Professional Documents
Culture Documents
2002 - Robust Combining of Disparate Classifiers Through Order Statistics - Doc Roi
2002 - Robust Combining of Disparate Classifiers Through Order Statistics - Doc Roi
!
"#!!%$&'() *+*-,.0/'21+ 3 #
#45!6
7 9:<;=>'
8
?A@CBEDFGIH0GKJL@CMHONQPSR
JLT
MRUT
VXWYJ[Z+\
]_^ P ^`^ BET
VabTUVcT!HOdcRIe?AT
M'GKTUd
f P8g0hCi(jlkm f @On+T
GcG_o&JLT
NLpqm? ^ miOk5rCsCt
uvCwSv0xyCz|{:}'~C0vC9&xvCvw}O
+ S/''*+U*
WYT
DG_@ONTURO\HOMp?A@OBEDq\MOdU\
eT
_MJZOTUdKVcJGl@0 THOV
^ FVcGJMqm =O5S gj r k
wC9}|3y|O|{CSv&CC
] @3ZCTUB
+T
d m:gOrCr
_ cI
%UI(
395(c!
:
9=Lc(S09c
#((U=IcAcU&.
93b(Ic)c
c%)
#U
c#
+[=0
S(c
3cS#c
(((03
'#((Qq(Q
Q30(K:O(Q5(3U3(0
0
q
#K
=c==!C(I(3c
=0
(c:QICcK!3
#(93Y3c#0
=c30l0=
=30KlcQ
A(X33
(I
=3A(c._XAK3':X=3`(
c![=3cq#((c5(c=3(!c0Xc
(O(c
K
(I
('33cK#(S33(I
(IYK#c(X
#(AO=(
cEI!3(#U
U(&IcO(c(A(A3#c&(930c=Uc&
O_c+
(#0=3
bI#
OI+c0(3
c
=IIIl((K5
3c&#cC==cAK(c'0cI
K00
#c
' A:_YA
(3CU&!0K+(c(A3Occ
Y#(30lAC(A3!K&30Kl
cc=O=(Q5+#(0USOc O3+(#
c
(c=c'c
Qc
O(c
b=IXK
Y)#Oc#X(c#cKlc(c
[
Y+=ccI
O((b(c##I((3I
YU(cXYcS
3K
0Y0=
#c (OU
&+3
I
O3K
A33I#(0#K((0cI
3c
'
q
(3(
|cc
KIcUOI#UKc
(=!A3S
(
!#"$$%'&'( )("* +,.-/,0"(12)4335* -76."$-78(,49:<;<=>?9:9:@ABDCFEA@9:GHIKJL@A>NM.A>POQ>=9:9:NR5S.9<T U
(Q
300cO
c V!'
WU|GX3YI(?YZX
Lc=
=3
#=(#(c|S&
|(|(!
K((3
0
((3(3O!
#(X
I
U: \[]L
^
cA0!
(ccO(cU).=cI
cc`
_ a
A(
cc: (9E [
qK#.0cUc.33(A
YbYG
AU
c. Yc [d(5B _/ aALccc|( WG+< e!() [Z Lf
q
A((==3QOc#cQ(
c+Q((3U3('#(c
O (Y=
g eC+(0Y=((ci hI+ccc9(E(A
=
(c33(Y_ccXOA_
(%A#K
(#
c
cQ9
K0Q(c j(ccY
0X(3
b(3!30+
(S=(#(c c Ybd3c [
k
q!O
YA
c(3Q!b'(
cQ#3IcXQX3KYKf _ (
I
#((3!A=G al
^ )=
=3
)AU(=c(IK
(c&
=AKA(K.c
((Y=XI)(3!(Q
0b_Ic(
(EKO+cbO(cAQO
_[cc\
a&
A0
!c ( Y
( (
3
cY 3cXA
_
0Qc(I&!Y=O(Ib&+KZ e
=cO95O!Q _L
!I(Qc(l
a lhI
KIc�I09Qc
(3!(#((
=
c&_=bI (
(3(
Ib=(0'#c(0#
(clS
m _[!c< aQ(c=Qc
=Ic(A_Q
nUK3c0KX0A
c#Ko _[c< a|c
=QI
(c#c(Ic(
c X
Q
qK#q
(3(KI
YO!+#(c&(I0b
OUII0)Ic:O(
pIcccbKb
(3(Qc&03!3(C
(0#=
qIS rU
O('(3#((U3Occ
O(=I3CU(+(3
(
%
#0
#K5(X#9cC(cA(
c&=I
c((XcA!O(
=
#=+c==(c
3(3&&Oc(C3&(A(U#Oc+
O!
(:
3(Q0#cQZ eK9&' e!
c s
Uc=c
3IUA+IA
(b#(w nUK
' v(YX=XK
(IqI!3K3CUU9
3CU+(#(+c0U#
QY
(3IY
(#3cAUK%
((cCOLA(X=Lc(&(#
(#UC=U|I3Kb!
