots
Soil accumulation -6790 -8230 14 -4 54 249 397 -878 -2 -9.3 413 720
Seepage 5900 11100 21 66 106 110 1125 2364 16.5 26.2 24 13
Balance -4150 -5950 102 74 364 549 507 -632 -0.5 -6.1 413 720
wim.salomons@home.nl
s:::
(1)
E
'"
S·
g-
>
~
~
if
(l
Terrestrial Ecosystems 123
the south and south-west, clearly indicating a major contribution from areas in
Central and Western Europe.
In another national survey the geographic distribution of lead in natural sur-
face soils, shown in Fig. 69, was found to be very similar to that of the airborne
deposition oflead (Allen and Steinnes, 1979).
Other volatile trace elements such as cadmium, arsenic, and antimony, were al-
so found to be strongly enriched in surface soils in the southernmost part of Nor-
way as compared to more northerly areas of the country, whereas less volatile ele-
ments such as copper and nickel did not exhibit this kind of trend. Most probably
this enrichment of the volatile-group elements is due to deposition of metals from
long-distance atmospheric transport and subsequent strong fixation in the organic
fraction of the soils, which is in most cases above 50%. This conclusion is support-
ed by similar findings from a study of trace element profiles in ombrotrophic bogs
from different parts of Norway (Hvatum et aI., 1983).
Not only are the soils affected by the regional differences in trace element de-
position, but also organisms living in the areas concerned. The content of lead and
cadmium in forest trees and heather is about 3-5 times higher in southernmost
wim.salomons@home.nl
124 Metals in the Atmosphere
The arctic and antarctic areas are influenced mainly by the atmospheric deposition
of trace metals and from (small) local sources. One of the differences between the
arctic and antarctic is that the latter is situated far away from major land masses
in the southern hemisphere which is less subject to pollution than the northern
hemisphere. Metal concentrations in dated ice cores taken from the North and
South Pole areas may provide, when sufficient precautions during sampling and
analysis are made (Ng and Patterson, 1981), a valuable record of the historical
changes in metal concentrations in the atmosphere. It has been proved that Pb/Si
ratios increased by about 300-fold in Greenland snows during the last 3000 years
(Murozumi et ai., 1969; Ng and Patterson, 1981). Present day concentrations oflead
in antarctic snows are only several times higher than prehistoric levels as a conse-
quence of inputs of industrial lead emissions. This is because the fraction of the
total world emission of industrial lead is small in the southern hemisphere and the
barrier to the transport of these lead aerosols to south polar regions presented by
the antarctic circumpolar atmospheric convergence is strong (Patterson, 1982, pri-
vate communication). No reliable data appear to be available to show whether
other trace metals like cadmium and zinc have also increased in polar snows (Bout-
ron 1980).
A second indication of pollution of the arctic atmosphere is the occurrence of
the arctic haze, a reduced visibility in northern regions due to the scattering oflight
wim.salomons@home.nl
The Arctic and Antarctic Aerosol 125
by atmospheric particles. Reports on it were first filed by airline pilots and it was
first reported in the scientific literature by Mitchell (1956). It has now been posi-
tively identified as being part of a global air pollution phenomenon.
Table 30. Metal concentrations (picogram per cubic meter) in arctic and
antarctic aerosol. Arctic data from the station Thule for the period 1 september
1978-15 january 1979 (Heidam, 1981). Data from the Antarctic for
1974--1975 (astral summer) (Meanhaut et aI., 1979)
Arctic Antarctic
(Greenland) (Geographic South Pole)
wim.salomons@home.nl
126 Metals in the Atmosphere
to show that the variations in concentrations were related to reports of major ant-
arctic volcanic eruptions (Boutron, 1980).
1000
Winter / Summer
New York City
/0 . . . 0 1972 -74
1'1
Ie
100
-3 0..,.,0- 0
'-0 °0 -0 _ _0 ,
,o~
/'0....... Northeast U.S.
0
11\
c:
,; ° 1974 - 77
~o '-0--0--
. 10 ';0 0 ........ 0 0 0 0
i 0/ '\ Spitsbergen
.
III
::I
II °/ O~OI
1973-74
c:
0 1.0
c: '::o1!-/' /-\
III
/.--...... \ 1976-77
•• "0.
•
III
-50 _
/
II
Ie
-
III 0.1 -5
0.01
/-/ ~ Fig. 70. Monthly mean concentration of
excess vanadium in arctic and non-arc-
A S 0 N D J F M A M J J tic sites (Rahn and McCaffrey, 1980)
wim.salomons@home.nl
The Arctic and Antarctic Aerosol 127
summer periods more material is removed by rain and the flux of pollutants to the
arctic is greatly reduced. Thus an aerosol travelling to the arctic via the North At-
lantic will be removed by an order-of-magnitude greater efficiency than will the
same aerosol travelling the same distance over Eurasia. A similar rapid removal
can be expected for an Eastern Asian aerosol traversing the North Pacific (Rahn
1981 ).
Another characteristic of the arctic aerosol is its highly aged character (travel
time to the arctic is around 10-20 days). The aged character can be derived from
the particle size distribution which favours the occurrence of submicron particles,
that have a low scavenging efficiency. The high concentrations of sulfate are also
an indication of the aged character, since the sulfate is derived from the oxidation
of S02 during transport (Rahn and McCaffrey (1980). The high concentrations of
21O-Pb during winter (in view of the lower production of its precursor 222-Rn pre-
cursor) can also be explained by the unusually long residence time of the arctic
aerosol, so that 21O-Pb produced in the arctic accumulates with little loss due to
precipitation (Rahn and McCaffrey, 1980). Vanadium and sulphate are not the on-
ly elements to show this seasonal change in concentrations but trace metals like
copper and zinc show similar trends (Barrie et al. 1981).
An interesting characteristic of the arctic aerosol is the high concentration of
soot (Rosen et aI., 1981), which causes the blackness of air sampling filters in the
winter period. The soot also shows the seasonal changes in concentrations
(Fig. 71).
Most of the carbon in the arctic aerosol consists of graphite carbon. Raman
spectroscopy showed that the graphite structures are similar to carbon black and
are derived from combustion processes. In fact the concentrations are in the same
order of magnitude as observed for major cities such as New York and Los
Angeles.
The presence of graphite carbon has important implications for the light scat-
tering properties of the arctic aerosol. Depending on the amount and vertical dis-
tribution assumed for the soot, the rates of heating of the local atmosphere have
been estimated to lie between 0.2 and 1 °C' d - 1 during spring (Rahn and Shaw,
1980). Future development of mining, petroleum extraction, refining and manu-
facturing is expected to double every 15-20 years, and in another 50 years arctic
40
.. ° ° - Biweekly averages
/0/
Barrow 1979 - 1980
c
•..
II
• 30
/°
D.
c
° r~New
°..
York
/°
Fig. 71. Seasonal varIatIOns of
0,°/"0
-'II
graphite carbon as a percentage of "
Co) 20
°
the total carbon content of the
aerosol particles at Barrow,
Alaska. The values are compared
~
:E
.."
D.
°
/ +-- Los Angeles
wim.salomons@home.nl
128 Metals in the Atmosphere
haze may be serious enough to cause significant heating of the atmosphere of the
northern polar regions (Shaw, 1981).
90 ·
wim.salomons@home.nl
The Arctic and Antarctic Aerosol 129
- However, the most direct and powerful evidence has been obtained by using the
Mn/V ratio of the aerosol (Rahn, 1981). Vanadium is the best indicator elements
since it is derived from only one significant source: combustion of residual oil
(Zoller et aI., 1973), whereas Mn has a variety of sources (Evendijk, 1974).
The elementl Al ratio has also been used to differentiate between various sour-
ces. However in the case of the arctic aerosol it is not possible to use the VIAl or
the Mnl Al ratio since the ratios between the various sources do not differ to a great
extent. More important, however, is the fact that aluminium is a crustal element
and does not occur in the same size fractions as vanadium. During transport, dif-
ferential settling processes will occur, resulting in a loss of aluminium and a change
in ratio VIAl as a function of the ageing of the aerosol. Aerosols are best traced
using two elements with the same mass-size function, so that their ratio will remain
nearly the same during transport (Rahn, 1981). For tracking pollutants an ideal
pair would be Pb and V since they are almost entirely derived from pollution and
are mostly found in submicron urban aerosols. However, data on lead are lacking
(Rahn, 1981). Therefore the ratio of noncrustal manganese to noncrustal vanadium
is used to trace pollutant sources. The noncrustal concentrations can be calculated
from the total concentrations using the formula (Rahn, 1981):
1000r-----~-.------r-._----~--r_----~~
/
/
/
/
/
,/0 /
/
100
~:)./
C'I
I
E
g!
c EURASIA
C
... 1./
...
•
..
:E 10 /, /
ia NORTH • /' •
.
III
::I
U
AMERICAN
ARCTIC .~
• .:.
/.
SHETLAND IS
NE USA
.
C
o \
Z "V'\. / ~ NORTHERN NORWAY
10 • / ~ /
~ /-)
Fig. 73. Scatter diagram of at- </~~ NORWEGIAN ARCTIC
/
mospheric concentrations of /
/
wim.salomons@home.nl
130 Metals in the Atmosphere
: 2 o 40
i ;:
.>-
~ fI
a:
..
~
:ii.
1
til
:
:I
20 Zn
V
c Cu
o v
3.-----~,--------------,
I
q~:n
o o 20
;:
~ 2 fI
a: a:
til til
til
: 10
~
v/v ~r
1 :I ~
V
IV
O~--~~~~~--~~-r~
ONDJFMAM o N D J F M A M
1979 1980 1979 1980
Fig. 74. Mass ratios of various elements and of blackness (soot) to excess (non-soil) vanadium in sus-
pended particulate matter collected at Mould Bay. Redrawn after Barrie et al (1981)
wim.salomons@home.nl
Metals in the Oceanic Aerosol: Continental or Ocean Derived? 131
The first period is characterised by high Mn/V ratios and high concentrations
of soot. Both characteristics point to a coal-burning industrialised area (Siberia).
The high Mn/V ratio cannot be explained by North American sources. Trajectory
analysis confirmed these conclusions (Barrie et aI., 1981). In January the Mn/V
ratio dropped to low values of 0.6. During this period no trajectories linking the
arctic with European sources were observed. Both the trajectory analysis and the
Mn/V ratio suggest a North American source. The increase in the Mn/V ratio from
0.6 to 2 in the week of 10-17 February could be attributed to Siberian sources and
the subsequent decrease during March and April to mainly European with possibly
some Siberian sources. Barrie et al (1981) concluded that the arctic atmosphere can
be described with the "bathtub" model. The arctic atmosphere is a horizontally
mixed reservoir into which air from mid-latitudes is periodically injected. Due to
the annual variation in scavenging processes, the flux of particles into the reservoir
and their residence time while in it are lower in summer than in winter. They
gradually increase in fall and decrease in spring. Consequently the reservoir be-
comes progressively dirtier throughout the winter. The air parcel trajectory anal-
ysis led to the conclusion that elemental ratios of soot, Pb, Zn,Cu,Ni and Mn to
non-soil vanadium in arctic aerosols are highest, intermediate and lowest for Si-
berian, European and North American sources, respectively.
wim.salomons@home.nl
132 Metals in the Atmosphere
•
50 .. m DIAMETER
•
FILM CAP
•
•
• • •
•
• •
• •
•
• FILM DROPS
• 15-20 PRODUCED
SUBMICRON TO
• 10 .. m DIAMETER
500 .. m DIAMETER
";.
RISE VELOCITY
3.5 em / sec.
Fig. 75. Processes involved in the breaking of an air bubble at the water surface and the formation of
an aerosol (Winchester and Duce, 1977)
ducing very small film drops. With the breaking of the bubble, a high speed jet of
water is produced which moves upward from the bottom of the bubble cavity. This
jet rises rapidly, becomes unstable and produces between 2 and 5 drops (jet drops)
whose size is about 10-20% of the size of the original bubble (Wu, 1981). The pro-
cesses involved in the breaking of the bubble at the water surface and the formation
of an aerosol are schematically shown in Fig. 75.
Cipriano and Blanchard (1981) have shown that most of the smaller sea salt
particles are film drops and these are derived from large bubbles (1 mm and larger),
which may produce as many as 100 or more film drops per bubble. Film drop pro-
duction reaches a maximum for bubbles with roughly 2 mm diameter; bubbles
smaller than 1 mm or larger than 5 mm are relatively inefficient. The production
of jet drops falls off rapidly as the bubble diameter exceeds 1 mm. The total flux
of salt to the air in the model experiments of Cipriano and Blanchard (1981) was
dominated by the jet drops, suggesting that most of the oceanic salt mass flux de-
rived from it. It should be noted, however, that although the total mass transported
into the atmosphere is dominated by jet drops, the film drops will have the largest
residence time. Important with respect to the composition of the oceanic aerosol
is the fact that the film cap skims off a portion of the surface layer of the water,
and in the formation of the jet drops the surface layer of the water is also skimmed
off (interior of the bubble cavity). Macintyre (1970) estimated that the top jet drop
is composed of material from the interior of the bubble surface to a depth of 0.05 %
of the bubble diameter. Therefore, the composition of the sea surface micro layer
determines to a large extent the composition of the marine component of the
oceanic aerosol.
wim.salomons@home.nl
Metals in the Oceanic Aerosol: Continental or Ocean Derived? 133
The sea surface microlayer may be operationally defined to extend from 3 A (the
diameter of a water molecule) to about 3 mm, which is near the extreme limit of
non-turbulent kinetics with no wind and also the penetration depth of jets from
small bubbles (MacIntyre, 1974).
Various ingenious methods have been designed to sample the surface
micro layer, which remove the layer varying in depth from 1 mm to 300 A (Lion
and Leckie, 1981a). This variation in sampling depth makes it difficult to compare
reported concentrations and enrichments of metals with the concentrations in the
bulk seawater. However, a recent survey showed that despite the large differences
in sampling methods, in most cases the concentrations of trace metals and organic
matter in the surface micro layer are enriched in comparison with the bulk seawater
(Lion and Leckie, 1981 b).
The absolute amount of trace metals in the surface layer may be quite high, and
in marsh areas high enough to necessitate taking it into account for flux calcu-
lations (Pellenbarg and Church, 1979).
The surface microlayer in oceans receives material from the water column by
rising bubbles (flotation) and from the atmosphere. The flotation process is similar
to the one used for the recovery of ore minerals in the mining industry. Organic
matter and particulate matter become attached at the water-air interface of the
bubble and are transported in this way to the surface.
In laboratory studies, Wallace and Duce (1975) showed that over 50 percent
of the particulate AI, Mn, Fe, V, Cu, Zn, Ni, Pb, Cr and Cd present in Narrangan-
sett Bay water could be scavenged by bubbles and transported to the surface
microlayer. These results were similar to those obtained for the Sargasso Sea (Wal-
lace and Duce, 1978). The upward bubble flux of trace metals was in the same order
of magnitude as the flux of atmospheric trace metals to the water surface.
In the experiments, large particles were formed, which could not be broken up
by vigorous shaking. This shows that bubbles in the sea may concentrate particu-
late trace metals, increase the size of particulate matter and hence the flux. The
downward flux from the sea surface layer was in remarkable agreement with the
independently estimated flux of particulate trace metals to deep waters associated
with sinking organic matter (Wallace etal., 1977). Bacon and Elzerman (1980) com-
pared 210-Po/21O-Pb ratios in bulk seawater, the surface layer and in atmospheric
fallout. The atmospheric ratio was much lower than the ratio in bulk seawater,
whereas the ratio in the surface layer showed only small deviations from that in
bulk seawater. This comparison suggests that the ocean is an important source of
trace elements in the ocean surface micro-layer.
Hunter (1980) made a detailed study of various processes affecting metal con-
centrations in the surface micro layer by considering atmospheric deposition,
Brownian diffusion, gravitational settling, bubble flotation and mixing. A sche-
matic presentation of these processes is shown in Fig. 76.
Both iron and manganese were strongly depleted in the surface micro-layer of
the North Sea on all occasions studied by Hunter (1980). The phase bearing these
two trace metals and probably also part of the other particulate trace metals (PTM)
consists of river-derived terrigenous material present on large particles. These par-
wim.salomons@home.nl
134 Metals in the Atmosphere
atmospheric
• deposition
CI a 7-\:
• •• U interfaclcal
Brownian diffusion •••• sedimentation boundary ~ 50 11m
---}------------;~~:-~----~-------~-~~!!~---------
o
~ ~0
~
i
r
mixing processes ". 0
eddy
I }
0°
0 bubble
It diffusion" 0 0 flotation
'......... °0
o
__________~~!!!.!I_~~!~~a.!.!!.!'~~~e_______ ~~~_~~_________ _
Fig. 76. Schematic presentation of the processes affecting trace metals in the surface microlayer (Hunter
1980)
ticles are transported to the micro layer by mixing processes but settle relatively
rapidly. The fact that other trace metals are enriched (Ni, Cu, Zn, Pb and Cd)
shows that for these trace metals the gravitational settling process is minor com-
pared with the other processes controlling these element concentrations in the sur-
face microlayer. By comparing residence times for both flotation and atmospheric
deposition necessary to cause a two-fold enrichment (times varying between 1 min
to 28 minutes for the enriched elements by flotation and 24 to 1500 minutes for the
atmospheric deposition) it was shown that bubble flotation was the major process
for the enrichment of particulate trace metals in the surface layer. Foggy con-
ditions, accelerating the scavenging of suspended particles in the atmosphere en-
hanced the atmospheric flux. After the fog had cleared, the metal concentrations
in the surface microlayer declined (Hunter, 1980).
Metals in aerosols are partly soluble (Fig. 67). Solubility of metals in aerosols
in seawater studies by Crecelius (1980) and by Hodge et al. (1978) indicate, that
the deposition of aerosol particles contributes both to the particulate and dissolved
metals in ocean surface waters.
Model calculations on the speciation of trace metals in the sea surface
microlayer have been carried out by Lion and Leckie (1981). In the bulk seawater,
both Cd and Hg are strongly complexed with chloride. Copper and lead compete
more effectively for dissolved complexing agents. If transport to the surface layer
takes place by dissolved organics, then the transport of copper and lead is favoured
over cadmium and mercury. These results support the fact that in surface layers
the enrichment by copper and lead has been more consistently observed than en-
richment of cadmium and mercury (Lion and Leckie, 1981).
wim.salomons@home.nl
Metals in the Oceanic Aerosol: Continental or Ocean Derived? 135
Element Ocean
additionally the bubbles scavenge the water column during their rise to the surface.
Piotrowicz et al. (1979) and Weisel (1981) observed a strong dependence between
the EF (sea) (the enrichment factor in the aerosol with respect to the composition
of the bulk seawater) and the depth at which bubbles were generated in an ex-
perimental set-up in the field for the metals Zn, Cd and Pb. Copper gave a positive
intercept in the graph depicting the relation of EF (sea) value to the bubble gener-
ating depth, which was attributed to microlayer enrichment of this trace metal
(Piotrowicz et al. 1979). Very high EF (sea) values for copper were found in areas
with visible slicks. It was concluded that the enrichment of copper on sea salt
aerosols may be related to biological and/or organic processes and that Cu and Zn
may be scavenged by rising bubbles (Piotrowicz et aI., 1979). The data from Weisel
(1981) on lead also suggest that rising bubbles play an important role in its enrich-
ment in the aerosol.
Therefore it appears that the marine component of the aerosol depends not on-
lyon the composition of the surface layer, but also on the bubble generation depth.
If the EF (sea) value for trace elements is known, the contribution of the sea
salt spray to the marine aerosol can be easily calculated from data on the amount
of sea spray produced annually. Since data are not available on the total number
of bubbles generated and the depth of submergence, Weisel (1981) made calcu-
lations for minimum EF (sea) values of metals by using the data obtained from ex-
periments conducted just below the sea surfaces and for maximum EF (sea) values
from experiments conducted at a depth of two meters. This depth was chosen be-
cause studies by Blanchard and Hoffmann (1978) suggested that at 2 meters the
bubble surface appears to be saturated and ceases to scavenge additional material.
The results of calculations by Weisel (1981) are shown in Table 31. Estimates
of natural and other fluxes are given in Chap. 4.1, Table 17.
The results show that upwards of 10% of the total global atmospheric con-
centrations of cadmium may come from the oceans; for vanadium there also may
be a significant marine input.
It should be noted, however, that anthropogenic sources are localized and that
their influence may be less for pristine marine environments than global data sug-
gest. Interesting results have been obtained on the relative strength of the various
sources contributing to the aerosol at Eniwetok in the North Pacific. The compo-
sition of the atmospheric aerosol at Eniwetok shows strong seasonal changes
wim.salomons@home.nl
136 Metals in the Atmosphere
100r---------------------,
.....
Fig.77. Atmospheric concentrations of sea salt
and dust at Eniwetok (Merrill and Duce, 1982)
g! Salt • • • • •
... 10
!! E
'E• .!
.a
II
C
g:.
II
;:
"II
II.
II
1.0 .. Dust
• E
.cII. .."
~ f 0.1
E Is
cE
0.01 '--__-'--_-'-__--'-_----L._--'
April 1 May 1 June 1 July 1 Aug 1 Sep 1
Sample Collection Date, 1979
(Fig. 77). The concentration of salt with a MMD of 3-4 !lm was nearly constant,
whereas the dust concentration showed strong variations.
The MMD of the dust particles ranged from 0.7 to 1 !lm, which is consistent
with a very long atmospheric transport path (Merrill and Duce, 1982). The alter-
ations could be explained by seasonal changes in large scale wind patterns over the
North Pacific and the seasonal character of dust storms in desert regions of China
(Duce et ai., 1980). The dust storm activity is apparently greatest in the spring in
China due to the combined effects of low rainfall, the increased occurrence of high
surface winds and wind erosion of soil freshly ploughed for planting (Merrill and
Duce, 1982).
Some trace metals (e.g. AI, Sc, Mn, Fe, Eu, Ni, Co, V, Hf, Cr, Th, Cu, and Rb)
were also found to be associated with the dust storms. Their EF (crust) values
varied between 1 and 3; Zn, Cs, Sb, Ag, Pb, Cd and Se had EF (crust) values higher
than 4, and apparently had some source other than continental weathering. The
MMD data, the EF (crust) data and the mean atmospheric concentrations at En-
iwetok are shown in Table 32.
The elements associated with crustal material showed seasonal cycles that re-
flected the input of dust from mainland China. However, the enriched elements did
not show these strong seasonal variations. These elements apparently have con-
tinental sources which are not as seasonal in nature, but are more evenly dis-
tributed throughout the year (Merrill and Duce, 1982) The MMD of the enriched
elements is <0.5 !lm, which is consistent with a possible pollution source. If they
were associated with sea spray, the MMD would be higher.
The sources for lead were unravelled by Settle and Patterson (1982) by using
isotope lead ratios. The 206-Pb/207-Pb ratios in the surface waters (0.184) differed
from that in the dry deposition (1.226) and showed that most of the dry deposition
originated from lead-rich particles which are transported from land. Experiments
with a bubble generating device confirmed this conclusion: both methods indicated
that only 1-15% oflead in air at Eniwetok originates from sea water lead in sea-
spray.
The deposition velocity of the lead indicated that it must be associated with
large diameter (7 !lm) particles. However, the MMD diameter of lead in the atmo-
wim.salomons@home.nl
Metals in the Oceanic Aerosol: Continental or Ocean Derived? 137
Table 32. Selected data for trace elements in the atmosphere at Eniwetok (Merrill and Duce, 1982)
Al 0.8 75 3
Fe 0.72 1 50 2
Mn 0.88 0.9 1 0.04
pg/m 3 pg/m 3
Sc 0.70 0.8 20 1
Cr 1.8 200 30
Co 0.75 1.0 25 1
Cs 0.79 4.8 15 0.5
Rb 1.1 3.0 200 40
Th 0.84 2.0 20 1
V 0.76 1.6 120 20
Zn 0.04 4.6 250 80
Cd 57 10 2
Cu 0.96 2.3 50 10
Pb 0.25 45 150 100
sphere was only 0.25 Jlm (Table 32). The small lead-rich sub-micron particles are
transferred to large sea salt particles during cloud forming condensation processes
(Settle et al. 1981). These processes make aerosols injected into the atmosphere by
bursting bubbles as efficient as plant foliage on land in sequestering small anthro-
pogenic lead-rich particles and makes the dry deposition flux of lead to the oceans
important (Settle and Patterson, 1982).
The 206-Pb/207-Pb ratio also showed seasonal changes. During the dry season,
when the silicate dust concentrations were highest, the ratio was similar to the ratio
in lead aerosols emitted from Asia and Japan. During periods oflow dust concen-
trations, the ratio of206-Pb/207-Pb was more like the ratio in lead aerosols emitted
from the United States.
In a comparison of experimental data with the atmospheric concentrations at
remote regions like Eniwetok, Weisel (1981) concluded that up to 10% of the lead
is from a marine source, for cadmium and vanadium this contribution is in excess
of 30% and zinc 10 to 20%. The marine component at Eniwetok is found mostly
on large particles.
Weisel (1981) estimated that for the oceans as a whole the oceanic contribution
is 10% for cadmium, 3% for zinc and 1% forlead present in the oceanic aerosol.
wim.salomons@home.nl
5 Metals in Continental Water
5.1 Introduction
Although the volume of continental waters is insignificant with respect to the mass
of the hydrosphere, these waters have their particular importance as the basis of
our freshwater supply as well as geochemically, since they are responsible for most
of the weathering and erosion of the land masses. In the latter sense terrestrial
waters are the major medium involved in the "exogenic cycle", i.e. processes on the
earth's surface and uppermost lithological units, in which solid and dissolved
weathering products are transported, deposited and solidified, and - after diagen-
esis and tectonic uplift - may be exposed to weathering and erosion again. While
most of these processes of deposition and rock formation take place in the marine
milieu, there are characteristic geochemical interactions in the soils and, particular-
ly interesting, in the lacustrine environment.
The input of material into the ocean is mainly affected by river discharges.
Table 33, where the different modes of transport are distinguished according to an
estimation made by Judson (1968), clearly demonstrates, that - in particular for
the river transport rates - there is an enormous effect of human activity on
weathering and erosion processes as a result of ploughing agricultural soils, defor-
estation, and all types of engineering on the earth's surface. On the global average
the concentration of dissolved constituents is 114 mg/l (Gibbs, 1972), while the
contents of solid are approx. 330 mg/l (Judson, 1968); of the latter more than 90%
are transported in suspension.
It should be noted, however, that there are very significant regional differences
with respect to transport and erosion efficiency in rivers. Table 34 (after Judson,
1968) shows rather similar distribution patterns for dissolved and solid mass trans-
port as well as for erosion rates in the examples from Amazon and Mississippi
River catchments, whereas the low and high denudation rates in the Congo River
basin on the one hand, and in the Colorado River basin on the other hand are
mainly affected by the strongly different modes of particle erosion and transpor-
tation.
These differences become even more spectacular when the seasonal influences
are considered. Table 35 (from Garrels and MacKenzie, 1971) compares the material
transport in selected tributaries to Amazon River (data from Gibbs, 1967): while
the material concentrations in the mountainous rivers are higher by a factor of ap-
prox. 12 to 14 compared to the tropical rivers during the dry season both for the
dissolved and suspended load, and this ratio is only insignificantly changed in the
dissolved concentration at stronger rainfall, there is a very strong increase in the
wim.salomons@home.nl
Introduction 139
Table 33. Annual discharge of material into the oceans (Judson. 1968)
(10 6 tonnes/year)
Transport in Erosion in
tonnes/Ian 2 / year cm/l,OOO years
Dissolved Solid
Amazon 37 87 4.7
Congo 40 14 2.0
Colorado 23 417 17
Mississippi 39 94 5
Table 35. Material transport in Amazon River tributaries. (Garrels and MacKenzie, 1971; after Gibbs,
1967). Data in mgjl
solid matter concentrations of the mountainous rivers during the wet season. This
influencing factor is significantly affecting the overall balance of material transport
in the lower Amazon River system and also the material discharges into the ocean.
The much higher variability of the solid matter transport, which is reflected by
an exponential increase with water discharge or flow velocities (Muller and Forstner,
1968), generally effects significantly larger differences in the mechanical denuda-
tion than in the chemical erosion rates for a particular catchment area (Garrels and
MacKenzie, 1971). With respect to the transport of metals in continental waters
it has been noted by Yeats and Bewers (1982) from a study of the St. Lawrence
River that the variability in the concentrations of dissolved metals is unrelated to
changes in water flow and therefore the dissolved fraction of metals exhibits a cer-
tain degree oflong-term stability, whereas particulate AI, Fe, Mn, and Zn concen-
trations characteristically depend from water discharge. This could make the cal-
culations of the flux rates particularly difficult for those elements, which exhibit
a strong tendency for solid associations (Martin and Meybeck, 1979).
wim.salomons@home.nl
140 Metals in Continental Waters
Table 36. Global metal fluxes in dissolved and particulate matter. (After Yeats and Bewers, 1982),
and solid/solution ratios. Fluxes in 106 kg/year
Fe Al Co Mn Ni Cu Zn Cd
Dissolved
St. Lawrence" 2,200 3,000 7 250 57 88 330 4
Amazon/Yukon b 1,400 3 630 11 61
Mississippi" 160 320 51 63 320 3
Particulate
St. Lawrence" 990,000 1,400,000 280 26,000 780 1,700 6,700 30
Amazon/y ukon b 1,100,000 - 750 21,000 2,200 6,300
Mississippi" 860,000 24,000 1,000 770 3,300 26
Avg. 22 rivers d 730,000 1,500,000 320 17,000 1,500 1,600 5,400
Ratio particulate/dissolved fluxes 510 480 100 55 35 35 15 8
However, the data in Table 36 (after Yeats and Bewers, 1982), which represent
the best contemporary estimates of global river-borne metal discharges (the data
of the individual rivers are scaled for the ratio to the global discharges) show a re-
markable degree of similarity. Despite the fact that the rivers vary from tropical
to subarctic, from natural to highly industrialized, and from suspended loads of
10 mg/l to 580 mg/l, the calculated metal discharges seldom vary by more than a
factor of three (Yeats and Bewers, 1982).
In the last line of Table 36 the ratios of average particulate and dissolved fluxes
of the individual metals are arranged in decreasing order; this sequence reflects an
increase in the relative mobility of the metals with Al and Fe being the least reactive
examples, Co, Mn, Ni, and Cu at intermediate mobilities, and Zn and Cd exhibit-
ing a relatively high percentage of the total flux in dissolved state. It should be
noted that some of these ratios - which resemble the "sink-effect-values" in the
"ecological risk index" of Hakanson (1980) - can be significantly different in rivers
affected by higher inputs of anthropogenic waste materials (see Chaps. 5.3.1.).
Metals released through weathering processes and their transport to rivers and the
oceans are one of the major fluxes in the hydrological cycle. The mass transport
rates of metals in these processes, however, depend significantly on their occur-
rence in igneous, metamorphic and sedimentary rocks (in a more regional view on
the distribution of these basic rock types in the particular watershed) and on the
intensity of the weathering processes and the mode of transport. During transport
anthropogenic additions can be made to the metals released by natural weathering
wim.salomons@home.nl
Igneous and Metamorphic Rocks 141
processes and the natural weathering intensity can be greatly enhanced by anthro-
pogenic effects such as acid precipitation, land use or deforestation.
The evolution of igneous rocks from molten magma - in a sequence from ultra-
mafic rocks to the series of gabbro-diorite-granodiorite-granite (the latter called
"felsic" rocks) - involves the continuous and discontinuous reaction of common
minerals as crystallization proceeds ("reaction principle", Bowen, 1928) (Fig. 78).
Rarer minerals which crystallize in this sequence include apatite, fluorite, mon-
azite, titanite, xenotim and zircon (Bowen, 1979). Later the elements which have
not been trapped in major or accessory minerals crystallize out separately, in small
amounts, forming pegmatites; these elements - e.g. Be, Cs, Li, Sn, U, W, Zr - have
unusual ionic radii which lead to their natural segregation. With respect to crystal-
lochemical factors, such as ionic radius, valence and electron configuration typical
elementary associations are found in igneous rocks (Krauskopf, 1979):
(i) Cations with large radii and low electric charges tend to substitute for potas-
sium, hence are concentrated in felsic rather than mafic rocks; these elements (Rb,
Cs, Ba, Tl) are often called the "large-ion lithophile" group (LIL);
(ii) several cations with smaller radii and mostly with higher charges (U, Th,
B, Be, Mo, W, Nb, Ta, Sn, Zr) also are concentrated at the felsic end of the series,
not because of extensive substitution but rather because their size and charge make
it difficult for them to substitute for any major ions in common silicate structures
("incompatible" elements);
(iii) many elements with intermediate radii, especially metals of the transition
groups, substitute readily for iron and magnesium, hence they are abundant in the
earlier members of the differentiation sequence; some (Cr, Ni, Co) are enriched
with Mg in ultramafic rocks, others (Mn, V, Ti) have maximum abundance in gab-
bros and basalts;
(iv) part of the metals, which substitute to some extent for major cations in sili-
cate structures, are left to accumulate in the residual solutions that may eventually
form sulfide ores ("chaicophile" elements);
(v) some minor elements indicate properties similar to major elements, e.g.
gallium/aluminium, cadmium/zinc, hafnium/zirconium, and are found in their
structures without significant differentiation.
Decreasing temperature---_
olivine _pyroxene_hornblende _ b i o t i t e \
quartz
7eldSpar)
Fig.78. The sequence of min-
erals formed during the crys-
tallization of a mafic magma Ca· plagioclase Na.plagioclase
(Bowen. 1928)
wim.salomons@home.nl
142 Metals in Continental Waters
wim.salomons@home.nl
Igneous and Metamorphic Rocks 143
Table 37. Distribution of selected elements in rock-forming minerals (date from Wedepohl, 1972, 1974)
% in earth's crust Cu Zn Pb
Table 38. Common mineral formed in magmatic crystallization (major constituents in capital letters)
and their co-crystallized elements (Bowen, 1979). With permission of Academic Press, London
wim.salomons@home.nl
In order to assess the influence of different magmatic rocks on the composition
of aquatic sediments, the relative percentage of individual rock types must be taken
into consideration. These calculations are still relatively controversial. Taylor
(1964) suggested that the crust consists of half basalt and half granite; Wedepohl
(1969) prefers a crust consisting of 44% granite, 34% granodiorite, 13% gabbro
and 8 % quartz diorite (see compilation of Bowen, 1979).
Weathering includes all physical, chemical and biologic actions which abrade or
dissolve rocks. The main agent of chemical weathering is water, especially when
it contains a small amount of dissolved carbon dioxide which makes it more acidic.
Sodium is readily leached from rocks, while calcium, magnesium and potassium
are dissolved somewhat more slowly; the other common rock constituents, alumin-
ium, iron and silicon are much less soluble (Bowen, 1979).
A general sequence of relative mobility of common elements during weathering
processes, corresponding to the ratio of the element in river water to that in rock,
was established in 1937 by Polynov (Table 39).
It is indicated that the sesqui-oxides of Al z0 3 and Fez03 are least mobile (ap-
prox. 10- 4 to chlorine) and silica moderately, whereas the basic cations of KzO,
MgO, NazO and CaO can be readily removed. This development is paralleled by
the migrational series during the weathering of silicious rocks in temperate cli-
mates, as established by Perel'man (1967).
The susceptibility of the minerals to chemical weathering generally shows a se-
quence which is reverse to the reaction series of Bowen (1928, see Fig. 78); least
stable minerals of the discontinuous series are olivine and pyroxene, of the contin-
uous series Ca-plagioclase (Goldich, 1938). The weathering stability for soil min-
erals has been found higher for most clay minerals - especially for aluminous
chlorites and kaolinites - than for quartz; on the other hand, calcite and, particu-
wim.salomons@home.nl
Weathering and Element Migration 145
Sesqui-oxides A1 z0 3 0.02
Fe303 0.04
Silica Si0 2 0.20
Basic cations K 20 1.25
MgO 1.30
NazO 1.40
CaO 3.00
Anions C0 3 57
CI 100
Table 40. Solubility products (S.P.) of the hydroxides and some compounds (Lelong et aI., 1976). With
permission of Elsevice Publ. Co.
• Arranged according to ionic potentials "</1" (ratio of the charge to the ionic radius)
wim.salomons@home.nl
146 Metals in Continental Waters
lady, gypsum are much less resistant than the least-resistant silicates (Jackson,
1968).
The element mobility depends, in the second place, on their solubility limits,
which are mainly a function of pH and, for elements such as Fe and Mn, of the
Eh (Lelong et aI., 1976). Solubility limits are mainly determined by the value of sol-
ubility products of the hydroxide compounds of the M(OH)n type, classified ac-
cording to their ionic potentials (IP; Table 40).
(Ions in solution attract water molecules, cations to the negative, anions to the
positive part of the polar molecule. Package density depends on size - as larger the
ion the more water molecules being attracted. The smaller the ionic radius and the
higher the charge of the central ion the more acid are its oxides. If the ionic poten-
tial, i.e. the positive charge on the surface of an ion is high enough, they repulse
part of the protons of the water molecules, thus giving neutral central ions, i.e. in-
soluble hydroxides. At higher repulse all protons are deprived from the water mole-
cules and an oxy-acid-anion formed, which is soluble).
In the presence of anions, such as bicarbonate, sulphate, hydrogen sulfide etc.
the values of Table 40 are no longer valid; the same pertains to the presence of com-
plexing agents, e.g. organic acids, where an increased mobility is noted for slightly
soluble or insoluble elements, such as metallic elements belonging to the Fe- or Al-
group (Pedro and Delmas, 1970; Lelong et aI., 1976; Saxby, 1976). The following
divisions of the elements have been proposed:
- elements forming soluble hydrated or simple cations in the full range of pH;
these are alkaline and alkaline-earth elements (ionic potential below 2);
- elements forming insoluble hydroxides in a certain range of pH; these are (with
increasing solubility product) Fe2+, Mn 2 +, Ni 2 +, Co2+, Pb 2 +, Zn2+, Cu2+,
Cr3+, AI3+, V3+, Fe3+, Ti 4 +, which have an ionic potential between 2 and 7;
most of them are only soluble at acid or very acid pH;
- elements forming simple or complex anions, which have IP above 7 and are more
or less soluble within a large range of pH, e.g. (N0 3)-, (S04)2 -, (P0 4)3-.
Of importance too, are the redox conditions that evoke a significant "migration
contrast" (Perel'man, 1967) for some elements; e.g., the migrational intensity for
uranium and zinc in oxidizing environments is "strong", but in strongly reducing
environments it is "weak" or "very weak". Copper, nickel and cobalt pass from
a moderate migrational intensity in an oxidizing milieu to near immobility in
strongly reducing environments.
A further mechanism for migration intensity during weathering is the "entrap-
ping of elements in secondary mineral products" (Lelong et aI., 1976). From a com-
prehensive data compilation by Tardy (1969) specific accumulation stages for
the various chemical elements in the major facies of weathering can be derived
(Table 41).
Chiefly the iron and manganese phases in crusts and their deposition on clay
minerals (mainly montmorillonite) are significant carrier substances for many
trace metals. Also of global importance in the are the amorphous weathering prod-
ucts in the selective entrapping of some elements: Si-Mg-gels from experimental
weathering of peridot contain high concentrations of Mn, Fe, Co, Ni, Zn and Cu
(Lelong et aI., 1976). The process of reverse weathering (Mackenzie and Garrels,
wim.salomons@home.nl
Weathering and Element Migration 147
Table 41. Partition of chemical elements between the main facies of weathering: oxi-hydroxides, clay
minerals, salt and alkaline silicates (Lelong et aI., 1976; after data from Tardy, 1969) with permission
of Elsevier Publ. Co.
Bauxite Iron crust Manganese crust Calcite crust Sulfates Sodium carbonates
AI-Ga-B Fe-Ti-V- Mn-Fe-Co- Ca-Sr-Ba- Ca-Sr-Ba Sodium chlorides
Cr-Mo Pb-Ba-Sn- Zn Na-Rb-Li
Ni-Cu
1966), in which marine clay minerals recrystallize from amorphic weathering prod-
ucts, is considered a decisive factor in the chemistry of major cations in ocean
waters.
It is important to note, however, that the bulk of the detrital trace elements
never leaves the solid phase from initial weathering to ultimate deposition. There-
fore, detrital minerals from magmatic, metamorphic and sediment source rocks
may significantly affect the metal composition of aquatic sediments. Placer de-
posits, which result from the residual accumulation of heavy, stable minerals dur-
ing weathering and from their absolute accumulation during formation of alluvial
fans by sedimentation are major sources of economic concentrations of metals
such as gold, platinum, zirconium, thorium, tin and tungsten (Hails, 1976). How-
ever, even in "normal" sediments the heavy mineral fraction can contribute signifi-
cantly to the enrichment of metals. Investigations performed by Loring (1978,
1979) on sediments of the St. Lawrence Estuary and open Gulf of St. Lawrence in-
dicate that 61-98% of total Zn, Cu, Pb, Cr, Ni and V concentrations are held de-
tritally in various sulfidic minerals (pyrite, chalcopyrite), oxide minerals (mag-
netite, ilmenite, chromite) and ferromagnesial silicates (amphiboles, chlorite,
pyroxene and garnet). Detrital host mineral concentrations are highest in the estu-
ary, decreasing seaward from the interior sources of terrigenous clastic material.
The products of weathering in the sequence given in Table 41 are equivalent to
the major groups of sedimentary constituents, as classified by Goldschmidt, 1954;
see also Degens, 1965; Bowen, 1979:
- Resistates, or unchanged minerals from primary rocks;
- Hydrolysates, mostly clay from weathering of aluminosilicates minerals;
- Oxidates, precipitates ofFe(OHh, e.g. as "coatings" on detrital grains;
- Carbonate precipitates, mostly calcite, e.g. as skeletons of marine plankton;
- Evaporates, mostly salt or gypsum from drying salt lakes.
In addition to this classification "Bioliths" or resistant organic matter, includ-
ing peat and petroleum, which are mainly deposited in anoxic regions where spe-
wim.salomons@home.nl
148 Metals in Continental Waters
cialized bacteria remove oxygen atoms from dead organic matter; typical elements
adsorbed are uranium in some peats, and Mo, Ni and V in some petroleum
(Bowen, 1979).
wim.salomons@home.nl
Table 42. Elemental composition of the earth's crust and sediments (major cations in %; minor and trace elements Ilg/g)
Element Mean crusta Mean sediment b Average shale c Deep-sea clayc Shallow water River sus- Sandstone f Limestone f Soil h
()
sediment d pended sed. e ::r
§.
Silicon 27.7% 24.5% 27.3% 25.0% 25.0% 28.5% 32.7% 3.2% 33.0% '"
::;
8.2% 8.4% 4.3% 0.7% 6.7% '<
Aluminium 7.2% 8.0% 8.4% 9.4% 0
Iron 4.1% 4.1% 4.7% 6.5% 6.5% 4.8% 2.9% 1.7% 3.2% ....
rn
4.1% 2.9% 3.1 % 34.0% 20% n
Calcium 6.6% 2.2% 2.9% 2.2% e:
Magnesium 2.3% 1.4% 1.5% 2.1% 2.1% 1.2% 1.2% 0.6% 0.8%
~
t:I
Sodium 2.3% 0.6% 1.0% 4.0% 4.0% 0.7% 1.0% 0.1% 1.1%
p;-
Potassium 2.1% 2.0% 2.7% 2.5% 2.5% 2.0% 1.5% 0.3% 1.8% ...
'<
Titanium 0.6% 0.4% 0.5% 0.5% 0.5% 0.6% 0.4% 0.03% 0.5% ~
550 0
Phosphorus 1,000 670 700 1,500 1,150 440 700 800 n
;0,-
Manganese 950 770 850 6,700 850 1,050 460 620 760 '"
Barium 500 460 580 2,300 600 320 90 568
Strontium 370 320 140 110 160 150 320 610 278
Zirconium 190 150 160 150 240 220 20 345
Vanadium 160 105 130 120 145 170 20 45 108
Chromium l00(?) 72 90 90 60 100 35 11 84
Nickel 80(?) 52 68 250 35 90 9 7 34
Zinc 75 95 95 165 92 350 30 20 60
Copper 50 33 45 250 56 100 30 5.1 26
Cobalt 20 14 19 74 13 20 0.3 0.1 12
Lithium 20 56 66 57 77 25 38 7.5 31
wim.salomons@home.nl
Scandium 16 10 13 19 12 18 1 1 10
Lead 14 19 20 80 22 150 10 5.7 29
Cesium 3.0 4.2 5 6 6 0.5 0.5 3
Beryllium 2.6 2 3 2.6 3 < I I 1.5
Uranium 2.4 3.1 3.7 1.3 3 0.5 2.2 2.2
Tin 2.2 4.6 6.0 1.5 2 0.5 0.5 5.8
Molybdenum 1.5 2.0 2.6 27 1 3 0.2 0.2 1.9
Arsenic 1.5 7.7 13 13" 5 5 I I 11.3
Tungsten 1.0 1.7 1.8 1.1" 1.6 0.6 1.1
Antimony 0.2 1.2 1.5 1.0 2.5 0.05 0.3 1.7
Cadmium 0.11 0.17 0.22" 0.42 1 0.05 0.03 0.6
Silver 0.07 0.06 0.07 0.11 0.25 0.12 0.4
Mercury 0.05 0.19 0.18 i 0.08 0.29 0.16 0.1 :;
Selenium 0.05 0.42 0.06 0.17 < 0.01 <0.03 0.4 '"
a Bowen (1979) C Turekian and Wedepohl (1961) e Martin and Meybeck (1979) • Marowski and Wedepohl (1971)
b Bowen (1979) after Wedepohl (1968) d Wedepohl (1969, 1978) f Bowen (1979) after Wedepohl (1968,1969,1974) h Ure and Berrow (1982)
150 Metals in Continental Waters
In the present chapter composition and processes of soils will be treated only so
far as their behavior in the aquatic cycles of metals are concerned. In this context
soils occupy an intermediate position between atmospheric fallout and terrestrial
waters, and act as substrates of plants which, on the one hand are the basic level
of the terrestrial food chain, and on the other hand, by their decomposition prod-
ucts, influence the chemical equilibria in the soil itself and in the aquatic environ-
ment. In the transfer of pollutants from the atmosphere to the receiving waters soils
may play several roles, e.g. as a medium of preconcentration, followed by mechan-
ical erosion and discharge into the surface water, or by combined effects or direct
inputs and chemical leaching of pollutants from terrestrial solids and subsequent
transport in dissolved or complexed form to both groundwater and surface water.
wim.salomons@home.nl
Metals in Soils 151
ot-
/!
___ c:
,. ~
H20 o-!--
I I o
H20 -
/OH2
Mn 2 +-OH 2 H20- Cu 2+ -OH 2
/OH 2
'\:\
-: c
H20 / I I y
H20 / o
H20 ot-
---c:
/!
~ot-
Fig. 80. Possible binding sites for Mn 2 + (left) and Cu 2 + (right) in soil organic matter. (Bloom, 1981)
wim.salomons@home.nl
152 Metals in Continental Waters
The complex formed between humates and Mn2+ can be described as an outer
sphere complex where the ligand does not interact directly with the Mn 2 + electron
(Fig. 80). This is not a chelation complex, since the latter would be an inner com-
plex where functional groups donate electron pairs to a metal ion. On the other
hand, it is likely that both water and carboxyl oxygen form coordinate bonds with
Cu2+ and that the charge on some carboxyl ions is shared by two (or more) metal
ions (Fig. 80). The formation of such an inner sphere complex affects the behaviour
of metals, in that, for example, copper mobility is more restricted than that of
manganese in the humate environment. Inner sphere complexation has been sug-
gested to exist also for Pb 2 + and V0 2 + while most other divalent ions are bound
in outer sphere complexes.
The affinities of metals to humates appear generally to follow the Irving-Wil-
liams order (Stevenson, 1977) and it has been found that Hg(II), Cu, Pb and Sn(II)
are exceptionally tightly bound by humates, while Mn(II) and the alkali and alka-
line earth metals are at most loosely bound (Bowen, 1979). Soils rich in organic
matter are reported also to concentrate Ge, Mo, Se, U and V, and most of the io-
dine and bromine in soils appears to be in the organic fraction (Vinogradov, 1959).
wim.salomons@home.nl
Metals in Soils 153
Soils act as the major suppliers of nutrients as well as contaminants to those classes
of organisms which are supported by soil (see summary of Haque and Subra-
manian, 1982). Any change of the concentration or chemical status of such sub-
stances, therefore, has a direct impact on the health of the organisms which follow
up in the food chain. With respect to the pollutant input the situation can become
even more serious, as removal of contaminants from soils is nearly impossible.
When metal transfer from soil to plants is estimated or plant uptake is mea-
sured this is usually done in terms of the "available fraction" of the total soil ma-
terial. A large number of studies have been performed on these relationships and
(as already mentioned in Chapter 2.6 on the speciation of particulate metals) a
similar number of chemical extraction methods have been proposed (e.g. Jackson,
1958; Mitchell, 1964; Mortvedt et aI., 1972; Viets and Lindsay, 1973; Anderson,
1976; Purves, 1977; Farrah and Pickering, 1978; Sterritt and Lester, 1980; Picker-
ing, 1981), generally belonging to one of the four broad categories (Shuman, 1980):
(1) complexing agents, (2) dilute acids, (3) chelating agents, (4) neutral salts.
Among the more widely used extractants in soil/plant studies, the combined soil
test DTPA leach - 0.005 M diethylenetriarnine penta-acetic acid, 0.01 M CaCI 2
and 0.1 M triethanoleamine - seems to give overall best correlations with transi-
tion metals such as Cu, Zn, Cd, Pb, Co, Ni, Fe and Mn.
A global investigation on the interactions of micro nutrients such as Mo, B, Cu,
Fe, Mn and Zn between soils and food plants was undertaken by Sillanpaa (1982)
with the objective of finding extreme situations with respect to both deficiency and
oversupply (from pollution or lithological sources) for characteristic examples of
elements. The example of the evaluation of the zinc data is presented in Fig. 81.
The plant-available zinc was determined by extraction with DTPA and correlated
with the zinc content in pot-grown wheat. Fig. 81 shows that there is a highly sig-
nificant correlation between the two data sets (r = 0.732 on the basis of 3537 sam-
ples), suggesting that the DTPA- extract is well suited to estimate the micronutrient
status of zinc with respect to the plant uptake from the respective soil material. The
regression graph has been divided into five zones (I-V) in such a way that the nu-
merical product of plant micronutrient content multiplied by soil micronutrient
content is constant at every point on the line separating two zones. The locations
of the zone limits have been determined so that five percent of sample pairs of the
whole international material falls below the line separating Zones I and II, i.e. into
Zone I. Accordingly, ten percent of the material falls below the line between Zones
II and III, i.e. five percent into Zone II. The next 80 percent of the material falls
in Zone III and the highest ten percent of the values in Zone IV and V, i.e. five per-
cent in each. The most likely cases of deficiency are to be found among samples
falling in Zone I and the most probable cases of toxicity in Zone V. In the example
for zinc no real cases of deficiency seem to exist, however, the pollution impact is
predominantly found in the examples from Malta and Belgium. It should be noted
that these examples do not necessarily reflect toxic conditions, since critical defi-
ciency and toxicity limits vary from one plant species to another. Further statistical
evaluation of the data sets with respect to the influence of characteristic parameters
such as soil texture, organic carbon content, cation exchange capacity, CaC0 3
wim.salomons@home.nl
154 Metals in Continental Waters
200
1\
\
Interndt.
Zn n=3537
1\ y=s = 18.33+10.77
x=s = 1.97+705
109 y=1.280+0.321 109 x
100 r=0.732···
90
\ .,/
80
70 1\ \ V"
60 \ \ io"
E
Q. 50
Q. \ 1\ L
~
..: \ [\ L V
IV 40
,r
~
--
GI
~
~
30
1\
i" ~ 1\
•• ~
1\
0
C
-
GI
20
~
..
V-• •• 1\1\
1\
c
~~
0
u
c
N
~ ""~~ 1\
V 1\
10 ./
9
8 V \ ~
7 \ \
1\
~
\
~ ,
6
I \ ][ ][ \ Dr 1\ Jz:
0.1 0.2 0.4 0.6 1 2 3 4 6 810 20304060 100
Zn in soil, mg/I (DTPA)
Fig. 81. Correlation between DPTA-extractable Zn in soils and the Zn concentrations in wheat
(Sillanpiiii, 1982)
equivalent, and pH-values indicate particularly strong effects of the latter factor,
but significant influences also from the other parameters (Sillanpiiii, 1982).
The various factors affecting the transfer rates of copper, lead and zinc from
soil to plants were reviewed by Haque and Subramanian (1982):
- Soil pH has a direct relationship to the availability of metals as it affects their
solubility and their capacity to form chelates in the soil. For example, Lindsay
(1972) reported that the solubility of Zn in soil solutes increased 100 times for
each unit decrease in pH; on the other hand the chelation activity was greater
at higher pH-values (Norvell and Lindsay, 1972).
- Soil organic matter has an essential function in the accumulation and transport
of metals as well as in delaying their circulation in the soil. Therefore, the toxicity
of metals may be both increased as well as decreased by organic substances
under specific environmental conditions.
- Phosphate content of soils also exhibits ambiguous effects on metal availa-
bilities; examples of both increase and decrease of the metal uptake at elevated
phosphate contents have been reported.
wim.salomons@home.nl
Metals in Soils 155
- Plant species differ widely in their physiology and hence accumulation of metals
is never the same for two plants growing under similar conditions. Ecotypes of
various plant species have been observed to develop characteristics which give
them the capacity to resist or withstand excess metals in soils.
- Relative accumulations in parts of the plants has often been observed; generally
roots exhibit higher metal concentrations than shoots. Soil pH, species of che-
lators, and quantity of metal in soil affects the passage of metal from root to
shoot.
- Exposure period has a direct influence on the accumulation of metals by plants.
It has been found, for example, that the zinc uptake in rice increased slightly at
maturity over the level at the young stage, while copper and lead uptake de-
creases with maturity (Takijima and Katsumi, 1973).
- Competition and synergisms of metals has been evidenced, for example, from
studies by Brar and Sekhon (1976) which found that copper competed for ad-
sorption with zinc in wheat and rice seedlings, and by Miller et al. (1977) indi-
cating an increased cadmium uptake by corn shoots at elevated soil lead concen-
trations. According to Haque and Subramanian (1982) it is suggested that anta-
gonism is due to competition for the same site of element, the sites being nor-
mally those which are responsible for adsorption or translocations; synergistic
effects are then thought to be due to the damage caused by one of the various
elements.
In addition to these factors cation exchange capacity (see above) may be con-
sidered; however, CEC does not act as an independent property of soil but is re-
lated to clays, hydrous oxides, organic matter, pH and presence of other ions in
the soil (Haque and Subramanian, 1982).
Until now there has been no information about the effects of contaminated soil
systems (soil particulate matter, soil solutes, plants and their decomposition prod-
ucts) on the metal concentration in receiving waters. The only quantitative
evaluations on the interactions of soil and surface waters as well as of their effects
on plants have been performed on agricultural areas irrigated by polluted surface
waters or affected by the deposition of contaminated sediments, e.g. from flood-
ings or disposal of dredged materials. These aspects will be treated in the conclud-
ing section of this chapter.
wim.salomons@home.nl
156 Metals in Continental Waters
mushrooms or food from polluted areas (see below) the tolerable daily intake of
60-70 Ilg Cd can be surpassed. Therefore, guidelines limiting cadmium applica-
tion, e.g. sewage sludge in agriculture, tend to be relatively conservative (Forstner,
1980).
Catastrophic poisonings by cadmium-polluted food has first been reported
from Japan. During 1947 an unusual and painful disease of "rheumatic nature"
was recorded in the case of 44 patients from villages on the banks of the Jinzu
River, Toyama Prefecture. The cause of this disease was completely unknown until
1953 when a close relationship between the disease and metal pollution from min-
ing wastes was postulated; further investigations found a definite overlapping of
limited localizations with Itai-Itai disease (as the disease was called) and polluted
environments such as soil, crop, and river water (Yoshioka, 1964). It has been evi-
denced that the Cd drain from the mine (together with other metal pollutants) had
been poured into the stream of the Jinzu River and had accumulated in paddy field
soils in the basin, and was later absorbed by crops such as paddy rice and soybeans
grown on the polluted soil (Morishita, 1981, with a compilation of the data on the
cadmium pollution in the Jinzu River Basin).
Another case study, which is reported here in more detail, has been performed
by Asami (1981) on the Ichi and Maruyama River basins situated between the Ja-
pan Sea (in the north) and Seto Inland Sea (in the south). Also here, rivers draining
mine wastes have been used to irrigate paddy fields. The cadmium concentrations
in the surface layers of paddy soil (sediment data are also given) are shown in Fig.
82.A.
In the paddy soil of the Ichi River basin, the Cd concentration was higher in
the upstream area where the Ikuno Mine was situated and decreased gradually
downstream: the maximum concentration of more than 10 mg Cd/kg was observed
in one sample in Kuri, Okochi Town, about 7 km downstream from Ikuno Mine.
The highest concentration of Cd in the Maruyama River basin was observed in the
upper reaches near Ikuno Town, where the soil sample contained 12.5 mg Cd/kg;
however, the Maruyama River basin exhibits a lower overall contamination level
for cadmium than the Ichi River basin. In addition to direct effects of mine ef-
fluents, serious pollution by cadmium in paddy soils originates from ore smelting
and dressing. Altogether, the paddy soil of both river basins, where Cd-rich waters
were used for irrigation, were thoroughly polluted by cadmium and other metals
such as copper and zinc; in some instances, subsoils were found to be even more
polluted than surface soils (Asami, 1981).
