Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Pump & Systems Marc 2013
Pump & Systems Marc 2013
.
Designed to improve the efciency and reliability of both water and wastewater ltration
systems, these next generation media retainers have been carefully engineered to do
their job and help you do yours. As part of the complete Leopold underdrain system,
these media retainers increase exibility in media design by eliminating up to 14" of
support gravel. And their physically rigid construction reduces exing of the slots and the
chance of clogging or biofouling. You now have two superior solutions for all your water
treatment applications that ensure a highly uniform distribution of air and water during
the backwashing process to eliminate deadspaces and provide longer lter runs.
To nd out more about how you can get greater performance with lower installation
and operating costs, please visit www.fbleopold.com
www.fbleopold.com
ENGINEERED TO
ELIMINATE
EVERYTHING YOU
WORRY
ABOUT.
circle 106 on card or go to psfreeinfo.com
2 March 2013 www.pump-zone.com PUMPS & SYSTEMS
From the Editor
PUMPS & SYSTEMS (ISSN# 1065-108X) is published monthly Cahaba Media Group, 1900 28th Avenue So., Suite 110, Birmingham, AL 35209. Periodicals postage paid at Birmingham, AL, and
additional mailing ofces. Subscriptions: Free of charge to qualied industrial pump users. Publisher reserves the right to determine qualications. Annual subscriptions: US and possessions $48, all
other countries $125 US funds (via air mail). Single copies: US and possessions $5, all other countries $15 US funds (via air mail). Call (630) 739-0900 inside or outside the U.S. POSTMASTER:
Send changes of address and form 3579 to Pumps & Systems, Subscription Dept., 440 Quadrangle Drive, Suite E, Bolingbrook, IL 60440. 2013 Cahaba Media Group, Inc. No part of this publication
may be reproduced without the written consent of the publisher. The publisher does not warrant, either expressly or by implication, the factual accuracy of any advertisements, articles or descrip-
tions herein, nor does the publisher warrant the validity of any views or opinions offered by the authors of said articles or descriptions. The opinions expressed are those of the individual authors,
and do not necessarily represent the opinions of Cahaba Media Group. Cahaba Media Group makes no representation or warranties regarding the accuracy or appropriateness of the advice or any
advertisements contained in this magazine. SUBMISSIONS: We welcome submissions. Unless otherwise negotiated in writing by the editors, by sending us your submission, you grant Cahaba
Media Group, Inc., permission by an irrevocable license to edit, reproduce, distribute, publish and adapt your submission in any medium on multiple occasions. You are free to publish your submission
yourself or to allow others to republish your submission. Submissions will not be returned. Volume 21, Issue 3.
is a member of the following organizations:
F
or several years, the industry has been buzzing
about pumps used in irrigation and agriculture
applications. It makes sense. Almost 60 percent
of the worlds freshwater withdrawals are used for
irrigation, according to several sources including a
recent study by the USGS Water Science School.
Consider this . . . power plants use 10 times
more water than is treated in municipal drinking
water plants. In fact, they extract and treat more
water than all other industries combined. Te only
larger use of water is for irrigation, according to a
2011 study by Te McIlvaine Company.
Efective irrigation systems use energy-ef cient
equipment and designs that also help minimize the
amount of unnecessary water use. Some common
causes of wasted energy in irrigation systems,
according to the Natural Resources Conservation
Service (NRCS), are worn or improperly sized
pumps, worn nozzles and improperly sized or
designed fttings. Irrigation equipment problems
and maintenance problems tend to go hand in
hand. Pumps, motors and engines that are badly
designed or poorly maintained reduce the irriga-
tors degree of control over water applications,
making it impossible to maintain correct soil
moisture levels. Tis leads to crop stress, reduced
yields, runof, erosion and other problems.
Agricultural irrigation is an energy intensive
operation, and modifying irrigation systems can
reduce energy usage and costs. Pressurized irri-
gation systems, especially center pivot sprinkler
installations, use a high fow rate pump and require
a large electric motor or engine. Te major causes
of increased energy use are associated with pipe-
line leaks, engine and pump ef ciency and well
maintenance. Poor uniformity of water applica-
tion can also afect energy use by increasing pump-
ing time.
As we increase our coverage of pumping systems
used in agricultural, irrigation and groundwater
applications, our cover series this month features
cutting-edge solutions to complex irrigation
installations (page 25). Te lead article describes
how todays agricultural irrigation is not just about
pumps. Variable speed drives, intelligent control
and remote management are all vital to a com-
plete energy-ef cient system. Complete pumping
systems have replaced large, isolated pumps as the
solution moving forward.
Our cover series also includes two articles that
describe the diesel versus electric debate for pow-
ering the pump (page 30 and page 34).
Pumps & Systems will continue to research and
report about pumps in agricultural irrigation. Tell
us about your experiences and share your case
studies by contacting me directly,
msegrest@pump-zone.com.
Michelle Segrest
Editor
Editorial Advisory Board
Thomas L. Angle, P.E., MSc, Vice President Engineering,
Hidrostal AG
Robert K. Asdal, Executive Director, Hydraulic Institute
Bryan S. Barrington, Machinery Engineer,
Lyondell Chemical Co.
Kerry Baskins, Vice President of Sales, Viking Pump
Walter Bonnett, Vice President Global Marketing,
Pump Solutions Group
R. Thomas Brown III, President,
Advanced Sealing International (ASI)
Chris Caldwell, Director of Advanced Collection Technology,
Business Area Wastewater Solutions,
Sulzer Pumps, ABS USA
David A. Doty, North American Sales Manager,
Moyno Industrial Pumps
Walt Erndt, Director of Market Development SSB,
Environment One Corporation
Joe Evans, Customer & Employee Education, PumpTech, Inc.
Ralph P. Gabriel, Chief EngineerGlobal, John Crane
Bob Langton, Vice President, Industry Sales, Grundfos Pumps
Larry Lewis, President, Vanton Pump and Equipment Corp.
Todd Loudin, President/CEO North American Operations,
Flowrox Inc.
John Malinowski, Sr. Product Manager, AC Motors,
Baldor Electric Company, A Member of the ABB Group
William E. Neis, P.E., President, Northeast Industrial Sales
Lev Nelik, P.E., APICS, President, Pumping Machinery, LLC
Henry Peck, President, Geiger Pumps & Equipment/
Smith-Koch, Inc.
Mike Pemberton, Manager, ITT Performance Services
Adam Stolberg, Executive Director, Submersible Wastewater
Pump Association (SWPA)
Bruce Stratton, Product Manager, KLOZURE, Garlock
Sealing Technologies
Kirk Wilson, President, Services & Solutions, Flowserve
Corporation
Publisher
Walter B. Evans, Jr.
VP of Sales
George Lake
glake@pump-zone.com 205-345-0477
VP of Editorial
Michelle Segrest
msegrest@pump-zone.com 205-314-8279
Creative Director
Terri Jackson
tjackson@cahabamedia.com
EDITORIAL
Editor
Michelle Segrest
msegrest@pump-zone.com 205-314-8279
Managing Editor
Lori K. Ditoro
lditoro@cahabamedia.com 205-314-8269
Associate Editor
Amanda Perry
aperry@cahabamedia.com 205-314-8274
Contributing Editors
Laurel Donoho
Joe Evans, Ph.D.
Dr. Lev Nelik, PE, APICS
CREATIVE SERVICES
Creative Director
Terri Jackson
Senior Art Director
Greg Ragsdale
Art Director
Jaime DeArman
jdearman@cahabamedia.com
PRODUCTION
Production Manager/Trafc
Lisa Freeman
lfreeman@pump-zone.com 205-212-9402
Web Advertising Trafc
Ashley Morris
amorris@pump-zone.com 205-561-2600
CIRCULATION
Jeff Heine
jheine@cds1976.com 630-739-0900
ADVERTISING
Derrell Moody
dmoody@pump-zone.com 205-345-0784
Mary-Kathryn Baker
mkbaker@pump-zone.com 205-345-6036
Mark Goins
mgoins@pump-zone.com 205-345-6414
Addison Perkins
aperkins@pump-zone.com 205-561-2603
Vince Marino
vince@pump-zone.com 205-561-2601
P.O. Box 530067
Birmingham, AL 35253
Editorial & Production
1900 28th Avenue South, Suite 110
Birmingham, AL 35209
Phone: 205-212-9402
Advertising Sales
2126 McFarland Blvd. East,. Suite A
Tuscaloosa, AL 35404
Phone: 205-345-0477 or 205-561-2600
305.591.8935 | info@ludeca.com | www.ludeca.com
Downtime is costly. Equipment reliability
is critical to your business. LUDECA is your
reliability partner. With over 30 years of
experience and commitment to quality, we will
never let you down. Keep it running.
