Research Methods (1) Observational studies (2) Experimental studies
(a) Descriptive studies
Case studies and Case series (a) Randomized controlled trial (b) Analytical studies (b) Field trials (i) Ecological or correlational (ii) Cross sectional or prevalence (c) Community trial (iii) Case-Control (iv) Cohort or Follow up study Descriptive Epidemiology Includes activities related to characterizing the distribution of diseases within a population In Descriptive Epidemiology: Who? – person - Demographic Where? – place - Geographical When? – time - Temporal to formulate • Concerns anrelated activities etiological to identifying hypothesis. possible causes for the occurrence of Procedures: Defining the population of the community Defining the disease under study Describing the distribution disease with reference to time, place and person Measurement of disease Making comparison with known indices Formulation of etiological hypothesis. Defining the population under study: The population must also be defined in terms of area (place) and time. For example, if we want to study the problem of measles in a primary health center area, during a given year, the population under study is all under fives, the area is the entire jurisdiction of PHC and the time is the particular year. Thus, the study population (defined population) becomes the population at risk, i.e. it becomes the denominator and helps in calculating the rates, i.e. in measuring the disease frequency. Defining the disease under study: That means the disease which is taken up for study has to be defined in such a way that the epidemiologist should not only be able to identify those with disease from those without the disease, but also be able to measure it with accuracy. This is called ‘Operational definition’. For example, leprosy is defined as a case with hypopigmented patch/patches with partial or total loss of sensation, with thickening of nerves and demonstration of acid-fast bacilli in the skin smear examination. Describing the distribution of the disease with reference to time, place and person. TIME DISTRIBUTION This means describing the time of occurrence/ onset of the disease with reference to year, month, week, day, hour of onset, season, atmospheric temperature, climate etc. This study often gives a clue about the etiology of the disease or the predisposing factors, so that preventive measures can be adopted. There are three kinds of time trends or fluctuations: 1. Short-term fluctuations. 2. Periodic fluctuations. 3. Long-term fluctuations. TIME DISTRIBUTION Short-term Fluctuations This means sudden occurrence of a disease in a given area, and lasting for a short period, e.g. an epidemic disease. There are two types of epidemics: Common source epidemics Propagated epidemic Common source epidemics: This is an epidemic occurring from a common source, either by single exposure or by repeated exposure. Accordingly, there are two subtypes.
Common source single exposure epidemic (Point source
epidemic): This means all the cases develop almost simultaneously following single exposure. For example, food poisoning, Bhopal gas tragedy, fire accident in an industry.
Common Source Repeated/ Continuous Exposure Epidemic
In this type, epidemic disease occurs from a common source, but the exposure occurs continuously or intermittently or repeatedly and not necessarily simultaneously. Therefore, the epidemic is not explosive. For example, A professional sex worker as a source of gonorrhea, infecting When this data is represented in the form of a curve in a graph, it is called ‘Epidemic curve.’ Salient features of point source epidemic curve are : There is sudden rise and sudden fall There are no secondary curves Large number of cases occur with a narrow interval of time All cases have the same incubation period Exposure is almost simultaneous and brief Short-term Fluctuations - Propagated Epidemic: In this type, the epidemic does not originate from a common source like food or water, but spreads from person to person, until all the susceptible are affected. Thus, there is gradual rise and gradual fall of the curve. Example: Epidemic of meningitis, measles, etc. TIME DISTRIBUTION Periodic Fluctuations: This means occurrence of a disease in a community during a definite period, either in a particular season or periodically in a cyclic form. Accordingly, there are two types: Seasonal trend and cyclic trend. Periodic Fluctuations: Seasonal Trend Some diseases occur in a definite season. Measles and chickenpox in the early spring season Upper respiratory infection in the winter season Diarrheal diseases during summer months. The seasonal trend of the disease is because of the favorable environmental factors such as humidity, rainfall, atmospheric temperature, over crowding, etc. Periodic Fluctuations: Cyclic Trend This means tendency of a disease to occur cyclically once in several days, weeks, months or years. Examples: Epidemic of measles once in 2 to 3 years, rubella once in 6 to 9 years, influenza once in 7 to 10 years. Accidents more on weekends. Thus, the knowledge on periodic fluctuations helps to protect the community TIME DISTRIBUTION Long-term Fluctuations (Secular Trend): This means changes in the occurrence of the disease over a long period of time, several years or decades. For example, coronary heart disease, diabetes, lung cancer have shown an upward trend in the developed countries during the last 50 years, followed by a downward trend of diseases like leprosy, tuberculosis, typhoid, amoebiasis, etc. Thus, studying the time distribution of a disease helps the epidemiologist not only to formulate an etiological hypothesis but also to implement prevention and control measures. PLACE DISTRIBUTION This means the pattern of occurrence of a disease in different places. This helps to compare the disease occurrence from one country to another country, and within the same country from one state to another state, from rural to urban areas and local areas. International Variations For example, cancer of stomach is common in Japan, unusual in US. Ca cervix common in India, less in UK, US, etc. Breast cancer low in Japan, high in Western Countries, etc. This helps the epidemiologist to identify the causative factors and thereby prevention. Other examples are yellow fever in South America, sleeping