Professional Documents
Culture Documents
MODULE 2
FIRM C4
WORKSHOP 2
GROUP 1 - TASK A
1 HASSAN – LEADER
2 SAMORA – SECRETARY
3 BENITA
FIRM C4
4 FAHIM
5 KENNEDY
6 AGNES
7 MARY
8 NORMAN
9 ROBERT
10 KENNETH
BRIEF FACTS:
FIRM C4
region and generally improve the livelihood of Ugandans served by the
station when completed. The Government of Uganda is determined to
have the land by January 2024 and hand it over to a Russian Company
that is going to execute the works. James intends to hold out for a hefty
compensation unlike some of his neighbors who the thinks are foolish
negotiators.
LEGAL ISSUES:
1. Whether the Government can acquire James Musajjalumba’s land
compulsorily?
2. What is the procedure and the process to be followed by government to
acquire James Musajjalumba’s Land compulsorily?
3. What are the rights of James Musajjalumba if government is to acquire
his land compulsorily?
4. Whether James has other options to take against the government if he
FIRM C4
is not satisfied by the government’s compensation?
LAW APPLICABLE:
FIRM C4
Art 26(2)(a) – No person shall be compulsorily deprived of property or
any interest in or right over property of any description except where the
following conditions are satisfied;
• The taking of possession or acquisition is necessary for public
use or in the interest of defense, public safety, public order,
public morality or public health. – Advocates for Natural
Resources Governance & Development & Others v AG & Others,
(Constitutional Petition No. 40 of 2013).
where government acquires or takes possession of any persons property,
such an act has to be made in a law which provides for “Prompt payment of
fair and adequate compensation; prior to the taking of possession or
acquisition of property”
Section 42 of the Land Acquisition Act – the Government or a local
government may acquire land in accordance with Articles 26 and 237(2)
of the Constitution.
FIRM C4
IN RESOLUTION OF ISSUE 2: What is the procedure and the process to
be followed by government to acquire James Musajjalumba’s Land
compulsorily?
The procedure for land acquisition is provided for under the Land
Acquisition Act, Cap 226 and also discussed in the case of Sheema
Cooperative Ranching Society & 31 Others v. AG, HCCS No. 103 Of
2010.
FIRM C4
any land is required by Government for public purpose with
retrospective effect. Therefore the said Statutory Instrument was
ultra vires of the power of the Minister and was illegal.
Also in Shema case above, a Statutory Instrument which was
made after the invasion of the squatters was held to be “a mere
mask to cloth the compulsory acquisition with legality”
STEP 4: The land is then accordingly marked out – Section 4 of the Land
Acquisition Act.
STEP 5: Notice of the government’s intention to take over must be
advertised in the gazette and accordingly placed on or near the land –
Section 5(1) of the Land Acquisition Act.
STEP 6: The notice shall inter-alia require all interested persons to appear,
with details pertinent to their interests in the land, objections and
compensation – Section 5(3) of the Land Acquisition Act.
FIRM C4
STEP 7: An assessment officer then holds an inquiry to determine the
amount of compensation and its apportionment – Section 6(1) of the Land
Acquisition Act.
A licensee cannot be compensated: Ngumuyo Estate L.T.D v.
A.G (1971) H.C.B 89.
All tenants are entitled to compensation: Abdulla v. The
Collector (1958) E.A 779.
Compensation is based on the market value of willing buyer
willing seller: Chand v. The Collector (1957) A.C 125:
Collector (1957) A.C 125:
STEP 8: Any disgruntled party may appeal within 60 days to the High court
pertinent to the compensation or any apportionment of the same – Section
13 of the Land Acquisition Act.
STEP 9: Upon the making of the award the assessment officer then takes
possession of the property – Section 7(1) of the Land Acquisition Act.
Uganda National Roads Authority v. Irumba Asumani & Peter
Magelah, SCCA No.2 of 2014.
FIRM C4
IN RESOLUTION OF ISSUE 3: What are the rights of James Musajjalumba
if government is to acquire his land compulsorily?
