FRIDAY www.thehindu.com https://newsth.

live/fb
May 3, 2024 https://newsth.live/x
https://newsth.live/ig
DELHI
CITY EDITION Regd. DL(ND)-11/6110/2006-07-08
22 Pages ₹ 12.00 RNI No. UPENG/2012/49940

Vol. 14 앫 No. 106

Printed at » Chennai » Coimbatore » Bengaluru » Hyderabad » Madurai » Noida » Visakhapatnam » Thiruvananthapuram » Kochi » Vijayawada » Mangaluru » Tiruchirapalli » Kolkata » Hubballi » Mohali » Malappuram » Mumbai » Tirupati » Lucknow » Cuttack » Patna
ffa76243-386b-4d4d-93fa-f34e5b20443d

ffa76243-386b-4d4d-93fa-f34e5b20443d

CM J ND-NDE
YK
 ffa76243-386b-4d4d-93fa-f34e5b20443d
Friday, May 3, 2024
Delhi

J ND-NDE
THE HINDU

CM
YK
J2
ffa76243-386b-4d4d-93fa-f34e5b20443d
 FRIDAY www.thehindu.com https://newsth.live/fb
May 3, 2024 https://newsth.live/x
https://newsth.live/ig
DELHI
CITY EDITION Regd. DL(ND)-11/6110/2006-07-08
22 Pages ₹ 12.00 RNI No. UPENG/2012/49940

Vol. 14 앫 No. 106

Printed at » Chennai » Coimbatore » Bengaluru » Hyderabad » Madurai » Noida » Visakhapatnam » Thiruvananthapuram » Kochi » Vijayawada » Mangaluru » Tiruchirapalli » Kolkata » Hubballi » Mohali » Malappuram » Mumbai » Tirupati » Lucknow » Cuttack » Patna

Prajwal booked for rape; India protests

Chinese road
Law and order a
State subject, says
IN BRIEF
쑽

construction
lookout circular issued in PoK valley SC on Bengal’s suit
Karnataka govt. asks PM to cancel MP’s diplomatic passport, appeals to victims to come forward; Dinakar Peri
NEW DELHI Krishnadas Rajagopal
his father, also named in harassment and kidnap cases, skips SIT summons, seeks anticipatory bail
India has registered its
NEW DELHI
The Hindu wins
ffa76243-386b-4d4d-93fa-f34e5b20443d

The Hindu Bureau plaint against Mr. Prajwal.
BENGALURU/KALABURGI/ The Minister also appealed
NEW DELHI to other victims, especially
those who were allegedly
he Karnataka Pol- featured in explicit videos
ffa76243-386b-4d4d-93fa-f34e5b20443d
protest with Beijing against The Supreme Court on top awards at
China’s “illegal attempts” Thursday categorically design contest
to “alter facts on the said law and order is a
ground” in the Shaksgam State subject, after West CHENNAI
valley of Pakistan-occu- Bengal complained that

T ice booked Hassan

MP Prajwal Revan-
na on rape charges on
Thursday, and issued a loo-
kout circular against the
“absconding” MP a day af-
ter he failed to appear be-
fore the Special Investiga-
tion Team (SIT) that is
probing his alleged sexual
crimes.
His father and former
Minister H.D. Revanna,
who also skipped the SIT
summons, approached a
court in Bengaluru seeking
anticipatory bail.
The charges against the
grandson of former Prime
Minister H.D. Deve Gowda
were filed after a second
woman filed a complaint
that she was “coerced to
Burning issue: A Congress protest in Bengaluru on Thursday night
seeking action against Prajwal Revanna. SPECIAL ARRANGEMENT
have sexual relationship”
with him. Based on the
complaint, Section 376 of
the Indian Penal Code, that
deals with rape, has been
invoked against the MP.
He has previously been
booked for sexual harass-
ment on the basis of anoth-
er woman’s complaint on
April 28. His father is also
named in the first case. Ac-
cording to sources, a new
FIR was filed on Thursday
evening against Mr. Revan-
na for kidnap. He allegedly
played a role in abducting
one of the victims of Mr.
Prajwal, they added.
Earlier in the day, Kar-
nataka Home Minister G.
Parameshwara said a se-
cond victim had come for-
ward and lodged a com-
which are being circulated
through social media, to
come forward and make
statements before the SIT.
He said the government
would ensure their safety
and protect their identity.
The MP is believed to
have left the country using
his diplomatic passport on
April 27, a day after the
elections. He is now be-
lieved to be in Germany.
Chief Minister Siddara-
maiah has already urged
Prime Minister Narendra
Modi to cancel his diplo-
matic passport and bring
him back to “face the full
force of law”.
CONTINUED ON
» PAGE 12
pied Kashmir, which faces
the Siachen glacier, the Mi-
nistry of External Affairs
said on Thursday. MEA
spokesperson Randhir Jais-
wal was responding to
questions on Chinese road
construction in the valley.
“The Shaksgam valley is
a part of the territory of In-
dia. We have never accept-
ed the so-called China Pa-
kistan Boundary
Agreement of 1963 through
which Pakistan unlawfully
attempted to cede the area
to China, and have consis-
tently conveyed our rejec-
tion of the same,” Mr. Jais-
wal said at a briefing.
CONTINUED ON
» PAGE 12
the Central Bureau of In-
vestigation (CBI) claims
“unilateral right” to inves-
tigate offences committed
by Central employees with-
in State jurisdiction.
“Law and order is a
State subject. Suppose a
Central employee commits
dacoity, will the case be in-
vestigated by the CBI on-
ly?” Justice B.R. Gavai que-
ried. Justice Sandeep
Mehta, also on the two-
judge Bench, said when Ar-
my personnel commit of-
fences even within their
camp, officers hand over
the culprits to the police.
Senior advocate Kapil
Sibal, for West Bengal, said
“their intent is to get in
through the CBI, then use
the Directorate of Enforce-
ment [ED] and then do
whatever is to be done…
This has far-reaching
repercussions”.
Another Bench of the
Supreme Court is tackling
a similar question of law
related to Tamil Nadu in
the case of Ankit Tiwari, an
ED officer against whom
the T.N. Directorate of Vigi-
lance and Anti-Corruption
had launched a criminal
prosecution for bribery.
CONTINUED ON
» PAGE 12
The Hindu’s explainer page
on Neeraj Chopra’s craft and
success, “The science behind
Neeraj’s skills”, has won
three awards at the 6th
International Newspaper
Design Competition. » Page 12
BJP fields Brij
Bhushan’s son
from Kaiserganj
LUCKNOW
The BJP on Thursday
announced the candidature
of Karan Bhushan Singh, son
of six-term MP Brij Bhushan
Sharan Singh, from the
Kaiserganj Lok Sabha seat.
The move drew criticism from
Opposition parties. » Page 4

EC: cease
registering
voters under
the ‘guise of
surveys’
The Hindu Bureau
NEW DELHI

The Election Commission

of India (EC) on Thursday
directed all political parties
to cease enrolling or regis-
tering voters for post-elec-
tion, beneficiary-oriented
schemes under the “guise
of surveys”.
A potential quid pro quo
for voting and induce-
ments amounts to bribery
or corrupt practice, the EC
said in an advisory to all
national and regional polit-
ical parties.

BJP complaint
The advisory comes fol-
lowing a complaint by the
BJP that said the Congress’s
“Ghar Ghar Guarantee”
outreach to people was a
“corrupt practice amount-
ing to bribery” and urged
the EC to put a stop to it.
Under this initiative, the
BJP claimed that the Con-
gress and its workers are
distributing “guarantee
cards” to households and
presenting them with ap-
plication papers for access-
ing the party’s promised
benefits.
In its advisory, the EC
cited five instances that
“obscure the distinction
between legitimate surveys
and biased attempts to en-
rol people in programmes
for political gain”.
These included new-
spaper ads seeking to regis-
ter voters for benefits by
giving missed calls on a
mobile or calling on a tele-
phone number, distribu-
tion of guarantee cards giv-
ing details of schemes
along with an attached
form asking for details of
voters, and distribution of
forms seeking details and
seeking online registration.
CM M ND-NDE
YK

2 Friday, May 3, 2024
One more quits
Congress over
AAP alliance
Press Trust of India
NEW DELHI
Delhi Congress leader Om
Prakash Bidhuri on Thurs-
day quit the party over the
Congress-AAP alliance. He
said he will not be joining
any political party now.
EDUCATIONAL
GENERAL
ffa76243-386b-4d4d-93fa-f34e5b20443d
CM
YK
Attendance drops
in Delhi schools day
after bomb threat
A teacher stands in front of a school in east Delhi on Thursday. PTI
The Hindu Bureau
NEW DELHI
A day after several private
schools in Delhi and Noida
received bomb threat
emails, a few schools re-
ported a drop in
attendance.
On Wednesday morn-
ing, students were evacuat-
ed from 131 schools in Delhi
and seven in Noida even as
fire tenders, bomb disposal
squads and sniffer dogs
were rushed to the premis-
es to search for explosives.
No suspicious object was
found in the searches and
the emails were found to be
a hoax.
A senior police officer
said the intention behind
the emails was to create
mass panic and disturb pu-
blic order.
Mock drills
Jyoti Arora, principal of
Mount Abu Public School
in Rohini, said there was a
10-15% drop in attendance
across classes. She said,
“We revisited the frame-
work to deal with such inci-
dents and discussed prepa-
redness. We also informed
new teachers and students
about the mock drills.”
Sudha Acharya, princi-
pal of ITL Public School in
Dwarka, said that atten-
dance had dropped from
the usual 95-97% to 85% on
Thursday. “We reiterated
the evacuation SOP with all
children, which is dis-
played at both ends of the
school corridors. Every
child is aware of which
staircase to take to reach
the playground in case of a
threat situation like yester-
day,” she added.
Fake news
In the wake of the incident,
the Delhi police took cogni-
sance of fake news circulat-
ing on WhatsApp. DCP
(PRO) Suman Nalwa said,
“We have received messag-
es that many parents were
having conversations on
WhatsApp groups regard-
ing a suspicious object
found inside a school.
Whenever you get such
messages, you should first
identify its source, and
then forward it. Fake news
spreads like wildfire.”
She also added that
strict action would be ta-
ken against those who
spread fake news.
THE HINDU
City
52 contractual workers of
DCW sacked; L-G to blame
for job losses, says AAP
Services terminated on the basis of 2017 report, which found that 223 posts in women’s panel
were created illegally: WCD; sacked employees include rape, acid attack survivors, says Maliwal
Samridhi Tewari
Satvika Mahajan
NEW DELHI
The Women and Child De-
velopment Department
(WCD) of the Delhi govern-
ment terminated the servic-
es of 52 “illegally appoint-
ed” contractual employees
of the Delhi Commission
for Women (DCW), officials
said on Thursday.
WCD officials said that a
proposal drafted by a 2017
committee, which found
over 200 posts in the com-
mission to have been creat-
ed illegally, was sent to
Lieutenant-Governor V.K.
Saxena for approval.
“The order to terminate
the services was issued af-
ter the L-G gave a nod to the
proposal,” a senior official
said.
Several Aam Aadmi Par-
ty (AAP) leaders held the
L-G responsible for the
sackings and termed the
WCD order “arbitrary”.
“The L-G in his Tughlaqi
farman [arbitrary order]
has directed the removal of
all contractual staff of the
commission,” said former
DCW chairperson and
AAP’s Rajya Sabha member
LS poll: BJP’s Sehrawat files nomination from West Delhi
The Hindu Bureau
NEW DELHI
Over 72 candidates, includ-
ing BJP’s West Delhi candi-
date Kamaljeet Sehrawat,
filed their nomination pap-
ers on Thursday, the fourth
day of the nomination pro-
cess for the Lok Sabha elec-
tion scheduled to be held
on May 25 in Delhi.
Before filing her papers,
Ms. Sehrawat held a road-
show, which was attended
by Rajasthan Chief Minister
Former Delhi Commission for Women chief Swati Maliwal
addressing a press conference on Thursday. SUSHIL KUMAR VERMA
Swati Maliwal. She said ma-
ny of the terminated em-
ployees were survivors of
various crimes, including
acid attacks, domestic vio-
lence, and rape. The com-
mission, after Ms. Maliwal’s
resignation in January this
year, remains without a
chairperson.
The BJP attacked Ms. Ma-
liwal and alleged that she
was responsible for the ter-
minations.
Delhi BJP president Vi-
rendra Sachdeva said the
DCW employees were
sacked due to the unconsti-
tutional and anarchic func-
tioning of the AAP govern-
ment, especially DCW’s
Bhajan Lal Sharma, Union
Minister Hardeep Singh Pu-
ri, and several senior party
leaders.
Many supporters turned
up to cheer Ms. Sehrawat,
who led the roadshow from
her Vikaspuri office to the
office of the returning offic-
er in Rajouri Garden.
The BJP nominee, who is
pitted against INDIA bloc
candidate Mahabal Mishra
(AAP), said her supporters’
enthusiasm had boosted
her confidence. “The way
DU to organise ‘Viksit Bharat Run’ on May 8;
some academics question timing of event
Ashna Butani
NEW DELHI
Nearly 5,000 students will
participate in a 2.5-km
“Run for Viksit Bharat”
event on May 8, Delhi Un-
iversity (DU) said in a state-
ment on Thursday. The an-
nouncement was made
following a meeting held
earlier in the day between
university officials and Kul-
jeet Singh Chahal, BJP lead-
er and New Delhi Munici-
pal Council member.
The event is part of the
Viksit Bharat programme,
which was launched by the
Prime Minister in Decem-
ber last year, and is aimed
at giving a platform to the
youth to contribute
thoughts to the vision of
Sisodia moves HC seeking bail in ED,
CBI cases; court to hear plea today
The Hindu Bureau
NEW DELHI
Former Delhi Deputy Chief
Minister Manish Sisodia
moved the High Court on
Thursday seeking bail in
the corruption and money-
laundering cases lodged by
the Central Bureau of In-
vestigation (CBI) and the
Enforcement Directorate
(ED), respectively, in con-
former chairperson, Swati
Maliwal.
2017 report
A senior WCD official said
the commission had “ille-
gally” created 223 posts in
2016.
The official added that a
committee, founded in Fe-
bruary 2017 by the then
Delhi L-G Anil Baijal to in-
vestigate complaints of ille-
gally created posts in the
commission, had stated in
its report that “the actions
taken by the DCW are
beyond its delegated power
and in violation of the DCW
Act”.
The commission had al-
party workers and voters
participated in the road-
show showed that eve-
ryone’s blessings and sup-
port are with Prime
Minister Narendra Modiji’s
soldier Kamaljeet Sehra-
wat,” she said.
Ms. Sehrawat declared
movable assets worth ₹1.30
crore and immovable assets
worth ₹27.60 lakh in her
poll affidavit.
She has done a Master’s
in Commerce from Hima-
chal Pradesh University.
The decision was
announced following
a meeting between
university officials
and a BJP leader
‘Viksit Bharat @2047’ — the
idea of a developed India
by 2047, the 100th year of
Independence.
While the university
said the event’s objective
was to “bring awareness in
the society to make Bharat
a developed nation by
2047”, some academics
termed it “a misuse of edu-
cational institutions”.
Maya John, a professor
and member of DU’s Aca-
demic Council, said, “Edu-
cational institutions should
nection with the Delhi ex-
cise policy case.
A Bench of Acting Chief
Justice Manmohan and Jus-
tice Manmeet P.S. Arora
agreed to hear the case on
Friday.
Mr. Sisodia approached
the High Court after a trial
court refused him bail on
April 30. The trial court
had denied relief to the
AAP leader, saying Mr. Si-
so been informed at the
time that the created posts
had not been approved by
the L-G, the official said.
“The DCW and its form-
er chairperson, Swati Mali-
wal, who in the first in-
stance had appointed these
[now-sacked] individuals,
illegally kept the recom-
mendations of the commit-
tee in abeyance and the
same could be moved by
the WCD only upon her de-
mitting the office,” the offi-
cial said.
‘Direct impact’
Ms. Maliwal claimed that
the termination of so many
employees would affect the
functioning of the DCW and
lead to the closure of multi-
ple DCW programmes, in-
cluding the Rape Crisis Cell
and Mahila Panchayat.
“The L-G’s move aims to
render the DCW as ineffec-
tive as other women’s com-
missions in the country,”
she said.
Senior AAP leaders and
Delhi Ministers Saurabh
Bharadwaj and Atishi hit
out at the L-G, accusing him
of “rendering thousands of
people unemployed in the
last year and a half”.
Kamaljeet Sehrawat at a roadshow ahead of filing her nomination
for the Lok Sabha poll on Thursday. SHIV KUMAR PUSHPAKAR
be neutral and autono-
mous. The Viksit Bharat
programmes in education-
al institutions, therefore,
represent a serious viola-
tion of the Model Code of
Conduct [MCC]. The Elec-
tion Commission of India
[EC] should take imme-
diate note of the practice.”
The MCC states that the
party in power, at the
Centre or in the State, must
not use its official position
for election campaigning.
The MCC came into force
on March 16 when the EC
announced the general
election schedule. Delhi is
slated for voting on May 25.
In the months following
the rollout of the Viksit
Bharat scheme, dedicated
cells created in universities
sodia and other co-accused
in the case had made “con-
certed efforts” to delay the
trial by filing multiple pleas
and making oral submis-
sions, some of which were
frivolous.
The former Deputy CM
was arrested by Central
agencies in February last
year. The CBI has alleged
him to be the “master-
mind” of the alleged scam.
Delhi
HC grants bail
to 3 accused in
Ankit Sharma
murder case
Press Trust of India
NEW DELHI
The High Court on Thurs-
day granted bail to three
men in a case linked to the
murder of Intelligence Bu-
reau employee Ankit Shar-
ma during the February
2020 north-east Delhi
riots, saying that during
the pendency of the trial,
bail is the rule, while jail is
an exception.
The court in its order
gave relief to three accused
— Shoaib Alam, Gulfam,
and Javed — noting that
while they have been in
custody for four years, the
trial in the case “is not like-
ly to conclude any time
soon”.
“The purpose of keep-
ing an accused in jail dur-
ffa76243-386b-4d4d-93fa-f34e5b20443d
ing the trial is to ensure
that he faces trial, does not
abscond, and, if found guil-
ty, is available to serve his
sentence. The purpose is
not to punish the accused,”
Justice Navin Chawla said.
The court, however, de-
nied bail to the fourth ac-
cused, Nazim, saying that
there was a likelihood of
him influencing important
public witnesses that are
yet to be examined by the
prosecution.
According to the com-
plainant, Ravinder Kumar,
the four accused were part
of a “violent mob” that
killed his son during the
communal violence.
and a multitude of semi-
nars conducted on the
theme. A professor from
every college was appoint-
ed as a nodal officer for the
programme.
Speaking on the condi-
tion of anonymity, a nodal
officer said, “University of-
ficials are conducting elec-
tion campaigns in the
name of Viksit Bharat.
Each of us has been asked
to register 100 students
[for the May 8 event].”
The officer added that
no notification for Viksit
Bharat events was issued
since the MCC’s enforce-
ment and that the next
week’s event would be the
first under the programme
since the announcement of
the general election.
Minor attacked
with blade by
her classmate
The Hindu Bureau
NEW DELHI
A 14-year-old girl was at-
tacked with a blade by her
classmate in Gulabi Bagh,
resulting in her receiving 17
stitches on her face, the
police said on Thursday, ad-
ding that action had been
taken under the Juvenile
Justice Act.
M ND-NDE
 THE HINDU
Friday, May 3, 2024 3
Delhi
States

Modi is a ‘crisis’ for Campaigning in Bihar, INBRIEF

쑽

the country: Pawar;

Fadnavis hits back
Press Trust of India
MUMBAI
Nationalist Congress Party
(SP) chief Sharad Pawar on
Thursday accused Prime
Minister Narendra Modi of
not basing his speeches on
facts and reality. Talking to
reporters in Kolhapur, Mr.
Pawar said, “I have never
seen such degradation of
the stature of the PM’s
post. I feel Mr. Modi is a cri-
sis for the country.”
Rebutting Mr. Pawar’s
charge, Maharashtra Depu-
ty Chief Minister and BJP
leader Devendra Fadnavis
said in Mumbai that the PM
is not a “crisis” for the
country, but definitely for
Mr. Pawar and his party.
“After Mr. Modi came to
ffa76243-386b-4d4d-93fa-f34e5b20443d
health when he was in hos-
pital. “It is the culture of
the PM to enquire about a
person’s well-being. You
may be in different politi-
cal parties, but helping a
person caught in a medical
situation is our culture,
and Mr. Modi always fol-
lows it,” he said.
Mr. Pawar had also said,
“The PM is satisfied with
targeting me and Uddhav
Thackeray.”
‘Why 5 phases?’
Wondering why Maharash-
tra was voting in five phas-
es in the Lok Sabha elec-
tion, the NCP (SP) chief
said, “It is because Mr. Mo-
di can campaign here as
much as possible... Those
in power are worried.”
Rajnath says NDA will
coast to 400-plus seats
Defence Minister, BJP chief target INDIA bloc over graft at rallies in State; Rajnath rejects charge
that BJP is creating Hindu-Muslim divide, highlights goodwill enjoyed by PM in Islamic countries
‘People will respond to Delhi
Amit Bhelari its leadership for not tak- CM’s arrest through votes’
PATNA ing steps to tackle corrup-
tion in the country. People are smart and will respond to the BJP’s
efence Minister “The Congress has not move to put AAP national convener and Delhi
D Rajnath Singh and
Bharatiya Janata
Party president J.P. Nadda
had a single government
without facing serious cor-
ruption charges. Even in
Chief Minister Arvind Kejriwal behind bars
through their votes, his wife Sunita Kejriwal said
in Ahmedabad on Thursday. Soon after arriving
targeted the Rashtriya Ja- Manmohan Singh’s re- in the city, she headed to address election rallies
nata Dal (RJD) and the gime, Ministers had to go for AAP candidates in Bharuch and Bhavnagar
Congress on Thursday ov- to jail but there had been Lok Sabha constituencies in Gujarat. “They [BJP]
er the issue of corruption no such instance in go- have put Kejriwal forcibly behind bars during
at separate public meet- vernments led by Atal Bi- elections so that his voice doesn’t reach the
ings in Bihar. hari Vajpayee and Modiji,” people. But the people are very smart and they
While Mr. Singh he said. will respond with their votes,” she said. PTI
claimed that the BJP-led In Araria, Mr. Nadda
National Democratic Al- said RJD is an abbreviation
liance (NDA) will easily for “Rishwatkhori [cor-
Repolling in Ajmer booth after

power, what happened to
his party? Now the NCP is
with us... I feel Mr. Modi is
definitely a challenge be-
fore him. But the country
loves Mr. Modi, and people
will respond to this criti-
cism through votes,” Mr.
Fadnavis said.
‘PM’s culture’
The BJP leader also said
the PM used to call up Udd-
hav Thackeray’s wife,
Rashmi, to enquire about
the Shiv Sena (UBT) chief’s
He alleged that Mr. Mo-
di’s frequent remark that if
voted to power, the INDIA
bloc would bring reserva-
tion based on religion, was
an attempt to create social
tension. “We have never
said this. This is Mr. Modi’s
creation,” Mr. Pawar said.
Mr. Modi has also been
speaking about redistribu-
tion of wealth and inheri-
tance tax, which does not
have any mention in the
Congress manifesto, he
pointed out.
achieve the target of “400-
plus” seats in the Lok Sab-
ha election, Mr. Nadda
said Prime Minister Naren-
dra Modi is working to put
“corrupt leaders in jail”.
Mr. Singh was cam-
paigning for BJP’s Saran
candidate Rajiv Pratap Ru-
dy while Mr. Nadda held a
rally in support of Pradeep
Kumar Singh, the BJP’s
Araria seat nominee.
“I have already ad-
dressed several rallies in
the country and seeing the
ffa76243-386b-4d4d-93fa-f34e5b20443d
Defence Minister Rajnath Singh, BJP’s Saran candidate Rajiv Pratap rupt] Jungleraj Daldal
Rudy, and party leader Ravi Shankar Prasad in Saran on Thursday. ANI [swamp]”. “Modiji wants
to put corrupt people in register of voters misplaced
kind of support we are get- countries of the Arab jail but the Indian National
ting, I believe we will easi- world, Modi has been con- Developmental, Inclusive Repolling was held at a booth at Nandsi village in
ly achieve the target of ferred with the highest ho- Alliance wants to protect Rajasthan’s Ajmer Lok Sabha constituency on
400-plus seats,” the De- nour. And they [the Oppo- them,” he said. Thursday following the Election Commission’s
fence Minister said in sition] have the temerity Later in the day, Mr. declaration of the April 26 polling as void. The
Saran. to charge us with [creating Nadda addressed another repolling was ordered at a booth in Nandsi’s
He rejected the Opposi- divisions] between Hindus rally in Muzaffarpur in Government Senior Secondary School because
tion’s charge that the BJP and Muslims,” Mr. Singh support of BJP candidate the presiding officer had misplaced the 17-A
was creating a Hindu-Mus- said. Raj Bhushan Nishad. Mr. register of voters. The voter turnout during the
lim divide, highlighting Singh addressed a second repolling was recorded at 68.66%, with 517 of the
the goodwill enjoyed by ‘Corrupt Cong. regimes’ rally in support of Dilesh- 753 registered voters turning up to cast their
Mr. Modi in several Islamic The Defence Minister war Kamat, the JD(U) can- ballots. CEO Praveen Gupta said the repolling
countries. “In at least five blamed the Congress and didate for the Supaul seat. was conducted amid tight security.

Value of our vote is zero, we

neither matter nor exist, says
Nandurbar’s Adivasi candidate
Purnima Sah
NANDURBAR
For over 75 years, the tribal
population of Nandurbar
in Maharashtra has been
kept away from develop-
ment and growth, and it is
high time that an Adivasi
stands up for their rights,
said 38-year-old Nirmala
Kagadya Vasave.
Ms. Vasave is contesting
this Lok Sabha seat on a Pe-
ople’s Party of India (De-
mocratic) ticket.
Her public rallies and
campaigns will begin from
Friday in this tribal-domi-
nated district, which votes
on May 13 in the fourth
phase of the election.
She faces Dr. Heena Vi-
jaykumar Gavit (BJP) and
Gowaal K. Padavi (Con-
gress). Ms. Gavit is the in-
cumbent and two-time MP
from the seat.
Talking to The Hindu
from Bhangarpada village
in the Akkalkuwa taluka,
Ms. Vasave said she is hap-
py that her party’s recently
finalised symbol is an ‘au-
torickshaw’. “An autorick-
shaw does not discrimi-
nate among its
passengers,” she said.
Belonging to the Bhil
Nirmala Vasave, striving for
change. PURNIMA SAH
community, her family
comes from an agricultural
background. “My family is
supportive of what I do,”
Ms. Vasave said. Her fami-
ly, including her mother
and nine siblings (five sis-
ters and four brothers), are
engaged in farming and
grow mahua, bhagar (bar-
nyard millet), jowar (sorgh-
um), bajra (pearl millet),
maize and pulses.
In 2006, she worked for
two years with Medha Pat-
kar in the Narmada Bachao
Andolan movement.
A postgraduate in social
work, Ms. Vasave founded
the Nirmal Adivasi Charita-
ble Trust to address tribal
community issues. Her
manifesto focuses on the
core issues of the district
such as migration, malnu-
trition, sickle cell anaemia,
maternal and child mortal-
ity, water crisis, displace-
ment of people, and
connectivity.
Also associated with
Ekal Mahila Sangathan, a
programme run by NGO
CORO-India that empow-
ers women in rural Maha-
rashtra, Ms. Vasave said
she would strive for 50%
reservation for women in
government jobs. Current-
ly, she is pursuing an LLB
from Jamia College of Law,
Akkalkuva, Nandurbar.
“Our party will work to
stop migration and create
jobs within our district. We
want special recognition
for Adivasis by forming a
separate State: ‘Khandesh’
(areas in the northwestern
corner of Maharashtra), of
which Nandurbar will be
the capital. This way Adiva-
si schemes will reach peo-
ple faster,” she added.
She said the tribal popu-
lation feels their votes are
not taken seriously. “For
political parties, the value
of our vote is zero because
we neither matter nor exist
for them.”
“There are 250 schemes
for tribal communities, not
even one is in use. We want
to make sure they are im-
plemented,” she added.

Timings
DELHI
BJP workers resign over Thane
FRIDAY, MAY. 03 Lok Sabha seat going to Sena
RISE 05:39 SET 18:58
RISE 02:27 SET 13:52 Some BJP workers from Navi Mumbai and
SATURDAY, MAY. 04 Mira-Bhayander have resigned over the nomination of
RISE 05:39 SET 18:59 Naresh Mhaske of the Shiv Sena as the Mahayuti
RISE 03:03 SET 14:58 candidate for the Thane Lok Sabha seat. Chief Minister
SUNDAY, MAY. 05 Eknath Shinde had announced the nomination, causing
RISE 05:38 SET 18:59 dissatisfaction among the BJP members, who felt former
RISE 03:36 SET 16:04
MP Sanjeev Naik was a ‘better candidate’.

CM M ND-NDE
YK
 THE HINDU
4 Friday, May 3, 2024

States Delhi

INBRIEF
쑽 Modi says Pakistan eager BJP fields Brij
to see Rahul Gandhi as PM Bhushan’s son
At four back-to-back rallies in his home State ahead of the May 7 election in Gujarat, Modi claims
from Kaiserganj
‘Congress was dying and Pakistan was crying’, takes a dig at ‘vote jihad’ remark by SP leader The Hindu Bureau
LUCKNOW
The Hindu Bureau deceased), the CM of the
AHMEDABAD State. The Bharatiya Janata Party
Cong. wants Karnataka quota rime Minister Na-
In Junagadh, the PM said
if Sardar Patel was not pre-
(BJP) on Thursday an-
nounced the candidature
model for the country: Dhami
Uttarakhand Chief Minister Pushkar Singh Dhami
P rendra Modi on
Thursday said Pa-
kistan was eager to see Con-
sent, Junagadh would have
gone to Pakistan, bringing
up the issue of the then Ju-
of Karan Bhushan Singh,
son of six-term MP Brij
Bhushan Sharan Singh,
on Thursday accused the Congress of aiming to gress leader Rahul Gandhi nagadh Nawab’s assertion from Kaiserganj Lok Sabha
replicate the Karnataka reservation model become the Prime Minister to make it a part of Pakistan seat and U.P. Minister Di- Karan Bhushan Singh
nationwide and claimed that a specific of India. “The enemies of during Independence. nesh Pratap Singh from
community in the southern State was added to the nation, including Pakis- Mr. Modi also took a dig Rae Bareli. The move drew choice, accusing the ruling
the OBC list overnight. Addressing an election tan, want a weak govern- at the “vote jihad” remark criticism from Opposition party of rewarding Mr. Brij
rally in ranchi in support of BJP nominee for the ment in India. They want a Prime Minister Narendra Modi during an election rally in Gujarat’s by Congress leader Salman parties. Bhushan. “Just when we
seat, Mr. Dhami urged people to vote for the BJP corrupt government which Surendranagar on Thursday. VIJAY SONEJI Khurshid’s niece and Sa- While the ruling party thought that the Prajwal
to protect the country from corruption, was there before 2014. Mo- majwadi Party leader Maria denied the ticket to Mr. Brij Revanna scandal [in Karna-
appeasement and dynastic politics. “At a time di’s strong government ised sections”. “When Con- In central Gujarat’s Alam during a recent rally Bhushan, the former Wres- taka] had exposed the
when the country is moving towards the Uniform does not bow down to gress released its manifes- Anand, the Prime Minister in Uttar Pradesh. He said tling Federation of India depths of the BJP’s deprav-
Civil Code, the Congress says it will implement anyone,” Mr. Modi said in to, I alerted the country... I said the Congress was “dy- that the country had heard chief accused of sexually ity, they show that there
Muslim Personal Law,” he said. PTI Gujarat, where voting will could see the image of the ing and Pakistan was cry- of “love jihad” but now a harassing women wres- are always new lows for
take place on May 7. Muslim League in their ma- ing”. “You all might have Congress leader has talked tlers, sources said he was them to fall to,” Congress
The Prime Minister’s nifesto,” he said in his ad- known by now that Pakista- about “vote jihad” to defeat consulted about his leader Jairam Ramesh
ffa76243-386b-4d4d-93fa-f34e5b20443d

ffa76243-386b-4d4d-93fa-f34e5b20443d
statement came a day after dress in Jamnagar. ni leaders are praying for Lord Ram. replacement. posted on X.
Farmers under SKM banner former Pakistan Minister
Ch. Fawad Hussain shared a
The Congress’s manifes-
to for the Lok Sabha poll
the Congress’s victory... to
make the Shehzada [refer- Kshatriya anger
Mr. Karan Bhushan’s el-
der brother Prateek Bhush-
“The BJP’s slogans of
Nari Shakti, Nari Samman
at odds with Kangana Ranaut video featuring Mr. Gandhi does not talk about reli- ring to Rahul Gandhi] of In Jamnagar, the PM called an Singh is a BJP MLA. His and Beti Bachao are all hol-
on X (formerly Twitter) gion-based reservations for Congress the PM of India.” on the former royal family mother Ketki Devi Singh is low, shallow, meaningless
Groups of farmers and horticulturists in with the caption, “Rahul any community. Mr. Modi, who has also member Shatrusalyasinhji a former MP from Gonda. and bogus,” said Trina-
Himachal Pradesh are up in arms against Gandhi on fire”. References to Pakistan in served as the Chief Minister Jadeja. The meeting was The family is influential in mool Rajya Sabha MP Saga-
actor-turned-politician Kangana Ranaut, who is Addressing election ral- the poll campaign and eq- of the State for 13 years, had seen as a bid to pacify the Gonda and nearby dis- rika Ghose.
contesting the Lok Sabha election from Mandi as lies in four different Lok uating the Opposition party in past elections as well eq- Kshatriya community, tricts. The BJP’s pick will Mr. Dinesh Pratap, a lo-
a Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) candidate. The Sabha seats — Anand, Su- with the neighbouring uated the Opposition party which is on the warpath contest against Narendra cal Rajput leader who con-
Samyukt Kisan Manch (SKM), an amalgamation rendranagar, Junagadh and country was reminiscent of with the neighbouring with the ruling party over Pandey of the Bahujan Sa- tested unsuccessfully
of over two dozen farmers’ and horticulturists’ Jamnagar — in his home the campaign during the country and accused it of the controversial remarks maj Party; the Samajwadi against Congress leader So-
outfits of the State, has asked Ms. Ranaut to be State, the Prime Minister run-up to the 2017 Assemb- doing “appeasement polit- by the BJP’s Rajkot candi- Party is yet to declare its nia Gandhi in the 2019 par-
ready to face farmers’ ire or apologise for her reiterated his claim that the ly poll in Gujarat, when Mr. ics”. In 2012 and 2017 As- date and Union Minister candidate for Kaiserganj. liamentary polls, was re-
alleged derogatory remarks during their Congress intends to create Modi had accused former sembly polls, Mr. Modi had Parshottam Rupala about The Congress, Trina- peated again by the BJP
year-long protests against the now-repealed farm reservations for Muslims in PM Manmohan Singh of said that if voted to power, former princely families mool Congress and Shiv even as the Opposition par-
laws. “We will oppose BJP candidate Kangana government jobs and edu- “holding a secret meeting the Congress would make and their alliances with the Sena (Uddhav Balasaheb ty is yet to announce its
Ranaut from Mandi, Sanjay Chauhan, cation “by snatching away with diplomats of Pakistan Ahmed Patel, its veteran British during colonial Thackeray) criticised the candidate for Rae Bareli.
co-coordinator of SKM, said on Thursday. the rights of the marginal- to conspire” against him. leader from Gujarat (now times. BJP for its Kaiserganj (With inputs from PTI)

