You are on page 1of 89

ETAP Real-Time

Operation

Maintenance

Planning

Operation Technology, Inc.


Irvine, California
ETAP Real-Time

Monitor

Simulate

Operate Analyze
Optimize
Predict Control
Manage
ETAP Real -Time
ETAP Real-Time

Power System Monitoring & Simulation

Energy Management System

Intelligent Load Shedding


ETAP Real -Time
ETAP Real-Time
Operations Maintenance

Financial

Engineering
Planning
As a component of the Enterprise Resource Planning
(ERP) system, ETAP optimizes the exchange of
information between diverse tiers of an organization
while channeling domain sensitive information.
Market Solutions
 Oil Refineries
 Oil Platforms
 Oil Production Fields
 Chemical Plants
 Mining
 Manufacturing Plants
 Health Care Facilities
 Generation Plants
 Data Centers
 Switchgear & Relay Manufacturers
ETAP Real -Time
Objectives
 Optimize Operation
 Optimal Load Shedding
 Prevent Downtime
 Minimize System Losses
 Minimize Energy Costs
 Predict System Response
 Train & Assist Operators
 Prevent Outage Due to Operator Error
 Safe Operation & Avoid Penalties
 Improve Equipment Life Time
 Provide Data Accessibility
ETAP Real -Time
ETAP Real-Time Users

ETAP Real -Time


OTI Test Lab

ETAP Real -Time


System Architecture

ETAP Real -Time


Bring Your ETAP To Life

ETAP Real -Time


Client Server Architect

Windows 2000 / XP, Multitasking


ETAP Real -Time
Protocols & Standards
 MMS  T103
 ModBus  NetDDE
 NetBeui  UCA
 DNP  IPX/SPX (Netware)
 ICCP  TCP/IP
 IEC870  OPC

ETAP Real -Time


Power System Monitoring & Simulation
 Virtual Monitoring
 Advanced Monitoring
 Real-Time Simulation
 Online Control
 Event Playback
 Trending
 Alarm & Warning
 Energy Cost Analysis
Power System Monitoring & Simulation
Monitoring Capabilities
 Multi-Console Server/Client Monitoring
 Graphical Monitoring via ETAP One-Line Diagram
 Visual Monitoring via Watch Windows (MMI)
 Archived (Historical) Data Retrieval / Display
 Electrical & Non-Electrical Metering Tags
 OPC Interface Layer
 Multi-Access Levels

Power System Monitoring & Simulation


Advantages of ETAP
 Intelligence
 Simple to Modify the System
 Option to Override Monitored Data
 Online Switching & Breaker Operation
 Visual Monitoring (MMI) by Watch Windows

Power System Monitoring & Simulation


Virtual Monitoring

Power System Monitoring & Simulation


Virtual Monitoring

Power System Monitoring & Simulation


Virtual Monitoring

Power System Monitoring & Simulation


Standard Monitoring Systems
Shortcomings
 Display Data on Static Images and Objects
 High Costs to Setup & Maintenance MMI
 Require Hardware for Every Monitored Point
 Modifications Require New Static Images
 Does Not Recognize Bad Data
 Lack Electrical Intelligence
 Primitive Data Reconciliation

Power System Monitoring & Simulation


Advanced Monitoring

Power System Monitoring & Simulation


Advanced Monitoring

Error Detection

Power System Monitoring & Simulation


Advanced Monitoring

Load Estimator / Distributor


Power System Monitoring & Simulation
Advanced Monitoring
 State Estimator
 Load Estimator / Distributor
 Error Detection
 Global (Server) & Local Alarm & Warning
 Alarm & Warning Acknowledgement
 Equipment Overload Detection
 Over-Voltage & Under-Voltage Detection
 Graphical Notification via One-Line Diagrams
 Pinned Data (Override Monitored Data)
Power System Monitoring & Simulation
Real-Time Simulation
Predict System Behavior to Operator Actions
 Open/Close Circuit Breakers
 Reject Generators
 Load Impact & Ramping
 Accelerate Motors
 Protective Device Sequence-of-Operation

