Human Rights Alert (NGO)

Joseph Zernik, PhD

PO Box 31440, Jerusalem jz12345@earthlink.net ;

"
,31440 "

Digitally signed by
Joseph Zernik
DN: cn=Joseph
Zernik, o, ou,
email=jz12345@ea
rthlink.net, c=US
Date: 2012.07.17
10:28:33 +03'00'

12-07-17 Moshe Silman v State of Israel (1752-08) at the District Court of Tel Aviv electronic
public records
The case was administered as a paper court file. The records, which are publicly accessible through Net
HaMishpat, the electronic record system of the District Courts, are inconsistent or inherently contradictory.
Based on the publicly accessible electronic records, it is impossible to determine the nature of the
proceedings.

Attached:
#

Record

Moshe Silman v State of Israel (1752-08) in the Tel Aviv District Court
Overview of electronic public records decisions, calendars, etc
08-07-10 Decision, unsigned by unnamed, different case number 13491-08
08-07-31 Decision by Magistrate Ethan Orenstein, unsigned
08-10-28 Decision by Magistrate Ethan Orenstein, unsigned
09-11-19a Decision by Magistrate Hagai Brenner appears in court file as a copy from Att Man's office,
issued in absence of parties
09-11-19b Decision - Protocol from Atty Man's office, stating the decision was issued on the same
date in presence of parties
09-11-19 Calendar of the Tel Aviv District Court all judges

2
3
4
5
6
7

LINKS:
[1] 12-07-14 Moshe Silman sets himself on fire in a Tel Aviv social protest, leaves a letter
http://www.scribd.com/doc/100289353/
[2] 10-04-19 Human Rights Alert (NG0) submission to the United Nations Human Rights Council for the
2010 Review (UPR) of Human Rights in the United States as incorporated into the UPR staff report:
http://www.scribd.com/doc/38566837/

Page
#
2
9
11
12
13
17
22

Moshe Silman v State of Israel (1752-08) in the Tel Aviv District Court
Overview of electronic public records
A. List of Decisions
Searched for Court Decisions by the Case Number (1752-08), retrieved from TakDin:

Five Decisions are listed, all under Case Number (1752-08) of the Tel Aviv District Court:
a) 08-07-10 Decision
b) 08-10-28 Decision
c) 08-07-31 Decision
d) 09-11-19a Decision
e) 09-11-19b Decision
Internet Explorer security blocked the download of the Word files of the decisions (an option provided on the
lower left), since the web site was unverifiable:
http://www.court.gov.il/NGCS.Web.Site/LocateDecisions/LocateDecisionOutput.aspx

B. Decisions
1. 08-07-10 Decision by unnamed
The Decision is unsigned, no name of a judge appears on the paper, and the paper bears a different Case
Number (13491-08).
2. 08-10-28 Decision by Magistrate Ethan Orenstein
The decision is unsigned.
3. 08-07-31 Decision by Magistrate Ethan Orenstein
Appears out of sequence in the list of decisions.
The decision is unsigned.

4. 09-11-19a Decision by Magistrate Hagai Brenner

The Decision, which appears online is not from the court file, but a copy of a paper from Attorney
Manns office.
The decision was given in the absence of the parties.
The instruction is to Mail not to serve the parties the Decision.
5. 09-11-19b Decision by Magistrate Hagai Brenner Protocol for November 19, 2009
The protocol, which appears online is not from the court file, but a copy of a paper from Attorney
Manns office?
It indicates, in contrast with the 09-11-19a Decision, that a proceeding was conducted in the presence of
the parties and decision was issued in the presence of the parties.
C. Calendars
1. 08-07-10 Decision by unnamed
The Calendar of the Court for July 10, 2008 shows no data for proceedings on that date:

2. 08-10-28 Decision by Magistrate Ethan Orenstein

The Calendar of the Court for October 28, 2008 shows no data for proceedings on that date:

3. 08-07-31 Decision by Magistrate Ethan Orenstein

The Calendar of the Court for October 28, 2008 shows no data for proceedings on that date:

4. 09-11-19a,b Decisions by Magistrate Hagai Brenner

The Calendar of Magistrate Judge Brenner for November 19, 2009 says:

Time of Proceeding: 10:10

Court File No: 1752-08
Type: Civil
Caption: Moshe Silman et al v Social Security, Tel Aviv, et al
Type of Proceeding: Pre-trial
Other: Hagai Brener
Status of the Proceeding: Did not take place.