3#c#(ccA
OK(
S%_
3=IU3
(#Kc
9#I#(c9K#cUc
b+S e=# 3UbOc_=b(
c!IQ
x j(3qcl
(#(SQ3(
3IKU(=
(
cl
y YA=cc+I
(#(0+cY#(qc+(X3c
O((!
c+(_IU3K&Kc(
< e!(
+IA(!3c+#I#
z
[d3[AYGL cf[AU33(c=3cq#(9qc
c_(3 c)b!
c#
IA+OI+c#(+
ccL({O<
(_
(&A
U+|
c30l#3IcQc
'% KlyVcU
bO(AQ3#(c
.YK9
(
G VL(
(I# o |9O'
}
v~+O((=' e3b l YbVG Kl30c
=cI0:C(c9(I
(C39#c9&#I
9O!(
3(3Q(3!('
0
:Y
% b#Kl
Y(_=cY
[d3[AYG7qQ
=Se)
nU(U_OKlq(
(
c.c#I
{([I
((K
0cbq
330c'
q(X(
< eU
((ccE(
lc(
((3#0YAA0l&9
3c#c(ccCcOc Kl
(P [((
=#U33(cbKK((.3((cm
qcb j(_0
(3Q(XOcqS
3cQI#c
S" U*
)5 b
'S!bbbSZl"#%
3|:/
Bg
)":!U$&4C
Y99 1q"#
"#:U!$'
^ Q_I#0)=33(
I!3bX#
Kc)O
Y
)3KS)c#I
qO
#c
0c(I3A
L=0&+cc e!IQY(cOc.Z O #. <3ccY
3(3&(3bU
(0|_
3(3(cKOc3)+
' e
39(
#(
(S eb(cX(cqcA=c=AKS n
0cQ(3I
f {( % [ |0c:K#O(b
c Y P
qc0cY
c5!I
((Kq((3UA((3I
c
((
OI
=33|=cU=L
33! _[K#O(_
q. a+(#(Q
c+90 03c_
3=c(#0C(3c S9 qK3K#
3c!
SO((&Q IQcQ _7?ax\_7?al
q+cKO((&Q ?c
Q(
_?a _7?at
q(qcc
QQcK_=U(
3cX|Q
S ' ] x<
[
lIlB _[cK)=!9c
0B':al0K)0K(#Q
=0c#Kl#(cc0&3=K!XAS e!Y#03Kc'0Q
c
IcK
! O(5Oc (f 2
|o n
0UX&c('0(#cb eX3IQ
O
#q(_(3=
+ nO5U==(c
#!
_7a ` _?a]
_Yba
4<9:AM.S#.<>=M.5'.9;<HBb#A>I.Gtxf
$$N3 AQ*"(,<%.6g%=Z$%:",S/%:1ZT
fi(x)
Optimum
Boundary
p (x)
Obtained
Boundary
p (x)
f j(x)
Class i dominates
Class j dominates
x*
xb
b
\50]]
\\]
75Z]5K]Z75]f]m!AgGF5G#K5K777]ZL 5.
q(Y(#_
=0
U=
5#b KI(O
#c=0
003!c(IQ(3cP
qc
(
=0
U
cqI
X3Ib5#K|
A3CU3=cc9()(
c=c(
I(P 4
q(c=0
U'&+&#=+(0bI(
c
=0U#
n
03I
((l
2cc
c I_
(3!('cc# s
Q5
cqb(cQ
=#c((#!c
=U dA= C0k dH 53K#Oc
II(Q0
(C0 _ ? a:&(3
IQ=(30#
((l
L _7?aQU#=cY(0&
X!O
w
_[a
?_7a
"!#
_ Aa
?_7?a%b
$
UI(IcX30#c)#0c.cY0_Uc)!k _?a9
I2(QUA=335cQcX0=_3Kcc
BSF
_ ` a
_Vba
(Ib#(cc'Cc
( Q933KL
SX=(
#
3#(bOcbcb(!c
0&=!O
9QC0cb
0lc
Q(
#K
0+ cf[
&
q(&0I
Q=Se+&#I(I((OKl| ((
(%) [d|(3cXQ(I0O(==33c'
c5 BSF D Zq'rZ5r
(K(Qc
KQ0A3cXO
#c(
(K _?a]
(3!(3(cS+
K5c(qSQ(+(c#I
+c(
.&bQKb%)(OKS O #
=Q(A
!
Q(
#K_
QI#QI(=c(
)4 q9/ ,(/|21 3S 45
B
%b(c'U+] j0A3(=(
#(39(b
0c#K:5
3c#I#
c | O(3 I&QX(
(b3c(=0lH _ a((I
33
((l
L_ Nal ' _ 2aO(3
=qQ
33
' I3(c X(3%3cK(3cc3I!0
('*)
,+
+/.
0.
1
32
54
76
8
:;8
9 <4
=6
>6
%9
?99?9 %6A@
5
>B
@C+/6
@E+F99?9G+$6A@
DB
q(Lb
#3K=U ULbI+
K
'K
q&3
I
33
Y(l
YQK(Y
c#Q3#cYO3c
!A(IK
_7ax _
i?ax
a#
_?a:
_
(5
_?a
_
i?ax D _
?ax
?a
_
_# w _ ?agax
_?aF
q(K#O03((3(=(l
(QO&3c_
K#G n
0I0
%cLAYE
=I#9IX33
0lK
(
((+3
lAS5&
K9(G nU(( Sl
q0
(_(Y qcYX! d
_?at
_
a
_
Ga _ .a H_7aF H_7aF _?a
q(cQ
I
Kcq!=O=3c
c
Y
qc
G6
: 8<H;I H
=6
: 85MNI H
=6
B
@
KJ L
7SJ L
7
=6
7
T6
=6
B
@
7QJ RL
@PO
: 8
7
=6
7Q: 8
@EO
G6VU
W6
08
IH
.YX
;
*X T.Z
X
:;8
7S:W8
8
: 4& |
I:A0EAIU
3c0#c_ #(c(#3
#c _ a9(3:
33:
+
=3|U
3
KXS (c+
QcXq9O3c(IQ=cc
[
^] `_
a
7acb
daW]fehg^i]ja
f.