Man arrested
for ‘sharing’
Priyanka promises reforms for tribals in Illegal mining in the PDP candidate
reaches out
fake video of biodiversity-rich areas of Chhattisgarh Aravali range must to families
Adityanath The Hindu Bureau elephant attacks [man-ani- hi did not inherit wealth
stop: Supreme Court with kin in jail
RAIPUR/BHOPAL mal conflict] have been but the sense of martyr-
The Hindu Bureau more frequent. Your envi- dom from his mother and The Hindu Bureau part of the range. Justice Peerzada Ashiq
LUCKNOW Making a pitch for tribal ronment is being des- ex-PM Indira Gandhi. “Mo- NEW DELHI Oka said the classification SRINAGAR
votes in Chhattisgarh, se- troyed. Which ever big in- diji cannot understand the was “very problematic”.
The Special Task Force nior Congress leader Pri- dustrialist is coming here is sense of martyrdom,” she The Supreme Court on “Aravali is the only geo- Peoples Democratic Party
(STF) of Uttar Pradesh pol- yanka Gandhi Vadra on getting whatever he needs, said as she refuted the Thursday said illegal min- graphical feature that stops (PDP) candidate Waheed
ice on Thursday arrested a Thursday alleged that at- be it land or mines, but you Prime Minister’s allega- ing in the Aravali range in dry winds from coming to ur Rehman Parra, contest-
person for allegedly post- tempts were being made to do not get it,” she added. tions that Rajiv Gandhi had Rajasthan must stop. “Ille- the Gangetic Plains — dry ing from the Srinagar Lok
ing an Artificial Intelli- muzzle the anti-mining In her speech, Ms. Vadra axed the inheritance law gal mining in Aravali has to winds that come from Af- Sabha seat, on Thursday
gence-generated “deep- movement in the Hasdeo also highlighted the Con- when he became PM to stop. What action have you ghanistan and Pakistan. reached out to families that
fake” of U.P. Chief Minister Aranya region, even as she gress “guarantees” for the avoid paying tax. taken against illegal mining Aravali is a natural barrier. have relatives in jails and
Yogi Adityanath. promised reforms for tri- welfare and empowerment Morena is part of the and officials who are per- If we lose the Aravali, we pledged to fight for a “jail-
The Additional Director bals if her party returned Cong. leader Priyanka Gandhi of the tribal communities. Gwalior-Chambal region in mitting this activity?” Jus- invite the arid, dry climate free and cases-free”
General of Police and head to power at the Centre. Vadra in Chhattisgarh’s Korba “We want to implement M.P. that sees many youth tice B.R. Gavai, heading a to enter from Afghanistan Kashmir.
of U.P. STF Amitabh Yash Mining and related de- on Thursday. PAWAN KUMAR the Forest Rights Act, this joining the forces. Special Bench with Justice and Pakistan,” Mr. Para- “I understand the plight
said the fake video was forestation has been a con- is our guarantee. There “How do I explain (to A.S. Oka, told Solicitor meshwar said. of the incarcerated youth
used to spread misleading tentious issue in the biodi- dustrialists in Hasdeo but will be a specific budget myself ) when Modiji calls General Tushar Mehta, ap- The lawyer said the in Kashmir. There is a need
facts and strengthening an- versity-rich areas in the tribals were getting and plan setting aside mo- my father a traitor, when pearing for Rajasthan. court in November 2023 to make their pain heard at
ti-national elements. tribal-dominant Chhattis- nothing. ney for work that can be Modiji says that my father The court’s amicus cu- had taken note of palaeo- the national level,” Mr. Par-
“On May 1, an AI-gener- garh. Resumption of min- “Today, your protest site done for you. The amend- changed some law to get riae, advocate K. Para- lithic findings in the Aravali ra said while canvassing in
ated deepfake video of the ing in recent months have is being burnt,” she said, ments that these people the inheritance from his meshwar, urged the court and directed the Archaeo- once militant-dominated
U.P. Chief Minster went vi- resulted in protests, and referring to a recent case of have made in the land ac- mother? Modiji will not un- to order a stop to fresh logical Survey of India to pockets of Pulwama and
ral after it was posted on X triggered a political blame arson in which unidenti- quisition law, which are derstand that my father mining leases. protect the site, which Budgam.
from a handle. The video game between the ruling fied individuals allegedly mostly weakening you, we did not get money and He said the Rajasthan could even be part of na- Mr. Parra faced jail for 19
was used to spread mis- Bharatiya Janata Party and set ablaze the protest site will remove those amend- wealth but shahadat ki government was trying to tional heritage. months under Sections of
leading facts,” Mr. Yash the Congress. of the Hasdeo Aranya Jun- ments,” she said. bhavna (feeling of martyr- pull wool over the eyes of Justice Oka pointed to the Unlawful Activities Pre-
added. Speaking at a rally in the gle Bachao Andolan in dom) as inheritance. You the court by considering apprehensions over cli- vention Act, and was re-
The accused, Shyam mining town of Chirmiri, Surguja. Rally in M.P.’s Morena can understand this as you only those mountains mate change. leased on bail by the J&K
Kishor Gupta, was arrested part of the Korba Lok Sab- “Your trees are being Later addressing a rally in have sent your sons to the which were 100 metres or Mr. Mehta said a meet- High Court in 2022. He
and further legal action is ha constituency, Ms. Vadra cut, more than 15,000 Morena, Madhya Pradesh, border and they attain more in height as part of ing had been scheduled on promised to fight for “ge-
being initiated according to alleged that resources were trees have been cut. Be- Ms. Vadra said her father martyrdom for this coun- the Aravali Range; it did May 7 and May 8 to review nuine aspirations” and
the law, Mr. Yash said. being handed over to in- cause trees are being cut, and former PM Rajiv Gand- try,” Ms. Vadra said. not treat shorter hills as the situation. “seek amnesty”.

‘Strong desire for change in Odisha, lack of performance has fuelled discontentment’
BJD run by group of bureaucrats, heavily dependent on imports from Congress, lacks strong leadership and grassroots support, says the Union Minister and BJP candidate for the Sambalpur LS seat

campaigning in Sambal- the reins of Odisha. Be- migrations of labour in the seats. We are going to form Assembly constituency re- lack of strong leadership
INTERVIEW pur, he spoke about how coming a people’s repre- country. This is also a mat- the next government. presented by the CM, has and grassroots support.
the BJD is putting Odia cul- sentative is altogether a dif- ter of Odia Asmita. become the focal point of The party seems to be rely-
Dharmendra ture in jeopardy, the lack of ferent issue. Today, who is Where does this distress migration. Indivi- ing heavily on imports
basic facilities in villages, the No. 1 star campaigner The BJP is facing confidence stem from? duals from Ganjam, the from the Congress, with
Pradhan and rising unemployment of the BJD? A non-Odia. criticism for not home district of Mr. Pat- few remnants of the iconic
levels causing large-scale Whose photographs figure mentioning Odia pride Our interactions with peo- naik, can be seen across Biju Patnaik era within its
Satyasundar Barik migration from the State. in all its campaign posters? and refraining from ple across the State re- various industrial areas in ranks. The BJD is run by a
Edited excerpts: That of a non-Odia. criticising the BJD vealed a strong desire for the country, often under- group of bureaucrats and
nion Education Mi- during alliance talks. change. Despite being in taking low-paying jobs. there is massive resent-

U nister and BJP lead-

er Dharmendra
Pradhan, who has entered
PM Narendra Modi and
BJP president J.P. Nadda
have raised the issue
Dharmendra Pradhan greets
supporters during an election
What are the major
issues in this election? When it comes to Odia As-
mita and the future of the
power for over two de-
cades, the government’s
lack of performance has
How confident are you
of victory?
ment within the party.

This election, the usual

the electoral fray after a Odia Asmita (pride) in a rally at Deogarh in Sambalpur An analysis of the health of State, the BJP has never fuelled discontentment. excitement among
gap of 15 years, filed his veiled reference to V.K. constituency. BISWARANJAN ROUT mothers and children compromised on fighting Sambalpur is the cultural voters is missing. Does
nomination papers to con- Pandian, close aide of shows 60% of them are against the present govern- The CM will be and political hub of west- the hot summer have a
test the Lok Sabha election CM Naveen Patnaik, Odia culture is in jeopardy. anaemic. Odisha’s villages ment nor does it intend to contesting from ern Odisha. The BJP had role in this?
from the Sambalpur con- assuming a greater role lack drinking water and do so in future. Kantabanji in western laid down its organisation-
stituency in Odisha on in the BJD. Aparajita Sarangi and diarrhoea is spreading in Odisha, which is your al roots long before the in- I don’t agree with this. I
Thursday. The seat, which Ashwini Vaishnaw, two March and April. There is What is your stronghold. Will it affect ception of the BJD. Howev- have been touring different
goes to polls in the sixth There is an attempt to cap- former IAS officers and no semblance of irrigation assessment of the your prospects? er, the BJD appears to be parts of the State. There is
phase on May 25, will see ture a political process by a ‘outsiders’, are holding in most parts of the State election result? struggling with nominating unprecedented excite-
Mr. Pradhan take on Na- non-Odia-speaking former key positions in the BJP. and the health system has Not at all. Unemployment candidates for the seven ment. People are attending
gendra Pradhan of the bureaucrat in a State collapsed. Schools lack We are going to win all 21 has reached critical levels, Assembly constituencies public meetings despite
Congress, and the BJD’s formed on the basis of lan- The difference is that they teachers. Odisha records Lok Sabha seats and a ma- leading to a significant exo- under the Sambalpur Lok temperatures soaring
Pranab Prakash Das. While guage. The PM rightly said are not going to take over one of the highest distress jority of the Assembly dus of people. Hinjili, the Sabha seat. This shows beyond 44 degrees Celsius.
Published by Nirmala Lakshman and Printed by S. Ramanujam at HT Media Ltd. Plot No. 8, Udyog Vihar, Greater Noida Distt. Gautam Budh Nagar, U.P. 201306, on behalf of THG PUBLISHING PVT LTD., Chennai-600002. Editor: Suresh Nambath (Responsible for selection of news under the PRP Act).
ISSN 0971 - 751X

CM M ND-NDE
YK
 THE HINDU
Friday, May 3, 2024 5
Delhi
States

Heat prompts Kerala to close all Bengaluru

records
Budgam youth held,
was planning to join
educational institutions till May 6 41.1 degrees
Celsius IS-inspired terror
Meeting of State Disaster Management Authority, chaired by CM, asks schoolchildren to avoid holiday classes from 11 a.m.
to 3 p.m; workplaces with asbestos and tin sheet roofs should be closed during the day; heatwave to continue in the State The Hindu Bureau
BENGALURU
group: J&K Police
The Hindu Bureau keep away from direct sun- ert for the State. The agen- The Karnataka State Natu-
THIRUVANANTHAPURAM light between 11 a.m. and 3 cy is also considering a ‘hot ral Disaster Management The Hindu Bureau Police said he was
p.m. Those working under day’ alert for the State after Centre (KSNDMC) district- SRINAGAR part of many
ith tempera- the sun like construction temperatures soared to un- wise minimum and maxi-

W ture staying un-

usually high in
the State, a meeting
chaired by Kerala Chief Mi-
nister Pinarayi Vijayan on
Thursday decided to sus-
pend classes in all educa-
tional institutions, includ-
ing professional colleges,
till May 6. The online meet-
ing of the State Disaster
Management Authority,
which was also attended
by Collectors, assessed the
possibilities of heatwaves
in the State and issued in-
structions to mitigate the
impact of the heat.
ffa76243-386b-4d4d-93fa-f34e5b20443d
Scorching heat: A man uses a cardboard box to shield himself from
the sun, in Kochi on Thursday. THULASI KAKKAT
liday classes from 11 a.m. to
3 p.m. Daytime parades
and drills should also be
avoided at training centres
of the police, Fire and Res-
cue Services and other
dets and so on. With the In-
dia Meteorological Depart-
ment (IMD) continuing to
issue a yellow alert for
heatwaves for Alappuzha,
Palakkad, Thrissur, and
workers, farmers, and
hawkers should resche-
dule their work timings.
Workplaces roofed with as-
bestos and tin sheets
should be closed during
the day. Workers living in
these types of roofed hous-
es should be shifted, said
Mr. Vijayan.
‘Warm night’
With daytime tempera-
tures remaining unusually
high and giving the people
a harrowing time, the India
Meteorological Depart-
ment (IMD) has issued a
precedented levels.
V.K. Mini, Director in-
charge, IMD, Kerala, says
normally warm night is de-
clared when the maximum
temperature remains
equal to or above 40 de-
grees Celsius and the mini-
mum temperature departs
from the normal by 4.5 to
6.4 degrees Celsius.
Meanwhile, one more
person died due to sun-
stroke in the State. Vijeesh,
a native of Kozhikode, suf-
fered sunstroke on Satur-
day, and died in hospital
on Thursday. Two indivi-
mum temperatures record-
ed from 8.30 a.m. on Wed-
nesday to 8.30 a.m. on
Thursday showed that Ben-
galuru Urban recorded a
maximum of 41.1 degrees
Celsius.
Many parts of Bengalu-
ru received rain on Thurs-
day evening after a
parched five months and
seven days. The IMD fore-
cast for Bengaluru City is-
sued on Thursday states
that for the next 36 hours,
the maximum and mini-
mum temperatures very
likely will be around 39 de-
The J&K Police on Thurs-
day said it arrested a local
youth from Budgam “who
was about to join terrorist
ranks on the motivation of
some Pakistan-based terro-
rist handlers”.
“One hard-core and rad-
icalised individual, Wa-
seem Ahmed Shaikh, from
Beerwah, Budgam, was
about to join terrorist
ranks on the motivation of
some Pakistan-based terro-
rist handlers. However,
the Counter Intelligence
Kashmir (CIK) has man-
aged to arrest him,” it said
WhatsApp and
Telegram groups,
associated with
terrorist outfits
washed and cultivated a
few committed hybrid over
ground workers in Kash-
mir valley and they in con-
nivance with Pakistani ter-
rorist handlers were
planning a terrorist re-
cruitment drive in the
valley”.
The police said the ar-
rest has resulted in busting
of a terrorist recruitment
module of the AuGH terro-

The meeting instructed
schoolchildren to avoid ho-
forces, National Cadet
Corps, Student Police Ca-
Kozhikode districts, Mr. Vi-
jayan urged residents to
‘warm night’ forecast
along with a heatwave al-
duals succumbed to heat
stroke in the State earlier.
grees Celsius and 25 de-
grees Celsius, respectively.
in a statement.
The police investigation
suggested that the arrested
youth “was a part of many
WhatsApp and Telegram
ffa76243-386b-4d4d-93fa-f34e5b20443d
rist outfit. “Several youths
have been saved from join-
ing terrorism,” the state-
ment added.
The J&K Police urged

Railways deletes reference to loco pilots watching cricket
S. Vijay Kumar
CHENNAI
The Railway Ministry has
deleted the reference
made to loco pilots “en-
grossed in watching a
cricket match on their mo-
bile phones” in the Vizia-
nagaram train accident in
safety circulars issued later
which banned the crew
from using Bluetooth
headsets, official sources
said on Wednesday.
The issue pertains to
Union Railway Minister
Ashwini Vaishnaw’s state-
ment made in New Delhi
on March 3, 2024, that the
accident “happened be-
cause both the loco pilot
and co-pilot were distract-
ed by the cricket match
which was going on.”
He was referring to the
rear-end collision between
Train No. 08504 Visakha-
patnam-Rayagada Passen-
ger with Train No. 08532
Visakhapatnam-Palasa Pas-
senger between Kantaka-
palle and Alamanda rail-
way stations in Waltair
Division of East Coast Rail-
way in Andhra Pradesh on
October 29, 2023, which
left 17 people, including
the loco pilot and his assis-
tant, dead and 34 injured.
After The Hindu pu-
blished the report “Loco
pilots were not watching
cricket at time of crash”
based on the final inquiry
report of the Commission-
er of Railway Safety (CRS)
on Saturday, the Minister
clarified that the findings
of the CRS would be final.
There was tentative initial
possibility that the loco pi-
lots may have been dis-
tracted at the time of the
accident, he said.
Soon after Mr. Vaish-
naw’s statement, the Rail-
ways issued circulars ban-
ning the crew from using
Bluetooth headsets while
The spot of the rail accident in
A.P.’s Kantakapalli.
on duty. In a circular, the
Southern Railway ex-
pressed shock that the
crew members were en-
grossed in watching a
cricket match on their mo-
bile phones, facilitated by
the use of Bluetooth devic-
es of headphones. “This
blatant disregard for safety
protocols is utterly unac-
ceptable and places count-
less loves at grave risk,” it
said in a circular.
In a similar circular the
South East Central Railway
said, “Disturbingly, it was
revealed that the crew
members were distracted
by watching a cricket
match on their mobile
phones, facilitated by the
use of Bluetooth devices or
headphones. This egre-
gious disregard for safety
protocols is unacceptable
and puts countless lives at
risk,” the circular said.
But with no evidence
forthcoming later in the
mobile data usage analysis
to substantiate the allega-
tion that the loco pilots
were watching cricket and
the final investigation re-
port of the Commissioner
of Railway Safety not mak-
ing any mention about the
same, the Railways have
recalled the safety circu-
lars, the sources said.
The railways have with-
drawn the circular and is-
sued a fresh circular after
deleting the portions refer-
ring to the loco pilots
watching cricket.
groups, associated with
terrorist outfits”.
“Further investigation is
on to identify other mem-
bers of such groups to take
further legal actions
against them,” the police
said.
The police said they had
received an input that ter-
rorist outfit Ansar Gazwat-
Ul-Hind, an offshoot of IS/
ISKP, was trying to re-esta-
blish its base and revive its
cadres in Kashmir.
“One Pakistan-based
terror handler of AuGH,
identified as Hamzah alias
Gazi, has been brainwash-
ing and radicalising Kash-
miri youth to join terrorist
ranks,” the police said.
According to the police,
the AuGH has “brain-
the parents “to keep an eye
on the activities of their
children using social
media”.
Property attached
Meanwhile, the police in
Baramulla attached the
property, including six ka-
nals and 10 marlas land, of
an alleged terror handler
based in Pakistan.
The police identified
him as Adrees Ahmad Mir,
a resident of Singtung Go-
whallan Uri, Baramul-
la. “In the first four months
of the current year, the pol-
ice in Baramulla have at-
tached 46 kanals of land
belonging to 11 terror han-
dlers who are currently op-
erating from Pakistan,” a
police statement noted.

IN BRIEF
쑽
Sea voyage PM should apologise
for seeking votes for
‘mass rapist’: Rahul
The Hindu Bureau
SHIVAMOGGA/RAICHUR

Calling Janata Dal (Secular)

leader and Hassan MP Praj-
wal Revanna, a “mass ra-
Jagan will protect reservation, pist”, Congress leader Ra-
hul Gandhi demanded that
Constitution, says Owaisi Prime Minister Narendra
Modi apologise to the na-
Hyderabad MP Asaduddin Owaisi has backed tion for campaigning for
Andhra Pradesh Chief Minister and YSRCP such a candidate.
president Y.S. Jagan Mohan Reddy, and said that Speaking in Raichur and
he would protect reservation and the Shivamogga at election ral-
Constitution. The AIMIM president was speaking lies on Thursday, Mr. Gand-
at a public meeting late on Wednesday night. He hi came down heavily on
said, “If Jagan Mohan Reddy wins, I am certain the BJP for “supporting
he will continue reservations in the State, and try Prajwal Revanna”.
to protect the Constitution.” Mr. Owaisi had In Raichur, he displayed
expressed his full support for Mr. Reddy, and his a copy of the letter said to
Opposition for Mr. Naidu in the past as well. be written by a local BJP
leader in Hassan to top
leaders of the party about
Water ways: Nearly 160 persons travelled from Lakshadweep to the Mangaluru Old Port, as the passenger shipping service between the the alleged sexual crimes
Modi to campaign for alliance island and the city resumed on Thursday. H.S. MANJUNATH of Mr. Prajwal Revanna and
Rahul Gandhi
questioned why Mr. Modi
shared the dais with the ac-
cused “despite knowing
the facts”. Speaking in Shi-
vamogga, he said: “Prajwal
Revanna’s case is not just a
sex scandal. It is a case of
mass rape.”
“The Prime Minister
should apologise to the na-
tion for campaigning for
him,” Mr. Gandhi said.

candidates in A.P. next week

Prime Minister Narendra Modi will campaign for
the candidates from the BJP-TDP-JSP alliance at
four places in Andhra Pradesh next week. Mr.
Driving schools in Removing exotic plants will ensure
Modi will address public meetings at Anakapalli
and Rajamahendravaram on May 6 and at
Vijayawada and Rajampet on May 8. BJP
Kerala oppose new food for wild animals, finds study
candidates C.M. Ramesh and Daggubati
Purandeswari are contesting for the Anakapalli
licence test format The Hindu Bureau “The Chinnakkanal
and Rajamahendravaram seats, respectively. IDUKKI landscape is overrun by
Similarly, TDP’s Kesineni Sivanath (Chinni) and The Hindu Bureau posing the reforms, boy- West Indian Lantana (kon-
BJP’s N. Kiran Kumar Reddy are in the fray for THIRUVANANTHAPURAM cotted the tests. In Removing exotic plants gini), inhibiting the growth
Vijayawada and Rajampet seats, respectively. Malappuram, members of from forest areas will help of other species and res-
The Kerala government’s a union affiliated to the CI- ensure food for wild ele- tricting access to animals,”
bid to switch to the revised TU barricaded a ground, phants at Chinnakkanal in says Mr. Santhosh.
driving licence test format preventing entry of vehi- Munnar, says a study by According to officials, 19
Congress alleges conspiracy hit a stumbling block on
the first day itself with driv-
cles and candidates. In
Kozhikode, union mem-
the Kerala State Forest Pro-
tective Staff Organisation,
wild elephants, including
two tuskers Chakkakom-
in Mayor-KSRTC driver tiff ing schools across the State bers protested against the an association of frontline pan and Murivalan Kom-
boycotting the tests en decision by wearing black forest officers. pan, five male calves, and
The Congress on Thursday alleged a political masse on Thursday, forcing badges and denying entry A group of ground forest Preventive measures: Wild elephants roaming in a Eucalyptus 12 female elephants, have
conspiracy in the mysterious disappearance of the Motor Vehicles depart- to vehicles and candidates team, including deputy plantation at Idukki’s Chinnakkanal. SPECIAL ARRANGEMENT been confined to the Chin-
the memory card of a CCTV camera on board the ment (MVD) to call off the to a test ground at Chevay- rangers, watchers, and a nakkanal landscape. An
Kerala State Road Transport Corporation test proceedings for the ur. protection watchers team, tary Santhosh P.G. says re- ing. Wild animals, includ- expert panel appointed by
(KSRTC) bus involved in the tiff between day. The MVD, in a circular visited Chinnakkanal re- moving exotic species such ing elephants, are unable the High Court to address
Thiruvananthapuram Mayor Arya Rajendran and Driving schools’ associa- in February 2024, re- cently and interacted with as Acacia mearnsii (black to move through these human-animal conflict in
the bus driver H.L. Yadhu. Alleging serious lapses tions, including unions affi- vamped the driving test local people and pan- wattle) and eucalyptus areas. If these areas change the region has recom-
on the part of KSRTC and the police, Leader of liated to the Centre of In- format by introducing an- chayat officials about steps from forests is vital to ad- to natural grasslands, it will mended reopening the ele-
the Opposition V.D. Satheesan alleged that the dian Trade Unions (CITU) gular parking, parallel to mitigate human-ele- dressing the problems. ensure food and water for phant corridor from Anayi-
memory card could have been deliberately and the Indian National parking, zig-zag driving, phant conflict in the “In many areas in for- wild elephants. The report rankal to Old Devikulam in
removed and destroyed, fearing the crucial piece Trade Union Congress (IN- and gradient test as part of region. ests filled with exotic trees, will be submitted to the go- Munnar for facilitating the
of evidence could weaken the Mayor’s case. TUC), which have been op- the ground test. KSFPSO district secre- no other plants are grow- vernment soon,” he says. movement of elephants.
CM M ND-NDE
YK

6 Friday, May 3, 2024
he waning crescent moon shimmered
T in the alleys of Rajkot’s Chamadia Pa-
ra, traditionally the animal skinning
quarter of the city in Gujarat. Two pol-
icemen accompanied by four gau rakshaks, self-
professed cow custodians, allegedly forced their
way into the courtyard of 60-year-old matriarch
Manju Parmar’s tiny brick house, on April 3.
They claimed to have seized 100 kilos of cow
meat that Manju and her son Mahesh, 25, had al-
legedly stocked in the house. They registered a
first information report (FIR) against the mother
and son, and both were imprisoned under Guja-
rat’s stringent anti-cow slaughter law, Gujarat
Animal Preservation (Amendment) Act, 2017.
Manju and Mahesh belong to the Dalit commun-
ity, traditionally involved in the skinning of dead
farm animals, including cows, in Gujarat.
Until last year, 500 to 600 families involved in
cattle skinning from different parts of Rajkot
worked at the Sokhada dumping ground, 10 kilo-
metres outside the city centre. Today, more and
more skinners are renouncing their jobs, sand-
wiched between an administration that denies
them legal recognition by way of identity cards
and a safe hygienic place to operate, and gau
rakshaks, vigilante squads that threaten to regis-
ter police complaints and have them imprisoned.
The narrow roads leading up to the leather go-
downs in Chamadia Para are difficult to find. On-
ly a local can locate the ramshackle warehouses
on the periphery of the city, hidden behind the
bright windows of silver jewellery workshops
and the dull exteriors of scrap dealers.
ffa76243-386b-4d4d-93fa-f34e5b20443d
The rancid stench of leather hides hangs hea-
vy. The loose limbs and tails of cattle jut out from
corners of trucks in an otherwise carefully co-
vered stock hidden under blue tarpaulin. Every
part of a dead animal is useful: the hide is sold off
to traders who send them by road to Kanpur,
Chennai, and Kolkata; the bones, used for gela-
tine in the food and medical industries, go to
bone mills dotted across Gujarat in Chalara, Juna-
gadh, Bhavnagar, and Vadodara, among others.
Cow horns are transported to Sambhal in Uttar
Pradesh to make toys and buttons.
The meat from the dead cattle is sold cheap in
the grey market, at ₹50 per kilo. “We don’t
slaughter cows. After they die, we skin them and
remove the dead cattle’s meat, which has been
traditionally consumed in poor Dalit households.
It is a cheap alternative to chicken and mutton,
which sell between ₹300 and ₹1,700 per kilo,”
says Ramesh Parmar, Manju’s neighbour, also
from the same community.
In what once was a bustling hub of old ware-
houses stocking piles of cattle hides, there is now
a pall of gloom. There were 10 godowns within a
radius of a kilometre in Chamadia Para, better
known as Rohidaspra, but only four of them now
operate under a shroud of secrecy; six have shut.
The decay of the cattle skinning trade
Until last year the cattle skinners would use their
pick-up trucks to drive out to a farm when a cow
died. “We have a close association with herders
and those that run gaushalas or panjrapole (plac-
es where old cows that no longer yield milk and
young abandoned male calves are taken care
of ),” says Suresh Rathod, 41, whose family has
been involved in the trade for three generations.
Over the past year, Rathod has given up skinning
and now ferries passengers and transports goods
in his vehicles to earn a living.
Traditionally, the District Magistrate allots a
piece of land to cattle skinners known as Charm
Kund in each district, where people, usually Da-
lits, skin dead cattle, goats, and sheep, and carry
out allied activities like scooping out the meat,
dismembering the hooves and horns, separating
the bones, and drying the skin, to send them
down the supply chain.
With rapid urbanisation, the 30 km stretch
along NH27, the Rajkot-Ahmedabad highway,
now engulfs Sokhada and beyond, leading to a
swanky new international airport for Rajkot, in-
augurated by Prime Minister Narendra Modi in
July 2023. The government boasts of construct-
ing a six-lane highway and an All India Institute of
Medical Sciences (AIIMS) hospital in the town.
As a part of the Lok Sabha 2024 poll promises
for infrastructural development, the stretches
adjoining the airport are seeing an escalation of
property rates. The price for this is being paid by
the Dalit skinners, who are no longer allowed to
skin cattle at the Sokhada dumping ground.
“In what we once used as Charm Kund, the
Rajkot Municipal Corporation has erected con-
crete boundary walls. Gau rakshaks in the city
hover around the area armed with steel rods dis-
couraging any skinning activity. They say it hurts
their sentiments,” says Haresh Parmar, who used
to be a skinner until a year ago.
“On the opposite side of the Sokhada dumping
ground, local leaders affiliated with the ruling
party are developing plots for parties,” says a lo-
cal Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) worker. Haresh
says they say the stink is repulsive and unaccep-
table, so animals should be buried whole. There
is a luxury car showroom adjacent to the plots.
Last year, after Haresh had returned home
from work at the Sokhada ground, he was sum-
A worker processing livestock skin in Rajkot, Gujarat. VIJAY SONEJI
CM
YK
THE HINDU
SPOTLIGHT
A livelihood silenced
With rising threats from gau rakshaks and an unsupportive administration, Rajkot’s Dalit cattle skinners are opting out of their
profession. Maitri Porecha travels to Gujarat, to the people who form the backbone of the leather sector and are important
suppliers to the food and pharmaceutical industries
Jitubhai Chavda, a resident of Wadhwan village, Surendranagar, at his cattle bone mill. VIJAY SONEJI
moned to the Taluka police station in Rajkot, and
later hauled into Rajkot central jail, where he was
lodged for three months in an allegedly false case
We don’t that named him as an accomplice for illegally
slaughter selling cow meat. “My bail application was reject-
cows. After ed five times, thrice in the sessions court, and
twice in the Gujarat High Court. I spent nearly ₹2
they die, we
lakh on bail,” Haresh says.
skin them Every 15 days, he presents himself at the pol-
and remove ice station. He cannot leave town and has to
the dead show up at monthly court hearings. “We are be-
cattle’s meat, ing punished for doing our jobs,” he says. If con-
which has victed, Haresh stares at a sentence of up to 10
been years in jail.
Ironically, Rajkot’s BJP candidate Parshottam
traditionally
Rupala, who is also the Union Minister for Fisher-
consumed ies, Animal Husbandry and Dairying, finds him-
in poor Dalit self in the eye of a storm for riling up the senti-
households. ments of Kshatriyas when he said that while the
It is a cheap upper caste community had been in close collu-
alternative sion with the British, the Dalits had not. Rupala
to chicken referred to Rukhi Samaj (a Dalit community) as
the most oppressed and said he “respected” and
and mutton
“honoured” them. Rajkot Lok Sabha constituen-
RAMESH cy has nearly 22 lakh voters, with Scheduled
PARMAR
Former cattle Castes making up a low 6.9% of the electorate.
skinner “Dalit flattery is limited to garnering votes. On
ground the reality is starkly different. We have
been fighting for over a decade for sheltered fa-
cilities at Sokhada dumping ground so that we
can go about skinning cattle hygienically, but
both the ruling party and the administration
have turned a deaf ear to our demands,” says
Rathod.
The crumbling cow economy
Gujarat is among India’s top five milk-producing
States, with a share of 7.49% of milk production
of 230.58 million tonnes during 2022-23, accord-
ing to Basic Animal Husbandry Statistics 2023 re-
leased by Rupala. From a population of over 2
crore cows, ox, and male as well as female buffa-
loes, only half are milk-producing.
“A cow lives for 25 years,” says Haresh Chavda,
manager of Wadhwan Taluka panjrapole in Su-
rendranagar district, nearly 115 kilometres away
from Rajkot city. It gives milk for 15 years, after
which it is deemed redundant. Cattle breeders
find it difficult to maintain non-milch cattle and
leave it at the panjrapole for care, Chavda adds.
Wadhwan’s panjrapole has 4,289 animals in-
cluding cows, calves, oxen, and buffaloes. Up to
20 of them are lodged in a separate hospice, suf-
fering at the end of life. On most days, there is at
least one death here and Chavda dials Jitubhai,
who picks up and disposes of carcasses. For Ji-
tubhai, who has been allotted 2 acres of land on
the outskirts of Wadhwan by the District Magis-
trate under the Charm Kund category, this is
business.
Tax registration certificates and licences un-
der the name ‘Saurashtra Hide Charm Udhyog
Natubhai Parmar, an activist with non-profit Navsarjan,
shows the mound of plastic extracted from cows’
stomachs. VIJAY SONEJI
Villagers dispose of leftover food in plastic
bags. Cows in search of food lick plastic bags
and end up consuming them too
NATUBHAI PARMAR
Activist, Navsarjan NGO
Cruss Bonds’ hang conspicuously on a wall in Ji-
tubhai’s godown, where he employs nearly 50
people to process cattle carcasses.
Motihari resident Bashir, 30, who has travelled
2,000 kilometres from Bihar to work in Jitubhai’s
skinning field, is one of them. In 40-degree-Celsi-
us heat, Bashir makes neat cuts on a dead cow’s
hide, deftly skins the carcass, and hangs it to dry,
within half an hour. “I earn ₹15,000 to ₹20,000
each month through this job. There is no employ-
ment for us back home,” says Bashir. He smirks at
the suggestion of going back home to vote in the
ongoing Lok Sabha 2024 elections. “Who will
earn money then?” he says, sniggering.
A few metres away from the skinning area, Ji-
tubhai has 2,000 to 3,000 pieces of cattle hide in
neat stacks. They are regularly sprinkled with
sacks full of coarse salt to preserve them. But the
market for cattle hide has slumped, he rues. “In
2016-17, we used to get anywhere between ₹400
and ₹500 for one hide; now we sell one at ₹100,”
he says. Many traders in Rajkot and Surendrana-
gar confirmed the slump in the leather trade.
Jitubhai points to a corner of the warehouse
Delhi
where cattle hide is rotting. “In summer, they de-
compose is faster. Only last week I had to throw
away 1,000 pieces as there were no immediate
buyers,” he says. But there is another business,
that of cattle bones, that he is banking on. Behind
the warehouse, hundreds of tonnes of cattle
bones are piled up in mounds, two storeys high.
The mounds open into the mouth of a 50-foot-
long bone crushing machine, which whirs its way
into crushing and separating good quality bone
pieces from bone dust.
Sacks full of what Jitubhai calls ‘number 1 qual-
ity’ are ready to be transported to active pharma-
ceutical ingredient (API) manufacturing factories
and gelatine manufacturing units in Gujarat.
“Each tonne of number 1 quality crushed bone
fetches me ₹25,000. I supply anywhere between
five and 20 tonnes every month,” says Jitubhai.
“Income from the bone mill business is between
₹1.25 lakh and ₹5 lakh a month.” He says after de-
ductions for salaries, electricity, and water, he
ffa76243-386b-4d4d-93fa-f34e5b20443d
makes a profit of ₹50,000 to a lakh a month.
In an adjoining godown, cattle horns are piling
up. “There are no takers for a few months now,”
says Hirabhai Chavda, 68, Jitubhai’s father. Jitub-
hai says he wants both his sons to take up ‘respec-
table’ jobs in cities and earn a stable income. A
few hundred metres from Jitubhai’s bone mill, an
international school campus has come up. He is
scared they’ll shut him down.
Plastic, the real killer
Bashir points at a wobbly sack next to a carcass,
the cow’s stomach. He holds up shredded plastic,
saying it had found its way into the cow’s tummy
when she was alive, grazing near the dumping
ground. Inside the Wadhwan village, a huge
dump of rubbish lies by the roadside, with a do-
zen cows lounging around.
Natubhai Parmar, 47, has installed a statue of a
cow at a road crossing, and put up an exhibit of
60 kilos of plastic bags, which he says was reco-
vered from dead cows’ stomachs in the nearby
skinning fields. “Villagers dispose of leftover food
in plastic bags. Cows in search of food lick plastic
bags and end up consuming them too,” says Na-
tubhai, who works as an activist with Ahmeda-
bad-based non-profit Navsarjan on Dalit issues. It
is worse when cows get pregnant, and have con-
sumed mounds of plastic. “They die in pain as
the plastic blocks their pregnancy. Even their
calves don’t survive,” he says.
In 2017, Natubhai remembers that the entire
Dalit community gathered plastic from dead
cows’ stomachs and filled bits in glass jars la-
belled “This bottle contains plastic extracted
from a dead cow’s stomach; this is the sin of the
Gujarat State Assembly.” They presented a bottle
each to 182 MLAs. Their demands included mak-
ing adequate grazing land available to cattle, so
they didn’t turn to garbage dumps for food.
A history of fear
In 2016, in Mota Samadhiyala village of Una dis-
trict in Diu, five Dalits who skinned dead cows for
a living were lynched by 40 gau rakshaks. The in-
cident was a turning point for the community,
which gave up skinning after the scare in and
around Diu. That year in Rajkot, urban cow skin-
ners like Rathod and Ramesh had, in protest,
dumped cow carcasses in front of the District Ma-
gistrate’s office, because of the terrible condi-
tions at the Sokhada dumping ground.
A few months after the protests, they resumed
work, but last year they too stopped skinning.
“Before last year, we would easily get five or six
dead cattle from across the district for skinning.
This would get us an income of ₹50,000 to
₹60,000 a month from selling skin and bones.
Now, we survive hand to mouth,” says Ramesh,
who picks up dead animals and deposits them in
pits dug by the municipal corporation.
Sidharth Parmar, who is a Rajkot-based former
MLA, says that atrocities against Dalits and
snatching away their right to work primarily stem
from the need to control land. “Our long-time de-
mand for recognising the Dalit right to Charm
Kund land has gone unheard in Rajkot. There are
some Dalits in neighbouring villages who have
become prosperous because of earnings from the
bone mill businesses, but there have been in-
stances of them being dragged out of their bunga-
lows and beaten up by upper caste people who
can’t stand to see them prosper,” Sidharth says.
During his five-year term (2002-2007), he re-
collects having raised the issue of a budget cut of
nearly ₹100 crore in the SC category with Guja-
rat’s former Chief Minister and current PM Na-
rendra Modi. “With increasing instances of injus-
tice against Dalits in Saurashtra and no visible
difference on ground, I got disillusioned by the
ruling government and tendered my resigna-
tion,” he says.
Despite a 2017 notification by the Department
of Social Justice and Empowerment to allocate
identification cards to those involved in skinning
of cattle, Haresh says that he was refused an ID.
“The department said I may misuse it,” he says.
A senior police officer in Rajkot says the police
are compelled to register FIRs and investigate com-
plaints of gau rakshaks. Between 2019 and 2024,
nine FIRs related to cow slaughter and ferrying of
cows have been registered in the district. The mo-
bile van of the Department of Forensics seizes sam-
ples of meat to investigate their origin. The officer
explains that it is up to the court to decide the out-
come. “In my career, I have witnessed actual cases
where cows were being transported with the inten-
tion of slaughter. But Dalits who have been tradi-
tionally involved in cattle skinning should be al-
lowed to do their jobs,” he says.
M ND-NDE

