You are on page 1of 1

1) WhatecologicalandhumanhealththreatsmightbeassociatedwiththeGoldKingMine

spill:initially,currentlyandinthefuture?
HavingstudiedtheeffectsonaquaticlifeduringtheminespillinthisprojectIcanconcludethat
thewaterqualitywasneveratacriticalpointforaquaticlife.Ourriverhashadhighamountsof
metalsinitforalongtimeduetoourhistoryinminingandbecauseofthisaspilltemporarily
worseningthewaterqualityisnottheworstthingtohappen.Thelevelsofmetalsintheriver
duringthespillneverpeakedaboveacutewaterstandardsaccordingtotheNewMexicoofficial
waterstandardsandEPAdatacollectedfromtheSanJuanRiverduringandafterthespill.To
haveacriticaleffectonfishlevelsneedtoexceedtheacutestandards.

2) Whatistheroleofscienceinmakingpolicydecisions?
Inthiscasetheroleofscienceinmakingpolicyistoinsurethataninformeddecisionismadeto
protectourenvironmentasmuchaspossible.Informationabouttherivergainedthrough
scientificexperimentationallowforthedangeroftherivertobeproperlyassessedandcritical
decisionstobemadeusingthatinformation.Thesedecisionsaffecthumanlifebecausethey
couldjustbethedifferencebetweenpeoplebeingpoisonedorbeingsafe.Scienceshouldplay
themostimportantroleinpolicydecisionsforthisandmanyotherenvironmentaldecisions.

3) Towhatdegreedoscientistshaveanobligationtocommunicatescientificconceptsand
datatothepublicinanunderstandablemanner?
Scientistshavetheutmostresponsibilityandobligationtocommunicatescientificconceptsand
datatothepublic.Withoutaninformedpopulacewecannothopetobeanintelligentandlogical
society.Beinginformedkeepsthepeoplesafeandallowsforeveryonetomakethereown
decisionsbasedoffofreasoning.Withoutscientistscommunicatinginformationwehavea
peoplewhoarebeingtoldwhattodowithouttheinformationconcerningwhytheyshoulddoit.
Webasicallyareatthemercyofscientistswiththeinformationandneedtotrustthattheyhave
ourbestinterestsinmind.Itcompletelytakesawaytheabilitytomakeindividualdecisions
whichissomethingwegreatlyvalueintheUnitedStates.

4) Howhasyourunderstandingofscientificknowledgeand/ortheprocessofdoingscience
changedthroughoutthesemesterasyouveexaminedandmanipulateddatacollectedby
professionalscientistsandperformedanalogousexperimentstocollectandanalyzeyour
owndata?
Myunderstandingofthescientificprocesshasgreatlyincreasedthroughoutthissemester.Ihave
adeeperunderstandingofhowcomplexthescientificprocesscanbeandunderstandwhyitcan
takesolongforsufficientdatatobepresentedtothepublic.Ittakesalongtimetoproperly
analyzedataandtocreateawaytopresentittononscientificpeopleinanunderstandableway.I
alsonowknowhowtoanalyzedatamyselfratherthanrelyingonnewsreportsorscientific
reports,IcannowbecertainthattheinformationIamreceivingisaccurate.

You might also like