Nk
.
B
_7al+
D B
_?al+m9?9?9G+
n
_7a
q(
+(#(5 U3I#
cc!#cKl U\eK33
Qc
X
_ _?aga0
qcK#cU0U
c
%Y(#K A| (
cq30cY
Ic
@
B
-do
' _7a
B.
Rz
q rts x wv s
p
H u M
@
B _7a
_7a
_7a
N!
>B
_7?a]
Hu I H
_FWZa
H ux MyI H
-q
- q3
<.
_ua
<.
_?a]
_Xa
q(c
=I
Occ(_EccUA=0
#U!nU(I
3
(Q
3(3A( c_I3 (cGnUIc
cQQqK:O
#K'%(3cc5(((Se&
3(3:U
Ib {( [I :3#(cSc_I3 c(K#cKl
b(c(I&=UY(3c
'
q(=Q(
< eYA3
(I+c(Ic)0==#K!
#b(c(OcIc3(I!3c
(
bIccl
qcb5A (9
I#=
3!(c
cQ(I( ecXXO
ccOc(AKl
cP
q!(cO
(&=(IcK ecc!Y(
#Ac
Ic#I
Yl
qQ
cq3C
(A&+ H
ccl hI
K
QcQ3O03U
Y=(
c3(OQAA3I
0c'3Iq(
I!L l
q=c3_
(9
(+(00#3:=U#!c3
cUI+K
(IC((c=3K#(
c&y YL =
c&#(3c
&
A(
Ac
(!
&cK
q(0!q(
IUK&3c0c(
YA(#3c#I#(
'
q(KQ!3(+ (c|!
_7a|(3:=33UK BSF
q(S e33I!cU
_?aqqc!C
K#0IQAIK#S(
0|(I!3ccc#= x{I [I
q(
(K
&# 2+&:U|/-
"#!!%$&'() *+*-,.0/'21+ 3 #
#45
Bg
(+cL _ d \al
+ _?a _?al# |3c
9 Klo Y3
O((k Q#(IQ_AO
_7<a _7Sa
_
G a
( B c(Q==UQQ'O3U5c
c p
cIKUb eU
3Q#Q'qAKX|Ok (! !A=
Uc!K!
wk
>1
1
1
1
1
}|
1
>1
"#
1
1
1
1
~
T T
1
1
<;>>M.5]MlM.AAM:M.S.L=9#@>M.]M.<>L9:9:GA<LM.2M.A;S>9:9#NM.LM.AA<9FM;<2A@M.A@bMT
=KC3C((OKlK5l
q
A Q(0Qc=K'!(=I(
Y
Y Q
c
_ Yba
Q( c(l
[
l0I3c0c(:
Q3c#Q(A3#3
I(9=
#933
( cA0Q
(A(c
YG:
:=A
S
(I!3c Ic3c&#A
c5
G d_
0O (
#(32 Y!l YW`_[K0#=A33
.AU==S( 8(c (
Q( &3c
cL(X#KXX( Uc< al
(A=q('3(
d(( I!0
B'F
B':
_G [a
Y
Y
Y
1
NN
"
K.
1
1
>1
>1
Y
A X W Yo_[Aa NYbVAW
_a W3
_[Aa XAY
[y_Va
NYbYbd
V
c
Yo_[a
[ d
NY3Gd
_Gda [
_Vba A u
_uAa [AWZ[
Yy_Xa
NY3V
V
Yo_[Aa
[ Y u Yo_Wba NYZ[X d [f_ua WbV
[
NYZu5W
[y_[Aa
NYZd(
_FWZa GVbu
_a (K
f_Va u5W
Vy_a
GV
xnU(I
G[#(I((_c3(.)_
3b((Y
(#K9
0&3KlIc_=K3(=I(9
O((=5# (=K((b0c'
3c+#c9
=|3#
3
(9qQ3Iq=
YQc30l09Oc nU(U(K5
&# .#:
S/-
":!!%$|(
**-,(/|21 3S 45
B
%A#Kl| :+_(!X
c(
#K(cc |0
#Uo #cC ( c(0=#(3c#c(I
(
c _ ]a 0 s
QScKYX#OcX=c(
I(|cSKXOI I9 nU(
&0K=K
_7 ` _?<aga
_7\`_?aga
_cA
a
| OX=cE
(Acc (k A(
bcL=K'
_7 a&(&(#A
=U
(I(H SQD b _7 a.]
Q( S3cc3OclcXIOIK
^k
>1
>1
>1
1
>1
1
>1
#
!0K0Q
3c# I#' nU(I
YQO=!=O=
AcUc4
q(Q(
=
AcUQ
_
a _
a
_ Vba
(I+& ccU+
q
#(
U(3
#I#=c=Ic'!
q
|c3((.c0_3c
-
=q
SA
IQ_(_(Ic
. I( (m _7 a(
bI(
` (Q
I(
_7 _7 a'a 0qI( t_ ` aQc .