The cadmium concentrations in unpolished rice produced in the basins of the
Ichi and Maruyama Rivers were analyzed every year from 1972 by Asami and col-
leagues. Fig. 82 B shows the maximum Cd concentrations in unpolished rice pro-
duced in each village from 1972 to 1979. These data significantly correlate with the
distribution patterns of Cd in soil samples; according to Asami (1981) a cadmium
concentration below 0.1 mg/kg in unpolished rice means that the rice is not pol-
luted; Cd concentration between 0.11 and 0.19 mg/kg are suspected pollution and
unpolished rice which contains above 0.2 mg/kg Cd will not be produced in unpo-
luted fields under normal conditions. The present maximum allowable limit for un-
polished rice in Japan is 1.0 mg/kg. These levels are surpassed in many examples,
mainly from the upper reaches if the Ichi River. However, it has been stressed by
wim.salomons@home.nl
Metals in Soils 157
JAPAN SEA
Cd in rice
• > 1.00 ppm
Cd In soil • 0.99-0.70 ppm
• > 5.00 ppm .. 0.69-0.40 ppm
.. 4.99-3.00 ppm o 0.39-0.20 ppm
o 2.99-1.00 ppm o 0.19-0.11 ppm
A SETO INLAND SEA "" < 0.99 ppm B SETO INLAND SEA "" < 0.10 ppm
Fig. 82. A Cadmium concentrations in surface layers of paddy soil and, B Maximum cadmium concen-
trations in unpolished rice. (Asami, 1981)
Asami (1981) that these limits may be probably too high, since the average Cd con-
centration in highly endemic areas of Itai-Itai disease of the Jinzu River was 0.53
mg/kg and the effects of renal dysfunction evidently occur at even lower levels; the
latter disease has been found in many examples in the upper portion of Ichi River
basin.
It has to be added that problems with river-borne cadmium contamination of
agricultural soils are not restricted to Japan. Salomons and colleagues (1982) have
summarized the experience in the Netherlands as follows:
The river flood plains along the rivers Rhine and Meuse, about 40,000 hectares,
are flooded almost yearly. The upper soil layer consists entirely of contaminated
river sediment. The flood plains are mainly in use as pastures for grazing dairy
cattle; a limited part is used for the cultivation of maize.
The sediments dredged out of the harbours and waterways of Rotterdam, situ-
ated in the Rhine estuary, are partly deposited on land. Depending on local con-
ditions these polders contain layers of dredged material up to a thickness of 10
meters. About 300 hectares of these disposal sites potentially have agronomic
destinations.
wim.salomons@home.nl
158 Metals in Continental Waters
Detailed investigations during the last years indicate that the heavy metal bur-
den of the cattle in the flood plains is higher than that of the cattle at the reference
pastures. Data of the heavy metal contents of the milk, kidney, liver and brains,
however, revealed that this did not result in elevated concentrations of metals. On
the other hand, cultivation of consumable crops on sediments heavily polluted with
heavy metals may involve risks of intolerable high levels of these contaminants in
the products. Pot experiments and field data have shown that significant accumu-
lation of most metals in the crops occurs as compared with non-contaminated sub-
strates. Particularly in the green, leafy vegetables, wheat grain and other cereals
and in most green fodders, the cadmium concentrations must be considered too
high for human and animal consumption.
wim.salomons@home.nl
Trace Metals in River Water 159
(i) The annual application of cadmium from solid waste does not exceed the
maximum addition below:
Present to December 31, 1981 2.0 kg/ha
Jan 1, 1981 to Dec 31, 19851,25kg/ha
Beginning Jan. 1, 19860.5 kg/ha
(ii) The maximum cumulative amount of cadmium applied to any hectare of
land does not exceed 5 kg on soils with a cation exchange capacity (CEC) of less
than 5 meq/100 g, 10 kg on soils whose CEC is between 5 and 15 meq/l00 g, and
20 kg on soils whose CEC exceeds 15 meq/100 g.
(iii) Solid waste containing cadmium concentrations in excess of 25 mg/kg dry
weight is not applied to sites where tobacco, leafy vegetables, or root crops are or
will be grown for direct human consumption.
Trace metal analysis on continental waters were commenced in the USA, in central
Europe, the USSR and Japan, mainly in areas where local anomalies from ore min-
eralizations had been expected. Huff (1948) studied the concentration of Cu, Pb
and Zn in five samples from the Colorado River; Turekian and Kleinkopf (1956)
analyzed the abundance of Cu, Mn, Pb, Ti and Cr in surface waters of Maine. In-
vestigations and literature compilations have been performed during the 60's and
early 70's by Merril et aI. (1960; Be - Delaware and Hudson Rivers), Durum and
Haffty (1961), Livingstone (1963; surface waters), White et aI. (1963; subsurface
waters), Silvey, (1967; California), Turekian et aI. (1967; Neuse River, North
Carolina), Bradford et aI. (1968; Sierra Nevada), VoegelI and King (1968; Mo -
Colorado), Angino et aI. (1969; lower Kansas River basin), Lindstedt and Kruger
(1969; V - Colorado), Weller and Chawla (1969; Great Lakes), Durum et aI. (1971;
surface waters), Bradford (1971; California), Mills and Oglesby (1971; Cayuga
Basin), Robbins et aI. (1972; tributaries to Lake Michigan), Mathis and Cummings
(1973; Illinois River), and Proctor et aI. (1973; Missouri River). In central Europe
early investigations have been performed by Heide and Singer (1954) and Heide
et aI. (1957) on the concentrations of Cu, Zn and Pb in the Saale River (German
Democratic Republic), by Heyl (1954) in the Siegerland mining area (Federal Re-
public of Germany), and by Fricke and Werner (1957) in the mineral waters of
Nordrhein-Westfalen (FRG). Both the European and Asian surface waters of the
USSR have been studied intensively; compilations and original data are given by
Konovalov (1959), Udodov and Parilov (1961), Kontorovich et aI. (1963),
Konovalov et aI. (1976a-b), Konovalov and Ivanova (1972), and Konovalov and
Nazarova (1975). An early review of data on acidic mine drainage was given by
Smirnov (1954). Of the early Japanese investigations on trace metals in natural
waters one should particularly mention the studies performed at Nagoya Univer-
sity (Morita, 1955; Sugawara et aI., 1956; Sugawara and Okabe, 1960; Kanamori
and Sugawara, 1965).
wim.salomons@home.nl
160 Metals in Continental Waters
AI 64 d 56
As I' 3 13 250 r
Cd 0.02" 0.1 5.5 52
Cr 0.5" 0.5 33 4,000
Cu Ih 2 34 5,400
Fe 55 d 5 35 550,000
Hg O.Oli 0.1 0.65
Mn 6d 10 5.2 200,000
Ni O.3 k 1.5 20 6,400
Pb 0.2' 0.2 57 290
Zn 10 (0.5)"(1) 10 330 26,000
During the last few years the number of trace metal analysis on river waters has
greatly increased in both geoexploration and environmental management (com-
pilation see Rose et aI., 1979, and Forstner and Wittmann, 1979). This progress
has been to a large extent due to improvements in analytical techniques which have
significantly lowered the costs and increased the effectiveness of these methods.
However, following the findings of Patterson et ai. (1976) on lead values from
oceanic samples, it has been argued that the same contamination effects associated
with marine sampling and analysis also exist in fresh and estuarine waters, and "it
is safe to assume that many of the natural water values quoted in the literature are
high solely for this reason" (Martin et aI., 1980).
For a general overview metal data from both less contaminated and polluted
water samples are given in Table 43.
Due to the variety of rock formations and the fluctuations in water discharge
it is even more difficult to establish natural background values for metals in inland
waters than in seawater. The examples for background values in Table 43 partly
stem from large inland water masses such as Lake Michigan; however, contamina-
tion from both atmospheric and river inputs cannot be excluded (see Sect. 5.4.6).
More reliable background values of those from Amazon and Yukon River (Boyle,
1978; Gibbs, 1977), where the effect oflarge catchment areas meets the prerequisite
oflow pollution activity.
It can be seen that the "dissolved" metal concentrations in the Rhine River (sta-
tion Bimmen at the Dutch/German border, 1970-1973) were enriched by a factor
200-500 for Zn, Cd and Pb, 30-60 for Ni, Hg, Cu and Cr, approx. 10 for As. Much
higher concentration factors have been analyzed in inland waters affected by acidic
mine effluents, e.g. in the Witwatersrand Goldfields in South Africa (Table 43),
where the levels of dissolved Ni, Mn, Fe (and Co) exceed the normal surface water
wim.salomons@home.nl
Dissolved and Solid Transport 161
concentrations by a factor of more than 10,000, values of Zn and Cr (and Fe, sul-
fate) are increased 1000-fold, whereas Pb and Cd in many instances are encoun-
tered at values exceeding a 100-fold enrichment. Lowering of pH-values on a re-
gional scale by acid precipitation is probably the most important single effect on
metal mobility in surface waters, particularly for AI, Cd, Mn, and Zn (see Sect.
5.4.6)
It has been suggested that the source of trace metals in aquatic systems significantly
determines their distribution ratio between the aqueous and solid phases. This is
especially true for river systems, where equilibrium between the solution and the
solid phases can often not completely be achieved due to the short residence times;
Bowen (1977) has noted the example of the Thames River flowing 250 km in 14
hours, while chemical equilibrium would require more than 100 hours in some in-
stances.
wim.salomons@home.nl
162 Metals in Continental Waters
Table 44. Dissolved transport index (DTI) in rivers (Martin and Meybeck, 1979): Percentage of
dissolved transport over total transport (ranked in decreasing order)
Cadmium 88.9 30
Zinc 90.1 40 45
Manganese 83 98.5 8-97
Chromium 83 98.5 76 72
Copper 93 91.6 63 55
Lead 99.2 84 79
Iron 99.4 99.9 98 98
a Gibbs (1977)
b Trefry and Presley (1976)
, Kopp and Kroner (1968)
d Heinrichs (1975)
Ni, Si, Rb, U, Co, Mn, Cr, Th, Pb, V and Cs is carried by river particulates, while
Fe, Al and the rare earths are almost exclusively transported in particulate forms
(Table 44). A similar sequence of the ratios between particulates and dissolved
metal phases has been found for polluted systems (Table 45). Typically, however,
the dissolved discharges in polluted waters are significantly higher than the less pol-
luted systems (example from the Lower Mississippi River), particularly for cad-
mium, zinc and copper.
The relative importance of the particulate forms in the decreasing sequence
AI> Fe > Mn > Co > Zn > Ni > Cu > Cd has also been found by Yeats and Bewers
(1982) from St. Lawrence River in Canada. According to these authors the lower
proportions of the metals in particulate phases from St. Lawrence compared to the
data from the Amazon (Gibbs, 1977) or the Mississippi (Trefrey and Presley, 1976)
rivers are a direct reflection of the contrasting levels of suspended matter in the St.
Lawrence (10 mg/I), Amazon (65 mg/I) and Mississippi (580 mg/I). The work of
Yeats and Bewers (1982) on the discharge of metals from the St. Lawrence River
also confirms earlier suggestions of Trefry and Presley (1976) that the dissolved
fractions are exhibiting a certain degree of long-term stability and are - at least in
less polluted systems - not significantly related to water flow.
wim.salomons@home.nl
Dissolved and Solid Transport 163
RHINE AT KOBLENZ
18~-----------------,
1500r-------------------,
..gig
12 .. gig
gOO
8
4
300
O~~ ____ ~ __ ~ ____ ~ O~~ ____ ~ __ ~ ____ ~
..gig Cd 119/g Cr
•
75 1500
50 1000
.:
•
25 500
,
• I •
O~--~~~~~~~~~ O~--~~~--~~~~
o 2000 4000 o 2000 4000
Fig. 83. The relationship between the water discharge and the metal concentrations in the suspended
matter. Above: Rhine River at Koblenz. (Schleichert, 1975) Below: Rhine River in the Netherlands.
(Salomons and Eysink, 1981)
wim.salomons@home.nl
164 Metals in Continental Waters
Such a development is due to the suspended sediments, rich in cadmium, being held
back in periods of poor flow, for example, mainly during the summer, in the lock-
regulated Neckar and Main rivers; in autumn/winter the tendency is reversed, the
material is carried by high water flows into the Rhine River in increased quantities.
From investigations in two Cornish estuaries (Boyden et aI., 1978) found that
- except for Ni and Pb - there are higher trace element concentrations in high and
low water surface and bottom samples in winter compared to summer; it is sug-
gested that this probably reflects increased weathering and transport in the catch-
ments in winter.
Studies performed by Grimshaw et ai. (1976) on the River Ystwyth in mid-
Wales, where strong metal pollution from past mining operations is still obvious,
indicate that metal concentrations in solution are highest during low flow periods,
suggesting a dilution effect. For brief periods during initial stages of storm runoff,
there is a very significant increase of the metal concentrations in solution, ap-
parently due to a flushing effect.
Data on the temporal variability of metal transport from the Susquehanna
River to Chesapeake Bay (Carpenter et aI., 1975) showed that the trace metal con-
centrations correlate well with the amount of solids discharged. When data are cal-
culated for weight concentrations of metals in the solid fraction, it is found that
all metals generally peak during December and January and secondary peaks occur
for Co, Cr, Ni, Cu and Mn in July. Troup and Bricker (1975) suggest that this effect
is due to decaying organic matter which is abundant in the Susquehanna River dur-
ing these two periods.
wim.salomons@home.nl
Metals in River Sediment 165
Table 46. Procentual standard deviation of metal data in multiple sampling in selected reservoirs of
the middle Neckar River (FRG); samples from a sediment depth of 0 to 10 cm (Schoer and Forstner.
1980)
Horkheim 117.7-117.9 4 23 34 25 29 41 18
Lauffen 125.3-125.6 7 62 56 76 38 93 49
Poppen weiler 165.0--166.3 6 38 28 33 21 41 38
Obertiirkheim 189.7-190.7 5 81 26 45 9 64 38
Plochingen 200.5-200.7 4 24 22 20 12 95 21
Mean percent standard deviation 46 33 40 22 67 33
wim.salomons@home.nl
166 Metals in Continental Waters
Fe Zn •
% ."",
7 • IRON mg/kg
ZINC
4000
- RIVER
5 MILE 3000
_ RIVER
0.5 MILE
0.5
4 X . 270ppm
o,
0 .........
,,
1
2000
,,
.,,
3 "'0...
RIVER/" ,
MILE • '. ,,
2 16.6 \ b, /'
1000
.~/ ~. RIVER', \
MILE - " , '\.
/-
0.02 0 .15 5.8 63 125 250 500 1000 I'm 0.02 0.15 5.8 83 125 250 500 1000 t'-m
GRAIN SIZE FRACTION
Fig. 84. Grain size distribution of iron and zinc in two sediment samples from Saddle River, upstream
(mile 16.6) and downstream (mile 0.5) from an urbanized area of Lodi, New Jersey (Forstner, 1982; af-
ter data from Wilber and Hunter, 1979)
wim.salomons@home.nl
Metals in River Sediment 167
is not the case and "coatings", for example, of iron/manganese oxides, carbonates,
and organic substances on relatively inert material in respect to heavy metals, such
as quartz grains, act as substrates of heavy metals in coarser grain size fractions
(Forstner and Patchineelam, 1980). Furthermore, an aggregate formation of finer-
grained substances occurs in which the relatively metal-rich clay particles partici-
pate as well.
Therefore it must be said that the selection of certain grain size fractions - espe-
cially in the tracing of sources of pollution - remains controversial for the following
reasons (see Fig. 84):
1. Since the larger sediment fractions are less affected by scour and transport, they
may reflecting the effect of urbanization on the distribution of heavy metals
over an extended period of time at a given location (Wilber and Hunter, 1979).
2. The fine sand fraction (approx. 20 ~m to 200 ~m diameter) seems to be of par-
ticular interest for the differentiation of natural and pollutant metal transport,
firstly because it comprises most of the total sediment, and secondly because
there are most obvious differences between individual metal examples (in Fig.
84, Fe is not affected in this grain size interval by man-made effects, whereas
the typical "anthropogenic" metals, e.g. Pb, Cr and Zn are significantly en-
riched in the same grain size fractions of the polluted material).
3. The silt and clay fractions comprise the major carriers for both natural and an-
thropogenic metal compounds (although in relatively small portions); they are
widely distributed within the sedimentation area and are least affected by grain
size effects (Banat et aI., 1972).
wim.salomons@home.nl
168 Metals in Continental Waters
Table 47. Chemical forms of cadmium in aquatic solids. (Forstner et aI., 1981)
Cation exchangeable 8 18 27 12 13
Easily reducible 32 49 42 61 64
Moderately reducible 45 14 2 13 10
Organic/sulfidic 12 17 17 12 12
Residual fraction 3 2 2 2
Total Cd (mg/kg) 3.0 4.3 9.0 18.1 33.6
(I) Dredged sediment; (2) suspended matter; (3) station Wesel (Dutch/German border); (4) Broek-
polder; (5) lock reservoir Lauffen
ter. This has the effect of increasing metal transport and the overall quantity of
metal accessible to the biota. With the exception of iron and aluminium, more than
90% of the manganese, copper, cadmium and lead occurred in transport modes
thought to be available to aqueous and biotic interactions.
Suspended sediment samples were collected by Tessier et al. (1980) at 12
stations on the Yamaska and Fran<;ois Rivers - located in southeastern Quebec -
and analyzed according to their elaborate scheme (Tessier et aI., 1979), which in-
cludes partition of five fractions: (1) exchangeable, (2) bound to carbonates, (3)
bound to Fe-Mn oxides, (4) bound to organic matter, and (5) residual (see Sect.
2.6). Although suspended sediment levels as well as total soluble and particulate
trace metal concentrations were highly variable in time and space, speciation pat-
terns for each metal proved reasonably constant. Deviation from the general be-
haviour were occasioned by man-induced perturbations (e.g. inputs of municipal
sewage or mine waste waters). At stations influenced by such factors, total particu-
late metal concentrations increased and the relative contribution of the residual
fraction decreased. The trace metal content of the fraction "bound to Fe-Mn-oxi-
des" proved to be particularly sensitive to anthropogenic inputs.
A scheme similar to that of Tessier et al. (1979) has been used by Forstner and
Salomons (1980) for the differentiation of metal species in fluvial and coastal ma-
rine sediments. A distinction is made between "easily reducible" (including carbon-
ate-associated metals) and "moderately reducible" metal fractions. Examples for
the solid phase partition of Cd have been given in Table 47, for samples from areas
of major dredging activities (Forstner et aI., 1981; Forstner and Calmano, 1982).
Compared to other metals, such as Pb and Cu, cadmium is characteristically
enriched in the more mobile fractions "cation exchange" and "easily reducible
phases", and is, therefore, more mobile than most of the other heavy metals.
A simplified scheme consisting of an extraction with 0.1 M hydroxylamine-H CI
(pH 2) followed by an extraction with hydrogen peroxide (30%, pH 2.5) and am-
monium acetate was used for the study of sediments from the Rhine, Meuse, Ems
and Scheidt Rivers from the North Sea (Salomons and De Groot, 1978). This
scheme, including an additional step for exchangeable cations ("Standard Extrac-
tion Method" after Salomons and Forstner, 1980), was used to study the speciation
wim.salomons@home.nl
Fig. 85. The speciation of trace metals in 18 different river sediments. (after Salomons and Forstner,
1980)
wim.salomons@home.nl
170 Metals in Continental Waters
The major part of this chapter will cover the case history of the metal pollution in
the Rhine River which is not only a characteristic example of origin, distribution
and fate of trace metals in fluvial systems but also gives evidence for the fact that
in many critical cases this type of pollution - which has caused considerable public
concern during the 1970s - has passed its climax and is now decreasing as a result
of recent improvements of waste water treatment.
wim.salomons@home.nl
Impact of Metals in River Systems 171
I geo - classes
Neckar
12
0 1
wim.salomons@home.nl
172 Metals in Continental Waters
Lippe River-Dutch border: Lead and mercury also advance one class, and cop-
per occurs in class 3 for the first time. It has been found that more than 90% of
the concentrations of copper, zinc, lead and mercury and more than 99% of cad-
mium originate from man-made sources in this section of the lower Rhine River.
2000
----z::--.--~
Zn
1000 . !
500
/~~'
.,<~::::::.
x--
/ . _0- ,\
200
III
"- 100
.
III As
::L.
50
t.'
i 20
~~~- Hi
CO _D~?\
~
10 "-"~:/"" \
5
2
f: H,
.
1 <>
the Rhine River in the Netherlands as re-
o 0 0 0 0 0 0
.... 0
0 (If CO) II) D co fleeted in its sediments (after Salomons et
...
III
... ... ... ...
III III III III
... ... ...
III III III
ai.,1982)
wim.salomons@home.nl
Impact of Metals in River Systems 173
Table 48. Tentative metal balance for the rivers Rhine and Meuse and of dredged material of fluvial
origin from the Rotterdam harbours in 1977 (Salomons et aI., 1982). In tonnesjyear
Of the total amount of metals transported by the rivers Rhine and Meuse,
about 2/3 accumulates in the Netherlands, which in fact acts as an effective "treat-
ment plant" for these river discharges (Salomons et aI., 1982). This situation may
be regarded as beneficial for the North Sea, but poses problems for the manage-
ment of inland waters and the land-fill areas in the Netherlands. The problems with
polluted sediments are intensified by the closing of lagoons, the extension of har-
bour areas, the deepening of navigation channels and the channelization of the
rivers. The total amount of dredged material from the Rotterdam harbour is pres-
ently about 20.10 6 m 3 , which represents a 20-25 fold increase compared with 70
years ago. The most severely contaminated spoil from the easterly harbours, with
high admixtures of fluvial sediment, is dumped on land. Thus the land-fill areas
are an important sink for fluvial (and partly marine) particulate metals. A tentative
balance for trace metals of fluvial origin in spoils from the Rotterdam harbour is
presented in Table 48.
Problems arise from the metal concentration in sediment both with land dis-
posal and marine dumping. From pot experiments under controlled conditions and
by surveying the contents of contaminants in the crops grown on polluted sedi-
ments under field conditions it has been shown that agricultural use of the land-fill
areas is restricted due to cadmium accumulation in crops, particularly in the green,
leafy vegetables, wheat grain and other cereals and in most green fodders. With re-
spect to the contamination of groundwater in disposal areas the transport of pol-
lutants was calculated with a one-dimensional dispersion programme (Kerdijk,
1981); chloride, showing conservative behaviour, will become apparent in the ad-
jacent polders in the year 2100 approximately, the heavy metals one to three cen-
turies later, and pesticides several thousand years later.
As a result of increasing efforts to reduce the waste-water input the metal dis-
charges in highly polluted rivers are now decreasing after a maximum in the early
1970s. From a review of data from the Rhine River at the German-Dutch border
it is shown by Malle and Muller (1982) that the suspended solids contents have
hardly changed since 1973, while the contents of Cr, Cu, Zn, Cd, Hg and Pb are
retrograde (Fig. 88).
The decrease in the Cr and Hg contents mainly occurred in the suspended sol-
ids, Zn and Cd concentrations were found to be reduced in the liquid phase.
wim.salomons@home.nl
174 Metals in Continental Waters
,,
Fig. 88. Changes of metal load (dis-
\ Cr Cu solved and particulate) in the Rhine
3000 '. 2000 "" River at the Dutch-German border
·····:~o" ....~~
from 1971 to 1979. (Malle and Miiller,
2000
1982)
1000
,72 74 76 18 12 14 76 18
18000 ,,
,,
.......
Zn 200
,,
12000
'"
........ '~100
C/I
'"c:: 6000 --- --~
0'"
\72 14 76 78 ,12747678
· . :~ooo ..~:~:~
80
\ Hg 2000
60
40
20
~
72 14 16 18 12 14 16 18
year
o D
soluble suspended
solids
wim.salomons@home.nl
3'
'0
~
o
....,
~
~
<;;
Input Output + Retention ;;-
~
~ .
...,
Industrial 'a'"
discharge ~ 1%
6t / a ~
Percentage of the
catchment area
wim.salomons@home.nl
j :; : ; j ;
I~ I; I; II;;I; I ; I ;I ; I ;Ii: I :
:::: Exported with::::
::::drinking water!:::
non point ~ : :: over the ::: :
sources ~4% :::: watershed ::: .
O
20 t / a :.:' 50 tt a :,':
,',',',',','
,! I ! I" !! I I !
,', ',', ',', ',',',II I:'
! ,
-..J
Fig. 89. Balance of heavy metal load in the Ruhr River catchment. (Imhoff et aI., 1980) V.
176 Metals in Continental Waters
Although many investigations have shown that increased inputs of natural organic
substances can affect the metal mobilization from the sediments, the introduction
of synthetic complexing agents can have an even more serious impact on heavy
metal remobilization.
Among these substances, nitrilotriacetic acid (NT A) as a possible alternative
to the polyphosphate in detergents was intensively discussed during the last few
years (Forstner and Wittmann, 1979). The extent of these effects depends on the
concentration of the complexing agent, its pH value, the mode of occurrence of
trace metals in the sediments and on competition by other cations (Salomons and
van Pagee, 1981). The influence is twofold:
1. The complexing agent may actively desorb heavy metals from the suspended
matter and the deposited sediment. Similar processes may occur within the de-
posited sediments (increased mobilization of trace metals to the interstitial
waters).
wim.salomons@home.nl
Complexing Agents in River Systems 177
2. When both NT A (or any other complexing agent) and metals are discharged in-
to a river system, the complexing agent may negatively influence the naturally
occurring adsorption processes, causing enhanced dissolved metal concen-
trations.
The active remobilization has been studied by many investigators and seems to
exhibit reliable results at NT A-concentrations above approx. 1-2 mg/1. Such con-
centrations of NT A could rarely be expected in normal river waters, but may occur
at even higher levels in sewage treatment plants. Recent data from experiments per-
formed by Dietz (1982) on sediments from the Ruhr River at relative high concen-
trations of solid matter (1 gil) and NT A-contents of 1 mg/l are summarized in
Table 49. Mobilization mainly occurs for zinc, nickel and copper, leading to four-
fold increase of the concentrations of zinc, three-fold for nickel and double for cop-
per concentrations in the water phase. Following the calculations of Dietz (1982)
the formation of 1: I complexes of metals with NT A - which has to be expected
from thermodynamical data - would consume total available NT A in the solution,
and, therefore, it would seem that calcium and magnesium complexation will not
play any significant role in these processes.
The "passive" effects of NT A on the sorption of metals on solid surfaces was
studied by Salomons and van Pagee (1981) using natural river water, metal dosages
of 5 and 10 l!g/l, respectively, for Cd and Zn, 200 mg/l solid matter, pH-values of
7 and 8, respectively, and variable NT A concentrations from 20 l!g/l to 5 g/1. Three
different systems were studied:
(a) The influence of NT A on the adsorption of trace metals on sediments. This
process occurs when NT A and dissolved metals are discharged simultaneously into
the river system, or when a pH change occurs when both NT A and metals are
present;
(b) the influence of NT A on the desorption of "labile" bound metals. This pro-
cess may occur during transport when, after a discharge of trace metals, NT A is
discharged further downstream. Over a period of 4 weeks trace metals were ad-
sorbed on sediments. Then NT A was added. The pH was not controlled (pH was
about 7.8).
Table 49. Remobilization of metals from Ruhr River sediments. (Dietz, 1982)
wim.salomons@home.nl
60 100 20
( .....
00
•-...... pH - 6 desorption Zn Cu ,pH - 7 _.-.
."", pH -7 2 days ..)
% Pb, pH-8 --0
pH - 8 8 days
,ug/l //
Zn t .~~ t /
/1 '
~o4°1 :a~ . I
50 10
.,. .
0
V ",'
.". " i
20-4
\
..... -.-- • .". ~.'
~.. '
/,/ ~ ..... '
.....,
.... • r~~o
-..---- ..-. ."-...,
0 . -------.:. -'- o ..A
. o 0
60 100 100
pH -6 desorption Cd Zn, pH - 7 _. - .
pH - 7
. ---~.-.-.
pH - 8
% 2 days
8 days
,ug/l N i , pH - 8 --0
......
.......j
Cd t t ..... .I
O~o • .... _.--.-. .... . rI
50 50 •
.-
.-.-' ." . /
wim.salomons@home.nl
..... ~
~J .-'-.'-'-'."'- ,.
.-.-.-.--:a. ~.
20 .-
'. .
._-----.----'., ~ .....~.-
, ~ •
We::..:.:=.·
~
O~i
.. i i i i "1 o.l...Ay I I i i I 0 '"E.
20 50 200 500 2000 20 50 200 500 2000 20 50 200 500 2000 5000 '"S'
--+ p.g/l N TA --+ p.gll NTA --+ p.g/l NTA n
o
a
S'
Fig. 91. Results of the experiments on metal-sediment-NT A interactions, presented as adsorption in % of added metal or as dissolved metal concen-
tration in fig/I. (Salomons and van Pagee, 1981)
'"
a
e.
~
~
;;l
Introduction 179
5.4.1 Introduction
wim.salomons@home.nl
180 Metals in Continental Waters
Table 50. Areas and approximate durations of typical lakes (Picard and High, 1972)
tivity, cause variations in the sediment mineral composition over scales ranging
from fractions of a millimeter to several centimeters. If burrowing or bottom stir-
ring zoo benthos are absent from the sediment such temporal variations can be pre-
served as laminated sediment [varves, if the period of obvious compositional vari-
ation is I year (Jones and Bowser, 1978)]. The composition of the sediments de-
pends on the composition of the particulate fluxes. However, after deposition
physical processes may cause a redistribution of the sediments over the lake bot-
tom; slumps may occur on river deltas in lakes resulting in turbidity currents; in
shallow lakes the energy of the wind may be sufficient to cause a resuspension and
redistribution of the bottom deposits.
Sources for trace metals in lakes are the atmosphere, riverine inputs and various
waste discharges (Fig. 92). Metals are introduced in the lake both in solution
and in particulate form. The allochtonous particles will partially settle to the bot-
tom. Whereas the dissolved trace metals are subject to removal processes by ad-
sorption, uptake by biota and incorporation in authigenous phases, in the oxic
epilimnion there is a strong interaction between the carbon cycle and the metal
cycle. The production of algal material causing an increase in pH, reprecipitation
of calcium carbonate, thus causing removal of trace metal by their incorporation
in algal tissues and in new mineral phases and by providing active surfaces for ad-
sorption. During their fall through the water column a partial dissolution of the
trace metals may take place, in the same way as in the oceans. In the lakes with
an anoxic hypolymnion there is a strong interaction between the metal and the re-
dox cycle. In the anoxic waters a strong redissolution of iron and manganese takes
place, which diffuses upward and precipitates at the oxic/anoxic interface in the
lake. The resulting hydrous iron and manganese particles are able to remove dis-
solved metals.
Metal research on trace metal in lakes has in most cases been based on sediment
analysis particularly using dated profiles to determine rates of input and the histor-
ical development of trace metals. Relatively less attention has been paid to process-
es which determine trace metal behaviour in lakes. Therefore, this chapter will start
wim.salomons@home.nl
a-d
0-
C
"g.
::>
wim.salomons@home.nl
00
Fig. 92. Processes affecting trace metals in lakes
182 Metals in Continental Waters
also with a discussion of the occurrence of trace metals in sediments and their ac-
cumulative phases.
wim.salomons@home.nl
Accumulative Phases in Lake Sediments 183
Table 51. Effects of autochthonous mineral phases (Fe/Mn oxyhydrates not included) on the
enrichment ( +, + + ) or reduction ( -, - - ) of heavy metals in lake sediments
Endo- Authi-
genic genic
Carbonates
Aragonite x Aci Crater GI b (Turkey) - - all heavy metals
Calcite x x Bande-Amir b (Afghanistan) All heavy metals
Mg calcite x x L. Balaton b (Hungary) Fe, ± heavy metals
Dolomite x L. Neusiedl b ± Mn, Zn, - Ni, Cr, etc.
(Austria/H ungary)
Rhodochrosite x L. Michigan C + to + + heavy metals
Siderite x Black Sea d, Birket Ram e + Mn, ± heavy metals
(Israel)
Sul/ates
Gypsum x Australian lakes b - - all heavy metals
Glauberite x Curtain Springsf (Australia) - - all heavy metals
Alunite x L. Brown b Australia ± Pb, - heavy metals
Opaline silica x Lake Malawi b - - heavy metals, - Cu
Sulfides
Hydrotroilite x x L. Constance f + Ni, Cu, Cr
Pyrite x Black Sea" ± Pb, Zn, Mn; + + Cu, Ni, Co
Lake Kivu h ++ Ni
Non/mllite x Lake Malawi f ± heavy metals; + Co, Mn
Phosphates x Lake Geneva; + Fe, Co, Cu, Zn, Pb(?)
d Stoffers and MUller (1978) ; Near sewage outfall- J.-M. Jaquet, Univ. Geneva
e Singer and Navrot (1978) (personal comm.)
(Harris and Troup, 1969) and upward migration in the pore water (Lynn and
Bonatti, 1965) both mechanisms being mediated and enhanced by organic diagen-
esis, - are assumed to occur for both shallow marine water (Calvert and Price,
1977) and lacustrine formations (Callender and Bowser, 1976)
The basic oxide mineralogy of lacustrine ferromanganese deposits appears to
be similar to marine ferromanganese nodules (Burns and Burns, 1977; Jones and
Bowser, 1978). Goethite is the dominant iron phase, whereas the manganese oxides
include todorokite, birnessite and psilomelane (Callender and Bowser, 1976).
Compared with the deep-sea nodules, ferromanganese oxide deposits in near-
shore and lacustrine environments indicate:
a higher variability of the Mn/Fe ratios,
higher contents of organic matter, and
characteristic lower contents of many minor elements.
wim.salomons@home.nl
184 Metals in Continental Waters
Table 52. Chemical composition of freshwater ferromanganese nodules (after Callender and Bowser,
1976; Forstner, 1978)
(1) Ljunggren (1955); (2) Dean (1970); (3) Harris and Troup (1969); (4) Schiittle and Friedman (1972);
(5) Cronan and Thomas (1970); (6) Rossmann (1973)
F = max. factor of enrichment compared with crustal element abundance
The examples in Table 52 show the composition of limnic nodules and con-
cretions to be highly variable with respect to the concentration of minor elements.
The highest contents of nickel, copper and zinc are found in the deeper lakes,
whereas the lower contents occur in the shallow Canadian lakes. This divergence
partially results from the primary metal supply to lake water, but at the same time,
it is a consequence of varying growth rates of the concretions or nodules (Man-
heim, 1965) and may be affected, for example, by the complexation with organic
substances or anthropogenic influences (Cronan and Thomas, 1972).
The majority of freshwater nodules show concentric bands of alternating Fe-
rich (lighter) and Mn-rich (darker) laminations; minor transition metal cations,
such as those of Cu, Co, Ni and Zn are associated with the Mn phase, whereas ele-
ments with aqueous anionic charge such as silica, phosphate and arsenic are related
to the iron laminas (Callender and Bowser, 1976; Damiani et aI., 1977).
There is little data on the presence of metal in limnic phosphate deposits al-
though significant enrichments of trace metals, e.g. of uranium, arsenic and cad-
mium have been found in marine phosphate deposits (Altschuler et aI., 1978). By
EDAX-analysis Jaquet (priv. comm.) has found characteristic enrichment of Fe,
Co, Cu, Zn (and probably Pb) in spherical phosphate aggregates in sediments from
Lake Geneva in the immediate neighbourhood of a sewage outfall.
High positive correlation between the contents of organic matter and heavy
metal concentrations may be interpreted as being due to direct bonding of heavy
metals to organic substances with some exceptions (Forstner, 1977). For instance
in deep-water sediments from Perch Lake in Lanark County, Ontario, Jonasson
(1976) found that gelatinous colloidal substances, which are formed from dissolved
organic acids, spores, pollen and decayed leaves, take up metal ions from water.
Similar effects have been observed by Tobschall et ai. (1978) from gels and sedi-
ments in subarctic lakes in northern Norway. In the latter example the heavy
metals, Ni, Cu, Zn, Pb, Hg, Th and U were enriched in the organic gels by factors
of2 to 500 in comparison to concentrations in the organic sediment. It may be con-
cluded, therefore, that organic substances - although not in long-term accumula-
tive phases - perform a major function in the transfer of metals between mineral
wim.salomons@home.nl
Trace Metal Fluxes as Reflected in the Sediments 185
Lake sediments reflect the history of metal pollution and the study of metal con-
centrations along profiles has extensively been used to elucidate the pollution his-
tory oflakes (Forstner and Wittmann, 1979). An example of such a study is shown
in Fig. 93.
This example is of the central basin of Lake Erie near Cleveland, Ohio at the
mouth of ·the Cuyahoga River and seems to be representative of a moderate pol-
lution in that area (Walters et a1., 1974). According to the distribution of mercury
in the sedimentary record, early industrial activity might have taken place begin-
ning in about 1835. Major increases in the values of zinc, arsenic and copper during
1939-1955 reflect the general growth of industry during World War II and the
Korean conflict. Strong enrichment of chromium and other metals occurred dur-
ing the late 1940's which corresponds for the most part to the growth of the Cleve-
land electroplating industry. It is assumed that the establishment of chemical
plants in the Cleveland area caused a characteristic increase in the Hg concen-
trations of the river sediments in 1949. The major break in 1955 would then cor-
respond to the opening of the Detrex chlorine-alkali plant near Ashtabula, Ohio
(Walters et a1., 1974).
Evaluation of both geochemical and civilizational input of metals into aquatic
sediments is more and more frequently established by means of flux calculations.
The sedimentary flux of any metal may be calculated by the formula (Hamilton-
Taylor, 1979):
F = R(l-4» (! . C [Ilg - cm - 2 . yr - 1].
where R is the sedimentation rate (cm/yr), 4> the porosity, y the dry density of the
sediment (g/cm - 3) and C is the metall concentration (in mg/kg). An important
requirement for the determination of these data is the extraction of undisturbed
sediment core samples and accurate dating (best with the Pb-210 method,
Chap. 2.3).
Nriagu et a1. (1979) give an example of such an investigation in this case on
Lake Erie. A comparison of natural and anthropogenic fluxes for the three partial
lake basins is of note (Table 53): the present flux of metals to the sediments is cal-
culated as the product of sedimentation rates and metal concentrations in the top
1.0 cm layer. The anthropogenic component was derived by substracting the pre-
colonial flux (below the ambrosia horizon ca. 1850 AD) from the total elemental
flux to the surficial sediments. Because of the higher overall sedimentation rates
the average anthropogenic flux of metals into the Eastern Basin sediments is higher
than those entering the other two lake basins. As shown in Table 54 the anthropo-
genic input of zinc, lead and cadmium into the Western Basins exceeds that for pre-
colonial sediments five fold, whereas in the central and Eastern Basins the anthro-
pogenic fluxes of these metals are approx. two to three times greater than the nat-
ural inputs. Metal pollution in Lake Erie originates from tributary inflow, coastal
wim.salomons@home.nl
LAKE ERIE (near Cleveland) 00
0\
-
Hg Zn As Cu Ni Cr
0.2 0.6 ppm 10 20 30 2 3 20 40 60 40 60 80 20 40 60 ppm
o I ... ..', ... .'. I L ••.• .' ..•• .Ie .....c...: I••••• ! ...."""""""= I •••• .' •••••
C:: F_._._._.J_._._._._.~._._._._._'._. LOIiii [ •.•.•.•.•.'•.•.•.•.• .1......... I
20
40
60
em
wim.salomons@home.nl
Fig. 93. History of metal pollution of Lake Erie as reflected in its sediments (Walters et aI., 1974)
~
CI>
e.
'"
::i"
(')
o
E!-
5'
CI>
::>
e.
~
a
CI>
;;l
Trace Metal Fluxes as Reflected in the Sediments 187
Table 53. Inventory of sources and sinks of heavy metals in Lake Erie and their residence times
(N riagu et aI., 1979)
wim.salomons@home.nl
I 00
00
mg Mg g-1 ~g Cu g-1 I.lg Pb g-1 I.lg Zn g-1
I
ng Hg g-1 mg P g-1
-
Minerals %
14 16 18 50 100 150 50 100 200 300 500 1000 90 94 98
E
t)
&.
0.
~ 50
Fig.94. Metal concentrations along sediment cores in Lough Neagh (North Ireland).
(Rippey et aI., 1982)
wim.salomons@home.nl
~
~
:or
()
o
a
s·
o
::l
E.
~
~
Metal Cycling in Lakes 189
Table 54. Selection of data on the sedimentary fluxes in lakes. The Lake Huron and Ontario data
are from Kemp and Thomas (1976), the Lake Erie data from Nriagu et al. (1979), the Loch Neagh
data from Rippey et al. (1981), the Woodhull Lake data from Galloway and Likens (1979) and the
Windermere data from Hamilton-Taylor (1979)
Lake Cr Ni Cu Zn Cd Hg Pb V
mgm- 2 a-I
Lake Huron:
Anthropogenic 2 - 14 7 - 57 0 -D.05 8 - 42
Natural 4 - 8 12 - 17 0.01-D.04 5 - 8
Lake Ontario:
Anthropogenic 22 - 33 109 -217 0.9-3 0.20-1.4 62 -169
Natural 13 -17 29 - 48 0.3-D.4 0.01-D.05 8 - 12
Lake Erie:
Anthropogenic 1.5-120 10 -362 0.1-5.4 - 2 -118
Natural 5.9- 78 6.8-148 0.1-1.6 - 3.8- 43
Lake Neagh:
Anthropogenic 84 58 61 164 1.8 0.5 72
Natural 61 56 15 47 1.2 0.08 12
Atmospheric 3 8 23 75 0.3 27
Woodhull Lake:
Anthropogenic 11 6.3 65 1.2 56 12.6
Natural 1.1 2.7 11 0.05 5.4 5.4
Atmospheric 3.6 13 50 1.2 25 16
Windermere:
Anthropogenic 18 169 0.49 99
Natural 12 75 0.05 26
Atmospheric 32 120 <0.24 55
mospheric flux could be a significant component for Cu, Zn, Hg and Pb in this
area (Table 54).
wim.salomons@home.nl
190 Metals in Continental Waters
Table 55. Fluvial and atmospheric input of some trace metals (tonsjyr) in the I1sselmeer (Salomons,
1983)
As Cd Cr Cu Ni Zn
Table 56. Mean metal concentrations in bottom deposits of the I1sselmeer (corrected for grain size
differences; metal concentrations refer to 50% 16 11m (see Chap. 3.5)
P Al Ni Zn Cu Cr Pb Cd Hg
% % Ilgjg
Table 57. Mean concentrations (based on monthly measurements in 1978) of dissolved metal con-
centrations and metal concentrations in the suspended matter in 11 sselmeer (Salomons, 1983)
Zn Cu Cr Cd Ni As pH
Zn Cu Cr Cd Ni As Mn
consequence of reclaiming parts of the lake. The present surface area is 1250 km 2
which makes it the largest lake in Western Europe. Its main source of pollutants
is the river 11 ssel, a distributary of the river Rhine which carries about 10% of its
pollutant load into the lake. Other sources include the input from the atmosphere.
However, compared with the fluvial input the input from the atmosphere is low
(Table 55).
The Rhine has been polluted with heavy metals since the early part of this cen-
tury (Fig. 87), thus the I1sselmeer has been subject to a increased metal input for
more than 50 years, and large amounts of trace metals have accumulatedd in the
bottom sediments. Especially the the mouthing area of the river I1ssel (Ketelmeer,
Fig. 130), is heavily polluted with trace metals (Table 56).
The increases in chromium and nickel are relatively minor or absent, this is be-
cause these metals are relative "newcomers" in the metal pollution of the river
Rhine (Fig. 87).
wim.salomons@home.nl
Metal Cycling in Lakes 191
The IJsselmeer is a well mixed reservoir. Its shallow depth of 4 m allows an easy
resuspension of the deposited sediments with an intensive mixing of recent and
older deposits. During stormy periods suspended matter concentrations of several
grams per litre are observed (Salomons and Eysink, 1981).
A five year study has been carried out in this lake (1977-1982) to identify and
quantify the processes which affect the dissolved and particulate metal concen-
trations. Jointly with this geochemical study a biological study was carried out
(Marquenie, 1981) to determine the relative importance of the various reservoirs
of trace metals (e.g. deposited sediments, suspended matter, dissolved metals and
metals in the pore waters).
With the exception of manganese all particulate metal concentrations in the wa-
ter leaving the lake are lower than in the river IJssel (Table 57). Dissolved metal
concentrations, with the exception of arsenic, are also lower than in the river IJssel;
e.g. the removal of dissolved metals does not cause an increase in particulate metal
concentrations in the lake. The changes in particulate and dissolved metal concen-
trations are directly or indirectly determined by the carbon cycle in the lake. Its in-
fluence is threefold:
9
x
x
pH x
x xx
x
x
8
X X
x x
Zn
20
X+observed
(.119/1) .+calculated
x
•
x
10
• •
Fig. 95. Seasonal cycles in pH and dissolved zinc con-
••
X X •
~,..
x.
centrations in the IJsselmeer. The calculated values
were obtained from a simple black box calculation
with adsorption as the only process. (Salomons, 1983) J A J 0
wim.salomons@home.nl
192 Metals in Continental Waters
Table 58. Mean metal concentrations in algae from the I1sselmeer and the Haringvliet (corrected for
admixtures of inorganic suspended matter), compared with the concentrations in the suspended
matter
Zn Cu Cr Pb Cd Ni Mn
I1g/g
Table 59. Dissolved concentrations in the pore waters of the 2 cm top layer
of the sediments and the theoretical flux from the sediment to the overlying
waters in the I1sselmeer. Fluxes of zinc, copper and nickel are small or absent
Cr 6.3 0.6 8
Cd 1.2 <0.2 1.4
As 21 0.9 28
Fe 21,000 20 33,000
Mn 9,160 50 13,000
P 5,380 145 7,000
wim.salomons@home.nl
Metal Cycling in Lakes 193
o 50 % 100
zinc!lillllllll!III!!IIIIIIIII!llllillllllll!111111111II1I
Fig.96. Fate of dissolved cadmium, zinc, chromium and copper in the IJsselmeer. (Salomons and
Mook,1980)
Thus the production of authigenous phases in the lake causes a decrease in par-
ticulate metal concentrations by dilution. The pH increase causes a removal of
those trace metals, whose adsorption depends on the pH over the range (7.4 to 9)
observed in the Usselmeer. However, the increase in particulate metal concen-
trations due to adsorption is offset by the dilution effects.
A balance calculation showed that adsorption processes are mainly responsible
for the removal of cadmium, zinc and chromium, whereas copper, whose adsorp-
tion characteristics do not depend on the pH over the range observed in the Ussel,
is hardly removed through physical adsorption processes (Fig. 96).
A second major factor which influences metal concentrations in the lake is the
bottom sediments. After deposition of the suspended matter, diagenetic processes
take place, causing a release of trace metals to the pore waters (see also Sect. 3.7).
Concentrations in the pore waters are high for manganese, iron and arsenic
(Table 59).
A simple flux calculation showed that the pore waters are able to release signif-
icant quantities of these three elements to the surface waters. Iron is known to pre-
cipitate in the surface oxidised layers in the sediments, however the oxidation of
manganese is much slower, and manganese is able to enter the surface waters,
where it precipitates/adsorbs on the suspended matter, causing the high particulate
manganese concentrations. Also arsenic is released to the pore waters. The adsorp-
tion of arsenic on sediments depends strongly on the pH (Pierce and Moore, 1982),
with maximum adsorption (on iron hydroxides) at pH values of about 8. The ar-
senic from the pore waters (PH 7 and lower) enters high pH surface waters (pH 9),
as a consequence little adsorption is expected to take place. The data on arsenic,
manganese and iron suggest that their concentrations are determined strongly by
kinetic processes and by the particular conditions in the lake (e.g. for arsenic the
pH in the pore waters and in the surface waters are shifted from the optimum ad-
sorption conditions).
wim.salomons@home.nl
194 Metals in Continental Waters
% Zn Cr % r
r r
Cu Cd
50 50 Zn
~ Cr
Cd /.
/'
0 ~ ~ 0 ~ h ~
Fig. 97. Balance calculation for the IJ sselmeer
suspended
matter
Zn -338 -166
_150.000 , -285.000 ---350 ---47
315.000 1472
water water t
sediment:::··· .
Fe Cu
-6000 -4588 _44.5 _14.2
---250 ---140 ---40.7 - --21.7
~1535 !47.3
Mn Cr
_318 _1097 -97.3 _41.3
---660 ---280 ---15.5 ---3.0
t400
I
~67.6
P
-1133
---3586
J1852
- Cd
-6.7
---4.7
'6.9_9.1
-1.3
---0_2.2
::;:::::::::::;:::::::;:;:;:;:::;:::::::::::;:::;:;:;:::::;:::::.:......
Hg Ni
-0.95 _0.34 _13.3 _13.3
---0_1.1 ---0_1.1 --_69.8 ---47.3
JO.61 , 16.7
As
- part iculate -5.2 -5.8
---8.3 ---1D.4
- -_ dis sol v e d t1.8
I
Fig. 98. Particulate and dissolved metal concentrations in the waters leaving the Haringviet and the IJs-
selmeer to the North Sea expressed as percentages of the concentrations in the incoming waters.
(Salomons, 1981)
wim.salomons@home.nl
Metal Cycling in Lakes 195
Balance calculations on the amount of metals entering the lake and by the river
Ussel and leaving the lake to the Wadden Sea showed that the lake acts as a sink
for copper, zinc, cadmium, chromium, mercury and nickel but as a major source
for manganese and arsenic (Fig. 97).
The Haringvliet lake in the Netherlands (see Fig. l30) was created in 1970 and
is fed by both the highly polluted rivers Rhine and Meuse. About 50% of the total
pollutant load of these two rivers enters this freshwater lake. The metal concen-
trations in the suspended matter and in solution leaving this lake through the
sluices, however, is different from that in the Usselmeer (Fig. 98). Both the particu-
late and dissolved metal concentrations in the Haringvliet are much higher.
This reflects differences in hydrodynamic and geochemical conditions in this
lake. The Haringviet is deep, thus the resuspension oflow metal containing bottom
sediments is almost absent. The residence time of the water is in the order of weeks,
much less than that of the six months in the Usselmeer. Fewer algal blooms are
observed, with a resulting smaller production of organic matter. The pH also does
not reach values much higher than 8 and no calcium carbonate precipitation takes
place. The smaller production of low metal authigenous material causes less dilu-
tion of the metal concentrations in the fluvial suspended matter. Finally, the rather
low pH causes less removal of dissolved trace metals by adsorption processes, thus
dissolved metal concentrations stay high.
The removal of dissolved trace metals from solution is also reflected in metal
uptake by the bivalve Dreissena polymorpha (Fig. 99). Between Lobith and Kam-
pen (river Rhine and river Ussel) the pH increases slightly, affecting the distribu-
tion of dissolved cadmium over the dissolved and particulate phase (e.g. the dis-
solved metal concentrations decrease and those in the suspended matter increase).
Rhine
100
so
so
Fig. 99. Cadmium accumulation by B
Dreissena Polymorpha (Marquenie,
1981), compared with changes in dis-
particulate
solved and particulate metal concen-
trations in the river Rhine, its distribu·
100
tary the river IJssel and in the IJssel-
meer (Salomons et aI., 1982)
wim.salomons@home.nl
196 Metals in Continental Waters
%
Fig. 100. Removal of di solved
r- and particulate trace metals In
la ke Alpnach (Baccini 1976)
80
60
- -
-
40 r- -
20
DO issolved
Fe Cu
11
Zn
n~ Cd Pb
010131
Although the total cadmium burden of the organism stays constant, the actual up-
take decreases, showing that dissolved trace metal fractions are more bioavailable
than the particulate forms.
In contrast to the extensive removal of a number of dissolved trace metals in
the Usselmeer, far less removal of dissolved metals has been observed from lake
Alpnach (Fig. 100).
The metal input in this lake is also predominantly by rivers. While iron is re-
tained almost completely, nearly 50% of the copper, zinc and cadmium is trans-
ported further. A comparison of the dissolved parts (Fig. 100) shows that copper
and cadmium are retained only to a small extent, zinc is retained for about 40%.
Temporal variations in metal distribution in the three phases - biomass, allochton-
ous particulate and dissolved phase, were calculated in a model in which particu-
late iron serves as an indicator for the allochthonous particulate material phase and
particulate organic nitrogen for the biomass phase. The major conclusions from
this simulation were:
- copper and zinc introduced in solution form are partly taken up by algae and
settle as part of the particulate organic matter to the bottom. The biogenic por-
tion of the total concentration varies between 5 and 15% for copper and 5 and
20% for zinc.
- the decomposition of the particulate organic matter during settling permits a
partial return of the metals to solution and the amount in the solution phase rises
in the hypolymnion (Fig. 101).
- the allochthonous particles are deposited on the lake bottom relatively un-
changed.
However, in contrast to the results from the Usselmeer study and from studies
in estuaries (see Chap. 6.7), adsorption plays a minor role in the removal of trace
metals from solution in Lake Alpnach; this lake does not act as a major sink for
dissolved copper and zinc.
In a laboratory study (Baccini et ai., 1982), the adsorption properties of sedi-
ment particles from Swiss lakes were compared with those of y-aluminium oxide
wim.salomons@home.nl
Metal Cycling in Lakes 197
EPILIMNION HYPOLIMNION
2.5-10m (depth) 25- 55m (depth)
J J D
%
80
60
40 mil Biomass
• Allochthonous particulates
I I
20 D Dissolved phase
Fig. lOt. Simulated seasonal variations of copper concentrations in biomass, allochthonous particles
and water of the Lake Alpnach. (Baccini, 1976)
100 b 100
tfl j 100
:g
..,c...
&.
150 I
0 150
II
1>0 150
I II
to
;\
200 0 200 200
I
250
0
I
250
1>0
250
9'"
o total
I>filtered
Fig. 102. Profiles for trace metals in the Bodensee (Sigg et aI., 1982)
in the presence of natural organic matter (NOM). Under natural lake conditions
the adsorption of copper, zinc and phosphate was reduced significantly by the pres-
ence of natural organic matter. It was postulated that the binding sites of mineral
surfaces are occupied almost completely by NOM under natural conditions, pre-
venting other ions being adsorbed. Differences in adsorption by zinc and copper
could be explained by differences in speciation due to the presence of NOM. These
experiments confirmed the field observations that allochthonous particles in Swiss
lakes are not very efficient scavengers while passing through the water column.
The first profiles of dissolved and particulate trace metal concentrations in deep
lakes have recently been obtained for the Bodensee (Germany) (Sigg et aI., 1982).
The results for cadmium, lead and copper are presented in Fig. 102.
wim.salomons@home.nl
198 Metals in Continental Waters
Table 60. Inputs, deposition rates and concentrations of heavy metals in the Bodensee compared with
the North Atlantic Ocean (Sigg et aI., 1982)
Cu Pb Cd Zn
Bodensee
Atmospheric input} _ 2/ 714 11,000 20 8,400
Deposition ng cm y 6,500 9,500 100 36,000
Concentrations in the lake ng/I 300-800 50-100 6- 20 1,000-4,000
North Atlantic
Atmospheric
. .input'
. } ngcm -2/ y 25 310 130
VertIcal transItIOnal flux 234 330 1,040
Concentrations in the ocean ng/l 100 3 10 100
(30-300) (1- 15) (1-120) (10- 6(0)
The results are similar to profiles obtained for ocean systems: a removal of trace
metals in the surface layers by biological activity and partial decomposition during
settling of the authigenous particles to the bottom (compare with Fig. 135). How-
ever, for the Bodensee, the high atmospheric input results in high levels of copper
and lead in surface layers. Although the input of trace metals in lakes are one or
two orders of magnitude higher than that of the oceans (Table 60), the metal con-
centrations are of the same order of magnitude. Therefore apparently highly effi-
cient removal processes are operating in lakes (Sigg et ai., 1982).
wim.salomons@home.nl
Metals Cycling in Stratified Lakes 199
m sand
~.~~ ... a ..
b
m clay
~ carbonate
fl!!lil!I marl
_ bituminous, shale
Fig. 103. a-il. F ormation and evolution of stratified waters. (Degens and Stoffers, 1976)
Metals, most notably those that are affected by changes in Eh/pH conditions,
may become concentrated or removed from the water column or sediment-water
interface. This pertains mainly to the behaviour of iron and manganese, however
as these scavenge other ions in their hydrate, oxide and hydroxide forms, this af-
fects the distribution of trace elements as well (see Chap. 2.5).
Metal behaviour in lakes which exhibit a pronounced stratification with anoxic
conditions in the hypolymnion are complicated as is shown by a number of recent
studies (Baccini and JoIler, 1981; Davison, 1981; Davison et aI., 1981; Sholkovitz
and Copland, 1981; Davison et aI., 1982; Davison and Woof, 1982). An analogue
of lakes with anoxic conditions in the hypolymnion is the Black Sea, which was
studied intensively in the late sixties (Spencer and Brewer, 1971; Spencer et aI.,
1972). The Black Sea is permanently stratified and does not exhibit the autumn
overturn of most freshwater bodies; as a consequence some aspects can be studied
in more detail.
The Black Sea is the world's largest anoxic basin. The surface salinity varies
from 17.2%0 to 18.3%0, the salinity of the deep water is relatively constant at 22.4%0
(Spencer et aI., 1972). Owing to the strong density gradient through the main halo-
cline, cold surface waters formed during the winter do not mix downward to great
depths as is the case for most freshwater lakes. The deep water of the Black Sea
is renewed only by Mediterranean water flowing in through the Bosporus.
