0% found this document useful (0 votes)
326 views24 pages

Chapter 3 Design Controls and Criteria Editted

Copyright
© © All Rights Reserved
We take content rights seriously. If you suspect this is your content, claim it here.
Available Formats
Download as PDF, TXT or read online on Scribd
0% found this document useful (0 votes)
326 views24 pages

Chapter 3 Design Controls and Criteria Editted

Copyright
© © All Rights Reserved
We take content rights seriously. If you suspect this is your content, claim it here.
Available Formats
Download as PDF, TXT or read online on Scribd

DEPARTMENT OF CIVIL ENGINEERING

Chapter three
Geometric Design of Highway
Introduction
Geometric design is the stage of road design process where the dimension and layouts of
roads are related to the needs of drivers and vehicle operation.
The safe, efficient and economic operation of highway is largely determined
by the geometric design.
The following are factors to be considered in geometric design:

 faulty designs which may need large
costs of rectify .



 he design should consider both initial construction costs and operation costs.
3.1 Design Controls and Criteria
The elements of design such as alignments and cross sections are influenced by a wide variety of
design controls, engineering criteria, and project specific objectives so that the designer must
have an understanding of the basic design control and criteria associated with the highway.
The choice of design controls and criteria is influenced by the following factors:
i) traffic volumes expected on the road;
ii) the design vehicle;
iii) design speed;
iv) traffic composition;
v) terrain;
vi) roadside population and land use;
vii) pavement type;
viii) soil type and climate;
ix) construction technology;
x) functional classification of the road;
xi) safety;
xii) economic and environmental considerations.
For a long road these factors usually vary along the route and therefore the design does not have
to be constant for the whole length of a road. On the contrary, changes in the design are usually
required in order to obtain proper balance between the road layout and the above factors, whilst
maintaining construction costs at realistic levels.
These considerations are not, of course, completely independent of one another. The functional
class of a proposed facility is largely determined by the volume and composition of the traffic to
be served. It is also related to the type of service that a highway will accommodate and the speed
that a vehicle will travel while being driven along a highway.
Of all the factors that are considered in the design of a highway, the principal design criteria are
traffic volume, design speed, sight distances, vehicle size, and vehicle mix.

Lecture Note: - CENG 3804: HIGHWAY I


1
DEPARTMENT OF CIVIL ENGINEERING

 Functional classification of the roadway

Note that throughout this course the term “highway” or “highways” is used to denote travel
surfaces. The term will be used whether the surface under discussion is a road, a street, an
avenue, a highway or has any other designation.

Highways are commonly classified in one of two ways: by purpose or by ownership. Functional
classification is the process by which highways are grouped into classes, or systems, according to
the purpose, or the character of service they are intended to provide. This classification
recognizes that individual roads and streets do not serve travel independently. Rather, most travel
involves movement through networks of roads and can be categorized relative to such networks
in a logical and efficient manner. This is done by defining the role a particular highway should
play in serving the flow of trips through the highway network. The major concept behind the
functional classification system is the relationship between highways and the functions they
serve. Once the major function of a highway is established, its classification is more easily
determined.
In general, the two basic functions of a highway are:
1. Access to property
2. Travel mobility
Almost all highways perform both of these functions, but in varying combinations. The
determination of these relationships (basically a determination of the highway's principal use)
will also determine to which of the three major functional classifications the highway belongs.
These three major classifications are arterial, collector and local. In general, the access/mobility
relationship of these three major classifications is as follows:
Arterial
These highways emphasize a high level of mobility for through movement. They provide the
highest level of mobility, at the highest speed, for long, uninterrupted travel. Arterials generally
have higher design standards than other highways, often with multiple lanes and some degree of
access control.
Collector
These highways provide a lower level of mobility but a larger level of property access than
arterials. They are designed for travel at lower speeds and for shorter distances. Collectors
typically are two-lane highways that gather and distribute traffic to and from the arterial system
and the local system.
Local
These highways emphasize a high level of land access. They provide the highest level of
property access, at the lowest speeds, and the lowest level of mobility. They generally have the
lowest design standards and are typically two lane highways with no striping or other painted
markings. They represent the bulk of the mileage in the public highway network.

Lecture Note: - CENG 3804: HIGHWAY I


2
DEPARTMENT OF CIVIL ENGINEERING

Figure 3.1
From the above figure 3.1 A, lines of travel desire are straight lines connecting trip origins and
destinations (circles). The relative widths of the lines indicate the relative amounts of travel
desire. The relative sizes of the circles indicate the relative trip generating and attracting power
of the places.

Lecture Note: - CENG 3804: HIGHWAY I


3
DEPARTMENT OF CIVIL ENGINEERING

From the above figure 3.1 B, labeled local access, collector, and arterial, which are terms that
describe their functional relationships. In this scheme the functional hierarchy is also seen to be
related to the hierarchy of trip distances served by the network.

A more complete illustration of a functionally classified rural network is shown in figure 3.2.The
arterial highways generally provide direct service between cities and larger towns, which
generate and attract a large proportion of the relatively longer trips. Roads of the intermediate
functional category (collectors) serve small towns directly, connecting them to the arterial
network. Roads of this category collect traffic from the local roads, which serve individual farms
and other rural land uses or distribute traffic to these local roads from the arterials.

