Making Histories Essay Evaluation Questions Argument and Structure How effective is the introduction?

uction? Is there a clear thesis statement? Is there signposting for the reader about the structure of the argument? Is there a clear division into paragraphs? Are there effective transition sentences? Is there a clear conclusion addressing the thesis statement or question? Do analysis and argument predominate over narrative and accumulation of evidence?

Grammar, Spelling and Syntax How accurate are the following: Syntax Spelling Punctuation Typing

Reading, Bibliography and Footnotes Are the titles listed correctly? Is there evidence of wide and appropriate reading?

Content How thoughtfully and analytically does the essay address the topic? How good is the choice of evidence? How effective is analysis of evidence? How effective is the evaluation of secondary sources? How well does the essay juxtapose primary and secondary sources? What level of understanding of the topic does the essay show?