ALIGNMENT VIBRATION BALANCING
ROTALIGN
Ultra iS
Laser Alignment, Geometric
Measurement and More!
VibXpert
II
Vibration Analysis,
Field Balancing and More!
circle 103 on card or go to psfreeinfo.com
4 March 2013 www.pump-zone.com PUMPS & SYSTEMS
Table of Contents
March 2013
Volume 21 Number 3
A
G
r
u
n
d
f
o
s
H
y
d
r
o
M
P
C
b
o
o
s
t
e
r
p
a
q
w
i
t
h
d
e
d
i
c
a
t
e
d
c
o
n
t
r
o
l
u
n
i
t
i
n
a
n
i
r
r
i
g
a
t
i
o
n
a
p
p
l
i
c
a
t
i
o
n
.
P
h
o
t
o
c
o
u
r
t
e
s
y
o
f
G
r
u
n
d
f
o
s
6 Readers Respond
8 20th Anniversary Top 20 List
By Amanda Perry
Top 20 Apps for Pump Users
12 News
15 Calendar of Events
42 Efciency Matters
By Arno Gehrer, ANDRITZ GROUP
Design Software Increases Hydraulic Efciency
45 Maintenance Minders
By Tom Davis, Maintenance Troubleshooting
Pump Rebuild Tips
48 Sealing Sense
By The Fluid Sealing Association
Gaskets for Rigorous Applications
51 HI Pump FAQs
By The Hydraulic Institute
Submersible Pump NPSH3, Trench-Type Wet
Wells & Starting Torque Requirements
65 Product Pipeline
72 Pump Market Analysis
By Jordan, Knauff & Company
SPECIAL
REPORT
20 Pump Specication, Purchase, Installation
& Application
By Amin Almasi, WorleyParsons Services Pty Ltd.
Sharing all the information about an application can help
with the selection and installation of the ideal pump.
Departments
25 Pump Systems for Todays
Agricultural Irrigation
By Vahan Bagdasarian, Grundfos
Complex irrigation applications require customized and
cutting-edge solutions.
30 Powering the Pump:
Diesel Versus Electric Motors
By Tim Albers, Nidec Motor Corporation
Make the ideal motor selection for irrigation applications.
34 Powerful Mine Dewatering
By Kristen Gurick, Godwin Pumps, a Xylem Brand
Electric and diesel centrifugal pump options
The Pump Purchase Process
Columns
16 Pump Ed 101
By Joe Evans, Ph.D.
Branch-Line Pumping and Other Options
18 Pumping Prescriptions
By Lev Nelik, P.E., Pumping Machinery, LLC
Will Impeller Velocity Triangles
Keep You Awake at Night?
2 From the Editor
41 Trade Show Coverage
68 Index of Advertisers
68 Pump Users Marketplace
COVER
SERIES
Agricultural Irrigation & Dewatering
Practice & Operations
54 Prefabricated Treatment System Solves Water Quality
Concerns
By Mark Koester, Koester Associates, Inc.
With the simultaneous construction and site preparation, the quick turnaround
required for the project was accomplished with cost-efcient results.
57 New Optimized Aeration System Reduces Energy
Consumption
By Lars Larsson, Xylem, Inc.
A wastewater treatment plant experiences a 65 percent energy savings with the
installation of improved equipment.
60 Positive Displacement Pumps in Wastewater Treatment
By Oakley Roberts, ARO Fluid Products, Ingersoll Rand
Select the right pumping technology to keep treatment processes running efciently.
62 Power Generation on Demand
By Brad Chrudimsky, Baldor Electric Company, a member of the ABB Group
The application, geography, regulations and proper size must be considered when
choosing a generator set.
circle 105 on card or go to psfreeinfo.com
READERS RESPOND
6 March 2013 www.pump-zone.com PUMPS & SYSTEMS
Pump System Design, February 2013
Thanks for your article Pump System Design
published in the February 2013 Pumps &
Systems. It included good items to consider for
simplifed system modifcations or upgrades.
Homework Background and Answers
For a 12-hour per day operation at 800 gallons
per minute (gpm), there will need to be storage
capacity for at least 576,000 gallons of oil. An approximate 70-foot
diameter by 21-foot deep storage tank was used in the analysis.
To keep the analysis simple, only half the 20-foot storage tank
draw-down was used to arrive at an average lift value. An average lift
of 20/2 + 50 = 60 feet was used. The recommended pump place-
ment close to the storage tank was used.
A 71-foot length of vertical discharge piping and a couple pipe
elbows were also included. Friction losses totaled about 97.7 feet
including tank entrance and process end discharge losses.
The calculated required pump head was 1.3-foot discharge
velocity head + 60 feet of lift + 97.7 feet for friction = 159 feet
(used 160 feet).
Using a 2-pole speed of 3,500 rpm, an approximate specifc
speed value of 2,200 was calculated. Based on the effciency-
versus-specifc speed graph at www.mj-scope.com/pump_tools/
pump_effciency.htm, a maximum, 81-percent pump effciency
might be expected for best-effciency-point (BEP) operation.
I did fnd a commercial refnery/API type pump with an approxi-
mate 78 percent effciency at the above design conditions. The
curve indicated an 80 percent best effciency zone.
Assuming that the BEP operating head (160 feet) is about 85
percent of the head at zero fow,
a shutoff head of 188 feet was
estimated.
Equating this shutoff head value
to V
t
^2 / 2g, where V
t
= [pi(D/12)
(N/60)] is the impeller tip speed, an
impeller diameter of 7.21 inches was
calculated.
The curve for the 78-percent eff-
cient pump indicated an approximate 7.25-inch diameter impeller
for the design conditions. The calculated minimum net positive suc-
tion head available at 6 p.m. full 20-foot draw-down was 37 feet.
This is greater than the curve net positive suction head required
value of 20 feet.
By designing to the average tank draw-down, the estimated
pump performance may vary between 825 gpm at 155 feet in the
morning to 775 gpm at 165 feet at 6 p.m. The design point, 800
gpm at 160 feet, would theoretically be seen around noon.
Good luck reflling the storage tank each day before 6 a.m.
Lee Ruiz
Oceanside, Calif.
Lev Nelik responds:
Tank you, Lee. Glad to see you got to use the Ef ciency
Estimator Program, with close correlation to an actual com-
mercial pump. I am reproducing the link you noted from
the website (see Figure 1) and compared the numbers to
a copy of a performance curve from a randomly selected
pump OEM catalogue.
Te 800 gpm and 143-foot head come out with a 6.79-
inch impeller and 81.7 percent ef ciency by the program
and about the same impeller size and 77 percent ef ciency
by a random OEM performance curve. Te diference in
ef ciency is about 4 percent. Tis is a question for Pumps &
Systems readers. Why the diference in ef ciency? (Please
feel free to share your answers to Levs question. Send these
answers to Amanda Perry, aperry@cahabamedia.com.)
Editors Note: For the Estimator Program referenced in
the February 2012 column to work, readers may need
to download a Microsof Web component from www.
microsoft.com/downloads/details.aspx?amp;display
lang=EN&familyid=982B0359-0A86-4FB2-A7EE-
F3A499515DD&displaylang=en). Readers should only
need to download the program once. P&S
To have a letter considered for Readers Respond, please send it to
Amanda Perry, aperry@cahabamedia.com.
Lee Ruiz
Figure 1. Screen shot from www.pumpingmachinery.com
Mobile
Power
If you need a wide range of
industrial quality generators
for rental use, light towers for
night construction projects, or
emergency power that can be
towed to a sewage lift station in a
moments notice, Baldor has the
mobile power solution for you. Built
to the highest standards of quality
for long life, low maintenance and
reliable service, Baldor stocks
towables from 25 to 400 kVA for
immediate shipment.
