Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Basic Presentation
Basic Presentation
1
PRESENTATION OUTLINE
1. Purpose
2. Introduction
3. Size and Shape of the Basic Education Sector
4. Background
5. Progress on key selected deliverables
6. Key Government Priorities
7. Education Sector Medium-Term Strategic Framework (MTSF)
8. State of the Nation Address (SoNA)
9. Action Plan to 2024: Towards the realisation of schooling 2030
10. Education Sector Priorities
11. 2020/21 Department of Basic Education (DBE) Annual Performance Plan (APP) development process
12. Measuring our performance:
– 2020/21-2024/25 Strategic Plan and 2020/21 APP
– Impact Statement,Outcomes, Outputs, Indicators and Targets
13. Department of Planning, Monitoring and Evaluation (DPME) analysis of the 2020/21 APP
14. AGSA review of the 2020/21 APP
15. 2020/21 APP monitoring activities affected due to Covid 19 and alternative mechanisms
16. Budget Review:
17. 2019/20 Audit Action Plan based on 2018/19 Audit findings: Finance and Performance Information
18. Recommendations
2
PURPOSE
To present the DBE Strategic Plan
2020/21-2024/25 and Annual
Performance Plan 2020/21 to the Joint
Meeting of the Portfolio Committee
on Basic Education and Select
Committee on Education and
Technology, Sports, Arts and Culture.
3
INTRODUCTION
“By 2030, South Africans should have access to
education and training of the highest quality,
leading to significantly improved learning
outcomes. The performance of South African
learners in international standardised tests
should be comparable to the performance of
learners from countries at a similar level of
development and with similar levels of access.”
National Planning Commission: National Development Plan, November 2011)
4
SIZE & SHAPE OF
THE BASIC
EDUCATION SECTOR
5
6
Provincial Education
Departments (9)
Independent (Private)
Public schools (23 076)
schools (1 922)
Non-subsidised
Greater financial autonomy Subsidised
independent
independent schools
schools
6
EDUCATION STATISTICS AT A GLANCE, 2019
Size of the Schooling Sector Learners Educators Schools
System:
Public 12 408 755 407 001 23 076
Learners: 12 408 755
Educators: 407 001 Independent 632 443 37 856 1 922
Schools: 23 076
Total 13 041 198 444 857 24 998
Official languages
Learners Educators Schools
English, isiZulu, isiXhosa,
isiNdebele, Afrikaans,
siSwati, Sepedi, Sesotho,
Public Public Public
Setswana, Tshivenda, Independent Independent Independent
Xitsonga, South African
Sign Language
7
BACKGROUND
• The Annual Performance Plan (APP) sets out what the Department intends doing in the financial
year and during the Medium-Term Expenditure Framework (MTEF) period to implement its
Strategic Plan.
• In fulfilling its legal obligation, the Department must produce and table an APP annually to
Parliament. The Strategic Plan should cover a period of at least five years and can be amended
• The 2020/21 APP represents the first year of activities towards achieving the objectives
• The DBE’s Strategic Plan is anchored on the Government’s long-term plan; the National
Development Plan 2030: Our future – make it work, the MTSF 2019-2024 and the draft Action
Plan to 2024.
8
PROGRESS ON SELECTED
KEY DELIVERABLES
9
PERFORMANCE OF THE CLASS OF 2019 NSC
2019
% Difference
Province Total Wrote Total Achieved % Achieved Ranking
10
NSC PERFORMANCE 2013-2019
90.0
81.3
78.2 78.2
80.0 75.8 75.1
70.7 72.5
70.0
60.0
50.0
40.0
30.0
20.0
10.0
0.0
2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019
11
BACHELOR PASS (%) PER PROVINCE 2019
44.5 43.6
45.0
39.1 37.8
40.0 37.2
12
0 to 4-year-olds attending Early Childhood
Development (ECD) facilities,
2009-2018
100
90
80
70
70
59
60 57
Percentage
50
42 43
40
29 28
30
20 18
15
10 6
0
0 1 2 3 4
Age
2009 2018
90.0
80.0
70.0
60.0
Percentage
50.0
40.0
30.0
20.0
10.0
0.0
2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018
14
EQUITY
Percentage of 7 to 15-year-olds with disabilities and those without
disabilities attending educational institutions by province, 2014-2018
100.0
90.0
Percentage
80.0
70.0
60.0
50.0
40.0
30.0
20.0
10.0
0.0
EC FS GT KZN LP MP NC NW WC
15
18
Percentage of primary and secondary schools combined
with a teacher who received specialised training in
Learners with Special Educational Needs (LSEN) by
province, 2017
100 96
93
90 87 89
82
80 76 78
70 69 68
63
60
Percentage
50
40
30
20
10
0
EC FS GT KZ LP MP NC NW WC SA
Province 16
Source: School Monitoring Survey, 2017
FILLING OF TEACHING POSTS
The percentage of primary and secondary schools combined where allocated teaching
posts were filled in terms of categories of compliance level by province
17
FUNZA LUSHAKA PLACEMENTS 2019
Number of placed
PEDs graduates Unplaced graduatesTotal allocation Placement percentage
Eastern Cape 620 136 756 82%
Free State 260 18 278 94%
Gauteng 741 160 901 82%
KwaZulu-Natal 524 182 706 74%
18
NATIONAL SCHOOL NUTRITION PROGRAMME (NSNP)
QUARTER 1-QUARTER 3 OF 2019/20
Provincial
Performance EC FS GP KZN LP MP NC NW WC Total
Indicators
Total
Number of
Learners in
1663387 592581 1146152 2061596 1655069 909948 209519 632257 404972 9275481
Q1 - 3
Schools
(Prim, Sec &
Special)
Total
Number of Q
5058 937 1167 4971 3770 1597 417 1331 690 19938
1 - 3 Schools
(Prim, Sec &
Special)
19
VOLUME 1 GRADE 1 TO GRADE 9 AND GRADE R
(2017)
Province Total Schools Total Books Schools Books Schools Books % Schools % Books
Allocated Allocated Dispatched Dispatched Delivered Delivered Delivered Delivered
Sum of Sum of Sum of Sum of Sum of Sum of
Province Schools Books DpSchools DpBooks DelSchools DelBooks
20
VOLUME 2 GRADE 1 TO GRADE 9 (2020)
Province Total Schools Total Books Schools Books Schools Books % Schools % Books
Allocated Allocated Dispatched Dispatched Delivered Delivered Delivered Delivered
21
KEY GOVERNMENT PRIORITIES
The MTSF 2019–2024 translates the ruling party’s electoral mandate
into government’s priorities over a five-year period. Basic Education is
critical in priority 2,3, and 6:
• Priority 1: A capable, ethical and developmental state.
• Priority 2: Economic transformation and job creation.
• Priority 3: Education, skills and health.
• Priority 4: Consolidating the social wage through reliable and quality
basic services.
• Priority 5: Spatial integration, human settlements and local
government.
• Priority 6: Social cohesion and safe communities.
• Priority 7: A better Africa and world.