[
30c Kl
y [(
l
q
I(&# qc!C
Ze
V
>1
1
W
>1
1
1
N N
1
N ` N
t_ `
a
N K
1
t_ i
a
Ylc
D
K
AYI(X
330c!)!#cIX
3CU
Q(o
(
s
=(AI
3(c=(0c(A
=Ut |(
=3
=33c'
c =( .(o _ a.
cA(
B': _7ca
_ a
_
WZa
Y
Y
_ t_ ` aK a]
_G ua
Y
q(K3(Y
QA
b(_
cqYcq+XQ=c
_ a
u
m 1 v
1
~
>1
1
>1
_TQ
1
>1
SF _caf _ _7Qa aH
Y
1
Qt_7ca a]
^ (!X
c30lXcq
#bnUceU(IQK3_0
3AX
U33(K!c
0Kve
KQ=0I(
U30_A
&A3=0(3c#!35C
OI
YUl
== G[ %(c2Y(
_Oc20#c
cE(Xc((
=3A=
&0#=_c3(&I(A YZu
q
#K.K#X(II
((xn
0I2X:=(=0Uc_Uc=Xccc
(
=O9K(c(
=c c3(cX_c( ` 9%
c&cqc3(YO3c#K_
_#
4a
BSF _7ca
_ Q _7ca c0BSFg_caK
_7ca
1
BSF _7Qay 0BSFg_7QaK
_c
St_7Qa a
_ GXa
1
7S
q(
(YCclQO
#=XEcX3cYc
(
c %
#
|=OUK3(b
(O
b(`_[ (|!0#
I
(=cc=33al
XQ0(5((
#Kq330=c==cY(
3+
3 d9%
#
!=33|
+Oc=cc
1
BSF _7Qa 0BSF._7Qac
_
_7ca a
(c&K3(
Q9O=0Uc
( #:
UI
%
[
lKOII==
&Qc9c9
(3
Q
:Q
Oc30cA=(A!c=
#KS5I+cccIA9
q=(K
b(OAc30lQSOAAL&(#=O E
(
cq&5(IK53Q0U(&Q(=3=+
(
(3U3(9#(ccCQ
X(
cU&
K
cL
q
(_U#cb0ccqc0
#c) [
> cy : ]
%+c!
(|c'3cc|K3(l
('Q(+
|0U
'+3c
KcX
_3cK
0Q3 (A(
(=0c
IQ_AI!3O(3_Q#Kl|U&!KUI(&(((Sc
(X3Q#cQOU
b
0q33
1(':/-&#|
g
q((#K((X3cX#(c
3(3Q#(3_3(cq
X!
^ 3(c Klw
[C==3 (=( #(
3
c
#OcOb=c(
c%(3K5(_I3 .0!c+K.
Q
=
#Q!3( =!(A 3c
cQY!(
%
qb
#(q(!(!
&Y=(
l
cU(
3(3c0K#IcXO
KUX( {O<
Kx
q(
# ecQ=0(&OcXO
(Xc
I
!(c
3(bAA
0
(q0YcQcY
d]
ehg
C\
^] <] i aWa *] \
Wa
y#y
<#t;lN>SV~#t#l0"w
(=(cQQ
!KQqb(KYc
_ _7af _7aga` _7a! _?a4
_?a
Y
Q(
_7a! _7a f
_?a
1?
B
1?
q(0&4
1
Yt
q!O
>B
1?
_7a
MyI H
H;I H
Y#?
_Ybda
_ B
_7?a]g B
_?aga]
_Y Ga
Q( _ accU+(II(OcY+=Ic_ccXQ(Y(
(3c0c(3c
KC3(AU33(K
I
(<al (Occ((3c(!
I(c5(:(5qc'!xnU(I
Y9&O3Kc'U9(3!30
(&I(K(A
O=II(0+c_
I#&
#
O3c=cYYIK 3#(cx
YAI!c(c(c
(#X33
X0c) YAWL#
q(q!(K
cX0&c=0c_
!=A3#309Qc _
0 0=#A33c/ a9(=c
:(
_
2a\
_YYba
%
%9 9
MyI H
=>
H;I H
>B
D B
Dy
Q( Q (_I(_Q(
c)=X( P YII(
Oc 80 2
3cK=Kc()(=c(
I( YW:+K(#U==3#'U(IK!A=
_[ (\
al
* *B
5K
DB
>
>
NY [Gu
Y3 [
ubX
dXV
[
N Y NYW Y3 d
V d5WZV
W
[ cAV
Y3NV
d
d
bd
u
N Y NYIU
[
ub[
NW du
X
[ GVbu
NY X
u d[AW
Y3 [
dAV
[ [Y
Y [
Kb[
Y3
Y3 [
NYZ[
dbXbX u Y YZ[
Y3NV
N Y NYbY
NV dAWbW
Y V
dXbu
Y3
[ Au
dbd
Y
d5W
X X Y3W
V
d
W W dAV
YNW
d
b[
Y3 u
NV dAWI
Y3 [
WZV
[(
VbY
[
Y3 [
NYZdu
Y3
[
[( V
Y3
[NV
Y3
GVbd
Y3NV
dY
[(
dXbu
[
N Y NYZdX
Y3
dbubd
0 V cX
[W
[ [X
[
c
Y
W
u
(NV
dAY
[NV
[bd
[ Y3
(
NV dAWW
NY u X
dX
dV u [ GY
V d5W
[
q('3(
nU(I
_0!I(|(0
(CP
Y
1
B
dVbX
dA X
dA d
db[(
G V
W
dbX[
dAWW
d [
dVY
5 Y
c
dbX[
dAWW
[5W
G [
cX0IK5
=>
* B
@Pa
_Yb[a
(U(xnU(I
3V !+&_c(l
_b(=33Cc3
c
(cc
1?
q
#KxnU(I
YI&(
(Kq(Y3Z
x[33'+cSK3((SIU3K
!A(&c_q (
=33l_q=(O
ccc
c(l
b 0 A
c+qI!c5 (
(
#(3'cqc3(X QGn
0CA(I A|N al
BSF
0BSF
B
V @ @
D B
Y
_Y Aa
N!