Profiles of the particulate manganese, zinc and dissolved copper, zinc, cobalt,
manganese and cobalt are presented in Fig. 104.
The profiles with depth are plotted relative to oxygen zero and the stations for
particulate metals identified into "near shelf' and "far shelf' groups. The concen-
trations of dissolved manganese and iron in the deep water exceed those in the sur-
face waters, which is attributed to the greater solubility of the sulfides and hydroxi-
des of the reduced species as compared with the solubility of hydroxides and oxides
of the oxidized species (Spencer and Brewer, 1971).
The concentrations of copper and zinc are depleted in the deep water by pre-
cipitation as insoluble sulfides. This precipitation of zinc starts below the oxygen
zero boundary and reaches maximum values of 2322 ng/kg at 35 m below the
boundary. Manganese is precipitated in the oxic layers above the boundaries, sug-
gesting an upward flux of dissolved manganese by diffusive and advective flow;
concentrations increase from less than 1 Ilg/kg to about 450 Ilg/kg at 30-40 m
above the oxygen zero boundary. The lack of a peak in the particulate zinc profile
wim.salomons@home.nl
200 Metals in Continental Waters
....~
-Flo'.
1 2 3 4 5 6 ~g/kg 1 2 3 4 5 6 ~g/k9
Ii!
III
II:
-200
.
l!!
..
I o o
-200 ••
~
~
~
o
-500 -500
..
•
-1000 -1000
-1500 -1500
,
-2000 Zn -2000 • Cu
Fig. 104. Profiles of dissolved copper, zinc, cobalt, and manganese in the Black Sea. (Spencer and
Brewer, 1971; Spencer et aI., 1972)
wim.salomons@home.nl
Metals Cycling in Stratified Lakes 201
- the presence of detrital silicate particles (Sc, La and partly iron) which is also
controlled by the other three processes;
- precipitation as sulfides in anoxic deep waters (Zn and Cu);
- coprecipitation with or adsorption by particulate manganese which is being
formed above the oxygen zero boundary (Co and Sb);
- concentration by marine organisms in the surface waters.
Processes in lakes may be different due to the fact that the salinity in the Black
Sea is higher and that lakes are subject to annual turnovers and the Black Sea is
not. In fact the present day salinity conditions in the Black Sea were established
about 3000 years ago (Spencer and Brewer, 1971).
Baccini and Joller (1981) studied the transport processes of copper and zinc in
the highly eutrophic and stratified lake Baldegg; this lake is, like the Black Sea,
characterised by a permanent anaerobic hypolimnion (Fig. 105).
The lake is in an anaerobic state all year (Fig. 105A). During spring the in-
creased oxygen flux into the hypolimnion causes a decrease in dissolved manganese
(Fig. 105B) and dissolved iron (Fig. lOSC). With increasing reducing conditions,
the redissolution of manganese starts in April and of iron in May. Large differences
in the behaviour of dissolved copper and zinc are observed. Zinc decreases in the
summer period and does not show a distinct variation with depth. Dissolved cop-
per on the other hand is higher in the epilimnion than in the hypolimnion. Further-
more particulate zinc does not show much variation with depth whereas particulate
copper concentrations increase with depth.
The authors offered the following transport processes as an explanation for
these variations: Both copper and zinc are removed from solution by the biomass
in the epilimnion. The metals removed from solution by the biomass are partly
mineralised during settling to the bottom. However, copper is additionally being
sorbed on the newly formed iron particles in the upper hypolimnion, causing an
increase in particulate copper, which is sedimented. (see also the general scheme
of lake processes in Fig. 92). Laboratory experiments showed that neither of the
other newly formed particles in the lake (calcium carbonate and manganese hy-
droxides) adsorb/coprecipitate under the conditions observed in Lake Baldegg.
However, the iron hydroxides are able to remove copper from solution (not zinc).
An empirical one diffusion-dimensional diffusion model was able to simulate the
observed copper profiles in the hypolimnion (Baccini and J oller, 1981).
A well studied lake with a seasonally anoxic hypolimnion is Esthwaite Water
(English Lake District). The particulate chemistry in this lake is controlled by three
biogeochemical cycles (Sholkovitz and Copland, 1981):
- The activity of phytoplankton in spring and summer results in the in situ gener-
ation oflarge excess concentrations ofP, S, Mg, Ba and K in the epilimnion.
- As the hypolimnion becomes anoxic, the release of ferrous iron from sediments
results in the formation of particulate iron hydroxides which scavenge by ad-
sorption and/or co-precipitation of S, P, Ca, Ba and K, and particulate organic
carbon (POC) from solution. The concentrations of these components follows
that of the excess particulate iron. As reducing conditions become more intense,
the iron hydroxide particles are solubilized along with the above mentioned
components.
wim.salomons@home.nl
202 Metals in Continental Waters
1-
0. S (mllll) d~n (10- 8 MIll
A B
d-Fe (10- 8 MI l) d-Cu (10- 0 MI ll
c D
p-Cu (10- 0 Mi ll p-Zn (10- 8 MI ll
E F
Fig. 105. Isolaths of oxygen and sulfide (A), dissolved manganese (B), dissolved iron (C), dissolved
copper (D), particulate copper (E) and particulate zinc (F) (Baccini and Joller, 1981)
- The anoxic conditions induce a large build-up of bacteria populations and in the
last stage of anoxia (before turn-over) bacteria supported POC and excess P,
Mg, Ca and K appear to become important components in the hypolimnion.
The flux of iron and manganese to the sediments in Esthwaite Water was stud-
ied by Davison et al. (1982) using sediment traps. The iron cycle is similar to that
found in the formerly discussed Lake Baldegg. During winter most of the iron and
manganese which flows into the lake is transported to the sediment. However, in
summer there is a vertical transport offerrous iron from the sediment (see also Fig.
92) by eddy diffusion, an oxidation to Fe(III) by oxygen, sinking of the particulate
iron and redissolution in the anoxic hypolimnion. The manganese cycle differs to
wim.salomons@home.nl
Atmospheric Inputs in Lakes 203
a large extent from the iron cycle. In winter, the manganese reaching the sediment
is rapidly reduced and is released to the overlying oxic waters. Only about 10% ac-
cumulates in the sediment. During summer the particulate manganese never
reaches the sediment, since it become redissolved in the anoxic hypolimnion. Near-
ly all manganese which enters the lake is washed out again; however, during its resi-
dence time in the lake it will have undergone a redox cycle (Davison et al., 1982)
However, not in all lakes with anoxic conditions in the hypolimnion an iron
cycle as described for Esthwaite Water and Lake Baldegg is observed. Davison and
Woof (1982) found in the hypolimnion of Rostherne Mere a complete removal of
oxygen and accumulation of Mn(II) for five months during the summer period.
However, both ferrous iron and dissolved sulfide were absent. They suggested that
this is due to the high concentrations of nitrate observed in the lake. The reduction
of ferric to ferrous iron usually only occurs after all the nitrate in the system has
been consumed (see Chap. 3.7). Their study showed convincingly that deoxygena-
tion of water above an active reducing sediment can be insufficient to ensure release
of iron or sulfide from the sediment. Rostherne Mere appears to be a finely poised
system which shows manganese reduction and the initial stages of denitrification.
The importance of the atmospheric input of trace metals in lakes is clearly shown
by the data in Table 54. A characteristic example depicts the atmospheric input of
trace metals in lake Michigan compared with a number of other sources in Fig. 106
(Eisenreich, 1980).
The atmospheric loading is especially important for lead (60%) and is a signif-
icant source for zinc (33%), for copper it contributes 13% and for cadmium and
manganese 11 %. The atmosphere is a minor source for aluminium, iron and co-
balt.
This correlates with the data of Sieve ring et al. (1980; 1981) who have studied
the input of atmospheric trace metals over Lake Michigan in detail (see also Win-
chester and Nifong, 1971; Gatz, 1975). Calcium and magnesium are for more than
90% lake derived and aluminium almost entirely soil derived. It is estimated that
Pb Zn Cu Mn Cd AI Co
D Atmosphere 100
f
D Tributary
I
f
f
f
f
f
D Erosion % I
I
I
I I
I
I
I
Fig. 106. Relative importance of the I
wim.salomons@home.nl
204 Metals in Continental Waters
Al 550
Ca 2,000
Fe 1,100 950 1,450
Mg 700
Mn 60 55 450
Pb 500 90 100
Zn 200 50 180
over 95% of the lead, 75% of the zinc and manganese and more than 50% of iron
are of anthropogenic origin (Sievering et ai., 1980).
Sievering et ai., 1981 compared the dry deposition loading with wet precipita-
tion and surface runoff (Table 61):
They found that the atmospheric input by dry deposition contributes 75% of
the total loading for Pb and 50% for the total loading of zinc to the lake ecosystem.
The interaction between the dry deposition and the lake waters is highly complex
due to processes in the surface micro layer (see Chap. 4.6.3.2). Moreover part of the
particles are highly soluble, and contribute in this way to the dissolved trace metal
loading of the lake.
The acidic deposition from the atmosphere affects the pH of soft water lakes.
Thousands of lakes and streams in southern Scandinavia and eastern North
America and Canada are affected by it; fish populations are lost and other vital
ecosystem components and processes are disturbed. With regard to heavy metal
behaviour three processes can be distinguished:
- the increased leaching of trace metals from soils in the drainage basin causing
elevated metal concentrations in the receiving waters;
- the changes in the distribution of trace metals over the particulate and dissolved
phase in lakes (e.g. more trace metals will be leached from atmospheric particu-
lates entering the lake);
- and the active leaching of trace metals from sediments in the lake.
Changes in pH affect the distribution of trace metals over the dissolved and
particulate phase (see Chap. 2.4.1); however, the actual changes in the lake depend
to a large extent on its buffering capacity. Kramer (1976) used the carbonate
alkalinity of lakes to access their susceptibility to acid input. In Fig. 107 this clas-
sification is superimposed on the relationship between pH and alkalinity for Min-
nesota and northern Wisconsin lakes (Glass et ai., 1980).
Also shown in Fig. 107 is the relationship between adsorption of trace metals
on silica and the pH. This shows that only a small shift in pH can cause a large
shift in adsorption equilibria.
wim.salomons@home.nl
Atmospheric Inputs in Lakes 205
pH
9.0 r - - - - - - , - - - - - - - r - - - - , - - - - - , - - - - - - - ,
NOT SUSCEPTIBLE
8.5 POTENTIALLY SUSCEPTIBLE
.. ' . .'. -.. ,. .
SUSCEPTIBLE
8.0
•• 0·... ;. :::. . 0
• • ••- 0·. •• • 0 •
Fig. 107. Relationship between pH and alkalinity in 105 northern Minnesota lakes and 350 northern
Wisconsin lakes (Glass et ai., 1980) (a), and the adsorption of trace metals on silica as a function of
the pH (b)
Cameron and Ballantyne (1975) studied the fate of dissolved lead and zinc orig-
inating from oxidizing mineral deposits during their flow in a river and lake system
in a permafrost region of northern Canada.
With an increase in pH the dissolved metal concentrations decrease and those
in the sediments increase. As is expected from Fig. 108, the reduction for lead is
stronger than for zinc. Similar observations on the distribution of trace metals over
the dissolved and particulate phase as a function of the pH have been observed for
the I1sselmeer (Netherlands) (Salomons and Mook, 1980). They found that an in-
crease of 0.5 pH units was sufficient to cause an almost complete removal of dis-
solved cadmium from river water entering the lake (see Fig. 95). In acidifying lakes
the reverse may be expected. Haines (1981) made a survey of the literature on re-
ported metal concentrations and the pH in lakes. Some of his results are presented
in Table 62.
In acidified lakes, metal concentrations are signifcantly higher than in non-
acidified lakes. Large changes are found for the dissolved manganese and alumin-
ium concentrations in particular.
In Swedish lakes a pronounced correlation was observed between dissolved
metals levels and pH in lakes (Fig. 109).
wim.salomons@home.nl
206 Metals in Continental Waters
1:11
~
.....
..
1:11
E
C
GI
1000
o~~o 0
Zn in lake sediment / "-..... ____ '\
E
:sGI \. 0 0
1/1
.5
c
100
o
/0
N
1000
..
GI 100
i
.5
g
..
:;:
~
C
GI
10
U
C
o
o
1
/e-••---.----.-
7~------------------------------------------~
5
.--.---- ........... --.-.-.
::t:
Co 3+-~------------------~~------------~ri
o 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 km
Fig. 108. Decay of zinc and lead concentrations in lake and stream water, Northwest Territories, Ca-
nada, and corresponding increase ofPb and Zn in lake sediments (from Cameron and Ballantyne, 1975;
after Rose et aI., 1979)
Al Cd Mn Zn
flg/ I
wim.salomons@home.nl
Atmospheric Inputs in Lakes 207
0.3 300
~
::::: :::::
IJI IJI
~
'0
0.2 ~200
"
CJ ~
• •
i i
.-----..-.-
0.1 100
0.05 •
<0.05
6.0 7.0 8.0
0
4.0
•8.0
4.0 5.0
----+ pH ----+ pH
.
30 5
::::: 4
IJI
:::::
~
C IJI
3
•
N 20 ~
i
4
D. 2
.. i
10 ••)-. 1
0 ~. •
4.0 5.0 6.0 7.0 8.0 5.0 6.0 7.0 8.0
----+ pH ----+ pH
Fig. 109. Metals in 16 lakes on the Swedish west coast with similar deposition but with a different pH
(Dickson, 1980)
Davis et aI., 1982 studied the influence of acidic precipitation on the release of
lead from sediments. Compared with the results on pure mineral particles (Fig. 107
B), the adsorption edges were shifted to lower pH values. Significant desorption
only occurred at pH values < 3.0 in sediments from Woods Lake and < 2.0 in sed-
iment from Lake Sagamore.
The input of acidity in lakes is not a continuous process; especially in spring
with the melting of snow large influxes are observed. Johannessen and Henriksen
(1978) showed with laboratory and lysimeter experiments that 50-80% of the pol-
lutant load is released with the first 30% of the meltwater. The average concen-
trations of pollutants in this fraction is 2-2.5 times the concentration in the snow-
pack itself. This phenomenon has been attributed to ion separation during melting
(Hultberg, 1977) or to a freeze-concentration process (Johannessen and Henriksen,
1978).
Norton et aI., (1981) in a study of New England lakes (USA) observed a de-
crease in zinc concentrations from near-recent sediment to present in lakes with pH
values < 5.5, which was explained by a leaching of zinc from the sediments by
acidic deposition. Three processes were suggested for this release:
Ion exchange:
ZnX + H + = Zn 2 + + HX (where X is a cation exchange surface)
Solution of a host (solid solution phase):
(Zn,Mn)O(OH)+H+ = Mn2+ (dominant) + Zn 2 + +e- +H 2 0.
Congruent solution of a Zn-phase:
ZnS+2H+ =Zn2+ +H 2 S
wim.salomons@home.nl
208 Metals in Continental Waters
Langtjern Hoyvata ppm
% ppm
20 40 60 80 100 50 100 150 o 20 40 60 80 100 SO 100 150
o
4 4
E E
2
:z: 8 iI-
8
ez
~ "-
w W
Zn
o 12 12
I-
Z w
w :!;
:!;
15
til
16 iii 16
<f) en
20
Langtjern % ~g / g Hovvata % ppm
1 4
E E
2 8 2 8
:z:
....
"-
til Co ~ Co
o 12 ~ 12
I-
Z
w !ztil
~ 16 ~ 16
til
<f) iiien
20 20
Lake Ramsey % ppm Lake Wavy % ppm
E
2
8 E 8
2
i=
"-
w
o
12 ~
til
12
I-
o
Z I- Ni
UJ Z
:!; 16 w 16
~
15 15
UJ
en w
(J)
20 20
Fig.BO. Historical evolution of chemical forms of trace metals in lake sediments of areas affected by
acid precipitation. Above: Zinc and cobalt in sediments of Hovvatn and Langtjern (Norway). Below:
Nickel in sediment cores from Lake Ramsey and Lake Wavy in the Sudbury mining and smelting area
(Ontario/Canada)
wim.salomons@home.nl
Atmospheric Inputs in Lakes 209
Fig. 110 (from Reuther et aI., 1981) presents data from two lakes in Southern
Norway and shows the different behaviour of zinc at different pH values. Lake
Hovvatn had before lime treatment in 1980/81 a pH of 4.4 and had been barren
of fish since the 1940's. Upon comparison with Lake Langtjern (PH 4.95) it is evi-
dent that zinc is remobilised from the upper sediment layers at that degree of acid-
ity, mainly from the easily reducible fractions (see Chap. 2.6). A significant de-
crease of the reducible fractions is also observed for cadmium, cobalt and nickel,
whereas lead and copper are affected by these changes only to a small, insignificant
degree. The fact that these effects are not discerned in Lake Langtjern indicates
that an increase in pH of half a point (0.5) may be enough to reduce the mobility
of these elements (see also insert in Fig. 107).
The impact of acid precipitation on lake sediments and the effects of metal re-
lease were studied by Nriagu et ai. (1982) and Reuther et ai. (1982) from examples
of the Sudbury area in Ontario/Canada. In the past uncontrolled open-air roasting
of copper and nickel ores released significant quantities of pollutant metals to the
air and the fumigation of the surrounding areas with the S02 - the biggest single
source of S02 of the world - had destroyed the vegetation. In 1972 a 381 m super-
stack was installed; however, in 1977 the smelters in Sudbury still emitted about
2.6 tons ofNi, 2.6 tons ofCu, 0.7 tons ofPb, 6.3 tons of Fe and 2500 tons ofS0 2
per day (Nriagu et aI., 1982). The substantial reduction in vegetation biomass
around Sudbury associated with the emission of S02 from the smelter stacks has
been well documented (Ontario Ministry of Environment, 1978); the contribution
of the laJ:ge-scale input of pollutant metals to the reduced primary production of
these lakes, however, remains to be fully assessed.
Sediment cores indicate characteristic pollution records, which are mainly af-
fected by the emissions of the Sudbury stacks. The onset of accelerated deposition
of both Ni and Cu began about 90-100 years ago in most lakes studied; the discon-
tinuation of the use of roasting beds and the building of the 170-m stack around
1923 brought a first change of the distribution of copper and nickel in the sediment
cores, followed by a sharp increase due to the expansion of the Sudbury's metal
industry in the 1950s. The maximum concentrations observed in Kelley Lake near
Sudbury include 440, 12,000 and 50,000 ppm for Cu, Ni and Cu, these are among
the highest values recorded in recent sediments anywhere. The concentration ofNi
and Cu in the surficial sediments tends to decrease with increasing distance from
Sudbury; the enrichment factors for Ni in sediments of unlimed lakes range from
2.5 for Windy (furthest from Sudbury) to 38 for Ramsey (closest to Sudbury); as
expected, considerably higher enrichment factors have been found in sediments of
lakes which have been treated with lime. The recent decrease of metal input to the
lakes in the immediate surroundings of the Sudbury smelters and the increase of
Cu and Ni in sediments of lakes further from Sudbury (Vermillion and Windy
Lakes) may be related to the installation of the superstack in 1972 (Nriagu et aI.,
1982)
In our study on the chemical forms of metals in sediments of the Sudbury area
(Reuther et aI., 1982) two examples were selected for core samples: Lake Ramsey,
within the reaches of the township of Sudbury, indicating pH-values of6 to 7 dur-
ing sampling, and Lake Wavy, 25 km southwest of Sudbury, exhibiting pH of 4.0
to 4.5 in its waters. The example of the nickel distribution demonstrates the typical
wim.salomons@home.nl
210 Metals in Continental Waters
OO~~OT~~rr~TTTr~r-~~~T-~~rr~~~~~~~~~~~
10
20 Zn Cd Pb Cu Ni Co Fe Mn Cr AI
-
.I:
1:1.
CI:I Ramsey lake
-
c
c
CI:I
E
0rr~-.r-~~~~~~~~~-r~--~~'-TT~~~-r~~-r-
AI
20
I '1
Wavy lake
Fig. HI. Contour lines of metals in sediments from Lake Ramsey and Lake Wavy
differences in the interactions of water and solid metal components as they have
developed during the last hundred years (Fig. 110): Both profiles are nearly iden-
tical in the older, pre-industrial deposits containing approx. 50% of nickel in resid-
ual fraction, 10-15% associated with organic and sulfidic phases, 35-40% in mod-
erately, and 5% in easily reducible phases. The raising input of metals shifts the
chemical form of nickel in the direction of the non-residual associations, which at
the same time are more reactive. At the climax of the metal emissions - in the 1950s
and 1960s - nearly 50% of the nickel contents exist in exchangeable form in the
sediments of Lake Ramsey; with the decrease of total Ni in these sediments since
1972 also the exchangeable components are decreasing. In Lake Wavy sediments,
on the contrary, the residually bound nickel fractions are relatively low even at
higher bulk concentrations, probably due to the enhanced remobilization at ele-
vated SOz-inputs and decreasing pH-values. According to the differences of the re-
sidual fractions in the uppermost deposits one may estimate that about 50% of the
nickel input in the solid matter of Lake Wavy has been remobilized. Similar mo-
bilities can be assumed for manganese and cobalt from the distribution curves,
whereas the contents of cadmium and zinc seem to be more stable, associated with
the solid matter, and the mobilization of Cu, Pb, Fe and Cr should only be signi-
ficant at much lower pH-values than those presently occurring in the waters of
Lake Wavy.
In Fig. III the contour lines of other metals in sediments from Lake Ramsey
and Lake Wavy are compared for the total metal concentrations. It is obvious that
also for metals other than nickel there is a distinct decrease in the upper layers of
wim.salomons@home.nl
Atmospheric Inputs in Lakes 211
the sediments from Ramsey Lake, e.g. for copper, chromium, cobalt, cadmium and
to a lesser extent for lead and zinc; the characteristic increase of the manganese
content in the uppermost layers of the deposits in Lake Ramsey possibly reflects
a change in the redox conditions, which is, however, not strong enough to affect
similar changes in iron content. The most evident feature in the metal contours of
Lake Wavy's sediments is the gradual decrease of the manganese concentrations
in the upper 20 cm; this evolution probably reflects the increasing acidity in the
lake water (as well as in the precipitation and in the contributing waters), which
also involves the interactions with sediments deeper than expected from the nickel
data (Fig. 110). It seems that the behaviour of manganese can be used as the most
sensitive indication not only for redox conditions but also for changes to increasing
acidity. Strong effects are also observed for zinc and cadmium in the core from
Lake Wavy, where the concentrations are strongly reduced in the upper layers,
whereas the concentration oflead is still increasing in this part of the sediment core.
However - as has also been stressed by Nriagu and colleagues (1982) from their
data on these and other lake examples of the Sudbury area - this documentation
that the contaminated sediments can release substantial quantities of toxic metals
to the overlying water must have interesting ramifications with regard to the lim-
nological impact of acid rain. Increased inputs of trace metals in lakes from the at-
mosphere and their subsequent incorporation in bottom deposits will affect ben-
thic organisms mainly. However, the combined input of metals and acids will affect
both benthic and pelagic organisms because the acid will cause a lowering of the
pH and metals will remain in solution and/or will be solubilized from the sediment.
wim.salomons@home.nl
6 Metals in Estuaries and Coastal Environments
6.1 Introduction
Like lakes, estuaries are ephemeral in respect to geologic time. They must be re-
garded as dynamically evolving land-forms that go through a life cycle from valley
creation, followed by the drowning phase, and ending up with the progressive
backfilling with sediments (Fairbridge, 1980). The origin of most modern estuaries
dates back to the rise of the sea level after the last Ice Age. The history of an es-
tuarine system after it has been established as a geomorphological entity is largely
determined by its sediment supply (Postma, 1967). Mass particulate balance is con-
trolled by the input to the estuary from rivers, the atmosphere and sea, as well as
by the output of substances to the ocean and to the bottom (Goldberg, 1978). Ac-
cumulation of sediment - even of fine-grained material- can take place due to pro-
tection from wave action and currents. Net shore-ward transport of suspended
matter is influenced by waves, tidal movement and a typical estuarine circulation,
the latter being caused by differences in specific gravity between river and sea water.
Compared with the behaviour of metals in the oceans or lakes, the estuarine
system is more complex and more dynamic due to the strong gradients in chemical
composition of the water, variable suspended matter concentrations and complex
hydrodynamic processes.
Time scales of estuarine processes vary by several orders of magnitude. The
residence time of metals of the Tamar Estuary is in the order of days; as a conse-
quence large daily changes in the relationships between the manganese concen-
\
FLUVIAL OR
UPPER .;
::~::;_!c__~~::{h§~~:~~
~l _
~ ~ sediment Tidal influence
transport onl, (tidal bores 0.
Salt - freshwater common)!
mixing ( brackish) - freshwater
zone
Fig. 112. Idealized map of a typical estuary showing three divisions, lower, middle and upper estuary;
the boundaries are transition zones that shift according to season, weather and tides (After Fairbridge,
1980)
wim.salomons@home.nl
Estuarine Circulation 213
trations and salinity are observed. On the other hand in the St. Lawrence Estuary
the residence time of the surface water is about four months whereas the bottom
waters may take several years to travel to the head of the estuary. It is evident that
these differences show up in processes governing the trace metal behaviour. Es-
tuaries are an important part of the hydrological cycle, since they determine the
amount of riverborne trace metals entering the coastal environment and ultimately
the deep ocean. Furthermore, estuaries are often subject to a large input of contam-
inants due the fact that industrial areas and cities are often located adjacent to
them. Therefore, a large amount of studies have been carried out on the fate of con-
taminants in the estuarine and coastal environment. Both subjects, their place in
the hydrological cycle and their function as recipients of waste loads will be dis-
cussed in this chapter.
RIVER SEA
~?\.\.//::~·;\::~:·::·~:~:;·:;·;·,;;.:oq~{~~~:;·:::··:·':.;;:: . :.....~
35
(a)
Salt wedge
30
7 ./
35
(e)
l30
I
35
Fully mixed
Fig. 113. Schematic presenta-
tion of types of estuaries. The
dots indicate sediment con-
centration and the arrows the
net water movements over ebb
and flood. (Postma, 1980).
0-35 are %0 Salinity (S) iso-
lines. For explanation see the
text
wim.salomons@home.nl
214 Metals in Estuaries and Coastal Environments
(a) Salt wedge estuary: Most or all suspended material is fluviatile and is carried
to the sea in the low salinity surface layer and does not enter the estuarine cycle
proper. If both the tidal and wave regimes in the adjacent sea are mild, a delta may
be formed, as is the case at the mouth of the Mississippi River.
(b) Partially mixed estuaries: The landward bottom flow is sufficiently strong
to move suspended sediments up the estuary until the head of the salt intrusion is
reached. This sediment may be fluviatile material that has settled from the upper
into the lower layer, but it may also be of marine origin, depending on the concen-
tration of suspended matter in the river or in the sea. There are several examples
on the Atlantic coasts of Europe and North America.
(c) Fully mixed estuary: The suspended matter is concentrated nearshore. This
occurs also for estuaries without appreciable river flow that are tidally dominated.
(d) Negative estuaries with net inflow at the surface and outward flow near the
bottom: These may form in areas where excess evaporation (arid regions) causes
high salinities in the inner section of the estuary; silt is transported by the bottom
current.
Estuaries are sinks for sediments derived from rivers but additionally from the
marine environment. An obvious reason is that estuaries offer an effective shelter
against strong waves and currents. But, in addition, water and sediment transport
mechanisms exist which actively prevent the escape of sediments. These are the
landward transport by waves, tidal movement and the estuarine circulation pattern
(Postma, 1980).
WATER DENSITY
~ WATER FLOW
-
~ ---.. --=:;.
~
-//{/'p --
SUSPENDED - MATTER
CONCENTRATION
SUSPENDED - MATTER
- - -.....-~
TRANSPORT
- -71/ / ........ \ \
t t
Fig. 114. Main features of water and sediment move-
RIVER OCEAN ment in a stratified estuary (Meade, 1972)
wim.salomons@home.nl
Estuarine Circulation 215
Suspended
Matter
•
Distance up Estuary
-0
10 c
til
<II
~
QI 0
-O.&.
.~ l-
S o~
Go.
- QI
<II
~
til
0 0.
100 80 60 40 20
Distance Above River Mouth
(K ilometers )
Fig. lIS. Example of the non-conservative behaviour of suspended matter in estuaries and the forma-
tion of a turbidity maximum at the fresh-sea water interface (Meade, 1972)
wim.salomons@home.nl
216 Metals in Estuaries and Coastal Environments
specific properties of material originating from coastal sources due to marine ero-
SIOn;
(b) The fluvial source includes materials eroded from the catchment area, oxy-
hydrates and clay minerals from weathering reactions, organic remains from
vascular plants or as humic matter;
(c) Airborne anthropogenic particulate matter constitutes an important source
locally because of the proximity of industries and urban settlements to most of the
world's major estuaries;
(d) Organic and inorganic flocculations in suspension are indicative of estuar-
ine sources as are certain authigenic minerals such as iron-phosphates and
manganese hydroxides.
While this source classification is based on modes of transport of particulate
matter, it is essential that material from anthropogenic sources be treated separate-
ly (Goldberg, 1978). This group includes metals, slag particles, tailings, fly-ash, in-
organic pigments, building materials, radionuclides, sewage and other waste par-
ticles. In "undersaturated" estuaries, most of the organic matter, whether imported
or produced in situ, is buried and preserved (or, at least is only partially decom-
posed), whereas, in "saturated" estuaries much of the organic matter is largely de-
composed within the water column.
When riverwater mixes with seawater a large number of physical and chemical pro-
cesses take place which affect the distribution of trace metals over the particulate
and dissolved phase and hence the composition of the deposited sediments.
If trace metals behave conservatively in estuaries both their particulate and dis-
solved concentrations can be calculated from the mixing ratio of marine to fluvial
components provided that the composition of the end-member remains constant
over the flushing time of the water (Loder and Reichard, 1981). Deviations from
the theoretical linear mixing curve point to processes other than simple mixing af-
fecting the trace metals (Fig. 116).
Mathematical relationships for mixing curves have been derived by Boyle et al.
(1974).
For dissolved trace metals the chlorinity or the chlorosity are more satisfactory
indices than salinity, because they are easily determined with a high degree of ac-
curacy by titration and there is little or no evidence that the halide ions show any
nonconservative behaviour during estuarine mixing (Aston, 1978). The difference
in oxygen isotopic composition of river- and seawater was first suggested by Boyle
et al. (1974) as a useful tracer for the mixing of water masses in estuaries. This
method was applied by Martin and Letolle (1979) for estuaries in France, Zaire and
India. The results show that with this method it may be possible to distinguish be-
tween more than one freshwater source during estuarine mixing. It should be
noted, however, than some rivers may exhibit seasonal changes in their oxygen
isotopic composition; the Rhine River for instance is fed mainly by rainwater dur-
wim.salomons@home.nl
Behaviour of Particulate Trace Metals during Estuarine Mixing 217
\, ", Theoretical
-..
c \, / . dilution line
.2 ,, ,
l!!
'E '"
CoO Removal"""""
=
C
c.J
"
'"
ing winter, however in spring and summer it is fed by meltwater whose isotopic
composition is different from rainwater, causing seasonal cycles in the oxygen
isotopic composition of the water (Mook, 1970).
In most studies, information on the behaviour of trace metals has been derived
from the mixing curve depicting the relationship between dissolved constituents.
In principle however, these observations should be confirmed by analysis of the
particulate components (e.g. losses from the dissolved phase should show up as ele-
vated levels in the particulate concentrations). However, the salinity cannot be
used to determine the mixing ratio of marine to fluvial sediments (Fig. 114 and Fig.
115), and due to a lack of suitable tracers for particulates in estuaries, this approach
has seldom been applied (Salomons and Mook, 1977; Eisma et ai., 1978; Salomons
and Eysink, 1981).
wim.salomons@home.nl
218 Metals in Estuaries and Coastal Environments
Mineralogy
Calcite/dolomite ratio Rhine, Ems Estuary Salomons (1975)
Heavy minerals Yaquine Bay, Oregon Byrne and Kulm (1967)
Clay mineralogy Estuaries US East Coast Hathaway (1972)
Gulf of Mexico Holmes (1982)
Elemental composition
Strontium content of carbonate Rhine, Ems Estuary Salomons (1975)
fraction Biogenic/terrigenous
material deep-sea sediments Parra et al. (1981)
Boron content Freshwater-marine sediments Harder (1970)
Trace elements in quartz Provenance studies sedimentary Dennen (1967)
rocks and sands Herrera and Heurtebise (1974)
Fe/Ti and Fe/Zn ratios Chesapeake Bay particulates Eaton et al. (1980)
B, Cr, Ga, Ni, V Marine and freshwater muds Shimp et al. (1969)
CS,Eu,La, Ta, Th, Yb North Sea, ScheIdt Estuary Salomons et aI. (1978);
Salomons (1978)
Silicones New York Bight Pellenbarg (1979)
Barium (from drilling mud) Gulf of Mexico Holmes (1982)
Isotopic composition
Organic matter ScheIdt, Ems, Rhine Estuary Salomons and Mook (1981)
St. Lawrence Estuary Tan and Strain (1979)
Estuaries of the Gulf of Mexico Schultz and Calder (1976)
Gironde Estuary Fontugne and Jouanneau
(1981)
Carbonates Rhine, Ems, Scheidt Estuary Salomons (1975); Salomons
and Mook (1977);
Salomons and Eysink (1981)
Clay minerals Rhine Estuary Salomons et aI. (1975)
Strontium isotopic composition Rio de la Plata Biscaye (1972)
of carbonate free sediment
Quartz Sands Savin and Epstein (1970)
wim.salomons@home.nl
Behaviour of Particulate Trace Metals during Estuarine Mixing 219
trations between riverine and marine sediments are large) precludes its use as a
tracer for Rhine sediments. However, in an unpolluted estuary, provided that the
other criteria of conservative behaviour are met, it may be useful as a tracer.
During transport differential settling/flocculation of minerals may take place.
This differential segregation is important for some estuaries and delta systems
(Edzwald and O'Melia, 1975; Gibbs, 1977). From a study in lateral variations of
clay mineral assemblages in modem and ancient sediments (Parham, 1966) it was
found that kaolinite settles first followed by illite, chlorite, attapulgite and sepi-
olite. Thus, in estuaries and deltas with differential settling processes, the mineral-
ogy of the sediments cannot be used as a tracer. Also if certain elements are associ-
ated with these particular clay fractions, they also cannot be used for tracer studies.
Although Gibbs (1977) found some evidence for selective transport of clay min-
erals from the Amazon along a distance of ca 1400 km along the north coast of
South America, the observed compositional change is small as compared with the
compositional difference between Amazon mud and Orinoco mud so that the clay
mineral composition could be used as an indicator for sediment sources in the
Orinoco Estuary (Eisma et aI., 1978).
If deposited sediments are used for transport studies, the tracer should also
show conservative behaviour after depositon. Notably iron, manganese and phos-
phorus are subject to large diagenetic changes in their concentrations, which results
in enrichment in the surface layer of the sediments. Therefore, care should be taken
in sampling deposited sediments for transport studies.
In carrying out transport studies it should be known if the conclusions based
on one tracer may be extrapolated to the whole sediments; for instance heavy min-
erals which, due to their high specific gravity, behave hydrodynamically differently
from the main mass of the sediment. Therefore conclusions based on heavy mineral
studies, or conclusions based on elements which are known to be concentrated in
heavy minerals, may not be extrapolated to the origin of the sediment as a whole.
The best tracers in our opinion are tracers which provide answers regarding the
origin of the individual minerals making up the sediments. Into this category be-
long the calcite/dolomite ratio, the Sr-content of the carbonates and the isotopic
composition of the carbonates, which give direct answers to the origin of the car-
bonate fraction. In a similar way the isotopic compositon of the clay minerals, or-
ganic matter and quartz (although no estuarine studies have been carried out on
the quartz fraction) gives answers to the origin of the sedimentary components.
Results on the mixing of marine and fluvial particulates in estuaries, as deter-
mined with the aid of natural tracers, are shown in Fig. 117.
Fig. 117 shows that the ratio of marine to fluvial mud in suspended matter is
not a simple function of salinity. The relationship shows three distinct regions. At
low salinities the percentage of fluvial mud decreases relatively quickly to about
70%0 and stays more or less constant between 5 and 15%0 salinity. The amount of
fluvial mud decreases again with salinities of 150/00 and higher. This second de-
crease coincides with a broadening of the estuary.
U sing the mixing ratio determined with the natural tracer techniques it is shown
that the metal concentrations in the sediments from the rivers Rhine and Ems could
be mainly explained by a mixing of marine and fluvial sediments (Salomons and
Mook, 1977). However, the calculated values were slightly lower than the mea-
wim.salomons@home.nl
220 Metals in Estuaries and Coastal Environments
100
0~
'C 75
:::I
E
iQ
.; 50
:S
t 25
0
0 5 10 15 20 25
--+ 5 (%0)
Fig. 117. Relationship between the percentage of fluvial matter in suspended matter from the Scheidt
estuary and salinity (Salomons and Eysink, 1981)
Leerort Haringvliet
sured concentrations, indicating the occurrence of removal processes for the dis-
solved trace metals (Table 64).
Apart from their use for the interpretation of trace metal data in estuaries,
natural tracers have great importance for the determination of the origin of
dredged material. A study in the Rotterdam harbour showed that the major mass
of the dredged material originates from the North Sea (Salomons and Eysink,
1981 ).
Compared with other trace metals, the behaviour of iron and manganese has been
rather well studied and it is possible to depict a more or less complete picture of
the processes affecting their fate in the estuarine environment.
wim.salomons@home.nl
Iron and Manganese 221
There is at present a considerable amount of field data showing that large scale
rapid removal of iron from riverwater (Fig. 122) is a general phenomenon (Shol-
kovitz, 1976; Boyle et aI., 1977; Moore et aI., 1979). Laboratory experiments using
the batch technique (Sholkovitz, 1976; Boyle et aI., 1977; Sholkovitz, 1978) as well
as experiments conducted in an estuarine mixing simulator (Bale and Morris, 1981)
confirmed the field observations. Ultra-filtration and ultra-centrifugation ex-
periments showed that iron exists as colloids stabilized by organic matter (Boyle
et aI., 1977; Moore et aI., 1979). In the Beaulieu Estuary 90% of the iron is associ-
ated with the nominal molecular weight fraction < 10 5 (Moore et aI., 1979). Sea-
water is able to neutralise the negatively charged iron-bearing colloids allowing
flocculation (Sholkovitz, 1976; Boyle et aI., 1977; Sholkovitz, 1978; Sholkovitz and
Copland, 1981). The removal of filtrable iron during estuarine mixing should not
be interpreted to mean removal from estuarine water parcels (Mayer, 1982). Lab-
oratory experiments corroborated by field measurements showed that in three
Maine (USA) estuaries neither gravity nor suspended sediments were very effective
in removing the flocculated iron from suspension, and a significant portion of the
flocculated riverine iron may escape to shelf waters (Mayer, 1982). If this non-sett-
ling of flocculated material is a general phenomenon then also trace metals re-
moved by flocculation (Sholkovitz and Copland, 1981) might remain in suspen-
sion.
Duinker and co-workers (1978; 1980; 1982a; 1982b) gave strong evidence for
the presence of two different fractions of suspended matter in estuaries. At low sus-
pended matter concentrations, a fraction with high concentrations of Cd, Zn, Cu,
Pb, Al and organic carbon was found, and a second fraction at higher suspended
matter concentrations with lower metal concentrations. However, the iron concen-
trations in the first fraction are lower than in the second one. These fractions had
different settling properties as well as being subject to different particle sorting
mechanisms within the estuary.
Manganese shows non-conservative behaviour in most estuaries with positive
deviations from the theoretical mixing curve at low salinities (Fig. 122) and nega-
tive deviations (removal) at higher salinities. In a few cases conservative behaviour
has been observed (Holliday and Liss, 1976; Moore et aI., 1979).
The deposited sediments play an essential role in biogeochemical cycling of
manganese in estuaries (Elderfield and Hepworth, 1975; Graham et aI., 1976;
Evans et aI., 1977; Sanders, 1978; Duinker et aI., 1979; Morris and Bale, 1979;
Knox et aI., 1981). As discussed in Chap. 3.2.3 a release of manganese from the par-
ticles takes place rather rapidly after deposition. Consolidation of the freshly de-
posited sediments, diffusion, bioturbation and erosion cause a release to the sur-
face waters. Although reprecipitation takes place in the oxidised surface, part of
the dissolved Mn(II) escapes to the surface waters due to its slow oxidation rate.
Oxidation rates of manganese(II) determined in the laboratory predict removal
rates in the order of hundreds of years in seawater (Morgan, 1964) in the absence
of particulates and weeks to months in the presence of iron oxides (Sung and Mor-
gan, 1981). However, the removal observed in near shore areas is in the order of
a few days (Graham et aI., 1976; Emerson et aI., 1979; Wollastet aI., 1979; Emerson
et aI., 1982). The rate of removal is enhanced by the action of bacteria (Wollast
et aI., 1979; Emerson et aI., 1982) which might explain the discrepancies between
abiotic laboratory experiments and the field situation.
wim.salomons@home.nl
l:3
N
RIVER
,REelPlTATION SEAWARD TRANS P ORT EXPORT
INPUT 111
;;:--;:"\",",":::: ";::):\:,':({)~;/;::}":"::":;;#\:~:\::\
" ."",
SEAWARD TRANSPORT
I----~I?~{\"I-I------1 LANDWARD TRANSPORT
V~~:.~:L l~
;~ "i{
DIFFUSION OUT
OF SEDIMENT a;::
~
e:..
wim.salomons@home.nl
'"
5"
m
~
t:
I"
~"
'"I"
8-
(j
o
~
e.
~
a'
t:l
3
Fig. 1I8. Schematic model of the recycling of manganese in the St. Lawrence Estuary (Sundby et aI., 1981) "
~
Trace Metals in Estuaries: Field Investigations 223
Morris et al. (1982) studied the rate of oxidation under estuarine conditions for
the Tamar Estuary and showed that the first rate constant increases with increasing
suspended matter concentration and temperature. An increase in chlorinity caused
a decrease in the rate constant. These data suggest that the release from the sedi-
ments may be more significant at high salinities than that at the head of the estuary,
due to the lower rate constant. The conservative behaviour of manganese in the
Beaulieu Estuary (Moore et aI., 1979) may be due to the low suspended matter con-
centrations (Morris et aI., 1982).
The manganese released from the bottom deposits is transported with the land-
ward flowing bottom current to the head of the estuary. During transport part of
it is converted to particulate manganese; also erosion of the bottom deposits (Mn-
enriched surface layers) may contribute manganese-rich particles to the landward
bottom flow (Sundby et aI., 1981). In the St.Lawrence Estuary a progressive in-
crease of dissolved and particulate manganese is observed in the bottom waters in
the landward direction. This "broom effect" as it is called by Sundby et ai. (1981)
causes seaward sediments to be a source of manganese for the head of the estuary.
Some of the landward transported manganese may be lost by vertical transport and
entrainment in the seaward moving surface layer (Fig. 118). This net landward
transport in the St. Lawrence Estuary is in the same order of magnitude as the an-
nual river input (Sundby et aI., 1981).
Recycling of manganese between the upper and lower estuary has also been ob-
served for the Rhine and ScheIdt estuaries (Duinker et aI., 1979) and the Newport
River Estuary (Evans et aI., 1977).
Particulate matter transported in the landward direction is subject to a decreas-
ing pH-gradient (Mook and Koene, 1975). The decrease in the pH causes a release
of manganese from the suspended matter, causing an increase in the dissolved frac-
tion at low salinities.
Although desorption from fluvial suspended matter may be a further source of
dissolved manganese at low salinities, calculation for the Rhine Estuary showed
that this desorption alone was insufficient to explain the high concentrations ob-
served.
The magnitude of these sources, and the intensity of removal processes result
in the observed deviations from the theoretical mixing curve at low salinities.
Results thus far obtained on the behaviour of manganese in estuaries show that
it is controlled by a complex interplay of hydrodynamic and kinetic processes in
which sediments play an important role as a source of additional dissolved (and
also particulate) manganese.
In the past there has been controversy regarding the interpretation of the seaward
decrease in metal concentrations in estuarine sediments. Such a decrease can be ex-
plained by a mobilization of trace metals from the sediments or by a mixing of ma-
rine (low metal concentrations) and fluvial sediments (high metal concentrations).
wim.salomons@home.nl
224 Metals in Estuaries and Coastal Environments
This controversy was mainly based on the interpretation of trace metals in the well
studied Rhine Estuary in the Netherlands. For historical reasons it might be useful
to discuss briefly the fundamental differences and discrepancies between the vari-
ous investigations. The conclusions of de Groot and co-workers (de Groot, 1966;
de Groot et aI., 1971; de Groot and Allersma, 1975) who favoured mobilization
processes, were based on a natural tracer study to distinguish between marine and
fluvial sediments. To determine the origin of sediments in the Rhine Estuary
manganese concentrations in the uppermost part (oxidised layer) of the deposited
sediments was used as a natural tracer. This study (de Groot, 1964) showed large
differences in manganese concentrations between fluvial and marine sediments,
and also that the concentrations of manganese in the sediments from the Rhine Es-
tuary were equal to those of the river Rhine. The conclusion, at that time, seemed
to indicate that the sediments in the Rhine estuary originated from the river Rhine
only. Later studies on the concentrations of copper, mercury, cadmium, zinc, lead,
nickel and organic matter showed a decrease in trace metal and organic matter con-
centrations in the seaward direction. Moreover the CjN ratio of the organic matter
also changed and the decrease in metal concentrations could be correlated with the
order of relative stabilities of metal chelates (Irving and Williams, 1948). The sea-
ward decrease in metal concentrations in the estuarine sediments therefore was in-
terpreted as a mobilization caused by a decay of the organic matter, the decompo-
sition products of the organic matter providing ligands for solubilization of par-
ticulate trace metals.
On the other hand, after studying the Columbia River Estuary Bothner and
Carpenter (1972) and Forstner and Muller (1974), basing their observations on the
distribution of heavy metals in the clay fraction of sediments of the Elbe River tidal
area, were the first to point out that the simplest explanation for the decrease is
the mixing of highly polluted river-derived material with less contaminated marine-
derived sediment particles. Forstner and Muller (1974) suggested that a similar
process might also be able to explain the observed decrease in metal concentrations
in the Rhine Estuary. Similar mixing processes have also been found for the Savan-
nah River Estuary (Goldberg et aI., 1979).
However, the studies discussed in the preceding section showed that manganese
does not behave conservatively in estuaries. Moreover after deposition, diagenetic
recycling takes place, leading to increased manganese concentrations in the oxi-
dized surface layer. Therefore manganese does not fulfill two criteria for its use as
a natural tracer. As a result low manganese marine sediments transported into the
estuary may acquire high manganese concentrations in the oxidized upper layer
ressembling fluvial deposits. In fact, natural tracers studies based on a large range
of different techniques have shown that indeed a mixing of marine and fluvial sed-
iments takes place in the Rhine Estuary (Salomons, 1974; Salomons, 1975;
Salomons et aI., 1975). Extensive studies on the behaviour of dissolved and particu-
late trace metals in the Rhine estuary by Duinker and co-workers found no evi-
dence for mobilization processes; on the contrary they observed an extensive re-
moval of dissolved trace metals in the Rhine Estuary (Fig. 119).
Although the controversy on the interpretation of the Rhine data is resolved
in favour of the mixing process with additional removal processes, the results of
studies on estuarine trace metal behaviour over the last 10 years have shown that
wim.salomons@home.nl
Trace Metals in Estuaries: Field Investigations 225
Ol+-------~------~--
Cu
,119/ 1
3 :.
04-~~~..=·=-:·~"'~--.~~::::==;=~
Cd
,119/ 1
Fig. 120. (A) Metal concentrations and isotopic composition
of the carbonates in suspended matter from the Scheidt Estu-
ary. (B) Metal concentrations and isotopic composition of
the carbonates in deposited sediments from the Scheidt 10 20
Estuary (Salomons and Eysink, 1981) T salinity %0 S
.,..
---------___ _ Zn
III
"- 800 .\-_ ----0 --------__ •. Cd
Pb C
-1.50
--------:\
III
.,.=---------. ,\0"
::I. l( 20 III
--. -0 In
800 -1.00 \0
i . Z
i
~
II:
400 o -0.50
Z
200
.- :, :-=- '~~ o
o l------r-r-------------------------~--------------_r~~~.~====:;~.~J +~
.." : r
--
c c 'i .c 1: c
o
o ..a.
oM
o •
CI
• ! c
Ii
.!!
Z'C
J! -
:I! ;:
c
1000 -2.00
III
"-
III
::I.
800
800
C
III
In
-1.50
...,
\0
i 400
200
i
o
-..•-.
c
a.
'i
o
CI
c
C
wim.salomons@home.nl
226 Metals in Estuaries and Coastal Environments
wim.salomons@home.nl
Trace Metals in Estuaries: Field Investigations 227
2.0r-----------------, 500
400
•
:c"- 1.5 •
:c"- •
•
I&. IlL
300
1.0
i 0.5
i 200 .e\
. ..
"10
• ,,-•
i .Il
0 0
0 50 100 0 50 100
~ % marine mud ~ % marine mud
100 40
:c"- 30
..
u
C
"-
i
i i
20·
•
10
.-=-\ -:r.a
20 • • • fII •
0 o~------~------~
0 50 100 o 50 100
~ % marine mud ~ % marine mud
2.0 20r-----------------~
C
1.5 :c"- 15
"-
III
"
.. ,
U
Z
i
1.0
i 0.5
0 o L:-----...I--....;.;.....;;.• .;::-:...z.~
0 50 100 o 50 100
~ % marine mud ~ % marine mud
Fig. 121. The relationship between trace element to aluminium ratio and the percentage marine mud
(determined with stable isotopes) in suspended matter from the ScheIdt Estuary. The straight line is the
theoretical mixing curve connecting the marine and fluvial end-members (Salomons and Eysink, 1981)
wim.salomons@home.nl
228 Metals in Estuaries and Coastal Environments
30 • 6 1.0 Cd
• Ilgll
•
,".... .
~,. ....,
• I. \ • •• •
•
,,~
•
15 { '( 3 0·5
••
• ,,_,e.
.,/:-. ~':.
I •• ..\.
,. • I.
I.· , -.. ../v...
1.. ., -\
~'.
~/····
...
.. \\
00 12 24 00 ~ ~ °0~----~~~----~24~-
%oSalinity %oSalinity %oSalinity
I•
I
.
Ie
",.
\
10
~
0.25 " 0.25
. ,..
-
\
\ ~
.~ •I
\
.'f i..
.
\
..
\ I
,
••-"
\
\
•
,\~
0
•~;e.;~ ••
00 12 24 0 12 24 00 12 24
%0 Salinity %0 Salinity %0 Salinity
Fig. 122. Relationship between dissolved trace metals and salinity in the ScheIdt Estuary (Kerdyk and
Salomons,1981)
way preventing their uptake or precipitations on the suspended matter. This release
of trace metals from anoxic sediments suspended in seawater, has also been ob-
served in laboratory studies (Salomons et aI., 1982).
Mobilization of cadmium has also been observed in the Weser Estuary in
Northern Germany (Calmano et aI., in press). Relatively high values of dissolved
Cd occur at Weser River km 80 (downstream from Bremen) at a salinity of appro x-
imately 60/00. Fig. 123 shows the distribution coefficient Kd of cadmium (Kd means
J.lg metal/g particulate matter: J.lg metal/ml solution) as a function of salinity; the
lower the Kd the higher is the dissolved fraction of cadmium. A decrease of the Kd
in the salinity ranges between 1%0 and about 6%0 suggests intensive mobilization
of Cd from riverine particles on the estuary mixing zone. The increase of Kd-values
in the outer estuary and in the marine zone can be interpreted by dilution of less
contaminated sea-water or by re-adsorption of Cd in the oxygen rich sea-water.
Mobilization processes such as in the example of the lower estuary do not neces-
sarily take place to the same extent under natural (uncontaminated) conditions.
Possibly the occurrence of freshly adsorbed Cd-inputs - in the Weser Estuary from
wim.salomons@home.nl
Trace Metals in Estuaries: Field Investigations 229
Cd Cd
,ug/' 80
•
0.4 km1Oi~ 90 5 ~
i •___ •
0.2 .", 4 '-.......- -
: ~IL. 3
r
a o0• 10 20 %.s 30 b 0 10 20 %.s 30
Fig. 123. Cadmium mobilization in the Weser Estuary (Calmano et aI., in press). (a) Cd-concentrations
(Jlg/I) vs. salinity (Ian = distance from Bremen) (b) Cd-distribution between particulate matter and so-
lution as a function of salinity Kd = distribution coefficient (Jlg Cd/g particulate matter: Jlg Cd/ml so-
lution)
waste water in the Bremen and Nordenham areas and from dredged spoil, which
is regularly dumped near the lower Weser River km 80 where the maximum for dis-
solved Cd was observed - are the reason of this phenomenon, which may establish
detrimental effects on the aquatic biota in such area.
It should be pointed out that observations on the behaviour oftrace metals for
one estuary cannot be extrapolated to other estuaries, since chemical and hydro-
dynamic processes may differ to a large extent. For instance in the Scheidt Estuary
a removal of arsenic is observed (probably associated with the removal of iron),
however, studies in several rivers in the southeastern United States (Waslenchuk
and Windom, 1978) showed that it is largely unreactive in the estuarine environ-
ment. Complexes were found between arsenic and low molecular weight dissolved
organic matter. Unlike high molecular weight organic matter, the low molecular
weight organic fractions (and associated As) passed conservatively through the es-
tuaries they studied.
In the same estuaries a complicated pattern for the behaviour of copper was
observed (Windom et aI., 1983). Results for the Savannah River Estuary are pre-
sented in Fig. 124A.
Deviations from the conservative mixing behaviour are found at both high and
low salinities, which implies a release from particles and/or bottom sediments. In
the Ogeechee Estuary (Fig. 124 B) a similar positive deviation at low salinities and
an even more pronounced at higher salinities was observed. Release of copper at
low salinities was more pronounced during times of high river discharge. Mixing
experiments showed that it was not associated with a release from bottom sedi-
ments. It was thought that the high release is caused by a higher amount of ex-
changeable copper on particles and colloids during these periods.
The increase of copper during periods of low discharge could be explained by
release from bottom sediments. During these periods the residence time of the wa-
ter is longer and release from bottom sediments would be expected to have a
greater influence on dissolved concentrations (Windom et aI., 1983). The influence
of discharge on the behaviour of copper has also been observed by Eaton (1979).
He observed removal of copper in the San Francisco Bay during periods oflow dis-
charge but an essentially conservative behaviour during high discharge periods.
wim.salomons@home.nl
230 Metals in Estuaries and Coastal Environments
I Savanna" Estuary
-
15
..... 10 ~
01 E
C c
~~- ~~ II 0
o ...::o~-~--II---'"
- _
....... .,,
CT, 5
.'':.7
~
A
O+---~----r----r----r---'----'----'-~O
1000
Ogeechee Estuary I 15
10 ~
500
ic
5
B
O+---~----r----r----r---,----,----~-LO
o 5 10 15 20 25 30 35
Salinity %0
Fig. 124. A. Dissolved copper in the Savannah Estuary during January 1979 (e) and June 1980 (0). The
dashed lines give only the general trend of the mixing curve B. Dissolved copper in the Ogeechee Estuary
during April (e) and may (0),1979 (Windom et aI., 1983)
The removal was observed in the turbidity zone, which comprises 30% phyto-
plankton during summer. Calculations showed that this removal of soluble copper
was caused by biological uptake. Eaton (1979) also observed that at high salinities
the copper concentrations are above the theoretical mixing values, which he could
attribute to anthropogenic sources; a release from sediments could be ruled out.
Direct observations in the field on the influence of pore waters on the compo-
sition of surface waters have been reported for the Wadden Sea area (The Nether-
lands). Studies carried out by Duinker and co-workers during severe wind con-
ditions showed strong maxima in the dissolved copper and zinc concentrations
during periods of maximum current velocities. No such maxima were observed
during a period of extremely calm weather (Duinker et aI., 1974). The results show
that under extreme conditions pore waters are able to supply the overlying waters
with large amounts of dissolved metals. It appeared that the suspended matter can
immediately take up part of the dissolved copper and zinc released by the intersti-
tial waters.
Gendron et al. (1982) found evidence for different release mechanisms for co-
balt and cadmium near the sediment-water interface. The hydroxylamine ex-
wim.salomons@home.nl
Trace Metals in Estuaries: Field Investigations 231
-..
a.
.:
125
-..
a.
125
!.. 100 .
.:
~
:;
......
S
.....
S
.=
';
...
75
-..
.=
co
Zn
...
;it. "#.
Cu
lit
-..
S S
..
Cd
.2
S
-..
