Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Gerald Steinberg
NGO Monitor
www.ngo-monitor.org
www.ngo-monitor.org
Related Material
:Also Available
Fatal Strikes
Download Summary and Recommendations
in French
Download Summary and Recommendations
in Hebrew
Deliberate destruction or "collateral damage"?
Israeli attacks on civilian infrastructure
AI Index: MDE 18/007/2006 23 August 2006
Amnesty International on
Wednesday accused
Israel of war crimes,
saying it broke
international law by The Guardian ..”Yesterday's attack
deliberately on the southern Lebanese town
destroying Lebanon's of Qana, which rights group
civilian infrastructure Human Rights Watch today
during its recent war labelled a ‘war crime’”.
with Hezbollah
guerrillas.
• HRW’s Questions and Answers on Hostilities Between
Israel and Hezbollah
• Updated August 02, 2006
• BBC
• “Oxfam's Shaista Aziz, in Beirut, said: "After 33 days of
war, large parts have been destroyed and devastated.“
NGO SUPERPOWERS
Annual budgets (2005)
NGOs
NGOs
Durban
Jenin Media
Media
UNHCR
UN
UNand
andDiplomats
Diplomats
UNGA and ICJ
Boycott and
Divestment
Academia
Academia
www.ngo-monitor.org
NGO FORUM:
DURBAN – SEPTEMBER 2001
www.ngo-monitor.org
NGO Credibility
“…Amnesty International has reported that Israeli
soldiers deliberately aim at Palestinian children. When
asked to document that they couldn't come up with a
single case.
“Human Rights Watch has made up stories that have
had no corroboration whatsoever. …..”
“I spoke with Donatella Rovera, who is AI's
researcher …and asked her to provide the data …Rovera
acknowledged that …the report was based on anecdotal
information, …from Palestinian NGOs.
“It is impossible …for any outside researcher to
replicate AI's study and to confirm or disconfirm its
conclusions.
- Prof. Alan Dershowitz
NGOs and the Hizbollah War - July 2006
• Accusations of "disproportionate force" by Israel, with no explanation
of proportionality in response to Hezbollah terror
• Few NGOs call for the release of the two abducted Israeli soldiers
www.ngo-monitor.org
42 Palestinian
Authority
Syria
91 Libya
Data based on the number and relative weight of documents produced in 2004,
compared to other countries in the Middle East, and excluding Iraq-related
documents, of which actually pertained to US policy.
www.ngo-monitor.org
Arabia
reports per million
4
N . Korea 3
3 Egypt Israel
2
Israel
2 1 0.3 0.6 0.6
Global
1
0 Rate
0.09 0.02
0
HRW’s use of “Durban” Rhetoric- 2005.
Violations International Arbitrary / Unlawful Killing/
Humanitarian law / Human Killing of Civilians / Extra Judicial
Rights Law Killing / Summary Execution
38
40 18
20
30 15
20 10
10 5 3
2 4 3 1 1 1
0 0
Israel Egypt Morocco Israel Syria Egypt Syria
•In HRW Middle East publications, Israel was the only country charged
with "collective punishment" and "war crimes".
•Israel charged with "grave" and /or "serious" human rights
"violations" and/or "abuses" 32 times; Egypt 22 ; all other countries
fewer than 10.
www.ngo-monitor.org
200
180
160
140
120
100 Israel / PA
80 Sudan
60
40
20
0
AI HRW ICJ