Professional Documents
Culture Documents
López Carrillo Et Al 1996 Prevalence and Determinants of Lead Intoxication in Mexican Children of Low Socioeconomic
López Carrillo Et Al 1996 Prevalence and Determinants of Lead Intoxication in Mexican Children of Low Socioeconomic
orts on the prvaence of lead poiso in children between 1 and 5 years of age consent. In those households having more
area to tof M o Ci d oinid:a evAtion of sotirces than one eligible child, only one subject was
....area..he...uls. T ta h dren i selected at random to constitute the final
. . . . . . . .... . ................ . . .... T... . . . . . . .. . . . . . ....... sample for the study reported herein.
q ire 4 e on 0.2OpI0 n. plO lD), and 112 In total, 411 mothers were approached
1teatment
(P-b]8 40 pg/i00 ml) In
d ladleels (2O d) corresponds to chidren whose moe use lead-lzed
e d hat the probabili- and agreed to participate in the study; along
with the interviews, 371 blood samples
:a = 2* Ca 95% 555 07) and i Wh
who ibe colo peA- were obtained from the children, thus ren-
.; ....5%. L3. 7 I p' ..n d...
w dering a 90.3% (371/41 1) overall response
rate. Reasons for not obtaining blood sam-
~ estmatin ~liair*nact.ad cos. nfpiap ase.intrventons amed ..a.................t.ples for 40 children included sickness at the
>ns and also co~afirmthe need to: program pro- time of the visit and, more often, extreme
Wan of lead expoe`in the nal pop on. umra blood lead, chidren, nervousness and crying.
di sources, epidemiology, Mextic-'o, prevalence Environ Health Perspect A structured questionnaire was used for
I(i99) ' .. .... the interview, which included questions
about environmental sources of lead, socioe-
conomic characteristics of the family, family
Several studies have reported that exposure to probabilistic sample) among children from health history, sickness profile of the child,
lead is an important health problem in 12 to 59 months of age who live in a mar- and use of health services. During the visit,
Mexico (1-5). Sources of exposure to this ginal area at the northern edge of Mexico each child was weighed and measured, using
metal, which have been identified, include City. We also include an assessment of the standardized instruments and procedures.
the use of lead-glazed pottery for cooking and sources of exposure to this metal in the Finally, a 1-ml blood sample was
storing food (6-10), residing in areas with same area. obtained for each child by qualified nurses
heavy vehicular traffic (6,9,11), consumption using lead-free tubes. Lead contents were
of canned foods (6,12), and the presence of Methods determined by spectrophotometric atomic
lead in indoor and outdoor dust (13,14). During the period from February 1991 to absorption (Perkin Elmer 3000, Perkin
Research in Mexico about the lead poi- March 1992, a longitudinal study of gener- Elmer, Mexico City, Mexico). Duplicate
soning problem has proceeded through well- al child health conditions was carried out measurements were performed for all sam-
defined stages. The first studies, carried out in Chimalhuacan, State of Mexico, which ples. Laboratory analysis included internal
in the mid-1960s, focused on the determina- is a suburban area adjacent to Mexico City and external quality control procedures, with
tion of lead contents in glazed pottery dishes with high levels of atmospheric pollution standards provided by the Centers for Disease
(15,16). During the 1970s and the early (mainly suspended particles). The majority Control and Prevention (CDC). Also, hema-
1980s, both clinical studies of lead poisoning of the residents are of very low economic tocrit and hemoglobin values were obtained
(17-20) and studies aimed at determining status, and public services such as running for each blood sample.
levels of lead in human biological samples water, electricity, sewage, etc., are deficient Statistical analysis. Prevalence of lead
such as urine (21-24), hair (25), and blood (32). We only used cross-sectional data poisoning levels was estimated using the cor-
(PbB) (14,22-24,26-29) were carried out. corresponding to one of the household vis- responding individual sampling weights
More recently, epidemiological studies its when PbB levels were measured.
focused on the identification of sources of The study population was made up of Address correspondence to M. Lopez-Cervantes,
lead intake for specific population sub- children aged from 12 to 59 months who Universidad Instituto Nacional de Salud Puiblica, Av.