50
-.
co co Ni
z
z
25 25
J 0
A
,
10
,
20
,
30
0
0
B
10 20 30
Surface salinity (%,) Surface salinity( "")
Fig. 125. A The net outflow of dissolved and particulate iron and manganese and suspended matter as
a function of salinity at various sections in the Gulf of St. Lawrence. B Net outflow of total Zn, Cu,
Cd, Co and Ni as a function of salinity at various sections in the Gulf of St. Lawrence (Redrawn after
Yeats and Bewers, 1982)
tractable fraction of the sediment surface layer in the St. Lawrence Estuary
(Laurentian Trough) was enriched in cobalt but depleted in cadmium relative to
the subsurface sediment. The concentrations of dissolved cobalt in this surface
layer were negligible while the highest cadmium concentrations were observed in
this layer. The profiles for cobalt resemble those for manganese and iron suggesting
a release in the reduced zone and reprecipitation in the surface layer. On the other
hand, cadmium appears to be released in the surface, probably as a result of
aerobic degradation of the organic matter. Concentration gradients showed that
the upward flux of cadmium across the sediment-water interface is an order of
magnitude higher than the downward flux into the sediment. This indicates that
the cadmium released near the sediment-water interface is efficiently recycled back
into the water column (Gendron et aI., 1982). Also high concentration of hydroxyl-
amine extractable zinc and copper were observed and high concentrations of these
metals in the pore waters of the surface layer (Vale et aI., 1982). Zinc and copper
are probably released from a labile phase. Part of the metals are turned back into
wim.salomons@home.nl
232 Metals in Estuaries and Coastal Environments
water column, whereas another part is adsorbed on the abundant iron and
manganese oxides in the surface layer (Vale et aI., 1982).
A balance for the St. Lawrence Estuary in Canada and the Gulf of St. Lawrence
was constructed taking into account the inflow of freshwater and the inflow of sea-
water into the Gulf (Bewers and Yeats, 1979; Yeats and Bewers, 1982). The net out-
flow of trace metals in % of the freshwater input is presented in Figs. 125 A and
125B.
The influence of the turbidity maximum is clearly shown in the high suspended
matter concentrations at Pte. aux Orignaux. Also an increased outflow of nickel
and particulate iron and dissolved manganese is observed. In the estuary and in the
nearshore area an extensive removal of particulate matter (99%) and particulate
iron and manganese takes place (> 97%). The removal of Ni, Co, Cu, Zn and Cd
varies between 25 and 50%.
The behaviour of copper, nickel and cadmium in the Amazon plume was stud-
ied by Boyle et al. (1982). Both field data and laboratory mixing experiments
showed conservative behaviour for copper and nickel, However, field data from
an earlier cruise in 1974 indicated a 25% removal of copper, probably by biological
processes. Some indications for desorption of cadmium were observed at low
salinities.
In the Gironde Estuary (France) extensive metal mobilization processes have
been recognised (Martin et aI., 1971; Jouanneau, 1982). The Gironde Estuary is
characterized by a turbidity maximum in which suspended matter concentrations
may reach values of several gil. The total mean mass of suspended sediment in the
turbidity maximum is 4.4 x 10 6 tons, which corresponds to a two year supply of
the river (Jouanneau, 1979). The position of the turbidity maximum depends on
hydrological conditions. The estuarine water masses and the suspended matter
move towards the sea during ebb and toward the estuary during flood. So, after
each trip in the open ocean, an important part of estuarine waters and suspended
matter comes back into the estuary. A minor part may reach the line of no return
and escapes from the estuary (Jouanneau and Latouche, 1982). Only when floods
coincide with high spring tides does a large expulsion of estuarine water masses and
suspended matter escape to the ocean.
Compared with the fluvial suspended matter, the concentrations of metals in
the lower estuary are much lower (Table 65).
Since oceanic sources are minor, the low concentrations in the estuary mouth
can not be explained by admixtures of low metal containing marine sediments as
is the case for a number of other European estuaries. The decrease in metal con-
Zn Cu Pb Ni
wim.salomons@home.nl
Trace Metals in Estuaries: Laboratory Investigations and Simulations 233
exchangeable + easily
reducible phase
800 ZINC
[ill]] organic phase
§ moderately reducible phase
rn
800
-
."
...
"-
." residual phase
o
i
10km
400
200
0
II
'0
..
:I
".o
II
II II
II:
II
..i ID
Fig. 126. Changes in the mode of occurrence of zinc in suspended matter from the Gironde Estuary
(Jouanneau, 1982)
The various field investigations have shown that a large number of processes gov-
ern the behaviour of dissolved trace metals in estuaries causing deviations from the
theoretical mixing curve. The more important processes are summarized in Table
66.
A number of processes have been studied in more detail in the laboratory. The
most simple experiments are those in which the two end-members (river- and sea-
water) are mixed in various proportions to obtain the salinity gradient in the estu-
ary (e.g. the influence of bottom sediments is cancelled out). Duinker and Nolting
(1978) mixed river water from the river Rhine with its suspended matter with fil-
wim.salomons@home.nl
234 Metals in Estuaries and Coastal Environments
Table 66. Summary of processes which cause deviations from the theoretical mixins curve between
dissolved trace metals and chlorinity
tered seawater. Their results showed conservative mixing for Cd, Cu, Cr, Fe and
Mn over a one hour period. However, Weijden v.d. et aI. (1977) showed that con-
siderable mobilization takes place when suspended matter from the river Rhine is
suspended in distilled water and mixed with artificial seawater. However, both ex-
periments did not give the expected removal of dissolved trace metals, as was ob-
served in the field. Other mixing experiments have been carried out with Ogeechee
water and seawater (Windom et aI., 1983), in this experiment the conditions ob-
served in the field (e.g. release of copper at low salinities) could be reproduced.
Flocculation processes and their effect on the removal trace metals have been stud-
ied in detail by Sholkovitz and co-workers (Sholkovitz, 1976; 1978; Sholkovitz and
Copland, 1981). Their experiments were carried out with filtered organic rich
waters from the river Luce in Scotland, which has higher concentrations of organic
matter than "average" rivers but has counterparts in the world including the Rio
Negro and the Zaire (Sholkovitz and Copland, 1981). Rapid flocculation of humic
substances is observed in their mixing experiments. The rate of removal of trace
metals varies to a considerable extent: iron was removed by 95%, copper and nick-
el by 40%, cobalt by 10% and cadmium by only 5%. Their experiments show that
for some rivers and some trace metals, flocculation may be an important process
for the removal of dissolved trace metals from solution.
A number of studies have adressed adsorption/desorption processes occur-
ring in estuaries with laboratory experiments (Salomons, 1980; Bourg, 1983; Mill-
ward and Moore, 1982). Processes which affect adsorption/desorption phenomena
under estuarine conditions are:
- oxidation either of organic particles containing trace metals or oxidation of
metal sulfides and the surface desorption of trace metals caused by a high dilu-
tion ratio (Rohatgi and Chen, 1976);
- the chlorinity increase, which affects a competition between chloride ions and
particulates for complexation of the dissolved metals;
- the changes in turbidity (turbidity maximum) which offers additional sites for
adsorption;
- the changes in pH (Mook and Koene, 1975, Fig. 127) which affect adsorption-
desorption processes significantly (Chap. 2.5);
wim.salomons@home.nl
Trace Metals in Estuaries: Laboratory Investigations and Simulations 235
- the formation of new particulate matter (e.g. iron and manganese hydroxides)
as well as the release of dissolved organic matter from the pore waters;
- the flocculation of dissolved organic matter and the fact that estuarine particles
change their surface properties, which are consistent with the formation of a
macromolecular film (Neihof and Loeb, 1974; Loeb and Neihof, 1977; Hunter
and Liss, 1979; 1982) may also affect their adsorption properties.
In a number of studies with radioactive cadmium and zinc the influence of pH,
turbidity, chlorinity and the formation of new particulate matter was studied by
Salomons (1980). Additional studies with a number of different particles and nat-
ural sediments were conducted by Bourg (1983). Millward and Moore (1982) stud-
ied the adsorption of trace metals on iron hydroxides on estuarine conditions.
Some results ofSalomons (1980) are presented in Fig. 127.
The simultaneous influence of chlorinity and pH on the adsorption is shown
in Fig. 127 A. With an increase in chlorinity the amount of metal which adsorbs on-
to the suspended matter decreases; however an increase in pH causes more adsorp-
tion. Especially for cadmium an increase in chlorinity causes at all pH values a
drastic decrease in the adsorption. Also the adsorption of zinc and cadmium on
freshly precipitated manganese shows the strong influence chlorinity (Fig. 127 B).
Fig. 127 C shows the important effect of suspended matter concentrations on the
adsorption. With an increase in suspended matter concentrations, as occurs in the
turbidity maximum, the suspended matter can effectively compete with chloride
ions for complexation of trace metals. Based on these studies the following picture
of adsorption-desorption processes can be drawn: With increasing chlorinity the
amount of metal which adsorbs to the suspended matter decreases, especially for
cadmium the influence of chlorinity is drastic at all pH values. The influence of
chlorinity on the adsorption of zinc is much smaller. Similar behaviour is observed
for the adsorption on hydrous manganese oxides. The influence of chlorinity on
adsorption on suspended matter is constant for chlorinities between 5 and 200/00,
whereas for cadmium the adsorption decreases still further (Fig. 127 C).
The results indicate that if the pH and the suspended matter concentration in
the river are equal to that in the estuary, no additional adsorption of dissolved cad-
mium will take place on the suspended matter, even a desorption may be found (if
the adsorption process is reversible) from the riverine particles. However, the situ-
ation is completely different if a turbidity maximum is found in the estuary. Since
the residence time of the particles in the estuary is higher than in the water, the
riverwater is in fact flowing through the turbidity maximum. If the turbidity maxi-
mum extends into the freshwater tidal area (Fig. 115), the river water with its dis-
solved trace metals encounters already an increase in suspended matter concentra-
tion in the river system. Due to the increase in turbidity, the dissolved metal con-
centrations decrease to reach a new equilibrium with the suspended matter. When
the remaining dissolved trace metals enter the estuarine system, the chloride ions
compete with the particulate matter for their complexation. Depending on hydro-
dynamic conditions (relation between suspended matter concentrations and
chlorinity), the decrease in adsorption may be cancelled out by increases in sus-
pended matter concentration. It is possible to define a zone of enhanced adsorption
in the estuary: a zone in which the adsorption is larger compared with the river up-
wim.salomons@home.nl
236 Metals in Estuaries and Coastal Environments
CADMIUM ZINC
100% 100%
75 o pH 8.5
• pH 8.0
• pH 7.5
50 ' pH 7.0
,
A 15 20 5 10 15 20
ii
;
---. %. CI ---. %. CI
E 100%
100% /;;;;-o-~r-
"e /A5W
."""
/ow
o
75 • 75
'i
'# = Artificial River Water
.5
I:
/ ASW = Artificial Sea Water
a...
~
o /
II
-: B 10 100 10 100
-.. mall Mn ---. mall Mn
100%
1 0_ ===================05000
01500
\\\~-05000 mall -------------------0500
~
suspended
o matter ------------------_0200
.~.'.o.
o
-------------------0100
o 0-
_ --
_ - --------- 0 500
----=::0200 -------------------050
o '-0 100 OL-__ ~ ____ _____ L_ _ _ _
~ ~
C 0 5 10 15 20 50
---. %. CI -.. %.CI
Fig. 127 A-C. Adsorption of Cd (5 Ilg/l) and zinc (50 Ilg/l) on sediment from the river Rhine. A Influence
of chlorinity and pH. B Adsorption of cadmium and zinc on hydrous manganese hydroxides in artificial
riverwater and artificial seawater. C Influence of chlorinity and suspended matter concentration on the
adsorption of cadmium and zinc
stream from the turbidity maximum (Salomons, 1980). To show these effects more
clearly, we have superimposed on Fig. 127 C the adsorption caused by a hypotheti-
cal turbidity maximum (Fig.128A). The adsorption of cadmium up to about 5%0
chlorinity is larger compared with the river upstream from the turbidity maximum.
If the turbidity maximum extends into the freshwater zone, a removal of dissolved
metals already takes place in the freshwater tidal area of an estuary. Even more
adsorption can be predicted if the estuarine circulation pattern is taken into ac-
count: the "broom-effect" carries suspended particles sedimented from the surface
layer in the landward direction (Fig. 128).
wim.salomons@home.nl
Trace Metals in Estuaries: Laboratory Investigations and Simulations 237
RIVER ESTUARY
75 F-----------~~--; 5000
mgll
50
1500
25
500
L______L-________~~~~~;;~~;;~~~~200
I 5 10 15
100
20 50
I .. : ~ ~CI
,OIl
zone of
- -
A enhenced ed.orption
-
R
I S
--
V E
E A
R
t
sediment flux of Mn, Fe, doc to s~rface water
B
Fig. 128. A Adsorption (heavy line) caused by a hypothetical turbidity maximum in an estuary. B The
estuarine circulation pattern and adsorption processes
Added to this flux of suspended matter is the manganese released from pore
waters and the erosion of the surface layer additionally provides Mn-enriched par-
ticles (Sundby et aI., 1981). In this way the landward transported suspended matter
acquires a higher adsorption potential. In the lower estuary, the chlorinity is less
and hence less competition of chloride ions for complexation of dissolved trace
metals (e.g. the suspended matter has entered the zone of enhanced adsorption).
In this way even more fluvial dissolved trace metals may be removed from solution.
In fact the estuarine circulation pattern and the bottom sediments generate a highly
adsorbant filter system in the estuary. It should be noted however, that the decrease
in pH encountered by the landward flowing particles may counteract some of the
before mentioned processes causing an increase in adsorption. Both Fig. 127 A and
the results from Millward and Moore (1982) show the importance of pH on ad-
sorption under estuarine conditions. Whether desorption of the trace metals out-
side the zone of enhanced adsorption will take place depends on the reversibility
of the adsorption processes. Results from Salomons (1980) and Kharkar et al.
(1968) show that only partial desorption may take place with increase in chlorinity.
Both Hodgson (1960) and Salomons (1980) found that with increase in time, the
metals become more strongly attached to the sediments and are less prone to de-
wim.salomons@home.nl
238 Metals in Estuaries and Coastal Environments
sorption. This shows that not only hydrodynamic conditions determine the ad-
sorption process but also the desorption process (a high residence time causes a
stronger binding of the metals to the sedimentary particles).
In laboratory experiments, a number of these processes can be isolated out and
therefore, studied in more detail. However, a drawback remains that the estuarine
system is extremely complex and particularly that the time scale of processes is dif-
ficult to simulate. Moreover, during storage the properties of sediments and sur-
face waters used for the experiments change in ways which might have affected the
results. On the other hand, controlled experiments with pure compounds and ar-
tificial estuarine water, are difficult to extrapolate to the field and may yield only
answers of purely physico-chemical interest. However, in most cases the qualitative
results can be extrapolated to the field situation.
During the past decade enclosures have been used to study geochemical pro-
cesses affecting contaminants in lake and ocean environments. Important studies
have been carried out in the enclosures of CEPEX (Controlled Ecosystem Pollu-
tion Experiment) at Saanich Inlet, British Columbia, Canada and Loch Ewe, Scot-
land and the outdoor tanks of the Marine Ecosystem USA (Santschi, 1982) The
mesocosm approach for studying geochemical processes lies between the complex
and highly variable natural world and the tightly controlled but less naturallabo-
ratory systems (Santschi, 1982). Relevant for the estuarine and coastal environ-
ment are the experiments conducted in the MERL (Marine Ecosystem Research
Laboratory) mesocosms, which were designed to simulate nearshore conditions.
The MERL experiments included both the pelagic and benthic system. The ecosys-
tems used consisted of outdoor fiberglass tanks, 5.5 m high and 1.8 m in diameter,
containing 13 m 3 of water and a 30 cm layer of silty-clay sediments. The water col-
umn is cyclically mixed to simulate tidal currents, turbulence and the sediment re-
suspension regime in the Narrangansett Bay (Amdurer et aI., 1982, 1983). A total
of 23 elements were added in radioactive form to the microcosm and their removal
measured both in summer and in winter. These list of elements included Th, for
which extensive data of oceanic measurements are available. Their purpose, there-
fore was, to establish a relationship between the removal behaviour ofTh and that
of other trace metals, in order to use Th in the ocean to predict the rates of removal
of other trace metals. The elements studied could be classified in four general
groups on the basis of their half removal times from the water column and chemical
forms (Table 67).
The differences in removal between the winter and summer period are remark-
able. Three mechanisms were studied in detail to explain the seasonal differences
in removal rate [Santschi et al. (1982)]:
- the filtering of suspended particles and associated trace elements by organisms
such as zooplankton or benthic suspension feeders;
- aggregation of particles followed by faster settling;
- impaction of particles i.e. convection or advection and entrainment of particles
into the laminar sublayer, and/or adsorption of trace elements at the sediment-
water interface.
To study the effect of organisms, zooplankton was caged and allowed to feed
on surrounding water and suspended sediments (Adler at aI., 1981). The zoo plank-
wim.salomons@home.nl
Trace Metals in Estuaries: Laboratory Investigations and Simulations 239
Table 67. Comparison of seasonal removal behaviour and distribution coefficients of different groups
of elements in the microcosm tanks. (Santschi et aI., 1982)
A. Particle reactive
Fe, Hg, Sn, Cr (III), Pb, Po, Th, Pa, Pu, Am, Be 10- 20 2- 3 (3-8) WS (0.5-2)10 5
B. Recyclable
Mn,Co 30- 50 5- 30 (1-5)J03 (0.6-1)J03
C. Biologically active
Zn, Cd, Se, As 60-100 10- 50 102_10 3 102 -10 3
D. Quasi conservative
Ba, Ra, Cs, Sb 150-600 80-150 10-102 10-102
ton filtered 5-8% of the suspended particles in the tank per day (however, the re-
moval time of trace metals from the tanks is a rapid 2-3 days in summer). Calcu-
lations showed that less than 4% of the total element transport from the water col-
umn occurred via fecal pellets. The removal and aggregation of particles was stud-
ied with microspheres. The settling velocity of these spheres in settling cylinders
was equal to that predicted by Stokes law. However, in the microcosms, the disap-
pearance from the water column was between 8 (15 ~m particles) to 100 times (3
~m particles) faster than predicted by the settling cylinders or Stokes law (Santschi
et aI., 1982). They concluded that some benthic processes play an important role
in the removal of particles and their associated trace metals.
The experiments also showed that the standing stock of particles in the water
is replaced 8 times a day by resuspension and deposition, while in winter only every
two days.
To determine the effect of benthic processes, the sedimentation in sediment
traps was compared to the total removal from the microcosm, and indicated by the
factor R, which is the rate of removal through sedimentation in the traps divided
by the total removal. A ratio of 1 implies that the removal can be accounted for
by settling of particles, which was indeed the case for microcosms with low benthic
activity. However, in tanks with active benthos (summer) the ratio was less than
1 for particle active trace metals. A comparison between the total filtering capacity
of organisms in the microcosm (mainly originating from the activity of benthic or-
ganisms) and the rate of removal of the micro spheres showed that benthic activity
could account for the removal of particles from the water column. The results show
that the most important mechanisms for the removal of trace metals from the water
phase is the resuspension of bottom sediments by tidal action providing ample sur-
face area for adsorption. This is followed by a fast removal by the activity of ben-
thic organisms. Since the benthic processes are efficient in removal of trace metals,
it was concluded that as the depth of the water column decreases the removal of
chemicals from the water to the sediments will accelerate (Adler et aI., 1982).
wim.salomons@home.nl
240 Metals in Estuaries and Coastal Environments
The contamination of coastal areas including estuaries and marginal seas can gen-
erally be attributed to one of the following causes (Weichart, 1973): (i) direct input
of effiuents from industries and communities situated near the coast, (ii) effiuents
from communities via sewer outfalls, (iii) dumping of waste from ships, (iv) soluble
and suspended load from rivers, (v) atmospheric fallout, (vi) waste derived from
the extraction of raw materials from the sea and (vii) pollution by the shipping in-
dustry. Terms such as "resiliency", "carrying ability" and "assimilative capacity"
denote the capacity of estuaries to receive a certain amount of waste material be-
fore this use of the system begins to affect other uses adversely (U.S. EPA, 1977).
This requires thresholds of water quality to be maintained (Goldberg, 1979). Es-
tuarine ecosystems are less resilient and may be seriously vulnerable to toxic ma-
terials which are not inherent in the genetic history of the biota, especially if they
are highly persistent in the estuary. The assimilative capacity for persistent toxic
substances which may repeatedly cycle in estuarine processes is very low. The re-
covery capacity of estuaries has been observed in a few investigations of benthic
macrofauna invertebrates. However, similar studies on meiofauna - which proba-
bly respond more rapidly to environmental changes than benthic organisms - and
sediments are scarce. However, the following should be noted in respect to the few
that are available:
Decontamination of sediments is in general a slow process but it is accelerated
by the presence of burrowing benthic organisms; the recovery of the bottom strata
is mainly due to the deposition of unpolluted sediments with a subsequent embed-
ding of the contaminated sediment cover (Cato et aI., 1980). Among the various
problems with heavy metals in coastal waters of Japan the catastrophic pollution
in the Minamata Bay and surrounding area of the Yatsushiro Sea still cause con-
siderable concern because of the long-term effects of methylmercury compounds,
even if there is a significant decrease of mercury concentration in bed sediments
with increasing distance from the effiuent discharge point (Fig. 129).
Calculations from Goldberg (1972) on a global basis indicate that approx. 140
million tons of wastes are annually dumped by ships into the sea. Furthermore, ap-
prox. 15 million tons of industrial particulates will reach the sea via atmospheric
wim.salomons@home.nl
United States Estuaries and Coastal Areas 241
"E 200
a.
.s-
..
100
III
c 50
III
E
:; 20
III
UI
10
"III
III
c 5
c
0
.."c.
:; 2
1
III
C)
c 0.5
0
U
01
Z 0.2
0.1 •
0.05~~__~~-L__~__- L__~_·__•__~__~
•
0.1 0.2 0.5 1 2 5 10 20 50 100
Distance from Sources (Km)
Aside from large construction projects or land reclamation activities, dredging and
disposal of dredged materials are among the most important activities affecting es-
tuaries and the coastal oceans near industrial centres (Gross, 1978). In the United
wim.salomons@home.nl
242 Metals in Estuaries and Coastal Environments
Table 68. Discharge and composition of various wastes dumped into coastal waters near New York
and their probable impact on these waters. (From Gross et aI., 1971)
Table 69. The best estimates for the flux of trace metals to the New York Bight Apex. Flux in
10 2 tons/yr (Krom et aI., 1981)
Cu Pb Zn Cd
States, about 2 x 10 8 m 3 are dredged each year from existing channels (mainte-
nance dredging) and about 6 x 10 7 m 3 are dredged during construction of new fa-
cilities (new work) at an annual cost of$ 150,000,000 (1970).
To visualize the volume of the dumping of waste from New York City (about
8.6 million tons) one must imagine that if the annual discharge of these waste solids
were spread uniformly over Manhattan, it would form a layer 13 cm thick each
year (Goldberg, 1976).
About 76 per cent of the wastes dumped in the New York Bight in the 1960s
was dredged wastes, fine-grained materials (for example, ash) and small stones
(Table 68; Gross et aI., 1971). After waste solids, rubble from building construction
and demolition is the second largest source; a third major type of waste dumped
in the New York Bight is sewage sludge from municipal sewage treatment plants.
In an area of New York Bight, including the Hudson Gulf Valley, approximately
60 km 2 , sediments contained Cu, Cr, Pb and Zn concentrations ten times higher
than normal values, whereas a larger area encompassing some 170 km 2 was shown
to contain a five-fold increase (Carmody et aI., 1973). These areas correspond to
the sewage sludge and dredge spoil disposal areas, respectively. In Table 69 the best
wim.salomons@home.nl
United States Estuaries and Coastal Areas 243
wim.salomons@home.nl
244 Metals in Estuaries and Coastal Environments
onstrated from their isotope ratios that the lead accumulations in sediment cores
from Baja California are probably derived from lead additives such as are present
in the type of gasoline sold in Southern California. It has been estimated that on
an annual basis, 180 tons of lead are deposited into the zone of California by at-
mospheric fallout, 200 are discharged through municipal waste effluents and 90
tons come from storm and river runoff.
Investigations of Christensen et al. (1978) on vertical profiles of heavy metals
in sediment cores from the tidal flats of Newport Bay, California, a very shallow
estuary located in Orange Country, 60 km southeast of Los Angeles, showed clear-
ly oscillating patterns in that maximum concentration of a metal, such as lead, is
associated by maximum grain size. It is suggested that material is carried by large
storms since there is a characteristic cause-effect relationship between patterns of
grain size/heavy metal concentrations and those of rainfall. Galloway (1979) stud-
ied the marine discharge of wastewater in the coastal area of Southern California.
Less than 10% of the metals injected from the outfall were present in the contami-
nated marine sediments of the study area. The remaining 90% are either dissolved
out of the waste solids suspended in seawater or transported out of the area by cur-
rents while still associated with the particulate matter (Galloway, 1979). He extra-
polated these data (Southern California with about 1% of the industrial world
population) to global discharge of waste into the marine environment (Table 70).
In the southern part of Puget Sound (Wash.) smokestack emissions from Ta-
coma Cu-smelter have resulted in significant accumulations of As, Sb, Cu, Pb and
Zn. Atmospheric input to Puget Sound was calculated by Schell and Nevissi (1977)
as approximately 450 tons/yr of zinc; the respective values for the inputs from Met-
ro's West Point Sewage Plant were 29 tons/yr Cu, 9 tons/yr Pb and 56 tons/yr Zn.
At the waste outfall from a mercury cell chloralkali plant in Bellingham Bay
(northern Puget Sound), an estimated 5-10 kg of mercury were discharged daily
between 1965 and 1970 (Bothner and Carpenter, 1974).
Cd 3 36
Cr 55 1.5 50
Cu 42 2.1 250
Pb 15 3.6 110
Ni 17 3.7 11
Ag 2.3 0.07 II
Zn 100 7 720
wim.salomons@home.nl
Mediterranean Sea 245
The pollution problems in the Mediterranean Sea are chiefly due to the high quan-
tity of domestic sewage and the virtually total absence of control on toxic com-
ponents. Among the rivers entering the Mediterranean, the Rhone, Po and Tiber
discharge by far the highest contaminant load, which originates from both indus-
trial and municipal inputs (Naeve, 1974). Characteristic increases of mercury con-
centrations have been reported from the French and Italian coast, e.g. the Gulf of
Lion (Aubert et al., 1974), the Ligurian coast and the Gulf of Genoa (Renzoni et
al., 1974), and from the industrial centres ofCagliary (Sardinia) and Naples (Shep-
pard and Bellamy, 1974). The 1975-review of Bernhard on heavy metals and
chlorinated hydrocarbons in the Mediterranean notes several areas of elevated
metal contents in the water phase (Table 71): The higher copper concentrations in
the coastal waters near Cadiz, for example, are affected by the Huelva copper
mines, so anthropogenic Cu pollution is superimposed on a geochemical Cu anom-
aly (Establier, 1969). Data from the Ligurian Sea and Tuscan coast by Capelli et
al. (1976), Frache et al. (1976) and Bernhard et al. (1977) show elevated concen-
trations of cadmium, copper, zinc and nickel in the harbour areas. Bernhard et al.
(1977) found that in the outer and inner harbour of La Spezia the ratios between
particulate and ionic species of zinc vary considerably, probably due to anthropo-
Table 71. Metal concentrations in the coastal waters of the Mediterranean Sea (after Bernhard, 1978).
Values in Ilg/1 (range in parenthesis)
wim.salomons@home.nl
246 Metals in Estuaries and Coastal Environments
genic input from the shipbuilding industry and the town of La Spezia. The lower
values of cadmium (0.005 Ilg/1), copper (0.13 Ilg/1) and lead (0.018 Ilg/1) of the
study of Niirnberg et ai. (1977) may be considered as local background data in rel-
atively unpolluted waters. The influence of an anthropogenic Hg source was stud-
ied south of Livorno in seawater and biota along the coast of Tuscany by Renzoni
et ai. (1973); near the outfall (1 km south) they observed relatively high values of
around 0.2 Ilg/1 Hg, but at about 10 km south and north of the outfall the Hg con-
centration was already below its detection limit of 0.02 Ilg/1 (Bernhard, 1978). The
Adriatic Sea is particularly susceptible to pollution, especially that from the indus-
trial centres in the northern part of the region. Neave (1974) noted 76 wastewater
effluents from industrial plants in Venice; thus the concentration of certain heavy
metals, e.g. mercury, in water and edible organisms lies at or even slightly above
the acceptable safety levels. Data of Grancini et ai. (1975; 1976) from the northern
Italian Adriatic coast from Triest to Ravenna indicate significantly higher values
of silver, cobalt, antimony and zinc compared to the data from open-sea water
samples; similar findings on sediment samples (Grancini et aI., 1975) suggest that
this increase is related to the waste input from rivers. Significant anthropogenic ef-
fects, mainly for zinc concentrations, were found in the Kvarner region (Rijeka)
of the Yugoslavian Adriatic Sea (Branica et aI., 197; Bubic et aI., 1977), the Saroni-
kos Gulf (Athens) in Greece (Papadopolou, 1972) and in the surface waters along
the Israel coastline from Rosh Hanigra to Haifa; in the latter area high metal values
could be attributed to the run-off of the River Qishon, which is heavily polluted
by industrial discharges, and the River Na'amon polluted by agricultural and do-
mestic wastes (Roth and Hornung, 1977).
In western Europe there are five areas of particularly high amounts of waste dis-
posal: Clyde Sea (Liverpool Bay), Thames Estuary, Rhine-Waal/Meuse/Scheldt
estuaries, the German Bight and the Baltic Sea. During the last decade, many stud-
ies have been performed with regard to metal pollution, of which only a few can
be mentioned here.
Sewage sludge from the city of Glasgow and adjoining areas is dumped into a
restric area of the Firth of Clyde, at a rate of I x 10 6 tons per year (Mackay et aI.,
1972). Metal analysis from bottom sediments indicate characteristic enrichment of
mercury, lead zinc and copper. From a summary of the heavy metal input to the
Clyde Sea given by Topping (lit. cit. Cam bray et aI., 1975), it is evident that rain-
water plays a significant role with regard to the input of cadmium, copper, zinc and
in particular, lead (Table 72).
Considerably higher amounts of metals are discharged with sewage materials
into Liverpool Bay than into the Firth of Clyde disposal site; it must be noted, how-
ever, that the Liverpool discharges are distributed over a larger area. Even higher
amounts of metals have been dumped with the sludge from the London sewage
works (Shelton, 1971).
Contaminants enter the North Sea mostly from rivers and the atmosphere, as
well as from direct discharges. According to recent mass-balance evaluations by
wim.salomons@home.nl
Western Europe 247
Table 73. Enrichment factors· of contaminant metals in sediments from different environments in
the Elbe, Weser, and Ems and North Sea. (Schoer et aI., 1982) n = number of samples
wim.salomons@home.nl
248 Metals in Estuaries and Coastal Environments
Table 74. Input routes of heavy metals to the North Sea. (From Norton, 1982)
Table 75. Major river inputs of heavy metals to the North Sea. (Norton, 1982)
Total contribution 33 45 31 63 34 44
from rivers
Rhine/Meuse 16 25 14 32 11 18
Elbe 5 6 5 9 6 7
Thames 1 1 1 2 4 3
ScheIdt 2 2 2 1 1 3
Humber 1 1 1 2 2 2
Other rivers 8 10 8 18 10 11
The North Sea is surrounded by one of the most industrialised areas in the
world. As a consequence it receives large contaminant loads, including heavy
metals. Norton (1982) recently summarised the available information on major in-
put routes of heavy metals to the North Sea (Table 74).
There are very significant atmospheric inputs for cadmium (63% of the total
Cd-load to the North Sea), lead and copper (58%), nickel (45%), zinc (35%), chro-
mium (25%) and mercury (14%). Of the major river inputs (Table 75 lists the per-
centage of the riverine metal inputs from total metal load to the North Sea) the
Rhine/Meuse system is by far the biggest contributor, followed by the rivers Elbe
and Thames.
However, estuaries, artificial lakes created in the lower courses of the rivers,
sedimentation on river flood plains and dredging activities cause a retention of
trace metals (Fig. 130). The data for the rivers Rhine and Meuse, in whose lower
courses large civil engineering activities have been carried out since 1900, have par-
ticularly to be corrected for this retention to determine the actual input to the
North Sea. Salomons and Eysink (1981) made a first balance study of metal trans-
port by these two rivers. Apart from transport to the North Sea by the estuarine
pathway, two additional pathways have to be considered:
wim.salomons@home.nl
Western Europe 249
2900 11
NORTH SEA
I
10
I
21
9600
Fig. 130. Particulate metal transport (tons/a) and dredging activities (106 m 3/a) in Belgium, The
Netherlands and Germany
Freshwater basins
The closing of river mouths (Haringvliet, 1970, see Fig. 130) and coastal lagoons
(Usselmeer, 1932) has created large freshwater basins in which the river water be-
fore it enters the marine environment, is subject to hydrodynamic and geochemical
processes causing a retention of both dissolved and particulate metals (see also
Chap. 5.4.4).
wim.salomons@home.nl
250 Metals in Estuaries and Coastal Environments
Table 76. Tentative metal balance for the rivers Rhine and Meuse
Cu Ni Zn Pb Cd Cr MeT
tons/a
Input
Meuse+ Rhine from 1,215 886 11,051 1,707 195 2,463 16,517
Belgium and Germany
Discharge in the 130 130 1,700 380 27 530 19,414
Netherlands
All data are based on 1977-1978, except for the input of trace metals in the Dutch
part of the rivers, which are for 1975.
The data show that more than 50% of the total metal transported by these two
rivers accumulates in its lower courses and is removed as part of the dredged ma-
terial to landfill sites. Similarly the data given for the other rivers in Table 76 have
to be corrected for retention in their lower courses and estuaries. The actual con-
tribution of rivers to the metal load of the North Sea is probably therefore less than
shown in Table 76, and the relative importance of the atmospheric contribution
much higher.
In general, estuaries contain more living organisms than any other part of seas and
oceans and their chemistries are correspondingly more influenced by these or-
ganisms than other marine zones (Wolfe, 1980). A complex of periodically chang-
ing parameters limit colonization to a restricted number of organism species with
a wide range of ecological adaptations (Day, 1951). While the magnitude and rel-
ative importance of the input from benthic and planktonic plants will depend upon
a variety of factors, e.g. topography and hydrology - accordingly varying mark-
edly from one estuary to the next - it is clear that a substantial proportion of prod-
ucts of plant growth will enter the estuarine sediments which are known to be im-
wim.salomons@home.nl
Environmental Impact of Metals in Biota 251
Table 77. Cadmium concentrations in water, seaweeds and shore animals of four collecting stations
on the southern side of Severn Estuary and Bristol Channel. (Butterworth et aI., 1972)
portant sites for many reactions involving the degradation of organic material and
the regeneration of inorganic forms (Goldberg, 1978). The fate of toxic metals, and
hence the capacity of the estuary to receive them, is mostly linked to the fine-
grained organic-rich sediments which may be concentrated, deposited, resus-
pended or distributed by physical processes; and since such sediment is an attrac-
tive food source for many bottom-dwelling organisms, it is clearly useful to study
how bioturbation affects metal concentrations and inventories in estuarine sedi-
ments (Goldberg, 1979). Exemplary investigations performed by Butterworth et al.
(1972) in the Severn Estuary are chosen to demonstrate the effects of contamina-
tion on the concentrations of metals in aquatic organisms. Coastal waters border-
ing the southern shore of the Bristol Channel have been shown to contain abnor-
mal amounts of cadmium, zinc and lead, which are probably introduced from the
Bristol area via the River Avon. In the water samples, the effects of the pollution
have been traced as far away as Hartland Quay, some 150 km to the west from
A vonmouth into the Bristol Channel. Table 77 indicates that the contamination in
the water (by cadmium, similar effects have been observed for zinc) is obviously
transmitted to the living material inhabiting this shore - at relatively low levels in
seaweed Fucus (the producer), at higher levels in the limpet Patella (a primary con-
sumer) and greatest concentrations in the whelk Thais (the secondary consumer of
contaminated organisms). Although this type of bio-amplification of metals at
higher trophic levels has generally not been confirmed, there is clear evidence that
the highest concentrations, both in the water and in the biological material, occur
near the source of pollution and that the metal content in the estuary decreases
towards the open sea.
In a study on more than 100 sites in over 30 estuaries in south-west England
and South Wales (Bryan et aI., 1980) three burrowing species, the polycheate
Nereis diversicolor and the deposit-feeding bivalves Scrobicularia plana and Ma-
coma balthica have been evaluated as indicators of the availability of metals in es-
tuarine sediments. Scrobicularia is the best accumulator of metals; it exchanges
metals slowly and appears to be a good indicator of changes in chronic contami-
nation. Most of the metals lie in the digestive gland and therefore this organ can
be taken for a general survey without analyzing the whole soft parts; studies on the
influence of size and season on metal levels show that sampling animals of 4 cm
shell length in the autumn or early spring is the most reliable method of comparing
different sites. When Scrobicularia was absent, Macoma balthica (1.5 cm) was used
wherever possible. The polycheate Nereis diversicolor was analysed at almost every
wim.salomons@home.nl
252 Metals in Estuaries and Coastal Environments
site and proved a useful indicator for Ag, Cd, Cu, and Hg, although not Zn which
it regulates. The data show that for six of the metals, the highest concentrations
in sediment occur in estuaries where the organisms are clearly also contaminated.
However, contaminated organisms have also been found in areas where the sedi-
ments are not so obviously contaminated. It has been suggested by Bryan et ai.
(1980) that chemical factors, e.g. the availability of particle associated metals, are
usually most important and that information on the chemistry of the sediments
from different estuaries will be useful because:
1. It may help to predict whether the properties of sediments in a particular
estuary are favourable or not for the introduction of metallic wastes and
2. it may indicate ways of controlling the composition of wastes so that the avail-
ability of metallic components is inhibited rather than promoted.
Although there are only few data available at present, it has been shown, for
example, that the biological availabilities of sediment-bound lead and arsenic to
Scrobicularia are strongly influenced by the level of readily extractable Fe in the
sediment, lower concentrations of Pb and As being found in animals from sedi-
ments high in Fe (Luoma and Bryan, 1978; Langston, 1981).
The reactivity of metal compound, as evaluated, for example by sequential
chemical extraction procedures (Chap. 2.3.2), also gives indications on possible re-
mobilization effects in the estuarine mixing zone.
The Western ScheIdt, where an extensive mobilization of cadmium from the
sediments and suspended matter takes place (Fig. 122), reflects this geochemical
process in the metal uptake by bivalves (Fig. 131). In fact, the relationship between
cadmium accumulation and salinity is similar to the dissolved cadmium-salinity re-
lationship shown in Fig. 122. Cadmium levels in Mytilus edulis in the Ems-Dollard
Estuary and in the mouthing area of the Rhine Estuary are much lower and are
similar to values observed in the North Sea. This reflects the extensive removal of
dissolved cadmium during estuarine mixing in the Rhine and Ems Estuaries
(Chap. 6.6).
It has been noted by Bryan et ai. (1980) that because different organism species
have different affinities for metals and absorb them from different sources, it seems
unlikely that any organism will come to be regarded as a universal indicator of
metallic contamination. Any reasonable monitoring programme should be in-
volved in an analysis of several species (e.g., seaweed, filter-feeding bivalve and a
deposit-feeding bivalve) to try to assess contamination in different forms.
An important limitation on the use of some suggested biological indicators in
estuaries is their inability to penetrate into the less saline areas where contamina-
tion is often greatest (Bryan et aI., 1980): In the lower reaches of an estuary, the
seaweed Fucus vesiculosus, the filter-feeders Mytilus edulis and Cerastoderma edule,
and the deposit-feeders Scrobicularia plana and Macoma balthica may all be pres-
ent, together with species of the herbivores Patella and Littorina; in the less saline
parts of an estuary the choice of species becomes more limited and will include, in
addition to Fucus, Scrobicularia and Macoma, the polycheate Nereis diversicolor.
A detailed study on metal uptake by marsh vegetation in two contrasting areas
in the Netherlands was carried out in the Eastern ScheIdt a coastal lagoon under
the influence of the North Sea and without local pollution and the Western ScheIdt
wim.salomons@home.nl
Environmental Impact of Metals in Biota 253
4 Cd conc. , IIg g -1
ash - free dry weight
3
i A B
Fig. 131. A Uptake of cadmium by Mytilus edulis in the North Sea compared with the Rhine Estuary,
the Ems Estuary and the Scheidt Estuary. B Cadmium uptake in the Scheidt Estuary as a function of
salinity (De Kock, 1982)
which is influenced by the River ScheIdt (Beeftink et aI., 1982). Cadmium concen-
tration in Salicornia (which is consumed as a vegetable by the local people) in the
Eastern ScheIdt was 0.19 mg/kg (dry weight), whereas in the Western ScheIdt
values up to 2.2 mg/kg, well above the maximum for vegetables) were observed.
Calculations on fluxes of trace metals in salt marshes have been made by Wolfe
(1975) for an ecosystem from the Newport River on the basis of several assump-
tions about trophic structure and flow efficiency within the system: (1) each con-
sumption step involves an assimilation efficiency of 0.2 with un assimilated 0.8 be-
ing returned to the detrital compartment as faeces; (2) the zooplankton population
regenerates itself on average 18 times per year; (3) biological half-life of Zn in zoo-
plankton is 7.6 days; (4) the macrofauna compartment regenerates with a mean
production/standing crop ratio of 2.0/yr; (5) an average of 2 trophic interactions
is effected on all Zn consumed by the macrofauna compartment; (6) biological
half-life of Zn in macrofauna is 300 days; (7) all detrital Zn, whether originating
directly from phytoplankton and S. alterniflora or from previously cycled fecal
matter, is assimilated by the microbiota and meiofauna with a net efficiency of
40% prior to becoming available to consumers.
The results show that the amount of zinc cycled annually through the trophic
structure is approximately 16 times greater than that entering the estuary from the
watershed. If most of the un assimilated Zn from the detrital compartment is re-
turned to the water column, the biological zinc cycle would very nearly represent
a closed system. These findings suggest that neither of the very large reservoirs of
potentially available zinc, i.e. the sediments and the ocean, is directly involved in
the rapid biological cycle, and furthermore, that biologically available zinc in es-
tuarine waters represents a different compartment than that involved in the sedi-
ment-water equilibrium. Wolfe (1975) notes that the major complexities involved
in progressing from this static "annual budget" concept to a dynamic model of the
wim.salomons@home.nl
254 Metals in Estuaries and Coastal Environments
flow of trace metals through the estuarine ecosystem arise because physico-chemi-
cal speciation of the metal itself must be superimposed upon food chain transfers.
Again, therefore, it becomes evident that the question of chemical reactivity of a
specific metal in both dissolved and particulate form is decisive for its adsorption,
excretion, and storage in an organism.
Estuaries are the interface between the continents and the oceans, and with regard
to the movement of trace metals along the hydrological cycle, the question arises
how efficient are the estuaries and the coastal zones in trapping the particulate and
dissolved metals. This question is especially important for assessing the input of
trace metals from natural and anthropogenic sources into the world oceans. Few
detailed balance studies have been carried out to answer this question. Turekian
(1977) considered the fate ofPb-21O in estuaries and showed that its residence time
in Long Island Sound is in the order of days before it is trapped by particles and
incorporated in the sediments. His observations on lead and related elements lead
him to the following conclusion: "The estuarine trace metal cycle is mainly self-
contained: release and deposition occur virtually entirely within the system" (Ture-
kian, 1977). Only very little leakage of particulate heavy metals to the deep sea will
occur. Only low-density particles of extremely fine-grained particles can escape this
process and may provide a mechanism of supply of metals to the ocean.
Lal (1977) calculated that for particles to be effectively transported to the open
ocean, they should have diameters less than 5 ~m. Also the observation of Mayer
(1982) (see Chap. 6.5) indicated that only very finely grained material escape the
estuarine circulation pattern. This fraction of the suspended matter may be similar
to the "non-settling" suspended matter fraction discussed by Duinker and co-
workers (see Chap. 6.5).
Although these more or less semi-quantitative studies indicate that estuaries are
an efficient trap for riverborne material, few balance studies have been carried out.
Metal balance studies have been reported for two West-European estuaries: the
Gironde and the Scheidt Estuary, and for the St. Lawrence Estuary. Results for the
Gironde and Scheidt Estuary are presented in Table 78 and Table 79. Results for
other estuaries show retentions between these two extremes (see Tables 78 and 79).
The metal balance for the Gironde estuary (Table 78) clearly shows that it acts
as a metal mobilizing system. Metals entering in particulate form are leaving the
estuary mainly in dissolved form. Retention in % of the input for Zn, Cu, Pb and
Ni are 17,3,13 and 17, respectively.
Balances and flux calculations have been made for the Scheldt Estuary (Kerdijk
and Salomons, 1982; Wollast and Peters, 1978) The outflow of trace metals from
the estuary, in % of the inflow from the river are presented in Table 79.
The results of both investigations show that relatively large amounts of trace
metals are held back in the estuary. The differences, considering the fact that dif-
ferent surveys have been conducted, are rather small. Interesting is the fact that
nickel is far less removed from the system than other trace metals, this small reten-
wim.salomons@home.nl
Estuaries as Sinks for Trace Metals? 255
Table 78. Mean annual metal balance for the Gironde Estuary (Jouanneau, 1982). In tons/year
Table 79. Metal balances for the Scheidt estuary (tons/y) (Kerdijk and
Salomons, 1982)
The values in brackets refer to the flux calculations by Wollast and Peters (1978)
tion for nickel was also found for the rivers Rhine and Meuse (Table 76). Similar
behaviour has also been found for other estuaries (Klinkhammer, 1983). The con-
trasting results for the Gironde and Scheidt Estuary may serve to illustrate the
large difference in efficiency observed in the estuarine trap for trace metals.
Also a large amount of metals transported by the rivers Rhine and Meuse in
the direction of the North Sea does not enter the marine environment. However,
in this case the retention is mainly caused by civil engineering activities (Salomons,
1981), such as the creation of freshwater basins, the construction of the Rotterdam
harbour (increased siltation) and estuarine and freshwater processes causing a re-
moval of dissolved trace metals (Table 76). Yeats and Bewers (1982) who studied
the St. Lawrence Estuary and the Gulf of St. Lawrence, used the results from this
large estuary and marginal sea as a model to obtain information on the magnitude
of exchanges between the freshwater and deep marine environments. They could
use the Gulf of St. Lawrence as a world model because it has many characteristics
that are similar to those of a section of continental shelf. The area of the Gulf is
about 250,000 km 2 with water depths comparable to those on the adjacent con-
tinental shelf. Fig. 125 shows that SPM and the associated particulate metals are
removed more rapidly outside the high energetic estuarine zone. Most of the dis-
solved trace metals are removed within the estuarine region of the system (Yeats
and Bewers, 1982). Yeats and Bewers (1982) recently made a generic model of trace
metal transport through the coastal zone. They compared the discharge ofparticu-
late and dissolved metals by rivers, with the average sedimentation in the coastal
wim.salomons@home.nl
256 Metals in Estuaries and Coastal Environments
Table SO. Results of the generic coastal zone model of Yeats and Bewers (1982). The retention in the
coastal zone refers to the % of the inititially settling river borne particulate flux which remains in
the coastal zone
COASTAL PELAGIC
:
. ________ jE~~~_S_~:~~:~_____________________________lr:T~~~~~~_~~::c
COASTAL ZONE : PELAGIC
: :OCEAN
RIVER DISSOLVED :I
,
I •
'
I :
PARTICULATE i 1.0xlU12!
1.8xlU13
SETTLING'(95% /
OF PARTICULATE
INPUT) ,:
,,
,,
,
and its mean metal contents with the composition of ocean sediments. The results
are presented in Table 80.
The transport of particulate matter within their generic coastal model is shown
in Fig. 132.
An interesting facet of this model is the differences in composition between
riverborne particulate matter and nearshore sediments. The concentrations of al-
uminium and iron are equal, however, the concentrations of Mn, Co, Cu, Zn and
wim.salomons@home.nl
Estuaries as Sinks for Trace Metals? 257
Cd are lower. This shows that some additional mechanism of metal transport from
the coastal zone to the deep-ocean must exist in order to maintain these low metal
concentrations. The percentage of metals which are redistributed (expressed as %
of the initial particulate metal sedimentation flux in the coastal zone) is given in
Table 80. Processes which may cause this redistribution are: size sorting of river-
borne particulates, diagenetic release to the water column and eventual reassoci-
ation with fine suspended particles. This is one of the major routes for the redis-
tribution of manganese but in the case of this metal and especially for others, size
sorting of suspended particles during transport through the coastal zone must also
be important (Bewers, 1982, personal communication). These results show that the
input of riverborne trace metals to the deep-ocean is determined not only by pro-
cesses in the estuaries, but by additional processes during transport in the coastal
zone, and by release of trace metals from coastal sediments.
The observed variability in the behaviour of trace metals in various estuaries
may be due to a number of reasons. These processes are operating on different time
scales, the adsorption processes in estuaries on a rather rapid time scale, the iron
precipitation being more rapid than the manganese oxidation. Also the flux varies
to a large extent. The results from the behaviour of copper in Eastern U.S. estuaries
(see Fig. 124), show that the flux from the sediments is rather constant and shows
up when the riverborne flux of copper is low. It seems highly likely that these dif-
ferences in fluxes and time scales obscure some processes in estuaries. Some of the
variability in trace metals in estuaries may be due to differences in time frame, hy-
drodynamic conditions, biological activity, sediment influence etc. Unfortunately,
at this moment it does not appear to be possible to depict a general description of
trace metal behaviour in estuaries. More field studies, jointly carried out with lab-
oratory and/or mesocosm studies on a number of contrasting estuaries are needed.
wim.salomons@home.nl
7 Metals in the Ocean
7.1 Introduction
The oceans are the last part of the hydrological cycle and here trace metals are re-
moved from the hydrological cycle and incorporated in the sediments. There they
spend several hundred million of years before taking part in the next hydrological
cycle.
Roughly three sources contribute to the input of trace metals in the world
oceans:
- rivers
- the atmosphere
- hydrothermal inputs from active ridges.
It should be remembered that the river inputs are retained to a large extent in
the estuaries and in the coastal zone (see Table 80). The atmospheric inputs, which
are less known than the fluvial inputs, have been discussed in Chapter 4, especially
with regard to the complex processes at the sea-air interface and the origin of the
oceanic aerosol. Little information is available on the influence of active ridges on
the supply of trace elements to the world oceans. The available data will be dis-
cussed in this chapter.
Removal of trace metals includes the settling of the particulate phases and the
incorporation of dissolved metals in biological tissues and their adsorption on par-
ticulate matter; furthermore manganese nodules may playa role in the removal of
trace elements from the oceans.
The reactivity of elements in the ocean varies to a large extent. In Fig. 133, the
mean oceanic residence time is shown together with current estimates on element
concentrations and some characteristic time scales for oceanic processes. The mean
oceanic residence time varies over several orders of magnitude between elements.
For major elements like sodium, the oceanic residence time is near to the age of
oceanic sediments, whereas for some trace elements the residence time is shorter
than one oceanic stirring time, showing their low reactivity in the marine environ-
ment.
The processes affecting trace metals in the oceans can be schematised with box
models (Broecker, 1974; Lerman, 1979). A four box model which includes the sed-
iments is shown in Fig. 134. (It is possible to include a fifth box: the air-sea inter-
face. However, the processes occurring in this box have already been discussed in
Chapter 4.)
wim.salomons@home.nl
Introduction 259
I I ~I~
I I I
: I Ca SM9 I Major
I I K:
I ------~-----~----E-----Jl---~r- ---
I
-4
.. 10 I N
I lSI F LI Sr :
- I I I
~ I I P Rt I Minor
I: I
I I I
Fig. 133. Concentrations and mean oceanic residence time of elements in the ocean together with some
characteristic time scales of oceanic processes (Whitfield, 1982)
Atmosphere
Rive rs
~
Dissolved
-• Particulate
... ::
..
:-(Bi ota)
Surface layer
Dow nwelling:
, Upwelling;
:
--
Selliing
particulate
... ..
.. -_. Deep layer
•
: Sedi ment -water
interlace
Net
sedimentation Sediments
Fig. 134. Four box model of the ocean
wim.salomons@home.nl
260 Metals in the Ocean
wim.salomons@home.nl
Vertical and Horizontal Distribution of Trace Metals 261
Deep ocean
Since the mid-seventies important advances have been made in solving the prob-
lems associated with sampling, storage and analysis of trace metals at the low levels
occurring in the oceans due to the pioneering work of C. Patterson at the California
Institute of Technology (Goldberg, 1981).
The amount of reliable data on the metal distribution in the oceans is still
limited and the present discussion gives merely a state-of-the-art overview of the
available knowledge in a field in which rapid advances are being made.
Metal distribution in the Pacific Ocean, which has been studied by independent
groups, is the best known at present. Profiles of cadmium, zinc, copper, nickel to-
gether with those for the nutrients phosphates, nitrate and silicate are presented in
Fig. 136.
All four metals studied (cadmium, zinc, copper and nickel) are depleted in the
surface layers, as are the nutrients nitrate, silicate and phosphate.
A comparison of the cadmium profile with those for the nutrients shows a
strong resemblance. In fact a high correlation is observed between phosphate and
cadmium (Boyle et ai., 1976; Bruland et ai., 1978; Bruland, 1980). The linear cor-
relation can be explained by a removal of cadmium from the surface waters by or-
ganisms. The organic tissue carrier is regenerated in the thermocline, releasing cad-
mium and the labile nutrients. Also a good correlation is observed between the Cd/
Ca concentration in recent benthic foraminifera and the phosphate concentrations
in bottom waters (Hester and Boyle, 1982). This relationship can be utilized to re-
construct chemical variations in the oceans from fossils in deep-sea sediment cores.
The profile of zinc shows a regeneration at greater depths, as is also the case
with silicate. A good linear correlation is observed between zinc and silicate, show-
wim.salomons@home.nl
262 Metals in the Ocean
.. to
PHOSPHATE (I/mol/kg) NITRATE (I/mol/kg) CADMIUM (nmol/kg)
..
SILICATE (I/mol/kg)
00 2.0 3.0 o.a to
. ..
00 10 20 30 40 40 80 120 160 00 0.2 0.4 0.6 t2
~
01'.
.. .
..
_2 2
e2 .. e 2
E
::I: e: '"
i"
:
:I:
.... :I:
.... ....
Il. .... Il. Il.
::;3
UJ UJ UJ
03 03 03
0
4 4 4 4
5 5 5 5
..
COPPER (nmol/kg) ZINC ("rimol/kg) NICKEL (nmol/kg)
00 1 2 3 4 5 00 2 4 6 8 10 00 2 4 6 8 10 12
e2 e: 2 e2
: :I:
~
:I:
.... ....
Il.
:I:
....
Il. W Il.
~ 3 03 ~ 3
4 4 4
5 5 5
Fig. 136. Metal concentrations along profiles in the central gyre of the Pacific Ocean (Bruland, 1980)
ing that the release of zinc is associated with the regeneration of hard skeletal ma-
terial.
The profile of nickel is similar to the one reported by Sclater et al. (1976). In
the upper 800 m it appears to be similar to phosphate (Bruland, 1980), while at
greater depths it exhibits a maximum similar to silicate. Nickel appears to undergo
both a shallow and deep water regeneration cycle.
The profile for copper differs from those for the other three metals; it shows
a surface minimum, but the copper concentration increases with depth. Similar ob-
servations have been made by Boyle et al. (1977). The curves are interpreted as the
result of vertical advection of bottom waters high in copper and diffusive mixing
with overlying intermediate waters. Results on copper in pore water show that
oceanic sediments are able to provide the overlying bottom waters with copper
wim.salomons@home.nl
Vertical and Horizontal Distribution of Trace Metals 263
(Klinkhammer, 1980) (see Chap. 7.4.3.1). The curvature of the copper profile im-
plies scavenging in deep and intermediate waters. Similar scavenging might also
take place for Cd, Zn and Ni. However, their distributions are strongly influenced
by the internal biogeochemical cycles, which makes it difficult to observe these re-
moval processes (Bruland, 1980).
The horizontal distribution of trace metals in the surface waters of the Pacific
(Bruland, 1980; Boyle et ai., 1981) and in the Atlantic (Boyle et ai., 1981) shows
large differences in concentrations. The lowest concentrations of Cd, Ni and Cu
were observed in non-upwelling open-ocean areas; metal concentrations are high
in cold nutrient-rich waters (Boyle et ai., 1981). The distinctly higher copper con-
centrations in the coastal waters north of the Gulf of Panama and in shelf waters
north of the Gulf Stream may be caused by copper remobilised from mildly reduc-
ing shelf sediments (Boyle et ai., 1981). As an example of horizontal variations in
the Pacific data for a transect from Hawaii to Monterey, California are presented
in Fig. 136. Although for Cu, Ni, Zn and Cd a large removal is found in the surface
layers a large part is regenerated in the deep water or at the sediment-water inter-
face (Cu) and returned to the water masses and through upwelling entering the sur-
face layer again. Comparatively little loss occurs to the sediments during each stir-
ring time. This means that the metals can participate in the vertical redistribution
processes under steady state conditions for a long time, requiring only small exter-
nal inputs to the water column, just sufficient to balance losses to the sediments
(Schaule and Patterson, 1981).
Crecelius (1982) calculated the input from the atmosphere and by upwelling in-
to a 100 m thick surface layer for an open ocean area remote from river inputs and
land masses. Some results are presented in Table 81.
Although these calculations give only order of magnitude estimates on the flux-
es, they clearly show the important contribution of the atmosphere for the elements
Pb and Zn, and the importance of upwelling for Ni, Cr, Cu and Co. It should be
noted, however, that the ocean at present is not in a steady state. The concen-
Table 81. Mean concentrations in the surface (0-100 m) and subsurface layer, the input and output
from the surface layer and the % contribution of the atmosphere to the total input to the surface layer
(Crecelius, 1982)
wim.salomons@home.nl
264 Metals in the Ocean
2
DEPTH
(km)
Copper (nM-kg- 1 )
.
