Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Group 4 Presentation
Group 4 Presentation
Towards this end, the State shall exert efforts to address violence committed
against women and children in keeping with the fundamental freedoms
guaranteed under the Constitution and the Provisions of the Universal Declaration
of Human Rights, the convention on the Elimination of all forms of
discrimination Against Women, Convention on the Rights of the Child and other
international human rights instruments of which the Philippines is a party.
DEFINITION OF TERMS
1. PHYSICAL VIOLENCE
refers to acts that include bodily or physical harm
2. SEXUAL VIOLENCE
refers to an act which is sexual in nature, committed against a woman or her child.
It includes, but is not limited to:
B. BATTERY
refers to an act of inflicting physical harm upon the woman or her child resulting
to the physical and psychological or emotional distress.
D. STALKING
refers to an intentional act committed by a person who, knowingly and without
lawful justification follows the woman or her child or places the woman or her child
under surveillance directly or indirectly or a combination thereof.
DEFINITION OF TERMS
E. DATING RELATIONSHIP
refers to a situation wherein the parties live as husband and wife without the
benefit of marriage or are romantically involved over time and on a continuing
basis during the course of the relationship. A casual acquaintance or ordinary
socialization between two individuals in a business or social context is not a
dating relationship.
F. SEXUAL RELATIONS
refers to a single sexual act which may or may not result in the bearing of a
common child.
DEFINITION OF TERMS
H. CHILDREN
refers to those below eighteen (18) years of age or older but are incapable of
taking care of themselves as defined under Republic Act No. 7610. As used in
this Act, it includes the biological children of the victim and other children under
her care.
Relationship, past
Married or not;
or present;
Including Lesbian
relationship with
common child
LIABLE PERSONS ON VAWC
i) Causing mental or emotional anguish, public ridicule or humiliation to the woman or her
child, including, but not limited to, repeated verbal and emotional abuse, and denial of
financial support or custody of minor children of access to the woman's child/children.
The Regional Trial Court designated as a
Family Court shall have original and exclusive
jurisdiction over cases of violence against women
and their children under this law. In the absence of
Sec. 7. Venue.
such court in the place where the offense was
committed, the case shall be filed in the Regional
Trial Court where the crime or any of its elements
was committed at the option of the compliant.
A protection order is an order issued under this
act for the purpose of preventing further acts of
violence against a woman or her child specified in
Sec. 5 of this Act and granting other necessary
relief. The relief granted under a protection order
Sec. 8. Protection Orders.
serve the purpose of safeguarding the victim from
further harm, minimizing any disruption in the
victim's daily life, and facilitating the opportunity
and ability of the victim to independently regain
control over her life.
Victim-survivors who are found by the courts
to be suffering from battered woman syndrome do
not incur any criminal and civil liability
notwithstanding the absence of any of the
elements for justifying circumstances of self-
Sec. 26. Battered Woman defense under the Revised Penal Code.
Syndrome as a Defense.
In the determination of the state of mind of the
woman who was suffering from battered woman
syndrome at the time of the commission of the
crime, the courts shall be assisted by expert
psychiatrists/ psychologists.
Being under the influence of alcohol, any
Sec. 27. Prohibited illicit drug, or any other mind-altering substance
Defense. shall not be a defense under this Act.
In addition to their rights under existing laws,
victims of violence against women and their
children shall have the following rights.
1. to be treated with respect and dignity;
❑ Religion- Several religious beliefs exists within the country, including Roman Catholicism,
the Aglipayan Church, Anitism and Islam, among many others. These different faiths have their own
views and opinions towards the topic of homosexuality.
1. Roman Catholicism-
• The Philippines is a predominantly Catholic country with approximately 82.9% of the
population claiming to be Roman Catholics. The Roman Catholic Church has been one of the
most active religious organizations in the country in opposition to the LGBT community.
• The Catholic Bishops' Conference of the Philippines firmly states that marriage should only exist
between a man and a woman.
• They also stated that "A homosexual union is not and can never be a marriage as properly
understood and so-called."