655, Col. Sta. Maria Ahuacatitlin,
groups such as nursing infants (7,12), were selected through a household sampling C.P. 62508, Cuernavaca, Mor., Mexico.
preschool and school-aged children frame specifically developed for this research. The authors are grateful for the participation in field
(9-11,13), pregnant women (7), adults Initially, based on maps of the entire work by workers of the Health Institute of the State
(6,8,13,30), and artisans or other occupa- residential area, 121 blocks were randomly of M6xico and to Noemi Lam and Maria Engracia
tionally exposed groups (31). chosen; later, we compiled detailed listings Guilldn for coordination and supervision of field
Evolving from this context, new of all the households in the selected blocks. work activities. We are grateful to Ilda Mufioz for
the field personnel in blood sample collec-
research to be undertaken must support the Finally, through household visits, we iden- training tion, and to Reina Collado and Betania Allen for
implementation and evaluation of interven- tified a total of 603 eligible children in the editing and translating this document.
tion programs aimed at reducing exposure specified age bracket. More details about This study was supported by grants from the
to lead in Mexico. Therefore, more accurate the methodology for the study are Maternal & Child Health Research Program (The
estimates of the prevalence of lead poison- described elsewhere (Lopez-Cervantes et Mexican Health Foundation/The Carnegie
ing in vulnerable groups, such as children, al., submitted). Foundation), the Advisory Board in Epidemiology
The mothers of all eligible children Mexico), (The Rockefeller Foundation/Secretary of Health-
become essential. and The American British Cowdray
In this paper we present the true preva- were asked to participate in the study; upon Hospital-Mexico.
lence of lead poisoning (as estimated from a acceptance, they signed a letter of informed Received 20 May 1996; accepted 26 July 1996.
1208 Volume 104, Number 11, November 1996 * Environmental Health Perspectives
Articles * Lead poisoning in Mexican children
Table 1. General characteristics of the study pop- Table 2. Prevalence of lead poisoning" by age and sex in Chimalhuacan, Mexico
ulation Girls
Boys
Characteristic No. Mean ± SD Cl 95% Lead level <2 years 22 years <2 years 22 years Total
Children's age (months) 411 36.3 ± 14.3 35.0-37.7 (pg/dl) No. (%) No. (%) No. (%) No. (%) No. (%)
Mother's age (years) 409 28.0 ± 6.0 27.4-28.6 <10 496 (16.2) 1191 (38.8) 433 (14.1) 946 (30.8) 3066 (32.5)
Blood lead level (pg/dl) 371 15.0* ± 8.5 7.6-9.4 10-14 230 (10.3) 947 (42.5) 257 (11.5) 795 (35.7) 2229 (23.6)
Children's weight (kg) 409 13.4 ± 2.7 13.1-13.7 15-19 175(8.1) 880(40.8) 242(11.2) 860 (39.9) 2157 (22.8)
Children's height (cm) 405 90.7 ± 10.6 89.7-91.7 >20 393 (19.8) 616 (31.0) 324 (16.3) 654 (33.0) 1987 (21.1)
Hemoglobin (g/dl) 360 12.9 ± 1.4 12.8-13.0 Total 1294 (13.7) 3634 (38.5) 1256 (13.3) 3255 (34.5) 9439 (100.0)
Hematocrit (%) 360 39.6 ± 3.1 39.3-39.9
"Lead poisoning = blood lead levels .10 pg/dl
*Geometric mean = 12.7
(i.e., the inverse of the product of the selec- there were 122 children in need of medical Table 3. Geometric means for blood leada accord-
tion probabilities); hence, we present both treatment (PbB .40 pg/dl), whose presence ing to selected variables
the proportions and the absolute numbers was unsuspected before the study. >10 pg/dl
of children for each particular category of The geometric means of blood lead did Variable No. Mean Min-max (%)
blood lead contents or other factors as esti- not show significant variation according to Children's age in months
mated for the whole study area. Because the the age or sex of the child, age, occupation, .23 96 13.06 1-46.99 66.7
distribution of PbB levels is skewed to the or education of the mother, time residing 24-35 66 12.68 3.00-45.6 69.7
left, we used a log transformation of this in the study area, levels of hemoglobin, or 36-47 98 12.93 3.00-50.90 73.5
variable, and statistical procedures such as t- hematocrit (Table 3). .48 111 12.30 1.99-47.94 68.5
In contrast, PbB levels were significant- Children's sex
tests or ANOVA (analysis of variance) were Female 170 13.32 3.00-50.90 72.3
used for contrasting subgroups on the bases ly elevated in children whose mothers Male 201 12.18 1-47.94 67.2
of their geometric means. habitually cooked or stored foods in lead- Mother's age (years)
In a later step, a case-control approach glazed pottery, as compared to children .25 129 14.15 1-50.90 76.7