~
N!
5K
0](ZK]\`,]d?]Z<YYV0K2\ c7
]$H]7
\7?Z
3 o
NVZdbd
[ Y
NYZXbX
NY
NYZ[
NY3 X
NYZdV
X
u
Y
[
W
u
X
Gd
y#T
b uY
N Vb
d
XY
u
(c
[bXY
[AW
[
[VW
[
N!
-
d#0t#l0"w
<#t;lN>
I3#(c(
#KQ
3(U#(KX
3Q
X!O
_ _?af _?a'aD _?a! _7 _7aK a
_7?ax
_YVba
U
1?
B
1?
%X(Ic!(0
(bCQQc_!C
1?
1?
_7 _ aga
_ ` _7 a'a
1?
Q(IQ!0(3=c
_ 0
cYO3c#K_c
1
_7 ` _ aga >B
_7 ` _7?<a'a
_ _7 a'a B
Y
B
@
_t`_7Sa'a
Y
_Y a
@
B
_YAWZa
q(0#&=
AcU c
0=K!0Uc(K qnU(wYAW!
%E[c+YC
330c!.X(#( CE
I##KA(D
Q(cQc
3cqc!
(
bOc=(E=
=Oc
qc _qYx nU(I
G Val3
XU
q(&I(4
cc=03cK x n
0Iy YW34 |3cAqXx nU(I
)c!I(&(#c
_(cO3c#K
1
V!
1?
1
MNI H
MyI H
H;I H
H;I H
v
1
= >
B
(=U==33
w_[Q
1?
B'F _ca
Y
Y
_
_T
B
K;@
* B
@2a]_ `
a
&
3XIQA
c
@ a_ ` aK
D B
@Pag0B'F'_7ca
D B
_Ybua
@2a
B
_
@
B
;@
>B
1?
1?
_YbXa
_ 2a]_ _ca a Y _7 a
Q(Xq
#=
x n
0IX(UQ(I )
Q(&
qI#
(IcK! !(=c_'&(#0 CX3c#(c
XO
#cqKI
;0# >|/ |
%0c:cb0#AUc=(cQq
#&QXcX
cc
YE(YO
#Ac#=Y0.(=gc EIKi hI+ccc:(#c
c)Y(c=33bAq=3(
+c0#Y(#(c
Q(
3!L -%E(=
(
c#l
&QI
q'(IS#|(
(5Q
U:(+
c|I(#c
(#' (A
c XKE0c=c!c(Q(3X
((l
XS(UQ(IcY(#(ccO(c+=(IQ(#'
MyI H
B
M H;I H
T~y
;lN>SV~#0#Tlw
Q(
_7a
_7a
4
S.
q(0&4
_.
_.
Q.
.
_[da
L @ M
S.
qQc_!C
L @ M
_?a
Ga
@
@
_7 B _?a' B _?a'a
L @ M L @ M
u
@
Ga
L @<M
IH
@<M ?
@
@
_7 B _?a' B _7?a'a
_[ Ga
'!([lk
(K&(oY33nU( [(bO(Q#=(K5
(I0K0#= (
3#.#!==|_II(A0+c
( U
( X
c_=cqq=
(0+cX( U(
_
G a
5
.
Q.
7Q
L @ M
u
Dy
P
_[AYba
Ga
?
Q( Q (_I(_Q(
c)=X( P YII(
Oc 80 2
3cK=Kc()(=c(
I( YAWL v#Y(=c
c
Kl
Y|0
xnU(I
[Y'A
3
IQ==33|
+c30l|
B
S F
Y
_[[a
0BSF
_
G a
?
q
#KY nU( [[b(m
SKA( Y0(
cIcY_= A
(cqK3(l
b:cc(&!=0U(K+ ( (I
3((#cAI!3KOK3(Ic++%(q=Q+(
cK YA0 E
(Ic
(Iq(&Ic#q(_(
c#Q(c
0bOc=IK5
A=(#
)0U#K_c30l[lQYc
(:
( Y&#(c:Q&(I!3co _
9 L 5:
0Qc30l
[
l } 8
cb [bd\ [YG#=qc+c3c_q
K
3
YI
7al ^ &c=!O3=
(
'
Y#(c0#K
(cc0] S q &+cc3
3q(3K#&
09I!3Kc(l
b[
0U&OcS(A#=
( YQ&
0K
q(
(I!3cK3([
l
&
=(_ (c &QO
(c3
3
!b
(=[
0K
Y
7V
_.
Q.
L @ M
R
Q.
L @ M
L @ M
7.
5.
.
G.E
S.
l.K
G.
5KV&
0] ZK]\
H]7V\7?Z
V
W
X
[b[[
fPa
NYbVbd
NYZdd
c5 W
A [
G YV
KS
yK - _ j.
'P
%
Y 3.