Friday, May 3, 2024
Delhi
In her swansong, the late
writer, curator and artist
Alka Raghuvanshi delved
into various jewellery
traditions to offer an easy
read; the book was
released on her 63rd birth
anniversary recently
Shailaja Tripathi
lka Raghuvanshi, the
A late writer, curator
and artist with an
infectious smile,
spent a large part of her life
propagating art. Delhiites
know well her love for textiles
and her emotional connect
with jewellery. The senior
journalist would always be
spotted with her signature big
bindi and unique jewellery.
ffa76243-386b-4d4d-93fa-f34e5b20443d
Three years after Alka’s
demise, Manisha
Gawade, her sister,
who is also a
designer, and
artist, released
the last book
Alka wrote, A
Rendezvous with
Traditional
Indian Jewellery,
published by
Shubhi Publications.
The book, launched on
Alka’s 63rd birth anniversary
last month, has a lavish
sprinkle of photographs by
seasoned photographer
Avinash Pasricha.
“The first time I saw the
Kohinoor in the Tower of
London, tears trickled down
my face. It was our heritage
that was on display and the
entry fee pinched in more
ways than one,” is how Alka
introduces the chapter on the
Set in a relaxed leafy neighbourhood, Cafe Monique offers home-style crepes, pastry and quiches
A slice of
France in Delhi
Anubhuti Krishna
s someone who enjoys
A her coffee and cake in
beautiful spaces I have
not had much success in Delhi.
A city where the finest bakeries
operate on delivery model and
most cafes run from malls, few
places, if any, suit my need.
Which is why Café Monique’s
opening became an occasion
for celebration. It helped that
the French style café and
patisserie is set in a leafy
neighbourhood far from the
din of malls and markets and
one has to make an effort to
visit it.
Founded by entrepreneur
Shivan Gupta and his partner
Chef Maxime Montay, Café
Monique attempts to bring a
bit of France to India. The
place is christened after Chef
Montay’s grandmother,
Monique, whose recipes are
replicated in the kitchen using
French ingredients.
The dairy, he tells me, is
imported from France and the
chocolates and berries come
from Belgium. “The quality of
STEPOUT
쑺 Celebrating Earth Day
Artist Paramjit
Singh joins five
emerging talents
from Kerala, KP
Prasad, Shaji
Appukuttan,
Sumesh Kumballur,
KP Pradeep Kumar and Sanam Narayan, to
present Paradise Regained, an exhibition as an
ode to our planet Earth. The artworks feature
meticulously painted and detailed landscapes
that create a conversation between form and
content, all cradled in the crucible of earth
studies and as envisioned by the artists
At Palette Art Gallery 14 Golf Links; Till June 1;
11am to 7pm
CM
YK
National Museum
Jewellery Collection and
underlines her innate love
for jewellery.
“She played
an important
role as an art
historian. She
was India’s first
trained art curator
and curated several
exhibitions across the
world... In this book, she didn’t
want to cover jewellery on a
superficial level but dig deep
into why a certain piece of
jewellery is worn in a
certain way. What
are the religious
and marital
connotations of
a piece of
jewellery? She
explains the
socio-economic
levels at which
jewellery plays an
important part in
India,” says Manisha who
curated the book.
From every angle
The book is divided into
different categories: Taking a
leaf out of Nature, ritual
jewellery, jadau jewels from
Avadh, jewels fit for kings,
Nizam’s jewellery, South Indian
jewellery, the National
Museum Collection, silver
accessories and reconditioning
jewellery.
ingredients and the generosity
with which we use them makes
a big difference and elevates
every dish on the menu,” he
explains while talking of the
pistachios he uses in the
signature Le Paris-Brest
Pistache, a traditional
wheel-shaped choux pastry
and La Crème de Pistache, a
pistachio spread and how they
lend the confections richness.
There is a good balance of
savoury and sweet: while
quiches, savoury loaves and
eggs bring novelty to the
menu, choux, pastries, and
tarts offer comfort. We try the
chorizo loaf with indulgent bits
metroPLUS
A jewel
in the
crown
Alka started working on the
book in 2016 and by 2021, she
had finished writing the text.
After her death in 2021,
Manisha had to bring it all
together, write the synopsis,
introduction and the author
profile, as well as match and
place relevant pictures with
the text.
In the book, Alka draws
X through the
Exotic The menu at Cafe Monique is a
good balance of savoury and sweet.
SPECIAL ARRANGEMENT
of sausages in a buttery
brioche, as well as the ham
and baguette sandwich, which
is textured and yet not hard to
chew. The eggs benedict has
just the right amount of
hollandaise and good quality
ham. It is however the Croque
Monsieur that steals my heart.
A quintessentially French
sandwich, it is made with
grated Gruyère, ham and a
rich, cheesy Mornay sauce.
“Chef Montay has worked
hard to bring to our guests
preparations and flavours that
you would not find in India,”
says Shivan, “be it the hot
sandwiches, croque monsieur
쑺 Thematic portraits
Figurative artist Kamal Devanatha
has exhibited his latest art piece
at his 15th solo exhibition Beyond
the Frames. Drawing inspiration
from Nature and the rhythms of
life, there are 55 artworks in
acrylic and oil colours on display.
In his signature style, the artist
has infused his canvases with
vibrant colours and fluid strokes
to draw delicate feminine figures
resonating with joy and
happiness.
At Visual Art Gallery, India Habitat
Centre, Lodhi Road, Lodhi Estate;
Till May 5; 10am to 8pm
THE HINDU
attention to ornaments like the
sarpech — a turban ornament
often sported by grooms. She
describes it saying, “a sarpech
usually consists of two or three
pieces: one is the sir-patti or
forehead band, the other is the
plume and the third is the jigha
or central piece. Three tassels
are provided to tie the sarpech
to the turban and while a
and
mademoiselle, or
the signature
buckwheat crepes, our savoury
dishes are big crowd pullers,”
he adds. The homestyle
crepes, he says, can be made
with a filling of mushrooms
and onion, chicken and
cheese, or salmon and dill
while the oafs cocotte (egg
casserole) comes with options
of mushrooms, peppers, or
ricotta and is served with
toasted homemade baguette.
They serve fragrant coffee in
double walled cups and
exceptional hot chocolate that
is perfect for evenings. For
쑺 Dance fest
Parikrama, Karna and Meera are three
different dance performances
choreographed by Shashidharan Nair
and directed by Shobha Deepak Singh,
to be staged over the weekend.
At Kamani auditorium, Copernicus
Marg; May 3 to 5; 7pm; For passes call
011-43503333/ 23386428/29
Diving into
abstractionism
A sense of minimalism rides through
the Ores of Trance exhibition in Delhi
X
Bespoke ornaments The
kundan kalgi for the Rajput
turban and the jadau choker
from Awadh region; the book
cover; and Alka Raghuvanshi.
SPECIAL ARRANGEMENT
number of kundan sarpechs
still survive, a few jadau pieces
X
Silent presence Exhibits at the Ores of Trance exhibition in Hauz
in emeralds and pearls are still Khas Village. SPECIAL ARRANGEMENT
in the possession of some old
Rajput families.”
Manisha’s personal favourite Abhijay Raj Vaish
is the section on Nizam’s
jewellery, which has some
“T
he power of
fascinating nuggets of history. zero in an
When the collection was artwork should
offered for sale to the never be underestimated,”
Government of India in 1972, it says art curator TK
caused a stir. Harindran, underlining the
“For it was for the first time imperative value of silence
in the history of India that the in the work of
jewellery collection of any Cholamandal artist, S
principality was offered for Bhagwan Chavan. He
sale to the Government. After points to the artwork
nearly 23 years of protracted Shadows of the Palm Trees
negotiations and prolonged that combines warmth and
drama, the jewels, assumed to darkness, using bright
be only a fraction of the acrylic colours. “There is
original treasure, were finally so much happening and
acquired in 1995.” yet nothing,” he says about
Jacob Diamond, the fifth the duality of chaos and
biggest polished diamond in relief presented in the
the world used by the last artwork.
Nizam, Mir Osman Ali Khan as The painting is part of
a paperweight and sarpech the exhibition, Ores of
Kalan Zamrrud Wa Kanval Ba Trance by eight
Awaiza-i-Zamarrud with contemporary artists, who
emerald drops that alone have unravelled the
weigh 300 carats are some of meaning of existence
the other pieces discussed with through non-figurative and
delight by Alka in the book. abstract art. The 15
paintings, curated by
Harindran, give an
opportunity to abstract
artists, especially
Cholamandal artists, to
showcase their work in
Delhi.
summer what works best are Another Cholamandal
the refreshing coolers, which
include a blue pea-lavender
and rose-hibiscus.
artist, P Gopinath has
mounted four small
paintings that add an air of
It is impossible to not depth to themes like
indulge your sweet tooth at freedom, cultural memory,
Café Monique: we try the and mundanity. Refraining
L’Aubéry, an entremet that from representing the
celebrates seasonal mango and physicality of the obvious,
passion fruit. It maybe hard to his works are an aesthetic
imagine how mango, passion presentation led by his life
fruit and chocolate can come experiences. “It is like a
together but together they
dance on your palate.
All cakes,
musician making music,
while maturing with time,”
says Harindran. The stark
confections and colour patterns in the
choux are paintings are reminiscent
made fresh of the symphony that a
musician creates.
day and the Eternal Reminiscence by
savoury Hemraj employs shadows
preparations are to signify vast plains and
made to order. conveys a certain longing
The breezy space reminds for the past. The
you of the quaint cafes of free-flowing images possess
Europe what with its blue and a wind-like characteristic
white palette and quiet portraying a shade of
elegance. Café Monique is also despair for what has gone
an ideal place to work from by. The idea of
during the day, read in peace reminiscence is also
in the afternoon and bring embodied in Un-rectified
your children or parents to in Melodies by Rashmi
the evening. On Sundays their Khurana. “Her memories
buffet offers plenty of options of having lived in Punjab to
for kids and adults. now living in an urban
setting is rendered into this
transfusion,” says
Cafe Monique, at The Manor, 77 Harindran. It is an
Friends Colony West (near engaging painting created
Friends Club); 11am to 11pm; from paper pulp and
Phone 09811012416; Cost for two: represents the petals of her
₹1,500 memories which have no
쑺 Habitat film 쑺 Celestial journey
festival
The 16th edition of the
Habitat Film Festival
features an impressive
curation of 40 feature
films, 10 documentaries,
three short film packages
along with a series of tangible and etheral aspects of
workshops, film making human existence. The show is a
master classes, film book discussions, a captivating odyssey transporting
retrospective segment with films by Kumar viewers into realms where astronomy,
Shahani and an engaging exhibition showcasing earthly elements and spirituality
iconic Hindi film posters and memorabilia from converge in harmony.
blockbuster films from the 1970s. At Rang Mirage Art Gallery, A-58
At IHC, Lodhi Colony; May 3 to 12; Entry free. Log Central Avenue, Gate No.1, Sainik
on to www.habitatworld.com for registration Farms; Till May 20, 11.30am to 7pm
7
boundaries. “Red is the
core colour of my art as it
signifies action,” says
Rashmi who uses only
ffa76243-386b-4d4d-93fa-f34e5b20443d
recyclable material in her
art works.
Akhilesh employs the
non-restrictive nature of
presentation in Black is
Missing, imparting his own
forms of aesthetic
expression of the
Bhimbetka cave paintings
in the Raisen district, of
Madhya Pradesh.
“There is nothing and
then suddenly something
happens. One must not
underestimate the power
of nothing,” says Shobha
Broota referring to her
artwork. She uses
geometrical representation
in warm colours such as
red and green that
converge into unique
expressions to highlight the
subdued mind.
The definitive shape of
this artwork is a contrast to
Jatra by Shridhar Iyer,
which has sparkles of
colours flowing like waves
across the canvas. The
The Ores of Trance
signifies a poetic
fusion where inner
ores are revealed
layer by layer through
a state of creative
trance
theme of agitation is
furthered through the work
of Yusuf whose paintings
show a form of dystopic
struggle through a
nightmarish window. The
seemingly broken windows
have scattered perspectives
accompanied by a dark hue
giving a sense of fear and
desperation to the
presentation.
“The title Ores of Trance
signifies a poetic fusion
where inner ores are
revealed layer by layer
through a state of creative
trance,” says Harindran.
Most of the artists are from
the Cholamandal Artists’
Village, a self-supporting
artists’ commune located
in Chennai credited for the
Madras Movement of Art
while also producing
prominent works in the
abstract school of
depictions.
At Gallery 1000A, G5-39,
Daryacha building, Hauz
Khas, New Delhi; Till May
20; 11.30am to 7.30pm
(Closed on Tuesdays)
In his exhibition, The
Divine Elements,
artist Divyaman
Singh blends the
enigmatic
wonders of the
cosmos with the
M ND-NDE
 THE HINDU
8 Friday, May 3, 2024

Editorial Delhi

The judiciary’s shadow over standard essential patents

Tipping point
With robust GST revenues, the next
government must prioritise reforms
T
here is a possible crisis brewing in
India over the manner in which certain
technology companies are wielding
‘standard essential patents’ (SEP)
against the telecom manufacturing sector in
India. This is a complex policy issue which has
direct ramifications for India’s effort to build a
domestic manufacturing industry for cellular
Taiwan (2017) and $1.2 billion (2018) and another
$272 million (2019) by the Europe Commission.
Not all these fines have been sustained on appeal
but are a useful indicator of how other countries
have responded to the issue from a competition
law perspective.
Prashant Reddy
T. The effect of judicial lethargy and activism
pending the conclusion of these long-winded
trials. For the last decade, the Delhi High Court
has short circuited the entire process by granting
a series of orders requiring manufacturers, many
of them Indian companies, to “deposit” money
with the court in order to continue
manufacturing during the pendency of the trial.
Such “deposit” orders, often running into

R
evenues from the Goods and Services
Tax (GST) crossed the ₹2 lakh crore mark
for the first time in April. The month of
April has usually delivered the highest GST kitty
as it involves taxes paid for activity undertaken in
March, when taxpayers close their books for the
year, scurry to meet tax filing deadlines, and
make adjustments to square off dues sought by
the revenue department owing to oversights or
interpretation differences. With slightly over ₹2.1
lakh crore of gross revenues, last month’s GST
collection was 12.4% higher than the April 2023
tally of ₹1.87 lakh crore, which marked the high-
est monthly intake prior to the latest data set. Mi-
nus the year-end effect, revenues in subsequent
months will moderate so the ₹2 lakh crore figure
may not be the new normal for monthly GST col-
lections just yet. However, assuming the present
momentum of the economy continues and GST
revenue growth persists in last year’s 11%-12%
range, last April’s high of ₹1.87 lakh crore could
well be this year’s monthly average. Bear in mind
ffa76243-386b-4d4d-93fa-f34e5b20443d
phones. So far, the issues of regulating SEPs have
been left to the judiciary, which, as an institution,
has mostly missed the ball.
To begin with, it is important to understand
the importance of SEPs. These are patents that
cover technologies which are adopted by the
industry as “standards”. For example,
technologies such as CDMA, GSM, LTE are all
industry standards in the telecom sector. Such
technological standards are especially important
to ensure interoperability of different brands of
cellular phones manufactured by different
companies. For example, once GSM was adopted
as a standard, all manufacturers had to ensure
that the handsets that they manufactured were
compatible with GSM. Otherwise there would be
no demand for their phones.
Opaque model
The process of setting standards in the
technology sector is largely privatised and
dominated by “standard setting organisations”
is the co-author of The Indian response to the issue has been
‘Create, Copy, Disrupt: characterised by both judicial lethargy and
India’s Intellectual judicial activism at the Delhi High Court. This
Property Dilemmas’ may seem contradictory but a few facts will help
(2017) explain how India landed in this situation.
In 2013, the Competition Commission of India
(CCI), acting on a complaint by Micromax began
an investigation under the Competition Act into
the issue of whether Ericsson abused its
dominant position by demanding extortionate
royalties for its SEPs. Ericsson challenged the
power of the CCI to do so, before the Delhi High
Court, on the grounds that the Patents Act vested
the power to remedy an abuse of patents only
with the Patent Office.
The first round of litigation was resolved in
favour of the CCI by a single judge on March 30,
2016. Ericsson then challenged this decision
before the Division Bench of the Delhi High
Court, where it remained pending for an
astounding seven years until a judgment was
delivered against the CCI on July 13, 2023. The
crores of rupees, before trial, are unprecedented
in the history of commercial law for the simple
reason that there is no provision in the law
granting judges such powers. In addition to being
unprecedented, these orders are also unfair to
defendants because they deprive them of
working capital (which is very expensive in India)
for the entire duration of the trial (which can take
up to eight years).
Yet, such judicial activism has been justified by
the Delhi High Court by invoking its “inherent
powers to do justice”. Such similar logic has been
used in the past by the judiciary to justify activist
measures such as “public interest litigation”. That
the same argument has been used to justify
activism in the name of the oppressed and also in
the name of multinational corporations
demonstrates how specious an argument it was in
the first place.
This judicial activism combined with judicial
delays will have a negative impact on the
government’s attempt to attract more investment

that the average monthly revenues last year were
₹1.68 lakh crore, and before the year began, the
highest monthly collection was seen in April
2022, at ₹1,67,540 crore.
Finance Minister Nirmala Sitharaman has
termed last month’s ₹2 lakh crore-plus GST reve-
nues a “landmark”, attributing them to a strong
economy and efficient collections. This should
put to rest the Centre’s concerns from a few years
ago that returns from the GST regime, now 82
months old, had been underwhelming. No
doubt, sustained action against frauds, such as
fake invoicing, and stricter compliance norms
have helped shore up revenues. With central GST
revenues overshooting last year’s targets, meet-
ing the goals set in the interim Budget for 2024-25
now requires less than 10% revenue growth. For
the next government, the easy part would be to
upgrade revenue targets in the full Budget. The
more critical imperative is to plan and execute
the expansion of the GST net, and expedite the
long-awaited reboot of its complex rate structure
to make it a truly simple tax for consumers and
investors, now that revenue worries are relatively
muted. Incidentally, the BJP’s election manifesto,
which takes credit for ringing in GST, only pro-
mises to make its portal simpler for small busi-
nesses to use. The Congress has assured a switch
to a single, moderate tax rate with few excep-
tions, no levies on farm inputs, and sharing of re-
venues with panchayats and municipalities.
Smart GST reforms, informed by stakeholder
consultations, need to be at the forefront of the
agenda of whoever comes into office, to correct
anomalies that hold consumption back and set
(SSOs) run largely by private technology
companies. Countries such as India with little
innovation in the telecom sector, have very little
influence over how standards are set or how SEPs
are licensed.
Theoretically, the companies which own the
SEPs, gain enormously because every
manufacturer of cellular phones has to licence
the technological standards in question in order
to survive in the market. The lack of alternatives
also means that owners of SEPs can demand
extortionary royalties or licensing terms from
manufacturers that block competition. In
economics, this is called the “patent holdup”
problem. In theory, the SSOs are supposed to
prevent such a scenario by requiring the owners
of SEPs to licence their technologies at a fair,
reasonable and non-discriminatory (FRAND) rate.
In practice, this model of self-regulation by the
technology industry has been marked with
opacity and has failed rather spectacularly, as
evidenced by the record fines that some of these
SEP owners have had to cough up across the
world for engaging in anti-competitive practices.
The largest of these SEP owners, Qualcomm, has
been fined $975 million by China (2015), $873
million by South Korea (2017), $774 million by
Recognise ‘this leave’ as a woman’s right
CCI has appealed against this decision to the
Supreme Court of India, where the matter
remains pending. As a result, India is the only
major economy to not yet investigate the
potentially abusive licensing practices of
technology companies that own SEPs.
While the competition law issues remained
mired in litigation, the Delhi High Court
proceeded to hear lawsuits filed by Ericsson and
other SEPs owners against manufacturers of
cellular phones on the question of whether the
The latter were infringing SEPs owned by the former
government and whether damages were payable. Ideally the
infringement lawsuits should have been stayed
must put in
until the competition law issues were resolved.
place measures The ordinary course of such litigation in most
to regulate countries is for the courts to conduct a trial on
standard the validity of the patents, whether there has
essential been infringement and, if so, the damages
patents before payable. These trials are complex and can take
the judiciary time. For example, one of the early lawsuits filed
by Ericsson against Lava International took eight
causes further
years to be decided in a remarkable judgment,
damage to running into 500 pages, and delivered by Justice
India’s Amit Bansal of the Delhi High Court, recently.
manufacturing The problem, however, is the manner in which
dreams Delhi High Court has granted “interim” remedies
ffa76243-386b-4d4d-93fa-f34e5b20443d
in the manufacturing sector. These measures, by
government, have included payouts to
manufacturers under the “production linked
incentives” scheme for manufacturing in India. It
is worth questioning the rationale of putting
money in the pockets of manufacturers, while
turning a Nelson’s eye to the manner and the
amount of money that is being removed from the
same pockets by the owners of SEPs. More
pertinently, unlike manufacturers who are
investing in India to create jobs, the owners of
SEPs are only taking their money out of the
country.
The case of Europe
It is time for the Indian government to intervene
and put in place measures to regulate SEPs before
the judiciary causes further damage to India’s
manufacturing dreams. India will not be an
outlier if it intervenes. The European Parliament
has already enacted one such set of measures to
regulate SEPs. India, arguably, has a much
stronger case to push for similar, if not stronger
regulatory measures, since it has no say in how
SEPs are selected by SSOs, while also being
compelled by international agreements to enforce
patents of foreign technology companies.

the foundations for the next virtuous cycle of in-
vestment and growth.
Eastern front
Polarisation of votes in West Bengal is
edging out the Left and the Congress
S
ometimes, elections throw up an
acceptance of and solutions to deeply
institutionalised gender biases and
discrimination against women. In the run-up to
the general election 2024, the election manifesto
of the ruling political party in Tamil Nadu, the
Dravida Munnetra Kazhagam (DMK), has made a
promise (under the topic “Women’s welfare”)
that the “DMK will insist that the Union
government enact a law providing menstrual
Tharoor, Congress MP from Kerala, introducing a
similar Bill named The Women’s Sexual,
Reproductive and Menstrual Rights Bill, 2018.
Hibi Eden, Congress MP from Kerala, also
introduced a private member Bill titled The Right
to Women to Menstrual Leave and Free Access to
Rehnamol Menstrual Health Products Bill, 2022.
Raveendran
The Supreme Court of India, early in 2023,
refused to entertain a public interest litigation in
teaches political
Shailendra Mani Tripathi vs Union of India which
legislation. For instance, Japan introduced
menstrual leave in 1947, Indonesia in 1948, and
South Korea. Taiwan and Vietnam have also
implemented paid leave. In relation to the Asian
countries, the progress made by the western
world, except in Sweden and Spain, is still
abysmal. Several international organisations have
promoted menstrual leave as a women’s right.
For instance, an International Labour
Organisation report, in 2003, asked nations to

T
he Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) nurtures
high hopes in West Bengal, where it won
18 of the 42 seats, and 40% vote share in
2019. This dramatic rise from two seats in 2014
gave the party the confidence to present itself as
the principal opposition in the 2021 Assembly
polls, but the Mamata Banerjee-led All India Tri-
namool Congress (TMC) stormed back to power
for a third term. With 77 of the 294 Assembly
seats, and a 38.1% vote share, the BJP came a dis-
tant second. This year, the polling in the State is
spread across all seven phases of the general elec-
tion, and the BJP is pulling out all stops in the
hope it could improve its tally which could also
compensate for any electoral loss elsewhere. The
BJP is keeping the TMC on the defensive with alle-
gations of corruption, the land grab and sexual
assault at Sandeshkhali, and the school recruit-
ment scam. The Calcutta High Court terminated
about 25,000 teacher appointments which is a
shot in the arm for the BJP. The TMC’s campaign
against the BJP is centred on New Delhi’s stop-
page of funds to the State under central schemes
and the Citizenship (Amendment) Act. It is also
banking on its cash transfer schemes such as
Lakshmir Bhandar for women. Highlighting the
issue of women’s safety, the BJP has fielded a wo-
man from Sandeshkhali, the constituency that
saw reports of assault on women.
The BJP hopes to perform better in the dis-
tricts of north Bengal, where it had won seven
out of eight seats in 2019, while the Trinamool’s
focus is more in the southern districts with a high
proportion of Muslim voters. For this, the TMC is
also battling the Left-Congress coalition. The al-
liance may turn out to be a factor in certain seats
in the minority-dominated districts of Malda and
Murshidabad, and the decision of the Indian Sec-
ular Front to walk out of the alliance is likely to
work to the advantage of the TMC. The BJP is
bringing up Ram Mandir, violence during Ram
Navami processions and the illegal movement of
people across the India-Bangladesh border. Po-
larisation of voters on religious lines had helped
the BJP in the 2019 Lok Sabha election and the
Trinamool in the 2021 Assembly polls, edging out
the Left and Congress from the field. The Trina-
mool is also harping on the Bengali identity by
presenting itself as its custodian and portraying
the BJP as an interloper and being insensitive to
the interests of the State. For the BJP, West Bengal
is not merely about winning more seats but is al-
so about expanding its foothold into a region that
claims exceptionalism. Some of the earliest argu-
ments for a Hindu polity had originated in Ben-
gal, and this gives the BJP hope.
CM
YK
science at the
leave to women, emphasizing the journey University of sought direction to the state on menstrual leave; recognise menstrual leave. The World Health
towards gender equality.” This promise has been Allahabad it was of the opinion that it is in the policy Organization recognised a non-governmental
made after a debate in the 17th Lok Sabha, in domain of the government. By December 2023, organisation driven World Menstrual Hygiene Day
December 2023, on menstrual leave, but with no the central government refused to agree on such on May 28 from 2014. However, India’s new code
outcome. a policy, and the Bharatiya Janata Party manifesto on Social Security, 2020, passed by Parliament,
for the general election 2024, the ‘Sankalp Patra which consolidated existing labour laws (yet to be
Legislators and Bills 2024’, has made no mention of it. The Congress notified), has not included the aspect of
In December 2021, S. Jothimani, Congress party’s manifesto for the general election 2024, menstrual leave in its code.
Member of Parliament (MP) from Tamil Nadu, the ‘Nyaya Patra’ has also not mentioned Women labourers in the sugarcane fields of
had introduced a Private Member Bill named, menstrual leave, but under the subject of Maharashtra and agricultural labourers in
‘Right to Menstrual Hygiene and Paid Leave Bill, “Health” has promised that “all employers shall Telangana have been documented to have
2019’, which sought to bring menstrual leave into mandatorily grant paid maternity leave for their hysterectomies as menstrual-related absences
the ambit of the rights of a woman, and a refusal employees”. could endanger their livelihoods. It is time the
of such leave into the domain of The Sexual Mahatma Gandhi National Rural Employment
Harassment of Women at Workplace (Prevention, Progressive Indian States, Asian nations Guarantee Act and laws governing industrial
Prohibition and Redressal) Act, 2013. It also History shows us that some States were ahead of labour and other establishments recognise
sought to impose a penalty for refusal. the times. For instance, the Kerala Sahitya menstrual leave like the way progressive gig
The Bill that envisaged menstrual rights for Academy published work, Kerala in 19th Century, worker platforms such as Swiggy and Zomato
women stipulates that every woman shall be mentions that Kerala was the first (in then Cochin have.
entitled to the right to self-perception of her State) to recognise the need for “ period leave”
menstruation, including but not limited to for students and allowed it during examinations Greater gender sensitivity needed
menarche (first menstruation), menopause, in 1912. In a recent progressive attempt, Kerala Policy solutions to gender inequalities that are
menstrual cycle, primary or secondary has encouraged the use of other menstrual defined by differentiated gender experiences of
dysmenorrhea (menstrual pain). The Bill sought hygiene products and made them available for women owing to socio-cultural and biological
remedies in the form of: rights, including paid A more students. Bihar, in 1992, allowed government reasons will not only ensure equity but also bring
leave for three days; right to leave or absence for pronounced employees two-day menstrual leave. Kerala, in new social change. The instrumentality of public
three days for students above class eight; right to stand by January 2023, introduced menstrual and policy and discussions on menstruation also lies
30 minutes rest twice a day during the menstrual political parties maternity leave to all students above the age of in shattering taboos and creating a
period for employees/workers, and right to on the issue of 18. Other States must be reminded that the gender-sensitive world that is open to issues
menstrual hygiene management facilities and existing laws are not a hindrance for State which are hitherto considered to be clandestine
menstrual leave
equity for all women. governments to go ahead and notify the right to by conservative-gendered social standards. In the
Ninong Ering, who was a Congress MP from will boost menstrual leave. political domain, recognition of the issue by
Arunachal Pradesh, introduced a private member women’s rights On the other hand, many other Asian political parties this election season will be a
Bill on menstrual leave in 2017 (the Menstruation and gender countries have ended the prejudices and major step to promote women’s rights and
Benefit Bill, 2017). This was followed by Shashi equality stereotypes around menstruation using gender equality.
LETTERS TO THE EDITOR
Hill stations, summer rush could board and alight at many of the reservoirs in Local people will be put to her popular singer husband melodies ever. Once while
There is no doubt that their will after ensuring that the Nilgiris are cause for hardship if curbs are A.V. Ramanan, and star at a bus stop opposite a tea
many of the hill stations in these buses operate to all worry. The district has had imposed on vehicular composer Ilaiyaraja, which kiosk, her song, “Aagaya
India, especially in the tourist locations every five cloudless blue skies for movement. This must be catapulted her to Vennilavae”, began to play
South, are facing grave minutes. All private cars long. It is also a fact that thought of in any move to nationwide stardom. Her on the radio in the shop. It
environmental pressures should be left in specific the residents of the Nilgiris impose a cap on the unique voice earned her a was one time when I wished
caused by the massive parking spaces and not will be thought of last when number of vehicles into the special place in the hearts that the bus would reach
influx of tourists. In allowed to operate to these it comes to the rationing of district. of music lovers. It is late as I wanted to listen to
connection with the e-pass points. Chaotic parking of water as the priority is to N.R. Ramachandran, unfortunate that her great the song in full. Her songs
plans for Kodaikanal and vehicles is a very common meet the needs of Udhagamandalam, The Nilgiris potential was not utilised by will live forever.
the Nilgiris, having issue in the hills. The hills commercial establishments. many music composers. T.S. Karthik,
battery-operated mini buses deserve better. J.W. Prabakar, Uma Ramanan R. Sivakumar, Chennai
to all the important tourist T. Murali, Udhagamandalam, The Nilgiris The passing of playback Chennai Letters emailed to
spots in these hill stations, Madurai singer Uma Ramanan is letters@thehindu.co.in
and at a fixed charge, can The peak summer season in deeply saddening (May 2). It Uma Ramanan sang some must carry the full postal
be thought of. Tourists The water storage levels in the Nilgiris is only in May. was her collaboration with of the most soul-stirring address and the full name.
M ND-NDE
 THE HINDU
Friday, May 3, 2024 9
Delhi
Opinion