22
MTSF 2019-2024 OUTCOMES (EDUCATION)
24
SONA FEB 2020
• The investments we make now in Early Childhood
Development and early grade learning will yield great
economic benefits in the next two decades – and beyond.
• We are making progress with the introduction of the three-
stream curriculum model, heralding a fundamental shift in
focus towards more vocational and technical education.
• Various technical vocational specialisations have already
been introduced in 550 schools and 67 schools are now
piloting the occupational stream.
25
SONA FEB 2020
• Plan to issue tablet computers to school students: The process
of distributing these tablets is underway.
• Every 10 year-old needs to be able to read for meaning: Our
early reading programmes are gathering momentum.
• This year, we will be introducing Coding and Robotics in grades
R to 3 in 200 schools, with a plan to implement fully by 2022.
• Following recognition by the Department of Basic Education in
2018 of South African Sign Language (SASL) as a home
language and the recommendation by the Parliamentary
Constitutional Review Committee that it be the 12th official
language, we are now poised to finalise the matter.
26
ACTION PLAN TO 2024
• The Action Plan to 2024: Towards the Realisation of
Schooling 2030 is the sector plan for basic
education.
• The Action Plan is based on 27 national goals that
are intended to improve basic education across all
levels.
– 13 of these goals, are output goals, dealing with
better school results and better enrolment of
learners in schools.
– The remaining 14 goals deal with things that
must happen for the output goals to be realised.
27
Action Plan to 2024:
Towards the realisation of Schooling 2030
(access, redress, equity, inclusivity, quality, & efficiency)
Goals 1 to 13:
Improved Learning
Outcomes
- Improve learning
outcomes in Language,
Mathematics and
Science as measured
in Grades 3, 6, 9 and
12
- Ensure full access to
compulsory schooling
- Decrease grade
repetition and
retention
- Improve access to
Goals 14 to 27: Further Education and
Interventions - the ‘how to Training (FET) colleges
Improve Learning - Improve quality of
Outcomes’ Grade R
28
COUNCIL OF EDUCATION MINISTERS (CEM)
PRIORITIES FOR THE SIXTH ADMINISTRATION
These priorities were approved…by the Council of Education Ministers to
lay a solid foundation for quality education, in support of improved reading
and learning outcomes:
a) Improving foundational skills of Numeracy and Literacy, especially
reading which should be underpinned by a Reading Revolution.
b) Immediate implementation of a curriculum with skills and
competencies for a changing world in all public schools (Three Stream
Model, Fourth Industrial Revolution, Entrepreneurship, Focus Schools,
etc.)
c) Deal decisively with quality and efficiency through the implementation
of standardised assessments to reduce failure, repetition, and drop out
rates and introduce multiple qualifications such as General Education
Certificate before the Grade 12 exit qualification
29
COUNCIL OF EDUCATION MINISTERS (CEM)
PRIORITIES FOR THE SIXTH ADMINISTRATION
30
STRATEGIC AND ANNUAL PERFORMANCE PLANS
PROCESS
• Discussions on priorities, outcomes for the Department, crafting of
indicators and TIDs started with Strategic sessions in August-September
2019, and were concluded and Branch Reviews convened from 4-30
October 2019.
• There are six (6) DBE Outcome Statements that are linked to the MTSF
2019-24, SONA February and June 2019, February 2020, Action Plan
Goals, and other sector commitments.
• This Strategic Plan incorporates the vision of the Action Plan to 2024 and
the Government Priorities.
• The Strategic Plan and the APP have been developed in accordance with
the requirements of the Treasury Regulations.
• The draft plans were submitted to National Treasury (NT) and Department
of Planning Monitoring and Evaluation (DPME) on 30 October 2019.
31
STRATEGIC AND ANNUAL PERFORMANCE PLANS
PROCESS
• The DPME provided feedback on Strategic Plan and APP on 31
January 2020 respectively.
• The Auditor General South Africa (AGSA) provided feedback on
Strategic Plan and APP on 17 March 2020 after tabling which took
place on 11 March 2020.
– The details have been processed and shared with relevant
Managers within Branches.
– An addendum has been prepared to address AGSA findings with
Audit implications.
– The addendum will be submitted to Parliament with relevant
pages after approval by the Minister.
32
MEASURING OUR PERFORMANCE
33
Strategic Plan 2020/21-2024/25
• The Strategic Plan is divided into four
parts:
• Part A: Our Mandate
• Part B: Our Strategic Focus
• Part C: Measuring Our Performance
• Part D: Technical Indicator
Descriptions
34
STRATEGIC PLAN
IMPACT STATEMENT, OUTCOMES AND INDICATORS
Provide quality basic education for all, and lead the establishment and development of a
South African schooling system for the 21st century.
Outcome: 1. Maintain and develop the system of policies, including the curriculum and
assessment, governing the basic education sector to advance a quality and inclusive, safe and
healthy basic education system.
Outcome Indicator Baseline Five-Year Target
35
STRATEGIC PLAN
IMPACT STATEMENT, OUTCOMES AND INDICATORS
Provide quality basic education for all, and lead the establishment and development of a
South African schooling system for the 21st century.
Outcome : 1. Maintain and develop the system of policies, including the curriculum and
assessment, governing the basic education sector to advance a quality and inclusive, safe and
healthy basic education system.
Outcome Indicator Baseline Five-Year Target
1.4 Increase the number of Bachelor-level passes in NSC: Bachelor-level passes:
youths obtaining Bachelor-level 172 043 (33.6%) in 2018. 190 000 by 2024.
passes in the NSC by 2024.
1.5 Increase the number of Youths passing Mathematics at Youths passing Mathematics
youths obtaining 60% and above 60% and above: 28 151 (12%) in at 60% and above: 35 000.
in Mathematics by 2024. 2018.
1.6 Increase the number of Youths passing Physical Science at Youths passing Physical
youths obtaining 60% and above 60% and above: 30 368 (17.6%) in Science at 60% and above:
in Physical Science by 2024. 2018. 35 000.
36
STRATEGIC PLAN
IMPACT STATEMENT, OUTCOMES AND INDICATORS
Provide quality basic education for all, and lead the establishment and development of a
South African schooling system for the 21st century.
Outcome 2. Maintain and develop information and other systems which enable transformation
and an efficient and accountable sector.
Outcome Indicator Baseline Five-Year Target
2.1 Improve learning outcomes in Grade 6 New Grade 6 performance in the new
in critical subjects reflected through the Systemic Evaluation: Mathematics
new Systemic Evaluation by 2024. Literacy: (targets to be determined after
first assessment).
2.2 Improve learning outcomes in Grade 9 New Grade 9 performance in the new
in critical subjects reflected through the Systemic Evaluation - Mathematics:
new Systemic Evaluation by 2024. (targets to be determined after first
assessment).