Conduct Engineering Analysis


 Using Actual Operating Loading, Generation, &
Configuration

Power System Monitoring & Simulation


Real-Time Simulation

Power System Monitoring & Simulation


Real-Time Simulation

Power System Monitoring & Simulation


Real-Time Simulation
Simulation Modules
 Load Flow  Sequence-of-Operation
 Motor Acceleration  Harmonics
 Short-Circuit ANSI/IEC  Transient Stability
 Arc Flash  Reliability Assessment
 Device Coordination &  More...
Selectivity

Power System Monitoring & Simulation


Event Playback

Power System Monitoring & Simulation


Event Playback
Playback Forward
Playback Reverse
Set Speed/Scan Rate
Pause
Step Forward
Step Reverse
Next Event
Previous Event
Scan Forward
Scan Reverse
Display Options

Power System Monitoring & Simulation


Event Playback

Power System Monitoring & Simulation


Event Playback
 Replay Archived Historian Data
 Improve Operator Knowledge
 Predict System Behavior On-Demand
 Investigate Cause & Effect
 Explore Alternative Actions
 Replay “What If” Scenarios

Power System Monitoring & Simulation


Energy Management System
 Intelligent Energy Management
 Demand-Side Management
 Automatic Generation Control
 System Optimization & Automation

Energy Management System


Energy Management System
Real-Time Data

Optimization
Requirements EMS System
Control

System Topology

Energy Management System


Energy Management System
 Auto Control Overload, OverVoltage & UnderVoltage
 Auto Control Generation, LTC, Shunt Capacitor, …
 Generation MW & Mvar Averaging with $ Constraints
 Minimize System Losses
 Peak Shaving
 Minimize Mvar & Power Factor Penalties
 Active Inhibition & Permissive Control of Load & Generation
 Optimize Spin Reserve
 Maximize Voltage Security Index
 …
Energy Management System
Energy Management System
Optimization Control
 Optimization Objectives

 Bus Voltage Constraints

 Branch Flow Constraints

 Control Movement Constraints

 User-Definable Constraints (Macros)

 Energy Costs (Generation & Exchange Power)


Energy Management System
Energy Management System
Savings
 Reduce Energy Costs
 Reduce Peak MWh Costs
 Reduce Mvar / Power Factor Penalties
 Improve System Operation & Stability
 Increase Equipment Life Time
 Increase System Capacity

Energy Management System


Intelligent Load Shedding

Intelligent Load Shedding


Intelligent Load Shedding
Objectives
 Operation Dependent
 Fast Response
 Optimal Load Shedding

Intelligent Load Shedding


Load Shedding

Why Load Shed:


 Partial loss of energy source due to a disturbance
(Generators and/or Utility Connections)

Optimal Load Shedding:


 Best combination (also minimum) load that must be
removed to keep the system operational

Load Shedding Protection is Essential:


 Critical loads with limited power supply

Intelligent Load Shedding


Improper Load Shedding

 Shed Too Much Load

 Loss of Critical Process

 Total Loss of Production

 Safety & Environmental Concerns

 $$$
Intelligent Load Shedding
Conventional Methods

A. Breaker Interlock Scheme

B. Under-Frequency Relay (81)

C. PLC-Based Load Shedding

Intelligent Load Shedding


Breaker Interlock Scheme

Shed load larger than max. import power


Intelligent Load Shedding
Breaker Interlock Scheme
 Advantages
 Fast Action
 Simple to implement
 Limitations
 Fixed load priority
 Only one stage of load shedding
 Usually more loads are shed than needed
 Modifications are costly and impractical
 Can result in complete system shutdown

Intelligent Load Shedding


Under-Frequency Relay (81)

Shed fixed load based on 81 relay settings


Intelligent Load Shedding
Under-Frequency Relay (81)

Frequency Delay MW
Stage
Hz Sec. Shed
1 58.5 0.25 10
2 57.5 2.00 30
Intelligent Load Shedding
Under-Frequency Relay (81)

 Features
 Detects after effects of disturbances

 Detects frequency & rate of change

 Can have multiple stage settings

 Settings are based on analysis

 Fixed settings (10% of load for .5 Hz drop)

