Professional Documents
Culture Documents
The Carriage of Goods and The Liability of Air and Sea Carriers
The Carriage of Goods and The Liability of Air and Sea Carriers
PREETHI.P
17MIB038
1
BAILMENTS & COMMON
CARRIER
• Bailment: l
owner of property transfers possession to
bailee, but retains ownership
• Shipper is bailor
• Carrier is bailee
• Common Carrier: carrier contracting with public
for transport services
• Contract of Carriage: contract btwn shipper and
carrier –in transport documents
BAILMENT LAW
• Bailee (Carrier) must return property to
bailor in same condition as it was
received
• Carriers liable for damage or loss to
cargo, except caused by:
• Acts of God
• Acts of public enemy or terrorist
• Acts of govt. intervention or court order
• Acts of shipper
• Inherent characteristics of cargo that cause its
destruction
• Carrier may use disclaimers, but legal
limitations on use
LIABILITY OF INTERNATIONAL
AIR CARRIERS: WARSAW
• General PINCILPLE :AIR CARRIER
presumptively liable for all damage to
cargo UNLESSthe airline shows:
• Not at fault or negligent
• Shipper was negligent
• Air Carrier liable for death or bodily injury
resulting from accident aboard aircraft or
in boarding or disembarking
• Accident: event that is peculiar risk of air
travel and “external” to passenger
• Warsaw Convention is exclusive remedy
2
WARSAW CONVENTION
PROVISIONS (AS AMENDED)
3
WARSAW CONVENTION PROVISIONS
(AS AMENDED)
4
COGSA PRINCIPLES
6
COGSA PRINCIPLES
• Delivery of damaged cargo: shipper must give written notice
to carrier at port of discharge
• For visible damage: give notice before or at time goods
taken from carrier’s custody
• Ifdamage not apparent or visible, give written notice within
3 days ofdelivery
• Failure to give notice creates presumption goods delivered
in good condition
• Suit must be brought within 1 year
• Pmust show goods loaded in good condition and lostor
unloaded in damaged condition
• Clean B/Lestablishes presumption goods delivered to
carrier in good condition –shifts burden to carrier
• Problem with sealed containers: clean B/Lonly establishes
outer condition of container
7
COGSA EXCEPTIONS TO
LIABILITY
• Errors in ship navigation • Acts of shipper
or management • Labor strikes
• Fire (unless carrier’s
• Riots
fault)
• Saving life or property
• Perils of the sea
at sea
• Act of God • Insufficient packing
• Act of war
• Inherent defect in
• Acts of public enemies goods
• Legal seizure • Inadequate marking of
• Quarantine goods
• Latent (hidden) defects
in ship
8
COGSA: DEFENSES TO
LIABILITY
• “Warranty of Seaworthiness”: ship reasonably fit to
carry cargo undertaken on intended journey
• Competence of crew, suitability of equipment, etc.
• Carrier responsibility for proper loading, storing and
carrying, and unloading goods
• May presume unseaworthy if breaks down shortly after
departure
• Errorsin Navigation or Management of ship:
carrier not liable for errors of master, mariner, pilot
or crew member
• Depends on severity of storm and how cargo damaged
• Negligence of crew may void defense
10
THE CARGO SHORTAGE
PROBLEM
• Carrier may be responsible unless can use Q
clause defense
• Pmust establish that shortage occurred
while goods in carrier’s custody:
• Pcan show weight or quantity at destination less
than that listed on B/L
• Disclaimer –“shipper’s weight”- on B/Lnot
recognized by court
• Westway Coffee Corp. v. M.V. Netuno (SDNY’81)
• ButPlastique Tags, Inc. v. Asia Trans Line, Inc. (11thCir.
1996)
12
COGSA “PACKAGE” LIMITATION
• Limits carrier liability to $500per package
or customary freight unit unless shipper
declares (and pays for) highervalue
• Container not package under COGSA if
contents and number of units disclosed on B/L
• Z.K. Marine v. M/V Archigetis (SDFl 1991):
i
s yacht a “package”?
• COGSA limitations generally don’t apply
to goods carried above deck –but
parties can provide for coverage in B/L
(clause paramount)
13
LIABILITY OF TRANSPORT
INTERMEDIARIES