Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Sharif Brother S Scandals
Sharif Brother S Scandals
Table of Contents
Agencies ............................................................................................................................................3 Former DG IB Says N-League against National Interest ............................................................................ 3 Anti-Western......................................................................................................................................3 The anti-global Nawaz Sharif .................................................................................................................... 3 Bad Governance .................................................................................................................................4 Express Tribune: Shahbaz is control freak ................................................................................................ 4 Bribery ...............................................................................................................................................6 Supreme Court to inquire into Sharif bribe claims ................................................................................... 6 Communalism ....................................................................................................................................8 Nawaz Sharif Accused in Religious Attacks ............................................................................................... 8 Corruption .........................................................................................................................................9 NAB launches $32 million money laundering scandal inquiry against Nawaz Sharif ............................... 9 Documents Point To Sharifs $32 Million Corruption Scandal ................................................................. 10 Expensive govt land on Murree Road allotted illegally .......................................................................... 14 Students Protest Corruption of Sharifs ................................................................................................... 15 Sharifs responsible for energy crisis ....................................................................................................... 16 Punjab stuffing PML-N men in govt jobs illegally ................................................................................... 17 Sharifs Use Courts To Avoid Paying Fair Share of Taxes ......................................................................... 19 Sharifs are defaulters of nine Pakistani banks ........................................................................................ 19 Nawaz Sharif Uses Taxpayer Money to Pay Personal Staff..................................................................... 20 Sharif Controlled Sugar Mill Responsible For Sugar Crisis ...................................................................... 21 Nawaz Sharif: The Premier of Graft ........................................................................................................ 21 Judiciary........................................................................................................................................... 23 Sharifs Double Game With CJ Restoration Exposed ............................................................................... 23 Nawazs secret dash to Dubai ................................................................................................................. 25 Taxes ............................................................................................................................................... 26 N-League Refuses To Pay Proper Taxes For Billboards ........................................................................... 26 Terrorism ......................................................................................................................................... 28 The Punjabi Taliban ................................................................................................................................. 28
1|Page
2|Page
Anti-Western
The anti-global Nawaz Sharif
Nawaz Sharif has built his entire career on Islamist populism. In 1990 he ran as the candidate for prime minister of the Islamic Democratic Alliance, known as IJI because of its Urdu initials. Sharif became Prime Minister for the first time after a nasty anti-Bhutto and anti-western campaign. Here is what the National Democratic Institute for
3|Page
Bad Governance
Express Tribune: Shahbaz is control freak
Paranoia has its consequences. Punjab Chief Minister (CM) Shahbaz Sharifs refusal to trust civil servants beyond a core of a few favorites has resulted in a condition of organizational atrophy and administrative paralysis within the provincial government and even resulted in losses worth billions of rupees to the exchequer. Sharif is a classic case of democratic autocracy, said Rai Manzoor Nasir, the president of the Punjab Civil Service Officers Association, a union of government officials in the province.
4|Page
5|Page
Bribery
Supreme Court to inquire into Sharif bribe claims
Islamabad, 4 Sept.(AKI) By Syed Saleem Shahzad Pakistans Supreme Court has signalled it will begin inquiring into allegations about a historic deal spearheaded by former prime minister Nawaz Sharif in a bid to protect his office in 1993. The appellate bench of the court will set a date soon for the hearing which will hear claims that Sharif paid seven MPs from the Federally Administered Tribal Areas near the border of Afghanistan.
6|Page
7|Page
Communalism
Nawaz Sharif Accused in Religious Attacks
Attacks on Christian minorities in Gojra shocked the world over the weekend. As the dust has started to clear, though, accusations are pointing to PML-N leader Nawaz Sharif and his apparent lack of action to stop the attacks. According to todays Asia Times, A leading bishop, Almas Hameed Masih, however, takes a different view and he has registered a complaint case with the police against the districts entire administration, which was handpicked by the provinces ruling Pakistan Muslim League (PML-N), led by former premier Nawaz Sharif.
