• Economy ↕ Efficiency / Effectiveness Definitions of Management & Leadership • Management : Working with and through individuals and groups and other resources to accomplish organizational goals • Leadership : Involves working through individuals and groups to accomplish goals , but these goals may be different from organizational goals Other definitions • Leadership : is setting a new direction or vision for a group that they follow , that is a leader is spearhead for that new direction • Management : controls or directs people/resources in a group according to principles or values that have already been established • The difference between leadership and management can be illustrated by considering what happens when you have one without the other : • Leadership Without Management ;.. • Sets a direction or vision that others follow , without considering too much how the new direction is going to be achieved • Other people then have to work hard in the trail that is left behind , picking up pieces and making it work • Management Without Leadership … • Controls resources to maintain the status quo or ensure things happen according to already- establish plans E.g.. management controlling resources to ensure that the laws of the (..) are followed and status quo is maintained • Leadership combined with management : .. • Does both – it both sets a new direction and manages the resources to achieve it . E.g. : a newly elected president or prime minister
• Leadership VS Management (Photocopy for
discussion in the class) • The key difference between the concepts of management and leadership is the phrase “Organizational Goals” • A manager works for an organization for example hospital administrator and carries the responsibility of accomplishing the organization’s goals through specific professional services • Leadership is a much broader concept because all health care professionals are leaders , anytime a person is a recognized authority and has followers who count on this person’s expertise to carry out their objectives , the person is a leader • So the key difference is that mangers are responsible for organizational goals while leaders may only be responsible for one segment of overall goals The Management Process • The management process are four : • 1-Planning : in planning we identify the problem , setting and specify both long-term and short-term goals ,developing objectives and then mapping how these goals and objectives will be accomplished • According to Marriner-Tomey Planning is the first and the most important step of management process • 2-Organizing : involves bringing all of the system’s resources – people , capital and equipment into action toward goal accomplishment • 3-Motivating or Leading : is a large factor in determining the performance level of employees and the quality of goal accomplishment • William James of Harvard conducting a research on motivation which concluded that hourly employees could maintain their jobs by only working to 20 to 30% of their capacity but when they are motivated by their leaders they could work to 80 to 90% of their ability , so James felt that approximately 60% of employees performance can be affected by motivation • 4-Controlling : is setting up mechanisms for ingoing evaluation , controlling is obtaining feedback of results and periodically following up in order to compare results with plans , so adjustments in plans can be made accordingly • Controlling is one aspect of management that is subject to myths and misinterpretations so to avoid misinterpretations the manager meet every week the group to discuss progress and problems • On a particular goal without being called autocratic , rigid Managerial Skills • There are three general categories of skills that managers and leaders must possess : • 1-Technical skill : ability to use knowledge , methods , techniques and equipment necessary for the performance of specific tasks acquired from experience , education and training • 2-Human skill : ability and judgment in working with and through people , including • An understanding of motivation and an application of effective leadership • 3-Conceptual skill : ability to understand the complexities of the overall organization and where one’s own operation fits in the organization Examples of these Skills • Suppose a nurse leader has the goal of increasing the quality of nursing care , Technical skill is the leader’s ability to perform the comprehensive individualized nursing care that is expected from staff nurses and nursing practice standards , Humans skill involve ability to influence others by teaching , role modeling , Conceptual skill involves seeing how the goal that is being accomplished fits into overall organizational goals of the client service in the agency . Management & Leadership Theory • 1-Classical & Non Classical Organizational Theory : • Classical Organizational Theory ; has a list of assumptions , which called theory X assumptions about human nature , these are the following : • A-People find work distasteful • B-People are not ambitious and prefer direction • C-People do not solve organizational problems creatively • D-People are motivated only by physiological and safety factors • E-People require close control and coercion to achieve the goals • Non Classical Organizational Theory : which called Y assumptions about people • A-People regard work to be as natural as play when conditions are favorable • B-People are self-directed in achieving organizational goals • C-people are creative in solving problems • D-People are motivated at all level of Maslow’s Hierarchy of needs-physiological , safety , social , esteem and self-actualization • E-People are self-controlled if properly motivated • 2-General System Theory : Composed of two systems • A-Closed system ; end when a quantity needed for fulfillment is obtained • B-Open system : human beings are open system because even though one can spend great amounts of time finding out properties , personality , wishes and desires of people there is and will always be no end • Von Bertalanffy identified four assumptions of open systems: • 1-A system is more than a sum of its parts ; in other words a system is composed of all people and things within it , in this system , the greater the amount of energy has working toward a goal , the higher the probability for effective goal completion , the challenge for management is to keep the groups working for organization rather than against the organization • 2-A system is ever-changing ; here an effective leader must allow for the group’s growth to be reflected in the group’s goals and the strategies that will best enable the goals to be attained so in this process involves constant assessment of the group • 3-A system has boundaries that are defined by the system’s purpose • For example the system that has goal of increasing the quality of care in a given unit may not be the same system in another unit • 4-System are goal oriented ; a system with no goal has no reason to exist , without goal we never get anything done Leader Behavior Style • There are three common labels for leader behavior: • 1-Autocratic leaders ; are often described as authoritarian , firm leaders who makes unilateral decisions • 2-Democratic leaders ; involve the group in decision- making and giving responsibility to followers • 3-Laissez-faire leaders generally maintain loose over their followers Leadership Styles • Other 3 major leadership styles are; • 1- Authoritarian or Autocratic • 2-Participative or Democratic • 3- Delegate or Free Reign • Although good leaders use all three styles with one of them normally dominant , bad leaders tend to stick with one style Authoritarian (Autocratic) • I WANT BOTH OF YOU TO … • This style is used when leaders tell their employees what they want done and how they want it accomplished , without getting the advice of their followers • Some think of this style is not an authoritarian style rather than it is an abusive , unprofessional style called “Bossing People around” Participative (Democratic) • LET’S WORK TOGETHER TO SOLVE THIS … • This style involves the leader including one or more employees in the decision making process , however , the leader maintains the final decision making authority , using this style is not a sign of weakness rather it is a sign of strength that employees will respect • This is normally used when you have part of the information and your employees have other parts . • Note that a leader is not expected to know everything- this sis why you employ knowledgeable and skillful employees • Also using this style is of mutual benefit it allows them to become part of the team and allows you to make better decisions Delegative (Free Reign) • YOU TWO TAKE CARE OF THE PROBLEM WHILE I GO … • In this style the leader allows the employees to make the decisions , however the leader is still responsible for the decisions that are made , this is used when employees are able to analyze the situation and determine what needs is to be done and how to do it • You cannot do everything ! You must set priorities and delegate certain tasks • This style to be used when you fully trust and confidence in the people • Do NOT BE AFRAID TO USE IT , USE IT WISELY • Laisser-faire French language which means Laisser to let , allow • Faire to do Forces • A good leader uses all three styles depending on what forces are involved between the followers , the leader and the situation , some examples include: • Using an authoritarian style on a new employee who is just learning job , the leader is competent and a good coach , the employee is motive to learn a new skill , the situation is a new environment for the employee • Using participative style with a team of workers who know their job , the leader knows the problem , but does not have all the information , the employees know their jobs and want to become part of the team • Using a delegative style with worker who knows more about the job than you • This allow the leader to be doing other things • Using all three : Telling your employees that a procedure is not working correctly and a new one must be established (authoritarian) , asking for their ideas and input on creating a new procedure (participative) , delegating tasks in order to implement the new procedure (Delegative)