Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Debate Essays Speech Discussiion Topics
Debate Essays Speech Discussiion Topics
Copyright, Board of Regents of the University System of Georgia, Atlanta, Georgia, 30334,© 1990. All
rights reserved.
Discuss the influence that advertising If you were asked to make a fair evaluation of
has had on your life or the lives of your your teachers, what criteria or standards would
friends. you use for the evaluation? Discuss.
What influence should students have in
Has college made you less sure about what is
the determination of college policies?
right and what is wrong? Discuss.
Explain.
How has your attitude toward your
If your doctor told you that you had only a few
home (either town or family) changed
months to live, how would you alter your way
between the time you entered college
of life? Discuss.
and now? Discuss.
Name someone you consider to be a
Do college students benefit from participation
modern hero or heroine and explain
in extracurricular activities? Explain.
why you so classify the person.
Is too much emphasis placed on grades Each year, many teen-agers run away from
in our educational system? Explain. home. What do you think are the chief causes?
Should every able-bodied citizen be required to
Explain why you would or would not serve for a certain period of time in some
want to live in a large city. branch of the military service? Why or why
not?
What do you believe are the chief
How does your public image differ from your
reasons for students' academic failure in
private self?
college? Explain.
Name two or three characteristics which you
How has the automobile been harmful feel a person must possess to be considered
to our society? Explain. "educated," and explain why you consider these
traits essential.
If you were an employer, under what
Should sex education be taught in public
circumstances would you fire an
schools? Why or why not?
employee? Explain.
"Television has made America a nation
What are the essential characteristics of an
of watchers, not doers." Agree or
effective leader? Discuss.
disagree.
Do you think that sports help develop "Treat people as if they were what they ought to
be and you help them to become what they are
good character? Discuss. capable of being." Do you think that this is an
effective practice? Discuss.
Explain the chief reasons why students Should the United States pass gun control laws?
drop out of high school. Discuss.
Should the 55 mph speed limit be Should Georgia legalize gambling to raise more
retained? Explain. revenue? Discuss.
Should Georgia's sales tax be removed
Is romantic love a good basis for marriage?
from groceries and other necessities?
Discuss.
Discuss.
Do you think that you receive your money's
Should children be disciplined by
worth for your student activity fees? Why or
physical punishment? Discuss.
why not?
Discuss one cause for which you would Are spectator sports overemphasized in this
be willing to risk your life. country today? Discuss.
Is college a good place to find out who Discuss the most important characteristics an
you really are? Discuss. elected official should have.
Which of the college courses that you have had
Do you long for the past or look eagerly
do you consider to be the most beneficial?
toward the future? Explain.
Why?
Has credit buying affected your way of What changes would occur in your way of life if
life? Explain. you were forced to live in a cash economy?
If, in your judgment, the leaders of this country
Was giving eighteen-year-olds the right
are clearly wrong in adopting a particular
to vote a mistake? Discuss.
policy, what should you do? Explain.
If you could have a conversation with a
Discuss some practical ways in which each of
famous person (living or dead), whom
us can help to conserve natural resources.
would you choose and why?
Do you believe that violence in television
What steps need to be taken in order to
programs leads to violence in our society?
reduce crime? Explain.
Explain.
Explain your reasons for admiring a How has the women's liberation movement
particular high school or college affected relationships between men and
teacher. women? Discuss.
Which do you think has a greater effect
on a person -- heredity or environment? Explain why you do or do not vote.
Explain.
Discuss what could be done to increase In your opinion, what invention or discovery
has brought about the most far-reaching and
the public's respect for police officers.
lasting changes in our civilization? Explain.
Should government-owned wilderness
Should every college student be required to
areas be preserved? Discuss why or
study history? Explain why or why not.
why not.
Is it beneficial for a high school
graduate to work full-time for a year Should the government subsidize our Olympic
before entering college? Why or why teams? Why or why not?
not?
If you had the power to change any
event in history (outcome of an What characteristics do you regard as important
election, who won a war, etc.), which in a person you would choose as a friend?
would you choose to change, and why?
Should both parents assume equal
What vice or weakness do you find most
responsibility in child rearing? Explain
offensive? Explain.
why or why not.
How great a role do you think
"knowing the right people" plays in What are the essential characteristics of a good
getting ahead in school or in work? parent? Discuss.
Explain.
"American family life would be more stable if
Should court proceedings be televised?
parents, not couples involved, arranged
Explain why or why not?
marriages." Agree or disagree.
Students at public colleges currently
pay, through tuition and fees, about
one-fourth of the cost of their
Is there any job that you would absolutely
education; however, some people say
refuse to take? Explain.
students should pay a greater share of
the cost. Argue for or against this
proposal.
Should government employees such as
What advice would you give to an entering
police officers and fire fighters have the
freshman? Discuss.
right to strike? Discuss.