Cadmium (nM-kg- 1 ) Zinc (nM-kg- 1 )
o 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1.0 0 2.0 4.0 6.0 8.0 0 1.0 2.0 3.0 4.0 5.0
o~ '."6
~
J
• P • ~
500 0
• 0
• 0
•
0
• 0
• 0
•
1000 0 • 0 • o •
1500 0
• 0
• o.
!
-
.I:.
Q,
CD
Q
2000 0
North Atlantic
0
North •
Pacific
0
North Atlantic
0
•
North
Pacific
Northo
Atlantic
0
•
North
Pacific
2500
• • •
3000 0
•
0
• 0
•
3500
• • •
4000 • • •
trations in the deep layers still partly reflect the pre-industrial period. Especially
for lead (and possible for cadmium) the anthropogenic inputs to the surface layer
have to be considered. Undoubtedly, this type of calculation will be refined in the
future when more data become available.
Schaule and Patterson (1981) compared the natural flux of lead to sediments
in the central North Pacific with present-day fluxes. The natural flux varied be-
tween 1.2 and 7.5 ng/cm 2 /yr with a mean value of about 3 ng/cm 2 /yr, whereas the
presentday flux to the surface waters was estimated to be 68 ng/cm 2 /yr, which is
wim.salomons@home.nl
Vertical and Horizontal Distribution of Trace Metals 265
a 10 fold increase. Due to larger industrial emissions in North America than in Asia
the fluxes in the Atlantic are even higher (170-330 ng/cm 2 /yr) (Schaule and Patter-
son, 1983).
The high atmospheric input of atmospheric lead in the surface waters of
the oceans is reflected in the depth profiles for both the Atlantic and the Pacific
(Fig. 137).
A notable feature of Fig. 137 is the difference in lead concentrations between
the Atlantic and the Pacific, those in the Atlantic being significantly higher. This
is not the case for all trace metals. In the Pacific the concentrations of Cd, Cu, Zn
(Bruland and Franks, 1983) exhibit 2 to 4-fold increases. Examples of these differ-
ences are shown in Fig. 138.
This observation can be explained by the continuous supply of some trace
metals from degrading organic particles to deep waters along the trajectory of the
watermasses (e.g. the deep waters of the Pacific are derived partly from the Atlan-
tic), in a way similar to that for the nutrients (Broecker, 1974). Since the residence
time of the trace metals (except lead) is much longer than the stirring time of the
ocean, this leads to a continuous build-up of metal concentrations. The residence
time of lead, however, 100-150 years for the Northwestern Atlantic and 80 years
for the Northeast Pacific (Schaule and Patterson, 1983), is much lower than the
transit time of the deep water masses, and no build-up occurs.
As a consequence the concentrations in these waters are increasing in response
to large increases of lead input (see Fig. 55) during the past decades. The longer
residence time in the Atlantic causes a slower response than in the Pacific, and have
certainly not reached steady state (Schaule and Patterson, 1983). In the surface
waters, the residence time of lead is about 2 years and steady conditions prevail,
so that the present larger industrial lead input flux to the North Atlantic compared
to that in the North Pacific is recorded directly as higher concentrations in its sur-
face waters.
A few other elements also exhibit pronounced maxima in the surface layers.
This is especially true for cobalt and manganese, and in particular in profiles taken
close to the continent; this reflects riverine inputs (Landing and Bruland, 1980;
Martin and Knauer, 1980; Schaule and Patterson, 1981; Knauer and Martin,
1982). The influence of riverine inputs on the distribution of manganese is also
shown by their increase in surface water concentrations close to the continents in
transects from the open ocean to the continent (Schaule and Patterson, 1981) and
by the correlation between salinity and cobalt concentrations (Knauer et aI., 1982).
Lead concentrations on the other hand (and also 21O-Pb) decrease (Fig. 139).
This removal oflead on the continental shelves is probably associated with the
increased biological activity and elevated loads of organic and inorganic particles.
Turekian (1977) showed that very little lead escapes the estuaries and coastal areas.
Li et aI. (1981) studied seasonal cycles of 210-Pb concentrations in waters of the
New York Bight. They found that the pathway of phytoplankton-zooplankton-fe-
cal pellets is not important for the removal of 21O-Pb in the shelf, but in the slope
areas. Also during winter periods they observed a regeneration of 21O-Pb from the
sediments and a transport back to the surface waters. The most likely overall re-
moval of 21O-Pb from the shelf surface water is adsorption onto suspended parti-
cles and subsequent settling to the bottom.
wim.salomons@home.nl
266 Metals in the Ocean
o o
111315 171820212325
HAWAII MONTEREY
BAY
A number of studies have been carried out in the Arctic Ocean and surrounding
areas (Moore, 1981; Rahn, 1981; Campbell and Yeats, 1982; Heggie, 1982). In po-
lar areas no surface depletion is observed; on the contrary, in most cases concen-
trations in surface waters are higher than in deep waters. The copper profiles ob-
served by Campbell and Yeats (1982) and by Heggie (1982) show, like the profiles
from mid-latitudes, an increase in copper concentrations with depth, indicating
that also in these areas the bottom sediments are a significant source for copper.
Campbell and Yeats (1982) found that the concentrations in sea ice and glacier
ice are higher than those for surface waters from the same area. They concluded
that the spatial and vertical variation in trace metal concentrations is determined
by the high metal concentrations in the inflowing waters. Rahn (1981) made a bal-
ance calculation for the Arctic Ocean, which showed that for aluminium,
manganese, cadmium and lead the riverine inputs were comparable to either the
surface or below-surface oceanic inputs. Except for lead the atmospheric inputs are
much lower than either the riverine or oceanic inputs.
Particulates form the conveyer belt by which dissolved metals are ultimately trans-
ported to the sediments. With regard to the interaction between particulates and
metals four depth zones can be recognised in the oceans (Lal, 1980):
- fluvial and aeolian input in surface waters and biological fixation in the euphotic
zone (0-100 m),
- grazing by zooplankton, fragmentation and oxidation in the top 1 km level,
- sinking of particulates through the water column with associated in-situ biolog-
ical, physical and chemical changes, and
- dissolution of particulates and particulate-water exchange occurring at the
ocean-sediment interface.
wim.salomons@home.nl
Particulates and Metal Behaviour 267
wim.salomons@home.nl
268 Metals in the Ocean
...
°I'~'E
an ....
en
E
18 33
~
726
64
"E
(33)
21
(4a)
876
6)
12 2 4 6 8 10 12 12 2 4 6 8 10 12 12 2 4 6 8 10 12 12 2 4 6 8 10 12
Month in 1980
Fig. 140. Total mass flux, organic carbon, carbonate and lithogenic particle flux at three different depths
in the Panama Basin (Honjo, 1982b)
impacting particle until the sticky layer degrades. The process happens repeatedly
for a particle of micron size so that the effective sinking velocity is that of the larger
impacting particle (Lal, 1980).
Recent experiments using sediment traps have given convincing evidence for
such a kind of mechanism. Result from sediment trap experiments in the Panama
Basin are presented in Fig. 140.
Fluxes are high in the months March and July corresponding to high carbon
fixation in the surface waters (March) and high zooplankton biomass in May-July.
Large differences in the lithogenic particle fluxes are observed between the traps
at 1890 m, 2590 m and 3560 m. A large fraction of these excess lithogenic particles
did not originate from surface waters (Honjo et aI., 1982a). Fine lithogenic parti-
cles are probably resuspended from the slope and lateralIy transported to the sta-
tion by the westerly undercurrent (Honjo, 1982a). The coccolithophorid Muscus
probably plays a major role in the vertical transport of these lithogenic particles
by scavenging and agglutinating them while they are settling through the water col-
umn (Honjo, 1982b), the sinking speed of the aggregates being accelerated due to
wim.salomons@home.nl
Marine Sedimentary Facies 269
the addition of heavier lithogenic particles. These factors would give rise to the
higher lithogenic flux in deeper traps, particularly during the period in which a
large quantity of Muscus is available.
In this way certain anthropogenic metal additions to the oceans, those which
are not redissolved during settling, are able to influence the composition of oceanic
bottom sediments on a relatively short time scale.
Marine sediments are highly variable in origin and composition. Terrestrial inputs,
marine-biogenous formations and hydrothermal discharge have made their im-
prints on the sedimentary components. Thus, the sedimentary sequence can reflect
the variations of wind directions, seasonal changes of river discharges and of pri-
mary production in the euphotic zones of the sea as well as variations of volcanic
activity in the rift areas (Soutar and Crill, 1977; Deuser and Ross, 1980; Campo
et aI., 1982). Marine deposits consist of debris from erosion processes on the con-
tinents - mainly quartz, feldspars, clay minerals and detrital carbonates, shells and
organic matter derived from biogenous processes, pumice from volcanic events and
cosmic spherules (Seibold and Berger, 1982).
The process of rock formation, which starts with sedimentation or resedimen-
tation, is governed by the intensity of diagenetic processes such as compaction, re-
crystallization, cementation and especially the rate of sedimentation. Sedimenta-
tion at the continental slopes occurs at a rate of 100 mm/l000 yr and 1-20 mm/
1000 yr in the deep-sea. This represents an average continental erosion rate of 60
mm/l000 yr (Seibold, 1975). Generally it can be determined that in the North At-
lantic, a relatively young ocean surrounded by various landmasses, substantial
amounts of weathering products are contributed by rivers. In the equatorial
Pacific, an oceanic region relatively isolated from land, however, internal effects
such as the composition of volcanoclastic materials combined with biological pro-
ductivity, and sea water chemistry are dominant (Davies and Gorsline, 1976).
Therefore, the general term "ocean sediment" should be specified according to the
particular situation with respect to the various inputs and processes.
Whereas the sediments of the shelf zone and the continental slope consist chiefly
ofland-derived detritus (terrigenous sediments), pelagic sediments, ooze or pelagic
ooze are made up mainly of organic skeletal remains of micro-organisms. Red
brown clays are either derived from land or originate from local input of volcanic
material. A differentiation of the biogenous deposits is usually made according to
the major groups of micro-organisms in the open ocean (Reineck and Singh, 1979):
(i) Globigerina ooze is made up mainly of tests of various planktonic foramini-
fera, especially of Globigerina; additional platelets of coccoliths, radiolarian shells,
diatom parts and pteropods are also abundant.
wim.salomons@home.nl
270 Metals in the Ocean
wim.salomons@home.nl
~
po
::l.
i'I
C/l
(1)
P.
~.
::s
S
~
'11
O.
(1)
'"
wim.salomons@home.nl
::~~~ Clay or no deposil .:: .' Calcareous Ooze ~ Siliceous Ooze D Shelf and Slope Deposils BDeep Sea Muds ~~ Glacial Debris
IV
-..J
Fig. 141. Distribution of principal types of sediment on the floors of the ocean (Berger, 1974)
272 Metals in the Ocean
RADIOLARIA FORAMNFERA
O~~~~~~~~~~----------------I°
VIRTUALLY NO 2
DISSOLUTION IN
TRANSIT
3
Fig. 142. Dissolution profiles of siliceous and calcareous material compared. (after Berger, 1970 from
Kenneth, 1982). Silica reflects biological fertility of surface waters, whereas carbonate biogenic sedi-
ments generally are an expression of the preservation of calcium carbonate at depth
compensation depth (CCD). The "CCD" tends to be depressed under the equator-
ial high productivity belt but occurs at lesser depths in highly productive ocean
margins. The latter effect is a result of an abundance of organic matter which leads
to the development of carbon dioxide-rich, and hence corrosive, bottom water. An-
other level similar to the CCD which can be charted to describe dissolution pat-
terns is the lysocline - a contour following the boundary zone between well- and
poorly-preserved foraminifera assemblages (Seibold and Berger, 1982). The rate of
carbonate dissolution increases at the lysocline, being approx. 3600 m in depth in
the tropical Pacific.
Residual red-brown clay dominates at lower organic productivities within
deep-sea basins. The median diameter of this material is in the clay size range
« 2 !lm). Clay minerals and other resistant mineral residues derived from land are the
main constituents together with volcanic ash. The red clay of the South Pacific is
mainly made up of authigenic clay minerals, produced by in situ alteration of vol-
canic material (Reineck and Singh, 1979). The accumulation rate of calcareous ma-
terial ranges from 10 to 20 mm/lOOO years, that for siliceous material from
4-5 mm/lOOO years, whereas the rate of deposition of pelagic clays in the Pacific is
about 2 mm/lOOO years (Van Andel et aI., cited in Davies and Gorsline, 1976).
wim.salomons@home.nl
Metal Concentrations 273
Fe Mn Cu Ni Co Zn
(I) Wedepohl (1960), (2) Forstner and Stoffes (1981), (3) Chester and Aston (1976), (4) Cronan (1976),
(5) Turekian and Wedepohl (1961)
wim.salomons@home.nl
274 Metals in the Ocean
wim.salomons@home.nl
Metal Enrichment in Deep-Sea Sediments 275
wim.salomons@home.nl
276 Metals in the Ocean
wim.salomons@home.nl
Metal Enrichment in Deep-Sea Sediments 277
0 20 250 500
0
E
U
II
I
II
II
20 I
...%
II. I
II I I
I
I
I
I I
I
W 40 I I I I I
0 I I I
I
80
Fig.143. Pore water distribution of nitrate, manganese, iron, copper and nickel (Klinkhammer, 1980)
A.
E.
Fig. 144. Fluxes of manganese and copper in northeast equatorial Pacific Ocean (Callender and Bowser,
1980)
7.4). The graphs in Fig. 144 show fluxes of manganese and copper in typical sed-
iments from the northeastern equatorial Pacific Ocean, as estimated by Callender
and Bowser (1980): Manganese is transported to and deposited in pelagic sediment
associated with terrigenous particles, whereas the input of copper is predominantly
regulated by biogenic phases such as organic matter, skeletal calcium carbonate,
or silica. During diagenesis there is a minimal transport of manganese from sedi-
ment to overlying water; dissolution of biogenic materials releases copper, which
wim.salomons@home.nl
278 Metals in the Ocean
is, in part, incorporated into micro nodules actively growing in surficial sediments
and, in part lost to the overlying water column by diffusive transport. The decreas-
ing ratios of manganese nodules to sediment accumulation rates of manganese in
the order of "pelagic clay" < "siliceous pelagic clay" < "siliceous ooze" evidently
represent a gradient of increasing diagenesis from pelagic clay to siliceous ooze.
With regard to the copper data, the most important aspect is that both sediment
accumulation and associated nodule accumulation flux rates are very small in com-
parison to diagenetic flux rates (Callender and Bowser, 1980). Experimental data
of Hartmann (1979) and Pfeiffer et al. (1982) have shown that with weak chemical
reduction, elements such as Mn, Ni and Co were preferentially leached from metal-
liferous sediments and nodules; the same elements revealed a typical deficiency in
yellow coloured zones of red-brown pelagic clay (Hartmann, 1979). The incon-
sistency which shows copper to be present in high concentrations, but barely mo-
bilized by diagenetic reduction has not been completely and satisfactory explained.
According to Ruppert (1980) Cu- and Zn-ferrites possibly occur in or on cells of
planktonic organisms that remain stable after transport to the ocean bottom and
after decomposition of the organic parts. Halbach et al. (1979) found copper and
zinc in Pacific Ocean sediment to be concentrated in small particles « I /lm),
whereas Ni and Mn are generally associated with "micronodules", which can be
considered as the reservoir of metals to be incorporated into the manganese nod-
ules.
The characteristic form in which autochthonous, diagenetic metal accumu-
lations occur is Mn nodules (Cronan, 1976). An estimated 1.5.10 12 tons of
manganese nodules are on the Pacific Ocean floor alone, and they are estimated
to be forming at an annual rate of about 10 6 tons (Mero, 1979). Averaging about
4 cm in diameter, these manganese nodules contain as much as 2.5 percent copper,
2.0 percent nickel, 0.2 percent cobalt and 35 percent manganese respectively. Such
concentrations would be considered high-grade ores if found on land. Because of
the large horizontal extent of the deposits, the nodules are a potential source of
many important industrial metals. (Preliminary work suggests that physical and
smelting methods of separation are not the best and that chemical techniques -
leaching with either hydrogen sulfide or hydrogen chloride and separation in ion-
exchange processes - hold the most promise; cost estimates of such a process are
about 8-15 US Dollars per ton of nodules; Ross, 1978).
Manganese nodules are particularly abundant -locally covering as much as 75
percent or more of the sea floor - in a broad area between about 6° Nand 20° N
extending from approx. 120° W to 160° E in the Pacific Ocean, where the sedimen-
tation rates are lower than in the equatorial zone to the south. The abundance and
spatial density of nodules in the Atlantic Ocean is lower than in the Pacific; rela-
tively high concentrations occur in the areas of clay deposition between the abyssal
plains bordering the continents and the Mid-Atlantic Ridge. An important factor
for the distribution of nodules or incrustations is the rate of accumulation of their
associated sediments. Generally high sedimentation rates are thought to inhibit
nodule growth, perhaps by burying potential nuclei - or even the nodules them-
selves (Cronan, 1976). On the other hand, nodule growth can also be increased by
higher sedimentation rates if these contribute to an increased diagenetic remobil-
ization of manganese, which is followed by an upward migration of this metal and
wim.salomons@home.nl
Metal Enrichment in Deep-Sea Sediments 279
its reprecipitation at the sediment-water interface, such as has been observed in the
area of Baja California (Cronan and Tooms, 1969).
In the discussion on the origin of the metals in the manganese nodules the
iron:manganese ratio plays an important role (Seibold and Berger, 1982). These
authors have noted that the Mn/Fe ratio is greater in the Pacific than in the Atlan-
tic and that the content of trace elements in Pacific nodules is, on the average,
about twice that of Atlantic ones. The Mn/Fe ratio obviously increases with the
degree of oxidation and with depth. High manganese content appears to be fa-
voured by both high biogenous sediment supply and low rates of accumulation;
under these conditions, presumably, the carrier material dissolves but leaves be-
hind its content of trace elements.
Four major types of nodules can be distinguished (Mero, 1965; Glasby and
Read,1976):
A-type, iron rich nodules found in the South Pacific are thought to have formed
by the preferential depositions of iron from a water mass moving towards Tahiti;
B-type, manganese-rich nodules found mainly in or near the Gulf of California.
These nodules are generally depleted in Cu, Ni and Co probably due to the rapid
formation, which provides insufficient time for the incorporation of trace metals
onto the manganese-rich colloids;
C-type, copper- and nickel-rich nodules found in the central parts of the Pacific
farthest from land and thought to reflect the importance of biological activity par-
ticularly associated with the high-productivity zone of the equatorial divergence;
D-type, cobalt-rich nodules on topographic highs in the central parts of the
Pacific, which are characterized by highly oxidizing environments.
A very strong enrichment of metals in manganese nodules is demonstrated by
Tl, Mo, Co (more than lOO-fold compared with crustal abundances), Ag, Ir, Pb,
Ni, Cu, Bi Wand Cd (30-100-fold enrichment), whereas other elements (e.g. Ca,
AI, Si and Cu) are more or less strongly "diluted" (Table 83; after Cronan, 1976).
The specific enrichment mechanisms have been discussed by Li (1982); using
R-mode factor analysis, most of the elements in abyssal ferromanganese nodules
and associated pelagic sediment would fall in one of the three major phases: "alu-
mino-silicates", "Fe-oxides" or "Mn-oxides".
These data have also been recalculated in terms of enrichment factors (Fig.
145). The enrichment factor, E, is defined here as the average concentration ratio
Table 83. Enrichment of elements in Pacific ferro-manganese concretions relative to crustal abundances
(data from Cronan, 1976)
wim.salomons@home.nl
280 Metals in the Ocean
3~--------------------------------------------------'
Ti
OSe W
• 500
2
--- -- -.- ....
Mn
.Co
-:
NI
•
-
~
·Ag
- - - •- - • - ·Sb
~
- - - - - - -?Ir
?
- - -OBi- -
~O
100
50
.-w« 1
CI
___
BOO P 0 Ti
OV)(
S~_ - - 0 - --0- ~~~N~ _ ~ _ :~"tJ~
Fe 0
In
S~ L~ Nd J ~o Lu
_______
oHg
10._
5 w
«
o
...I M9)( )( Ca Pd)( U Yb )(Au 3
o A A
Si~S~c
A Ga Ba
________________________________________ ~
2
Be AI AK
ANa 0.5
ACr
• Manganese oxide phase
o Iron oxide phase
-1 ... Aluminosillcate 0.1
X More than one phase
wim.salomons@home.nl
Metal Enrichment in Deep-Sea Sediments 281
Pb have been interpreted according to the data of Buser (1959), Goldberg (1961),
Burns (1965), Burns and Fiirstenau (1966), Burns (1976), and Moorby and Cronan
(1981) to imply that divalent manganese in the disordered layer of 10 A manganite
(todorokite) might be replaceable by other ions. These mechanisms lead to a stable
phase containing Ni, Cu, Zn and other divalent ions, whereas the general associ-
ation of Co and Pb with b-Mn0 2 -rich nodules may result from the replacement of
Mn 4 + in b-Mn0 2 by Co3+ and Pb 4 + or their substitution for Fe3+ in the iron ox-
ide phases of the nodules, such as FeOOH. Recently evidence has been given for
a non-hydrogenous origin of some of the manganese crusts. "Hydrothermal
manganese deposits" from the Galapagos Rift (Malahoff et aI., 1982) and from the
south-west Pacific Island Arc (Cronan et aI., 1982) characteristically consist of
well-crystalline birnessite, as well as todorokite (whereas normal hydrogenous
ferromanganese oxide encrustations consist mainly of b-Mn0 2 or amorphous
ferromanganese oxides). Elements Cu, Ni, Co and Zn are generally lower than
their concentrations in hydrogenous Fe/Mn-oxides.
wim.salomons@home.nl
282 Metals in the Ocean
et aI., 1980) showed two main types of intimately associated products: a polymetal-
lic sulfide-rich material composed of pyrite and marcasite in association, zinc-rich
phases, and copper-rich compounds, and an iron-rich and hydroxide material com-
posed largely of goethite and limonite. Whereas the polymetallic sulfides are be-
lieved to have been formed by rapid cooling at the sea floor-seawater interface,
many of the hydrous iron oxides observed - forming large portions of the specimen
collected - result from low-temperature alteration of pre-existing sulfide phases.
Silicate phases such as opaline silica, iron-silicon clay, and trace amounts of mica
and zeolite are encountered in both types of autochthonous products. The discov-
ery of these deposits provides a new focus for deep-sea exploration, leading to new
assessments of the concentration of metals in the upper layers of the oceanic rust.
Following the earlier deposition of iron silicates and polymetallic sulfide (Red
Sea, Galapagos Rift) the last phases of a hydrothermal fractionation sequence
seems to be the formation of very Mn-rich deposits poor in Cu, Ni and Co, as was
recognised by Cronan et aI. (1982) in the south-west Pacific Island Arc; it is clear
therefore that in addition to mid-ocean ridges, modem island arcs must also be tar-
gets in future exploration for potentially exploitable submarine massive sulfide de-
posits. Recent data of Edmond et aI. (1982) show that ridge crest hydrothermal ac-
tivity is pervasive and chemically relatively uniform and that the fluxes of the vari-
ous elements injected into (or removed from) the ocean are substantial when com-
pared with fluvial transport. The dispersal of this effluent is controlled by the glo-
bal oceanic circulation at mid-depths. Hotspring organisms that have motile ben-
thic larvae also control the dispersal of elements.
A characteristic example of metal accumulations resulting from geothermal ac-
tivity - the chemistry of the brines is determined by the sediment or rock through
which water percolates - are the Red Sea deposits. Ridge crest accumulations of
the Red Sea were found in 1883 by the British vessel "Discoverer". In some
"deeps" of the central graben, the bottom is filled with a hot salt brine with a tem-
perature of about 60°C and a salinity of25%, seven times that of seawater (Degens
and Ross, 1969). Although the exact formation mechanisms of the Red Sea mineral
deposits is still essentially unknown, Bischoff (1969) has proposed some processes
to explain the different facies in the hot brine (Fig. 146).
Hot, metalliferous solutions may have developed from reactions of seawater
with the freshly formed basalt near the axis of an active spreading center. These
solutions may have percolated through deposits of Tertiary age, containing sever-
al-hundred-meter-thick salt and gypsum layers which abut against the newly
formed sea floor. Metals and salts have been dissolved and issued into the brine
(Seibold and Berger, 1982). These brines are probably composed of metal-chloride
and metal-bisulfide complexes of low Eh and near-neutral pH; part of the metals
precipitate upon cooling or oxidation. In the Red Sea deposits three different facies
are the major carriers of metal accumulations (Bischoff, 1969; Degens and Ross,
1976).
1. Goethite-amorphous jacies, consisting of orange to yellow beds underlying iron-
montmorillonites: Poorly crystalline goethite and amorphous limonite of vary-
ing proportions are the major components. In some areas there is a well-crys-
tallized hematite suggesting a higher temperature, perhaps due to proximity to
a vent.
wim.salomons@home.nl
Metal Enrichment in Deep-Sea Sediments 283
(
ATLANTIS ]I DEEP SILL
CaS04 PRECIPITATES
PRECIPITATES
(OXIDATION)
~
,/ ~t + ~
~ Zns PRECIPITATES
COOLING, REALEASE OF
METALS FROM COMPLEXES
/ \.
"
\Ol\,:O
o
~
\, I
.~"'"
1f
~
..
I POINT OF
I BRINE DISCHARGE
II
ZnS and PbS PRECIPITATION
ALONG CRACKS and FISSURES
(COOLlNG,RELEASE OF
METALS FROM COMPLEXES)
~'*'-/
.\ I
° ~
METAL METAL-CI- METAL-HS-,COMPLEXES
LOW Eh,pH NEAR NEUTRAL T > saGc
Fig. 146. Schematic representation of some of the possible processes of mineral precipitation within the
Atlantis II Deep of the Red Sea (Bischoff, 1969)
2. Sulfide facies, a black homogenous unit and generally the deepest unit pen-
etrated. Sphalerite, with lesser amounts of chalcopyrite and pyrite make up this
unit, which is potentially the economically most valuable unit.
3. Manganite facies, containing well-crystallized manganite with occasional to-
dorokite oflocal occurrence.
In the economically most valuable of the Red Sea "deeps", the Atlantis II
Deep, which has an area measuring only 6 x 15 km, the exploitable ore minerals
in the extremely fine grained sediments are mainly sphalerite and chalcopyrite. The
minerals containing the valuable metals zinc, copper and silver can be separated
from the prevailing iron oxides and silicates by flotation methods. Due to the rel-
atively low grade of the ore, transport of the bulk mined material and processing
onshore is not feasible economically; therefore, separation has to be carried out on
bord of the mining vessel and the resulting tailings have to be disposed off nearby
(Lange et aI., 1981). According to calculations from 1980 there are 1.7 million tons
of zinc, 400,000 tons of copper and 4,000 tons of silver, apart from exploitable por-
wim.salomons@home.nl
284 Metals in the Ocean
tions of sulfur and gold. The analytical total value of the Zn, Cu- and Ag-contents
represents an actual market value of approx. 3 billion US dollars (Lange et aI.,
1981). Studies carried out since 1976 to investigate the environmental implications
of the tailings disposal indicate that the adverse effects can be minimised if the ma-
terial is discharged below 800-1000 m water depth (Lange et aI., 1981); with these
procedures the tailings can be kept away from the biologically active coastal areas,
i.e. from the coral reefs and their associated fauna.
The processes discussed in the preceding sections show the complex interactions
between geochemical and biological cycles, and their influence on lateral and ver-
tical distributions of trace metals in the world oceans. However, we have not yet
adressed the processes governing the absolute concentrations of metals in the
oceans (Fig. 133).
An order of magnitude estimate of these concentrations can be made by placing
the hydrological cycle in its proper geological context as has been done by Whit-
field and co-workers (Whitfield and Turner, 1979a; Whitfield, 1979; Whitfield,
1981; Martin and Whitfield, 1983). In this content the oceans are part of the four
reservoir geological system (Fig. 147).
The sedimentary material deposited in the oceans is incorporated in the endo-
genic cycle. Here it is compacted and/or subject to metamorphic processes and
forms new continental material (after uplift). The residence time of the elements
on the continents is relatively short and sedimentary material will have been re-
cycled through the oceans ten or a dozen times; sedimentary rocks took on "mod-
em" characteristics implying that also the composition of the ocean has been con-
stant over the same period to the same extent (Garrels and Mackenzie, 1972). So-
lution of the differential equations describing the four reservoir model at steady
state suggest that there is a relationship between the mean oceanic residence time
and the partition function Ky defined as:
K/SW) = Y(concentration in seawater)/Y(concentration in crustal rock)
This partition function describes the efficiency with which seawater extracts ele-
ments from crustal rocks. The relationship is found to hold good for nearly 60 ele-
Sediment
Fig.147. The oceans as part of a four-re-
servoir system (Whitfield, 1981).
wim.salomons@home.nl
Cycling of Trace Metals Between Continents and Oceans 285
1o.-------------------------------------------------------------------------,
CI
•
Na
8
•
Rb,U
• Ca
6
•co •
F. tl.MO
LU,Tm
v• • :~
. / . P Au Sa
.N
.z.
AI. F.... Pb Cu
./ e .Mn •
·Ce
~L8----------_~6-------------~4-----------~2~------~0~---------~2---------~4
Log Ky (SW)
4.-----------------------------------------------,
'.
2
.
-.........C
N ............
o -.........
R-"""'"
:.M~~
As .U ,
i -2 •
.Sb
lAg
Hg
.Cd
-.........
~
... '-... "-... PI w ·Bi
Ge,Ni .Zn
-.........
-.........
~ '-...... • TI • • V "-...
CI
~U Si Cr "-...
.3 -4 ~
•
·Co : ...... Ta Hf '-......
~n. G~Pb Be ~I Tm,Lu ............
-......... • Nb Mn. E Ybl OY ........
Ti .Zr r, Ho La,Nd,Sm,Eu,Gd
-6 .Fe '-...
.AI
SCI
Y
Tb~pr -.........
-......... Ce.
"-...
'-...... B
-8~----------~------------~----------~----------~
2 4 6
Q yO
Fig. 148. A Correlation between mean oceanic residence time (ry) and the partition coefficient of ele-
ments between crustal rocks and seawater. B Correlation between the electro negativity function (Qyo)
and the partition coefficient (Whitfield, 1981)
wim.salomons@home.nl
286 Metals in the Ocean
ments (Fig. 148 A), providing strong circumstantial evidence for the steady state
ocean (Whitfield, 1981).
For the removal of elements in his model, Whitfield used the approach of
Schindler (1975), which assumes that the initial removal takes place by adsorption
at the surface of oxygen dominated mineral lattices followed by incorporation into
the crystal structure. Elements which bound strongly to the solid phase (e.g. those
which have a high electro negativity function for the element in question and for
oxygen) should therefore have small partition coefficients. In fact such a correla-
tion is indeed observed (Whitfield and Turner, 1979): Fig. 148A, B shows that the
partition coefficients of the elements in the main sequence (e.g. trace metals) are
controlled by their solid state chemistry (Whitfield, 1981). These correlations also
imply a series of simple relationships between the mean oceanic residence time and
the electronegativity function.
With this approach, by taking the electronegativity function and the present
flux of dissolved components discharged into the oceans from the world rivers, it
was possible to calculate a sea water composition that is correct to within an order
of magnitude for more than 40 elements (Fig. 149).
This shows that the composition of the world ocean is controlled by relatively
simple geochemical processes. Furthermore the oceans have been in a steady state
equilibrium with crustal rocks for about 2 billion years. However, for some trace
elements, this equilibrium state is no longer in existence due to large anthropogenic
additions of elements such as lead into the hydrological cycle.
7r-------------------------------------~~
'0 2
~
;;
u
iii
.2
,. 0
1>-•
.2'" -2
-4
-4 -2 o 2 4 6 7
Fig. 149. The calculated and observed concentrations of elements in the oceans (Whitfield, 1979)
wim.salomons@home.nl
8 Summary and Outlook
In the preceding six chapters an overview of recent developments of trace metal be-
haviour on the earth's surface has been given. Hydrological cycles have been used
as a convenient framework, which enable the various interactions ofbiogeochemi-
cal factors in an integrated system - both natural as well as effected by man's im-
pact to be presented.
In retrospect it seems that the single most important development over the last
decade was the recognition of the manifold problems associated with trace metal
analysis and especially with sampling. The partial solution of these difficulties has
resulted in an increasing number of reliable data on metal concentrations in rivers,
lakes, estuaries, and, in particular, in the world's oceans. In addition, data have
been obtained on metal concentrations in biological materials and increasingly on
metal concentrations in the atmosphere. These basic data are essential for an
understanding of the processes affecting trace metal distribution in the hydrologi-
cal cycle and for elucidating the sources, transport, and fate of man-made dis-
charges of trace metals, as well as the results of other human pertubations on the
natural cycling of trace metals, such as eutrophication, discharge of complexing
agents, and acid rain.
There are still several open questions connected with sampling and analysis,
and in some respect with the interpretation of the data. One major question is stiII
the position of colloidal metal species in water samples. Many difficulties are as-
sociated with the discrimination of dissolved and particulate metal concentrations
by filtration, centrifugation, etc. Moreover it has become evident that total metal
concentrations in surface waters, as they are being measured on a large scale by
several agencies, have at most only a monitoring character and bear little relevance
to the ecotoxicological impact on the aquatic environment.
Both the ecotoxicological impact and geochemical processes are determined by
the physicochemical forms of the metals (speciation). Several approaches are pres-
ently being carried out to study the speciation of metals. Only one class of metals
can be measured directly, e.g. the organo-metal compounds like methyl-mercury
and similar compounds. Several elegant analytical methods have been developed
in this respect. However, for the majority of the heavy metal species in surface
waters, it is necessary to rely on operational defined metal speciation schemes. Sev-
eral are in use. However, a good link with metal speciation in the field and bioac-
cumulation has been reported only in a few cases. A complicating factor in finding
this link is the labile nature of the metal species which causes changes in the spe-
ciation after sampling. In the field of particulate metal speciation the several ap-
proaches have resulted in the proposition of a "recommended" speciation scheme.
However, in the field of dissolved metal speciation a large number of schemes are
wim.salomons@home.nl
288 Summary and Outlook
in use with different approaches (e.g. ASV, filtration, etc.) and no single scheme
of a more general nature has appeared; undoubtedly in the near future one will
have to reach some kind of mutual agreement on a simple scheme which would
make it possible to compare the results of different investigators.
Speciation is not only important for a study ofbioavailability, in addition it de-
termines geochemical processes as well. The adsorption of metals on model com-
pounds is rather well studied, and the application of the results and approaches to
the "real world" have recently started. Although research and understanding in
this field are increasing, they are hampered by the limited knowledge of the adsorp-
tive species and the exact nature of the surface of the particulates in the water.
Much more research is needed to understand the removal of trace metals from sur-
face waters and their incorporation in the sediments. This also holds true for the
reverse process: the circumstances which cause a remobilization of the trace metals.
The importance of sediments in the aquatic system is now well recognized.
Since sediments, in contrast to the dissolved metals, reflect the condition of the wa-
ter body over longer periods of time, information can be obtained on the current
condition of a water system as well as on the historical development of certain hy-
drological and chemical parameters. Sediment data are playing an important role
within the framework of environmental forensic investigations, particularly in
those cases in which a short-term or past pollution event is not or only insufficient-
ly traceable from water analysis. Furthermore, sediments are increasingly recog-
nized as a pollutant proper and as a carrier and possible source of contaminants
in aquatic systems. Metals temporarily immobilized on the suspended matter and
in bottom sediments of aquatic systems may be released, for example, as a result
of physicochemical changes, such as the lowering of the pH, increased salinity, an
alteration in the redox conditions, and an increased input of organic chela tors. It
seems, therefore, that for effective strategies in pollution control, more attention
has to be paid to the dynamic nature of metal distribution, and, in particular, to
the relative stabilities of the metal pollutants within interim storage sites. It is quite
probable that in the assessment of the availabilities of metals for biological inter-
action, the concept of relative mobility is more relevant than that of accumulation.
The former includes knowledge of the concentrations, the fluxes, as well as the spe-
cies of the metals - both actual and potential- in the environment.
Within the hydrological cycle the atmospheric trace metals playa central role.
They are able to influence all geochemical compartments of the hydrological cycle
on very short time scales. The importance of atmospheric trace metals has been rec-
ognized over the last 10 years, which reflects in the increased research in this field
especially with regard to the association with acid rain. Both pollutants (acidity
and metals) combined have a greater impact on aquatic and terrestrial ecosystems
than either of them alone. Research will have to be carried out on processes at the
interface between atmosphere and surface water to determine the fate of the metal
input from the atmosphere, and, at the interface between atmosphere and vegeta-
tion (e.g. the processes of metal uptake at leaf surfaces). Furthermore acid precip-
itation may enhance metal uptake by vegetation. This is an area in which further
research is necessary.
The great variety in soils in drainage areas of rivers, the variety in industries
and the variability in the hydrological regime of a river make the processes affect-
wim.salomons@home.nl
Summary and Outlook 289
ing metal concentrations in rivers extremely complicated. Often no steady state be-
tween dissolved and particulates exists. Periods of deposition of contaminated sed-
iments are intermittent with periods of high discharge resulting in erosion of the
contaminated sediments. In addition discharges of other chemicals (NT A, chloride
and phosphates) effect metal behaviour in a complicated pattern. The same is true
for lakes fed by rivers. For some lakes the atmosphere may be an important addi-
tional source of metals. In lakes, metal research is still hampered by a lack of good
data. Only recently data have become available, which show a strong link between
the carbon cycle in the lake and trace metal behaviour. In lakes subject to acidic
input and lying in areas devoid of carbonate rocks, the pH decrease causes an in-
crease in metal concentrations. In deep lakes both the links of metals with the car-
bon cycle and with the redox cycle have to be taken into account. The link with
the redox cycle is complicated and needs further research. On the whole, trace
metal behaviour in lakes and rivers appears to be less well studied than trace metal
behaviour in oceans. Further research is strongly needed since lakes are major eco-
logical units and, compared with other ecological units in the hydrological cycle,
more subject to the stress imposed by man.
Intensive research has been carried out over the last decade on the processes
occurring at the interface between the continents and the oceans (e.g. the estuaries).
The nature of the processes has been subject to large shifts in the common census.
Earlier investigations favoured mobilization, later on removal was favoured,
whereas nowadays it is recognised that the processes are highly complicated. In the
same estuary mobilization of one element may occur whilst for other elements re-
moval takes place. Trace metal concentrations are highly influenced by hydro-
dynamic processes, causing mixing of marine and fluvial sediments, and the exis-
tence of turbidity maxima, the latter favouring adsorption processes. Due to com-
bination of chemical and physical processes it has not yet been possible to present
a general theory on the processes affecting both particulate and dissolved metal
concentrations in estuaries. This also makes it difficult to predict the fate of dis-
charges of chemicals in estuaries and in the near shore environment.
The strong impetus on trace metal analysis, resulting in the many new dis-
coveries over the last 10-15 years, has been borne out by studies on the metal be-
haviour in the oceans. A number of good profiles of trace metal concentrations in
both major oceans, the Pacific and the Atlantic, have been obtained, and also data
for arctic areas have been reported. The profiles show a strong link, as in lakes,
with the carbon cycle in the surface waters. The deeper layers show release from
and scavenging by particulates as well as the release from bottom sediments. The
extent of these different processes is element-specific. In remote areas of the oceans,
the atmosphere is a major source of trace metals, isotope analysis oflead even mak-
ing it possible to identify their sources. The further development of theories on the
interactions between particles and metals as well as man's influence on metal con-
centrations in the oceans will continue to form major research areas.
Metal pollution of surface waters, which caused considerable public concern
during the 1970's, seems to have passed its climax in critical cases partly as a result
of recent improvements of waste water treatment, partly as the result of the partial
replacement of metals in several applications, and as a result of the general effects
of the slowdown in industrial activity. However, problems with metal pollutants
wim.salomons@home.nl
290 Summary and Outlook
still exist both on a local and regional scale: Waters oflarge areas in southern Scan-
dinavia and in eastern North America are severely endangered by the combined
effects of air-borne pollutants and acidity. Increasing quantities of dredged ma-
terials and waste deposits represent long-term reservoirs for the release of metals
possibly involving detrimental effects for the quality of both ground water and ag-
ricultural products.
Since the general objective in pollution control is containment, processes in-
volving dispersion should be restricted. Examples of the latter, which generally
seem to be increasing, include high-temperature emissions from fossil fuel burning,
smelting and from the cement production. Acid precipitation multiplies the effects
of the influences of high temperature emissions on a regional scale. The introduc-
tion of synthetic chelators, such as nitrilotriacetic acid (to replace phosphates in
detergents), elevated salinities (due to salt discharges) and the change of the redox
conditions, all interfere with natural removal processes and may mobilize metals
from the sediments. The knowledge of the chemical interactions of metals in the
hydrological cycle can therefore, in a practical sense, be used to establish counter-
measures against the mobility of metals at critical sites, e.g. predominantly at the
sources of metal release, such as coal-burning power plants, smelters and electro-
plating works; acid mine drainage; at waste dumps, both on land and in the sea;
at sites where sewage sludge is applied as fertilizer; and casually in the water supply
system at enhanced corrosion.
Modelling of the processes affecting trace metals is becoming increasingly im-
portant, however there is still a lack of thermodynamic and kinetic data. Neverthe-
less, modelling is extremely useful in predicting trends under changing environ-
mental conditions.
The environmental impact assessment of trace metals is still subject to intensive
research. Results up to now show that total metal concentrations have only a moni-
toring function and cannot be used to assess their ecotoxicological impact. The
same holds for the classification of sediments by pollution indices. As has already
been stressed sediments are part of a dynamic system. Contaminated sediments in
high pH environments have a different ecotoxicological impact than the same sed-
iments in a low pH environment. Also, in the selection of dumping sites for metal-
contaminated wastes the dynamic approach should be used in contrast to a strict
classification scheme. At present, environmental impact can only be assessed on a
case by case study, and extrapolation of the results from one study area to other
areas should be carried out with extreme caution.
wim.salomons@home.nl
References
Abdullah MI, Royle LG (1974) A study of the dissolved and particulate trace elements in the Bristol
Channel. J Mar Bioi Assoc U K 54:581-597
Abdullah MI, Royle LG, Morris AW (1972) Heavy metal concentration in coastal waters. Nature
235: 158-160
Ackermann F (1980) A procedure for correcting the grain size effect in heavy metal analysis of estuarine
and coastal sediments. Environ Technol Lett I: 518-527
Adler DM, Santschi PH, Chervin M, Amdurer M, Hinga KR (1981) The role of zooplankton grazing
in the removal of metals from shallow estuaries (unpublished manuscript)
Agemian H, Chau ASY (1976) Evaluation of extraction techniques for the determination of metals in
aquatic sediments. The Analyst \0 1:761-767
Allan RJ (1971) Lake sediment, a medium for regional geochemical exploration of the Canadian Shield.
Can Inst Min Met Bull 64:43-59
Allan RJ (1974) Metal contents oflake sediment cores from established mining areas: An interface of
exploration and environmental geochemistry. Geol Surv Can Pap 74:43-49
Allan RJ (1977) Natural versus unnatural heavy metal concentrations in lake sediments in Canada.
Proc Int ConfHeavy Metals in the Environment, Toronto. II/2:785-808
Allan RJ, Brunskill GJ (1977) Relative atomic variation (RAY) of elements in lake sediments: Lake
Winnipeg and other Canadian lakes. In: Golterman H (ed) Proc Int Symp Interactions between
sediments and fresh water. Junk Publ. The Hague. 108-118
Allen HE, Noll KE, Jamjun 0, Boonlayangoor C (1978) Reactions of cadmium in Lake Michigan.
Kinetics and equilibria. Abstr Pap Am Chern Soc 176: 14
Allen HE, Hall RH, Brisbin TD (1980) Metal speciation. Effects on aquatic toxicity. Environ Sci Tech-
noI14:44I-443
Allen HE, Boonlayangoor C, Noll KE (1982) Changes in physiochemical forms of lead and cadmium
added to a freshwater. Environ Int 7:337-341
Allen RO, Steinnes E (1979) Contribution from long-range atmospheric transport to the heavy metal
pollution of surface soil. In: Heavy Metals in the Environment. CEP Consultants, London: 271-274
Altschuler ZS (1978) Trace elements as discriminants of origin in marine phosphorites. Abstr 10th Int
Congress of Sedimentology, Jerusalem. pp 16-17
Amdurer M, Adler DM, Santschi, PH (1982) Radiotracers in studies of trace metal behavior in me-
socosms: advantages and limitations. In: Grice GD, Reeve MR (eds) Marine Mesocosms. Biolog-
ical and chemical research in experimental ecosystems.
Amdurer M, Adler DM, Santschi PH (1983) Studies of the chemical forms of trace elements in sea water
using radiotracers. Proc Adv Res Inst "Trace metals in sea water" Erice, Sicily, Italy. Wong CS,
Boyle EA, Bruland KW, Burton JD, Goldberg ED (eds) Plenum Press, New York. 537-562
Andel TJ van, Heath G, Moore TC (1975) Cenozoic history and paleoceanography of the Central
Equatorial Pacific Ocean. Mem Geol Soc Am 143: 134
Anderson A (1976) On the determination of ecologically significant fractions of some heavy metals in
soils. Sew J Agric Res 6: 19-27
Anderson MA (1981) Kinetic and equilibrium control of interfacial reactions involving inorganic ionic
solutes and hydrous oxide solids. In: Brinckman FE, Fish RH (eds) Environmental Speciation and
Monitoring Needs for Trace Metal-Containing Substances from Energy-Related Processes. US
Dept. Commerce, Washington DC. 146-162
Anderson MA, Rubin AJ (eds) (1981) Adsorption ofinorganics at Solid-Liquid Interfaces. Ann Arbor
Sci Publ, Ann Arbor: 357 pp
wim.salomons@home.nl
292 References
Anderson TW (1973) Historical evidence ofland use in a pollen profile from Osoyoos Lake, British
Columbia. Geol Surv Can Rep 73: 178-180
Andreae MO (1979) Arsenic speciation in seawater and interstitial waters: The influence of biological-
chemical interactions on the chemistry of a trace element. Limnol Oceanogr 24:440-452
Andreae MO, Klumpp D (1979) Biosynthesis and release of organoarsenic compounds by marine algae.
Environ Sci Technol13:738-741
Andren AW, Lindberg SE (1977) Atmospheric inputs and origin of selected elements in Walker Branch
Watershed, Oak Ridge, Tennessee. Water Air Soil Pollut 8: 199-215
Andren AW, Harriss RC (1975) Observations on the association between mercury and organic matter
dissolved in natural waters. Geochim Cosmochim Acta 39: 1253-1257
Andrew RW, Biesinger KE, Glass GE (1977) Effects of inorganic complexing on the toxicity of copper
to Daphnia Magna. Water Res 1l:309-315
Andrews, RD (1977) Tailings: Environmental consequences and controls. Proc Int Conf Heavy Metals
in the Environment, Toronto 1975 II/2:645-675
Angino EE, Galle OK, Waugh TC (1969) Fe, Mn, Ni, Co, Sr, Li, Zn, and Si0 2 in streams of the lower
Kansas River basin. Water Resour Res 5:698-705
Anonymous (1976) Environmental problems of River Rhine. The Council of Experts on Environmental
Affairs (FRG) Kohihammer, Stuttgart, 258 pp
Anonymous (1979) Richtwerte fUr Blei, Cadmium und Quecksilber in und auf Lebensmitteln. Dtsch
Lebensm Rundsch 75:319
Anonymous (1982) DFG-Forschungsbericht "Schadstoffe im Wasser", 3 Vols., H. Boldt, Boppard
(FRG)
Arnold RG (1970) The concentration of metals in lake waters and sediments of some Precambriam
lakes in the Flin Flon and La Ronge areas. Sask Res Counc Div Circ 4: 30 pp
Arrhenius GOS, Korkish J (1959) Uranium and thorium in marine minerals. Int Oceanogr Congr Am
Assoc Adv Sci Preprints, Washington DC, 497 pp
Asami T (1981) The Iche and Maruyama River basins: Soil pollution by cadmium, zinc, lead and copper
discharged from Ikuno mine. In: Kitagishi K, Yamane I (eds) Heavy Metal Pollution in Soils of
Japan. Jpn Sci Soc Tokyo: 227-236
Aston SR (1978) Estuarine chemistry. In: Riley JP, Chester R (eds) Chemical Oceanography, vol 7,
Academic London, 508 pp
Aston SR, Chester R (1973) The influence of suspended particles on the precipitation of iron in natural
water. Estuarine Coastal Mar Sci 1:225-232
Aston SR, Thornton I (1975) The application of regional geochemical reconnaissance surveys in the
assessment of water quality and estuarine pollution. Water Res 9: 189-195
Aston SR, Thornton I (1977) Regional geochemical data in relation to seasonal variations in water
quality. Sci Total Environ 7:247-260
Aston SR, Thornton I, Webb JS, Millford JB, Purves JB (1975) Arsenic in stream sediments and waters
of south-west England. Sci Total Environ 4:347-358
Aubert M, et a!. (1974) Use of a trophodynamic chain of the neritic type with molluscs for the study
of the transfer of metallic pollutants. Rev Int Oceanogr Med. 33, cit JWPCF. 4: 1625 pp
Baccini P (1976) Untersuchungen iiber den Schwermetallhaushalt in Seen. Schweiz Z HydroI38:121-
158
Baccini P, Joller T (1981) Transport processes of copper and zinc in a high eutrophic and meromictic
lake. SchweizZ HydroI43:176-199
Baccini P, Suter U (1979) Melimex, an experimental heavy metal pollution study: chemical speciation
and biological availability of copper in lake water. Schweiz Z Hydrol41 :291-314
Baccini P, Grieder E, Stierli R, Goldberg S (1982) The influence of natural organic matter on the ad-
sorption properties of mineral particles in lake water. Schweiz. Z. Hydro!. 44:99-116
Bacon JR, Maas RP (1979) Contamination of Great Smoky Mountains trout streams by exposed
Anakeesta Formations. J Environ Qual 8:538-543
Bacon MP, Elzerman AW (1980) Enrichment ofPb-210 and Po-21O in the sea surface micro layer. Na-
ture 284:332-334
Bacon MP, Anderson RF (1982) Distribution of thorium isotopes between dissolved and particulate
forms in the deep sea. J Geophys Res, 87:2045-2056
Bale AJ, Morris AW (1981) Laboratory simulation of chemical process induced by estuarine mixing:
the behaviour of iron and phosphate in estuaries. Estuarine Coastal Shelf Sci 13: I-I O.
wim.salomons@home.nl
References 293
Balistrieri L, Brewer PG, Murray JW (1981) Scavenging residence times of trace metals and surface
chemistry in sinking particles in the deep ocean. Deep-Sea Res 28A: I 0 1-121
Balzer W (1982) On the distribution of iron and manganese at the sediment/water interface: thermo-
dynamic versus kinetic control. Geochim Cosmochim Acta 46: 1153-1161
Banat K, Forstner U, Miiller G (1972) Schwermetalle in Sedimenten von Donau, Rhein, Ems, Weser
und Elbe im Bereich der Bundesrepublik Deutschland. Naturwissenschaften 12:525-528
Barendrecht E (1967) In: Bard AJ (ed) Electroanalytical chemistry.Vol 2 Marcel Dekker, New York
Barrie LA, HoffRM, Daggupaty SM (1981) The influence of mid-latitudinal pollution sources of haze
in the Canadian Arctic. Atmos Environ 8: 1407-1420
Basin NJ (1975) Suspended marine clay mineral identification by scanning electron microscopy and en-
ergy-dispersive X-ray analysis. Limnol Oceanogr 20: 133-137
Batley GE (1983) The current status of trace element speciation studies in natural waters. In: Leppard
GG (ed) Trace element speciation in surface waters and its ecological implications. Plenum, New
York, 17-36
Batley GE, Florence TM (1976) A novel scheme for the classification of heavy metal species in natural
waters. Anal Lett 9:379-388
Batley GE, Florence TM (1976) Determination of chemical forms of dissolved cadmium, lead and cop-
per in seawater. Mar Chern 4:347-363
Batley GE, Gardner D (1978) A study of copper, lead and cadmium speciation in some estuarine and
coastal waters. Estuarine Coastal Mar Sci 7:59-70
Batley G E, Giles MS (1980) A solvent displacement technique for the separation of sediment interstitial
waters. In: Baker RA (ed). Contaminants and Sediments. Ann Arbor Sci Pub I 2: 101-117.
Baudo R (1982) The role of the speciation in the transfer of heavy metals along the aquatic food web.
In: Ravera 0 (ed) Ecological effects on heavy metals speciation in aquatic ecosystems. Ispra-Cour-
ses, Ispra/ltaly. Unpublished manuscript, 31 pp
Beeftink WG, Nieuwenhuize J, Stoeppler M, Mohl C (1982) Heavy metal accumulation in salt marshes
from the Western and Eastern Scheidt. Sci Total Environ 25: 199-223.
Beijer K, Jernelov A (1978) Ecological aspects of mercury-selenium interactions in the marine environ-
ment. Environ Health Perspect: 25-43
Beijer K, Jernelov A (1979) Methylation of mercury on aquatic environments. In: Nriagu JO (ed) The
biogeochemistry of mercury in the environment. Elsevier/ North-Holland Biomedical Amsterdam
New York Oxford, p 203-211
Benes P (1980) Semi continuous monitoring of truly dissolved forms of trace elements in streams using
dialysis in situ. 1. Principle and conditions. Water Res 14:511-513
Benes P, Steinnes E (1974) In situ dialysis for the determination of the state of trace elements in natural
waters. Water Res 8:947-953
Benes P, Steinnes E (1975) Migration forms of trace elements in natural fresh waters and the effect of
the water storage. Water Res 9:741-749
Benes P, Steinnes E (1976) On the use of radio nuclides in the study of behaviour and physicochemical
state of trace elements in natural waters. Int J Environ Anal Chern 4:263-274
Benes P, Gjessing ET, Steinnes E (1976) Interactions between humus and trace elements in freshwater.
Water Res 10:711-716
Benjamin MM, Leckie JO (1980) In: Baker RA (ed) Contaminants and sediments. Ann Arbor Sci Publ,
Ann Arbor, Mich. Vol 2: 305-322
Benjamin MM, Leckie JO (1981) Multiple-site adsorption of Cd, Cu, Zn and Pb on amorphous iron
oxyhydroxide. J Colloid Interface Sci 79:209-211
Benjamin MM, Hayes MM, Leckie JO (1982) Removal of toxic metals from power-generation waste
streams by adsorption and co-precipitation. J Water Pollut Control Fed 54: 1472-1481
Benjamin MM, Leckie JO (1982) Effects of complexation by CI, S04, S203 on adsorption behaviour
of Cd on oxide surfaces. Environ Sci TechnoI16:162-169
Berg CMG, Kramer JR (1979) Conditional stability constants for copper ions with ligands in natural
waters. In: Jenne EA (ed) Chemical modelling in aqueous systems. Am Chern Soc Symp Ser 93: 115-
132
Berg CMG, Wong DTS, Chau YK (1979) Measurement of complexing materials excreted by algae and
their ability to ameliorate copper toxicity. J Fish Res Board Can 36:901-905
Berg CMG v d, Kramer JR (1979) Determination of complexing capacities of ligands in natural waters
and conditional stability constants of the copper complexes by means of manganese dioxide. Anal
Chim Acta 106: 113-120
wim.salomons@home.nl
294 References
Berger WH (1970) Biogenous deep-sea sediments: fractionation by deep-sea circulation. Bul1 Geol Soc
Am81:1385
Berger WH (1974) Deep-sea sedimentation. In: Burk CA, Drake CL (eds) The geology of continental
margins. Springer, Berlin Heidelberg New York. 213-241
Berner RA (1980) Early Diagenesis. A theorethica approach. Princeton Univ Press, Princeton, NJ,
241 pp
Berner RA (1981) A new geochemical classification of sedimentary environments. J Sediment Petrol
51:359-365
Bernhard M, Renzoni A (1977) Mercury concentration in Mediterranean marine organisms and their
environment: natural or anthropogenic origin. Thalassia Jugosl 13:265-282
Bernhard M, Branica M, Piro A (1978) Distribution of zinc in the Ligurian Sea and the Gulf of Taranto
with special consideration of the sampling procedure. Mar Chern 6:260-274
Bernhard M (1978) Heavy metals and chlorinated hydrocarbons in the Mediterranean. Ocean Manage-
ment 3:253-313
Bertine KK, Goldberg ED (1971) Fossil fuel combustion and the major sedimentary cycle. Science
173:233-235
Betz M (1979) Separation ofnatural1y occurring high molecular weight metal complexes from sea wa-
ter. Mar Chern 7:165-170
Bewers JM, Yeats PA (1977) Oceanic residence times of trace metals. Nature 268:595-598
Bewers JM, Yeats PA (1978) Trace metals in the waters of a partial1y mixed estuary. Estuarine Coastal
Mar Sci 7: 147-162
Bewers JM, Yeats PA (1979) The behavior of trace metals in estuaries of the St. Lawrence Basin. Nat
Can 106:149-161
Bewers JM, Yeats PA (1981) Behaviour of trace metals during estuarine mixing In: Martin JM, Burton
JD, Eisma D (eds) River inputs to ocean systems. Proc UN Rev Worksh Rome, 103-115
Bewers JM, Windom HL (1982) Comparison of sampling devices for trace metal determinations in sea
water. Mar Chern II :71-86
Bhat GA, Saar RA, Smart RB, Weber JH (1981) Titration of soil-derived fulvic acid by copper(ii) and
measurement of free copper(ii) by anodic stripping voltammetry and copper(Il) selective electrode.
