You are on page 1of 1

A-10

Republic v. Grijaldo (1965)

1953

Simple loan or Muttum Pay equal amount

Grijaldo obtained 5 loans from Bank of Taiwan, the interest went to Japan, US then to Phil govt Loan secured by chattel mortgage of standing crops destroyed Gs heirs refused to pay, the crops were destroyed, contract of loan is extinguished

WON the contract of loan was extinguished

NO The loan was for a sum of money, a generic thing Chattel mortgage on the crops only to secure the payment of loan The loss of a generic thing does NOT extinguish the contract The loan can be paid from other sources

You might also like