Professional Documents
Culture Documents
COMMERCIAL PRACTICE.
MODULE 2 WORKSHOP 2
TASK1 ( GROUP 1)
BRIEF FACTS
Imara Ventures (the company) is an existing Telecommunications
company in Uganda dealing in both voice and internet services. They
are interested in raising funds to the tune of United States Dollars Ten
Million (USD 10,000,000) from a Mauritius Venture Capital Fund, Otis
Capital Partners for working capital. The anticipated close of this
financing round is 31st December 2023. They are also interested in
taking the company public in order to comply with the licensing
requirements of the Uganda Communications Commission by 31 st
December 2024.
ISSUES ARISING
• The venture capitalists beyond providing capital to the business, they also
offer strategic guidance, industry connections, and operational support to help
the company grow and expand.
• For a company or business to look at the financing or pre preparation steps are
in summary as below;
1. The business starts by looking out for the Potential Venture Capitalists who
do specialize in investing in your business ventures are look pout for their
terms and conditions their maximum capital value amongst other features.
• Thereafter Prepare business plans and ideas and an investor pitch deck that
does tell the story of your business to do go ahead and persuade the potential
investors and this includes outlining your company's growth potential,
market opportunity, competitive advantage, and financial projections.
•
Con’t…….
• 5. After the negotiation is closed the agreements reached upon are legally
documented like the stock purchase agreement and upon finalization the
venture capitalist do provide the necessary funds as promised to the
business
1. The seed financing and here funds are provided by the venture capitalists
to go ahead and finance the initial coming up of a new idea.
2. The startup financing and here funding is provided for the establishment,
development of the product and its marketing.
3. The third stage is the first round financing and here the capitalists fund
the business’s manufacturing and early sales funding. Here usually the
funding covers the manufacturing of the product.
Con’t…….
• 4.Upon coming up with a term sheet which is a non-binding
agreement that shows the basic terms and conditions of an investment
you start negotiations with the venture capitalist to finalize the terms
of the investment. This may involve discussions around valuation,
equity stake, governance rights, and other terms such as board
representation and investor protections.
1. The seed financing and here funds are provided by the venture
capitalists to go ahead and finance the initial coming up of a new idea.
2. The startup financing and here funding is provided for the establishment,
development of the product and its marketing.
3. The third stage is the first round financing and here the capitalists fund
the business’s manufacturing and early sales funding. Here usually the
funding covers the manufacturing of the product.
• Cons
1. The main downside is that the investors usually get equity in the
company, and, thus, a say in company decisions. a business that
accepts VC support can lose creative control over its future direction.
VC investors are likely to demand a large share of company equity, and
they may start making demands of the company's management as well.
Many VCs are only seeking to make a fast, high-return payoff and may
pressure the company for a quick exit.
1. By the time a private equity firm acquires a company, it will already have a
plan in place to increase the investment's worth. That could include dramatic
cost cuts or a restructuring, steps the company's incumbent management may
have been reluctant to take. Private equity owners with a limited time to add
value before exiting an investment have more of an incentive to make major
changes.
2. The private equity firm may also have special expertise the company's prior
management lacked. It may help the company develop an e-commerce
strategy, adopt new technology, or enter additional markets. A private-equity
firm acquiring a company may bring in its own management team to pursue
such initiatives or retain prior managers to execute an agreed-upon plan.
3. The acquired company can make operational and financial changes without
the pressure of having to meet analysts' earnings estimates or to please its
public shareholders every quarter. Ownership by private equity may allow
management to take a longer-term view, unless that conflicts with the new
owners' goal of making the biggest possible return on investment.
Con’t……………
• Cons
a) Certificate of incorporationS
• Section 22 of the Companies Act 2012 finds the certificate of incorporation
to be conclusive evidence that the requirements of the act in registration
have been compiled with thus a prospective financer must ascertain its self of
the due registration of the company that it intends to finance .