Anal Chern 53:2275-2280
Billen G, Joiris C, Wol1ast R (1974) Bacterial methyl mercury mineralizing activity in river sediments.
Water Res 8:219-225
Biscaye PE (1972) Strontium isotope composition and sediment transport in the Rio de la Plata estuary.
In:Environmental framework of coastal plain estuaries. Geol Soc Am Memoirs 133:349-357
Bischoff JL (1969) Red Sea geothermal brine deposits: their mineralogy, chemistry and genesis. In: De-
gens ET, Ross DA (eds) Hot brines and recent heavy metal deposits in the Red Sea. Springer, Berlin
Heidelberg New York. 368-40 I
Bischoff JL, Greer RE, Luistro AD (1970) Interstitial waters of marine sediments: Temperature of
squeezing effects. Science 167: 1245-1246
Bitton G, Freihofer V (1978) Influence of extracel1ular polysaccharides on the toxicity of copper and
cadmium toward Klebsiella Aerogennes. Microb Ecol4: 119-125
Blanchard DC, Woodcock AH (1957) Bubble formation and modification in the sea and its meteoro-
logical significance. Tenus 9: 145-158
Blanchard DC (1963) Electrification of the atmosphere by particles from the sea. Prog Oceanogr 1:71-
202
Blanchard DC, Hoffmann EJ (1978) Control of jet drop dynamics by organic material in sea water.
J Geophys Res 83:6187-6191
Blanchard DC, Woodcock AH (1980) The production, concentration and vertical distribution of sea
salt aerosols. Ann N Y Acad Sci 338:330-347
Bloom H, Ayling GM (1977) Heavy metals in the Derwent Estuary. Environ GeoI2:3-22
Bloom PR (1981) Metal-organic matter interactions in soil. In: Chemistry of the Soil Environment.
ASA Spec Publ Soil Sci Soc Am, Madison, Wisc. 40: 129-150
Blutstein H, Shaw RF (1981) Characterization of copper binding capacity in lake water. Environ Sci
TechnoI15:1100-1102
Bonatti E, Kraemer J, Rydel1 H (1972) Classification and genesis of submarine iron-manganese de-
posits. In: Hom DR (ed) ferromanganese deposits on the ocean floor. Nat Sci Found, Washington
DC. 149-166
wim.salomons@home.nl
References 295
Bond AM (1980) Modern polarographic methods in analytical chemistry. Marcel Dekker New York,
Basel
Bopp F, Biggs RB (1981) Metals in estuarine sediments: Factor analysis and its environmental signif-
icance. Science 214:441-443
Bostrom K, 10ensuu 0, Brohm I (1974) Plankton: Its chemical composition and its significance as a
source of the pelagic sediments. Chern GeoI14:255-271
Bothner MH, Carpenter R (1972) Sorption-desorption reactions of mercury with suspended matter in
the Columbia River. Symp. Interactions of radioactive contamination with the constituents of the
marine environment. Seattle, Wash., 10-14 luly 1972. IAEA-Vienna.
Bothner MH, Carpenter R (1974) Rate of mercury loss from contaminated estuarine sediments in Bel-
lingham Bay, Washington. Proc First Ann NSF Trace Contam Conf 1973: 198-210
Bothner MH, lahnke RA, Peterson ML, Carpenter R (1980) Rate of mercury loss from contaminated
estuarine sediments. Geochim Cosmochim Acta 44:273-285
Boulegue 1 (1983) Trace metals (Fe, Cu, Zn, Cd) in anoxic environments. In: Wong CS, Boyle E, Bru-
land KW, Burton lD, Goldberg ED (eds) Trace metals in sea water. NATO Conf Series, IV: Ma-
rine Sciences, Plenum, New York London, pp 563-577
Boulegue 1, Lord Cl, Church TM (1982) Sulfur speciation and associated trace metals (Fe, Cu) in the
pore waters of Great Marsh, Delaware. Geochim Cosmochim Acta 46:453-464.
Bourg ACM (1979) Effect ofligands at the solid-solution interface upon the speciation of heavy metals
in aquatic systems. Proc Int Conf Heavy Metals in the Environment, London: 365-368
Bourg ACM (1982) Reactions at the water-solid particulate matter (S.P.M.) interface. In: Ahrland S,
Nancollas G (eds) Trace elements in natural waters. I UPAC
Bourg ACM (1983) Role of fresh water/sea water mixing on trace metals adsorption phenomena. In:
Wong CS, Burton lD, Boyle E, Bruland K, Goldberg ED (eds) Trace Metals in Sea Water, Plenum
New York: 195-208
Boust D, 10uanneau 1M, Latouche C (1981) Methodologies d'interpretation des teneurs totales en me-
taux traces contenues dans les sediments estuariens et littoraux. Bull Inst Geol Bassin d'Aquitaine,
Bordeaux. 30:71-86
Boutron C (l979a) Alkali and alkaline earth enrichments in aerosols deposited in Antarctic snows. At-
mos Environ 13:919-924
Boutron C (l979b) Past and present day trophospheric fallout fluxes ofPb, Cd, Cu, Zn and Ag in Ant-
arctica and Greenland. Geophys Res Lett 6: 159-162
Boutron C (1979c) Trace element content of Greenland snows along an east-west transect. Geochim
Cosmochim Acta 43: 1253-1258
Boutron C (1980) Respective influence of global pollution and volcanic eruptions on the past, variations
of the trace metals content of antarctic snows since 1880's. 1 Geophys Res 85:7426-7432
Boutron C, Delmas R (1980) Historical record of global atmospheric pollution revealed in polar ice
sheets. Ambio 9:210-215
Boutron C, Martin S (1980) Sources of twelve metals in Antarctic snows determined by principal com-
ponent analysis. 1 Geophys Res 85:5631-5638
Bowen H1M (1977) Residence times of heavy metals in the environment. Proc Symp Heavy Metals in
the Environment. Toronto 1975, I: 1-9
Bowen H1M (1979) Environmental Chemistry of the Elements. Academic, London New York Toronto.
333 pp
Bowen HJM, Berrow ML, Burton lD, Cawse PA, Patterson DSP, Statham Pl, Ure Am (1982) Environ
Chern Vo12. R Soc Chern, Burlington House London
Bowles FA (1968) Microstructure of sediments: investigation with ultrathin sections. Science 19: 1236-
1237
Boyden CR, Aston SR, Thornton I (1979) Tidal and seasonal variations of trace elements in two Cor-
nish estuaries. Estuarine Coastal Mar Sci 9:303-317
Boyle EA (1978) Trace element geochemistry of the Amazon and its tributaries. EOS 59:276
Boyle EA, Huested SS, Grant B (1982) The chemical mass balance of the Amazon Plume II: copper,
nickel and cadmium. Mass Inst Technol: 24 pp
Boyle RW, 10nasson IR (1973) The geochemistry of arsenic and its use as an indicator element in geo-
chemical prospecting. 1 Geochem Explor 2:251-296
Boyle E, Collier R, Dengler AT, Edmond 1M, Ng AC, Stallard RF (1974) On the chemical mass-bal-
ance in estuaries. Geochim Cosmochim Acta 38:1719-1728
wim.salomons@home.nl
296 References
Boyle EA, Sclater F, Edmond JM (1976) On the marine geochemistry of cadmium. Nature 263:42-44
Boyle EA, Edmond JM, Sholkovitz ER (1977) The mechanisms of iron removal in estuaries. Geochim
Cosmochim Acta 41: 1313-1324
Boyle EA, Edmond JM (1977) Determination of copper, nickel and cadmium in sea water by APDC
chelate coprecipitation and Ilameless atomic absorption spectrometry Anal Chim Acta 91:189-197.
Boyle EA, Sclater FR, Edmond JM (1977) The distribution of dissolved copper in the Pacific. Earth
Planet Sci Lett 37:38-54
Boyle EA, Huested SS, Jones SP (1981) On the distribution of copper, nickel and cadmium in the sur-
face waters of the North Atlantic and North Pacific Ocean. J Geophys Res 89:8048-8066
Bradford GR, Bair FL, Hunsker V (1968) Trace and major element content of 170 High Sierra lakes
in California. Limnol Oceanogr 13:526-529
Bradford G R (1971) Trace elements in the water resources of California. Hilgardia 41 :45-53
Branica M, Sipos L, Bubic S, Kozar S (1976) Electroanalytical determination and characterization of
some heavy metals in sea-water. Nat Bur Stand Spec Publ442:917-928
Branica M, Novak OM, Bubic S (1977) Application of anodic stripping voltammetry to determination
of the state of complexation of traces of metal ions at low concentration levels. Croat Chern Acta
49:359-547
Brainina KhZ (1974) Stripping voItammetry in chemical analysis. Wiley, New York
Brannon JM, Engler RM, Hunt PG, Smith I (1976) Distribution of manganese, nickel, zinc, cadmium
and arsenic in sediments and the standard elutriate. Environ Effects Lab, US Army Eng Waterways
Exp Stn, Vicksburg Miss. Misc. Pap 0-76-18: 38 pp
Brar MS, Sekhon GS (1976) Interaction of zinc with other micronutrient cations. I. Effect of copper
on zinc adsorption by wheat seedlings and its translocation within the plant. Plant Soil 45: 137-143
Bratter P, Moller P, Rosick U (1971) In: Brunfeld AO, Steinnes E (eds) Activation analysis in geo-
chemistry and cosmochemistry. U niversitetsforlaget, Oslo. 461
Bray JT, Bricker OP, Troup BN (1973) Phosphate in interstitial waters of anoxic sediments: oxidation
effects during sampling procedure. Science 180: 1362-1364
Brewer PG (1975) Minor elements in seawater. In: Riley JP, Skirrow G (eds) Chemical Oceanograpgy.
Academic, London New York San Francisco. 2:425-496
Brewer PG, Nozaki Y, Spencer OW, Fleer AP (1980) Sediment trap experiments in the deep North At-
lantic: isotopic and elementaliluxes. J Mar Res 38:703-728
Brierley CL (1978) Bacterial leaching. Crit Rev MicrobioI6:207-262
Brierley JA (1981) Bacterial processes for transformation of metals. In: Brinckman FE, Fish RH (eds)
Environmental speciation and monitoring needs for trace metal-containing substances from energy
related processes. NBS Special Publication
Brinckman FE, Jackson JA, Blair WR, Olson GJ, Iverson WP (1983) Ultratrace speciation and biogen-
esis of methyItin transport species in estuarine waters. In: Wong CS et al. (eds) Trace Metals in
Sea Water. Plenum New York, 39-72
Brinkman GA, Raaphorst van W, Lyklema L (1982) In situ sampling of interstitial waters from lake
sediments. Hydrobiologia 92:659-663
Broecker WS (1974) Chemical Oceanography. Harcourt Brace Jovanovich, New York, 214 pp
Brooks RR, Presley BJ, Kaplan IR (1968) Trace elements in the interstitial waters of marine sediments.
Geochim Cosmochim Acta 32:397-414
Bruland KW (1980) Oceanographic distributions of cadmium, zinc, nickel and copper in the north
Pacific. Earth Planet Sci Lett 47: 176-198
Bruland K W, Bertine K, Koide M, Goldberg ED (1974) History of metal pollution in Southern Califor-
nia coastal zone. Environ Sci TechnoI8:425-432
Bruland KW, Franks RP (1983) Mn, Mi, Zn and Cd in the western North Atlantic. In: Wong CS, Boyle
E, Bruland KW, Burton JD, Goldberg ED (eds) Trace metals in sea water. NATO ConfSeries.
IV. Mar Sci, Plenum, New York London, pp 395-414
Bruland KW, Knauer GA, Martin JH (1978) Cadmium in northeast Pacific waters. Limnol Oceanogr
23:618-625
Bruland KW, Knauer GA, Martin JH (1978) Zinc in north-east Pacific water. Nature 271 :741-743
Brunner PH, Baccini P (1981) Die Schwermetalle, Sorgen kinder der Entsorgung? Neue Ziircher Zeitung
25 MarzNr70
Bryan GW (1980) Recent trends in research on heavy metal contamination in the sea. Helgol
Meeresunters 33:6-25
wim.salomons@home.nl
References 297
Bryan GW, Langston Wl, Hummerstone (1980) The use of biological indicators of heavy-metal con-
tamination in estuaries with special reference to an assessment of the biological availability of
metals in estuarine sediments from south-west Britain. Mar Bioi Assoc UK Occas Publ 1:73 pp
Bryan GW, Hummerstone LG (1971) Adaptation of the polycheate Nereis diversicolor to estuarine sed-
iments containing high concentrations of heavy metals. 1 Mar Bioi Assoc UK 52:845-863
Bryan GW, Hummerstone LG (1973) Adaptation of the polycheate Nereis diversicolor to estuarine sed-
iments containing high concentrations of zinc and cadmium. 1 Mar Bioi Assoc UK 53:839-857
Buat-Menard P (1979) Influence de la retombee atmospherique sur la chimie des metaux en trace dans
la matiere de l' Atlantique Nord. Doctoral Thesis, University Paris-VII, 434 pp
Bubela B, McDonald lA (1969) Formation of banded sulphides. Nature 221: 465-466
Bubic S, Sipos L, Branica M (1977) Electroanalytical determination of ionic zinc, cadmium, lead and
copper in sea-water. Proc IVth Int Symp Chemistry of Mediterranean, Rovinj. May 1976. Thalas-
sialugosl13:122-143
Buffle 1, Greter FL, Haerdi W (1977) Measurements of complexation properties of humic and fulvic
acids in natural waters with lead and copper ion-selective electrodes. Anal Chern 49:216-222
Buffle 1, Deladoey P, Haerdi W (1978) The use of ultrafiltration for the separation and fractionation
of organic ligands in fresh waters. Anal Chim Acta 101 :339-357
Buffle 1, Deladoey P, Greter FL, Haerdi W (1980) Study of the complex formation of copper (II) by
humic and fulvic substances. Anal Chim Acta 116:225-274
Buffle 1 (1980) A critical comparison of studies of complex formation between copper(II) and fulvic
substances of natural waters. Anal Chim Acta 118:29-44
Burns RG (1965) Formation of cobalt (III) in the amorphous FeOOH· nH 2 0 phase of manganese nod-
ules. Nature 205:999
Burns RG, Fuerstenau DW (1969) Electron-probe determination of inter-element relationships in
manganese nodules. Am Mineral 51 :895-902
Burns RG (1976) The uptake of cobalt into ferromanganese nodules, soils and synthetic manganese(IV)
oxides. Geochim Cosmochim Acta 40:95-102
Burrell DC (1979) The behaviour of iron, manganese and zinc in a heavely polluted river-estuary sys-
tem. Mar Sci Comm 5:283-295
Burton lD (1978) The models of association of trace metals with certain compounds in the sedimentary
cycle. In: Goldberg ED (ed) Biogeochemistry of Estuarine Sediments. Unesco Paris: 33-41
Burton lD, Statham Pl (1982) Occurrence, distribution and chemical speciation of some minor dis-
solved constituents in ocean waters. In: Bowen H1M (ed) Environmental Chemistry. R Soc Chern,
London 2:234-263
Buser W (1959) The nature of the iron and manganese compounds in manganese nodules (abst.). In:
Sears M (ed) Oceanography-Preprints Int Oceanogr Congr, Am Assoc Adv Sci. Washington DC.
962-964
Butterworth 1, Lester P, Nickless G (1972) Distribution of heavy metals in the Severn Estuary. Mar
Pollut Bull 3:72-74
Byrne lV, Kulm L (1967) Natural indicators of estuarine sediment movement. 1 Waterw Harbour Div
181-194
Callender E, Bowser Cl (1980) Manganese and copper geochemistry of interstitial fluids from
manganese nodule-rich pelagic sediment of the northeastern equatorial Pacific Ocean. Am 1 Sci
280: 1063-1096
Callender E, Bowser Cl, Rossman R (1974) Geochemistry of ferromanganese and manganese carbon-
ate crusts from Green Bay, Lake Michigan. Trans Am Geophys Union 54:340
Calvert SE, Price NB (1977) Geochemical variation in ferromanganese nodules and associated sedi-
ments from the Pacific Ocean. Mar Chern 5:43-74
Calvert SE, Price NB, Heath G R, Moore TC (1978) Relationship between ferromanganese nodule com-
positions and sedimentation in a small survey area of the equatorial Pacific. 1 Mar Res 36:161-183
Calvert SE, Batchelor CE (1978) Major and Ie 379A, Leg 42B, Deep Sea Drilling Project, Initial Reports
of the Deep Sea Drilling Project. US Govt Printing Office, Washington DC, 42:527-539
Cambray RS, lefferies DF, Topping G (1975) An estimate of the input of atmospheric trace elements
into the North Sea and the Clyde Sea (1972-1973). UK Atomic Energy Auth Harwell, R30
Cameron EM, Ballantyne SB (1975) Experimental hydrogeochemical surveys of the High Lake and
Hackett River areas, Northwest Territories. Geol Surv Can 75-29: pp 19
wim.salomons@home.nl
298 References
Campbell JA, Yeats PA (1982) The distribution of manganese, iron, nickel, copper and cadmium in
the waters of Baffin Bay and the Canadian Arctic Archipelago. Oceanol Acta 5: 161-168
Campo Evan, Duplessy JC, Rossignol-Strick M (1982) Climatic conditions deduced from a 150-kyr
oxygen isotope pollen record from the Arabian Sea. Nature 296:56-58
Capelli R, Contardi V, Zanicchi G (1976) Enquete explorative sur la teneur en metaux lourds (Cd-Co-
Cu-Cr-Mn-Ni-Pb) dans les echantillons de moules (Mytilus galloprovincialis L.). J Etudes Pollut
Mar. XXV Congres Comm Int Explor Sci Mer Split Oct. 1976
Carmody DJ, Pearce JB, Yasso WE (1973) Trace metals in sediments of New York Bight. Mar Pollut
Bull 4: 132-135
Carpenter JH, Bradford WL, Grant V (1975) Processes affecting the composition of estuarine water
(H 2 C0 3 , Fe, Mn, Zn, Cu, Ni, Cr, Co, and Cd). In: Cronin LE (ed) Estuarine Research,!. Aca-
demic, London New York: pp 137-152
Castilho P del, Gerritse RG, Marquenie JM, Salomons W (1983) Metal speciation and the in-situ ac-
cumulation by the mussel Dreissena Polymorpha. Int Conf: Heavy metals in the environment,
Heidelberg:47 1-474
Cato I, Olsson I, Rosenberg R (1980) Recovery and decontamination of estuaries. In: Olausson E, Cato
I (eds) Chemistry and Biogeochemistry of Estuaries. Wiley Chichester/England 13:403-440
Cauwet G, Elbaz F, Jeandel C, Jouanneau JM, Lapaquellerie Y, Martin JM, Thomas AJ (1980) Com-
portement geochimique des elements stabiles et radiactifs dans I'Estuaire de la Gironde en peri ode
de crne. Bull Inst Geologie Bassin d' Aquitaine (Bordeaux, France) 27:5-33
Cawse PA (1981) Trace elements in the atmosphere of the UK. ESNA Meeting Aberdeen, AERE Har-
well,15pp
Cawse PA (1982) Inorganic particulate matter in the atmosphere. In: Bowen HJM (ed) Environmental
Chemistry. R Soc Chern, London 2: 1-68
Challenger F (1945) Biological methylation. Chern Rev 36:315-361
Chamberlain AC, Chadwick RC (1953) Deposition of air borne radio-iodine vapour. Nucleonics 8:22-
25
Chaney RL, Brown JC, Tiffin LO (1972) Plant PhysioI50:208-221
Chao LL (1972) Selective dissolution of manganese oxides from soils and sediments with acidified hy-
droxylamine hydrochloride. Soil Sci Soc Am Proc 36:764-768
Chase RRP (1979) Settling behavior of natural aquatic particulates. Limnol Oceanogr 24:417-426
Chau YK, Lum-Shue-Chan K (1974) Determination oflabile and strongly bound metals in lake water.
Water Res 8:383-388
Chau YK, Wong PTS (1978) Occurrence of biological methylation of elements in the environment. In:
Organometals and organometalloids - occurence and fate in the environment. ACS Symp Ser
82:39-53
Chau YK, Wong PTS (1983) Direct speciation analysis of molecular and ionic organometals. In: Lep-
pard GG (ed) Trace element speciation in surface waters. NATO ConfSeries. I Ecology, 6:87-103
Chen YR, Butler IN, Stumm W, (1973) Kinetic study of phosphate reaction with aluminum oxide and
kaolinite. Environ Sci Technol 7:327-332
Chen KY, Lu JCS, Sycip AZ (1976) Mobility of trace metal during open water disposal of dredged ma-
terial and following resedimentation. Proc Spec ConfDredging and its Environmental Effects. Mo-
bile, Ala. New York: ASCE: 435-454
Chesselet R (1979) Modes of settling and organic input to the sediment seawater interface. A review.
Colloq Int CNRS 293:27-33
Chester R (1978) Lecture given on the 28th of June 1978; Comitato Nazionale Nucleare, La Spezia,
Italy, 28 pp
Chester R, Aston SR (1976) The geochemistry of deep-sea sediments. In: Riley JP, Chester R (eds)
Chemical Oceanography. Academic Press, London New York 6:281-381
Chester R, Hughes MJ (1967) A chemical technique for the separation of ferromanganese minerals, car-
bonate minerals and adsorbed trace elements from pelagic sediments. Chern GeoI2:249-262
Chester R, Hughes MJ (1969) The trace element geochemistry of a North Pacific pelagic clay core.
Deep-Sea Res 16:639-654
Chester R, Messiha-Hanna R (1970) Trace-element partition patterns in North Atlantic deep sea sed-
iments. Geochim Cosmochim Acta 34: 1121-1128
Chester R, Stoner JH (1974) The distribution of zinc, nickel, manganese, cadmium, copper and iron
in some surface waters from the world ocean. Mar Chern 2: 17-32
wim.salomons@home.nl
References 299
Chester R, Voutsinou FG (1981) The initial assessment of trace metal pollution in coastal sediments.
Mar Pollut Bull 12:84-91
Chork CY (1977) Seasonal, sampling and analytical variations in stream sediment surveys. 1 Geochem
Explor7:31-47
Chow Tl, Bruland KW, Bertine K, Soutar A, Koide M, Goldberg ED (1973). Lead pollution, records
in Southern California coastal sediments. Science 181 :551-552
Christensen ER, Scherfig 1, Koide M (1978) Metals from urban runoff in dated sediments of a very
shallow estuary. Environ Sci Technol12: 1168-1173
Cipriano Rl, Blanchard DC (1981) Bubble and aerosol spectra produced by a laboratory "breaking
wave". 1 Geophys Res 86:8085-8092
Clayton lR, Sibley TH, Schell WR (1982) Effects of selected organic compounds on radionuclide ad-
sorption to sediments in fresh-water systems. Bull Environ Contam ToxicoI28:409-415
Coker WB, Nichol I (1975) The relation of lake sediment geochemistry to mineralization in the north-
west Ontario region of the Canadian Shield. Econ GeoI70:202-218
Cooper BS, Harris RC (1974) Heavy metals in organic phases of river and estuarine sediments. Mar
Pollut Bull 5:24-26
Copeland RA, Ayers lC (1972) Trace element distributions in water, sediment phytoplankton, zoo-
plankton and benthos of Lake Michigan. Rept Environ Res Group. Inc Ann Arbor, Michigan
Corliss JB (1976) Sea water, sea-floor spreading, subduction, and ore deposits. Am Geophys Union
Monogr Abstract 19:297
Corliss lB, Lyle M, Dymond 1, Crane K (1978) The chemistry of hydrothermal mounds near the Gala-
pagos Rift. Earth Planet Sci Lett 40: 12-24
Corliss JB, Dymond 1, Gordon LI, Edmond 1M, Von Herzen RP, Ballard RD, Green K, Williams 0,
Bainbridge A, Crane K, Van Andel TjH (1979) Submarine thermal springs on the Galapagos Rift.
Science 203: 1073-1083
Craig P (1981) Biomethylation: pollution amplified. New Sci 90:694-697
Crecelius EA (1982) The significance of atmospheric input on metal concentrations in oceanic surface
water and suspended matter. Paper presented at the NATO Adv Res Inst Symp Trace Metals in
Sea Water, Erice, Italy, 1981.
Crecelius EA (1980) The solubility of coal fly ash and marine aerosols in seawater. Mar Chern 8:245-250
Crecelius EA, Gurtisen 1M, Apts CW (1981) Biological uptake and chemical speciation of copper in
sea water determined by electrochemistry. In: Brinckman FE, Fish RH (eds) Environmental spe-
ciation and monitoring needs for trace metal-containing substances from energy-related processes.
NBS Special Publication
Critchley RF (1982) The river Rhine as a source of pollution of the North Sea. Water Res Centre,
Stevenage Lab. Rep 266-M
Cronan DS (1969) Inter-element associations in some pelagic deposits. Chern Geol 5:99-106
Cronan DS (1976) Manganese nodules and other ferromanganese oxide deposits. In: Riley lP, Chester
R (eds) Chemical Oceanography. Academic, London New York Vo15: 217-263
Cronan DS, Tooms lS (1969) The geochemistry of manganese nodules and associated pelagic sediments
from the Pacific and Indian Oceans. Deep-Sea Res 16:335
Cronan DS, Thomas RL (1970) Ferromanganese concretions in Lake Ontario. Can 1 Earth Sci 7:1347-
1349
Cronan OS, Thomas RL (1972) Geochemistry of ferromanganese oxide concretions and associated de-
posits in Lake Ontario. Geol Soc Am Bull 83: 1493-1502
Cronan OS, Glasby GP, Moorby SA, Thomson 1, Knedler KE, McDougall lC (1982) A submarine
hydrothermal manganese deposit from the south-west Pacific island arc. Nature 298:456-458
Cross FA, Duke TW, Willis lN (1970) Biochemistry of trace elements in a coastal plain estuary: Dis-
tribution of manganese, iron, and zinc in sediments, water and polychaetous worms. Chesapeake
Sci 11:221-234
Crosser ML, Allen HE (1977) Determination of complexation capacity of soluble ligands by ion ex-
change equilibrium. Soil Sci 123: 176-181
Cyamex Scientific Team (1979) Massive deep-sea sulphide ore deposits discovered on the East Pacific
Rise. Nature 277:523-528
Dahlberg EC (1968) Application of a selective simulation and sampling technique to the interpretation
of stream sediment copper anomalies near South Mountain, Pa. Econ GeoI63:409-417
wim.salomons@home.nl
300 References
Damiani V, Ferrario A, Gavelli G, Thomas RL (1977) Trace metal composition and fractionation of
Mn, Fe, S, P, Ba and Si in the Bay of Quinte freshwater ferro-manganese concretions, Lake On-
tario. In: GoIterman H (ed) Interactions between sediments and freshwater. Junk/Pudoc, The
HaguefWageningen, pp 83-93
Dams R, de Jonge J (1976) Chemical composition of Swiss aerosols from the Jungfraujoch. Atmos En-
vir 10: 1079-1084
Davaud E (1976) Contribution a I'etude geochimique et sedimentologique de depots lacustres recentes
(Lac de Morat, Suisse). Diss Fac Sci, Univ Geneva, Switzerland. 129 pp
Davey EW, Morgan MJ, Erickson SJ (1973) A biological measurement of the copper complexation ca-
pacity of sea water. Limnol Oceanogr 18:993-997
Davey HA, Moort JC van (1974) Current mercury deposition at Ngawha Springs, New Zealand Search
5:154-156
Davidson CI, Chu L, Grimm TC, Nasta MA, Qamoos MP (1981) Wet and dry deposition of trace ele-
ments onto the Greenland ice sheet. Atmos Environ 15: 1429-1437
Davies BE (1975) The role of organic material in heavy metal problems of soil and water. Welsh Soils
Disc Group Rep "Soil Organic Matter" 16: 120-123
Davies TA, Gorsline DS (1976) Oceanic sediments and sedimentary processes. In: Riley JP, Chester R
(eds) Chemical Oceanography. Academic, London New York 5: 1-80
Davis A (1978) Coastal sedimentary environments. Springer, Berlin Heidelberg New York
Davis AO, Galloway IN (1981) Atmospheric lead and zinc deposition into lakes of the Eastern United
States. In: Eisenreich SJ (ed) Atmospheric pollutants in natural waters. Ann Arbor Science: 401-
408
Davis AO, Galloway IN, Nordstrom DK (1982) Lake acidification: Its effect on lead in the sediment
of two Adirondack lakes. Limnol Oceanogr 27: 163-167
Davis JA (1980) Adsorption of natural organic matter from fresh water environments by aluminum
oxide. In: Baker RA (ed) Contaminants and sediments. Ann Arbor Sci Publ, Ann Arbor, Mich.
Vol 2:279-304
Davis JA, Gloor R (1981) Adsorption of dissolved organics in lake water by aluminium oxide: Effect
of molecular weight. Environ Sci Technol 15: 1223-1227
Davis JA, Leckie JO (1978) Effect of adsorbed complexing ligands on trace metal uptake by hydrous
oxides. Environ Sci Technol 12: 1309-1315
Davis JA, Leckie JO (1979) Speciation of abdorbed ions at the oxide/water interface. In: Jenne EA (ed)
Chemical Modelling in Aqueous Systems. Am Chern Soc Symp Ser 93:299-317
Davis JA, James RO, Leckie JO (1978) Surface ionization and complexation at the oxide/water inter-
face. I. Computation of electrical double layer properties in simple electrolytes. J Colloid Interface
Sci 63:480-499
Davison W (1978) Defining electroanalytically measured species in a natural water sample. J Electro-
anal Chern Interfacial Electrochem 87:395-404
Davison W (1981) Supply of iron and manganese to an anoxic lake basin. Nature 290:241-243
Davison W (1982) Transport of iron and manganese in relation to the shapes of their concentration-
depth profiles. Hydrobiologia 92:463-471
Davison W, Heaney SI (1978) Ferrous iron-sulfide interactions in anoxic hypolimnetic waters. Limnol
Oceanogr 23:1194-1200
Davison W, Heaney SI, Tailing JF, Rigg E (1981) Seasonal transformations and movements of iron
in a productive English lake with deep-water anoxia. Schweiz Z Hydrol42: 196-223
Davison W, Seed G (1983) The kinetics of the oxidation of ferrous iron in synthetic and natural waters.
Geochim Cosmochim Acta, 47:67-79
Davison W, Woof C (1982) A seasonal study of the cycling of manganese and other elements in a sea-
sonally anoxic lake, Rosthern Mere, U.K. Water Res
Davison W, WoofC, Rigg E (1982) The dynamics of iron and manganese in a seasonally anoxic lake;
direct measurement of fluxes using sediment traps. Limnol Oceanogr 27:987-1003
Davison W, Woof C, Turner DR (1982) Handling and measurement techniques for anoxic interstitial
waters. Nature 295: 582-583
Day JH (1951) The ecology of South African estuaries. Trans R Soc S Afr 33:53-91
Dean WE (1970) Fe-Mn oxidate crusts in Oneida Lake, New York. Proc ConfGreat Lakes Res 13:217-
226
Degens ET, Okada H, Honjo S, Hathaway JC (1972) Microcrystalline sphalerite in resin globules sus-
pended in Lake Kivu, East Africa. Miner Deposita 7:1-12
wim.salomons@home.nl
References 301
Degens ET, Ross DA (1969) Hot brines and recent heavy metal deposits in the Red Sea. Springer, Berlin
Heidelberg New York, 600 pp
Degens ET, Ross DA (1976) Strata-bound metalliferrous deposits found in or near active rifts. In: Wolf
KH (ed) Handbook of Strata-Bound and Stratiform Ore Deposits. Elsevier, Amsterdam Oxford
New York. 4: 165-202
Degens ET, Stoffers P (1976) Stratified waters as a key to the past. Nature 263:22-27
Degens ET, Stoffers P (1977) Phase boundaries as an instrument for metal concentration in geological
systems. In: Klemm DD, Schneider H-J (eds) Time- and Strata-Bound Ore Deposits. Springer Ber-
lin Heidelberg New York. pp 25-45
Delcroix G, Philippot JC (1973) Neutron activation analysis by the mono-standard method. J Radio-
anal Chern 15:87-101
Delfino 11, Lee GF (1968) Chemistry of manganese in Lake Mendota, Wisconsin. Environ Sci Technol
2: 1094-1100
Dennen WH (1967) Trace elements in quartz as indicators of provenance. Geol Soc Am Bull 78: 125-130
Deurer R, Forstner U, Schmoll G (1978) Selective chemical extraction of carbonate-associated trace
metals in recent lacustrine sediments. Geochim Cosmochim Acta 42:425-427
Deuser WG, Ross EH (1980) Seasonal changes in the fluxes of organic carbon to the deep Sargasso
Sea. Nature 283:364-365
Deuser WG, Ross EH, Anderson R (1980) Seasonality in the supply of sediment to the deep Sargasso
Sea and implication for the rapid transfer of matter to the deep ocean. Deep-Sea Res 28:495-502
Dickson W (1980) Properties of acidified waters. In: Drablos D, Tollan A (eds) Ecological Impact of
Acid Precipitation. Proceedings of an International Conference, Sandefjord, Norway, March 11-
14, 1980. pp 75-83. Oslo-Aas, Norway: SNSF project.
Dietz F (1982) Zur Frage der Remobilisierung von Schwermetallen durch Nitrilotriessigsiiure. Korresp
Abwasser 29:692-693
Dominik J, Forstner U, Mangini A, Reineck HE (1978) Pb-21O and Cs-137 chronology of heavy metal
pollution in a sediment core from the German Bight (North Sea). Senckenberg Mar 10:213-227
Dominik J, Mangini A, M iiller G (1981) Determination of recent deposition rates in Lake Constance
with radioisotopic methods. Sedimentology 28:653-677
Dossis P, Warren LJ (1980) Distribution of heavy metals between the minerals and organic debris in
a contaminated marine sediment. In: Baker RA (ed) Contaminants and sediments. Ann Arbor Sci
Publ, Ann Arbor, Mich. 1:119-138
Duce RA (1979) Pigeon key results. SEAREX news letter 2 as cited by Galloway et al (1980)
Duce RA, Hoffman GL (1976) Atmospheric vanadium transport to the ocean. Atmos Environ 10:989-
996
Duce RA, Hoffmann GL, Zoller WH (1975) Atmospheric trace metals at remote northern and southern
hemisphere sites - pollution or natural? Science 187:59-61
Duce RA, Ray BJ, Hoffman GL, Walsh PR (1976) Trace metal concentration as a function of particle
size in marine aerosols from Bermuda. Geophys Res Lett 3:339-342
Duce RA, Unni CK, Ray BJ, Prospero JM, Merrill JT (1980) Long range atmospheric transport of soil
dust from Asia to the tropical North Pacific:temporal variability. Science 209: 1522-1524
Duchart P, Calvert SE, Price NB (1973) Distribution of trace metals in the pore waters of shallow water
marine sediments. Limnol Oceanogr 18:605-610
Duinker JC (1980) Suspended matter in estuaries: Adsorption and desorption processes. In: Olausson
E, Cato I (eds) Chemistry and Biogeochemistry of Estuaries. Wiley, New York pp 121-153
Duinker JC, Kramer CMJ (1977) An experimental study on the speciation of dissolved, Zn, Cd, Pb and
Cu in River Rhine and North Sea, by differential pulsed anodic stripping voltammetry. Mar Chern
5:207-228
Duinker JC, Nolting RF (1976) Distribution model for particulate trace metals in the Rhine estuary,
Southern Bight and Dutch Wadden Sea. Neth J Sea Res 10:71-102
Duinker JC, Nolting RF (1977) Dissolved and particulate trace metals in the Rhine estuary and the
Southern Bight. Mar Pollut Bull 8:68-71
Duinker JC, Nolting RF (1978) Mixing, removal and mobilization of trace metals in the Rhine estuary.
Neth J Sea Res 12:205-223
Duinker JC, Nolting RF (1982) Dissolved copper, zinc and cadmium in the Southern Bight of the North
Sea. Mar Pollut Bull 13:93-96
Duinker JC, Eck GTM van, Nolting RF (1974) On the behaviour ofCu, Zn, Fe and Mn and evidence
for mobilization processes in the dutch Wadden Sea. Neth J Sea Res 8:214-239
wim.salomons@home.nl
302 References
Duinker lC, Wollast R, Billen G (1979) Behaviour of manganese in the Rhine and ScheIdt estuaries;
ii Geochemical cycling. Estuarine Coastal Mar Sci 9:727-738
Duinker lC, Hillebrand MTJ, Nolting RF, Wellershaus S (1982) The River Elbe: Processes affecting
the behaviour of metals and organochlorines during estuarine mixing. Neth 1 Sea Res 15: 141-169
Duinker lC, Hillebrand MTJ, Nolting RF, Wellershaus S (1982) The River Weser: processes affecting
the behaviour of metals and organochlorines during estuarine mixing. Neth 1 Sea Res 15: 170-195
Durum WH, Haffty 1 (1961) Occurrence of minor elements in water. US Geol Surv Circ445:11 pp
Durum WH, Hem lD, Heidel SC (1971) Reconnaissance of selected minor elements surface waters of
the United States. US Geol Surv Circ 643: 49 pp
Duursma EK (1976) Radioactive tracers in estuarine studies. In: Burton lD Liss PS (eds) Estuarine
Chemistry. Academic, London New York: 159-183
Dyck W (1971) Lake sampling, stream sampling for regional geochemical surveys. Geol Surv Can Pap.
71-1:70-71
Dyer KR (1973) Estuaries: a physical introduction. Wiley, London, p 140
Eakins lD, Lally AE, Burton Pl, Kilworth DR, Pratley FA (1982) Studies of environmental radioactiv-
ity in Cumbria. Part 5. The magnitude and mechanism of enrichment of sea spray with with ac-
tinides in west Cumbria. Harwell AERE, 40 pp
Eaton A (1979a) The impact of anoxia on Mn fluxes in the Chesapeake Bay. Geochim Cosmochim Acta
43:429-432
Eaton A (l979b) Observations on the geochemistry of soluble copper, iron, nickel and zinc in the San
Francisco Bay estuary. Environ Sci TechnoI13:425-432
Eaton A, Grant V, Gross M (1980) Chemical tracers for particle transport in the Chesapeake Bay. Es-
tuarine Coastal Mar Sci 10:75-83
Edmond 1M (1980) The chemistry of the 350°C hot springs at 21 N on the East Pacific Rise. EOS
0
wim.salomons@home.nl
References 303
Elderfield H, McCaffrey RJ, Luedtke N, Bender M, Truesdale VW (l98Ia) Chemical diagenesis in Nar-
ragansett Bay sediment. Am J Sci 281: I 021-1 055
Elderfield H, Luedtke N, McCaffrey RJ, Bender M (l98Ib) Benthic flux studies in Narragansett Bay.
AmJ Sci 281:768-787
Elderfield H, Thornton I, Webb JS (1971) Heavy metals and oyster culture in Wales. Mar Pollut Bull
2:44-47
Elliot HA, Huang CP (1979) The adsorption characteristics of Cu(lI) in the presence of chelating
agents. J Colloid Interface Sci 70:29-45
Elliot HA, Huang CP (1981) Adsorption characteristics of some Cu(lI) complexes on aluminosilicates.
Water Res 15:849-855
Elster HJ (1974) Zum Geleit (Foreword). In: Forstner U, Muller G (1974) Schwermetalle in Flussen
und Seen als Ausdruck der Umweltverschmutzung. Springer, Berlin Heidelberg New York: pp V-
VI
Emerson S (1976) Early diagenesis in anaerobic lake sediments: chemical equilibria in interstitial waters.
Geochim Cosmochim Acta 40:925-934
Emerson S, Widmer G (1978) Early diagenesis in anaerobic lake-sediment. Thermodynamic and kinetic
factors controlling formation ofiron phosphate. Geochim Cosmochim Acta 42: 1307-1316
Emerson S, Cranston RE, Liss PS (1979) Redox species in a reducing fjord: equilibrium and kinetic
considerations. Deep Sea Res 26:859-878
Emerson S, Jacobs L, Tebo B (1983) The behaviour of trace metals in marine anoxic waters: solubilities
at the oxygen-hydrogen sulfide interface. In: Wong CS, Boyle E, Bruland KW, Burton JD, Gold-
berg ED (eds) Trace metals in sea water. Plenum, New York London, 579-608
Emerson S, Jahnke R, Bender M, F.roelich P, Klinkhammer G, Bowser C, Setlock G (1980) Early dia-
genesis in sediments from the Eastern Equatorial Pacific. I. Pore water nutrients and carbonate re-
sults. Earth Planet Sci Lett 49:57-80
Emerson S, Kalhorn S, Jacobs L, Tebo, BM, Nealson KH, Rosson RA (1982) Environmental oxidation
rate of manganese(II): Bacterial catalysis. Geochim Cosmochim Acta 46: 1073-1079
Engel DW, Fowler BA (1979) Factors influencing cadmium accumulation and its toxicity to marine
organisms. Environ Health Perspect 28:81-88
Engler RM (1980) Prediction of polluted potential through geochemical and biological procedures: De-
velopment of regulatory guidelines and criteria for the discharge of dredged fill material. In: Baker
RA (ed) Contaminants and Sediments. Ann Arbor Sci Publ. Ann Arbor, Mich. I: 143-169
Engler RM, Brannon JM, Rose J, Bigham G (1974) A practical selective extraction procedure for sed-
iment characterization, 168th Meeting Am Chern Soc Atlantic City, NY, 17 pp
Eriksson E (1959) The yearly circulation of chlorine and sulfate in nature: Meteorological, geochemical
and pedological implications. Part I Tellus II :375-403
Eriksson E (1960) The yearly circulation of chlorine and sulfate in nature: Meteorological, geochemical
and pedological implications. Part II Tellus 12:63-109
Erlenkeuser H, Suess E, Willkomm H (1974) Industrialization affects heavy metal and carbon isotope
concentrations in recent Baltic Sea sediments. Geochim Cosmochim Acta 38:823-842
Ernst R, Allen HE, Mancy KH (1975) Characterization of trace metal species and measurement of trace
metal stability constants by electrochemical techniques. Water Res 9:969-979
Establier R (1969) Estudios del contenido en cobre del aqua de mar y ostiones (Crassostrea angulata)
de las costas de Cadiz. Invest Pesc Barc 33:69-86
Etcheber H, Jouanneau JM (1980) Comparison of the different methods for the recovery of suspended
matter from estuarine waters: deposition, filtration, and centrifugation; consequences for the de-
termination of some heavy metals. Estuarine Coastal Mar Sci 2:701-707
Etcheber H, Jouanneau JM, Relexans JC (1981) Seasonal Zn cycles of suspended material in the upper
part of the Gironde estuary (France). The role of organic matter. Proc Int Conf: Heavy metals in
the environment. Amsterdam 1981
Etcheber H, Jouanneau JM, Latouche C, Azoef P, Caillot A, Hoslin R (1980) L'experience "double
marquage de vase en Gironde". Contribution a la connaissance du devenir d'une pollution metal-
lique en estuaire. Oceanol Acta 3:477-486
Eugster HP, Hardie LA (1978) Saline lakes. In: Lerman A (ed) Lakes - chemistry, geology, physics.
Springer, Berlin Heidelberg New York, 8:237-293
Evans DE, Cutshall NH, Cross FA, Wolfe DA (1977) Manganese Cycling in the Newport River Estu-
ary, North Carolina. Estuarine Coastal Mar Sci 5:71-80
wim.salomons@home.nl
304 References
Evendijk (1974) Onderzoek naar sporen elementen in atmospherisch stofte Rotterdam. Extern 3:555-
573
Fairbridge RW (1980) The estuary: its definition and geodynamic cycle. In: Olausson E, Cato I (eds)
Chemistry and biogeochemistry of estuaries. Wiley, Chichester New York Brisbane Toronto: 1-36
Fanning KA, Pilson MEQ (1971) Interstitial silica and pH in marine sediments: some effects of sam-
piing procedures. Science 173: 1228-1230
Farrah H, Pickering WF (1978) Extraction of heavy metal ions sorbed on clays. Water Air Soil Pollut
9:491-498
Feely H, Larson RJ (1979) The chemical composition of atmospheric deposition. Environmental
Measurements Lab Quaterly EML 363, Appendix
Figura P, McDuffie B (1979) Use of chelex resin for determination of labile trace metal fractions in
aquatic ligand media and comparison of the method with anodic stripping voltammetry. Anal
Chern 51:120-125
Figura P, McDuffie B (1980) Determination of labilities of soluble trace metal species in aqueous en-
vironmental samples by anodic stripping voltammetry and chelex column and batch methods. Anal
Chern 52: 1433-1439
Filipek LH, Owen RM (1979) Geochemical associations and grain size partitioning of heavy metals in
lacustrine sediments. Chern Geo126: 105-117
Fitchko J, Hutchinson TC (1975) A comparative study of heavy metal concentrations in river mouth
sediments around the Great Lakes. J Great Lakes Res 1:46-78
Flocchini RG, Cahill TA, Ahsbaugh LL, Eldred RA, Pitchford M (1981) Seasonal behavior ofparticu-
late matter at three rural Utah sites. Atmos Environ 15:315-320
Florence TM (1982) The speciation of trace elements in waters. Talanta 29:345-364
Florence TM, Batley, GE (1980) Chemical speciation in natural waters. Crit Rev Anal Chern 9:219-296
Fontugne M, Jouanneau JM (1981) Sedimentologie: la composition isotopique du carbone organique
des matieres en suspension dans I'estuaire de la Gironde. Application a l'etude de la distribution
du plomb et du zinc particulaires. C R Acad SC Paris 293:389-392
Forstner U (1977) Metal concentrations in recent lacustrine sediments. Arch Hydrobiol80: 172-191
Forstner U (1978) Metallanreicherungen in rezenten See-Sedimenten - geochemischer background und
zivilisatorische Einfliisse. In: Mitt. Nationalkommitee der B.R. Deutschland fiir das Internationale
Hydrologische Programm der UNESCO, Vol2 Koblenz, p 66
Forstner U (1980a) Cadmium in polluted sediments. In: Nriagu JO (ed) Cadmium in the environment.
Wiley, New York, 1:305-363
Forstner U (1980b) Inorganic pollutants, particularly heavy metals, in estuaries. In: 01ausson E, Cato
I (eds) Chemistry and Biogeochemistry of Estuaries. Wiley, Chichester 10:307-348
Forstner U (1981) Recent heavy metal accumulations in limnic sediments. In: WolfKH (ed) Handbook
of Stratabound and Stratiform Ore Deposits. Elsevier, Amsterdam 9: 179-270
Forstner U (1982) Accumulative phases for heavy metals in limnic sediments. Hydrobiologia 91:269-
284
Forstner U, Calmano W (1982) Bindungsformen von Schwermetallen in Baggerschlammen. Vom Was-
ser 59:83-92
Forstner U, Miiller G (1973) Anorganische Schadstoffe im Neckar. Ruperto Carola 51 :67-71
Forstner U, Miiller G (1974a) Schwermetalle in Fliissen und Seen als Ausdruck der Umweltverschmut-
zung. Springer Berlin Heidelberg New York, 225 pp
Forstner U, Miiller G (1974b) Schwermetallanreicherungen in datierten Sedimentkernen aus dem Bo-
densee und aus dem Tegernsee. Tschermaks Min Petr Mitt 21: 145-163
Forstner U, Miiller G (1981) The concentration of trace metals and polynuclear aromatic hydrocarbons
in river sediments: geochemical background, man's influence and environmental impact. GeoJour-
naI5:417-432
Forstner U, Patchineelam SR (1980) Chemical associations of heavy metals in polluted sediments from
the lower Rhine river. In: Kavanaugh MC, Leckie 10 (eds) Particulates in water. Am Chern Soc
Adv Chern Ser 189:177-193
Forstner U, Patchineelam SR (1981) Chemical associations of heavy metals in marine deposits with spe-
cial reference to pollution in the German North Sea. Rapp P-v Reun Cons Int Explor Mer 181:
49-58
Forstner U, Reineck H-E (1974) Die Anreicherung von Spurenelementen in den rezenten Sedimcnten
eines Profilkernes aus der Deutschen Bucht. Senckenberg Marit 6: 175-184
wim.salomons@home.nl
References 305
Forstner U, Salomons W (1980) Trace metal analysis on polluted sediments. I. Assessment of sources
and intensities. Environ Technol Lett 1:494-505
Forstner U, Stoffers P (1981) Chemical fractionation of transition elements in Pacific pelagic sediments.
Geochim Cosmochim Acta 45: 1141-1146
Forstner U, Wittmann G (1979) Metal Pollution in the Aquatic Environment. Springer, Berlin Heidel-
berg New York, 486 pp
Forstner U, Calma no W, Conradt K, Jaksch H, Schimkus C, Schoer J (1981) Chemical speciation of
heavy metals in solid waste materials (sewage sludge, mining wastes, dredged materials, polluted
sediments) by sequential extraction. Proc Int ConfHeavy Metals in the Environment, Amsterdam:
698-704
Forstner U, Niihle C, Schottler U (1979) Sorption of metals in sand filters in the presence of humic
acids. DVWK Bulletin 13:95-125
Fowler BA (1981) Relationship between trace element speciation and intracellular mechanisms of toxic-
ity. In: Brinkman FE, Fish RH (eds) Environmental speciation and monitoring needs for trace
metal-containing substances from energy-related Processes. NBS Spec Publ6
Frache R, Baffi F, Dadone A, Zanicchi G (1976) The determination of heavy metals in the Ligurian
Sea. I. The determination ofCu, Co, Ni and Cd in surface waters. Mar Chern 4:365-375
Francheteau J, Needham HD, Choukroune P, Juteau T, Seguret M, Ballard RD, Fox PJ, Normark
W, Carranza A, Cordoba 0, Guerrero J, Rangin C, Bougault H, Cambon P, Hekinian R (1979)
Massive deep-sea sulphide ore deposits discovered on the East Pacific Rise. Nature 277:523-528
Fricke K, Werner H (1957) Geochemische Untersuchungen von Mineralwiissern auf Kupfer, Blei und
Zink in Nordrhein-Westfalen und angrenzenden Gebieten. Heilbad Kurort, pp 45-46
Frink CR (1967) Nutrient budged and rational analysis of eutrophication in a Connecticut lake. En-
viron Sci Technol 1:425-428
Froelich PN, Klinkhammer GP, Bender ML, Luedtke NA, Hartmann B, Maynard V, (1979) Early oxi-
dation of organic matter in pelagic sediments of the eastern equatorial Atlantic: suboxic diagenesis.
Geochim Cosmochim Acta 43: 1075-1090
Froslie S, Norheim G, Rambaek JP, Steinnes E (1983) Connection between atmospheric deposition and
trace metal contents in lamb's liver. In prep
Giichter R, Davis JS, Mares A (1978) Regulation of copper availability to phytoplankton by macro-
molecules in lake water. Environ Sci TechnoI12:1416-1421
Gadow S, Schiifer A (1973) Die Sedimente der Deutschen Bucht: KorngroBen, Tonmineralien und
Schwermetalle. Senckenbergiana Marit 5: 165-178
Gadow S, Reineck HE (1974) Diskontinuierliche Sedimentation von Sand und Schlick in Watt-Sedi-
menten. Senckenbergiana Marit 6: 149-159
Galloway JE (1979) Alteration of trace metal geochemical cycles due to the marine discharge of waste
water. Geochim Cosmochim Acta 43:207-218
Galloway JE, Likens GE (1979) Atmospheric enhancement of metal deposition in Adirondack lake sed-
iments. Limnol Oceanogr 24:427-433
Galloway IN, Eisenreich SJ, Scott BC (1980) Toxic substances in atmospheric deposition: A review and
assessment. National atmospheric deposition program. Rep NC 141
Galloway IN, Thornton JD, Norton SA, Volchok HL, McLean RAN (1982) Trace metals in atmo-
spheric deposition: a review and assessment. Atmos Environ 16: 1677-1700
Gambrell RP, Khalid RA, Verloo MG, Patric WH jr (1977) Transformations of heavy metals and plant
nutrients in dredged sediments as affected by oxidation reduction potential and pH. II. Materials
and methods/results and discussion. US Army Corps Eng Dredged Material Res Prog Vicksburg/
Miss Rep 0-77-4, 309 pp
Gardner LR (1973) Chemical models for sulfate reduction in closed anaerobic marine environments.
Geochim Cosmochim Acta 37:53-68
Garrels RM, MacKenzie FT (1971) Evolution of sedimentary rocks. WW Norton, New York: 397 pp
Gatz OF (1975) Pollutant aerosol deposition into southern Lake Michigan. Water Air Soil Pollut 5:239-
251
Gatz OF (1975) Relative contributions of different sources of urban aerosols: applications of a new es-
timation method to multiple sites in Chicago. Atmos Environ 9: 1-18
Gatz OF (1975) Scavening ratio measurement in Metromex. Precipitation scavening 1974. Beadle RW,
Semonin RG Coords., ERDA Symposium Series. CONF-741014 available from NTIS, Springfield
VA (1975), pp 71-87
wim.salomons@home.nl
306 References
Gatz DF, Warner BK, Chu LC (1982) Solubility of metal ions in rain water. Am Chern Soc Div Environ
Chern Acid Precipitation Symposium. Las Vegas, Nevada, April 1982
Gavis J, Guillard RRL, Woodward BL (1981) Cupric ion activity and the growth of phytoplankton
clones isolated from different marine environments. J Mar Res 39:315-333
Gendron A, Sundby B, Silverberg N, Lebel J (1982) Evidence for different release mechanisms for co-
balt and cadmium near the sediment water interface during the diagenesis of marine sediments. Ab-
stract submitted to joint oceanographic assembly
George SG (1980) Mechanisms of metal uptake and accumulation from sediments by aquatic or-
ganisms WHO Regional Office for Europe Trier 5-8/8
George SG, Coombs TL (1977) Effects of high stability iron-complexes on the kinetics of iron accumu-
lation and excretion in Mytilus Edulis (L.). J Exp Mar BioI EcoI28:133-140
German Council of Environmental Advisers (Der Rat von Sachverstandigen fUr Umweltfragen 1980)
Umweltprobleme der Nordsee. Kohlhammer, Stuttgart Mainz
Gibbs RJ (1967) The geochemistry of the Amazon river system. 1. The factors that control the salinity,
the composition and the concentration of the suspended solids. Geol Soc Am Bull 78: 1203-1232
Gibbs RJ (1972) Water chemistry of the Amazon River. Geochim Cosmochim Acta 36: 1061- 1066
Gibbs RJ (1973) Mechanisms of trace metal transport in rivers. Science 180:71-73
Gibbs RJ (1977) Clay mineral segregation in the marine environment. J Sediment Petrol 47:237-243
Gibbs RJ (1977) Transport phases of transition metals in the Amazon and Yukon Rivers. Geol Soc
Am Bull 88:829-843
Gibs PE, Bryan GW, Ryan KP (1981) Copper accumulation by the polychaete Melinna Palmata: an
antipredation mechanism. J Mar BioI Assoc UK 61:707-722
Gieseking JE (ed) (1975) Soil Components. Springer, Berlin Heidelberg New York
Giesy JP, Briese LA (1977) Trace metal transport by particulates and organic carbon in two South
Carolina streams. Verh Int Ver LimnoI20:1401-1417
Giesy JP, Briese LA (1977) Metals associated with organic carbon extracted from Okefenokee Swamp
water. Chern Geo120: 109-120
Giesy JP, Briese LA (1980) Metal binding capacity of northern european surface waters for Cd, Cu and
Pb. Org Geochem 2:57-67
Giesy JP, Alberts JJ, Briese LA (1978) Cadmium, copper and lead binding capacities of naturally oc-
curring aquatic organics. Am Chern Soc Abstr Pap 176: 175
Giesy JP, Leversee GJ, Williams DR (1977) Effect of naturally occurring aquatic organic fractions on
cadmium toxicity to Simocephalus Serrulatus (Daphnidae) and Gambusia Affinis (Poeciliidae).
