Knowledge Management in Theory

and Practice

Lecture 2: Knowledge Management

Processes
 Lecture Overview

 Major KM Processes
 Knowledge-Information Processes (ACIIC Knowledge
Economy)
 Meyer and Zack KM Processes
 Bukowitz and Williams Processes
 McElroy KM Processes
 Wiig KM Processes
 Carlile and Rebentisch KM Processes
 Evans et al KM Processes

2
 KM Processes

 Knowledge Capture
 Knowledge Creation
 Knowledge Codification
 Knowledge Sharing
 Knowledge Access
 Knowledge Application
 Knowledge Re-Use
“Where do I put this in the company’s knowledge book???”
3
 Knowledge-Information KM
Processes*
 The ability to manage knowledge is
becoming ever more crucial in the
knowledge economy
 Where creation and diffusion of knowledge are
increasingly important factors in competitiveness
 Knowledge is a commodity now
 Embedded in products, especially hi-tech products
 Embedded in the tacit knowledge of highly mobile
employees
* Australian Centre for Innovation and International Competitiveness www.aciic.org.au
4
 Knowledge Economy & the
Knowledge- Information Processes

 Some paradoxes of knowledge:

 Using knowledge does not consume it
 Transferring knowledge does not lose it
 Knowledge is abundant, but the ability to use it
is scarce
 Producing knowledge resists organization
 Much of knowledge walks out the door at the
end of the day

5
 Knowledge -Information
Processes/2
 Need to systematically identify, generate, acquire,
diffuse, and capture the benefits of knowledge that
provide a strategic advantage
 Clear distinction must be made between
information – which is digitizable, and knowledge –
which exists only in intelligent systems
 Knowledge-information processes look at how
information is transformed into knowledge and vice
versa via creation and application processes

6
Knowledge-Information
Procresses/3

7
 Knowledge-Information
Processes
 Establish appropriate information management systems and
processes
 Identify and locate knowledge and knowledge sources
within the organization
 Code knowledge (translate knowledge into explicit
information) to allow re-use economies to operate
 Create networks, practices, and incentives to facilitate
person-to-person knowledge transfer where the focus is on
the unique solution
 Add personal knowledge management to the organizational
repertoire (“corporate memory”)

8
M. Zack KM Processes

9
Zack KM Processes/2

10
 Zack KM Processes/3

 The Meyers Zack model is an information-

processing model
 Adapted to knowledge content
 Refinement step is a crucial one
 Also – the notion of renewal
 Based on notion of an information asset

11
 KM Processes

 Knowledge Capture
 Knowledge Creation
 Knowledge Codification and refinement
 Knowledge Sharing
 Knowledge Access
 Knowledge Application
 Knowledge Re-Use

12
 McElroy KM Processes

Individual &
Group
Learning
Formulate Codified Knowledge
Knowledge Knowledge Knowledge Claim
Claim Claim Claim Evaluation
Formulation

Information
Acquisition
13
 McElroy KM Processes/2

Information about:
•Surviving knowledge claim
•Falsified knowledge claim
•Undecided knowledge claim

Knowledge Organizational
Production Knowledge

14
 McElroy KM Processes/3

 Organizational knowledge is held collectively in

both individuals and groups
 Knowledge use either meets or fails to meet
business expectations
 Matches lead to reuse
 Mis-matches lead to adjustments in business
processing behaviour (learning)
 Clear step where knowledge is evaluated and a
conscious decision is made as to whether or not it
should be incorporated into organizational memory

15
 KM Cycle Processes

 Knowledge Capture
 Knowledge Creation
 Knowledge Codification & Refinement
 Knowledge Sharing
 Knowledge Access
 Knowledge Application
 Knowledge Evaluation & Re-Use

16
 Bukowitz and Williams

ASSESS
GET

BUILD/SUSTAIN
USE Knowledge

LEARN CONTRIBUTE OR: DIVEST

17
 Bukowitz and Williams /2

 Get: seeking out information

 Tacit and explicit
 Being selective when faced with information
overload
 Use: combine content in new and interesting
ways to foster innovation in the organization
 Learn: learning from experiences
 Creation of an organizational memory

18
 Bukowitz and Williams/3

 Contribute: motivate employees to post

what they have learned to a knowledge base
 Link individual learning and knowledge to
organizational memory
 Assess: evaluation of intellectual capital
 Identify assets, metrics to assess them and link
these directly to business objectives

19
 Bukowitz and Williams/4

 Build and Sustain: allocate resources to

maintain knowledge base
 Contribute to viability, competitiveness
 Divest: should not keep assets that are no
longer of any business value
 Transfer outside the organization e.g.
outsourcing
 Patent, spin off companies etc.