For more information on our
complete line of mobile generators
and light towers, contact Baldor to
learn how you can have ready to
roll power.
baldor.com 479-646-4711
2011 Baldor Electric Company
c
i
r
c
l
e
1
0
0
o
n
c
a
r
d
o
r
g
o
t
o
p
s
f
r
e
e
i
n
f
o
.
c
o
m
8 March 2013 www.pump-zone.com PUMPS & SYSTEMS
Top 20 Apps for Pump Users
Mobile applications assist pump users in the feld and on the go.
First of Two Parts
By Amanda Perry
YEARS
1 9 9 3 - 2 0 1 3
A
s we continue to celebrate 20 years as the leading magazine for pump users worldwide, we bring you a favorite Top 20
list compiled from reader surveys and editorial research in each issue. See Part Two of Top 20 Apps for Pump Users in
the April issue.
Flatness App for ALiSENSOR LEVEL Alignment Supplies, Inc.
Te Flatness App for ALiSENSOR Level makes geometric measurement cost-efective, more accessible
and easier to perform. Te app allows users to measure the fatness of surfaces of a wide range of shapes and
sizes to be calibrated to user-made fxtures of all sizes. Users can perform precise fatness measurements and
customize the number of measurement points for specifc applications. Te measurements are performed
quickly, and the user is guided in every step by a live 3D model of the measurement. Upon completing
their measuring, users can create an instant PDF report with all the data, including an adjustable-scale
schematic drawing of the fatness results. Tis app requires separately purchased hardware.
Free / iPad, iPhone, iPod Touch
KoolApp: KoolCode, Refrigerant Slider,
CoolGame, Fitters App, Compass Danfoss
Danfoss designed the new KoolCode app for service technicians, refrigeration engineers and in-store
technicians to easily look up alarm, error, status and parameter codes for a range of Danfoss refrigeration
controllers with a three-digit display. KoolCode joins Refrigerant Slider, CoolGame, Fitters App and
Compass in Danfoss app library.
Users can look up KoolCode display codes by:
Quick code translation without knowing the controller
Hierarchical controller selection among Danfoss refrigeration controllers
Automatic controller identication using a QR-code scan
Free / Android, iPad, iPhone, iPod Touch
Toolbox Technician Emerson Industrial Automation
Power Transmission Solutions
Power Transmission Solutions designed the award-winning Toolbox Technician app for HVACR
technicians. Named an Honorable Mention winner of the 2013 AHR Expo Innovation Award, it
combines the Browning Bearing & Belt Drive Pocket Reference Guide with an energy-ef cient calculator.
Toolbox Technician enables users to easily search the reference guide and quickly calculate information
on ef ciency savings. Te material can be continually updated as new products are developed, so users will
have the most current information. Te upgraded app also provides improved navigation, a belt identifca-
tion wizard and GPS functionality.
Free / Android, iPad, iPhone, iPod Touch
PUMPS & SYSTEMS www.pump-zone.com March 2013 9
20
READERS CHOICE
Grundfos GO Remote Grundfos Pumps Corporation
Grundfos GO Remote is an app that works as a mobile tool box. GO Remote provides handheld pump
control that can save users time on control, reporting and data collection. Tis app works with all of
Grundfos e-pumps and communicates with radio and infrared technology. Users have full access to
all the Grundfos Online tools with this app. Features include product dashboard, status data, alarms
and warnings, confguration/commissioning, create installation report, and read/write profles. Special
hardware from Grundfos is required to communicate with the pumps.
Free / Android, iPad, iPhone, iPod Touch
Laser Align LUDECA Inc.
Te Laser Align app is a reference tool for the shaf alignment of rotating equipment. Users can access
important reference material and learn about key laser shaf alignment concepts. Laser Align features
several tools with useful reference guides, including Short Flex Tolerance Table, Spacer Shaf Tolerance
Table, Termal Growth Calculator and Sof Foot Assistant.
Laser Align also provides interactive links for additional information on Prufechnik laser shaf align-
ment products and condition monitoring products.
Free / Android, iPad, iPhone, iPod Touch
circle 122 on card or go to psfreeinfo.com
WHY MONITOR POWER INSTEAD OF JUST AMPS?
NO LOAD NO LOAD
Power is Linear-Equal Sensitivity
at Both Low and High Loads
No Sensitivity
For Low Loads
FULL LOAD FULL LOAD
P
O
W
E
R
A
M
P
S
WWW.LOADCONTROLS.COM
CALL NOW FOR YOUR FREE 30-DAY TRIAL 888-600-3247
PROTECT PUMPS
DPY PbNNING - CAVIIAIION - 8EAPING FAIIbPE - OVEPIOAD
MONITOR PUMP POWER
Best 8ensitivit]
Digital Displa]
TWO ADJUSTABLE SET POINTS
Rela] 0utputs
Adjustaole Dela] Timers
4-20 MILLIAMP ANALOG OUTPUT
COMPACT EASY MOUNTING
0nl] 8.25" x G.25" x 2"
8tarter Door Panel
Racewa] wall
UNIQUE RANGE FINDER SENSOR
works on wide-range of Notors
8implifes lnstallation
PUMP POWER
PUMPING
VALVE CLOSING
VALVE OPENING
NO FLUID
10 March 2013 www.pump-zone.com PUMPS & SYSTEMS
Amanda Perry is associate editor of Pumps & Systems.
Send information about your favorite mobile
app to her at aperry@cahabamedia.com.
seepex Pumps, SCT seepex, Inc.
Te seepex Pumps, SCT app provides users with information on seepexs Smart Conveying Technology
(SCT) for progressive cavity pumps. In addition to providing valuable information, the seepex app also
has a comparison calculator, which directly shows the potential cost savings that can be made with SCT
compared to an equivalent conventional seepex progressive cavity pump over a period of up to 10 years.
Free / Android, iPad, iPhone, iPod Touch
Versa-Matic and Sandpiper Mobile Apps Warren Rupp, Inc.
Te Versa-Matic and Sandpiper mobile apps are designed to help pump owners quickly and easily fnd the
tools to support pumps installed in the feld and pumps being built and shipped. Users can locate specifc
pump information with quick bar scanning or manual entry. Both apps allow users to review the Chemical
Compatibility Guide using the interactive guide, access the latest full line catalogs, and watch service and
repair training videos. Although not yet available for Android or Blackberry, users with these devices can
use the web version, which allows access to many of the mobile apps tools.
Free / iPad, iPhone, iPod Touch
Pump Energy Savings Calculator Rockwell Automation, Inc.
Rockwell Automation addresses rising energy costs with Te Pump Energy Savings Calculator app.
Tis app compares conventional fow control methods with PowerFlex drives and shows the diferential
power consumption of each. It calculates the potential energy savings of using variable frequency drives to
power pumps and fans. Users can calculate energy consumption by entering the minimum pump or ow
percentages, annual operating hours, cost per kilowatt and other information about their facility or by
using the built-in sample data provided by Rockwell Automation.
Free / Android, iPad, iPhone, Blackberry
20
W
i kl
W
READERS CHOICE
Xylect Mobile Xylem Inc.
Xylect Mobile is designed to give users quick and easy access to detailed product information from any
location. Since users ofen work on site, the ability to access this information is important. Te app allows
users to input specifc requirements and search for the ideal product to meet their needs. It gives users the
ability to search by application or product type, input required fow and pump head specifcations, and
identify all available spare parts for a product by inputting the products serial number. It also allows users
to search products from a defned duty point (fow and head) and from a product denomination.
Free / Android, iPhone, iPad
TDH Pump Calculator Rain for Rent
Te TDH Pump Calculator provides users with a tool to estimate hydraulic conditions required for pump
systems. Te app is designed for engineers, feld operators and technicians. It is based on Hazen-Williams
equations, and users can enter the hydraulic parameters of the pumping system. Te app will return the
total dynamic head (TDH). It is useful in the feld or of ce. Intuitive controls allow users to simulate any
combination of pre-loaded valves and fttings.