2.3 Improve learning outcomes in Grade 6 Average score for Grade 6 Average score for Grade 6 in the
Mathematics according to the in the SEACMEQ: Southern and Eastern Africa Consortium
international SEACMEQ by 2020. Mathematics: 552 (2013) for Monitoring Educational Quality
(SEACMEQ) for: Mathematics: 600
37
STRATEGIC PLAN
IMPACT STATEMENT, OUTCOMES AND INDICATORS
Provide quality basic education for all, and lead the establishment and development of a
South African schooling system for the 21st century.
Outcome 2. Maintain and develop information and other systems which enable transformation
and an efficient and accountable sector.
Outcome Indicator Baseline Five-Year Target
2.4 Improve learning outcomes Average score for Grade 6 in Average score for Grade 6 in the
in Grade 6 Reading according to the SEACMEQ: Literacy: 538 SEACMEQ: Literacy: 600 by 2020.
the international SEACMEQ by (2013).
2020.
2.5 Improve learning outcomes Grade 9 performance in the Average score for Grade 9 in the
in Grade 9 in Mathematics in the TIMSS: Mathematics: 372 Trends in International
TIMSS programmes by 2023. (2015) Mathematics and Science Study
(TIMSS): Mathematics: 420 by
2023.
2.6 Improve learning outcomes Grade 9 performance in the Average score for Grade 9 in the
in Grade 9 Science in the TIMSS TIMSS: Science: 358 (2015). TIMSS: Science: 420 by 2023.
programmes by 2023.
38
STRATEGIC PLAN
IMPACT STATEMENT, OUTCOMES AND INDICATORS
Provide quality basic education for all, and lead the establishment and development of a
South African schooling system for the 21st century.
Outcome 3. Maintain and develop knowledge, monitoring and research functions to advance
more evidence-driven planning, instruction and delivery.
Outcome Indicator Baseline Five-Year Target
39
STRATEGIC PLAN
IMPACT STATEMENT, OUTCOMES AND INDICATORS
Provide quality basic education for all, and lead the establishment and development of a
South African schooling system for the 21st century.
Outcome 4. Advance the development of innovative and high-quality educational materials.
Outcome Indicator Baseline Five-Year Target
4.1 Increase the percentage of 64% of schools have some 90% to be connected for
schools with access to functional connectivity (POA Q4: teaching and learning (DTPS
internet connectivity for teaching 2018/19). and private sector).
and learning connected through
different options, working with the
Department of Telecommunications
and Postal Services (DTPS).
4.2 Improve the availability of New 100% of Grade 3 learners who
quality early reading materials for learn through indigenous
teaching Home Language Literacy in languages have graded
indigenous languages. reading books.
40
STRATEGIC PLAN
IMPACT STATEMENT, OUTCOMES AND INDICATORS
Provide quality basic education for all, and lead the establishment and development
of a South African schooling system for the 21st century.
Outcome 5. Conduct strategic interventions to assist and develop provincial education
systems.
Outcome Indicator Baseline Five-Year Target
5.1 Increase the number of New 10 by 2024/25
mediation sessions
conducted to ensure accurate
interpretation of assessment
data.
Outcome :6 Increase the number of District Director forums held
6.1 Increase the number of 3 per year 15 by 2024/25
District Director forums held.
41
PROGRAMMES OF THE DBE
The ANNUAL PERFORMANCE PLAN summarises the priorities of the DBE as
aligned to the MTSF 2019-2024 and the Action Plan to 2024: Towards the
Realisation of Schooling 2030.
The activities of the DBE have been structured into five programmes as
elaborated in the Annual Performance Plan:
• PROGRAMME 1: ADMINISTRATION
42
ANNUAL PERFORMANCE PLAN
2020/21
The Annual Performance Plan is
divided into four parts:
• Part A: Mandate
• Part B: Strategic Focus
• Part C: Measuring Our Performance
• Part D: Technical Indicator
Descriptions
43
2019/20
PROGRAMME PERFORMANCE INDICATORS
Programme No. of Annual Bi-annual Quarterly
indicators Targets Targets Targets
per
programme
One 2 1 - 1
Two 14 9 1 4
Three 10 8 - 2
Four 12 8 1 3
Five 5 2 - 3
Total 43 28 2 13
distribution
Percentage 100% 65% 5% 30%
distribution
44
2020/21 APP
PROGRAMME PERFORMANCE INDICATORS
Programme No. of Bi-Ennial Annual Bi-annual Quarterly
indicators Targets Targets Targets
per
programme
One 5 2 - 3
Two 31 29 1 1
Three 13 8 1 4
Four 16 1 15 - -
Five 5 2 - 3
Total 70 1 56 2 11
distribution
Percentage 100% 1% 80% 3% 16%
distribution
45
2020/21 APP: PROGRAMME 1
Medium-term targets
Output Reporting
Indicators Cycle 2020/21 2021/22 2022/23
Outcome 2: Maintain and develop information and other systems which enable transformation
and an efficient and accountable sector.
Output: Ensure that administration, planning and Human Resource (HR) systems evolve to deal
with, and support emerging priorities, of the National Department.
1.1.1 Percentage of valid
invoices paid within 30 days
upon receipt by the Quarterly 100% 100% 100%
Department
1.1.2 Number of reports on 4 4 4
misconduct cases resolvedQuarterly
within 90 days
1.1.3 Number of capacity
building programmes Annually 10 12 14
offered to the DBE officials
46
2020/21 APP: PROGRAMME 1
Medium-term targets
Output Reporting
Indicators Cycle 2020/21 2021/22 2022/23
Outcome 2: Maintain and develop information and other systems which enable transformation
and an efficient and accountable sector.
Output: Ensure that administration, planning and Human Resource (HR) systems evolve to deal
with, and support emerging priorities, of the National Department.
1.2.1 Annual 2021/22 APP2022/23 APP
Performance Plan 2020/21 APP approved
Annually approved byapproved by
approved by 31 March by March 2020
each financial year March 2021 March 2022
1.2.2 Quarterly Reports Quarterly Four Quarterly ReportsFour QuarterlyFour Quarterly
submitted to National submitted to NT andReports Reports
Treasury(NT) and the DPME 30 days after thesubmitted tosubmitted to NT
DPME 30 days after the end of each quarter NT and DPMEand DPME 30
end of each quarter 30 days afterdays after the
the end ofend of each
each quarter quarter
47
2020/21 APP: PROGRAMME 2
Medium- term targets
Output Reporting
Indicators Cycle 2020/21 2020/22 2022/23
Outcome 1: Maintain and develop the system of policies, including the curriculum and
assessment, governing the basic education sector to advance a quality and inclusive, safe and
healthy basic education system.
Output: Ensure that policies and the curriculum evolve to deal with emerging priorities, including
those relating to early childhood development, inclusive education, twenty-first-century skills, the
support and monitoring of learning outcomes.
2.1.1 Number of Technical schools
monitored for implementation ofQuarterly
Curriculum and Assessment Policy 18 18 18
Statements (CAPS).
2.1.2 Number of learners obtaining subject
passes towards a National Senior
Certificate (NSC) or extended SeniorBi-annually 60 000 60 000 65 000
Certificate, including upgraded NSC per
year.
