Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Let Us Make Some Crystals
Let Us Make Some Crystals
In this section we will deal with some ‘model’ examples. These examples have sometimes
been chosen to give a ‘startling effect’ (so that the essential points are ‘driven home’).
1D
Making a 1D Crystal
Some of the concepts are best illustrated in lower dimensions hence we shall construct
some 1D and 2D crystals before jumping into 3D.
A strict 1D crystal = 1D lattice + 1D motif. There is only one kind of a 1D lattice.
The only kind of 1D entity, which can contribute to a motif is the line segment (or a
collection of line segments). Though in principle a collection of points can be included.
There are only two types of crystals in 1D (for now restricting ourselves to Euclidean space) (true 1D where the
lattice and motif both are 1D).
Crystal-1 with ‘m’ symmetry
Crystal-2 with only ‘t’. (as in upcoming slide)
Lattice
+
Motif
=
Crystal
A ‘natural way’
m1 m2 m0 m½
Note: the mirror plane of the lattice has been made to coincide with that of the motif
(this is a preferred way of ‘doing things’!!).
1 (with only t)
Note that in 1D the action of a mirror is equivalent to that of a inversion centre is equivalent to that of a
2-fold axis. Click here to know more
Note:
For illustration purposes we will often relax this strict requirement of a 1D motif.
We will put 2D motifs on 1D lattice to get many of the useful concepts across.
These are called ‘frieze patterns’ (note the spelling of frieze). Note the periodicity is still in 1D.
We could also use 3D entities as a motif to decorate the 1D lattice.
The periodicity in all these cases (where the lattice is 1D) remain in one dimension.
1D lattice +
2D Motif*
An example of a ‘frieze pattern’: artisans have used such patters in various architectures.
The lattice points are at the centres of the red patterns (i.e. alternate black dot).
We will see more such examples (from a symmetry point of view) in the coming slides (albeit not as creative as the ones made by artisans)
* the circles look like 3D due to the shading!
** needless to say these are not ‘atoms’
Time to brush-up some symmetry concepts before going ahead
If any of the coming 7 slides make you a little uncomfortable – you can skip them
(however, they might look difficult – but they are actually easy)
As we had pointed out we can understand some of the concepts of crystallography better by
‘putting’ 2D motifs on a 1D lattice. These kinds of patterns are called Frieze groups and
there are 7 types of them (based on symmetry).
Asymmetric
Unit cell Unit
a
Asymmetric Unit is that part of the structure (region of space), which in combination with
the symmetries (Space Group) of the lattice/crystal gives the complete structure (either the
lattice or the crystal)
(though typically the concept is used for crystals only) The concept of the
Asymmetric Unit will
become clear in the
coming slides
The unit cell is a line segment in 1D shown with a finite ‘y-direction’ extent for clarity and for understating
some of the crystals which are coming-up
This 1D lattice has some symmetries apart from translation. The complete set is:
Translation (t)
Horizontal Mirror (mh)
Vertical Mirror at Lattice Points (mv1)
Vertical Mirror between Lattice Points (mv2)
Note:
The symmetry operators (t, mv1, mv2) are enough to generate the lattice
But, there are some redundant symmetry operators which develop due to their operation
In this example they are 2-fold axis or Inversion Centres (and for that matter mh)
mh
mmm
mirror
Note of Redundant Symmetry Operators
t
mmm
It is true that some basic set of symmetry operators (set-1) can generate the structure (lattice or crystal)
It is also true that some more symmetry operators can be identified which were not envisaged in the basic set
(called ‘redundant’)
But then, we could have started with different set of operators (set-2) and call some of the operators used in set-1 as
redundant
the lattice has some symmetries which we call basic and which we call redundant is up to us!
We have already seen that Unit Cell is the least part of the structure which can be used to
construct the structure using translations (only).
Asymmetric Unit is that part of the structure (usually a region of space), which in
combination with the symmetries (Space Group) of the lattice/crystal gives the complete
structure (either the lattice or the crystal) (though typically the concept is used for crystals only)
Simpler phrasing: It is the least part of the structure (region of space) which can be used to build the
structure using the symmetry elements in the structure (Space Group)
Asymmetric Unit
+ mv2 + mh
Lattice point
Which is the
Unit Cell
Unit cell
If we had started with the asymmetric unit of a crystal
then we would have obtained a crystal instead of a lattice
Lattice t +
Decoration of the lattice with a motif may reduce the symmetry of the crystal
The crystals obtained by the decoration of a 1D lattice (i.e. with 1D periodicity) with a 2D
motif gives rise to patterns, which are historically known as frieze patterns.
t
1 mmm
Decoration with a “sufficiently” symmetric motif does not reduce the symmetry of the lattice
Instead of the double headed arrow we could have used a circle (most symmetrical object possible in 2D)
t
2 mm
Decoration with a motif which is a ‘single headed arrow’ will lead to the loss of 1 mirror plane
mirror
Lattice points
t
3 g mg
t
4 ii
2 inversion centres
t
6 g g
7 t
We shall make various crystals starting with a 2D lattice and putting motifs and we shall
analyze the crystal which has thus been created.