FIRM C4
Section 41(6)(a) of the Land Act Cap 227 – any compulsory acquisition
of land, compensation shall be at a fair market valuation assessed on a
willing seller buyer basis.
Section 41(6)(b) – the commission shall pay all reasonable costs of
disturbance to the person from whom land is to be acquired.
Section 41(6)(c) – in case the land occupied under customary tenure, in
addition to compensation assessed under this section, there shall be
paid as a disturbance allowance a sum not exceeding 15% percent of
the sum awarded to the person from whom land is to be acquired where
that person was using the land as his or her home.
IN RESOLUTION OF ISSUE 4: Whether James has other options to take
against the government if he is not satisfied by the government’s
compensation?
FIRM C4
section 6, any person awarded or claiming that he or she should have been
awarded compensation may within sixty days of the date of the award
appeal to the High Court by way of objection to any or all of the following—
(a) The total amount of the compensation awarded;
(b) The apportionment of the compensation;
(c) Any failure or refusal of the assessment officer to include him or
her in the apportionment
GROUP 3 – PART B
1 PAULA – LEADER
2 LAMECH – SECRETARY
3 DAVID K
FIRM C4
4 MARIAM
5 JACKSON
6 HAKIM
7 BRENDA
8 SHIRLEY
9 SIMON
BRIEF FACTS:
FIRM C4
appointed to which warring parties reached a compromise to allow
unhindered access to the well.
LAW APPLICABLE:
1. The Constitution of the Republic of Uganda, 1995 [as amended].
2. The Land Act, Cap 227 [as amended].
3. The Registration of Titles Act, Cap 230.
4. The Survey Act, Cap 232.
5. Case law
FIRM C4
LEGAL ISSUES:
FIRM C4
An easement is not a personal right but a right that is annexed to land
and passes with land.
In Re Ellen Bouilgh Park (1958) CH 131, Evershed MK adopted the test
to determine whether an easement existed. He said that;
FIRM C4
land vested in it.
Section 71 thereof – public rights of way.
Section 61 of the Road Act – Minister to specify requirements and
specifications of access roads and Section 62 thereof – deals with an
application for leave to construct access road through private property
where negotiations fail.
Therefore, our facts are to the effect that James can fence off his piece of
land with due regard to the legislations concerning Easements in particular
right of way to access community well.
IN RESOLUTION OF ISSUE 2: What appropriate agreement can be
drafted to protect interests of the community?
The community can enter into a Right of way Agreement with Mr. James.
FIRM C4
This is as a result of easements created by express grant/ reservation
This agreement is inferred by legislation, common law and case law.
FIRM C4
statement to the effect that the person named in the certificate is entitled
to any easement, the statement shall be received by all courts as
conclusive evidence that they is so entitled.
Section 61 – 65 of the RTA are also pertinent as well as 3rd & 5th
Schedule.
The process is as follows:
1. Express grant of the right of way by an agreement.
2. The agreement is registered as a public document under
URSB.
3. Agreement delivered to the Registrar of Titles together with a
certificate of Title and proof of payment of fees.
4. Easement instrument effected on the Certificate of Title.
GROUP 3 – PART C
1 ISAAC – LEADER
2 GABRIEL – SECRETARY
3 AMINAH
FIRM C4
4 DAPHINE
5 JONATHAN
6 MADINAH
7 ZAM
8 PATIENCE
9 RUTH
BRIEF FACTS:
Erukana Sentongo in the year 2016 bought from a one Ssempijja a third
of an acre of land situated at Kyandondo Block 256 Plot 110 on the
fringes of Muyenga bordering some slummy areas of Namowongo in
Kampala District. He developed a state of the art mansion facing the
lake with a very beautiful panoramic view. In December 2022 Ssempijja
decided to sell to two thirds of the residue to Col. Mansur and currently
putting a skyscraper that blocked Erukana’s access road to the public
FIRM C4
way claiming its part of his land. Majje has refused to listen to any
negotiations.
LEGAL ISSUES:
1. Whether Erukana can lawfully have access to the road by public way
and procedure there under?