Should prostitution be legalized? Which courses that you did not take in high
Discuss. school do you now wish you had taken? Why?
Research indicates that you and your
friends are likely to have fewer children
What makes one college course more enjoyable
than your parents and grandparents.
than another? Explain.
What do you think are reasons for this?
Explain.
"Professional athletes and entertainers are
Should smoking in public places be
among the highest paid people in this country --
illegal? Explain why or why not.
and justifiably so." Agree or disagree.
What are the characteristics of a good Should college students have complete freedom
college student? Explain. to choose their own courses? Discuss.
If you were to be deprived of one of
your five senses (sight, touch, smell, Would you prefer to rear a family in the city or
taste, and hearing) which one would the country? Explain why.
you most hate to give up? Explain.
In general, do movies and/or television How should public high schools deal with
provide a realistic picture of life in students considered to be constant
Ameri- ca? Explain. troublemakers? Discuss.
Some states now permit single men and women
Should the military draft be reinstated?
to adopt children. Do you favor such a policy?
Discuss.
Explain why or why not.
For what qualities or achievements would you
Should college students be required to
feel justified in calling an individual successful?
attend classes? Discuss.
Explain.
Recent elections have been
characterized by small turnouts of
eligible voters. Some democracies --
Discuss some of the status symbols of today's
Australia, for example -- require their
society.
citizens to vote. Explain why such a
policy should or should not be adopted
in the United States.
Various commentators have suggested
that no person should serve more than
Should people on welfare be forced to work?
twelve years in either the U.S. Senate
Explain why or why not.
or the U.S. House of Representatives.
Discuss.
Why do you believe radio has Should all college courses be specifically
continued to be popular in the age of related to one's future occupation? Explain why
television? Discuss. or why not.
Many families today are growing home
Is there too much government
vegetable gardens. Discuss some reasons for
regulation in our lives? Explain.
this.
How can a course in government,
To what do you attribute the recent decline in
political science, or civics help students
literacy? Discuss.
to become better citizens? Explain.
What do you think are the major causes Choose a profession whose members make a
worthwhile contribution to society and discuss
of divorce? Explain. the benefits that society receives from members
of this profession.
Discuss ways to increase the public's What, in your opinion, are some of the reasons
respect for elected officials. so many people have pets? Discuss.
Apart from chronological age, what are
Do you prefer shopping at a large shop- ping
some major differences between an
center or at downtown stores? Discuss.
adolescent and an adult? Explain.
It is only recently that doctors and lawyers have
Should women in the military services
begun to advertise. Attack or defend this
be assigned combat duties? Discuss.
practice.
"The current generation is lazy and
Discuss what you like or do not like about the
lacks discipline." Defend or attack this
South.
state- ment.
Does our society allow women to assume
What do you think would be the conse-
masculine roles more readily than it allows
quences of the legalization of
males to assume roles traditionally called
marijuana? Explain.
feminine? Discuss.
If you were made the programming
direc- tor of a major television network, If you could live in some other historical period,
what changes in the programming which would you choose, and why?
would you make? Explain.
Should fathers be given the same We now have more people over 65 than at any
chance as mothers to gain custody of other time. What are the major effects of this
their minor children? Discuss. increased proportion of older people? Discuss.
Should victims of crime be Do you function best in the morning, afternoon,
compensated? Explain. or evening? Explain.
It has been proposed that American presidents
What do you think are the major effects be elected for one six-year term and not be
of divorce upon children? Discuss. eligible for reelection. Do you agree with this
proposal? Discuss.
Why did you choose the career for Do you favor increased spending for national
which you are preparing? defense? Why or why not?
Should the United States severely "In spite of advances in scientific knowl- edge,
restrict the import of foreign cars for people are still superstitious." Agree or
sale in the United States? Discuss. disagree.
Watching the "soaps" has become an American
Should cheating be grounds for
pastime. Why are these tele- vision shows so
dismissal from college? Discuss.
popular?
Which is most useful to a college In the United States, as a rule, are the
student -- a pick-up truck, a car, or a punishments imposed appropriate to the crimes
bicycle? Explain. committed? Explain.
Why do some couples choose to live
Would you like to be a candidate for public
together without getting married?
office? Why or why not?
Explain.
Do college students benefit from
If music reflects the mood of an age, what does
having to earn at least part of their
current music say about America? Explain.
tuition? Discuss.
Are Americans too dependent on the What are the characteristics of an effective
automobile? Discuss. television newscaster? Explain.
Why are so many people over the age
Discuss changes which would make the public
of twenty-one enrolling in college?
less hesitant to report crime.
Discuss.v
"Human rights" is a term frequently used but
Do Americans seem unable to relax in
seldom defined. What rights should belong to
their leisure time? Discuss.
every human being? Discuss.