Does PMJAY need a design change?

are lots of interesting State schemes that are
PARLEY taking care of providing free medicines: Tamil
Nadu and Rajasthan are doing great work in

A
yushman Bharat, the government’s
flagship programme to achieve
universal health coverage (UHC), was
Nachiket launched in 2018. The scheme has
Mor
two inter-related components: health and
wellness centres and the Pradhan Mantri Jan
is Visiting
Scientist, Arogya Yojana (PMJAY) that aims to provide a
Banyan health cover of ₹5 lakh per family per year for
Academy of secondary and tertiary care hospitalisation to
Leadership in over 12 crore families that form the bottom 40%
Mental Health of the population. PM-JAY has issued 34.27 crore
cards. About 6.5 crore have received treatment
and there are over 30,000 empanelled
hospitals. However, over the past year, hospitals
in some States have reported they are owed
hundreds of crores in dues, and some are
reportedly turning away or taking in fewer
PMJAY patients. Does PMJAY need a design
change? Avani Kapur and Nachiket Mor discuss
Avani Kapur the question in a conversation moderated by
Zubeda Hamid. Edited excerpts:
is Senior
Visiting Fellow,
Does PMJAY’s design need to be changed to
Centre for
Policy Research make the scheme more sustainable?
and Founder-
Director, Nachiket Mor: PMJAY was required as there was
ffa76243-386b-4d4d-93fa-f34e5b20443d
The Rajiv Gandhi Institute for Chest Diseases in Bengaluru. THE HINDU
while 43% are private, the rest are government.
There is a belief that a private hospital delivers
better services and so people choose to go to a
private hospital even when they have a public
hospital close to them. It’s possible that this is
not just an assumption: in most places, the
To deliver PMJAY will be difficult until the
public sector is strengthened. This is because
patients will choose to go to an already
overburdened private player.
AVANI KAPUR
coverage, some have been quite low compared
to others, and even within States, the dispersion
of hospitals is skewed. Governance processes
make a big difference. In terms of claim
payments, some States saw a delay of more than
45 days, while others paid the claims faster.
What is also interesting is that there is a
concentration of claims in Andhra Pradesh,
Arunachal Pradesh, Rajasthan, Karnataka,
Maharashtra, and Tamil Nadu. More research is
needed to understand why this is the case.
NM: The issue of delays [in payments] should
not have anything to do with poor or rich States;
these are technology-enabled platforms. The
fact is, in Shravasti district in U.P., for example,
there isn’t enough hospital capacity. This is the
driver of these differences. In most jurisdictions
trying to provide some form of universal
healthcare. India is ranked 67th out of 189
countries in terms of out-of-pocket expenditure.
Also, the Union government is meant to allocate
60% of PMJAY funds, but the amount [it is]
actually spending is less than this. In some ways,
PMJAY was designed to take care of [healthcare
cost] shocks, as inpatient treatments can cost a
lot relative to outpatient treatments. But we
need to think about it in its entirety rather than
looking at it as bits and pieces.
The government said this was a step towards
providing UHC. Would you argue that the
insurance model is not correct for India’s
path towards achieving UHC? Has any other
country been able to achieve it through an
insurance model?
NM: The insurance model, if defined narrowly
as separating the money from the provider, and
not giving budget-based allocations but saying to
the provider that if you perform, then you get
paid — in India, my own belief is that the
insurance model, if restricted exclusively to the
public sector, could have a big impact on its

Foundation for a belief that while the public sector exists and is
Responsive supposed to offer universal healthcare for free,
Governance there were deficiencies in what it could do.
Therefore, there was a need to allow patients to
access the private sector. I don’t think this
scheme was ever designed to deal with
comprehensive universal health coverage or
comprehensive healthcare costs — it is currently
at under 2.5% of total health expenditure. Our
research suggests that if you pool government
departmental expenditure with PM-JAY
expenditure in many States, government health
expenditure may be enough to offer universal
health coverage, including drugs and
diagnostics. The reason we see high
out-of-pocket expenditure in Kerala, for
example, is that the public sector, despite being
well funded, is unable to deliver universal
healthcare. Its primary care is underutilised and
there is enormous waste and inefficiency. I
worry that if schemes are layered on top of a
hospital-centric design, it exacerbates
misallocation of government resources. In fact,
there are distortions now: even a government
hospital that is supposed to give you free care is
now checking whether you’re authorised to
receive PMJAY. Why? Have we created a barrier
now? Because, while a high-income family can
handle a claim rejection or delay, a low-income
family cannot. How can you deliver better
healthcare to people to eliminate out-of-pocket
expenditure? Where can the National Health
Authority (NHA) and the State Health Authority
(SHA), with their ability to purchase care in an
organised, high quality manner, help you? I
think that’s the question we should pursue.
Avani Kapur: Nachiket spoke about the supply
side, and I wanted to bring in the demand side.
It’s interesting that of empanelled hospitals,
chances of getting better quality care in a private
hospital could be higher than in a public
hospital. We have not done enough to increase
belief in the public health system.
Why would the private sector turn away
patients? One, capacity. In many States, the
number of people per empanelled healthcare
provider (EHCP) is really high. In Bihar, it was
over 10,000 families per EHCP. So, you don’t
necessarily have an adequate number of beds
and facilities to be able to cater to that demand.
Two, the delays in claim payments despite the
guidelines being clear about turnaround time.
Three, there are claim rejections too, which
means a hospital takes in a patient, does the
surgery, and then the insurance company rejects
that claim because of documentation errors or a
technicality. Four, the Union government has
put a cap on the amount you can charge for
different treatments. That doesn’t always work
well for private providers.
To deliver PMJAY will be difficult until the
public sector is strengthened. This is because
patients will choose to go to an already
overburdened private player. Of course, private
hospitals charge more and may do unnecessary
procedures, but what is often not spoken about
enough is that there is a burden on them
because the public sector either isn’t performing
or people don’t trust the sector to perform.
How wide is the performance disparity
among States under PMJAY?
AK: Not only do hospitals not exist [in many
parts], but even empanelled hospitals haven’t
been active. In Uttar Pradesh, for instance, 39%
have been inactive since empanellment, and
only 50% have been active in the last six
months. The States’ [performances] vary. In
around the world, there is an obligation for the
insurer to have network adequacy. This means
you can’t offer an insurance scheme unless you
have hospitals nearby. That restriction is not
there in India, so you can offer a card to
somebody even though there is no way for him
to go and claim it. And that is a key deficiency in
much of the northern and north-eastern States.
And that’s where we need to pay attention. The
private sector is unlikely to go to Bastar and
build a hospital. It would have to be led by the
public sector for the foreseeable future.
India’s out-of-pocket expenditure for health
has decreased, but it still hovers around the
47-50% mark, which is much higher than
global average. Do we need to look at a
system where outpatient care, diagnostics
and drugs can also be covered?
NM: We are making an error in equating PMJAY
and health and wellness centres with
government efforts on the healthcare side. The
largest component of healthcare expenditures
are government expenditures through the State
and Centre and they are multiples higher than
what these two schemes are doing. These are
supposed to include outpatient (OP) care: in
fact, the bulk of the expenditure is on drugs and
OP care. Are there governments (in the world)
that have a separate government-financed public
sector and then added an insurance layer on top
of it? I have not seen [this] because it adds to the
fragmentation of the overall health landscape.
And that is something we need to address to
solve the problem of out-of-pocket expenditure.
AK: In the current design and given the fiscal
cost, it may be too much to expect the current
model of PMJAY to cover everything. But there
ffa76243-386b-4d4d-93fa-f34e5b20443d
performance, particularly in the poorer States.
It’s almost become the only way many countries
have delivered UHC, such as Thailand, Turkey,
Vietnam, and Uruguay. India’s current model is
no longer the dominant model. That is what is
exciting to me about the NHA/SHA — we have
the capacity to implement something like this.
But it wouldn’t be in the way you’re thinking
about insurance perhaps, which is indemnity: I
file a claim, I get refunded. Those approaches
are a pathway to bad outcomes. This is the error
Medicare/Medicaid made in the U.S. in 1965 – it
led to massive inflation in healthcare prices. But
with the purchaser-provider split, I would say it
is the only idea that can take us forward, but if
we restrict it only to the public sector and bring
all the multiple pools of money together.
AK: I agree. I don’t think in its current design,
insurance is going to yield what we want it to
yield, which is not just reducing out-of-pocket
expenditure, but also ensuring quality care. A
recent paper on low- and middle-income
countries and health insurance said the issue is
not just whether government subsidy should be
channelled through health insurance or direct
subsidies to public facilities, but how do you
reach a system where you have specific payment
structures and non price mechanisms that can
actually change both provider behaviour and
also patient choice? In its current form, I don’t
think PM-JAY is going to get us there unless we
focus a lot more on the public health system.
To listen to the full interview
Scan the code or go to the link
www.thehindu.com

PICTURE OF THE WEEK

NOTEBOOK

In the grip of a heatwave

The difficulty of learning how
opinions are shaped
During elections, it is a challenge to separate the voter’s own personal
experience or opinion from propaganda

Sobhana K. Nair elsewhere. I did not know whether the

Prime Minister’s comments indicated

E
very time I have travelled to rural
areas in India during elections, I
have run into astute voters who
are aware of every aspect of the candi-
dates in the fray, including how many
times they have switched parties, and
well-versed with the caste equations of
the constituency. This hyper awareness is
helpful for a reporter. It makes our lives
easier when we meet a respondent who
is knowledgeable, eager to engage, and
does not need to be persuaded to speak.
However, the penetration of the Inter-
net and mobile phone has also meant a
surge in disinformation. The challenge
then is to separate the voter’s own perso-
nal experience or opinion from propa-
ganda. Establishing this distinction is es-
sential to understanding the impact of
various election campaigns and what
may influence voter choices.
In the run-up to the 2017 Uttar Pradesh
elections, while touring the western part
of the State, I heard a common complaint
among people belonging to upper castes
and non-Yadav backward communities
against the incumbent government led by
Akhilesh Yadav of the Samajwadi Party.
They lamented that the government had
been building boundary walls for gra-
veyards, even as it took away land from
cremation grounds. Nearly a week later,
Prime Minister Narendra Modi said at an
election rally, “If you create a kabristaan
(graveyard) in a village, then a shamshaan
(cremation ground) should also be creat-
ed. If electricity is given uninterrupted in
Ramzan, then it should be given in Diwali
without a break.” In hindsight, I feel I
should have asked the people whether
their opinion was based on their own ex-
periences or whether they had heard this
CM
YK
that his party had its ear to the ground or
whether he was merely amplifying pro-
paganda that had already been running.
This election, in Churu, Rajasthan, I
found that people feared that reservation
would be scrapped. This time, I asked for
the source. Why did they think reserva-
tion would go? Pat came the reply: they
had heard an election speech of BJP can-
didate Jyoti Mirdha, who was contesting
from the Naguar Lok Sabha seat, on
WhatsApp. Building a case for voting the
BJP and its allies to at least 400 seats, she
spoke of “tough decisions” that needed
to be taken in the “country’s interest”
and that needed constitutional amend-
ments. However, neither her speech nor
the reactions to it from the Opposition,
which has run a consistent campaign
against the BJP saying the “Constitution is
in danger”, mentioned any scrapping of
reservation. I was puzzled.
Then, miles away in Chhattisgarh, I
heard people voicing this fear again. It
was clearly not Ms. Mirdha’s words that
had prompted this reaction in Chhattis- X
garh. When I probed further, the voters Women draw water from a well on a hot day in Kasara, a town in Thane district in Maharashtra. Maharashtra has registered 25 deaths from heat stroke since late March, the
said they had been hearing about reser- highest toll in the past five years. Scientists have linked the early onset of an intense summer to climate change. REUTERS
vation for the last three or four months.
One of them mentioned Mr. Modi saying
in a speech in November 2023 that
among all the “caste groups”, he consi- FR OM THE ARCH IVES A HUNDRED YEARS AGO MAY 3, 1924
dered four the biggest — “the poor, the
youth, women, and farmers.” Mr. Modi’s FIFTY YEARS AGO MAY 3, 1974 adjournment motion to censure the Plaintiff in the box
remarks were a counter to the Congress’s Government on the arrest of Mr. George
demand for a caste census. But the voters Fernandes and other important Railway London, May 2: Sir Michael O’ Dwyer was in the
believed, not without a nudge from the Talks if Ry. strike notice is labour leaders early this morning after a box all Thursday. In cross-examination he
principal Opposition party, the Congress, stormy debate. Mr. L.N. Mishra, Railway denied he had been guilty of tyranny, but was
that if the reality of caste is ignored, then withdrawn: Mishra Minister, vigorously defended the action of the attacked for his opinions by the members of the
so will reservation. Government and said this was done because would-be oligarchy. Sir Sankaran Nair’s book
New Delhi, May 2: By an overwhelming Mr. Fernandes was working for a strike even as was translated and circulated in the vernacular
sobhanak.nair@thehindu.co.in majority, the Lok Sabha to-day rejected an negotiations were going on. by most provincial Governments.
M ND-NDE

10
Text&Context
NEWS IN NUMBERS
The homes destroyed
in Gaza, expected to
be rebuilt by 2040
3.7
in lakh. If the Israel-Hamas
conflict ends, reconstruction
of these homes might last
until 2040, according to a United Nations
report. The Health Ministry reports an
additional 28 deaths from the fighting on
Thursday. AP
Why are Indian spices facing the heat?
ffa76243-386b-4d4d-93fa-f34e5b20443d
Why have countries such as Singapore, Hong Kong and the U.S. announced an investigation into possible contamination of spice mixes sold by MDH and
Everest? How has the Spices Board of India responded? What has the U.S. FDA said?
EXPLAINER
Saptaparno Ghosh
Saumya Kalia
The story so far:
A
t least five countries —
including Singapore, Hong
Kong and the U.S. — have
announced an investigation
into possible contamination of spice
mixes sold by Indian brands, MDH and
Everest. The complaints cite the presence
of ethylene oxide (EtO), a toxic chemical
used as a food stabiliser, beyond
permissible limits. The Spices Board of
India in response has initiated mandatory
testing of products shipped abroad and is
reportedly working with exporters to
identify the root cause of contamination.
Which countries have flagged safety
of Indian spices?
The domino first shook on April 5, when
Hong Kong’s Centre for Food Safety
suspended the sale of three MDH spice
blends (Madras curry powder, Sambhar
masala and Curry powder masala) and
Everest Fish curry masala. The spice
mixes had high levels of ethylene oxide,
the regulator said, and advised
consumers against purchasing these
products. Days later, Singapore ordered a
recall of the Everest spice mix, stating that
it is unfit for human consumption.
MDH has called allegations over EtO
contamination “baseless and
unsubstantiated”. “We reassure our
buyers and consumers that we do not use
ethylene oxide at any stage of storing,
processing, or packing our spices,” the
company said in a statement. It added
that neither the Spices Board nor the
Food Safety and Standards Authority of
India (FSSAI) have received
communication or test reports from
Singapore or Hong Kong authorities.
The U.S. Food and Drug Administration
(FDA), which had previously rejected food
and spice imports from India, told Reuters
that it is “aware of the reports and is
gathering additional information about
the situation”. Regulatory bodies in
Maldives, New Zealand, Bangladesh and
Australia have announced similar plans.
What are the health concerns?
MDH and Everest’s spice mixes allegedly
contain high levels of EtO, a prohibited
pesticide. EtO is a colourless, flammable
gas that was originally intended for
sterilising medical devices. It is used as a
chemical in industrial settings,
agriculture, and as a sterilising agent in
food products, including spices, dried
vegetables and other commodities. The
chemical lends life to the spice industry —
it reduces microbial contamination, and
in turn, extends products’ shelf life.
However, this process is not always
airtight. The improper and excessive use
of EtO may leave behind residues, causing
toxic and even carcinogenic compounds
to form, thus contaminating the product.
One such compound is ethylene glycol, an
ingredient which was found in
Indian-made cough syrups that were
linked to the deaths of more than 300
children in Cameroon, Gambia, Indonesia
and Uzbekistan. Long-term exposure to
ethylene oxide is associated with cancers
including lymphoma and leukaemia,
some evidence shows.
Is there a history of rejections in U.S.?
A scrutiny of FDA’s import refusal report,
for the calendar year 2023, cites at least
30 instances wherein entry was refused
because the products appeared to contain
salmonella. These are agents known to
cause salmonellosis — a common bacterial
CM
YK
Delhi www.thehindu.com Friday, May 3, 2024
● ●
0
The aid pledged to
Lebanon by the
European Union
1.06
in $ billion. The aid is
expected to
strengthen border
control to halt the flow of asylum seekers
and migrants from the small, crisis-ridden
country across the Mediterranean Sea to
Cyprus and Italy. AP
Follow us facebook.com/thehindu
food-borne illness. Other than this, there
have been at least 11 counts of products
being rejected because of misbranding,
adulteration, artificial colouring or
incorrect labelling. The two causes have
existed in combination as well. The report
tabulates Ramdev Food Products to have
had the maximum rejections in 2023
(about 30), followed by MDH (about 19),
MTR (7), Everest (5), makers of Catch: DS
Group (2) and Badshah (1).
In fact, in September 2019, a recall of
MDH’s Sambhar Masala was initiated in
the U.S. after FDA discovered the product
was contaminated with salmonella. The
recall terminated in December 2021.
Another such recall involved Everest’s
Garam Masala and Sambhar Masala, and
Maggi’s Masala-ae-Magic in June last year.
The U.S. Dept of Agriculture had in
February 2022 stated that India and
Mexico were the top sources of
pathogen-based food import refusals.
Their study, from 2002-19, held Indian
imports had the maximum number of
The Myanmar The forest land in the
refugees deported Garhwal division
amid border tensions affected by fires
38 350
Following the 2021 military
coup in Myanmar, India has
completed its first phase of
deportation. Manipur is set to deport 77 Kumar said that there had been more than
people. Thousands of civilians and troops 300 such incidents in the region. 37 people,
from Myanmar crossed the border to India all underage, have been apprehended for
after ethnic clashes. REUTERS setting fire to the forests. PTI
twitter.com/the_hindu
ISTOCKPHOTO
pathogen-related violations. With 5,115
refusals — the figure represented 22.9% of
overall import refusals for pathogen/toxin
related violations.
How has India responded?
On April 25, the Spice Board in India
announced a slew of corrective measures
including initiating mandatory testing of
consignments shipped to Singapore and
Hong Kong and gathering technical details
and analytical reports from the relevant
food and drug agencies. It also sought to
propose corrective measures to the
concerned exporters and initiate
inspections to ensure adherence to
relevant standards. A circular dated April
30 contains guidelines to exporters on
preventing EtO contamination. The
guidelines prescribe norms for testing at
raw and final stages, storage of EtO
treated products and use of alternate
methods curtailing the use of the
chemical compounds. The Spices Board
issued a similar advisory in September
Highest single-day
migrant arrivals in the
U.K. in 2024
711
in hectares. The Chief The illegal migrants arrived
Conservator of Forests in small boats, raising the
in Garhwal, Naresh overall number of crossings
this year to 8,278. The highest-ever figure
in single-day arrivals was 1,295, recorded
on August 22, 2022. AFP
COMPILED BY THE HINDU DATA TEAM
instagram.com/the_hindu
ffa76243-386b-4d4d-93fa-f34e5b20443d
2021, after the EU observed EtO THE GIST
contamination in certain Indian exports.
Furthermore, the FSSAI has directed state
regulators to collect samples of major 쑽
spice brands, including MDH and Everest, On April 5, Hong Kong’s Centre
to test for EtO. for Food Safety suspended the
Activists have called for stringent safety sale of three MDH spice blends
checks of curry powders and spices to (Madras curry powder,
detect and control the use of EtO in food Sambhar masala and Curry
products and ensure proper powder masala) and Everest
implementation of regulatory norms. A Fish curry masala.
recent CUTS report also recommended
updating food safety standards to align 쑽
with global practices, and improving MDH and Everest’s spice mixes
information flow to food industries so that allegedly contain high levels of
they better comply with regulations. EtO, a prohibited pesticide. EtO
is a colourless, flammable gas
Is food safety in India lacking? that was originally intended for
Simi T.B., who works with CUTS sterilising medical devices.
International, a global advocacy group for 쑽
consumer welfare told The Hindu,
notwithstanding stringent food laws in GTRI assessed that if regulators
place, that the recent controversies in China follow their peers in
Hong Kong, Indian exports
“collectively underscore the persistent
could see a “dramatic
nature of food safety challenges across
downturn”. This could affect
various sectors of the food industry”. exports valued at $2.17 billion
One challenge is operational — India’s — about 51.1% of the country’s
diverse food landscape, the lack of global spice exports.
standardised record-keeping and
intentional food fraud may prevent
manufacturers from tracing ingredients
and assessing potential risks which
compromise the safety of the entire food
supply chain. Traceability is particularly
challenging for small and medium sized
businesses with limited resources.
Some are logistic barriers. At least 10
States/Union Territories lack government
or private notified food testing labs, as
mandated under the Food Safety and
Standards Act 2006. These labs are
distributed unevenly across regions; have
insufficient number of food safety
officers; and were found to operate
ineffectively due to resource constraints,
showed the FSSAI Annual Report of
2021-22. FSSAI’s operations often lack
transparency, which “hinders efforts to
meet safety standards”, build
accountability and trust, adds Ms. Simi.
What next?
Delhi-based think tank Global Trade
Research Initiative (GTRI) in a recent note
held, “With nearly $700 million worth of
exports to critical markets at stake, and
potential losses soaring to over half of
India’s total spice exports due to
cascading regulatory actions in many
countries, the integrity and future of
India’s spice trade hang in delicate
balance.” According to the think tank, the
issue demands urgent attention to uphold
the reputation of the entire ecosystem.
Vijoo Krishnan, General Secretary of
the All-India Kisan Sabha explained that
the chain of events could put other small
companies or co-operatives’ exports
under a cloud of suspicion. Importantly,
Mr Krishnan explained that in the event
of potential losses, farmers of such crops
too could find themselves at the receiving
end. “We have instances where
companies have not paid appropriate
prices to farmers even when they were
making profits,” he stated, adding,
“Should the companies make losses now,
it could be used as a pretext to reduce
prices, thus, burdening the farmer.”
GTRI also assessed that if regulators in
China follow their peers in Hong Kong,
and ASEAN based on that by Singapore,
Indian exports could see a “dramatic
downturn”. This could affect exports
valued at $2.17 billion — about 51.1% of the
country’s global spice exports. The
paradigm could further worsen if the EU,
which it states, “regularly rejects Indian
spice consignments over quality issues”,
follows suit. The impact could be an
additional $2.5 billion, bringing potential
losses to 58.8% of India’s global exports.
M ND-NDE

Friday, May 3, 2024
Delhi
FROM THE ARCHIVES
ffa76243-386b-4d4d-93fa-f34e5b20443d
The movies and documentaries that
Satyajit Ray couldn’t film
Ray was always assessing the cinematic potential of literary sources that ignited his imagination. Some of his unfinished projects are well known —
The Alien, A Passage to India and the Mahabharata. But there were many more which only Ray aficionados are aware of
Amitabha Bhattacharya
May 2 was Satyajit Ray’s 103rd birth
anniversary. In this article, dated June 15,
2021, Amitabha Bhattacharya talks about
the ideas and scripts of the legendary
auteur which did not make it to the screen.
atyajit Ray is universally admired
S for his cinematic creations.
However, to understand his
mind, it may be worthwhile to
reflect on the literary ideas that he could
not transform on celluloid. Some are well
known — The Alien, A Passage to India
and the Mahabharata. But there were
many more which only the Ray
aficionados are aware of. Fortunately, the
essays and letters of Ray and his son
Sandip; the biographies by Marie Seton
(Portrait of A Director , 1971) and Andrew
Robinson (Satyajit Ray: The Inner Eye,
1989); Suresh Jindal’s My Adventures with
Satyajit Ray — The Making of Shatranj Ke
Khilari (2017), Nasreen Munni Kabir’s
Conversations with Waheeda Rehman
(2014); and articles by Bangladeshi
photojournalist Amanul Haque and
others throw some light on the subject.
An idea about aliens
Based on his own story and ideas, and
encouraged by the famous author Arthur
C. Clarke, Ray drafted the screenplay of
his sci-fi film The Alien in 1967. Columbia
Pictures agreed to produce it with Peter
Sellers in an Indian role. Steve McQueen
was contacted and even Robert Redford
considered, and the Indian cast was
almost finalised. Columbia even advanced
some money for the project. However,
there were many unexpected twists and
turns, as recounted by Ray in “Ordeals of
the Alien” (The Statesman, October 4 and
5, 1980), and the project had to be
abandoned. Ray wrote to Sellers:
“Dear Peter, if you wanted a bigger part
Why, you should have told me so right
at the start.
THE DAILY QUIZ
On May 3, 1715, a total solar eclipse occurred over Europe. A quiz on the event
Vasudevan Mukunth
X promised rewards for anyone who
QUESTION 1
The English astronomer X is famous
for, among other things, predicting the
onset of the eclipse with an accuracy
of four minutes. As a result, the event
is also known as “X’s eclipse”. Name X.
X eclipse to within four minutes, he’d
QUESTION 2
At the time the eclipse occurred, the
date was April 22 and not May 3 (the
year was 1715 in either case). The
reason for this is that Great Britain
would adopt the _________ ________
only 37 years later. Fill in the blanks.
X In 1686, X (in Q1) coined the name
QUESTION 3
Before the eclipse occurred, the
English cartographer John Senex had
published maps of the eclipse’s path
created by both X (in Q1) and Y in
March. Y is famous for pushing the
CM
YK
By declining at this juncture
You have simply punctured
The Alien balloon,
Which I daresay would be grounded
soon, Causing a great deal of dismay
To Satyajit Ray.”
The project was revived later, but by
then Steven Spielberg’s E.T. the
Extra-Terrestrial was released (1982), with
‘striking parallels’ noticed by Clarke and
others. Ray held, as Robinson quotes, that
E.T. “would not have been possible
without my script of The Alien being
available throughout America in
mimeographed copies”. However,
Spielberg commented, “Tell Satyajit I was
a kid in high school when his script was
circulating in Hollywood’. Despite advice,
Ray did not pursue the matter further. His
depiction, as communicated to Jindal,
that the aliens were “benign by nature,
small and acceptable to children,
possessed of certain supernatural powers,
not physical strength but other kinds of
powers, particular types of vision, and
that they take interest in earthly things”
was indeed influential.
The West’s image of India
Ray met E.M. Forster at Cambridge in
1966 with the intention to film A Passage
to India . Robinson quotes Ray, “… but he
knew my name. He kept shaking his head
much of the time which meant that he
didn’t want the book to be filmed. That
was the drone — no! — in words, gestures,
looks, everything. He was adamant. And I
felt there was no point in asking why.”
Later, much after Forster’s death, Ray was
approached in 1980 by the trustees at
King’s College, but by then he had lost
interest in the subject. David Lean’s
version (1984), understandably, could not
satisfy Ray — “… The whole thing is too
picturesque… For me none of the
characters come alive… Peggy Ashcroft’s
performance notwithstanding…” In a
famous essay “Under Western Eyes”
(Sight & Sound, Autumn 1982), Ray had
parliament of Great Britain to pass
the Longitude Act in 1714. It
devised a simple method to estimate
a ship’s longitude while at sea. Name
Y.
X Prime Minister for three terms
QUESTION 4
While X (in Q1) had predicted the
got the path of the eclipse wrong by
around 30 km. X later realised he’d
used the wrong lunar _________ (a
table that describes the path of the
moon). Fill in the blank.
X (Part II)’
QUESTION 5
‘_____’ to refer to a period of about
6,585.3 days, which could be used to X fought and Lord Voldemort was
predict the occurrence of solar and Visual question:
lunar eclipses. X said he was inspired Name the man whose bust is depicted here. X (in Q1) succeeded to his
by a term in an 11th century title in 1720, and his work helped Y (in Q3) prepare the eclipse map. PUBLIC
Byzantine book. Fill in the blank. DOMAIN
THE HINDU
Text&Context
touched upon the limitations of the West’s
interest in India and how its views were
often distorted and unreal, sometimes
even with “grotesque stereotypes as
Hurree Jamset Ram Singh…” He ended,
“Slighted for so long, India will not yield
up her secrets to the West so easily…” It is
a pity that A Passage... could not be
filmed by Ray.
All on paper
The Mahabharata fascinated Ray from his
early childhood. From the late fifties he
had been planning to film it. But in what
language? “How to introduce even the
main characters to a non-Indian
audience?” At one time, he intended to
cast Dilip Kumar, Toshiro Mifune and
others. Ray was interested in the dice
game part. More than the war, it was the
exploration of personal relationships
between the characters that appealed to
him cinematically. In jest, he once told
Jindal, “I gave up, because I couldn’t
imagine Kirk Douglas playing Arjuna.”
Waheeda Rehman, who acted in Ray’s
Abhijan (1962), said that Ray had been
keen to adapt R.K. Narayan’s The Guide
and had contacted her for the female
lead. As she observed, the approach and
treatment of the film would have been
entirely different under Ray’s direction.
But then we would have missed the
Bollywood blockbuster.
There were many Bengali film ideas
that Ray had nurtured at some point or
the other, as detailed by Sandip Ray in
Ananya Satyajit (1998) and others.
Bankimchandra Chattopadhyay’s
Rajasimha (with Balraj Sahni) and Devi
Chaudhurani (with Suchitra Sen),
Saratchandra Chattopadhyay’s Mahesh,
Bibhutibhusan Bandyopadhyay’s
Drabamayeer Kashibash and Ichhamati,
Manik Bandyopadhyay’s Padma Nadir
Majhi, Mahasweta Devi’s Bichhan,
Buddhadeva Bose’s Ekti Jiban , Prafulla
Roy’s Ram Charitra, Shibram
Chakraborty’s Debotar Jonmo,
Banaphool’s Kichhukshan, Bangladeshi
writer Shahed Ali’s Jibrailer Dana and
Selina Hossain’s Hangor Nodi Grenade
were thought of. For a variety of reasons,
including non-availability of actors
(Chunibala Devi and Suchitra Sen, for
example), these ideas had to be
abandoned at different stages. According
to Sandip, his father moved on with his
work, never regretting what could not be
pursued.
Ray was approached by Indira Gandhi
to make a documentary on Jawaharlal
Nehru for whom he had admiration.
Besides, in a letter of June 1, 1978, Ray
wrote to Jindal about the proposals he
had been requested to consider “… (a)
documentary on Rajasthani music for
French TV… (b) a 3-part film for BBC
(each 90 minutes long) on any subject or
subjects of my choice… (c) a proposal
from UNO to make a film on ‘the horrors
& miseries of war’, for worldwide TV
screening… (d) a revival of The Alien
under a major U.S. company backing with
an updated script and a new title…”
UNICEF approached him for a film on
child labour. Ray was also interested in
the operatic form of Balmiki-Pratibha, and
documentaries on notables like
Radhanath Sikdar who first calculated the
world’s highest mountain peak. None of
these eventually took off for reasons not
publicly known.
Conscious of what’s happening all
around, Ray was immersed in ideas. A
storyteller, both in celluloid and print, he
was always assessing the cinematic
potential of literary sources that ignited
his imagination. Now, on the occasion of
Ray’s 100th birth anniversary
celebrations, it is for the researchers to
probe and delve into the available
material in order to fathom why many of
these ideas couldn’t get transported to the
medium of cinema.
Amitabha Bhattacharya is a retired IAS
officer who has also worked with the UNDP.
Views are personal
Please send in your answers to
dailyquiz@thehindu.co.in
Questions and Answers to the previous
day’s daily quiz: 1. This British football
legend was the runner up for the Ballon
D’Or in 1999. Ans: David Beckham
2. The party to which Tony Blair belonged
to. Ans: Labour party. He was the U.K.
3. Identify this novel that won the Pulitzer
Prize for Fiction in 1932. Ans: The Good
Earth by Pearl. S. Buck
4. This movie based on a popular comic
book saga was released in 2008. Ans: Iron
Man
5. This song by Pink Floyd was banned in
South Africa. Ans: ‘Another Brick in Wall
Visual: The reason why May 2 is celebrated
as International Harry Potter day. Ans: It is
the day the battle of Hogwarts was
defeated
Early Birds: Vasumann Yadav| Neha
Vaddiparti| ViswanadhaRao Batchu| M.
Suresh Kumar
11
FROM THE ARCHIVES
Know your
English
K. Subrahmanian
“Wake, waken, awake, awaken (D. Ashok,
Madras).”
“Those are simple words, but are not
easy to distinguish. Fowler’s “Modern
English Usage” revised by Cowers deals
ffa76243-386b-4d4d-93fa-f34e5b20443d
with the distinction between the forms
thus: “Distinction between the forms is
difficult, but with regard to modern usage
certain points may be made: (1) Wake is
the ordinary working verb (You will wake
the baby; Something woke me up; I
should like to be waked at 7.30; Wake the
echoes) for which the others are
substituted to add dignity or formality, or
to suit metre, or as in (3) or (5) below. (2)
Wake alone has (and that chiefly in
waking) the sense be or remain awake
(Sleeping or waking; In our waking
hours). (3) Awake and awaken are usually
preferred to the others in figurative senses
(When they awoke, or were awakened, to
their danger; This at once awakened
suspicion; The national spirit awoke, or
was awakened; A rude awakening). (4)
Waken and awaken tend to be restricted
to the transitive sense; when he wakens is
rarer for when he wakes than that will
waken him for that will wake him. (5) In
the passive, awaken and waken are often
preferred to awake and wake, perhaps
owing to uncertainty about the p.p. forms
of the latter part; it wakened me is rare
for it woke or waked me, but I was
wakened by it is common for I was waked
or woke or woken by it; see also the
alternative forms in (3) above. (6) Up is
very commonly appended to wake, rarely
to waken, and never to awake and
awaken.”
In American English, the past and past
participle of ‘wake’ are ‘woke’ or ‘waked’
respectively. ‘Woken’ is used only in
British English. Again in American
English, the past and past participle of
‘awake’ are ‘awoke’ or ‘awaked’
respectively. ‘Awoken’ is used only in
British English. ‘Awake’, ‘waken’ and
‘awaken’ as verbs are generally used in
literary writing.”
“Social, sociable (Amrit Kaur,
Chandigarh).”
“ ‘Social’ means ‘pertaining to society.’
Social service, social problems, social
disorganisation, social evil. There was a
time when it meant friendly,
companionable. Even now some use it in
this sense. But the word that is used these
days to convey the sense of ‘friendly’ is
‘sociable.’
She is a very sociable person.
A social club is a club where you spend
some time with others. Not all of them
may be sociable! ‘Unsociable’ means ‘not
disposed to seek the company of others,
not companionable, reserved’.
He is an unsociable person.
The opposite of ‘sociable’ is
‘unsociable.’”
“Selenology (S. K. Banerjee, Calcutta).”
“ ‘Selenology’ means the scientific
study of the moon. In Greek, ‘selene’
means ‘the moon.’ The first ‘e’ is
pronounced like the ‘ee’ in ‘feel,’ the
second ‘e’ like the ‘i’ in ‘fill,’ the first ‘o’ as
in ‘hot’ and the second ‘o’ like the ‘a’ in
India.’ The stress is on the third syllable.”
Published in The Hindu on November
12, 1991.
For feedback and suggestions for
Text & Context, please write to
letters@thehindu.co.in
with the subject ‘Text & Context’
M ND-NDE
 THE HINDU
12 Friday, May 3, 2024

