A A.

53

A
A Hegel Marx

E
X ,
,
.
M , , , ,
, Hegel
.
, Marx , , ,
, , Marx .
,

.

1. Hegel: A
A ,
Georg Wilhelm Friedrich Hegel , -

O A A. X T K

54

A A. X

:
H ,
[...],
, ,

. T , ,

, [ ] , 1.

. T , , ,
, . M , , ,
2, , .
T , Hegel, ,
. E
, 3.

A , , , , , . , Hegel 4 :
, , , 5.

K , , Hegel , ,
, .
:

A K

55

1. H 6.
2. H , , 7.
3. H
8,
Stnde, , , ,
9.
A , ,
Hegel, T.M. Knox:
, Knox, [ Hegel]
, , X , , , , 10.

A , Knox 11, Hegel

X ,

, :
, , , , ; M
, 12 - , , 13;
A
14, , ,
I15, 16.
18
19 17, 18, Hegel :
A , ,
,
. A , Hegel, . -

56

A A. X

,
, . E
19 ( ).

A , Hegel
. H
, , - . E, ,
Hegel , 20.
A . A , , , , , 21,
,
. M , , - , / ,
, , , 22.
M , , ,
, - .
Hegel
, ,
23.
T , Hegel,
, [...]
, [...]
H . E ,
24 ( ).

. A, , -

A K

57

,
, , . H
, Hegel, ,


.
A :
T , . H ,
,
25.

M [] Hegel ,
. H , , 26. K , , Hegel, .
,
27

, , , . A
X ,

.

2. Marx: A .

A ,
Marx (1838-1841) Hegel
- , -.
X
, Marx
28, 29,
30.

58

A A. X

H , , , , , , , [] ,
[...]
E
, ,
, , ,
, Marx , .
, ,
, , , 31.

A Marx Marx
, ,
, 32.
, ,
,
.
A Marx
, , 33, ,
, 34.
, Marx,
,
,
, , . O ,
, 35.

K P,
36, ,
. T / I ,
. T /
I .
E, , K X
(1843) , ,
.

A K

59

A 261 , Marx , , , ,
, : O Hegel .
A , 37.
A ,
, ,
:
; H
, .
T ; H
, 38.

A, , Hegel Marx . Marx

Hegel , , .
,

Stnde Hegel39. T
, Marx, 40.
K , Marx, . H , , . , [ ]

. M , ,
. M,
, .

: ,
41.

M Marx !
A , JeanJacques Rousseau,
42,
, / (Hegel)43.
, ,

60

A A. X

Marx ,
44,

, ,
45.
X , Karl Marx . E P .
, ,
, , ,
/ ; A ,
. ,
, Marx; M , ; E, ,
, ;
A K X
E Z, O
X 1844 A O,

,
, ,
.
, , : Marx , , . , , , .
M 46, , , / , Marx -

A K

61

,
, 47.
M , , Marx, / , ,
, . ,
, , , ,
, 48.
, ,
:
1. T 49 ,
, , , , , .
2. ,
, , Marx . H , , ,
. H
. H
,
,
.
[H] , Marx,
. H
, , ,
, , . A
. H
, , ,
. ,
[...] , , ,
, 50.

M , O X 1844,
51
,

62

A A. X

,
, .
, , I
I, ,
52.
Marx,
Marx Stirner,
,
, , , I .
, Marx,
, . T
. [...] A , ,
. [...]
M ,
,
,
, ,
53 ( ).

, / ,
, ,
[] / , ,
.


. A 54, , , , ,
.
A , , , , : O Marx , , -

A K

63

, Hegel,
,
, ,
,
. A ,
, , , , .
A Marx

,
, ,
.

3. A :
T ;
, K K Marx Engels
, ,
, .
A , K, , ,
, ,
. M ,
, .
T Marx Engels , ,
,
,
. H , K,
55.

X , . ,
, Marx Engels , , .

64

A A. X

E, ,
, Marx Engels
. , ,
.
M , , Marx
Engels , , , , ,
/ . , , , . E,
Georg Lukcs, O K E,
, ,
. A ,
Marx , , , . A ,
, Marx 56.

