Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Vulnerability, Green Political Theory and The Human Condition' in The Anthropocene
Vulnerability, Green Political Theory and The Human Condition' in The Anthropocene
Theory and
the ‘Human Condition’ in the
Anthropocene
The ‘Silence of the Limbs’ in Western
Political Theory
Lack of analysis to vulnerability within western political theory, especially liberalism and
orthodox economic thinking (exception, green and feminist thinking, Alastair MacIntyre)
Incomplete view of the human being and human condition (ideal of independence,
autonomy etc.) , since vulnerability is constitutive of what it means to be human
Vulnerability thus speaks to that which modernity seeks to sequester: our dependence on
one another, our frailty: our embodiedness and ecological embeddedness
And a flourishing human life is one which acknowledges our dependence, vulnerability
and related experiences of death, suffering and pain
Myths and Dangers of Invulnerability
Dominance of the ‘myth’ of the independent ‘man’ as the model of what it means
to be a free human being
In the ‘Western imaginary’ (cultural and normative) vulnerability signifies not just
something to be overcome, but also something which was dominant at an earlier
stage of human evolution and history. It is an unwelcome ‘reminder’, representing
an earlier stage of human evolution, and also a reminder of our animal character.
Neither vulnerability nor the harm that arises from it, nor
indeed the resilience in coping with or mitigating harm or
injury, are equally distributed
Also a more creative ethical and political position for navigating the
human condition in the anthropocene