Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Litio, Funcion de Onda, Estado Fundamental
Litio, Funcion de Onda, Estado Fundamental
Pauli Principle
Contents
Identical particles, permutation symmetry, Pauli principle, Pauli repulsion, Pauli
exclusion principle, symmetric and antisymmetric wavefunctions, Fermion and
Boson, Slater determinants, permutation symmetry on electronic structure of atoms.
Central Concepts
Identical particles, permutation symmetry.
Difficult Points
Construction of proper wavefunctions for a given atomic/molecular system.
Notes
1. Permutation Symmetry of Identical Particles
Consider a system consisting a number of electrons which can access the same
volume of space. We call these electrons are identical. (However, if the electrons are
well separated in space, they are distinguishable because their spatial positions are
different.)
We may denote the electronic wavefunction as (q1,q2,q3.) with qi representing ALL
the parameters of the electron i. i.e. , qi =(ri,pi,msi). Obviously, since all electrons are
the same (identical), the wavefunction should reflect such a trivial fact that the
wavefunctions should give the same probability distribution of system if two (or
more) electrons i and j permute (exchange) their coordinates (qi is changed into qj
and vise versa), i.e.,
(qj,qi,qn.)=c(qi,qj,qn.)
where c is a non-zero constant.
(1.1)
Now we want to see what type of wavefunction can be selected as the candidate to
reflect the aforementioned fact, that is to say, what values the constant c may take.
Since permutation is an action that causes the wavefunction change, we can take the
permutation of the electrons as an operation just like any other operators. We may
rewrite eq.(1.1) as
Pij(qi,qj,qn.)(qj,qi,qn.)=c(qi,qj,qn.)
(1.2)
Then the task is to find out the eigenvalues of the permutation operator Pij.
Suppose that the eigenfunction of Pij. is w(qi,qj,qn.):
Pijw(qi,qj,qn.)=cw(qi,qj,qn.)
(1.3)
We notice that the repetition of applying Pij on the same eigenfunction returns it back
to its original state:
PijPijw(qi,qj,qn.)= Pijw(qj,qi,qn.)= w(qi,qj,qn.) (1.4)
but on the other hand, we have from the eq.(1.3) that PijPijw(qi,qj,qn.)=c2w(
qi,qj,qn.). (1.5)
Compare eqs.(1.4,5), we have c2=1 which means c=+1 or -1.
Thus we get the result: the wavefunction of a system of identical particles must satisfy
this condition: The permutation of the particles causes at most a sign change on the
wavefunction. We call the wavefunction symmetric if it upon permutation does not
change the sign and anti-symmetric if it does. In other words, only symmetric or antisymmetric wavefunctions are proper candidates for describing a system consisting of
identical particles.
2. Pauli Principle
According to above section, we can classify the identical systems into two categories:
one whose wavefunctions change sign after permutation (anti-symmetric) and the
other whose wavefunctions remain the same (symmetric) upon permutation.
Wolfgang Pauli found that fermions (particles with odd-half-integer spin quantum
numbers 1/2, 3/2, 5/2 etc) belong to the former while bosons (particles with integer
spin quantum numbers 0, 1, 2, ) belong to the latter. Because electrons are of spin1/2, it concludes that the wavefunctions of identical electrons must be anti-symmetric
(2.1)
which leads to
c1c1*+c2c2*=1
(2.2)
(2.3)
which means c1=-c2. From eq.(2.2), we have c1=1/2=-c2. Thus we get the antisymmetric spin states as
[(1)(2)-(1)(2)]/2
(2.4)
Since the two states in eq.(2.4) differ only by a sign, meaning they are equivalent,. We
may take either of them as the state function we need. Usually, we take the plus state.
Therefore, we get the correct ground state of helium atom:
1s(1)1s(2) [(1)(2)-(1)(2)]/2
(2.5)
which means that the two electrons have the same spatial wavefunction but have
opposite spin orientations. However, we must be careful about the exact meaning of
opposite orientationsit is an anti-symmetric combination of two basic spin states.