48
2020/21 APP: PROGRAMME 2
Medium- term targets
Output Indicators Reporting
Cycle 2020/21 2021/22 2022/23
2.1.5 Amend legislation to Annually Amendment of National Approved costed plan Drafting of Education
regulate the new ECD landscape. Education Policy Act legislation with new
(NEPA), SASA and Children’s ECD functions from the
Act completed within 9 Children’s Act.
months of Cabinet
proclamation on change.
49
2020/21 APP: PROGRAMME 2
Medium- term targets
Reporting
Output Indicators Cycle 2020/21 2021/22 2022/23
Report on
2.1.6 Develop new
investigation into First phase of Approved funding
funding models for ECD Annually
delivery. ECD funding implementation model
models
Approved report
2.1.7 Develop and on the national DBE begins to
operationalise an ECD
audit conducted on ECD Registration register ECD
Education Management Annually
Information System Early Childhood system developed centres and
(EMIS). Development (ECD) programmes
centres
2.1.8 Develop and Report on ECD
Online NQF Level 4
operationalise an Early service delivery Provincial Quality
ECD qualification
Childhood Development Annually model and its Assurance Partners
(ECD) Human Resource platform
workforce identified
Development (HRD) Plan. operational
implications
50
2020/21 APP: PROGRAMME 2
Medium- term targets
Reporting
Output Indicators Cycle 2020/21 2021/22 2022/23
51
2020/21 APP: PROGRAMME 2
Medium- term targets
Output Indicators Reporting Cycle
2020/21 2021/22 2022/23
2.1.12 An Annual Sector Report is Annually Approved Annual Sector Approved Annual Approved Annual
produced on the implementation Report on the Sector Report on the Sector Report on
of the General Education implementation of the implementation of the the
Certificate (GEC). General Education General Education implementation
Certificate (GEC) Certificate (GEC) of the General
Education
Certificate (GEC)
2.1.13 An Annual Sector Report on Annually Approved Annual Sector Approved Annual Approved Annual
is produced schools that are Report on schools that Sector Report on Sector Report on
prepared to respectively are prepared to schools that are schools that are
implement and pilot the Technical respectively implement prepared to prepared to
Occupational Stream in 2021/22. and pilot the Technical respectively implement respectively
Occupational Stream in and pilot the Technical implement and
2021/22 Occupational Stream in pilot the Technical
2021/22 Occupational
Stream in 2021/22
2.1.14 Number of schools Annually 10 schools (2 per piloting 10 schools (2 per 10 schools (2 per
monitored for piloting the coding Province) piloting Province) piloting Province)
and robotics curriculum.
2020/21 APP: PROGRAMME 2
Medium- term targets
Reporting
Output Indicators Cycle 2020/21 2021/22 2022/23
Outcome 3: Maintain and develop knowledge, monitoring and research functions to advance
more evidence-driven planning, instruction and delivery.
Output: Ensure that national decisions relating to innovations in areas such as reading and
language acquisition are informed by sound evidence.
2.2.1 Number of schools monitored on the
implementation of the reading norms. Annually 30 40 50
2.2.2 Number of schools monitored on the
implementation of the Incremental Annually 30 40 50
Introduction to African Languages (IIAL).
2.2.3 Number of underperforming schools
monitored on the implementation of the Annually 125 130 135
Early Grade Reading Assessment (EGRA).
2.2.4 Number of schools with Multi-grade
classes monitored for implementing the Annually 81 90 90
Multi-grade toolkit.
53
2020/21 APP: PROGRAMME 2
Medium- term targets
Output Indicators Reporting
Cycle 2020/21 2021/22 2022/23
Approved AnnualApproved Approved
Sector Report onAnnual SectorAnnual Sector
the Report on theReport on the
2.2.5 An Annual Sector Report is implementation implementation implementati
produced on the implementationAnnually of the Nationalof the Nationalon of the
of the National Reading Plan. Reading Plan Reading Plan National
Reading Plan
54
2020/21 APP: PROGRAMME 2
Medium- term targets
Reporting
Output Indicators
Cycle 2020/21 2021/22 2022/23
Outcome 4: Advance the development of innovative and high quality educational materials.
Output : Promote the use of evidence in materials development through a stronger use of
emerging technologies.
2.3.1 Number of schools per province
monitored for utilisation of Information, 27 (3 per 27 (3 per 27 (3 per
Communication and Technology (ICT) Annually
province) province) province)
resources.
2.3.2 Percentage of public schools with
Home Language workbooks for learners in
Grades 1 to 6 per year after having placed Annually 100% 100% 100%
an order.
2.3.3 Percentage of public schools with
Mathematics workbooks for learners in
Grades 1 to 9 per year, after having placed Annually 100% 100% 100%
an order.
56
2020/21 APP: PROGRAMME 2
Medium- term targets
Output Reporting
Indicators Cycle 2020/21 2021/22 2022/23
Outcome 5: Conduct strategic interventions to assist and develop provincial education systems.
Output: Continue with the strategic use and monitoring of conditional grants and other funds to
advance national priorities, as well as additional interventions in all or specific provinces to
advance the attainment of sector-wide goal.
Approved Annual Approved Approved
Sector Report on Annual Sector Annual Sector
2.4.1 An Annual Sector Report is the number of Report on the Report on the
produced on the number of Annually teachers trained number of number of
teachers trained on inclusion. on inclusion. teachers trained teachers
on inclusion… trained on
inclusion.
Approved Annual Approved Approved
Sector Report on Annual Sector Annual Sector
the number of Report on the Report on the
2.4.2 An Annual Sector Report is
produced on the number of Annually learners in public number of number of
learners in public special schools. special schools. learners in learners in
public special public special
schools schools.
57
2020/21 APP: PROGRAMME 2
Medium- term targets
Output Reporting
Indicators Cycle 2020/21 2021/22 2022/23
Outcome 5: Conduct strategic interventions to assist and develop provincial education systems.
Output: Continue with the strategic use and monitoring of conditional grants and other funds to
advance national priorities, as well as additional interventions in all or specific provinces to
advance the attainment of sector-wide goal.
Approved Annual Sector Approved Annual
2.4.3 An Annual Sector Report on the percentage Sector Report on Approved Annual
of public special schools the percentage of Sector Report on
Report is produced on the
serving as resource public special the percentage of
percentage of public special Annually centres. schools serving as public special
schools serving as resource resource centres. schools serving as
centres. resource centres.
59
2020/21 APP: PROGRAMME 3
Medium- term targets
Reporting
Output Indicators
Cycle 2020/21 2021/22 2022/23
3.1.4 Number of quarterly
monitoring reports tracking the
percentage of Funza Lushaka
graduates placed within six (6) Quarterly 4 4 4
months upon confirmation that
the bursar has completed studies.
3.1.5 Number of quarterly
monitoring reports indicating the
number and percentage of schools Quarterly 4 4 4
where allocated teaching posts
are all filled.
