Study_name Ne Pre Xe Pre SdE Pre Nc Pre Xc Pre SdC Pre

Murad(2021)_1 25 1.49 0.40 25 1.62 0.46

Lee(2018)_1 14 34.35 9.644 14 50.14 13.254

Mi-Youn(2018)_1 33 1.71 0.63 33 1.74 0.46

Ji-Soo(2020)_1 24 50.2 11.97 24 73.33 5.82

Agarwal(2014)_1 25 89.6 18.58 25 129.4 32.66

Agarwal(2014)_2 25 119.04 20.16 25 126.4 24.05

Mawaddah(2016)_1 11 30.5 4.6 11 35.6 0.1

Phang(2015)_1 37 16.32 7.62 36 18.7 6.61

Phang(2015)_2

Phang(2015)_3

Warnecke 31 16.5 6.5 34 15 4.8

Warnecke 31 12.3 6.6 34 14.3 8.7

Waktu Jenjang Terapi Negara
Cognitive-
University Behavioral Yordania
Therapy
Plant-mediated
University Korea Selatan
Therapy
One-Time
University Laughter Korea Selatan
Therapy
Laughter
4 Minggu University Korea Selatan
Therapy
Movement
University India
Therapy
Movement
University India
Therapy
Group
2 Minggu Mts Discussion Indonesia
Therapy

Mindfulness
24 Minggu University Malaysia
Therapy

Mindfulness
8 minggu University Australia
Therapy
Mindfulness
16 minggu University Australia
Therapy
No Urutan
Sample Ok

1 1

2 2

6 3

7 4

8 5

9 6

10 7

11 8

12 9

13 10
Title

Effectiveness of a Cognitive-Behavioral Therapy Program on Reducing Psychological Stress

and Improving Achievement Motivation among University Students

Effect of Plant Mediated Therapy Activity on College Student' Academic Burnout and Stress

The Effects of Internet-Delivered Mindfulness Training on Stress, Coping, and Mindfulness in

University Students
The Effects of Laughter Therapy for the Relief of Employment-Stress in Korean Student
Nurses by Asessing Psychological Stress Salivary Cortisol and Subjective Happiness

Effect of Movement Therapy on Academic Stress in Physiotherapy Students

Effect of Movement Therapy on Academic Stress in Physiotherapy Students

Efektifitas Group Discussion Therapy dalam Menurunkan Stres Remaja di MTs Pesantren Al-
Amin Mojokerto

Effects of a brief mindfulness-based intervention

program for stress management among medical students:
the Mindful-Gym randomized controlled study

A randomised controlled trial of the effects of mindfulness practice on medical student stress
levels
A randomised controlled trial of the effects of mindfulness practice on medical student stress
levels
Nama Jurnal Tahun Vol No Hal

Universal Journal of Educational Research 2021 9 6

Journal People Plants Environment 2018 21 3 233

Journal of Management Practices, Humanities and Social

2018 2 1 Nov-15
Sciences

Osong Publich Health and Research Perspective 2020 11 1 44

MGM Journal of Medical Sciences 2014 1 4 189

MGM Journal of Medical Sciences 2014 1 4 189

Medica Majapahit 2016 8 2

Advance in Health Science Education - Springer Feb-15

Blackwell Publishing Ltd 2011. Medical Education 2011 2011 45 281-388

Blackwell Publishing Ltd 2011. Medical Education 2011 2011 45 281-388

Author Jenis Penelitian/ Metode Penelitian

Odeh Suleiman Murad

Min Hui Lee, Yong Hyun

Kim, Eun Jung Park, Moo
Ryong Huh
Cha Mi-Youn, Kim Ji Suk

Ji-Soo Lee, Soo Kyoung

Lee
Bela Agarwal, Meghana
Chowdry, Rajani
Mullerpatan
Bela Agarwal, Meghana
Chowdry, Rajani
Mullerpatan