8|Page
Corruption
NAB launches $32 million money laundering scandal inquiry against Nawaz Sharif
ISLAMABAD: The National Accountability Bureau (NAB) on Thursday said it has started investigations against the Sahrif brothers in a $32 million money laundering scandal. The reference against Sharif brothers was sent by Interior Minister Rehman Malik and it will be decided on merit, NAB spokesman Zafar Iqbal said while addressing a media briefing at the NAB headquarters. Replying to a question about the reports that President Asif Ali Zardari has directed the NAB chairman to initiate an inquiry against the Sharifs and reopen pending cases against them, the spokesman said the president had only directed the NAB chairman to ensure that there was no political victimisation. Malik had earlier claimed he had evidence to prove that the PML-N leaders were involved in laundering $32 million. Iqbal said NAB has so far recovered Rs 2.012 billion from Rental Power Plants (RPPs) on the directives of the Supreme Court (SC). Giving details, he said Rs 109 million were recovered from Pakistan Power House and Walter International, Rs 546 million from
9|Page
10 | P a g e
11 | P a g e
12 | P a g e
13 | P a g e
15 | P a g e
20 | P a g e
21 | P a g e
22 | P a g e
Judiciary
Sharifs Double Game With CJ Restoration Exposed
KARACHI: Even as PML-N chief Nawaz Sharif was rallying street support by publicly refusing to back down from demands for the restoration of Chief Justice Iftikhar Chaudhry in February and March 2009, the party was privately telling American diplomats that the future of the then-non-functional chief justice was up for negotiation. Shahbaz stated that following the restoration, the PML-N was prepared to end the issue and remove Chaudhry once and for all, reported Lahore Consulate Principal Officer Bryan Hunt in a secret American diplomatic cable describing his meeting with the younger Sharif on March 14, 2009. On the issue of former Chief Justice Iftikhar Chaudhry, Shahbaz claimed that the PML N was open to negotiation, provided that Chaudhry was symbolically restored. The conversation took place just a day before Nawaz Sharif wo uld join a lawyers long march in a dramatic public protest for the reinstatement of judges deposed by Gen Musharraf, a demand that President Zardari had been resisting. In private, however, a different story was being told. Shahbaz stressed that his party could not afford the political humiliation of abandoning what had become a long-standing principle in favour of Chaudhrys restoration, Mr Hunt reported. At the same time, Shahbaz claimed to understand that Chaudhry was a problematic jurist, whose powers would need to be carefully curtailed.
23 | P a g e
25 | P a g e
Taxes
N-League Refuses To Pay Proper Taxes For Billboards
The Pakistan Muslim League-Nawazs (PML-N) Punjab government is causing a loss of millions of rupees to the national exchequer, as all political billboards of the party are installed without paying a single penny to the Parks and Horticulture Authority (PHA) and most of them violate the PHA Outdoor Publicity Policy framed to regularise outdoor advertisement in 2008, Pakistan Today has learnt. Since the PML-N, led by Shahbaz Sharif, assumed power in Punjab in 2008, outsized billboards bearing big pictures of PML-N chief Nawaz Sharif, ministers and parliamentarians were installed on roads, rooftops and even in residential areas while all of them are untaxed and defy rules. According to Punjab Gazette, copy of which is available with Pakistan Today, PHA laid down regulations in exercise of the power conferred under Section 44 of the Punjab Development of Cities Act 1976 with government notification No SO (P)-3-4/98 on September 21, 1998 when Shahbaz was enjoying his first stint as Punjab CM. The regulations ban all sort of billboards on roadside areas and rooftops that could disturb the skyline. They also prohibit installation of billboards in residential localities. But a political billboard is placed on one side of the residence of Punjab Excise and Taxation Minister Mujtaba Shujaur Rehman at Cooper Store Locality near GT Road. Some hoardings carrying pictures of the PML-N leadership are affixed on an iron-made gate at the Garhi Shahu Bridge. Some billboards showcasing snaps of PML-N Member of the National Assembly (MNA) and Shahbazs son Hamza Shahbaz are installed on the rooftop at a building near the Lahore Hotel. Adding insult to injury, all of them were installed without the formal permission of PHA. Their presence in different parts of the city is mocking the Punjab government, which loves to talk about merit, impartiality, good governance and treating everyone, including itself, equal in compliance of law, a senior PHA official told Pakistan Today. PHA Additional Director General Captain (r) Usman Younis said that he did not know