News Delhi

From Page One Suspense over Amethi, West Bengal

Governor
Prajwal booked for rape; Rae Bareli continues accused of
harassment
lookout circular issued Mallikarjun Kharge meets Rahul Gandhi to finalise candidates; today is
the last day for filing nominations for the two key seats in Uttar Pradesh The Hindu Bureau
In view of the lookout circular, Mr. Prajwal will be KOLKATA
detained as soon as he reports at any of the immi-
gration points at airports, sea ports, or at border The Hindu Bureau An employee at the Raj
checkposts. SIT sources said his return ticket has NEW DELHI Bhavan in Kolkata on
been booked for May 15. An advocate claiming to Thursday alleged that she
represent the Hassan MP had sought seven days’ ith Friday being was sexually harassed by
time for his client to present himself before the
SIT. External Affairs Ministry spokesperson A.
Randhir Jaiswal said that they were not ap-
W the last day for
filing nomina-
tions for the Amethi and
West Bengal Governor C.V.
Ananda Bose. The woman
lodged a complaint at the
The prizewinning explainer page dated September 3, 2023.

proached for “political clearance”; nor did the Mi- Rae Bareli seats in Uttar Hare Street police station
nistry issue any clearance for enabling foreign tra-
vel by Mr. Prajwal. “No political clearance was
Pradesh that go to the polls
on May 20, sources said
in Kolkata.
The allegation came
The Hindu wins top
either sought from or issued by the MEA in res-
pect of the travel of the said MP to Germany. Ob-
Congress president Malli-
karjun Kharge had a meet-
hours before Prime Minis-
ter Narendra Modi was awards at international
viously, no visa note was issued either. No visa is
required for diplomatic passport holders to travel
to Germany,” he said.
ing with senior leader Ra-
hul Gandhi at Shivamogga
in Karnataka, where the
Awaiting decisions: Congress leader Rahul Gandhi, with AICC chief
Mallikarjun Kharge, at an election campaign in Karnataka. ANI
scheduled to arrive at the
Raj Bhavan for a night stay.
He is scheduled to address
design competition
The Hassan MP has now been suspended by two addressed an election three election rallies in
the Janata Dal (Secular). He is seeking re-election rally. shift to Rae Bareli, which is hi. In 1977, Janata Party West Bengal on Friday. The Hindu Bureau cellence in the ‘Best of
from the Hassan Lok Sabha constituency where There was no informa- deemed to be a “safer leader Raj Narain famously Reacting to the allega- Double Spread’ category.
he is pitted against Congress nominee Shreyas tion on the outcome of the seat”. His mother and defeated Indira Gandhi tions, Mr. Bose said he The Hindu’s explainer page The judges noted that the
Patel. meeting. There is intense former Congress president here. would not be cowed down on Neeraj Chopra’s craft “standout sports page of
speculation that Mr. Gand- Sonia Gandhi represented Congress general secre- by engineered narratives. and success, “The science the competition was
hi may return to Amethi, a the seat from 2004. She tary Priyanka Gandhi Va- “... If anybody wants some behind Neeraj’s skills”, pu- layered with information
ffa76243-386b-4d4d-93fa-f34e5b20443d

seat he lost in 2019 to Un-
India protests Chinese ion Minister and BJP leader
Smriti Irani.
road work in PoK valley Mr. Gandhi had won the
seat in 2004, 2009, and
2014. In 2019, he contested
“We have registered our protest with the Chinese from Wayanad in addition
side against illegal attempts to alter facts on the to Amethi. This time too,
ground. We further reserve the right to take ne- he is in the fray from
cessary measures to safeguard our interests,” Mr. Wayanad.
Jaiswal added. There is also specula-
The Shaksgam Valley is part of Pakistan-occu- tion that Mr. Gandhi could
pied Kashmir, and was ceded by Pakistan to China
in 1963, a year after the India-China war. Recent
satellite pictures indicate that China is building a
road into the lower Shaksgam valley. This has also
been confirmed by official sources.
The Siachen glacier is a piece of Indian territo-
Gaming body warns
ry wedged between China and Pakistan. The 2020
standoff between Indian and Chinese troops in
eastern Ladakh has made the control of Siachen
of action against ads
even more critical for India. China has underta-
ken a massive build-up and deployment along the
on online gambling
Line of Actual Control, especially in eastern La-
dakh, threatening Indian positions in Depsang
and Daulat Beg Oldie. The Hindu Bureau
CHENNAI
The Tamil Nadu Online
Gaming Authority (TNO-
Law and order is a GA) on Thursday said it
State subject, says SC had “proposed to take
stringent action” against
those who advertise online
The ED had approached the top court claiming gambling and online
the case be transferred to it as Mr. Tiwari was a games of chance and bet-
Central government employee. The hearing be- ting, among others, to pro-
fore Justice Gavai’s Bench was based on an origi- mote their website/appli-
nal suit filed by West Bengal under Article 131 of cations in the State.
the Constitution against the Union government. Those who wish to
The State alleged that CBI was probing several cas- share information about
es and registering FIRs within its jurisdiction with- online gambling or betting
out taking prior consent from the West Bengal go- activities, or offer sugges-
vernment. Mr. Sibal said the State had withdrawn tions to regulate online
prior consent under Section 6 of the Delhi Police games could do so at
Special Establishment Act to CBI investigations https://tnonlinegamin-
within its territory on November 16, 2018. gauthority.tn.gov.in/ or
“It is not our case that there should be no inves- email tnoga@tn.gov.in, the
tigation in these cases. But you cannot claim I TNOGA chairperson said in
have a unilateral right to investigate them by giv- a release.
ing the Code of Criminal Procedure a go-by. You The Tamil Nadu Prohibi-
cannot say that the offences relating to Central go- tion of Online Gambling
vernment employees will be investigated only by a and Regulation of Online
Central agency,” Mr. Sibal submitted. Solicitor- Games Act, 2022, provides
General Tushar Mehta, for the Union government, for prohibiting online gam-
said the original suit of the State was not maintain- bling and online games of
able and should be dismissed by the court. chance, betting, among
opted out of the Lok Sabha
election race this year,
choosing to enter Parlia-
ment through the Rajya
Sabha instead.
The Congress has
won Rae Bareli 17 times
since the first general elec-
tion. The seat was first re-
presented by Feroze Gand-
hi and later on three
occasions by Indira Gand-
others. Violators are liable
for imprisonment that may
extend to 3 months or a
fine of up to ₹5,000 or
both. “...The Act prohibits
financial institutions/pay-
ment gateways from engag-
ing in transactions towards
online gambling or online
game of chance,” the re-
lease said.
The advertisement of
online gambling services
and online games of
chance are prohibited un-
der the Act. No person
shall make or cause to
make any advertisement in
any media, including elec-
tronic means of communi-
cation, in Tamil Nadu that
promotes or induces any
person to indulge in online
gambling with money or
other stakes, the Act states.
It also provides for a penal-
ty of imprisonment, which
may extend to one year or
a fine extending up to ₹5
lakh or both for the per-
sons/company indulging in
such advertisements.
dra’s name has also been
doing the rounds for one of
the two seats. On Friday,
Ms. Vadra is scheduled to
address a roadshow in Fa-
tehpur Sikri, some 500 km
away from both Amethi
and Rae Bareli.
Sources, however,
claimed that she remains
reluctant to make her elec-
toral debut.
BJP expelled Mahua from
Parliament as she cannot
be cowered down: Mamata
Shiv Sahay Singh
KOLKATA
The BJP cannot stand Ma-
hua Moitra because she
cannot be cowered down,
West Bengal Chief Minister
Mamata Banerjee said on
Thursday while campaign-
ing for the party’s Lok Sab-
ha candidate for the Krish-
nanagar constituency.
“You had elected Mahua
Moitra to Parliament. Did
BJP have any right to expel
her?” the Chief Minister
said at a rally in Nadia.
Ms. Moitra was expelled
from Parliament in January
after the Ethics Committee
had found her guilty of
“unethical conduct” and
contempt of the House by
sharing her Lok Sabha
member portal credentials
with unauthorised per-
sons. Soon after the expul-
sion, the Trinamool had
announced that Ms. Moitra
will contest the election
from Krishnanagar.
election benefits by ma-
ligning me, God bless
them. But they cannot stop
my fight against corruption
and violence in Bengal,”
the Raj Bhavan said in a
statement, quoting the
Governor.
The ruling Trinamool
Congress said the “sanctity
of Raj Bhavan has been
tarnished”.
Mamata Banerjee with Mahua Moitra, the TMC candidate for the
Krishnanagar constituency, during a rally in Nadia on Thursday. ANI
“They [BJP] cannot
stand Mahua Moitra be-
cause she replies on their
face and cannot be co-
wered down,” Ms. Baner-
jee said. She added that on
Friday BJP leaders will visit
the constituency and “tell
lies”. Prime Minister Na-
rendra Modi is expected to
address a public meeting at
Tehatta in Nadia district on
Friday in favour of the BJP
candidate.
The Chief Minister also
blished on September 3,
2023, has won three
awards at the 6th Interna-
tional Newspaper Design
Competition organised by
newspaperdesign.in.
‘Standout sports page’
The Hindu won the ‘Best of
show’ award; ‘Gold’ in the
‘Best of Sports Page’ cate-
gory; and an award of ex-
raised the issue of suspen-
sion of 150 MPs from Par-
liament and said majority
does not mean using brute
force. Ms. Banerjee ac-
cused the Centre of at-
tempting to marginalise
SCs, STs, and OBCs.
The Chief Minister also
addressed the Matua com-
munity and said that the
BJP is going to implement
Uniform Civil Code. Krish-
nanagar has a significant
Matua population.
ffa76243-386b-4d4d-93fa-f34e5b20443d
organised on a simple grid
around world-class illustra-
tions” and every part of
this page informs and en-
gages readers. They went
on to add that the pages
were a “great balance of
strong visuals, detailed ex-
plainers and well-edited
narrative text that com-
bined to deliver a medal-
winning experience”.
‘Instead of
hate speeches,
seek votes on
performance’
The Hindu Bureau
NEW DELHI
Prime Minister Narendra
Modi will be remembered
as someone who “indulged
in divisive and communal
speeches filled with lies to
avoid an inevitable de-
feat”, Congress President
Mallikarjun Kharge said in
a letter to Mr. Modi. He also
rebutted the various charg-
es levelled by the Bharatiya
Janata Party (BJP) in the
ongoing election
campaign.
The letter has been
framed as a response to
Mr. Modi’s missive to the
BJP candidates asking
them to spread awareness
among voters of the Con-
gress’s intention to snatch
“reservation from SC, ST,
and OBC communities and
give it away to their vote
bank”. He urged Mr. Modi
to seek votes on the perfor-
mance of his government
over the last 10 years in-
stead of indulging in “hate
speeches”.

Guarantee cards: Congress gateway to voters’ minds POCSO Act’s objective

Sobhana K. Nair
NEW DELHI
Every morning, between 8
a.m. and 10 a.m., before
the heat rises, Congress
worker Basvaraj Ajari
Ghadhinglaj, 55, goes door-
to-door armed with the
party’s “guarantee card” in
the Kolhapur Lok Sabha
constituency of
Maharashtra.
While the Congress ma-
nifesto has been in the li-
melight with sustained at-
tacks from Prime Minister
Narendra Modi, the gua-
rantees that sum up the
manifesto have become a
conversation starter with
voters for workers like Mr.
Ghadhinglaj.
Questions arising
The cards are printed in
Marathi, making it easier
for him to explain the five
Nyays and 25 guarantees
that the Congress is pro-
mising to deliver if it comes
to power. The party has
printed over eight crore
cards in 12 languages. In
the last week that he has
been doing the rounds
CM
YK
with the cards, the conver-
sation follows a familiar
pattern.
As he reads out the pro-
mises — usually to a group
of men — curious women
of the household stroll in
midway with questions.
The talk often gets redirect-
ed to the rising prices of es-
sential commodities. He
utilises the opportunity to
reel off comparative prices
of food items, fuel, and
LPG cylinders, during the
United Progressive Al-
liance (UPA) years and Mr.
Modi’s 10-year tenure.
“One of the questions
that is often being asked, is
‘how will the Congress find
money to deliver all these
promises?’ I simply point
to our neighbouring State
Karnataka, where our go-
vernment has already deli-
vered on all the promises,”
he remarks. It helps that
Kolhapur is located on the
Maharashtra-Karnataka
boundary.
The promise that draws
the most enthusiasm is the
Mahalakshmi Scheme.
“When I tell them that they
will receive ₹8,500 each
nected from the ground
realities in sharp contrast
to the BJP’s dense network
of Panna Pramukhs (those
in charge of each page of
the electoral roll).
In January, the party be-
gan an exercise to change
this. It instituted a central
war room, headed by
former IAS officer Sasi-
kanth Senthil. The average
age of the five members of
the war room is 39, signall-
ing a generational shift in
the decision-making pro-
cess. Mr. Senthil headed
the war room during the
Karnataka and Telangana
elections too. The 2024
Promises to keep: Congress candidates say that the ‘guarantee war room is replicating the
cards’ serve as great conversation starters with voters. ANI processes that were suc-
cessfully tested in these
month if they vote for the Ms. Semariya is glad that two States. A chain of
Congress, they are scepti- instead of pamphlets that workers was created ex-
cal at first. Then comes a she carried around in the tending from the war room
barrage of questions and 2019 election, she has in Delhi to the block level
our conversation usually cards that lend the promis- in all States.
ends with squeals of ap- es a more concrete air. “It
proval as they count the feels good that we are not Change of focus
possible ways they could asking for votes, we are Mr. Senthil believes that
use this money,” Purnima making promises,” Ms. Se- the Congress’s 2024 cam-
Semariya, who is going mariya added. paign is materially diffe-
door-to-door in Chhattis- The Congress has al- rent from their 2019 one.
garh’s Sarguja constituen- ways been criticised for be- “Our focus in 2019 was on
cy, said. ing top-heavy and discon- the narrative, today our fo-
cus is on the cadre and or-
can’t be ignored: SC
ganisation,” he said. Each
State capital has a war Krishnadas Rajagopal asked in court.
room that, in turn, coordi- NEW DELHI The top court was deal-
nates with districts and ing with the case of kidnap
blocks. Mr. Senthil insists The Supreme Court on and rape of a 14-year-old
that they be called “con- Thursday said the objec- girl in West Bengal. Her
nect centres”. tive of the Protection of mother had registered an
A call from Delhi, he Children from Sexual Of- FIR. However, she is cur-
said, makes a strong con- fences (POCSO) Act could rently living with her child
nection with the worker on not be ignored merely be- and the accused, whom
the ground, and that is cause child marriages con- the trial court had convict-
what these centres are de- tinue, or worse still, abus- ed under the POCSO Act.
signed for. For the worker, ers marry their minor Deciding his appeal
the guarantee cards, in victims to escape against conviction, the Cal-
turn, forge their connec- conviction. cutta High Court, in Octob-
tion with the voter. Each “What is the assurance er last year, had acquitted
card carries the signatures that he will not abandon the 20-year-old man, con-
of Congress president Mal- her after avoiding convic- cluding that both had been
likarjun Kharge and form- tion?” Justice A.S. Oka romantically linked.
er President Rahul Gandhi.
“It is a tangible assurance
from our end,” he added.
The Congress also sees
this pithy card as a tool to
counter the attack on its
manifesto from the BJP.
“Guarantee cards are an ef-
fective weapon in the hand
of the karyakarta to coun-
ter the disinformation be-
ing spread by the BJP on
the Congress manifesto,”
vice-chairman of the cen-
tral war room, Varun San-
thosh, said.
M ND-NDE
 THE HINDU
Friday, May 3, 2024 13
Delhi

ELECTIONS 2024

Naveen Patnaik, closer to three Lok Sabha
seats — Balangir, Kalahandi
Pradhan file and Bargarh — which are BJP
nominations strongholds.
The day saw heavyweights
쑽 filing nomination for the Lok
Sabha poll. Union Minister
Chief Minister Naveen Patnaik Dharmendra Pradhan and
on Thursday filed nomination former Minister Jual Oram
for the Kantabanji Assembly filed papers from Sambalpur
seat in Balangir district, the and Sundargarh, respectively.
second seat after his BJP spokesperson Aparajita
traditional Hinjili constituency Sarangi filed papers from
for the Odisha Assembly Bhubaneswar while BJD
election. His selection of leader and former Mumbai
Kantabanji as the second seat Police Commissioner Arup
assumes significance as it is Patnaik filed papers from Puri.
Naveen Patnaik filing papers
for the Kantabanji seat on
Thursday. BISWARANJAN ROUT
Baramulla fight
is against Delhi’s
might, RSS: NC
쑽 We have a direct contest with
National Conference
vice-president Omar Abdullah,
who filed his nomination
papers from the Baramulla
seat on Thursday, said he was
“up against Delhi’s might and
the Rashtriya Swayamsevak
Sangh (RSS)”.
“Voters in the Baramulla
constituency have to make a
simple choice on May 20.
Whether they want to vote for
a local representative in
Parliament or send a Delhi’s
representative to Parliament.
Delhi’s might and Nagpur’s
RSS. They have fielded their
men against the NC and the
INDIA bloc candidates on all
seats in Kashmir,” Mr.
Abdullah said. “We will fight
for the snatched rights. I will
ensure I take the struggle to
Parliament and work hard,
even though the opponent is
very shrewd,” he said.
J.P. Nadda has
become Jhooth
Prachar Nadda... He said
Cong.’s thinking on
economic inequalities is
Maoist in nature. There
cannot be a bigger lie
JAIRAM RAMESH
Congress leader
Congress fields
Tsering Namgyal
from Ladakh
쑽
The Congress on Thursday A majority of
fielded Tsering Namgyal from the leaders of
the Ladakh Lok Sabha seat.
the INDIA bloc, including
The Congress’s central
election committee has those of the Congress
approved the name of Tsering and RJD, are either in jail
Namgyal as the candidate to or out on bail. RJD
contest the poll from Ladakh, means corruption
an official communication J.P. NADDA
from the party said. PTI BJP president

In the BJP’s scheme of things,

good politics is good economics
ffa76243-386b-4d4d-93fa-f34e5b20443d

ffa76243-386b-4d4d-93fa-f34e5b20443d
Hindutva ideology believes that India’s growth is because of nationalism and not in spite of it; under the ideology, the Ram
temple is not seen as a distraction from, or barrier to, India’s development, but as an essential foundation and catalyst for it

other way round. India’s V.K. Pandian

NEWS ANALYSIS national movement ques-
Family feud: NCP (SP) candidate for Baramati,
Supriya Sule, during her campaign in Jejuri. PTI Varghese K. George
tioned the development
claims of the colonial go-
I am successor
NEW DELHI vernment on this ground, to Naveen’s
In Baramati, f only his politics
asserting that unless there
was a national govern- great values,
the Pawars “I were as good as
his economics” —
this is a familiar refrain in
ment, progress and deve-
lopment would not arrive.
The Bharatiya Janata
says Pandian
liberal commentaries Party has taken this to the

battle it out for about Prime Minister Na-

rendra Modi. The sugges-
tion is that there is a dis-
next level to argue that the
development claims of the
Congress’s nationalism
Press Trust of India
BHUBANESWAR

supremacy connect between Mr.

Modi’s economic policies
that liberal commentators
were unachievable be-
cause of its inadequate cul-
tural moorings, or even its
Unfazed by the ‘outsider’
barb from his opponents,
Naveen Patnaik’s closest
approve of, and his Hin- continuing association associate V.K. Pandian has
Shoumojit Banerjee dutva politics that they dis- with colonial ideas and said he is a “natural succes-
PUNE approve of. institutions. sor” to all the great values
The merits of the argu- Hindutva is a compre- of the Odisha Chief Minis-
s the 83-year-old Nationalist Congress ments about Mr. Modi’s hensive scheme that en- ter and that he would do

A Party (SP) chief Sharad Pawar takes

on his nephew, Maharashtra Deputy
Chief Minister Ajit Pawar, for control of
economics and politics
apart, this liberal view is
formed by an inadequate
Different formula: During the consecration of the Ram temple, Narendra Modi said that by embracing
tradition and modernity, Bharat will reach the goals of prosperity by walking on both these paths. PTI
compasses all facets of the
individual and collective
lives of the people. But it is
everything under the sun
to help his “guru” serve the
people of the State.
Baramati, which goes to the polls on May 7, appreciation of Hindutva not a static one, and has In a no-holds-barred at-
the paterfamilias of the Pawar family and as an ideology, and an un- January 2024, a milestone from the development in the absence of this cultu- been dynamically evolving tack on the Bharatiya Jana-
Maharashtra’s politics faces the toughest questioning adherence to in the BJP’s political jour- agenda, or a barrier to it, ral politics, no material over time, as it confronted ta Party (BJP), Mr. Pandian
contest of his life. the dubious claim that lib- ney, is particularly the temple is an essential progress is possible, ac- new questions. Its early said it is the ruling party at
Mr. Sharad Pawar’s daughter, Supriya Sule eral democratic politics instructive. foundation, and a catalyst cording to the nationalist proponents clearly identi- the Centre that has done
(the Opposition Maha Vikas Aghadi’s and free market capitalism for that agenda, by view. And cultural nation- fied the opportunity pro- nothing for the ‘Odiya As-
candidate and incumbent Baramati MP), is are inevitable cohabitants. Cultural politics implication. alism protects the econom- vided by universal fran- mita’ or for promoting the
pitted against Mr. Ajit’s wife, Sunetra Pawar Hindutva understands Connecting the country’s This idea is common to ic interests of the country chise to build a Hindu language, art and culture
(the ruling Mahayuti’s candidate), and the the link between politics material progress to the re- all forms of economic na- as a whole, as opposed to polity. It believes that pro- of the State despite repeat-
contest is leavened with high political drama and economics differently. surgence of cultural polit- tionalism, and Hindutva is the particular interests of gress is possible only when ed pleas by the Chief
which has seen bitter foes turning into The free market slogan, ics, he said: “We are wit- only a more strident var- groups within that might Hindus are united. Minister.
overnight friends across the six Assembly “good economics is good nessing that this iant of that. Consolidation want to undermine nation- Global liberals think that Asked about his being
segments in the Lok Sabha constituency. politics”, works in the in- construction is not causing of national identity al sovereignty in pursuit of India’s growth is in spite of seen as a successor to Mr.
On paper, the arithmetic seems to favour verse in the Hindutva any fire, but, in fact, is giv- through cultural tropes is profits globally. To para- nationalism, but Hindutva Patnaik, Mr. Pandian said,
Mr. Ajit and the Mahayuti as his ‘palace scheme of things, as “good ing birth to energy… Em- not in contradiction with phrase Stephen Bannon, a thinks it is because of it. It “I’m a natural successor to
revolution’ in July last year, which split the politics is good econom- bracing the sacredness of ambitions in the fields of champion of current could be called the “Hin- all the great values he pos-
NCP founded by his uncle in 1999, has ics”. This is a strand of tradition and the endless economy or technology, or American nationalism, “it dutva rate of growth” in sesses, whether it’s his im-
completely upset the political balance in thought that runs through possibilities of modernity, in global standing. In fact, has an economy, but a na- contradistinction to the peccable integrity, his
Baramati. all of Mr. Modi’s speeches, Bharat will reach the goals it is cultural assertion and tion is not an economy”. phrase “the Hindu rate of commitment to the people
As a result, Mr. Sharad Pawar (and Ms. but the one he made dur- of prosperity by walking consolidation that leads to Historically, nationalism growth”, which denoted of Odisha, his hard work,
Sule) today has no MLA in the NCP (SP) camp. ing the consecration of the on both these paths.” Far progress, growth, and sees politics as the mover the slow growth of the pre- punctuality, sincerity, eve-
The father and daughter are dependent on Ram temple in Ayodhya in from being a distraction prosperity. Not only that, of economics and not the liberalisation era. rything.”
the goodwill of their Maha Vikas Aghadi ally,
the Congress, which holds the Bhor and
Purandar segments.
Khadakwasla, which has the largest
concentration of voters (4.7 lakh), is firmly in
the grip of the ruling BJP. So is the Daund
Big names try their luck in Madhya Pradesh’s battle royale
Assembly segment, whose legislator is the
BJP’s Rahul Kul. Mehul Malpani tions from some consti- terms, including once with tion of the BJP’s 2019 stra-
His wife, Kanchan Kul, was the saffron GUNA tuencies have led obser- the BJP. tegy, the Congress has
party’s candidate in the 2019 general vers to believe that the Mr. Singh, 77, known for fielded Rao Yadvendra
election. While Ms. Sule coasted to victory Political fortunes of two upcoming phase could be his hold on the Congress’ Singh Yadav, who had
with a comfortable margin of more than 1.5 former Chief Ministers and the Congress’ best shot in organisation across the switched sides just before
lakh votes, Ms. Kul performed creditably, a Union Home Minister the State. State, is using a localised the 2023 Assembly elec-
garnering more than 40% of the vote share as and the control of the cru- The party has intensi- approach to campaign, tion, hoping to consolidate
opposed to Ms. Sule’s 52%. cial Gwalior-Chambal re- fied its campaigning for the while also trying to strike votes of the Yadav com-
Both Khadakwasla and Daund had voted gion will be at stake when third phase with Rahul an emotional chord declar- munity.
against Ms. Sule (and the NCP) in the last voters from nine consti- Gandhi holding a rally in ing that this is his last elec- While Mr. Singh and Mr.
election. tuencies in Madhya Pra- Bhind and warning voters tion. Scindia have limited them-
This leaves the other two Assembly desh vote on May 7. that the BJP will “throw The Congress leader, selves to campaigning in
segments — Baramati and neighbouring In Phase 3 of the elec- away” the Constitution if it however, has an uphill task their respective consti-
Indapur, both totally dominated by Mr. Ajit. tion in the State, BJP candi- returns to power. in bridging Mr. Nagar’s tuencies, Mr. Chouhan has
Last time, it was Mr. Ajit, as Ms. Sule’s date Shivraj Singh Chou- From the BJP, Prime Mi- 2019 victory margin of 4.31 been touring the State to
“campaign manager” in the undivided NCP, han, who was the State’s nister Narendra Modi, Un- BJP candidate from Guna Jyotiraditya Scindia addressing a public lakh as he will look to over- campaign for party candi-
who had ensured a lead of 1.25 lakh votes for longest serving Chief Mi- ion Home Minister Amit meeting at Athai Kheda village in Madhya Pradesh. A.M. FARUQUI come the BJP’s popularity dates as the people in Vid-
his cousin from the key Baramati Assembly nister, is returning to his Shah, and national presi- among the OBCs in the isha say that he appears
segment alone. (Mr. Ajit has been an MLA traditional Vidisha consti- dent J.P. Nadda have cam- chosen to lead the BJP’s go- term from Vidisha, a con- constituency and the Hin- comfortable in one of BJP’s
from Baramati a record seven times since tuency after nearly 20 paigned in Morena, Betul vernment in the State. The stituency he held from 1991 dutva factor. safest seats in the State.
1991). years. and Rajgarh. 65-year-old held the State’s to 2005. He is facing senior One of the most keenly
This time around, Mr. Ajit, along with the Another former Chief top post until 2023, bar- Congress leader Bhanu Reclaiming the bastion watched contest will be
BJP top brass and the NDA alliance, have Minister, Congress veteran Diverse regions ring a 15-month period Pratap Sharma, 77, who re- In Guna, Mr. Scindia, the from Morena in the Cham-
thrown their full weight behind Ms. Sunetra. Digvijaya Singh, is contest- Spread across a large por- when the Congress was in presented the seat from scion of the erstwhile Gwa- bal belt as the Congress
A key region in western Maharashtra, ing from his home turf Raj- tion of the State, the consti- power from 2018 to 2020. 1980 to 1984. lior kingdom, looks to re- hopes to wrest the seat
Baramati has its politics revolving round garh after 30 years. Union tuencies fall under diffe- And though he was not de- Another stalwart, Mr. claim his family’s bastion from the BJP after nearly
influential sugar barons and political clans in Minister Jyotiraditya Scin- rent regions and have clared the BJP’s face in the Singh is working to reignite that he had lost in 2019 three decades. The seat is
this region. dia, who lost his family varying demography and 2023 Assembly election, his old connect in Rajgarh when he was with the locked in a three-way fight
Given the intense rivalry between the seat of Guna as a Congress issues. The northern-most Mr. Chouhan is credited to as he takes on the BJP’s Congress. with the BSP, despite the
Pawar family and other prominent political candidate in 2019, is hop- Gwalior-Chambal region have defied the anti-incum- two-time MP Rodmal Na- This will be Mr. Scindia’s downward trend in its vote
families here, Mr. Ajit and the Mahayuti ing to regain the consti- that shares boundaries bency trend and led the gar who is facing anti-in- first election since he shift- share, continuing to have a
gained considerable success in mending tuency on BJP ticket. with Uttar Pradesh and Ra- party to a resounding cumbency sentiments. ed to the BJP in March significance presence in
fences with old rivals. Apart from these seats, jasthan is heavily in- majority. Mr. Singh, fondly called 2020, leading a rebellion the area.
According to observers, a defeat for Ms. Morena, Bhind (SC) and fluenced by caste politics. However, Mr. Chouhan, Raja Saheb, hails from the with 22 MLAs to bring Bhind (SC) and Gwalior
Sunetra would pose a big question mark on Gwalior seats of the crucial Unemployment, poverty fondly called Mama, was erstwhile royal family of down the Kamal Nath-led are expected to see caste
Mr. Ajit’s political future in Mahayuti. Gwalior-Chambal belt, and and migration are the key replaced as Chief Minister Rajgarh’s Raghogarh and Congress government. equations play a major role
If Ms. Sule loses, it would mean the Bhopal, Sagar, and Betul issues in the tribal-domi- with a younger face, Ujjain his family has long enjoyed The BJP fielded him af- in the polls with voters and
twilight of Baramati’s idol — Mr. Sharad. (ST) will also vote on May 7. nated Betul. MLA Mohan Yadav. After a a dominance in the region ter denying ticket to in- local BJP leaders admitting
Either way, the last verse of this Homeric At present, all the nine Mr. Chouhan had vacat- few months of suspense as he held the seat for two cumbent MP K.P. Yadav, that the Congress’ candi-
tussle between the Pawars has yet to be seats are held by the ruling ed the Vidisha constituen- over his future role, Mr. terms and his brother Lax- who had defeated Mr. Scin- date selection has made
written. BJP, but emerging equa- cy in 2005 when he was Chouhan is back for a sixth man Singh held it for five dia last time. In a replica- the contests more intense.
CM M ND-NDE
YK
 THE HINDU
14 Friday, May 3, 2024

News Delhi

INBRIEF
쑽 Manipur violence: a year Year since conflict,
kin of missing Meiteis
on, number of FIRs brought in Delhi seek closure
down from 11,000 to 3,000 Abhinay Lakshman
NEW DELHI
#Justice4MissingMeeteis”.
In the one year of the
conflict between the val-
The number of cases had shot up owing to overlap, several duplicate FIRs for the same incident Nearly six months after her ley-based Meitei people
19-year-old son Anthony and the hills-based Kuki-Zo
and thousands of zero FIRs, says official; Biren Singh appeals to people to surrender weapons
ED gets custody of Haryana went missing upon cross-
ing the buffer zone, Prem-
tribals, over 220 people
have been killed, thou-
Congress MLA’s son till May 6 lata Ningthoujam keeps a sands of others have been
Vijaita Singh violence stood at 150, plate out for him even to- injured, and tens of thou-
The Enforcement Directorate (ED) has taken the NEW DELHI while subsequently 71 had day while they eat their sands of people have been
custody of Sikandar Singh Chhoker, son of been killed, bringing the daily meals. A tradition in internally displaced. Amid
Congress MLA Dharam Singh Chhoker, in the year after ethnic death toll to 221. As many Meitei communities, the this, while the Meitei com-
case of Sai Aaina Farms Private Limited and
others for allegedly siphoning off hundreds of
crores of homebuyers’ money related to multiple
A violence erupted in
Manipur, the clean-
up of records has brought
as 15 members of the Kuki-
Zo community and 32
members of the Meitei
practice is something fami-
lies follow in the hopes that
their loved ones will re-
munity has said that there
was no news of 31 of their
people still missing, the
projects in Gurugram, the agency said on down the total number of community have been mis- turn. “Every time we clear Kuki-Zo people have said 15
Thursday. It is alleged that Mr. Sikandar had been violence-related first infor- sing for a year. the untouched plate, our of theirs were still unac-
absconding for the past four months and was mation reports (FIRs) from Mr. Singh said in a post hearts break all over counted for.
traced to Haridwar in Uttarakhand on April 30. A over 11,000 to around on X that the first phase of again,” Ms. Ningthoujam
court had issued non-bailable arrest warrants 3,000, a government deportation of “illegal im- said. Ex-journalist missing
against him. After arresting him, the probe source told The Hindu. migrants” from Myanmar She was among dozens In the national capital for
agency produced him before a special court, The number of cases was completed on Thurs- of people who arrived in the gathering, 47-year-old
which sent him to ED custody till May 6. had shot up owing to over- day as 38 immigrants left Delhi on Thursday in a bid Kabita Atom said: “I last
lap, several duplicate FIRs The first phase of deportation of “illegal immigrants” from Myanmar Manipur for Myanmar to make an appeal to find saw my husband on May 6
for the same incident and has been completed, the Manipur government said. @NBIRENSINGH/X through the Moreh border their loved ones — people last year. That afternoon,
ffa76243-386b-4d4d-93fa-f34e5b20443d

thousands of zero FIRs, the
SC advocates’ association official said. Zero FIRs are
filed irrespective of juris-
elects new office-bearers diction and are later trans-
ferred to the police station
The powerful Supreme Court Advocate-on where the crime took
-Record Association (SCAORA), which place.
spearheaded the case against the National Chief Minister N. Biren
Judicial Appointments Commission, elected a Singh said that the people
change of guard in polls held recently. Advocate should be united and there
Vipin Nair was elected president of SCAORA in should be no attempts to
the election held on April 29. Mr. Nair, a former divide society. “Those who
secretary of SCAORA, has been a part of several have committed the crimes
public interest litigation pleas, including those in should be prosecuted le-
the NJAC and the right to privacy writ involving gally. I appeal to the people
Aadhaar. Advocate Amit Sharma, who represents from both sides to surren-
the Election Commission in the top court, was der weapons,” Mr. Singh
also elected vice-president. Advocates Nikhil Jain told The Hindu.
and Aljo Joseph were elected secretary and More than 4,500 wea-
treasurer, respectively. pons were looted from pol-
ice armouries after ethnic
violence erupted in the
State on May 3, 2023. Till
now, around 1,800 wea-
pons have been recovered
or surrendered by the civi-
lians. The conflict is bet-
ween the tribal Kuki-Zo pe-
ople and the majority
Meitei community.
The government source
said that thousands were
displaced and due to the
prevailing law and order
situation, they registered
FIRs at places convenient
to them, which also includ-
ed neighbouring States.
“If an arson has taken
place in a village, several
FIRs were registered for
the same crime, a team
was constituted that
cleaned up the records,”
said the source.
According to a status re-
port filed by the State go-
vernment on August 1 last
year, 4,766 regular FIRs
were registered till July 30
the same year. Out of 11,414
zero FIRs, as many as 6,621
FIRs were converted to reg-
ular FIRs, the report said,
adding that “there is an
overlap of offences”.
The death toll in the in-
itial three months of the
check post. “Without any
discrimination, we have
completed the first phase
of deportation of illegal im-
migrants from Myanmar
with 38 more immigrants
leaving Manipur today
through Moreh. A total of
77 illegal immigrants have
been deported in the first
phase. One Indian national
was also brought back
from Myanmar during the
handover ceremony. The
State government is conti-
nuing the identification of
illegal immigrants and at
the same time biometric
data are being recorded,”
he said.
who were reported to have
gone missing in the course
of the ethnic conflict in Ma-
nipur, which began one
year ago on May 3, 2023.
A group of Meitei civil
society organisations had
brought the families to-
gether for a press meet at
the Press Club of India in
New Delhi, stating that
there was still no news of 31
people from the communi-
ty who had gone missing
during the conflict. As the
families addressed the
press, a poster behind
them had pictures of those
missing, with the phrase:
“Let them Rest in Peace,
ffa76243-386b-4d4d-93fa-f34e5b20443d
he was visiting a friend and
he told me on the phone
that he would be back
soon. We never saw him af-
ter that.” A former journal-
ist, Atom Samarendra,
along with his friend Y. Ki-
ran Kumar, had gone mis-
sing that day.
“If he is alive, then we
request that he be released
and if not, at least his re-
mains should be sent back
to us for the last rites,” she
said, adding that while the
Manipur police registered
a First Information Report
that very day, they had not
got in touch with them
since about the probe.