sickness in Africa. National Variations For example, goiter is more in subhimalayan region, lathyrism in Madhya Predesh, leprosy in Tamil Nadu and Andhra Pradesh, filariasis in coastal areas, etc. Thus, diseases show variations in the same country. This also helps the epidemiologist to find out the favourable factor for the disease, thereby appropriate health care services can be provided. Rural-Urban Variations The prevalence of non-communicable diseases such as diabetes, hypertension, cancer, mental diseases are more in urban areas than rural areas. On the other hand, zoonotic diseases and soil borne diseases are more in rural areas than urban areas. These variations help the epidemiologist to identify the risk factors and the risk-groups, so that care can be taken. Local Distribution of the Disease (in an Area) This is studied by representing the number of cases in the area-map, in the form of spots, depending upon the area to which they belong. This is called ‘Geographic spot map’ or ‘Shaded map’ Such a map at a glance shows area of high frequency and area of low frequency. Area of high frequency (Cluster of spots) gives a clue to the epidemiologist about the common source of infection. It was by such a study that John Snow of England in 1854 was able to focus attention that a common water pump in the Broad street of London was the source of infection of cholera epidemic. Thus, he was also able to hypothesize that cholera was a water borne disease, much before the organisms were isolated by Robert Koch. PERSON DISTRIBUTION This means describing the distribution of a disease in the community with reference to the host characters of the persons affected, such as age, sex, occupation, literacy level, marital status, social class, behavior, and such other factors. Age Certain diseases occur more frequently in certain age group. For example, measles and diphtheria among preschool children, cancer in the middle age, atherosclerosis among elderly. But there are certain diseases like Hodgkin’s disease and leukemia, which has increased incidence in two age groups. For example, Hodgkin’s disease is more between 15 to 35 years and between 70 to 90 years. Such a tendency of a disease to show two separate peaks, is called ‘Bimodality phenomenon.’ Tuberculosis has ‘Trimodality distribution’: a small peak in early childhood, an extensive peak in adult age and a moderate peak in old age Sex Certain diseases are more common among men. For example, lung cancer, TB, coronary heart disease and some are more Marital Status This often becomes a risk factor. Cancer cervix is rare in nuns compared to married women. Similarly, mortality rates are high among unmarried than among married persons. This is because married people lead a secured and protected life. Occupation Persons working in particular occupations are exposed to particular types of risks. Example, Tetanus, Ankylostomiasis are common among agriculturist workers, Pneumoconiosis are common among industrial workers. Social Class Diseases like hypertension, diabetes, coronary artery diseases are common among people of higher socioeconomic class and diseases like malnutrition, rheumatic heart disease and communicable diseases are common among people of lower socioeconomic class. Thus, social factors like poverty, illiteracy, ignorance, poor standard of living, overcrowding, etc. play a very important role in the development of the diseases in the community Behavior Human life-style or behavior such as smoking, alcoholism, over eating, multiple sexual partnership, drug-abuse, etc. influence the development of the disease. Thus, study of these risk factors help the epidemiologist to formulate an etiological hypothesis. Stress Stress increases the susceptibility of an individual to the disease and often exacerbates the symptoms. Migration Movement of the people from rural to urban areas has resulted in the spread of diseases from one place to another. Migration of the people is a challenge for the prevention and control of the disease. (3) Measurement of Disease This means estimating the ‘Disease load’ or magnitude of the problem in terms of morbidity, mortality, disability, etc. Mortality is measured directly in terms of death rates. Morbidity is expressed in terms of incidence (Longitudinal study) and prevalence (Cross-sectional study) rates. (4) Making Comparison with Known Indices: The observations are compared with different groups. This helps to find out the etiological factors and also helps to identify the ‘Risk’ group, so that preventive measures can be adopted. (5) Formulation of Etiological Hypothesis By studying the distribution of a disease in the community, with reference to time, place and person, the epidemiologist can formulate an etiological hypothesis (supposition). The hypothesis must be correct and complete. For example, ‘Chronic alcoholism causes cirrhosis of liver’—is an incomplete hypothesis. Better statement would be ‘Drinking 200 to 300 ml of alcohol per day causes cirrhosis of liver among 20 percent of drunkards after 25 years of exposure’. Uses of Descriptive Epidemiology
It helps to know the extent/magnitude of the
disease in the community, in terms of morbidity and mortality rates. It helps to know the distribution of the disease with reference to time, place and person. It helps to identify the risk group. It helps to formulate an etiological hypothesis. It helps to plan, organize and implement curative and preventive services. It helps in doing research. Thanks.. & MCQs 1) Studying distribution of disease or health related characteristics in human population and identifying the characteristics with which disease seem to associated is: [MH 2002]
(a) Descriptive epidemiology
(b) Experimental epidemiology (c) Analytical epidemiology (d) Ecological epidemiology 2) All are Observational studies except? a) Case control study b) Cohort study c) Cross sectional study d) Randomize control trail 3) Case-control study is a type of ? (a) Descriptive epidemiological study (b) Analytical study (c) Longitudinal study (d) Experimental epidemiological study 4)Which is not an analytical study? (a) Case control study (b) Cohort study (c) Ecological studies (d) Field trials 5) Descriptive study define distribution of disease according to: a) Time b) Place c) Person d) All of above Thank you..