Free / iPad, iPhone, iPod Touch
20
iled product info
READERS CHOICE
circle 107 on card or go to psfreeinfo.com
NEWS
12 March 2013 www.pump-zone.com PUMPS & SYSTEMS
NEW HIRES, PROMOTIONS & RECOGNITIONS
TIM CALLANDER, SJE-Rhombus
DETROIT LAKES, Minn. (Feb. 6, 2013)
SJE-Rhombus announces the addition of Tim
Callander as regional sales manager for their
wholesale controls product line. He will sup-
port customers in the central region of North
America from Texas to Canada. SJE-Rhombus
is a control solutions provider for the water and wastewater
industry. www.sjerhombus.com
GREG DUNCAN & CHRIS DISTASO, Pump
Solutions Group
OAKBROOK TERRACE, Ill. (Feb. 1, 2013)
Pump Solutions Group (PSG) named Greg
Duncan senior director of business develop-
ment and Chris Distaso director of engineer-
ing. Duncan will be responsible for leading the
organizations growth and proftability eforts.
Distaso will be responsible for the overall
supervision and management of the Research
and Development function. PSG is a business
unit within Dover Corporation and manufac-
tures positive displacement pumps and related
technologies. www.psgdover.com
STUART CAMPTON, Precision Polymer
Engineering Ltd
BLACKBURN, England ( Jan. 28, 2013)
Precision Polymer Engineering (PPE)
appointed Stuart Campton as new distribu-
tion manager for its EMEA (Europe, Middle
East and Africa) sales territories. Tis is a
new role to enhance the support that PPE gives to exist-
ing dealers and distributors and to identify new partners in
new geographies. PPE provides o-rings, technical moldings
and sealing solutions to a diverse range of industries. www.
prepol.com
MICHAEL JAMMAL, RACO Manufacturing and
Engineering Company Inc.
EMERYVILLE, Calif. ( Jan. 29, 2013) RACO Manu-
facturing and Engineering Company Inc. announced the
addition of a new director of engineering and manufactur-
ing. Michael Jammal, former program manager at Rockwell
Automation, joins the RACO team and will oversee
engineering, engineering-related departments, and new
business growth and development. RACO Manufacturing
and Engineering Co. provides municipalities, industry and
government with remote communications systems and
RTUs for data logging, alarm auto dialing, remote monitor-
ing, reporting and control. www.racoman.com
ERIC FORD, Graphite Metallizing Corporation
YONKERS, N.Y. ( Jan. 28, 2013) Graphite Metallizing
Corporation named Eric Ford vice president of sales and
marketing. Ford joined Graphite Metallizing in 2007
as director of sales. Graphite Metallizing manufactures
GRAPHALLOY, a graphite/metal alloy that is a unique
self-lubricating bearing material used in machinery and pro-
cess equipment. www.graphalloy.com
AROUND THE INDUSTRY
BIO-MICROBICS and HELD & ASSOCIATES Meet with
Nigerian Delegation
SHAWNEE, Kan. ( Jan. 30, 2013) Bio-Microbics, Inc.
and Held & Associates, Inc., hosted an event welcoming the
visiting delegation of the U.S. Ambassador to Nigeria. Te
purpose of the visit was for the Delegation to participate in
AG CONNECT, an international trade show for the agri-
culture industry. Bio-Microbics is a manufacturer of decen-
tralized wastewater. www.biomicrobics.com
NATIONAL PUMP & COMPRESSOR Opens New Branches
BEAUMONT, Texas ( Jan. 24, 2012) National Pump &
Compressor (NPC) starts 2013 with the opening of three
new locations in Williston, N.D.; Fort Collins, Colo.; and
Wilmington, Del. In addition, NPC announced the grand
opening of the branch in Bakersfeld Calif. NPC produces
industrial pumps, industrial compressors, industrial dryers,
and related equipment for the industrial, petrochemical,
refnery, construction, marine, oilfeld, municipal, environ-
mental and mining industries. www.npcrents.com
MCILVAINE COMPANY Revises Growth Forecast
CHICAGO ( Jan. 22,
2013) McIlvaine Com-
pany has revised its forecast
for growth in the industrial
valve industry over the
next fve years. Te current
forecast is for 5 percent
Tim Callander
Stuart
Campton
Greg Duncan
Chris Distaso
Continent 2013 ($ Millions)
Africa 2,913
America 15,483
Asia 23,956
Europe 13,340
Total 55,692
PUMPS & SYSTEMS www.pump-zone.com March 2013 13
growth. Tis is being revised to 5.5 percent CAGR for the
2013 to 2017 period. Te basis is the increased anticipated
revenues from the sales of smart valves. Tis is the latest
forecast in Industrial Valves: World Markets published by
the McIlvaine Company. McIlvaine Company is a market
research company. www.mcilvainecompany.com
FLUKE CORPORATION Recalls Digital Clamp Meters
EVERETT, Wash. ( Jan. 21, 2013) Fluke Corporation is
recalling certain digital clamp meters that were manufac-
tured between Sept. 1, 2010, and Oct. 31, 2012. Certain
Fluke 373, 374, 375 and 376 Digital Clamp Meters are
afected by the recall. If you own one of these clamp meters,
please stop using it immediately, and send it back to Fluke
for repair. Te printed circuit assembly in these units may
not be properly fastened to the test lead input jack. Tis
may result in inaccurate voltage readings, including a low or
no voltage reading on a circuit energized with a hazardous
voltage, presenting a shock, electrocution or thermal burn
hazard. Fluke Corporation is a manufacturer of compact,
professional electronic test tools. www.fuke.com
HYDRAULIC INSTITUTE Publishes New Standards
PARSIPPANY, N.J. ( Jan. 18, 2013) The Hydraulic
Institute (HI) has published ANSI/HI 9.6.12012
Rotodynamic Pumps Guideline for NPSH Margin.
MERGERS & ACQUISITIONS
NSF INTERNATIONAL
acquires INASSA Group LLC Jan. 29, 2013
BILFINGER
acquires Johnson Screens Jan. 22, 2013
DANFOSS
acquires ownership of Danfoss Turbocor Jan. 21, 2013
AES ENGINEERING LTD GROUP
acquires AVT Jan. 16, 2013
SKF GROUP
to acquire Blohm + Voss Industries Gmbh Jan. 9, 2013
SULZER METCO
acquires Protective Coatings LLC Dec. 19, 2012
For details about industry M&A activity subscribe to
Pump Industry Insider and visit www.pump-zone.com.
circle 114 on card or go to psfreeinfo.com
Dont pump without us.
1. Spill prevention & leak containment 2. Diaphragm seals/gauge guards 3. Inlet stabilizers
4. Pulsation dampeners 5. Pressure relief valves 6. Back pressure valves 7. Surge suppressors
800.603.7867
951.342.3100
www.BLACOH.com
Sales@Blacoh.com
POSITIVE
DISPLACEMENT
PUMP
TANK
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
Theres more than one reason
we are the leader in fuid control.
14 March 2013 www.pump-zone.com PUMPS & SYSTEMS
NEWS
HI also updated the 1998 edition of the ANSI/HI stan-
dard on pump intake design and published ANSI/HI 9.8
2012 Rotodynamic Pumps for Pump Intake Design.
In addition, membership in HI has been opened to pump
and supplier companies that manufacture wholly outside
North America but who sell into the North American
market. Tis change signifcantly expands HI membership
opportunities globally.
Te Hydraulic Institutes mission is to be a value-adding
resource to member companies, engineering consulting
frms and pump users worldwide. www.pumps.org
XYLEM Expands into the Middle East
ABU DHABI, UAE ( Jan. 16, 2013) Xylem Inc. will
expand its presence in the Middle East region with the open-
ing of a new of ce in Saudi Arabia in
the coming months, as well as up to
three additional of ces in other key
regional markets later this year. Xylem
is a global water technology provider.
www.xyleminc.com
KIRLOSKAR BROTHERS LIMITED
Inaugurates New Delhi Facility
NEW DELHI, India ( Jan. 11, 2013)
Kirloskar Brothers Limited (KBL)
inaugurated its second Authorised
Refurbishment Centre (ARC). Te
facility will ofer services such as
overhauling pumps, impeller bal-
ancing, hydro testing, corrocoating,
performance enhancement, testing,
shot blasting and painting. Kirloskar
Brothers Limited is a global fuid
management company. www.kirlos-
karpumps.com
Clean Water Groups Collaborate to
Shape the Utility of the Future
WASHINGTON ( Jan. 13, 2013)
The National Association of Clean
Water Agencies, the Water Envi-
ronment Research Foundation and
the Water Environment Federation
have jointly released a document that
defnes the evolving environmental,
economic and social roles that clean
water utilities are playing in their
communities.
