Professional Documents
Culture Documents
An Exploration of Leadership
By
Yoshie Fujimoto Kateada
Submitted in partial fulfillment of the requirements of the
Department of Dance and the Honors Program
Dominican University of California
2015
______________________________
(First Readers Signature)
Date: ____________________
_______________________________
(Second Readers Signature)
Date: ____________________
_______________________________
(Honors Directors Signature)
Date: ____________________
Table of Contents
1
Abstract
Introduction
11
15
18
19
Conclusion
21
Bibliography
Fujimoto Kateada !1
Abstract
In Western culture good leadership is usually defined as the role of the extroverted, outspoken,
and independent. As a student in the LINES Ballet BFA Program, I had the opportunity to lead a
cast of six dancers as I created my Senior Piece. Throughout this process I identified a
disconnect between the way that I lead and how I had learned to define good leadership. I
became interested in investigating how my identity as an introverted Asian American woman
affects the way I operate as a leader. I began to realize that the tendencies of introverts and the
values of Asian culture are in direct conflict with the dominant Western definition of good
leadership. My own experience and research began to point me toward a different and more
inclusive definition. This is to say that my choreographic process challenged me to act with
authority while remaining myself, and this sparked my curiosity about the challenges and
potential that exist for introverts and Asian American women in leadership positions. I found
that the qualities that these individuals possess, namely an inclination towards inclusion and
collaboration, are powerful assets in leadership. Here it should be noted that patriarchy and
internalized oppression are clear issues within Asian culture and in general Western attitudes
towards women in leadership. My thesis will explore and acknowledge the leadership
experiences of Asian American introverted women, and the need to create a balance between
Speaking Softly and Speaking Up. Although many of my sources address this issue within
academic and corporate leadership, I will show that these findings resonate with, and are
applicable to, dance and the choreographic process. This investigation is valuable beyond my
own particular experience, for it has the potential to universally widen the definition of good
leadership, and acknowledge the need for a broader understanding of who can lead.
Fujimoto Kateada !2
Introduction
In my experience, my leadership both succeeded and failed throughout the process of
creating my Senior Piece. I am curious about which strategies I should keep for next time, and
what I can and should change. I am also curious about why I led the way I did. I am curious
about my inclination towards introversion and collaboration, as opposed to a more extroverted
and individual style of leadership. I am thinking about how to care for my dancers needs,
without being desperate for their approval. I am thinking about how to lead as the quiet person I
am, and still be heard. I am thinking about who taught me that leaders do not look or act like I
do. I am thinking about how to have confidence without conceit. I want to learn to be a better
leader the next time, and I believe that the trademarks of the way that I lead, both the advantages
and the struggles, are deeply connected to two distinct parts of my identity: first, I am an
introvert, and second, I am an Asian American woman.
While these may seem like two disparate and random ideas on which to focus, the more
that I investigate these two aspects of who I am and how they apply to leadership, the more I
realize the complexity of being a good leader, both in general, and as an introvert and a
woman of color. Leaders are human, and they personify an incredible range of cultural
backgrounds, learned values, and personal tendencies that human beings embody. Effective
leaders use a variety of skills and personality traits to create a cohesive leadership style.
However, leaders do not have control over the assumptions that others make about their ability to
lead, or the value that others assign to a particular style of leadership. For example, in Quiet:
The Power of Introverts in a World That Cant Stop Talking, Susan Cain discusses the Western
bias towards extroversion and an independent outspoken way of life. She argues that quiet
Fujimoto Kateada !3
introverts can also make successful leaders; they often let their collaborators run with their ideas
rather than taking over, and this results in a more diverse array of ideas brought to fruition. This
value can be applied to my own process, throughout which it was important to me that the voices
of my dancers were heard as fully as my own. Similarly, many Asian American Pacific Islander
(referred to from now on as AAPI) women face challenges in a culture that sees them as
incapable of exercising authority at all. This is despite the fact that research conducted by
Caroline Sotello Viernes Turner has shown AAPI women are more likely to value collaboration
and view leadership as a participatory process, which results in supportive and productive
work environments.
During my research I learned that despite dominant cultural assumptions, there is
precedent for good leadership by both introverts and AAPI women. At the same time, I am
aware that there were aspects of my leadership style that were detrimental and inhibited both my
dancers and me from creating as effectively as we could have. I have always felt out of place
and somewhat unworthy standing at the front of the room. As I reflect on my identity, I see that
these feelings of inadequacy may stem from a source far deeper than my own individual
experience. Asian culture has a history steeped in patriarchy and the oppression of women. My
research deepened my understanding of an inherited identity which makes me reluctant to speak
up. Here it must be acknowledged that Asian culture is an extremely broad statement, and
does not begin to touch on the intricacies that exist within this larger category. Additionally,
Western culture also encompasses a broad range of patriarchal attitudes that silence the voices of
women. Ultimately, while some of my doubt may be attributed to my own personality, I believe
that a large part of my penchant for self-effacement can be traced back through a long line of
Fujimoto Kateada !4
women before me, who were taught to shrink. I doubt myself, and while quiet leadership has the
potential to be effective, doubtful leadership may leave everyone stranded.
