THEMES: LOVE, TRUTH, FREEDOM, FANTASY VS REALITY, OBJECTIFICATION OF WOMEN, BEAUTY, MATERIALISM, DECADENCE/HEDONISM, SURREALISM "This is a story about beauty, freedom, truth, and above all things, love." "The greatest thing you'll ever learn is just to love and be loved in return." The lyrics of 'Come What May', both sung and spoken, in a rare example of an Arc Song it acts as a motif and aids foreshadowing. 1 SETTING The movie opens with scenes of Montmartre 1899 black and white vs bright colour. The beautiful creatures of the underworld are introduced Satine the courtesan the Sparkling Diamond at the Moulin Rouge cabaret nightclub where the ringmaster is also an (apparently) benevolent pimp. It actually still exists in Paris and you can visit it. Charles Zidler owned it in 1900. The bright colour mirrors a reckless abandonment portrayed by the characters in their behaviour and suggestive dress. Christian is the main protagonist and narrator. He calls the people of Montmartre the children of the revolution but that ended in 1815 grandchildren more apt. He is a writer and dreamer juxtaposed with his stuffy father, and wants to write, but gets sucked into the underworld by chance to read for the Argentinian. TINKERBELL represents MAGIC freedom, beauty, love Music and costume: We see risqu shots of knickers with Nirvana playing in the background and other more contemporary music in fact a mishmash of genres. Tattooed men dance and break gender stereotypes. The set is opulent, crude, base and suggestive, as is the costume and dance. All aspects of mise-en-scene are designed to be provocative. Satine emerges from the ceiling in a shower of silver confetti and the pace changes. She swings from the ceiling and dazzles. Satine is seen snatching flowers displaying a wild side to the background of Madonnas Material Girl so were told fairly early on that she is concerned with An actual document 2 | P a g e
the material/remuneration. She changes costume on stage and is thus further objectified. Her dream is to become a famous actress and she will go about this in any way necessary. The Duke can help her. The Duke is introduced as the antagonist and the pace moves on swiftly. He wants to meet her totally alone and his scheduled meeting sets a collision course with Christians meeting with her. The Duke says he wants a smouldering temptress. Satine meets the writer and theres confusion as she thinks he is the Duke. She dresses very provocatively. He wants to read her a poem and she says this is a wonderful place for poetry reading, to which he says I want to get is over and done with DRAMATIC IRONY the audience knows that he doesnt want to have sex and use her, but she thinks that is what he wants. This fuels the humour when he says that he wants to stand and as he starts to read she pretends to be in ecstasy by his naughty words. When she suggests making love she thinks he is impotent and there are verbal puns when she calls him a Big Boy and says hes got a huge talent referring to his manhood. He starts singing you can tell everybody and shows that he is really just a hopeless romantic at heart. She falls in love immediately with the young talented Duke (or so she claims) and claims that title isnt important, but when he corrects her and says he is a writer she contradicts herself and proves that it is in fact very important. When the Duke walks in she uses the same song Christian sang her to convince him of her sincerity and grabs a bottle suggestively. This shows her to have a duplicitous nature and the ability to lie convincingly and easily using whatever womanly wiles at her command, however we learn this is out of necessity more than anything else so we reserve judgment and are gentle with her. She faints again, further highlighting how unwell she is. The Elephant Room surreal, opulent, exotic, almost impossible. The works of art are all very suggestive nudes and Kama Sutra positions/statues kitsch The Moulin Rouge is contrasted with very domestic scenes at the crummy digs where they cook and laugh in their gowns. They act normal as they write and plan. This normal world seems happier and less complicated than the Moulin Rouge. 2 CHARACTERISATION 3 | P a g e
Satine is silky and hard to hold onto, like her name and like the fabric. Christian is sincere like a Christian and is more genuine. The Duke is ridiculous, and so are his courting scenes My dear, a frog. He is portrayed as a fool, but a dangerous and powerful one. The playhouse director/ringmaster advances, sings, screams, FLIES! He is grotesque, sweaty and brutal and lies when necessary to further his own ends. Toulouse actually existed and was a well-known painter who knew Van Gogh. He had short limbs but a normal sized torso linked to a congenital disability thought to be linked to inbreeding. 3 FORESHADOWING Satine faints more than once which halts the pace. The ringmaster treats this as part of the show, but she is obviously sick. Youre going to bad for business, I can tell (business = prostitution) and he is bad for business when she falls in love with him. Later when they kiss behind a column the stage dialogue states The lovers are discovered. Narrator A force darker than jealousy and stronger than love had begun to take hold of Satine she coughs blood - consumption 4 BACKSTORY/PLAY-WITHIN-A-PLAY JUXTAPOSITION OF FANTASY VS REALITY A courtesan falls for a penniless sitar player instead of an evil Maharajah in India. The writer throws together a plot on the spot to get funding for a play. They use strange fast forward motion giving the scene a surreal feel when selling the script to the Duke giving it a dreamlike, nightmarish quality. Why would the courtesan go for the penniless writer? Whoops, I meant sitar player one of the actors causes trouble by telling the Duke this and we see realisation cross his face close-up camera shot. He decides he doesnt like the ending and calls REAL LOVE security and wealth. The dwarf tries to promote the Bohemian ideals of truth, beauty and love, and the Duke asks Why? to which Christian snaps Because she doesnt love you!... him She doesnt love him The Duke doesnt budge. It is irrelevant what Satine wants or feels. He makes the decision and the ending must be rewritten. Satine placates him and tells him they should have a supper and discuss the new ending. 4 | P a g e