Nurul Mawaddah, Elvin

Titiani

Cheng Kar Phang,

Firdaus Mukhtar,
Normala Ibrahim, Shian-
Ling Keng, Sherina
Mohd. Sidik
Emma Warnecke,
Stephen Quinn, Kathryn
Ogden, Nick Towle & Mar
Emma Warnecke,
R Nelson
Stephen Quinn, Kathryn
Ogden, Nick Towle & Mar
R Nelson
Teknik Pengumpulan dan Analisa Data Kode Sample (By author)
 Eksperimen
Study_name Waktu Total
Penelitian Sample Pre Eks
Ne Pre Xe Pre SdE Pre

Murad(2021)_1 50 25 2.42 0.40

Lee(2018)_1 28 14 46.5 9.296

Mi-Youn(2018)_1 66 33 2.04 0.62

Ji-Soo(2020)_1 1 Month 48 24 70.87 6.87

Agarwal(2014)_1 50 25 124.8 16.38

Agarwal(2014)_2 50 25 124.8 16.38

3 Sesi dengan
durasi masing-
masing 60-90
Mawaddah(2016)_1 22 11 35.2 4.6
menit, dalam
kurun waktu 2
minggu

Phang(2015)_1 6 Month 73 37 18.11 6.4

Warnecke 8 minggu 66

Warnecke 16 minggu 66
Eksperimen Control
Post Eks Pre Cont Post Cont
Ne Pre Xe Pre SdE Pre Nc Pre Xc Pre SdC Pre Nc Pre Xc Pre SdC Pre

25 1.49 0.40 25 1.75 0.44 25 1.62 0.46

14 34.35 9.644 14 53.35 8.731 14 50.14 13.254

33 1.71 0.63 33 1.78 0.52 33 1.74 0.46

24 50.2 11.97 24 53.25 9.63 24 73.33 5.82

25 89.6 18.58 25 124.12 36.35 25 129.4 32.66

25 119.04 20.16 25 124.12 36.35 25 126.4 24.05

11 30.5 4.6 11 35.5 0.1 11 35.6 0.1

37 16.32 7.62 36 19.58 5.7 36 18.7 6.61

31 16.5 6.5 34 15 4.8

31 12.3 6.6 34 14.3 8.7

 Tipe
Tempat/
Jenjang Jenis Terapi Negara (Journal, Waktu
Disertasi, Penelitian
Thesis, Dll
Cognitive-
University Behavioral Yordania Journal
Therapy
Plant-mediated
University Korea Selatan Journal
Therapy
One-Time
University Laughter Korea Selatan Journal
Therapy
Laughter
University Korea Selatan Journal
Therapy
Movement
University India Journal
Therapy
Movement
University India Journal
Therapy

Group
Mts Discussion Indonesia Journal
Therapy

Mindfulness
University Malaysia Journal
Therapy

Mindfulness
University Australia Journal
Therapy
Mindfulness
University Australia Journal
Therapy

Yoga
Hasil Penelitiran
 Urutan
No Sample Ok

1 1

2 2

3 (skip)

4 (skip)

5 (skip)

6 3

7 4

8 5

9 6

10 7
11 8

Skip
Title

Effectiveness of a Cognitive-Behavioral Therapy Program on Reducing Psychological Stress

and Improving Achievement Motivation among University Students

Effect of Plant Mediated Therapy Activity on College Student' Academic Burnout and Stress

The Effects of Internet-Delivered Mindfulness Training on Stress, Coping, and Mindfulness in

University Students

The Effects of Internet-Delivered Mindfulness Training on Stress, Coping, and Mindfulness in

University Students

Student Well-Being Intervention: The Effects of Stress Management Technique and Gratitude
Journaling in the Management Education Classroom

The Effects of Internet-Delivered Mindfulness Training on Stress, Coping, and Mindfulness in

University Students

The Effects of Laughter Therapy for the Relief of Employment-Stress in Korean Student
Nurses by Asessing Psychological Stress Salivary Cortisol and Subjective Happiness