26 | P a g e
27 | P a g e
Terrorism
The Punjabi Taliban
Punjab, with Lahore as its bustling capital, contains half of Pakistans population. The provincial government is in the hands of the conservative, mildly Islamist party of a former prime minister, Nawaz Sharif. In a speech in March his brother, Shahbaz Sharif, who is chief minister, pleaded with the Taliban to leave Punjab alone as his administration shared their ideology of keeping out foreign dictation (ie, Americans). Officials bristle at comparisons between Punjab, which is moderately well run, and the lawless tribal areas. It is correct to say that there has been no territorial takeover by extremists in any part of the province, nor any enforcement of Islamic law. However, Punjab functions as an ideological nursery and recruiting ground for militants throughout the country. Distinctions between the Taliban in the north-west and older jihadi groups in Punjab have broken down. The federal government says Punjabi groups have been responsible for most of the big terrorist attacks in the province. Punjabs minister of law, Rana Sanaullah, went on the campaign trail in February with the reputed head of Sipah-e-Sahaba, for a by-election in the southern town of Jhang. The two rode through the streets in an open-top vehicle. The minister says that he was just trying to bring the group into the mainstream. Jhang is Sipah-e-Sahabas headquarters; the group makes little effort to hide its presence there. Another outfit, Jaish-e-Mohammed, is based in Bahawalpur, also in southern Punjab, where it has a huge seminary. Former members of both organisations are integral parts of the Pakistani Taliban. Another group, Lashkar-e-Taiba, blamed for the devastating attack on Mumbai in 2008, also has Punjab as its home. The Punjab government is not only complacent, there is a certain ambivalence in their attitude towards extremists, says Arif Nizami, a political analyst based in Lahore. They compete for the religious vote bank. Source: http://www.economist.com/node/16281220
28 | P a g e
29 | P a g e
Shahbaz, are we now caught?!? Pakistans president alleged that the brother of Pakistans opposition leader, Nawaz Sharif, tipped off the militant group Lashkar-e-Taiba (LeT) about impending UN sanctions following the 2008 Mumbai attacks, allowing the outfit to empty its bank accounts before they could be raided. Six weeks after LeT gunmen killed more than 170 people in Mumbai, President Asif Ali Zardari told the US of his frustration that Sharifs government in Punjab province helped the group evade new UN sanctions. A month earlier, Shahbaz Sharif, who is chief minister of Punjab, tipped off the Jamaat-ud-Dawa (JuD), LeTs charity wing, resulting in almost empty bank accounts, Zardari claimed in a conversation with the US ambassador to Islamabad, Anne Patterson. US diplomats were unable to confirm the allegation and noted that they came at a time of rising political tension between Zardari and Sharif. But they conceded that JuD did appear to have received a warning from somewhere. Information from the ministry of the interior does indicate that bank accounts contained surprisingly small amounts, said the cable in January 2009. A Punjab government spokesman vigorously denied the charge. Theres nothing true in it, said senator Pervaiz Rashid, an adviser to Sharif. Zardari is our political opponent and he wants to topple our government. Sharif couldnt have known about the UN sanctions, he said, because the UN co -ordinated its action with the federal government and not the provincial one.
30 | P a g e
31 | P a g e
32 | P a g e
33 | P a g e
October 1990: Bin Laden Allegedly Helps Install Pakistani Leader Nawaz Sharif
In October 1990, Nawaz Sharif is running for election to replace Benazir Bhutto as the prime minister of Pakistan. According to a senior Pakistani intelligence source, bin Laden passes a considerable amount of money to Sharif and his party, since Sharif promises to introduce a hard-line Islamic government. Bin Laden has been supporting Sharif for several years. There is said to be a photograph of Sharif chatting with bin Laden. Sharif wins the election and while he does not introduce a hard-line Islamic government, his rule is more amenable to bin Ladens interests than Bhuttos had bee n. Sharif will stay in power until 1993, then will take over from Bhutto again in 1996 and rule for three more years. [Reeve, 1999, pp. 170-171] Former ISI official Khalid Khawaja, a self-proclaimed close friend of bin Laden, will later claim that Sharif and bin Laden had a relationship going back to when they first met face to face in the late 1980s. [ABC News, 11/30/2007] There are also accounts of additional links between Sharif and bin Laden (see Spring 1989, Late 1996, and Between Late 1996 and Late 1998).
