What is a Beta Reader? In my mind a beta reader is a person with multiple tasks.

The first order of business is to spell and grammar check. The second order is to read the story and ensure the characters are portrayed accurately (unless it is AR/AU). The next step is to ensure continuity within the story. For example, timelines are important for accuracy. A story set in 1870 would not have a hair dryer in it, for instance. This is, of course, a blatant example but the point is made. The overall content must then be examined and questions asked. The same old who, what, when, where, why and how applies. There is a lot more to being a beta reader than simply checking for proper spelling and verbage. A good beta will tell the author what works and what doesn't. She/he will have the courage to debate a point with the author. Ultimately, the author has the final say, of course. However, if a beta finds themselves in such abject disagreement with the author's portrayal, the only recourse is to gracefully bow out and suggest a different beta. What a beta should never do is discuss the story with anyone else without the author's express permission. If the beta feels they need help, they should first ask the author if they may bring in an additional beta. If the author disagrees, no more should be said. Express your concerns with the author and leave the final decision in their hands. It is possible and correct to express your disagreement in a civil and polite manner. Criticism without constructive feedback is useless and, at times, hurtful. These are, of course, only my opinions of what a good beta does for her/his author. lancermadam