LAW APPLICABLE:
FIRM C4
3. The Constitution of the Republic of Uganda, 1995 [as amended].
4. The Roads Act, 2019.
5. The Practice Direction No.1 of 2006
6. Case law
RESOLUTION OF ISSUES:
IN RESOLUTION OF ISSUE 1: Whether Erukana can lawfully have access
to the road by public way and procedure there under?
FIRM C4
The case established that a property owner doesn’t have unqualified
rights over the airspace above their land. An owner of land has a rights
in heights above, only to such a height in above, as is necessary for
the ordinary use and enjoyment of his land and structures upon it.
In the Case of Phipps v. Pears (1965) 1 QB 76 Lord Denning noted
that where one has a fine view from his house, and has enjoyed the view
for many years, but where his neighbours choose to abstract by building
up and blocking it ,the person with the fine view has no redress , and
has no right to the view.
As per the facts above Erukana has no right over the panoramic view in
light of the intended blockage by Majje.
IN RESOLUTION OF ISSUE 2: What are the necessary documents
required to pursue the remedy?
Section 3 of the Road Access Act, 2019 defines a right to way to means
the right to use a public road.
FIRM C4
Article 43 of the Constitution of the Republic of Uganda provides that, in
all enjoyments of the rights and freedoms described in the Constitution
no person shall prejudice the fundamental human rights and freedoms of
other public interest while enjoying their rights.
In the even that negotiation fails, section 62(1) provides that the owner
FIRM C4
of the land should be unable to obtain leave from adjoining land owners
through negotiation to construct a road access to the public.
FIRM C4
Direction No. 1 of 2006.
Therefore, with regard to the facts Erukana can lawfully have access to
the road by virtue of provision of section 62 of the Road Act.
GROUP 4 – TASK D & E
1 ANNET – LEADER
2 EDNA – SECRETARY
3 JOHN
FIRM C4
4 NATHAN
5 CATHERINE
6 CHRISTOPHER
7 CYNTHIA
8 ANNAH
9 JOSEPHAT
BRIEF FACTS:
FIRM C4
months in advance however in the corridor one of the tenants has allowed
his younger brother to display his art work which he covers when Mukalazi
Mansur comes around. James Kapwepwe intends to clear this entire
building and start on a clean slate and also wants to construct a basement
parking on a plot that he purchased from Jakana Kato however this will
involve deep excavations and yet the plot is next to another buiding owned
by Mugaga Ramazani.
LAW APPLICABLE:
FIRM C4
6. The Land Regulations of 2004 (as amended).
7. Case law
LEGAL ISSUES:
2. What are the different interests and rights of the occupants of this
buildings?
FIRM C4
4. What are the obligations of Kapwepwe to Mugaga as he undertakes
his excavation works?
Copies of all the lease agreements for the different occupied spaces;
highlighting the duration of each and general terms which govern
them.
Ascertainment of who the two people that have rent arrears are and
how much money they are owing.
FIRM C4
How many tenants are on the second floor and what nature of
business do they carry out?
Whether Mansur has taken any means to recover the money from
these defaulters( has he lodged a case in court)?
What are the rights/interests of Salongo Matayo and Zaituni ?(are they
tenants?, licensees?)
Are there any other people that hold proprietory interests in this
building apart from the known tenants?
What are the rent charges for each tenant?
When does Kapwepwe intend to clear /vacate the tenants from the
entire building?
IN RESOLUTION OF ISSUE 2: What are the different interests and rights
of the occupants of this buildings?
FIRM C4
have rights as provided for under the Landlord and tenant Act, 2022;
A right to an agreement copy of a tenant. This is provided for under
Section 5 of the Landlord and Tenant Act 2022.
A right to get receipts after payment of rent is made to the landlord, this
is issued immediately or within 5 working days of receiving the payment,
as per section 25 (1) of the Landlord and Tenant Act, 2022.