X
YbXbu
YYW
G u
VbV
G [
[
"!$#2\kK7
]
]]Z]Q\K7
Ga
.c
dbd
Vbdbd
[[b[
YVZd
Ybdbd
KA W
c[
_
f.ZDYa
T~T
^#t#l0"w
;l%;
I!S(ccq3c0==c=cX
3qc
!C
%X(IcO((5#Q
UC
_ ` _7Sa'a
_7x`_7aga
_[AVba
q(b(===UA2
cOX3c) cAA(I=Q
c
K%(3cc5|cAK5#&U!(K!Oc03#I#
qQSOC&!_
U!(KXx 0 X==c=K
(
#KqQ''3!((Q==c
4
_[
a
%!XbI(0 S
I_=b#0 Kl0 [N YY(
0
i
qYc(O0.I(X==A. nU(K9(_
c(l
b+3c+
(5(&3cA
3c
9c=!
& Q
c Y P
& _
_[5WZa
G a
'?
q(&=33c'
qK3(l
Xc&qc!C
S F _7Qa Y Y _ a
B
U
Q.
L @ M
Q.
L @ M
"
T.
Q.
L @ M
&
&
_ i aK_7
0B':g_7ca
L @ M
&
1?
_
_7ca aK_7
1?
a at
_[ua
0)
2+
KE!b eIYUc
l80+c2
(#(
c
c(l
'B
q(Q(I!3ccQc30l=(cA33c|cQ
b(3U3(0
0KQ
q&# & c=
cK3(l
=cQ0O:%=
c(Y0
(&((5C_=SI
& 0#:IX
(3U3('cqqcq(cc _) ( _ca.al
k
q(
3c&#c(
#K
_=3&O
c#Ac
((qQc
q=
IQ(AO
%03!3(|#(cO(q(c(XQ3O03U/
*
]ja ^i ~a
&
S|'O
#_(3bUS(cA
U'3
Ga0Q(::9(3!30
(Q30#b
=3(3O(=(!(0
[( ^ 'KI(KQ&(I='
0
(#((=3cK
=cKlQ
Q3(
Qc
(IX-
#K=
#==c
0
#
((
c
(
3(b
0
I#
Qc(c+cc
3
(
(3O=c
c0
#c0cI
+Q0#KOc3f _p K|xaQ
Q3ccQ
Q+c
U:q(3=cc9K=' ^ 00cI
b(_c=
AF {C :
qI=_(ccS=(#
(O
cc
GBg H ("# *(*-1q'>|+ 3 3#
q((Y930c=U!(
#(cq(I&0K(#9(c
_ (
!\ aQ(
A
cX(+=:KI(c ^
#0I
Oc
=f nUb== Y [b[|(qq!(=3)IY#
Qcl
A(%(#K_+Q5cII=_+
|
0c' }Zv2~+QO((=' e3= (K
YbVLA+] j(c=IX'(
cO(3X#
S p c|E0#K5(
I ~'f V3%3=(
(Lc YI
Y(
#K
.c3(II9c
Q
Xbd(Ic(/ (o p c|Q
G dA(3Y/
I &cAG YZd=0#(
&#:Q&
ccI(
#KQ3KlAC#(
D((l
(Q) B ^ #G n
((cc3Qy [( WbV(#c00 (o p K|Q) dA3Y(0
Y
JLK >>AM.lbS.<
M.9.<:M.S.?C].>9FM.GA"GUB<A9M.AMc;<>=9:9:NR5S.9c<9:<2>=4QS.lM:gA<
5>NI9x>G9lM.A>QG@>5 <S0b5M.A<SL9FMgANM >AB;<>=9:9:NRAS.9<T
O 4BZ@A2'lI=ASL@ANM.94l9x'M.S.AbS.<
Mg>>
T
n
I Ic:L[3=((UI%9IQ[V=c+5KI(c
!lc_
Ic=cP3 yp4K| QYbd3cc
q(cQ#9U#cb=(
]
q LIrU2@
5 C= &.QSZQ35 ll!#
AcQ(I
!OI_OUc'((0c)(3cU
SK#K ^
(I&(L|
0c'O('e3&(#0OII
0YK#(&:
v~+X#Q=I v
' }b}IQQ c (L K3? }SR=K? }
p Q
O
U=L
qK#(_cUc (X0c
(((
II
(K03(cX. YVGL0Q((I=Q(c
q((
(YH n
0qKQI(IY0_c#=0U#K
s
=!
c#
IY#((c&=Qc=
(KI(KA(3=(
T DU(#
c=A
&3CU
AcUc(Ac
(AQq(Q9=
I
A
cIcqX3CU#c=Ul
q
l#c=U
U(!OQ
KIKqQcX#c=UQ#Oc0cXf
V3
(K)IXK|=K#cU
(!0ccIcc5_U(Oqc
KIK_0Ic_Qc cI#__=c
c _ &c((
bc#c(Oc(I3=(
(_
U!bc
AcUI
alO(
cb!OccQc
#c=UQ(YQIcY=(
KIK
^
(A(=
(I`
=c
K(3CU_
0
0cY
CU#c=Ucw sX!OA
0(c(#c_qc(
U(OX=c
_ uAa=(22
0 _ E3CU
KI
a
+cX(A&KI(K
j4
5c
n fL
<U]4Z#NV4WAYX2K5]
]
4
wZ5]]Z7
KI(Kq0c
=U
=U c
(cc
~
V3
X(O==QE( I_)=Q(O=(Y=
(3!(#(cQ(=
A
c
(%
#
(c
(#(XU#&qA=K=K'
B (O<k
( (O
d.