3.1.6 An Annual Sector Report is Annually Approved Annual Approved Annual Approved Annual
produced on the number of Sector Report on the Sector Report on Sector Report on
qualified teachers aged 30 and number of qualified the number of the number of
below entering the public service teachers aged 30 qualified teachers qualified teachers
as teachers. and below entering aged 30 and aged 30 and
the public service as below entering below entering
teachers the public service the public service
as teachers as teachers
60
2020/21 APP: PROGRAMME 3
Medium- term targets
Reporting
Output Indicators
Cycle 2020/21 2021/22 2022/23
Outcome 3: Maintain and develop knowledge, monitoring and research functions to advance
more evidence-driven planning, instruction and delivery.
Output: Ensure that national decisions relating to educator conditions of service, and innovations
in areas such as teacher training, development and assessments, are informed by sound
evidence.
Approved Approved Approved
National Report National National Report
on monitoring the Report on on monitoring
functionality of monitoring the the functionality
3.2.1 A National Report is produced on Provincial Teacher functionality of of Provincial
monitoring the functionality of Provincial Development Provincial Teacher
Teachers Development Institutes and Annually
Institutes and Teacher Development
District Teacher Development Centres. District Teacher Development Institutes and
Development Institutes and District Teacher
Centres. District Teacher Development
Development Centres.
Centres.
61
2020/21 APP: PROGRAMME 3
Medium- term targets
Reporting
Output Indicators
Cycle 2020/21 2021/22 2022/23
Outcome 3: Maintain and develop knowledge, monitoring and research functions to advance
more evidence-driven planning, instruction and delivery.
Output: Ensure that national decisions relating to educator conditions of service, and innovations
in areas such as teacher training, development and assessments, are informed by sound
evidence.
3.2.2 A National Report is Approved National Approved National Approved National
produced on monitoring the Report on monitoring Report on Report on
implementation of Teacher the implementation monitoring the monitoring the
Development Programmes by of Teacher implementation of implementation of
PEDs with special focus on Development Teacher Teacher
EFAL, Mathematics, Physical Programmes by PEDs Development Development
Sciences and Accounting. Annually
with special focus on Programmes by Programmes by
EFAL, Mathematics, PEDs with special PEDs with special
Physical Science and focus on EFAL, focus on EFAL,
Accounting. Mathematics, Mathematics,
Physical Science Physical Science
and Accounting. and Accounting.
62
2020/21 APP: PROGRAMME 3
Medium- term targets
Output Indicators Reporting
Cycle 2020/21 2021/22 2022/23
Outcome 3: Maintain and develop knowledge, monitoring and research functions to advance more evidence-
driven planning, instruction and delivery.
Output: Ensure that national decisions relating to educator conditions of service, and innovations in areas
such as teacher training, development and assessments, are informed by sound evidence.
Outcome 5: Conduct strategic interventions to assist and develop provincial education systems.
Output: Strategic use and monitoring of provinces to advance national priorities, as well as
additional interventions in all or specific provinces to advance the attainment of sector-wide goal.
64
2020/21 APP: PROGRAMME 4
Medium-term targets
Output Indicators Reporting Cycle
2020/21 2020/21 2021/22
Outcome 1: Maintain and develop the system of policies, including the curriculum and
assessment, governing the basic education sector to advance a quality and inclusive, safe and
healthy basic education system.
Output: Ensure that policies and the infrastructure evolve to deal with emerging priorities,
including those relating to basic services and the replacement of inappropriate structures.
4.1.1 Number of new
schools built and completed
through Accelerated Schools Annually 31 29 30
Infrastructure Delivery
Initiative (ASIDI).
65
2020/21 APP: PROGRAMME 4
Medium- term targets
Output Reporting
Indicators Cycle 2020/21 2021/22 2022/23
Outcome 2: Maintain and develop information and other systems which enable transformation
and an efficient and accountable sector.
Output: Ensure that monitoring systems such as South African School Administration and
Management system (SA-SAMS), assessment and examination systems evolve to deal with, and
support emerging priorities, in particular those relating to school completion, learning outcomes
and the accountability of schools.
4.2.1 Number of General Education
and Training (GET) Test items
developed in Language and Annually 500 500 500
Mathematics for Grades 3, 6 and 9.
66
2020/21 APP: PROGRAMME 4
Medium- term targets
Reporting
Output Indicators
Cycle 2020/21 2021/22 2022/23
4.2.3 Number of question papers
set for June and November Annually 292 292 292
examinations.
4.2.4 Percentage of public schools 98% 98% 98%
using the standardised School Annually
Administration System (SA-SAM).
4.2.5 A National Report is Annually Approved National Approved National Approved
produced on the number of Report on the Report on the National Report
provinces monitored for number of number of on the number
implementation of LURITS. provinces provinces of provinces
monitored for monitored for monitored for
implementation of implementation of implementation
LURITS LURITS of LURITS
67
2020/21 APP: PROGRAMME 4
Medium- term targets
Reporting
Output Indicators Cycle 2020/21 2021/22 2022/23
Approved National
4.2.6 A National Report is Approved National Approved National
Report on learner
produced on learner Report on learner Report on learner
performance
performance linked performance linked
performance linked to Annually to the National
linked to the
to the National
National Assessment Assessment
National
Assessment
Framework. Assessment
Framework Framework
Framework
Output: Strategic use and monitoring of districts to advance national priorities, as well as
additional interventions in all or specific districts to advance the attainment of sector-wide goal in
relation to mentorship, development and support of officials at district level.
69
2020/21 APP: PROGRAMME 5
Medium- term targets
Output Reporting
Indicators Cycle 2020/21 2021/22 2022/23
70
2020/21 APP: PROGRAMME 5
Medium- term targets
Output Reporting
Indicators Cycle 2020/21 2021/22 2022/23
Outcome 1: Maintain and develop the system of policies, including the curriculum and
assessment, governing the basic education sector to advance a quality and inclusive, safe and
healthy basic education system.
Output: Ensure that policies relating to care and support services evolve to deal with emerging
priorities, including those relating to school nutrition, school safety, social cohesion, and learner
health and wellness.
5.1.1 Number of schools monitored for
the provision of nutritious meals. Quarterly 115 120 125
5.1.2 Number of professionals trained
in South African School Choral Annually 900 900 900
Eisteddfod (SASCE) programmes.
5.1.3 Number of PEDs with approved
annual business plans for the
HIV/AIDS Life Skills Education Annually 9 9 9
Programme.
71
2020/21 APP: PROGRAMME 5
Medium- term targets
Output Reporting
Indicators Cycle
2020/21 2021/22 2022/23
72
DPME FEEDBACK
ON 2020/21 APP
73
DPME FEEDBACK ON 2020/21 APP
DPME COMMENT MANAGEMENT RESPONSE
The Department is advised to ensure To ensure MTSF alignment, MTSF analysis
alignment between the APP and MTSF. was conducted and all Branches were
engaged.