February 1991: Pakistan Supposedly Considers Funding Covert Operations through Drug Money
Pakistans army chief and the head of the ISI, its inte lligence agency, propose to sell heroin to pay for the countrys covert operations, according to Nawaz Sharif, Pakistans prime minister at the time. Sharif claims that shortly after becoming prime minister, army chief of staff Gen. Aslam Beg and ISI director Gen. Asad Durrani present him with a
34 | P a g e
Spring 1993: US Discovers that Ramzi Yousef and KSM Have Ties with ISI
US agents uncover photographs showing Khalid Shaikh Mohammed (KSM) has ties with the Pakistani ISI. Several weeks after the World Trade Center bombing (see February 26, 1993), US agents come to Pakistan to search for Ramzi Yousef for his part in that bombing. Searching the house of Zahid Shaikh Mohammed, Yousefs uncle, they find photographs of Zahid and KSM, who is also one of Yousefs uncles, with close associates of Pakistani Prime Minister Nawaz Sharif. [Financial Times, 2/15/2003] According to another account, the pictures actually show Zahid with Sharif, and also with Muhammad Zia ul-Haq, president of Pakistan until his death in 1988. [Jacquard, 2002, pp. 66] Pictures of Osama bin Laden are also found. US agents are unable to catch Yousef because Pakistani agents tip him off prior to the US raids. Yousef is able to live a semi-public life (for instance, he attends weddings), despite worldwide publicity naming him as a major terrorist. The Financial Times will later note that Yousef, KSM, and their allies must have felt confident that their ties to senior Pakistani Islamists, whose power had been cemented within the countrys intelligence service [the ISI], would prove invaluable. [Financial Times, 2/15/2003] Several months later, Yousef and KSM unsuccessfully attempt to assassinate Benazir Bhutto, who is prime minister of Pakistan twice in the 1990s (see July 1993). She is an opponent of Sharif and the ISI. [Slate, 9/21/2001; Guardian, 3/3/2003] The Los Angeles Times will later report that KSM spent most of the 1990s in Pakistan. Pakistani leadership through the 1990s sympathized with Osama bin Ladens fundamentalist rhetoric. This sympathy allowed [him] to operate as he pleased in Pakistan. [Los Angeles Times, 6/24/2002]
35 | P a g e
36 | P a g e
Between Late 1996 and Late 1998: Bin Laden Allegedly Pays $1 Million to Pakistani Prime Minister
According to FBI agent Jack Cloonan, in 1999, imprisoned double agent Ali Mohamed will tell Cloonan that he helped arrange a meeting between bin Laden and representatives of Nawaz Sharif, who is prime minister of Pakistan from 1990 through 1993 and again from 1996 to 1999. Mohamed claims that after the meeting he delivered $1 million to Sharifs representatives as a tribute to Sharif for not cracking down on the Taliban as it flourished in Afghanistan and influenced the Northwest Frontier Province in Pakistan. It is unknown when this took place, but it is likely between late 1996, when the Taliban gain control over much of Afghanistan and Sharif as prime minister would have been in a position to crack down against them or not, and late 1998, when Mohamed is arrested in the US (see September 10, 1998). Cloonan will later say that he believes the information from Mohamed is accurate. [ABC News, 11/30/2007] There have been other allegations that Sharif met bin Laden in 1996 and used his help to win the election for prime minister (see Late 1996), and also allegations that bin Laden helped Sharif win the election for prime minister in 1990 (see Late 1996).