‘Chinese govt. was ultimate USCIRF is

paymaster of NewsClick’
Ishita Mishra
NEW DELHI
The Delhi Police have ac-
cused NewsClick founder
Prabir Purkayastha and hu-
man resources head of the
news portal Amit Chakra-
borty of acting at the beh-
est of the Chinese govern-
ment, which the
chargesheet describes as
their “ultimate
paymaster”.
The chargesheet filed
under anti-terror law Un-
lawful Activities (Preven-
tion) Act (UAPA) is primari-
ly based on the police’s
interpretation of strings of
emails exchanged between
Mr. Purkayastha, Ameri-
can millionaire Neville Roy
Singham and a few others
(whose role in the case is
under investigation), along
with the testimonies of
protected witnesses,
which includes employees
of the news portal.
In the 169-page primary
The chargesheet says
accused wanted to
replace Indian
democracy with
party-state system
chargesheet that has 7,382
pages of annexures, the
police say that Mr. Pur-
kayastha and Mr. Singham
were conspiring “nothing
else but to forcibly replace
Indian democracy with the
party-state system similar
to the one that exists in
present-day China”.
The chargesheet also al-
leged that Mr. Purkayastha
infused funds from China
into India to stoke and sus-
tain the 2020 Delhi riots
and even the farmers’
protest.
The police said that the
accused allied with, sup-
ported and funded Pakis-
tan-sponsored Kashmiri
terrorists’ groups and
Maoist LWE (Left Wing Ex-
tremist) organisations.
The chargesheet also al-
leged that out of the funds
received from Mr. Sing-
ham, Mr. Purkayastha gave
₹36 lakh to a person with
the direction to give it
further to Sharjeel Imam
for inciting the Delhi riots
of 2020.
Meanwhile, NewsClick
has rejected allegations
made by the police in the
chargesheet and main-
tained that neither is Mr.
Purkayastha associated
with any terror outfit nor is
there any evidence for the
same.
The organisation said
that the investigations by
the Delhi Police and other
agencies are attempts to
target its independent
journalism.
The Special Cell of the
Delhi Police arrested Mr.
Purkayastha and Mr. Chak-
raborty on October 3 last
year. They have been in
judicial custody since.
biased and
has a political
agenda: MEA
The Hindu Bureau
NEW DELHI
India on Thursday hit out
at the U.S. Commission on
International Religious
Freedom (USCIRF), and
said that it is trying to “in-
terfere” in the Indian elec-
tion process. Speaking to
the media during the week-
ly interaction, Ministry of
External Affairs spokesper-
son Randhir Jaiswal de-
scribed the U.S. govern-
ment entity, which came
out with a report on reli-
gious freedom earlier this
week, as a “biased organi-
sation with a political
agenda”.
The report had de-
manded that India should
be declared by the U.S. go-
vernment as a “country of
particular concern” be-
cause of what it described
as “particularly severe reli-
gious freedom violations”.
Centre to train State police
forces on new criminal laws
S. Vijay Kumar
CHENNAI
The Union government has
rolled out an intensive
training strategy for police
and prison department
personnel across the coun-
try on the new criminal
laws and to sensitise them
to the transition from the
colonial legacies to a new
system of justice.
In a communication to
heads of police forces and
prison departments, the
Ministry of Home Affairs
said Parliament had re-
placed the three existing
laws, namely the Indian
Penal Code, 1860; the Code
of Criminal Procedure,
1973; and the Indian Evi-
dence Act, 1872 by three
new progressive and mod-
ern pieces of legislation —
the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhi-
ta, 2023; Bharatiya Nagarik
Suraksha Sanhita, 2023;
and Bharatiya Sakshya Ad-
hiniyam, 2023,
The Bureau of Police Research
& Development developed a
training module. FILE PHOTO
respectively.
The new laws that were
aimed at providing speedy
justice to the citizens and
strengthening the judicial
and court management
system were based on the
principle of access to jus-
tice by all and would come
into force from July 1.
The Home Ministry said
the new criminal law had
several new provisions,
synchronised with mod-
ern-day times and contem-
porary technologies. They
were envisaged at bringing
in an era of ease of policing
and justice. It was the en-
deavour of the Union go-
vernment to reach out to
all ranks of police and pri-
son officers in the country
to make them aware of the
positive and advanced
changes so as to equip
them with the basic know-
ledge and understanding
of various new provisions.
The Bureau of Police Re-
search & Development
(BPR&D), a premier train-
ing and research arm of
the Home Ministry, had de-
veloped the Training of
Trainers’ module and va-
rious other training pro-
grammes for different le-
vels of police/prison
personnel on the new cri-
minal laws. Integration had
been completed with the
‘Integrated Government
Online Training’ (iGOT)
portal to make the courses
available to the trainees.
‘All adverse
events after
vaccine being
monitored’
The Hindu Bureau
NEW DELHI
All adverse events follow-
ing immunisation (AEFI)
after COVID-19 vaccina-
tions continue to be moni-
tored, a senior Union
Health Ministry official,
who did not wish to be
named, said on Thursday.
Earlier this week, phar-
maceutical company As-
traZeneca admitted in a
U.K. court that its COVID-19
vaccine had the potential
to cause thrombosis with
thrombocytopenia syn-
drome (TTS), a rare side ef-
fect associated with blood
clotting.
“After 2022-23, the de-
mand for COVID vaccine
dropped and now we are
seeing less than a lakh peo-
ple coming in for vaccina-
tion or the booster dose,”
public health expert N.K.
Arora said.

To solve this puzzle online,

SCAN TO PLAY
SUDOKU
14165 get across to our crossword site. 쑽
@ https://qrgo.page.link/jjpTn
(set by Saral)

14 Husband checking attractive vocation (5)

15 Grab bits of guava (ripe) fruit (7)
18 Partners returning incentives including benefit (7)
19 Second tenor with often best composition (5)
20 Used my parents' names once at first, created Saral, for
example (9)
24 Troop falsely arresting journalist for explosive (7)
25 They cover, perhaps home with certain risk initially (7)
27 Careless chap beside blazing ingle (9)
28 Man driving out large untied animal (5)
Down
1 Dossier about company director on vacation is returned (6)
2 Restricts drunk son outside empty IIM (6)
3 Snowman still followed by Indian? (4)
4 Chairs before teams (8)
5 Complaint of general (army officer) diagnosed at last (6,4)
6 Harry, I've coins for bills (8)
7 Problems in note by assessors (8)
9 Yearns for trees (5)
13 Feeling it induces vomit while circling passage (10)
15 German maiden decked by fantastic set, one in diamond, say
Across (8)
8 The best among the literates (5) 16 Adjust, say ring of intimate friend (5,3)
9 Auditor's private staff (9) 17 Blows up old cartel finally with dopes in shambles (8)
21 Expel European champion missing gold (5)
10 View over wing (7)
22 New marker is thin (6)
11 Sly mobs defiled logos (7)
23 Eliminate the German behind drink counter (6)
12 Scattered and chased by daughter, spiders wandering near
base (9) 26 Score? Zero for wrestler (4)
CM
YK
Solution to previous puzzle
FAITH
쑽
Dwelling places of Lakshmi
People can follow the tenets of the Vedas but cannot ques-
tion them. They have been time-tested and followed by va-
rious sages and saints from the days of yore and handed to
us. The Vedas teach about dharmas. Because of the Vedas,
dharmas are established, and because dharmas are fol-
lowed, Vedas are fostered.
Sri Anantha Padmanabhachariar Swamy said in a dis-
course that “Upanyasam” (discourse) means to bring a
person nearer to God, like the Upanishads. The common
cherished desire of all human beings is to derive wealth
(Lakshmikataksham).
Karma yoga includes the performance of yagnas and
Solution to yesterday’s Sudoku
giving to charity. For all these, wealth is essential. People
can earn money to lead a legitimate and pious life. An oft-
repeated question is where Goddess Lakshmi (in charge of
wealth) will reside. The simple answer is that She dwells in
all places where righteous activities and good deeds are
undertaken. Rama Himself worshipped Sri Ranganatha,
showing that worshipping Kuladevatha (presiding deity) is
important.
Goddess Mahalakshmi declares that she will reside in
those houses where the following dharmas are practised:
guests coming to a house are well received and enter-
tained; poojas are done with sincere devotion.
M ND-NDE
 THE HINDU
Friday, May 3, 2024 15
Delhi
Business

INBRIEF
쑽 April PMI signals second-best gain in MARKETS
쑽
MARKET WATCH

manufacturing sector in 42 months THURSDAY

Sensex dddddddddddddddddddddddddddddd 74,611 dddddddddddddddddddddd 0.17
US Dollardddddddddddddddddddddddddddd 83.46 dddddddddddddddddddd -0.03
Gold dddddddddddddddddddddddddddddddddd 72,350 dddddddddddddddddddd -0.34
% CHANGE

Brent oil ddddddddddddddddddddddddddddd 83.20 dddddddddddddddddddddddddd —

New orders increased at the second-fastest pace in almost 40 months with domestic demand outpacing export orders, the
PMI survey showed; manufacturers ramped up hiring at a moderate pace, which was still the quickest since last September NIFTY 50
PRICE CHANGE
Adani Enter . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . 3039.60. . . . . . . . -15.10
Vikas Dhoot employees at a moderate- nium, paper, plastics and Adani Ports. . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . 1338.80. . . . . . . . . . 13.90
Apollo Hosp. . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . 5958.55. . . . . . . . . . 11.45
NEW DELHI pace, which was still the steel, and producers last Asian Paints. . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . 2975.40. . . . . . . . . . 99.50
quickest since September. month raised selling prices Axis Bank . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . 1149.85. . . . . . . . -16.05

I
Bajaj Auto . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . 9110.65. . . . . . . . 207.00
NPCI’s global arm to develop ndia’s manufacturing
activity eased in April
However, pressure on ca-
pacities remained mild.
at the fastest pace in three
months, noting that labour
Bajaj Finserv . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . 1615.45. . . . . . . . . . . . 0.45
Bajaj Finance . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . 6882.70. . . . . . . . -40.85

UPI-like system for Namibia but still signalled the
second-best improvement
NPCI International Payments Ltd. (NIPL), the in three-and-a-half years,
international arm of the National Payments as per the seasonally ad-
Corporation of India (NPCI), has signed an justed HSBC India Manu-
agreement with the Bank of Namibia to support facturing Purchasing Man-
the institution in developing an instant payment agers’ Index (PMI), which
system like the Unified Payment Interface (UPI) slid to 58.8 from March’s
for Namibia. “By leveraging technology and 16-year high of 59.1.
experiences from India’s UPI, the partnership New orders rose at the
seeks to help Namibia modernise its financial second-strongest pace in
ecosystem,” NIPL said in a statement. almost 40 months, with
domestic demand rising
faster than export orders,
the PMI survey suggested.
Aadhar Housing Finance
Output growth slowed but
was still the second-fastest
in 42 months.
Bolstered by current
and anticipated upticks in
demand, manufacturers
reported higher confi-
dence levels with expecta-
tions of higher output a
year ahead. Firms added
Even though input costs
rose, producers took input
purchases to the highest le-
vel since June, and expan-
sion of stock inventories
was the third-strongest
since early 2005, when the
PMI data collection began.
Expectations that demand
conditions will remain con-
ducive to growth support-
ed inventory-building in-
itiatives, HSBC said.
Price gains were report-
ed for materials like alumi-
costs had also gone up.
“Higher costs of raw ma-
terials and labour led to a
modest uptick in input
costs, but inflation remains
below the historical aver-
age.” said HSBC’s chief In-
dia economist Pranjul
Bhandari. “However, firms
passed these increases on-
to consumers through
higher output charges, as
demand remained resi-
lient, resulting in improved
margins,” she added.
Bharti Airtel . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . 1304.05. . . . . . . . -18.25
BPCL . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . 634.65. . . . . . . . . . 27.30
Britannia Ind . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . 4759.65. . . . . . . . -16.30
Cipla . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . 1420.05. . . . . . . . . . 20.05
Coal India . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . 453.90. . . . . . . . . . -0.40
Divis Lab . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . 3964.65. . . . . . . . -37.75
Dr Reddys Lab . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . 6287.50. . . . . . . . . . 83.20
Eicher Motors . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . 4602.40. . . . . . . . . . . . 5.00
Grasim Ind . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . 2437.35. . . . . . . . . . 25.70
HCL Tech . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . 1360.70. . . . . . . . . . -5.90
HDFC Bank . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . 1532.25. . . . . . . . . . 12.15
HDFC Life . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . 576.35. . . . . . . . . . -7.30
Hero MotoCorp . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . 4561.50. . . . . . . . . . 18.45
Hindalco . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . 641.45. . . . . . . . . . -2.95
Hind Unilever . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . 2226.30. . . . . . . . . . -4.15
ICICI Bank . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . 1139.45. . . . . . . . -10.95
IndusInd Bank. . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . 1505.20. . . . . . . . -10.50
Infosys . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . 1414.45. . . . . . . . . . -6.10
ITC . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . 439.00. . . . . . . . . . . . 3.35
JSW Steel . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . 890.35. . . . . . . . . . . . 8.15
Kotak Bank . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . 1575.65. . . . . . . . -48.30
L&T . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . 3599.50. . . . . . . . . . . . 5.20
LTIMindtree Ltd. . . . . . . .. . . . . . . 4692.70. . . . . . . . -13.70
M&M . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . 2185.15. . . . . . . . . . 28.80

unveils ₹3,000-crore IPO Maruti Suzuki . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . 12805.35. . . . . . . . -12.15

ffa76243-386b-4d4d-93fa-f34e5b20443d

ffa76243-386b-4d4d-93fa-f34e5b20443d
NestleIndia . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . 2512.30. . . . . . . . . . . . 4.90

Aadhar Housing Finance Ltd. has announced to

open its ₹3,000-crore initial public offering (IPO)
on May 8. The price band has been fixed at
Federal Bank
Q4 net profit
Maersk raises profit guidance on NTPC . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . 369.05. . . . . . . . . . . . 5.85
ONGC . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . 282.80. . . . . . . . . . -0.05
PowerGrid Corp . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . 313.60. . . . . . . . . . 11.75
Reliance Ind . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . 2933.10. . . . . . . . . . -0.90

strong demand and Red Sea conflict

SBI Life. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . 1460.90. . . . . . . . . . 24.35

₹300-₹315 per equity share of a face value of ₹10

each. Bids will close on May 10. Bids can be made
inches up to
for a minimum of 47 equity shares in multiples of
47 shares thereafter. The IPO comprises a fresh
₹906 crore
issue of ₹1,000 crore and an offer for sale
aggregating up to ₹2,000 crore by BCP Topco VII The Hindu Bureau
Pte. Ltd., the promoter selling shareholder. MUMBAI
Federal Bank Ltd. reported
fourth-quarter net profit
LTTS bags €45 mn order from inched up to ₹906.30
crore, from ₹902.61 crore
French auto major FORVIA in the year-earlier period.
For the quarter ended
L&T Technology Services said it has signed a €45 March 31, Net Interest In-
Reuters
COPENHAGEN
Shipping group Maersk
raised its full-year profit
guidance after reporting
first-quarter earnings on
Thursday, citing strong de-
mand and longer sailing
times to avoid conflict in
the Red Sea.
Maersk posted a
third straight
quarterly loss in the
ocean container
shipping division
demand for container
shipping had been stron-
ger than forecast.
Maersk and rivals have
diverted ships around Afri-
ca since December to avoid
attacks by the Houthi mili-
tants, sending freight rates
higher because of the lon-
ger sailing times.
‘Adjusted networks’
“We have only seen an es-
calation of the situation in
$6 billion this year, com-
pared with previous gui-
dance between $1 billion
and $6 billion.
EBITDA stood at $1.59
billion in the first three
months of the year, com-
pared with $1.46 billion ex-
pected by analysts in an
LSEG poll, and $3.97 bil-
lion a year earlier when
State Bank . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . 830.05. . . . . . . . . . . . 3.80
Shriram Finance
Ltd. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . 2582.10. . . . . . . . . . 30.40
Sun Pharma . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . 1519.00. . . . . . . . . . 16.90
TataConsumerPro-
duct . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . 1091.15. . . . . . . . -17.20
Tata Motors . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . 1027.80. . . . . . . . . . 19.90
Tata Steel . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . 167.35. . . . . . . . . . . . 2.35
TCS . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . 3863.30. . . . . . . . . . 42.65
Tech Mahindra . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . 1266.90. . . . . . . . . . . . 3.40
Titan. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . 3568.45. . . . . . . . -20.80
UltraTech Cement . . . .. . . . . . . 9983.45. . . . . . . . . . 11.60
Wipro . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . 457.40. . . . . . . . . . -5.00
EXCHANGE RATES
Indicative direct rates in rupees a unit except yen at 4
p.m. on May 02

million contract with FORVIA, a French global come (NII) grew 15% to The company, viewed as High volumes the area and therefore we freight rates were boosted CURRENCY TT BUY TT SELL

automotive supplier, to offer engineering ₹2,195.11 crore. a barometer of world “The container volumes can see that not only by a pandemic-related US Dollar . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . 83.27. . . . . . . . . . 83.59
Euro. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . 89.11. . . . . . . . . . 89.46
development services to the latter’s Clean The Board recommend- trade, said that shipping we see today are quite high Maersk but all shipping boost to demand. British Pound . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . 104.20. . . . . . . . 104.60
Mobility division. As part of the five-year ed a dividend of ₹1.2 per disruptions caused by compared to GDP growth lines have adjusted their Still, Maersk posted a Japanese Yen (100) . . . . . . .. . . . . 53.63. . . . . . . . . . 53.84
Chinese Yuan . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . 11.50. . . . . . . . . . 11.54
partnership, about 300 engineers from FORVIA’s equity share with a face va- Houthi militants’ attacks in the world economy,” networks more or less per- third straight quarterly loss Swiss Franc. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . 91.28. . . . . . . . . . 91.63
Augsburg and Bengaluru sites had been lue of ₹2 for FY24. on vessels in the Red Sea said CEO Vincent Clerc. “At manently,” Mr. Clerc said. in its ocean container ship- Singapore Dollar . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . 61.23. . . . . . . . . . 61.48
Canadian Dollar . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . 60.67. . . . . . . . . . 60.91
transferred to LTTS. This represents a 95% In FY24, the bank’s total were expected to last at one point or another, we Maersk now expects ping division, mainly ow- Malaysian Ringitt . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . 17.51. . . . . . . . . . 17.58
transfer success rate in securing the skills of business grew 19.1% YoY to least until the end of the will see a normalisation of full-year underlying EBIT- ing to higher costs related Australian Dollar . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . 54.32. . . . . . . . . . 54.53

these teams, the company said in a statement. ₹4,61,937.36 crore. year, adding that growth in volumes,” he added. DA between $4 billion and to the Red Sea disruptions. Source:Indian Bank

Adani Enterprises Q4
net profit slides 37%
Press Trust of India
NEW DELHI
Adani Enterprises Ltd., the
flagship incubator of billio-
naire Gautam Adani’s con-
glomerate, on Thursday re-
ported a 37% drop in
March quarter net profit,
bogged down by one-time
past airport dues and com-
mercial-mining losses.
Consolidated net profit
of ₹450.58 crore in the
fourth quarter of FY24
compares with a net profit
of ₹722.48 crore in the
same period last year and
₹1,888.45 crore earnings in
the preceding quarter, ac-
cording to a filing.
The firm reported an 8%
decline in EBITDA (earn-
ings before interest, taxes,
depreciation, and amorti-
sation) at ₹3,646 crore.
While incubating busi-
nesses like new energy and
airports showed strong
momentum, it suffered a
loss of ₹201.83 crore in
commercial mining, while
pre-tax earnings from the
road business plummeted
84% to ₹222.03 crore.
Also, its unit Mumbai In-
ternational Airport Ltd.
(MIAL) recognised a one-
time exceptional expense
of ₹627 crore to make up
for past payments.
Outlook for venture capital, private NMDC output slid 1%,
equity has improved: TVS Capital
Mini Tejaswi
BENGALURU
The outlook for India’s
private equity and venture
capital market appears
positive this year, com-
pared with last year, as
‘normalcy’ has returned in
the lives of investors, said
Anuradha Ramachandran,
Managing Partner, TVS
Capital Funds.
‘Excess funding’
Ms. Ramachandran said,
there had been excess
funding during 2020 and
2021 as both investors and
business owners had got
carried away. The pandem-
ic had brought about struc-
tural changes. Edtech
boomed because students
could not go to school and
sales rose 3% in April
Anuradha Ramachandran
they required digital edu-
cation, while consumer
goods had to be mostly
bought online and there-
fore B2C ventures did well.
“Now, the question is
how do you sustain growth
when structural disadvan-
tages no longer exist. That
is the conundrum both in-
vestors and businesses al-
ways faced and are still fac-
ing,” she added.
‘Return to normalcy’
Ms. Ramachandran ob-
served a lot of ‘normalisa-
tion’ had happened among
investors and entrepre-
neurs and conversations
were now getting better
with realistic expectations
from both sides.
“This scenario will
boost the growth of the
domestic funding market.
We hope, from now on,
things are going to be ea-
sier for both parties,” she
commented.
Funding winter, set in a
couple of years ago after
many global funds dialed
down their investments in
India because of a lack of
private fund availability,
coupled with the global
economic uncertainty.
“However, India by itself
is an attractive market, and
we do attract capital in the
early stage investments.
But in terms of return on
capital, our funding mar-
kets are yet to gain maturi-
ty,” she observed.
‘Credit averse’
On lending to women, she
said, women were credit
averse and were very res-
ponsible, yet opportunities
available for them could be
fewer, and that could also
be one of the reasons why
a lesser number of women
became entrepreneurs.
However, “it is encou-
raging to see some start-
ups having women co-
founders,” Ms. Ramachan-
dran added.
The Hindu Bureau
HYDERABAD
State-owned NMDC report-
ed iron-ore production for
April slid almost 1% while
sales increased almost 3%.
Production stood at 3.48
million tonne (mt) (3.51 mt)
and sales 3.53 mt (3.43 mt),
NMDC said in a filing on Amitava Mukherjee
the provisional numbers.
India’s largest iron-ore dia’s iron-ore output and
producer has been report- demand,” CMD (additional
ing a year-on-year decline charge) Amitava Mukher-
in output since February. jee said in a statement.
In March, production and
sales fell. For the year end- ‘Promising start’
ed March, it had reported a “All our mining complexes
10% increase in production have delivered a promising
to a record 45.1 mt and 16% start and are geared up to
higher sales at 44.48 mt. harmonise with the new
“We are targeting north mining technologies, navi-
of 10% growth in our vol- gate sectoral challenges
umes in FY25 attuned to and achieve 50 million
the growth trajectory of In- tonne,” he added.

‘Shriram Finance to focus on
small-ticket loans, used vehicles’ swell to 3-month high’ setting Brent oil benchmark
N. Anand
CHENNAI
Shriram Finance Ltd. (SFL)
will focus on building its
bottom line in a granular
manner by offering small-
ticket loans and high-yield-
ing products during the
current fiscal year, said ex-
ecutive vice chairman
Umesh G. Revankar.
“We will be focusing on
our niche area of small-
ticket lending and used
vehicle portfolio, where
high-yielding assets will be
given a little higher weight-
age,” Mr. Revankar said
during an interaction.
Asserting that the com-
pany’s growth would be ca-
librated and SFL would be
focusing on improving the
bottom line, he said the
CM
YK
‘April palm-oil imports Reliance starts trading U.S. oil
Umesh G. Revankar
emphasis would be to raise
efficiency and profitability,
and not unduly focus on
the top line growth.
In FY24, SFL’s standa-
lone net profit rose 20%
YoY to ₹7,190 crore, while
total income increased by
17% to ₹34,998 crore.
According to him, the
industry might expect
slower growth in Q1 of
FY25 as the government
machinery was involved in
the elections during April
and May.
“There is likely to be
some slowdown in the ca-
pex activity of the govern-
ment and infrastructure
projects,” he said.
Mr. Revankar said
though the growth may be
a little slow in Q1, SFL ex-
pects good demand from
rural areas in Q2 with the
IMD’s prediction on the
monsoon being a positive.
Talking about the FY25
guidance for return on
equity, he said: “We are al-
ready at 16.4% and we
should be able to cross
17%. By FY26, we will be at
18%”. “Assets under man-
agement will grow at 15%
for FY25,” he added.
Reuters
MUMBAI
India’s palm-oil imports
jumped by 41% in April
from the previous month
to reach the highest level in
three months, as easing
prices prompted refiners
to increase purchases, five
dealers told Reuters.
Higher palm-oil pur-
chases by India, the
world’s biggest importer of
vegetable oils, could sup-
port the benchmark Malay-
sian palm oil futures that
are trading near their low-
est level in three months.
Palm oil imports in April
jumped to 6,82,000 metric
tonne, dealers estimate.
Palm oil has become
more attractive to buyers
due to a recent price cor-
rection that eliminated its
premium over soybean
and sunflower oil, said Ra-
jesh Patel, managing partn-
er at GGN Research.
Crude palm-oil imports
are offered at about $920 a
metric tonne, including
cost, insurance and
freight, in India for June
delivery, while soyoil and
sunflower oil are offered at
about $920 and $945 a
tonne, respectively.
Reuters
LONDON
India’s Reliance has made
its first foray into trading a
type of U.S. crude oil that
underpins the global Brent
benchmark in a process
run by oil-index publisher
S&P Global Commodity In-
sights, the publisher said.
RIL, operator of the
world’s biggest refining
complex, on Wednesday
offered a cargo of WTI Mi-
dland in the Platts Market
on Close process, known
as the Platts window.
It was Reliance’s first
time offering WTI in the
window, Platts spokesper-
son Kathleen Tanzy told
Reuters. A Reliance spo-
kesperson did not imme-
diately respond to a Reu-
ters request for comment.
India, the world’s third-
biggest oil importer and
consumer, is looking to di-
versify its oil supplies as
fresh U.S. sanctions on
Moscow threaten to dent
Russian oil sales to India,
the biggest buyer of Rus-
sian seaborne crude.
Reliance made its first
oil purchase from Canada’s
new Trans Mountain pipe-
line last month, trade
sources said.
More players have be-
come involved in trading
crude that can set the
Brent price in the Platts
window since Platts added
WTI to the benchmark last
year.
U.S. WTI Midland is one
of six crude-oil grades as-
sessed by Platts that can set
the value of dated Brent,
part of the wider Brent
complex used to price
more than three-quarters
of the world’s traded oil.
The price of dated Brent
is set by the cheapest of the
six crudes and Midland, by
far the largest of the six
crude streams, often plays
a role in setting its value.
The other five are North
Sea crudes.
M ND-NDE
 THE HINDU
16 Friday, May 3, 2024

World Delhi

EDINBURGH LAHORE WASHINGTON HONIARA

John Swinney on course to be PML-N leader hints at early polls Biden calls ally Japan ‘xenophobic’ China-friendly Manele elected as
crowned Scotland’s First Minister to facilitate Nawaz’s return as PM along with India, China and Russia Solomon Islands Prime Minister

AFP REUTERS AP AFP

X X X X
Scotland’s John Swinney was poised on Thursday to become First Senior Pakistan Muslim League-Nawaz (PML-N) leader Javed Latif Japan and India are struggling economically because they are Solomon Islands MPs elected China-friendly former Foreign Minister
Minister and return as leader of the governing Scottish National has hinted at the possibility of fresh elections in Pakistan within the “xenophobic,” U.S. President Joe Biden told a campaign event. Jeremiah Manele as Prime Minister on Thursday, choosing him over
Party (SNP) after his main rival and former Finance Secretary Kate next two years to pave the way for Nawaz Sharif to secure a record “Why is China stalling so badly economically? Why is Japan in an opposition leader intent on curbing Beijing's reach in the Pacific
Forbes decided against running for the top job. Outgoing First fourth term as Prime Minister. Mr. Latif’s comments came during an trouble? Why is Russia in trouble? And India? Because they are nation. Manele won 31 votes in a secret ballot of 50 MPs in polls that
Minister Humza Yousaf announced his resignation on Monday. AFP interview with a private TV channel. PTI xenophobic. They don’t want immigrants,” Mr. Biden said. AFP will resonate in China, the U.S. and across the South Pacific. AFP

Police make arrests at UCLA Sri Lanka political parties use May
after clashes with protesters Day to put forward poll aspirations
ffa76243-386b-4d4d-93fa-f34e5b20443d

ffa76243-386b-4d4d-93fa-f34e5b20443d
Pro-Palestinian demonstrators arrested from college campuses across the U.S. overnight; police Meera Srinivasan Leader of Opposition Sajith
crackdown echoed actions decades ago against a much larger movement protesting Vietnam War COLOMBO Premadasa, pledged to im-
plement the 13th Amend-
With a presidential elec- ment to the Sri Lankan
Associated Press nationwide. The ensuing tion expected later this constitution, which pro-
LOS ANGELES police crackdowns echoed year, the May Day rallies of mises a measure of power
actions decades ago all main political parties in devolution to the provinc-

T
he police arrested
pro-Palestinian
protesters on col-
lege campuses across the
country overnight, notably
at the University of Califor-
nia, Los Angeles, where
chaotic scenes played out
early on Thursday as offic-
ers in riot gear surged
against a crowd of demon-
strators and made arrests.
The police removed bar-
ricades and began disman-
tling demonstrators’ forti-
fied encampment at UCLA
after hundreds of protes-
ters defied orders to leave,
some of them forming hu-
man chains as police fired
flash-bangs to break up the
crowds.
Numerous protesters
were arrested, their hands
bound with zip ties.
The action came after
officers spent hours threa-
Reining in: Protesters being detained by the police at the University
of California, Los Angeles, on Thursday. REUTERS
tening arrests over loud-
speakers if people did not
disperse. A crowd of more
than 1,000 had gathered
on campus, both inside a
barricaded tent encamp-
ment and outside it, in sup-
port. Protesters and the
police shoved and scuffled.
Protesters chanted,
“Where were you last
night?” at the officers, in
reference to Tuesday
night, when counterprot-
esters attacked the en-
campment and the UCLA
administration and cam-
pus police took hours to
respond.
Tent encampments of
protesters calling on un-
iversities to stop doing bu-
siness with Israel or com-
panies they say support
the war in Gaza have
spread across campuses
against a much larger prot-
est movement protesting
the Vietnam War.
Yale University police
arrested four persons on
Wednesday night after
around 200 demonstrators
marched to the school pre-
sident’s home and to the
campus police depart-
ment.
In Oregon, the police
have started working to
clear demonstrators out of
a library at Portland State
University.
The protests at UCLA
appeared to be getting the
most attention. Iranian
state television carried live
images of the police action,
as did Qatar’s pan-Arab Al
Jazeera satellite network.
Live images of Los Angeles
also played across Israeli
television networks, as
well.
Sri Lanka seemed a pre-
lude to their poll cam-
paigns. Leaders of various
political camps made a di-
rect pitch to the people in
their respective public
events, seeking their sup-
port in what would be the
first election since the is-
land nation’s debilitating
economic crisis in 2022.
A year into the Interna-
tional Monetary Fund’s
programme, that brought
with it tough austerity
measures, many Sri Lan-
kans are reeling under the
impact of steep tax hikes,
and higher fuel and energy
prices, amid high living
costs.
Increase in daily wage
President Ranil Wickre-
mesinghe, who participat-
ed at the May Day event of
the Ceylon Workers’ Con-
Show of strength: The May Day rally held by the centre-left
Janatha Vimukthi Peramuna in Colombo. MEERA SRINIVASAN
gress in Kotagala in the
Central Province, where
many Malaiyaha Tamils, in-
cluding estate workers re-
side and work, announced
an increase in the daily
wage of plantation sector
workers, to LKR 1700
(roughly ₹ 477). Underscor-
ing his government’s “dili-
gent efforts” to stabilise the
country’s economy, he
further pledged to convert
workers’ colonial-era line
room accommodation to
“villages”.
Speaking later at a Co-
lombo rally organised by
his United National Party
(UNP), Mr. Wickremes-
inghe said his government
took “difficult decisions”
for economic recovery
while challenging the main
Opposition party Samagi
Jana Balawegaya (SJB or
United People’s Force) and
the centre-left Janatha Vi-
mukthi Peramuna ( JVP or
People’s Liberation Front)
on what their response had
been.
Addressing the SJB’s
May Day rally in Colombo,
es. Further, he proposed a
“national wealth fund” to
ensure prosperity of future
generations.
The JVP-led National Pe-
ople’s Power coalition put
up a big show in capital Co-
lombo, with scores of
members and supporters
marching across the city,
chanting “we want a go-
vernment”. The party and
its now-popular leader An-
ura Kumara Dissanayake
told supporters gathered
near Colombo’s Town Hall:
“We should create Sri Lan-
ka’s biggest people’s move-
ment, in order to bring in a
new era.”
Tamil parties from the
island’s north and east
held May Day events high-
lighting pending concerns
over accountability, power
devolution, and ongoing
land grabs in the region.