Should American students be required Do you or your family support public television
to learn a second language? Why or (the educational channels) either as viewers or
why not? contributors? Why or why not?
Are elementary and high schools
How do you account for the popularity of horror
adequately meeting the needs of their
films? Discuss.
students? Discuss.
In what ways has the availability of fast Robert Frost said, "We come to college to get
food restaurants affected your eating over our littlemindedness." Discuss in relation
habits? to your own experiences.
Because of the high cost of gasoline,
many people are using transportation
What do you hope to accomplish within the
other than the automobile. In your
next ten years? Explain.
opinion, what other types of
transportation are most feasible?
Should college students be required to It has been said that "Evil, like good, has its
take physical education courses? Why own heroes." Name some characters that you
or why not? consider to be "evil heroes." Explain.
If you could ban anything in the world, Should prison inmates be allowed to take
what would it be and why? college courses? Explain why or why not.
Do you think that you have the If you were awarded an expense paid trip to any
qualifica- tions of a good parent? one place in the world, where would you go?
Discuss. Why?
If you were guaranteed a steadily improving
What do you consider the most standard of living (in terms of buying power,
important event of the past decade? free time, quality of goods and services, etc.),
Why? would you be willing to give up your right to
vote? Explain.
Jogging has become extremely popular
Is it possible for anger ever to be bene- ficial?
in the last few years. Explain why you
Explain.
jog or why you don't.
How can the individual citizen reduce
What are the most important skills and/or values
the probability of his or her home's
that children learn from their parents? Explain.
being burglarized? Explain.
We often hear education attacked or defended
Is it better for a political leader to be
on the basis of its utility. Define and explain
feared instead of loved? Why or why
what you mean by "useful" or "useless" when
not?
you apply those terms to academic work.
What specific sacrifice or sacrifices Most people consider themselves part of a
would you endure as a partial solution particular generation. Discuss what you
to our country's economic problem? consider the most important values of your
Discuss. generation.
Should a graduating college senior be
required to pass a comprehensive Is an academically competitive atmosphere
examination in his or her major before helpful or harmful to you as a student? Discuss.
receiving a degree? Why or why not?
Should the government do more to
"Manners belong to a bygone age; they are no
discourage cigarette smoking? Why or
longer relevant." Attack, defend, or modify.
why not?
At a scientific conference, Russia's chief space
scientist, Leonid I. Sedov, taunted a U.S.
In your view, what would most impress
colleague: "You Americans have a better
(favorably or unfavorably) a foreign
standard of living than we have. But the
student spending his or her first
American loves his car, his refrigerator, his
weekend in an American home?
house. He does not, as we Russians do, love his
Discuss.
country." If you had to answer Mr. Sedov, what
would be your reply?
Do competitions like the Miss America Discuss the advantages and/or dis- advantages
Pageant exploit women? Discuss. of nuclear power as a source of energy.
In what areas should all college
Is marriage an outmoded institution in the
graduates be required to have some
United States? Explain why or why not.
competence? Why?
Is athletic competition good for Many American homes and offices have
become a jungle of houseplants. Why do you
children under twelve years old?
think that so many people surround themselves
Explain why or why not.
with growing things?
If you could make one scientific Given all the evidence that cigarette smoking is
discovery in your lifetime, what would harmful, why do people con- tinue to smoke
it be? Why? cigarettes? Discuss.
If the average life span were increased
What would cause you to end a friendship?
to 150 years, what major changes in
Explain.
society would you expect? Discuss.
When we return to places we knew as
children, we are often surprised at how
different these places seem. Compare
Do you believe that banning certain books from
and/or contrast your impression of
public and school libraries is justified? Discuss.
some place you knew as a child with
your current impression of the same
place.
Can you tell something about a person
Do high schools put too much emphasis on
from the way she or he dresses?
athletics? Discuss.
Explain.
What would you place in a time-
capsule to allow people opening the "Self-discipline is the most important ingredient
capsule 1,000 years from now to for success." Attack or defend.
understand life in the 1980's? Explain.
Does our public educational system promote
Describe a model physical fitness plan.
mediocrity? Discuss.
Is it harmful for children to be in day-
Should the custom of tipping be abolished?
care centers all day? Explain why or
Explain why or why not.
why not.
"In the United States, we waste a great Beauty contests, despite some criticism, are still
natural resource: the elderly." Agree or very popular. In your opinion, what are the
disagree. chief reasons for their popularity? Explain.
What are the chief causes of shoplifting?
Is war sometimes justifiable? Explain.
Discuss.
Overcrowded prisons are one of the major
Should the death penalty be abolished?
problems facing Georgia. What might be done
Discuss.
to ease this problem?