Example 2: First excited state of helium atom. Without considering spin variables, the
first excited state is the anti-symmetric combination of 1s and 2s (see Eq.(9.105) on
page 268 of the textbook): [1s(1)2s(2)-2s(1)1s(2)]/2. The spin states then have be
symmetric for the total wavefunctions to be anti-symmetric. The two possible
symmetric states were given before: (1)(2), (1)(2). The other one can be
constructed following the same procedure of eqs.(2.1-2.4) and it is
[(1)(2)+(1)(2)]/2. Therefore, the correct first excited states of helium atom are
(1)(2) [1s(1)2s(2)-2s(1)1s(2)]/2
(2.6a)
(1)(2) [1s(1)2s(2)-2s(1)1s(2)]/2
(2.6b)
[(1)(2)+(1)(2)][1s(1)2s(2)-2s(1)1s(2)]/2
(2.6c)
(2.7)
(3.3)
(3.5)
(3.6)
f(2)
f(3)
g(1)
g(2)
g(3)
h(1)
h(2)
(3.8)
h(3)
therefore, the acceptable wavefunction of a three-identical-particle-system is a threeorder determinant. For three spin-1/2-electron case, we have only two different
choices for f, g, h and eq.(3.8) becomes
(1)
(1)
(1)
1/6
(2)
(2)
(2)
(3)
(3)
(3)
(1)
(1)
(1)
(3.9a)
or
1/6
(2)
(3)
(2)
(3)
(2)
(3.9b)
(3)
It is easy to see both eqs.(3.9a, 3.9b) are zero because both have two identical
columns. [A determinant is zero if there are two identical columns or rows.]
Therefore, we have proved that the anti-symmetric spin state of a three-electron
system does not exist.
Eq.(3.8) has a famous effect on the electronic states in an atom. We consider both
the spatial and spin variables. Denote a spin orbital as 1s(i)(i) for i-th electron. It
instantly tells us from eq.(3.8) that it is not possible for two electrons occupy the
same spin orbital because the determinant would be zero if, for example, f=1s and
g=1s or g=1s and h=1s or f=1s, g=1s and h=1s. This is called Pauli
exclusion principle. We see Pauli exclusion principle is a special case of Pauli
principle.
For lithium atom, we see, it is impossible for three electrons to occupy 1s state. 2s
state has to be occupied. This is an example of the fact that there are very important
restrictions of the electron spin on atomic structure. According to eq.(3.8), we can
construct the following ground state for lithium atom:
1s(1)(1) 1s(1)(1) 2s(1)(1)
1/6 1s(2)(2) 1s(2)(2) 2s(2)(2)
1s(3)(3) 1s(3)(3) 2s(3)(3)
4. Slater Determinants
(3.10)
Eq.(3.8) can be extended to more general electronic systems. If ther are n electrons in
an atom, the general zero-th order ground state wavefunction can be written as a nthorder determinant, called the Salter determinant:
(0)(1,2,,i,..n)=
1(1) 2(1) i(1)n(1)
1(2) 2(2) i(2)n(2)
(4.1)
E(0)=-(1/12+1/12+1/12)(Z2e2/2a0)=-27(e2/2a0)=-27(13.6eV)=-367.4 eV (5.3)
The first order energy correction is
E(1)=|1s(1)|2|1s(2)|2|1s(3)|2(e2/r12)dv+|1s(1)|2|1s(2)|2|1s(3)|2(e2/r23)dv+|1s(1)|
2
|1s(2)|2|1s(3)|2(e2/r13)dv
(5.4)
Because the symmetry of the indices 1, 2 and 3, above equation can be changed into
E(1)=|1s(1)|2|1s(2)|2|1s(3)|2(e2/r12)dv+|1s(3)|2|1s(2)|2|1s(1)|2(e2/r21)dv+|1s(1)|
2
|1s(3)|2|1s(2)|2(e2/r12)dv
(5.5)
All three integrals are the same, so we have
E(1)=3|1s(1)|2|1s(2)|2|1s(3)|2(e2/r12)dv
=3|1s(1)|2|1s(2)|2 (e2/r12)dv1dv2|1s(3)|2 dv3
=3|1s(1)|2|1s(2)|2 (e2/r12)dv1dv2=3(5Ze2/2a0)=153.1 eV (5.6)
Therefore the ground state energy is E(0)+E(1)=-214.3 eV where the experimental
result (by adding up the first, second and third ionization energies) is
(5.39+75.64+122.45) eV=-203.5 eV
which is larger than the theoretical result, violating the variation principle. Therefore,
the state 1s(1)1s(2)1s(3) cannot describe the correct ground state of lithium atom.