Crime and cost of living left, London Mayor election has a

right and centre as London Delhi-born candidate in the fray
citizens vote for a Mayor
Sriram Lakshman
LONDON
Voters in England and
Wales are going to the polls
on Thursday, to elect a
number of local govern-
ment officials, but the
most-watched race is in
London, where the incum-
bent Mayor, the Labour
Party’s Sadiq Khan, is seek-
ing a third term as he runs
against 12 other
candidates.
The three other conten-
ders dominating the air
waves are Conservative
candidate Susan Hall, Lib-
eral Democrat (Lib Dem)
Rob Blackie and the Green
Party’s Zoë Garbett. Also
running is independent
candidate, Delhi-born Ta-
run Ghulati.
Crime and safety have
been at the top of the list
for voters as has the related
topic of confidence in the
Met (Metropolitan Police).
On Tuesday, a sword-
wielding man killed a 14-
year-old child and injured
several other people in
London, where blade relat-
ed crimes are high relative
to other cities. The cost of
living, especially as it im-
pacts housing and tran-
sport costs is another cru-
cial manifesto issue for
candidates.
School meals
Mr. Khan’s main pledge is
free primary school meals.
He introduced these at the
start of the 2023 school
year as an emergency mea-
sure to help parents with
the cost of living crisis. He
is now proposing making
CM
YK
Sadiq Khan
the scheme permanent. He
has also pledged to in-
crease policing and is in
competition with Ms. Hall
over how many new police
offers they will deploy.
Opinion poll
The incumbent’s other
priorities include afforda-
ble housing and transport
— but with Londoners reel-
ing from higher costs of liv-
ing than when he assumed
office, Mr. Khan has the ad-
ded task of defending his
record so far. A YouGov
poll report released on
Wednesday said 47% of po-
tential voters planned to
vote for Mr. Khan while
25% planned to vote for
Ms. Hall (1,192 adults sur-
veyed between April 24-
30).
Nevertheless, respon-
dents were split on his re-
cord to date, with 41% ap-
proving and 46% saying he
has done a bad job.
One of the messages of
the Khan campaign has
been that he will be able to
achieve much more than in
the last few years if there is
a Labour Chancelor of the
Exchequer and govern-
ment following the U.K.’s
Sriram Lakshman
LONDON
whether to heat or eat,”
Mr. Ghulati told The Hindu,
Mr. Ghulati’s formula for
making housing more af-
describing the cost of living fordable in London in-
general election later this As London goes to the crisis. He hopes to bring cludes rent-control laws in
year. Ms. Hall, a London polls on Thursday to elect his finance background to areas undergoing gentrifi-
Assembly member, has a Mayor, Delhi-born Tarun create funds for London. cation and changing land-
said that she will increase Ghulati is among the 13 As part of his plan, Mr. use regulations. He also
the number of police offic- candidates for voters to Ghulati said he would want wants to reduce the
ers and introduce Bo- choose from. Mr. Ghulati, more “bobbies (police) on amount of congestion
rough-based policing to an investment banker and the beat” . “But of the right charges paid by car drivers
tackle crime (i.e., more lo- strategic advisor, is run- kind,” he adds, meaning using London roads.
calised police forces). ning as an Independent. they should come from di- (Full interview
She has also said she will “People don’t know verse backgrounds. at bit.ly/Ghulati)
end the expanded Ultra
Low Emissions Zone
(ULEZ) on day 1. The ex-
panded zone, which im-
poses congestion charges
on certain vehicles, was
created by Mr. Khan in Au-
gust last year. The Mayor
has defended the expan-
sion of the zone and has
linked it to better health
and environmental out-
comes for Londoners.
Ms. Hall has previously
courted controversy for
her comments on crime in
the black community and
for her social media style —
where she ‘liked’ racist
posts, including some in-
volving Mr. Khan, who is
Muslim.
LibDem candidate
Reforming the Met is the
main priority for the Lib
Dem candidate, Mr. Black-
ie, who was the victim of a
violent mugging some
years ago. “One night I was
attacked while walking
home from work. My neck
was broken, and I was
lucky to live,” he said on
his campaign page.
Ms. Garbett, who re-
minds voters repeatedly
that she is a home renter
(and not owner), is focused
on transport fare reform
and rent control and regu-
lation in the city.
M ND-NDE

Friday, May 3, 2024
Delhi
THE STRATEGY
My aim is to bowl a lot of dot balls
as they create wickets: Harpreet
X X
PBKS left-arm spinner Harpreet Brar revealed his strategy while
bowling to some of the big hitters in the IPL. “I don’t think wickets,
my aim is to bowl a lot of dot balls as dot balls create wickets. When
there is spin in the surface, the bowlers’ confidence goes up and it is
a bit helpful,” said Harpreet Brar after the win against CSK.
Sunrisers pull off a one-run heist with
a thrilling last-ball victory over Royals
ffa76243-386b-4d4d-93fa-f34e5b20443d
Bhuvneshwar bowls a brilliant final over to complement his first; Jaiswal and Parag’s fantastic stand to no avail; Nitish sizzles for the host
Home heroes: Nitish put on attacking masterclass, while the wily Bhuvneshwar struck when it mattered most. B. JOTHI RAMALINGAM
IPL-17
V.V. Subrahmanyam
HYDERABAD
Bhuvneshwar Kumar
turned out to be the hero,
striking the big blows
when it mattered most, to
help Sunrisers Hyderabad
pull off a sensational one-
run win over table-topper
Rajasthan Royals, in an IPL
match at the Rajiv Gandhi
Stadium here on Thursday.
With 13 runs needed off
the last over bowled by
Bhuvneshwar, the match
We were muddled and inaccurate
with bat and ball, says Fleming
Dube. S.R. RAGHUNATHAN
Sankar Narayanan E.H.
CHENNAI
Chennai Super Kings
coach Stephen Fleming
said the pitch getting ea-
sier to bat in the second in-
nings and the rival spin-
ners winning the
middle-overs battle in the
first essay proved crucial
in his side’s heavy loss to
CM
YK
FILE PHOTO
came down to two runs off
the last ball. He trapped
the big-hitting Rovman Po-
well leg-before to trigger
celebrations in the stands
and in the team’s dug out.
Earlier, Bhuvneshwar
produced a dream first ov-
er, sending back Impact
Player Jos Buttler and San-
ju Samson for ducks to
make an early dent to
Royals’ hopes, who were
chasing 202 for a win.
But the visitors stayed in
the hunt when the young
guns Yashasvi Jaiswal (67,
40b, 7x4, 2x6) and Riyan
Parag (77, 49b, 8x4, 4x6)
Punjab Kings.
“They got good pur-
chase and we just got sti-
fled through the middle
overs… we were muddled
and inaccurate with bat
and ball,” Fleming said on
Wednesday.
“Every match we played
has been wet. Our spin-
ners have had no impact
because they could not
SOLID SUPPORT
Kohli is ‘one of the best’ to ever
play the game, says de Villiers
A.B. de Villiers heaped praise on Virat Kohli, saying he is “one of the
best” to ever play the game. “He’s incredible in the IPL, he plays a
certain role for RCB, and I’ve pretty much had enough of
data-driven pundits who keep criticising this man. I’m frustrated to
say the least,” said de Villiers.
put on 134 off 82 balls by
treating the bowlers with
contempt and playing
strokes all over the park.
SRH skipper Pat Cum-
mins’ third and fourth ov-
ers, during which he
picked up the wickets of
Parag and Dhruv Jurel
without being expensive,
put the home team back in
the hunt.
Earlier, the in-form
opener Abhishek Sharma
and Anmolpreet Singh fell
cheaply as the home team
scored just 37 for two in
the PowerPlay against a
disciplined Royals bowling
turn the ball.”
He also backed Ajinkya
Rahane’s timid approach
in the PowerPlay.
“I thought he was good.
He was probably too ag-
gressive in terms of what
he was trying to do. We
have to pause to see what a
good score is.
“If you’re three for 30
then the game is pretty
THE HINDU
Sport
VIJAY SONEJI
attack. Travis Head, who
scored 18 runs off 17 balls in
the first six overs, was
lucky to survive when a
slash off the first ball of the
innings from Trent Boult
just flew past Parag at back-
ward point.
Soon the left-hander
switched gears, and in the
company of the free-strok-
ing Nitish Kumar Reddy (76
not out, 42b, 3x4, 8x6),
pulled and lofted leggie
Yuzvendra Chahal for two
sixes in the ninth over.
Later, Nitish hit two
huge sixes and a four in
Chahal’s third over and
much over. We have an as-
sessment period which we
want those two (openers)
to do. So, we’re fine with
the role Rahane plays,”
Fleming added.
PBKS batter Rilee Ros-
souw lauded skipper Sam
Curran’s brave call to give
the penultimate over to
leg-spinner Rahul Chahar
with M.S. Dhoni on strike.
INJURY UPDATE
‘Nitish has started batting now,
working towards getting match fit’
X X
He may have resumed batting in the nets but Nitish Rana, who
injured his finger while fielding during KKR’s season opener, is not
yet available for selection. “He is on the road to recovery. He has
started batting and getting match fit is something he is working
towards,” said Abhishek Nayar, KKR assistant coach.
SCOREBOARD
쑽
SUNRISERS HYDERABAD
Travis Head b Avesh 58 (44b, 6x4,
3x6), Abhishek Sharma c Jurel b
Avesh 12 (10b, 1x6), Anmolpreet
Singh c Jaiswal b Sandeep 5 (5b,
1x4), Nitish Reddy (not out) 76
(42b, 3x4, 8x6), Heinrich Klaasen
(not out) 42 (19b, 3x4, 3x6); Extras
(w-8): 8; Total (for three wkts. in 20
overs): 201.
FALL OF WICKETS
1-25 (Abhishek, 4.1 overs), 2-35
(Anmolpreet, 5.1), 3-131 (Head,
14.4).
ROYALS BOWLING
Boult 4-0-33-0, Ashwin 4-0-36-0,
Avesh 4-0-39-2, Sandeep 4-0-31-1,
Chahal 4-0-62-0.
RAJASTHAN ROYALS
Yashasvi Jaiswal b Natarajan 67
(40b, 7x4, 2x6), Jos Buttler
(Impact Player in place of
Chahal) c Jansen b Bhuvneshwar
0 (1b), Sanju Samson b
Bhuvneshwar 0 (3b), Riyan Parag c
Jansen b Cummins 77 (49b, 8x4,
4x6), Shimron Hetmyer c Jansen b
Natarajan 13 (9b, 1x4, 1x6),
Rovman Powell lbw b
then one over extra-cover
off pacer Sandeep Sharma
to show his class.
Nitish’s two crucial
stands — 96 (57 balls) with
Head (58, 44b, 6x4, 3x6)
Super Kings, blowing hot and cold,
face a steep climb to the playoffs
S. Dipak Ragav
CHENNAI
At the core of Chennai Sup-
er Kings’ metronomic con-
sistency in the IPL has been
its ability to have a clear
game-plan and stick to it,
even in the face of adversi-
ty, and not be reactive. But
the team’s journey in 2024
has been anything but that.
CSK has blown hot and
cold, unable to string to-
gether a series of good re-
sults. When it wins, it dom-
inates the tie from start to
finish. But at the same
time, it has meekly surren-
dered in defeats and ap-
peared to be behind the
eight-ball throughout,
showing it has been out-
played. After its fifth defeat
of the campaign — and the
fifth straight reverse
against Punjab Kings — on
Wednesday, the defending
champion faces a steep
climb to make the playoffs.
Super Kings had a gol-
den chance of getting clos-
K.R. DEEPAK
Bhuvneshwar 27 (15b, 3x4, 1x6),
Dhruv Jurel c Abhishek b Cummins
1 (3b), R. Ashwin (not out) 2 (2b);
Extras (nb-2, w-11): 13; Total (for
seven wkts. in 20 overs): 200.
FALL OF WICKETS
1-1 (Buttler, 0.2), 2-1 (Samson,
0.5), 3-135 (Jaiswal, 13.3), 4-159
(Parag, 15.5), 5-181 (Hetmyer,
17.4), 6-182 (Jurel, 18.1), 7-200
(Powell, 19.6).
SUNRISERS BOWLING
Bhuvneshwar 4-0-41-3, Jansen
4-0-44-0, Cummins 4-0-34-2,
Natarajan 4-0-35-2, Unadkat
(Impact Player in place of
Anmolpreet) 2-0-23-0, Nitish
1-0-12-0, Shahbaz 1-0-11-0.
Toss: SRH; PoM: Bhuvneshwar.
SRH won by one run.
for the third wicket and an
unbeaten 70 with Heinrich
Klaasen (42 not out, 19b,
3x4, 3x6) — saw Sunrisers
come back strongly and
breach the 200-run mark.
In hot water: CSK has deviated from its philosophy and struggled.
S.R. RAGHUNATHAN
er to qualifying when they
had three successive
matches at home. Howev-
er, the five-time winner lost
the plot with two defeats
and will need to get its act
together in the remaining
four fixtures.
For a team famed for its
philosophy of consistency
in selection and playing to
its strengths, it has deviat-
ed from this philosophy
and struggled to nail its
combination.
While CSK has been cre-
GETTING IT STRAIGHT
You can’t judge yourself based on
just the run-rate, says Shepherd
Romario Shepherd, who smashed 32 runs in an over against Delhi
Capitals, has now lost his place in the Mumbai Indians side.
“Sometimes you can’t judge yourself based on just the run-rate. You
have to ask yourself if you did exactly what you wanted to do. I try
to assess as fast as possible and try to come up with plans,” he said.
KKR hopes to make
life difficult for MI
Engrossing: Salt’s pyrotechnics have lit up this edition.
EMMANUAL YOGINI
Amol Karhadkar
MUMBAI
For long, facing Kolkata
Knight Riders used to be
like a walk in the park for
Mumbai Indians, and its
batting mainstay Rohit
Sharma.
But even the bogey team
has turned the reputation
around in the last few
years.
Add to it the form this
season and it puts the
home under severe pres-
sure come Friday night at
the Wankhede Stadium.
Another loss will put Mum-
bai Indians’ – placed at the
ninth place in a table of 10 –
mathematical hopes of
making the Indian Premier
League Playoffs up in the
air.
The Knight Riders – on
the other hand – will look
to solidify its position as a
clear second-placed team
with its seventh win of the
season.
The only solace that
Hardik Pandya and Co. will
have is the Knight Riders’
poor record while bowling
at its den. The conditions
at the Wankhede and Eden
Gardens are quite similar,
with flat decks, short boun-
daries and dew making life
miserable for bowlers with
every passing over.
dited for reviving Shivam
Dube’s career by providing
clarity on his role, the same
cannot be said for some
others this year. It has
struggled to get its combi-
nation right, from bench-
ing Rachin Ravindra after a
few quiet outings to persist-
ing with an underperform-
ing Ajinkya Rahane.
The outfit has also been
unable to identify the right
slots for Daryl Mitchell and
Moeen Ali.
Against PBKS, the team’s
17
EMMANUAL YOGINI
ffa76243-386b-4d4d-93fa-f34e5b20443d
With the Knight Riders’
bowling unit having fal-
tered at home, the Mumbai
Indians batters will be hop-
ing to make merry, for a
change. The onus will be
on veteran Rohit Sharma
to set the tone against
Mitchell Starc.
Despite Starc succumb-
ing to the price-tag pres-
sure, Rohit’s woes against
left-arm pace have come to
the fore repeatedly this
season.
Rohit and Ishan Kishan
will have to come out all
guns blazing to match the
onslaught of their Knight
Riders counterparts – Sunil
Narine and Phil Salt – who
have been taking virtually
every opposition attack to
pieces.
batting order reflected the
confused thinking. After
losing Shivam Dube in the
ninth over, the team pro-
moted Ravindra Jadeja to
four despite having Moeen
Ali, who can be aggressive
against pace and spin. Jade-
ja also struggled at number
four in the home match
against LSG, coming ahead
of Dube. The all-rounder
has often been more effec-
tive when coming lower
down toward the final
phase of the innings. Mitch-
ell, who finally found form
at number three in the pre-
vious game, was shunted
down.
The team has also unde-
rutilised Moeen, wasting an
overseas slot on a player
who is not getting a chance
to make a mark with bat or
ball. Going forward, CSK
can ill-afford to waste re-
sources and need to quick-
ly identify its core group if
it hopes to get its title de-
fence campaign back on
track.
M ND-NDE

18
Good, but...Though proving his worth as a ‘designated’ finisher,
Rinku does not find a place in the World Cup squad. FILE PHOTO
‘Rinku has done
nothing wrong’
Amol Karhadkar
MUMBAI
His family was ready to
burst firecrackers. But, it
was not to be.
Instead of celebrating
their son’s selection for the
T20 World Cup, Rinku
Singh’s parents were sur-
prised at his omission from
India’s provisional squad.
ffa76243-386b-4d4d-93fa-f34e5b20443d
Since his debut for India
in the shortest format in
August last year, Rinku, a
‘designated finisher’, has
been dismissed only four
times in the 11 innings he
has batted in the National
blues. Despite emerging as
a reliable finisher, Rinku
has been overlooked with
the selectors preferring to
add all-rounders Axar Patel
and Shivam Dube. As a re-
sult, the left-hander has to
be content as a travelling
reserve.
Ajit Agarkar, the chair-
man of the national selec-
tion panel, admitted it was
a harsh call without the
player’s fault.
“It’s probably the tough-
A fit Hardik gives the balance the team needs: Agarkar South Africa women
Complete backing: Agarkar and skipper Rohit are confident Hardik
can things turn around at the T20 WC. EMMANUAL YOGINI
India beats Bangladesh to take unassailable lead Indian shuttlers’ campaign
INDIA IN BANGLADESH
Press Trust of India
SYLHET
A dominant India grabbed
an unassailable 3-0 lead in
the five-match women's
T20I series as it pum-
melled Bangladesh by se-
ven wickets in the third
match here on Thursday.
After skipper Harman-
preet Kaur opted to field
first looking at the cloud
cover and a mild breeze,
India's bowlers dished out
another disciplined perfor-
mance to restrict Bangla-
desh to 117 for eight, which
the visitor overhauled with
nine balls to spare.
Useful partnership
When they came to bat,
openers Smriti Mandhana
and Shafali Verma put on
91 runs in just 12.1 overs to
take India closer to a series
win.
Shafali got out after a 38-
ball 51, hitting eight fours,
while Mandhana found
form as she struck 47 off 42
balls with the help of five
boundaries and a six.
Ritu Moni took a blinder
off her bowling to dismiss
CM
YK
est thing that we had to dis-
cuss, frankly. He has done
nothing wrong, nor has
Shubman Gill, for that mat-
ter. It’s the combinations.
We are not quite sure what
conditions we’ll get, so we
wanted to try and have
enough options,” Agarkar
said here on Thursday.
“There are a couple of
spinners (Chahal and Kul-
deep) that were included in
the squad to give Rohit
more options. It’s just un-
fortunate. I don’t think it’s
anything to do with Rinku
Singh.”
“It’s not his fault that he
has missed out. It’s the 15 —
with two keepers who are
both terrific batters and an
extra batter sitting out,
whoever doesn’t play — that
gives us the best balance.
We thought another bow-
ling option might be handy
going forward in the tour-
nament. He is still one of
the travelling subs. That’s
how close he was. It’s a lit-
tle bit tough on him, but at
the end of the day, you can
only pick 15.” Agarkar said.
Clinical: India's bowlers dished out another disciplined performance to restrict Bangladesh to 117 for
eight. X@BCCIWOMEN
Shafali while Nahida Akter
accounted for Smriti. But
the damage was done.
Earlier, the decision to
bowl first did not yield the
desired result immediately,
as Bangladesh raced to 44
I definitely wanted four
spinners in squad: Rohit
The skipper confirmed that he had stressed this with the selectors based on the conditions in the
West Indies and USA; chief selector Agarkar said they had an idea of what they were looking for
T20 WORLD CUP
Amol Karhadkar
MUMBAI
ne of the most de-
O
fining aspects of
India’s squad for
the T20 World Cup is the
inclusion of four spinners
and just three specialist
pacers. India captain Rohit
Sharma has owned up to
the change in strategy,
stressing that he sought
four spinners to the selec-
tors, anticipating slower
conditions in the West In-
dies and the USA.
“I definitely wanted four
spinners. We have played a
lot of cricket there. We
know what the conditions
are like. The match starts
at probably 10-10.30 in the
morning, so there is a little
bit of technical aspect in-
volved in this. I wanted
four spinners for sure, and
three seamers and Hardik
(Pandya) being the fourth
one,” Rohit said, with chief
selector Ajit Agarkar seat-
ed next to him, in a media
interaction at the BCCI
headquarters here on
Thursday.
Getting the balance
“You get that balance of
seamers as well, and then,
you know, the spinners as
well. Obviously, two spin-
ners being all-rounders
Sports Bureau
MUMBAI
Hardik Pandya’s indiffe-
rent form in the Indian Pre-
mier League has not led to
the national selection pa-
nel and the India team
management changing its
approach towards the all-
rounder. Not only has
Hardik been appointed
as Rohit Sharma’s deputy
for India’s T20 World Cup
sojourn but Ajit Agarkar,
the chief selector, has
stressed there is no re-
placement for him.
“He has come after a
longish lay-off. The good
part that we have looked at
is he has gotten through all
the games so far and we
for no loss in the six Power-
Play overs.
However, the Indian
bowlers tightened the
screws on the home team
batters after the dismissal
of Dilara Akter, who blazed
THE HINDU
Sport
Inside view: Rohit and Agarkar reveal the thinking behind selecting the squad for the marquee event.
EMMANUAL YOGINI
can bat — Axar (Patel) and
Jaddu (Ravindra Jadeja) —
and then the two attacking
spinners, Kuldeep (Yadav)
and (Yuzvendra) Chahal,
give you a little bit of ba-
lance in your spin depart-
ment as well.”
Ever since the ploy of
going in with four spinners
failed miserably during the
T20 World Cup in 2021, In-
dia has relied on playing
three specialist pacers
along with Hardik, the all-
rounder, in a majority of
T20Is. Even when Hardik
was the captain for most of
“It’s part of life. Not
everything will go your
way. It’s been a good
experience. Earlier in my
life as well, I have played
under a lot of captains.
It’s nothing new to me.”—
Rohit Sharma
have got another month
and a little bit till we play
our first game, so we know
he is doing that and the
hope is that he keeps build-
ing on that form,” Agarkar
said here on Thursday.
“So as long as he stays
fit, we know what he
brings, how much balance
away to 39 off 25 balls.
The host's brisk start
was largely due to the bat-
ting of Dilara, who struck a
few boundaries and nego-
tiated the Indian bowlers
without much difficulty
the T20Is since India’s
semifinal exit from the
2022 edition, the think-
tank preferred to include
three specialist pacers in
the XI.
“Based on the opposi-
tion composition and con-
ditions, we can decide who
to play. There is a good
chance Kuldeep and Cha-
hal can play together.
There is a good chance
both left-arm spinners can
play along with Kuldeep or
Chahal, so all sorts of
things are possible.”
Agarkar admitted that it
he gives the team. I don’t
think there is a replace-
ment for the things that he
can do as a cricketer at the
moment, especially when
it comes to the way he
bowls. It really gives ba-
lance.
“He will give Rohit op-
tions to play different com-
binations, so his fitness for
us is critical. So far, fortu-
nately, he has gone okay in
this IPL.”
Captain Rohit Sharma
played down the fact that
he will lead Hardik days af-
ter playing under his cap-
taincy in the Indian Pre-
mier League.
“It’s part of life. Not eve-
rything will go your way.
It’s been a good expe-
early on at Sylhet Interna-
tional Cricket Stadium.
Trailing 0-2 in the five-
match series, Bangladesh
looked determined to give
a better account of them-
selves and keep the rubber
alive, two days after being
shot out for 119 at the same
venue.
With the T20 World Cup
around the corner, the ob-
jective is to finalise their
middle-order, which has
been having some difficul-
ty.
At the end of the 10th
over, Bangladesh was 66
for two, with captain Nigar
Sultana and Sobhana Mos-
tary in the middle.
A poor example of run-
ning between the wickets
led to the dismissal of Sob-
hana (15 off 20 balls), the
diving batter failing to beat
Renuka's throw at the strik-
er's end.
Fahima Khatun was out
the first ball, given lbw off
Shreyanka Patil after the
batter shuffled across to
sweep the ball but missed
the line completely.
The scores: Bangladesh 117/8 in
20 overs (Dilara Akter 39, Nigar
Sultana 28) lost to India 121/3 in
18.3 overs (Smriti Mandhana 47,
Shafali Verma 51).
was a bit of challenge to
not get swayed by indivi-
dual performances in the
IPL while finalising the
combination.
“We had a fair idea of
what we were looking for.
In IPL, you keep track of
fitness levels of players,
but if you start getting
swayed by three-four
weeks of cricket, there is
something wrong in your
thinking.
“All performances are
noticed and it will help us
in the future anyway,”
Agarkar said.
rience. Earlier in my life as
well, I have played under a
lot of captains. It’s nothing
new to me. You go by wha-
tever is required from you
as a player,” Rohit said.
Stressing that Virat Koh-
li’s strike rate has never
been discussed by the se-
lection committee, Agar-
kar added that Rohit taking
over the India captaincy
from Hardik will not be a
bone of contention.
“As selectors, you want
a leader. Rohit has been a
terrific leader. I know Har-
dik had been leading in a
few series before (the ODI
World Cup). Rohit’s form
in the World Cup... Rohit’s
a great player. It’s not as if
it’s forced on us,” he said.
ends in the quarterfinals
THOMAS & UBER CUP
Press Trust of India
CHENGDU
Lakshya Sen was the lone
bright spot as the Indian
men’s team failed to defend
its title after going down
fighting 1-3 to China in the
quarterfinals, while the wo-
men’s side suffered a 0-3
loss to Japan to also end
their campaign in the Tho-
mas and Uber Cup Final
here on Thursday.
Two years after claiming
a maiden title at the presti-
gious team championships,
the country’s male shuttlers
endured a tough day in of-
fice as World No. 9 H.S.
Prannoy, World No. 3 Sat-
wiksairaj Rankireddy and
Chirag Shetty, Dhruv Kapila
and K. Sai Pratheek failed to
go the distance in their res-
pective matches.
A roaring start ended
with a dampener for Pran-
noy as his spirited fight con-
cluded with a 21-15, 11-21, 14-
21 loss against World No. 2
Shi Yu Qi. in a 66-minute
clash which gave China a 1-0
Agarkar explains
rationale to pick
Samson over Rahul
Amol Karhadkar
MUMBAI
India captain Rohit Shar-
ma has revealed that
Washington Sundar and R.
Ashwin were discussed for
the last slot of a fourth
spinner before zeroing in
on Axar Patel’s all-round
skills.
“We discussed it a lot,
whether to have an off-
spinner or not. Unfortu-
nately Washi hasn’t played
a lot of cricket lately,
hasn’t been getting an op-
portunity and it was then
between Ash and Axar,”
Rohit said here on
Thursday.
Axar bowling well
“Ashwin hasn’t played the
format (T20Is) lately as
well for a long time. Axar
was in real good form
since 50-over World Cup
when he played that five-
match series against Aus-
tralia. He was the player of
the series, so he has been
bowling well.
“He has been bowling
well in the format and has
done well for India. We
considered all of it and
that left-handed option, if
we have to send someone
in the middle to do so-
mething different.”
Besides Axar’s addition
as the fourth spin-bowling
option, the selectors final-
ly gave Sanju Samson the
nod for a World event,
to tour India
Lavanya L
CHENNAI
The Indian women’s team
will host the Laura Wol-
vaardt-led South African
team in a multi-format se-
ries in June-July 2024.
The ODI leg of the se-
ries will be held in Benga-
luru at the M. Chinnaswa-
my Stadium while
Chennai’s M.A. Chidamba-
ram Stadium will be the
venue for the one-off Test
and three T20Is.
The Test has reportedly
been scheduled from June
28.
It will be India’s third
Test in six months and
Lone success: Lakshya was the only Indian to register a win in the
quarterfinals. X@@BAI_MEDIA
lead. Satwik and Chirag had
to walk back without log-
ging a point for India after
they were outmanoeuvred
15-21, 21-11, 12-21 by the
World No. 1 pair of Liang
Wei Keng and Wang Chang.
All eyes were on Lakshya
Sen to keep India afloat, gi-
ven his 6-3 head-to-head
count against Li Shi Feng,
and the 22-year-old lived up
to the expectations, seeing
off the World No. 6 13-21,
21-8, 21-14 to pull one back.
However, Dhruv and Sai
went down 10-21, 10-21 to
World No. 11 pair of Ren
Xiang Yu and He Ji Ting to
put paid to India’s hopes.
Earlier, though Ashmita
Friday, May 3, 2024
Delhi
Samson. PTI
thanks to his consistent
outing in the IPL.
Chief selector Ajit Agar-
kar has explained the ra-
tionale behind preferring
Samson as the second
wicketkeeper in place of
K.L. Rahul. According to
ffa76243-386b-4d4d-93fa-f34e5b20443d
Agarkar, Rahul’s prefe-
rence to bat as an opener
went against him.
“KL is a terrific player.
We were looking at some-
one who bats in the mid-
dle. At the moment, he is
batting at the top,” Agar-
kar said.
Batting down the order
“Sanju, we like to believe,
has the ability to come
down the order, if need
be. Rishabh (Pant) is bat-
ting down the order for
Delhi Capitals.
It’s about the slots we
needed. We felt these two
are better and have spent
more time down the order
which might be needed at
the World Cup.”
South Africa’s third ever.
The T20Is are likely to be
staged on July 5, 7 and 9.
An official confirmation
of the tour is awaited from
the Board of Control for
Cricket in India (BCCI).
Second women’s Test
Chennai will be hosting a
women’s Test for the se-
cond time after November
1976 when India took on
the West Indies. The
match ended in a draw.
After the South Africa
series, India will head to
the Asia Cup in Sri Lanka
and the T20 World Cup in
Bangladesh in September-
October.
Chaliha and Isharani Ba-
ruah gave a good account of
themselves by winning a
game, the inexperienced In-
dian women lost to formid-
able Japan.
The results:
Thomas Cup: China bt India
3-1 (Shi Yu Qi bt H.S. Prannoy
15-21, 21-11, 21-14; Liang Wei
Keng & Wang Chang 21-15, 11-21,
21-12; Li Shi Feng lost to Lakshya
Sen 21-13, 8-21, 14-21; Ren Xiang
Yu & He Ji Ting bt Dhruv Kapila
and K. Sai Pratheek 21-10, 21-10).
Uber Cup: Japan bt India 3-0
(Aya Ohori bt Ashmita Chaliha
21-10, 20-22, 21-15; Nami
Matsuyama & Chiharu Shida bt
Priya Konjengbam & Shruti Misra
21-8, 21-9; Nozomi Okuhara bt
Isharani Baruah 21-15, 21-12).
M ND-NDE
 THE HINDU
Friday, May 3, 2024 19
Delhi
Sport