What can be done to prevent violence Should law enforcement agencies be permitted
and crime in public schools? Discuss. to tap telephone lines? Explain.
Should public agencies be required to If you could pass one law, what would it be?
inform parents if their minor children
(those under 17) seek birth control? Why?
Discuss.
What do you consider to be your duties Should national and state governments set aside
as an American citizen? Discuss. land for parks? Discuss.
Do you believe that it is the
responsibility of the young to provide Why are many people afraid of growing old?
financial security for the aged? Why or Discuss.
why not?
The changes brought on by the women's
What can parents do to prepare their liberation movement are typically seen as
children for school? Discuss. benefitting women. Do men also benefit from
women's liberation? Discuss.
According to studies, the average
American watches television as much Do you have a positive or a negative view of
as six hours a day. Why do Americans lawyers? Explain.
watch so much television? Discuss.
America has many regional foods.
What would you recommend to a If you could hold any job for one year, what
traveller who wanted to experience would you choose? Why?
Southern food? Explain.
If you could change one thing about
How can parents promote good reading habits
your childhood, what would it be?
in their children? Discuss.
Discuss.
Is it better to have brothers and sisters Is the traditional role of fathers changing?
than to be an only child? Explain. Discuss.
It has been said that computers are
Is the person without knowledge of com- puters
taking over our lives. Do you agree or
in the 1980's handicapped? Discuss.
disagree? Explain.
Should adoption records be open to the people
Does a person's name affect his or her directly involved (the person adopted, the
personality? Discuss. biological parents and/or the adoptive parents)?
Explain why or why not.
How does a person make a good first
What is your most prized possession? Why?
impression in an interview? Discuss.
What is your definition of a gentleman
What is the value of recreation? Explain.
or a lady? Explain.
Should teenaged children of divorced Many American communities have only one
parents have the right to decide which newspaper. What negative effects could this
parent to live with? Discuss. absence of competition have? Explain.
P.T. Barnum said that "a sucker is born
Why are there more female than male public
every minute." Explain how this idea
school teachers? Explain.
relates to American advertising.
Do you favor or oppose a rule that would
Should college physical education
prohibit professional teams from recruiting
grades be included in the grade point
college student athletes until their college sports
average? Discuss why or why not.
eligibility is over? Why or why not?
Knowledge can be gained from books Whether we want them or not, many of us get
and scientific observation. What are tagged with one or more nicknames during our
some other important sources of lives. Discuss the positive and/or negative
knowledge, and why are they valuable? aspects of the practice of nicknaming.
Archaeologists have learned much about the
lives of first-century Romans from the
Whom would you identify as a truly excavations of houses buried by lava at
wise person? What makes him or her Pompeii. Suppose that your home were
seem wise to you? preserved just as it is now. What con- clusions
about life in the 1980's might this evidence lead
future archaeologists to draw?
What steps should be taken to improve the
Discuss what people reveal about them-
quality of education in our public schools?
selves by the way they drive.
Discuss.
Discuss the following statement: "As Name your favorite game or sport and explain
we get older, our toys cost more." why you find it enjoyable.
What should a college athlete consider Athletic programs at some colleges are big
in deciding whether to turn professional business. Discuss the advantages and/or
or to remain in college? disadvantages of this situation.
Should financial aid be denied to those In the development of a national budget, which
students who have not registered for the should be more important -- fighting poverty at
draft? Explain. home or arming to fight an aggressor? Explain.
Should all students be required to take a Which of the four seasons of the year appeals to
course in computer science some time you the most? Why?
during their education? Explain why or
why not.
Suicide among high school and college
students is on the rise in this country.
What is the best advice you ever got? Explain.
Discuss possible reasons why young
people take their own lives.
Discuss why people are fascinated by
amusement parks such as Disney World Explain why you do or do not hunt.
and Six Flags.
"The love of money is the root of all Discuss some of the roles a college student
evil." Agree or disagree. plays.
What steps would you recommend be taken to
How effective is television in
make health care in America more available to
disseminating news? Explain.
everyone? Explain.
Is it better to know a little about many Should an introduction to art, music, and drama
sub- jects than to know a lot about one be a part of every college student's education?
subject? Discuss. Explain why or why not.
Explain why you think so many people Are people in the U.S. overly concerned about
get the post-Christmas blues. being thin? Discuss.
Americans are fast becoming the most
overweight people in the world. To Should animals be used in medical research?
what do you attribute this trend? Discuss.
Explain.
What can be done to make the What can be done to make the public more
treatment of the elderly more humane? aware of the dangers of drinking and driving?
What has been the most useless Do you think a person's looks affect his or her
invention of the twentieth century? success in the job market? Discuss why or why
Explain. not.
What should be done to reduce the How can Halloween be made safer for young
problem of homelessness in the U.S.? people?
