Professional Documents
Culture Documents
RESEARCH
■ The number of cardiac arrests (pri- Cardiac surgery 188 (163–213) 141 (119–163)
mary outcome measure); Thoracic surgery 142 (120–164) 117 (97–137)
■ The number of patients who died General surgery 288 (259–317) 318 (288–348)
from cardiac arrest; Orthopaedic surgery 253 (225–281) 285 (256–314)
■ The number of in-hospital deaths; Vascular surgery 160 (137–183) 132 (111–153)
■ The number of ICU bed-days occu-
Neurosurgery 147 (125–169) 111 (92–130)
pied by survivors of cardiac arrest;
Plastic surgery 77 (61–93) 84 (67–101)
and
■ The number of hospital bed-days Other (includes liver transplantation) 114 (94–134) 125 (104–146)
occupied by survivors of cardiac *Major surgery is defined as any surgery requiring a hospital stay > 48 hours.
arrest.
5
Reasons for MET calls
In the intervention period, there were 99 0
Nov Dec Jan Feb May Jun Jul Aug Sep Oct Nov Dec Jan Feb
MET calls triggered by different, and
Seasonal control Before MET MET run- After MET
sometimes multiple, criteria for physio- Nov 1998 - 1 May 1999 - in Sep - 1 Nov 2000 -
logical instability (“worried about the Feb 1999 31 Aug 1999 Oct 2000 28 Feb 2001
patient”, 46; haemoglobin desaturation Educational period
on pulse oximetry, 37; change in con- 1 Sep 1999 - 31 Aug 2000
scious state, 28; low systolic blood pres-
month period 2 years before the introduc- cause hospital mortality. This effect was Suctioning of tracheostomy tube 6
tion of the MET, there were 275 deaths only partly accounted for by the impact Initiation of IV glyceryltrinitrate infusion 6
(P = 0.27 compared with the “before” of the MET on cardiac arrests. The Administration of anticonvulsants 5
period; P = 0.018 compared with the MET might, therefore, confer other ben- Administration of IV vasopressors 5
intervention period). efits, such as increasing awareness of the Insertion of a Guedel airway 4
consequences of physiological instability. Administration of IV morphine 4
It is also possible that the educational Insertion of a urinary catheter 4
Bed-days program to introduce the MET had an Cardioversion 3
After cardiac arrest, and in the absence impact on the care of acutely unwell Administration of IV  blockers
of any change in the cardiac arrest patients. or digoxin 3
treatment protocol, survivors in the It is important to consider our study’s Administration of IV naloxone 2
“before” period required a total of 163 limitations. First, this trial was not dou- Transfer to operating room with
ICU bed-days and 1353 hospital bed- ble blind, or placebo-controlled or ran- ongoing resuscitation 2
days, and survivors in the intervention domised. It is not possible to have a Administration of IV metoclopramide 2
period required 33 ICU bed-days double-blind MET intervention, and Administration of IV ranitidine 2
(RRR, 80%; P < 0.001) and 159 hospi- introducing “sham” intervention as pla- Administration of IV insulin or glucose 2
tal bed-days (RRR, 88%; P < 0.001) cebo was ethically untenable, and “con- Insertion of new tracheostomy tube 1
(Box 3). tamination” (so-called Hawthorne Insertion of minitracheostomy tube 1
effect) would have been inevitable. Acute transfusion of red cells 1
Finally, a traditional, patient randomi- Administration of dexamethasone 1
DISCUSSION sation study of the MET would be Administration of intravenous
magnesium 1
We found that the incidence of in- ethically, scientifically and logistically
Administration of atropine 1
hospital cardiac arrests decreased by impossible in a single hospital.