20
 KM Processes

 Knowledge Capture
 Knowledge Creation & Contribution
 Selectively filter contributions
 Knowledge Codification & Refinement
 Knowledge Sharing
 Knowledge Access
 Knowledge Learning &Application
 Knowledge Evaluation & Re-Use OR Divest

21
 Wiig KM Processes

 Processes by which we build and use knowledge

 As individuals
 As teams (communities)
 As organizations
 How we:
 Build knowledge
 Hold knowledge
 Pool knowledge
 Apply knowledge
 Discrete tasks yet often interdependent & parallel
22
 Wiig KM Processes/2
•Personal experience
•Formal education and training
Build Knowledge •Intelligence sources
•Media, books, peers

Hold Knowledge •In people

•In tangible forms (e.g. books)

•KM systems (intranet, dbase)

Pool Knowledge
•Groups of people- brainstorm

•In work context

Use Knowledge •Embedded in work processes

23
 Wiig KM Processes/3
•Personal experience
•Formal education and training
Build Knowledge •Intelligence sources
•Media, books, peers

Hold Knowledge •In people

•In tangible forms (e.g. books)

•KM systems (intranet, dbase)

Pool Knowledge
•Groups of people- brainstorm

•In work context

Use Knowledge •Embedded in work processes

24
 Building Knowledge

 Learning from all kinds of sources to:

 Obtain Knowledge
 Analyze Knowledge
 Reconstruct (Synthesize) Knowledge
 Codify and Model Knowledge
 Organize Knowledge

25
 Obtaining Knowledge

 Create new knowledge

 Research and development projects
 Innovations, experimentation, trial and error
 Reasoning with existing knowledge
 Hire new people
 Import knowledge from existing sources
 Elicit knowledge from experts
 Acquire from manuals, books, other documents
 Transfer people between departments
 Observe the real world
26
 Analyzing Knowledge

 Extract what appears to be knowledge from

obtained materials
 Analyze transcripts, reports about new concepts
 Listen to explanation and select key concepts
 Abstract extracted material
 Identify patterns to describe, estimate
 Create explicit relations between knowledge
elements (e.g. causal, correlation, contribution nets)
 Verify that extracted content is correct through
observation
27
 Reconstruct (Synthesize)
Knowledge
 Generalize analyzed materials to obtain broader
principles
 Generate hypotheses to explain observed behaviour
in terms of causal factors
 Establish conformance between new and existing
knowledge (validity, coherence)
 Update total knowledge pool by incorporating new
knowledge
 Discard old, false, outdated, no longer relevant
knowledge
28
 Codify and Model Knowledge

 Represent knowledge in our minds by building

mental models
 Model knowledge by assembling declarations and
relational statements into a coherent whole
 Document knowledge in books and manuals
 Encode knowledge into knowledge bases
(computerized KBS tools)

29
 Organize Knowledge

 Organize new knowledge for specific uses

 E.g. sequence for diagnostics, help desk, FAQs
 Organize new knowledge according to an
established framework
 Categorize according to organizational standards
 Taxonomy, ontology, official list of key words,
attributes, linguistic/translation guidelines….

30
 Building Knowledge -
Examples
 Market research
 Focus groups
 Surveys
 Competitive intelligence
 Data mining on customer preferences
 Synthesis of lessons learned (what worked, what
didn’t) – generate hypotheses
 Validate using customer satisfaction questionnaire and
interviews
 Document as training manual for marketing to this
specific target market
31
 Wiig KM Cycle/4
•Personal experience
•Formal education and training
Build Knowledge •Intelligence sources
•Media, books, peers

Hold Knowledge •In people

•In tangible forms (e.g. books)

•KM systems (intranet, dbase)

Pool Knowledge
•Groups of people- brainstorm

•In work context

Use Knowledge •Embedded in work processes

32
 Holding Knowledge

 In people’s minds, books, computerized knowledge

bases, etc.
 Remember knowledge – internalize it
 Cumulate knowledge in repositories (encode it)
 Embed knowledge in repositories (within procedures)
 Archive knowledge
 Create scientific library, subscriptions
 Retire older knowledge from active status in repository (e.g. store
in another medium for potential future retrieval – cd roms, etc.)

33
 Holding Knowledge -
Examples
 Company owns a number of proprietary methods
and recipes for making products
 Some knowledge documented in the form of
research reports, technical papers, patents
 Other tacit knowledge can be elicited and
embedded in the knowledge base in the form of
know-how, tips, tricks of the trade
 Videotapes of specialized experts explaining various
procedures
 Task support systems
34
 Wiig KM Cycle/5
•Personal experience
•Formal education and training
Build Knowledge •Intelligence sources
•Media, books, peers

Hold Knowledge •In people

•In tangible forms (e.g. books)

•KM systems (intranet, dbase)

Pool Knowledge
•Groups of people- brainstorm

•In work context

Use Knowledge •Embedded in work processes

35
 Pooling Knowledge

 Can take many forms such as discussions, expert networks

and formal work teams
 Pooling knowledge consists of:
 Coordinating knowledge of collaborative teams

 Creating expert networks to identify who knows what

 Assembling knowledge – background references from

libraries and other knowledge sources
 Accessing and retrieving knowledge

 Consult with knowledgeable people about a difficult problem,

peer reviews, second opinions
 Obtain knowledge directly from a repository – advice,
explanations
36
 Pooling Knowledge -
Examples
 An employee realizes he or she does not have the
necessary knowledge and know-how to solve a
particular problem
 She contact others in the company who have had
similar problems to solve, consults the knowledge
repository and makes use of an expert advisory
system to help her out
 She organizes all this information and has subject
matter experts validate the content