Tis new Water Resources Utility
of the Future will transform the way
traditional wastewater utilities view
themselves and manage their opera-
tions. Te document explores how
traditional, publicly-owned treat-
ment works have mastered their core
Discfo Corp. | Santee, CA | Phone 619.596.3181| www.Discfo.com
Providing Solutions for the Difcult to Pump
Applications Worldwide
Industries include: Oil & Gas, Subsea, Pharmaceutical,
Chemical, Wastewater, Mining, Biofuels, Power Generation
and Food.
Unique features of the patented disc design are:
No-Lmulslflcatlon
Pulsation Free
Laminar Flow
Non-Impingement Pumping
No Degredation or Maceration of Product
NPSHr less than 1/3 of all competitors
No Radial Loads
No Close Tolerances
These features give Discfo the ability to produce a superior
product that will signifcantly outlast all other pumps in the market.
Discfo disc pumps reduces operational costs saving hundreds of
thousands of dollars in parts, maintenance and product loss.
For more information contact Dlscflo at lnfo@discfo.com
Discfo Disc Pumps work on the principles of
boundary layer and viscous drag to produce
pulsation free laminar fow.
circle 131 on card or go to psfreeinfo.com
PUMPS & SYSTEMS www.pump-zone.com March 2013 15
APRIL
WQA AQUATECH USA
April 2 5, 2013
Indianapolis Convention Center
Indianapolis, Ind.
630-505-0160 / www.wqa.org
ENDRESS+HAUSER APRIL TRAINING
SCHOOLS
April 8 10, Flow School-Introductory
Memphis, Tenn.
April 23 24, Pressure & Temperature School
Matthews, N.C.
317-535-7138 / www.us.endress.com
SWPA PUMPING SYSTEMS AND
CONTROLS TRAINING SEMINAR
April 17 18
Hotel InterContinental OHare
Chicago, Ill.
847-681-1868 / www.SWPA.org
CALENDAR
wastewater treatment function and
are now redefning themselves as
resource recovery agencies and vital
community enterprises.
ITT GOULDS PUMPS Heart of
Industry Award, Pulse of Industry
Honor Roll Nominations
SENECA FALLS, N.Y. ( Jan. 10,
2013) ITT Goulds Pumps is now
accepting nominations for the Heart
of Industry Award and the Pulse of
Industry Honor Roll. Te Heart of
Industry Award recognizes industrial
operations for excellence in using
pump technology to improve plant
processing, satisfy customers and
enhance our modern way of life. Te
deadline is March 1, 2013.
ITT Goulds Pumps is a manu-
facturer of pumps for a wide range
of industrial markets. www.gould-
spumps.com
HYOSUNG GOODSPRINGS
Announces Supplier Agreement
with Siemens
PITTSBURGH (Nov. 20, 2012)
Hyosung GoodSprings announced
that Siemens selected the company as
the supplier for condensate extraction
pumps (vertical can) and conden-
sate recirculation pumps (API 610)
for fve combined cycle plants being
constructed in Texas and Argentina.
Hyosung GoodSprings also delivered
its frst circulating water pumps in the
U.S. to a geothermal power plant in
northern Nevada.
Hyosung GoodSprings manufac-
tures pumps.
www.hsgoodsprings.com
P&S
To have an item considered for News, please
send the information to Amanda Perry,
aperry@cahabamedia.com
Xylem brings you dewatering solutions from Godwin and
Flygt. Godwin NC series Dri-Prime pumps incorporate
Flygt N-technology for non-clog performance, sustained
high efciency and long-term energy savings.
These 3-, 4- and 6-inch pumps offer ows to 1,750 gpm
and heads to 200 feet. Their ability to handle stringy
sewage is second to none. The automatic self-priming
system primes and re-primes from dry to 28 feet. Let
us show you what our NC series pumps can do. Also
available in Heidra hydraulic submersible pumps.
Call us today at 856.467.3636 | 800.247.8674.
godwinpumps.com
circle 119 on card or go to psfreeinfo.com
PUMP ED 101
16 March 2013 www.pump-zone.com PUMPS & SYSTEMS
By Joe Evans, Ph.D.,
PumpTech, Inc.
P&S Editorial Advisory Board
Branch-Line Pumping and Other Options
Last of Two Parts
L
ast month, this column reviewed several examples of
open fow, branch-line pumping applications. We used
the Branch Line Pumping Calculator (available at www.
PumpEd101.com) to compare a branch-line system with
two diferent discharge elevations to a multi-line system
that used two individual pumps. Based on the input data,
the multi-line system was more ef cient, and its breakeven
point was barely more than 2 years.
ALTERNATIVE SYSTEMS
In addition to multi-line, multi-pump systems, a system
designer has several other alternatives to open-ended,
branch-line systems with multiple elevations. One of the
most common is the tank-based system. In this type appli-
cation, a storage tank is installed at or above the upper most
elevation. A lower fow pump is used to keep the tank flled,
and gravity supplies water, under pressure, to the lower ele-
vation discharge points.
One of the more common examples is a municipal water
supply system. Elevated tanks or those located on hillsides
use gravity to supply pressure to the surrounding areas.
Another example is high-rise buildings. Many older build-
ings use roof-mounted tanks to supply pressurized water to
the upper foors. One more option is to use a single-service
line with two or more pumps operating in series. Figure 1
compares this design to an open-branch system.
SYSTEM COMPARISON
Te upper pipeline shown in Figure 1 is the same open-fow,
branch-line design illustrated in Part 1. Te pump at Point
A produces 600 gallons per minute (gpm) at a total dynamic
head (TDH) of 200 feet and supplies outfows of 400 gpm
and 200 gpm at branch Points B and C. Te power required
to meet the two branch fows is 43.2 horsepower. Te high
horsepower is required because the total head seen by the
pump is directly proportional to the elevation at Point C.
Te pumping system in the lower portion of Figure 1 is
diferent. Te pump at Point A still provides 600 gpm, but
since it is pumping to Point B only, its discharge head is
reduced to 100 feet. A second pump, located at Point B and
operating in series, moves the remaining water to Point C.
Tis design reduces the total power required by 33 percent.
Tis results in a smaller pump at Point A that requires 21.6
horsepower and an even smaller one at Point B requiring
just 7.2 horsepower. Figure 2 is the calculator portion and
compares the variables involved in these two alternatives.
As in the confgurations in Part 1, the required data are
entered into the yellow cells, and the column to the lef is
the open-fow, branch-line system. Te two columns in the
middle represent the series system from Points A to B and B
to C. Te initial cost of the branch-line system is $44,000.
When converting to a series system the cost is reduced by
$8,000 because of the smaller pump required at Point A.
Te additional pump and controls
required at Point B adds an addi-
tional $11,000 to the cost of the series
system. Terefore, the total additional
cost for the series system is $3,000.
Based on an annual electrical savings
of about $3,300, the payback is less
than one year.
For this example, the series system
is more ef cient than the single pump
system. It also trumps the two pipe-
line design shown in Part 1 of this
series. Te horsepower required for
the series system and the two pipeline
design are exactly the same, but the
lower piping cost of the series system
makes it a more cost-efective system.
Figure 1. Comparison of a single service line with two or more pumps operating in series to an
open-branch system
PUMPS & SYSTEMS www.pump-zone.com March 2013 17
As I stated in Part 1, my branch-line pumping calculator
is not a design tool. Instead, it is an evaluation tool that
allows you to compare traditional branch-line systems with
several alternatives. Once a choice is made, any number
of sofware systems can assist with the design phase. Te
Branch Line Pumping Calculator can be downloaded from
the Pump Evaluation, Selection
& Testing Tools page at www.
PumpEd101.com. P&S
Note: Part 1 (February 2013) of
this series contained an error. When
describing Figure 2, I said that Point
A was at an elevation of 100 feet and
Point B is 100 feet higher. Point A
should have been Point B and Point
B should have been Point C.
Joe Evans is responsible for customer and
employee education at PumpTech, Inc., a
pump and packaged systems manufacturer
and distributor with branches throughout
the Pacifc Northwest. He can be reached
via his website www.PumpEd101.com.