Some television series (such as
M.A.S.H. and Leave It To Beaver) have What are the chief reasons for our youth's
enjoyed a long life both in production interest in music videos? Explain.
and in reruns. Explain why.
According to some observers,
Choose a character in a recent movie or
Americans are watching less network
television show whom you find especially
television. What do you think are the
appealing or unappealing. Explain your choice.
reasons for the decline in interest?
Why are television game shows so Why do many people prefer watching television
popular? Discuss. news shows over reading newspapers? Discuss.
Do you like being in the presence of
small children? Discuss why or why
Women today are waiting until they are older to
not. Should people accept it as their
marry for the first time. Why?
duty to take care of their aging parents?
Discuss.
If you could take back any deed you Fill in the blank in the following statement and
have done and do it differently, what discuss: "They don't make ________ like they
would it be? Why? used to."
What commonly held ideas about the
What is the dumbest thing you ever did?
South seem to you most true or untrue?
Explain why you did it.
Explain.
What kind of injustice makes you How is the threat of AIDS changing dating
"fighting mad"? Explain. habits? Explain.
Which qualities or characteristics of What can be done to reduce the high rate of
child- hood should we strive to preserve teenage pregnancy in the United States?
throughout our lives? Discuss. Explain.
How should students who turn in
Should high-school students go steady? Discuss
someone else's work as their own be
why or why not.
punished? Discuss.
Name the worst movie or television
Is there ever a situation in which a person
pro- gram you have ever seen, and
should hide his or her true feelings? Explain.
explain why you dislike it.
Name some place you would not like to go on a
Name your favorite pastime and
date and explain why you would choose not to
explain why you enjoy it.
go there.
Propose a model sex education
program.
Take A Side - 25 Debate Topics
Business
Essay Topic: Define the four marketing utilities and explain their role in business.
Computer Science
Essay Topic: Discuss how computer has changed education. How specifically is/can
technology be used in classroom to improve learning and instruction?
Environmental Science
Essay Topic: Imagine that it is the year 2050. Although governments and their
citizens were warned about the dangers of the greenhouse effect as early as the
1970's, they did not take the necessary steps to prevent it from worsening. As a
result, global warming and ozone depletion continued unchecked. In a well-
organized essay, describe what life would be like in 2050 under these conditions.
What would be the state of the climate? What would the nations of the world look
like? What would be the day-to-day living conditions of the people of the world?
Essay Topic: Describe one of the following earthquakes:
Be sure to include all important information, such as the date of the earthquake, the
magnitude of the earthquake, any precursors to the earthquake, the major effects of
the earthquake. Please include a bibliography containing at least two sources in
addition to your textbook reading. These sources may be print or electronic.
Psychology
Essay Topic: Discuss the various components of human memory. What is the
difference between Short-term memory and Long-term memory? How are
memories stored in the brain? What can we do to help improve our memory?
Essay Topic: Do you think that the families of schizophrenics should be responsible
for the decision to commit the schizophrenic, or do you believe that a person, even if
diagnosed as schizophrenic, should have some say in the decision to commit? In
your answer be sure to use concrete examples from the readings and other materials
used for the lesson. Provide both psychological and physiological support for your
opinion.
•
• Persuasive Speech Topics
• The case for organ donation
• The need for recycling
• Why the death penalty should be abolished
• The need for gun control
Gay marriage
Euthanasia
Animal rights
Political
Creative thinking
Vote for me
Why there should be a United States of Europe
An easy way to give up smoking
Why prostitution should be legalized
How we can get more people to vote?
Why the death penalty should be abolished in the United States
Why we should not consume genetically modified crops?
Should religious clothes be banned in schools?
Ladies and gentlemen, at this moment in the US there are 79,000 U.S
patients on the transplant waiting list. Three thousand a month are
added to this total. Not a lot you may say when the population is close
to three hundred million, but now add twenty to thirty family and
friends to each patient, and the number increases vastly.
So, how can you help? All you have to do is get in touch with your
local doctor and he will tell you all you need to know. You fill out one
form, and receive a card; it really is that easy. Then, once you have
passed away in many years to come, your organs will be removed and
will give somebody else the chance of life.
Ladies and gentlemen - the gift of life is the most amazing gift
anybody can give. How I see things, and what made me become a
donor, is that after I am gone I will have no use for my organs. So
why should I deprive someone else from using them.
You can freely use this speech for your own purposes, but you cannot
publish it or display it on a web site without the prior permission of
Presentation Helper.
List Of 200+ Controversial Speech Topics
Scan the list of controversial speech ideas below and select a few
topics you like. Focus on specific controversies within an issue.
Every controversial or convince speech topic has its own sub-
topics with different contentious speech issues, questions and
topics for speech class. Consider this just as a start.
