Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Outside SF
(Landing Client)
Outside SF
(Landing Client)
Hunters:
Get Accounts,
Grow Base
Outside SF
(Landing Client)
Hunters;
Get Accounts
Reward SF for?
Outside SF
(Landing Client)
Hunters;
Get Accounts
(Reward for
Landing Client
# of New Clients
GM, Effective)
Progressive: Total potential compensation for client development (i.e increase sales /client) exceeds
total for meeting the current sales goal for client
While client-development goals depend partially on the sales performance, the A/C manager is
also selling these products.
As bonuses are relatively similar to hitting minimum, acceptable, and excellent performance
targets, managers will likely prioritize accounts with targets they perceive are easy to hit
(ROE – Return on Effort).
A/C MANAGER COMPENSATION PLAN
ANALYSIS (2)
The revenue targets encourage maximizing and increasing revenue for the PacketShield,
NetStrobe, and Macroterra accounts.
They also encourage the Illumex team to focus on the revenues that can be closed
most quickly. (+)
As managers bonuses depend on team performance, the plan encourages them to keep their
account teams happy, well-trained, and committed so that they continue to maximize revenue.
(+)
This plan does not directly encourage managers to control costs. So, headcount, sales spiffs,
and other such expenses must be managed through some other means. (-)
Nothing in the plan directly encourages managers to keep their team’s composition stable or to
take any specific client-satisfaction steps
(beyond those required for the client development goals). (-)
SOME POSSIBLE PLAN
ADJUSTMENTS
SOME POSSIBLE PLAN
ADJUSTMENTS?
This plan’s effectiveness is very sensitive to the EVP’s ability to set appropriate targets.
In many cases, the A/C managers themselves will have better insight into the targets and how
easily they can be achieved.
The company could implement bonus and target systems based on tiered increases in Q-o-Q or
Y-o-Y revenues.
Building a comp plan that treats managers’ accounts in aggregate (e.g., by giving A/C managers
an aggregate target for all of their accounts and letting them decide from which accounts to
generate those revenues) might maximize overall revenues. However, some individual accounts
may not reach their full potential.
Outside reps would want the A/C managers compensation to be by individual accounts to
ensure that none of the accounts comprising their compensation would ever be neglected
while they are due their ‘annuity’ commissions from them.
SOME QUESTIONS
What management aspects are the Inside Reps management positions (team leader and A/C manager)
more oriented towards ?
What management aspects are the Outside Reps management positions more oriented towards ?
Should the duration of the outside reps compensation decrease or end after a certain
period of time ?
Should outside reps be compensated only for the revenue volume they can control
and the number of products and initial referrals that the client offers the company ?
Because revenues on accounts are not apparent at the signing of the contract,
it is difficult to pay out variable compensation at the beginning of the contract.
The obvious alternative to paying out variable compensation at the contract’s inception is
-- to pay it on a monthly basis, as those revenues are realized.
The company had been using this scheme, creating some problems.
Outside reps management positions (team leader and A/C manager) are more oriented towards HR
management, selling, landing new clients - effectiveness .
Need to reward EVP on Faster Sales Learning Curve, Acquisition of New Clients, Retention of best
SF…
Inside reps management team positions are more oriented towards sales operations management
- efficiency.
Need to reward EVP on Renewal Rates, Meeting Customer Retention Rates, Operational Efficiencies,..
Inside sales cycle relatively more mechanistic than outside sales so not so challenging for
a sales manager oriented towards sales goals and selling.
But the inside sales force would not be willing to be led by someone with no sales experience.
As inside reps and A/C managers take on responsibility for generating and increasing revenues
from an account, the outside sales reps responsibility for those revenues decreases.
BACK TO SOME QUESTIONS
What management aspects are the Inside Reps management positions (team leader and A/C manager)
more oriented towards ?
What management aspects are the Outside Reps management positions more oriented towards ?
Should the duration of the outside reps compensation decrease or end after a certain
period of time ?
Should outside reps be compensated only for the revenue volume they can control
and the number of products and initial referrals that the client offers the company ?
- Doesn’t the gross margin component effectively cover the revenues from existing customers
(as existing customers are going to offer the best GM opportunities)?
- Of the 3 components of compensation, the inside sales EVP has the least control over EBITDA.
Sales EVP has more control over Gross Margin than other managers, and so Gross Margin
performance should be a substantial part of their compensation.
The equity compensation is important to the EVP’s “playing nice in the sandbox”.
-How large should it be? Competitive with the industry ?
Additional questions:
The company almost exclusively promoted A/C managers from within the inside sales team.
David and Mike suggest if they hired managers from outside, the company would have to pay them
considerably more than if promoted from within.
The model reduces friction and costs associated with hiring from outside and the likelihood of hiring
managers who turn out to be disasters, but they do not necessarily recruit the very most talented people.
Presidio Solutions is a unique company; insiders would know and understand the business.
Hiring just a few account managers from outside would create inequity and ultimately
raise salary levels - There are less salary differential issues with inside promotions.
Interest in sales process, tactics, and reps vs. sales strategy, organization, and pricing:
Prefer? Winner?
EVP OUTSIDE SALES: BENNETT VERSUS
KANITSKY
Tech sector experience vs. outsourcing logistics sector experience:
Prefer?: Winner: If Outsourcing - Kanitsky; if Tech sector - Bennett
Interest in sales process, tactics, and reps vs. sales strategy, organization, and pricing:
Prefer?: Winner: If Tactical - Kanitsky; if Organization - Bennett
EVP OUTSIDE SALES: BENNETT VERSUS
KANITSKY
Tech sector experience vs. outsourcing logistics sector experience: Prefer? Winner?