Effect of Movement Therapy on Academic Stress in Physiotherapy Students

Effect of Movement Therapy on Academic Stress in Physiotherapy Students

Efektifitas Group Discussion Therapy dalam Menurunkan Stres Remaja di MTs Pesantren Al-
Amin Mojokerto
Effects of a brief mindfulness-based intervention
program for stress management among medical students:
the Mindful-Gym randomized controlled study

Effects of Briefing Group Mindfulness-based Cognitive Therapy for Stress Reduction among Medi
Nama Jurnal Tahun Vol No Hal

Universal Journal of Educational Research 2021 9 6

233
Journal People Plants Environment 2018 21 3
241

1
American Educational Research Association (AERA) 2016 2 1
8

1
American Educational Research Association (AERA) 2016 2 1
8

1
Journal of Management Education 2011 20 10
29

11
Journal of Management Practices, Humanities and Social
2018 2 1
Sciences
15

44
Osong Publich Health and Research Perspective 2020 11 1
52

189
MGM Journal of Medical Sciences 2014 1 4
192

189
MGM Journal of Medical Sciences 2014 1 4
192

Medica Majapahit 2016 8 2

Advance in Health Science Education - Springer Feb-15

Science Business Media New York - Springer Mar-15

Author Jenis Penelitian/ Metode Penelitian

Odeh Suleiman Murad

Min Hui Lee, Yong Hyun

Kim, Eun Jung Park, Moo
Ryong Huh

David Messer, John J.

Horan, Wesley Turner,
Wanda Weber

David Messer, John J.

Horan, Wesley Turner,
Wanda Weber

Carol L Flinchbaugh,
E.Whitney G.Moore,
Young K. Chang, and
Douglas R.May

Cha Mi-Youn, Kim Ji Suk

Ji-Soo Lee, Soo Kyoung

Lee

Bela Agarwal, Meghana

Chowdry, Rajani
Mullerpatan

Bela Agarwal, Meghana

Chowdry, Rajani
Mullerpatan

Nurul Mawaddah, Elvin

Titiani
Cheng Kar Phang,
Firdaus Mukhtar,
Normala Ibrahim, Shian-
Ling Keng, Sherina
Mohd. Sidik

Cheng Kar Phang, Kai Chon

Teknik Pengumpulan dan Analisa Data Kode Sample (By author)
 Waktu Total
Population Study_name Penelitian Sample

250 Murad(2021)_1 50

Lee(2018)_1 28

Messer(2016)_1

Messer(2016)_2

Flincbaugh(2011)_1

Mi-Youn(2018)_1 66

Ji-Soo(2020)_1 1 Month 48

Agarwal(2014)_1 50

Agarwal(2014)_2 50

3 Sesi dengan
durasi masing-
masing 60-90
Mawaddah(2016)_1 22
menit, dalam
kurun waktu 2
minggu
Phang(2015)_1 6 Month 73

Phang(2015)_2 2 Month 135

 Eksperimen Control
Ne Xe SD e Nc Xc
Status Status
Sample Test Standar Sample Test
Eksperimen Rata-Rata Deviasi Kontrol Rata-Rata

Pre Test 2.42 0.40 Pre Test 1.75

25 25

Post Test 1.49 0.40 Post Test 1.62

Pre Test 46.5 9.296 Pre Test 53.35

14 14
Post Test 34.35 9.644 Post Test 50.14

Pre Test Pre Test

114 43
Post Test Post Test

Pre Test Pre Test

114 43
Post Test Post Test

Pre Test Pre Test

Post Test Post Test

Pre Test 2.04 0.62 Pre Test 1.78

33 33
Post Test 1.71 0.63 Post Test 1.74

Pre Test 70.87 6.87 Pre Test 53.25

24 24
Post Test 50.2 11.97 Post Test 73.33

Pre Test 124.8 16.38 Pre Test 124.12

25 25
Post Test 89.6 18.58 Post Test 129.4

Pre Test 124.8 16.38 Pre Test 124.12

25 25
Post Test 119.04 20.16 Post Test 126.4

Pre Test 35.2 4.6 Pre Test 35.5

11 11
Post Test 30.5 4.6 Post Test 35.6
 Pre Test 18.11 6.4 Pre Test 19.58
37 36
Post Test 16.32 7.62 Post Test 18.7