Perhaps my perspective on the effectiveness of my own leadership needs to be redefined.
I want to be less afraid the next time. I want to know that I deserve the respect that my dancers
gave me from day one for what seemed to me no reason at all. I want to be less concerned
with how much people like me and my work. I want to learn to balance my tendency towards
quiet, thoughtful, and kind leadership, with a confidence in the validity of my opinion, and an
ability to speak up. And ultimately, I want to learn the value of speaking softly and speaking up,
because I know that there is a time for both.
In this thesis I begin with a personal reflection on my choreographic process: What Kind
of Leader Am I? Following this, in Speaking Softly: A Definition of Introversion, I will
examine introversion, and its effect on leadership in Speaking Softly: The Value of Quiet
Leadership. Next, in Speaking Up: AAPI Women in Leadership, I examine the unique
perspectives brought to leadership roles by AAPI women; following this, I consider the influence
of culture on these roles in leadership in Speaking up: Culture Versus Growth and The
Oppression of Womens Voices. I will then highlight A Role Model in Speaking Softly and
Speaking Up. Finally, I will return to my personal experience as a leader and apply this
research to the choreographic process, and I will conclude with an understanding of what
leadership means to me now.
Personal Reflection: What Kind of Leader Am I?
As a freshman in the LINES BFA Program I was excited and nervous about the prospect
of creating a Senior Piece. I could not see myself at the front of the room leading, but I
Fujimoto Kateada !5
assumed that by the time I reached senior year I would become a capable leader. I aspired to
look like and act like many of the leaders and teachers whom I admire. I would be decisive, I
would push my dancers, and I would offer direction confidently and easily. Many of the
processes and resulting pieces that I have enjoyed throughout my BFA college career have been
led by people who were unafraid to push me past what I thought I was capable of. When it came
time to create my Senior Piece, this is what I wanted to give my dancers: an opportunity to
express themselves beyond what they thought was possible.
However, as I moved toward senior year, I realized that I was not becoming the
outspoken strong-willed person I imagined a leader must be. I had gained much, but an
outspoken personality and extroverted disposition were not a part of the package. I do not move
through the world as a loud, gregarious, and extroverted person, so it was illogical to assume that
that is the kind of leader I would be. I have always, in fact, been more comfortable following
direction than giving it. I love listening and collaboration. When we listen generously to others
they can hear the truth in themselves, and collaboration means more energy, more wisdom, and
more ideas. I am often afraid to take up too much space in the room. I prefer to wait - editing
and re-formatting my thoughts several times - before I speak. None of these traits seemed like
good leadership material to me. As I approached my first Senior Piece rehearsal I had this
irrational fear that my dancers would not respond to me at all. When I began my process I
realized that I was working with six incredibly intelligent and respectful artists, and I allowed
myself to enlist their help. Collaboration became a key part of the time we spent together, and it
was clear that I was not the only one in the room creating.
Fujimoto Kateada !6
Yet, I was still concerned. I was concerned that I was not challenging my dancers
enough, and that I was not helping them to realize their inherent potential. I watched the videos I
took of rehearsal and realized how many times I said good! I heard myself thank my dancers
repeatedly for their hard work and commitment. I noticed that I wanted to be liked by my
dancers, and I worried that I was not truly gaining their respect because I was too afraid to
command it. As I continued creating, I started thinking more about this need for approval and
support. I began to give my dancers choreographic prompts that explored the idea of wanting to
be liked, and what movement would you choose to do if you were trying to impress
someone? I realized how much wanting to be liked is a motivator for me. Because of this,
the piece evolved into an exploration of the line between vulnerability and a need for approval.
In dance, we are often asked to reveal our true selves, the expectation being that art has
the unique power to uncover our essence. At the same time, in dance and in life, we often
choose to reveal or exhibit certain qualities in the hope that we will impress someone; in the
hopes that they will like us. In this way, our vulnerability becomes warped by how we want to
be seen. Within the piece, I juxtaposed moments that were meant to impress the audience,
with moments that came out of what my dancers and I were truly interested in exploring and
sharing with the audience. The title of my Senior Piece, Viscera at the exhibition was
inspired by this push and pull between impressing and sharing. Exhibition was an
acknowledgement of the human tendency to exhibit ourselves in the way we wish to be seen,
and in the hopes of gaining approval or respect. Viscera, on the other hand, literally means
internal organs, and referred to the vulnerability and revelation of self that dance has the ability
to facilitate.