Intelligent Load Shedding


Under-Frequency Relay (81)

 Limitations
 Slow response time

 Lack of knowledge about system loading

 Lack of knowledge about the disturbance

 Lack of knowledge about spin reserve

 Analysis knowledge is always lost


Intelligent Load Shedding
PLC-Based Load Shedding

Shed load based on the PLC tables


Intelligent Load Shedding
PLC-Based Load Shedding

 Advantages

 Access to system loading


 Access to system generation
 Access to CB operating status
 Knowledge about spin reserve

Intelligent Load Shedding


PLC-Based Load Shedding

 Limitations
 Lack of system topology / connectivity / islanding

 Lack of system islanding conditions

 Load priority is predefined and fixed

 Slow response - initiation from frequency relays

 Drop load based on the frequency relay settings

 Fixed logic – calculations are preformed at PLC


Intelligent Load Shedding
Needs for Fast Response

Load 1
P+jQ
Gen Load 2

Load 3

Normal Operation – 0 Spin Reserve

Intelligent Load Shedding


Needs for Fast Response

Load 1
j QG j QL
Gen Load 2

P=0 Load 3

3-Phase Fault for 5 Cycles

Intelligent Load Shedding


Needs for Fast Response

Load 1
P’ + j Q’
Gen Load 2
P’ > P
Q’ >> Q Load 3

Power Inrush after Fault Clearance

Intelligent Load Shedding


Needs for Fast Response

Load 1
P+jQ
Gen Load 2

Load 3

Slow Load Shedding

Intelligent Load Shedding


Needs for Fast Response

Load 1
P+jQ
Gen Load 2

Load 3

Fast Load Shedding

Intelligent Load Shedding


Needs for Optimal Solution
Requires Intelligence to Recognize
 System Topology
 Configuration
 Operating Status
 Generation Level
 Power Exchange
 Operating Load
 Spin Reserve
 Disturbance Type & Location
 Transient Response to Disturbances
Intelligent Load Shedding
Needs for Optimal Solution
P1 + jQ1
P+jQ Load 1
P2 + jQ2
Gen1 Load 2
P3 + jQ3
Load 3
P4 + jQ4
Load 4
P’ + j Q’ P5 + jQ5
Gen2 Load 5
P6 + jQ6
Load 6
Study Condition
Intelligent Load Shedding
Needs for Optimal Solution
jQ Load 1
jQ
Gen1 Load 2

Load 3

Load 4
jQ jQ
Gen2 Load 5

Load 6
Study Disturbance
Intelligent Load Shedding
Needs for Optimal Solution
P1 + jQ1
Load 1
P+jQ
Gen1 Load 2
P3 + jQ3
Load 3

Load 4
P’ + j Q’
Gen2 Load 5
P6 + jQ6
Load 6
Study 81 Relay Response
Intelligent Load Shedding
Needs for Optimal Solution
P1 + jQ1
Load 1
P+jQ
Gen1 Load 2
P3 + jQ3
Load 3
P4 + jQ4
Load 4
P’ + j Q’
P5 + jQ5
Gen2 Load 5
P6 + jQ6
Load 6
Actual Operating Condition
Intelligent Load Shedding
Needs for Optimal Solution
jQ1
Load 1
jQ
Gen1 Load 2
jQ3
Load 3
P4 + jQ4
Load 4
P’ + j Q’
P5 + jQ5
Gen2 Load 5
P6 + jQ6
Load 6
Actual Operating Condition
Intelligent Load Shedding
Needs for Optimal Solution
P1 + jQ1
Load 1
P+jQ
Gen1 Load 2
P3 + jQ3
Load 3

Load 4
P’ + j Q’
Gen2 Load 5
P6 + jQ6
Load 6
81 Relay Response
Intelligent Load Shedding
Intelligent Load Shedding
Objective
 Shed Minimum Load
Dependencies
 Disturbance Type & Location
 Generation Level
 Spin Reserve
 System Configuration
 System Loading
 Load Distribution
 Operation Constraints
 Individual Circuit Breaker Loading
Intelligent Load Shedding
Intelligent Load Shedding