Pre Test 23.41 6.86 Pre Test

135 135
Post Test 19.56 6.72 Post Test

Pre Test Pre Test

Post Test Post Test

trol
SDc
Standar z t F p Jenjang Jenis Terapi
Deviasi
Kontrol

0.44 Cognitive-
University Behavioral
Therapy
0.46

8.731
Plant-mediated
University
Therapy
13.254

Mindfulness
University
Therapy

Relaxation
University
Therapy

Stress
Management
University and Gratitude
Journal
Therapy

0.52 One-Time
University Laughter
0.46 Therapy

9.63
Laughter
University
Therapy
5.82

36.35
Movement
University
Therapy
32.66

36.35
Movement
University
Therapy
24.05

0.1 Group
Mts Discussion
0.1 Therapy
5.7
Mindfulness
University
Therapy
6.61

Mindfulness-
based
University
Cognitive
Therapy

University
 Tipe Tempat/
(Journal, Waktu
Negara Disertasi, Hasil Penelitiran
Thesis, Dll Penelitian

Yordania Journal

Korea Selatan Journal

USA Journal

USA Journal

USA Journal

Korea Selatan Journal

Korea Selatan Journal

India Journal

India Journal

Indonesia Journal
Malaysia Journal

Malaysia Journal
 Urutan
No Sample Ok

1 1

2 2

3 3

4 6
5 7
 Title

Massage Therapy in Management of Occupational Stress in Emergency Medical Services

Staffs

The effect of massage therapy on occupational stress of Intensive Care Unit nurses

The effects of “Workplace Health Promotion Program” in nurses: A randomized controlled trial
and one-year follow-up
cara cara mengetahui Mean dan SD jika median, nilai Z dan p di ketahui, ada 3 data dari
Akyurek

Effectiveness of aromatherapy massage on the stress of the surgical center nursing team: a
pilot study
Effect of Structured Yoga Program on Stress and Professional Quality of Life Among Nursing
Staff in a Tertiary Care Hospital of Delhi—A Small Scale Phase-II Trial
 Nama Jurnal Tahun Vol No

International Journal of Therapeutic Massage and Bodywork 2019 12 1

Iranian Journal of Nursing and Midwifery Research 2015 20 4

2020 23 5

Journal of School of Noursing 2017

Journal of Evidence Based Integrative Medicine 2021
 Author Jenis Penelitian/ Metode Penelitian

Mahdi Mahdizadeh, BSc,1 Ali

Ansari Jaberi, MSc,2
Eksperimen / Uji Coba Acak Terkontrol
Tayebeh Negahban Bonabi,
PhD3

Fateme Nazari1, Mojtaba

Mirzamohamadi2, Hojatollah Randomized Critical Trial
Yousefi3

Gokcen Akyurek , Nergis

A randomized controlled trial
Avci & Gamze Ekici

Juliana Montibeler1 , Thiago

da Silva Domingos1 , Eliana
Mara Braga1 , Juliana Rizzo a randomized controlled clinical trial pilot
Gnatta2 , Leonice Fumiko study
Sato Kurebayashi3 , Alberto
Keidi Kurebayashi4
Suprakash Mandal, MD1,
Puneet Misra, MD,
MPHhttps://orcid.org/0000-
0002-2019-15241, Gautam
Sharma, MD2, Rajesh Sagar, randomized controlled clinical trial
MD3, Shashi Kant, MD1, SN
Dwivedi, PhD4, R. Lakshmy,
PhD5, and Kiran Goswami,
MD1
 Total
Teknik Pengumpulan dan Analisa Data Kode Sample (By auth Sample