Interest in sales process, tactics, and reps vs. sales strategy, organization, and pricing:
Prefer? Winner?
Interpersonal “sales guy” skills vs ability to build and articulate a business case: Prefer? Winner?
EVP OUTSIDE SALES: BENNETT VERSUS
KANITSKY
Tech sector experience vs. outsourcing logistics sector experience:
Prefer?: Winner: If Outsourcing - Kanitsky; if Tech sector - Bennett
Interest in sales process, tactics, and reps vs. sales strategy, organization, and pricing:
Prefer?: Winner: If Tactical - Kanitsky; if Organization - Bennett
Interpersonal “sales guy” skills vs ability to build and articulate a business case:
Prefer?: ability to build a business case: Winner: Bennett better at building a business case
EVP OUTSIDE SALES: BENNETT VERSUS
KANITSKY
Tech sector experience vs. outsourcing logistics sector experience: Prefer? Winner?
Interest in sales process, tactics, and reps vs. sales strategy, organization, and pricing:
Prefer? Winner?
Interpersonal “sales guy” skills vs ability to build and articulate a business case: Prefer? Winner?
Purely sales career vs. some executive suite experience: Prefer? Winner?
EVP OUTSIDE SALES: BENNETT VERSUS
KANITSKY
Tech sector experience vs. outsourcing logistics sector experience:
Prefer?: Winner: If Outsourcing Kanitsky; if Tech sector : Bennett
Interest in sales process, tactics, and reps vs. sales strategy, organization, and pricing:
Prefer?: Winner: If Tactical Kanitsky; if Organization; Bennett
Interpersonal “sales guy” skills vs ability to build and articulate a business case:
Prefer?: ability to build a business case: Winner: Bennett seems better at both
Purely sales career vs. some executive suite experience: Prefer?: balanced.
Executive experience helps the VP understand what is important to customers but may also be a
sign you have someone who wants to be a CEO rather than a VP of Sales. (Is this a concern?)
Draw: Bennett has exec experience but may want to be a CEO?
EVP OUTSIDE SALES: BENNETT VERSUS
KANITSKY
Tech sector experience vs. outsourcing logistics sector experience: Prefer? Winner?
Interest in sales process, tactics, and reps vs. sales strategy, organization, and pricing:
Prefer? Winner?
Interpersonal “sales guy” skills vs ability to build and articulate a business case: Prefer? Winner?
Purely sales career vs. some executive suite experience: Prefer? Winner?
Interest in sales process, tactics, and reps vs. sales strategy, organization, and pricing:
Prefer?: Winner: If Tactical Kanitsky; if Organization; Bennett
Interpersonal “sales guy” skills vs ability to build and articulate a business case:
Prefer?: ability to build a business case: Winner: Bennett seems better at both
Purely sales career vs. some executive suite experience: Prefer?: balanced.
Executive experience helps the VP understand what is important to customers but may also be a
sign you have someone who wants to be a CEO rather than a VP of Sales. (Is this a concern?)
Draw: Bennett has exec experience but may want to be a CEO?
Interest in sales process, tactics, and reps vs. sales strategy, organization, and pricing:
Prefer?: Winner: If Tactical Kanitsky; if Organization; Bennett
Interpersonal “sales guy” skills vs ability to build and articulate a business case:
Prefer?: ability to build a business case: Winner: Bennett seems better at both
Purely sales career vs. some executive suite experience: Prefer?: balanced.
Executive experience helps the VP understand what is important to customers but may also be a
sign you have someone who wants to be a CEO rather than a VP of Sales. (Is this a concern?)
Draw: Bennett has exec experience but may want to be a CEO?
Initially need tech experience and tech expertise, understanding the technology,
and able to convey nuances to SF; as firm grows & product matures, need leader
understanding the sales model, an outside sales expert. Transition timing?
VP SALES TYPES:
Evangelist:
Hunter, Enthusiastic, Must have ability to sell as well
Playbook Maker:
Can build basic processes by assimilating individual cases;
good at figuring out patterns and puzzles
Scaler:
Can work with VP Marketing to get the Lead Gen engine and the Sales Funnel working.
(Hiring someone who joined companies who were already selling billion $ deals not a match
since they have not got experience scaling from lower ACV (Annual Contract Value) deals)
Dashboarder; Boardroomer:
Metrics Builder; can work with C-suite; make presentations; get resources ($, people);
- a manager of managers
VP SALES BY COMPANY LIFE
CYCLE
Start–Up:
Traction:
Growth:
Maturity:
VP SALES BY COMPANY LIFE
CYCLE
3) In-Bound or Out-Bound;
In-Bound experienced in managing a bevy of Inside Telesales;
Out-Bound needs to know how to hire a floor full of bizdev associates .
COMPENSATION PLANS
What are fundamental Objectives? What are Priorities?
What behaviors does it need to encourage?
Lead Generation
Lead Scoring
Lead Routing
Lead Rationing
WHAT HAPPENED THEN
Presidio Solution’s new compensation plan:
The company kept the 4% of revenue run rate as the variable compensation figure
90 days later, the company looks at the account’s run rate and then pays the other 2%,
making adjustments for accounts that are performing better or worse then expected
so that after 90 days the rep has received 4% of the account’s revenue run rate.
PRESIDIO LATER
Business Performance:
Key Milestones: