Professional Documents
Culture Documents
waters. How extraordinarily soft is the light, and how the dark waters dance, with
the morning star over the trees, the only star in the sky. Do you ever notice any
of that? Or are you so busy, so occupied with the daily routine, that you forget
or have never known the rich beauty of this earth — this earth on which all of us
have to live? Whether we call ourselves communists or capitalists, Hindus or
Buddhists, Moslems or Christians, whether we are blind, lame, well or happy, this
earth is ours.
Do you understand? It is our earth, not somebody else's; it is not only the rich
man's earth, it does not belong exclusively to the powerful rulers, to the nobles
of the land, but it is our earth, yours and mine.
We are nobodies, yet we also live on this earth and we all have to live together.
It is the world of the poor as well as of the rich, of the unlettered as well as
of the learned. It is our world, and I think it is very important to feel this and
to love the earth, not just occasionally on a peaceful morning, but all the time.
We can feel that it is our world and love it only when we understand what freedom
is.
KRISHNAMURTI
ON THE FLIGHT FROM DISTURBANCE
A Collection of Krishnamurti's Teachings
Introduction
1. Background. Krishnamurti noted that many people, having suffered in their
lives, seek comfort and peace of mind in religion. But, throughout his public
talks he roundly criticised the flight from disturbance as a destructive and
"dangerous" tendency -- settling for pacifiers in the absence of peace (6Aug49),
settling for tranquillisers in the absence of tranquillity (7Jul55).
Flight from disturbance is a rather natural impulse, especially for those who feel
exhausted by the burdens they have carried. One might well expect a compassionate
teacher to offer comfort to those in such a situation. But that was not
Krishnamurti's way. Instead he sounded a warning to beware of those who offer
comfort -- "a snare in which you are caught like a fish in a net" (13Apr35). This
is one of many vivid metaphors he used to convey the urgency of facing reality in
a more robust spirit. From early to late, he counselled against putting up "Please
Do Not Disturb" signs when the house we live in is burning. (11Jul48, 27Jul77).
We have collected below a number of passages from public talks in which
Krishnamurti examines in detail the longing for shelter, and explores the
strategies man has invented to avoid discomfort. Through these passages the reader
can see Krishnamurti in action, analysing the causes and destructive consequences
of flight from disturbance, and see him responding to it with acute poignancy: "We
carry on; and the beauty of life passes by." (21Jan54). These passages also
explain how flight from disturbance can actually increase insecurity. After
carefully building protective walls around ourselves, we may naturally fear the
day when those walls break down ("Something will Crack" 27Jul77). The remedy he
offers is to learn the vitality that comes from being "entirely vulnerable to
life". (26Jun35)
2. The Documentary Record For the present study, we canvassed nearly two thousand
contexts from Krishnamurti's public talks between 1926 and 1985. From this vast
material we selected nearly one hundred passages to introduce several aspects of
this rather subtle theme.
We have not so far found any single term in common usage or in Krishnamurti's
special vocabulary, to capture this particular topic. It might well be explored
through any chosen terms from a background set of more than sixty alternatives
that we initially looked at. We chose to focus on three main
keywords: disturbance, comfort andvulnerability. These three terms provided more
than sufficient material to illustrate some central issues and, we hope, to give
readers a useful starting point for their own inquiries in this field.
3. Arrangement of the Source Material. We have organised our selections under
seven headings (1) Beware of Those Who Offer Comfort (2) I am Afraid of Losing
What I Have (3) I Have Built My Own Prison (4) Security or Awareness? (5) No
Escape From Life (6) Entirely Vulnerable (7) That is the Moment to Inquire.
For the present study, we have not adhered to any chronological arrangement of
selections within each section. After experimenting with several arrangements, it
is our sense that this particular topic lends itself better to a thematic
arrangement. We have aimed for a sequence of passages which could help readers to
identify an important but perhaps somewhat neglected thread that runs through many
contexts in Krishnamurti's public talks.
4. Its Destructive Consequences. We have already noted one major consequence that
Krishnamurti drew out of the flight from disturbance -- that it creates artificial
fears and new anxieties. In this respect it may be a self-defeating impulse, which
begins in weariness and ends in even more suffering. Gradually we bind ourselves
by commitments and vested interests and then we fear to lose what was gained in
these ways. Krishnamurti noted how this promotes conservative attitudes -- "we
want to live an undisturbed, respectable, bourgeois life" (7Sep61). Here and
elsewhere Krishnamurti wryly treated material and spiritual comfort as two sides
of the same debased coin -- "I want a comfortable chair or ... a comfortable,
secure idea which can never be shaken" (30Aug77; see also 31Dec33). He warned that
all these attitudes encourage disengagement, and we let things drift, even when
that entails complicity in "world catastrophe" (11Jul48). What is more, flight
from disturbance is ultimately self-destructive: "your thoughts and feelings
become shallow, barren, trivial, and life becomes an empty shell" (1Jan34).
5. It Blocks Free Inquiry. Krishnamurti's critique of authority as a hindrance to
free inquiry, is well-known. His critique of the flight from disturbance as
another major hindrance to free inquiry, is considerably more subtle and probably
less widely recognised. One of the deepest and most destructive consequences that
he saw in flight from disturbance is the way it makes one insensitive and closes
the doors to the "laboratory of life" in which we learn (22Nov59). It makes one
run away from many of those learning opportunities which present themselves
precisely at moments of disturbance and engagement in a crisis. Because of the
cardinal importance he attached to completely free inquiry, it would seem to
follow that one must choose between comfort and awareness, or as he sometimes puts
it, one must choose between security and truth. While leaving this choice to the
individual, there is no mistaking where he positions himself on this issue. These
themes are developed fully in Section 7 ("That is The Moment to Inquire").
6. Strength Through Vulnerability Vulnerability as a source of strength is a
characteristic twist for Krishnamurti, who held the search for comfort to be an
illusion that weakens the spirit and very much aggravates the unavoidable
insecurities of life. In many passages he puts forward an invitation to find the
vitality and strength that come from facing uncomfortable facts directly and
engaging fully with the challenges of life. "To live greatly, to think creatively,
one must be completely open to life, without any self-protective reaction ... in
love with life" (15Mar35).
7. A Difficult Message to Convey Once, Krishnamurti hinted that the impulse toward
security might be part of our conditioning (22Mar72). And, there are indications
in his talks that flight from disturbance is a field where resistance is high and
self-deception is rampant. Over a long period of time, Krishnamurti expounded his
treatment of the problem. And he sometimes prefaced his remarks with cautionary
words that indicate a steady resistance on the part of his audience. In one of the
earliest passages in this study he remarked: "What I am saying today I have said
innumerable times; I have said it again and again. But you don't feel these things
because you have explained away your suffering" (31Dec33). Twenty-six years later
his words suggest a continuing stalemate in the discourse: "Probably you will say,
'Well, I have heard this before, he is on his favourite subject', and go away. I
wish you [could] listen as if for the first time ... [and] discover freedom for
yourself" (22Nov59). Another twenty-six years passed, and he was still remarking
how walls, even "soft walls", hinder free inquiry (29Aug85). We have already noted
how flight from disturbance encourages us to let things drift. Now, after the
passage of yet another decade in which drifting has become very much more
dangerous, readers may be left to ponder the question as to how widely this
particular aspect of Krishnamurti's teaching has been recognised and fully
absorbed in action.
PART 1: BEWARE OF THOSE WHO OFFER COMFORT
All My Life I Have Been Hurt (1972)
I have been hurt all my life, I am sensitive -- you know what hurt is, the wounds
that one receives, and what effect it has in later life. I have been hurt. I can
deal with superficial hurts fairly intelligently. I know what to do. I either
resist, build a wall around myself, so isolate myself so that I will never be
hurt, grow a thick skin -- which most people do. But behind that they are wounded
deeply. (Saanen 23Jul72)
Looking For Peace (1955)
Essentially you are seeking a state of mind which will never be disturbed and
which you call peace + Our life is disturbed, anxious, full of fear, darkness,
upheaval, confusion, and we want to escape from all that; but when a confused man
seeks ... what he finds is further confusion + I may want perfect bliss, which
means an undisturbed state of mind in which there will be complete quietness, no
conflict, no pain, no inquiry, no doubt + I might just as well take a drug, a
pill, which will have the same effect - only that's not respectable, whereas the
other is. (Laughter). Please, it is not a laughing matter, this is what we are
actually doing. (Ojai 7Jul55)
We Want To Be Enclosed (1948)
Love is the most dangerous thing, because when we love somebody, we are
vulnerable, we are open; and we do not want to be open. We do not want to be
vulnerable. We want to be enclosed, we want to be more at ease within ourselves.
(Bangalore 11Jul48)