If there are topics that you would like to
see discussed in future columns, drop him
an email.
Figure 2. The Branch Line Pumping Calculator computations of the systems
circle 124 on card or go to psfreeinfo.com
18 March 2013 www.pump-zone.com PUMPS & SYSTEMS
PUMPING PRESCRIPTIONS
By Dr. Lev Nelik, P.E., Pumping Machinery, LLC
P&S Editorial Advisory Board
Will Impeller Velocity Triangles
Keep You Awake at Night?
Last of Two Parts
A
pparently, impeller velocity triangles do keep some folks
awake at night.
Part 2 contains information that is similar to what was
discussed in Part 1, but it includes more detail regarding
the vectors for each vane outlet at the same location for the
three types of impellers. Tis detail will hopefully make the
interpretation of the triangle more realistic.
We have shown only three positions on each type to pro-
vide the best possible illustration without sacrifcing clarity.
Tis also helps show, more clearly,
the velocity vectors on Figures 1
and 2 from Part 1.
As shown in Figures 1 and 3,
the locations for the backward
and forward vane inlets are dif-
ferent, assuming that the same
inlet vane angle is maintained.
Note that the impeller curvature
(inlet and outlet) is set by a cir-
cumference used to fx the rela-
tive inlet and outlet velocities.
A tangent is drawn to the inlet
and outlet from the center of the
circumference. Inlet and outlet
peripheral velocities are drawn
using tangents from the center of
the impeller.
In the case of the radial impel-
ler (see Figure 2), the vanes are
straight to the center of the cir-
cumference. Any vane curvature
is ignored for simplicity.
Note that for the turbopump
(see Figure 4), the fow vectors
for its turbine wheel, which has
the fow direction reversed compared to the pump impel-
ler, are shown as infows rather than outfows like the other
examples. In particular, note the match between the vectors
at the inlet of the pump and the outlet of the turbine wheel.
We also assumed, for simplicity, that the tangential veloc-
ity components at the pump impeller outlet can be consid-
ered equal to the turbine inlet and the turbine outlet equal
to the pump inlet.
u
2
2
W
2
u
2
W
2
v
2
2
v
2
v
2
Figure 1. Backward-bladed centrifugal impeller ( < 90 degrees)
Editors Note: Lev Nelik received many comments on this subject after Part 1 (Pumps & Systems,
January 2012). Alberto Delgado, a former process engineer with Brown & Root, provided interesting
feedback and detailed gures that resulted in several exchanges of ideas between the two. Tis infor-
mation is presented as a follow up on this advanced and specialized subject of pump hydraulic design
and is coauthored by Delgado.
PUMPS & SYSTEMS www.pump-zone.com March 2013 19
Te following legend applies to Figures 1 through 4,
which are used to illustrate the velocity triangles:
U = rotational, peripheral, tip velocity vector
v = absolute resultant velocity
W = relative velocity to blade tip
= absolute vector angle
= blade vane angle
= angular, rotating velocity
P&S
Dr. Nelik (aka Dr. Pump) is president of Pumping Machinery, LLC, an Atlanta-
based frm specializing in pump consulting, training, equipment troubleshoot-
ing and pump repairs. Dr. Nelik has 30 years of experience in pumps and pump-
ing equipment. He can be contacted at www.pump-magazine.com.
Alberto Delgado is a retired process engineer who formerly worked at Brown
& Root.
v
2
u
2
2
W
2
v
3
u
3
3
W
3
W2 v2
u2
3
W3
u3
v3
2
v
2
v
W4
u4
v4
1
W1
v1
u1
v
4
1
v
u
2
2
W
2
W
2
u
2
2
v
2
v
2
v
2
W
2
u
2
u
2
2
2
v
2
W
2
v
2
v
2
Figure 4. A pressure recovery hydraulic turbine, backward bladed (left) and a turbopump, forward bladed (right)
Figure 3. Forward-bladed centrifugal impeller ( < 90 degrees) Figure 2. Radial-bladed centrifugal impeller ( < 90 degrees)
SPECIAL REPORT
20 March 2013 www.pump-zone.com PUMPS & SYSTEMS
M
ore than 90 percent of all pumps in many diferent
industries are centrifugal pumps. Variable-speed, large
centrifugal pumps are well-known for critical and large
pumping services. Centrifugal pumps exhibit a suitable
operating curve compared to other pumps (for example,
axial pumps and positive displacement pumps ofer relatively
steep curves). Te curve characteristics can be matched with
the system requirements. A more backward angle could
make a higher reaction (from the pump impeller) and a
relatively steeper curve.
As pump stages are put together, the overall fow range
of the combined stages could be less than the smallest fow
range of the individual stages. Because of the compound-
ing efect, as the fow is changed, the combined curve of
a multistage pump could have a smaller operating range.
When developing a pump system and before specifying and
purchasing a pump, many factors should be considered
including the application, installation, lubrication system,
pump operation and pump noise generation. Tese consid-
erations are discussed in the frst part of this article. Part 2
will be in the April 2013 issue of Pumps & Systems.
PUMP SPECIFICATION AND PURCHASE
Te pump operation conditions should be divided into a set
of normal conditions and a set of abnormal conditions. Te
entire anticipated range of operating conditions should be
defned either by range limits or alternative operating con-
ditions. Unusual operating conditions, even insignifcant
ones, should be indicated when developing a list. All avail-
able details should be shared with the pump manufacturer.
Above: An example of different pump sizes/models in a pump family. These are sealless magnet drive ANSI pumps. Six models
are in this family.
Pump Specifcation, Purchase,
Installation & Application
Sharing all the information about an application can help with the selection and installation
of the ideal pump.
First of Two Parts
By Amin Almasi, WorleyParsons Services Pty Ltd.
The Pump Purchase Process
PUMPS & SYSTEMS www.pump-zone.com March 2013 21
In many cases, insignifcant system or environmental condi-
tions can cause considerable problems. Examples could be
corrosive traces in the liquid, even if they are in the parts-
per-million level.
Te purchaser should know as much as possible about
the system in which the pump will be installed and the fuid
that the pump/system will move and then inform the manu-
facturer. Particularly, the purchaser should be aware of any
unusual conditions and potential upsets that could afect
the pump. An example is the liquid temperature runaway
potential in some hot liquid units. Te pump specifcation
should note all expected maximum temperature values, and
the pump vendor should be asked about the maximum tem-
perature that the pump can handle.
Another example is the potential of the sudden dead-
heading of a centrifugal pump when switching operations
during some batch-type processes. Te pump manufac-
turer should also be informed of any fouling potential. Te
potential pump conditions should be carefully explored and
any fouling potential should be noted. By correctly includ-
ing the fouling potentials in the description of the system
conditions, the pump vendor may be able to include a solu-
tionsuch as additional head marginswhen selecting/
manufacturing the best pump for the application.
Te pump requisition should include a complete list of
the scope of supply and service (preferably in a table format).
Te pump nozzle orientation is important as well. Ideally,
the nozzle orientation details should be agreed upon with
the pump manufacturer from the beginning.
Do not assume that the pump vendor is completely knowl-
edgeable about the material requirements for the system/
process. Stating the minimum material of construction
requirement can help the pump vendor during the pump
design/selection phase and avoid future problems. Te
vendors focus is to provide a pump that is compatible with
the specifcations and reliable enough to cover the vendors
guarantee period at the minimum possible cost. With the
proper wording of the pump specifcations, the minimum
material requirements can be noted. It can also invite com-
ments that may reveal the vendors experience with pump
material selection.
A large number of unscheduled shutdowns are traced
back to the vendor design; the vendor material selection;
or the component selectionsuch as seal problems, bear-
ing issues, excessive fouling, high degradation, corrosion,
erosion and other factors. However, these problems actually
refect a lack of application knowledge, which could have
been prevented if the purchaser communicated improper
specifcations. A good example is the use of austenitic stain-
less steels, which are normally considered premium materi-
als. However, they cannot be used if chlorides are present in
the pumped liquid because of intergranular corrosion and
subsequent cracking problems.
Te orientation of the inlet piping and its infuence on
pump performance is important. Tere should be neither
pre-rotation nor anti-rotation. Te fow should be free from
random distortion. Based on the design, the liquid veloci-
ties and the system/process conditions, a minimum length
of straight pipe may be required before the pump inlet.
