Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Perceptions of the effects of heart failure and its The physical, emotional, social, and mental
2. Quality of treatment on daily life dimensions of daily life when diagnosed with heart
Life failure as measured with the Minnesota Living with
Heart Failure Questionnaire.
Why are Nursing Theories Important?
Nursing theories are the basis of nursing practice today. In many cases, nursing
theory guides knowledge development and directs education, research, and
practice. Historically, nursing was not recognized as an academic discipline or as
a profession we view today. Before nursing theories were developed, nursing was
considered to be a task-oriented occupation. The training and function of nurses
were under the direction and control of the medical profession. Let’s take a look at
the importance of nursing theory and its significance to nursing practice:
Nursing theories help recognize what should set the foundation of practice by
explicitly describing nursing.
Defining nursing, a nursing theory also helps nurses understand their purpose
and role in the healthcare setting.
Theories serve as a rationale or scientific reasons for nursing interventions and
give nurses the knowledge base necessary for acting and responding
appropriately in nursing care situations.
Nursing theories provide the foundations of nursing practice, generate further
knowledge, and indicate which direction nursing should develop in the future
(Brown, 1964).
By providing nurses a sense of identity, nursing theory can help patients,
managers, and other healthcare professionals to acknowledge and understand the
unique contribution that nurses make to the healthcare service (Draper, 1990).
Nursing theories prepare the nurses to reflect on the assumptions and question
the nursing values, thus further defining nursing and increasing the knowledge
base.
Nursing theories aim to define, predict, and demonstrate nursing phenomenon
(Chinn and Jacobs, 1978).
Provide a common language and terminology for nurses to
use in communication and practice.
Serves as a basis for the development of nursing education
and training programs.
In many cases, nursing theories guide knowledge
development and directs education, research, and practice,
although each influences the others. (Fitzpatrick and Whall,
2005).
Purposes of Nursing Theories
There are generally three levels of nursing theory, which begin with abstract ideas and
become more specific according to each level. The three main categories of nursing theories
are grand nursing theories, middle-range nursing theories and practice-level nursing theories.
Different levels of nursing theories may influence others. The following details each type .
1. Grand Nursing Theory- are the broadest category. They’re the most abstract and
complex concepts and propositions that provide a general nursing care framework. A grand
nursing theory can apply to a variety of nursing care environments and situations.
ex. Ida Jean Orlando-Pelletier’s (Deliberative Nursing Process Theory)
This theory examines the definition of the function of nursing and the interaction
between the nurse and the patient. It explains how to use the nursing process to improve patient
outcomes.
2. Middle-Range Nursing Theories
- Middle-range nursing theories are more specific in focus compared to grand nursing
theories, but they’re broader than the more specific practice-level nursing theories. Middle-
range nursing theories may derive from theories of similar disciplines, nursing research or
nursing practice.
- Since they’re less abstract than grand nursing theories, middle-range theories tend to be
more verifiable through testing. These theories attempt to explain, describe or predict specific
issues in clinical nursing practice.
Example: Imogene King’s (Goal Attainment theory)
- This theory focuses on the factors that affect the attainment of certain life goals
and explains how a nurse and a patient can communicate, set goals together and take actions to
achieve goals. The theory examines how the personal system, the interpersonal system and the
social system affect goal attainment.
3. Practice-Level Nursing Theories/Micro-Theories
- Practice-level nursing theories are situation-specific. They’re the most narrow in scope
and focus of the three levels of nursing theories. They may be based on concepts from grand
nursing theories and middle-range nursing theory but provide specific frameworks for specific
nursing interventions.
- Nurses and nurse researchers may apply a practice-level nursing theory when it relates to a
defined patient population at a specific time. Since these theories are more specific and unique,
they may draw upon multiple theories to create the optimal recommended practice for that
particular patient group.
Four Ways of Knowing
1. Empirical Knowing
- evidenced based practice, involves accurate and thoughtful decision making
about health care delivery for clients. Based on the result of the most relevant and
supported evidence.
- there is a scientific, research-based, theoretical, & factual
information that is being use.
Ex. Research, Books
2. Aesthetic Knowing
- EMPHATIC (Primary form) aspect of Nursing.
- Art and act of nursing through practice and critique.
- Related to understanding what is of significance to particular such asa
feelings, attitudes
- Shows compassion, mercy
- Uses laymen terms in explaining the needs of a patient.
Ex. When a nurse place himself in the “patient’s shoes” when
communication, giving judgment and providing care.
3. Ethical Knowing
- describes, analyzes, and clarifies moral obligation and values in nursing.