The Department has also listed some The policy on Incremental Introduction of
weaknesses without indicating how these African Languages (IIAL) is currently being
will be resolved. For example, for the issue of implemented, to promote use of other
disadvantaging some learners through the African languages in our schools.
usage of English as a language of teaching
and learning, there is no clear plan besides
mentioning that the schooling system needs
to pay special attention to the promotion of
all official languages.
The Department has reflected an impact Impact statement was revised and finalised in
statement which is in line with their mandate January to read as follows: Provide quality
and the MTSF. However, phrases such as Basic Education for all, and lead the
“develop, maintain and support” make the establishment and development of a South
impact statement read like an activity. African schooling system for the 21st century
74
DPME FEEDBACK ON 2020/21 APP
DPME COMMENT MANAGEMENT RESPONSE
In programme 5, the department is advised The activities proposed for the suggested
to include indicators that focus on indicators are conducted by health personnel
deworming of learners, health and wellness from the Department of Health. It is not
in schools; for example, health and wellness practicable/prudent to include such as
drive i.e. eye test, hearing aid, and BMI ultimately, the DOH has the final say in its
testing among others. resource allocation and use. They also collect
the data.
There must be alignment between outputs This alignment was checked for all output
and output indicators. indicators in the final 2020/21 APP.
The Department has developed key risks; Mitigation Strategies were updated in the
however, the mitigating factors are not final 2020/21 APP.
included. The department is advised to
develop the key risks and mitigating factors
for all the outcomes.
Court Rulings to be included in plans: Sign Language has been part of National
KwaZulu-Natal Court Judgement on Senior Certificate exams since 2018.
Provisioning of South African Sign Language
as language of instruction.
75
AGSA FEEDBACK
ON 2020/21 APP
76
AGSA FEEDBACK ON 2020/21 APP
DPME COMMENT MANAGEMENT RESPONSE
Ensure that the indicator clearly indicates the Indicators indicate the specified fields as
nature of the input or output, the activities, recommended.
the desired outcomes and impacts, and all
relevant definitions and standards used in
each field.
Data limitations as well as factors that may Data limitations have been provided for all
be beyond the entities’ control should be indicators in the 2020/21 APP.
identified and documented.
77
2020/21 APP MONITORING
ACTIVITIES AFFECTED DUE
TO COVID 19
78
2020/21 APP MONITORING ACTIVITIES AFFECTED DUE TO
COVID 19
INDICATOR ALTERNATIVE MONITORING PLAN
2.1.4 A National Report is produced on Possibilities for virtual monitoring will be
monitoring of the implementation of the explored to ensure effective implementation.
Policy on Screening, Identification,
Assessment and Support (SIAS) as a
mechanism for early identification and
intervention.
79
2020/21 APP MONITORING ACTIVITIES AFFECTED DUE TO
COVID 19
INDICATOR ALTERNATIVE MONITORING PLAN
3.1.4 Number of quarterly monitoring reports Virtual meetings.
tracking the percentage of Funza Lushaka
graduates placed within six (6) months upon
confirmation that the bursar has completed
studies.
3.3.1 Number of PEDs monitored on the Monitoring through physical visits will be
Quality Management System (QMS). replaced with desk-top / virtual monitoring
(video/tele conferencing, emails etc)
3.3.2 Number of PEDs monitored on the
implementation of Education Management
System: Performance Management and
Development System (EMS PMDS).
5.1.1 Number of schools monitored for the Technology based methods will be used.
provision of nutritious meals.
81
2020/21 APP MONITORING ACTIVITIES AFFECTED DUE TO
COVID 19
INDICATOR ALTERNATIVE MONITORING PLAN
5.1.5 Number of stakeholder Co-curricular activities such as Stakeholder Engagements
engagements held to promote were meant to be face-to-face but DBE will need to
the Constitution and its values migrate engagements completely to virtual interactive
using social cohesion, sports spaces. Thus the proposal to adjust targets from counting
and enrichment programmes the number of engagements to counting the number of
participants reached through the multiple virtual
engagements. Therefore the indicator should be adjusted
to now read as follows:
5.1.5 Number of learners, educators, parents, SGBs and
other educations stakeholders reached through social
cohesion programmes.
Medium Term Targets:
1. 2020/21 7500
2. 2021/22 8000
3. 2022/23 8500
82
2020 BUDGET
REVIEW
83
DEPARTMENTAL APPROPRIATION
• The Department has been allocated R25.3 billion in 2020/21, R27.3
billion in 2021/22 and R28.6 billion in 2022/23. Included in these
allocations is Compensation of Employees amounting to R584
million, R622 million and R649 million respectively over the
Medium-Term Expenditure Framework (MTEF) years.
2020/21 2021/22 2022/23
R’000 R’000 R’000
84
PROGRAMMES ALLOCATIONS OVER THE 2020 MTEF
BUDGETS
Teachers, Education Human Resources 1 437 738 1 516 940 1 589 270
and Institutional Development
85
COMPARISON BETWEEN PROGRAMMES
ALLOCATIONS FROM 2019 TO 2020 MTEF
BUDGETS
2019/20 2020/21 Percentage
R’000 R’000 Increase/
Decrease
PROGRAMME
Administration 496 253 519 401 4.7%
Curriculum Policy, Support and Monitoring 1 988 959 2 025 646 1.8%
Teachers, Education Human Resources and 1 366 199 1 437 738 5.2%
Institutional Development
86
ECONOMIC CLASSIFICATIONS ALLOCATIONS FOR 2020
MTEF
BUDGETS
2020/21 2021/22 2022/23
R’000 R’000 R’000
Economic Classification
Compensation of Employees 584 252 622 166 649 219
Payments for Capital Assets 1 509 245 2 056 909 2 059 085
87
COMPARISON BETWEEN ECONOMIC CLASSIFICATIONS
ALLOCATIONS FROM 2019 TO 2020 MTEF
BUDGETS
2019/20 2020/21 Percentage
R’000 R’000 Increase/
Decrease
Economic Classifications
Compensation of Employees 546 751 584 252 6.9%
88
DETAILS OF EARMARKED ALLOCATIONS (R’000) OVER
THE 2020 MTEF
Earmarked Funds 2020/21 2021/22 2022/23
R’000 R’000 R’000
Workbooks 1 191 884 1 248 712 1 273 617
89
COMPARISON ON DETAILS OF EARMARKED ALLOCATIONS
(R’000) FROM 2019 TO 2020 MTEF
90
DETAILS OF CONDITIONAL GRANTS ALLOCATIONS /TRANSFERS
(R’000) OVER THE 2020 MTEF
Conditional Grants 2020/21 2021/22 2022/23
R’000 R’000 R’000
HIV and AIDS ( Life Skills) 246 699 258 542 262 204
Grant
91
COMPARISON ON DETAILS OF CONDITIONAL GRANTS
ALLOCATIONS/TRANSFERS (R’000) FROM 2019 TO 2020 MTEF
Conditional Grants 2019/20 2020/21 Percentage
R’000 R’000 Increase/
Decrease
92
DETAILS OF TRANSFERS (R’000) OVER 2020 MTEF
Other Transfers 2020/21 2021/22 2022/23
R’000 R’000 R’000
National Education Collaboration Trust 115 738 122 104 126 644
Southern and Eastern Africa Consortium for Monitoring 3 671 3 873 4 016
Educational Quality
93
DETAILS OF TRANSFERS (R’000) OVER 2020 MTEF