37
 Wiig KM Cycle/6
•Personal experience
•Formal education and training
Build Knowledge •Intelligence sources
•Media, books, peers

Hold Knowledge •In people

•In tangible forms (e.g. books)

•KM systems (intranet, dbase)

Pool Knowledge
•Groups of people- brainstorm

•In work context

Use Knowledge •Embedded in work processes

38
 Using Knowledge

 Use established knowledge to perform routine tasks, make

standard products, provide standard services
 Use general knowledge to survey exceptional situations,
identify problem, consequences
 Use knowledge to describe situation and scope problem
 Select relevant special knowledge to handle situation,
identify knowledge sources
 Observe and characterize the situation, collect and organize
information
 Analyze situation, determine patterns, compare with others,
judge what needs to be done
39
 Using Knowledge (con’t)

 Synthesize alternative solutions, identify options, create new

solutions
 Evaluate potential alternatives, appraise advantages and
disadvantages of each, determine risks and benefits of each
 Use knowledge to decide what to do, which alternative to
select
 Rank alternatives & test that each is feasible, acceptable
 Implement selected alternative
 Choose and assemble tools needed
 Prepare implementation plan, distribute it, authorize team to proceed
with this solution

40
 Using Knowledge - Examples

 Expert mechanic encounters a new problem

 Gathers info to diagnose and analyze
 Synthesizes a list of possible solutions with the
tools he knows are available to him
 Decides on the best option and uses it to fix the part

 Non-routine tasks are approached in a different way

than familiar, standard ones

41
 KM Processes

 Knowledge Capture
 Knowledge Creation & Contribution
 Knowledge Codification & Refinement (inc. Sanitize) &
Reconstruction (e.g. synthesis)
 Selectively filter contributions
 Knowledge Modeling
 Knowledge Sharing & Pooling
 Knowledge Organization &Access
 Knowledge Learning &Application
 Knowledge Evaluation & Re-Use OR Divest

42
Carlile and Rebentisch KM
Processes

Retrieval

Storage

Transformation
 Carlile and Rebentisch KM
Processes /2
 Focus is on integrating knowledge into complex
technologies and products
 New knowledge is created through the integration of
existing knowledge from multiple sources
 Introduce the notion of retrieving knowledge (both tacit
from people and explicit
 Assumption is that there is never a blank slate in an
organization – some valuable knowledge already exists
somewhere
 As this existing knowledge is used, reused, it is transformed
(rarely used “as is”)
44
 KM Processes

 Knowledge Capture & Retrieval

 Knowledge Creation & Contribution
 Knowledge Codification & Refinement (inc. Sanitize) &
Reconstruction (e.g. synthesis)
 Selectively filter contributions
 Knowledge Modeling
 Knowledge Sharing & Pooling
 Knowledge Organization &Access
 Knowledge Learning &Application
 Knowledge Evaluation & Re-Use & Transformation OR
Divest

45
 Evans et al KM Processes

AND / OR

Request for
Knowledge

Double Loop
Learning
(Argyris and
Schon, 1996)

46
 Evans et al KM Processes /2

 A more holistic approach that integrates KM and

organizational learning
 Distinguishes between finding existing knowledge
(explicit) and creating new knowledge (tacit)
 Learning is part of all KM processes therefore there
should be some improvement
 Single loop learning: improve existing ways of doing
things (e.g. efficiency)
 Double loop learning: improve the ways of doing things
(e.g. effectiveness)
47
 KM Processes

 Knowledge Capture & Identification &Retrieval

 Knowledge Creation & Contribution
 Knowledge Codification & Refinement (inc. Sanitize) &
Reconstruction (e.g. synthesis)
 Selectively filter contributions Single
 Knowledge Modeling & double

 Knowledge Sharing & Pooling

 Knowledge Organization &Access
 Knowledge Learning &Application & Improvement
 Knowledge Evaluation & Re-Use & Transformation
OR Divest

48
 Dalkir Meta-KM Processes Summary
Organizational culture

Assess

1. Create or 2. Share and

capture disseminate

Update Contextualize
3. Use, apply
and re-use

Information & communication technologies

49
 Five Critical Knowledge Functions
for each KM Process Step

 Type of knowledge or skill involved

 Securities trading expertise
 Business use of that knowledge
 Increase the value of a retirement fund portfolio
 Constraint that prevents knowledge from being fully
utilized
 Expert will retire at the end of the year with no successor
 Opportunities, alternatives to manage that knowledge
 Elicit and codify knowledge before person retires
 Expected value-added of improving the situation
 Valuable knowledge is not lost to organization
50
 Group activity

 In small groups, discuss the following:

 What knowledge object would you want next
year’s class to have? To re-use?
 Go through the KM processes and see how you
would capture and make available to them
 What would you have liked to have known
before coming to our program? Anything
unexpected? Surprises? Things you had to
discover….?
Can continue discussion online…
51
 Next:

 Selected knowledge management models

52