The same troublemaker says to Christian Dont worry Shakespeare, youll get your ending Once the Duke gets his! Pun reality/play. The salsa dance to Roxane mirrors what the Duke is doing to Satine as we flash between scenes the play-within-the-movie mirrors what is happening in reality to Satine. Jealousy will drive you maaad! You dont have to sell your body to the night. What the actor sings and what Satine does show us that she is merely a pawn and reflect stereotypically sexist attitudes towards women during that era when women did not have a say. The Duke gives her diamonds and tries to rape her but she escapes. The moon has a face sings backup break with reality. 5 LIGHTS AND CAMERA Shadow is also contrasted with light good vs evil blue light vs red light. The Duke says the play will end his way or the boy will be killed and the director uses a blue light and close up, low angle to show his insane jealousy it also highlights his position of power as the camera looks up at him (low angle). Pan shot from the stage to the balcony sweeping shot with an overload of visual information accentuating the hyperrealism. Nature rebels the elements rebel storm, lightening and grey no colour when she says I choose the Maharajah. Blue light demonises the faces.
6 DIEGETIC AND NON-DIEGETIC MUSIC Diegetic sound = sound whose source is visible on the screen or whose source is implied to be present by the action of the film: voices of characters sounds made by objects in the story music represented as coming from instruments in the story space ( = source music) Diegetic sound is any sound presented as originated from source within the film's world Digetic sound can be either on screen or off screen depending on whatever its source is within the frame or outside the frame. Another term for diegetic sound is actual sound Diegesis is a Greek word for "recounted story" The film's diegesis is the total world of the story action
5 | P a g e
Non-diegetic sound = sound whose source is neither visible on the screen nor has been implied to be present in the action: narrator's commentary sound effects which are added for the dramatic effect mood music Non-diegetic sound is represented as coming from a source outside story space. The distinction between diegetic or non- diegetic sound depends on our understanding of the conventions of film viewing and listening. We know of that certain sounds are represented as coming from the story world, while others are represented as coming from outside the space of the story events. A play with diegetic and non-diegetic conventions can be used to create ambiguity (horror), or to surprise the audience (comedy). Another term for non-diegetic sound is commentary sound. Duets slow the pace Note music montages in the form of conversation: All you need is love Love is just a game etc etc Dont leave me this way Silly love songs Like a virgin convincing the Duke diegetic. Roxane sung aggressively and hes told never to fall in love with a woman who sells herself. Bollywood-esque dancing and song in Spectacular Spectacular Harold sings It all ends today looking grainy and sweaty when he tells her she is dying and convinces her to send him away. THE SHOW MUST GO ON. We are creatures of the underworld, we cant afford to love. Between scenes the blurring between the movie and the play continues as seamstresses hang around the auditorium singing. 7 FEMINIST CONCERNS Satines predicament: You said you loved me It was just an act It felt real Im a courtesan, Im paid to say what men want me to say I cant fall in love Being on the street is awful The prostitute in shadow in the street women for sale. The Dukes attitude No one must touch my things! 8 DEBAUCHERY, HEDONISM, DECADENCE Sex to explain her absence you make her feel like a virgin touched for the very first time heightens her appeal to the Duke shes been saving it all for you. EVERYTHING IS A SHOW. The Duke sings and breaks the spell as he speaks directly to the audience and we see the champagne spray out of phallic bottles like ejaculation. 6 | P a g e
We see a close up of Toulouse as a jester, but paradoxically he is not in jest, but looks sad with bloodshot eyes. He has a drinking problem, but is also moved by the internal plot. Note how makeup plays a role here. Switch to another domestic scene where we find out shes dying contrasts with the opulence and dreams of stage to harsh reality. Shes told she has to end it. 9 CLIMAX Is it when she finds out she is dying, or is it on stage when he says I paid my whore!? 10 RESOLUTION/DENOUEMENT Toulouse realises that The greatest thing is just to love and to be loved in return. The surreal magic of the stage intruded upon by reality but the audience quickly accept Harolds feeble excuse and the magic is recaptured. The gun flies off the stage into the night and pings against the Eiffel Tower again a break with reality and the spell is broken, only this time within the movie (or apparent reality) reminding the audience that it is hard to know what is real and what is not the director toys with us. She dies vacant eye again gritty, harsh reality. The magic is gone from his life and from the play and he cries like a baby raw and palpable pain. The audience feels pain too as the fairy tale ends. Months later one not so very special day he wrote a story about love. A love that will live forever - THE END. Curtains close. Conductor stands alone. Music carries it a close. The finale in the Red Curtain Trilogy.