Removal of central venous catheter 1
two-thirds after the introduction of a Our favourable findings may have been
Acute investigations
MET. This reduction, in both medical due to a high incidence of cardiac arrests
Chest x-ray 14
and surgical patients, is internally con- in the control period or an abnormally
Electrocardiogram 16
sistent and suggests a widespread low seasonal incidence in the interven-
Computed tomography scan 4
impact, irrespective of admission diag- tion period. Australian data show a car-
Arterial blood gases 36
nosis. It is also consistent with previous diac arrest incidence ranging from 36 to
Urea, creatinine, electrolytes and
observations that between 50% and 51 per 10 000 admissions.2,8 In the liver function tests 40
84% of in-hospital cardiac arrests are “before” period, there were 30 cardiac Invasive procedures
preceded by physiological instability.2- arrests per 10 000 hospital admissions, IV line insertion 18
4,6,7 and there was no statistically significant
By appropriately responding to Arterial line insertion 5
physiological instability, most in-hospi- seasonal variation in the incidence of Endotracheal intubation 3
tal cardiac arrests can be prevented. cardiac arrests in our hospital. Further- Central venous catheter insertion 3
With the MET there was also a more more, the 4-month MET intervention
than 50% reduction in the number of period included, by chance, 3 months
IV = intravenous.
cardiac arrest-related deaths, and a immediately after the start of the working
ing a MET intervention, and these or advances in medical or surgical treat- 10. Lee A, Bishop G, Hillman K, Daffum K. The medical
emergency team. Anaesth Intensive Care 1995; 23:
arrests were counted as such. Further- ment that could explain a greater than 183-186.
more, most of the interventions were 60% reduction in cardiac arrests and a 11. Hurihan F, Bishop G, Hillman KM, et al. The medical
technically “simple”, suggesting that 25% reduction in overall mortality. emergency team: a new strategy to identify and
intervene in high-risk patients. Clin Intensive Care
timely intervention (within minutes Another recent study showing a possi- 1995; 6: 269-272.
rather than hours) at the time of deterio- ble beneficial effect of a MET9 had 12. Smith GB, Nolan J. Medical emergency teams and
cardiac arrests in hospital. Results may have been
ration might also decrease the complex- several methodological shortcomings.12 due to education of ward staff. BMJ 2002; 324: 1215.
ity of care required. Together with the Despite other indirect supportive evi- 13. Goldhill DR, White SA, Sumner A. Physiological
dominance of the “worried” criterion for dence,10,11,13-17 the MET approach has values and procedures in the 24 hours before ICU
admission from the ward. Anaesthesia 1999; 54:
activation of the MET, this also suggests not yet been adopted by most hospitals 529-534.
that some relatively simple acute inter- in Australia or elsewhere, and contro- 14. McQuillan P, Pilkington S, Allan A, et al. Confidential
ventions may appear too technically versy continues concerning its safety inquiry into quality of care before admission to
intensive care. BMJ 1998; 316: 1853-1858.
demanding to junior medical or nursing and effectiveness.8,12 15. Hillman KM. Redefining resuscitation. Aust N Z J
staff, or that such staff might lack the In conclusion, introducing an ICU- Med 1998; 28: 759-760.
experience to recognise that these inter- based MET in a teaching hospital 16. Daly FFS, Sidney KL, Fatovich DM. The medical
emergency team (MET): a model for the district
ventions are needed immediately. decreased the incidence of and deaths general hospital. Aust N Z J Med 1998; 28: 795-798.
Similarly, it is possible that our overall from cardiac arrests, postcardiac-arrest 17. Henderson SO, Ballestreros D. Evaluation of a hospi-
in-hospital mortality was high during tal-wide resuscitation team: does it increase survival
bed-days, as well as overall mortality. for in-hospital cardiopulmonary arrest? Resuscita-
the “before” period and was simply Further testing of this approach is now tion 2001; 48: 111-116.
restored to standard levels by the MET, needed in a variety of hospital and (Received 18 Feb 2003, accepted 2 Jul 2003) ❏
or fell because of seasonal variation. In geographical settings.
Australia, data from other large hospi-
tals show an overall crude mortality rate
between 138 and 184 deaths per 10 000 ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
admissions.8 Our crude mortality rate in
We thank our Medical Records Department for their
the “before” period was 143 deaths per assistance with this project. This study was funded by a
10 000 admissions, and there was no grant from the Quality Improvement Branch of the Acute
statistically significant seasonal variation Health Care section of the Victorian Department of Human
Services.
in in-hospital mortality.
Our findings within a single institu-
tion might not apply to other hospitals. COMPETING INTERESTS
Institution-specific heuristics and
unique administrative features may have None identified.