D. Online Court File Information

1. General Details

Sealing: Not sealed,

Sum: NIS 8,000,000.00,
Status: Closed
Cause of Closure: Failure to pay Complaint Filing Fee
2. General Details Complaint - General

Opening Date: July 8, 2008

File Type: Paper
Closing Date: February 3, 2010.

3. General Details Complaint Expanded

Location of the Paper Court File

Unit: Tel Aviv District Court,
Comments: Judge Brenners Chambers,
Start Date: November 5, 2009
4. General Details Complaint Jurisdiction

Adjudicating Body: Judge

Start Date: December 14, 2009
Previous Adjudicating Bodies:
Start Date: July 8, 2008

End Date: December 14, 2009

Name: Shmuel Baruch
5. General Details Complaint Related Data

No related data.
E.

Search for the Case Number (13491-08), which appears on some records

Court File Number 013491-08 was not found.

Page 1 of 2

http://www.court.gov.il/EPDefault/FlashReader/print.asp

7/16/2012

Page 2 of 2

http://www.court.gov.il/EPDefault/FlashReader/print.asp

7/16/2012

Page 1 of 1

http://www.court.gov.il/EPDefault/FlashReader/print.asp

7/16/2012

Page 1 of 1

http://www.court.gov.il/EPDefault/FlashReader/print.asp

7/16/2012

Page 1 of 4

http://www.court.gov.il/EPDefault/FlashReader/print.asp

7/16/2012

Page 2 of 4

http://www.court.gov.il/EPDefault/FlashReader/print.asp

7/16/2012

Page 3 of 4

http://www.court.gov.il/EPDefault/FlashReader/print.asp

7/16/2012

Page 4 of 4

http://www.court.gov.il/EPDefault/FlashReader/print.asp

7/16/2012

Page 1 of 5

http://www.court.gov.il/EPDefault/FlashReader/print.asp

7/17/2012

Page 2 of 5

http://www.court.gov.il/EPDefault/FlashReader/print.asp

7/17/2012

Page 3 of 5

http://www.court.gov.il/EPDefault/FlashReader/print.asp

7/17/2012

Page 4 of 5

http://www.court.gov.il/EPDefault/FlashReader/print.asp

7/17/2012

Page 5 of 5

http://www.court.gov.il/EPDefault/FlashReader/print.asp

7/17/2012

Page 1 of 3

19/11/2009

>>

<<
"

15/11/2009

16/11/2009

17/11/2009

18/11/2009

19/11/2009

20/11/2009

15

'

' -

'

'

'
1

'

11

"

'

12

12

11

''

'

'

' -

'

' -

'

'

'
6

'

'

21/11/2009

'

'
1

1
2

'

' -

'

"

11

'

''

"

7/16/2012

http://www.court.gov.il/NGCS.Web.Site/Reports/ReportCourtWeeklyCalendarView.aspx

Page 2 of 3

"

14

11

'

4
1

'

43

-
3

'

-
3

7/16/2012

13

-
5

22

12

11

http://www.court.gov.il/NGCS.Web.Site/Reports/ReportCourtWeeklyCalendarView.aspx

Page 3 of 3

"

137

160

114

7
202

163

" :
Copyright 2003 The State of Israel. All Rights Reserved

7/16/2012

http://www.court.gov.il/NGCS.Web.Site/Reports/ReportCourtWeeklyCalendarView.aspx