• A Venture can as well raise extra capital though selling a debenture. Section 2
of the Company’s Act, 2012 defines a debenture to include debenture stock,
bonds and any other securities of a company whether constituting a charge on
the assets of the company or not. A debenture may as well pay periodic
interest payment however they have low interest rate with long due payment
therefore Imara ventures can raise money through issuing a debenture.
ISSUE THREE
Would Our Advice Be Different If the Company Decided to
Issue Corporate Bonds Rather Than Listing As A Form Of
Financing?
• Yes, our advice would be different if a company decided to issue corporate bonds rather
than taking on stock exchange listing as a form of debt financing for expansion because of
the key differences in terms of legal and regulatory considerations.
• Issuing corporate bonds is considered a way of raising debt capital without diluting
ownership and typically involves paying an interest rate, while stock exchange can raise
equity capital but does require sharing the corporate control with new shareholders.
• In essence, when you buy a share of stock, you own equity in the company and will
receive any dividends declared by the company but when you buy corporate bond, you
will not own equity in the company. However, will receive interest and principle on the
bond, no matter how profitable or financial difficulties that it faces. The company has no
similar obligation to pay dividends to shareholders. In bankruptcy, bond investors have
priority over shareholders in claims on the company`s assets.
Con’t………….
• Corporate bonds
• A bond is a debt obligation; where investors who buy corporate bonds are
lending money to the company issuing the bond and in return, the
company makes a legal commitment to pay interest on the principal and,
in most cases, to return the principal when the bond comes due, or
matures.
• For a company to issue corporate bonds, it has to meet the standards in the
guidelines
Con’t…….
• Guideline 7 provides that no company shall issue corporate bonds unless it fulfills the
following requirements;
• (a) The issuer’s paid up share capital and reserves should not be less than Uganda
• Shillings One billion (Ushs. 1,000,000,000) and shall be maintained at that level
during the period the bond remains outstanding.
• (2) The issuer shall have made profits in at least two of the last three financial years
preceding the issue.
• (3) (a) The issuer’s total indebtedness, including the new issue of bonds should not
exceed 400% of the company’s net worth (or gearing ratio of 4:1) as at the date of the
latest balance sheet.
• (b) The issuer’s funds from operations to total debt for the three accounting periods
preceding the issue shall be maintained at a weighted average of 40% or more.
• (c) The conditions in paragraphs (a) and (b) shall be maintained for as long as the bond
remains outstanding.
Con’t……….
Issuance of corporate bonds is primarily regulated by Capital Markets Authority.
Procedure:
The issuer of corporate bonds shall submit to the CMA, and upon obtaining the
approval of the CMA, publish an offer document in the form of a Prospectus or
Information Memorandum, which complies with all the requirements for the issue
of securities as prescribed under the Capital Markets (Prospectus Requirements)
Regulations 1996, as amended. (Guideline 5 of the Capital Markets Corporate
Bonds Guidelines)
The issuer shall make a public announcement in English language in both the
electronic and print media with nationwide circulation at least one week before the
issue opens. (Guideline 17 of the Capital Markets Corporate Bonds Guidelines)
The issuer shall designate one receiving bank. All payments with respect to the
issue shall be made in the issuer’s name and shall be banked in a designated bank
account in the receiving bank. (Guideline 20 of the Capital Markets Corporate
Bonds Guidelines)
Con’t………
•
LISTING
• The procedure for Cross Listing is embedded under Rule 17 of the Uganda Securities Exchange Listing Rules as follows;
• Under part I pursuant to Rule 2 of the Uganda Securities Exchange Listing Rules,
cross listing is defined as the listing or intended listing of a security on the exchange
which security is already listed on another stock exchange.
• The procedure for Cross Listing is embedded under Rule 17 of the Uganda Securities
Exchange Listing Rules as follows;
• It is important to note that only those issuers meeting the eligibility criteria for the Main
Investment Market Segment or equivalent segment in their home market shall be
eligible to be admitted to the Main Investment Market Segment of the official list and
shall be allowed to cross list.