Figure 3.2
Although this example has a rural setting, the same basic concepts also apply in urban and
suburban areas. A similar hierarchy of systems can be defined; however, because of the high
intensity of land use and travel, specific travel generation centers are more difficult to identify. In
urban and suburban areas additional considerations, such as the spacing of intersections, become
more important in defining a logical and efficient network. A schematic illustration of a
functionally classified suburban street network is shown in figure 3.3.

Lecture Note: - CENG 3804: HIGHWAY I


4
DEPARTMENT OF CIVIL ENGINEERING

Figure 3.3

Roads generally serve a multitude of purposes:


• As through route - for long distance traffic
• As local route – for local traffic
• In urban and rural areas –urban roads/rural roads
• For fast and slow vehicles – 2 wheels to 10+ wheels
• As servicing/access roads
• For use by pedestrians
• For parking areas
• For Street Vendors, etc

Lecture Note: - CENG 3804: HIGHWAY I


5
DEPARTMENT OF CIVIL ENGINEERING

Such a mix of uses Reduces SAFETY, EFFICIENCY, and CAPACITY; hence a hierarchical
road system is necessary. Roads are therefore classified according to their respective functions in
terms of the character of the services they are providing.
Objectives in setting a hierarchy
• To obtain best use of an existing network
• To ensure that each type of traffic is using the most appropriate route
• To minimize the risk to users and to the natural built environment
• To ensure better management, maintenance regimes and design policies
• To ensure funding for routes is targeted appropriately
• To offer network users a choice for how to travel

Characterstics
Primary Distributor Fast moving long distance through traffic, no frontage
↓ development and pedestrian.
District Distributor

Local Distributor

Access Distributor slow moving vehicles, delivery vehicles, and frontage
development, walking, no through vehicle movement.

The classification in Ethiopia comprises five functional classes.


Trunk Roads (Class I): Centres of international importance and roads terminating at
international boundaries are linked with Addis Ababa by trunk roads. They are numbered with an
"A" prefix: an example is the Addis-Gondar Road (A3). Trunk roads usually have a design
AADT ≥1000, although they can have volumes as low as 150 AADT.
Link Roads (Class II): Centres of national or international importance, such as principal
towns and urban centres are linked to each other by link roads. A typical link road has an AADT
greater than 300 although values can range between 75 and 10,000 AADT. They are numbered
with a "B" prefix. An example of a typical link road is the Woldiya- Debre Tabor- Woreta Road
(B22), which links, for instance, Woldiya on Road A2 with Bahir Dar of Road A3.
Main Access Roads (Class III): Centres of provincial importance are linked between each
other by main access roads. The AADTs are typically between 150 and 300 but can range from
25 - 1000. They are numbered with a "C" prefix.
Collector Roads (Class IV): Roads linking locally important centres to each other, to a more
important centre, or to higher class roads are linked by a collector road. AADTs are between 25
and 300. They are numbered with a "D" prefix.
Feeder Roads (Class V): Any road link to a minor centre such as market and local locations
is served by a feeder road. AADTs are less than 150. They are numbered with an "E" prefix.

Roads of the highest classes, trunk and link roads have, as their major function to provide
mobility, while the primary function of lower class roads is to provide access. The roads of
intermediate classes have, for all practical purposes, to provide both mobility and access.

Lecture Note: - CENG 3804: HIGHWAY I


6
DEPARTMENT OF CIVIL ENGINEERING

 The role of functional classification in the design process


The first step in the design process is to define the function that the facility is to serve. The level
of service needed to fulfill this function for the anticipated volume and composition of traffic
provides a rational and cost-effective basis for the selection of design speed and geometric
criteria within the ranges of values available to the designer.
Once the functional classification of a particular roadway has been established, so has the
allowable range of design speed with the allowable range of horizontal and vertical alignment are
also defined. Similarly, a determination of functional classification establishes the basic roadway
cross section in terms of lane width, shoulder width, type and width of median area, and other
major design features.

 Human factors
Driver performance
An appreciation of driver performance is essential to proper highway design and operation. The
suitability of a design rests as much on how safely and efficiently drivers are able to use the
highway as on any other criterion. When drivers use a highway designed to be compatible with
their capabilities and limitations, their performance is aided. When a design is incompatible with
the capabilities of drivers, the chance for driver errors increase, and crashes or inefficient
operation may result.
Design response; Designers should strive to satisfy the following criteria:
 Driver‘s expectations are recognized, unexpected, unusual or inconsistent design or
operational situations avoided or minimized.
 Predictable behavior is encouraged through familiarity and habit (e.g. there should be a
limited range of intersection and interchange design format, each appropriate to a given
situation, and similar design should be used in similar situation).
 Consistency of design and driver behavior is maintained from element to element (e.g.
avoid significant changes in design and operating speeds along a roadway).
 The information that is provided should decrease the driver‘s uncertainty, not increase it
(e.g. avoid presenting several alternatives to the driver at the same time).
 Clear site lines and adequate site distance are provided to allow time for decision making
where ever possible, margins are allowed for error and recovery.