- Moral directions of Nursing
- Requires knowledge or different philosophical positions what is good and right
in making moral actions and decisions, particularly in the theoretical
- Code of morals or code of ethics that leads the conduct of nurses is the main
basis for Ethical Knowing.
Ex. Presents patient advocate and defends his client’s right to
choose care.
4. Personal Knowing
- Therapeutic use of self
- Takes a lot of time to fully know the nature of oneself in relation to fully
know the nature of oneself in relation to the world around
- Stresses that human beings are not in a fixed state but are
Ex. Good relationship between you and the patient
Nursing Theory Development
- The history of professional nursing began with Florence Nightingale. It was
Nightingale who envisioned nurses as a body of educated women at a time
when women were neither educated nor employed in public service. Following
her service of organizing and caring for the wounded in Scutari, during the
Crimean War, her vision and establishment of a School of Nursing at St.
Thomas’ Hospital in London marked the birth of modern nursing.
- Nightingale’s pioneering activities in nursing practice and subsequent writings
describing nursing education became a guide for establishing nursing schools in
the United States at the beginning of the twentieth century (Kalisch & Kalisch,
2003; Nightingale, 1859/1969). Nursing began with a strong emphasis on
practice, but throughout the century, nurses worked toward the development
of nursing as a profession through successive periods recognized as historical
eras (Alligood, 2006a).
• The curriculum era addressed the question of what prospective nurses should
study to learn how to be a nurse. In this era, the emphasis was on what courses
nursing students should take, with the goal of arriving at a standardized
curriculum (Alligood, 2006a). By the mid-1930s, a standardized curriculum had
been published. However, it was also in this era that the idea of moving nursing
education from hospital-based diploma programs into colleges and universities
emerged. Even so, it was the middle of the century before this goal began to be
acted upon in many states (Kalisch & Kalisch, 2003).
• As nurses increasingly sought degrees in higher education, a research emphasis
era, as it is deemed, began to emerge. This era came about as more and more
nurses embraced higher education and arrived at a common understanding of
the scientific age, that is, that research is the path to new nursing knowledge.
Nurses began to participate in research, and research courses began to be
included in the nursing curricula of many developing graduate programs
(Alligood, 2006a).
- The research era and the graduate education era developed in tandem.
Master’s degree programs in nursing emerged to meet the public need for nurses
with specialized clinical nursing education. Many of these programs included a
nursing research course. It was also in this era that most nursing master’s
programs began to include courses in concept development or nursing models
that introduced students to early nursing theorists and the knowledge
development process (Alligood, 2006a).
- The theory era was a natural outgrowth of the research and graduate education
eras. As our understanding of research and knowledge development increased, it
soon became obvious that research without theory produced isolated
information, and that it was research and theory together that produced nursing
science (Batey, 1977; Fawcett, 1978; Hardy, 1978). In the early years of the theory
era, doctoral education in nursing flourished with an emphasis on theory
development.
- In the theory utilization era, emphasis was placed on middle range theory for
theory-based nursing practice, as well as on theory development (Alligood &
Tomey, 1997, 2002, 2006; Batey, 1977; Chinn & Kramer, 2008; Fawcett, 2005;
Tomey & Alligood, 2006).
- Each era addressed nursing knowledge in a unique way that contributed to and
is observable in the history of nursing. Within each era, the pervading question
“What is the nature of the knowledge that is needed for the practice of nursing?”
seems to have been addressed at the level of understanding that prevailed at
that time (Alligood, 2006a).
- Nightingale’s (1859/1969) vision of nursing has been practiced for more than a
century, and theory development in nursing has evolved rapidly over the past 5
decades, leading to the recognition of nursing as an academic discipline with a
substantive body of knowledge (Alligood, 2006a, 2006b; Alligood & Tomey, 2006;
Chinn & Kramer, 2008; Fawcett, 2005; Tomey & Alligood, 2006; Walker & Avant, 2005).
- In the mid-1800s, Nightingale wrote that nursing knowledge is distinct from medical
knowledge. She described a nurse’s proper function as putting the patient in the best
condition for nature (God) to act upon him or her. She proposed that care of the sick is
based on knowledge of persons and their surroundings—a different knowledge base
than that used by physicians in their practice. Despite this early edict from Nightingale
in the 1850s, it was 100 years later, during the 1950s, that the nursing profession began
to engage in serious discussion about the need to develop, articulate, and test nursing
theory (Alligood, 2006d; Alligood, 2004; Chinn & Kramer, 2008; Meleis, 2007;
Walker & Avant, 2005)).