• A draft prospectus shall then be sent by the sponsoring broker to the markets of prior
listing.
• Consequently, the Authorities and Exchanges of those markets shall respond within ten
(10) business days with a confidential report on the applicant and a letter of no objection
or otherwise addressed to the exchange.
Con’t…….
• It is further averred therein that all applicants must comply with the Main
Investment Market Segment provisions of these Rules.
• An applicant for cross listing is expected to provide such float that provides
such liquidity as may be deemed reasonable and agreed to by the exchange.
• Sub rule (2) of the Instant provision goes on to stipulate that on receipt of
written approval from the Authority, the Exchange may admit the shares.
• It is important to note that for cross listing to be successfully achieved, the
issuer must address the aspect of Introduction pursuant to Rule 19 of the
same. Introduction under part 1 rule 2 of the listing rules is defined as a
method of bringing securities to listing not involving an issue of new
securities or any marketing of existing securities, subject to compliance
with the condition of listing in the relevant market segment. Similarly,
Regulation 2(1) of Capital Markets (Cross Boarder Introductions)
Regulations, 2004 defines introduction as the listing of securities which
are already listed and trading on stock exchange in another jurisdiction. To
this effect, the issuer must comply with the conditions for listing set out in
part V and Appendix 1(b) of the Rules herein.
Con’t…….
• Sub rule (2) of the instant rule essentially avers that an applicant for
listing by Introduction shall comply with the conditions and procedures
required for listing Securities on the Exchange and shall meet the
eligibility criteria for listing on the Main Investment Market
Segment (MIMS).
• Pursuant to Part V of the Uganda Securities Exchange Listing
Rules, Main Investment Market Segment (MIMS) refers to main
quotation market segment with stringent eligibility, listing and
disclosure requirements.
• Cognizant of the above statutory provisions, the company can
successfully cross list in Uganda.
Con’t…….
• REQUIREMENTS FOR LISTING.
• Under part V Rule 32 of the Uganda Securities Exchange Listing Rules provides
for the requirements for listing on Main Investment Market Segment (MIMS);
• Subrule(1)(a) is to the effect that the issuer shall be a company limited by shares and
incorporated or registered under the Companies Act 2012 as a Public limited liability
company, or if it is a foreign company as purported by the instant facts, it shall be
registered under the relevant provisions of the Companies Act.
• Subrule(1)(b) goes on to guide that the issuer shall have a minimum authorized, issued
and fully paid-up share capital of 50,000 currency points and net assets of 100,000
currency points before the public offering of shares and,
• Subrule(1)(c) avers further that the issuer shall have published audited financial
statements for a period of at least 5 years in compliance with International Accounting
Standards for an accounting period ending on a date not more than six (6) months prior
to the propossed date of the offer.
• Subrule 3 provides that the issuer shall have prepared financial statements for the latest
accounting period on a going concern basis.
• Furthermore, the issuer shall not be in breach of any of its loan covenants pursuant to
subrule 4.
Con’t…….
• Subrule 5 is to the effect that as at the date of the Application and for
of at least two (2) years prior to the date of application, no director
of the issuer;
a. An information memorandum
b. A letter of No objection from the applicant’s primary regulator
c. A letter of No objection from the applicant’s primary exchange.
d. The fees specified in the Third Schedule.
• The contents of the Information Memorandum are stated below subject to
Regulation 4 of the Capital Markets (Cross boarder Listing)
Regulations,2004;
• (1) An Information Memorandum submitted to the Authority for approval of
• an Introduction shall contain the information specified in the Second Schedule.
• (2) The Authority may, in its discretion, waive, modify or dispense with
• any criterion specified in the First Schedule or any requirement to disclose any of
the information specified in the Second Schedule.
• (3) The Authority may require an applicant to furnish such further
Con’t…….