ADDICTION AND DRUGS - Alcohol Abuse, Children of Alcoholics, Drugs and Sports, Medical Marijuana.
BUSINESS, FINANCE AND ECONOMICS - Bribery, Budget Deficits, Credit Card Fraud, Income Tax, Malpractice
Insurance, Junk Bonds, Leadership, Direct Marketing, Minimum Wage, Wage Price Policy.
COMPUTING, INTERNET AND MEDIA - Chatrooms Internet, Computer Viruses, Spam, Cybercrime and Privacy,
Harmful Media, Internet Hate Speech, Internet Pornography, Media Violence, Television And Children, Violent
Computer Games.
EDUCATION AND SCIENCE SPEECH TOPICS - Education Reform, Bilingual Education, Ethics In Life Sciences,
Creationism versus Evolutionsm, Dating, Campus Issues, Home Schooling, Information Science, Intelligence
Levels, Intercultural Education, School Prayer, School Choice, School Uniforms, School Violence, Condoms In
Schools, Space Exploration.
ENVIRONMENTAL, NATURE AND ANIMAL - Acid Rain, Air Pollution, Animal Cloning, Animal Experimentation,
Animal Rights, Antarctica Research, Biodiversity, Changing Weather Patterns, Ecology, Endangered Oceans,
Endangered Species, Energy Conservation, Global Resources, Global Warming, Oil Spills, Littering, Marine
Pollution, Noise Pollution, Pesticides, Rain Forests, Recycling, Vivisection, Water Pollution, Water Resources.
ETHICAL AND MORAL CONTROVERSIAL SPEECH TOPICS - Abortion, Assisted Suicide, Beginning Of Life Issues,
Birth Control, Euthanasia, Gender Identity, Genetic Engineering, Human Cloning, Implanted GPS, Physician
Assisted Suicide, Pro Choice Movement, Pro Life Movement, Reproductive Technologies, Separation of Church and
State, Stem Cell Research.
FAMILY, MARRIAGE AND DIVORCE - Bigamy, Family Violence, Gay Marriage, Gay Parents, Polygamy, Single
Parent Families, Surrogate Mothers, Teenage Fathers, Teenage Mothers.
MEDICAL, HEALTH AND NUTRITION - Aids Testing, Alternative Medicine, Anorexia Treathment, Artificial
Insemination, ADHD, Bulimia, Burn Out, Depression, Dieting, Food Labeling, Food Prices, Health Care System,
Infectious Diseases, Medical Ethics, Medicine Abuse, Passive Smoking, Plastic Surgery, Tobacco Industry.
POLITICS AND GLOBAL POLICY - Afghanistan, Armed Conflicts, Arms Control, Asylum Policy, Ballot Initiatives,
Biological And Chemical Weapons, Boycotts, Campaign Funding, Child Labor, Cold War Politics, Immigration Laws,
Farm Susidies, Iraq, Islamic Fundamentalism, Militias, Nuclear Technology, Nuclear Weapons, Peace Movements,
Political Correctness, Privatization Of Social Security, Slavery, Terrorism, United Nations, Voting Behavior, War
Crime Trials, War on Drugs.
SOCIETY - Affirmative Action, Aging Population, Celibacy, City Curfews, Demographics, Dropouts, Homeless
Persons, Flexible Hours Of Labor, Inner City Poverty, Integration, Moral Majority, Nonsmoking Areas.
WOMEN ISSUES - Breast Feeding in Public, Breast Implants, Feminism, Women in the Military, Women's Rights,
Working Mothers.
To tickle your mind quickly: check out possible sub-topics or special angles of view of
the list above.
Choose A Side
By now, pick out one controversial speech topic and take a stand. Your choice has to
deal with the assigment rules, the occassion, your personal interests and the
reaction of your listeners. Ask yourself:
Or opposite sides of course if you like! By now you have learned how to create, write
and develop controversial speech topics.
THE OCCASION
Now narrow your ideas into the best angles of approach for good
speech topics. If you don't like the outcome, try other ideas. Only
answer questions that are appropriate to your ideas and select
the main points for a text to speech. If you are in a hurry, try my
quick speech topic steps.
• Where?
• What is it called?
• What does it look like?
• What is a good description?
• Size?
• Architecture?
• People?
• What are very special facts?
• Historical value?
• Why do you like the place?
• What do other people think of the place? Why?
• Why is it important to you/us?
• Why is it useful?
• How can it benefit your audience?
• Can you compare it to other places?
• What are the differences? Beter/worse?
• Stories, poems to honor the place?
Bottomline: Always choose a topic you're interested in, know a lot about or you can
easily research. Learn to find for example good persuasion topics everywhere you go.
Keep our eyes and ears open, like my friend Jonathan has done. He has listed good
speech topics sources. They are very helpful in combination with the checklists above.
