Professional Documents
Culture Documents
8
3 Models of Management Ethics
3. Amoral Management—
Intentional - does not consider ethical factors
Unintentional - casual or careless about ethical
considerations in business
9
Developing Moral Judgment
6-23
Making Ethical Judgments
Value judgments
and perceptions of
the observer
11
Warren Buffet’s rule of thumb for
ethical conduct
“…I want employees to ask themselves (when
they are in doubt about whether a particular
conduct is ethical or not) whether they are
willing to have any contemplated act appear the
next day on the front page of their local paper –
to be read by their spouses, children and friends
– with the reporting done by an informed and
critical reporter.” [Berkshire Hathaway’s code of
ethics]
What is Business Ethics ?
• Business ethics is the application of general ethical
ideas to business behaviour & business ethics is not
a special set of ethical ideas different from ethics
from general
• If dishonesty is considered to be unethical and
immoral, then anyone in business who is dishonest
with stakeholders is acting unethically and
immorally
• If protecting others from harm is considered to be
ethical, then company that recalls a dangerously
defective products is acting in ethical way
What is Business Ethics ?
•To be considered ethical, business must draw its
ideas about what is proper behaviour from the same
sources as everyone. Business should not try to
make up its own definitions of what is right and
wrong
What is Business Ethics ?
Observations of Unethical Behavior at Work
Fifty-two percent of employees observed at least one type of misconduct
in the workplace in the past year Types of misconduct include (in order
of frequency observed):
• Abusive or intimidating behavior toward employees
•Lying to employees, customers, vendors, or the public
•A situation that places employee interests over organizational interests
•Violations of safety regulations
•Misreporting of actual time worked
•Discrimination on the basis of race, color, gender, age or similar
categories
•Stealing or theft
•Sexual harassment
Source: 2005 National Business Ethics Survey, Ethics Resource Center,
Washington, D.C
Some Examples
• Toyota Motor Company has announced a recall
campaign for the RAV4 model in the United States,
soon extending it globally- The 1,124,000 vehicles
that will be called back in the U.S. are RAV4 units of the
2006-2012 model years and MY 2012-2014 RAV4 EV
models.
•Toyota is making this precautionary recall action to
improve the safety
of the second-row outboard seats on both sides of the
vehicle
http://www.autoevolution.com/news/toyota-will-recall-11-million-rav4-models-in-the-usa-
104778.html#; 18 February 2016
Some Examples
• Mitsubishi Motors admitted that it had used
improper methods to test the fuel economy of cars
sold in Japan for 25 years, drastically widening the
scope of a mileage-doctoring scandal gripping the
company.
•The automaker said it still did not know exactly how
many models had been given exaggerated fuel
ratings. But it said it now believed it had been using
unapproved methods since 1991 — a period that
covers dozens of vehicle introductions and millions
of cars and trucks.
http://www.nytimes.com/2016/04/27/business/interna
Some Examples
In September 2015
the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) found
that many Volkswagen cars being sold in America
had a "defeat device" - or software - in diesel
engines that could detect when they were being
tested, changing the performance accordingly to
improve results. The German car giant has since
admitted cheating emissions tests in the USA. With
VW recalling millions of cars worldwide from early
next year, it has set aside €6.7bn (£4.8bn) to cover
costs. That resulted in the company posting its
first quarterly loss for 15 years of €2.5bn in late
October.
Red Bull said it could "give you wings”
Energy drinks company Red Bull was
sued in 2014 for its slogan "Red Bull gives you wings." The company
settled the class action case by agreeing to pay out a maximum of $13
million — including $10 to every US consumer who had bough the
drink since 2002.
The tagline, which the company has used for nearly two decades, went
alongside marketing claims that that the caffeinated drink could
improve a consumer's concentration and reaction speed.
Beganin Caraethers was one of several consumers who brought the
case against the Austrian drinks company. He said he was a regular
consumer of Red Bull for 10 years, but that he had not developed
"wings," or shown any signs of improved intellectual or physical
abilities.
Red Bull released this statement following the settlement:
Red Bull settled the lawsuit to avoid the cost and distraction of
litigation. However, Red Bull maintains that its marketing and
labeling have always been truthful and accurate, and denies any and
New Balance said its shoe could help wearers burn
calories
New Balance was accused of false advertising in
2011 over a sneaker range that it claimed could help
wearers burn calories, according to Reuters. Studies
found that there were no health benefits from wearing
the shoe.