INBRIEF
쑽
All-rounder Saad Bin Zafar to
lead Canada in T20 World Cup
Press Trust of India mostly of Indian and Pakis- (capt.), Aaron Johnson, Dilon
TORONTO tan origin players, is in Heyliger, Dilpreet Bajwa, Harsh
Group A alongside co-hosts Thaker, Jeremy Gordon, Junaid
Canada will make its mai- USA, India, Pakistan and Siddiqui, Kaleem Sana, Kanwarpal
Tathgur (wk), Navneet Dhaliwal,
den appearance in the T20 Ireland.
Nicholas Kirton, Pargat Singh,
World Cup with all-roun- Canada will play its first Ravinderpal Singh, Rayyankhan
der Saad Bin Zafar, a player match against USA in Dal- Pathan, Shreyas Movva (wk).
of Pakistan origin, set to las on June 1. Reserves: Tajinder Singh, Aaditya
Alcaraz loses to Rublev, lead the side.
The team, comprising The squad: Saad Bin Zafar
Varadharajan, Ammar Khalid,
Jatinder Matharu, Parveen Kumar.
Sabalenka breezes through
Carlos Alcaraz's bid to win a third straight Madrid
Open title ended with a three-set loss to Andrey
Rublev in the quarterfinals. The second-seeded NEW DELHI ROUND-UP
Spaniard got off to a good start but then was 쑽
Slick finish: Fullkrug gives Dortmund a slight advantage with this strike against PSG. REUTERS
outplayed by the seventh-seeded Rublev, losing Quick-fire century by 158 runs in the Late Shri Sports Gold Cup T20
4-6, 6-3, 6-2 on Wednesday. Defending champion Nikhil Ratan Singh memorial tournament.
Aryna Sabalenka defeated 17-year-old Mirra
Andreeva 6-1, 6-4 win in Wednesday's
quarterfinals. Sabalenka will next play
fourth-seeded Elena Rybakina, who saved two
Feisty Dortmund Nikhil Chandel’s 62-ball
100 and Pratham’s 58 saw
Rajinder Nagar Colts beat
Kishan Ganj Colts by six
tournament.
The scores:
Ravi Brothers 328/6 in 40 overs
(Yugal Saini 180 n.o., Pranav
The scores:
Khurrat XI 86 in 13 overs (Harish
Dagar 5/10, Keshav Dua 3/13) lost
to DCH 87/2 in 10 overs (Harish

outmuscles PSG
match points en route to a 4-6, 7-6(4), 7-5 win wickets in the DDCA Rajvanshi 67, Karan Sharma 3/78)
Dagar 39).
over Yulia Putintseva. bt GNCC Seniors 170 in 32 overs.
League.
The scores:
Delhi Challenger in Sanat shines
Kishan Ganj Colts 250 in 39 overs
(Lakshay Rawat 105, Karan semifinals Sanat Sangwan top-scored
The win ensures that the Bundesliga will have five teams next season; Pangeni 3/36) lost to Rajinder Half-centuries by Tarun with 92 and Neelmani
ffa76243-386b-4d4d-93fa-f34e5b20443d

ffa76243-386b-4d4d-93fa-f34e5b20443d
Amul to sponsor USA cricket Nagar Colts 254/4 in 32 overs Yadav, Qamran and Kumar returned four for
Mbappe & Hakimi hit the post while Dembele blazes over 38 as Bhawani Youth
team in T20 World Cup (Nikhil Chandel 100, Pratham 58).
Delhi Police Club 304/8 in 40
Bhagmender Lather and
three wickets each by Academy (BYA) beat 22
overs (Manjeet 96, Manish Yadav and Ayachi saw Yard Academy by two
Indian dairy giant Amul will sponsor the USA row advantage before the ly in the second half, when Sharma 60 n.o., Harsh 4/31) lost
CHAMPIONS LEAGUE Delhi Challenger Club beat wickets in the DDA Saket
cricket team in the T20 World Cup in June, the teams play again in the se- Mbappe hit the right post to Golden Hawks 307/5 in 37
Victory Club by two tournament.
country’s cricket Board announced on Thursday. cond leg in Paris next Tues- before Achraf Hakimi overs (Ankit Kumar 110, Keshav
USA will make its tournament debut as co-host of Associated Press day, when the French struck the left post. Dabas 79 n.o., Kunal Sharma 56
wickets to enter the The scores:
the tournament beginning on June 1. Part of the DORTMUND champion will need to n.o.). semifinals of the 39th 22 Yard Academy 172/9 in 20
Gregor Kobel saved
tournament, including the semifinals and finals, overturn the result if it’s Ajmal Khan Club 350/5 in 40 all-India Laxman Das overs (Shaurya Verma 37,
Mbappe’s next effort and
will take place in the Caribbean. Amul was iclas Fullkrug going to capture Europe’s overs (Aman Tyagi 128) lost to Chabra tournament. Neelmani Kumar 4/38, C.K. Yadav

N
named the Lead Arm sponsor of the USA scored and Borus-
national team at an event in New York. sia Dortmund
earned a 1-0 win over Paris
Saint-Germain in the first
leg of their Champions
LIVE TELECAST
League semifinal on
쑽 crucial block to deny Julian
Wednesday.
Dortmund defender Ni-
Badminton: Thomas & Uber Cup, Sports 18-1 (SD & HD) &
JioCinema, 7 a.m. & 2.30 p.m. co Schlotterbeck sent a
long pass over the top for
Bangladesh vs Zimbabwe: 1st T20I, FanCode, 5.30 p.m.
Fullkrug to control bril-
IPL: Star Sports 1 (SD & HD) & JioCinema, 7.30 p.m.
liantly with his first touch
Bundesliga: Sony Sports Ten 2 & LIV, 12 a.m. (Saturday) before firing it past PSG
goalkeeper Gianluigi Don-
Serie A: Sports 18-1 & JioCinema, 12.15 a.m. (Saturday)
narumma with his next in
Premier League: SS Select 1 & Hotstar, 12.30 a.m. (Saturday) the 36th minute.
LaLiga: Sports 18-1 & JioCinema, 12.30 a.m. (Saturday) It gives Dortmund a nar-
biggest prize before Kylian
Mbappe leaves the club.
PSG is under pressure to
finally win to the Cham-
pions League to justify
more than a decade of
huge investment from its
Qatari owners.
Dortmund’s win en-
sured it qualified for the
tournament next season
and it gives the Bundesliga
five teams in the expanded
tournament. Dortmund is
assured of finishing at least
fifth.
PSG pushed hardest ear-
Dortmund survived the
pressure.
Fullkrug went on to
miss further good chances
for the German team,
while Marquinhos made a
Brandt late on.
Ousmane Dembele
should have scored on his
return to Dortmund when
he blazed a shot over late,
then Vitinha flashed a shot
wide of the left post.
The result: Semifinal, first leg:
Borussia Dortmund 1 (Fullkrug
36) bt Paris Saint-Germain 0.
Pelican 351/4 in 37 overs (Bhavya
Tiwari 102, Gautam Kohar 80 n.o.,
Parv Singh 65, Pragan Sharma
54).
Collage Sports 377/8 in 40 overs
(Rahul 159, Ankit Dabas 71,
Baljinder Singh 4/85) bt Paragon
367 in 39 overs (Yashveer Nagar
85, Jai Ahuja 65, Kashish 59,
Jayanshu 3/80).
Yugal smashes
unbeaten 180
Man-of-the-match Yugal
Saini cracked an unbeaten
180 and Pranav Rajvanshi
made 67 as Ravi Brothers
crushed GNCC Seniors by
The scores:
Victory 300/8 in 40 overs (Gaurav
Coacher 105, Tanuj Pawar 49,
Arun Legha 48, Ayachi 3/45, Tarun
Yadav 3/60) lost to Delhi
Challenger 301/8 in 38 overs
(Qamran 68, Bhagmender Lather
63, Tarun Yadav 61, Gaurav
Coacher 3/47).
Harish and Keshav bowl
DCH to victory
Harish Dagar took five for
10 and Keshav Dua
claimed three for 13 as
Delhi Cricket Hub (DCH)
beat Khurrat XI by eight
wickets in the Sapience
3/19) lost to BYA 176/8 in 19 overs
(Sanat Sangwan 92, Shivam 30).
Krishankant makes 112
Man-of-the-Match
Krishankant made 112 as
GRM Academy put it
across Telefunken Club by
seven wickets in the first
Summer Cup under-17
cricket tournament.
The scores:
Telefunken 229/8 in 40 overs
(Shaurya Seth 65, Abhishek Singh
3/32, Amir Khan 3/44) lost to
GRMA 233/3 in 38.2 overs
(Krishankant 112, Praveen 58).

0
DISCLAIMER: Readers are requested to verify
and make appropriate enquiries to satisfy
themselves about the veracity of an advertise-
ment before responding to any published in
this newspaper. THG PUBLISHING PVT LTD., the
Publisher & Owner of this newspaper, does not
vouch for the authenticity of any advertisement
or advertiser or for any of the advertiser’s
products and/or services. In no event can the
Owner, Publisher, Printer, Editor, Director/s,
Employees of this newspaper/company be held
responsible/liable in any manner whatsoever
for any claims and/or damages for advertise-
ments in this newspaper.

EDUCATIONAL
GENERAL

TENDERS

DEATH
T A Srinivasan (83), Retired Assistant
Editor, The Hindu, Chennai passed
PUBLIC NOTICE away on 01-May-2024.Address: 23/36
Kambar Street, S.S Colony, Madurai
-625010. Contact: 9840145047

CM M ND-NDE
YK
 THE HINDU
20 Friday, May 3, 2024

Sport Delhi

INBRIEF
쑽 Salima to lead as Hockey India names
24-member squad for FIH Pro League
Indian women to play 10 games in Belgium and England; coach Harendra is yet to make an official statement since his appointment last month

FIH PRO LEAGUE
Momota bows out of Uthra Ganesan
NEW DELHI
international competition
he passing of baton
Two-time World champion Kento Momota bowed
out of international badminton on Thursday
without hitting a shuttlecock, after his Japan side
T in the Indian wo-
men’s hockey team
seems officially on course
lost to Malaysia in the Thomas Cup quarterfinals. with youngster Salima
The Japanese, who was badly injured after a Tete handed captaincy for
horrific car accident in 2020, returned after a the upcoming European
year but suffered double vision. He failed to leg of the FIH Pro League
regain his form although he did win two more 2023-24 and Navneet Kaur
titles. Now ranked 52 and having missed out on a named her deputy as the
place at the Paris Olympics, he said last month he 24-member squad was an-
would retire after playing at Thomas Cup. nounced on Thursday.
Interestingly, long-serv-
ing captain Savita and se-
niors like Vandana Katari-
Parma returns to Serie A after
three-year absence
ffa76243-386b-4d4d-93fa-f34e5b20443d
ya, Monika and Neha
Goyal are part of the
squad, clearly indicating
that Hockey India (HI) and
coach Harendra Singh are
looking forward to long-
term leadership while re-
taining experience in the
ranks.
India will play Argenti-
na, Belgium, Spain, Great
Britain and Germany
twice each across Belgium
and England, starting May
22 and ending on June 9.
Sixth in standings
The Indian women are
currently sixth in the nine-
team competition with
eight points from eight
matches. India is also the
only team in the fray to
not qualify for the Paris
Olympics.
Big responsibility
“I am happy that I have
been appointed to lead the
team. It is a big responsi-
bility and I am looking for-
ward to this new role. We
have a strong squad and
it’s a mix of experienced
and young players.
“In the upcoming Belgi-
um and England legs of
the FIH Hockey Pro
League 2023-2024, we
look to put our strong foot
forward,” the 22-year old
Salima said.
Coach Harendra is yet
to make an official state-
ment or comment since
his appointment last
month while HI too hasn’t
made any formal announ-
cement of the same so far.
The squad: Goalkeepers:
Savita, Bichu Devi Kharibam.
Defenders: Nikki Pradhan, Udita,
Ishika Chaudhary, Monika, Jyoti
Chhatri, Mahima Chaudhary.
Midfielders: Salima Tete (capt.),
Vaishnavi Vitthal Phalke, Navneet
Kaur, Neha, Jyoti, Baljeet Kaur,
Manisha Chauhan, Lalremsiami.
Forwards: Mumtaz Khan,
Sangita Kumari, Deepika,
Sharmila Devi, Preeti Dubey,
Vandana Katariya, Sunelita
Toppo, Deepika Soreng. At the helm: Salima Tete. FILE PHOTO

ffa76243-386b-4d4d-93fa-f34e5b20443d
Parma made sure of promotion to Italy’s Serie A
on Wednesday after three years in the second
Three Indians make Prarthana and Arianne enter Woods targets
playing three
division following a 1-1 draw with Bari. With two
games still to play, Parma has 74 points, seven
more than Venezia in third place. Parma is likely
the semifinals Gifu ITF quarterfinals Majors in next
to be joined in the top flight by second-placed
Como. kush (71kg) won their res- Challenger, Cagliari, Italy: bt Vaishnavi & Camilla Bossi 0-6,
three months
BOXING pective bouts with RSC de- TENNIS Doubles: Pre-quarterfinals: 6-4, [10-8].
cisions against Mongolia’s Sriram Balaji & Andre Begemann Aaddi Gupta & Sara Lanca w/o Agence France-Presse
bt Luciano Darderi & Thiago Lamis Aziz & Patricija Paukstyte.
Sports Bureau Damdindorj P. and Korea’s Sports Bureau NEW YORK
Tirante 4-6, 6-3, [10-4]; Yuki $100,000 ITF women, Bonita
Premier League misses out on Mandengbam Jadumani
Lee Ju Sang respectively.
Ashish, however, went Prarthana Thombare and
Bhambri & Francisco Cabral bt Springs, USA: First round:
Tiger Woods still hopes to
Niccolo Dessi & Alberto Sanna Fanny Stollar bt Sahaja
fifth Champions League spot Singh, Nikhil, Ajay Kumar down 2-3 to Oyun Erdene Arianne Hartono saved 7-5, 6-0. Yamalapalli 6-3, 6-0. play one tournament a
and Ankush registered im- E of Mongolia in the 54kg two match points to beat $82,000 Challenger, $100,000 ITF women, Gifu, month for the rest of the
The Premier League has missed out on a fifth pressive victories to move category. Ma YeXin and Mananchana Guangzhou: Doubles: Japan: Doubles: year, despite his physical
Champions League spot for next season to the into the men’s under-22 On Wednesday night, Sawangkaew in the dou- Quarterfinals: Calum Puttergill Pre-quarterfinals: Rutuja limitations in the wake of a
Bundesliga after the poor performance of English semifinals at the ASBC Aryan (92kg), Nisha bles pre-quarterfinals of & Reese Stadler bt Ray Ho & Bhosale & Sarah Grey bt Natsumi 2021 car crash.
clubs in Europe. One club from each of the two Asian Under-22 & Youth (52kg), Akansha Phalaswal the $100,000 ITF women’s Ramkumar Ramanathan 6-4, 6-3. Kawaguchi & Park Sohyun 5-7, “I have the next three
countries who collectively perform best in Boxing Championships (70kg) and Rudrika (75kg) tennis in Gifu, Japan, on $15,000 ITF, Monastir: Men: 6-0, [10-6]. months — three Majors —
European club competition this season is granted 2024 in Astana on won their respective quar- Thursday. Pre-quarterfinals: Karan Singh Arianne Hartono & Prarthana and hopefully that works
bt Kacper Szymkowiak 6-2, 4-2 Thombare bt Ma YeXin &
an additional place in the new-look 36-team Thursday. terfinals in the youth cate- Rutuja Bhosale and Sa- out,” Woods said in an in-
(retired). Mananchaya Sawangkaew 6-7(1),
league phase being introduced for the 2024/25 Jadumani won 5-0 gory. rah Grey also advances in terview on NBC’s “Today”
Women: Pre-quarterfinals: 6-4, [13-11].
season. No matter what Aston Villa does in the against Bhutan’s Phuntsho Twenty-two Indians the same tournament Vaishnavi Adkar bt Zeel Desai 6-4,
show on Wednesday.
$25,000 ITF women,
Europa Conference League, England cannot Kinley in the 51kg while will be vying for a place in when they got the better of 6-0. Hammamet, Tunisia: Doubles: Woods indicated he was
secure an extra berth. Villa must now hold on to Nikhil (57kg) won 4-0 the finals of their respec- Natsumi Kawaguchi and Doubles: Quarterfinals: Quarterfinals: Jasmijn looking forward to tackling
fourth spot in the Premier League to qualify for against Uzbekistan’s Bak- tive weight categories in Park Sohyun. Dayeon Back & Zeel Desai bt Ahn Gimbrere & Zhibek Kulambayeva the PGA Championship at
the Champions League. They are seven points htiyorov Ayubkhon. the youth section on Fri- Yujin & Lee Gyeong Seo 6-3, 6-1; bt Diva Bhatia & Sophia Valhalla on May 16, and the
ahead of Tottenham. Ajay (63.5kg) and An- day. The results: €205,000 Hiromi Abe & Natsuho Arakawa Ksandinov 6-0, 6-0. US Open in June.

CM M ND-NDE
YK

Friday, May 3, 2024
Delhi
Wrestler Anshu confident of a
good show at Paris Olympics
She talks about the work put in to return from injury, her inspiration Vinesh Phogat and the belief of securing the remaining quota places at the qualifiers
ffa76243-386b-4d4d-93fa-f34e5b20443d
Y.B. Sarangi
hree more years of experience,
T improved muscle mass and
more maturity have helped
former World championships
silver medallist wrestler Anshu Malik grow
in confidence in the run-up to the Paris
Olympics.
Anshu, who overcame a frustrating
knee injury which kept her out of the mat
for most part of the last year, has rode on
her better fitness level to bounce back in
style to assert herself first at the
competitive domestic level and then at the
Asian Olympic Games qualifier in Bishkek
to secure her second consecutive Olympic
qualification in women’s 57kg.
While remaining focused on her
training with an aim of achieving her peak
by the time of the Olympics, the
22-year-old, who had crashed out in the
first round in the Tokyo Games in 2021, is
quietly confident about her ability to
medal this time in Paris.
Looking back at her injury lay-off,
which coincided with the wrestlers’
protest and the negativity surrounding
Indian wrestling last year, Anshu said her
positivity pushed her ahead.
“In the last Asian championships (in
Astana, Kazakhstan, in April 2023) I
picked up the injury (while winning a
bronze). I began training early for the
Asian Games, but I again got injured 10
days prior to the Asian Games trials. It was
a tough time because of such a long lay-off
CM
YK
and I wanted to make a comeback as 2024
was an important year because of the
Olympics. I stayed positive, I thought if the
injury had happened there must be
something good in it,” Anshu told The
Hindu.
“An athlete needs to leave behind all
sorts of negativity and go forward
positively. We needed to remain mentally
strong and keep fighting. Whatever be the
situation, we have to accept it and move
forward. Sport teaches us that.”
Planned approach
A planned approach helped Anshu
become fighting fit. “After returning from
injury, I had planned my comeback,
which competition I should participate in
and for how much duration I should train.
It has been going on smoothly as per my
plans.
“We have planned it well (to reach my
peak around the Olympics). That’s why I
fought the Nationals in 59kg. I had put on
a lot of weight, my body weight was
around 68kg-69kg, after the injury. I had
to cut that. Had I cut down to 57kg, then
the chances of injury would have
increased. Everyone recommended that I
should fight at 59kg, because in trials
there was a two kg tolerance. I maintained
59kg even after the trials so that I don’t
face any problems during the Asian
Olympic qualifier. Meanwhile, I went to
Japan for training and there I learnt a lot
and noticed improvement in my game. I
know how much work I need to do for
THE HINDU
Sport
myself.
“My fitness level is much better now,
my body is in good shape. After coming
back from the knee injury, I had some
apprehensions as I had not competed for a
while. I competed in the National
championships and selection trials (for the
Asian Olympic qualifier). Slowly I grew in
confidence,” said Anshu.
Elaborating on the benefits of her
training in Japan, Anshu said, “When I
went there I found Olympic and World
champions in training. When you train
with the legends, you learn where to
work. In our academy, I train with the
boys. Some days when I do well and feel
great about it. Some other days when I
don’t do well, I get disheartened. In Japan
I found champions in 53kg, 57kg, 62kg etc.
So when I fought with them, I got an idea
where I stood and on which areas I should
work on and how much work was needed.
“Japan is a leading country in women’s
wrestling. When you compete with their
wrestlers, you get to know where you lag.
“I will go to Japan again next week for
training but for the trials we have to return
early. We have planned a 40-day training
schedule.”
Much wiser
Anshu has become much wiser since the
last Olympics. “At that time I was younger.
My muscle mass was less. I was training
but it was not enough. After the Tokyo
Olympics, I got to know where I stood and
what were the areas of improvement. Now
I
ffa76243-386b-4d4d-93fa-f34e5b20443d
SHASHI SHEKHAR KASHYAP & GETTY IMAGES
I have been trying to avoid the mistakes I THE GIST
made in the past.
“I can feel the difference. My strength
has increased and a lot of work has gone
into techniques. A lot of work has gone
into the mistakes I used to make. Now you
can say my peak is coming.”
Anshu, who is working with a
쑽
Anshu, a former World
championships silver medallist,
has overcome a frustrating
knee injury, which kept her out
psychologist on her mental health and of action, for most part of 2023,
focus, knows that she needs to work to win a quota place in
harder than ever to give a memorable women's 57kg in the Asian
performance in a weight packed with Olympic Games qualifier in
several strong athletes. Bishkek and ensure India's
“In the Olympics, we cannot think presence in that weight in Paris
someone is strong or weak. A lot of strong 2024
wrestlers are there in my weight from 쑽
countries like Japan, USA, Nigeria and
Moldova. Since 57kg is a middleweight With more experience and
category, the competition is more. improved muscle mass, the
Hopefully, I will rectify my mistakes and 22-year-old, who competed in
go for a medal this time.” the Tokyo Olympics, is working
on her game to get better for
Through the ups and downs in her
the Olympics
career, Anshu has been blessed to have
the solid support of her father Dharamvir. 쑽
“He has been very supportive all through.
She acknowledges that a
He has been behind me since the time I training stint in Japan, a
started wrestling. I am where I am superpower in women's
because of him. He will continue to be wrestling, has helped her
with me all the time.” immensely
Four high quality wrestlers, Vinesh
(50kg), Antim Panghal (53kg) and Reetika
(76kg) and herself (57kg), have already
qualified for the Olympics. Anshu feels
Indian women are capable enough to win
the remaining two quota places at the
World Olympic Games qualifier, scheduled
in Istanbul from May 9 to 12.
“Last time four Indian women had
qualified. This time four have qualified as
well. In 62kg and 68kg, we could have
qualified as well but our wrestlers lost
narrowly in Bishkek. Hopefully, we qualify
in all six weights and do really well in
Paris.”
Watching a seasoned campaigner like
two-time World championships medallist
Vinesh Phogat, who cut down her weight
drastically to win an Olympic quota place
in 50kg in Bishkek, from close quarters
was also an education for the young
Anshu.
“For a wrestler, more than wrestling on
the mat, controlling one’s weight is a
bigger challenge. We get motivated that
she (Vinesh) has come down to a lower
weight category after coming back from
an injury. Having returned from an injury,
I can understand what an athlete could
have gone through. When you cut down
weight, then your strength also goes down
and weakness comes in. As an athlete, I
can consider her a role model as she has
come back despite knowing that there
could be another injury by losing weight.
Seeing her dedication, we get motivation
to achieve something noteworthy,” said
Anshu, managed by IOS, with a lot of
optimism.
S ND-NDE
 THE HINDU
II Friday, May 3, 2024

SCIENCE
Delhi

A computer science conundrum

that could transform healthcare
While it may sound like a cryptic puzzle reserved for computer science mavens, the implications of the P versus NP problem stretch beyond
algorithms and data structures, rippling through diverse fields, including antimicrobial resistance, cancer care, and medical insurance

C. Aravinda Liquid nitrogen being poured from a container

into a bowl. CORY DOCTOROW/FLICKR

n the 17th century, a Dutch draper

Liquid nitrogen
I named Anton van Leeuwenhoek
used a small handmade microscope
to peer into a world previously
unseen by the human eye. Thus he
discovered microorganisms and gave rise
in foods draws
to the field of microbiology. It offered
solutions to challenges in healthcare that
Tamil Nadu’s
until then had seemed intractable.
Today, we face a new set of complex
problems in healthcare that seem more
ire, yet again
intractable than others before for their
inherent complexity and the constraints R. Sujatha
they threaten to impose on resources.
A week ago, a video of a child screaming
P versus NP went viral on social media. There were
ffa76243-386b-4d4d-93fa-f34e5b20443d

ffa76243-386b-4d4d-93fa-f34e5b20443d
It so happens that an unsolved problem in visuals of adults spewing white smoke
computer science, simply called the P from their mouth and nose. What the
versus NP problem, could hold the key to child said was garbled but it was soon
these modern-day conundra. While it may apparent the child had consumed a food
sound like a cryptic puzzle reserved for item infused with liquid nitrogen.
computer science mavens, its Television channels and online media
implications stretch beyond algorithms took up the issue. The Tamil Nadu
and data structures, rippling through government issued an advisory banning
diverse fields including healthcare. But the use of liquid nitrogen in food and
what exactly is this puzzle, and how could warned of stringent action against
its resolution unlock a new era in medical violators.
science? In 1991, The Hindu reported that a
Let’s start with a simple arithmetic London-based company developed a
example. Say you’re asked to multiply 17 system to improve the quality and shelf
with 19. With some time, you’d arrive at life of food by introducing droplets of
the answer: 323. This is a ‘P’ problem: you liquid nitrogen in the packaging. When
can solve it reasonably quickly. (‘P’ stands nitrogen evaporates, it displaces oxygen
for polynomial time.) Suppose you’re in the food pack, preventing microbial
presented with 323 and asked to identify action and preserving freshness.
the two prime numbers multiplied to get Healthcare is filled with complex issues like assigning doctors and nurses to shifts, booking operating theatres for surgeries, and organising patient The technique was useful in packing
this. In this case, you will have to take the appointments. GETTY IMAGES/ISTOCKPHOTO coffee, potato crisps, peanuts and peanut
trial and error route until you arrive at 17 butter, milk products, cheese, and dried
and 19. This is an ‘NP’ problem: it takes emerging diseases. Of course, patients’ and algorithms rely on problems that are potatoes, the article said.
longer to solve, but once you have the adherence will still matter. currently hard to solve, believed to be in As with every novelty, some chefs also
solution, you can verify it quickly. (‘NP’ Cancer is a complex disease with the set of ‘NP’, not ‘P’ problems. That is, experimented with liquid nitrogen to
here is nondeterministic polynomial myriad mutations. Deciding the best If P equals NP, we may have a way to these schemes protect secrets by hiding make food more interesting. In 2016, a
time.) treatment plan is an NP problem because quickly analyse bacterial genomes and them behind a problem that is very hard few upmarket restaurants and eateries in
Healthcare is filled with complex it involves considering all possible predict their resistance patterns, to solve but easy to verify. If P equals NP, Chennai and elsewhere used it to entice
issues. Consider scheduling in a hospital: combinations of drugs and therapies. If P these problems will become easy to solve, customers.
helping doctors prescribe the most
assigning doctors and nurses to shifts, equals NP, we may have an opportunity to rendering these encryption schemes But in August 2017, the then Union
booking operating theatres for surgeries, swiftly identify the optimal treatment for effective antibiotics. This would vulnerable to attacks and compromising Environment Minister Harsh Vardhan said
and organising patient appointments. It is each individual cancer patient and improve patient outcomes and combat digital security. in Rajya Sabha the government would
an intricate puzzle that requires potentially save many lives. The catch antibiotic resistance This said, healthcare isn’t the sole investigate the addition of liquid nitrogen
considering various factors — staff here is that we will still need a large beneficiary of this problem-solving. The
availability, urgency of medical cases, etc. volume of data. barrier that the P vs NP problem stands The Tamil Nadu Food Safety
— and potential changes such as Insurance companies grapple with NP of which they have unearthed for encompasses every field where the Department has issued a circular
emergency cases and cancellations. problems when they have to determine improvements to algorithms and new solution to a problem is blocked by the on the use of liquid nitrogen
The P vs NP question is this: could premiums and packages based on approaches to dealing with complex availability of significant computational
saying the substance can only be
there be a shortcut to solve ‘NP’ problems considering numerous variables like age, problems. resources. So these fields include
as quickly as ‘P’ problems? Because the health status, lifestyle, and medical Throughout history, there have been logistics, finance, and even climate used to preserve packaged food
implication is that if P equals NP, we could history. Having a shortcut to crack the P many instances of seemingly modelling, all of which could experience
quickly find the optimal solution to these vs NP problem could help these insurmountable problems being paradigm shifts if the P vs NP problem is in food and drinks served in some
scheduling problems, thus significantly companies optimise their overcome with innovative thinking. solved in favour of the P = NP outcome. restaurants.
improving patient care. decision-making and pave the way to Before the discovery of electricity, for The Clay Mathematics Institute in Six months ago, in Tiruchirappalli, a
The implications of resolving this fairer and more accurate premiums and example, candlemakers lit our world. Yet Colorado continues to offer a million vendor’s shop was sealed after authorities
question are profound and wide-reaching, conditions. Further, government most of them may never have foreseen dollars to anyone who can definitively found liquid nitrogen in food, the city’s
including for healthcare. spending on healthcare can also be the revolutionary consequences of solve the P vs NP problem. But for anyone designated food safety officer said.
utilised with minimal leakage while Thomas Edison’s incandescent bulb, who does, a million dollars will pale in “Liquid nitrogen, an inert, colourless,
Implications for healthcare programmes like Ayushman Bharat can which brought light to more people and comparison to the rewards they stand to odourless cryogenic fluid has traditionally
The P vs NP question is a problem in contribute more effectively to achieving for longer hours. collect by revolutionising various human been used in the management of many
mathematics and computer science, but universal health coverage. Similarly, following the invention of enterprises, potentially driving human benign pre-cancers and cancers since the
that does not mean it will be confined By solving these complex problems calculus and expanding the binomial progress in unimaginable ways. 1960s,” Arvind Krishnamurthy, professor
there. If an existing problem can be given more efficiently, we could potentially theorem to negative integers and As we look to the future, let us and head of surgical oncology at the
a faithful mathematical representation dramatically reduce resource constraints fractions, Isaac Newton considerably remember that problems that seem Adyar Cancer Institute, said. “This form
and is found to be an ‘NP’ problem, the and improve health outcomes. improved our understanding of the insurmountable today might not be so of treatment is generally used to manage
shortcut in question could help by irrational number pi. Why, the technology tomorrow. As with the candlemakers, the cancers wherein conventional surgery is
turning it into a ‘P’ problem. Surprising sources of progress giant Apple has been transforming our watchmakers, and even Anton van not possible or can be used as an adjunct
For example, antibiotic resistance is a While the P vs NP problem is a topic of expectations of what a watch can be Leeuwenhoek, the solution often comes to conventional surgery.”
significant global health concern. If P ongoing study in computer science, the expected to do in ways that Swiss from where we least expect it. Today’s The procedure involves using the
equals NP, we may have a way to quickly consensus among most experts is that P watchmakers may never have anticipated. brightest minds grappling with the P vs element at a frosty -196 degrees C to
analyse bacterial genomes and predict probably does not equal NP, implying that NP problem may be on the brink of a freeze and destroy cancer cells. “The
their resistance patterns, helping doctors some problems will remain very difficult Not all will be winners breakthrough that could redefine treatment is scientifically described as
prescribe the most effective antibiotics. to crack, even if a solution — once it is This said, one potential drawback of P healthcare as we know it. cryotherapy. It can also be used to obtain
This would improve patient outcomes found — will be easier to verify. But this being equal to NP, if ever that outcome (Dr C. Aravinda is a public health biopsies from cancer tissues for further
and help combat antibiotic resistance, has not deterred researchers from comes to pass, lies in the realm of physician and student at IIT Madras molecular analysis. Another application is
including new antibiotics discoveries for exploring this question, and in the pursuit cryptography. Many encryption schemes pursuing a BS degree in data science.) to use it as cryo-adhesion to remove
foreign bodies,” he explained.
Cryotherapy has been attempted to
treat many cancers, including those of
skin, bone, breast, cervical, eye, kidney,
Please send in your answers to liver, lung, and prostate.
THE SCIENCE QUIZ science@thehindu.co.in “Liquid nitrogen should be handled by
trained professionals with proper
protective gear, preferably in a controlled
lab or industry, as improper handling or
Revisiting malaria and its unique challenges consumption of liquid nitrogen can cause
severe damage to the skin, mucous
membranes, and internal organs,” the
Saumya Kalia speed up malaria Answers to May 1 quiz: surgeon said.
transmission. Identify the 1. Line beyond which human A day after the viral video, the Tamil
X cheapest and most-used activity is astronautic – Ans: Nadu Food Safety Department cited the
QUESTION 1 antimalarial drug to which Karman line Food Safety and Standards Regulations,
Malaria is caused by parasites mosquitoes have become 2. Line above which exposed and the Drug Administration department
transmitted through the bite resistant over time. water boils away – Ans: issued a circular on the use of liquid
of this category of emale X Armstrong line nitrogen saying the substance can only be
mosquito, discovered in 1897 QUESTION 4 3. Conditions in which water used to preserve packaged food.
by a British doctor. Name the vapour bubbles accumulate The department also warned of
This country made history in
mosquito and the doctor. in body’s fluids – Ans: stringent action, including fines and legal
2024 by launching the world’s
X
Ebullism proceedings, if it is used for other
first malaria vaccine as part
QUESTION 2 purposes.
of its immunisation 4. Entity of which around 1%
Which country contributes to (sujatha.r@thehindu.co.in)
programme. Name the is lost in every month in
more than half of the malaria
country and the vaccine. space – Ans: Bone
cases in the World Health
Organisation’s administrative X 5. Terrestrial counterpart of
Southeast Asia region? QUESTION 5 space adaptation syndrome –
X Which vaccine manufacturer Ans: Motion sickness For feedback and suggestions
QUESTION 3 has currently established Visual: Gemini 11 for ‘Science’, please write to
Global warming, population production capacity for the First contact: Vijayram X science@thehindu.co.in with the
displacement, and insecticide second malaria vaccine, Ganasala | ViswanadhaRao Visual: This chemist in 1939 identified the insecticidal properties of DDT, an achievement subject ‘Daily page’
resistance are expected to called R21/Matrix M? Batchu | Shiva Nigam that later won him a Nobel Prize. Name him. PUBLIC DOMAIN
CM S ND-NDE
YK