A Review on Design and Analysis of Composite Spur Gears using Finite
Element Method
S. V. Pavan Kumar and P. Chris Richard’s
Department of Mechanical Engineering,
Adikavi Nannaya University, Rajamahendravaram.
Abstract
In this review, the parametric design and contact analysis of composite spur gears were investigated numerically. Composite
gear provides an adequate strength to weight ratio, more hardness, durability and low maintenance cost. It was emerged better
alternatives for replacing metallic gears. The finite element model of spur gear was developed with the assistance of the Ansys
software. In this study, each design factor such has stress distributions, strain and deformation were considered to compare
composite gear with steel and polymer gears. An APDL gear model was developed for the design evaluation and comparison
study [1].
I. INTRODUCTION
A Gear is a rotating circular machine part having cut 4. BEVEL GEAR:
teeth/cogwheel which mesh with another toothed part to
transmit torque/speed. The Bevel gears are most commonly used to transmit power
basic principle behind the between shafts that intersect at a 90-degree angle.
operation of gear is
analogous to the basic
principle of levers. Geared
devices can change the
speed, torque and direction
of power source.
II. CLASSIFICATION OF GEARS
Generally, we know that the gears have different sizes,
which produce different torque and they are used in two & 5. WORM GEAR:
three - wheelers. There are seven types of gears.
Worm gears transmit power through right angles on non-
1. SPUR GEAR: intersecting shafts. Worm gears produce thrust load and are
good for high shock load applications but offer very low
Spur gears or straight-cut gears are the simplest type of gear. efficiency in comparison to the other gears.
They consist of a cylinder or disk with teeth projecting radially.
Viewing the gear at 90 degrees from the shaft length (side on)
the tooth faces are straight and aligned parallel to the axis of
rotation.
6. HERRINGBONE GEAR:
Herringbone gears are very similar to the double helical gear,
2. HELICAL GEAR: but they do not have a gap separating the two helical faces.
Helical gears have teeth that are oriented at an angle to the
shaft, unlike spur gears which are parallel. This causes more
than one tooth to be in contact during operation and helical
gears are capable of carrying more load than spur gears.
7. HYPOID GEAR:
3. DOUBLE HELICAL GEAR:
Double helical gears
are a variation of
helical gears in which
two helical faces are Hypoid gears look very much like a spiral bevel gear but they
placed next to each operate on shafts which do not intersect, which is the case with
other with a gap a spiral bevel gear.
separating them.
So, these are the six various sorts of gears, each with their Contact stress equation given below
unique significance. So, let's speak about spur gears now. Spur
gears distribute power across parallel shafts. The spur gear
teeth are parallel to the shaft axis. As a result, the gears
generate radial reaction loads on the shaft but not axial loads.
Spur gears are louder than helical gears because they only
have one line of contact between teeth. While the teeth are
rolling through the mesh, they roll off of one tooth and
accelerate to the next tooth. This is in contrast to helical gears,
which have many teeth in contact and transmit torque more
smoothly.
Three different materials are selected for this analysis which
Spur gears are known for their ease of use, dependability, are, composite material, Peek material and steel. The material
compact design, constant speed drive, and efficiency. These properties of composite, peek and steel are obtained from
are the benefits of using a spur gear. reference [5-6].
.
III. ADVANTAGES & DISADVANTAGES
1. Spur gears are simple components, very easy to design
and install in drive mechanisms.
2. They are very straightforward and they are ideal for
limited spaces.
3. These gears are suitable for driving systems because they
have more power transmission efficiency
4. A spur gear is built with teeth made straight and parallel
to the axis of the gear. Eliminating any issue of axial thrust
allowing ball bearings to be installed.
5. Spur gear are slow-speed gears.
6. Gear teeth experience a large amount of stress.
7. They cannot transfer power between non-parallel shafts
8. They cannot be used for long distance power
transmission.
9. Spur gears produce a lot of noise when operating at high
speeds.
10. When compared with other types of gears, they are not
as strong as them.