• However, according to Archbishop Socrates Villegas, "being a homosexual is not a sin. It is a
state of a person.“ The Catholic Bishops’ Conference of the Philippines made a statement
welcoming the LGBT community, stating that gay people should be "welcomed with respect and
sensitivity"
2. Metropolitan Community Church 3. Philippine Independent Church
• The Metropolitan Community Church (MCC) is • The Philippine Independent Church (also known as
a progressive, LGBT-affirming and ecumenical Iglesia Filipina Independiente and Aglipayan Church)
has had a history of violence against members of the
Christian Denomination that started in Los
LGBT community.
Angeles, October 6, 1968. It has 3 local
churches in the • However, in the early 21st century, the church position
changed dramatically to an extent where the church
Philippines, Mandaluyong, Makati, and Baguio,
leadership apologized through an official statement to
has been celebrating weddings between same- the LGBT community.
sex couples since the 1991.
• The apology statement's groundwork first came up in
• The local churches consider themselves as an 2014, when a gay man articulated during the church
ecumenical Christian church which performs plenary his query about the church's plans for sexual
weddings for LGBTQI+ couples "regardless of minorities.
their Christian backgrounds". • This led to discussions among the newly elected set of
• The church leadership has said that "weddings national youth officers, led by an openly gay president
and a lesbian executive vice president, which would later
are an inherent right of people who love each
be succeeded by another openly gay president. The
other. church position on LGBT persons was officially adopted
• The executive director of the non-governmental by the entire church in February 2017.
organization EnGendeRights has said that while
the same-sex marriages performed by the MCC
are not recognized civilly or legally, they are
considered valid under the MCC's religious
4. Iglesia ni Cristo
• The Iglesia ni Cristo adheres to the teachings of the Bible and they denounce those who
practice homosexual acts, as they are seen as immoral and wicked.
• The organization has been called by international human rights organizations as one of the
most homophobic religious sects operating in the Philippines.
• These acts include having sexual affairs and relations with partners of the same sex, cross-
dressing, and same-sex marriage. Furthermore, men are not allowed to have long hair, for it is
seen as a symbol of femininity and should be exclusive to women only. LGBT people born into
INC families reportedly suffer the greatest as their existence is branded explicitly as wicked by
their own family and the pastor of their locality.
• Hate crimes and forced conversion therapy committed by family members towards INC LGBT
teenagers have also surfaced and are backed by the Templo Sentral, the central establishment of
the INC church.
• The INC has been widely known to the Filipino LGBT community as the most dangerous and
discriminating religion for LGBT Filipinos. The church believes that no matter what a person
does, good or bad, if the person is homosexual (closeted or not), he or she will still burn in hell.
5. United Methodist Church
• The position of the United Methodist Church towards LGBT-inclusiveness is divided worldwide. In
developed nations, members of the church tend to be more in favor of LGBT rights, whereas
members in developing nations tend to oppose.
• In 2019, during a worldwide church meeting, held in the United States, Filipino delegates voted in
favor of a strengthened ban on LGBT members. The agenda was approved with 438 voting in favor
and 384 voting against.
6. Islam
• For Muslim communities in the Philippines, dealing with homosexuality or transgender issues is a
matter of sin and heresy. The city of Marawi, which has declared itself as an "Islamic City", has
passed an ordinance that allows discrimination against LGBT citizens.
• The ordinance has yet to be challenged in court. Mohagher Iqbal, a senior MILF leader once said that
"we have no policy to kill gays and lesbians, but we discourage homosexuality". The statement came
after reports that LGBT people are fleeing Marawi and a surge of reported derision and abuse at home
and discrimination at school had steadily increased.
7. Anitism
• Indigenous belief systems and religions in the country, collectively known
as Anitism, regard homosexual acts as part of nature, and thus, acceptable, and to
some extent, even sacred. Local men dressed up in women's apparel and acting
like women were called, among other things, babaylan, bayoguin, bayok, agi-
ngin, asog, bido and binabae.
• Some of these feminized men worked as spiritual leaders or shamans. They were
respected leaders and figures of authority: religious functionaries and shamans.
However, due to the influential spread of Islam in the south and Christianity in the
entire country, such indigenous belief systems were
subjugated. Concepts of homosexuality, bisexuality, and hermaphrodites are
known in the epics and indigenous stories in Anitism.
• Around 2% of the population continue to practice the religion.