Pedestrians
The interaction of pedestrian with traffic should be carefully considered in road planning and
design, because over 50 per cent of all road fatalities are pedestrian. The urban pedestrian, being
far more prevalent, more often influences roadway design features than the rural pedestrian does.
o General characteristics
 Pedestrian actions are less predictable than those of motorists. Pedestrians tend to
select paths that the shortest distance between two points. They also have a basic
resistance to change in gradient or elevation when crossing roadways and tend to
avoid using underpasses or overpasses that are not convenient.
 Pedestrian age is an important factor that may explain behavior that leads to
collisions b/n motor vehicles and pedestrians. Very young pedestrian are often
careless in traffic from either ignorance or sensory, perceptual, cognitive, or
motor skills. Pedestrians‘ accidents can also be related to the lack of pedestrian
facilities.

Lecture Note: - CENG 3804: HIGHWAY I


7
DEPARTMENT OF CIVIL ENGINEERING

 Walking speed vary from a 15th percentile speed of 1.2 m/s to an 85th percentile
of 1.8 m/s, with average of 1.4m/s.
 Pedestrian with disability (with mobility, visual, development impairment)
require special attention during road planning and design.

Cyclists
Bicycle use is increasing and should be considered in road planning process. During planning
designing roads, consideration of providing cycle ways such as:
 Paved shoulders
 Wider outside traffic lanes (4.2 minimum)if no shoulder exists
 Adjusting manhole covers to grade, and
 Maintaining a smooth, clean riding surface can considerably enhance the safety of a
street or a highway and provide for bicycle
traffic.
At certain locations it may be appropriate to supplement the existing road system by providing
specifically designated cycle paths.

 Design Vehicle: It is the size of the largest vehicles that use the road that dictates many aspects
of geometric design. Such vehicles must be able to pass each other safely and to negotiate all
aspects of the horizontal and vertical alignment. Thus the vehicle characteristics and dimensions
affecting design include power to weight ratio, minimum turning radius and travel path during a
turn, and vehicle height and width. The road elements affected include the selection of maximum
gradient, lane width, horizontal curve widening, and junction design.
In Ethiopia four different design vehicles have been used as shown in Tables 3.1 and 3.2, but
there is very little difference between design vehicles DV2 and DV3. Roads designed for the
single unit truck will be suitable for the bus provided the front and rear overhangs of the bus are
taken into account when designing curves; and this can be done with suitable curve widening
where required. The standard for only the lowest class of road is insufficient for DV2 and DV3.
One of the key controls in geometric highway design is the physical characteristics and the
proportions of vehicles of various sizes using the highway. Therefore, it is appropriate to
examine all vehicle types, establish general class groupings, and select vehicles of representative
size within each class for design use. These selected vehicles, with representative weight,
dimensions, and operating characteristics, used to establish highway design controls for
accommodating vehicles of designated classes, are known as design vehicles. For purposes of
geometric design, each design vehicle has larger physical dimensions and a larger minimum
turning radius than most vehicles in its class. The largest design vehicles are usually
accommodated in freeway design.
Physical characteristics
Design vehicles are used to define several geometric features. Some examples are:
Turning radii: In constricted situations minimum turning radii for the outer side of design vehicle
is appropriate only to crawl speeds (at less than 15 km/hr)
Vehicle height: The 15th percentile height of a passenger car has been established to be 1.3 m.
This has been selected for design purposes as the passenger car is also an object that has to be
seen by the driver in the cases of passing and intersection sight distance.
Driver Eye Height: The passenger car is taken as the critical vehicle for driver eye height and a
figure of 1.05 meters is recommended. For buses and single unit vehicles a typical value is 1.8

Lecture Note: - CENG 3804: HIGHWAY I


8
DEPARTMENT OF CIVIL ENGINEERING

meters and for semi-trailer combinations the height of the eye can vary b/n 1.9m and 2.4m (SA
manual)
Table 3.1 Design Vehicle: Physical Characteristics (ERA Geometric Manual)

Table 3.2 Design vehicle for each road class

Performance Characteristics
 Acceleration and deceleration rates of the vehicles are often critical parameters in
determining the dimensions of features such as intersections, ramp, climbing or passing lane.
When a road is located in recreational area, the performance characteristics of recreational
vehicles should be considered.
 Pollutions (emission and noise) from the motor vehicles and their impact on land use
adjacent to roads are factors affecting the road design. The rate of pollutants from vehicles
depends on vehicle mix, speed, vehicle age, etc. The highway designer should therefore be
concerned with how highway location and design influence the vehicle noise perceived by
persons residing or working nearby. The perceived noise level decreases as the distance to
the highway from a residence or workplace increases.

Lecture Note: - CENG 3804: HIGHWAY I


9
DEPARTMENT OF CIVIL ENGINEERING

Finally, the dimensions of the motor vehicles that will use the proposed facility also influence the
design of a highway.
– The width of the vehicle naturally affects the width of the traffic lane;
– The vehicle length affects roadway capacity and turning radius;
– The vehicle height dictates the clearance of the various structures.
– Vehicle weight affects the structural design of the roadway.