A right to quiet enjoyment of the premises. A landlord shall take all
reasonable steps to ensure that the tenant has quiet enjoyment of the
premises during their tenancy as per section 19 of the Landlord and
tenant Act 2022
A right to non-discrimination. Section 20 of the Landlord and tenant Act
2022 the landlord shall not refuse to rent on grounds of sex, race, colour,
ethnic origin, tribe, birth, creed or religion, social or economic standing,
political opinion or disability.
FIRM C4
not apply to repair of damage caused by the tenants negligence or failure
to take reasonable care as per section 8 (1) of the Landlord and Tenant
Act.
Taxes and rates: Under this the landlord is responsible for the payment
of all taxes and rates imposed by law in respect of the premises and
where the tenant pays any taxes or rates in respect of the premises , the
landlord shall compensate the tenant the amount paid as per section 10
of the Landlord and Tenant Act.
In the instant facts we see that the building Kapwepwe bought has
occupants in the floors and have been paying rent and these occupants
have several rights under the landlord and tenant Act. However there
are two tenants described by Mansur as difficult and have rent arrears
and in this Kapwepwe can address this issue by applying to a court with
competent jurisdiction to recover the rent owed as per section 29 of the
Landlord and tenant Act 2022.
FIRM C4
ZAITUN
She operates a Mobile money Kiosk on the Veranda and pays some
minimal fees to Mansur which is 100,000/= every month.
FIRM C4
any consideration made.
A bare license effectively confers the right only of not being a trespasser
so long as they comply with the terms of the license, it does not confer
any higher status than that.
Section 33 of the LAND LORD AND TENANT ACT provides for invalid
assignment and subletting of premises and it states that an assignment of
a tenancy or subletting of the whole or any part of the premises by a
tenant without the consent of the landlord is invalid and immediately
terminates the tenancy.
In the facts, we see that one of the tenants did not inform the landlord
Mansur of his assignment of the corridor to his young brother Enoch to
display his art pieces and this evidenced when Enoch hides when he hears
that Mansur is passing by thus this makes this assignment invalid for
there’s no consent from the Landlord. This simply implies that Enoch has
no rights and is a trespasser.
FIRM C4
occupants above to vacate?
FIRM C4
1. Make an application to the Building Committee, in writing for
approval of the required structural temporary works prior to the
commencement of excavation;
2. Take precautionary measures as may be specified by the Building
Committee.
3. Maintain open excavations in a safe condition at all times to the
satisfaction of the Building Committee; The Contractor must take all
steps necessary to safeguard the existing property and adjacent
property, make good at his own expense any injury to persons or
damage to property caused thereon, and hold the Government
indemnified against any such claim arising.
4. Present the permit issued by the Building committee. Regulations 14 of
the building Control Regulations 2020, provides for Excavations.
FIRM C4
6. Proximity of adjacent buildings; Engineers must consider the proximity of
adjacent buildings to ensure their stability during and after excavation. By
employing appropriate support systems, such as soil nailing, and
anchors, in order to minimize potential damages to the adjacent
structures. Saba Gifco Uganda Limited v. DFCU Bank Limited & 2
Others (CIVIL SUIT NO. 157 OF 2017).
IN RESOLUTION OF ISSUE 6: What are the appropriate legal fees and their
justification?
FIRM C4
Regulation 14(b) of the Advocates (Remuneration and Taxation of Costs)
Rules S.I 267-4 provides that in respect of leases, agreements for lease
or conveyances reserving rents or agreements for the same completed,
the remuneration shall be that prescribed in the second schedule to these
rules.
Part 1(c) of the Second Schedule to the Regulations provides for the scale
of charges where the consideration exceeds UGX 20,000,000; 5% of the
amount not exceeding 10,000,000 UGX, 3% of the amount exceeding
10,000,000 shillings but not exceeding 20,000,000 UGX; and 2% of the
amount exceeding 20,000,000 UGX.
According to our facts, Kapwepwe wants each of the 45 tenants to pay
UGX 3,500,000 Per month which totals to UGX 157,500,000 Per month.
FIRM C4
Therefore, I would charge UGX 3,650,000 as fees for execution of the
tenancy agreement.