Professional Documents
Culture Documents
BOOK REVIEW
OR ARTICLE
CRITIQUE
What is a Book Review ?
• DESCRIPTIVE REVIEW
Presents the content and
structure of a book as possible,
describing essential information
about a book’s purpose and
authority.
• CRITICAL REVIEW
Describes and evaluates the
book in relation to accepted
literary and historical standards
and supports the evaluation
with evidence from the text
and, in most cases, in contrast
to and comparison with the
research of others.
FACTORS TO CONSIDER BEFORE WRITING A
BOOK REVIEW OR ARTICLE CRITIQUE
17
IDENTIFY
• Author’s content and
purpose
• Structure
• Audience
18
EVALUATE
• Accuracy
• Up-to-datedness of the
information
• The sources used to justify
the author’s purpose
19
RESPOND
• What issues does it raise?
• What issues are omitted?
• The effect of the book
• Your recommendation
WRITING A BOOK REVIEW/ARTICLE
CRITIQUE
BEFORE READING
Consider the questions listed below
LITERATURE
REVIEW
What is Literature and Review ?
In-text citation
• Role-play can help children learn techniques for coping
with bullying (Kraiser, 2011).
In-text citation
• The term Nittany Lion was coined by Penn State football
player Joe Mason in 1904 ("All things Nittany," 2006).
Web page with no date
In-text citation
• Establishing regular routines, such as exercise, can
help survivors of disasters recover from trauma
(American Psychological Association [APA], n.d.).
General Guidelines
• In-text references should immediately follow the title,
word, or phrase to which they are directly relevant,
rather than appearing at the end of long clauses or
sentences. In-text references should always precede
punctuation marks. Below are examples of using in-
text citation.
Author's name in parentheses
Group as author:
First citation: (American Psychological Association [APA],
2015)
Subsequent citation: (APA, 2015)
Multiple works
(separate each work with semi-colons)
Direct quote
(include page number and place quotation marks
around the direct quote)
”
Gass and Varonis (1984) found that “the listener’s
familiarity with the topic of discourse greatly facilitates
the interpretation of the entire message”
RESEARCH
PAPER
What is a Research Paper ?
It should include;
• The type of research you did
• How you collected and/or selected your data
• How you analyzed your data
• Any tools or materials you used in the research
• Your rationale for choosing these methods
Writing a Methodology
Presentation of Data
This is the last chapter of the research, which includes an overview of the
research. It consists of the restatement of the problem, the procedures
and the findings.
Conclusion
Is intended to help the reader understand why your
research should matter to them after they have finished reading
the paper. A conclusion is not merely a summary of your points or
a re-statement of your research problem but a synthesis of key
points.
Recommendation
Are based on the results of your research and indicate the specific
measures or directions that can be taken.
Writing a Conclusion and Recommendation
Examples;
APA STYLE
Nunn, G. D., & Jantz, P. B. (2009). Factors within response to
intervention implementation training associated with teacher efficacy
beliefs. Education, 129(4), 599-607. Available at
http://www.projectinnovation.biz/education_2006.html
MLA Style
Dean, Cornelia. "Executive on a Mission: Saving the Planet." New York
Times. New York Times, 22 May 2007. Web. 25 May 2009.
HOW TO WRITE A
RESEARCH PAPER
1. Choose a Topic
If your topic is too broad, your research
paper is unlikely to be successful because
it will look like a general overview. You
should narrow your topic down to a
certain aspect, concept or idea and make
it specific and manageable.
2. Write a Working Thesis Statement
Prepare a working thesis before you actually organize
your research because it will guide your investigation
and will help you stay focused on your subject. Your
thesis statement should be concise and reflect the type
of paper you are writing. All research papers can be
divided into 3 categories:
• incomplete sentences;
• dangling modifiers;
• easily confused words (such as to, too,
and two);
• spelling mistakes;
• apostrophes for possessives and
plurals;
• quotation rules obeyed;
• comma use;
• eliminate contractions.
evaluate your argument, transitions, and
the balance and look for any
inconsistencies with usage, grammar or
mechanics.
7 MOST POPULAR TYPES OF
RESEARCH PAPERS
• Argumentative papers
• Analytical papers
• Definition papers
• Compare and contrast papers
• Cause and effect papers
• Reports
• Interpretive papers
ARGUMENTATIVE PAPER
Present two sides of a controversial
issue in the one paper. A good
argumentative paper will include in-
text citations from researchers that
present logical facts from both sides of
an issue, and will conclude with the
author analyzing the pros and cons of
each argument.
ANALYCTICAL PAPERS
Include information from a range of sources
but the focus on this type of research paper is
in analyzing the different
viewpoints represented from a factual rather
than opinionated standpoint. The author of
an analytical paper may focus on the
findings, methodology or conclusions of
other researchers and will conclude such a
paper with a summation of the findings and a
suggested framework for further study on the
issue.
DEFINITION PAPERS
Relatively self-explanatory. They describe a
topic from a factual standpoint that is
usually devoid of emotion or the opinion of
the author.
PROJECT
PROPOSAL
What is a Project Proposal?
2. Clarifies Expectations
4. Increases Budget
Successful proposals lead to approved
budgets and financial support for
organizational growth and project
replication.
5. Fuels Business Growth
Proposals play an integral part in
organizational growth, helping in budget
approval and new client adoption.
2. INFORMALLY SOLICITED
Informally solicited project proposals are
the same as formally solicited ones,
except the information they are based on
isn’t set out in a specific document.
3. UNSOLOCITED
Unsolicited project proposals are the
project equivalent of cold calls– nobody
asked to receive one, but (if you’ve done
your homework) it can still provide a ton
of value.
4. CONTINUATION
Are by far and away the easiest to write,
since these are essentially
reminders/updates for ongoing (and
already approved) projects.
5. RENEWAL
This can be written to make the case for
its continued support
6. SUPPLEMENTAL
c) Project Deliverables
a) Project Budget
• Plan ahead.
• Make it a team effort.
• Be realistic in what you are proposing. Be a learning
organization.
• Be factual and specific.
• Limit technical and organzational jargon Call the donor
if you have questions.
• Clarify partner’s roles and responsibilities.
• Be aware of donor priorities Use action words when
writing your proposal
5
POSITION
PAPER
What is a Position Paper ?
A position paper presents an arguable opinion about an
issue. The goal of a position paper is to convince the
audience that your opinion is valid and worth listening
to. Ideas that you are considering need to be carefully
examined in choosing a topic, developing your
argument, and organizing your paper. It is very
important to ensure that you are addressing all sides of
the issue and presenting it in a manner that is easy for
your audience to understand. Your job is to take one side
of the argument and persuade your audience that you
have well-founded knowledge of the topic being
presented. It is important to support your argument with
evidence to ensure the validity of your claims, as well as
to address the counterclaims to show that you are well
informed about both sides.
PURPOSE OF
POSITION PAPER
The purpose of a position paper is to
generate support on an issue. It describes
the author’s position on an issue and the
rational for that position and, in the same
way that a research paper incorporates
supportive evidence, is based on facts that
provide a solid foundation for the author’s
argument. It is a critical examination of a
position using facts and inductive
reasoning, which addresses both strengths
and weaknesses of the author’s opinion.
An author who writes a position paper is
making an argument which has to be built
upon evidence. The structure used to do this is
very similar to that used when writing a critical
essay.
THE CLASSIC POSITION PAPER
CONTAINS THREE MAIN ELEMENTS
An Introduction, which identifies the issue that will be
discussed and states the author’s position on that
issue.