Other Transfers 2020/21 2021/22 2022/23
R’000 R’000 R’000
94
DETAILED BREAKDOWN OF THE BUDGET OVER THE 2020 MTEF
Economic Classification 2020/21 2021/22 2022/23
R’000 R’000 R’000
Earmarked Funds( Including CoE) 1 340 900 1 405 574 1 435 865
95
2020 MTEF CABINET BASELINE REDUCTIONS
2020/21 2021/22 2022/23
R’000 R’000 R’000
2019 Indicative Allocation 25 987 648 28 189 376 29 643 169
Less: Conditional Grants (525 021) (696 407) (875 801)
Maths, Science and Technology Grant (12 397) (13 079) (13 708)
Education Infrastructure Grant (458 665) (616 331) (775 099)
HIV and AIDS ( Life Skills) (23 945) (26 987) (33 939)
National School Nutrition Programme Grant (30 014) (40 010) (53 055)
Baseline reduction (134 395) (160 005) (174 973)
Goods and services (39 536) (41 380) (43 239)
Non-profit institution ( 2 364) (2 494) (2 586)
School Infrastructure Backlog: Building and other (32 623) (43 836) (46 345)
Infrastructure
Machinery and Equipment (136) (150) (159)
96
CABINET BUDGET REDUCTION
(CONTINUES)
2020/21 2021/22 2022/23
R’000 R’000 R’000
Software and other intangible assets (7) (8) (8)
Matric Second Chance Programme (20 000) (22 000) (25 000)
National Assessment: Goods and Services ( 10 000) (10 000) (10 000)
97
DEPARTMENTAL BUDGET CUTS ON GOODS AND
SERVICES
2020/21 2021/22 2022/23
R’000 R’000 R’000
98
GENERAL BUDGET SUPPORT
General Budget Support 2020/21 2021/22 2022/23
R’000 R’000 R’000
99
2019/20 AUDIT ACTION
PLAN – FINANCIAL AND
PERFORMANCE
INFORMATION BASED ON
2018/19 AGSA AUDIT
REPORT
100
2019/20 AUDIT ACTION PLAN
Findings AG DBE Actions Q2 Progress Q3 Progress Q4 Progress
Recommendation
1. Immovable a) Improve Monthly The ASIDI unit is Project Project Completed
tangible capital monitoring reconciliations on currently reversing all Completed for Q3 for Q4 and Year
Assets: controls pertaining expenditure are done IA fees previously reporting. end reporting.
Overstatement to obtaining and the values of accounted as part of Total IA Fees and Total IA Fees and
of capital assets invoices from the completed projects are Capital Expenditure. To Disbursements Disbursements
and capital implementing only based on actual date R380 000 000 removed totals removed.
expenditure as agents payments processed which represents just under R550m.
well as through BAS with 47.5% of the estimated
understatement b) Update policies provision for both R800 000 000
of goods and and procedures on Accruals, Retention, overstatement has
services immovable assets PSP & Implementing been reversed. The
expenditure. to address matters Agents fees. projected completion
related to the period of adjustment
value of in-use of of Capital Expenditure
assets. Overstatement and
Operational
expenditure
understatement is the
end of quarter 3. All
DBSA project (114);
CDC Batch 1 (26); IDT
Batch 1( 12) have been
completed).
101
2019/20 AUDIT ACTION PLAN
Findings AG DBE Actions Q2 Progress Q3 Progress Q4 Progress
Recommendation
1. c) Strengthen DBE is busy The adjustment Capital Assets and Capital Assets and
Immovable monthly performing the process is linked Expenditure values Expenditure values
tangible controls over split between and is targeted adjusted to exclude adjusted to exclude
capital the operational and for completion Implementing
by the end of the Agent Fees and
Implementing Agent
Fees and
Assets: preparation capital 3rd Quarter. The Disbursements and Disbursements and
Overstatem of the expenditure for value of reported as such for will be reported as
ent of immovable the period since completed Q3 Financials. such for Annual
capital asset register the inception of assets will be Financial
assets and ASIDI in 2012. strictly limited Statements.
capital d) Review all This should be to Construction
expenditure assets completed on Costs
Fees.
and PSP
as well as capitalised in time for
understate the assets accurate
ment of register. disclosure in
goods and the 2019/20
services Annual
expenditure Financial
. Statements.
102
2019/20 AUDIT ACTION PLAN
Findings AG DBE Actions Q2 Progress Q3 Progress Q4 Progress
Recommendati
on
2. Commitments (a) In previous Financial Disbursements . Modified Cash Modified Cash
Misstatement of Management Years, Projects commitments have System (MCS) has System (MCS) has
commitments must take formally allocated to been adjusted to be changed to changed to exclude
due to appropriate IAs were classified as on a proven costs and exclude commitments for
insufficient audit steps to Approved but not line with the commitments for Operational
evidence understand and Contracted, even if authorised contract Operational Expenditure.
provided. address the these were not yet percentage. Where Expenditure. Disbursements were
estimation awarded. All project the disbursements Disbursements removed from Capital
uncertainty, and values previously have already been were removed Assets and
should develop recorded as “Approved incurred and from Capital Expenditure and is
a point estimate but Not Contracted” in accounted, the Assets and classified as an
that meets the the Commitment amount equaling the Expenditure and operational expense
measurement Register have been expenditure has been is classified as an in accordance with
objective and is removed with effect raised as the operational the AG’s instructions
supported by from the 31 March Commitment Value. All expense in
sufficient 2019. estimated amounts accordance with
appropriate will be deduced from the AG’s
evidence. proven trends and instructions.
follow pattern of
expenditure on same
103
2019/20 AUDIT ACTION PLAN
Findings AG DBE Actions Q2 Progress Q3 Progress Q4 Progress
Recommendati
on
2. (b) The Disbursements Disbursements Not applicable
Commitments Management commitment commitments have commitments have anymore i.t.o. the
been adjusted to be been adjusted to MCS as
Misstatement must ensure values are on proven costs and be on proven costs commitments are
of that auditors strictly for line with the and in line with the no more raised on
commitments are furnished projects with authorised contract authorised contract disbursements
due to with sufficient award tender percentage. Where percentage. Where
values. the disbursements the disbursements
insufficient information in have already been have already been
audit evidence order to re- All estimated incurred and incurred and
provided. perform work disbursement accounted, the accounted for, the
done by the values to the amount equaling amount equaling
end of 31 the expenditure has the expenditure has
management been raised as the been raised as the
and to March 2019 Commitment Value. Commitment Value.
determine if have been All estimated All estimated
management’s replaced with amounts will be amounts will be
point estimate actual expenses deducted from deducted from
is reasonable. reimbursed to follow pattern of proven
proven trends and trends and
follow patterns of
the expenditure on expenditure on
Implementing same. same.
