Human Rights Alert (NGO)

Joseph Zernik, PhD

PO Box 33407, Tel Aviv, Israel
Fax: 077-3179186

"
6133301 ",33407 "
Email: joseph.zernik@hra-ngo.org

[]
December29,2015
JudgeDrAvrahamAvraham
PresidingJudge,NazarethDistrictCourt
Byfax:046087930
Re:ProceduresforinspectionofdecisionsandjudgmentsintheNazareth
DistrictCourt,entryandregistrationofjudgmentsinNetHaMishpatITsystem
intheNazarethDistrictCourtingeneral,andinStateofIsraelvZadorov(502
07)inparticular.
DearJudgeAvraham:
RegardingmyNovember12,2015inquiry,IgratefullyreceivedyourDecember1,
2015response,inpartsaying:
OnJuly1,2014theAdministrationofCourtspublishedProcedureforInspection
CourtFiles,whicharrangesthematterinall[boldinoriginaljz]officesofthe
clerksofthecourts.WefollowsuchProcedure.ByadoptingtheProcedure,
Regulation6(b)[RegulationsoftheCourts,OfficeoftheClerkInspectionof
CourtFiles(2003)jz]isupheld.
IamnotfamiliarwithsuchpublicationbytheAdministrationofCourts,andIcouldn't
finditamongGuidelinesofDirectoroftheAdministrationofCourts.Myrequestin
thismattertotheAdministrationofCourtshasnotbeenansweredyet.
Therefore,Irequestthatyoupleaseforwardtomeacopyoftheabovereferenced
ProcedurewithacopyofyourDecember1,2015letter,therebyconfirmingthatsuch
Procedure,aswritten,isalsoeffectualunderyourauthority,therebyupholdingthe
abovereferencedRegulation6(b).
ReviewofthedatainNetHaMishpatcasemanagementandpublicaccessITsystem
oftheNazarethDistrictCourtindicatesthefailuretoincludevalidregistrationof
thejudgmentsintheabovereferencedcourtfileundertheJudgmentstab.
TheRegulationsoftheCourtsRegistrationOffice(1936)(fromtheBritishMandate
period)explicitlyplacedthedutiesontheChiefClerkforexcellentcustodyofthe
filesandregistrationbooks,andalsothedutytomaintainaseparatebook(in
additiontotheregistrationinthecourtfileitself)withregistrationofalljudgmentsof
therespectivecourt.Similarlawsandregulationsarefoundincompetentcourts
worldwide.
Incontrast,suchdutiesandobligationsoftheChiefClerkwereentirelyabolished
withthepromulgationoftheRegulationsoftheCourtsOfficeoftheClerk(2004),in
conjunctionwiththeimplementationofNetHaMishpat.
Therefore,Irequestyourclarifications:
a.Wholawfullyholdstheauthorityandthedutytoregisterjudgmentsofthe
NazarethDistrictCourtundertheJudgmentstabinNetHaMishpat?
1/3

b.DoestheregistrationofacourtrecordasaJudgment,Verdictand/or
SentencingundertheJudgmentstabinNetHaMishpatsaythatitisindeeda
?lawfullyvalidandeffectualjudgmentintherespectivecourtfile
c.DoesthelackofregistrationofacourtrecordasaJudgment,Verdictand/or
SentencingundertheJudgmentstabinNetHaMishpatsaythatitisNOTindeed
?alawfullyvalidandeffectualjudgmentintherespectivecourtfile
Vaguenessandambiguityregardingthelawfulexistence,validityandeffectof
judgmentsinanycourt,andinparticularjudgmentspertainingtoconvictionandlife
imprisonmentinamurdercase,wouldnodoubtraiseseriousconcernsregarding
competenceoftherespectivecourtandthesafeguardoffundamentalHumanRights.
Truly,

_________________
JosephZernik,PhD
HumanRightsAlertNGO
OccupyTLV
CC
AttorneyDanYakirSeniorCounseloftheAssociationforCivilRightsinIsrael
292015,
'

046087930:
:,
"","(50207)
',
122015,1
,2015,:
1.7.2014,
][.
.)6(]
2003[".
,"
"..
,"
1,2015,,,,
".
" "

" , " ".
)()1936(
",
2/3

)(.
.
,
)(.2004
,:
.
""""?
.""",",/"""
"""?
.""",",/"""
"""?
,
,
,.
,

'
"
HumanRightsAlertNGO

",.

3/3