❑ Media
• Recognized as an important venue for the promotion of issues related to the LGBT community
by participants in national dialogue facilitated by the UNDP, the media acknowledges the
negative impact of religion concerning the treatment of such issues, where it provides a blanket
context that society views homosexuality as negative.
• In May 2004, producers of several television programs received a memorandum from the chair
of the Movie and Television Review and Classification Board (MTRCB), which warned against
positive depictions of lesbian relationships; it was stated in the memo that "lesbian and
homosexual relationships are an abnormality/aberration on prime-time TV programs gives the
impression that the network is encouraging homosexual relationships.“
• The lack of sexual orientation and gender identity awareness is emphasized in other
circumstances; transphobia is ubiquitous with media practitioners who do not address
transgender people in accordance with how they self-identify.
• Beyond mainstream media, which already has a niche for the sector, the Internet has provided
LGBT people ways to tell their stories outside the realm of film, television, print, and radio.
There are blogs kept, opportunities to connect with others, publications with LGBT sections
and a web-based magazine, Outrage, catering to the community.
❑ Economy
• The LGBT community, although a minority in the economic sphere, still plays an integral role in the
growth and maintenance of the economy. LGBT individuals face challenges in employment both on
an individual level and as members of a community that is subject to discrimination and abuse. This
can be compounded by the weak social status and position of the individuals involved.
• A USAID study conducted in 2014, entitled "The Relationship between LGBT Inclusion and
Economic Development: An Analysis of Emerging Economies", has shown that countries which
have adopted anti-LGBT economic laws have lower GDPs compared to those who do not
discriminate against employers/employees based on their sexual orientation.
• On the other hand, studies have shown that the integration of the LGBT community into the
economic system yields a higher income for the country. In a recent USAID study, it is said that a
wide range of scholarly theories from economics, political science, sociology, psychology, public
health and other social sciences support the idea that full rights and inclusion of LGBT people are
associated with higher levels of economic development and well-being for the country.
• Also, the acceptance of LGBT people within the office environment can lead to higher income for
the company since the people do not feel as disadvantaged and as discriminated as before.
• Naturally, passing a non-discrimination law will not immediately lead to a sudden boost in the
country's economy, although less discrimination should eventually lead to more output.
LESSON 20:
Discrimination on the Basis of
Sexual Orientation, Gender
Identity and Expression
(SOGIE)in the Philippines.
Enacting an Anti-Discrimination Based on Sexual Orientation and
Gender Identity Law
WHAT IS THE ISSUE? WHAT HAS BEEN OUR
RECENT EXPERIENCE/S WITH REGARDS TO ❑ Prejudicial attitudes of some law enforcers and
THE ISSUE? service providers towards LGBT people deter
❑ Persons with diverse sexual orientation and them from reporting cases of abuse and
gender identity (SOGI) experience abuse and
violence (ranging from subtle jokes to extreme violence committed against them.
forms of stigma and assault) from their families, ❑ The stigma that LGBTs face in everyday life
neighbors, educational/training institutions and
even from government institutions. takes a toll on their mental and physical well-
❑ Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual and Transgender
being. takes a toll on their mental and physical
(LGBT) people also experience lost economic well-being.
opportunities due to discrimination in
employment such as being required to wear
❑ The study also established that long-term
clothes according to their sexassigned at birth as bullying is a major contributory factor to
condition for hiring and outright refusal to hire depression, anxiety, loss of confidence,
applicants on the ground of their SOGI.
withdrawal, social isolations, self-harm and
❑ Prejudicial attitudes of some law enforcers and suicidal tendencies among the victims.
service providers towards LGBT people deter
them from reporting cases of abuse and violence ❑ The lack of a national policy as legal basis to
committed against them. address these discriminatory practices leaves
the LGBTs with no recourse for redress.
❑ This results to continued violations of LGBTs
human rights by private as well as public
institutions and individuals.
WHY IS THE ISSUE IMPORTANT?
❑ Eliminating discrimination based on SOGI will
address disparity in treatment that stems from
❑ Schools or academic institutions assert
gender biases and double standards that provide their academic freedom in
protection selectively to those who adhere to the institutionalizing policies against cross-
patriarchal concept of male and female, and dressing and reserve the right not to accept
discriminate against those who do not fit in the or even expel students that violate these
socially constructed norms of what is a man and a
woman.
policies.