Figure 3.1: Selection Procedure for Appropriate Geometric Standards

Lecture Note: - CENG 3804: HIGHWAY I


10
DEPARTMENT OF CIVIL ENGINEERING

 Traffic characteristics: Traffic Volume and Composition


Factual information on expected traffic volume is an essential input to design. Traffic volume
affects the geometric features such as no of lanes, widths, alignment and grades. The way that
vehicle size influences the geometric design of low and high volume roads is fundamentally
different. When the volume of traffic is high, the road space occupied by different types of
vehicle is an important element in designing for capacity (ie. the number of vehicles that the road
can carry in a unit of time -vehicles per hour or per day). At the highest traffic levels, when
congestion becomes important, traffic volume and the space it occupies, therefore traffic
composition, dictates how many traffic lanes need to be provided. The criteria for providing
additional lane are based solely on traffic volume irrespective of composition.
Traffic volume – AADT, ADT, PHV, DHV
o ADT is the basic measure of traffic demand. Traffic flows vary months of the year, days of
the weak and hours of the day. The designer should be familiar with the extent of this
fluctuation to enable him or her to assess the flow patterns. Direct use of ADT in geometric
design is not appropriate except for local and collector roads with relatively low volumes
because it does not indicate traffic volume variation. The volume on certain days may be
significantly higher than the ADT.
o Peak hour volume; traffic volume for an interval of time shorter than a day shorter than a
day more appropriately reflect the operating conditions that should be used for design. A
key decision involves determining which of these hourly traffic volumes should be used as a
basis for design. A chart relating the highest volumes and ADT on rural roads were
produced from the analysis of traffic count data covering a wide range of volumes and
geographical conditions. The charts were prepared by arranging all the hourly volume for
one year, expressed as a percentage of ADT, in a descending order of magnitude. Based on
the review of the charts, it is recommended that the hourly traffic volume that should
generally be used in the design is the 30th highest volume of the year, 30HV.The design
hourly volume (DHV) for rural highways should generally be the 30HV of the future chosen
for design. On rural roads with average fluctuation in traffic flow, the 30HV is typically
about 15% of the ADT.
o Directional distribution – the percentage of traffic volume flowing in each direction. It is
important to realize that the design flow is actually a composite and not a single value. A
road must be able to accommodate the major flow in both directions. The actual distribution
to be used for design purposes should be measured in the field. If an existing road is to be
reconstructed, the field studies can be carried out on it beforehand. For new facilities,
measurements should be made on adjacent roads from which it is expected the traffic will be
diverted and modeling techniques applied.

Traffic composition: The percentages of different types of vehicles in the traffic stream –
different types of vehicles are converted into passenger car unit to design a road width. Traffic
volume for basic design purposes is based on the number of two (or more)-axled motorised
vehicles. Consideration of other traffic (motor cycles, motor cycle-based taxis (bajaj), non-
motorised vehicles, pedestrians, etc) is taken into account by modifying the basic standards. This
is done by combining the number of such road users using the PCU (passenger car unit) concept
Lecture Note: - CENG 3804: HIGHWAY I
11
DEPARTMENT OF CIVIL ENGINEERING

as shown in Table 3.3. Besides being heavier, trucks are generally slower and occupy more
roadway space. Consequently, trucks have a greater effect on highway traffic operation than do
passenger vehicles. The overall effect on traffic operation of one truck is often equivalent to
several passenger cars. The number of equivalent passenger cars is dependent on the roadway
gradient and, for two-lane highways, on the available passing sight distance. Thus, the larger the
proportion of trucks in a traffic stream, the greater the traffic demand and the greater the
highway capacity needed.
Table 3.3: PCU values

If the number of PCU‘s exceeds certain limits on some classes of road, the geometric design
is modified to cater for them by increasing the width of the shoulders (Table 3.4).

Lecture Note: - CENG 3804: HIGHWAY I


12
DEPARTMENT OF CIVIL ENGINEERING

Table 3.3 Modifications for PCUs greater than 300 AADT.

Large heavy vehicles are defined as vehicles with three or more axles and gross vehicle weights
of greater than 10 tonnes.
Table 3.4 Adjustments for excessive numbers of large heavy vehicles

 Traffic characteristics: Speed


Drivers on the whole, are concerned with minimizing their times, and speed is one of the most
important factors governing the selection of alternate routes to gain time savings. The
attractiveness of a specific road or route is generally judged by its convenience in travel time,
which is directly related to travel speed.
Various factors influence the speed of vehicles on a particular road. These include
 Driver capability, driver culture and driver behavior

Lecture Note: - CENG 3804: HIGHWAY I


13
DEPARTMENT OF CIVIL ENGINEERING

 Vehicle operating capabilities


 The physical characteristics of the road and its surroundings
 Weather
 Presence of other vehicle
 Speed limitations (posted speed limits)
The objective of the designer is to satisfy the road user‘s demands for service in a safe and
economical way. This means that the facility should accommodate nearly all reasonable demands
(speed) with appropriate adequacy (safety and capacity) but should not fail completely under
sever load, i.e. the extremely high speeds maintained by a small percentage of drivers.
Roads should, therefore, be designed to operate at a speed that satisfies most, but not necessarily
all, drivers.
• Design speed is the max safe speed selected for designing specific section of road
considering the terrain, land use, classification of the road, etc.
The road elements include horizontal and vertical alignment, super elevation and sight distance.
Other elements such as lane width, shoulder width and clearance from obstacles are directly
related to design speed. Other relevant factors include traffic characteristics, speed capabilities of
vehicles, economics and social or political impacts. The chosen design speed should be a logical
consistent with the road function as perceived by the driver and also one that takes in to account
the type of the road, the anticipated operating speed, and the terrain that the road traverses.
Ideally, the design speed should be chosen to reflect 85th percentile desired speed that is likely to
materialize. This is often achievable for roads for which the primary function is mobility and
where sever physical constraints do not exist. Consistency of design is fundamental to good
driver performance, based on satisfying the driver‘s expectation. Design consistency exists when
the geometric features of a continuous selection of road are consistent with the operational
characteristics as perceived by the driver.
 Access control and access management
Regulating access is called ―access control.‖ It is achieved through the regulation of public
access rights to and from properties abutting the highway facilities. These regulations generally
are categorized as full control of access, partial control of access, access management, and
driveway/entrance regulations. The principal advantages of controlling access are the
preservation or improvement of service and safety.

The functional advantage of providing access control on a street or highway is the Management
of the interference with through traffic. This interference is created by vehicles or pedestrians
entering, leaving, and crossing the highway. Where access to a highway is managed, entrances
and exits are located at points best suited to fit traffic and land-use needs and are designed to
enable vehicles to enter and leave safely with minimum interference from through traffic.
Vehicles are prevented from entering or leaving elsewhere so that, regardless of the type and
intensity of development of the roadside areas, a high quality of service is preserved and crash
potential is lessened. Conversely, on streets or highways where there is no access management
and roadside businesses are allowed to develop haphazardly, interference from the roadside can
become a major factor in reducing the capacity, increasing the crash potential, and eroding the
mobility function of the facility.
Access control techniques can be implemented with two basic legal powers: police power and
eminent domain. This first power allows a state to restrict individual actions for the public

Lecture Note: - CENG 3804: HIGHWAY I


14
DEPARTMENT OF CIVIL ENGINEERING

welfare. Police power provides sufficient authority for most access control techniques associated
with highway operations, driveway location, driveway design, and access denials. The second
power allows a state to take property for public use provided an owner is compensated for his
loss. A State may need to use eminent domain when building local service roads, buying abutting
property, acquiring additional right-of-way, and taking access rights. However, an agency
usually has the power to deny direct access through the use of police power when reasonable
alternative access is available.
Full control of access means that preference is given to through traffic by providing access
connections by means of ramps with only selected public roads and by prohibiting crossings at
grade and direct private driveway connections.
With partial control of access, preference is given to through traffic to a degree. Access
connections, which may be at-grade or grade-separated, are provided with selected public roads,
and private driveways. Generally, full or partial access control is accomplished by legally
obtaining the access rights from the abutting property owners (usually at the time of purchase of
the right-of-way) or by the use of frontage roads.
Access management involves providing (or managing) access to land development while
simultaneously preserving the flow of traffic on the surrounding road system in terms of safety,
capacity, and speed. Access management applies to all types of roads and streets. It calls for
setting access policies for various types of roadway, keying designs to these policies, having the
access policies incorporated into legislation, and having the legislation upheld in the courts.
Access management views the highway and its surrounding activities as part of a single system.
Individual parts of the system include the activity center and its circulation systems, access to
and from the center, the availability of public transportation, and the roads serving the center. All
parts are important and interact with each other. The goal is to coordinate the planning and
design of each activity center to preserve the capacity of the overall system and to allow efficient
access to and from the activities.
Access management extends traffic engineering principles to the location, design, and operation
of access roads that serve activities along streets and highways. It also includes evaluating the
suitability of a site for different types of development from an access standpoint and is, in a
sense, a new element of roadway design.
Driveway/entrance regulations may be applied even though no control of access is obtained.
Each abutting property is permitted access to the street or highway; however, the location,
number, and geometric design of the access points are governed by the regulations.
 Basic Principles of Access Management
The following principles define access management techniques:
· Classify the road system by the primary function of each roadway. Freeways emphasize
movement and provide complete control of access. Local streets emphasize property access
rather than traffic movement. Arterial and collector roads must serve a combination of both
property access and traffic movement.
· Limit direct access to roads with higher functional classifications. Direct property access
should be denied or limited along higher class roadways, whenever reasonable access can be
provided to a lower class roadway.
· Locate traffic signals to emphasize through traffic movements. Signalized access points should
fit into the overall signal coordination plan for traffic progression.
· Locate driveways and major entrances to minimize interference with traffic operations.
Driveways and entrances should be located away from other intersections to minimize crashes, to

Lecture Note: - CENG 3804: HIGHWAY I


15
DEPARTMENT OF CIVIL ENGINEERING

reduce traffic interference, and to provide for adequate storage lengths for vehicles turning into
entrances.
· Use curbed medians and locate median openings to manage access movements and minimize
conflicts.
 Methods of Controlling Access
Public agencies can manage and control access by means of statutes, land-use ordinances,
geometric design policies, and driveway regulations.
· Control by the transportation agency: Every State and local transportation agency has the basic
statutory authority to control all aspects of highway design to protect public safety, health, and
welfare. The extent to which an agency can apply specific policies for driveways/entrances,
traffic signal locations, land use controls, and denial of direct access is specifically addressed by
legislation and, to some degree, by the State courts.
· Land-use ordinances: Land-use control is normally administered by local governments. Local
zoning ordinances and subdivision requirements can specify site design, setback distances, and
type of access, parking restrictions, and other elements that influence the type, volume, and
location of generated traffic.
· Geometric design: Geometric design features, such as the use of raised-curb medians, the
spacing of median openings, use of frontage roads, closure of median openings, and raised-curb
channelization at intersections, all assist in controlling access.
· Driveway regulations: Agencies may develop detailed access and driveway/entrance policies
by guidelines, regulations, or ordinances, provided specific statutory authority exists. Guidelines
usually need no specific authority, but are weak legally. Cities can pass ordinances implementing
access management policies. Likewise, state agencies may develop regulations when authorized
by legislation. Regulations can deny direct access to a road if reasonable, alternative access is
provided, but they cannot ―take away‖ access rights.
 Environmental factors
It is essential that a road infrastructure considered as an element of the total environment.
Designers should consider various factors besides providing safe and efficient transport systems.
Some of these include

 Land use landscape integration; design objectives should include to choose the route least
damaging to the landscape.
 Aesthetic of design: the location of the road, its alignment and profile, the cross section
design, and other feature should aesthetically be in harmony with setting.
 Noise abatement. a design objectives is to keep the noise at or below acceptable levels.
 Air pollution by vehicles.
 Safety
Crashes seldom result from a single cause—usually several influences affect the situation at any
given time. These influences can be separated into three groups: the human element, the vehicle
element, and the highway element. Highways should be designed to minimize driver decisions
and to reduce unexpected situations. The number of crashes increases with an increase in the
number of decisions required of the driver.
Some of the design features which have been found significant contributor to safety.
 Access control: research demonstrated relationship b/n accident and number of access
points.
Lecture Note: - CENG 3804: HIGHWAY I
16
DEPARTMENT OF CIVIL ENGINEERING

 Speed: It is often a contributing factor in crashes, but its role must be related to actual
conditions at a crash site to be understood. It is improper to conclude that any given
speed is safer than another for all combinations of the many kinds of drivers, vehicles,
highways, and local conditions. For a highway with particularly adverse roadway
conditions, a relatively low speed may result in fewer crashes than a high speed, but this
does not necessarily mean that all potential crashes can be eliminated by low speeds.
 Presence, type, and width of median affect the safety of pedestrian and head on
collusions.
 A study relating crashes to shoulder width, alignment, and grade found that rates on
sections with curves or grades were much higher than on levels tangents rod sections.
 Terrain
Terrain has the greatest effect on road costs therefore it is not economical to apply the same
standards in all terrains. Fortunately drivers of vehicles are familiar with this and lower
standards are expected in hilly and mountainous terrain. Four categories have been defined
which apply to all roads.
Terrain class needs to be established before a road is designed hence it needs to be defined
independently of the alignment that is finally selected for the road. It is determined by
counting the number of 5-metre contours crossed by a straight line connecting the two ends
of the road section in question according to the following definitions:
Flat: 0-10 five-metre contours per km. The natural ground slopes perpendicular to the ground
contours are generally below 3%;
Rolling: 11-25 five-metre contours per km. The natural ground slopes perpendicular to the
ground contours are generally between 3 and 25%.
Mountainous: 26-50 five-metre contours per km. The natural ground slopes perpendicular to
the ground contours are generally above 25%.
Escarpment: Escarpments are geological features that require special geometric standards
because of the engineering problems involved. Typical gradients are greater than those
encountered in mountainous terrain.
It is important to note that a road in mountainous terrain can be designed to follow a
reasonably direct route involving considerable earthworks or it can follow contour lines more
closely. This will require less earthworks but the road will be considerably longer.
Whichever option is chosen, the classification of the terrain remains the same irrespective of
road gradients, cross slopes or any other feature of the road itself.
i. Hilly Terrain
An important aspect of geometric design concerns the ability of vehicles to ascend steep
hills. Roads that need to be designed for very heavy vehicles or for animal drawn carts
require specific standards to address this, for example, special climbing lanes. On the other
hand, animal drawn vehicles are unable to ascend relatively low gradients and catering for
them in hilly and mountainous terrain is rarely possible. Climbing lanes cannot be justified
on LVRs and nor can the provision of very low maximum gradients.
ii. Mountainous and Escarpment Terrain
In mountain areas the geometric standard takes account of the constraints imposed by the
difficulty and stability of the terrain. This design standard may need to be reduced locally in
order to cope with exceptionally difficult terrain conditions. Every effort should be made to
design the road so that the maximum gradient does not exceed the standards but where higher
gradients cannot be avoided, they should be restricted in length.

Lecture Note: - CENG 3804: HIGHWAY I


17
DEPARTMENT OF CIVIL ENGINEERING

Gradients greater than 12% should not be longer than 250m and relief gradients are also
required. Horizontal curve radii of as little as 13m may be unavoidable, even though a
minimum of 15m is specified.
 Roadside Population and Adjoining Land Use
The more populated areas in village centers are not normally defined as ‗urban‘ but in any
area having a reasonable sized population or where markets and other business activities take
place, the geometric design of the road needs to be modified to ensure good access and to
enhance safety. This is done by using:
• A wider cross section;
• Specifically designed lay-byes for passenger vehicles to pick up or deposit passengers;
• Roadside parking areas.
The additional width depends on the status of the populated area that the road is passing
through. If the road is passing through a Wereda seat or a larger populated area, an extra
carriageway of 3.5m width is provided in each direction for parking and for passenger pick-
up and a 2.5m pedestrian footpath is also specified. The latter is essentially the shoulder. In
addition, the main running surface is paved and is at least 7.0m wide. Thus the road in such
areas is similar to Class DC4 but with an additional wide parking/activities carriageway and a
footpath on each side.
When passing through a Kebele seat, a 2.5m paved shoulder is specified but no additional
footpath; although one could easily be provided if required. The carriageway is also
increased to 7.0m and therefore the standard is very similar to DC4 but with wider shoulders.
These standards are not justified for the lower traffic levels of DC2, which is a single
carriageway, unless the road is passing through a particularly well populated area that is not
classified as a Kebele or Wereda seat but where additional traffic may be expected. In such
circumstances the shoulders should be widened to 2.5 metres for the extent of the populated
area.

 Economic Analysis
Economic analysis of a proposed new roads or improvements of the existing ones is the most
important control of geometric design together with the available funding.

3.2 Highway Cross Section Elements


Elements of Road Cross-section
• Principal elements
• Traffic lanes
• Auxiliary lanes – climbing lanes, acceleration and deceleration lanes, etc
• Shoulders
• Median (for divided roads)
• Marginal elements include
• Median and roadside barrier
• Curbs
• Gutters
• Guard rails
• sidewalks,
• Side slopes,
Lecture Note: - CENG 3804: HIGHWAY I
18
DEPARTMENT OF CIVIL ENGINEERING

• Cross slopes

Figure 3.4

Roadway: The portion of a highway, including shoulders, for vehicular use. A divided
highway has two or more roadways.
Carriageway; The portion of the roadway for the movement of vehicles, exclusive of
Shoulders.
Width of travel lanes
• Usually vary from 3 to 3.65 m, but occasionally 2.7 m lane width is used
in urban areas where the traffic volume is low and there is extreme right-
of-way constraints
• On two way two lane rural roads, accident rate for large trucks increases
as the traveled way decreases from 6.5 m
• The capacity decrease significantly as the lane width decrease from 3.0 m
Shoulders
• Serves for an emergency and stop of vehicles
• Used to laterally support the pavement structure
Shoulder width
• Recommended shoulder width is in the range of 1.8 to 2.4 m
• for highways serving large number of trucks and on highways with high
traffic volumes and high speeds, shoulder width of 3.0 to 3.5 m is
preferable

Lecture Note: - CENG 3804: HIGHWAY I


19
DEPARTMENT OF CIVIL ENGINEERING

• Minimum shoulder width 0.6 m on the lowest type of roads


• Shoulders should be flush with the edge of the traveled lane and be sloped to
facilitate drainage (2-4 % if paved, 4-6 % if not paved)
Median – section of divided road that separates lanes in the opposite directions.
Functions:
• Provide recovery area during emergency
• Provide stopping area for left and U-turning vehicles
• Provide refuge for pedestrians
• Reduce headlight glare
• Median can be either raised, flush or depressed
• Median width vary between 0.6 up to 24 m or more depending on the availability
of right-of-way
Median barrier – a longitudinal structure used to prevent an errant vehicle from crossing
the portion of a divided highway separating the traveled way for traffic in the opposite
directions
Roadside barrier – protect vehicles from causing hazards onto roadside and shield
pedestrians
Curbs – raised structures used mainly on urban roads to delineate pavement edge and
pedestrian walkways. Curbs are also used:
• To control drainage Improve aesthetic
• Reduce right-of-way
• Are classified as
• Barrier curbs – relatively high designed for preventing vehicles from
leaving the toad
• Mountable curbs – are designed so that vehicles can cross them

Gutters – drainage ditches located on the pavement side of a curb to provide the principal
drainage facility for the highway
Guard rails – longitudinal barriers on the outside of sharp curves at sections with high
fills (greater than 2.5 m)
Sidewalks – provided on urban or rural roads
• When pedestrian traffic is high along main or high speed roads
• When shoulders are not provided on arterials even when pedestrian traffic
is low
• In urban areas, sidewalks are provided along both sides of streets to serve
pedestrians access to schools, parks, shopping centers, and transit stops.
Cross-slopes – to enhance the flow of surface water
• High type pavement – 1.5 –2 %
• Intermediate type of pavement – 1.5- 3%
Side slopes – provided for stability of earthworks; the slope varies depending on the
material type
Lecture Note: - CENG 3804: HIGHWAY I
20
DEPARTMENT OF CIVIL ENGINEERING

Right-of-way – the total land area required for the construction of the roadway
• To accommodate all the elements of the road cross-section
• Planned widening of the road
• Public utility facilities that will be installed along the highway

3.3 Elements of Geometric Design


3.3.1 Sight distance
The safe and efficient operation of vehicles on the road depends very much on the visibility of
the road ahead of the driver. Thus the geometric design of the road should be done such that any
obstruction on the road length could be visible to the driver from some distance a head. This
distance is said to be the sight distance.
 Types of sight distance
Sight distance available from a point is the actual distance along the road surface, over which a
driver from a specified height above the carriage way has visibility of stationary or moving
objects.
Three sight distance situations that are considered for design:
 Stopping sight distance: the sight distances needed for stopping, which are applicable on
all highways.
 Passing sight distance: the sight distances needed for the passing of overtaken vehicles,
applicable only on two-lane highways;
 Intersection sight distance; the distance require to clearly seeing an intersection and its
means of traffic controls, and evaluate whether it is safe to cross or enter the opposing
streams of traffic.
Stopping sight distance
Stopping sight distance (SSD) is the minimum sight distance available on a highway at any spot
having sufficient length to enable the driver to stop a vehicle traveling at design speed, safely
without collision with any other obstruction.
Stopping sight distance is the sum of two distances:
(1) Brake reaction distance: The distance traversed by the vehicle from the instant the driver
sights an object necessitating a stop to the instant the brakes are applied;
Dr = 0.278 V *t

(2) Brake distance. The distance needed to stop the vehicle from the instant brake application
begins. These are referred to as brake reaction distance and braking distance, respectively.

V2
Db 
254 f  G 
SSD = Stopping Sight Distance (meter)
= Dist. traveled during perception/reaction time + Braking Dist.
t = Driver reaction time, generally taken to be 2.5 seconds.
V = Initial speed (km/h)
f = Coefficient of friction between tires and roadway
V2
SSD  (0.278)(t )(V ) 
254 f  G 
Coefficient of friction between tires and roadway
Lecture Note: - CENG 3804: HIGHWAY I
21
DEPARTMENT OF CIVIL ENGINEERING

Pavement condition Maximum Slide


Good, dry 1.00 0.8
Good, wet 0.9 0.6
Poor, dry 0.8 0.55
Poor, wet 0.60 0.3
Packed snow and Ice 0.25 0.1
Effect of grade on sight distance
Gradient of the road also affects the sight distance. While climbing up a gradient, the vehicle can
stop immediately. Therefore sight distance required is less. While descending a gradient, gravity
also comes into action and more time will be required to stop the vehicle. Sight distance required
will be more in this case.

Passing sight distance


 Minimum distance required to safely complete passing maneuver on 2-lane two-way
highway.
 Allows time for driver to avoid collision with approaching vehicle and not cut off passed
vehicle when upon return to lane.
 Assumes:
1. The overtaken vehicle travels at uniform speed.
2. The passing vehicle has reduced speed and trails the overtaken vehicle as it enters a
passing section.
3. When the passing section is reached, the passing driver needs a short period of time to
perceive the clear passing section and to react to start his or her maneuver.
4. Passing is accomplished under what may be termed a delayed start and a hurried return in the
face of opposing traffic. The passing vehicle accelerates during the maneuver, and its average
speed during the occupancy of the left lane is 15 km/h [10 mph] higher than that of the overtaken
vehicle.
5. When the passing vehicle returns to its lane, there is a suitable clearance length between it and
an oncoming vehicle in the other lane.

Lecture Note: - CENG 3804: HIGHWAY I


22
DEPARTMENT OF CIVIL ENGINEERING

PSD = d1 + d2 + d3 + d4
d1 = distance traveled during perception/reaction time and distance traveled while accelerating to
passing speed and when vehicle just enters the left lane.
at1
d1  0.278t1 (V  m  )
2
Where:
t = perception/reaction time and the time for acceleration, for example, 70-85km/h,
t=4 sec, for 100-110 km/h, t=4.5sec,
v = average speed of passing vehicle, km/h;
m = difference in speed of passed vehicle and passing vehicle, km/h
a = acceleration (km/hr/sec), for 70-110 km/h, a =2.4.
d2=0.278*v*t2.
d2 = distance traveled during overtaking time
d3 = clearance distance between the passing vehicle and the opposing vehicle at the moment the
passing vehicle returns to the right lane. Usually d3 varies b/n 30 and 90m.
d4 = distance traveled by opposing vehicle during 2/3 of the time the passing vehicle is in the left
lane. (d4 usually taken as 2/3 d2 ).
Table 7-4: Clearance Distance (d3) vs. Ambient Speeds

The value of each parameter is given in table below (source AASTO).

Lecture Note: - CENG 3804: HIGHWAY I


23
DEPARTMENT OF CIVIL ENGINEERING

Lecture Note: - CENG 3804: HIGHWAY I


24

You might also like