was used to calculate odds ratios (OR) for whose mothers did not use those items 26-30 112 11.82 1.99-45.60 63.4
assessing the importance of putative (14.9 vs. 11.7 pg/dl; p = 0.003) (Table 4). .31 128 12.06 3.00-47.94 67.2
Maternal employment
sources of lead intake, using the cut-off Likewise, children who lived in houses with Housewife 307 12.67 1-50.90 69.4
points recommended by the CDC for the walls that had been painted in the year Paying job 64 12.67 3.00-33.11 70.3
diagnosis of poisoning due to this metal before the interview had higher blood lead Maternal education
(<10 Rg/dl, 10-14 jig/dl, 15-19 pg/dl, .20 levels than those living in houses that were Illiterate 34 12.43 3.00-33.11 76.5
,ug/dl) (33). All the analyses were per- not recently painted (13.9 vs. 12.2 ,ug/dl; p Elementary 222 12.67 3.00-50.90 65.3
formed using the statistical software = 0.046). Biting colored pencils was also a Junior high 96 13.73 1.99-36.23 78.1
High school + 17 9.49 1-26.84 58.8
STATA 4.0 (Stata Corporation, College determinant of higher blood lead levels in Time living in the area
Station, TX). children (13.8 vs. 12.1 pg/dl). <6 months 14 15.02 2.32-35.87 78.6
Finally, crude ORs showed that prepar- 6-12 months 26 12.18 5.00-50.90 69.2
Results ing food in lead-glazed pottery and a history >12 months 331 12.67 1-47.94 69.2
Table 1 shows the characteristics of the of biting colored pencils significantly Hemoglobin (g/dl)
study population. On the average, children increased the risk of having blood lead levels <12 94 13.06 3.00-46.99 69.0
were approximately 3 ± 1.2 years old while .10 pg/dl; the ORs were 1.54; CI 95%, .12 277 12.55 1-50.90 71.3
Hematocrit
the mean age of the mothers was 28 ± 6 0.95-2.50, and 1.77; CI 95%, 1.10-2.85, .40 183 12.93 1-50.90 72.1
years. The overall arithmetic mean blood respectively. Meanwhile, the risk for high >40 188 12.43 1.99-46.52 67.0
lead level was 15.0 ± 8.5 pg/dl (geometric PbB levels in relation to recently painting aBlood lead in pg/dl.
mean = 12.2 pg/dl). the house interior walls was not significantly
According to the anthropometric and elevated (Table 5).
clinical measurements, the average weight When the analyses were repeated using Table 4. Geometric means for blood leada accord-
of the children was 13.4 ± 2.7 kg and their .20 pg/dl as the cut-off point for PbB, we ing to sources of exposure
average height was 90.7 ± 10.6 cm. The found again that children whose mothers
mean hemoglobin level was 12.9 ± 1.4 g/l habitually used lead-glazed pottery dishes Variable No. Mean Min-max % >10 pg/dl
and the mean hematocrit was 39.6 ± 3.1%. were more likely to belong to the high PbB Mother habitually cooks
The prevalences of lead poisoning (levels category (OR = 2.80; CI 95%, 1.55-5.07). in lead-glazed pottery
Yes 239 14.88 1.99-50.90 66.5
.10 jig/dl) by age and sex subgroups are Biting colored pencils was significantly No 130 11.70 1-45.60* 75.4
shown in Table 2. We estimated that out of associated with PbB levels between 15 and 19
all the children from 12 to 59 months of age j.g/dl, as compared with blood levels below House painted in
living in Chimalhuacin, Mexico, 67.5% 10 /dl (OR = 2.05; CI 95%, 1.13-3.71). last year
had PbB levels equal or greater than 10 Yes 134 13.87 3.00-51.0* 73.13
pg/dl (which corresponds in absolute num- Discussion No 237 12.18 1-49.40 67.5
bers to a total of 3132 girls and 3241 boys). The principal finding of this research is the Child bites
Most subjects (45.4% of the total) had lead estimation of a true population number of colored pencils
levels between 10 and 19 pg/dl. However, children (n = 6373) with lead poisoning Yes 142 13.73 1.99-50.90* 76.8
21.1% of the children (an estimated n = [PbB levels .10 jig/dl, as defined in the No 229 12.06 1-47.94 65.07
1987) had PbB levels requiring medical CDC guidelines (33)] in a well-defined aBlood lead in pg/dl.
evaluation (.20 jig/dl, but <40 jg/dl), and geographic area with a population of very *p<0.05.
Environmental Health Perspectives * Volume 104, Number 11, November 1996 1209
Articles L6pez-Carrillo et al.
-
1210 Volume 104, Number 11, November 1996 * Environmental Health Perspectives
Articles Lead poisoning in Mexican children
-
20. Montoya-Cabrera MA, Sauceda-Garcia JM, Landazuri-Laris P, Montes-Allende F, Escobar- 32. CONAPO. Sistema automatizado de informa-
L6pez-Martin G, Falc6n-Diaz 0, Rodriguez- Mairquez R, Margain-Compean JC. cion sobre la marginacion en Mexico 1990.
