Professional Documents
Culture Documents
2. The above formulae (6-13) and (6-13a) are true provided all
the values of the variable which are above the average (M or
Md) are also above ‘a’ and those which are below the average
are also below ‘a’. The arbitrary constant ‘a’ should be taken
some arbitrary integral value near the average value, i.e.., it
should be a value in the average class. The short cut method
will not yield correct result if ‘a’ is taken outside the average
class.
Merits and Demerits of Mean Deviation
Merits: (i) Mean deviation is rigidly defined and is easy to
understand and calculate.
(ii) Mean deviation is based on all the observation and is thus
definitely a better measure of dispersion than the range and
quartile deviation.
(iii) The averaging of the absolute deviations from an average
irons out the irregularities in the distribution and thus mean
deviation provides an accurate and true measure of
dispersion.
(iv) As compared with standard deviation (discussed in next
article $ 6-9), it is less affected by extreme observations.
(v) Since mean deviation is based on the deviations about an
average, it provides a better measure for comparison about
the formation of different distributions.
Merits and Demerits of Mean Deviation
Demerits: (i) The strongest objection against mean deviation is that
while computing its value we take the absolute value of the
deviations about an average and ignore the signs of the
deviations.
(ii) The step of ignoring the signs of the deviations is mathematically
unsound and illogical. It creates artificially and renders mean
deviation useless for further mathematical treatment. This
drawback necessitates the requirement of another measure of
variability which, in addition to being based on all the
observations is also amenable to further algebraic manipulation.
(iii) It is not a satisfactory measure when taken about mode or while
dealing with a fairly skewed distribution. As already pointed out,
theoretically mean deviation gives the best result when it is
calculated about median. But median is not a satisfactory
measure when the distribution has great variations.
Merits and Demerits of Mean Deviation
Demerits: (iv) It is rarely used in sociological studies.
(v) It cannot be computed for distribution with open end classes.
(vi) Mean deviation tends to increase with the size of the sample though
not proportionately and not so rapidly as range.
M
X
MD X MDM
A. Individual Series:-
MDX = ∑f I dx I I dx I = I x-x I
∑f
Coef of MDX = MDx
x x= 28.88
X f fx I dx I = I x-x I f I dxI MDx = ∑f IdxI
10 3 30 10-28.88=18.88 56.64 ∑f
20 6 120 8.88 53.28 = 220 = 12.22
30 2 60 1.12 2.24 18
40 4 160 11.12 44.48 Coef. Of MDx = MDx
50 3 150 21.12 63.36 x
∑f=18 ∑fx=520 ∑f IdxI = 220 = 12.22 = ?
28.88
x = ∑fx = 520 = 28.88
∑f 18
C. Continuous Series:-
MDX = ∑f I dx I I dx I = I m-x I
∑f
Coef of MDX = MDx
x x= 25.52
C.I f Midpoint M fm I dxI = Im-xI f IdxI MDx = ∑fIdxI
0-10 3 5 15 5- 25.52 =20.52 61.56 ∑f
10-20 5 15 75 10.52 52.6 = 230.52
20-30 2 25 50 0.52 1.04 19
30-40 6 35 210 9.48 56.08 =?
40-50 3 45 135 19.48 58.44
∑f=19 ∑fm=485 ∑f IdxI = 230.52