$k
B
5K
~
GY3NY3kj dbd
[bd [bdtjY3 Y
u
GY3NY3k j dbd
&(
uNVbYwj d
[( ubdtj( d
u
u dt j d
I
(ct j dbu
c dtjmdNV u (N Y3k j dV
]\_^
lSmno@pjqnrm$s
lSmnruPv2jqnrm$m
lxuknam$y2jqnTlSz
lSznQlxzjqnrm$s
c(W
[tj Gu
V3NYW|j V
NZ
5K
]\_^
\fZZZ5]]Z]\
75
pI
p
~
Y3NY3kj dd xl mknuP~2jqnam"z xl mknuP~2jqnam"z
u
Y3NY3k j dd d(NWZutj dAW d(NWZutj. dAW
[d XbdtjwY3
&
Y( [VwjG [ G V uAYwjGV X(Vwj.NYbY
[
uAW|j[ d
u
Yb[ [b[tjG X
0 XXtj c (NWZutj.NYI
IQ c( [bXtj dX G V
tjGV G V Utj.
GB
a` cbedgf@h i
7
7]] cZ
K
S _
a
B&I
[Z
?
\fZZiZ5]Z]D
75
a` <bCdgf@h i
7
7]] cZ
c
y.
lxmknuP~jnam"z
lxmknao$y2jnam@u
l4u{nrm$~jnQl"l
lxzknay"zjnQlSo
GV
k.j
GVGut.j d
S _ a
GY Yj dbdo_[L5a
N.
()c
(X3O=c
_0#+E#KbA
(#(3cqIX#
(
(L I(
('#
(Q
(CU(q
S Dc _OO#
((5!< e!(0A+CU+Q0((S ac+QU
lcG VG
I s ~! YbVI=0#(KI(&#c3
(## Oqc+!cUc
A
O'c3q(Y0Kl5=Kc=U/ 3(5
I B YI%3=(
(KI(_K(Y] j(Kl
)!bU(c
O#
#(X
=Q(3Ic3(=0
'3c3
c
(=OcX9 p c|Q VZd(3Aq(#K5`
qK#YIA
Io v 9={F [0:: Z < r5%' 5 E 53 (cX30
3_
(
c Y0
(.G V! [(
(
uYcU&b
YK#(&(3cqI(#=I#Q
=03!3(
(&0c#
(A&(I
qAc&x
H u
U#
_. [AYG|(3&(Q((!3('
(qO=(q
IS3#c(c
c _[(Y {C< (c< a!
(I!30#
0 K#(=(_A((
qbO=(
=I=c
==3cEQ0(YA((cc
c((5
_A!K)(c
.
#I#
(##U0#c(
b=K
q!(&=OK|3
(
lAO
0#=3#cq(cX
cYQK#=3ct _[/ a (cq
Kk
ff4
?
?
Kk
e.G<xO K
SMg>.<9:@>NM.9x
) 05A<;<0.BM#.<]M.S.GT
A]Mg29:SM.9l4S.B.<:M.
U0]Z]ZiwL\0575K777 X<Z77]a`K
Ut
]d?\5(H5]\_^ 7]
7]aK` Zbedgf@h gi
^
(K
&B I
p
p
| _T. N. a
B k
NVW|j
Xgj Y
NVbYwj Ybd l$l"nam@uj,nrm$~
[gj y_[L5a
G[ [Ywmj d ub[ u
gj dX
5W|j
l$l"ny@~jqnTlSz
NV3kj dX GY [dtj dbuo_:Va
sKk~
u ubdtj dX vFnap@ujqnTlSm X [{j Y uNVIgj d
u( A[g.j [y_[L5a
Y3 dAW|j GY u u uYwj du vFnas"pjqnTly u X{j d
uNYIgj
W3 u({.j dbuy_WFuAa
5K
2\kK7Z]7]7]
qQ50#(I!3&O#
OI
bIK+(DZq3QQQ3b
3A=Q(XQ:0==(cc#X#Oc0=X#c'
=
=O_(=0#&I_c+
Ic:(K_/a ^ c(cA
D0(&= {C<
cq(0#U\ e3q=(0KQ
3cQI#
cc
L
>AY
%X+cU0X(!
cq(
#K_
Y3#c
q(cA
(cc(A(_cQXc=IcccQ
q(
0OKl
AA0UII
(=Y
AO(U#(&
c
Q=(#'g D
UQ3L
3Q(
9I0+cQcb(&(3
!3(C(AQ(QO(3c&'
CZ =K+
===c
(IYKb:=c&Q(
cc&((3cL==(IY
nU#)(
0cI
c(c=33cYK+
IAAqQYI(
#K
Q((3
(==3I
(3O(
0=
lc=39c
A
(3(3
(=c VG(#=0c
#c
c
&#b(3Q
c#(!3((c3Oc(AI#(&[cL _ (
=[#c(#
< al
q(A(U|=S eI!c&(0c
n
0U(c(c30l0c
KQ( 3#c=(cE(X(c'_)#
KA(A
b=3Q
(c&
(I
Y93cI#U33(cYY0O
(I!3=c(Kc(O
#cq(!_:(3!(S3
#+
c s+Uc(Q(c'
(S0K|=(+=U
=3
(((3UAc+
' eCD |(0(
c#A
=3(
#(3X|ct _7aX nOC L
5
0(A
!+#(A
(I&c#((c _7aQ(3c0c(3c
U#K0
q(#
=3
&K(&+
Acc=3&Y3&#( Y
5
Q(=
#Q3cK3
#c Q=
0K#Q=3(
=!K=33L53
0
=cIKII
(Q333(
!_
(5(
K
q(b3O=Uc ci
VY(3(IAQ)b.I
=
0I
3c#I##(c=
c90UO A
ji da
<k
3('(AcqY=IK(XQ0cb(#UXICclcX!