Pakistans first nuclear test take place underground but shakes the mountains above it. [Source: Associated Press]Pakistan conducts a successful nuclear test. Former Clinton administration official Karl Inderfurth later notes that concerns about an Indian-Pakistani conflict, or even nuclear confrontation, compete with efforts to press Pakistan on terrorism. [US Congress, 7/24/2003] Pakistan actually built its first nuclear weapon in 1987 but kept it a secret and did not test it until this time for political reasons (see 1987). In announcing the tests, Prime Minister Nawaz Sharif declares, Today, we have settled the score. [New York Times, 5/4/2003]
37 | P a g e
Nawaz Sharif meeting with US Defense Secretary William Cohen at the Pentagon on December 3, 1998. [Source: US Department of Defense]Pakistani Prime Minister Nawaz Sharif comes to Washington to meet with President Clinton and other top Clinton administration officials. The number one issue for Clinton is Pakistans nuclear program, since Pakistan had recently illegally developed and exploded a nuclear weapon (see May 28, 1998). The second most important issue is Pakistans economy; the US wants Pakistan to support free trade agreements. The third most important issue is terrorism and Pakistans support for bin Laden. Author Steve Coll will later note, When Clinton himself met with Pakistani leaders, his agenda list always had several items, and bin Laden never was at the top. Afghanistans war fell even further down. Sharif proposes to Clinton that the CIA train a secret Pakistani commando team to capture bin Laden. The US and Pakistan go ahead with this plan, even though most US officials involved in the decision believe it has almost no chance for success. They figure there is also little risk or cost involved, and it can help build ties between American and Pakistani intelligence. The plan will later come to nothing (see October 1999). [Coll, 2004, pp. 441-444]
38 | P a g e
Shortly Before May 26, 1999: United Arab Emirates Minister Tours Pakistani Nuclear Weapons Site
Sheikh Abdullah bin Zayed Al-Nahyan, the United Arab Emirates (UAE) minister for information, tours Pakistan. He meets with Pakistani Prime Minister Nawaz Sharif and nuclear scientist A. Q. Khan. He is also shown around Khan Research Laboratories, the main facility for producing nuclear weapons in Pakistan. According to the Pakistani newspaper Jasarat, the visit is directly linked to nuclear activities: Prince Abdullah bin Zayed also asked Dr. Qadeer Khan what help he could give them. Dr. Qadeer replied that Pakistan would not present the atomic bomb or a missile on a platter but could train UAE manpower. [Levy and Scott-Clark, 2007, pp. 286-287]
39 | P a g e
Nawaz Sharif [Source: Publicity photo]In early May 1999, the Pakistani army, at the instigation of Gen. Pervez Musharraf, seizes a strategic height called Kargil in the Indian province of Kashmir. This creates a grave crisis between Pakistan in India. By early July, the CIA picks up intelligence that Pakistan is preparing to launch nuclear missiles against India if necessary. Pakistani Prime Minister Nawaz Sharif comes to the US on July 4 to meet with President Clinton about this. Clinton is livid and yells at Sharif for breaking promises, not only about Kashmir but also about failing to help with bin Laden. According to notes taken at the meeting, Clinton says he had asked repeatedly for Pakistani help to bring Osama bin Laden to justice [Sharif] promised often to do so but had done nothing. Instead, the ISI worked with bin Laden and the Taliban to foment terrorists. Clinton threatens to release a statement calling worldwide attention to Pakistans support for terrorists. He adds, Youve put me in the middle today, set the US up to fail, and I wont let it happen. Pakistani is messing with nuclear war. Sharif backs down and immediately withdraws his troops from Kargil, ending the crisis. But as a result, Sharif becomes deeply unpopular in Pakistan. A few months later he will be ousted in a coup by Musharraf (see October 12, 1999), the general who started the crisis in the first place. [Coll, 2004, pp. 476-478]
40 | P a g e
Pakistani President Pervez Musharraf. [Source: Government of Pakistan]Gen. Pervez Musharraf becomes leader of Pakistan in a coup, ousting Prime Minister Nawaz Sharif. One major reason for the coup is the ISI (Pakistans intelligence agency) felt Sharif had to go out of fear that he might buckle to American pressure and reverse Pakistans policy [of supporting] the Taliban. [New York Times, 12/8/2001] Shortly thereafter,
41 | P a g e
September 10, 2007: Pakistani President Musharraf Thwarts Return of Former Prime Minister
Former Pakistani Prime Minister Nawaz Sharif attempts to return to Pakistan, but his return is thwarted by the Pakistani authorities and he is deported to Saudi Arabia. Sharif, ousted by General Pervez Musharraf in 1999 (see October 12, 1999), had been in exile for seven years due to corruption charges. After landing in Pakistan, Sharif, the leader of the political party Pakistan Muslim League-N, is briefly taken into custody and then put on a flight to Jeddah, Saudi Arabia. The deportation is a major political event in Pakistan and is marked by clashes between police and Sharifs supporters. [CNN, 9/10/2007] However, Pakistans ISI agency will later broker a deal with Saudi authorities regarding Sharif (see November 20-23, 2007), enabling him to return (see November 25, 2007).
42 | P a g e