, Marx
, , ,
.
, ,
Marx , ;
K ,
, , !
A , , :
, Marx;
, , Grundrisse, Y
K, :
T , , Marx,
, , ,
, ., ; [T ]
, , ; [T ] [
] , , -

A K

65

, ,
, [] ;
, ; M
, ;57.

, ()
, .

; T , Marx;
A,
,

58. T I , ,
, ,
.
I, Georg Lukcs,
, . T ,
, 59.

H , ,

. A
, ,
, , ,
.
, , O X 1844, I,
Grundrisse, Marx
, ,
, .
E Herbert Marcuse,

,
Marx .

66

A A. X

O , Marcuse,
. H Marx
, , 60.

A, , Marcuse,
,
. E , ,
61.
A , , ,
Marx.
, , ,

62, ,
. M ,

.
A , ,
,
.
- -
,
/ .
O Hegel , Marcuse,
. [...] O
[...] H
. H , ,
. H . O
. H , per contra, ,
63.

K , , ,
, ,
.
E: A Marx , -

A K

67

() , , () ,
;
A , , , ,
, Marx, ,

, . A ,
, ,
,
. T
/ .
Y Marx, A O Marx
T, , . : , ,
. , [...], , ,
, 64.

A, ,
, , , , ,
. A
- .
A , Lukcs
, [...]
[...] 65.

X , () . H I , () ,
Marx. H , ,
,
,
,
, .

68

A A. X

E , , Jean Hyppolite Marx

, , , , , :
O Hegel, Hyppolite, I
, Marx I
, 66.

N , Marx, / ; N ,
; N
Marx , A,
67;
,
:
M Marx;
T ,
, , , ,
A, ;68

A , Marx
.
X Marx , , .
, Hegel, . A , ,
, 20 , Martin
Heidegger, : Hegel
, , ,
69. T ,
, , . A A T, Marx , , ,


.

A K

69

1. Hegel, , 260.
2. .., 289 .
3. .., 260 .
4. H H A K E , Karl Popper,
Herbert Marcuse, E, ,
Hegel, Hobbes,
, ,
(Marcuse, Reason and Revolution, Hegel and the Rise of Social
Theory, Routledge and Kegan Paul, London and Henley 1986, p. 80, pp. 176 ..
,
Hegel, Knox, Carrit, Hook, Avineri Kaufmann, . W. Kaufmann (ed.), Hegels Political Philosophy,
Atherton Press, New York 1970.
5. Hegel, , 262 , 185 299 .
6. .., 258 .
7. .., 303, 308, 311.
8. .., 301 .
9. .., 301 , 302, 311 .
10. T.M. Knox, Hegel and Prussianism, W. Kaufmann (ed.), .., p. 26.
11. B.
Z. A. Pelczynski (ed.), Hegels Political Philosophy, problems and perspectives, Cambridge University Press,
Cambridge 1971 : Z.A. Pelczynski, The Hegelian conception of the state,
.., pp. 1-29 J. Plamenatz, History as the realization of freedom, .., pp. 30-51.
12. , Hegel, . H
I , (Hegel, ,
259 ).
13. , Georg Lukcs: H [...] , ,
Hegel (Lukcs, The Young Hegel, Studies in the Relations between Dialectics and Economics, Merlin Press, London
1975, p. 317).
14. T Hegel 267 .
15. .., 257.
16. Pelczynski, .., p. 14, o Hegel
,
, .
17. M Lukcs (The Young Hegel, .., p. 316), Hegel : Hegel,
Haym, ,
, Hegel Bentham.
18. , . 258 .
Robert Wokler
Contextualizing Hegels Phenomenology of the French Revolution and the Terror, Political Theory, vol. 26, Nol,
February 1998, pp. 33-35, : O Hegel, Fichte, , -