- Until the emergence of nursing as a science in the 1950s, nursing practice was
based on principles and traditions that had been passed on through an
apprenticeship model of education and hospital-kept procedure manuals
(Alligood, 2002a; Kalisch & Kalisch, 2003.
- The nursing theory era, coupled with an awareness of nursing as a profession and as an
academic discipline in its own right, emerged from debates and discussions in the 1960s
regarding the proper direction and appropriate discipline for nursing knowledge development.
The explosive proliferation of nursing doctoral programs and nursing theory literature
substantiated that nursing doctorates should be in nursing (Nicoll, 1986, 1992, 1997;
Reed, Shearer, & Nicoll, 2003; Reed & Shearer, 2008). In the 1970s, nursing continued to make
the transition from vocation to profession as more and more nurses asked, “Will nursing be
other-discipline based or be nursing based?” The history records the answer, “Nursing practice
needs to be based on nursing science” (Alligood, 2006a; Fawcett, 1978; Nicoll, 1986).
- The 1980s was a period of major developments in nursing theory characterized as
a transition from the pre-paradigm to the paradigm period (Fawcett, 1984;
Hardy, 1978). The prevailing nursing paradigms (models) provided perspectives for
nursing practice, administration, education, research and further theory
development. In the 1980s, Fawcett’s seminal proposal of four global nursing
concepts presented a nursing metaparadigm that served as an organizing structure
for existing nursing frameworks, and introduced a way of grouping what previously
had been viewed as individual theoretical works (Fawcett, 1978, 1984, 1993).
- It was the 1st school of nursing that provided both theory-based knowledge
and clinical skill building.
A. 1860 to 1959
1. In 1860, Florence Nightingale developed her Environmental Theory.
2. In 1952, the journal Nursing Research was established, encouraging
nurses to become involved in scientific inquiry.
3. In the same year, Hildegard Peplau published Interpersonal Relations
in Nursing; her ideas have influenced later nursing theorists.
4. In 1955, Virgina Henderson published Definition of Nursing.
5. In the mid-1950s, Teachers College, Columbia University, New York
City, began offering master's and doctoral programs in nursing education
and administration, resulting in student participation in theory
development and testing.
B. 1960 to 1969
1. During the 1960s, Yale University School of Nursing, New Haven, Conn.,
defined nursing as a process, interaction, and relationship.
2. Also during the 1960s, the U.S. government began funding master's doctoral
education in nursing.
3. In 1960, Faye Abdellah published Twenty-One Nursing Problems.
4.In 1961, Ida Orlando published her theory in The Dynamic Nurse-Patient
Relationship: Function, Process, and Principles of Professional Nursing.
5. In 1962, Lydia Hall published Core, Care, and Cure model.
6. In 1964, Ernestine Wiedenbach published her theory in Clinical Nursing: A
Helping Art
7. In 1965, the American Nurses Association published a position paper
8. In 1966, Myra Levine published Four Conservation Principles.
C. 1970 to 1979
1. During the 1970s, Case Western Reserve University, Cleveland, sponsored symposia
to stimulate theory development.
2. During the mid 1970s, the National League for Nursing established an accreditation
requirement that nursing schools base their curricula on a nursing conceptual framework.
3. In 1970, Martha Rogers published her model in An Introduction to the Theoretical
Basis of Nursing.
4. In 1971, Dorothea Orem published Self-Care Deficit Therory of Nursing, Imogene
King published Theory of Goal Attainment, and Joyce Travelbee published Interpersonal
Aspects of Nursing. Travelbee published Interpersonal Aspects of Nursing.
5. In 1972, Betty Neuman published Health Care Systems Model.
6. In 1976, Sister Callista Roy published Adaptation Model.
7. In 1978, Madeleine Leininger published Humanistic Nursing.
8.In 1979, Jean Watson published Nursing: Human Services and Human Care - A
Theory of Nursing.
D. 1980 TO THE PRESENT
1. In 1982, Joyce Fitzpatrick published Life Perspective Model.
2. In 1984, Patricia Benner published from Novice to Expert:
Excellence and Power in Clinical Nursing Practice and Power in
Clinical Nursing Practice
3. In 1986, Margaret Newman published Model of Health
4. In 1994, Rogers proposed "Occupational Health Nursing Model"
WAYS IN ANALYSIS AND
EVALUATION OF
NURSING THEORY
1. Clarity- “How clear is this theory?”
- Words often have multiple meanings
within and across disciplines;
therefore words should be defined
carefully and specifically to the
framework (philosophy, conceptual
model, or theory) from which it is
derived.
- Diagrams and examples may
facilitate clarity and should be
consistent.
2. Simplicity- “How simple is the theory?”