Blanca MC. Niveles de plomo en nifios con Determinacion de plomo en la sangre del Mexico DF, Consejo Nacional de Poblacion,
hiperactividad y atenci6n deficiente. Respuesta cordon umbilical en recien nacidos normales. 1993.
a la administraci6n de D-penicilamina. Bol Med Arch Invest Med Mex 12:457-462 (1981). 33. Centers for Disease Control. Preventing lead
Hosp Infant Mex 42:88-91 (1985). 27. Molina G, Zufiiga MA, Cardenas A, Solis PR, poisoning in young children. Atlanta, GA:U.S.
21. Molina-Ballesteros G, Zufiiga-Charles MA, Solis PV. Concentracion de plomo en sangre de Centers for Disease Control and Prevention,
Sanchez-Anzaldo FJ. determinaci6n del acido nifios de familias alfareras. Bol Oficina Sanit 1991.
delta aminolevulinico urinario en poblacion Panam 92:33-40 (1982). 34. SSA. NOM-010-SSA1-1993. Normas y
expuesta a plomo. Arch Invest Med Mex 7: 28. Molina G, Zufiiga MA, Cirdenas A, Medina R, anteproyectos de normas oficiales Mexicanas,
115-122 (1976). Solis Camara Ph, Solis QCmara P. Alteraciones 12/11/93. Mexico City:Secretaria de Salud,
22. Montoya MA, Hernandez A. Intoxicaci6n por psicol6gicas en nifios expuestos a ambientes 1993.
plomo. Origen de la exposici6n al metal en tres domesticos ricos en plomo. Bol Oficina Sanit 35. SSA. NOM-007-SSA1-1993. Normas y
familias. Rev Med IMSS Mex 19:337-339 Panam 94:239-247 (1983). anteproyectos de normas oficiales Mexicanas,
(1981). 29. Legaspi JA. Niveles de plomo en sangre, en 12/11/93. Mexico City:Secretaria de Salud,
23. Garcia E, Junco PR, Molina G, Arrieta ND. poblacion general del Valle de Mexico. Estudio 1993.
Efectos t6xicos por impurezas de plomo encon- preliminar. Gac Med M6x 124:375-380 (1988) 36. SSA. NOM-Q-46-1991. Norma oficial
tradas en fabricas de aluminio. Rev MMd IMSS 30. Junco P, Arrieta ND. Concentracion de plomo Mexicana. Mexico City:Secretaria de Salud,
Mex 19:561-565 (1981). en la sangre de los habitantes de la Ciudad de 1191.
24. Garcia JE, Molina G, Cueto LM, Cardenas A, Monterrey, Nuevo Le6n. Gac Med Mex 37. Bellinger D, Leviton A, Waternaux C,
Zufiiga MA. Niveles de plomo en alfareros. 129:63-67 (1993). Needleman H, Rabinowitz M. Longitudinal
Higiene 29:129-139 (1979). 31. Namihira D, Saldivar L, Pustilnik N, Carreon analyses of prenatal and postnatal lead exposure
25. Garcia JE, Rivas F, Olivares N. Concentra- GJ, Salinas ME. Lead in human blood and milk and early cognitive development. N Engl J Med
ciones de plomo en el cabello. Salud Publica from nursing women living near smelter in 316:1037-1043 (1987).
Mex 25:343-349 (1983). Mexico City. J Toxicol Environ Health
26. Montoya-Cabrera MA, Maldonado-Torres L, 38:225-232 (1993).
S O C IETY O F
4
A DEVELOPMENTAL Toxc
PSDOCTORAL STUDEN
We announce our intention to make awards of recognition for the best platform and/or
poster presentation by graduate students or postdoctoral fellows in the areas of repro-
ductive and developmental toxicology at the 36th Annual Meeting of the Society of
Toxicology to be held March 9-13, 1997 in Cincinnati, Ohio. General areas of research
may include male or female reproductive toxicology, reproductive endocrine toxicology,
teratology/developmental toxicology, and/or postnatal development. By November 8,
1996, candidates for these awards should send to the address below a copy of the
abstract that is being submitted to the Society for this meeting. An outline of the talk or
a copy of the poster material should also be included, if possible, to assist the judges in
their evaluation. The abstracts and posters should describe the original research which
may include applied studies, investigations of mechanisms of toxic response, or studies
of basic mechanisms of action. Interested individuals may request Society information
and abstract forms from the Society of Toxicology in Reston, Virginia (703) 438-3115 or
sothq@toxicology.org). All submitted material will be treated as confidential. The
winning presentations will be announced at the Annual Meeting of the Specialty
Subsection in Cincinnati. For further information, contact:
BETSY D. CARLTON, DABT RH6NE-POULENC
2 T.W. ALEXANDER DRIVE
RESEARCH TRIANGLE PARK, NC 27709
Environmental Health Perspectives * Volume 104, Number 11, November 1996 1211