70

A A. X

, , Rousseau , [...] Rousseau

(.., p. 46).
19. Hegel, , 258 .
20. .., 261.
21. .., 258 .
22. B. Marcuse Reason and Revolution, .., pp. 60-61,
Hegel, , , ,
[...] H Hegel
.
23. Hegel, , 324.
24. .., 321, 322.
25. Hegel, Lectures on the Philosophy of World History, Introduction: Reason in History, Cambridge University
Press, Cambridge 1975, p. 115.
26. .., pp. 93 ..
27. .., pp. 117 ..
28. Marx, Marginal Notes to Accusation of Ministerial Rescript, Marx-Engels,
Collected Works, vol. 1, p. 363.
29. B. Marx, Leading Article in No 179 of Klnische Zeitung,
Marx-Engels, .., vol. 1, pp. 200, 202 Marx, Marginal Notes to Accusation of Ministerial Rescript,
.., p. 362.
30. B. Marx, Debates on the Theft of Wood, Marx-Engels, ..,
vol. 1, p. 241 Marx, The Ban on the Leipziger Allgemeine Zeitung, MarxEngels, .., vol. 1, p. 318.
31. Marx, Leading Article in No 179 of Klnische Zeitung, .., pp. 192, 202.
32. , ,
(Marx, Debates on Freedom of the Press, MarxEngels, .., vol. 1, p. 162).
33. .., p. 158: H , , .
34. B. Marx, Justification of the Correspondence from the Mosel, Marx-Engels, .., vol. 1, pp. 348-349.
35. .., p. 349.
36. ..
37. Marx, Contribution to the Critique of Hegels Philosophy of Law, MarxEngels, .., vol. 3, p. 6.
38. .., p. 100.
39. H Marx Stnde
On the Commissions of the
Estates in Prussia, Marx-Engels, .., vol. 1, pp. 292-306, pp. 296, 303.
40. Marx, Contribution to the Critique of Hegels Philosophy of Law, .., pp. 116-117.
41. .., p. 117.
42. .., pp. 30-31.
43. B. Marx
(308-313) Marx, .., pp. 111-129.
44.
, . N B E , M E, 4-14 M 1966, A, K M M E,
. Marx.
45. Marx, .., p. 121, [...] , .

A K

71

46. A , Isaiah
Berlin, Two concepts of liberty, I. Berlin, Four Essays on Liberty,
Oxford University Press, Oxford 1969, pp. 118-172.
47. B. Marx, On the Jewish Question,
Marx-Engels, .., vol. 3, pp. 162-168.
48. B. Marx Marx-Engels, The Holy Family, MarxEngels, .., vol. 4, pp. 120-121.
49. , , Herbert Marcuse, .., p. 283, O X Marx,
, ,
, . [...] E,
. T . H
.
50. Marx, Critical Marginal Notes on the Article by a Prussian, Marx-Engels, ..,
vol. 3, pp. 204-205.
51. B. Marx O X 1844, Marx-Engels, .., vol. 3, p. 296 ..
52. B. Marx-Engels, The German Ideology, Marx-Engels, .., vol. 5,
p. 50 ..
53. .., pp. 438-439.
54. Lukcs,
, , , , ,
[...] . [...] T , , (Lukcs,
The Ontology of Social Being, Merlin Pres, London 1978, vol. 2 (Marx), pp. 139, 142).
55. K, H K, E P, A 1985, . 164.
56. Lukcs, The Ontology of Social Being, .., p. 1.
57. Marx, Grundrisse, Penguin Books, Harmondsworth 1973, p. 488.
58. Lukcs, .., p. 80.
59. .., p. 93.
60. Marcuse, .., p. 293.
61. .., pp. 293-295.
62. Marx K, E, A 1978, . 3, . 1007-1008, ,
, [] [] . [ ],
Marx, ,
, .
63. Marcuse, .., p. 294.
64. Axelos, Marx, Penseur de la Technique, Les ditions de Minuit, Paris 1961, p. 264.
65. Lukcs, The Ontology of Social Being, .., vol. 1 (Hegel), p. 13.
66. Hyppolite, Studies on Marx and Hegel, Heinemann, London 1969, p. 117.
67. Axelos, ., p. 275.
68. .., p. 287.
69. Heidegger, , University Studio Press, , . 107, 109.