In many of the examples which follow we will use the square lattice as an illustrative
starting point. We will progressively decorate the lattice with motifs of lower and lower
symmetry.
The square lattice has 4mm symmetry.
The important point to be noted (which can be a cause for considerable confusion) is that
the adjective/term in front of a lattice or a crystal (e.g. a square lattice or a rectangle
crystal), denotes the symmetry of the structure and not any shape or geometry (i.e. not the
shape of the unit cell).
I.e. the term square refers to the presence of at least a 4-fold axis and the term rectangle
refers to the presence of m or 2mm symmetry.
Based on symmetry there are 10 types of crystals possible in 2D:
Square (4mm, 4); Rectangle (2mm, m); Hexagonal (6mm, 6, 3m, 3); Parallelogram (2, 1).
Note that 3 & 3m point groups fall under the hexagonal class.
Continued
Example-1 Square Lattice Note that this is a ‘patch’ of an infinite lattice
+ Circle Motif
Square Crystal
Continued…
Square Lattice
+ Circle Motif
Square Crystal
Including mirrors
4mm
Continued…
Important Note
Any fold rotational axis allowed! (through the centre of the circle)
Mirror in any orientation passing through the centre allowed!
Centre of inversion at the centre of the circle
Funda Check What do the ‘adjectives’ like square mean in
the context of the lattice, crystal etc?
Continued…
Important Note Symmetry of the Motif = Symmetry of the lattice
4mm symmetry
If the
Important Rule Symmetry of the Motif Symmetry of the Lattice*
The Symmetry of the lattice and the Crystal are identical
i.e. Symmetry of the lattice is NOT lowered but is preserved
Common surviving symmetry determines the crystal system
* This could be phrased in the language of subsets
Example-3
In a the above example we are assuming that the square is favourably oriented. And that
there are symmetry elements common to the lattice and the motif.
In the current example, we rotate the square (motif) by an arbitrary angle before decorating
the square lattice.
The lattice and motif both have 4mm symmetry, but due to the rotation of the square only
the 4-fold axes survive. Due to the presence of this 4-fold this kind of crystal is classfied
under the ‘square class’.
+
Triangle Motif
= Square Crystal
Rectangle Crystal*
Here the word square does not imply the shape in the usual sense
* This can also be called pseudo-square crystal (as the geometry is square, but the
symmetry is ‘rectangular’. (Similarly in 3D we can have pseudo-cubic, etc.) Continued…
Symmetry of the structure Only one set of parallel mirrors left
m
m0 m½
The symmetry of the motif determines the symmetry of the crystal it is lowered to
match the symmetry of the motif (common symmetry elements between the lattice and
motif which survive) (i.e. the crystal structure has only the symmetry of the motif left:
even though the lattice started of with a higher symmetry)
Rectangle Crystal (has no 4-folds but has mirror)
Note that the word ‘Rectangle’ denotes the symmetry of the
crystal and NOT the shape of the UC
If the
Important Rule Symmetry of the Motif < Symmetry of the Lattice
The Symmetry of the lattice and the Crystal are NOT identical
Crystal has No symmetry except translational symmetry as there are no symmetry elements
common to the lattice and the motif (given its orientation)
* As before this is a pseudo-square crystal (as the geometry of the unit cell is square, but the
symmetry is that belonging to the parallogram class.
Some more
twists
Example-6 Square Lattice
= Square Crystal
Parallelogram (Oblique)
Crystal
Except translation
Example-7 Square Lattice
= Square Crystal
Amorphous Material
(Glass)
Hence, this structure can be considered to be a ‘crystal’ with positional order, but
without orientational order! Click here to know more
Click here to know more
Summary of 2D Crystals Click here to see a summary of 2D lattices that these crystals are built on
1(i
1(ii
)
) 2
Q&A Describe the crystal in the figure below. The lattice parameters are a = b, = 90.
In the absence of the motif the lattice is a square lattice (simple square lattice, UC at 45).
The crystal has only one set of vertical mirrors and hence is a rectangle crystal.
Now comes the tricky point ‘How do I describe the crystal?’.
The crystal has to be described as:
Lattice: Centred rectangle lattice
Motif: UC of ‘just the lattice’
UC of the crystal
3
6mm 6 3m
2 Parallelogram/Oblique 1
Q&A Give examples of crystals belonging to all the ten 2D point groups.
Use conventional unit cells this time around.
Crystal Symmetry of Crystal Symmetry of
the underlying the underlying
lattice lattice
6mm
4mm
4mm Square 4
6
2mm
6mm
3m
2mm Rectangle m
2 3
Note the symmetry
2 Parallelogram 1 of the lattice defines
Hexagonal the Crystal System
4 crystal systems in 2D
Q&A How to “go” from a square crystal to a rectangle crystal? (Illustrate with
examples).