Fujimoto Kateada !7
Despite my strategy of incorporating and acknowledging my struggle with insecurity
during the creative process, I was still worried that the dancers would not be challenged. I was
worried that the piece would look too tame because I had not pushed them enough. I was
worried that I was being too nice. However, during this whole process, some small part of me
sensed that there was no other way for me to lead. As I sat in the audience and watched my
dancers perform the piece that we created together, I began to let go of my old definition of
leadership. I had asked that my dancers bring their whole selves to each rehearsal, and I had told
them that they had the right to expect the same from me. In the beginning of our time together,
when they told me it is easier to follow when theres someone to lead, they were not asking for
the perfect leader I imagined, that is, one who was outspoken and decisive; rather, they were
asking for me to show up with my whole and real self and be the best leader I could be. I did not
do a perfect job, but I stayed with myself, and I learned. I learned that kindness is a valid
leadership style. I learned that if you not only push your dancers, but also give them the space
and support they need, they will give you more than you could ever imagine. As I looked at
those six dancing bodies on the stage, I knew that together we created something of value. For
five months we listened to one another, and we challenged one another, and we trusted one
another, and that is worth much more than becoming the perfect leader I had hoped to be. As I
look forward to choreographing again, I am reflecting upon what being a leader means to me
now and I am realizing that it means something vastly different than it meant four years ago.
Speaking Softly: A Definition of Introversion
What does it mean to be an introvert? During her 2012 Ted Talk entitled The Power of
Introverts, Susan Cain distinguished between being shy and being introverted. She defines
Fujimoto Kateada !8
shyness as a fear of social judgment. This differs from introversion which, according to Cain,
is not caused by fear, but by a knowledge of being most productive, happy, and turned on
when one is alone and quiet. Cain also asserts that the qualities of introvert and extrovert exist
on a spectrum, that is, people are scattered along the line with varying needs for solitude and
social interaction in order to function at their optimum level. Introverts often function best in
small groups, and need a fair amount of time alone in order to recharge, but this is not true of all
introverts. On the other hand, extroverts tend to be outgoing individuals who find a lot of social
interaction stimulating and interesting, but this is not true of all extroverts. We all have some of
both within us. In her Introduction to Quiet, Cain stresses that, even if you identify yourself as
extremely introverted, you will likely find at least a few of the qualities that represent
extroversion in you and vice versa. Ultimately, these personality traits have a significant affect
on the way we lead.
Speaking Softly: The Value of Quiet Leadership
To presuppose that extroverts are a natural fit for leadership is a logical assumption; after
all, leadership requires a great deal of interaction and communication with other people.
However, Cain argues that introverts bring an equally vital set of skills to leadership positions.
One of these skills is a penchant for collaboration, something about which my six dancers taught
me a great deal. Because I was so uncomfortable at the front of the room, I immediately rejected
my role as all knowing choreographer. It should be said that some amazing work is created by
leaders who view their dancers as the clay they mold. However, I discovered the value of
allowing my piece to be shaped by more than my own voice. This choice felt almost intuitive,
because the alternative seemed impossible to me. Much of the choreography that my dancers
Fujimoto Kateada !9
ended up performing was movement of their own creation that was curated by me. I would give
the dancers choreographic prompts, and then edit the movement they made and/or make
decisions about where to place it in the overall structure of the piece. This style of leadership
enabled a certain freedom among us all, which included personal reflection and creative
opportunities for the dancers and myself, as well as the knowledge that I was not alone in my
process. Yes, it was uncomfortable for me to be in charge, yet this discomfort drove me towards
an intensely collaborative relationship with my dancers, which was one of the most fulfilling
parts of our time together.
Speaking Up: AAPI Women in Leadership
As leaders, AAPI women face many of the same issues as introverts. In her article
Pathways to the Presidency, Caroline Sotello Viernes Turner interviews four minority women
who have high ranking positions at universities across the country. She discovers that these
women bring a unique set of skills and strategies to their jobs. One of her subjects, the
Chancellor of the University of Hawaii at Hilo, was not a native of the community her
university serves when she was hired. She moved to Hawaii for the job and was aware that
many of the intricacies of island culture would be lost on her, so she hired an executive assistant
who was from Hilo. This strategy, for a leader to acknowledge the limits of her knowledge, is
part of a pattern that Turner discovered in her research. Speaking to this she writes:
Each [Interviewee] has underscored the importance of adhering to a set of institutional
core values, which include the importance of treating people with respect, seeking
consensus, being polite, and being humble. These are values also noted in the literature
about women of color in higher education leadership positions. (22)
Of significance here is the fact that this inclination to enlist others as respected and equal