How to Achieve Objectives


 Fast Load Shedding (less than 100ms)
 Optimal Combinations of Loads (CBs)
 Neural Network + Direct Logic
 Knowledge Base
 Direct User-Definable Logic
 Multiple Subsystems

Intelligent Load Shedding


ILS Knowledge Base

 Hundreds of TS Studies Stored

 System Knowledge is Never Lost

Intelligent Load Shedding


ILS Configuration

Intelligent Load Shedding


Intelligent Load Shedding

Intelligent Load Shedding


Intelligent Load Shedding
Fault
Detection CB
(50) Trip
Trigger
Signal
to CB

Fault
Time
Clearing 10 70
ms

Local 10 30 90
Time
PLC ms

Trigger PLC Load


Received Output CB
by PLC Triggers Open

Remote 70 90 150
Time
PLCs 30 ms

Trigger PLC Load


Received Output CB
by PLCs Triggers Open

Fast Load Shedding


Intelligent Load Shedding
Intelligent Load Shedding
Fault
Detection CB
(50) Trip
Trigger
Signal
to CB

Fault
Time
Clearing 0.5 5.5
Cy

Local 0.5 2 7
Time
PLC Cy

Trigger PLC Load


Received Output CB
by PLC Triggers Open

Remote 5.5 7 12
Time
PLCs 2 Cy

Trigger PLC Load


Received Output CB
by PLCs Triggers Open

Fast Load Shedding


Intelligent Load Shedding
Intelligent Load Shedding
ILS vs. Frequency Relay LS

Intelligent Load Shedding


Intelligent Load Shedding
ILS vs. Frequency Relay LS

Intelligent Load Shedding


ILS Comparison

PMS PowerLogic PMS Frequency


ETAP ILS
Siemens SQD ABB Relays

Response <100ms 100ms* 150ms** <100ms** Seconds

* PLC time only ** Exclude detection of signal

Fault 81 Relay
100ms to 500ms

Time

150ms to 300ms
PLC Load
Receives CB
Signal Open

Intelligent Load Shedding


Intelligent Load Shedding
ILS vs. PLC Based LS

Intelligent Load Shedding


Intelligent Load Shedding

Key Features
 User-Defined Load Priority
 User-Defined Load Groups
 Unlimited Load Shedding Schedules
 Operator Friendly Interface
 On-Line Testing to Validate ILS Actions
 User-Defined Trigger Inhibition
 Operator Alerts

Intelligent Load Shedding


Optimal CB Combination

Load Shed Req. to


MW Load Shed
16.00
ILS Group1 7.22
2.00
4.57
ILS Group2 3.25 17.04 -1.04

PLC Based 7.22


2.00
4.57
8.23 22.02 -6.02

Intelligent Load Shedding


ILS Operator Friendly Interface

Operator Display
 Load MW
 Loads to Shed
 Spinning Reserve
 Required Load to Shed
 Active Triggers

Unlimited Load Shedding Schedules


Intelligent Load Shedding
ILS Load Shed Verification

Intelligent Load Shedding


ILS Configuration

Intelligent Load Shedding


ILS Normal Operation

ILS Server

Intelligent Load Shedding


PLC Based Backup Operation
System Data

X
Frequency Relay

ILS Server
Intelligent Load Shedding
ILS Response
Response to Mechanical & Electrical Disturbances
 Generator Breaker Trip
 Utility Main Breaker Trip
 Fuel Availability
 Process Alarms
 Faults in the System
 Spinning Reserve Availability
 User-Customizable Triggers

Intelligent Load Shedding


P.T. Newmont Project

Intelligent Load Shedding


P.T. Newmont Project

Intelligent Load Shedding


Integration Services
 Integration Strategy
 System Modeling & Development
 Architecture & Technology Consulting
 Technology Pre-Study & Piloting
 Enterprise Systems Connectivity
 Metering Hardware Evaluation
 Monitoring & Control System Design
 and more
ETAP Real -Time

You might also like