Square lattice + Square lattice + Rectangle motif = Rectangle crystal
Square motif = 2
Square crystal
2mm
4mm
Rectangle lattice +
Square motif =
Rectangle crystal 2mm
3
Rectangle lattice +
Rectangle motif = 2mm
Rectangle crystal
Funda Check How come both the below crystals (in Fig.1) have ‘2’ symmetry?
In the first case the shape and orientation of the motif leads to the lowering of the symmetry
of the underlying lattice from 4mm to 2.
In the second case the lattice itself has only a 2 symmetry and using a motif of higher
symmetry (the well oriented yellow rectangle motif has 2mm symmetry) cannot increase
the symmetry of the structure and hence the crystal has only 2 symmetry.
The location of these symmetry elements is given in the figure to the right (Click here to
know more about space groups in 2D (Click here to know more about space groups in 2D).
p2
2
2 Fig.1
Funda Check Can the symmetry of the lattice be increased by using a higher symmetry motif?
No.
The maximum symmetry one can get is that of the lattice.
As an example let us consider a rectangle lattice (whose symmetry is 2mm). Let us make a
crystal by associating with each lattice point a square (with a higher 4mm symmetry).
However, the crystal thus obtained still has a 2mm symmetry!
We could use a circle (the object with the highest symmetry possible in 2D) and still we
will get a crystal with 2mm symmetry (only).
CRYSTALS
MOTIFS
In practice some of the strict conditions imposed might be relaxed and we might call a
something a crystal even if
Orientational order is missing
There is only average orientational or positional order
Only the geometrical entity has been considered in the definition of the crystal and not
the physical property
3D
Making a 3D Crystal
A strict 3D crystal = 3D lattice + 3D motif.
We have 14 3D Bravais lattices to choose from.
As an intellectual exercise we can put 1D or 2D motifs in a 3D lattice as well.
(we could also try putting higher dimensional motifs like 4D motifs!!).
We will illustrate some examples to understand some of the basic concepts
(most of which we have already explained in 1D and 2D).
Chapter_4a_Structure_of_Solids_Metallic
Simple Cubic (SC) Lattice + Sphere Motif
Graded Shading to give 3D effect
If these spheres were ‘spherical atoms’ then the atoms would be touching each other.
The kind of model shown is known as the ‘Ball and Stick Model’.
In the true unit cell 1/8th of the atom is within the unit cell.
To know more about
Close Packed Crystals
Body Centred Cubic (BCC) Lattice + Sphere Motif click here
Atom at (½, ½, ½)
Atom at (0, 0, 0)
Close Packed
implies CLOSEST
PACKED
Point at (½, ½, 0)
Cubic Close Packed Crystal
Point at (0, 0, 0)
(Sometimes casually called the FCC crystal)
Unit cell of the FCC lattice
=
Tetrahedral bonding of C
(sp3 hybridized)
It requires a little thinking to convince yourself that the two atom motif
actually sits at all lattice points!
(0,0,0) (½,0,0)
NaCl Crystal
The Na+ ions sit in the positions (but not inside) of the
octahedral voids in an CCP crystal click here to know more
Solved
Note: This is not a close packed crystal Has a packing fraction of ~0.67 Example
NaCl crystal: further points Click here: Ordered Crystals
More views
Triclinic Crystal
(having only translational symmetry) Amorphous Material (Glass)
(having no symmetry what so ever)
Making Some Molecular Crystals
We have seen that the symmetry (and positioning) of the motif plays an
important role in the symmetry of the crystal.
Let us now consider some examples of Molecular Crystals to see practical
examples of symmetry of the motif vis a vis the symmetry of the crystal.
(click here to know more about molecular crystals → Molecular Crystals)
It is seen that there is no simple relationship between the symmetry of the molecule and
the symmetry of the crystal structure. As noted before:
Symmetry of the molecule may be retained in crystal packing (example of
hexamethylenetetramine) or
May be lowered (example of Benzene)
The FCC lattice has a true 4-fold axis. On the formation of a diamond crystal the symmetry
along <100> is lowered to a 2-fold.
Note: the DC structure has a 41 screw axis (along <100>).
Funda Check
From reading some of the material presented in the chapter one might get a feeling that
there is no connection between ‘geometry’ and ‘symmetry’. I.e. a crystal made out of
lattice with square geometry can have any (given set) of symmetries.
In ‘atomic’ systems (crystals made of atomic entities) we expect that these two aspects are
connected (and not arbitrary). The hyperlink below explains this aspect.
Click
Clickhere
here→
→connection
connectionbetween
betweengeometry
geometryand
andsymmetry
symmetry
Q&A How do we handle the case wherein the symmetry of the lattice and motif do not
coincide (i.e. shifted by a translation vector)?
Let us consider the example as below (F1 and F2).
In F1 the symmetries of the lattice and motif coincide; while in F2 there is a relative shift
(red vector).
In the second case (F2) we have to ignore the lattice and overlay the symmetry operators on
the crystal.
Lattice point