they contribute? Characteristics of a Participant-Oriented Approach • The evaluation is dependent on inductive reasoning • The evaluation utilizes data from multiple sources • The evaluation does not follow a standard plan • The evaluation records multiple point-of-views or perspectives Three Theorists Involved in Approach
Egon Guba & Yvonne
Robert Stake Michael Q. Patton Lincoln Advantages of This Approach • Gain new insights and usable theories Educational, social or corporate programs • Flexibility Addresses user training as a feature of the assessment Consideration to related variables Numerous data collection techniques • Empowers stakeholders Reaches even those who are at times left out of the evaluation process Add a political constituent Cultivates activism(Fitzpatrick, Sanders, and Worthen, 2004) Disadvantages of This Approach • Subjective Relies heavily on human observation and personal perspective • Expensive • Labor-intensive • Time-consuming and extensive • Evaluator loses objectivity may become caught up in advocacy trends(Fitzpatrick, Sanders, and Worthen, 2004) Scenarios for Use of Participant-Oriented Evaluation • Social reform • Evaluating programs developed to improve the environment • Education Evaluating new and existing instructional programs on all levels Evaluating instructional materials Evaluating professional development • Corporations Evaluating new and existing training programs • Government Evaluating programs • Whenever qualitative formative evaluation is conducted