The document discusses concepts related to revolt, resistance, and revolution. It defines these terms and notes that centers of power often portray such actions negatively while disregarding their own oppression. It also states that for a revolution to be complete, the oppressive system must be dramatically changed and all aspects of oppression removed. The document raises questions about who the subaltern classes are, whether they can speak, and their role in the 2011 Egyptian revolution.
The document discusses concepts related to revolt, resistance, and revolution. It defines these terms and notes that centers of power often portray such actions negatively while disregarding their own oppression. It also states that for a revolution to be complete, the oppressive system must be dramatically changed and all aspects of oppression removed. The document raises questions about who the subaltern classes are, whether they can speak, and their role in the 2011 Egyptian revolution.
The document discusses concepts related to revolt, resistance, and revolution. It defines these terms and notes that centers of power often portray such actions negatively while disregarding their own oppression. It also states that for a revolution to be complete, the oppressive system must be dramatically changed and all aspects of oppression removed. The document raises questions about who the subaltern classes are, whether they can speak, and their role in the 2011 Egyptian revolution.
Revolt, Resistance, and Revolution • Revolt, resistance, and revolution refers to systematic challenges, from below, to centers of power • Centers of power will often try to paint instances of revolt, resistance, and revolution as being conducted by enemies of the people / nation / state • Centers of power will disregard or defend their own oppressive activities to maintain power • Threat of terrorism • Legitimate criticisms of government as inciting violence • Oppression is necessary to maintain stability Assumes that those who need to be oppressed are uncivilized, immoral, backwards Revolt, Resistance, and Revolution • Violence is necessary in resistance • Revolt is not complete unless all trails of oppression are removed • Revolutions (the turnover of power) are not complete unless the system dramatically changes Revolt, Resistance, and Revolution • The destruction of the oppressive [colonial] world requires the removal of coopted native elites, the destruction of structures and institutions, the rise of the peasant / working classes • This then raises the question: Can the subaltern speak? Revolt, Resistance, and Revolution • Who are the subaltern classes? • The lower classes of society Class is understood in the widest terms • Extends beyond the class-position/consciousness The subaltern references the cultural and political movement into the hegemony
Why can’t the subaltern speak?
Revolt, Resistance, and Revolution • The role of the middle class in the 2011 Egyptian revolution • The bourgeoisie took hold of government • Privatization and neo-liberalization became rampant • Taxation skyrocketed for the middle classes • Inequality became greater
Where is the subaltern in this story?
• Where do the working classes come into play? • Where did women perform their rights?