Penelitian melalui angket dengan skala liker 0-4, untuk melihat

tingkat stress, Data were analyzed by SPSS version 16 (SPSS
Inc., Chicago, Illinois, USA), using descriptive statistics, the
Mahdizadeh(1) 58
Kolmogorov-Smirnov, Chi-square, paired and independent-samples
t tests, and the one-way ANCOVA. P value less than .05 was
considered as level of significance

The data gathering tool was a questionnaire, which was completed

before, immediately after, and 2 weeks after the intervention by the
researcher. The questionnaire consists of two parts. The first
section consists of 12 questions relating to personal and
professional information, including age, gender, marital status,
education level, number of children, income, years of work
experience, work experience in the ICU, type of employment, and Nazari(1)
work shifts. The second part includes the OSI, which was first used
in 1987 by Osipow et al. This instrument has been frequently used
by researchers in the country and its reliability was calculated and
verified with Cronbach’s alpha at a satisfactory level of 0.89%.[26]
It consists of 60 questions and is graded based on a 5 ‑point Likert
scale, from never to always

Akyurek(1)

Akyurel(2)

Akyurek(3)

Data was entered into a Microsoft ExcelÒ worksheet and

processed by the program Statistical Package for Social SciencesÒ
(version 17.0.). Since there was a normal distribution of the
population sample, the paired t test was applied for continuous
variables in intragroup analysis before and after the intervention.
For analysis between groups, it was applied the analysis of
Montibeler(1) 38
variance (ANOVA) in order to verify associations between two
variables. For the variables obtained through the WSS, was applied
the chi-square test ‘(χ²)’ because this is a nonparametric method
designed for evaluation of evidence of association between two
categorical variables. The analyzes considered 95% Confidence
Interval (CI) and p-value of 0.05
Data collection was done at baseline and 3rd month. Data was
entered in Microsoft Excel and was analyzed in STATA version 12.
Per protocol analysis was done. The categorical variables were
summarized using absolute frequency and proportions and the
quantitative variables were summarized by mean, standard
deviation. The significance between the 2 groups was assessed by Mandal(1)
Fisher Exact/Chi-square test for categorical variables and unpaired
t-test/Wilcoxon rank-sum test for the continuous variables. The
effect size for the primary outcome variable was calculated by
standardized mean difference.45 The level of statistical significance
was considered as 5%.
 Eksperimen Control
Ne Xe SD e Nc Xc
Status
Sample Status Test Standar Sample Test Sample
Eksperimen Rata-Rata Deviasi Kontrol Kontrol

Pre Test 130,20 26,45 Pre Test 114,41

29 29

Post Test 110,41 21,75 Post Tes 112,58

Pre Test 172,2 15,9 Pre Test 167,5

33 33

Post Test 145,6 23,5 Post Test 169,7

Pre Test 15 Pre Test 100

15
Post Test Post Test

Pre Test 15 Pre Test

15
Post Test Post Test
Pre Test 15 Pre Test
15
Post Test Post Test

19 Pre Test 52.15 30.04 19 Pre Test 45.11

 Post Test 46.31 22.72 Post Test 44.44

58 Pre Test 71.2 5.6 52 Pre Test 68.7

18 Post Test 66.8 6.7 30 Post Test 69.6

ntrol
SDc
Standar t F p Jenjang Jenis Terapi
Deviasi
Kontrol

30,11 Provinsi Kerman, Iran

30,62

19,5

15,1

30.62
27.45

6.9

6.9
 Tipe Tempat/
(Journal, Waktu
Negara Disertasi, Hasil Penelitiran
Thesis, Dll Penelitian

Staff IGD
Provinsi Kerman, IranJournal Rafsanjan,
Kerman, Iran

Iran Journal

Brazil Journal