BID EVALUATION FOR PUMPS
A bid evaluation should be made that factors the energy
cost, frst cost and reliability issues using an established eco-
nomic equation. If the data are available, the total cost of
ownership can be estimated, which is the best available mea-
sure for the bid evaluation of a pump. It is absolutely nec-
essary to fx all items and clarify all issues before the pump
purchase order placement. Until the vendor is sure he has an
order, he will stay in a trading posture.
Te successful bidder becomes the vendor when a con-
tract is written and accepted. Tis is important because the
clock has started at this time, and all future dates will be ref-
erenced back to this date. Tis also is the date from which
the pump delivery is counted.
Figure 1. An example of different pump sizes in a pump family
SPECIAL REPORT
22 March 2013 www.pump-zone.com PUMPS & SYSTEMS
PUMP LUBRICATION SYSTEM
Based on some reports, considerable reductions in the
oil fow of the manufactured lubrication oil system can
occur compared to the initially-proposed system that was
included at the biding stage. Te purchaser and vendor have
many discussions and debates regarding this issue.
In some cases, the lubrication systems capacity can be
reduced by 20 to 30 percent, occasionally by as much as
40 percent for some large and critical pumps. Te proposal
technical data (the bid technical details) are not fnal and
some modifcations could be expected.
However, an oil fow reduction of more than 25 per-
cent, compared to the purchase order, should not usually
occur. Any reduction in excess of 30 percent would require
a detailed justifcation. Te vendor should supply the data
and the basis for any oil fow reductions that occur, particu-
larly any signifcant reduction in the oil fow of the hydrody-
namic bearings. Suf cient oil supply to the hydrodynamic
bearing(s) and the gear units is always a concern.
PUMP INSTALLATION
How and where the pump/pump system will be installed
must also be considered. Te prime function of the pump
foundation is to hold the pump train in alignment during
all operating modes. To perform this function, the foun-
dation should be rigid. Establishing and maintaining the
alignment between pump train componentsparticularly
for large pump trains delivered in several skidsis dif cult
if the foundation is prone to excessive defections.
Te foundation should be large enough to prevent exces-
sive diferential defections and dynamic vibrations, which
can have considerable efects on long-term operation.
Another aspect is the foundations natural frequency. Te
foundation should be tuned in such a way that any founda-
tion natural frequency is not in coincidence with any of the
pump train excitation frequency. It is desirable to have all
the foundations natural frequencies well above any pump
excitation speed, as far above as practical.
Ideally, the pump can be placed on the foundation, aligned
and grouted, and piping can be connected according to the
pump installation procedure. Lags ofen occur between dif-
ferent steps. Carelessness can delay start-up and could result
in an unsuccessful pump installation. More details on instal-
lation will be covered in Part 2 in the April 2013 issue.
PUMP OPERATION
In many cases, the main contributors to centrifugal pump
problems are related to the seal, the bearing and rotor
dynamics. Long slender rotors can cause problems in cen-
trifugal pumps. Some high-speed pump rotors are subjected
to critical speeds, which are encountered during startup
(particularly in high-pressure pumps).
Sensitivity to unbalance can also cause operational prob-
lems. During operation, as time passes, pumps experience
degradation, which usually manifests in ever-increasing
levels of unbalance. Te more sensitive the rotor, the shorter
the runtime.
In many cases, the decision to replace or redesign a pump
train component was incorrect. An incorrect diagnosis or
wrong interpretation of the reason for a pump failure some-
times results in a solution that appears to fx the problem.
However, if it is incorrect, the solution could possibly
lead to worse problems in the future because an incorrect
symptom-cause relationship is established. Careful problem
solving should accurately determine the real cause of a prob-
lem and prevent complications.
Te cleanliness of the liquid stream is a key factor, as well,
for smooth pump operation and reliability. Te corrosive
substances and traces require a special material selection
and operation considerations. Fouling because of contami-
nation or liquid reaction can cause rapid degradation.
PUMP NOISE
Te overall sound pressure level is generally based on 1
meter from the pump skids edge. Tis means that the sound
pressure level of each component at 1 meter from the skids
edge could be diferent, usually lower for the large pump
packages, than the indicated noise value for each compo-
nent, which is the noise at 1 meter from that component.
Te pump package noise is not simply the sum of the noises
of diferent package components.
Figure 2. An example of a belt-driven ANSI pumpthe ANSI pump
design can sometimes help overcome issues, such as space
restrictions or low NPSH.
The Pump Purchase Process
PUMPS & SYSTEMS www.pump-zone.com March 2013 23
Te gear unit, if used in a pump package, is the major
source of noise. For the noise emission of a gear unit, the
design of the gear unit has more infuence than the trans-
mitted power. A gear unit may generate the same noise or
sometimes a slightly higher noise during part-load opera-
tion compared to full-load operation. As another example,
a 1-megawatt gear unit and a 1.5-megawatt gear unit using
the same design principles may generate practically the same
noise level.
Te pump vendors sound calculation programs usually
do not simulate any sound boundary condition near the
pump package. For example, the boundary conditions (such
as a wall close to the pump skid) can infuence the noise
measured in the plant. Terefore, an allowance is needed
to accommodate for this efect. Based on experience, an
increase of around 3 to 5 decibels of the expected sound
level for a pump package is observed at some unfavorable
boundary conditions.
CONCLUSION
When the pump user and the pump vendor work together
as a team and if all the engineers involved give suf cient
attention to details, changes and requirements, reliable and
high performance pumps can be expected. Te keys to suc-
cess are up-to-date knowledge, correct specifying, proper
review of pump vendor documents, correct inspection of
vendor activities, and modern operation and maintenance
policies. Te true proftability and cost savings in a pump
installation can only be achieved by combining perfor-
mance, reliability, safety, availability and maintainability.
See the April 2013 issue of Pumps & Systems for more infor-
mation on installation and alignment. P&S
Amin Almasi is lead rotating equipment engineer at
WorleyParsons Services Pty Ltd., Brisbane, Australia. He pre-
viously worked at Technicas Reunidas (Madrid, Spain) and
Fluor (various offces). He holds a chartered professional
engineer license from Engineers Australia (MIEAust CPEng
Mechanical) and a chartered engineer certifcate from
IMechE (CEng MIMechE), RPEQ (Registered Professional
Engineer in Queensland). He specializes in rotating machines including cen-
trifugal, screw and reciprocating compressors, gas and steam turbines, pumps,
condition monitoring and reliability. Almasi is an active member of Engineers
Australia, IMechE, ASME, Vibration Institute, SPE, IEEE, and IDGTE. He has
authored more than 60 papers and articles dealing with rotating machines.
Almasi can be reached at amin.almasi@ymail.com or +61 (0)7 3319 3902.
es including cen-
Premiere Alternative for Progressing
Cavity Pumps and Replacement Parts
Seepex BN* Replacement Pumps and Parts Netzsch** NM Replacement Parts
All parts are manufactured in the U.S.A. and readily available for quick shipment to minimize down time
Constructed using high quality materials, machined to precise tolerances and checked for perfect ft
and function every time
Dedicated application engineers and support staff to ensure proper selection
* seepex
A2
PERISTALTIC TECHNOLOGY EXCELLENT PRICE POINT PPEEEERRRRIIIIISSSSSTTTTTAAAAALLLLTTTIIICCCC TTTTEEEECCCCHHHNNNOOOLLLOOOGGGYYYEEXC XCEL L ELLE LE LENT NTTT NT PPPPRI RR CE CE POINT PPEEEERRRIISTAALLTTIICC TECHNOLOOOGGGGYY EEEEXC X ELLEENTT N PPPRRI RI R CE PPOINT
NEM NEM EM EMMMMA 4 A 4 A 4 A 4 A 4 A 4 A 4 A 4 A 4 A 4 4XXXXXXXXXXXXXX
WWA WA WAS WAS WASH WASH WASH WASH WASH WASH WASH WASH WASH ASH DO DO DO DO DO DO DO DOWWWWWWWWWNNNNNNNNNN
IP6 IP6 IP6 IP6 IP6 P6 P6666666666666
Standard 61
5300 Business Drive, Huntington Beach, CA 92649 USA - 714-893-8529
saIes@bIue-white.com - www.blue-white.com - fax: 714-894-9492
es essssssss DDDDDDr Dr Dr Dr Dr Driiiiiv iv iv iv iv iveeeeee, HHHHHHHHHHun un un un un u ii ti ti ti ti ti ti ti tinng ng ng ng ngtttto to to to to tonnnnnn BBBe Beac ac ac cc achhhhhhhhhh, CCCCCCCCCCAAAAAAAAAA 92 92 92 92 92 92 92 92 9264 64 64 64 64 64 64 64 64 64999999999 US US US US US US US US US US USAAAAAAAAAAA -- 71 71 71 71 71 71 71 71 714444444- 44-889
Self-priming Valve-less Design Cant Vapor-lock
Near Continuous Output, Even at Low Feed Rates
Smooth, Quiet Pumping Action
Optional Advanced Serial and Ethernet Communications
Patented Tube Failure Detection System
circle 115 on card or go to psfreeinfo.com
COVER
SERIES
30 March 2013 www.pump-zone.com PUMPS & SYSTEMS
O
f the 6.3 million farms in the U.S. in January 1925, only
205,000 received centralized electric services. Private
utility companies that supplied electric power to most of
the nations consumers argued that it was too expensive to
string electric lines to isolated rural areas, and most farmers
were probably too poor to aford it.