The toning sneaker claimed to use hidden board
technology and was advertised as calorie burners that
activated the quads, hamstrings and calves. Plaintiffs
in the lawsuit claimed to have been harmed and
misled by the sneaker company.
On August 20, 2012, New Balance agreed to pay a
settlement of $2.3 million,
according to The Huffington Post
Why Business should be ethical?
A. Meet Demands of Business Stakeholders
• Organizational stakeholders demand business to
exhibit high levels of ethical performance and social
responsibility
• In a 10-country poll of public opinion, people in 9 of
the 10 countries (Australia, Canada, Great Britain,
Mexico, Japan, Germany, South Africa, Russia, and
the United States, with only the Chinese people
disagreeing) preferred setting higher ethical standards
and improving society over the more traditional
corporate goals of making a profit, paying taxes,
creating jobs, and obeying the law
Why Business should be ethical?
A. Meet Demands of Business Stakeholders
• Some businesses know that meeting stakeholders’
expectations is good business
• When a company upholds ethical standards,
consumers may conduct more business with the firm
and the stockholders may benefit as well
B. Enhance Business Standards
• Being ethical imparts a sense of trust, which promotes
positive alliances among business partners
• If this trust is broken, the unethical party may be
shunned and ignored
Why Business should be ethical?
B. Enhance Business Standards
• The nurturing of an ethical environment and the
development of ethical safeguards can be critical,
influences in positively affecting a firm’s financial
performance
. Conflicts of Interest
• A conflict of interest occurs when an individual’s self-
interest conflicts with acting in the best interest of
another, when the individual has an obligation to do so
• For example, if a purchasing agent directed her
company’s orders to a firm from which she had received a
valuable gift, even if this firm did not offer the best
quality or value, she would be guilty of a conflict of
interest
Why Ethical problems occur?
Conflicts of Interest
• Conflicts of interest are normally considered unethical,
because a failure to disclose a conflict of interest
represents deception and may hurt the person or
organization
• In recent years, much attention has been focused on
organizational conflicts of interest in the accounting
profession
• When an accounting firm audits the books of a public
company, it has an obligation to shareholders to
provide an honest account of the company’s financial
health, but sometimes, though, accounting firms may
be tempted to overlook irregularities to increase their
chances of attracting lucrative consulting work from the
Why Ethical problems occur?
D. Cross-Cultural Contradictions
• Some of the knottiest ethical problems occur as corporations
do business in other societies where ethical standards differ
from those at home
• Today, the policy makers and strategic planners in all
multinational corporations, regardless of the nation where
they are headquartered, face this kind of ethical dilemma
• Are multinational companies ethically responsible for what
happens to their products, even though they are being sold
legally? What or whose ethical standards should be the guide?
• As business becomes increasingly global, with more and more
corporations penetrating overseas markets where cultures and
ethical traditions vary, these questions will occur more
frequently
Why Ethical problems occur?
D. Cross-Cultural Contradictions - Example
Consider the following situation: The pesticide methyl parathion is
officially banned or restricted in many countries including the United
States, China, Malaysia, Indonesia, and Cambodia. The World Health
Organization classified methyl parathion as “extremely hazardous.”
The
chemical can be fatal for humans if swallowed, inhaled, or absorbed
through the skin. Yet, methyl parathion and nearly 50 other dangerous
pesticides are being sold in Thailand and Vietnam and, from there,
being illegally exported to Cambodia. Cambodian farmers argue that
they need the pesticides to increase agricultural production, despite the
lack of protective safety equipment or procedures for properly
disposing of used containers. Multinational companies that manufacture
the chemicals say that they are not responsible because they do not
directly market to Cambodia. This episode raises the issue of ethical
relativism, alluded to earlier in this chapter. Although the foreign sales
of methyl parathion to Thailand and Vietnam were legal, were they
Consequences of ethical problems
• Reduced sales of goods - Customers may boycott
goods produced by company for unethical behaviours
Age Group Development Stage and Major Ethics Referent Basics of Ethics
Reasoning