They help you at unexpected occasions when you quickly have to come up with good
speech topics for an impromptu. And by now, after trying my checklists, are you still
asking yourself: What are good speech topics?
Program
The idea of my college holding a series of discussions in English which are open to the
public and sponsored by the Japanese Ministry of Education was quite appealing to me.
I've always believed that universities and colleges, at least in Japan, tend to lack sufficient
connection to the citizens who financially support them. With the encouragement of a
Japanese colleague, I presented a plan to the Ministry of Education to conduct a
discussion forum in which local people could participate in English in discussions on a
variety of topics.
The overall purpose of the project was to provide an opportunity for Japanese people to
use their English skills in a more natural way than they might get in an ESL classroom.
Through this experience, it was hoped that the participants could further their
communicative competence in English in preparation for the times when they discuss
similar topics with native-English speakers in the future. One had to always keep in mind,
however, the main risk in this approach - namely, the prospect of the participant's
perception of his/her failure to communicate and therefore a desire to drop out of the
program as a result.
Preparation
The plan we had drawn up was approved and limited to 20 hours of lesson time. We
proceeded to choose 10 topics to be discussed for 2 hours each week. My
Japanese
colleague and I wanted topics which were closely associated to international themes,
partly due to our personal interests and partly to justify a discussion in English. After all,
if the issue is so localized, what's the point of discussing it in English?
We set out to advertise for approximately 20 participants, focusing on those who had the
confidence to express their opinions and feelings in English, and in public. Relevant
articles were taken from English-language newspapers in Japan as well as those from
abroad to provide some background information to help participants to prepare for each
meeting. Participants were not required to read them or use them during the forum as they
could have an obstructive influence on the discussion.
We were delighted to see the program oversubscribed (22 people finally selected) in spite
of the nominal fee required, although we anticipated problems that would likely arise
with such a large group. Wouldn't the atmosphere be inhibiting? Wouldn't participants
feel unable to say all the things they want to say? On the other hand, such forums are
rarely held in this part of Japan and one could imagine a large group is needed in order to
simply have enough people who are willing to speak spontaneously. Indeed, helping
participants to adapt to our format was no easy task.
Roles
In the first meeting, our roles (mine as distinguished from the participants') were orally
clarified. My role was not that of a teacher, but somewhat of a moderator who
coordinates discussion by calling on people to speak, clarifying comments at my
discretion and intercepting occasionally with questions as if 'throwing logs on the fire'.
The role sounds pretty heavy-handed but along with some corny jokes, I tried to
encourage attendees to imagine themselves not as passive students but active participants
who have at least as much knowledge of the topics as the moderator, if not more. They
would have to be conscious of the desires of others to speak -- and at the same time be
spontaneous in the initiation of questions or comments on the points being raised.
Topics
Format
As the moderator, I introduced the topic in the beginning of the discussions. Often I
would rephrase the question or make some clarification with concrete examples of what
aspects would be touched on as the meeting proceeded in order to prevent
misunderstandings from early on.
Each participant was allowed approximately a minute to summarise his/her views, often
based on personal experiences. To many, this approach might appear to foster a series of
mini-speeches and not discussion. This is true. However, it was deemed necessary in
order to help some of the reluctant speakers to 'break the ice' and become accustomed to
public speaking. It was presumed that the more often they did this successfully, the more
confident they'd become at making comments more spontaneously during the meeting.
This proved to be true according to the participant feedback. At the end (about 20
minutes later), anyone was free to make comments on what was previously said.
When the comments started to dry up, I introduced a series of sub-questions. For
example, in the first topic on the list, I asked participants if they could comment on any
positive or negative personal experiences with foreigners they had encountered. Those
with something to say either to answer my question or respond to the comments of others,
would raise their hands. I would then call on them to speak until I thought it was a good
idea to offer another question relating to the topic. This, of course, would be unnecessary
if the participants would initiate their own sub-topics and, in a sense, take control of the
meeting. As for the raising of hands, it was regarded as appropriate by the moderator
because it allowed language learners who are still not totally confident in their oral
English to organise their thoughts without the pressure of being prematurely interrupted.
Subsequently, domination of the event by more confident speakers was prevented.
In the last 20 minutes, everyone was given a chance to make a brief final comment.
Throughout the meeting, one was conscious of the fact that some people speak out more
than others. This may appear unfair to an observer, but for 80 minutes opportunities to
speak anytime were encouraged. Forty minutes were allocated to guarantee everyone the
chance to make at least two brief comments during the meeting. Otherwise, it was feared
that many participants would resort to only a listening role.
Success or Failure?
As everyone has their own standards as to what constitutes a vibrant discussion, I decided
to distribute a questionnaire at the end of the series of meetings to help me determine the
successes and failures of the project (see appendix for a sample in both English and
Japanese). The questions and a general summary of responses are as follows:
Did you enjoy the discussion forum? Please state why or why not?