• information or documentation, as the Authority may deem necessary for
purposes of the application for an Introduction.
• (4) An Information Memorandum shall not be published or distributed
• without compliance with any amendments, directions made or issued by
the
• Authority, unless any such amendments or directions have been
withdrawn inwriting by the Authority.
• (5) An Information Memorandum shall include a declaration by the
• Applicant stating that to the best of the applicant’s knowledge and belief
—
• (a) all the information required to be included in the Information
• Memorandum under these Regulations or by an amendment or
• directive made or issued by the Authority has been so included; and
• (b) there are no other facts bearing on the application, which in the
• applicant’s knowledge and belief should be disclosed to the Authority.
Con’t…….
• Regulation 5 of the instant statutory provision provides for fees
wherein sub regulation 1 avers that the Authority shall not receive
any application for approval of the information Memorandum unless
it is accompanied by the prescribed fees.
• Sub regulation 2 goes on to state that the fees paid under these
Regulations are non-refundable notwithstanding;
• Ham Enterprises Limited and 2 Others v Diamond Trust Bank (U) Limited
and Another (Civil Appeal 13 of 2021)
• It was held that the relationship between these two banking institutions (DTB-U
and DTB-K), and between them and Ham, with regard to the financial credit
transactions, were neither governed by the Financial Institutions Act, 2004, as
amended, nor the Financial Institutions (Agent Banking) Regulations, 2017. This
was a syndicated agency relationship between DTB-U and DTB-K.
• There is no law that forbids the creation of the syndicated agency relationship
entered by DTB-U and DTB-K. Similarly, no law forbids foreign financial
institutions from extending credit facilities to any financial institution or person in
Uganda. If anything, in furtherance of international trade and investment, financial
institutions the world over are known to engage in global financial business
transactions by dealing with, or through, financial institutions based in other
jurisdictions. In the case of Uganda, such international financial business
transactions are certainly neither governed by the Financial Institutions Act, 2004,
as amended, nor the Financial Institutions (Agent Banking) Regulations, 2017. The
trial judge therefore erred in holding that the credit agreements between the parties
were clothed with illegality.
Con’t……….
• In a syndicated lending scenario involving both a venture capital (VC) fund
and a private equity (PE) fund, some considerations for protecting their
respective commercial interests include the following;
• Risk Allocation: syndicate lenders should also clearly identify and allocate
risks among themselves. This includes risks associated with the venture itself,
market conditions, and any potential default scenarios. In the agreements,
provisions for risk mitigation strategies and decision-making processes in case
of unforeseen circumstances should be expressly included.
• Governing Law and Dispute Resolution: Specify the governing law to be applied
in case of disputes. Determine the jurisdiction for dispute resolution and establish
mechanism for resolving conflicts efficiently.
• Collateral and Security Interests: Clearly define the collateral and security
interests associated with the venture debt. Establish how these interests will be
shared or prioritized among the syndicate members.
The documents that usually protect the interests of the PE and VC are:
Term sheet
Share pledge agreement
Term sheet
• A term sheet is a nonbinding agreement that shows the basic terms and
conditions of an investment. The term sheet serves as a template and
basis for more detailed, legally binding documents. Once the parties
involved reach an agreement on the details laid out in the term sheet, a
binding agreement or contract that conforms to the term sheet details is
drawn up.
Con’t………
• Term sheets are most often associated with startups. Entrepreneurs find this
document crucial for investors, often VCs (VC), who may offer capital to fund
startups.
• A term sheet used as part of a merger or attempted acquisition would typically
contain information regarding the initial purchase price offer, the preferred
payment method, and the assets included in the deal. The term sheet may also
contain information regarding what, if anything is excluded from the deal or any
items that may be considered requirements by one or both parties.
• The company valuation, investment amount, percentage stake, voting rights,
liquidation preference, anti-dilutive provisions, and investor commitment are
some items that should be spelled out in the term sheet.