Water Res 11:1013-1020
Gillespie PA, Vaccaro RF (1978) A bacterial bioassay for measuring the copper chelating capacity of
sea water. Limnol Oceanogr 23:543-548
Gillespie RA, Vaccaro RF (1981) Heterotrophic microbial activity in experimentally perturbated ma-
rine ecosystems. In: Marine environmental pollution. Vol II. Dumping and mining. Elsevier, Am-
sterdam
Giovanoli R, Brutsch R, Diem D, Osman-Sigg G, Sigg L (1980) The composition of settling particles
in Lake Zurich. Schweiz Z HydroI42/2:89-1 00
Gjessing ET (1965) Use of "Sephadex" gel for the estimation of molecular weight of humic substances
in natural waters. Geochim Cosmochim Acta 208: 1091-1092
Glasby GP, Read AJ (1976) Deep-sea manganese nodules. In : Wolf KH (ed) Handbook of Strata-
Bound and Stratiform Ore Deposits. Elsevier, Amsterdam Oxford New York, 7:295-340
Glass NR, Glass GE, Rennie PJ (1980) Effects of acid precipitation in North America. Environment
Int 4:443-452
Gobeil C, Sundby B, Silverberg N (1981) Factors influencing particulate matter geochemistry in the
St. Lawrence estuary turbidity maximum. Mar Chern 10: 123-140
Goldberg ED (1954) Marine geochemistry. Chemical scavengers of the sea. J GeoI62:249-266
Goldberg ED (1963) The composition of sea-water, comparative and descriptive oceanography. In: Hill
MN (ed) The Sea. Intersci New York, 2:3-25
Goldberg ED (1972) Man's role in the major sedimentary cycle. In: Dyrssen D, Jagner D (eds) The
changing chemistry of the oceans. Nobel Symposium. Almquist and Wiksell, Sweden, 267-288
Goldberg ED (1976) Pollution history of estuarine sediments. Oceanus 19: I 8-26
Goldberg ED (1976) The health of the oceans. UNESCO Press, Paris, 172 pp
wim.salomons@home.nl
References 307
wim.salomons@home.nl
308 References
Hague MA, Subramanian V (1982) Copper, lead and zinc pollution of soil environment. Crit Rev En-
viron Control: 13-68
Hails JR (1976) Placer deposits. In: Wolf KH (1976) Handbook of strata-bound and stratiform ore de-
posits. Elsevier, Amsterdam 3:213-244
Haines TA (1981) Acidic precipitation and its consequences for aquatic ecosystems: A review. Trans
Am Fish Soc 110:669-707
Hakanson L (1977) Sediments as indicators of contamination - investigations in the four largest
Swedish lakes. Naturvardsverkets Limnol U ndersok 92: I 55 pp
Hakanson L (1980) An ecological risk index for aquatic pollution control. A sedimentological ap-
proach. Water Res 14:975-1001
Halbach P, Rehm E, Marchig V (1979) Distribution of Si, Mn, Fe, Ni, Cu, Co, Zn, Pb, Mg and Ca
in grain-size fractions of sediment samples from a manganese nodule field in the Central Pacific
Ocean. Mar GeoI29:237-252
Halcrow, Mackay DW, Thornton I (1973) The distribution of trace metals and fauna in the Firth of
Clyde in relation to the disposal of sewage sludge. J Mar Bioi Assoc UK 53:721-739
Hallberg RO (1972) Sedimentary sulfide mineral formation - an energy circuit system approach. Miner
Deposita 7:189-201
Hallberg RO (1974) Paleoredox conditions in the eastern Gotland Basin during the recent centuries.
Merentutkimuslait Julk/Havsforskninginst Skr 238:3- I 6
Hallberg RO (1978) Metal-organic interaction at the redox-cline. In: Krumbein WE (ed). Environ Bio-
geochem Geomicrobiol Ann Arbor Sci Publ3: pp 947-954
Hallberg RO (1982). Diagenetic and environmental effects upon heavy metal distribution in sediments.
(pre print)
Halberg RO, Bubela B, Ferguson J (1980) Metal chelation in sedimentary systems. Geomicrobiol J
2:99-113
Hamilton-Taylor J (1979) Enrichments of Zn, Pb and Cd in recent sediments of Windermere, England.
Environ Sci Technol 13:693-697
Hanck LW, Dillard JW (1977) Determination of the complexing capacity of natural water by cobalt-
(III) complexation. Anal Chern 49:404-409
Hanssen JE, Rambaek JP, Semb A, Steinnes E (1981) Atmospheric deposition of some heavy metals
in Norway. Proc. Conf. on heavy metals in the environment. Amsterdam, 322-325
Harder H (1970) Boron content of sediments as a tool in facies analysis. Sea Geol4: 153-1 75
Harris RH, Mitchell R (1973) The role of polymers in microbial aggregation. Annu Rev Microbiol
27:27-50
Harris RC, Troup AG (1969) Freshwater ferromanganese concretions, chemistry and internal struc-
ture. Science 166:604-606
Harrison RM, Laxen DPH, Wilson SJ (1981) Chemical associations oflead, cadmium, copper and zinc
in street dusts and roadside soils. Environ Sci Technol 15: I 378-1383
Hart BA, Scaife BD (1977) Toxicity and bioaccumulation of cadmium in Chlorella Pyrenoidosa. En-
viron Res 3:401-413
Hart BT (1981) Trace metal complexing capacity of natural waters: a review. Environ Tech Lett 2:95-
110
Hart BT (1982) Uptake of trace metals by sediments and suspended particulates: A review. In: Sly PG
(ed) Sediment/Freshwater Interaction, Dev in Hydrobiol. Junk, The Hague, Vol 9: 299-313
Hart BT, Davies SHR (1977) A new dialysis-ion exchange technique for determining the forms of trace
metals in water. AustJ Mar Freshwater Res 28:105-112
Hart BT, Davies SHR (1977) A batch method for the determination of iron exchangeable trace metals
in natural waters. Aust J Mar Freshwater Res 28:397 -402
Hart BT, Davies SH (198Ia) Trace metal speciation in the freshwater and estuarine regions of the Yarra
River, Victoria. Estuarine Coastal Mar Sci 12:353-374
Hart BT, Davies SHR (1981 b) Trace metal speciation in three Victorian lakes. Aust J Mar Freshwater
Res 32: 175-189
Hartinger L (1981) Stand der Behandlung komplexbildnerhaltiger Abwiisser. Galvanotechnik 72:164
Hartmann M (1965) An apparatus for the recovery of interstitial waters from recent sediments. Deep-
Sea Res 12:225-226
Hartmann M (1979) Evidence for early diagenetic mobilization of trace metals from discolorations of
pelagic sediments. Chern GeoI26:277-293
wim.salomons@home.nl
References 309
Hartmann M, Muller PJ (1979) Trace metals in interstitial waters from Central Pacific Ocean sedi-
ments. In: Fanning KA, Manheim F (eds) The dynamic environment of the ocean floor. Lexington,
Mass pp 285-301
Hasle JR, Abdullah MI (1981) Analytical fractionation of dissolved copper, lead and cadmium in coast-
al seawater. Mar Chern 10:487-503
Hathaway JC (1972) Regional clay minerals facies in estuaries and continental margin of United States
east coast. Environmental Framework of Coastal Plain Estuaries. 133:293-316
Hawkes HE, Williston SH (1962) Mercury vapour as a guide to lead-zinc-silver deposits. Min Congr
J 48:30-32
Heath GR (1974) Dissolved silica and deep-sea sediments. In: Studies in paleo-oceanography. Soc Econ
Paleontol Mineral Spec PubI20:77-93
Heath G R, Dymond J (1977) Genesis and transformation of metalliferrous sediments from the East
Pacific Rise, Bauer Deep and Central Basin, Northwest Nasza Plate. Geol Soc Am Bull 88:723-733
Heggie DT (1982) Copper in surface waters of the Bering Sea. Geochim Cosmochim Acta 46: 1301-1306
Heidam NZ (l98Ia) Review: Aerosol fractionation by sequential filtration with nuclepore filters. At-
mos Environ 15:891-904
Heidam NZ (1981b) On the origin of the Arctic aerosol: a statistical approach. Atmos Environ 8: 1421-
1428
Heide F, Singer E (1954) Der Gehalt des Saalewassers an Kupfer und Zink. N aturwissenschaften 37: 541
Heide F, Lerz H, Bohm G (1957) Der Gehalt des Saalewassers an Blei und Quecksilber. Naturwissen-
schaften 44:441
Heinrichs H (1975) Die Untersuchung von Gesteinen und Gewassern auf Cd, Sb, Hg, TI, Pb, und Bi
mit der flammenlosen Atomabsorptions-Spektralphotometrie. Thesis U niv Gottingen, 82 pp
Heinrichs H, Mayer R (1977) Distribution and cycling of major and trace elements in two Central Eu-
ropean forest ecosystems. J Environ Qual 6:402-407
Heinrichs H, Mayer R (1980) The role offorest vegetation in the biogeochemical cycle of heavy metals.
J Environ QuaI9:111-118
Heisinger JF, Hansen CD, Kim JH (1979) Effect of selenium dioxide on the accumulation and acute
toxicity of mercuric chloride in goldfish. Arch Environ Con tam ToxicoI8:279-283
Hekinian R, Fevrier M, Bischoff JL, Picot P, Shanks WC (1980). Sulphide deposits from the East
Pacific Rise near 21 N. Science 207: 1433-1444
0
Helling CS, Chesters G, Corey RB (1964) Contribution of organic matter and clay to soil cation-ex-
change capacity as affected by pH and the saturating solution. Soil Sci Soc Am Proc 28:517-520
Helmke PA, Koons RD, Schomberg PJ, Iskandar IK (1977) Determination of trace element contam-
ination of sediments by multi-element analysis of clay size fraction. Environ Sci Technol11 :984-989
Helz GR (1976) Trace element inventory for the northern Chesapeake Bay with emphasis on the influ-
ence of man. Geochim Cosmochim Acta 40:573-580
Hem JD (1972) Chemistry and occurence of cadmium and zinc in surface water and groundwater. Wa-
ter Resour Res 8:661-679
Herms U, Brummer G (1978a) Loslichkeit von Schwermetallen in Siedlungsabfallen und Boden in Ab-
hangigkeit vom pH-Wert, Redoxbedingungen und Stoffbestand. Mitt Dtsch Bodenkundl Ges
27:23-34
Herms U, Brummer G (1978b) Einfluf3 organischer Substanzen auf die Loslichkeit von Schwermetallen.
Mitt Dtsch Bodenkdl Ges 27: 181-192
Herms U, Brummer G (1979) Einfluf3 der Redoxbedingungen auf die Loslichkeit von Schwermetallen
in Boden und Sedimenten. Mitt Dtsch Bodenkundl Ges 29:533-544
Herms U, Brummer G (1980) Einfluf3 der Bodenreaktion auf Loslichkeit und tolerierbare Gesamtge-
halte an Nickel, Kupfer, Zink, Cadmium und Blei in Boden und kompostierten Siedlungsabfallen.
Landwirtsch Forsch 33:408-423
Herrera R, Heurtebise M (1974) Neutron activation analysis of trace elements in quartz sands: its possi-
bilities in the assessment of provenance. Chern GeoI14:81-93
Herron MM, Langway CC, Weiss HV, Cragin JH (1977) Atmospheric trace metals and sulphate in the
Greenland ice sheet. Geochim Cosmochim Acta 41 :915-920
Hesslein R (1976) An in situ sampler for close interval pore water studies. Limnol Oceangr 21:912-914
Hester K, Boyle E (1982) Water chemistry control of cadmium content in Recent benthic foraminifera.
Nature 298:260-262
wim.salomons@home.nl
310 References
wim.salomons@home.nl
References 311
Huang CP, Elliot HA, Ashmead RM (1977) Interfacial reactions and the fate of heavy metals in soil-
water systems. J Water Pollut Control Fed 49:745-756
Huang CP, Bowers AR (1980) The effect of complex formation on the removal of heavy metals from
water and wastewater. Proc Nat ConfEnviron Engineer ASCE, New York: 240-248
Huber F, Schmidt U, Kirchmann H (1978) Aqueous chemistry of organolead and organothallium com-
pounds in the presence of micro-organisms. In: Organometals and organometalloids-occurence
and fate in the environment. ACS Symp Ser 82:65-81
HuffLC (1948) A sensitive field test for heavy metals in water. Econ GeoI43:675-681
Hultberg H (1977) Thermally stratified acid water in the late winter - a key factor inducing self-accel-
erating processes which increase acidification. Water Air Soil Pollut 7:279-294
Hunt CD, Smith DL (1982) Controlled marine ecosystems - A tool for studying stable trace metal
cycles: Long-term response and variability. In: Grice GO, Reeve MR (eds) Marine mesocosms.
BioI Chern Res Exp Ecosystems. Springer, New York Heidelberg Berlin
Hunter KA (1980) Microelectrophoretic properties of natural surface-active organic matter in coastal
seawater. Limnol Oceanogr 25:807-822
Hunter KA (1980) Process affecting particulate trace metals in the sea surface microlayer. Mar Chern
9:49-70
Hunter KA, Liss PS (1979) The surface charge of suspended particles in estuarine and coastal waters.
Nature 282: 823-825
Hunter KA, Liss PS (1982) Organic-matter and the surface-charge of suspended particles in estuarine
waters. Limnol Oceanogr 27:322-335
Hvatum 00, Bolviken B, Steinnes E (1983) Heavy metals in Norwegian ombrotrophic bogs. Ecol Bull
35:351-356
ImhoffKR, Koppe P, Dietz F (1980) Heavy metals in the Ruhr River and their budget in the catchment
area. Prog Water Technol IAWPR 12:735-749
International Council for the Exploration of the Sea (1978) Input of pollutants to the Oslo Commision
area. Cooperative Res Rept No 77, ICES Charlottenlund/Denmark
Irving H, Williams R (1948) Order of stability of metal complexes. Nature 162:746-747
Jackson ML (1958) Soil Chemical Analysis. Printice Hall Englewood Cliffs, N J, 498 pp
Jackson ML (1968) Weathering of primary and secondary minerals. Trans 9th Int Congr Soil Sci,
Adelaide 4:281-292
James RO (1978) Effects of heavy metals on aquatic life. Common Sci Indus Res Org, Canberra. Cit
in Warren (1981)
Jenne EA (1968) Controls on Mn, Fe, Co, Ni, Cu and Zn cncentrations in soils and water: the signil~
icant role of hydrous Mn- and Fe-oxides. Am Chern Soc Adv Chern Ser 73:337-387
Jenne EA (1977) Trace element sorption by sediments and soils - sites and processes. In: Chappell W,
Petersen K (eds) Symposium on molybdenum. Marcel Dekker, New York Vol 2:425-553.
Jenne EA (ed) (1979) Chemical modeling in aqueous systems - speciation, sorption, solubility and
kinetics. Am Chern Soc Symp Ser Washington DC 93: 914 pp
Jenne EA (1981) Speciation of aqueous contaminants - role of the geochemical model. In: Brinkman
FE, Fish RH (eds) Environmental speciation and monitoring needs for trace metal-containing sub-
stances from energy-related processes. NBS Spec Publ, pp 39-53
Jenne EA, Luoma SN (1977) Form of trace elements in soils, sediments, and associated waters: an over-
view of their determination and biological availability. In: Wildung RE, Drucker H (eds) Biological
implications of metals in the environment. Conf-750929 NTIS Springfield, VA: 110-143
Jenne EA, Kennedy VC, Burchard JM, Ball JW (1980) Sediment collection and processing for selective
extraction and for total trace element analysis. In: Baker RA (ed) Contaminants and sediments.
Ann Arbor Sci Publ, Ann Arbor Mich 2: 169-191
Jernel6v A (1970) Release of methyl mercury from sediments with layers containing inorganic mercury
at diffent depths. Limnol Oceanogr 15:958-960
Jernel6v A, Landner L, Larsson T (1975) Swedish perspectives on mercury pollution. J Water Pollut
Control Fed 47:810-822
Johannessen M, Henrikson A (1978) Chemistry of snow meltwater: changes in concentration during
melting. Water Resour Res 14:615-619
John MK (1977) Transfer of heavy metals from soils to plants. Proc Int ConfHeavy Metals in the En-
vironment, Toronto, 1975 II/I: 365-378
Johnson DL (1972) Bacterial reduction of arsenate in seawater. Nature 240:44-45
wim.salomons@home.nl
312 References
10nasson IR (1976) Detailed hydrogeochemistry of two small lakes in the Greenville Geological Prov-
ince. Geol Surv Can Pap 76-13: pp 37
10nasson IR (1977) Geochemistry of sediment/water interactions of metals, including observations on
availability. In: Shear H, Watson AEP (eds) The fluvial transport of sediment-associated nutrients
and contaminants. IJC/PLUARG, Windsor/Ont: 255-271
10nes BF, Bowser Cl (1978) The mineralogy and related chemistry of lake sediments. In: Lerman A
(ed) Lakes - chemistry, geology physics. Springer, New York Heidelberg Berlin 179-235
10uanneau 1M (1979) Evaluation du volume et de la masse des matieres en suspension dans Ie systeme
bouchon vaseuxcreme de vase de la Gironde. Bull Inst Geol Bassin Aquitaine 25: 11-120
10uanneau 1M (1982) Matieres en suspension et oligo-elements metalliques dans Ie systeme estuarien
Girondin: Comportement et flux. These de doctorat d'etat et sciences, l'Universite de Bordeaux
10uanneau 1M, Latouche C (1981) The Gironde Estuary. E Schweizerbart'sche Verlagsbuchhandlung
(Nagele u. Obermiller) Stuttgart 200 pp
10uanneau 1M, Latouche C (1982) Estimation of fluxes to the ocean from mega-tidal estuaries under
moderate climates and the problems they present. Hydrobiologia 91 :23-29
10uanneau 1M, Etcheber H, Latouche C (1983) Impoverishment and decrease of metallic elements as-
sociated with suspended matter in the Gironde estuary. In: Wong CS, Boyle E, Bruland KW, Bur-
ton 10, Goldberg ED (eds) Trace metals in sea water. Plenum, New York London, 245-263
ludson S (1968) Erosion of the land, or what's happening to our continents? Am Sci 56:356-374
lunge (1974) Atmospheric chemistry. In: Encyclopedia of Environmental Science. McGraw-Hill, New
York San Francisco 37-39
Kalil EK, Goldhaber M (1973) A sediment squeezer for removal of pore water without air contact. 1
Sediment Petrol 43:553-557
Kanamori S, Sugawara K (1965) Geochemical study of arsenic in natural waters. 1 Earth Sci Nagoya
Univ 13:36-45
Katz A, Kaplan IR (1981) Heavy metals behaviour in coastal sediments of southern California: A criti-
cal review and synthesis. Mar Chem 10:261-299
Keeney DR, Walsh LM (1977) Heavy metal availability in sewage sludge amended soils. Proc Int Conf
Heavy Metals in the Environment, Toronto, 1975 lIjI :379-402
Kemp ALW, Thomas RL (1976) Impact of man's activities on the chemical composition in the sedi-
ments oflakes Ontario, Erie and Huron. Water Air Soil Poll 5:469-490
Kemp, AL W, Thomas RL, Dell CI, 1aquetJM (1976) Cultural impact on the geochemistry of sediments
in Lake Erie. 1 Fish Res Board Can 33:440-462
Kennedy VC, Sebetich Ml (1976) Trace elements in northern California Streams. In: Geological Survey
Research 1976, Washinghton DC: 208-209
Kennett lP (1982) Effect of volcanism in water chemistry. Mar Geol13:M I-M6
Kerdijk HN (1981) Groundwater pollution by heavy metals and pesticides from a dredge spoil dump.
In: van Fuyvenboden W, Glasbergen P, van Lelyveld H (eds) Quality of groundwater. Elsevier Am-
sterdam: 279-286
Kerdijk HN, Salomons W (1981) Heavy metal cycling in the Scheidt Estuary (in dutch). Delft Hydraul-
ics Report M I 640/M 1736
Kerdijk HN, Salomons W, (1983) Early diagenesis in sediments and their importance for the dumping
of dredged material. In preparation
Kerndorf H Kerndorf H, Schnitzer M (1980) Sorption of metals on humic acid. Geochim Cosmochim
Acta 44: 1701-1708
Khalid RA (1980) Chemical mobility of cadmium in sediment-water systems. In: Nriagu 10 (ed) Cad-
mium in the environment. Wiley, New York, 1:257-304
Kharkar DP, Turekian KK, Bertine KK (1968) Stream supply of dissolved silver, molybdenum, anti-
mony, selenium, chromium, cobalt rubidium and cesium to the oceans. Geochim Cosmochim Acta
32:285-298
Kitano Y, Sakata M, Matsumoto E (1980) Partitioning of heavy metal and organic fractions in a sed-
iment core from Tokyo Bay. Geochim Cosmochim Acta 44: 1279-1285
Kitano Y, Sakata M, Matsumoto E (1981) Partitioning of heavy metals into mineral and organic
fractions in a sediment core sample from Osaka Bay. 1 Oceanogr Soc lpn 37:259-266
Klein LA, Lang M, Nash N, Kirschner SL (1974) Sources of metals in New York City waste-water.
lWPCF 46:2653-2662
wim.salomons@home.nl
References 313
Klinkhammer GP (1980) Early diagenesis in sediments from the Eastern Equatorial Pacific. II. Pore
water metal results. Earth Planet Sci Lett 49:520-527
Klinkhammer G, Heggie DT, Graham DW (1982) Metal diagenesis in oxic sediments. Earth Planet Sci
Lett61:211-219
Klinkhammer G (1983) Separation of copper and nickel by low temperature processes. In: Wong CS,
Boyle E, Bruland KW, Burton lD, Goldberg ED (eds) Trace metals in Seawater. NATO Conf.
series IV. Mar Sci, Plenum, New York London, pp 317-330
Klotz 1M (1982) Numbers of receptor sites from Scatchard graphs: facts and fantasies. Science
217:1247-1249
Knauer GA, Martin lH, Gordon RM (1982) Cobalt in north-east Pacific waters. Nature 297:49-51
Kock WC de (1983) Accumulation of cadmium and PCB by Mytilus Edulis L., transplanted from pris-
tine water into pollution gradients. Can 1 Fish Aquat Sci 40:282-294
Konovalov GS (1959). Removal of microelements by the principal rivers of the USSR. Dokl Akad
NaukUSSR 129:1034-1038
Konovalov GS, Ivanova AA, Kolesnikova TKh (l967a) Rare and dispersed elements (microelements)
in the water and suspended substances of rivers in the European USSR. SOy HydroI1967:520-533
Konovalov GS, Ivanova AA, Kolesnikova TKh (l967b) Microelements in the water and suspended
substances of rivers in the Asiatic USSR. SOy HydroI1967:533-542
Konovalov GS, Ivanova AA (1972) Content and regime of trace elements in the water and suspended
substances in the Volga River basin. SOy HydroI1972:506-514
Konovalov GS, Nazarova LN (1975) Mapping trace elements in river waters. Gidrokhim Mater 62:
37-42
Kontorovich AE, Sadikov MA, Shvartsev SL (1963) Abundances of certain elements in the surface and
groundwaters of the northwestern part of the Siberian Platform. Dokl Akad Nauk USSR 149:168-
173
Kramer 1 (1976) Geochemical and lithological factors in acid precipitation. U S For Serv Tech Rep
N E-23:611-618
Kranck K (1980) Sedimentation processes in the sea. In: Hutzinger 0 (ed) The Handbook of Environ-
mental Chemistry.VoI2A. Springer, Berlin Heidelberg New York, p 61-75
Krauskopf, KB (1956) Factors controlling the concentration of thirteen rare metals in seawater.
Geochim Cosmochim Acta 9: 1-32
KrauskopfKB (1979) Introduction to geochemistry. McGraw-Hill, New York: 617 pp
Kremling K, Petersen H (1977) The distribution of zinc, cadmium, copper and iron in seawater of the
Iceland- Faroe Ridge area. Meteor F orsch Ergeb A 19: 10-17
Krishnaswami S, Lal D (1978) Radionuclide limnochronology. In: Lerman A (ed) Lakes - chemistry,
geology, physics. Springer, New York Heidelberg Berlin, 153-177
Krishnaswami S (1981) Geochronology of estuarine sediments. In: Martin 1M, Burton lD, Eisma D
(eds) River inputs to ocean systems. United Nations, New York. 92-99
Krom MD, Sholkovitz ER (1978) On the association of iron and manganese with organic matter in
anoxic marine pore water. Geochim Cosmochim Acta: 42:607-611
Krom MD, Turekian KK, Cutshall NH (1981) The fate of trace metals in the sediments of the New
York Bight. 3rd Int Ocean Disposal Symposium, Woods Hole, Mass, 28 pp
Kudo A, Miyahara S, Miller DR (1980) Movement of mercury from Minamata Bay into Yatsushiro
Sea. Prog Wat Tech. 12:509-524
Lag 1 (1968) Relationships between the chemical composition of the precipitation and the content of
exchangeable ions in the humus layer of natural soils. Acta Agric Scand 18: 148-152
Lag 1, Steinnes E (1974) Soil selenium in relation to precipitation. Ambio 3:237-238
Lag 1, Steinnes E (1976) Regional distribution of halogens in Norwegian forest soils. Geoderma 16:317-
325
Lal D (1977) The oceanic microcosm of particles. Science 198:997-1009
Lal D (1980) Comments on some aspects of particulate transport in the oceans. Earth Planet Sci Lett
49:520-527
Lambert CE, lehanno C, Silverberg N, Brun-Cottan lC, Chesselet R (1981) Log-normal distributions
of suspended particles in the open ocean. 1 Mar Res 39:77-98
Lammers WT (1967) Biophysical limnology. Separation of suspended and colloidal particles from nat-
ural water. Environ Sci Technol 1:52-57
Landing WM, Bruland K W (1980) Manganese in the North Pacific. Earth Planet Sci Lett 49:45-56
wim.salomons@home.nl
314 References
wim.salomons@home.nl
References 315
Lindberg SE, Harriss RC (1980) Emissions from coal combustion: use of aerosol solubility in hazard
assessment. In: Singh n, Deepak A (eds) Environmental and climatic impact of coal utilization.
Academic Press, New York 1980
Lindberg SE, Harriss RC (1981) The role of atmospheric deposition in an eastern US deciduous forest.
Water Air Soil Pollut 16:13-31
Lindberg SE, Harris RC (1983) Water and acid soluble trace metals in atmospheric particles. J Geophys
Res 88:5091-5100
Lindberg SE, Harriss RC, Turner RR (1982) Atmospheric deposition of metals to forest vegetation.
Science 215: 1609-1611
Lindberg SE, Maclaughlin SB (1982) Air pollutant interactions with vegetation: Research needs in data
aquisition and interpretation. In: Krupa SV, Legge AH (eds) Air pollutants and their effects on
terrestrial ecosystems. Wiley, New York (in press)
Lindsay WL (1972) Zinc in soils and plant nutrition Agron 24:147-186
Lindsay WL (1974) Role of chelation in micronutrient availability. In: Carson EW (ed) The Plant Root
and its Environment. Univ Virginia Press, Charlotsville pp 507-524
Lindsay WL, Norvell W A (1969) Development of a DTPA micronutrient soil test. Agron Abstr, p 84
Linstedt KD, Kruger P (1969) Vanadium concentrations in Colorado River basin waters. J Am Water
Works Assoc 61 :85-88
Lion LW, Leckie JO (1981) The biochemistry of the air-sea interface. Annu Rev of Earth Planet Sci
9:449-486
Lion LW, Leckie JO (1981) Chemical speciation of trace metals at the air-sea interface: The application
of an equilibrium model. Env GeoI3:293-314
Lion LW, Altman RS, Leckie JO (1982) Trace-metal adsorption characteristics of estuarine particulate
matter: Evaluation of contribution ofFe(Mn oxide and organic surface coatings. Environ Sci Tech-
nol 16:660-666
Livingstone DA (1963) Chemical composition of rivers and lakes. In: Fleischer M (ed) Data of Geo-
chemistry. Geol Surv Prof Pap 440-G: 64 pp
Livingston HD, Anderson RF (1983) Large particle transport of plutonium and other fallout radionu-
clides to the deep ocean. Nature 303:228-231
Ljunggren P (1955) Chemistry and radioactivity of some Mn and Fe ores. Geol Foren Stockh Forh
77:33-44
Loder TC, Richard RP (1981) The dynamics of conservative mixing in estuaries. Estuaries 4:64-69
Loeb GI, Neihof RA (1977) Adsorption of an organic film at the platinum - seawater interface. J Mar
Res 35:283-295
Lonsdale P, Burns VM, Fisk M (1980) Nodules of hydrothermal Birnessite in the caldera of a young
seamount. J GeoI88:611-618
Loring DH (1975) Mercury in the sediments of the Gulf ofSt. Lawrence. Can J Earth Sci 12:1219-1237
Loring DH (1978) Geochemistry of zinc, copper, and lead in the sediments of the estuary and Gulf of
St. Lawrence. Can J Earth Sci 15:757-772
Loring DH (1979) Geochemistry of cobalt, nickel, chromium and vanadium in the sediments of the es-
tuary and open GulfofSt. Lawrence. CanJ Earth Sci 16:1196-1209
Loring DH, Rantala RT (1977) Geochemical analysis of marine sediments and suspended particulate
matter. Fish Mar Serv Techn Rept 700, 58 pp
Lu CSJ, Chen KY (1977) Migration of trace metals in interfaces of seawater and polluted surficial sed-
iments. Environ Sci Technolll:174-182
Lum KR (1982) The potential availability ofP, AI, Cd, Co, Cr, Cu, Fe, Mn, Ni, Pb, and Zn in urban
particulate matter. Environ Technol Lett 3:57-62
Lundgren DG, Vestal JR, Tabita FR (1972) The microbiology of mine drainage pollution. In: Mitchell
R (ed) Water pollution microbiology. Wiley, New York, 69-88
Lundgren DG, Silver M (1980) Ore leaching by bacteria. Ann Rev MicrobioI34:263-283
Luoma SN, Bryan GW (1978a) Trace metal bioavailability: modelling chemical and biological inter-
actions of sediment bound zinc. Abstr Pap Am Chem Soc 176: 149
Luoma SN, Bryan GW (1978b) Factors controlling the availability of sediment-bound lead to the es-
tuarine bivalve Scrobicularia plana. J Mar Bioi Ass UK 58:793-802
Luoma SN, Bryan GW (1979) Trace metal bioavailability: modelling chemical and biological inter-
actions of sediment-bound zinc. In: Jenne EA (ed) Chemical modelling in aqueous systems. Am
Chem Soc Symp Ser 93:577-609
wim.salomons@home.nl
316 References
Luoma SN, Bryan GW (1981) A statistical assessment of the form of trace metals in oxidized estuarine
sediment employing chemical extractants. Sci Total Environ 17: 165-196
Luoma SN, 1enne EA (1976) Factors affecting the availability of sediment-bound cadmium to the es-
tuarine deposit-feeding clam, Macoma baltica. In: Cushing CE (ed) Radioecology and energy re-
sources, Proc 4th Nat Symp on Radioecology, Dowden, Hutchinson and Ross Stroudsberg, Penn:
283-291
Luoma SN, 1enne EA (1976) Estimating bioavailability of sediment bound trace metals with chemical
extractants. In: Hemphill DD (ed) Trace substances in environmental health, Univ Missouri Press,
Columbia X:343-351
Luoma SN, 1enne EA (1977) The availability of sediment-bound cobalt, silver and zinc to a deposit-
feeding clam. In: Wildung RE, Drucker H (eds) Biological implications of metals in the environ-
ment, NTIS Springfield VA: 213-230
Luther GW, Meyerson AL, Krajewski 11, Hires R (1980) Metal sulfides in estuarine sediments. 1 Sed-
iment Petrol 50: I I 17-1120
Lynn DC, Bonatti E (1965) Mobility of manganese in diagenesis of deep-sea sediments. Mar Geol
3:457-474
Lyons WB, Fitzgerald WF (1983) Trace metals speciation in nearshore anoxic and suboxic pore waters.
In: Wong CS, Boyle E, Bruland KW, Burton 1D, Goldberg ED (eds) Trace metals in sea water.
Plenum, New York London, pp 62 I -64 I
Lyons WB, Wilson KM, Armstrong PB, Smith GM, Gaudette HE (1980) Trace metal pore water geo-
chemistry of nearshore Bermuda carbonate sediments. Oceanol Acta 3:363-366
MacCarthy P, Smith GC (1979) Stability surface concept. A quantitative model for complexation in
multiligand mixtures. In: 1enne EA (ed) Chemical modelling in aqueous systems. Am Chern Soc
Symp Ser 93:201-222
MacDonald KC (1982) Mid-ocean ridges: fine scale tectonic, volcanic and hydrothermal processes
within the plate boundary zone. Ann Rev Earth Planet Sci 10: I 55- I 89
MacIntyre F (1970) Geochemical fractionation during mass transfer from sea to air by breaking bub-
bles. Tellus 22:45 I :462
MacIntyre F (1972) Flow pattern of bursting bubbles. 1 Geophys Res 77:521 1-5228
MacIntyre F (1974) Chemical fractionation and sea surface micro layer processes in the sea. In: Gold-
berg (ed) Marine Chemistry, Wiley, New York, 5:245-299
Mackay DW, Halcrow W, Thornton I (1972) Sludge dumping in the Firth of Clyde. Mar Pollut Bull
3:7- II
Mackenzie FT, Garrels RM (1966) Chemical mass balance between rivers and oceans. Am 1 Sci
264:507-525
Maenhaut W, Zoller WH (1977) Determination of the chemical composition of the South Pole aerosol
by instrumental neutron activation analysis. 1 Radioanal Chern 37:637-650
Maenhaut W, Zoller WH, Duce RA, Hoffman GL (1979) Concentration and size distribution of par-
ticulate trace elements in the south polar atmosphere. 1 Geophys Res 84:242 I-243 I
Magnuson VR, Harriss DK, Sun MS, Taylor DK, Glass GE (1978) Relationship of activities of metal-
ligand species to aquatic toxicity. In: 1enne EA (ed) Chemical modelling aqueous systems. Am
Chern Soc Symp Ser 93:634-656
Malle KG, Miiller G (1982) Metallgehalt und Schwebstoffgehalt im Rhein. Z Wasser Abwasser Forsch
15: 11- 15
Malo BA (1977) Partial extraction of metals from aquatic sediments. Environ Sci Technol I 1:277-282
Manheim FT (1965) Manganese-iron accumulations in the shallow marine environment. In: Symp on
Marine Geochemistry. Occ Publ Univ Rhode Island, 3:217-276
Manheim FT (1966) A hydraulic squeezer for obtaining interstitial waters from consolidated and un-
consolidated sediments. Prof Pap US Geol Surv 550-6:256-261
Manheim FT (1974) Comparative studies on extraction of sediment interstitial waters: Discussion and
comment on the current state of interstitial water studies. Clay Miner 22:337-343
Mantoura RFC, Riley 1P (1975) The use of gel filtration in the study of metal binding by humic acids
and related compounds. Anal Chim Acta 78: 193-200
Mantoura RFC, Dickson A, Riley 1P (1978) The complexation of metals with humic materials in nat-
ural waters. Estuarine Coastal Mar Sci 6:387-408
Marquenie 1M, de Kock WChr, Dinneen PM (1983) Bioavailability of heavy metals in sediments. Proc
Int Conf: Heavy metals in the environment. Heidelberg, 944-947
wim.salomons@home.nl
References 317
Marowsky G, Wedepohl KH (1971) General trends in the behaviour of Cd, Hg, TI and Bi in some major
rock forming processes. Geochim Cosmochim Acta 35: 1255-1267
Marquenie JM (1981) The freshwater mollusc Dreissena polymorpha as potential tool for assessing bio-
availability of heavy metals in aquatic systems. Int Conf Heavy Metals in the Environment, Am-
sterdam: 409-412
Martens CS, Goldhaber MB (1978) Early diagenesis in transitional sedimentary environments of the
White Oak River Estuary, North Carolina. Limnol Oceanogr 23:428-441
Martin DC, Bella DA (1971) Effect of mixing on oxygen uptake rate of estuarine bottom deposits. J
Water Pollut Control Fed September 1971
Martin JH, Knauer GA (1980) Manganese cycling in northeast Pacific waters. Earth Planet Sci Lett
51:266-274
Martin JH, Knauer GA, Flegal AR (1980) Distribution of zinc in natural waters. In: Nriagu JO (ed)
Zinc in the Environment. Wiley, New York 2: 193-197
Martin JM, Jednacak J, Pravdic V (1971) The physico-chemical aspects of trace element behaviour in
estuarine environments. Thalassia Yugosl 7:619-637
Martin JM, Letolle R (1979) Oxygen 18 in estuaries. Nature 282:292-294
Martin JM, Meybeck M (1979) Elemental mass balance of material carried by major world rivers. Mar
Chern 7:173-206
Martin JM, Whitfield M (1983) The significance of the river input of chemical elements to the ocean.
Wong CS (ed) Trace metals in sea water. Proc NATO Adv Res Inst, March 30-April I, 1981 Erice,
Italy, Plenum, NY, in press
Martin JM, Salvadori F, Thomas AJ (1978) Le mercure et les oligoeU:ments dans Ie Delta du Rhone.
IVes. Joum Etud Pollut (CIESM, Antalya) 197-202
Mason B (1966) Principles of Geochemistry. Wiley, New York, 310 pp
Mathis BJ, Cummings TF (1973) Selected metals in sediments, water and biota in the Illinois River.
J Water Pollut Control Fed 45: 1573-1583
Mattiat B (1969) Eine Methode zur elektronenmikroskopischen U ntersuchung des Mikrogefiiges in to-
nigen Sedimenten. Geol Jb 88:87-111
Mayer LM (1976) Chemical water sampling in lakes and sediments with dialysis bags. Limno1 Oceanogr
21:909-911
Mayer R (1981) Natiirliche und anthropogene Komponente des Schwermetallhaushalts von Waldoko-
systemen. Gott Bodenkdl Ber 70: 1-152
Mayer LM (1982) Retention of riverine iron in estuaries. Geochim Cosmochim Acta 46: 1003-1009
Mayer R, Ulrich B (1982) Calculation of deposition rates from the flux balance and ecological effects
of atmospheric deposition upon forest ecosystems. In: Georgii HW, Pankrath J (eds) Deposition
of atmospheric pollutants. Reidel, 195-200
McBride BC, Wolfe RS (1971) Biosynthesis of dimethylarsine by methano bacterium. Biochemistry
10:4312-4317
McCave IN (1975) Vertical flux of particles in the ocean. Deep- Sea Res 22:491-502
McColl JG (1981) Trace elements in the hydrologic cycle of a forest ecosystem. Plant Soil 62:337-349
McColl JG, Bush OS (1978) Precipitation and through fall chemistry in San Francisco Bay area. J En-
viron Qual 7:352-357
McCrady JK, Chapman GA (1979) Determination of copper complexing capacity of natural river wa-
ter, well water and artifially reconstituted water. Water Res 13: 143-150
McDowell OM, O'Connor BA (1977) Hydraulic behaviour of estuaries. MacMillan, London, 1977
McInnes G (1979) Multi-element survey: analysis of the first two years' results. Report LR 305 (AP),
Warren Springs Laboratories. Dept ofIndustry, Stevenage
McKnight OM, Morel FMM (1979) Release of weak and strong copper complexing agents by algae.
Limnol Oceanogr 24:823-837
McKnight OM, Morel FMM (1980) Copper complexation by siderophores from filamentous blue-
green algae. Limnol Oceanogr 25:62-71
McLaren RG, Crawford DV (1973) Studies on soil copper: fractionation of copper in soils. J Soil Sci
24:172-181
McMahon TA, Denison PJ (1979) Empirical atmospheric deposition parameters; a survey. Atmos En-
viron 13:571-585
Meade RH (1972) Transport and deposition of sediments in estuaries. Geol Soc Am Memoir 133:91-120
wim.salomons@home.nl
318 References
Measures CI, Burton JD (1980) The vertical distribution and oxidation states of dissolved selenium in
the northwest Atlantic Ocean and their relationship to biological processes. Earth Planet Sci Lett
46:385-396
Meent D van de, Los A, Leeuw WJ de, Schenck PA (1982) Size fractionation and analytical pyrolysis
of suspended particles from the river Rhine delta In: Bjoroy M (ed) Advances in Organic Geo-
chemistry 1981. Wiley 336-349
Meent D van de, Los A, Leeuw WJ de, Schenck PA, Salomons W (1981) Stability constants and binding
capacity of fractionated suspended matter for cadmium. Env Technol Lett 2:569-578
Meiggs TO (1980) The use of sediment analysis in forensic investigations and procedural requirements
for such studies. In: Baker RA (ed) Contaminants and sediments, Ann Arbor Sci Publ, Ann Arbor,
Mich 1:297-308
Mero JL (1965) The mineral resources of the sea. Elsevier, Amsterdam. 312 pp
Mero JL (1979) Economic aspects of oceans and seas. In: Encyclopaedia Brittannica. Macropaedia.
Univ Chicago Press 13:501-504
Merrill JR, Lyden EFX, Honda M, Arnold JR (1960) The sedimentary geochemistry the beryllium
isotopes. Geochim Cosmochim Acta 18: 108-129
Merrill JT, Duce RA (1982) The meteorology and atmospheric chemistry of Enewetak atoll. The nat-
ural history of Enewetak atoll. In: Reese E (ed) The natural history of Enewetak atoll. US Depart
Energy, Tenn USA
Meylan MA, Glasby GP, Knedler KE, Johnston JH (1981) Metalliferrous deep-sea sediments. In: Wolf
KH (ed) Handbook of strata-bound and stratiform ore deposits. Elsevier, Amsterdam Oxford New
York 9:77-178
Miesch AT (1967) Theory of error in geochemical data. US Geol Surv Prof Pap 574-A: 17 pp
Migniot C (1968) Etude des proprietes physiques de differentes sediments tn:s fins et de leur compor-
tement so us des actions hydrodynamiques. La Honille Blanche 23:7
Miller JE, Hassett 11, Koeppe DE (1977) Interactions oflead and cadmium on metal uptake and growth
of corn plants. J Environ Qual 6:18-26
Mills EL, Oglesby RT (1971) Five trace elements and vitamin BI2 in Cayuga Lake, New York. Proc
14th ConfGreat Lakes Res: 256-267
Mills GL, Quinn JG (1981) Isolation of dissolved organic matter and copper organic complexes from
estuarine waters using reverse-phase liquid chromatography. Mar Chern 10:93-102
Millward GE, Moore RM (1982) The adsorption of Cu, Mn and Zn by iron oxyhydrate in model es-
tuarine solution. Water Res 16:981-985
Ministry for Transport and Public Works, The Netherlands (1981) Water Action Programme: 1980-
1984
Mitchell M (1956) Visual range in the polar regions with particular reference to the Alaskan arctic. J
Atmos Terr Phys, Spec Supp1195-211
Mitchell RL (1964) Trace elements in soils. In: Bear FE (ed) Chemistry of the soil. Reinhold, New York,
320-368
Mook WG (1970) Stable carbon and oxygen isotopes of natural waters in the Netherlands. IAEA Iso-
tope Hydrol: 163-190
Mook WG, Koene BKS (1975) Chemistry of dissolved inorganic carbon in estuarine and coastal brack-
ish waters. Estuarine Coastal Mar Sci 3:325-336
Moorby SA, Cronan DS (1981) The distribution of elements between co-existing phases in some marine
ferromanganese oxide deposits. Geochim Cosmochim Acta 45: 1855-1877
Moore DP (1974) In: Carson EW (ed) The plant root and its environment. Univ Press of Virginia, Char-
lotsville, 6:135-151
Moore RM (1981) Oceanographic distributions of zinc, cadmium, copper and aluminum in waters of
the central Arctic. Geochim Cosmochim Acta 45: 2475- 2482
Moore RM, Burton JD, Williams PJ, Young ML (\979) The behaviour of dissolved organic material,
iron and manganese in estuarine mixing. Geochim Cosmochim Acta 43:919-926
Morel F, McDuff RE, Morgan 11 (\973) Interactions and chemostasis in aquatic chemical systems.
Role of pH, pE, solubility and complexation. In: Singer PC (ed) Trace metals and metal-organic
interactions in natural waters. Ann Arbor Sci, Ann Arbor Mich: 157-200
Morgan JJ (1964) Chemistry of aqueous manganese II and IV. Ph. D. dissertation, Harvard Univ Cam-
bridge, MA, 244 pp
wim.salomons@home.nl
References 319
Morishita T (1981) The Jinzu River basin: Contamination of soil and paddy rice with cadmium dis-
charges from Kamioka Mine. In: Kitagishi K, Yamane I (eds) Heavy metal pollution in soils of
Japan. Jpn Sci Soc, Tokyo: 107-124
Morita Y (1955) Distribution of copper and zinc in various phases of the earth materials. J Earth Sci
Nagoya Univ 3:33-45
Morris AW, Bale AJ (1979) Effect of rapid precipitation of dissolved Mn in river water on estuarine
Mn distributions. Nature 279:318-319
Morris AW, Bale AJ, Howland RJM (1982) The dynamics of estuarine manganese cycling. Estuarine
Coastal Shelf Sci 13,2: 175-192
Morris AW, Mantoura RFC, Bale AJ, Howland RMJ (1978) Very low salinity regions of estuaries: im-
portant sites for chemical and biological reactions. Nature 274:678-680
Mortvedt 11, Giordano PM, Lindsay WL (1972) Micronutrients in Agriculture. Soil Sci Soc Am, Ma-
dison, Wisc.
Mouvet C, Bourg ACM (1983) Speciation (including adsorbed species) of copper, lead, nickel and zinc
in the Meuse River: Observed results compared to values calculated with a chemical equilibrium
computer program. Water Res 17:641-649
Mulhearn PJ (1981) Distribution of micro bubbles in coastal waters. J Geophys Res 86:6429-6434
Muller G (1967) Beziehungen zwischen Wasserkorper, Bodensediment und Organismen im Bodensee.
Naturwiss 54:454-466
Muller G (1979) Schwermetalle in den Sedimenten des Rheins - Veranderungen seit 1971. Umschau
79:778-783
Muller G (1980) Schwermetalle in den Sedimenten der Elbe bei Stade. Naturwiss. 67:560
Muller G, Forstner, U (1968) General relationship between suspended sediment concentration and wa-
ter discharge in the Alpenrhein and some other rivers. Nature 217:244-245
Muller G, Irion G, Forstner U (1972) Formation and diagenesis of inorganic Ca-Mg carbonates in the
lacustrine environment. Naturwissenschaften 59: 158-164
Muller G, Forstner U (1975) Heavy metals in sediments of the Rhine and Elbe estuaries: mobilization
or mixing effect. Environ Geoll:33-39
Murozumi M, Chow TJ, Patterson CC (1969) Chemical concentrations of pollutant lead aerosols, ter-
restrial dusts and sea salts in Greenland and Antarctic snow strata. Geochim Cosmochim Acta
33:1247-1294
Murthy ASP, Ferrell RE Jr (1972) Comparative chemical composition of sediment interstitial water.
Clay Miner 20:317-321
NEDECO (1965) A study on the siltation of the Banglet Por Channel, Volume II, The field investi-
gations, The Hague
Naeve E (1974) Sources of pollution in the Mediterranean and its effects on living resources and fishing.
Rev Intern Oceanogr Med XXXV -XXVI:5-20
National Enforcement Investigation Center (NEIC), Denver Federal Center (1978) NEIC Policies and
Procedures Manual. Denver, CO
National Institute for Sewage and Wastewater Treatment (Netherlands RIZA 1981) Die Wasserquali-
tat der Maas in den Niederlanden im Zeitraum 1953-1980. Lc1ystad, The Netherlands. Rept 81-048
NeihofRA, Loeb GI (1972) Surface charge of particulate matter in sea water. Limnol Oceanogr 17:7-16
Neihof RA, Loeb G (1974) Dissolved organic matter in seawater and the electric charge of immersed
surfaces. J Mar Res 32:5-12
Nelsen TA (1981) The application ofQ-mode factor analysis to suspended particulate matter studies:
Examples from the New York Bight apex. Mar Geol 39:15-31
Nelson PO, Chung AK, Hudson MC (1981) Factors affecting the fate of heavy metals in the activated
sludge process. J Water Pollut Control Fed 53: 1323-1333
Neubecker TA, Allen HE (1983) The measurement of complexation capacity and conditional stability
constants for ligands in natural water. A review. Water Res 17: 1-14
Ng A, Patterson C (1981) Natural concentrations of lead in ancient Arctic and Antarctic ice. Geochim
Cosmochim Acta 45:2109-2121
Nicholls GD (1969) In: Murchison D, Westoll TS (eds) Coal and coal-bearing strata. Oliver and Boyd,
Edinburgh. 269
Nie NH, Hull CH, Jenkins JC, Steinbrenner K, Bent DH (1975) Statistical Package for the Social Sci-
ences (SPSS). McGraw-Hill, New York 675 pp
wim.salomons@home.nl
320 References
Nikiforova EM, Smirnova RS (1975) Metal technophility and lead technogenic anomalies. Abstr Int
Conf: Heavy metals in the environment. Toronto, C-94-96
Nipkow F (1920) Vorliiufige Mitteilungen iiber Untersuchungen des Schlammabsatzes im Ziirichsee.
ZHydroll:I-23(1920)
Nishida H, Tada F, Suzuki S (1980) Computation of the index of pollution caused by heavy metals of
river sediments. Report of Research, Nippon Institute of Technology, Vol 10:87-93
Nissenbaum A, Swaine Dl (1976) Organic matter-metal interactions in recent sediments: The role of
humic substances. Geochim Cosmochim Acta 40:809-816
Noller BN, Bloom H, Arnold AP (1981) Sampling and analysis of metals in atmospheric particulates
by graphite furnace atomic absorption spectrometry. Prog Analyt Atom Spectrosc 4:81-189
Nordstrom DK, and eighteen co-authors (1979) A comparison of computerized chemical models for
equilibrium calculations in aqueous systems. In: lenne EA (ed) Chemical modelling in aqueous sys-
tems. Am Chern Soc Symp Ser 93:857-892
Norton RL (1982) Assessment of Pollution Loads to the North Sea. Water Res Centre, Stevenage Lab,
Rep 233-M
Norton SA, Hess CT, Davis RB (1981) Rates of accumulation of heavy metals in pre- and post-euro-
pean sediments in New England lakes. In: Eisenreich SI (ed) Atmospheric pollutants in natural
waters. Ann Arbor Sci, Mich, 409-421
Norvell W A, Lindsay WL (1972) Reactions of DTPA chelates of iron, zinc, copper and manganese with
soils. Soil Sci Soc Am Proc 36:778-789
Nriagu 10 (1979) Global inventory of natural and anthrapogenic emmissions of trace metals to the at-
mosphere. Nature 279:409-411
Nriagu 10, Coker RD (1980) Trace metals in humic and fulvic acids from Lake Ontario sediments. En-
viron Sci TechnoI14:443-446
Nriagu 10, Kemp ALW, Wong HKT, Harper N (1979) Sedimentary record of heavy metal pollution
in Lake Erie. Geochim Cosmochim Acta 43:247-258
Nriagul0, Wong HKT, Coker RD (1981) Particulate and dissolved trace metals in lake Ontario. Water
Res 15:91-96
Nriagu 10, Wong HKT, Coker RD (1982) Deposition and chemistry of pollutant metals in lakes
around the smelters at Sudbury, Ontario. Environ Sci TechnoI16:551-559
Niirnberg HW (1977) Potentialities and applications of advanced polarographic and voltammetric
methods in environmental research and surveillance of toxic metals. Electrochim Acta 22:935-949
Niirnberg HW, Mart L, Valenta P (1977) Concentration of Cd, Pb and Cu in Ligurian and Tyrrhenian
coastal waters. Proc XXVth Congr. and Plenary Assembly Comm Int Explor Sci Mediterr, Split,
1976
O'Conner BH, laklevic 1M (1981) Characterization of ambient aerosol particulate samples from St.
Louis areas by X-ray powder diffractometry. Atmos Environ 15: 1681-1690
O'Connor TP, Kester DR (1975) Adsorption of copper and cobalt from fresh and marine systems.
Geochim Cosmochim Acta 39: 1531-1543
Oakley SM, Nelson PO, Williamson Kl (1981) Model of trace-metal partitioning on marine sediment.
Environ Sci TechnoI15:474-480
Ochs HT, Gatz DF (1980) Water solubility of atmospheric aerosols. Atmos Environ 14:615-616
Oliver BG (1973) Heavy metal levels of Ottawa and Rideau River sediments. Environ Sci Technol
7:135-137
Papadopoulou C (1972) The elementary composition of marine invertebrates as contribution to the sea
pollution investigation. Int Rep (mimeogr.) Nuclear Res Centre, Athens. cit Bernhard (1978)
17pp
Parham WE (1966) Lateral variations of clay mineral assemblages in modern and ancient sediments.
Proc Int Clay Conf, Jerusalem, 135-145
Parra M, Puechmaille C, Carruesco C (1981) Strontium as a marker of the origin of biogenic and ter-
rigenous materials as a hydrodynamic tracer in the deep sea North Atlantic area. Chern Geol31 :91-
102
Partheniades E (1964) A summary of the present knowledge of the behaviour of fine sediments in es-
tuaries. Tech Note 8, Dept Civil Eng, MIT Cambridge
Patchineelam SR (1975) Untersuchungen iiber die Hauptbindungsarten und die Mobilisierbarkeit von
Schwerrnetallen in fluviatilen Sedimenten. Diss. Univ Heidelberg, 136 pp
wim.salomons@home.nl
References 321
Patric FM, Loutit M (1976). Passage of metals in effiuents through bacteria to higher organisms. Water
Res 10:333-335
Pattenden NJ (1974) Atmospheric concentrations and deposition rates of some trace elements measured
in the Swansea/Neath/Port Talbot area. AERE Harwell Report R 7729, HMSO, London
Patterson CC (1971) Native copper, silver and gold accessible to early metallurgists. Am Antiq 36:286-
321
Patterson (1972) Silver stocks and losses in ancient and medieval times. Econ Hist Rev 2nd series
25:205-235
Patterson CC, Settle D, Schaule B, Burnett M (1976) Transport of pollutant lead to the ocean and with-
in ocean ecosystems. In: Windom HL, Duce RA (eds) Marine pollution transfer. Lexington DC,
Heath: 23-38
Pedro G, Delmas AB (1970) Principes geochimique de la distributions des eJement-traces dans les sols.
Ann Agron, Paris 21:483-518
Pellenbarg R (1979) Silicones as tracers for anthropogenic additions to sediments. Mar Pollut Bull
10:267-269
Pellenbarg RE, Church TM (1979) The estuarine surface micro layer and trace metal cycling in a salt
marsh. Science 203: 10 10-10 12
Perdue EM (1979) Solution thermochemistry of humic substances. In: Jenne EA (ed) Chemical mod-
elling in aqueous systems. Am Chern Soc Symp Ser 93:99-113
Perel'man AI (1967) Geochemistry of epigenesis. Plenum, New York, 266 p
Petrenchuk OP (1980) On the budget of sea salts and sulfur in the atmosphere. J Geophys Res 85:7439-
7444
Pfeiffer G, Forstner U, Stoffers P (1982) Speciation of reducible metal compounds in pelagic sediments
by chemical extraction. Senckenbergiana Marit 14:23-38
Picard GL, Felbeck GT (1976) The complexation of iron by marine humic acid. Geochim Cosmochim
Acta 40: 1347-1350
Picard MD, High LR (1972) Criteria for recognizing lacustrine rocks. In: Rigby JK, Hamblin WK (eds)
Recognition of ancient sedimentary environments. Soc Econ Palaeont Min, Spec Pub I 16: 108-145
Pickering RJ (1969) Distribution of radionuclides in bottom sediments of the Clinch River. US Geol
Surv Pap 433-H:24 pp
Pickering WF (1981) Selective chemical extraction of soil components and bound metal species. CRC
Critical Rev Anal Chern Nov: 233-266
Pierce ML, Moore CB (1982) Adsorption of arsenite and arsenate on amorphous iron hydroxide. Water
Res 16:1247-1253
Pilkington ES, Warren LJ (1977) Determination of heavy-metal distribution in marine sediments. En-
viron Sci Technol 13:295-302
Piotrowicz SR, Duce RA, Fasching JL, Weisel CP (1979) Bursting bubbles and their effect on the see-
to-air transport of Fe, Cu, and Zn. Mar Chern 7:307-324
Piotrowicz SR, Harvey GR, Springer-Young M, Courant RA, Boren DA (1983) Studies of cadmium,
copper and zinc complexation by marine fulvic and humic materials in seawater using anodic strip-
ping voltammetry. In: Wong CS, Burton JD, Boyle E, Bruland K, Goldberg ED (eds) Trace metals
in seawater. Plenum, New York, pp 699-717
Piper DZ, Leons K, Cannon WF (1979) Manganese nodules and surface sediment compositions: home
sites A, B, and C. In: Bischoff JL, Piper DZ (eds) Marine geology and oceanography of the Pacific
manganese nodule province. Plenum, New York, 437-473
Polynov BB (1937) Cycle of weathering. Murby, London, 220 p
Pons LJ, Breemen N van (1982) Factors influencing the formation of potential acidity in tidal swamps.
In: Drost H, Breemen N van (eds) Proceedings of the Bangkok symposium on acid sulphate soils.
International Institute for Land Reclamation and Improvement/ILRI, Wageningen, pp 37-51
Popp CJ, Laquer F (1980) Trace metal transport and partitioning in the suspended sediments of the
Rio Grande and tributaries in central New Mexico. Chemosphere 9:89-98
Postma D (1981) Formation of siderite and vivianite and the porewater composition of a recent bog
sediment in Denmark. Chern Geol31 :225-244
Postma H (1967) Sediment transport and sedimentation in the marine environment. In: LauffGH (ed)
Estuaries. AAAS-PubI83: 158-179
Postma H (1980) Sediment transport and sedimentation. In: Olausson E, Cato I (eds) Chemistry and
biogeochemistry of estuaries. Wiley: 153-186
wim.salomons@home.nl
322 References
Presley BJ, Brooks RR, Kappel HM (1967) A simple squeezer for removal of interstitial waters from
ocean sediments. J Marine Res 25:355-357
Presley BJ, Kolodny Y, Nissenbaum A, Kaplan IR (1972) Early diagenesis in a reducing fjord, Saanich
Inlet, British Columbia. II. Trace element distribution in interstitial water and sediment. Geochim
Cosmochim Acta 36: I 073-1090
Presley BJ, Trefry JH (1980) Sediment-water interactions and the geochemistry of interstitial waters.