The overwhelming majority of the 18 participants who stayed until the end of the
program (4 had dropped out previously) stated that they enjoyed it very much. Here are
some reasons given:
There were several problems raised by some members, most of which I had already
discovered after conducting the first few meetings. One participant, who stated that he
didn't enjoy the forum so much, felt that the sub-topics ('logs on a fire') introduced by the
moderator changed too quickly which exacerbated his difficulty in concentrating. I
suspect that some others had the same feeling and, as the moderator, I now realise that I
should have relaxed and allowed the discussion to be carried out at a slower pace.
Which topics did you enjoy the most? Please state reasons for your choice(s).
The most popular topic was #9 about tourism. Several participants indicated that their
personal experiences as tourists overseas as well as the lack of seriousness in the
discussion made it particularly enjoyable and easy to relate to. The second most popular
was #4 about Japan's uniqueness. One member came to the conclusion that 'Japan is
strange' while another appreciated learning about the foreign perception of Japan's
uniqueness.
The most unpopular topics were #2 and #6. As for #2, one member claimed to have no
knowledge of it while another stated his belief that 'war deeds of other countries must be
discussed.' As for #6, two members said that they had no interest in the topic.
What other topics of international concern would you have been interested in discussing?
Those who responded to this question provided the following ideas in no particular order:
Did you like the meeting format (structure)? What did you like or dislike about it?
The responses were mostly positive, and mainly cited the appropriateness of having
everyone making opening and closing comments. This allowed everyone to have a
chance to speak, albeit not without some coercion.
Please comment on the moderator. Did he do a good job? How could he have done
better?
Generally, the moderator was praised for doing a good job in directing the discussion. In
particular, he was complimented by some as being well-prepared, fair-minded and
humorous.
Suggestions that were proposed centered on the idea that he should have made more
effort to get participants to discuss topics with each other more often instead of only
responding to his questions. One suggestion was that it was not always necessary to raise
hands to speak and that such a procedure was rather detrimental to a more relaxed, free-
flowing discussion.
As for the suggestion that the moderator should have encouraged participants to discuss
topics with each other, no specific idea was offered as to how this desirable outcome
could be developed. As the moderator, I believed that it would be too ambitious for
participants who aren't use to speaking English publicly to a large group to handle the
added pressure of a formal debate. Clearly, a minority did have the willingness to raise
objections to others' opinions (and they often did), but as most did not have this
confidence, it was viewed as unrealistic for such a condition to be imposed.
Although many participants appreciated receiving the materials, they found them difficult
to read due to lack of time or insufficient knowledge of English. As mentioned earlier,
one respondent wanted more specific or detailed information.
Would you like to take part in another forum? Why or why not?
All the respondents answered in favor of joining another forum. Here are some reasons:
Several members expressed the desire to keep a forum of this nature on-going (beyond
the 10 meetings allocated). Some of them recommended getting more native-speakers of
English involved and observing an example of a 'model discussion' in order to learn about
the role of discussion in western society.
There was common feedback, however, that can help organizers of future forums. In
general, the exercise of discussion in English on a comprehensive topic is difficult, even
for advanced speakers of English. Due to the popularity of the event, more careful initial
screening of participants could have helped collect a more cohesive group of confident
English speakers. This was not done as it was feared that the program would be
undersubscribed. Hence, there was a sizable gap between participants' confidence in
public speaking as well as language levels with none falling below what may be regarded
as an intermediate level.
As the pressure was high, especially for participants lacking in confidence, it's important
for organizers to keep the atmosphere light and relaxing, even when a 'heavy' topic (e.g.
#2) is introduced. As the forum progressed, members gradually began to relax and could
contribute more effectively as a result. If more relatively light topics (e.g. #9) were
introduced in the first few forums, it might have helped to prevent some participants from
dropping out of the program in the early stages.
Another way to lower the pressure would be to initially separate the participants into
small groups to discuss the topics as one can experience in educational workshops. A
chosen leader could present the views of his/her group. An over dependency on this
format, however, may have the detrimental effect of allowing participants to casually slip
into their native tongue and not provide them with sufficient opportunities to express
their opinions directly to a wider group. Organizers can decide for themselves how much
pressure is beneficial for language learners according to their specific circumstances.
Finally, with increasing numbers of advanced speakers of English in Japan, even flawed
discussion forums like the one outlined may be useful in motivating students to continue
to study English. In addition, the transition of the role of teacher to moderator or
organizer can help introduce greater flexibility in the management of language learning
environments.
Biographical information
Peter Connell has been teaching English conversation classes in Japan for 8 years and
currently teaches in Asahikawa, Hokkaido.