3
^ IY!KUIK&(0cQc3CU(3
#
KI=&0#KX3c0==((3U!!c=c(:!
OAcU|K#QI2(
X3(Y(bAc=I
G Y!!G V3 uZL(:Q!0(0l+I.3#I#S(
#K
c
[#(Y0U
{xCTx"xxCKN
q|ccqS#(0
#c(#SU YUS ~ XbXdbdb[AVZ[(
(X!_AK#K_U
%UcQ ~+'
-
Y
e= ^ &
(&t =g D#U<K |c)\e3=Qc#
S e3_%!!cX(0c<a%x{{?<Z[ZLZO[]A. t]Z$53'Z"LIIL7
q
5rI.9(2w(=YIAXY3!(K+
EU
( ^ XbXAV3
Y
=& ~ ^ 5 b e!#(('0 h UE D#(x , g9E 53 q :
l
s
9S eC5 XXY3
[Z 0qIS( ^ ? p. ~+
Bc=!
bc'cg :(_(=cq
OI
't 0 53'
$ l? W\_A a X \W
dX0 XbX(
b!~Ub e
[ c
'0 ~ 0b pc
? v~+O
C
(KI(
#K
G XbXu
_v 9U#' }b}QQ c ( cf }[Ac }
p QO
U=/ a
V
H| |3
(D vc p.(!
5 Q((O
&=c0(((
%< G Z Arg '9 % ?
[
9
G ?
cmb895C SS 5rc;'Ek4_NAI
0K X6 XbX(x
XXbu(
Z c=' ~+(c3l% ^ 0 ~ (S ecKc3
c$ 9
C=]Ar x
53S
@ ((
c [ VZd(
:c0OG XbXX
WH| ~+(_0 ( _c='=IK(q(&I=((
3 53 ?
|g =rU] |]%F r' Z[Z . HZ[Z (? u_ al u\YbV3O XXAW3
uZe= ~+c' ^ (c&=(!(I
OI
Q3cccc
0
%< S rZ[Z yS] l5 X( VA V\VbVbuG XbXbu(
XZ=& B&IU
t < < [Z )5! [
(:+
~ |9c 'U ^ =
c ~ ^ | XbX(
dZHh ^ " B!5 :
< l s
9S eC5 X5W
d
H
AN Bc'C9(q=39=Qc((%e 0N #c(= Q
L
K3cP )5= {% Q +2 0 %] l3(
c&6 CG V3 2~ :L' uAVW3 (cc Ybdbdd
G Y
| sw B ( B p. (#
I5:3O=c
AQE(cA(
K.%
0t #(E Q
Lc3
c 5 {?
Q +) 0 +(
cXcE YbX 2~
:
| uVAW! (K YZddbd(
]f] <]
7]ja
0
ff4
4;
G4
~k
w4
0
"
w4;
;4;
9Z 0{P5FZ[Z (? W\_Vba u
A W5ubuu0 XbXAV3
Y3 HhE 30 |b ~+(|Ic3
cS
q
l L T=5%
C B'
O rU
qIlI ^P^^ ' }
p.
|9c ~ p ^ YZddbd(
YbY
e0@ #cc p h | s@ B'0() ( pIc (=
(g Ltt
' Z b[Z
B
% >P
ZOe mL9O2 =rU] Ybd_[alN YbY \YZ[bX((G XbXbu(
YZ[Z!~ 05 p&( p. 0\ |:KLQ ~+
(OS e=cc#KcQ
cc)KA+c
Uc
% p.x ~l pcK# p.lw
'90i
l |
:c3
x Z qZ?l0 C0 53' Z[GI
[
G l ArO< % _(
c VE \VWZd p l
|KcC XXAW!
YIb Hp | |c(( 9 ~+!
0cc# s(+
' e3q3
9(A3Q
!!
c:+
' e3cA% k (c p==
|K3K 53' Z{ LI IB e Z{(S 89
ZO
rU q < 5r0(3G d ~+((=3: hL5 XXb[
YbV
|3B |Kc | &q | ^ #:(O((=' e30O(' e!cSc3
C+
' eAAcc
Sc QOB Y }ZX(U(b eU( I qL q%3I eC
v I w
(E B. WG Ybu}#
&=! c3cOq XX( ^ !!=(
B| } }(0c }KcO }!G XbX }!G XZXI. Y3 (c =X' \ eI 3
4
YZ Hp B Q(_( | |(' 5+
' eb
(Kqc_
O
#cC(ccw 53S
t9
{$5:
[
0 [_[A a U6 ! u[(G XbX(
YW ^ (=(=& A &cUO(0#=AC3cI=0q(Ac!
qI# (b(X3(b(c=Kt P
. YmZ9(]
<
4
"k
G4
#
?U
d4
G4
jk
4
<
z5
4
"4
A
k