In: Olausson E, Cato I (eds) Chemistry and biogeochemistry of estuaries. Wiley, New York: 187-
222
Presley BJ, Trefry JH, Shokes RF (1980) Heavy metal inputs to Mississippi Delta sediments. Water Air
Soil Pollut 13:481-494
Preston A, Jefferies DF, Dutton JWR, Harvey BR, Steele AK (1972) British isles coastal waters: the
concentrations of selected heavy metals in seawater,suspended matter and biological indicators. A
pilot study. Environ Pollut 3:69-82
Price NB (1976) Chemical diagenesis in sediments. In: Riley JP, Chester R (eds) Chemical oceanogra-
phy. Academic, London New York San Francisco 6: I -58
Proctor PD, Kisvarsanyi G, Garrison E, Williams A (1973) Heavy metal content of surface and ground
waters of the Springfield-Joplin areas, Missouri. In: Hemphill DD (ed) Trace Substances in En-
vironmentalHealth. UnivMo, Vol VII: 63-73
Prosi F (1979) Bioavailability of heavy metals in different freshwater sediments: uptake in macroben-
thos and biomobilization. In: Management and control of heavy metals in the environment. Lon-
don September 1979. CEP Consultants Ltd. 1979,288-292
Purves DC (1977) Trace-element contamination of the environment. Elsevier, Amsterdam, 260 pp
Rahn KA (1976) The chemical composition of the atmospheric aerosol. Kingston (Rhode Island) Grad-
uate School of Oceanography. Univ. of Rhode Island. Techn Rep 265 pp
Rahn KA (198Ia) The MnjV ratio as a tracer oflarge-scale sources of pollution aerosol for the Arctic.
AtmosEnviron 15:1457-1464
Rahn KA (198Ib) Relative importance of North America and Eurasia as sources of arctic aerosol. At-
mosEnviron 15:1447-1455
Rahn KA (198Ic) Atmospheric, riverine and oceanic sources of seven trace constituents to the arctic
ocean. Atmos Environ 15:1507-1516
Rahn KA, McCaffrey RJ (1979) Compositional differences between arctic aerosol and snow. Nature
280:479-480
Rahn KA, McCaffrey RJ (1980) On the origin and transport of the winter Arctic aerosol. Ann NY Acad
Sci 388:503
Rahn KA, Shaw GE (1980) Potential radioactive effects of the arctic aerosol. Mon Weath Rev (in press)
as cited by Shaw 1981
Rambaek JP, Steinnes E (1980) Atmospheric deposition of heavy metals studied by analysis of moss
samples using neutron activation analysis and atomic absorption spectrometry. Nucl Methods En-
viron Energy Res, USDOE CONF-800433: 175-180
Rapin F (1980) Les sediments des Baies de Nice et de Villefrance-sur-Mer (Mediterranee, France). Diss
Fac Sci Univ Geneva, Switzerland 139 pp
Rapin F, Forstner U (1983) On the selectivity of various extractants used in sequential leaching tech-
niques for particulate metal speciation. Proc Intern Conf. Heavy Metals in the Environment, Sept
6-9, 1983, pp 1074-1077, CEP-Consulants, Edingburgh
Raudkivi AJ (1976) Loose boundary hydraulics. Pergamon, Oxford
Reay PF (1972) The accumulation of arsenic from arsenic-rich natural waters by aquatic plants. J Appl
EcoI9:557-565
Reichert J, De Haar U (eds) (1982) Schadstoffe im Wasser. I. Metalle. Ger Res Council, Res Rep Har-
ald Boldt Boppard, 446 pp
Reid JD, McDuffie B (1981) Sorption of trace cadmium on clay minerals and river sediments: Effects
of pH and Cd(II) concentrations in a synthetic river water medium. Water Air Soil Pollut 15:375-
386
Reineck H-E, Singh IB (1975) Depositional sedimentary environments. Springer, Berlin Heidelberg
New York 439 pp
Reisinger K, Stoeppler M, Niirnberg HW (1981) Evidence for the absence of biological methylation
oflead in the environment. Nature 29 I :228
Rendell PS, Batley GE, Cameron AJ (1980) Adsorption as a control of metal concentrations in sedi-
mentextracts. Environ Sci Technol 14:314-318
wim.salomons@home.nl
References 323
Renfro WC (1973) Transfer of Zn-65 from sediments by marine polychaete worms. Mar Bioi 21:305-
316
Renzoni A, Bacci E, Fa1ciai L (1973) Mercury concentration in the water, sediments and fauna of an
area of the Tyrrhenian Coast. Rev Int Oceanogr Med 36/37: I 7-45
Reuther R, Wright RF, Forstner U (198 I) Distribution and chemical forms of heavy metals in sediment
cores from two Norwegian lakes affected by acid precipitation. Int Conf: Heavy metals in the en-
vironment, Amsterdam: 318-321
Rijkswaterstaat (1981) Kwaliteitsonderzoek in de rijkswateren 1980. National Institute for Public
Health (RIV) and National Institute for Drinking Water (RID) of the Netherlands
Rijncommissie Waterleidingsbedrijven (RIWA, Netherlands) (1980) Rhine River quality between Col-
ogne and Hoek van Holland. Sampling 24th April, 1980
Rippey B, Murphy Rl, Kyle SW (1982) Anthropogenically derived changes in the sedimentary flux of
Mg, Cr, Ni, Zn, Hg, Pb and P in Lough Neagh, Northern Ireland. Environ Sci Technol 16:
23-30
Rise Project Group (1980) East Pacific Rise: Hot springs and geophysical experiments. Science
207:1421-1433
Robbins lA (1978) Geochemical and geophysical applications of radioactive lead. In: Nriagu 10 (ed)
The Biogeochemistry of Lead in the Environment. Elsevier North Holland, Amsterdam, 284-353
Robbins lA, Callender E (1975) Diagenesis of manganese in Lake Michigan sediments. Am 1 Sci
275:512-533
Robbins lA, Landstrom E, Wahlgren M (1972) Tributary inputs of soluble trace metals to Lake Michi-
gan. Proc 15th ConfGreat Lakes Res: 270-290
Robinson AR (1973) Sediment our greatest pollutant? In: Tank RW (ed) Focus on Environmental
Ecology. Oxford Univ. Press, New York, 186-192
Rohatgi NK, Chen KY (1976) Fate of metals in wastewater discharge to ocean. 1 Environ Eng Div AS-
CE 102:675-685
Rona P, Lowell RP (eds) (1981) Sea floor spreading centers: Hydrothermal systems. Dowden, Hutch-
inson and Ross, Stroudsburg, Pennsylvania, 424 pp
Ros Vicent 1, Costa Yangue F, Parsi P, Statham G, Duursma EK (1976) The ease of release of some
trace metals and radionuclides being sorbed for long periods by marine sediments. Bol Inst Esp
Oceanogr (cit Duursma EK 1976)
Rose AW, Hawkes HE, Webb lS (1979) Geochemistry in mineral exploration. Academic Press: 657 pp
Rosen H, Novakov T, Bodhaine BA (1981) Soot in the Arctic. Atmos Environ 15:1371-1374
Ross DA (1978) Opportunities and uses of the ocean. Springer, New York Berlin Heidelberg, 320 p
Rossmann R (1973) Lake Michigan ferromanganese nodules. Ph D thesis Univ Michigan, pp 151 (un-
published work)
Roth I, Hornung H (1977) Heavy metal concentrations in water, sediments and fish from Mediterra-
nean coastal area, Israel. Environ Sci Technol 11:265-269
Runnels DD (1973) Detection of molybdenum enrichment in the environment through comparative
study of stream drainages, Central Colorado. In: Hemphill DD (ed) Trace substances in environ-
mental health. Univ Missouri Press, Columbia 7:99- I 04
Ruppert H (1980) Fixation of metals on hydrous manganese and iron oxide phases in marine Mn-Fe-
nodules and sediments. Chern Erde 39:97-132
Rutgers van der Loeff MM (1980) Time variation in interstitial nutrient concentration at an exposed
subtidal station in the Dutch Wadden Sea. Neth 1 Sea Res 14:123-143
Saar RA, Weber lH (1982) Fulvic acid: Modifier of metal-ion chemistry. Environ Sci Technol16:5 IOA-
517A
Salomons W (1974) Chemical and isotopic composition of carbonates during an erosion-sedimentation
cycle. Dissertations Abstract International 35, 3. Xerox University microfilms Ann Arbor. Order
No 74-20094
Salomons W (1975) Chemical and isotopic composition of carbonates in recent sediments and soils
from Western Europe. 1 Sediment Petrol 45:440-449
Salomons (1978) Application of the multi-element tracer technique to determine the origin of mud in
the North Sea and adjoining areas. Delft Hydraulics Report R I 136, 82 pp
Salomons W (1980) Adsorption processes and hydrodynamic conditions in estuaries. Environ Technol
Lett 1:356-365
Salomons W (1981) Impact of civil engineering on the pathways of heavy metals from rivers to the
southern North Sea. Int Conf: Heavy metals in the environment, Amsterdam: 359-362
wim.salomons@home.nl
324 References
Salomons W (1983) Trace metal cycling in a polluted lake (IJsselmeer, the Netherlands). Oelft Hydraul-
ics Laboratory Report S 357/EEC contract no 199-7-1 ENV N. 50 pp
Salomons W, Oriel W van (1980) Interactions of trace metals between water, sediment and biota. WHO
Regional Office for Europe; Trier 5-8/8/1980
Salomons W, Eysink W (1981) Pathways of mud and particulate trace metals from rivers to the South-
ern North Sea. In: Nio SO, Schuettenhelm RTE, Weering TCE van (eds) Holocene Marine Sed-
imentation in the North Sea Basin. Spec Publ Int Assoc SedimentoI5:429-450
Salomons W, Forstner U (1980) Trace metal analysis on polluted sediments. II Evaluation of environ-
mental impact. Environ Technol Lett 1:506-517
Salomons W, Oe Groot AJ (1978) Pollution history of trace metals in sediments, as affected by the
Rhine River. In: Krumbein WE (ed) Environmental Biogeochemistry. Ann Arbor Sci Publl:149-
162
Salomons W, Gerritse RG (1981) Some observations on the occurrence of phosphorus in recent sed-
iments from western Europe. Sci Total Environ 17:37-49
Salomons W, Mook WG (1977) Trace metal concentrations in estuarine sediments: mobilization, mix-
ing or precipitation. Neth J Sea Res II: 199-209
Salomons W, Mook WG (1980) Biogeochemical processes affecting metal concentrations in lake sed-
iments (lJsselmeer, The Netherlands). Sci Total Environ 16:217-229
Salomons W, Mook WG (1981) Field observations of the isotopic composition of particulate organic
carbon in the Southern North Sea and adjacent estuaries. Mar Geo141:M 11-M20
Salomons W, Van Pagee J A (1981) Prediction of NT A levels in river systems and their effects on metal
concentration. Int Conf: Heavy metals in the environment, Amsterdam: 694-697
Salomons W, ScheItens SO (1977) Analyse van zware metalen in slib. Oelft Hydraulics Report S248.
Salomons W, de Bruin M, Ouin RPW, Mook WG (1978) Mixing of marine and fluvial sediments in
estuaries. Abstr 16th Coastal Engineering Conf, Hamburg, West Germany 4 pp
Salomons W, van Oriel W, Kerdijk H, Boxma R (1982) Help! Holland is plated by the Rhine (environ-
mental problems associated with contaminated sediments). Effects of waste disposal on ground-
water. Proc Exeter Symp IHAS 139:255-269
Salomons W, Hofman P, Boelens R, Mook WG (1975) The oxygen isotopic composition of the fraction
less than 2 microns (clay fraction) in recent sediments from Western Europe. Mar Geol 18:m23-
m28
Sanders JG (1978) Enrichment of estuarine phytoplankton by the addition of dissolved manganese.
Mar Environ Res 1:59-66
Sanders JG (1978) The sources of dissolved manganese to Calico Creek, North Carolina. Estuarine
Coastal Mar Sci 6:231-238
Sanders J G (1980) Arsenic cycling in marine systems. Mar Environ Res 3:257-266
Sanders JG, Windom HL (1980) The uptake and reduction of arsenic species by marine algae. Estuarine
Coastal Mar Sci 10:555-567
Santema P (1980) The pollution of the River Rhine - the perspective for improvement. In Stiff MJ (ed)
River pollution control, Horwood, Chichester
Santschi PH, Adler OM, Amdurer M (1983) The fate of particles and particle-reactive trace metals in
coastal waters: Radioisotope studies in microcosms. In: Wong CS, Boyle EA, Bruland KW, Burton
JO, Goldberg EO (eds) Proc Advanced Res Inst on "Trace metals in sea water". Erice, Sicily, Italy.
Plenum:331-350
Santschi PH (1982) Application of enclosures to the study of ocean chemistry. In: Grice GO, Reeve
MR (eds) Marine mesocosms. Biological and chemical research in experimental ecosystems.
Springer, New York Berlin Heidelberg, pp 63-80
Santschi PH, Carson S, Li YH (1982) Natural radionuclides as tracers for geochemical processes in
MERL mesocosms and Narragansett Bay. In: Grice GO (ed) Marine mesocosms. Biological and
chemical research in experimental ecosystems.
Satenner RO, Nickless G (1975) Heavy metals in organisms of the Atlantic coast of southwest Spain
and Portugal. Mar Pollut Bull 6:89-92
Savin SM, Epstein S (1970) The oxygen and hydrogen isotope geochemistry of clay minerals. Geochim
Cosmochim Acta 34: 25-42
Savin SM Epstein S (1970) The oxygen and hydrogen isotope geochemistry of ocean sediments and
shales. Geochim Cosmochim Acta 34:43-63
wim.salomons@home.nl
References 325
Saxby JD (1976) The significance of organic matter in ore genesis. In: Wolf KH (ed) Handbook of
strata-bound and stratiform ore deposits. Elsevier, Amsterdam 2: 111-133
Sayles FL, Ku TL, Bowker PC (1975) Chemistry offerromanganoan sediment of the Bauer Deep. Geol
Soc Am Bull 86:1423-1431
Sayles FL, MangelsdorfPC, Wilson TRS, Hume ON (1976) A sampler for the in situ collection of ma-
rine sedimentary pore waters. Deep-Sea Res 23:259-264
Schafer HA (1976) Characteristics of municipal wastewater discharges, 1975. South Calif Coastal Wa-
ter Res Proj EI Segundo. Ann Report: 57-60
Schafer HA, Bascom W (1976) Sludge in Santa Monica Bay. South California Coastal Water Res Proj
EISegundo. Ann Report: 77-82
Schaule BK, Patterson CC (1981) Lead concentrations in the northeast Pacific: evidence for global an-
thropogenic perturbations. Earth Planet Sci Lett 54:97-116
Schaule BK, Patterson CC (1983) Perturbations of the natural depth profile in the Sargasso Sea by in-
dustriallead. Proc NATO Adv Res Inst. Trace Metals in Seawater. Erice Italy, 1981, Plenum, NY,
pp487-504
Schell WR (1977) Concentrations, physico-chemical states and mean residence times ofPb-210 and Po-
210 in marine and estuarine waters. Geochim Cosmochim Acta 41: I 0 19-1 031
Schell WR, Nevissi A (1977) Heavy metals from waste disposal in Central Puget Sound. Environ Sci
Technolll:887-893
Schindler PW (1967) Heterogeneous equilibria involving oxides, hydroxides, carbonates and hydroxide
carbonates. In: Stumm W (ed) Equilibria concepts in natural water systems. Am Chern Soc, Adv
Chern Ser 67: 196-233
Schindler PW (1975) Removal of trace metals from the ocean, a zero order model. Thalassia Jugosl
11:101-111
Schindler PW (1981) Surface complexes at oxide-water interface. In: Anderson MA, Rubin AJ (eds)
Adsorption of inorganics at solid-liquid interfaces. Ann Arbor Sci, Ann Arbor, pp 1-49
Schindler PW, Furst B, Dick R, WolfPU (1976) Ligand properties of surface silanol groups: Surface
complex formation with Fe 3 +, Cu 2 +, Cd 2 + and Pb 2 +. J Colloid Interface Sci 55:469-475
Schleichert U (1975) Schwermetallgehalte der Schwebstoffe des Rheins bei Koblenz im Jahresablauf.
Dtsch Gewasserkd Mitt 19:150-157
Schmidt RC (1956) Adsorption of Cu, Pb and Zn on some common rock forming minerals and its ef-
fects on lake sediments. Ph 0 Thesis, Gill Univ Montreal, Quebec
Schoer J, Forstner U (1980) Die Entwicklung der Schwermetallverschmutzung im mittleren Neckar.
Dtsch Gewasserkd Mitt 24: 153-158
Schoer J, Nagel U, Eggersgluess 0, ForstnerU (1982) Metal contents in sediments from the Elbe, Weser
and Ems Estuaries and from the German Bight (southeastern North Sea): Grain size effects. Mitt
Geol-Palaont Inst Univ Hamburg, SCOPE/UNEP, Special Volume 52:687-702
Schottle M, Friedman GM (1972) Freshwater iron-manganese nodules of Lake George, New York.
Geol Soc Am Bull 82: 101-110
Schultz OJ, Calder JA (1976) Organic carbon 13Cf 12C variations in estuarine sediments. Geochim Cos-
mochim Acta 40:381-385
Schutz L, Jaenicke R, Pietrek H (1981) Saharan dust transport over the North Atlantic Ocean. Geol
Soc Am Spec Pap 186:87-100
Schwertmann U (1964) Differenzierung der Eisenoxide des Bodens durch photochemische Extraktion
mit saurer Ammoniumoxalat-Losung. Z Pflanzenemahr Dung Bodenkd 105: 194-202
Sclater FF, Boyle E, Edmond JM (1976) On the marine geochemistry of nickel. Earth Planet Sci Lett
31:119-128
Scott BC (1981) Modelling of atmospheric wet deposition. In: Eisenreich SJ (ed) Atmospheric pol-
lutants in natural waters. Ann Arbor Science, Ann Arbor
Sehmel GA (1980) Particle and gas dry deposition: a review. Atmos Environ 14:983-1011
Seibold E (1975) Der Meeresboden; Forschungsstand und Zukunftsaufgaben. Naturwissenschaften
62:321-330
Seibold E, Berger WH (1982) The sea floor - an introduction to marine geology, Springer, Berlin
Heidelberg New York, 288 pp
Settle OM, Patterson CC (1980) Lead in Albacore: Guide to lead pollution in Americans. Science
207: 1167-1176
wim.salomons@home.nl
326 References
Settle DM, Patterson CC (1982) Magnitudes and sources of precipitation and dry deposition fluxes of
industrial and natural leads to the North Pacific at Enewetak. J Geophys Res 87:8857-8869
Settle DM, Duce RA, Patterson CC (1981) Importance of transfer in the atmoshere of metal-rich sub-
micrometer particles to large particles in determining magnitudes of dry deposition fluxes of
metals. Presented at the IAMAP Third Scientific Assembly, Symposium on the Role of Oceans in
Atmospheric Chemistry, Hamburg, West Germany, August 1981
Seyfried WE, Bischoff JL (1981) Experimental seawater-basalt interactions at 300°C, 500 bars, chemi-
cal exchange, secondary mineral formation and implications for the transport of heavy metals.
Geochim Cosmochim Acta 45: 135-147
Shaw GE (1981) Eddy diffusion transport of Arctic pollution from mid-latitudes: a preliminary model.
AtmosEnviron 15:1483-1490
Shelton RGJ (1971) Sludge dumping in the Thames Estuary. Mar Pollut Bull 2:24-27
Shepard FP (1963) Submarine geology. Harper & Row, New York 557 pp
Sheppard CR, Bellamy DJ (1974) Pollution of the Mediterranean around Naples. Mar Pollut Bull
5:42-44
Shimp NF, Witters J, Potter PE, Schleicher JA (1969) Distinguishing marine and freshwater muds. J
Geol77:566-580
Sholkovitz ER (1976) Flocculation of dissolved organic and inorganic matter during the mixing of
riverwater and seawater. Geochim Cosmochim Acta 40:831-845
Sholkovitz ER (1978) The flocculation of dissolved Fe, Mn, AI, Cu, Ni, Co and Cd during estuarine
mixing. Earth Planet Sci Lett 41:77-86
Sholkovitz ER, Copland D (198Ia) The chemistry of suspended matter in Esthwaite Water, a biologi-
cally productive lake with seasonally anoxic hypolimnion. Geochim Cosmochim Acta 46:393-410
Sholkovitz ER, Copland D (198Ib) The coagulation, solubility and adsorption properties of Fe, Mn,
Cu, Ni, Cd, Co and humic acids in a river water. Geochim Cosmochim Acta 45: 181-189
Shuman LM (1979) Zinc, manganese and copper in soil fractions. Soil Sci 127: 10-17
Shuman LM (1980) Zinc in soils. In: Nriagu JO (ed) Cadmium in the environment. Wiley, New York
1:39-69
Shuman MS, Woodward Jr GP (1977) Stability constants of copper organic chelates in aquatic samples.
Environ Sci Technol II :809-813
Shuman MS, Cromer JL (1979) Copper association with aquatic fulvic and humic acid. Estimation of
conditional formation constants with a titrimetric anodic stripping voltammetry procedure. En-
viron Pollut TechnoI13:543-545
Sieburth J McN (1969) Studies on algal substances in the sea. III The production of extracellular or-
ganic matter by littoral marine algae. J Exp Mar Bioi Ecol 3:290-309
Sieburth J McN, Jensen A (1968) Studies on algal substances in the sea. I. Gelbstoff (humic material)
in terrestrial and marine waters. J Exp Mar BioI EcoI2:174-189
Siever R (1962) A squeezer for extracting interstitial water from modern sediments. J Sediment Petrol
32:329-331
Sievering H (1976) Dry deposition loading of Lake Michigan by airborne particulate matter. Water Air
Soil Pollut 5:343-351
Sievering H, Dave M, Dolske D McCoy P (1980) Trace element concentrations over midlake Michigan
as a function of meteorology and source region. Atmos Environ 14:39-53
Sievering H, Dave M, Dolske DA, McCoy P (1981) Transport and dry deposition of trace metals over
southern lake Michigan. In: Eisenreich SJ (ed) Atmospheric pollutants in natural waters. Ann Ar-
bor Sci, Ann Arbor, Mich, pp 285-325
Sigg L, Sturm M, Stumm W, Mart L, Niirnberg HW (1982) Schwermetalle im Bodensee - Mechanis-
men der Konzentrationsregulierung. Naturwissenschaften 69: 546-548
Sillanpaa M (1982) Micronutrients and the nutrient status of soils: A global study. FAO Soils Bull
48:442pp
Silvey WD (1967) Occurrence of selected minor elements in the waters of California. US Geol Surv Wa-
ter Supply Pap 1535- L: 17 pp
Simkiss K, Taylor M, Mason AZ (1982) Metal detoxification and bioaccumulation in molluscs. Mar
BioI Lett 3:187-201
Simmers JW, Folsom BL, Lee CR, Bates DJ (1981) Field survey of heavy metal uptake by naturally
occurring saltwater and freshwater marsh plants. Office, Chief of Engineers, US Army Washington
DC,64pp
wim.salomons@home.nl
References 327
Simpson WR (1981) A critical review of cadmium in the marine environment. Prog Oceanog 10: 1-70
Sims JL, Patrick WH (1978) The distribution of micronutrient cations in soil under conditions of vary-
ing redox potential and pH. Soil Sci Soc Am J 42:258-262
Singer A, Navrot J (1978) Siderite in Birket Ram Lake sediments. Abstr. 10th Int Congr on Sedimen-
tology, July 9-14, Jerusalem p 616-617
Singer PC (1977) Influence of dissolved organics on the distribution, transport, and fate of heavy metals
in aquatic systems. In: SuITet IH (ed) Fate of pollutants in the air and water environment. Wiley,
New York I: 155-182
Singer PC, Stumm W (1970) Acidic mine drainage: the rate determinating step. Science 167: I 121-1 123
Skei JM, Price NB, Calvert SE, Hogdahl E (1972) The distribution of heavy metals in sediments of
S6rfjord, West Norway. Water Air Soil Pollut 1:452-461
Slinn WGN (1977) Some approximations for the wet and dry removal of particles and gases from the
atmosphere. Water Air Soil Pollut 7:513-543
Slinn SA, Slinn WGN (1980) Predictions for particle deposition on natural water. Atmos Environ
14:1013-1016
Slinn WGN, Hasse L, Hicks BB et al. (1978) Some aspects of the transfer of atmospheric trace constit-
uents past the air sea interface. Atmos Environ 12:2055-2087
Sly P (1978) Sedimentary processes in lakes. In: Lerman A (ed) Lakes - chemistry, geology, physics.
Springer, New York Heidelberg Berlin, pp 65-89
Smies M (1983) Biological aspects of trace element speciation in the aquatic environment. In: Leppard
GG (ed) Trace element speciation in surface waters and its ecological implications. Plenum, New
York 177-193
Smirnov SS (1954) Die Oxidationszone sulfidischer Lagerstiitten. Akademie, Berlin. 312 pp.
Smith JD, Nicholson RA, Moore PJ (1973) Mercury in sediments from the Thames Estuary. Environ
Pollut 4: 153-157
Smith R (1976) Longitudal dispersion of a buoyant contaminant in a shallow channel. J Fluid Mech
68:677-688
Smith RG (1976) Evaluation of combined application of ultrafiltration and complexation capacity
techniques to natural waters. Anal Chern 48:74-76
Solberg W, Steinnes E (1983) Heavy metal contamination of terrestrial ecosystems from long-distance
atmospheric transport. In Prep
Soutar A, Crill PA (1977) Sedimentation and climatic patterns in the Santa Barbary Basin during the
19th and 20th centuries. Geol Soc Am Bull 88: I 16 I- I 172
Spencer OW, Brewer PG (1971) Vertical advection diffusion and redox potentials as controls on the
distribution of manganese and other trace metals dissolved in waters of the Black Sea. J Geophys
Res 76:5877-5892
Spencer OW, Brewer PG, Sachs PL (1972) Aspects of the distribution and trace elements composition
of suspended matter in the Black Sea. Geochim Cosmochim Acta 36:71-86
Spiess FN, MacDonald KC, Atwater T, Ballard R, Carranza A, Cordoba 0, Cox C, Diaz Garcia VM,
Francheteau J, Guerrero J, Hawkins J, Haymon R, Hessler R, Juteau T, Kastner M, Larson R,
Luydendyk B, MacDougall JD, Miller S, Normark W, Orcutt J, Rangin C (1980) East Pacific Rise:
Hot springs and geophysical experiments. Science 207: 1421-1432
Srna RF, Garret KS, Miller SM, Thurn AB (1980) Copper complexation capacity of marine water sam-
ples from Southern California. Environ Sci Technol 14: I 482- I 486
Steeman Nielsen E, Wium-Andersbn S (1971) The influence of copper on photosynthesis and growth
of diatoms. Physiol Plant 24:480-484
Steinberg C (1980) Species of dissolved metals derived from oligotrophic hard water. Water Res
12:1239-1250
Steinnes E (1980) Regional distribution of arsenic, selenium and antimony in humus layers of Norwe-
gian soils. In: Lag J (ed) Geochemical aspects in present and future research. Universitetsforlaget,
Oslo, 217-221
Steinnes E (1983) Physical separation techniques in trace element speciation studies. In: Leppard GG
(ed) Trace element speciation in surface waters and its ecological implications. Plenum, New York,
pp 37-47
Sterritt RM, Lester IN (1980) Effects of the agricultural use of sewage sludge contaminated with toxic
elements. Imperial College London 43 pp
wim.salomons@home.nl
328 References
Stevenson FJ (1977) Nature of divalent transition metal complexes of humic acids as revealed by a
modified potentiometric titration method. Soil Sci 123: 10-17
Stockner JG, Benson WW (1967) The succession of diatom assemblages in the recent sediments of Lake
Washington. Limnol Oceanogr 12:513-532
Stoffers P, Muller G (1978) Mineralogy and lithofacies of Black Sea sediments-Leg 42B Deep Sea Dril-
ling Project. In: Ross DA, Neprochnov YP, et al. (eds) Initial reports of deep sea drilling project
42(2). US Govt Printing Office, Washington DC, p 373-411
Stoffers P, Summerhayes C, Forstner U, Patchineelam SR (1977) Copper and other heavy metal con-
tamination in sediments from the New Bedford Harbour, Mass: A preliminary note. Environ Sci
Technolll:819-821
Strathmann H (1981) Membrane separation processes. J Membr Sci 9(1-2):121-189
Stumm W, Baccini P (1978) Man-made pertubation of lakes. In: Lerman A (ed) Lakes - chemistry, ge-
ology, physics. Springer, New York Berlin Heidelberg, 91-126
Stumm W, Morgan 11 (1981) Aquatic chemistry. Wiley, New York, 780 pp
Stumm W, Hohl H, Dalang F (1976) Interaction of metal ions with hydrous oxide surfaces. Croat Chern
Acta 48:491-504
Stumm W, Huang CP, Jenkins SR (1970) Specific chemical interaction affecting the stability of dis-
persed systems. Croat Chern Acta 42:223-245
Stumm W, Kummert R, Sigg L (1980) A ligand exchange model for the adsorption of inorganic and
organic ligands at hydrous oxide surfaces. Croat Chern Acta 53:291-312
Suess E, Erlenkeuser H (1975) History of metal pollution and carbon input in Baltic Sea sediments.
Meyniana (Kiel) 27:63-75
Sugai SF, Healy ML (1978) Yoltammetric studies of the organic association of copper and lead in two
Canadian inlets. Mar Chern 6:291-308
Sugawara K, Naito H, Yamada S (1956) Geochemistry of vanadium in natural waters. J Earth Sci Na-
goya Univ 4:44-61
Sugawara K, Okabe S (1960) Geochemistry of molybdenum in natural waters. J Earth Sci Nagoya Univ
8:93-107
Summers AO, Silver S (1978) Microbial transformations of metals. Ann Rev MicrobioI32:637-672
Sunda WG, Engel DW, Thuotte RM (1978) Effect of chemical speciation on toxicity of cadmium to
grass shrimp, palaemonetes, pugio: importance of free cadmium ion. Environ Sci TechnoI12:409-
413
Sunda WG, Ferguson RL (1983) Sensitivity of natural bacterial communities to additions of copper
and to cupric ion activity: a bioassay of copper complexation in seawater. In: Wong CS, Burton
JD, Boyle E, Bruland K, Goldberg ED (eds) Trace metals in seawater. Plenum, New York, pp 871-
891
Sunda WG, Gillespie PA (1979) The response ofa marine bacterium to cupric ion and its use to estimate
cupric ion activity in seawater. J Mar Res 37:761-777
Sunda WG, Guillard RRL (1976) The relationship between cupric ion activity and the toxicity of cop-
per to phytoplankton. J Mar Res 34:511-519
Sunda WG, Hanson PJ (1979) Chemical speciation of copper in river water: effect of total copper, pH,
carbonate and dissolved organic matter. In: Jenne EA (ed). Chemical modelling in aqueous sys-
tems. Chern Soc Symp Ser 93: 147-180
Sundby B, Silverberg N, Chesselet R (1981) Pathways of manganese in an open estuarine system.
Geochim Cosmochim Acta 45:293-307
Sung W, Morgan 11 (1981) Oxidative removal ofMn (II) from solution catalyzed by the y-FeOOH (lepi-
docrocite) surface. Geochim Cosmochim Acta 45:2377-2384
Symeonides C, McRae SG (1977) The assessment of plant-available cadmium in soils. J Environ Qual
6:120-123
Tada F, Suzuki S (1982) Adsorption and desorption of heavy metals in bottom mud of urban rivers.
Water Res 16:1489-1494
Tada F, Nishida H, Miyai M, Suzuki S (1983) Classification of Japanese rivers by heavy metals in bot-
tom mud. Environ GeoI4:217-222
Takijima Y, Katsumi F (1973) Cadmium contamination of soils and rice plants caused by zinc mining.
Soil Sci Plant Nutr 19:173-180
Talbot Y, Magee RJ, Hussein M (1976) Distribution of heavy metals in Port Philip Bay. Mar Pollut
Bull 7:53-55
wim.salomons@home.nl
References 329
Tan PM, Strain FC (1979) Carbon and oxygen isotope ratios in the Saguenay Fjord and the St. Law-
rence estuary and their implications for paleoenvironmental studies. Estuarine Mar Sci 8: 119-126
Tang IN, Munkelwitz HR (1977) Aerosol growth studies-III Ammonium bisulfate aerosol in a moist
atmosphere. J Aerosol Sci 8:321-330
Tardy Y (1969) Geochimie des Alterations. Etude des Arenes et des Eaux de quelques Massifs Cristal-
lins d'Europe et d'Afrique. These Doc Fac Sci, Strasb, Mem Serv Carte Geol Als Lorr 31:199 p
Taylor SR (1964) Abundance of chemical elements in the continental crust - a new table. Geochim Cos-
mochim Acta 28:1273-1285
Terzaghi K, Peck RB (1948) Soil mechanics in engineering practice. Wiley, London New York
Tessier A, Campbell PGC, Bisson M (1979) Sequential extraction procedure for the speciation of par-
ticulate trace metals. Anal Chern 51 :844-851
Tessier A, Campbell PGC, Auclair JC, Bisson M, Boucher H (1982) Evaluation del' Impact de Rejects
Miniers sur des Organismes Biologiques. Univ Quebec, Rapp Sci, INRS-Eau, 146: 237 pp
Tessier A, Campbell PGC, Bisson M (1980) Trace metal speciation in the Yamaska and St. Francois
River (Quebec). Can J Earth Sci 17:90-105
Thayer JS, Brinckman FE (1982) The biological methylation of metals and metalloids. Adv Organomet
Chern 20:313-356
Theis TL, Singer PC (1974) Complexation of iron(II) by organic matter and its effect on iron(II) ox-
ygenation. Environ Sci TechnoI8:569-572
Theis TL, Richter RO (1980) Adsorption reactions of nickel species at oxide surfaces. In: Kavanaugh
M, Leckie JO (eds) Particulates in water. Adv Chern Ser, Am Chern Soc Washington DC, 189:73-96
Thomas AJ, Martin JM (1982) Chemical composition of river suspended sediment: Yangtse, Macken-
zie, Indus, Orinoco, Parana and French Rivers (Seine, Loire, Garonne, Dordogne, Rhone). Mitt.
Geol Palaont Inst Univ Hamburg, SCOPEjUNEP Spec Vol 52:555-564
Thomas RL (1972) The distribution of mercury in the sediment of Lake Ontario. Can J Earth Sci 9:636-
651
Thomas RL (1978) Maps of the metal distribution in Great Lakes sediments. In: Int Ref Group on
Great Lakes Pollution from Land Use Activities. Environmental Management Strategy for the
Great Lakes System. Final Report to the International Joint Commission, July 1978, 115 pp
Thomas RL, Jaquet J-M, Kemp ALW, Lewis CFM (1976) Surficial sediments of Lake Erie. J Fish Res
Board Can 33:385-403
Thompson JAJ, Crerar JA (1980) Methylation oflead in marine sediments. Mar Pollut Bull 11:251-253
Thornton I (1977a) Some aspects of environmental geochemistry in Britain. In: Proc Intern ConfHeavy
Metals in the Environment, Toronto 1Ij1: 17-38
Thornton I (l977b) Biogeochemical studies on molybdenum in the United Kingdom. In: Chappell WR
Petersen KK (eds) Molybdenum in the environment. Marcel Dekker, New York 2:341-369
Thornton I, Webb JS (1973) Environmental geochemistry: Some recent studies in the United Kingdom.
In: Hemphill DD (ed) Trace substances in environmental health. Univ Missouri Press, Columbia
VII:89-98
Thornton I, Watling H, Darracott A (1975) Geochemical studies in several rivers and estuaries for oys-
ter rearing. Sci Total Environ 4:325-345
Tipping E (1981) The adsorption of aquatic humic substances by iron hydroxides. Geochim Cos-
mochim Acta 45: 191-199
Tipping E, Woof C, Cooke D (1981) Iron oxide from a seasonally anoxic lake. Geochim Cosmochim
Acta45:1411-1419
Tobschall HJ, Gopel C, Rast U (1978) Geochemistry of organic gels and organic sediments from se-
lected lakes of northern Norway. Abstr 10th Int Congress on Sedimentology, Jerusalem, pp 682-
683
Tomlinson DL, Wilson JG, Harris CR, Jeffrey DW (1980) Problems in the assessment of heavy-metal
levels in estuaries and the formation ofa pollution index. Helgol Meeresunters 33:566-575
Trefry JH, Presley BJ (1976) Heavy metal transport from the Mississippi River to the Gulf of Mexico.
In: Windom HL, Duce RA (eds) Marine pollution transfer. Heath & Co Lexington: 39-76
Trent JD, Shanks AL, Silver MW (1978) In situ and laboratory measurements on macroscopic aggre-
gates in Monterrey Bay. Limnol Oceanogr 23:625-635
Troup BN, Bricker OP, Bray JT (1974) Oxidation effect on the analysis of iron in the interstitial water
of recent anoxic sediments. Nature 249:237-239
wim.salomons@home.nl
330 References
Troup BN, Bricker OP (1975) Processes affecting the transport of materials from continents to oceans.
In: Church TM (ed) Marine chemistry in the coastal environment. ACS Symp Ser 18: 135-151
Truitt RE, Weber JH (1981) Determination of complexing capacity of fulvic acid for copper(II) and
cadmium(II) by dialysis titration. Anal Chern 53:337-342
Tsonugai S, Y onemaru I, Kusakabe M (1979) Post depositional migration of Cu, Zn, Ni, Co, Pb and
Ba in deep sea sediments. Geochem J 13:239-252
Turekian KK (1967) Estimates of the average Pacific deep-sea clay accumulation rate from material
balance calculations. In: Sears M (ed) Prog Oceanog. Pergamon, Oxford 4:227-244
Turekian KK (1971) Rivers tributaries and estuaries. In: Hood OW (ed) Impingment of man on the
oceans. Wiley, London New York, 9-73
Turekian KK (1977) The fate of metals in the oceans. Geochim Cosmochim Acta 41: 1139-1144
Turekian KK, Kleinkopf MD (1956) Estimates of the average abundances of Cu, Mn, Pb, Ti, Ni, and
Cr in surface waters. Maine Bull Geol Soc Am 67:1129-1132
Turekian KK, Wedepohl KH (1961) Distribution of the elements in some major units of the earth's
crust. Bull Geol Soc Am 72:175-192
Turekian KK, Harriss RC, Johnson DG (1967) The variations of Si, Na, Ca, Sr, Ba, Co, and Ag in
the Neuse River, North Carolina. Limnol Oceanogr 12:702-706
Turekian KK, Nozaki Y, Benninger LK (1977) Geochemistry of atmospheric radon and radon prod-
ucts. Ann Rev Earth Planet Sci 5:227-254
Turner DR, Whitfield M (1980) Chemical definition of the biological available fraction of trace metals
in natural waters. Thalassia Jugosl 16:231-241
Turner DR, Dickson AG, Whitfield M (1980) Water-rock partition coefficients and the composition
of natural waters-reassessment. Mar Chern 9:211-218
Turner DR, Whitfield M, Dickson AG (1981) The equilibrium speciation of dissolved components in
freshwater and sea water at 25°C and I atm. pressure. Geochim Cosmochim Acta 45:855-881
Tuschall Jr JR, Brezonik PL (1980) Characterization of organic nitrogen in natural waters: its molec-
ular size, protein content and interaction with heavy metals. Limnol Oceanogr 25:495-504
Tuschall JR, Brezonik PL (1981) Evaluation of the copper anodic stripping voitammetry complexomet-
ric titration for complexing capacities and conditional stability constants. Anal Chern 53: 1986-1989
Udodov PA, Parilov YUS (1961) Certain regularities of migration of metals in natural waters. Geo-
chemistry 8:763-769
Ure AM, Berrow ML (1982) The chemical constituents of soils. In: Bowen HJM (ed) Environmental
Chemistry. R Soc Chern, Burlington House, London 2:94-202
US Environmental Protection Agency (1977) cit Goldberg (1979)
Vale C, Sundby B, Lebel J, Silverberg N (1982) Release and uptake of copper and zinc at the sediment-
water interface. Abstr submitted to joint oceanographic assembly
Vernet JP, Thomas RL (1972) Levels of mercury in the sediments of some Swiss lakes including Lake
Geneva and the Rhone River. Eclogae Geol Helv 65/2:293-306
Vernet JP (1976) Etude de la Pollution des Sediments du Leman et du Bassin du Rhone. Comm Inter
pour la Protection des Eaux du Lac Leman contre la Pollution. Geneva. 247-321
Vinogradov AP (1959) Geochemistry ofrare and dispersed elements in soils. Chapman and Hall, Lon-
don
Viets FG, Lindsay WL (1973) Testing soils for zinc, copper, manganese, and iron. In: Welsh LM,
Beaton JD (eds) Soil testing and plant analysis. Soil Sci Soc Am Madison, Wisc: 153-200
Voegeli PT, King RU (1968) Occurrence and distribution of molybdenum in the surface water of Col-
orado. US Geol Surv Water-Supply Pap 1535-N
Volkov II, Fomina LS (1974) Influence of organic material and processes of sulfide formation on dis-
tribution of some trace elements in deepwater sediments of Black Sea. In: Degens ET, Ross RA
(eds) Am Assoc Petrol Geol Mem 20:456-476
Wallace GT, Duce RA (1975) Concentration of particulate trace metals and particulate organic carbon
in marine waters by a bubble flotation mechanism. Mar Chern 3: 157-181
Wallace GT, Duce RA (1978) Open ocean transport of particulate trace metals by bubbles. Deep-Sea
Res 25:827-835
Wallace GT, Hoffmann GL, Duce RA (1977) The influence of organic matter and atmospheric depo-
sition on the particulate trace metal concentrations of northwest Atlantic surface seawater. Mar
Chern 5:143-170
Walsh PR, Duce RA, Fasching JL (1979) Considerations of the enrichment, sources and flux of arsenic
in the troposphere. J Geophys Res 84: 1719-1726
wim.salomons@home.nl
References 331
Walters LJ jr, Wolery TJ, Myser RD (1974) Occurrence of As, Cd, Co, Cr, Cu, Fe, Hg, Ni, Sb and
Zn in Lake Erie sediments. Proc 17th ConfGreat Lakes Res 219-234
Waslenchuk DG, Windom HL (1978) Factors controlling the estuarine chemistry of arsenic. Estuarine
Coastal Mar Sci 7:455-464
Waslenchuk DG (1978) Budget and geochemistry of arsenic in a continental shelf environment. Mar
Chern 7:39-52
Webber MD, Comeau DGM (1977) Metal extractability from sludge-soil mixtures. Proc Int Conf
Heavy Metals in the Environment, Toronto, 1975,1:205-225
Wedepohl KH (1960) Spurenanalytische Untersuchungen an Tiefseetonen aus dem Atlantik. Geochim
Cosmochim Acta 18:200-231
Wedepohl KH (1967) Geochemie. Samml Giischen, de Gruyter, Berlin
Wedepohl KH (1968) In: Ahrens LH (ed) Origin and distribution of the elements. Pergamon, Oxford,
999
Wedepohl KH (ed) (1969,1972,1974,1978) Handbook of Geochemistry. Springer, Berlin Heidelberg
New York
Weichart G (1973) Pollution of the North Sea. Ambio II :99-106
Weijden CH van der, Arnoldus MJHL, Meurs, CJ (1977) Desorption of metals from suspended mate-
rial in the Rhine estuary. Neth J Sea Res II: 130-145
Weiler RR, Chawla VK (1969) Dissolved mineral quality of Great Lakes waters. Proc 12th ConfGreat
Lakes Res: 801-818
Weisel CP (1981) The atmospheric flux of elements from the ocean. Ph D diss, Univ Rhode Island
Weiss HV, Herron MM, Langway CC jr (1978) Natural enrichment of elements in snow. Nature
274:352-353
Weissberg BG, Zobel MG (1973) Geothermal mercury pollution in New Zealand. Bull Environ Con tam
ToxicoI9:148-155
Westall J, Hohl H (1980) A comparison of electrostatic models for the oxide/solution interface. Adv
Colloid Interface Sci 12:265-294
Whitby KT (1977) The physical characteristics of sulfur aerosols. Atmos Environ 12: 135-159
White DE, Hem JD, Waring GA (1963) Chemical composition of surface waters. In: Fleischer M (ed)
Data of geochemistry. US Geol Surv Prof Pap 440-F: 25 pp
Whitehouse UG, Jeffrey LM, Debrecht JD (1958-1960) Differential settling tendencies of clay minerals
in saline waters. 7th Nat Congr on Clays Clay Miner, London
Whitfield M (1975) The electro analytical chemistry of sea water. In: Riley JP, Skirrow G (eds) Chemical
Oceanography. Academic Press London New York, 1-154
Whitfield M (1982) The salt sea - accident or design? New Sci 94: 14-17
Whitfield M (1979) The mean oceanic residence time (MORT) concept - A rationalisation. Mar Chern
8:101-123
Whitfield M (1981) The world ocean. Mechanisms or machination. Interdis Sci Rev 6: 12-35
Whitfield M, Turner DR (1982) Ultimate removal mechanisms of elements from the ocean - a com-
ment. Geochim Cosmochim Acta 46: 1989-1992
Whitfield M, Turner DR (1979) Water-rock partition coefficients and the composition of seawater and
river water. Nature 278: 132-137
Wilber WG, Hunter JV (1979) The impact of urbanization on distribution of heavy metals in bottom
sediments of the Saddle River. Water Resour Bull 15:790-800
Willis JP, Ahrens LH (1962) Some investigations on the composition of manganese nodules, with par-
ticular reference to certain elements. Geochim Cosmochim Acta 26:751-764
Winchester JW, Nifong GD (1971) Water pollution in Lake Michigan by trace elements from pollution
aerosol fallout. Water Air Soil Pollut 1:50-64
Winchester JW, Duce RA (1977) The air-water interface: Particulate matter exchange across the air-
water interface. In: Suffet IH (ed) Fate of pollutants in the air and water environment. Wiley, New
York
Windom HL (\976) Lithogenous material in marine sediments. In: Riley JP, Chester R (eds) Chemical
Oceanography. Academic Press, London New York San Francisco 5: I 03-135
Windom HL (\ 981) Comparison of atmospheric and riverine transport of trace elements to the con-
tinental shelf environment. In: Martin JM, Burton JD, Eisma D (eds) River inputs to ocean sys-
tems. Proc UN Rev Workshop Rome: 360-370
Windom HL, Gardner WS, Dunstan WM, Paffenhofer GA (1976) Cadmium and mercury transfer in
a coastal marine ecosystem. Mar Pollut Transfer, Lexington Books: 135-157
wim.salomons@home.nl
332 References
Windom H, Wallace G, Smith R, Dudek N, Maeda M, Dulmage R, Storti F (1983) Behavior of copper
in southeastern Unites States estuaries. Mar Chern 12: 183-193
Wisniewski J (1982) The potential acidity associated with dews, frosts, and fogs. Water Air Soil Pollut
17:361-377
Wittmann GTW, Forstner U (1976) Metal enrichment of sediments in inland waters - the Jukskei and
Hennops River drainage systems. Water 2:67-72
Wolfe DA (1975) The estuarine ecosystems at Beaufort, North Carolina. In: Cronin LE (ed) Estuarine
Research. Academic Press, New York San Francisco London 1:645-671
Wolff WJ (1980) Biotic aspects of the chemistry of estuaries. In: Olausson E, Cato I (eds) Chemistry
and Biogeochemistry of Estuaries. Wiley, Chichester/England 8:293-295
Wollast R, Peters JJ (1978) Biogeochemical properties of an estuarine system: the River Scheidt. In:
Biogeochemistry of estuarine sediments. Unesco 279-293
Wollast R, Billen G, Duinker JC (1979) Behaviour of manganese in the Rhine and Scheidt Estuaries.
I. Physico-chemical behaviour. Estuarine Coastal Mar Sci 9: 161-169
Wong PTS, Chau YK, Luxon PL (1978) Toxicity of a mixture of metals on freshwater algae. J Fish
Res Board Can 35:479-481
Wood JM (1972) A progress report on mercury. Environment 14:33-39
Wood JM (1974) Biological cycles for toxic elements in the environment. Science 15: I 049-1052
Woodcock et al. AH (1953) Giant condensation nuclei from bursting bubbles. Nature 172: 1144
Wu J (1981) Evidence of sea spray produced by bursting bubbles. Science 212:324-326
Wu J (1981) Bubble populations and spectra in the near surface ocean: summary and review of field
measurement. J Geophys Res 86:457-463
Yeats PA, Bewers JM (1982a) Anthropogenic influences on trace metal distributions in the North At-
lantic. Presented at Ocean Pollution Conf 1981 Halifax Novae Scotia, 25 pp
Yeats PA, Bewers JM (1982b) Discharge of metals from the St. Lawrence River. Can J Earth Sci 19:982-
992
Yeats PA, Bewers JM, Walton A (1978) Sensitivity of coastal waters to anthropogenic trace metal emis-
sions. Mar Pollut Bull 9:264-268
Yeats PA, Sundby B, Bewers JM (1979) Manganese recycling in coastal waters. Mar Chern 8:43-55
Yoshioka K (1964) Epidemiological study on relationship between Itai-itai disease and mining
nuisance. Yamaguchi Med J 13:146-170
Young JS, Gurtisen JM, Apts CW, Crecelius EA (1979) The relationship between the copper complex-
ing capacity of sea water and copper toxicity in shrimp zoeae. Mar Environ Res 265-272
Zimmerman CF, Price MT, Montgomery JR (1978) A comparison of ceramic and teflon in situ sam-
plers for nutrient pore water determinations. Estuarine Coastal Mar Sci 7:93-97
Zoller WH, Gordon GE, Gladney ES, Jones AG (1973) The sources and distribution of vanadium in
the atmosphere. In: Trace elements in the environment. Adv Chern Ser 123:31-47
Ziillig H (1956) Sedimente als Ausdruck des Zustandes eines Gewassers. Schweiz Z Hydrol 18: 7-143
wim.salomons@home.nl
Subject Index
wim.salomons@home.nl
334 Subject Index
wim.salomons@home.nl
Subject Index 335
wim.salomons@home.nl
336 Subject Index
wim.salomons@home.nl
Subject Index 337
wim.salomons@home.nl
338 Subject Index
wim.salomons@home.nl
Subject Index 339
wim.salomons@home.nl
340 Subject Index
Iron Lagoon 66
estuarine mlXlng 220 ff., 226, 228, 23 I f., 234 Lake Alpnach (Switzerland) 23 f., 196
fluxes (IJsselmeer) 194 f. Lake Baldegg (Switzerland) 20 I
forest ecosystem 121 f. Lake Bonneville (Nevada) 180
grain size effect 166 f. Lake Erie 71 f., 73, 185 f., 187 f., 189
half removal time 239 f. Lake Geneva 38, 218 f., 240, 254 f.
humic acids 37 Lake Huron 71 f., 189
lacustrine nodules 184 LakeMichigan 71f.,93, 159, 160, 167, 184,
lake water 201 f. 230f.
marine sediment 273 f. Lake Oneida 184
minerals 143 Lake Ontario 24,71 f., 184, 189
organic complex 93 f. Lake Ramsey (Ontario) 208 f.
oxidized layer 97 Lake Superior 71 f.
particulate concentrations 139 f. Lake Wavy (Ontario) 208f.
particulate/dissolved fluxes 140 Lake Windermere (U.K.) 189
pore water 89 f., 95 f., 193 f., 276 f. Lake Zurich (Switzerland) 78
ratio to aluminium 227 Lakes
redox processes 86 atmospheric input 203 ff.
reference element 73 f. current 179
retention in coastal zone 256 f. grain size effects 182
river particulates 162 size 179
river water 160 systems 179 f.
sea surface micro layer 133 f. temperal variation 179 f., 196f.
sediments 72,73, 149 vertical flux 198
background 77 f. Langtjern (Norway) 208 f.
enrichment 80, 93 f. Lead
soil 149f. adsorption experiments 28 ff.
solid speciation 49 f. quartz 26
solubility product 145 f. algae 192
speciation in river sediment 169 f. Atlantic Ocean profile 264
technologic migration 79 f. atmospheric emission 101 f.
urban/remote air I 14 f. atmospheric input 99 f., 103, 118 f., 198,
waste material 72 203 f., 263 f.
weathering 144ff. atmospheric particles 107 f.
Iron oxyhydrate automotive emission 100 f., 117
adsorption edges 28 coastal flux 242 f.
chemical extraction 45 f., 49 ff. dissolved species 16 f.
coatings 43 dry deposition 136 f.
concretions 181 f., 183,235,273 f. Eniwetok atmosphere 136 f.
core profiles 89 ff. enrichment in nodules 279 f.
forms 36f.,48 enrichment phases 49
grain size distribution 69 f. estuarine mixing 225 f., 231
kinetics of transformation 90 f. fluxes, estuary 255
precipitation type 6 lake sediment 187 f.
sorption in seawater 32 forest ecosystem 121 f.
Iron phosphate 216 half removal time 239f.
Irrigation 68 history IOOf.
Isotopic composition 225 humate complexes 152
Isotopic measurements 79 hydroxy carbonate 14
Itai-itai disease 156 f. index of geoaccumulation 170 f.
Jinzu River (Japan) 156 f. input North Sea 248 f.
Jungfrau Mount (Switzerland) 113 f. lake sediment 190
lake water 206
Kansas River 159 lambs liver 124
Kaolinite 147 marine aerosol 135 ff.
Kinetic fractionation 17 methylation 60 ff.
Klebsiella aerogennes (bacteria) 61 minerals 142 ff.
wim.salomons@home.nl
Subject Index 341
wim.salomons@home.nl
342 Subject Index
wim.salomons@home.nl
Subject Index 343
wim.salomons@home.nl
344 Subject Index
wim.salomons@home.nl
SUbject Index 345
wim.salomons@home.nl
346 Subject Index
Redox potential, manganese release 211 Scheidt River estuary 168 f., 218 f., 226,229,
processes 86 ff. 248 f., 252, 254 f.
Redox titration 90 Scrobicularia plana (bivalve) 54,251 f.
Reducible phases 49 ff. Sea surface micro layer 132 ff.
Residence time Searles Lake (California) 180
estuary 212 f., 254 Seasaltspray 99, 103 f., 13 If.
ocean 258 ff., 265 f., 267 f.
soil 152 Seasonal effets
Residual fraction 49 f. estuary 216f.
river transport 138
Resiliency 240
Reverse-phase liquid chromatography 13 Seaweed 251
Reverse weathering 146 f. Sediment
Rhine River 20,69 f., 157 f., 160 f., 163, 168 f., accumulation (estuary) 215
170ff.,179,216f.,246,255 background 76 ff., 82
Rhine River estuary 218f., 223 f., 226 chemical phases 46 ff.
Rhizome 57 compaction 65
Rhodochrosite (Mn-carbonate) 87 ff., 92 ff., 183 composition 63 ff.
Rhone River (France) 40 f., 245 f. concentration factor 83
Rio Grande 167 core profile 73 f., 77, 78 ff., 88 f., 165,209,
Rio de la Plata 218 f. 244,247
River discharge 138 dating 79,102
River pollution 170 ff. distribution 67 ff.
River Qishon (Israel) 246 dynamics 65
Rotterdam Harbour 157 f., 170 f., 173,220,249, early diagenesis 85 ff.
255 effect of NT A 177 f.
Rubidium enrichment (deep-sea) 274 ff.
atmosphere 136 f. environmental impact 79 ff.
minerals 142f. environments 86 f.
reference element 73 f. fluxes in lakes 180
rocks 141 f. grain size 69 ff.
Ruhr River (W.-Germany) 81,171, 174ff., hydraulic conditions 66 f.
177f. marin nearshore 272 f.
mobile fraction 72 f.
oceanic 269 ff.
SaaleRiver(GDR) 159 organic matter 64 f.
Saanich Inlet (B.C.) 22 f., 95 f. pH 204
Saddle River (N. Y.) 166 f. pore waters 85 ff.
Sahara dust 131 release 223
Salicornia 253 residence time 259 f.
Salicylic acid 36 f. transport 65 ff., 173
Salinity 219 f. uptake of metal 234
gradient Black Sea 199 ff.
Sedimentary rocks 148 ff.
metal uptake 57
Sedimentation rate 2,185,272
reference element 73 f.
Segregation 219
sorption 38 f.
Selectivity 20
Sampling 12,165,261 Selenium
San Francisco Bay 38,41,55 f., 229 f. atmospheric emission 101 f.
Sand filter 49 atmospheric particles 108 f.
Sargasso Sea 23 half removal time 239 f.
Saronikos Gulf (Greece) 245f. minerals 143
Savannah River estuary 224,230 organic material 152
Scandium precipitation type 6
Eniwetok atmosphere 136 f. residence time in soil 152
reference element 73 f. sediment 149
sediment 149 soil 149 f.
soil 149 f. urban/remote air 114 f.
urban, remote air 114f. Sepiolite 219
wim.salomons@home.nl
Subject Index 347
wim.salomons@home.nl
348 Subject Index
wim.salomons@home.nl
Subject Index 349
wim.salomons@home.nl
U. Forstner, G. T. W. Wittmann
" ... the authors present what is probably the first successful
compilation on a world-wide basis, including a critical
inventory and evaluation of the prevailing investigations in
water, sediments and organisms ....
Springer-Verlag The book contains an extensive list of references (ca. 2000),
is well written in a lively and critical style ....
Berlin ... the book is more than a necessary inventory; it should
Heidelbeg stimulate further research and be helpful in solving prob-
New York lems. I highly recommend this book to everyone involved in
aquatic trace metal research, whether biologist, chemist or
Tokyo geologist." Marine Chemistry
wim.salomons@home.nl
S.A.Gerlach
Marine Pollution
Diagnosis and Therapy
wim.salomons@home.nl