Replication Scenario 1 Scenario 2 Scenario 3

1
54.48
56.01
57.22
2
57.36
54.08
56.95
3
54.81
52.14
58.3
4
56.2
53.49
56.11
5
54.83
55.49
57
6
57.69
55
57.83
7
58.33
54.88
56.99
8
57.19
54.47
57.64
9
56.84
54.93
58.07
10
55.29
55.84
57.81
Sum
563.02
546.33
573.92
Mean
56.302
54.633
57.392
S.D.
1.37
1.17
0.66
Variance
1.89
1.36
0.43

Anova: Single Factor

SUMMARY
Groups
Scenario 1
Scenario 2
Scenario 3

ANOVA
Source of Variation
Between Groups
Within Groups
Total

Count
10
10
10

SS
38.62
33.10
71.72

Sum
563.02
546.33
573.92

df
2
27
29

Average
56.30
54.63
57.39

MS
19.31
1.23

Variance
1.89
1.36
0.43

P-value
15.75 2.93E-005

F crit
3.35

Comparison Based on Paired Differences

Replication

1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
Sum
Mean
S.D.
Alpha value
t (n-1), alpha/2

2%
2.821

Scenario 1
54.48
57.36
54.81
56.2
54.83
57.69
58.33
57.19
56.84
55.29

Scenario 2
56.01
54.08
52.14
53.49
55.49
55
54.88
54.47
54.93
55.84

Scenario 3
57.22
56.95
58.3
56.11
57
57.83
56.99
57.64
58.07
57.81

563.02
56.30
1.37

546.33
54.63
1.17

573.92
57.39
0.66

S1-S2
-1.53
3.28
2.67
2.71
-0.66
2.69
3.45
2.72
1.91
-0.55

Half Width (hw)

Lower C.I.
Upper C.I.

S1-S3
-2.74
0.41
-3.49
0.09
-2.17
-0.14
1.34
-0.45
-1.23
-2.52

S2-S3
-1.21
-2.87
-6.16
-2.62
-1.51
-2.83
-2.11
-3.17
-3.14
-1.97

16.69
1.67
1.85

-10.90
-1.09
1.58

-27.59
-2.76
1.37

1.65
0.02
3.32

1.41
-2.50
0.32

1.22
-3.98
-1.54

Comparison Based on Paired Differences

Replication

1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
Sum
Mean
S.D.
Sample variance

Alpha value
t (n-1), alpha/2

Scenario 1
54.48
57.36
54.81
56.2
54.83
57.69
58.33
57.19
56.84
55.29

Scenario 2
56.01
54.08
52.14
53.49
55.49
55
54.88
54.47
54.93
55.84

563.02
56.30
1.37

546.33
54.63
1.17

1.89

1.36

2%
2.821

t-Test: Paired Two Sample for Means

Mean
Variance
Observations
Pearson Correlation
Hypothesized Mean Differ
df
t Stat
P(T<=t) one-tail
t Critical one-tail
P(T<=t) two-tail
t Critical two-tail

Scenario 1
56.30
1.89
10
-0.05
0
9
2.86
0.01
2.40
0.02
2.82

Scenario 2
54.63
1.36
10

Scenario 3
57.22
56.95
58.3
56.11
57
57.83
56.99
57.64
58.07
57.81

S1-S2
-1.53
3.28
2.67
2.71
-0.66
2.69
3.45
2.72
1.91
-0.55

S1-S3
-2.74
0.41
-3.49
0.09
-2.17
-0.14
1.34
-0.45
-1.23
-2.52

S2-S3
-1.21
-2.87
-6.16
-2.62
-1.51
-2.83
-2.11
-3.17
-3.14
-1.97

573.92
57.39
0.66

16.69
1.67
1.85

-10.90
-1.09
1.58

-27.59
-2.76
1.37

0.43

3.40

2.51

1.88

1.65
0.02
3.32

1.41
-2.50
0.32

1.22
-3.98
-1.54

Half Width (hw)

Lower C.I.
Upper C.I.
t-Test: Paired Two Sample for Means

Mean
Variance
Observations
Pearson Correlation
Hypothesized Mean Di
df
t Stat
P(T<=t) one-tail
t Critical one-tail
P(T<=t) two-tail
t Critical two-tail

Scenario 1
56.30
1.89
10
-0.10
0
9
-2.18
0.03
2.40
0.06
2.82

t-Test: Paired Two Sample for Me

Scenario 3
57.39
0.43
10

Mean
Variance
Observations
Pearson Correlation
Hypothesized Mean Dif
df
t Stat
P(T<=t) one-tail
t Critical one-tail
P(T<=t) two-tail
t Critical two-tail

d Two Sample for Means

Scenario 2
54.63
1.36
10
-0.06
0
9
-6.36
0.00
2.40
0.00
2.82

Scenario 3
57.39
0.43
10

Replication Scenario 1 Scenario 2 Scenario 3

1
54.48
56.01
57.22
2
57.36
54.08
56.95
3
54.81
52.14
58.3
4
56.2
53.49
56.11
5
54.83
55.49
57
6
57.69
55
57.83
7
58.33
54.88
56.99
8

57.19

54.47

57.64

56.84

54.93

58.07

10

55.29

55.84

57.81

Sum

563.02

546.33

573.92

Mean
S.D.

56.302
1.37

54.633
1.17

57.392
0.66

1.89

1.36

0.43

Variance

Anova: Single Factor

SUMMARY
Groups

Count

Sum

Average

Variance

Scenario 1

10

563.02

56.30

1.89

Scenario 2
Scenario 3

10
10

546.33
573.92

54.63
57.39

1.36
0.43

ANOVA
Source of Variation
Between Groups
Within Groups
Total

SS
38.62
33.10
71.72

df
2
27
29

MS
19.31
1.23

P-value
15.75 2.93E-005

Difference in mean treatments

X1-X2
1.669

X1-X3
-1.09

X2-X3
-2.759

Absolute value of difference in mean treatments

|X1-X2|
|X1-X3|
1.669
1.09

N=
K=
n=

30
3
10
0.05
2.052

Alphad =
t (dof error,alpha/2)=
LSD =

|X2-X3|
2.759

d.o.f total=
d.o.f treatment=
d.o.f total=

29
2
27

1.02

is |X1-X2|>LSD ?
is |X1-X3|>LSD ?
is |X2-X3|>LSD ?

0.65
0.07
-1.02

F crit
3.35

yes
yes
no

<<<===

Treatment 3 is the best

Treatment 3 is the best