5.2 Perturbation treatment of lithium ground state
As we learned before, the correct ground state is given by eq.(3.10). Now we use
that zero-order ground state to calculate energy.
E(0)=-(1/12+1/12+1/22)(Z2e2/2a0)=-81(e2/2a0)/4=-81(13.6eV)/4=-275.5 eV (5.7)
To obtain the first order energy correction, we must calculate <(0)|H(1)|(0)> where
(0) and H(1) are given by eq.(3.10) and eq.(5.2), respectively. (0) can be expanded as
(0)=[1s(1)1s(2)2s(3)(1)(2)(3) 1s(1)2s(2)1s(3)(1)a(2)(3) - 1s(1)1s(2)2s(3)
(1)(2)(3)+ 1s(1)2s(2)2s(3)(1)(2)(3) + 2s(1)1s(2)1s(3)(1)(2)(3)
-2s(1)1s(2)1s(3) (1)(2)(3)]6-1/2 (5.7)
Which can be re-written as
(0)= 6-1/2[1s(1)2s(2)1s(3)-1s(1)1s(2)2s(3)] (1)(2)(3) + 6-1/2[1s(1)1s(2)2s(3)2s(1)1s(2)1s(3)] (1)(2)(3) + 6-1/2[2s(1)1s(2)1s(3)-1s(1)2s(2)1s(3)] (1)(2)(3)
=a(1)(2)(3)+ b(1)(2)(3) + c(1)(2)(3)=A+B+C (5.8)
a=6-1/2[1s(1)2s(2)1s(3)-1s(1)1s(2)2s(3)]
(5.9a)
b=6-1/2[1s(1)1s(2)2s(3)-2s(1)1s(2)1s(3)]
(5.9b)
c=6-1/2[2s(1)1s(2)1s(3)-1s(1)2s(2)1s(3)]
(5.9c)
(5.11)
(5.13)
Finally, the first order energy correction is found to be E(1) =5965e2/a0)/972=83.5 eV.
The energy through the first order is therefore -275.5 eV+83.5 eV=-192.0 eV. It
does not violate variation principle although it is still not sufficiently accurate.
Higher- order corrections have to be included to further improve the accuracy.
5.2 Variation treatment of lithium ground state
According to Table 6.2 (textbook p.149), we use the following trial function as the 1s
state:
f=(b1/a0)3/2e-b r/a0/1/2
1
(5.14)
(5.15)
The trial variation function for the ground state of lithium atom then is given by
=
f(1)(1) f(1)(1) g(1)(1)
1/6 f(2)(2) f(2)(2) g(2)(2)
(5.16)
Summary
The fermionic properties of the electrons demand that the wavefunction must be antisymmetric. One important consequence of Pauli principle is that one spin orbital
cannot be occupied by two or more electrons. Anti-symmetric wavefunctions can be
constructed by making use of the Slater determinant.
Questions
See assignment
Problems
See assignment
References
Textbook pp.285-299. .
Assignment
Back to lecture note index
Back to quantum chemistry II home
Questions?
Back to Dings home