❑ Although the 1987 Philippine Constitution ❑ Enacting an Anti-Discrimination Law will
guarantees the right of every person to equal affirm and enforce the equal application of
protection of the laws, without distinction or existing laws that protect the human rights
discrimination, the laws protecting human rights are
of those who face human rights violation
not being equally applied especially to persons with
diverse SOGI. because of their SOGI and will address the
impunity by which they are discriminated.
❑ Private establishments and companies assert their
management prerogative in hiring and
distinguishing who can and cannot enter their
premises which sometimes discriminate against
LGBTs.
WHAT ARE THE EXISTING LAWS OR POLICIES RELATED TO THE
ISSUE?
❑ In the legal battle for gender equality, there have been cases
that were ruled in favor of LGBTs such as when the Supreme
Court ruled in favor of the Ang Ladlad Partylist, declaring
that the LGBT sector deserves to participate in the party-list
system on the same basis as other marginalized and under-
represented sectors.
❑ In another case, wherein the husband petitioned for the
custody of his child with an estranged wife whom the
petitioner claimed was immoral on the grounds that the ex-
wife had a lesbian relationship, the Court decided in favor of
the wife saying that “moral laxity alone does not prove
parental neglect or incompetence”
WHAT ARE THE CONSIDERATIONS IN
ADDRESSING THIS ISSUE IN THE COUNTRY?
2. Responding to International Commitments
1. Promoting women’s rights and gender
equality ❑ Protection of the rights of persons with diverse SOGI or
the LGBT community is embedded in international
human rights laws/ treaties.
❑ Enacting a law that prohibits and
penalizes acts of discrimination based ❑ The Universal Declaration of Human Rights declares
on SOGI will contribute to the that everyone has the right to life, security of person and
achievement of gender equality. privacy, the right to be free from torture, arbitrary arrest
and detention, the right to be free from discrimination
and the right to freedom of expression, and association.
❑ An anti-discrimination law will ensure
that all people, regardless of SOGI are ❑ The International Convention on Civil and Political
able to exercise their rights to life, Rights (ICCPR) affirms that the inherent right to life of
education, employment and expression every person shall be protected by law and that no
without fear of reprisal, torture, arrest person should be arbitrarily deprived of life.
and detention.
POLICY RECOMMENDATION
▣ Consistent with the Philippine Constitution mandating 4. Provide guidelines in: a) handling of LGBT victims of
SOGI-based discrimination and abuse, and b) handling
the State to uphold the equal protection of all people LGBTs arrested and detained for criminal and civil offense;
before the law, the PCW supports the passage of the
anti-discrimination law that will ensure that human 5. Mandate the review and repeal or amendment of
rights of all people, regardless of their SOGI, are provisions of existing national and local policies
protected and promoted. The PCW pushes for a law that discriminatory to LGBTs (e.g., Amend RPC to define acts
that constitutes grave scandal provision of the RPC, DOH
will: Memorandum that forbids homosexuals to donate blood);
1. Penalize discriminatory acts such as but not limited to: non-
hiring or dismissal of workers, refusal of admission from
6. Mandate the crafting of non-discriminatory policies in
any educational institution, denial of access to services employment and job retention, training and education;
available to the general public, revocation of license, denial 7. Mandate awareness-raising campaigns with media, public
of access to establishments or facilities on the basis of and private institutions, educational and training institutions;
SOGI; and
2. Establish mechanism to monitor, report and record incidents 8. Integrate orientation on SOGI rights in new employee
of SOGI-based discrimination and abuse;
3. Create redress mechanism to address complaints of acts of
orientation in in both public and private institutions.
discrimination;
▣ The PCW or Philippine Commission on
Women reiterates its advocacy to end gender-
based discrimination and recommends the
passage of an antidiscrimination bill that
prohibits discriminatory practices based on
SOGI. The enactment of such law is deemed
necessary towards ending all forms of gender
discrimination, and the achievement of gender
equality.
Thank you for listening
☺☺☺
References
▣ https://www.slideshare.net/FayeMadrigal1/ra-9262-vawc
▣ https://20Policy-Brief-11-SOGIE.pdf