To rectify that situation, the Rural Electrifcation
Administration (REA) was created by executive order and
was charged with administering loan programs for electri-
fcation and telephone service in rural areas. Between 1935
and 1939the frst 4 years afer REAs establishment
the farms using electric services more than doubled.
Even though farmers were gaining access to the power
grid, they were still using diesel engines to power their
pumps. One reason for this is that they had already invested
in diesel. Also, in most cases there simply was not enough
juice to power the farmhouse and the pump house.
By the early 1970s, about 98 percent of all U.S. farms had
access to afordable electric service. Many farmers, though,
were still using engines to power their pumps and would
continue to do so. Most would argue that despite some price
spikes, diesel fuel was still cheaper than electricity. Afer all,
those diesel engines still worked. Why switch to electric?
Te trend toward switching from diesel to electric began
gaining steam within the last 15 years. Environmental con-
trols and regulations on the operation of diesel engines and
the rising cost of diesel fuel have accelerated the conversion.
Changing from diesel to electric makes sense from several
diferent standpoints.
COST
Operating and maintenance cost advantages are available
when switching from diesel to electric. On the operational
front, end users must consider the cost of diesel fuel. It is
expensive, and likely to remain so as global demand rises.
Figure 1 illustrates that running an engine on electricity is
less expensive than running one on diesel. Tat was not the
case in 1992, but times have changed. Te economics of irri-
gation pumping favor electric motors.
Figure 2 details the operating hour scenarios and cost
points for diesel and electricity. It shows estimates of the
total costs of operation for an irrigation pumping system.
Te costs include estimates for energy, repairs, fxed cost
depreciation, maintenance and service. Because each pump-
ing station will be unique, the costs are an estimate, but they
clearly show the economics of today.
1
Te cost for electricity can vary depending on when and
where it is consumed. Avoiding peak power demand times
can lower the costs of electricity even further. In some parts
of the U.S., irrigating at of-peak hours is a good economic
idea and ofen mandated.
From a maintenance standpoint, electric motors win
this battle, too. Maintenance on a diesel motor requires
more time and attention than electric motors. Depending
on the application, a pump engine may be required to run
for extended periods if that pump drives multiple systems
during the irrigation season. If so, the diesel engine will con-
stantly need to be refueled and the oil levels and flters will
require monitoring.
Electric motors do not have to be refueled. Tey also do
not have engine oil and flters that must be checked and
replaced. Tey only require lubrication once every season.
Powering the Pump:
Diesel Versus Electric Motors
Make the ideal motor selection for irrigation applications.
By Tim Albers, Nidec Motor Corporation
Figure 1. Total annual costs in thousands to operate a 75-horsepower
irrigation pump 1,500 hours per year using an electric motor or
diesel engine.
Source: Curley, Robert G. & Gerald D. Knutson,Cost Comparison: engines vs.
electric motors for irrigation pumping, California Agriculture, Vol. 48, Num. 5
Agricultural Irrigation & Dewatering
PUMPS & SYSTEMS www.pump-zone.com March 2013 31
ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT
Perhaps the overriding motivation to change to electric, par-
ticularly in the past few years, is the concern with environ-
mental issues. An electric motor runs cleaner than a diesel-
powered engine. Electric power plants continue to create
power in cleaner ways. Also, the addition to the grid of alter-
nate energy sources, such as wind and
solar, provide electricity with virtually
zero carbon emissions.
An electric motor allows for the use
of much lower carbon emission power
versus a comparable diesel engine.
Te harmful environmental efects
from internal combustion engines
outnumber those from electricity.
PUMP CONTROL
In addition, installing pump controls
and variable speed controls is easier on
an electric motor than it is for a diesel
engine. While these types of con-
trols can be added to diesel engines,
they are costly, and more important,
they can reduce the ef ciency of the
engine.
Tis is not the case when adding
controls and variable speed features to
electric motors, which when applied
correctly, greatly increase the ef -
ciency and durability of the motor,
improve control in pipelines and
canals and reduce energy use. Electric
motors can be automated and con-
trolled remotely. Variable speed drives
and sof starters in electric motors
are components that help mitigate
power surges. Te technology exists
and is growing quickly based on ever
decreasing costs to monitor and con-
trol an electric-driven irrigation pump
system remotely.
THE DECISION
Diesel engines remain in use today and
for good reason. In some areas of the
world, electricity is unavailable. Also,
the diesel engines installed years ago
continue to work today. Operators
do not want to scrap something that
works to spend more money on new motors, even if those
new motors will eventually pay for themselves in reduced
operating costs and improved ef ciency and have less impact
on the environment.
Te question becomes when to make the switch. Te
answer is easy if and when that diesel engine fails. However,
Pumps
Valves
Service
A KSB Company
Recovery rate is essential to cyclone performance.
GIWs hydrocyclone assures continuous delivery
of sized material to further processing. Our design
replaces glued in rubber liners with metal reinforced
high energy urethane. Our ceramic is bonded directly
to rigid urethane backing providing extra protection
against tramp or grinding balls that infltrate your
system. For consistent and continuous operation,
count on GIW. We will keep you running!
www.giwindustries.com 1.706.863-1011
Keeps You Running.
circle 118 on card or go to psfreeinfo.com
COVER
SERIES
32 March 2013 www.pump-zone.com PUMPS & SYSTEMS
if end users engines are operating well, they should
consider having a plan in place to switch to electric
motors at some point in the future. Hopefully, they
can make that switch when they want to instead of
being forced to repair a broken diesel engine to com-
plete the irrigation season.
Te bottom line is thisin 2013, for many irriga-
tion applications, operators choose electric motors, if
electricity is available, to power their pumps. P&S
Figure 2. Operating scenarios and costs for diesel fuel and electricity.
Reference
1. Curley, Robert G. & Gerald D. Knutson,Cost Comparison: engines vs.
electric motors for irrigation pumping, California Agriculture, Vol. 48,
Num. 5.
Timothy Albers is the director of product management and OEM marketing for the
Industrial Motor Division of Nidec Motor Corporation and is responsible for product
management, marketing and quotation support. During the past 16 years, Albers has
held different positions in marketing for Nidec Motor Corporation and Emerson Motor
Company, including product-line manager for NEMA motors. Before joining Emerson, he
was employed by General Electric Company in the marketing and sales of electric motors
and drives. Albers career includes a stint in the U.S. Navy as an operating engineering
offcer. He is a senior member of IEEE.
NETZSCH TORNADO
's
high performance sealing
solutions. For your
facility and your
own peace of
mind, check out
SEPCO
.
800.633.4770 www.sepcoUSA.com
SeaIing Equipment Products Co., Inc.
SEPCO
is your preferred
partner. With over 35 years of experience working with
original equipment manufacturers (OEMs), we provide
high quality, cost-effective custom control solutions
for a variety of control applications:
877-712-BASE (2273)
FAX: 216-274-9296
Zanite is a registered trademark of BaseTek, LLC Made in USA
Guaranteed Price Match
Thermal stability