Different Approaches towards Managment • Management theories and approaches in evolution….
1. Scientific management theory
2. Administrative theory 3. Bureaucratic theory 4. Human relations/behavioral theory 5. Quantitative/Qualitative theory 6. Contingency theory General Administrative Theory Henri Fayol from the perspective of entire organization constituting good management practice developed 14 principles of management: Division of work -specialization increase output making efficient Authority –managers must be able to give orders Discipline –employees must obey and respect rules of organization Unity of command - receive orders from one superior Unity of direction – single plan to guide managers and workers Subordination of individual interests to general interest Remuneration - Fair wage for the service Centralization – degree to which subordinates are involved in decision making Scalar chain – the line of authority from top to lowest rank Order – people and materials in the right place at the right time Equity – kind and fair to subordinates Stability of tenure – replacement are available to fill vacancies Initiative – high levels of effort to carry out plans Team spirit – to build harmony and unity in the organization Bureaucracy Max Weber in early 1900 developed theory of authority structures and relations called bureaucracy Bureaucracy – a form of organization; division of labor (jobs broken down into simple defined tasks) clearly defined hierarchy (positions with clear chain of command) Detailed rules and regulations (standard operating procedures) Impersonal relationships (Uniform application of rules) Career orientation (Managers as career professionals) Formal selection (selected for jobs on technical qualifications) These days this model is regarded hindrance to individual’s creativity, and organizations’ limit to respond dynamic environment However some of the bureaucratic mechanisms even in flexible organizations of creative professionals as Infosys, Cisco, are felt necessary to ensure resource efficiency and effectivity Quantitative Approach Use of quantitative techniques to improve decision making as : Applying statistics Optimization models Information models Computer simulations Linear programming to improve resource allocation Critical path scheduling analysis Total Quality Management (TQM)
TQM –a philosophy to continual improvement
responding to customer needs and expectation Customers means all who interacts with organization products and service internally and externally Continuous improvement is possible with measurements requiring statistical techniques measuring every critical variables in work process Measurements compared against standards to correct TQM a great departure from keeping costs low to increase productivity TQM Principles • Intense focus on the customer • Concern for continual improvement • Process focused • Improvement in the quality of everything the organization does • Accurate measurement • Empowerment of employees Eg. • In 2006, Dell had to announce a worldwide recall of certain models of laptops that contained defective batteries. • Renouncement in 2008 again • 22nd jan, 2020, Toyota Motor Corp said on Tuesday that it will recall 3.4 million vehicles worldwide because of an electronic defect that can result in airbags not deploying in crashes. • The recall, which includes 2.9 million vehicles in the United States, covers 2011-19 Corolla, 2011-13 Matrix, 2012-18 Avalon and 2013-18 Avalon Hybrid vehicles and is tied to a report of one fatal crash. Behavioral Approach Management is to get works done with people Organizational Behavior has been the focus of research on actions of people motivating, leading, building trust and team, managing conflict Early advocates of OB approach led foundation for selection, motivation, team building – Robert Owen (Late 1700) - improving labor and work place Hugo Munsterberg (Early 1900) –scientific study of people at work, suggested psychological tests for selection, learning for training, human behavior for motivation Cont Mary Parker Follet (Early 1900) – perspective of individual and group behavior, group ethics, proposed people oriented ideas Chester Barnard (1930s) – organization as social system requiring cooperation, communicate and stimulate, organization as open system Great Depression of 1930 forced Managers to examine their job rather than production with least cost in materials and labor Recently group effectiveness became key to survival as Managers to think more on Motivation, Group behavior and leadership Organization as an open system Contingency Approach Early theorists relied on principles to be universally applicable It is realized changing situation require different techniques and approaches Contingency approach is situational as organizations are different requiring different ways of managing facing different situations No simplistic rule to follow for managers Even units within organization differs in size, goals, activities Situational or contingency variables may be numerous but most Cont widely used are: Size of Organization differs with problem of coordination Structures, leadership style and control system of routine technologies differ from customized technologies Best in stable environment may be inappropriate in rapidly changing unpredictable environment Individual differences for growth, autonomy, expectations matters for job design, leadership and motivation Case Study • Fast Forwarding Blockbuster