IV. APPLICATIONS Pt is the tangential component of resultant force P between two
Spur gears are mostly used to reduce speed and increase meshing teeth.
torque for low-speed applications. But in some consumer
products, they are also used in high-speed applications. Here 3.4 Finite element analysis of spur gear
are some applications of spur gears in various products.
An APDL program was developed to plot a one pair of teeth
1. Mixer and Blender. in contact. Finite element contact models and contact analysis
2. Washing Machines. were used in APDL coding for various gears under rotational
3. Automobiles. force. In gear meshing, surface-surface contact was
4. Bicycle Machines. considered and target element (TARGE170) also used to
5. Mechanical Clocks etc. represent the contact pairs.
V. MODELLING OF SPUR GEARS IN ANSYS
The spur gears were designed for the applications of lathe
machine and oil pump etc. The PSG design procedure used to
evaluate the parameters of spur gear. The spur gear was
sketched and modelled in finite element software using the
basic dimensions
5.1 Material property
Three different materials are selected for this analysis which
are, composite material, Peek material and steel. The material
This target surface was discretized by a set of target segment
properties of composite, peek and steel are obtained from
elements. Contact element (CONTA174) was used to
reference [2-3]. The material properties of the glass
represent contact and sliding between 3-D "target" surfaces.
fiber/epoxy composite and peek material and steel material
CNCHECK command was used to check the contact status
between the contact and target elements in the mating surface
5.2. Specifications of gear
of the gears.
The specification of gears is: power, speed, center distance,
number of teeth and face width for lathe applications.
5.3. Calculation of contact stress using hertz equation
The importance of contact analysis is to prevent gear pitting
failure. Contact stresses in gears are calculated by using Hertz
equations which was originally derived for contact between
two cylinders.
Power (P) = 2*π*N*T / 60
Torque T = F * (d/2)
Force F = T/ (d/2)
Evaluate the contact stress using hertz equations:
VI. RESULTS AND DISCUSSIONS
The design and analysis spur gears were carried out for
showing the stress for three different materials with various
speeds distribution and identifying the maximum von-mises
stress which occurred at the root of the tooth roves the
efficiency of the gear based on the loading conditions. It was
observed that the stress value in composite gear was less
compared to the peak gear.
VII. SUMMARY
In this paper, the gear tooth contact analyses in spur gears
through finite element analysis were carried out. A general
finite element model was developed for evaluating the contact
stress in spur gears of equal geometry in both gears. FEA was
used to simulate the gear tooth contact behavior through the
mesh, contact elements and adaptive method with the aid of
an augmented Lagrange contact algorithm. The detailed
procedures to create a 3D model in finite element software
were described. The displacements, stress distributions and
strain for three different materials with two different speeds
were obtained. From the result it could be concluded that the
deformation of composite material gear was very less
compared to steel and plastic materials. Also, the rotational
speeds of the spur gear influence the behavior of the materials
like stress, strain and deformation etc. Therefore, the
composite material has better alternative for steel and plastic
material.
VIII. REFERNCES
[1] S Rajeshkumar and R Manoharan School of Mechanical
Engineering, VIT University, Vellore-632014, Tamil Nadu,
India.
[2] Vijayarangan S, Ganesan N 1993 Stress analysis of
composite spur gear using the finite element approach.
Comjmrers & Structures 46 869-875.
[3] Rao SS 1989 The finite element method in engineering
(University of Michigan: Pergamon Press).
[4] "How Gears Work". howstuffworks.com. 16 November
2000. Retrieved 20 September 2018.
[5] Senthilvelan S, Gnanamoorthy R 2007 Effect of rotational
speed on the performance of unreinforced and glass fiber
reinforced Nylon 6 spur gears Elsevier- Materials and Design
28 765-772.
[6] Shanmugasundaram S, Muthusamy N 2010 Profile
modification - a design approach increasing the tooth
strength in spur gear Springer- Int J Adv Manuf Technology
55 1–10.