Agents.
104
2019/20 AUDIT ACTION PLAN
Findings AG Recommendation DBE Actions Q2 Progress Q3 Progress Q4 Progress
106
2019/20 AUDIT ACTION PLAN
Findings AG Recommendation DBE Actions Q2 Progress Q3 Progress Q4 Progress
5. (a) Ensure that proper All related The final accounts for The DG signed a The AASF has
MATERIAL and due processes are irregular Phase 2 have been done letter addressed responded to the
IRREGULA followed with regards to expenditure be for all three schools and to AASF with a letter of demand
RITY the appointment of disclosed consequently approved by claim for the indicating that they
Cost service providers and accordingly and the DG. The Adopt-a- irregular would like to have
incurred implementing agents cost incurred School Foundation (AASF) expenditure. further discussions
for and to ensure that the for remedial has submitted their Final with the DBE on this
remedial providers meet the action be Accounts for Phase 1 to matter. Meeting to
constructi necessary requirements recovered from the PSU on the be arranged after
on for in line with CIDB to the IA. 11/11/2019. The process lockdown. In the
projects perform construction of review is underway and meantime the
undertake work in the public expected to be completed infrastructure unit
n by sector. by the end of 3rd quarter will be raising the
Adopt-a- b) Ensure compliance so that the quantum quantum demanded
School. with CIDB and NT would be issued to AASF from AASF as a
procurement prescripts for repayment. Contingent Asset in
c) Ensure compliance the financial year-
with the PFMA section end report.
38 with regards to
investigation into
permitted irregular and
fruitless and wasteful
expenditure.
107
2019/20 AUDIT ACTION PLAN
Findings AG DBE Actions Q3 Progress Q4 Progress
Recomme
ndation
6. Irregular, a) To investigate all Irregular Expenditure – Confirmed Irregular Expenditure – Confirmed
confirmed Investigation of previous cases Investigation of previous cases completed.
Fruitless and Irregular, completed. 85% of confirmed irregular expenditure was
Wasteful Fruitless irregular, 85% of confirmed irregular expenditure investigated (previous and 2018/19) included.
Expenditure and fruitless and was investigated (previous and
Investigation wasteful wasteful 2018/19) included. Consequence Management has already been
Non- expenditur expenditure Consequence Management has already implemented in some previous and 2018/19
within the been implemented in some previous cases.
compliance e must be and 2018/19 cases. 13 out of 20 cases cautionary/ warning /final
with the investigate financial year 12 out of 20 cases cautionary/ warning letters were issued
PPPFA when d within warning /final warning letters were Implementing Agents were requested to
awarding three Source issued account.
contracts. months additional Implementing Agents were requested Investigated 3 out of 13 possible irregular
investigation to account. expenditure. The TOR was approved to source
a service provider to assist with other
capacity to Investigated 3 out of 13 possible investigation.
finalize the irregular expenditure. The TOR was
possible irregular approved to source a service provider Fruitless and Wasteful Expenditure
expenditure to assist with other investigation. Previous cases were investigated. 2018/19
investigation investigation is at final stage waiting for
Fruitless and Wasteful Expenditure comments from the relevant managers
Previous cases were investigated. Possible Fruitless and Wasteful Expenditure
2018/19 investigation has started. 18/19 -80% investigated (12/15) and the
committee and internal audit is in the process
Possible Fruitless and Wasteful of verifying the professional assessment
Expenditure -70% investigated and the reports conducted at school to assess the
committee and internal audit is in the condition.
process of verifying the professional Assessment verified of 5 Implementing
assessment reports conducted at school Agents ( cases)
to assess the condition. Three (3) cases still under investigation.
108
2019/20 AUDIT ACTION PLAN
Findings AG DBE Actions Q3 Progress Q4 Progress
Recommendation
Programme The teacher guides and
2: An indicator The Performance lesson plans are not The Branch has verified
should have a Indicators have monitored in 2019/20 that all indicators have
Planned specific target per been quantified for clear targets that are
targets were term or per year. the 2019/2020 The Branch has now measurable.
not specific. There should be a years and beyond. included clear targets
numerical number that are measurable
of Technical for all indicators.
Mathematics
lesson plans
monitored per
year. There should
also be a numeric
number of
Technical Sciences
lesson plans
monitored per
year.
109
2019/20 AUDIT ACTION PLAN
Findings AG DBE Actions Q3 Progress Q4 Progress
Recommendation
Programme 3 DBE has communicated All issues that were All PEDs adhered to
with relevant highlighted in the the AG’s
The reported o Implement programme managers in previous audit have recommendations.
achievement proper record Provinces to ensure that been resolved.
in the annual keeping by scripts are identifiable
performance ensuring that the through a name or a The Annual
report did not actual code, and also to ensure Performance Plan
performance that they are dated. indicators for 2020 have
agree to the reported is valid,
supporting changed, and new
and accurate. The DBE is also reporting requirements
evidence encouraging more have been complied
provided. o Establish provinces to take the with.
adequate process tests online on the
of verification of Moodle Platform. This
the source will improve validity and
documentation reliability.
on a quarterly
basis and review Going forward, the DBE
source will only be required to
documentation provide a report on the
to validate assessments.
reported
achievements
110
2019/20 AUDIT ACTION PLAN
Findings AG DBE Actions Q3 Progress Q4 Progress
Recommendation
Programme 4: a) The Project Manager Monthly reports from A total of 77 district
Implement proper is working more closely mentors have been officials were mentored
The reported record keeping by with mentors to verify amended to include for 2019/20 financial
achievements ensuring that the numbers and number of sessions as year.
in the annual actual performance designation of officials well as number of
performance reported is valid, and that are targeted for the officials mentored.
report did not accurate. mentoring support and The reports are The Implementing Agents
agree to the who those who receive verified against the include as part of their
supporting Establish adequate support. attendance registers monthly reports a
evidence process of by DBE officials. schedule of completed
provided. verification of the Practical Completion
source b)Monthly 2018/19 Audit findings Certificates which are
documentation on a reconciliation and were received and reviewed by the PSU
quarterly basis and verification of projects workshopped. The Team leaders for validity.
review source that achieved practical Technical Indicator The Infrastructure unit
documentation to completion between (TID) descriptions and reconciles the list to
validate reported Asset Management; processes have been ensure duplications are
achievements Implementing Agents developed and minimized and that the
and the Infrastructure refined. PCs are for valid projects
Unit to ensure accurate and align to the scope of
and common reporting works as per Masterlist.
on performance.
111
RECOMMENDATION
It is recommended that the Joint Meeting of the
Portfolio Committee on Basic Education and Select
Committee on Education and Technology, Sports,
Arts and Culture note:
– The 2020/21-2024/25 Strategic Plan and the 2020/21
Annual Performance Plan of the DBE.
– 2020/21 APP monitoring activities affected due to covid
19.
– The 2020/21 Budget Review of the DBE.
– Progress on 2019/20 Audit Action Plan based on the
2018/19 Audit findings.
112
113